Latest / Politics with Paul / How Much Does Authenticity Matter in Elections? | Politics with Paul #92
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today is about authenticity in politicians and how much does that matter in elections.
- 0:17Politicians are generally considered untrustworthy, sleazy, underhanded, slimy,
- 0:22backstabbing, dirty, treacherous, dishonest, devious, and whatever other negative
- 0:27description you want to use to describe them as.
- 0:30Now, whether that's true or not or regardless of how true that is, when we perceive a
- 0:37politician as authentic, it's like a breath of fresh air to us, maybe even a sigh of relief.
- 0:44We've found one of the good ones.
- 0:47Authenticity is all the rage in evaluating government officials and candidates for elected
- 0:53office, and it's often used to describe much of why a politician is so effective at generating
- 0:59support.
- 1:00This candidate won because their voters perceived that they were super authentic, and
- 1:05yeah, that's all well and good.
- 1:07But what exactly is an authentic politician?
- 1:10Because if you peer below the surface level commentary just a bit, you'll find with that
- 1:15what makes an authentic politician isn't exactly straightforward, even if we like to
- 1:21think it is.
- 1:22So what exactly is authenticity and how do we measure it?
- 1:27How do our biases color our perception of somebody's authenticity?
- 1:32How much do people value authenticity and how much should we value it?
- 1:37These questions make for very important discussions about how we evaluate candidates
- 1:43and government officials and what elections should be about.
- 1:47So let's explore authenticity and get a better sense of the answers to these questions.
- 1:54And I think first
- 1:56off, it makes sense to talk about how do we define authenticity?
- 2:02Well, if we just want to look at the plain dictionary definition, Merriam Webster's
- 2:07definition of authenticity is the quality of being authentic.
- 2:12Okay, that's the unhelpful definition.
- 2:13Don't you hate it when dictionaries give you the unhelpful definitions, the act of or the
- 2:18quality of being?
- 2:20Don't even bother putting that definition.
- 2:22Stupid, wasting time.
- 2:24Anyways, the actual helpful definition from Merriam Webster of what authenticity is, is
- 2:30that it's the quality of being authoritative, valid, true, real or genuine.
- 2:38Okay, that's all well and good.
- 2:42But is that how authenticity is defined in political context?
- 2:47Because the problem is authenticity is one
- 2:50of those many words that we just take for granted as self explanatory, but it's not as
- 2:55straightforward as we like
- 2:56to think because we all have our specific
- 3:01people that we support and we oftentimes think them as, Oh yes, that person is very authentic.
- 3:05But then somebody else is going to look at them and like, Are you kidding me?
- 3:08That person's
- 3:09the least authentic person I've ever seen.
- 3:11Whether we realize it or not, we have different definitions of what an authentic candidate is.
- 3:18And even if you
- 3:19look at the dictionary definition, that may not include some aspect that we would argue
- 3:25authentic.
- 3:26Authentic can also mean integrity, which generally means consistency with one's
- 3:30principles, and that was not in the Merriam Webster dictionary.
- 3:34So what are some potential meanings people have when they are looking for an authentic
- 3:41candidate?
- 3:41And I'm gonna list a few of these and some of the strengths and weaknesses to each of these
- 3:46in terms of whether these make sense as a definition for authentic.
- 3:52So first one, we just said it, consistency.
- 3:56So authentic candidates are seen as consistent.
- 3:59They stick to their guns.
- 4:00They're keeping integrity.
- 4:02They're voting and supporting on issues in a similar manner repeatedly.
- 4:07They're voting in a way that you would expect them to vote.
- 4:11So that makes sense.
- 4:12We want to support somebody who is consistent on what they believe.
- 4:16We want to be able to get a sense of what somebody believes in.
- 4:22We want them to get and especially if we vote for them because they have similar views to us,
- 4:27we want to we want them to continue to adhere to the to those views and not just change on
- 4:33a whim, especially because some people may say other changing on a whim because it's
- 4:38politically expedient.
- 4:39And sometimes that's true.
- 4:41So authentic meaning consistency makes a lot of sense.
- 4:46However, people can also genuinely change.
- 4:50They could be moved by opposing arguments.
- 4:53Maybe that opposing arguments show them a side of an issue that they never thought about
- 4:58before and it really convinces
- 5:01them to say, you know what, I'm actually gonna vote differently on this issue in this
- 5:07particular instance.
- 5:09You also have to make deals when you're in office to get laws passed.
- 5:12Even if you're the same party, sometimes you'll see intra party squabbles, both for Republicans
- 5:17and Democrats, about what a policy should encompass or the specific language of a bill or
- 5:25just the general overall strategy of what a party should be in a given election.
- 5:32But people can genuinely change and not because it's politically expedient.
- 5:38And theoretically, we like people who are open to other viewpoints.
- 5:43Now, the most partisan and ideological people don't that.
- 5:45They just want them to stay in their boxes.
- 5:49But if somebody genuinely changes their mind on a particular issue, does that mean that
- 5:56suddenly that's a lack of consistency and therefore it's inauthentic?
- 6:00What if it was just one time they did it, but that one time incensed a group so badly that
- 6:08they wanted to get that person out of office, they they put up another candidate to primary
- 6:13them.
- 6:14Candidate and I like let's take you if you take the redistricting issues going on right now.
- 6:20In Indiana, several Indiana state legislators lost their primary because they did not go
- 6:26along with redistricting, and they got primaried largely because of that.
- 6:31Now, they might have been consistent on everything else.
- 6:35They might have towed the party line in every other instance.
- 6:39I don't know their specific voting histories off the top of
- 6:41my head, but they may have otherwise been stalwarts of
- 6:45the party.
- 6:46But just that one time, that one time was a perception of inconsistency.
- 6:51And I will assume that a lot of voters perceived those candidates as inauthentic
- 6:57because they went against the party.
- 7:00And we'll talk more about those how authenticity is colored by those partisan
- 7:07biases shortly.
- 7:09But another way we can look at authenticity is how truthful somebody is.
- 7:13And I think this is probably the most common meaning that people mean behind authentic.
- 7:18An authentic person is seen as truthful, that they're honest, that
- 7:23they tell you what they really think.
- 7:25They tell you what's really on their mind.
- 7:28Because that makes sense.
- 7:29Authenticity is often synonymous with telling the truth about who you are and what you
- 7:34believe.
- 7:35And generally speaking, we're going to Even if somebody doesn't like another candidate or
- 7:41doesn't like a particular candidate, if they're staying true to themselves or at least they're
- 7:46perceived to stay true to themselves, somebody may still agree that that person is authentic.
- 7:51But on the flip side, it's not just about being honest about what you believe.
- 7:57Sometimes people see authentic as, are you telling the truth about specific, about facts
- 8:05or issues?
- 8:07So that makes sense.
- 8:09However, many times it turns out that truthfulness is but a facade.
- 8:14Callous politicians once seen as authentic or truthful suddenly get caught in a lie and it
- 8:20might be a massive lie.
- 8:22Maybe it's a small lie.
- 8:24Maybe it's multiple small lies over a period of time.
- 8:29But even many truthful people lie at some point.
- 8:34Now, course, that doesn't justify lying.
- 8:37But if somebody does it just one time,
- 8:40does that mean that they're no longer authentic?
- 8:42How often does somebody have to lie and how big do those lies have to be to no longer be
- 8:48authentic?
- 8:48Or what if it's not necessarily a lie, but they weasel their way out of something where they
- 8:54are like, Oh no, no, no.
- 8:55I actually said blah, blah, blah.
- 8:57And it's technically not going back on their word, but they said it in a way where they can
- 9:02sort of hedge their bets, that can also often be seen as more inauthentic than simply just
- 9:09saying, Yeah, you know, I changed my mind, or I was wrong about this, or yes, I lied about
- 9:15this.
- 9:15Sorry.
- 9:17Obviously that can take a serious hit to somebody's authenticity and credibility.
- 9:23Or what about, how about another definition for authenticity as relatability?
- 9:30We tend to perceive authentic people as more relatable to us, that they understand our
- 9:35problems, they're going to advocate for us, or the people that we can relate to are inherently
- 9:40more authentic.
- 9:41So if we are working class and we encounter a working class candidate or a candidate shares
- 9:49our demographics like whether they're a man or a woman, whatever their race is, whatever, take
- 9:55your pick about what demographic, what industry they work in.
- 9:59Sometimes that can work hand in hand with approachability when we see somebody that is
- 10:04relatable to us in some sort of demographic fashion or, you know, their viewpoints we find
- 10:11relatable.
- 10:13We may see those people as inherently more approachable, more inherently relatable, and
- 10:18therefore, we'll see them as more authentic.
- 10:22And that makes sense.
- 10:23If we trust somebody, we tend to find them more relatable.
- 10:27And we tend to trust people more if we find them relatable in the first place.
- 10:32So it's kind of relatability can lead to more trust can lead to more perception of
- 10:37authenticity or the or, you know, we trust somebody and then find them more relatable,
- 10:43which then feeds into the perception of authenticity can work a couple different ways.
- 10:48And of course, we don't want to think that somebody who is inauthentic is like us, right?
- 10:53Unless you're somebody who just really just does not care.
- 10:56You have like no moral scruples whatsoever.
- 10:59You you want you hope people think you're authentic, but you don't personally care if
- 11:03you're authentic.
- 11:04Beyond that, though, most people generally want to see themselves as authentic people.
- 11:09And if we see some of ourselves in somebody who's inauthentic, that comes back and hurts
- 11:17our egos.
- 11:18So we're we're gonna tend
- 11:19to think that somebody who's similar to us in some way, somebody that we could relate to is
- 11:24going to be more authentic.
- 11:26Again, makes sense.
- 11:27However, relatability can encompass a whole variety of characteristics.
- 11:33So once again, all those demographics that we talk about, they can be relatable in one
- 11:38aspect, but not relatable in another.
- 11:40And often that relatability is still used as a political ploy and a tool so that someone can
- 11:46get themselves into a position of power.
- 11:49They tell you about, you hear a lot from people who call themselves outsiders.
- 11:53The funny thing about outsider candidates is that eventually they become the insider.
- 12:00And once you run for office and once you win, you can no longer call yourself an outsider
- 12:05even though some people like to call themselves outsiders.
- 12:09Yeah.
- 12:09You may not be part of the quote unquote establishment, but you're not an outsider.
- 12:14Not anymore.
- 12:16That whole outsider shtick kind of becomes hollow, although it works for some people.
- 12:21But just because somebody is similar to
- 12:24you in many respects, does that make them authentic?
- 12:28We're
- 12:28seeing a reflection of ourselves in that person.
- 12:32So we're tending to think that they are authentic because of that.
- 12:37But if we really think about it, is that person really an authentic person just because they're
- 12:44similar to us?
- 12:45Can we dissociate ourselves enough from the fact that that person is similar to us in
- 12:51certain respects, like politically or demographically.
- 12:55A lot of times we can't because we tend to think of
- 12:58it as a reflection on our groups that we associate with.
- 13:03And that's a
- 13:04serious problem for political discourse, but that's a little bit of a different discussion.
- 13:09But lastly, one other way that authenticity can be defined and most people won't actually
- 13:15define it this way, but in reality, down, this is what some people mean And it happens to all
- 13:22of us.
- 13:22Authenticity sometimes really just means that we agree with what that person says.
- 13:28We tend to perceive people that share many of our opinions as authentic.
- 13:32I mean, look at memes, for example, who doesn't enjoy a good meme?
- 13:35But a lot of those memes are sort of not microcosms, but they are representative of
- 13:40those opinions.
- 13:42We we see if we laugh at a
- 13:43meme about politics or whatever, we tend it tends to
- 13:48be because we share that opinion.
- 13:50If we don't share that opinion, a lot of times we tend to not find it funny.
- 13:54But once again, kind of goes back to relatability.
- 13:56These people think like us, then they have to be authentic people, right?
- 14:02People who think like us have to have positive traits just like us, right?
- 14:06And authenticity is a positive trait.
- 14:09Yes, that makes sense.
- 14:11Because people who think like us, you're going to want to think that they're positive people.
- 14:17And being in agreement makes us more likely to see this person as these other definitions of
- 14:25authenticity too.
- 14:26So if we agree with these people, we may also see them as more consistent, more truthful,
- 14:34more relatable, having more integrity, and so on.
- 14:37However, being in agreement on issues also activates our biases and predispositions.
- 14:44Obviously, it's talking about confirmation bias here.
- 14:47So of course, we're going to be incentivized to see these people as more authentic and also
- 14:52more likely to dismiss contrary evidence.
- 14:55No, no, no, no, this person actually is really authentic because blah, blah, blah.
- 14:59This other stuff doesn't matter.
- 15:01And it tends to not matter if your political views are being pandered to or your political
- 15:07interests are becoming reality because of
- 15:12you know, the party in power happening to be yours and they support policies that you
- 15:18support.
- 15:20But can you agree with somebody while still thinking they are inauthentic?
- 15:27Can you look at somebody and
- 15:29be like, boy, that guy's a weasel, but I do like some of the things that he stands for.
- 15:34Can you do that?
- 15:35Some people can.
- 15:36Can you disagree with somebody while still thinking they are authentic, trustworthy,
- 15:42consistent, relatable, because you see more and more people can't just disagree on stuff.
- 15:49Has to be an existential crisis.
- 15:50And it's not just, this person, I don't think they see things correctly.
- 15:55It has to be this person is stupid, evil, terrible.
- 15:59They're going to destroy this country.
- 16:01Everything is going to go wrong if they get back in power or if they stay in power or get
- 16:06in power.
- 16:07So we should be able to and of course, that doesn't mean that somebody you disagree with
- 16:12is automatically authentic, but you should be able to disagree with somebody and still be
- 16:21able to see,
- 16:22at least in some cases, them being as authentic.
- 16:25And some people will say, Oh, yeah, of course.
- 16:27Of course, I believe that.
- 16:28I don't just treat people differently based on their political views, although is that
- 16:32actually true?
- 16:33In any case, though, our biases do influence us to not feel this way about individual people we
- 16:39disagree with.
- 16:41And this subjectivity of authenticity can be problematic for trying to study it from a
- 16:49scientific point of view.
- 16:52And when it is studied from a scientific point of view, it's probably most studied from the
- 16:57perspective of citizens because after all, the idea is that voters' perception of a
- 17:02candidate's authenticity influences who that voter chooses at the ballot box.
- 17:09It's about how authentic that candidate appears to those voters.
- 17:16But other measurements have tried to take other ways of or other perspectives into account,
- 17:24like a candidate's self presentation, what some people would call performed political
- 17:29authenticity.
- 17:30So does this person talk like you would expect an authentic person to talk?
- 17:36Or do they dress a certain way that exudes an authentic vibe?
- 17:42Is this person attractive?
- 17:45That as much as we don't
- 17:46want to admit it, how attractive we think a candidate is can can influence our opinion more
- 17:53on that shortly.
- 17:54But you can also look at it through media depictions as well what some people would call
- 17:59mediated political authenticity.
- 18:01So how are these various political outlets painting this person?
- 18:05Are they talking about this person's inconsistencies?
- 18:08Do these outlets flat out say this person is untruthful?
- 18:12There's a lot of biased outlets out there.
- 18:14Do these outlets focus on how relatable they are?
- 18:17Or are they saying like, has this person fulfilled all their promises from when they got
- 18:22elected?
- 18:23That sort of thing.
- 18:24And so the scientific study of authenticity is a burgeoning field, but it's arguably
- 18:31relatively new.
- 18:32I'd say the vast majority of scientific study has been over the past couple decades or so.
- 18:39Now there might be some roots to it in even earlier decades, but this really honing in on
- 18:47authenticity is probably about twenty-twenty five years.
- 18:52But one study I will cite comes from Simon Lubke and Ennis Engelman in the Public Library
- 19:01of Sciences, actually just a couple of years ago.
- 19:04They cite a lot of previous studies authenticity in an attempt to craft their own
- 19:10political authenticity scale.
- 19:13And sources they cite used measurements such as the self presentation of the candidate in
- 19:19social media, the candidate's portrayal by newspapers, the difference between the public
- 19:25persona and the private persona, how they measure how that was measured before a
- 19:29politician's quote unquote realness, and so on all sorts of factors and measurements that they
- 19:36used or that previous studies have used to measure authenticity.
- 19:43And so in this article that I'm citing here, Lubke and Engelman came up with this idea of
- 19:50four dimensions of political authenticity based on the existing research.
- 19:55One was consistency, two was intimacy, three was ordinariness, and four was immediacy.
- 20:02So consistency refers to politicians acting consistently and according to expectations
- 20:09based on prior experiences.
- 20:11Now whether it's that citizen had prior experiences with that politician, maybe they
- 20:15went to that politician's rally, maybe they've sent letters to that congressperson's office.
- 20:22Maybe they've called the office or they've talked to their staff.
- 20:27Maybe that citizen has a view of their consistently based on that candidate's or that
- 20:34office holders party or ideology or just politicians in general.
- 20:39At the very top of the episode talked about how politicians are often seen as conniving and and
- 20:45devious and dubious.
- 20:48So that often will just paint somebody's view of politicians in general as inauthentic.
- 20:55Then you have intimacy.
- 20:56So citizens that refers to when citizens believe they know politicians, true characters
- 21:02and personalities behind the public figures, because there can be pretty much everybody has
- 21:07at least some level of difference between their public persona and their private persona.
- 21:11But how big is that gap?
- 21:14It's not necessarily that one is completely different from the other.
- 21:18It's just that one might mask some of the personality traits that you normally would show
- 21:25to people that you know very well.
- 21:27Those get masked when you talk to people in the public.
- 21:30We all do that to some extent, or at least most of us do that to some extent.
- 21:34So intimacy also being how open you are to others by sharing private thoughts and views
- 21:40and life details when we see more and more behind the curtain of somebody, or at least
- 21:45what we think is behind
- 21:46the curtain, because some people can, when especially on social media in general, not just
- 21:53politicians, but they look at all the good stuff that's happening on social media, but
- 22:00they rarely talk about all the bad things that are going on in their lives, all the negative
- 22:06aspects, unless maybe it's a way they can
- 22:08use it to try to score some political brownie points.
- 22:10Sometimes that happens too, but that's that's a little bit cynical, but it does happen.
- 22:16But in any case, intimacy, this openness to sharing your private thoughts, views, life
- 22:21details, or at least what people perceive to be sharing of private details, that can also make
- 22:28somebody perceive a politician to be more authentic.
- 22:32Ordinariness.
- 22:33Politicians appear as ordinary people.
- 22:36They are close to the people from our communities and daily lives, similar to that
- 22:39relatability aspect we just mentioned earlier.
- 22:43So they seem down to earth and they might have minor flaws and show moments of imperfection,
- 22:48but then that can also make them feel more authentic.
- 22:53Now don't show too big of flaws because then people will turn on you.
- 22:57More minor flaws, you know, obviously that's relative because what's minor to some people
- 23:03may be a big deal to other people.
- 23:06So it's hard to come up with an objective way to measure that.
- 23:11And then lastly, immediacy.
- 23:13So directly revealing your true selves to the public, not seeming strategic, but driven by
- 23:19true convictions and emotions.
- 23:22And to some extent, that sounds a little bit like intimacy, but you also appear spontaneous
- 23:28and say what you think regardless of the consequences, like when somebody talks about
- 23:33how politically incorrect they are.
- 23:35Sometimes those people are considered more authentic.
- 23:39So the immediacy is that, oh, you're not just revealing your your true thoughts, you're
- 23:44just immediately saying what's on
- 23:46your mind.
- 23:46You're not saying it in a metered way.
- 23:49You are just outright saying, this is what I think.
- 23:54So those are other valid ways to look at the issue, if you will, of authenticity.
- 24:03But
- 24:04problem is with all these different criteria for what makes somebody authentic, there
- 24:10also isn't always agreement on who is authentic Because
- 24:17obviously authenticity is seen as a positive trait and we tend to not want to ascribe
- 24:23positive traits to people we don't like or that we disagree with.
- 24:28So would you, person who is listening to this or watching this, would you say Donald Trump is
- 24:36authentic?
- 24:37Would you say Barack Obama is authentic?
- 24:40Is your state's governor authentic?
- 24:43Like, is it my state is Florida, so Ron DeSantis?
- 24:47Or are you in California with Gavin Newsom, Illinois with J.
- 24:50B.
- 24:50Pritzker in Texas with Greg Abbott?
- 24:54Or the other 46 governors in The United States,
- 24:58are they authentic?
- 24:59Is your local congressperson authentic?
- 25:03Whether it's your US House representative or one of your US senators, are your state
- 25:10legislators authentic?
- 25:12If you ask two different people from your same area, maybe it's your neighbor about whether
- 25:20that person's authentic,
- 25:22you might get two very different answers there.
- 25:24And you might really think that your view of whether a candidate or an office holder is
- 25:30authentic is factual.
- 25:32I mean, you may be strongly convicted.
- 25:34I've been there too.
- 25:35I felt very strongly convicted about an opinion of mine.
- 25:39Everybody has.
- 25:40Just some people do it a lot more often than others and are not willing to admit that it's
- 25:47subjective.
- 25:48But how much is your perception of that politician's authenticity colored by your
- 25:54biases?
- 25:54Now party is the most obvious one, but what about those demographic similarities that we
- 26:01brought up?
- 26:02Or maybe you personally know the person, especially if they're local enough.
- 26:06Other various traits that can be used to activate biases.
- 26:10We're more likely to perceive somebody as more authentic if we share the same party ideology,
- 26:17issue stances, political group affiliations, etcetera.
- 26:21And it is a very subjective term, but any attempts to be at least objective about it kind
- 26:28of go go by the wayside because our biases are heavily influencing us to feel one way or
- 26:37another.
- 26:38But there are other things that can influence our view of a politician's authenticity that
- 26:44aren't necessarily partial from a partisan or ideological view, or at
- 26:49least they're totally a matter of partisan or ideological views.
- 26:55We mentioned a couple
- 26:56of those earlier.
- 26:57News media reports can take the role of, quote, unquote, authenticating agents who evaluate
- 27:02politicians' performances and authenticity claims.
- 27:07Now, of course, many of these outlets also have their own partisan or ideological leanings, and
- 27:12we will seek them out in large part because of that reason.
- 27:16So if you're Republican and or conservative, probably gonna go to something like Fox News or
- 27:21One American Network.
- 27:22If you're liberal and or Democrat, you're probably gonna go to something like CNN or
- 27:26MSNBC.
- 27:28There's also the fact that candidates with a lot more backing from their community and
- 27:35advocacy groups, they can seem more authentic because they're more quote unquote verified by
- 27:41more groups.
- 27:43That's why candidates try hard to get endorsements, especially from the really
- 27:49biggest groups like how a lot of Republicans try to get small businesses or small business
- 27:55owners or trade associations to support them or how democrats try to get a lot of labor union
- 28:03leaders to support them.
- 28:05It acts as a sort of like social media, almost like that blue check mark you see on Twitter.
- 28:10It's kinda like that in an election context and trying to generate support when you see more,
- 28:18more public faces backing a specific candidate, you see more endorsements, a lot of people will
- 28:24see them as more authentic, especially if we already have a predisposition towards those
- 28:32groups that are or those specific people that
- 28:36are endorsing that candidate.
- 28:39So if we're very pro labor, very pro business, and we see those relevant groups accordingly
- 28:46endorsing somebody, it acts as sort of like a mental shortcut where if we're, you know, we're
- 28:54having trouble deciding between candidates and we see these groups that we trust endorsing
- 28:59these candidates, we'll say, oh, okay, that person, that one is an authentic person.
- 29:04I'm gonna go ahead and vote for that person because this group I like would not support
- 29:08somebody who's not authentic.
- 29:10Or how about how viral information can become, which unfortunately is part of what makes
- 29:17misinformation and disinformation so potent, because it's getting circulated by so many
- 29:23people.
- 29:24And even though we may intuitively know that that doesn't necessarily make it true that just
- 29:30because the internet doesn't make it doesn't mean it's true.
- 29:34How many times have we seen something that we were predisposed to agree with and a whole
- 29:40bunch of people shared it and you're like, Woah, wait, what?
- 29:42That person said that?
- 29:44Oh, that that thing is true?
- 29:46And then later on, it turns
- 29:47out to not be true.
- 29:48We've all gotten got before.
- 29:50But when you
- 29:52see that and depending on how positive or negative it is towards a candidate, that will
- 29:58influence our views of that candidate's authenticity, especially if that viral
- 30:03information is focused on this person went against what they said before or see this
- 30:10person do this really one great thing in the community.
- 30:13They're just like us.
- 30:14Or how about the appearance and or attractiveness of candidates that can make us
- 30:20assume that somebody is more authentic as well as other positive traits like, oh, this person
- 30:25knows what they're doing.
- 30:27It happens.
- 30:28And it doesn't necessarily completely sway our opinion about a given candidate or a given
- 30:34race, but all of us have some seen somebody run for office that we thought was attractive.
- 30:39And we stopped for a moment and thought, Oh, you know what?
- 30:41I'm really interested in what this person has to say.
- 30:44It happens.
- 30:45It's about being self aware about that and not letting it completely cloud your opinion.
- 30:51And then lastly, but this is not a comprehensive list, but another thing that can
- 30:59influence how we perceive somebody's authenticity that is not inherently partisan or
- 31:04ideological is economic context.
- 31:08Because if the economy is in the dumps, more voters, especially those who are more
- 31:12retrospective in their voting, they're more likely to think the power party in power is not
- 31:16only responsible, but that they are less authentic that they're inauthentic, partly
- 31:22because they'll think something like, how can an authentic person do this?
- 31:27How could they let this happen?
- 31:29If they were really authentic, they wouldn't do that.
- 31:31Or probably more likely because that party or person that's being blamed for the economic
- 31:37issue is trying to find ways to not accept blame.
- 31:41Whether they really are to blame or not, that's not
- 31:43the point.
- 31:44But the fact
- 31:45that they're evading blame for economic issues is going to lead a lot of people to say, oh,
- 31:53that person's following it.
- 31:54They're not an authentic person.
- 31:56I can't vote for them.
- 31:58Even if they voted for them before.
- 32:00You hear people talk about how much they regret voting for somebody in a previous election.
- 32:06Now, we've talked a lot about how authenticity can be very subjective.
- 32:12But in any case, regardless of how we define it, how much do we actually look for
- 32:17authenticity in our candidates and elected officials or even appointed officials?
- 32:24Because authenticity has become a more common buzzword in recent decades.
- 32:29But how much do people really care about it?
- 32:32It is true that authenticity has some impact on vote
- 32:36vote choice.
- 32:38But who is it a major driver for?
- 32:41I mean, there's probably nobody that actually wants a lack of authenticity.
- 32:48Just about everybody, I think, wants their candidates to be authentic, but it doesn't mean
- 32:52that it's a high priority for a lot
- 32:54of voters.
- 32:56Once again, some people can think that a candidate is right for the job, but
- 33:01they don't necessarily think that they're authentic.
- 33:03They might think they're a little sleazy, but they they say, you know what?
- 33:07This I think this person has a good track record in office.
- 33:12I'm gonna have to vote for them.
- 33:14Could be all sorts of reasons.
- 33:15But survey research sometimes misses this info of how strongly someone prioritizes a view on a
- 33:23political issue or a character trait or whatever the case is.
- 33:29They just simply measure people's views.
- 33:32And sometimes they'll say like, do you strongly agree with this?
- 33:35Do you strongly disagree with this?
- 33:36And that might be a very short term thing.
- 33:39Maybe they strongly support the war in Iran right now.
- 33:43Does that necessarily mean that they are going to hold that strength of support later?
- 33:51Or if they could really strongly support it, but it's still not that important of an issue
- 33:57to them in the grand scheme of things.
- 34:00Because you could really support something, but it doesn't necessarily impact you directly or
- 34:05at least you don't feel like it impacts you directly.
- 34:08Talk about the Iran war.
- 34:10I remember back in grad school, a book that really took eight chapters to say basically the
- 34:17same exact thing.
- 34:18But what it was about was a pollster who was working in the business
- 34:23during when The US was going to evade Iraq.
- 34:29A lot of polls had found that there was a lot of support for going to Iraq, but I'm trying to
- 34:38remember the details, I believe that basically a lot of the information about how strongly
- 34:43somebody really felt about it, like they strongly agreed that we needed to go to Iraq,
- 34:49but
- 34:49if the government didn't do it, people
- 34:53didn't really care as much about that.
- 34:55It's something along those lines.
- 34:57But even if you think you're really measuring how much somebody strongly cares about
- 35:02something, might not actually be getting that.
- 35:06Somebody can strongly agree with something,
- 35:08but it doesn't necessarily mean that they actively care about that problem.
- 35:13And also, could just say that they care about that problem.
- 35:18But they,
- 35:21in reality, really don't.
- 35:23If push came to shove, their actions would show maybe they don't actually care as much as they
- 35:29think they do.
- 35:30But how about some more specific mathematical data on this about how much people value
- 35:41authenticity in our candidates and officials.
- 35:44So I can point you to one particular survey from late twenty twenty four that shed some
- 35:51light on such preferences.
- 35:52And it comes from American University's Sign Institute of Policy and Politics.
- 35:58And it said that out of 1,200 Americans sampled ages 18 to 34, 47% valued authenticity and 51%
- 36:07valued integrity, which sometimes gets used interchangeably with authenticity.
- 36:13And there's been a bunch of studies that I've been told about and heard about over, you know,
- 36:19however many years now that say that young people or, you know, particularly my
- 36:25generation, millennials and the generation after me, Gen Z, have this particular focus on
- 36:31somebody's authenticity.
- 36:32There's been a lot about like how specifically millennials and Gen Z care about authenticity.
- 36:39And not just in the context of politics, but when it comes to social media influencers and
- 36:44actors and athletes and so on, how much we see those people as authentic is a really core
- 36:51focus of a lot of these studies.
- 36:53And this extra focus by academic studies on the desire for authenticity from younger people
- 36:59like myself is kind of, I don't know what the word to describe it is, but it feels kind of
- 37:04odd to some degree because it almost acts as if like this is something new, almost as if it's
- 37:10only younger people that really want authenticity.
- 37:12It might be more desired now than in previous generations, but it's not like previous
- 37:18generations didn't want somebody authentic or didn't care about authenticity.
- 37:23It just wasn't as well studied back then.
- 37:27So it's just kind of odd that it feels like it's being talked about as if it's a new trend.
- 37:31And also, all this focus on authenticity often misses a key aspect.
- 37:38And part of the problem is because perception of authenticity is largely subjective.
- 37:44And this aspect is how good or in a lot of cases bad we are at assessing a candidate's
- 37:51authenticity.
- 37:52Regardless of whether we are Gen Z, millennial, Gen X, baby boomer, doesn't really matter what
- 37:58generation you are.
- 37:59There are we can be extraordinarily bad at assessing authenticity.
- 38:06But it's also, again, very hard to quantify how bad we are doing that because authenticity can
- 38:12be very subjective.
- 38:14Even if we come up with these concrete definitions of how to measure authenticity,
- 38:19somebody can go back and say, I don't think that's really a good way to measure that aspect
- 38:25of authenticity.
- 38:27This is actually how you should do it.
- 38:29And for myself, I'll admit I've had more than a few occasions both in my personal life and in
- 38:35my political assessments where I really thought somebody was authentic, that they were
- 38:40truthful, relatable.
- 38:42I really thought this person was a great candidate or a great office holder.
- 38:48And then they gave me some sort of reason.
- 38:51Sometimes it was objective where they objectively lied about something or they were
- 38:56objectively a jerk, or it might have been a subjective reason where I, they just said
- 39:02something in a way that I really didn't like or I I thought that their reason for voting a
- 39:09certain way was awful.
- 39:11I'm as much as I try to not let my biases color my perceptions, I'm a human too, it happens to
- 39:18me as well.
- 39:19I try to be as self aware of it as I can, but in any case, I've been quite bad at assessing
- 39:26authenticity or somebody could have been really authentic at that specific point in time and
- 39:32then later on just something happens and they're suddenly not authentic anymore.
- 39:36And that might be objective or subjective, but in any case, all of us can be very, very bad at
- 39:42assessing authenticity because we don't ultimately, authenticity is about what we
- 39:48perceive somebody to truly be.
- 39:50And for a lot
- 39:51of people, you really can't know what they're truly like.
- 39:56They might show it off a little bit at some points, but
- 40:01our biases can still very much influence that perception of authenticity or that
- 40:09little bit of private detail that they show,
- 40:13whether it's a private moment of weakness, our biases can still influence us to believe, I
- 40:18knew that that was how that person was.
- 40:20I knew they were a terrible, horrible person, that they sucked.
- 40:25Or if you're more predisposed to think they're authentic, you might say, but that was that was
- 40:30one moment of weakness.
- 40:32That is not we should not judge people on that one moment of weakness.
- 40:36Which one
- 40:37of those sides is accurate?
- 40:39That's can oftentimes be very hard to say.
- 40:43But it's one thing to perceive somebody as authentic, but
- 40:49are we able to in any way measure how accurately we assess somebody's authenticity?
- 40:56To some extent, you might be able to, but there is also still going
- 40:59to be plenty of subjectivity and bias to even doing that.
- 41:04But I think it is reasonable to say that we're not all that great at trying to figure
- 41:13out if somebody is being true to themselves, at least not all the time.
- 41:17And there's also the fact that we can say we value authenticity and we might really believe
- 41:23that we value authenticity, but yet we don't really support it as much as we think.
- 41:28When push comes to shove, maybe at some point authenticity doesn't become important us.
- 41:33Maybe we say that we really support authenticity and this one candidate we thought
- 41:38was really authentic, they do something that we really support, but then they show a different
- 41:45side
- 41:46of them that seems to be very inauthentic, but because their
- 41:53stance or action on a specific issue, whatever they did was something we really agreed with,
- 41:59suddenly we might not care as much about authenticity.
- 42:03So sometimes our biases still lead us to perceive authenticity or a lack thereof instead
- 42:09of trying to independently assess it ourselves, which brings us to this last point.
- 42:16There's one thing about how to define authenticity and then it's another to say how
- 42:24much we do value it and how well we assess it.
- 42:28But how should we value authenticity?
- 42:33Now, I think it's safe to say, obviously, it's a good thing to have.
- 42:39We generally should be authentic in our dealings.
- 42:43We should want our elected officials to be authentic.
- 42:49It's an important trait to have.
- 42:51But the problem is it partly depends on our definition of authenticity, whether it's based
- 42:57on consistency, relatability, truthfulness, integrity, immediacy, willingness to show
- 43:03private details, integrity, or I already said integrity, take your pick.
- 43:09But if a candidate goes against one or more of these definitions,
- 43:12does that make them inauthentic?
- 43:15So if somebody is, you know, consistently pro whatever, and they suddenly one day vote
- 43:24differently,
- 43:26they might have been inconsistent, but what if they were really truthful about why they
- 43:30changed their vote at that time?
- 43:31They said, look, I know I normally support I'm normally against gun control, for example, but
- 43:39this one particular situation, I was really swayed by this opposing argument, and I think
- 43:47this one particular instance, this one particular law is a reasonable law.
- 43:53Let's just use that as an example.
- 43:56So, technically, they were inconsistent because they went against their typical
- 44:05voting pattern.
- 44:06But what if that was really the truth about why they went against that voting pattern?
- 44:13But then they also only did it once.
- 44:15So does that mean that they're not consistent?
- 44:18But what if that is inconsistent, but they
- 44:20were still being truthful?
- 44:22And maybe they were willing to show you their private musings and mullings over why they were
- 44:30going to vote a different way on that issue.
- 44:35So they may fit one definition of authenticity,
- 44:41but not another.
- 44:42So does that mean that they're inauthentic?
- 44:44Is authenticity a binary measurement?
- 44:47Is it simply this person is authentic, this person's not authentic?
- 44:52Is there some sort of scale like five points, 10 points, a 100 points that says how authentic
- 45:00somebody is?
- 45:01In any case, even if we were to objectively measure authenticity and objectively be able to
- 45:07say this person is authentic.
- 45:09That still doesn't make them a good candidate.
- 45:11You still need some skills and knowledge about how the political process works.
- 45:15You still need to be able to work with other people.
- 45:18You still need a little bit of luck on your side.
- 45:20You still need to be able to raise funds.
- 45:23You still need to be able to do all sorts of things, communicate with voters, be able to run
- 45:32your office efficiently and find the right staff to help run your office efficiently.
- 45:38You have to be accessible.
- 45:40If you're not any of those things or you're woefully inadequate on some of those things,
- 45:45but you're an authentic candidate, does that mean you should be voted for?
- 45:50Not to mention, you know, all of our predispositions based on what that candidate
- 45:56thinks about various political issues.
- 45:59But just because somebody's authentic doesn't necessarily mean that they're a good candidate.
- 46:04And at the end of the day, we might want to be careful that we don't become too wrapped up in
- 46:08how authentic somebody is.
- 46:11Yes, it's a great trait to have.
- 46:14Yes, it's something that we should value.
- 46:17But we should be careful about how much we evaluate.
- 46:21Because somebody not being authentic doesn't automatically mean that they're good at the
- 46:26job.
- 46:26And just because somebody's not authentic doesn't mean that they're bad at
- 46:29the job that they're running for or that they were already elected to do so.
- 46:35And so I think the two biggest points to end off on are careful just how much we value
- 46:43authenticity and really think about what we actually mean by authenticity.
- 46:49Because a lot of times we think somebody is authentic based
- 46:57on our biases.
- 46:58We don't actually try to independently assess somebody's authenticity and biases are going to
- 47:05creep in because we're human beings.
- 47:07And that's just how it is.
- 47:09But actually being self aware about those biases and trying to step outside of those and
- 47:16really think about, okay, do I really believe this person's authentic?
- 47:19Or is it just because I tend to agree with their views on something?
- 47:24Do I really believe this other person is inauthentic?
- 47:27Or is it just because I don't agree with what they believe?
- 47:32I think it's something that we need to ask ourselves a lot more.
- 47:35But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 47:39As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 47:41Please like, comment, share, and subscribe.
- 47:43YouTube, Spotify, Apple podcasts.
- 47:46My links in the show notes, my Facebook, pollwriter author and speaker, LinkedIn
- 47:50profile, medium.com profile, my five day educational email course about how we can all
- 47:54more effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization in American politics, my book on
- 48:01Amazon, my website, paulrayder.org, and my email, paulraderwritesgmail dot com.
- 48:08And that's gonna end things today.
- 48:10So as always, thank you so
- 48:11much for listening, and we will see you next time.