Latest / OICs Wide World of Options / Wide World of Options: On the Road Discussions: Market Access, Emerging Technology, and Trading Tales
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Options Insider Radio Network, the home of the Options Podcast.
- 0:06For more quality options programs, visit theoptionsinsider.com or search for Options Insider Radio Network
- 0:14in your podcast provider of choice.
- 0:17Listeners can also access all of our programming through our mobile app available on the iTunes
- 0:22and Google Play stores.
- 0:24Options programs are also available via livestream at mixler.com/options-insider.
- 0:31That's mixlr.com/options-insider.
- 0:36Don't forget to follow along with your favorite programs and submit your own questions for
- 0:40the host set twitter.com/options, stocktwits.com/options, facebook.com/theoptionsinsider, or via questions
- 0:52at theoptionsinsider.com.
- 1:04This is the Options Industry Council's Wide World of Options.
- 1:07Before we start today's show, listeners should know that options involve risk and are not
- 1:12suitable for all investors.
- 1:14Individuals should not enter into an options transaction until they have read and understood
- 1:18the disclosure document, characteristics and risks of standardized options, available by
- 1:22visiting theocc.com or by contacting your broker, any exchange on which options are traded,
- 1:29or the Options Clearing Corporation at 125 South Franklin Street, No. 1200, Chicago,
- 1:34Illinois 60606.
- 1:37The Options Industry Council is an industry resource provided by the Options Clearing
- 1:41Corporation, collectively OCC.
- 1:44Any strategies discussed are strictly for illustrative and educational purposes only,
- 1:48and are not to be construed as an endorsement or solicitation to buy or sell securities.
- 1:52Commissions, fees, margins, interest and taxes have not been included in any of the examples
- 1:58used in this show.
- 1:59These costs impact the outcome of all stock and options transactions.
- 2:03Consult your tax advisor about any potential consequences.
- 2:07OIC was created in 1992 to educate investors and their financial advisors about the benefits
- 2:13and risks of exchange traded equity options, and the Wide World of Options radio show is
- 2:18one of several resources investors can utilize to learn more about options.
- 2:23Other resources OIC offers include webinars, articles and self-guided options related coursework.
- 2:30For more information, check out www.optionseducation.org.
- 2:35Now here's your host, Mark Benzoquin.
- 2:42Hello everyone and welcome to OIC's Wide World of Options.
- 2:46I'm your host, Mark Benzoquin.
- 2:48For today's episode, we're continuing to feature conversations that we had with some
- 2:52of the industry's biggest names at the recent Options Industry Conference in Asheville,
- 2:57North Carolina.
- 2:58Today we're featuring Arianne Adams of Webull, who will tell us her views on market accessibility
- 3:04and potential for future growth.
- 3:06We'll also have a visit with Lex Lutheringhousing from Tradier, who gives us his opinion as
- 3:11to whether or not the market is a level playing field for all investors.
- 3:16And finally, JJ Kinahan of IG North America, better known to our listeners as TastyTrade,
- 3:22as JJ talks about the early days of trading and where he sees the market going forward.
- 3:28For those interested in our webinar program and what OIC has in store for August, we're
- 3:33continuing our summer with a deep dive into selling straddles, strangles and ratio spreads
- 3:39amongst others.
- 3:41To register, please visit our optionseducation.org website and click on the Events tab.
- 3:47For our Wide World of Options podcast, however, we're excited to bring you more of our extended
- 3:52tales from the road as we've been traveling, meeting new friends and having great conversations
- 3:57about options.
- 3:59We should note that as our guests are not directly affiliated with OIC or OCC, the opinions
- 4:05expressed are their own and not necessarily those of OCC, nor do we endorse, warrant or
- 4:11guarantee the products, services or information discussed by our guests.
- 4:16And with that out of the way, let's go ahead and get started by listening into a conversation
- 4:20that we had with Arianne Adams, Chief Strategy Officer and Head of Derivatives at Webull.
- 4:26I had the good fortune to meet Arianne when we caught up with her at the recent OIC Options
- 4:31Industry Conference in Asheville, North Carolina, where we discussed a variety of topics, including
- 4:37market accessibility, popular misconceptions about options and potential opportunities
- 4:42for growth.
- 4:44Let's go ahead and listen in now.
- 4:46All right, everybody, we are sitting down once again at the Options Industry Conference.
- 4:51I'm very fortunate that Arianne Adams from Webull has joined me.
- 4:56Arianne has had several positions, many venerable names in the industry, including Vice President
- 5:01Rose at Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs and CBOE.
- 5:05Now Arianne is the Chief Strategy Officer and Head of Derivatives at Webull.
- 5:11Arianne, with all that experience that you have working with investors, let me ask you
- 5:15this question.
- 5:19Investors often feel that maybe there's an unlevel playing field in the industry, meaning
- 5:26at our investor education desk, we often get emails and live chat with investors thinking
- 5:32that the big banks have an advantage over the small time investor and it's not entirely
- 5:38a level playing field.
- 5:39How would you address that question?
- 5:41I think it's a great question and to lead off our conversation today, so I'm looking
- 5:45forward to having this discussion and thanks for having me here today.
- 5:48One, we've seen unprecedented growth in the industry.
- 5:51So with unprecedented growth, there tends to be lags in technology and development to
- 5:57meet demands of all the customers and all the investors.
- 6:01I'd say there's been a substantial amount of resource and spend on the technology side
- 6:08for institutional investors who have historically used this product as a way to diversify their
- 6:12investment profile.
- 6:14What we've seen is a significant growth larger than the institutional investor base from
- 6:19retail brokerage platforms as well as the retail, i.e., the retail investor.
- 6:25As a result of this demand increasing, what we've seen is maybe not as many tools or applications
- 6:32to allow them to transact as easy as maybe an institutional firm who have been granted
- 6:38the tools because the resources have been spent over the last 20 years to allow them
- 6:43to enter orders as easy as possible.
- 6:46In my current role, we are seeing an evolution of users, not unlike the institutional where
- 6:52we might have long-only retail and long-only institutional asset managers to the most sophisticated
- 6:57Vol Arb systematic traders.
- 7:02And with those, you can see there's varying degrees of tools that might be needed to be
- 7:06offered for that investor base, point and click, to algorithmic, to systematic algorithmic,
- 7:13to API tools that allow them to transact or execute the strategy.
- 7:17We're seeing that evolution start to emerge not as severe as the institutional space with
- 7:23the retail community, meaning the retail community where historically just started to dabble
- 7:28years and years ago in options and they might have only needed point and click or just easy
- 7:32access to the marketplace.
- 7:34Now that user base is getting smarter about the product, about the risks, and they're
- 7:40asking and needing for more sophisticated tools from all the retail brokerage platforms, i.e.,
- 7:45that evolution of that customer is happening very quickly, and we're seeing varying degrees
- 7:50of demands from our customers.
- 7:53And I think because the technology has not been spent there, but we're all rapidly trying
- 7:57to catch up with this increase in volume, you're going to start to see an increase in
- 8:01tools and applications to be able to make that level playing field look a little bit
- 8:07closer to par or on even playing field than what we maybe might be seeing right now.
- 8:13So in your opinion, one of the differences between a retail investor and, for example,
- 8:21Wall Street is technology, the access to that technology in terms of information, speed of
- 8:30execution, et cetera.
- 8:32Yeah, that's exactly right.
- 8:33I like using access a lot, and even in my prior role at SIBO as well as my current role,
- 8:40we're constantly getting asked on how can I gain access to one of the most liquid markets,
- 8:44not only the U.S. equity market, but the U.S. listed options market.
- 8:48And how we could help solve that is not only granting access tools, applications, frontends,
- 8:54GUIs, and solutions to allow that order to get to the marketplace, but also getting those
- 9:00people to those tools to be able to enter that order.
- 9:04That's problem one, and problem two is then giving them the tools that they need to execute
- 9:08more effectively.
- 9:09Interesting.
- 9:10I like that.
- 9:11Thank you.
- 9:12So with this new influx of volume, new influx of trader, a new demographic, I just had Kevin
- 9:19Dabit from the NASDAQ speak with me, and we were talking about this new demographic of
- 9:24trader.
- 9:26This new demographic, they're not seasoned, obviously.
- 9:30They don't have a grasp on the ins and outs of options.
- 9:34They may not fully understand volatility.
- 9:36They may not fully understand corporate actions and things that affect their trading account.
- 9:42At Webull, what is your approach to education, the importance of education to investors as
- 9:48well as how you approach that?
- 9:50Yeah, no.
- 9:51Education is the critical component to the growth and the further growth of this industry
- 9:56and the ability for us to provide access to education, whether that's our own education
- 10:02materials for our users, joint partnerships to allow this industry and these users to
- 10:08be able to educate themselves prior to entering their first trade.
- 10:13It's critical that we make those steps or methodical on it and what kind of tools that
- 10:18we offer to be able to get it as easily as possible.
- 10:21I think that's why we've seen the growth that we've seen where that material is getting
- 10:25more readily available.
- 10:27There's more avenues for people to get educated quicker.
- 10:30Actually I do think that we're seeing the turn that they have gotten educated.
- 10:36I've seen that in the demographics of volume, meaning to start maybe there was a customer
- 10:42that might have expressed a view in a stock by buying a call or buying a put.
- 10:47What you're starting to see is that evolution of, "I want to roll that position.
- 10:51I want to maybe spread that position or I want to do multiples of those and then I want
- 10:57to hedge the position with an underlying ETF or an index option."
- 11:01That's showing me that they're not only getting the grasp of understanding what an option
- 11:05can do from a diversification of a portfolio standpoint or expressing a view.
- 11:10They're also using it from a hedging standpoint.
- 11:12Then furthermore, they'll be able to spread or use complex instruments to be able to express
- 11:18more sophisticated opinions by utilizing option spreads.
- 11:25Shows that the education is working and we're seeing a multiple about people starting to
- 11:29get educated at a faster pace.
- 11:32But there's still a lot of work to be done.
- 11:33There certainly is.
- 11:35Part of that work is maybe dispelling some misconceptions about options.
- 11:40Do you come across any misconceptions that people have about options?
- 11:44Do you think there's things that particularly new investors misunderstand and that misunderstanding
- 11:52can lead to an unsatisfactory experience trading options?
- 11:57I probably echo those thoughts in terms of the misconceptions I've heard, very similar
- 12:06headlines that I've heard as well as I think the media also overemphasizes those misconceptions
- 12:13and risk, which is unfortunate.
- 12:15I think it's our job as industry leaders to dispel those myths as much as we possibly
- 12:23can.
- 12:24I think there's more people in the industry that are aligned with that because what we
- 12:28realize is how fantastic this utility and this product is for a person's portfolio when
- 12:34understanding the demographics of the product, properly getting educated and the risk attributed
- 12:40to it, just like the risk attributed to trading an equity or an option.
- 12:47I think that the ability for us to continue to dispel those myths is the step that we're
- 12:58at right now, especially when I, in my prior role, there was a tremendous amount of risk
- 13:03around or headlines around VIX and they would call it the fear factor and how challenging
- 13:11or that product can be and hard to understand.
- 13:16I think that maybe the person who's actually articulating that point is probably the person
- 13:21that maybe needs also the education to help them understand the value of that product.
- 13:27Dispelling those myths, understanding the market, those might be some of the key challenges
- 13:31we have as industry professionals.
- 13:35What about opportunities?
- 13:37What opportunities do you see going forward in the industry?
- 13:40I think I'll pull up on it.
- 13:43We've already talked a lot about technology, but I think now next is solving the access
- 13:46gap problem.
- 13:48I would say only a percentage of our user base at Webull and even generally in the industry
- 13:56trade U.S. equities or a local equity and only a smaller percentage, call it 5, 10, 15, 20
- 14:03percent, depending on the firm you're at, use options as well.
- 14:09There's a way to go in terms of opportunities and conversion there.
- 14:13Sometimes I believe that it's an access problem, so there might be someone who has access to
- 14:17equities, but maybe they don't have access to a derivatives product to hedge or properly
- 14:22hedge their portfolio.
- 14:24It's kind of knocking down the barriers, whether it's jurisdictional barriers, it's product
- 14:29barriers or technology barriers, or areas where we see a strategic growth opportunities that
- 14:37will allow to enhance or continue to grow this industry.
- 14:41I think that opportunities are pretty astounding as you knock down those boundaries, whether
- 14:46that's in a given industry or excuse me, given region as well as a given offering.
- 14:53I think the other part, which is interesting, is as we see more and more demand come out
- 14:57of non-domestic regions, whether that's Europe, whether that's in Asia, or everyone talks
- 15:04a lot about India right now, it's the ability for us to provide access overnight.
- 15:11There's a lot of work to be done.
- 15:13At SIBO, we obviously do it for a couple proprietary products, not unlike what the CME does for
- 15:18futures businesses, but the ability for us to start to think about providing access around
- 15:26the globe or 24/5, I think unlocks or provides an opportunity for the industry to continue
- 15:32to grow.
- 15:33You think that 24-hour option trading is on the horizon?
- 15:38I do think so.
- 15:39I think clearly the first step in expanding the U.S. options industry is allowing the
- 15:46U.S. equity industry to be able to trade overnight with the proper regulations as well as SIP
- 15:55being able to be disseminated overnight, which then allows us to have the proper hedge for
- 16:00a U.S. listed option to have a liquid marketplace, a liquid hedge for us to contemplate listing
- 16:08options overnight.
- 16:10That will take a tremendous amount of time, but I think that is the right foresight to
- 16:14be able to think about where we might be in five years.
- 16:17Interesting.
- 16:18Well, I'm glad that I'm off the trading floor now, so I don't have to worry about trading
- 16:2224 hours around the clock.
- 16:24But yeah, very interesting.
- 16:26Thank you.
- 16:27Excellent information.
- 16:28Arianne, thank you so much for sitting down with us.
- 16:30I really appreciate it.
- 16:31Thank you.
- 16:32Thanks for being here.
- 16:35And we're back.
- 16:36Thank you to Arianne Adams of Webull for taking the time to sit down with us and for the great
- 16:41conversation.
- 16:43Next up is Lex Lutheringhausen of Tradier, with whom we had an interesting discussion
- 16:47of emerging technology, especially the role of AI and whether, in his opinion, whether
- 16:53the market is a level playing field.
- 16:56Let's go ahead and listen in now.
- 16:58Welcome back, everybody.
- 16:59I am extremely fortunate to be sitting with Lex Lutheringhausen of Tradier, the senior
- 17:06VP of partner relations and chief content officer.
- 17:10Lex got his started back on the floor of the CBOE, as did many of my friends here in the
- 17:16industry that we've been speaking with.
- 17:18Back in 1987, Trading Equities, he founded Boda Trading in '92, became involved in trading
- 17:23software and created Trade Hawk in 2016 before joining Tradier as the senior vice president
- 17:30in 2020.
- 17:32Also an alum of Nordredame, so I'm assuming Rudy is probably one of your favorite movies.
- 17:37Rudy's one of my favorites.
- 17:38Yeah, you probably get that.
- 17:39Ask that a lot, I would expect.
- 17:42Let me ask you this.
- 17:44You created software for Trade Hawk back in the day.
- 17:47Obviously technology and innovation is important too.
- 17:50How do you assess the role of technology in driving innovation within the markets?
- 17:57We started in the technology space, even in our pro days when we were market makers.
- 18:02We were one of the first to have machines on the trading floor.
- 18:06That background stuck with me.
- 18:08I think as I started phasing out of the market maker side of the business and getting into
- 18:13the retail side of the business, it became even more important.
- 18:17We developed a platform as you refer to it, Trade Hawk.
- 18:20It became a retail sophisticated trading platform, something that has a lot of bells and whistles.
- 18:27You can go anywhere in it to find your trade idea.
- 18:31I think from the retail side of the equation, those folks are really looking for a trade
- 18:36idea generator.
- 18:38We try to solve that problem.
- 18:39We try to give them a lot of data, a lot of volatility data, a lot of charting data, even
- 18:44strategy type data within the platform.
- 18:48The other thing that I'm seeing today is the advent of the bot.
- 18:58We have several partners who have structured their business around bots.
- 19:03All that means, it's a fancy word for robot, right?
- 19:05It means that you're making a workflow that's automated as a retail person.
- 19:11Once that workflow is automated, it takes that emotion out of the equation.
- 19:15That's very critical for retail people.
- 19:17They tend to get engulfed in emotionalism.
- 19:22We're seeing that as a really popular technology innovation that's helping those folks out.
- 19:30Let me transition that into the next question, how is AI going to affect all that?
- 19:35Well, we're starting to see a little bit of that with AI.
- 19:40I think it's in its infancy relative to the trading side of it, only because AI still
- 19:45can't figure out sell here, buy there kind of thing.
- 19:48It hasn't done that yet, at least not well as from what I can see.
- 19:53What it also helps is a little bit of the workflow message as well.
- 19:57One of the new technology platforms that I'm dealing with, and I can't say any names right
- 20:01now, they can actually read a chart, whether it's a minute, day, whatever.
- 20:08You can spit it through their AI machine, and it'll give you an analysis of chart pattern
- 20:12or price action and give you a suggested direction.
- 20:16Interesting.
- 20:17Okay.
- 20:18That's all AI-based.
- 20:19That's kind of cool.
- 20:20Now, whether it's right or wrong, I'm not sure yet.
- 20:24It's probably just as accurate as anything else in the world.
- 20:28We've got all of our charts.
- 20:29We've got all of our indicators.
- 20:31Get in here, get out here.
- 20:33Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.
- 20:36Interesting.
- 20:37Talking about retail, you were mentioning retail versus market makers versus institutional.
- 20:44Retail, especially newer investors, in my opinion, often feel that they're playing on
- 20:51an uneven playing field in terms of Wall Street.
- 20:56Simply put, do you think that they're right?
- 21:00Are they correct in that assessment?
- 21:01What do you think?
- 21:02Well, I love this question, by the way.
- 21:04I think it's a two-part answer.
- 21:07There's a yes and no to the answer to the question.
- 21:10They can't be in the bid-ask game.
- 21:13What I mean by that is that's what market makers do.
- 21:15They buy their bid, they sell their offer.
- 21:20I preach this around the country.
- 21:22Don't get caught up in between that market.
- 21:24You're never going to buy a bid, you're never going to sell an offer.
- 21:27You have to have another edge in the marketplace.
- 21:30I think the ones I talk to understand that.
- 21:32The first part of the question is that the market-making community definitely has an
- 21:37advantage over the retail community because they can buy their bid and sell their offer.
- 21:41That's their edge proposition.
- 21:43I said, get that out of your mind.
- 21:45You have to have a new set of edge.
- 21:47In terms of the institutional folks, the only edge I see there is that they have a team
- 21:52of analysts and a team of quants and a team of whatever who can process a trade idea and
- 22:00bring it to fruition.
- 22:03Typical retail person doesn't have that.
- 22:05He or she has to dig.
- 22:06They don't have the, for lack of a better word, infrastructure that a professional Wall
- 22:11Street firm might have.
- 22:12Probably not, no.
- 22:13I would say not.
- 22:14Is that a disadvantage?
- 22:15I guess it's a little bit.
- 22:16A retail person has really gotten a great new set of tools and it's democratized the industry.
- 22:22They can get into the game with a very inexpensive computer.
- 22:26You can open a account with very little money now.
- 22:29Look at it.
- 22:30I think part of the reason I got into this part of it is because it got to be a little
- 22:35overwhelming on the professional side.
- 22:37It got so cheap on the retail side to play this game that I think I liked it better.
- 22:44The obvious things that I can't buy my bid and sell my offer, I come from the market
- 22:47making community.
- 22:48Also, with the influx of so many bodies now trading, bid-ask markets have become so much
- 22:58tighter.
- 23:00If the market's one bid at 102, does it really matter that you're paying 101 or even paying
- 23:06the offer?
- 23:08It doesn't matter.
- 23:09No, that's a pick 'em.
- 23:10That's a pick 'em pick 'em.
- 23:11That's okay.
- 23:12I think, again, one last point on this is that what the retail person has is he or she has
- 23:17time.
- 23:18You have the ability to put something on intelligently and have a little time for it to develop.
- 23:23Your entry point is probably a little negative edge, but your horizon can make it much more
- 23:27positive, especially if you discipline.
- 23:30Right, certainly.
- 23:31That was something that I would talk to people when they're asking the difference between
- 23:36a retail investor versus a market maker, for example.
- 23:38A market maker doesn't care if your trading calls are puts.
- 23:41They don't care if they're buying or selling.
- 23:42All they want is that edge that you had mentioned, whereas the retail investor, they've got their
- 23:47forecast.
- 23:48They want something to happen, whether it's good, bad, or indifferent, but they have a
- 23:53different objective than the market maker, typically.
- 23:56Absolutely.
- 23:57That's right.
- 23:58Yeah, and then the markets themselves are so much more accessible now.
- 24:02There's so many people trading.
- 24:04Education is all over the place.
- 24:08Researchers are finally understanding what it is that they're getting themselves into.
- 24:13Part of that, I think, is due to these advanced trading platforms, the bells and whistles
- 24:19that you had mentioned.
- 24:20Why don't we talk about that, discuss the evolution of trading platforms, if you would,
- 24:29technology solutions, and how you think that's impacted everything.
- 24:33Yeah, back to the trade idea generator.
- 24:36When we first started in the business, we did our deltas and our Greeks on a little
- 24:40red card, right?
- 24:42That's come a long way.
- 24:44I think the trading platform has to be something that opens up the flow of ideas for a retail
- 24:52trader.
- 24:53The retail trader, in my opinion, he blocks the flow.
- 24:57If we can make the technology piece so efficient and almost so automated, as I mentioned earlier,
- 25:04it makes that retail person's life so much easier.
- 25:07You can't imagine the mistakes that our retail person makes.
- 25:11Look at it.
- 25:12Some of it's a little inexperienced.
- 25:14Some of it's fear.
- 25:15Some of it's capitalization.
- 25:17I get that.
- 25:18But a lot of it's emotion, and they don't have a discipline pattern.
- 25:22We grew up in the business on the market maker side.
- 25:24We were taught certain discipline.
- 25:27Now the trading technology and the platforms have built in discipline to a large degree,
- 25:32most of them.
- 25:33Clearly, the very basic ones don't have that, but our platform at Trader's is very sophisticated.
- 25:40It can be as intricate or as easy as you want it to be.
- 25:43That helps that person, I think.
- 25:46Tell me more, if you would, about these bots that you were talking about, examples of what
- 25:49it can and cannot do.
- 25:52I've seen them as sophisticated as natural language learning, where you could type in
- 25:58something and it'll pull the code out for you.
- 26:02That's probably on the higher end.
- 26:03I've also seen something that has a library of commands, if-then statements and/or that
- 26:10sort of thing.
- 26:11You can build your own bot by dragging those commands into condition one, condition two,
- 26:18condition three, condition four.
- 26:20Then once you have that condition, the machine will make sure the logic is correct, so that
- 26:25if there's a loop or any sort of illogical expression, it'll tell you that.
- 26:29You can test that.
- 26:30Then once you have it right, give it a name, save it, and you can use that particular workflow
- 26:36about over and over again.
- 26:39They're pretty amazing.
- 26:40We have several now that we're in partner with.
- 26:44Let me take that a step further.
- 26:48Do you think that we're going to get to the point?
- 26:52You had mentioned something about this a little earlier.
- 26:54Do you think we're going to get to a point where the bots or AI specifically will make
- 27:01trading decisions for us at some point?
- 27:04I don't know.
- 27:08I'm not sure about that.
- 27:09Here's why.
- 27:10Take airline travel.
- 27:13Very automated.
- 27:14They have pretty much robots that can take that plane off and land it without the need
- 27:19of a pilot.
- 27:20Don't forget what the pilot does.
- 27:21He inputs the coordinates.
- 27:23He's putting in the dials and making sure it's at the right level and all the wings
- 27:27are set.
- 27:28I think the AI part of trading, I think you're still going to need to have a human mind behind
- 27:34it to build that workflow.
- 27:38I could be wrong.
- 27:39Maybe 15 years from now, that workflow is built before you say, "Hey, I want to be a
- 27:43swing trader and I want to make 40 cents on every trade I make.
- 27:47Figure it out."
- 27:48That would be wonderful.
- 27:49I'm not sure we're there yet.
- 27:50I think even though there's a lot of AI there, I still think the human has to make sure the
- 27:56flow of ideas works well.
- 27:58Yeah.
- 27:59Lex, this was wonderful.
- 28:00I really appreciate you stopping by.
- 28:01This was a good time.
- 28:02Awesome.
- 28:03Thanks for having me, Mark.
- 28:04Appreciate it.
- 28:05You're welcome.
- 28:06Thank you.
- 28:07Thank you, Lex, for that terrific discussion and for your insight into the future of trading.
- 28:10Now to close things out, let's go ahead and listen into our talk with JJ Kinahan of IG
- 28:15North America.
- 28:16Again, better known as Tasty Trade to most of our listeners.
- 28:21Let's go ahead and listen in what JJ has to say.
- 28:24Welcome back, everybody.
- 28:25I have the extreme fortune of sitting with JJ Kinahan, CEO of IG North America.
- 28:32JJ began his career back on the CBOE as a market maker back in 1985, worked his way
- 28:38up through the industry, including a 16-year stop at TD Ameritrade where he was the managing
- 28:44director of trader services before joining Tasty Trade in 2022.
- 28:49Along the way, JJ was invited to be a board member of OCC and CBOE's advisory board.
- 28:55He's also a frequent contributor to Forbes, CNBC, acclaimed author of Essential Options
- 29:01Strategies.
- 29:02A very busy, busy man.
- 29:05With all that said, JJ, thank you so much for joining us.
- 29:07My pleasure.
- 29:08Thanks for having me.
- 29:09Let me ask you this.
- 29:10You've had a long, illustrious career in options.
- 29:14You've learned a lot, made a lot of mistakes along the way, I would expect, just like everybody
- 29:18else.
- 29:20Is there something that sticks out to you now with a top of mind where you're like,
- 29:24"Boy, if I only knew that going in, things would have been so much different"?
- 29:28Well, there's a lot.
- 29:29And to your point, Mark, I've made so many mistakes along the way.
- 29:32And one of the things I enjoy is always been teaching people.
- 29:36I've always really, really liked that part of my job.
- 29:39I don't get to do it as much anymore.
- 29:42But I would say the biggest thing I've learned, and I think this is youth as well as experience,
- 29:46is not to get too high or too low.
- 29:49And I think when you first start out, every loss is just such a punch in the gut.
- 29:55Not that, "If I lose $5, I'm still pissed."
- 30:01When you have good days to be like, "All right, that's fantastic, but tomorrow's a new day."
- 30:05That's the old Marine thing, the only easy day was yesterday.
- 30:10And so I really think that learning how to...
- 30:13People say, "Control your emotions."
- 30:15It's money.
- 30:16So you're always going to be emotional about it.
- 30:20But I think the biggest thing that I learned, and I hope that the retail traders listening
- 30:25to this learn, is to really start small.
- 30:30Because when you do that, the first few trades that $80 or $100, you'll have enough pain and
- 30:37suffering, but most importantly, you'll have learning in there.
- 30:40The easiest thing in the world to do is to become a bigger trader.
- 30:43The hardest thing to do is to lose capital early and try and make it up.
- 30:47Yeah.
- 30:48I remember, obviously, a distinct difference between an investor and a market maker.
- 30:54I remember starting out in the business, I was clerking for somebody in the OEX who I'm
- 30:59sure you know, but I won't mention.
- 31:01I was in there for a lot of years.
- 31:03And I remember there was a big, I don't know if it was an unexpected Fed announcement,
- 31:08either a rate cut or a rise, but one of the guys that I was clerking with, I was looking
- 31:14at his P&L the next day, like as a clerk, I always do set everything up for him.
- 31:18And he lost, I don't know, like $225,000 overnight unexpectedly.
- 31:24And as a clerk who started out on the floor making $18,000 a year, I approached him and
- 31:31said, how do you come back to work knowing that you just lost more money than the average
- 31:35American family makes in four or five years?
- 31:39And he had said that if there was a stack of cash next to me and it got bigger or smaller
- 31:46with each trade that I did, I would trade one lot all day long.
- 31:50Right.
- 31:51And it's an interesting story because actually you made 18th.
- 31:53Wow.
- 31:54I made $150 a month as a clerk.
- 31:56But I used to bounce at a bar every Friday, Saturday, Sunday night to make extra money.
- 32:00But that all said, I actually remember the day it was a Fed rate cut.
- 32:05The markets in Chicago closed at 3 o'clock.
- 32:08The Fed News came out surprise rate cut at $225 in the afternoon.
- 32:11I remember the day like it was yesterday.
- 32:14It's interesting how these really good or really bad days leave such an impression in your
- 32:19mind.
- 32:20And again, things to be learned on that day in terms of keeping your positions in control
- 32:28and really understanding your risk.
- 32:30Yeah, absolutely.
- 32:32Let me ask you this.
- 32:33Let me shift gears for a second.
- 32:36Where do you see the market going?
- 32:37And not bullish bearish, but what trends do you see in the industry?
- 32:43Technology wise, access to the market wise, et cetera.
- 32:48What significant trends do you see coming up?
- 32:50Well I think one of the biggest thing has been the short dated options.
- 32:52Some call them zero day options, et cetera.
- 32:55They're not zero day options.
- 32:56It's just that we have an expiration every single day.
- 32:59Those options are at least been on the board for a week.
- 33:01But all that being said, they have been very popular.
- 33:04There's no question about it.
- 33:05But I think people are losing sight of one of the reasons they're so popular.
- 33:10There's two things going on about them.
- 33:12People's average attention span is so much shorter.
- 33:15When I started out on the retail side of the business, we were flying around the country
- 33:19doing seminars for hopefully two, three hundred people.
- 33:22Now you do only a few of those a year and you're aiming for 800 or a thousand people
- 33:26on a Saturday.
- 33:28And the other thing is you have to use social media in short hits to get people interested
- 33:33in the longer bits where they can learn.
- 33:35Now all that said, let's take that so people's attention spans are shorter.
- 33:38They want more media gratification.
- 33:40I think that plays into it.
- 33:41But what's also playing into it, and this is not being publicized, is think about the
- 33:45environment right now.
- 33:47We have been talking about Fed rate heights or Fed rate cuts.
- 33:50There were expected Fed rate cuts coming into this year.
- 33:53Now as we speak, Chairman Powell spoke yesterday saying, "We may not get one this year."
- 33:59So it's really interesting to me.
- 34:01So what does that mean for the average retail trader?
- 34:05It means that they're a little more afraid to put money out on a directional move in
- 34:12time.
- 34:13They have more confidence in the short term.
- 34:15What we're starting to see more is an adjustment of directional type plays, be they vertical
- 34:19spreads, et cetera, to a more compressed time period.
- 34:23And what you're starting to see on the longer time periods is what I would call more investment
- 34:27or additional return type of strategy.
- 34:32The covered call, the cash covered put where people are just enhancing their returns or
- 34:36a stock substitute.
- 34:38Sell your stock, buy a deep in the money call and sell another call against it type thing.
- 34:42Those are the longer term plays you're seeing.
- 34:45And that is being under publicized as to why people are doing that.
- 34:49And I would expect that trend to continue at least through the new year as we come into
- 34:53this election.
- 34:55And I don't think the interest rate picture is going to get settled any time throughout
- 34:59the year, partly because of that.
- 35:01And when we do and we see who's in what seats, maybe you start to get a little bit of a settlement
- 35:05from that point of view.
- 35:06Yeah, it was interesting that you bring up the election.
- 35:09I had the fortune of catching a panel just a little bit ago where they were talking about
- 35:14market volatility in an election year.
- 35:16And what was interesting is that when Trump was president, everyone expected the world
- 35:22to end and the market survived.
- 35:25The market did very, very well.
- 35:27When Biden was elected, everybody expected the world to end and the market to crash and
- 35:33the market survived and record highs.
- 35:35The point being is that regardless of who's sitting in the Oval Office, the market's doing
- 35:40pretty well.
- 35:41I thought that was kind of interesting that we may not necessarily get the volatility
- 35:46from who is elected president, but we may get that volatility from maybe contesting
- 35:53the election, something like that.
- 35:54Well, I think one of the things you have to do as a trader is put your emotions again
- 35:59as much as possible aside.
- 36:01You may feel more loyalty to one presidential candidate or the other, one side of the House
- 36:09or the other, be it Democrat, Republican, whatever it may be.
- 36:12How you feel personally is not what's necessarily happening in the market.
- 36:16And it's a bit of a skill to do that.
- 36:20And you can have your opinions and you're going to have bad trades.
- 36:23That's part of life.
- 36:24And that's why we always talk about defining your risk upfront.
- 36:29But you really have to say, well, oh my God, as an example, I support Republicans so if
- 36:34a Democrat in the world's going to hell or I support Democrats so the Republicans get
- 36:38in the world's going to hell.
- 36:39Forget that.
- 36:40The market doesn't care.
- 36:41The market cares about what do we think the policies are going to be.
- 36:44They're going to help drive earnings, because at the end of the day, earnings drive the
- 36:47market.
- 36:48And so that's what you really have to look at, separate who you're voting for, for what
- 36:52the market's telling you is going on at that moment.
- 36:55And again, that pile of cash next to you, if it were real, it got bigger with every
- 36:59trader smaller, leaving that emotion out.
- 37:02I want to visit that for a second, because I think one of the greatest things that retail
- 37:07traders are really good at and never give in credit for is how fantastic they are at
- 37:11managing their capital.
- 37:13When I was trading in the pit, I never thought to myself, I can't make this trade because
- 37:17I don't have enough money in my account.
- 37:18It's too big.
- 37:19You manage your risk, of course.
- 37:21But retail traders have to do, because by and large, they have a limited amount of capital.
- 37:27Maybe they have $50,000 in their account, $100,000, $1 million, whatever it may be.
- 37:31They're like, OK, I can put this much money at risk to that trade because I have to manage
- 37:35the rest of my capital.
- 37:38And retail traders are really, really smart, really, really good at that.
- 37:41And it's one of the reasons when we educate, we talk about doing smaller trades and waiting
- 37:46maybe for some movement to do another trade, because you want to manage that capital in
- 37:51the best way possible.
- 37:53And it's what Options allows you to do, is to really manage that capital efficiently.
- 37:57And as I said, as people become more educated and start to understand the products a little
- 38:01better, they do such a good job of it.
- 38:03I never hear people give retail traders credit for it.
- 38:06They're absolutely awesome.
- 38:07I like that.
- 38:08Thank you.
- 38:09And you're right.
- 38:10Retail traders really don't get the credit.
- 38:13We speak to many, many of them on the investor education desk.
- 38:18And what I've noticed is, number one, they're educated more than they used to be.
- 38:23They know more about the industry.
- 38:27They know more about strategies.
- 38:29They go into trading with their eyes wide open more so than they used to in the past.
- 38:33There's no question about it.
- 38:34Again, I've spent a lot of my career educating people.
- 38:37And I really feel good when people come back and you see them.
- 38:41Maybe you saw somebody at some event five, 10 years ago and they're like, oh my god, here's
- 38:44what's happened to my life.
- 38:45And it's been very positive.
- 38:47You helped in some of the education.
- 38:49You can't help but feel great about that.
- 38:51I encourage everybody at our firm to go to the events, meet the clients.
- 38:55People are really happy to talk to someone who's trying to help them.
- 38:58And that's our responsibility as an industry, not just our firm, not any one firm, not just
- 39:04the exchange, not just you guys.
- 39:06We owe it to people.
- 39:08That's how you grow an industry is helping people understand how great it is and how
- 39:12their quality of life would be their goal, something small, their kid going to college
- 39:18or wedding, whatever it is, their quality of life can improve once they start to understand
- 39:23this stuff.
- 39:24Yeah.
- 39:25And you guys are out meeting the investor where they are.
- 39:27I know Tasty travels the country having these seminars.
- 39:31You know, I certainly follow you on social media.
- 39:33Jermaul is a good friend of OIC.
- 39:36When you meet these investors, what opportunities do you see for them in the future?
- 39:43Or on the other side, what key challenges are you seeing?
- 39:46Well, I think the key challenge for everybody is having a failure and being like, oh my
- 39:53God, I'm not smart enough for this.
- 39:54They screwed me, whatever it may be.
- 39:57And so again, I hammer the same themes a lot.
- 40:01Stay small.
- 40:02So one setback, okay, what did I learn from it?
- 40:05And it didn't cost me a ton of money to learn that.
- 40:07Now here's how I'll adjust that until you get the hang of it.
- 40:10And just like everything else.
- 40:11So when you and I were in the pits, when I started trading, I'll never forget my first
- 40:17day I'm going down to the pit.
- 40:18You're so nervous, right?
- 40:19Yeah.
- 40:20And at the time, the OEX was the biggest pit in the world and I was going to be the youngest
- 40:23person to step in there.
- 40:24I was 22 years old.
- 40:26And I will never forget as I'm going down, the guys who started me in the business said,
- 40:30oh, by the way, in six months after expenses, if you're back to zero, welcome aboard.
- 40:35We're so happy to have you.
- 40:36If you're not, it's been great knowing you and thanks.
- 40:40When you hear that, you know, as you're walking down the first time, it makes you a little
- 40:44scared.
- 40:45Yeah.
- 40:46But the point being, and it's certainly hard to keep the emotion out of trading.
- 40:49It's impossible.
- 40:50You know, you're shaking my job.
- 40:51I'm alive the first time.
- 40:53Well, I mean, luckily I had nothing.
- 40:54So I lived in a, you know, 500 square foot apartment and a studio.
- 40:58And, you know, as I said, I was bouncing on weekends still.
- 41:02But what it did do is it's like, okay, once you figure it out, once you get over being
- 41:08frightened, what they're basically saying is you're not going to be very good at the
- 41:11beginning.
- 41:12So learn, keep your trading and your losses small so that as you start to learn, all of
- 41:18a sudden it'll click.
- 41:20And as I tell people who, you know, I've ever done any education with teach people how to
- 41:24break even because once you learn how to break even over time, making money sort of takes
- 41:30care of itself because you don't have those giant losses anymore.
- 41:34And I think it's a really important message for particularly those just starting out to
- 41:39understand.
- 41:40Nobody became great at this right away.
- 41:42And again, when we were doing it, what it was probably about a 25% survival rate after
- 41:46one year of new people stepped into the pit.
- 41:49And again, it's not pit trading anymore, but some of the concepts certainly go a long way.
- 41:55So if you are newer and you're getting a little discouraged, go back to one lots if you have
- 42:00to.
- 42:01That's fine.
- 42:02Learn from those one contract in just after six months, if you're breaking even, all of
- 42:07a sudden you got it.
- 42:08You'll start to see the money coming slowly but surely.
- 42:12Right.
- 42:13No, I like that.
- 42:14And it's interesting what you just mentioned.
- 42:16While I'm here at the conference, I ran into somebody that I clerked with way back in the
- 42:20day.
- 42:21And out of our clerking class, if you will, of maybe about 15 or so, there's only four
- 42:27of us left in the business.
- 42:28I mean, everybody else is off doing something else.
- 42:31So yeah, it's interesting how it's almost like restaurants, for example, so many fail
- 42:37within the first number of years.
- 42:39But yeah, I like the idea of maybe going back to the basics.
- 42:43If things aren't working out for you, relearn.
- 42:47And I think there comes a time, if you've been doing this a long time, it's just like
- 42:52almost playing.
- 42:53I played baseball high school and college, and I see a lot of analogies to baseball about
- 42:59doing it every single day.
- 43:01And there's going to be times where you just, for whatever reason, are in a bit of a slump.
- 43:04You just don't have the right instincts.
- 43:06And it's going to happen to everybody at some point.
- 43:09And you're like, man, I couldn't hit the water if I fell out of the boat right now.
- 43:13And so you go back to, OK, I'm going to go to really small trades again.
- 43:17I'm going to get my feel back.
- 43:19I'm going to get my basics back.
- 43:21A lot of times, I think what happens, quite honestly, is you become a little bit undisciplined.
- 43:27And you have to go back to say, OK, well, what am I doing wrong?
- 43:30Let's go back to the discipline of trading.
- 43:32Let's go back to making sure I understand my risk in every trade.
- 43:35And you get yourself back in the groove.
- 43:37But once every few years, everybody I've talked to who's done this for a long time comes into
- 43:41that same sort of little short period where, for whatever reason, you just get out of sync.
- 43:47JJ, thank you so much.
- 43:49Really appreciate your time.
- 43:50Always great to see you.
- 43:51Thanks for having me.
- 43:52A lot of fun.
- 43:53All right, take care.
- 43:54That's going to do it for today's episode of Wide World of Options.
- 43:57Special thanks to our guests, Ariane Adams, Lex Lutheran Housing, and JJ Kinahan for sitting
- 44:03down with us on the road.
- 44:05And be sure to visit the events section of optionseducation.org to register for the continuation
- 44:10of our Summer of Selling webinars.
- 44:13Thanks again to all of our listeners and supporters out there.
- 44:16And as always, please feel free to send us your questions via email at options@theocc.com
- 44:22or live chat with us on our website as we love hearing from our listeners.
- 44:26Take care, everyone, and we'll be talking with you again very soon.
- 44:31You've been listening to the Options Industry Council's Wide World of Options.
- 44:36If you have questions about anything you've heard on today's show, email options@theocc.com
- 44:42or visit www.optionseducation.org and chat with OIC's investor education team.
- 44:50Interested in connecting with OIC on social media?
- 44:53Subscribe to the OIC YouTube channel, like them on Facebook, follow them on Twitter at
- 44:57options.edu, and follow their page on LinkedIn.
- 45:02Thanks for listening, and be sure to tune in to the next episode of Wide World of Options.
- 45:07You're listening to the Options Insider Radio Network, the home of the Options podcast.
- 45:16For more quality options programs, visit theoptionsinsider.com or search for Options Insider
- 45:24Radio Network in your podcast provider of choice.
- 45:27Listeners can also access all of our programming through our mobile app available on the iTunes
- 45:32and Google Play stores.
- 45:34Most programs are also available via livestream at mixler.com/options-insider.
- 45:41That's mixlr.com/options-insider.
- 45:47Don't forget to follow along with your favorite programs and submit your own questions for
- 45:51the host set twitter.com/options, stocktwits.com/options, facebook.com/theoptionsinsider, or via questions
- 46:02at theoptionsinsider.com.