Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Signs of Attachment Disturbance & How to Spot Them
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:21love you. Keep going.
- 0:22It is Thursday, July 3rd, 2025 at 7:37 PM Pacific Daylight Time
- 0:29and I thought that I would talk about attachment conditioning or
- 0:34attachment disturbances and how they tend to manifest in people.
- 0:40Partly because it it's interesting to be able to
- 0:45understand your own conditioning, but also the
- 0:49conditioning of other people and how it shows up.
- 0:57You know, we all see ourselves not as we are particularly, but
- 1:02as is reflected back to us and we create these working models.
- 1:08Actually it's as gists is the word, these little memory events
- 1:12that are encoded and then associated with the working
- 1:17model. And so that when we want to
- 1:19create a sense of ourselves or a sense of someone else, we bring
- 1:23up this pattern the gists fire. And then we recognize in our
- 1:28sensing experience the the pattern of of what that is.
- 1:35Human beings are not great at self reflection.
- 1:38You may have encountered people along the way whose idea of
- 1:42themselves and who they seem to be don't match that well.
- 1:47You might even say that about all of us at at certain moments
- 1:52in time, what we think is happening, is it really
- 1:55happening? But it seems vivid, real.
- 2:00We're a little bumble of joy. I've always liked that phrase
- 2:06bumble of joy. It's from Edward Alvey's work.
- 2:11That little activity that we are certainly conditioned to believe
- 2:20is a wonderful experience being my mother or father, I some of
- 2:25us have actually done it. The idea that you're always
- 2:34joyful, always delighting in the child seems to be mysterious.
- 2:42There you are, this expressive being that just is showing the
- 2:47world who you are, and the world being your caregiver and how
- 2:51they show up is that reflected back to you.
- 2:53And we gradually develop this sense of who we are and what to
- 2:57expect from the world based on that reflection.
- 3:02And if we had a resource caregiver who was responsive,
- 3:06who delighted in us, that's what they reflected back to us.
- 3:09And we developed a sense of ourselves as someone who could
- 3:14be expressive in the world of what we needed and that the
- 3:18world would then be responsive to that.
- 3:21And So what you notice in the secure people is that they tend
- 3:26to be able to touch into themselves and understand what
- 3:30it is that they need. And then they tend to be
- 3:33expressive of that because their expectation is that their needs
- 3:41will be provided for. This of course, doesn't seem to
- 3:46shake out so well for insecure and disorganized.
- 3:51They have a different experience.
- 3:54Somebody who grows up to be a dismissing adult will have the
- 3:58experience in childhood of a caregiver who's not responsive
- 4:02but consistently not responsive. So that you don't develop an
- 4:06expectation that somebody will be responsive, but they also are
- 4:12demanding of you presenting yourself in a certain way.
- 4:17Usually it's an idealized version, but not an idealized
- 4:22version of yourself. What they want you to do is
- 4:24reflect back an ideal version of the parent of the caregiver.
- 4:28And so you learn to do that. So you're idealizing can you can
- 4:34present well preoccupied people. It's a it's a, a sense that you
- 4:42present yourself to the world in hopes of getting care, but then
- 4:47the care is unreliable. Sometimes you get it, sometimes
- 4:50you don't. Sometimes it's the completely
- 4:52wrong thing. And so you don't really track
- 4:55how it is that you present so much as you keep presenting,
- 5:00hoping something will cause a response from the caregivers
- 5:04that will meet your needs. Sometimes it happens, sometimes
- 5:09it doesn't. Often it doesn't.
- 5:14And then disorganized kids are frightened of their caregiver
- 5:19either either because the caregiver is so frightened of
- 5:22the the burden of child care or the caregiver is actually
- 5:28harming. We have these three modes, the
- 5:34attachment system, the exploration system, and then the
- 5:38collaborative relationship system.
- 5:42When the attachment system is active, it causes us to seek
- 5:46physical proximity to somebody who we think will protect us,
- 5:50comfort us, soothe us. And when it settles, it then
- 5:54activates the exploration system where we can go out into the
- 5:58world and look for the things that have meaning to us and come
- 6:02into a place of meaning with it. With it, we can explore the
- 6:08collaborative relationship system stays on for the most
- 6:11part, but of course it has to be trained.
- 6:13We come into the world kind of like a tablorosa, just a Warren
- 6:20of unconnected axons waiting to absorb the experience of life as
- 6:28it unfolds. And so that experience of the
- 6:33caregivers providing that for us, what do they expose us to?
- 6:38What do we learn? Did you have one of those
- 6:43parents that insisted that you eat a variety of vegetables so
- 6:46that it the end of childhood when the brain reorganizes
- 6:51around cognitive speed and not the capacity to absorb
- 6:58information? Did you have a wide range in
- 7:01your palate or was it confined the back and forth?
- 7:15So in that early period, that first three years, of course
- 7:19nobody really remembers the first three years of of life.
- 7:23You developed this orientation who you think you are based on a
- 7:29working model of self that is built around the encoding of all
- 7:34of these experiences you had, all of which includes the
- 7:38expectation of what might happen.
- 7:43And then you hit mid childhood, the, the, the birth in some
- 7:49sense or the activation of the autobiographical memory.
- 7:55You're already oriented attachment wise by the time you
- 7:58get there. And then what we begin to do in
- 8:03using the the Buddhist idiom, fixate our sense of self and
- 8:09fixate our expectation of the world.
- 8:14Part of that is a luck of the draw.
- 8:17When you showed up on the playground and presented
- 8:21yourself in the full glory of your attachment conditioning,
- 8:26did you meet people who were delighted by that and embraced
- 8:32you, or did you find it difficult to fit in, or did you
- 8:37not make much of an impression? The what do you remember?
- 8:49I remember quite distinctly coming up the stairs at Lincoln
- 8:52School when I was 5 or 6 and saying to my mother that I, I, I
- 9:00wish that she had sent me to kindergarten, but she had sent
- 9:04me to kindergarten. I just remember going to
- 9:06kindergarten because she sent me at 4:00 instead of five.
- 9:12So I sort of remember a little bit of first grade when I was 5,
- 9:19but I remember 2nd grade when I was older. 7 maybe.
- 9:24What is that, six or seven? I was always a year behind.
- 9:27I didn't catch up until I was a sophomore in high school.
- 9:31This is not a good thing, incidentally, if you're
- 9:34considering to do this to a child because they're always
- 9:37behind, so it gives them the impression that they're not
- 9:41coordinated physically and can't think very well because
- 9:46everybody's better coordinated and can think faster.
- 9:54You're following me on this. You get conditioned and you get
- 9:57to the playground with your underlying basic conditioning.
- 10:01And then depending on how well you can navigate that and how
- 10:03much help you had in navigating that, you developed that that
- 10:10autobiographically oriented view of who you are and what to
- 10:13expect from the world who did. Hey George, you said about a
- 10:19better coordination and thinking faster.
- 10:22I was curious about this the the intelligence.
- 10:26Why isn't like that aspect of intelligence thinking faster?
- 10:31Is that related to the attachment system?
- 10:33Why are some kids poor versus not academically?
- 10:41Oh, well, you know, there's a whole range of learning
- 10:46capacities, and our educational systems, particularly in this
- 10:55country, are organized around certain what was supposed to be
- 11:03a meritocracy, right, Gifted kids getting the resources that
- 11:08they need to develop. But it was based on a certain
- 11:13kind of testing. And So what really happened is
- 11:20rather than it being a means for transversing the class system,
- 11:26it really embedded and reinforced the class system
- 11:31based on a certain kind of learning, which actually is kids
- 11:36who are good at taking a certain kind of tests.
- 11:39It's not even all, all tests. But in this country, the, the,
- 11:44the IQ tests are actually not IQ tests.
- 11:48They don't measure IQ. They measure your ability to
- 11:51take that test, which is an unfortunate thing.
- 11:57And then the educational system is based on fast tracking the
- 12:01kids that can take the test well and everybody else going into a
- 12:06different kind of track. And so I wouldn't be able to
- 12:11reasonably answer the question. The, the kids that can take that
- 12:15do well taking that test tend to be moved quicker and the kids
- 12:20that don't do well taking that test are denied the resources
- 12:23that might make them learn in a way that would be useful.
- 12:30So in our education system, for instance, it doesn't the, your
- 12:35capacity for vocabulary doesn't improve beyond what it what you
- 12:41hear at the dinner table at night.
- 12:43So it it really has almost no impact on changing the
- 12:48orientation of the education level of the family, but it but
- 12:52it is a justification for organizing resources.
- 12:59How's that for an answer? Yeah, we're just like if two
- 13:03kids go to the exact same school for the exact same education,
- 13:07their intelligence is still different.
- 13:09Kindergarten few like they're. Yeah.
- 13:12No, it's, it is totally different.
- 13:14And also the resources that they are given in order to develop
- 13:18based on their learning styles are different.
- 13:21You mean the family giving them the resources?
- 13:25Well, the public school system here is the the resources are
- 13:28gauged based on your out testing outcomes so that if your family
- 13:33doesn't have resources to provide for you beyond what the
- 13:37the system will provide for you, you don't have it.
- 13:40And guess what happens to kids who don't have resources to help
- 13:44them learn in the way that they need to?
- 13:48They don't learn. That would imply all the kids
- 13:52going to the same school will come out approximately similar
- 13:56performance after school. Well, no, it doesn't really
- 14:03because they go into the school coming from family systems that
- 14:06are are are prepping them or not prepping them.
- 14:09We're supporting them. We're not supporting them.
- 14:13So for instance, I remember my mother raging in my childhood
- 14:19because parents were having their kids show up to
- 14:23kindergarten and being able to read, which meant they sat at
- 14:30home and and taught the child to read.
- 14:32And my mother resented it because she thought that it was
- 14:35unnecessary for children to learn how to read until 2 grades
- 14:40later, right? Shouldn't they have a childhood
- 14:42where they could just play and when that makes sense?
- 14:46And so then you look at a different school system, for
- 14:48instance, like the Japanese school system, the main
- 14:52curriculum is manners until you're 7 or 8 years old, and
- 14:56then you get into a different kind of curriculum there.
- 15:01But because we've set up this meritocracy where resources are
- 15:05given based on the outcomes of these tests that really only
- 15:08test whether you take the test, well, it is a cascade of
- 15:14resources or nothing really is what what happens.
- 15:20So no, I wouldn't say that. I would say it's more likely
- 15:24that the next Einstein is parking your car because of
- 15:27where he was born in the class system and the resources that
- 15:31were available to him. Then he wouldn't or she wouldn't
- 15:34be capable of understanding the nature of the universe.
- 15:42Yeah, I think this is where karma comes in.
- 15:43That's what I believe in. But.
- 15:47Also or injustice? How about that?
- 15:55Sorry Carmen. In a sense, inclination of a kid
- 15:58which comes in this world with some pre inclination towards
- 16:02something. Yes, indeed.
- 16:05Yeah, it's a it's a tough nut, that one.
- 16:13Hello. Thanks George.
- 16:17I actually want to 1st just mention or maybe ask Christian
- 16:20because Christian was trying to raise his hand a bit before I
- 16:22raised my electronic. When Christian, you just have a
- 16:24question. Say that again.
- 16:27Christian was, I think, an asking question as well, but he
- 16:30was he was physically raising his physical hand before I
- 16:33raised my electronic hand. Christian all.
- 16:39Right. Poor lighting in here.
- 16:40I you're going to be disappointed with what I have to
- 16:42say. But I had a job interview like
- 16:4814 years ago or something where they made me do some kind of IQ
- 16:53tests like Raven's Progressive Matrices.
- 16:56And then I didn't get the job. So it's like, it's like a double
- 16:59blow. We did not get a job by by, I
- 17:04assume by virtue of failing an IQ test.
- 17:11That was that was my question. OK, that was your comment.
- 17:14Yes, it is an interesting thing. I can also tell you this, if you
- 17:20score really high, that is to say you have a a super high IQ
- 17:26on on on the test, but you are in a school where they don't
- 17:30provide resources for high achieving students because they
- 17:34don't expect them to be there based on the class of the people
- 17:37that go there. You will not be given the
- 17:39resources to develop your high IQ and it will be of no
- 17:43advantage. That's just the way the system
- 17:46operates. But you will have a brilliant
- 17:52person to park your car. Indeed, for a certain type of
- 18:03brilliance. Thanks, George.
- 18:06Maybe just a side commentary before my real question.
- 18:09If you want to see the, if you're concerned about financial
- 18:12resources, look at Raj Chetty's work.
- 18:14He will convince you more than anyone else other than maybe
- 18:18you, George, that your post code where you're born has more
- 18:22impact on your financial well-being of the course of your
- 18:24life than anything else. It is the big, it is the biggest
- 18:26single predictor. And that is like some of the
- 18:29most. He's spent 18.
- 18:31The guy, the guy's a genius, right?
- 18:32He entered Harvard at 17, had his PhD by age of 20 or
- 18:35something. He's a really smart guy in terms
- 18:38of academic credentials, but his care is a lot.
- 18:41So he's mostly around like what's happening in preschools
- 18:43and public policy around it. So that's Raj Chetty, Raj
- 18:48Chetty. And then in terms of this is
- 18:51going to actually be a segue to my, to my real question.
- 18:55But if you want to get a, a, a research, a neuroscientist
- 18:58research side sense of the role of brain development and
- 19:02learning and the intersection and sorry, the role of
- 19:05relationships. So our our interest in brain
- 19:08development and learning in children and adolescents
- 19:11certainly have a look at Mary Helen in Bardino Gang's work,
- 19:14which the important thing, the salient thing to us in our
- 19:17context here, I think, is that the way that adolescent brains
- 19:21develop and kids really learn is when they interact with each
- 19:25other and dialogue about the meaning of what they're
- 19:27learning. Right.
- 19:30It literally leads to brain development.
- 19:32No great shocker to us. I would I would hope, but she
- 19:34was she was putting that stuff out 25 years ago.
- 19:38And so you know, there's also there's like the resource part.
- 19:41There's like the resource part also got your community
- 19:42resources like what? What are the, you know,
- 19:46attitudes? The the world views and the
- 19:49attachment styles of your classmates makes the difference
- 19:52basically. It does.
- 19:53And on the infant side of that is Gretchen Camera name
- 19:57neuroscientist out of Canada. The book name is nurture, where
- 20:00she just points out that the main thing that makes infant
- 20:03brains develop is literally being physically nurtured by by,
- 20:06you know, mother and other caregivers, right?
- 20:09And that that sets you up. To be able to take advantage of
- 20:13the other things. And I'll just end on saying like
- 20:15I'm an I'm an amazingly gifted bubble filler.
- 20:18I've said I've got anywhere in the world, including not living
- 20:21in my birth country of course, because I can fill that bubbles
- 20:23like nobody's like no one else. I didn't go to school after age
- 20:287 and somehow a the number one ranked Ivy League school for the
- 20:33terminal degrees. I have given 2° because I could
- 20:35fill up bubbles like nobody's business.
- 20:38So just saying, with all of that said, you can still be left at
- 20:41home alone after age 9 by your parents all day, totally
- 20:44neglected and still somehow come out.
- 20:46To your point, George, it's not my selective aptitude so much as
- 20:50like I had an aptitude for taking tests.
- 20:51I'm really, I'm actually really good at it.
- 20:54Right. Because I, because I analyzed
- 20:55the tests and see how they work and they're like, oh, now how
- 20:57the test works. Nice.
- 21:01It doesn't matter what the content is.
- 21:02I know how the test works now. So sorry.
- 21:07This is all recorded for everyone's hopefully benefit and
- 21:12like actual benefit as well as the humorous benefit of it.
- 21:16My real my my question, the reason I raised my hand.
- 21:20Sorry I entered a little late, so maybe if you answered this,
- 21:22forgive me in the way that you introduced the autobiographical
- 21:26childhood memory. I'm wondering if there's any
- 21:30just for attachment or the relation interactions.
- 21:34Is there any implications of having or maybe even like
- 21:37traumatic events or something? Implications of having much more
- 21:42like childhood amnesia for me begins around age 2 as opposed
- 21:46to most people around age 7 or 8 or something, right?
- 21:49And I have quite a collection of fairly clear memories that are
- 21:53verified by their people from about age 2 onward, including.
- 21:58Synthetic, continuous flow of memories or just sporadic?
- 22:04It's interesting you say that because I I try to keep them
- 22:07alive and so there's like a pretty continuous flow from
- 22:09about the age of 3. OK.
- 22:14They're they're shadowy before the age of 2, but I have some
- 22:16like as early as like probably 18 or 19 months that are kind of
- 22:19shadow. Those are the sporadic ones.
- 22:22And I've partly posited this on. I had AI was clinically dead at
- 22:27the age of 2, had a very severe physical trauma that, you know,
- 22:30had to be resuscitated from that coupled with I know that I was
- 22:36speaking and running at the age of nine months and my mother
- 22:39taught me to read before the age of 2.
- 22:41So I had a lot of linguistic ability, which might have been
- 22:45it. But I'm just sort of wondering,
- 22:47would there be some of the component that like something
- 22:50about the relationships with my caregivers and something about,
- 22:53you know, almost did in fact die or was resuscitated.
- 22:57Would that sort of do something to the brain where it would be
- 23:00actually tracking these autobiographical memories now in
- 23:03a way that might not otherwise happen if someone's so young?
- 23:07My understanding is it's it's associated with the the sense of
- 23:11vigilance that the child needs to have.
- 23:14So that the earlier the vigilance, the the more likely
- 23:18you are to have those memories. But that before the normal range
- 23:23of memory, it's sporadic. That is to say, they're episodes
- 23:28that you remember, but it's not a kind of continuous memory.
- 23:33Yeah. OK.
- 23:34Because I mean, again, I would say the continuous stuff still
- 23:36seems early to my recording. Yeah, and and. 3 or 4 but.
- 23:40Probably within the in the curve on the early end of the of the
- 23:44curve. But the early sporadic memories
- 23:46are mainly when when the child has to be vigilant from a very
- 23:51early. Age.
- 23:52OK, that got it. Thank you.
- 23:56And thank you for entertaining my entertainment.
- 24:01But did are you OK? Yeah.
- 24:14So I think one of the things about attachment conditioning
- 24:20and recognizing attachment conditioning, understanding your
- 24:24own attachment conditioning is when once you get into the posts
- 24:31of puberty into the the 20s and the beginning of forming
- 24:36autonomous relationships that are extra to the family system.
- 24:45As you begin to notice these, particularly if you have more
- 24:48than one, these patterns of how they they form and how they come
- 24:53apart. And then that's the thing to
- 24:55begin to look at and recognize your own attachment condition,
- 25:00but also recognizing the attachment conditioning of who
- 25:04you are drawn to in terms of forming relationships.
- 25:08Once you get into your your mid 30s or so, what you'll also
- 25:14notice is that the most commonly available person is on the
- 25:19dismissing end of things because their relationships last the
- 25:22shortest. So they're more available than
- 25:26other people are. Secure people tend to meet and
- 25:31form long lasting relationships and they tend to couple for the
- 25:36first time for substantial periods in their 20s.
- 25:39And so the 20s is a period of secure people meeting and
- 25:44coupling for relationships that will carry them past the 20s,
- 25:48past the 30s into the 40s, into their 40s.
- 25:53And so you'll notice in the beginning of the 20s, there were
- 25:56a lot more secure people available than there are toward
- 26:00the end of your 20s. If you are preoccupied, the most
- 26:04common person that you'll engage in a relationship with is a
- 26:09dismissing person. That's the second most common
- 26:13coupling. If you use the the parameters of
- 26:17the whole society, the distribution, maybe 28 or 30% of
- 26:23the population is secure, 20% are dismissing and 20% are
- 26:29preoccupied. And so that takes up 70% of the
- 26:33population and then 30 or 32% are disorganized, which would be
- 26:41the third most common coupling disorganized with disorganized.
- 26:46So what you recognize is the the pattern of the person that
- 26:51you're drawn to it, the dynamics of those relationships.
- 26:54And if you see in the other person that they're dismissing,
- 26:57you can reflect back on yourself as probably being preoccupied.
- 27:02Or if you're drawn to or a preoccupied person is drawn to
- 27:07you, then it's likely that you are on the dismissing side of
- 27:11things. If you are disorganized and the
- 27:15person that you you're drawn to is disorganized, then it's
- 27:20likely that you are also disorganized.
- 27:22Is that making sense? It's a shorthand.
- 27:28How do you tell if somebody's disorganized, they're
- 27:32unreliable, they have a lot of beginnings, some middles and not
- 27:37many finishes. And in their narrative is the
- 27:40way that they describe the circumstances of your life.
- 27:43That's what you're going to hear.
- 27:45They also tend to begin to withdraw from pursuing actively
- 27:50relationships in their middle 30s because they're disappointed
- 27:54over and over again in relationships not working.
- 27:58And it is actually the disappointment that they begin
- 28:01to avoid entering into the another attempt at forming a
- 28:06relationship, but not really being able to understand exactly
- 28:10why it doesn't go well. And then the relationship
- 28:14becoming troubled and then actually disruptive, often to
- 28:18the point that it makes life harder rather than easier, and
- 28:23then withdrawing from the relationship, dismissing person
- 28:29with a preoccupied person in the organized world can form long
- 28:34lasting relationships. They're transactional, not
- 28:38intimate in the way that secure functioning relationships are.
- 28:44And so, and what we really mean is the care is transactional.
- 28:48I'll do this for you if you do this for me.
- 28:50If you don't do this for me, I won't do that for you.
- 28:53It's a transactional nature. The secure, collaborative nature
- 28:58of relationship is I take on your care and take care of you
- 29:03in the way that you need to be taken care of, and you take on
- 29:06my care and you take care of me in the way that I need to be
- 29:10taken care of. It's very ordinary to encounter
- 29:17problems around that, particularly in insecure
- 29:22relationships. I, from the point of view, say
- 29:28of a dismissing person, you take care of me and I give you stuff.
- 29:31That's how this relationship works.
- 29:34And I give you my demands and you, you, you take care of them
- 29:38and you are. And I allow you to be proximate
- 29:42to me and that that's the nature of the relationship.
- 29:45And if you don't like it, then you can go somewhere else.
- 29:50And the preoccupied person is willing to do that.
- 29:53It it's, it satisfies a few things for them.
- 29:55One is they feel emotionally regulated when they're the
- 30:00person that they regulate is regulated because they're, they
- 30:04displace their own emotional experience for the empathetic
- 30:08experience of the other person. And they don't explore well.
- 30:12And so it's much easier for them to operate in the world if
- 30:16somebody is telling them what it is that they're supposed to do.
- 30:20And then the reward follows for them doing it.
- 30:24So that the the way that it's a kind of secondary exploration
- 30:30where they're they're given the task to do without having to
- 30:34generate the need to do it if they perform it and then there's
- 30:37a reward at the end of it that has some value to them.
- 30:42Is that making sense? Disorganized people, You know,
- 30:52the the thing about disorganized people is that social isolation
- 30:56is the way that they mainly regulate their emotions so that
- 30:58they have to be in relationship to somebody who doesn't mind if
- 31:03they get disregulated, that they don't show up without
- 31:06explanation. And they really the only people
- 31:09that aren't willing to do that are dismissing people 'cause
- 31:11they don't care whether you show up or not as long as when you do
- 31:15you have the juice that they want or other disorganized
- 31:19people because you get a pass for not showing up.
- 31:22Because they can't show up either.
- 31:24It doesn't make the relationship stable.
- 31:26It makes them quite volatile. But still they're willing to be
- 31:35in relationship over time with you because the not showing up
- 31:39pieces and penalize in the same way would it?
- 31:43What you were talking about disorganized people when asked
- 31:46about the narrative about their life, There's there's this
- 31:51beginning, there's. Some Any finishes if any?
- 31:57Yeah, so that's not just for their life story, but any story,
- 32:02right? It could be their trip last
- 32:04week. Right.
- 32:06Literally anything that you're asking will not have a a
- 32:12beginning, middle, and end. Well, what, what you'll notice
- 32:16is a lot of beginning. So if they're giving you a job
- 32:19history, it's a lot of jobs. But that didn't go that far,
- 32:26right? If you listen to my narrative, I
- 32:29have a very typical fearful avoidant narrative.
- 32:35I ran a campaign office for a while.
- 32:37I, I was a, a systems analyst for a while.
- 32:42I worked in nightclubs for a while.
- 32:44I, what else did I do? I, I worked in sales for a
- 32:49while. I, I worked in administration in
- 32:57a college for a while. I mean, there's just these many,
- 33:00many different job things that happen, none of the well, well,
- 33:08maybe well in the job category rather than in, in something
- 33:11that was more likely to lead somewhere.
- 33:16Is that making sense? I don't think I understand this
- 33:19example. So you're asking about job
- 33:21history. It's person is giving job
- 33:23history to you. Well, if you listen to the
- 33:27narrative of somebody and, for instance, you focus on their job
- 33:30history, it's a lot of jobs that didn't go that far, a lot of
- 33:37different jobs. Didn't go that far.
- 33:39Yeah, a lot of different companies.
- 33:44Maybe it's another way to put a lot of different kinds of jobs.
- 33:49Might be another way to think of it.
- 33:51I thought you were saying the way that they describe anything
- 33:56doesn't have a continuity. Oh, not necessarily the the
- 34:01physical structure of the language that they use, although
- 34:05it can be when they're disorganized that there's a lack
- 34:08of coherence. There's also depends on how
- 34:12frightened they are. You'll notice that in
- 34:16disorganized speech, they tend to like to leave a lot of exits.
- 34:21That is to say, they, they, they make the meaning ambiguous so
- 34:25that if they sense that there's disapproval, they can pivot and
- 34:30make the meaning something else. They often have difficulty
- 34:34expressing themselves authentically.
- 34:36So they tell you what they want you to know, but it's in a
- 34:41puzzle so that you have to work out the puzzle so that they have
- 34:47a, a way of deflecting. If, if, if you're disapproving
- 34:50of what they want to say, I, you know, it's, it's rococo is in
- 34:57the way that they organize their speech.
- 35:00A lot of furnish is without any real substance a lot of the
- 35:04time. What are you trying to tell me?
- 35:11That's the, the, the thing that comes into your mind when you're
- 35:14listening to somebody who's disordered fast.
- 35:17What are you? What are you actually trying to
- 35:18tell me 'cause I can't figure it out?
- 35:22I said that was preoccupied also would tend to do a lot of.
- 35:26Well, what do you notice about preoccupied speech is that they
- 35:29leave out all of the natural spaces where you might respond
- 35:36because it's, it's just like a solid wall of words that's
- 35:40coming at you. And you, you would have to be
- 35:43impolite to break into the flow of words in order to reflect
- 35:48back. So we might even talk about it
- 35:50in terms of crisis maxims. The their the volume of words
- 35:55violates A quantity. They have a tendency to change
- 36:03the topic, change the the agreed topic, which is the violation of
- 36:09relevancy. And the reason that they do that
- 36:12is that they want the tension to remain on them.
- 36:16And the way that they succeeded that is by continuously changing
- 36:20the topic until they land on a topic that only they can talk
- 36:23about. So once they've managed to do
- 36:27that, then they're the only person who could comment on it
- 36:30because they're the only person who knows anything about it.
- 36:33That would be that would feel like a successful maneuvering of
- 36:39the conversation. But what they would miss is that
- 36:42nobody else is interested in the topic.
- 36:46And then they lose the attention of the people that they're
- 36:50trying to hold the attention of. And it's confusing to them why
- 36:54they're losing the attention, not understanding that when you
- 36:59keep switching the agreed topic to something that only you can
- 37:02talk about, the reason that only you can talk about it is nobody
- 37:05else is interested in. Whereas if you had allowed it to
- 37:09stay on a topic that had general interests in the group, when
- 37:13when your turn came and you could add something to it that
- 37:16was relevant to the group, the whole group would be interested.
- 37:23But because they're in pretend mode, most of the time they
- 37:25don't have genuine interests that they might use as a as a
- 37:29way of guiding that. So that's what you notice about
- 37:36them. They're the there's a lot of
- 37:39different violations that they make.
- 37:41Crisis is a good way of understanding conversation and
- 37:45content. Dismissing people will hold the
- 37:51entire attention of the group and they'll do it, but not in
- 37:57the way that preoccupied people. Preoccupied people do it by
- 38:01violating the consent of the group and dismissing people
- 38:07licensed. The set the the, the the group
- 38:10into giving them permission to dominate the conversation by
- 38:16making it more entertaining, by making it more interesting, by
- 38:22making it feel good to the people that are participating.
- 38:28So they're they engage in the kind of idealization where
- 38:31people feel intoxicated by the conversation that's happening
- 38:37and give their permission for the dismissing person to take
- 38:42too much of the bandwidth. Is that making sense?
- 38:47So when you get around somebody who's really charismatic, of
- 38:50course you cede your time to them so that they'll present
- 38:54themselves in a way that's very appealing to you, because it
- 38:59makes you feel good to be in that experience.
- 39:03But when you reflect back on it, you realize, of course, that
- 39:06they just juiced you. That is to say, they they just
- 39:10stripped the psychic juice from you without you really having
- 39:14much control over or much participation in that happening.
- 39:18But it felt really good, which is the mastery of that kind of
- 39:29dismissing charisma that idealize it crisp.
- 39:36Yeah. If you if you're with somebody
- 39:37and you feel totally intoxicated and completely drained, then
- 39:44you're likely hanging out with a dismissing person who's just
- 39:49like a succubus juicing you. It's not about the quantity of
- 39:57words or the dismissive. They can also speak a lot, just.
- 40:01Right. Yeah, totally.
- 40:03Then it's not a violation of quantity because they've
- 40:06licensed it from you. You've given them permission to
- 40:08do it, whereas the preoccupied person usually doesn't get
- 40:11permission to do it. They just take it they.
- 40:15Interfering. Yeah, You'll notice in the
- 40:19sentence pattern, the first sentence is along the lines of
- 40:22the topic that's talked about. And they make a break and
- 40:25introduce a new topic. And then if somebody else can
- 40:29contribute to it, they repeat the pattern until they land on
- 40:31one where nobody else knows anything.
- 40:33And then they pursue that topic. And there isn't.
- 40:38You can when you what you'll what you'll notice is there's a
- 40:44group of people chatting and then a preoccupied person enters
- 40:48the group because they want to be in that circle of attention.
- 40:52And a short time later the group disbands that from the outside.
- 40:56That's what it looks like. The I think really all you have
- 41:08to do is say, let me, let me look at what's happening here
- 41:12through the lens of attachment, See if I can begin to
- 41:17understand. The most rigid and easiest to
- 41:21identify is the dismissing person 'cause they're the least
- 41:24flexible, the least mobile. The hardest one to track is the
- 41:29secure person because they're the most dynamic and the most
- 41:32adaptable and most flexible. The preoccupied person is the
- 41:36one that once they get a hold of the conversation, you have to
- 41:40pry the words apart to get any your ability to participate in
- 41:44it. And the dismissing the the
- 41:48disorganized person on the avoided and are absolutely the
- 41:53sweetest person you're likely to be.
- 41:58But but it's very hard to find much substance there.
- 42:03And the fearfully preoccupied people are usually demanding and
- 42:13and so they tend to be much harder to manage in terms of
- 42:19willingness to to participate with them.
- 42:23George, is there a book on this Hut or is this on the
- 42:26attachment, the behavior based stuff that you just talked
- 42:28about? The pretty much any relational
- 42:35book that you can find will describe dismissing in
- 42:43preoccupied relationships. Like there is a book, I think
- 42:48the most popular book still is called Attached and it describes
- 42:52basically preoccupied and dismissing attachment.
- 42:57It it says that it won't. They don't discuss disorganized
- 43:01relationships because there's so few disorganized people.
- 43:04But what they really mean is disorganized people have no
- 43:08resources and they don't buy books.
- 43:09So why should we write a chapter on?
- 43:14Them. Yeah, that book.
- 43:15Sucks. I like the Wallen, the Wallen
- 43:22book because it has a chapter in the middle of it that describes
- 43:26the different attachment strategies and that that that's
- 43:29pretty good. Dan's book describes is the best
- 43:33on disorganized attachment in terms of describing it and then
- 43:37the relational dynamics between the the groups.
- 43:43Secure people tend to go with secure people because they they
- 43:47don't put up with not having that complete skill set.
- 43:52Dismissing people tend to go with helplessly preoccupied
- 43:56people or other dismissing people.
- 44:00They don't go with secure people because they don't reciprocate
- 44:03and collaborative is the name of the game for secure people.
- 44:08They will even go with disorganized people, but but
- 44:12they don't rely so much on those relationships because and it
- 44:16doesn't matter to them that they're not reliable as long as
- 44:19they show up. The David Wallin A
- 44:25psychotherapy, an attachment. I think it's called an
- 44:28attachment in psychotherapy. You might even read a general
- 44:33theory of love. I think that's pretty good,
- 44:35although it's 20 years old at least now.
- 44:40Maybe you should write a book on this also.
- 44:44Yes, the preoccupied people can go with secure people, and often
- 44:55for them it's even healing of attachment.
- 44:57Because the secure person shows up so reliably, their
- 45:01preoccupation doesn't activate. But it can also be deleterious
- 45:06to the secure functioning person, because if they get
- 45:10caught up in pretend mode and they don't notice it for quite a
- 45:14long time, because the preoccupied person in pretend
- 45:19mode is pretending to be attached, that they could walk
- 45:23out on the relationship. And it would be quite
- 45:25devastating to somebody who was actually attached to have
- 45:29attached to somebody that was only pretending to attach.
- 45:33So the preoccupied person would move on very rapidly and the
- 45:37dismissing person would be quite bereft.
- 45:42Secure people won't be in relationships too much with
- 45:45disorganized people because they're not reliable.
- 45:47Dismissing people are totally happy to be in relationship to
- 45:51disorganized people as long as they show up with Jews
- 45:55Preoccupied people Organized preoccupied people tend to not
- 45:59want to be in relationship disorganized with disorganized
- 46:02people. Because disorganized people
- 46:04withdraw to regulate and preoccupied people need
- 46:08proximity to regulate, disorganized people tend to
- 46:15fearful avoidant people tend to form relationships with either
- 46:19fearful avoidant or fearfully preoccupied people are complexly
- 46:23disorganized people, and fearfully preoccupied people
- 46:26also tend to form relationships with dismissing people.
- 46:31Anybody who's empathetic has a hard time forming a relationship
- 46:34with a fearfully preoccupied person because they're in
- 46:38tantrum mode most of the time, which is this very intense
- 46:42internal emotional state. And if you're empathetic at all,
- 46:45you can't, you can't deal with the intensity.
- 46:48But strongly dismissing people don't feel anything and they're
- 46:52not empathetic. So it doesn't matter to them
- 46:54that you're in a in a tornado the whole time, as long as you
- 46:59provide for them what they want. Is that making sense?
- 47:06So why don't we do a little bit of practice?
- 47:08What would you like to do? OK, go over the meditation.
- 47:21How's that? Good.
- 47:24So let's see, we started Level 2 today on Thursday at 4:30 in the
- 47:28afternoon. If you want to join that, you
- 47:31still can. And then what's coming up on the
- 47:3812th? We're starting a new Level 1,
- 47:42which is running for three Saturdays, the 12th, 18th and
- 47:49then 26th. Is it?
- 47:51No, 19th and 26th, Yeah. I'm giving a talk on July 20th
- 48:00at Open Door Dharma, which is in Los Angeles.
- 48:03So every now and then I do something in person.
- 48:05And if you happen to be in Los Angeles and want to drop by,
- 48:09it's from noon to 1:30. What else we got coming up?
- 48:18Going to do Level 1 addiction, which is on starting on
- 48:27Saturday, August 9th for three Saturdays.
- 48:31So the 9th, the 16th and the 23rd.
- 48:38I'm doing another Open Door Dharma on August 24th.
- 48:49Looking to see and then I'm going to do the exploration
- 48:57series Saturday, the 13th of September and then the 20th of
- 49:03September and then the summer will be over and we'll be into
- 49:08the fall. So if any of that's interesting
- 49:14to you, it's up on the website. Take a look at it.
- 49:17Really appreciate your practice. I'm glad you came Ioffer the
- 49:22teaching freely. But if you're able to make a
- 49:25donation, I do appreciate it. It helps support me and also the
- 49:28work Medigroup is doing. There's a link on the website to
- 49:30make a donation. Good to see you.
- 49:33Hope to see you soon. Bye.