Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Zeigarnik Effect to Build Influence at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that feeling when you walk away from a conversation and you can't stop thinking about it because the other person didn't quite finish their thought? Luna: Oh, absolutely. It's like a mental itch. I'll be replaying it in my head all day. Lucas: Right. That's actually a well-studied cognitive phenomenon — it's called the Zeigarnik effect. The psychologist Bluma Zeigarnik noticed back in the 1920s that waiters could remember complex orders only until the food was delivered. Once the task was done, they forgot it. Luna: So our brains hold onto unfinished tasks more tightly than finished ones. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a huge lever in office politics. If you can strategically leave things unfinished — a sentence, a proposal, a request — people's brains will keep chewing on it. And they'll associate that mental energy with you. Luna: Okay, I love this. But before we go deeper — and I know this isn't a huge show, but a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. If you've gotten something out of the podcast, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It makes a real difference. Lucas: Yeah, absolutely. We don't have ads, and listener support is the only reason we can keep digging into these topics. So if this helps you think through a career move or a tricky situation, that's the place. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: And we really mean it — even a small amount adds up. Okay, back to Zeigarnik. So how do you actually use this without being manipulative? Lucas: Great question. Let me give you a concrete example. Say you're in a meeting pitching a new initiative, and you've laid out three reasons it should be approved. But instead of finishing with 'So that's why we should do it,' you pause after reason number two and say, 'There's a third reason, but I want to let that sink in first. Let me come back to it.' Luna: And now everyone's waiting for reason number three. They're hooked. Lucas: Exactly. They'll be thinking about it during the rest of the meeting, and when you finally deliver it, it lands with more weight. The unfinished business creates a gravitational pull. Luna: I can see how that works in a live setting. What about email? Because that's where a lot of office politics happens these days. Lucas: Email is actually perfect for this. One tactic: send a Friday afternoon email that outlines a problem or a question, but don't include the solution. Say something like 'I've been thinking about this and I'd love your take — I have a few ideas but I'm curious what you think first.' Luna: So you're leaving the loop open over the weekend. Lucas: Right. And on Monday morning, you're top of mind because their brain has been subconsciously working on it. You haven't been pushy — you've just planted a seed that their own mind watered. Luna: That's clever. But I have to ask — where's the line between influence and manipulation? Because if someone realizes you're doing this deliberately, they might feel played. Lucas: That's a fair point. And I think the key is intent and transparency. The Zeigarnik effect is a tool — it's not inherently good or bad. If you're using it to get your idea heard in a noisy environment, that's influence. If you're using it to create anxiety or pressure someone into a decision, that's manipulation. Luna: So it's about whether you're adding value or just creating unease. Lucas: Exactly. A good rule of thumb: if the unfinished thing you're leaving behind is a genuine question or a valuable insight, it's fine. If it's a vague threat or a dangling obligation, you're crossing a line. Luna: Let me give you a real example from my own experience. I had a product manager who used this really effectively. She wanted to get a feature prioritized, but she knew the engineering lead was skeptical. So she pitched the idea in a meeting, but deliberately left out the data on customer impact. She said, 'I have the numbers but I want to make sure the reasoning is solid first. Let me share those tomorrow.' Lucas: And what happened? Luna: The engineering lead emailed her that evening asking for the data. He wanted to see it before the next meeting. She'd created enough curiosity that he came to her, instead of her having to push. Lucas: That's a textbook example. She used the effect to flip the power dynamic. Instead of being the asker, she became the source of the answer. Luna: Exactly. And when she shared the data the next day, he was already primed to accept it because he'd been thinking about the problem. Lucas: One more variation: you can use it in one-on-ones with your manager. If you have a career development ask or a request for a project, bring it up near the end of the conversation. Say, 'I had something I wanted to discuss, but we're out of time. Can I send you a note?' Luna: And now it's on their radar. They're wondering what it is. Lucas: Right. And when you follow up, they're more likely to give it attention because the unfinished loop is already open. But you have to follow up — if you don't, the effect fades and you look disorganized. Luna: So the timing of the closure matters too. You want to leave it open long enough to create tension, but not so long that it becomes irrelevant. Lucas: Exactly. A few hours to a day is usually the sweet spot. Anything longer and people start to forget or get annoyed. Luna: I want to talk about the flip side though. Can the Zeigarnik effect work against you? Like if you're the one who's always leaving things unresolved, doesn't that make you seem flaky? Lucas: Absolutely. If you overuse it, people start to see you as someone who never finishes anything. The effect only works if you eventually deliver. It's a spice, not the main ingredient. Luna: So you need a reputation for following through, otherwise the unfinished thing just looks like incompetence. Lucas: Right. And that's the ethical safeguard too — if you're genuinely going to complete the thought or deliver the data, then it's a legitimate communication strategy. If you're just leaving things hanging to manipulate attention, it backfires. Luna: Let me ask you this — are there situations where you should absolutely not use the Zeigarnik effect? Lucas: Yes. Crisis situations. If something urgent is happening, do not leave things unfinished. People need clarity and closure. Also, don't use it with people who are already anxious or overwhelmed — you'll just add to their cognitive load. Luna: Good point. It's about reading the room. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing — don't use it in written performance reviews or feedback. Those need to be complete and unambiguous. The Zeigarnik effect is for conversations where you want to build engagement, not for formal evaluations. Luna: So the takeaway is: use it sparingly, with genuine intent, and always follow through. Lucas: That's it. And remember, the goal is to make your ideas more memorable, not to make yourself more mysterious. If people walk away thinking 'I need to hear what they have to say,' you've done it right. Luna: I think the product manager example really drives it home. She didn't tricks — she just structured her communication to align with how brains naturally work. Lucas: And that's really the heart of office politics — understanding how people think, and working with that, not against it.