Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: West of Shetland shakeups and Labour take the fight to Reform
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:09the UK energy market. This week it was all kicking off
- 0:15on the West of Shetland and of course, Labour had its party
- 0:19conference. There's a big couple of topics.
- 0:22I'm not going to be able to do that on my own.
- 0:24I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, and joining me this week
- 0:27is news reporter Matthew Perry. How are you today, Matt?
- 0:30I'm doing well, I'm not looking as sun kissed and refreshed as
- 0:34as you are after your little trip away to Tenerife.
- 0:37Yeah, I'm, I'm sure the listeners were longing for me
- 0:40last week when I wasn't on an episode.
- 0:42I'm sure, I'm sure you're all very hurt when I don't show up.
- 0:45I was often Tenerife for a week. I was doing yoga.
- 0:47It was that yoga retreat through my girlfriend getting a press
- 0:50trip. But it was, it was really
- 0:51interesting. Not something I'd usually sign
- 0:53up for. Sounds lovely, but I'm actually
- 0:56as interesting as that sounds. I'm more interested in where
- 0:58Floyd's been in the past week. That is very true.
- 1:01I feel like he's probably done more than I have.
- 1:04Floyd, how are you doing? Yeah, I'm good.
- 1:07I'm a little bit fatigued from the party conference circuit
- 1:10over the last coming weeks and I've got the Conservative 1 next
- 1:13week. So yeah, it's non-stop on the
- 1:16party conference tour for me. At least you didn't have to get
- 1:19serenaded by is it Dame Andrea Jenkins who was gave a stunning
- 1:24rendition of a. Yeah, that's right.
- 1:27But yeah, I was kind of hoping Andy Burnham would come and do
- 1:30some kind of like Oasis song or something, but yeah, don't think
- 1:33he's in great favour with Starmer at the moment.
- 1:35So maybe, maybe next year. Keeping.
- 1:37Off the the the stage lights. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:42Do you know Floyd, your job titles, NW correspondent?
- 1:45I feel like you're quickly becoming political correspondent
- 1:47with all these all these party conferences.
- 1:50Yeah. For sure, we should probably
- 1:52leave that to the end, keep the keep them waiting because there
- 1:55is a lot to talk about on on that.
- 1:58But as I mentioned at the top of the show, there is also a lot
- 2:02happening in the West of Shetland.
- 2:04This week we saw Sarika finally complete an M and a deal.
- 2:09You know, they've been teasing the idea of expansion through
- 2:12mergers and acquisitions for some time now since Chris Cox
- 2:16took over the company and this week they delivered by picking
- 2:22up some of Prax's assets. Now you might remember Prax as
- 2:26the Bermo and closing down energy company that started off
- 2:31with a couple of petrol stations and then ended up owning the
- 2:34Lancaster field. They were planning on buying the
- 2:37Greater Lagan area and Shetland Gas plant from Total Energies,
- 2:42but then that fell through when they went into administration
- 2:46and there was a lot of sort of toing and froing around that.
- 2:50This week CERICA bought those assets, the Lancaster field in
- 2:55the West of Shetland, the Greater Lagan area in the same
- 2:58region, and of course the Shetland Gas plant from the
- 3:02firm's administrators for around 19,000,000 lbs.
- 3:07So this sort of offered a little bit of clarity because, you
- 3:10know, around the time that practice went belly up, I think
- 3:13is the technical term we'll use. Total were retaining ownership,
- 3:18but they were clearly looking to offload these assets.
- 3:21And now Circus swooped in and obviously they're claiming this
- 3:24is a great, great deal for them as as well they should.
- 3:27This is, this is a part of the overall strategy.
- 3:30People may remember that they were, you know, trying to sort
- 3:32of merge with inquest earlier in the, in the year and that sort
- 3:37of fell through. I, I, you know, I was speaking
- 3:40to Chris Cox at Offshore Europe and he was saying there's big
- 3:43M&E deals on the horizon. I can't really tell you anything
- 3:47about it, but you know, sorry, keep you, I'll keep you posted.
- 3:50Now, Chris, I hate to tell you, I wasn't kept posted on this
- 3:53one. I felt like this was a bit, a
- 3:55bit of a blind side move, but hey, congratulations to Sarah
- 3:58and Chris. That was obviously delivering
- 4:01the strategy and something that happened on the exact same
- 4:05morning, which I feel like was definitely planned, but who
- 4:08knows, it might. It might just be coincidence as
- 4:11Shell brought on its Victory field in the West of Shetland as
- 4:15well. Now why am I mentioning that?
- 4:19Well, it goes through the Greater Lagan area and gas from
- 4:23Victory is piped straight to the Shetland gas plant before being
- 4:26further piped over to the mainland and landing in Saint
- 4:30Fergus. So, you know, previously Kistos,
- 4:34a shareholder in the Greater Lagan area, had spoken about how
- 4:40when Victory comes online, this is going to improve operating
- 4:43expenditure. Obviously that makes sense.
- 4:46The the more gas quantities go through, you know, the sort of
- 4:49cheaper it gets to operate. That makes sense.
- 4:53So this this came as a really sort of serendipitous move for
- 4:57Sarika, right? You know, just as they take over
- 5:00or the announcement goes through that they're going to be taking
- 5:02over, things look a little bit rosier in the West of Shetland.
- 5:07Well, it's a great bit of deal making from Sarika because I
- 5:10think if I recall, Prax had snapped up the Lancaster field,
- 5:15which is sort of in, in that West of Shetland, Greater Lagan
- 5:19area from Hurricane Energy for around £250 million in 2023.
- 5:24So 2 years later, Ceraco is picking that up at the, you
- 5:27know, at the, at the garage sale, the, you know, put all
- 5:30the, the assets out on and Praxis failed a company to snap
- 5:34up cheaply and for £19 million, that's a a pretty decent bit of,
- 5:37of deal making. Wellington's has just sort of
- 5:41posted about the analyst firm and they they said that it you
- 5:45know, brings a lot of material upside for Viserika.
- 5:48They're acquiring producing barrels at a very low cost and
- 5:51they sort of benefit from one of the lowest decommissioning
- 5:53liabilities in the UK. They don't have a lot of near
- 5:56term expenditure in on the horizon for for that.
- 5:59So it seems like a good bit of expansion for Viserika there.
- 6:03And there's obviously we, we we joke about Praxis.
- 6:07It's obviously a very unfortunate time for a lot of
- 6:09the people employed and down in in the Lindsay refinery.
- 6:11But you know, I am looking forward to one day seeing the
- 6:15Netflix series or something dramatizing this because it
- 6:18seems I've been you do wonder how this is all, you know, gone,
- 6:21gone down with with the the Praxis owners seemingly having
- 6:26run, run off to Dubai And then. So it'd be interesting to see
- 6:30what what comes of this. The Netflix documentary, Why
- 6:33don't Energy Voice do it? Remember how good our Rosebank
- 6:36documentary was, Matt? And Speaking of Rosebank, that's
- 6:40another West of Shetland development and there was some
- 6:43news there as well. Now, as we mentioned, I was off
- 6:45on holiday last week, so I was, I was sort of relaxing, not
- 6:50really paying attention to this. But Matt, you could tell us a
- 6:53little bit about an environmental impact assessment,
- 6:55right? Well, I mean, it was auspicious
- 6:58timing from, from Ecuador really when they submitted this because
- 7:02it came out kind of like late on a on a Friday, which is, you
- 7:06know, what you tend to do when you don't want things or people
- 7:09to, to pay attention to the, the news that gets announced on a,
- 7:11on a Friday. How cynical you are.
- 7:14Obviously this all goes back to way, way back to if people
- 7:18remember a thing called the Finch case.
- 7:19I won't go through the whole details, but you know,
- 7:22environmental campaigners launched a legal challenge
- 7:25against an onshore oil well that was held up basically said that
- 7:30the fossil fuel projects in the UK have to take account of the
- 7:33scope 3 emissions. Obviously Rosebank, one of the
- 7:36major ones, hadn't done that. That was then challenged
- 7:40alongside Shell's Jackdaw project by Greenpeace and
- 7:43Uplift. Their approvals were overturned.
- 7:46The Labour government has updated the environmental impact
- 7:49assessment guidance and now we're at the point where Equinor
- 7:52has obviously gone through, they've ticked all their boxes,
- 7:55dotted all their IS and crossed their T's and they've now
- 7:58resubmitted that. And I guess what you know, will
- 8:02will be interesting to see is, is where, you know, the decision
- 8:07that it's eventually made by by Ed Miliband on on this one,
- 8:10senior Labour figures like Chancellor Rachel Reeve is Ed
- 8:13voice support for that and, and sort of said that they don't
- 8:15want to see these projects not going ahead.
- 8:18So, you know, I guess we would assume that they will eventually
- 8:22receive their their approvals. You know, the courts have
- 8:25allowed development work to continue on both Rosebank and
- 8:28Jackdaw. So it, it will be interesting to
- 8:30see, I guess what, you know, as it reaches closer, whether we
- 8:34see, you know, a, a resurgence of those really widespread
- 8:39protests that we we often saw down in in London and other
- 8:42areas of the UK against Roy's bank.
- 8:43Whether that becomes, I guess, very, very topical in the news
- 8:47again or kind of whether shell in in Ecuador soon to be a
- 8:51juror, kind of just just carry on.
- 8:54And, you know, you talk about being cynical, Ryan.
- 8:57I wonder whether how much of this new branding comes from
- 9:01Ecuador not no longer wanting to be associated with with Roy's
- 9:04bank anymore. Well, do you know, I think we
- 9:06spoke about at the time as well when they announced that.
- 9:09And obviously, you know, it was around the time of the Jackdaw
- 9:12Rosebank as a court case. And we did kind of joke in the
- 9:17old first. Well, if if they're all under
- 9:19one roof, that's only one set of lawyers fees rather than two.
- 9:23But yes, was a juror, you know, a juror could potentially stand
- 9:27to gain from Rosebank if this time it gets approved.
- 9:30Obviously the government announced that sort of guidance
- 9:33and scope 3 earlier in the year. And no doubt Ecuador feel like
- 9:37they can they can sort of square that circle if if they've
- 9:42submitted this EIA or you could argue that they've spent as much
- 9:46money on it now that they've kind of got to take a punt
- 9:48regardless. But a jurors also a way to sort
- 9:51of get a quick win in the form of victory as well.
- 9:54You know, I think I wrote about it earlier in the week that the
- 9:58majority of victories gas will be produced by 2030.
- 10:04So, you know, a nice quick win for for a Dura to boost
- 10:08production as they as they come on the stream.
- 10:11But that does it for this segment.
- 10:13Thank you for providing your insights, Matt, And more
- 10:16importantly, thank you for picking up my slack for the
- 10:19Rosebank stuff from when I was on holiday.
- 10:23Stick around because after this break, our editor has been over
- 10:26in gas tech and we're going to show show you just one of his
- 10:30many, many conversations he had there.
- 11:20So as I said before the break, Mark Selby, our editor was over
- 11:25in Milan in gas techs a couple of weeks ago and he was speaking
- 11:29to Zubin Bamji, Manager of the World Bank's Flaring and Methane
- 11:35Reduction Partnership. Now, flaring is a a big issue in
- 11:40the North Sea as we're looking to hit 0 routine flaring under
- 11:44the NSTA guideline guidelines. Well, it's an issue everywhere
- 11:48and that's something they discussed and tackling the
- 11:51underlying issues around the practice as well as the
- 11:55likelihood of hitting 2030 targets.
- 11:59But I'm going to stop flapping my gums because you want to hear
- 12:02what he had to say. So the the World Bank launched
- 12:05the zero routine flaring by 20-30 initiative almost a decade
- 12:09ago. How much progress has been made?
- 12:11And like, maybe if you could give us an outline of how this
- 12:13initiative got started and where it's headed?
- 12:15Yeah, thanks. Happy to do that.
- 12:17So we started the initiative, as you said about a decade ago.
- 12:21And the reason we started the initiative is because we have
- 12:24the sense that this was an important not just for the
- 12:28climate, but important in the developing world.
- 12:30You have half a billion people that still have no access to
- 12:34energy, mostly in Africa, but in other countries as well.
- 12:38And then the third reason we started the initiative is
- 12:42besides the climate and the energy access issues, there's
- 12:45also the economic issues. There's a tremendous amount of
- 12:49gas that's wasted through flaring and methane emissions in
- 12:52oil and gas infrastructure. Then the fourth reason is energy
- 12:57security, and you might have heard a lot of that energy
- 13:00security being an issue in the last few years.
- 13:03So we launched this initiative about a decade ago and the idea
- 13:06was to raise the visibility of flaring and methane as an
- 13:10important issue that oil and gas companies and operators and
- 13:14governments need to address. And then just sort of set a
- 13:17target for industry and governments as well.
- 13:20Because at the time, leading into the Paris COP, there wasn't
- 13:24a lot of visibility on this issue.
- 13:26So we thought this was the two reasons that we would launch it.
- 13:29Now as far as progress is concerned, some progress has
- 13:33been made. We have over 100 governments and
- 13:36oil companies, gas companies that have made this commitment.
- 13:40But the progress has been slow, especially in the developing
- 13:43world where you have a lack of resources or you still have
- 13:48issues of making these difficult choices between do we address
- 13:53this issue or that issue. But what we're happy to see is
- 13:58that those companies and governments that have endorsed
- 14:01the Zero Routine Flaring initiative are performing better
- 14:04and have made substantive progress, especially when it
- 14:07comes to flaring intensity. Flaring intensity is the amount
- 14:11of gas flared per barrel of oil produced as opposed to the
- 14:15overall volume of gas that's been flared.
- 14:19So we've seen about a 12% reduction in flaring intensity
- 14:23in those countries and those companies that have actually
- 14:27made the commitment to 0 routine flaring.
- 14:29So some progress, but in the next 5 years we need to see a.
- 14:33Lot more. Obviously energy security is a
- 14:36huge theme at this conference and it's come up especially in
- 14:38the keynote speeches yesterday. Obviously you've touched on this
- 14:42to a certain extent, but why, you know, in your, how would you
- 14:45articulate why, why it's so important to eliminate methane
- 14:50and, and flaring generally? And like their role in, and
- 14:54there's a lot of, you know, dispute around the optics on
- 14:58climate change and what contributes and what doesn't and
- 15:00so on. But yeah, like, what?
- 15:03What What do you see is their role in in climate change and
- 15:05also wasted energy potential? Yeah, that's exactly right,
- 15:08right. So it's not just the climate
- 15:10aspects of it. And even now, when we've seen
- 15:13politically, perhaps some countries and governments not
- 15:16paying as much attention to the climate agenda as perhaps they
- 15:19had previously, you have to recognize that this is not just
- 15:23a climate issue. In many developing countries.
- 15:26You have, again, this lack of access to energy.
- 15:29In many developing countries, you also have energy security
- 15:34issues. And so these are the reasons why
- 15:38people need to pay attention to it.
- 15:40And then again, in a lot of these developing countries, as a
- 15:42country we're working in just now where we did a pilot program
- 15:46on methane emissions and identifying them and mitigating
- 15:50those emissions leaks, if you will, the future to break their
- 15:53emissions. And we discovered that if they
- 15:56just kept that gas in the pipeline, in their value chain,
- 16:00in their system, they would save millions of dollars annually.
- 16:05So what we've said to these companies and and governments is
- 16:09if you fix these leaks, if you address your flaring, you're
- 16:12going to see more revenue generated for your country as
- 16:15well as your company. And then that money, What you
- 16:18should do if you were looking at this as in a programmatic long
- 16:22term approach so that these things don't happen in the
- 16:24future again, is reinvest a portion of that money that
- 16:28you've saved by selling the additional gas into your system.
- 16:32And constantly do these leak detection and repair campaigns.
- 16:37And use that money to continuously monitor your
- 16:40infrastructure and your gas value chain to ensure that
- 16:43you're not losing this money, you're not losing the gas that
- 16:46could be utilized for all sorts of economically productive
- 16:50purposes as well. Yeah.
- 16:52So in terms of that, that mission for zero routine flaring
- 16:56by 20-30, what has been achieved so far in terms of that, you
- 17:00know that road to trying to hit that target and what where do
- 17:05you see the gaps? Yeah, The gaps are really not in
- 17:07technology, Mark. The technology exists, whether
- 17:11it's modular types of technologies, because, you know,
- 17:14with flaring, it's a real challenge.
- 17:16You've got countries where the oil production takes place in
- 17:19remote regions, perhaps in the middle of Siberia, as it's the
- 17:23case with Russia. In other countries in Latin
- 17:25America, could be in the middle of the Amazon rainforest.
- 17:29So how do you address the emissions in those cases?
- 17:33How do you get rid of the flaring?
- 17:34And you can't just build a pipeline through a rainforest.
- 17:37It's it's not feasible, it's not economically viable.
- 17:40Be a bit counterintuitive given the whole.
- 17:43Yes, exactly. So there are modular solutions
- 17:46in those cases. So some companies and operators,
- 17:49what they're doing is they're taking that associated gas and
- 17:53they're using it to generate power in their own operations
- 17:56right there in that same vicinity.
- 17:59Or you could see in a place like Africa where the gas flaring is
- 18:04taking place in a remote village, but the village still
- 18:08doesn't have access to energy. So why wouldn't you take that
- 18:12associated gas that's currently being wasted and find a way to
- 18:15generate power for the villagers?
- 18:18So those types of solutions exist and also the the
- 18:23regulations exist. So there are many countries
- 18:26around the world that have put in good effective regulations
- 18:30and those regulations then incentivize these oil companies
- 18:33and governments rather than wastefully flaring the gas, they
- 18:37would actually then find it more economically viable to do
- 18:41something with that gas. But you have to have the
- 18:44enforcement side of the regulation.
- 18:46So you see some countries where they have good effective
- 18:48regulations in place, but then they're not enforcing that
- 18:52regulation and they're not monitoring it effectively to
- 18:55make sure that the operators within their jurisdiction are
- 18:59actually complying. So where the real problem
- 19:02exists, Mark, is in the financing and the economic side
- 19:05of things. And that's where the World Bank
- 19:07is coming in and helping these operators and governments
- 19:11identify economically viable solutions.
- 19:14There are some cases where you know again, you're going to be
- 19:18able to generate additional revenue and some of these
- 19:20projects can be done at a, you know, a net negative loss.
- 19:25So you're not actually you're actually not even worried about
- 19:29the money that's being spent. And we estimate there's quite a
- 19:33few projects around the world that that would be the case if
- 19:37the operator again just focused on that and made this a priority
- 19:42and had the political will to do something about it.
- 19:45So that's really where the the gap exists.
- 19:48It's on the financing and the economic side of things and the
- 19:51political will, as as always is the case.
- 19:53Yeah. So, I mean, obviously financial
- 19:55incentives are going to be a huge part of the, you know, the,
- 19:58the, the issue of persuasion and trying to.
- 20:01Help coax. Governments and companies into
- 20:03actually doing the right thing in this, but I mean there are
- 20:07there any other ways that you are helping governments so or
- 20:10companies to overcome barriers? Yeah, there are.
- 20:13So we started a new trust fund just last year.
- 20:16It's called the Global Flaring and Methane Reduction
- 20:18Partnership. This is a fund that's supported
- 20:21by governments like the UAE, strong support from the UAE, the
- 20:25United States of America, Norway, similar leading oil
- 20:28producing countries in the world, and then a lot of the
- 20:31international oil companies like Shell, BP, ENI, Ecuadora,
- 20:35Occidental, they all contributing to this fund.
- 20:39And what we want to do with this new trust fund at the World Bank
- 20:42is 2 things. We'll continue to provide
- 20:44developing country governments with technical advice, technical
- 20:48assistance, help them create the enabling environment, if you
- 20:52will, to make gas flaring and methane reduction far more
- 20:56viable. And then on the other side, what
- 20:58we also will do is provide some grab funding to these operators.
- 21:02So in the developing world, you know, lack of resources is of
- 21:06course one of the main issues for them.
- 21:08So what hope to do is provide some grant funding.
- 21:11We call it catalytic because if the World Bank comes in and
- 21:15identifies a project with some good grant funding, then there's
- 21:19a good chance that other lending institutions, whether they be
- 21:23concessional financiers, commercial financiers, would
- 21:27say, look, this might be a project that we could also come
- 21:30in and support with the World Bank providing a little bit of a
- 21:32risk assurance and also contributing some financing.
- 21:36In that case, we've already started to, we do that in some
- 21:39countries in Central Asia and are starting to yield some
- 21:43really good results that we're excited about that hopefully we
- 21:47can replicate in other countries around the world.
- 21:51If you look at the magnitude of the problem too, Mark, this is
- 21:54the issue, right? If you were to say that methane
- 21:57emissions are the second largest contributor to climate change
- 22:00after CO2, however, it's a far more potent greenhouse gas.
- 22:06And if you look at methane emissions, you're talking about
- 22:09the oil and gas sector being responsible for somewhere around
- 22:131/3 of all methane emissions globally.
- 22:15So it's a huge chunk. Now within that third, you could
- 22:18say the developing world, all of these national oil companies in
- 22:21the developing world are primarily responsible, about 50%
- 22:26responsible for all the methane emissions.
- 22:28So World Bank has a really good case to make why they should be
- 22:32engaged in this and why the support is needed.
- 22:35Again, it's not just the climate, it's also the economic,
- 22:39you know, value that's lost. It's also the energy access
- 22:42issues. And then it's also the energy
- 22:45security as everybody has been talking about for the last few
- 22:48years. And finally, in terms of the
- 22:50road ahead, because obviously there's still a way to go to
- 22:542030, let alone to 2050, you know, what are the realistic,
- 22:58what do you see as the realistic prospects for eliminating
- 23:01routine flaring? Is 20-30 really realistic?
- 23:04Is that just, you know, a challenging target as is, you
- 23:07know, the wire 2030 target? And what would be your message
- 23:11to those who might be a bit hesitant in this process?
- 23:14Yeah, that's a good question. And and I'll be honest here,
- 23:16look when we launched the initiative A decade ago, we did
- 23:20think 20-30 would be achieve achievable.
- 23:23That's 15 years. A lot of these gas flaring
- 23:26reduction projects do take a long time.
- 23:28It's several years really. So even if you built that in, we
- 23:34thought it was doable. Now a decade in and not showing
- 23:39the progress as much as we wanted, 2030 does seem to be a
- 23:43stretch goal, but we will hopefully see some governments,
- 23:47some countries, some operators actually achieve that target.
- 23:51In fact, there are some major international oil companies that
- 23:54have the technical capacity and the resources they're already
- 23:58going to, you know, achieve that, if not beat it by a few
- 24:02years. So that's encouraging.
- 24:03And hopefully they'll set an example for other operators to
- 24:06do the same, to prioritize this and get senior management at
- 24:10these companies to say, no, we have to do this.
- 24:15This oil industry practice that has persisted for 160 some years
- 24:19now, ever since oil production began, it now needs to end.
- 24:24Can I get you to put a pain in a realistic date but.
- 24:28Isn't it's too hard, Mark, right.
- 24:30Because again, you're talking about really.
- 24:33So, for example, in Russia, you've got oil production
- 24:37happening in the Siberian region, way far away from the
- 24:41markets in the western part of Russia.
- 24:43And now even politically, that's also become a little bit of a
- 24:46chance. So you see how these things
- 24:47evolve and where you think it could be possible by 20-30, it
- 24:52isn't. And then in some other places,
- 24:53perhaps you thought it wasn't achievable in a developing
- 24:58country. But they recognize how important
- 25:00it is. They have leadership that shows
- 25:03strong, you know, potential to do something about it.
- 25:07Then things can happen pretty quickly.
- 25:09I remain optimistic, let me put it that way, OK?
- 25:13Zubian Bamji, thank you very much.
- 25:14Thanks Mark. I appreciate it.
- 25:16From international flares to politics in the UK heating up,
- 25:20Floyd was over at the Labour Party conference this week, so
- 25:24stick around to hear what he has to say.
- 26:23Floyd, we're throwing it back to our political correspondent as
- 26:27I'm going to dub you this week. You were obviously the Labour
- 26:30Party conference. There was quite a few
- 26:32announcements, maybe not like massive groundbreaking thing.
- 26:36Well, I suppose they were avoiding groundbreaking with the
- 26:39fracking news. Do you want to?
- 26:42Hey there we. Go.
- 26:43Thank you very much. Thank you.
- 26:45Try my best. Floyd.
- 26:47What were your big takeaways from this week?
- 26:50Well, First off, you stole one of my jokes, that was.
- 26:54I'm really sorry, Floyd. But yeah, I mean, you'd be
- 26:59forgiven for thinking it was a reform conference, to be fair.
- 27:02But the amount of mention of reform, it was crazy.
- 27:05I thought on Twitter, I think that or X, that there was over
- 27:0965 mentions of reform in cabinet speeches.
- 27:12And then it was like in the hundreds when you considered all
- 27:15the other fringe events and stuff like that.
- 27:17Someone was trying to track it. It was an event where weirdly
- 27:21battle lines would seem to be drawn for an election that's
- 27:24like years and years away, mainly on net zero, to be fair.
- 27:29And I think that that was a bit of a reaction from obviously the
- 27:32Reform Party conference where they set out their stall for
- 27:36fracking quite early on. And then obviously there was all
- 27:40the mere drama with Andy Burnham speaking at fringe events.
- 27:44So I feel like it was, it was a party conference, not of someone
- 27:49just over a year into into power.
- 27:52And it would be quite symbolic, really quite interesting to see,
- 27:57you know, the last three Labour Party conferences, you know,
- 28:01three years ago it was like, oh, we think we're going to win.
- 28:04Then there was on the high of an election.
- 28:06And then this time it was almost like they were fighting for
- 28:10their lives a little bit. Yeah.
- 28:13It was quite an interesting conference because I wasn't
- 28:15quite sure what to kind of like, set myself up for what, what the
- 28:19messaging would be. There was a lot, lots of talk,
- 28:23obviously after Keir Starmer's speech about how he's taken the
- 28:26fight to directly to Nigel Farage.
- 28:29But I think something that was kind of under reported a little
- 28:32bit was how much Miliband took the fight to reform on energy
- 28:36policy. He was very strong in his words,
- 28:40especially on fracking and, you know, using the the fight
- 28:45against Liz Truss when she tried to to unban fracking and he said
- 28:49we defeated her and will defeat reform too.
- 28:52Yeah, quite a lot of fighting talk from Miliband, but not a
- 28:55lot on policy. There was a lot of will he won't
- 28:58he, you know, North Sea announcement.
- 29:00But yeah, kind of left all of that.
- 29:03I think it's also really interesting what was kind of
- 29:05unsaid at the conference, and that's the the Tories, the
- 29:08Conservatives were barely mentioned at all, it seems.
- 29:11And I guess it's just sort of breaking as we record this this
- 29:14morning, but Cammie Badenoch has come out this morning vowing
- 29:17that the Conservatives would repeal the Climate Change Act.
- 29:20So it almost feels as if the Conservatives have noticed that
- 29:23as well. And they're probably feeling a
- 29:24bit left out, hardly being mentioned during the Labour
- 29:27conference. And I guess they're trying to
- 29:29get their their name back in the headlights and then sort of or
- 29:34sort of, I guess point out to, I guess that wing of people that
- 29:38that might be considering voting for for reform and kind of say,
- 29:41hey, we're here too. And it's a strange position for
- 29:44a party like the conservatives to to be.
- 29:46And I guess what, what do you make of that?
- 29:48I guess a lack of conservatives talk at the the conference.
- 29:51Floyd. Yeah, well, like I mentioned
- 29:53before, I think it was the fact that Keir Starman needed to
- 29:57acknowledge the fact that the fight probably isn't going to be
- 30:00with the conservatives in the next election.
- 30:02And they set that stall out pretty quickly.
- 30:05But yeah, for for Kemi, I think, you know, she's got to just try
- 30:08and try and steal those headlines away and try and just
- 30:11get into that discourse a little bit.
- 30:12And obviously they've got their conference coming up next week,
- 30:15so it's probably like a good time for her to start talking
- 30:18about energy. But yeah, it's definitely going
- 30:21to be the key talking point ahead of the next election, even
- 30:24though we are so far away, in my opinion.
- 30:28Yeah, it's quite strange to see that there's no consensus on
- 30:30that zero anymore, you know, cross party support, whereas,
- 30:35you know, the last five or six years or so it seemed to be the
- 30:37case. So yeah, a bit backtracking on
- 30:41energy and net zero, I think from from the Conservatives.
- 30:44You know, to be fair, I feel like maybe maybe to play devil's
- 30:47advocate here, to call something that my local MP Stephen Flynn
- 30:52once said to me, he was, you know, we were speaking about
- 30:55elections and he said, you know, if you're as a politician, if
- 30:59you're not always campaigning, you're doing something wrong.
- 31:01So I suppose this is probably what they're what they're
- 31:04speaking about here, right? You know, it's, it's kind of
- 31:07trying to steal the Thunder from reform or try to knock, knock
- 31:11them down before they get too big.
- 31:13But if you look, if you look at the polls that already
- 31:15massively, you know, making massive strides.
- 31:20But on just just getting onto onto fracking, I wanted to speak
- 31:23about that because it also sort of ties into to reform.
- 31:26Obviously you mentioned the the party conference where Big Nige
- 31:31got up on stage and say they'll you know, we're going to go hell
- 31:34for a lab that I'm fracking, it's the best that we should do
- 31:37that. But.
- 31:39That's something that's, you know, even fractured where he
- 31:43another pun a reform level because they're Lincolnshire
- 31:47councils also came as saying, well, hold on a minute, you want
- 31:50to do fracking here, but we don't right?
- 31:53You reported that. Yeah, yeah.
- 31:54So Josh Roberts, he he's the cleric paint lead in Lancashire
- 31:58County Council and he's basically like fracking is OK,
- 32:02but not here. But it's not like a NIMBY
- 32:04stance. It's through like heritage and
- 32:07you know, fracking problems and it's been a widely disgusting in
- 32:10Lancashire for a long, long time.
- 32:12But he just says like, you know, on the geological level, it
- 32:16doesn't work in Lancashire. Like it's not safe.
- 32:19It's quite interesting that it's not actually been picked up that
- 32:22much because it's quite it will could end up being quite a big
- 32:25internal, that's all. And, you know, a party with, you
- 32:29know, a handful of MPs, 10 councils, a couple of mayors,
- 32:33like party unity you'd think would be an all time high.
- 32:36But when it comes to energy, you know, if Lancashire say no,
- 32:40there's going to be a big problem, especially because like
- 32:43Raj is pinning a lot on fracking, you know.
- 32:47So yeah, potential problem in the in the pipeline.
- 32:50Yeah, it's one of those things where these new parties that
- 32:52haven't had, I guess a long enough time in parliament or in
- 32:56in, you know, positions of authority to actually hammer out
- 33:00their positions issues, they do tend to fall apart.
- 33:02You know, I've seen similar things in Australia with these
- 33:05sort of insurgents, insurgent populist parties that sort of
- 33:08get a few MPs or senators into the Australian Parliament and
- 33:11then they all tend to go their own separate ways when they
- 33:14discovered that after a few sound bites in an election
- 33:16campaign, they can't actually agree on what they want to do,
- 33:19you know, when when they've actually got decision making
- 33:22powers. Yeah, I guess it's the same with
- 33:25your party, right? With Jeremy Corbyn, they've kind
- 33:27of fallen out. The first hurdle when it even
- 33:29came to, you know, signing up. Yeah, it's it.
- 33:32It felt like for for a while there, it felt like Corbyn was
- 33:36going to be trying to set up set up the air.
- 33:39So anti reform, right. But it seems they've already
- 33:42seems to have been trapped at the gates.
- 33:44It doesn't seem to be getting out the out the traps.
- 33:47So energy was obviously would I say a big talking point.
- 33:51There was a couple of headlines came out of it, But you know,
- 33:54there's a lot of sort of Oh yeah, well, you'll have a
- 33:56strategy before the November budget.
- 33:59What was it? What was your key take away?
- 34:01What was your sort of right? OK, this is, this is labor
- 34:05staking its, its flag into the ground.
- 34:07Was it fracking or, you know, GB MGNH rooftop solar was expanding
- 34:12to military sites this morning. What, you know, what sort of
- 34:16what was the keynote? Oh, well, that felt tangible.
- 34:19That felt like something we can actually expect, something the
- 34:22market can respond to. Yeah, well, outside of GB
- 34:26engine, not that much. He's definitely skirted around
- 34:29North Sea. I think Rachel Reeves had
- 34:31mentioned that there's going to be something coming before the
- 34:33autumn budget and that was kind of it on, you know, traditional
- 34:37oil and gas. He would he like spent a bit of
- 34:41time just like reeling off some like quick successes gave a
- 34:45shout out to high net and the like with a recent bids.
- 34:49So yeah, GB Energy really was was the biggest like tangible
- 34:53announce announcement really. So announced a bit more money,
- 34:5675 extra million on top of the original 280 million.
- 35:02Sorry, yeah, just to expand their like rooftop solar mission
- 35:07through GB Energy. So yeah, before it was the
- 35:10schools and NHS sites. And now they're rolling out to
- 35:1315 military sites across the UK. So I guess yeah, that that was
- 35:19the biggest tangible thing really.
- 35:22And that extra money will go to 50 more schools and 70 more NHS
- 35:27sites. So I guess that's quite a big
- 35:29deal. You know, a lot of schools and a
- 35:32lot of NHS sites will be getting roofed up solar.
- 35:34Then hopefully from DB energy perspective, energy bills will
- 35:38come down. But yeah, outside of that there
- 35:41was like no mention of like some grand new policy.
- 35:44There was like nothing on CCS from from the mainstage, that
- 35:49is, from Cabinet. Yeah.
- 35:51That was the only tangible thing really, like for four days.
- 35:54Like I thought it's quite strange that Ed Miliband was
- 35:56speaking on the final day as well.
- 35:59Like, I was at a CCSA dinner and they seemed to think that he'd
- 36:03been scheduled to speak earlier in the week and that they'd been
- 36:07like movements around to kind of trouble in to the back end of
- 36:09the conference. So there was all sorts of rumors
- 36:12around the dinner table as to why that could be.
- 36:16Well, let's let's keep the rumor mill going.
- 36:18Why do you think, you know, if you're listening to this, tell
- 36:22us on LinkedIn or e-mail as I think it's probably the best way
- 36:25to do it. I guess we'll need to round up
- 36:27here. I feel like we could talk about
- 36:29this all day. But one last question.
- 36:33You know, with oil and gas being such a hot button topic, the
- 36:37Tories are saying that they go drill, baby drill very much like
- 36:40Donald Trump. And it's, you know, it's in no
- 36:43doubt that reformer kind of following the MAGA playbook as
- 36:47well. So with oil and gas being such a
- 36:50big fag and in previous years labour being very anti oil and
- 36:53gas, no new licenses was kind of the the big signal in recent
- 36:57months. We've heard, you know, a recent
- 36:59weeks even we've heard, you know, that maybe Kier Starmer's
- 37:02government will look into this, our tie back proposal that John
- 37:07Underhill from Aberdeen University proposed.
- 37:11Do you think this was maybe like sort of, you know, softening the
- 37:14stance a little bit for an announcement on North Sea oil
- 37:18and gas is very speculative. I'd just be interested to hear
- 37:21what you guys have to say. I think they've been doing that
- 37:24softening for for months now. I think, you know, Michael
- 37:27Shanks in particular has been very explicit to, you know, no
- 37:30new licenses for new fields. He's always got that line very
- 37:34rehearsed. So I think they've been laying
- 37:36the groundwork for this for quite a while, but I honestly
- 37:38don't think it, it's starting to matter potentially less and less
- 37:42because you've, if you've got Kimmy Beta not coming out and
- 37:44pledging to repeal the Climate Change Act, that I'd say that's
- 37:48almost, you know, it. I guess people who maybe voted
- 37:52for Labour because they, they saw that pledge for no licenses,
- 37:56I guess maybe need to start thinking about, I guess what,
- 37:59what the alternatives are. And I guess, you know,
- 38:02potentially where there are a couple of extra new licenses
- 38:06compared to completely repealing the Climate Change Act.
- 38:08It seems as if, you know, that as we keep talking about the
- 38:11political consensus on net zero is is fractioning.
- 38:14And then and that speed seems to be increasing and that that
- 38:17fracturing increasing, you know, more than than anything.
- 38:23So I think Labour really needs to come up with some concrete
- 38:27policies and sort of start announcing them because they're
- 38:30kind of being hemmed in by by the other side who can obviously
- 38:35say whatever they want because they're not in government at the
- 38:36moment. Floyd, take us home.
- 38:39What do you think? Well, yeah, I completely agree
- 38:41with Matt. But then you, you've also got
- 38:43the Greens on the other side, which you know, Labour are
- 38:45bleeding some votes over to the Greens and, and they'll
- 38:47obviously go strong on the fact that they they would do no new
- 38:52oil and gas licensing. You know, the more Just Stop oil
- 38:55stunts, Labour got quite the headache.
- 38:58But you know, everyone in government always has the
- 39:00headache because like Matt said, when you're not in government,
- 39:02you can you can promise the earth, can't you?
- 39:04And have no consequence. Exactly that it's always easier
- 39:08being the opposition, but I don't know that's entirely true,
- 39:13but it's definitely true in this in this stance.
- 39:15Anyway, that does it for this week's episode of Energy Voice
- 39:19Out Loud. If you'd like to stay up to date
- 39:21with everything that's happening in the energy sector, both here
- 39:25in the UK and further afield, then go to energyvoice.com
- 39:29because that's where you'll keep up to date until next week,
- 39:32where you'll find us on the same place at the same time.