Latest / Sobering Stories / White Van Syndrome: $2.8 Billion in Taxes For Trafficking
Transcript
- 0:00It's a scheme involving human trafficking and healthcare
- 0:02fraud. Some Indigenous leaders calling
- 0:05it White van syndrome. Nearly a billion dollars of
- 0:08fraud made off the vulnerable, picking up substance abusers on
- 0:12the street, bleeding the state of billions of dollars, and then
- 0:15leaving patients often to die. One of the biggest scandals in
- 0:20the history of the state of Arizona.
- 0:22This is tragic. Massive Medicaid scandal that
- 0:25defrauded the state of almost $3 billion.
- 0:28This complaint shifts the root of the blame to state leaders
- 0:32who allegedly knew about a scam praying on Native Americans back
- 0:35in 2019 and didn't do enough to stop it.
- 0:39Attorney General Mays is calling this a game of whack A mole.
- 0:42So where do you live? Yeah, we'll go.
- 0:44Are you OK? You are OK 'cause you can barely
- 0:49stand. And I saw you laying there on
- 0:51the porch. I need.
- 0:52Help. 'Cause this is not the first
- 0:54time we find you passed out. Let me drive you around.
- 1:00Sometimes they're beaten, sometimes they're raped.
- 1:03This is a new kind of trauma that they're going to experience
- 1:06on top of why they have trauma to begin with.
- 1:09As Arizona's Family Investigates first reported, he died in a
- 1:12Mesa motel room from a cocktail of drugs and alcohol.
- 1:16The motel was being used for intake by another unlicensed
- 1:20sober living home as a neighbor was walking her dog.
- 1:23She basically saw a body laying there in between two unlicensed
- 1:28group homes. And they're just two of the more
- 1:30than 8000 investigators say were victimized as part of a
- 1:33widespread Arizona Medicaid scam.
- 1:36One story that did not end with death sticks out to these
- 1:39lawyers. Their client, Randy Honeyumptua,
- 1:42was detoxing from an alcohol bitch, stayed in a gated
- 1:45community known to have dozens of unlicensed sober living homes
- 1:48at the time, and was not feeling well.
- 1:50And the house manager says I have a pill for you, this will
- 1:53help you take care of you. Turns out it was fentanyl.
- 1:55Honeyumptua went into cardiac arrest and sustained A traumatic
- 1:58brain injury. And she's on a feeding tube.
- 2:00She's totally incapacitated. She can't speak or communicate,
- 2:04eat, do anything. Residents here have taken
- 2:06pictures of large unmarked vans they say Indigenous people are
- 2:09transported in. The FBI says all kinds of
- 2:11vehicles are involved, staking out locations like flea markets,
- 2:15trading posts and the Phoenix Indian Medical Center.
- 2:17Can they just leave? Why can't they just leave?
- 2:19Yeah, it's not as simple as that.
- 2:20I mean, we heard from someone coming up in Part 2, he stayed
- 2:23in dozens of homes. It's not so simple for them just
- 2:26to leave because they'll get picked up again.
- 2:28And when you're talking about being vulnerable or being
- 2:31addicted to drugs or alcohol and that behavior keeps going on,
- 2:34you're enabled. It's definitely very hard to
- 2:36leave. It was commonly New Mexico, now
- 2:38Montana, Alaska. Where else?
- 2:41South Dakota, Oklahoma, North Dakota.
- 2:45We have Florida and Nevada. We had some from Minnesota.
- 2:51This fraud was allowed to metastasize largely because the
- 2:55people in charge prior to 2023 were asleep at the wheel.
- 3:11Oh shit sub sobers just realizing how burn my nose is.
- 3:15Imagine being at your lowest point.
- 3:18You're struggling with addiction.
- 3:20You've hit a rock bottom moment. You've finally built up the
- 3:23courage to reach out for help, maybe seek help through a rehab
- 3:27center or some sort of sober living center.
- 3:30And instead of being met with patience, comfort, hospitality,
- 3:35care and rehab, you become a paycheck.
- 3:38On September 28th, 2022, a 44 year old man named Carson Leslie
- 3:44is hanging out at the Victory Group home in Flagstaff, AZ when
- 3:47he's approached by a windowless white creeper van offering
- 3:51promises of a fresh start, sober living, free room and board.
- 3:57Why would he say no? The only catch is it's in
- 3:59Phoenix, so he's got to ride with them to Phoenix so he can
- 4:04enroll in this rehab center. They don't even make it halfway
- 4:07when Carson starts throwing up, chokes on his own vomit, and
- 4:13passes away. His blood alcohol level was
- 4:16.541. Little fun fact for you guys,
- 4:21.35 is what they would consider to be lethal.
- 4:25And of course, anything above that, and I mean, damn, he was
- 4:30well above that, but they notified his family and made
- 4:33sure that he got a proper burial and was given the utmost
- 4:35respect. No, what they did was they
- 4:37dumped his body at a sober living facility that was halfway
- 4:41between Flagstaff and Phoenix and said, well, not our problem
- 4:46anymore. So I carry a Taser now.
- 4:48I will not walk without one. It was in September when
- 4:51Massagia said she was out walking with her dog when in
- 4:54front of one of the homes. I got to come across a dead
- 4:56body. A body that she said was left
- 4:58out in the open. The way it was positioned, it
- 5:01was put out on the street. There's no way that they died
- 5:04right there. Police later identified the body
- 5:06as Carson Leslie, a Native American who group home workers
- 5:09said they picked up in Flagstaff.
- 5:11The workers said he appeared drunk and they offered him
- 5:13rehab, but on the drive back workers that he threw up and
- 5:17fell asleep. It wasn't until they got to the
- 5:19home that workers said he was cold to the touch and called
- 5:22police. This is Evelyn.
- 5:24I spoke with the group home administrator on the phone.
- 5:26I'm recording this conversation for broadcast purposes.
- 5:28Evelyn Desabi runs Victory Homes, which has two locations
- 5:31in the gated community. The problem is, according to
- 5:34Massagia and Phoenix police, Leslie's body wasn't found at
- 5:37either one. But Desabi denies several
- 5:39details in the report, saying Leslie wasn't throwing up in the
- 5:42car or showing signs of being sick, and her workers didn't put
- 5:45him down the street. That's not what it says here in
- 5:47this report. It says they found him in the
- 5:49road. That's the wrong one.
- 5:51She also said Leslie was taken to one of their license
- 5:54locations, a group home that just closed in July, and was
- 5:57ordered to pay $18,000 to the state health department for
- 6:01repeat violations, including untrained staff and safety
- 6:04hazards in the home. The SABE did not deny that her
- 6:07workers picked up Leslie while he was drunk in Flagstaff and
- 6:11brought him to the Valley. But with the glaringly obvious
- 6:14question of how did he get that, that wasted in another part of
- 6:17Phoenix, a young man named Lionel Sandoval.
- 6:20He just completed a Salvation Army rehab program.
- 6:24He was then transferred to Falcon Care at this facility.
- 6:28He immediately knew things were off.
- 6:30And then he called his mom, Roberta, and was telling her
- 6:33mom, I just really want to come home.
- 6:35I don't want to be here. But unfortunately, he wouldn't
- 6:37make it home because two days later, he would seize up into a
- 6:41coma and pass away. And it unfortunately doesn't end
- 6:45there because Roberta Romero, which is Lionel's mother,
- 6:49reports that her other son couldn't handle the pain of what
- 6:53happened to his brother and he decided to pass himself away.
- 6:57What's really strange about his situation is that the toxicology
- 7:02report revealed that there was methanol in his system.
- 7:06Now, I didn't know about this. I knew that there's isopropyl
- 7:09alcohol and then like tequila and vodka kinds of alcoholic
- 7:14grain alcohol, probably more types, but methanol is like wood
- 7:19alcohol and it does have the same intoxicating effects.
- 7:24But when it breaks down in your body, it breaks down into
- 7:27formaldehyde and effectively poisons you from the inside out.
- 7:31The first thing to happen is it destroys your optic nerve, makes
- 7:34you go blind. So like, what gives?
- 7:37I guess if you're brewing your own alcohol at home, this is
- 7:41oftentimes where people end up drinking something that's super
- 7:45poisonous to them. Other than that, it's found in,
- 7:48you know, household cleaners, antifreeze, things like that.
- 7:51So that is definitely something that I found suspicious and
- 7:56confusing. How did he get this in his
- 7:58system? Even his mom says he wouldn't
- 8:01have knowingly drank this stuff. Going to another part of
- 8:03Phoenix, a young lady named Jade Laura who was five months
- 8:07pregnant. She entered into this facility
- 8:10called Healing Touch and at 5:00 AM, she was woken up by a super
- 8:15drunk guy crawling into bed with her trying to make moves.
- 8:20And of course, nothing happened. But she was so freaked out she
- 8:24left the facility immediately. But this is the kind of stuff
- 8:27that is going on at these sober living facilities.
- 8:31So how sober and how much are people really living at these
- 8:37facilities? And just a reminder, these are
- 8:39not criminals. These are desperate, vulnerable
- 8:42people that are looking for help.
- 8:44So today we are exposing one of Arizona's darkest scandals, $2.8
- 8:50billion of your hard earned taxpayer dollars has been
- 8:55fraudulently stolen. People are being taken advantage
- 8:59of. These addicts are being placed
- 9:01in these fake sober living homes that ultimately end up becoming
- 9:06death traps. Let's go.
- 9:25All right, welcome back to Sobering Stories with me, DJ
- 9:29Petrovsky. This is your first time here.
- 9:31Well, welcome to the channel. We talk about addiction focused
- 9:34crimes and conspiracies on a never ending search for the
- 9:38truth. If you're a returning
- 9:40subscriber, you already know that Welcome back today.
- 9:44We don't really have a sponsor, but I haven't shouted out my
- 9:47other channel in a long time. It's called We Subscribe. 9 out
- 9:51of 10 leading certified physicians recommend we
- 9:53subscribe because it begins working after the first
- 9:56subscription. Some common side effects do
- 9:59include headache, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal
- 10:03pain, dizziness, consciousness, sudden and unexplained euphoria,
- 10:07loss of appetite, doomscrawling, loss of motor function, memory
- 10:10loss, death, and advanced sensitivity to COVID-19 virus.
- 10:14So consult with your doctor and see if once in a lifetime We
- 10:18Subscribe is right for you. Please subscribe.
- 10:25Me and my brother haven't made a video on there in a long time
- 10:28because I've been really busy grinding this channel.
- 10:31We're definitely going too soon. I think those videos are
- 10:34hilarious and it might be a good comedy cleanser after this one
- 10:39because this episode gets kind of dark in my opinion.
- 10:42I'm still not understanding what are they subscribing for?
- 10:47Dude, we subscribe is a subscription for subscribers.
- 10:53It's a lifetime subscription for subscribers who understand and
- 10:57appreciate the value of subscribing and it and what it
- 11:00means to be a subscriber. Especially for a lot of you guys
- 11:05who have been through these similar situations where you've
- 11:09been in that same place, that same vulnerable dark place, and
- 11:15it seemed like your only hope was to put your trust into these
- 11:18strangers offering rehabilitation.
- 11:21So I could totally understand it being a bit triggering for some
- 11:25people. Just make sure that you take
- 11:28care of yourself. Your sobriety is more important
- 11:30than anything else. So if it is triggering, don't
- 11:33keep watching, don't feel bad about turning it off.
- 11:36You're not going to hurt my feelings.
- 11:37And there will be more episodes. But yeah, anyways, go ahead and
- 11:41super smash that like button so that we push this video out to
- 11:44everybody. And if you like what we got
- 11:46going on here, please subscribe to the channel trying to hit
- 11:49100K before December 31st of this year.
- 11:53And if you do subscribe, please make sure you hit that
- 11:55notification bell that way you don't miss any time I post.
- 12:00And I have multiple other social medias so go follow those.
- 12:04And in the instance that we do a censored content on here, if you
- 12:08want the uncensored raw early access version of said content,
- 12:13then become a patron or become a YouTube member.
- 12:16Super sober. But other than that, let's go.
- 12:19The Arizona Healthcare Cost Containment System, abbreviated
- 12:24AHCCCS, which is still just as awful to say so most people just
- 12:31call it AXIS, is basically Arizona's Medicaid program.
- 12:35Like, come on you guys, that name is ridiculous.
- 12:38This is the organization that is responsible for paying out
- 12:41healthcare benefits to any of the low income residents that
- 12:45qualify. And a lot of these low income
- 12:48residents qualify for behavioral health, medical visits,
- 12:52outpatient treatment, sober living treatment, any sort of,
- 12:56you know, surgeries or health issues they have pop up all
- 13:00kinds of things. But in addition to these
- 13:02benefits, Native Americans who live on the reservations in
- 13:06Arizona and multiple other states actually get additional
- 13:10benefits on top of these axis benefits.
- 13:14So Native Americans are often times #1 targets for these
- 13:19fraudulent sober living homes that are looking to recruit new
- 13:23clients so that they can cash in on these really big
- 13:27reimbursements for treatment that isn't even happening on top
- 13:31of being targeted for these American Indian Health Program
- 13:34benefits. The AIHP Native Americans were
- 13:38targeted especially because they were far more susceptible to
- 13:42addiction issues than most other cultures because Native
- 13:47Americans were not exposed to drugs or alcohol until the
- 13:51European showed up in the Americas and exposed them to all
- 13:55these different things. So it's said that Native
- 13:58Americans are 500 times more likely to suffer from alcoholism
- 14:03or alcohol dependence than any other person.
- 14:06Native Americans are 500% more likely to experience alcohol
- 14:11induced deaths and 20% more likely to die from drug use,
- 14:14according to a 2021 report by Arizona's Department of Health
- 14:18Services. Now they're being recruited from
- 14:20multiple reservations in our state, New Mexico and South
- 14:23Dakota by behavioral group homes and sober living homes.
- 14:26For these scum of the earth sober living center fraudsters,
- 14:30this is a walking ATM machine. And because of the lack of
- 14:33oversight over the AIHP, these payments, these reimbursement
- 14:38payments were never regulated. So they were getting thousands
- 14:42of dollars per patient per day. Those fake providers then
- 14:46allegedly billed for services not provided up to $1300 per
- 14:51person per day, collecting millions in Medicaid payments
- 14:54from the state. The city did its research,
- 14:57learning a sober living home could profit $180,000 annually
- 15:01off of one person on the American Indian Health Plan.
- 15:04Now, how this scam actually worked reminded me very much of
- 15:08the Leering Center and the expose that Nick Shirley did on
- 15:13just all of the Minnesota fraud that was going on with those
- 15:16daycare centers. This is very similar.
- 15:18They're just using these loopholes in the law to set up
- 15:21these sober living facilities, basically putting on a front
- 15:25that they're offering legitimate sober living like services,
- 15:29rehabilitation services, and they actually send out these
- 15:33creepy windowless white creeper vans to recruit clients.
- 15:39They go to these group homes. They go to places like The Zone,
- 15:43which is like Arizona Skid Row, essentially.
- 15:46They go to hospitals. They've just find people
- 15:49wherever they can. They'll even travel to different
- 15:52states. There was one report saying that
- 15:54they were actually recruiting people from Montana all the way
- 15:57from Arizona. So it's like they're travelling
- 16:00long distances to find people to bring back to this sober living
- 16:04facility so that they can start profiting off of them.
- 16:08A group home or sober living home is set up by either
- 16:10purchasing or renting a house. The services offered are for
- 16:14substance abuse or mental health issues.
- 16:16Organizers target Native Americans from several Indian
- 16:20reservations. These individuals may be
- 16:22intoxicated and will likely be offered alcohol while
- 16:25transported to the home. Organizers receive government
- 16:29funding through the Arizona Healthcare Cost Containment
- 16:31System or access capitalizing on Arizona Medicaid benefits
- 16:36belonging to members. Tenants are also told to give up
- 16:39their food stamps to provide food for the home or as rent
- 16:42payment and. What ends up happening is that
- 16:45they're not offering any rehab services.
- 16:48They offer this promise of real treatment but also free rent and
- 16:53free meals and everything's like taken care of for you.
- 16:57But once they get there, they're fed drugs and alcohol.
- 17:01Their addiction is actually enabled and encouraged to the
- 17:04point where they end up having to stay for another 30 days and
- 17:07they call in and get more funding for another 30 day
- 17:10stretch and then they'll get discharged, but then they'll
- 17:13bring them back so that they can get another 30 days.
- 17:16A lot of people end up getting kicked out of the sober living
- 17:18facilities, but they know that they're just going to be able to
- 17:21readmit them at another point for another 30 days.
- 17:25So it is just a continuous revolving door of taking
- 17:28advantage of these poor, vulnerable, helpless addicts,
- 17:33the most vulnerable people in our society besides children and
- 17:37old people. So it's just this never ending
- 17:39cycle of constant treatment and the only person who wins is this
- 17:43awful treatment center or is it one sober living center called
- 17:47Beyond Four Walls was actually submitting billing for
- 17:51reimbursements for about 3.5 million per year.
- 17:55But in one single year, they jumped up from 3.5 million to
- 18:00$11.1 million and billing reimbursements, which is a crazy
- 18:05jump, like 3 times plus of a jump.
- 18:08Not only that, the AIHP payments going into these reimbursements
- 18:14for basically their program benefits jumped from
- 18:18$132,000,000 to $668 million from 2020 all the way till 2022.
- 18:27Before Access began major reforms to its Medicaid system,
- 18:30there was a lack of oversight as fee for service providers build
- 18:33the state increasingly over the last three fiscal years on one
- 18:37code alone, from $53.5 million in 2020 to $668 million in 2022,
- 18:45non-native Americans could enroll in the American Indian
- 18:47Health Plan just by signing up over the phone.
- 18:51That was until this past June. The previous loophole allowed
- 18:54fraudsters to not only target Natives, but all vulnerable
- 18:57people in need of free housing. Providers also build on behalf
- 19:00of other providers, upping the risk of fraud.
- 19:03That's massive. Also, it's just after COVID when
- 19:07everything in the world suddenly got more expensive, more
- 19:11difficult, mom and pop shops went out of business, corporate
- 19:14world took over and suddenly we're all struggling in survival
- 19:18mode just to pay our bills. But they're forking out millions
- 19:21more dollars to these program benefits and they don't even
- 19:24care where it's going. But with this level of fraud,
- 19:27lying, deceit, somebody's bound to notice, right?
- 19:31Right. Not only did neighbors of these
- 19:34sober living houses start to realize that there was trash
- 19:37everywhere. People passed out on front
- 19:40porches, in yards, just in their cars, in front of houses, Just a
- 19:46complete wreck of a place. Certainly doesn't look like a
- 19:50sober living house. Usually sober living places have
- 19:53you like clean the place as part of your, you know, like part of
- 19:56your stay there. It's part of your chores so that
- 19:59you can maintain your residency. So like, I don't know, it's kind
- 20:03of weird that people didn't say anything sooner, but neighbors
- 20:06finally started getting sick of it.
- 20:08They started calling things in, reporting them to the Hoas.
- 20:12They were calling the police for noise complaints, people being
- 20:15passed out in random places, just.
- 20:18Constant police activity being called to these different
- 20:20houses, which you would think would be enough to put a stop to
- 20:24it, right? No, because the police systems
- 20:28where they put all this information in and document what
- 20:30happened does not connect at all with the Axis systems.
- 20:35So it doesn't let them know. Like, hey, there's been tons of
- 20:38police activity. There's been lots of drug and
- 20:41weapons and all this other stuff going on at this residence where
- 20:45you guys are now paying them thousands of dollars per month
- 20:49under the guise of them being a sober living facility.
- 20:52Unfortunately, these multiple police interactions don't do
- 20:55anything for for anybody. Treatment centers where they're
- 20:58saying that they're going there fraudulently documenting that
- 21:01they're receiving substance abuse services and then cost
- 21:05sharing for the offsetting for the sober living.
- 21:08Several residents voiced concerns to officials about
- 21:11unlicensed sober living homes in their neighborhoods.
- 21:14That's when we finally put all the pieces together.
- 21:16When people started showing up at the meetings for our City of
- 21:21Surprise and other people were coming forward with information,
- 21:24That's when we put it together that that's what this house was
- 21:27about. Lynette Irisabal lives in Belle
- 21:30W Ranch near Bell Road and State Route 3 O 3.
- 21:33She says earlier this year she started seeing strange activity
- 21:36outside. There was people coming and
- 21:38going. There was no supervision.
- 21:41She describes seeing drug use, garbage on the street and
- 21:44transients pushing shopping carts.
- 21:46Anthony Johnson is another resident who witnessed the same.
- 21:49People are staggering around the neighborhood, falling down.
- 21:51It was. It was some some of the erratic
- 21:53behavior we saw just wasn't a common in our community.
- 21:56But the aspect of this situation where they do pay attention is
- 22:00the money aspect because somebody's tracking these
- 22:03numbers, somebody's looking into this and seeing, whoa, what's
- 22:06going on with this massive spike.
- 22:08And there's all these facilities that might be getting audited or
- 22:11something. They quickly change their name,
- 22:13close that business and just start a new one.
- 22:16And so there's all these little laws and loopholes that they're
- 22:18avoiding and finding to be able to operate in this Gray area of
- 22:23the law. And they're making thousands and
- 22:25thousands of dollars by operating these illegitimate
- 22:29sober living houses. The worst part is there's
- 22:32legitimate sober living houses that are fully respectable.
- 22:37They do everything by the book. They are actually there to
- 22:40rehabilitate people, but sometimes they will pay these
- 22:44illegitimate off the record recruiters to go grab their
- 22:47white creeper vans and go around and find new clients.
- 22:51In order for group homes to get paid directly through access,
- 22:54that requires licensing with the Department of Health.
- 22:57The FBI believes licensed facilities are also paying
- 22:59unlicensed individuals to recruit patients.
- 23:02Well, for example, if I opened a legitimate facility and then I
- 23:06asked you to bring patients to me, I could pay you to bring
- 23:09those patients to me. So that's kickback, and that's
- 23:12illegal, and that's healthcare fraud.
- 23:14Where the root of the kickback money comes from, exactly, is
- 23:17part of the FBI's investigation. It may not be as bad because
- 23:22their intentions are still good, but they're still going about it
- 23:25in a very shady way. Kind of like those places that
- 23:28go around and just like spayed your cat and cut their ear just
- 23:31to let other people know that this cat is spayed.
- 23:34You guys know what I'm talking about.
- 23:35Kind of like that. Like it's a good thing, but it's
- 23:37also just kind of effed. Well somebody with the AIHP,
- 23:41that was pretty important. Did notice her name was Doctor
- 23:44Satya Sarma. She was the medical director for
- 23:47the Division of Fee for Service. These freaking names are out of
- 23:51control. Her office directly oversaw the
- 23:54AIHP and was essentially the organization being defrauded of
- 23:59all this money. She brought this to the
- 24:01attention of Mark A Adams, her direct supervisor.
- 24:04They organized a meeting with the Office of the Inspector
- 24:07General with a lady named Sharon Ormsby, and during this meeting,
- 24:11Doctor Sarma was basically told to stay in her lane.
- 24:15Drop it, don't bring it up. And this is with somebody from
- 24:19the Office of the Inspector General there to witness
- 24:22sometime in late 2021, Doctor Sarma was written up for
- 24:26insubordination and then ultimately she was pushed out of
- 24:30the AIHP and this position with the fee for service whatever.
- 24:36My name is Doctor Satya Sarma. I joined Access first in
- 24:40November of 2019, and then about a year later I moved to the part
- 24:46of Access that houses the American Indian Health Plan,
- 24:49which is the Division of Fee for Service Management or DFSM, and
- 24:53I stayed there for about 10 months.
- 24:55When was the first time that you actually either heard about the
- 25:00fraud or suspected there might be fraud?
- 25:03Very soon after I first got to the agency, I heard frontline
- 25:07staff present information to a group of Access leaders that it
- 25:13was around financial improprieties when I moved to
- 25:17DFSM. When I moved to my new role in
- 25:212020, my team investigated and uncovered cases of patients
- 25:26being harmed. Sometimes that harm rose to the
- 25:29level of criminality in my department.
- 25:32We took in complaints from providers from Access recipients
- 25:37around concerns they had about the care they were receiving
- 25:41from providers. Certain behavioral health
- 25:43providers who had complaints lodged against them ended up
- 25:49having findings of serious harm to those patients.
- 25:53All Access leadership had to do was listen to my team and take
- 25:58them seriously instead of taking decisive action.
- 26:02What I saw there was that leadership delayed, deflected,
- 26:07ignored us, shut us down and intimidated us, and that calls
- 26:12for accountability. She says she still lies awake
- 26:15wondering how many people passed away between the years of 2020
- 26:20and 2022, before any of this stuff started coming to light.
- 26:24But instantly, as most of you probably did as well, my mind
- 26:28went straight to, well, why are they shutting this down right
- 26:32here? And that typically means they
- 26:34don't want you looking into it because the money that's
- 26:37disappearing is disappearing for a reason that they probably know
- 26:41about, might even be tied to, might even be benefiting from.
- 26:45And who knows how far up the ladder this goes Because these
- 26:49are organizations that are directly overseeing these sober
- 26:54living centers, but they're also directly reporting back to
- 26:58government agencies, IE the government, all of this stuff.
- 27:02So are these people getting paid through these fraudulent theft
- 27:07networks? Doctor Sarma stops talking about
- 27:10things publicly because obviously somebody doesn't want
- 27:14her to. But she starts working with
- 27:15these anonymous private individuals who are also
- 27:18building a case about this massive fraud scheme that's
- 27:21going on. And on February 7th of 2022, a
- 27:25private anonymous citizen delivers a 107 page document to
- 27:31the Arizona Office of the Attorney General.
- 27:34Hoping for some action and some answers.
- 27:37And this document is not just documenting these ugly houses in
- 27:41people's neighborhoods that are attracting possible, you know,
- 27:44substance users and or dealers. They're talking about the actual
- 27:48white collar fraudulent network of crime that's happening where
- 27:52these people are defrauding the government for billions of
- 27:56dollars. This isn't chump change.
- 27:58This is a lot of money. But on top of the money piece,
- 28:01they're contributing to people's active addictions and often
- 28:05times it's leading to people being unalived from whatever
- 28:11their substance of choice is because they're being put in
- 28:13these situations where they're being enabled with other users
- 28:17around. Even thousands of missing
- 28:19persons are said to be linked to these different sobriety
- 28:22centers. In fact, they're just now
- 28:24starting to pass laws where in order to get accepted to a rehab
- 28:28facility that is registered and above board that follows the
- 28:32rules, they have to let your family know where you're at.
- 28:35Of course, these illegitimate ones, they don't let your family
- 28:39know where you're at. They don't call anybody.
- 28:41They just scoop you up and hope to God that nobody comes looking
- 28:43for you, honestly. But then if you couple this with
- 28:46all of the neighborhood testimony and all the complaints
- 28:49coming in saying that there's over 30 plus different sober
- 28:53living houses that have been reported that are suspicious or
- 28:57proven to be illegitimate. They're finally starting to look
- 29:01into this stuff and take it seriously at a government level.
- 29:05But how did this happen? How could we let this happen?
- 29:08How was this even legal? Well, it was surprisingly easy
- 29:12to start a sober living facility in most states at that time,
- 29:16including Colorado, Arizona, California, New Mexico, Montana.
- 29:22South Dakota, Oklahoma, North Dakota.
- 29:27We have Florida and Nevada. We had some from Minnesota.
- 29:34Lots of them. If you've seen the Netflix
- 29:36documentary series called Worst Neighbor Ever, there's a story
- 29:40about a lady in there named Carrie Phoenix, and she actually
- 29:44starts up a sober living facility in California.
- 29:48And this is after she's already defrauded this guy that she just
- 29:52happens to have found dead in his house.
- 29:54And he has this trust that she claims as her own, signs herself
- 29:59as a cosigner on the trust, and then boom, she steals millions
- 30:03of dollars from him and then randomly decides she's going to
- 30:06open up a sober living facility even though she's definitely not
- 30:09sober. A judge has sentenced a West
- 30:11Hills woman to 20 years for her role in a scheme involving
- 30:15forged power of attorney documents and the dismemberment
- 30:18of a victim's body. Caroline Hurling, also known as
- 30:22Carrie Phoenix, was sentenced by AUS District Judge, who also
- 30:26ordered her to pay nearly $4 million in restitution,
- 30:29prosecutors say. She and her accomplices sought
- 30:32out vulnerable victims by searching for properties in
- 30:34affluent neighborhoods that appeared unkempt in 2020.
- 30:38She. Used a forged power of attorney
- 30:40reform to steal real estate and financial accounts from Charles
- 30:44Wielding Junior, an older, shy single man in Sherman Oaks.
- 30:48He later died from still unknown causes.
- 30:51Hurling and her Co conspirators are accused of dismembering him
- 30:54and dumping the body parts into San Francisco Bay.
- 30:58But the qualifications to open up a sober living facility are
- 31:02none. There are none.
- 31:03There's no qualifications needed, no licenses needed, no
- 31:07former experience or background in helping sober people, no CPR
- 31:13certifications or anything. Nothing.
- 31:16You don't need anything to start a sober living house except for
- 31:19a solid dealer A. Sober living home is required to
- 31:22have a a manager there. They're supposed to provide a
- 31:26sober environment if it's pure run or if it's a roommate
- 31:31situation, it may be something outside of our scope because
- 31:35anyone can call themselves a sober living home.
- 31:37State law does not prohibit unlicensed facilities from using
- 31:40the title sober living home. For sober living home owners
- 31:43trying to do things the right way, the stories are especially
- 31:45frustrating. This is definitely not something
- 31:47where you're going to get a quick buck unless you're doing
- 31:50it improperly. Stephanie Womble and her husband
- 31:52opened up this recovery home in Gilbert.
- 31:54I cashed in my 4 O 1K, we put the down payment on this house
- 31:57and we started and it's been a glorious adventure.
- 32:00Womble aims to help folks like 20 year old Hunter Dubin.
- 32:03It's comforting. I like the accountability here
- 32:07and the support. The meetings are really good
- 32:09too. Dubin received his high school
- 32:12diploma after years of legal trouble stemming from his
- 32:14addiction and is now working on his music career.
- 32:17Nothing to lose. Why y'all hate on the?
- 32:19But I think the important thing about this Netflix documentary
- 32:22is that it highlights that this isn't just happening in Arizona.
- 32:25It's not just happening in New Mexico.
- 32:28It's not just happening to Native American people just
- 32:31because they are higher targets and more profitable for these
- 32:34scams. That's not the only population
- 32:37affected. It's now branched out from the
- 32:39reservations as we're learning to all over the Valley, as you
- 32:44saw the Phoenix Indian Medical Center, flea markets and things
- 32:46like that. And it may not just be Native
- 32:48American people, as you'll see in Part 2, homeless people can
- 32:51also be recruited because we're talking about shelter, food, a
- 32:55nice neighborhood, and there's obviously intoxication of this
- 32:59type of behavior going. That's just more money for them.
- 33:01It's any and all addicts, people seeking recovery, some sort of
- 33:06help, people seeking mental assistance.
- 33:08A lot of these people have mental health issues and yet
- 33:11they're finding themselves in these fraudulent centers that
- 33:14are only exacerbating the problem and oftentimes leading
- 33:17to their death. I would recommend the worst
- 33:20neighbor ever series. I don't think all of those, you
- 33:23know, worst whatever shows are the are really good, but that
- 33:27one was really good, like all of them were.
- 33:29But the most obviously frustrating piece about this
- 33:31entire thing is very similar to all these Minnesota fraud cases,
- 33:37because this is our hard earned taxpayer dollars being stolen
- 33:42and the government doesn't seem to know what's going on.
- 33:45Or do they? Because we've had whistleblowers
- 33:48coming forward saying lots of money is missing and the amounts
- 33:52of money going missing is increasing every year.
- 33:56So we need to have somebody do something about this, please.
- 33:59We need more regulation. We need people to start looking
- 34:02at these different facilities and going in and checking on
- 34:05them and making sure that they're legit.
- 34:07We need something to happen, but nothing happens.
- 34:10And I'm sure none of you are surprised that it's this system
- 34:14of the revolving door where you scratch my back and I'll scratch
- 34:19yours. You know, it's just a constant
- 34:21system of bringing your people in and setting up these behind
- 34:26the scenes money making schemes. And that's exactly what seems to
- 34:30be going on here. Because not only was Sharon
- 34:32Ormsby at that meeting where Doctor Sarma was told to stay in
- 34:37her lane, but she didn't say a single thing about what was
- 34:41being said. She didn't say no, no, no, no.
- 34:43We should look into this. Like, if lots of money is going
- 34:46missing, then we should definitely look into this.
- 34:48As a representative of the Office of the Inspector General,
- 34:51we definitely want to look into this.
- 34:54Nothing these fraud schemes really ramped up between 2015
- 34:57and 2023. Nobody really started noticing
- 35:01until about 2019-2020. Dr. Sarma was really the first
- 35:05person to blow the whistle on all of this, but it was because
- 35:08of Governor Doug Ducey, his extraordinarily loose lack of
- 35:12legislation and oversight on all of these different programs,
- 35:16especially following COVID, because during COVID everything
- 35:21got relaxed, and then following COVID, they never really
- 35:24followed up on it. He billed the state for patients
- 35:27who were already dead. He billed for children, toddlers
- 35:32for alcohol dependence treatment that they could never receive.
- 35:36He billed for patients who were incarcerated and could not have
- 35:40been in his care. Even after Doctor Sarma brought
- 35:44this stuff to their attention, they just continued to ignore
- 35:47it, which makes you wonder why. But this is not a bipartisan
- 35:51issue. Doug Ducey was a Republican
- 35:54governor, but underneath the leadership of Katie Hobbs, who
- 35:57was a Democratic governor, she appointed a young lady named
- 36:00Carmen Herrera to be the director of access.
- 36:04We have suspended payments to approximately 100 Medicaid
- 36:09providers based on credible allegations of fraud.
- 36:13Carmen Heredia, appointed by the governor as the director of the
- 36:16Arizona Healthcare Cost Containment System last
- 36:18December. Access also needs to be held
- 36:21accountable for allowing this to happen for the last three years.
- 36:26Now, what's really interesting about this is because just like
- 36:29I mentioned before, this revolving door, you scratch my
- 36:32back, I'll scratch yours. Carmen was previously working as
- 36:37a director at this sober living facility called Valle del Sol.
- 36:42And this facility was legitimate.
- 36:44But like I said before, even these legitimate facilities were
- 36:48hiring illegitimate recruiters to bring in more clients to make
- 36:52more money. The FBI believes licensed
- 36:55facilities are also paying unlicensed individuals to
- 36:57recruit patients. Well, for example, if I opened a
- 37:01legitimate facility and then I asked you to bring patients to
- 37:04me, I could pay you to bring those patients to me.
- 37:08But that's kickback and that's illegal and that's healthcare
- 37:10fraud. 1 suspect admitting 1 clinic paid $300,000 for
- 37:14patients in just three months. At least one sober living
- 37:17business was a licensed LLC but does not appear on the
- 37:20Department of Health database. The head of licensing for DHS
- 37:23says that's not unusual. So the fraud may not have
- 37:26stopped with these illegitimate centers.
- 37:29Just saying. But she also sat on the industry
- 37:32board of directors where she lobbied for the industry
- 37:36basically for legislation, for market caps, for whatever.
- 37:41She was a an industry representative.
- 37:43Then she gets basically promoted over and moved over to the
- 37:48director of Axis, where she directly overseas the funds
- 37:52going to these different programs that she previously was
- 37:55lobbying for. I don't know, seems interesting.
- 37:58But what was really damning for Carmen was when her own staff
- 38:03pointed out this extreme overbilling that was happening
- 38:07with all these sober living facilities.
- 38:09Instead of looking more into it or putting a stop to it, she
- 38:14actually sent an e-mail out to all of these different centers
- 38:17removing the rate cap entirely so there was no more overbilling
- 38:22because, well, there was no over anything.
- 38:25There's no cap. This e-mail leaking was not good
- 38:28for Carmen because it just highlighted how she clearly
- 38:32wasn't investigating this despite being this massive
- 38:37advocate for the cause and talking about how this needs to
- 38:41be investigated. She's on their website
- 38:43discussing how much of A widespread problem this is.
- 38:46We are continuing to evolve our processes to meet the needs of
- 38:50our members, ensure proper billing from our providers and
- 38:53keep our commitment to fraud prevention.
- 38:56And yet she would eventually resign April 30th of 2025, just
- 39:01before a state Senate hearing where they were going to be
- 39:04grilling her with some tough questions on her poor handling
- 39:09of this entire fraud scheme. And then she just happens to
- 39:12resign. Anything that harms our ability
- 39:15to prevent this fraud and save lives is, frankly a travesty.
- 39:22Arizona Attorney General Chris Mays lit into Senate Republicans
- 39:25Thursday, a day after the director of access, Carmen
- 39:28Heredia, resigned rather than face a confirmation hearing.
- 39:30What I'll say is this. It's certainly not helpful when
- 39:34the legislature, the Republicans in the legislature refuse to
- 39:39confirm the governor's appointees, especially when they
- 39:44are working on such critical issues as this.
- 39:47She doesn't want to end up like Epstein or what?
- 39:49Just to give you a little bit of insight into the structure, the
- 39:53director of Axis directly reports to the office of the
- 39:57governor. So this might mean something,
- 40:01might mean nothing. Grab some merch.
- 40:03Worth noting that in nearly every single report that I was
- 40:07able to find, everybody keeps saying the words bad actors.
- 40:12With the state wedding out bad actors.
- 40:14Actively going after these bad actors.
- 40:17We're going to take the action we need to to stop bad actors
- 40:20when I'm trying to go after these bad actors and I think.
- 40:23That they got some good actors in here, people that can do some
- 40:25good work. There are people that were bad
- 40:28actors before. It's been damaged by the frog
- 40:30and a lot of bad actors in the industry, vulnerable people
- 40:33battling addiction, being preyed upon by bad actors.
- 40:36We've exposed the alleged bad actors in behavioral health.
- 40:40Even licensed providers that are that are engaging in bad acts.
- 40:47It's just these bad actors out here that are running these
- 40:50sober living facilities and they're ruining it for everybody
- 40:54else who's trying to do things the right way.
- 40:57It's just all of these bad actors from central casting
- 41:01maybe. I don't know.
- 41:02That is such a strange term to use.
- 41:05Bad actors were these guys placed into these acting roles
- 41:10and now they're like, oh, freaking bad actors ruining it
- 41:13for the rest of us. I don't know, it's just
- 41:15something I picked up on. I'm curious what you guys think
- 41:18about that though. And since we're kind of on the
- 41:20topic, if you haven't seen my Pizzagate shooter crisis actor
- 41:24video, I'll put it at the end. It's probably a card up here,
- 41:27but good video. I would be completely off base
- 41:31if I didn't mention that the CIA has been proven they have a long
- 41:36track record of bringing drugs into the country.
- 41:40It's a very profitable industry, much like the trafficking
- 41:43industry. And it's very obvious that
- 41:46they're using these substances, this whole culture of drug use
- 41:51in America to keep people subdued, stupid, addicted, not
- 41:57focused on what's going on and separated.
- 42:00Because, I mean, people don't willingly just band together
- 42:03with a bunch of addicts. So it just feeds into this
- 42:06entire platform of them making money off of funneling drugs
- 42:11into our society. And it goes from the beginning
- 42:14stages of selling it, bringing it in, transporting it, all the
- 42:18way to the end process of the person who's so addicted they go
- 42:21to a sober living facility hoping to get help with this
- 42:24addiction they've developed. And then the sober living
- 42:26facility is getting government spending sent to them, taking
- 42:30full advantage of this person. And now they're not even a
- 42:33person. They're just a paycheck.
- 42:35It's super heartbreaking. And this is not a problem that
- 42:38we figured out and solved. In fact, all of the lawmakers in
- 42:42Arizona keep saying that we figured it out.
- 42:44We've got an AI program that now looks and tracks for any strange
- 42:48monetary overspending and immediately flags the system and
- 42:52blah blah. Touting this AI tool that will
- 42:55be coming in the coming months. And a big thing we're told that
- 42:58it will do is prepayment review to hopefully stop Medicaid fraud
- 43:03before any possible fraudsters are paid.
- 43:06So a bit more about what we heard from the Inspector General
- 43:09here. So she says that this tool using
- 43:11AI with stopping Medicaid fraud could be the first of its kind
- 43:14introduced in any statewide Medicaid agency.
- 43:18But it does not eliminate humans completely from the equation,
- 43:22Templeman told her. Quarters that this technology
- 43:25would involve people in multiple parts of flagging fraud in the
- 43:29whole process, which will break down a bit more and a bit here.
- 43:32According to the AG's office, Mays lawyers have obtained 140
- 43:36indictments and 41 convictions payments under the native.
- 43:40American Health Program have plunged 68%.
- 43:44Which sounds very much like a DOGE procedure.
- 43:47So I'm kind of wondering how DOGE didn't catch this $2.8
- 43:51billion overspending in the Arizona State Medicaid program.
- 43:57And if it did, they very quietly rolled out this new AI software,
- 44:01very DOGE like to be able to track and catch all of these
- 44:05overspendings. It also links all of their
- 44:08systems together so that if the police end up having issues with
- 44:12some house residents, whatever, it will then actually have a
- 44:16system that can communicate with this other system within
- 44:20Medicaid. But unfortunately, people on the
- 44:23ground level, people working at these legitimate sober living
- 44:26houses, people who are actively trying to solve this problem and
- 44:30are speaking up about it very loudly, people who have lost
- 44:33friends and family members to the struggle of addiction and
- 44:37these sober living fraud schemes that I would almost call murder
- 44:41schemes. They're speaking out saying that
- 44:43nothing has changed, nothing's different.
- 44:46They can say all they want that they're doing all these things
- 44:48to change it, but nothing has changed.
- 44:50Staff in the governor's office have told me massive fraud is
- 44:53not currently ongoing. Seeing the data doesn't show
- 44:56fraud. This kind of fraud is not going
- 44:58to happen under my watch and we're going to take the action
- 45:02we need to to stop bad actors. Nobody wants to listen.
- 45:06Nobody wants to fix this. Too many people have died.
- 45:09State leaders promise to stop it, but advocates and these
- 45:12attorneys tell us it hasn't happened.
- 45:15We can go north-south, east, West. 10 miles in any direction
- 45:19and I can find you huge amounts of this sober living crisis
- 45:24going on. It's still happening and it's
- 45:27going to continue to happen if everybody keeps pointing
- 45:30fingers. Riva Stewart tells me she saw
- 45:32people just this weekend asking unhoused Native Americans in
- 45:35Phoenix if they needed a place to go.
- 45:37And it's truly heartbreaking to know that this is still a very
- 45:41active problem. I don't know.
- 45:43I find it absolutely infuriating that millions of Americans,
- 45:48including myself, are struggling to pay our basic necessity bills
- 45:52every month, and yet the government is allowing $2.8
- 45:56billion to be funneled into fraudulent thieves pockets who
- 46:01are not only thieves, but they're probably the worst types
- 46:05of human beings. They're praying on vulnerable
- 46:08weak people and they're taking advantage of their addictions
- 46:11and they're funneling drugs to these people that that
- 46:15ultimately end up killing a lot of them.
- 46:17And not only that, they're taking them without mentioning
- 46:20it to anybody. So there's thousands of missing
- 46:22persons cases in New Mexico, Arizona, a lot of the
- 46:26surrounding area really, that eventually get linked back to
- 46:29these sober living facilities. But there is still only a
- 46:32handful of facilities that have been cracked down on.
- 46:36And the ones that have been closed or suspended, they might
- 46:39just pop up under a new name because they don't follow the
- 46:42rules. So it's not like they're going
- 46:43to be in some system, in some database where they're going to
- 46:47be easy to find and track. It seems like kind of a cluster.
- 46:50But we've got a pretty healthy list of active, suspended sober
- 46:54living houses. And these are only the active
- 46:57ones. And this list is outrageously
- 46:59long, but it makes me feel like they are doing something.
- 47:03Like I said, they might just be closing one down for one or two
- 47:06more to pop right back up. They also might be involved in
- 47:10closing one down and setting up a new one.
- 47:13I just can't help but feel like there's some serious government
- 47:17political involvement in this, because otherwise it doesn't
- 47:20seem like that hard of a problem to figure out.
- 47:22It seems like they could do a pretty quick audit, even using
- 47:26AI, of all of these different sober living houses and send out
- 47:29actual boots on the ground to go visit these sober living houses
- 47:33unannounced to see what's really going on here.
- 47:36You have literal people's lives in your hands.
- 47:39You have people who are so messed up on certain drugs that
- 47:42they might need extreme medical assistance.
- 47:45You would need to know that. But of course, this could all
- 47:47just be a massive psyop by the government and the media trying
- 47:52to convince people who are struggling with addiction not to
- 47:55seek help because of the fear of it going badly.
- 47:59Who really knows? But for right now, the best
- 48:02thing we can do is to just keep spreading the word and just
- 48:05making sure that if you see something, you say something.
- 48:08If you have a bad feeling about something that's going on with
- 48:12maybe a friend or a family member that's at a recovery
- 48:14center, maybe just reach out to them because a lot of the time
- 48:18they're restricted from communicating.
- 48:20They can't reach out to anybody. They are completely isolated.
- 48:24And then when things get bad enough, they're just dumped
- 48:27alone in this city that they're not familiar with.
- 48:30I don't know, just if you know somebody that might be in that
- 48:32situation, reach out for sure. But this case just broke my
- 48:36heart. I had no idea this was going on.
- 48:38I'm glad that I do now. I mean, I'm not glad I know it,
- 48:41but I'm glad that I know more about what's happening in the
- 48:44world and I can be more aware. And I'm super, super happy that
- 48:48I can present this story to you guys and help spread the word
- 48:52because I feel like that's what we need right now.
- 48:55But drop it in the comments what you guys think.
- 48:57Make sure you like this video on the way out.
- 48:59Make sure you hit hit the subscribe button if you do like
- 49:02what we got going on here and then tick that cute little bell
- 49:05over there in the side. That way you don't miss when I
- 49:09post on Tuesdays and Fridays and when I go live on Mondays.
- 49:13And if you want early access uncensored videos, follow me on
- 49:16Patreon or become a super sober here on YouTube.
- 49:20But that's all I got for you guys this week.
- 49:22I appreciate you chilling, hanging, just just chilling.
- 49:26I look forward to doing this again with you guys next week
- 49:28for another one. Until then, sleep safe, stay
- 49:32sober, stay awake, stay alive. And if a van with only three
- 49:36windows rolls up offering you literally anything, just say no
- 49:41to drugs. I'm OK, so don't be bad by doing
- 49:44drugs later, Sobers. Being sober is so beautiful.
- 49:52You know, the the the more you distance yourself when negative,
- 49:54the more beautiful things happen.
- 50:03Let's go.