Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 12)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to dive right
- 0:06back in to the alex Acosta interview with the OIJ inspectors. Question,
- 0:13I'm sorry when you say some concern, some concern about
- 0:16the federalism argument. Answer. Yeah, going back to what we
- 0:19talked about with respect to the earlier conversation about solicitation
- 0:24versus trafficking and the federal nexus. But back in July,
- 0:27we had decided that we would be going forward and
- 0:30that either there is this pre indictment resolution or we
- 0:34go forward with an indictment. The September meeting did not
- 0:37alter or shift our position. Question, even though you had
- 0:42some federalism concerns of your own, they didn't rise to
- 0:46a sufficiently high level answer. So their request was to
- 0:49drop the matter and going back again understood, there is
- 0:54a legal risk, there is witness risk, all of these.
- 0:57If we can get a pre indictment resolution, good, If not,
- 1:00the indictment was not a bluff, It was real question.
- 1:04So I mean Ken Starr is of course well known
- 1:07answer right question. He was listener in general, you know,
- 1:11et cetera, et cetera. Did you find his arguments well
- 1:14set forth impressive answer, So you're asking for something that's
- 1:19twelve years old. If I had to characterize, by the
- 1:22time this meeting took place, there had been a fair
- 1:25amount I thought around these there had been a fair amount,
- 1:28and at least I felt comfortable that while there was
- 1:32some legal risk we needed, you've got to balance the
- 1:35legal risk and the precedent risk with outcome, and mister
- 1:38Epstein should go to jail and should register. And I
- 1:41felt comfortable enough to basically reiterate our position that question.
- 1:47But my question with respect was did you enjoy the joy,
- 1:51the give and take with a man of mister Starr's standing?
- 1:55Answer no, question no, not at all. Answer no, not
- 1:59a because it would have been easier to not have
- 2:03the meeting in the first place. Question all right, do
- 2:06you recall an exchange where you the person to whom
- 2:09he was directing most of his comments? Answer most likely,
- 2:13question and do you recall any exchange with him about
- 2:16the fact that sort of an observation that the two
- 2:19of you and he were the only two people in
- 2:22the room who had been presidentially nominated and Senate confirmed
- 2:26to any position, so that the two of you had
- 2:28that kind of commonality. Does that ring a bell? Answer?
- 2:33Was he trying to butter me up? Question? Was he?
- 2:36I mean? Was he? Answer? Look, this was twelve years ago.
- 2:40I don't recall, you know. I think as we talk
- 2:42about this, it's important to note that the position did
- 2:45not change. Whatever exchange we may have had, our position
- 2:49did not change. Question. Right after this meeting, within a
- 2:53few days, in furtherance of the resolution that had been
- 2:56offered redacted and redacted, LORI met with the state attorneys
- 2:59off to sit down and try to work out how
- 3:02this thing would work. And mind you, this was before,
- 3:05well before the NPA is actually formulated. Did you learn
- 3:09what happened at that meeting? Do you know how it evolved? Answer?
- 3:13I may have, I don't recall, you know sitting here today.
- 3:16Question all right, it's at this meeting that somehow the
- 3:20three charges that you specified your office specified in the
- 3:23term sheet became one. So suddenly Epstein was depleted only
- 3:27to one charge, and this was agreed to by the
- 3:29US Attorney's office. Folks who were there, do you know
- 3:32how or why that happened? Answer? I haven't the slightest
- 3:36IDEA question if you had known, if they had called
- 3:40you on the phone, sort of the mid trial call
- 3:43to the boss, asking what you wanted them to do?
- 3:46What would you have said answer? So from my perspective,
- 3:50you know, when I indicated I approved this term sheet,
- 3:53this is the minimum, I meant what I said. I
- 3:55also recognized that ausas in the usual course, need some
- 3:59degree discretion to negotiate. And so my assumption after that
- 4:04September meeting, I think indicated that there was a deadline
- 4:08that was fairly short, and that redacted and redacted and
- 4:12some working together would go back and work out an
- 4:15agreement based on those terms. And you know, in the
- 4:17give and take, if they think that this is an
- 4:20important concession, that's within their discretion. But I would have
- 4:24been comfortable with sticking with the charge sheet with something
- 4:27that drove me is when when I said something as
- 4:30a general matter, I didn't bluff. I really meant what
- 4:33I said. Question. So in that term sheet, I mean
- 4:36to be fairer. That mental letter says is two years
- 4:39answer write question is a minimum. If the decision to
- 4:44agree to let them plead to one as opposed to
- 4:46all three had no impact on that two years, would
- 4:49you have cared answer fair enough, and so going back
- 4:53to where you know, to an earlier discussion, can I
- 4:55get another red bull? Going back to an earlier discussion,
- 4:58I think I indicated that the charges, the state charges
- 5:01I wasn't familiar with, and so if in the give
- 5:05and take those charges changed, my focus was on two
- 5:08years registration and restitution as long as those charges were
- 5:12captured the conduct in some appropriate way. Question. So later,
- 5:16rather much later, the Defense Council admitted that at this
- 5:20meeting they thought that under misinformation from the State Attorney's
- 5:24office that the charge that they got the U. S
- 5:26Attorney's Office or somehow the US Attorney's Office approved the
- 5:30seven ninety three, seven ninety six to dot ZHO three
- 5:33charge was not sex offender registrable. And that's a pretty
- 5:37major mistake, right, I mean, it goes right to the
- 5:41heart of it, to one of your major concerns. Answer,
- 5:45And they tried to get us to change that, and
- 5:47I said, no, question, the defense tried to get you
- 5:50off sex offender registration answer pretty vigorously. Question right, But
- 5:56at this point the focus is on the charge and
- 5:59the defense is one might characterize it as trying to
- 6:02pull a fast one by agreeing wholeheartedly to plead the
- 6:05one charge, knowing or at least believing incorrectly that it
- 6:08was not registerrable, and the US Attorney's Office not having
- 6:12that belief but thinking it was registerrable. So there's a disconnect.
- 6:17There is error, and the error stems as they later
- 6:20learned from the ASA herself. So as we look at
- 6:24that and wonder whether that shouldn't have raised some concern
- 6:28that this plan to put things back in the hands
- 6:31of the state, which had kind of mishandled the case
- 6:33to begin with, was at this point even a good
- 6:36idea because they were continually well, I won't characterize it
- 6:41but less than reliable. Is that a fair comment or
- 6:44a concern answer? So one question I would have is
- 6:48at what point did we become aware that there had
- 6:51been First the error was in our favor, not the
- 6:53defense's favor, because redacted got it right as opposed to
- 6:57the ASA question correct answer. And secondly, at what point
- 7:02did our team become aware of them trying to pull
- 7:04a fast one? Was it before or after the signing
- 7:07of the NPA question? It was well after answer right question.
- 7:13But the point here is that the US Attorney's Office
- 7:16folks were not familiar with the state procedure, the state
- 7:19criminal procedure, and the ins and outs of the sentencing
- 7:22and incarceration as you learn later. So didn't this put
- 7:26the US Attorney's office side at a substantial disadvantage in
- 7:29trying to play in the sandbox in which both defense
- 7:33Local Defense Council and the asas were very comfortable answer possibly,
- 7:38although I would point out that it was the AUSA
- 7:41who got it right question eventually, answer not eventually, the
- 7:47AUSA was correct in her analysis. So in this case
- 7:51she was more familiar than the state attorneys. Question not
- 7:54by practice but by research, answer by research. So my
- 7:59point is, if we had good people that were able
- 8:01to if they weren't familiar with something, the research clearly
- 8:04worked question. But it took as you saw in the
- 8:08process of dealing with the work release and all of that,
- 8:11it took a lot of work to keep up with
- 8:13those errors answer. Which is why I say, in hindsight,
- 8:17if given all the effort that took place after this
- 8:20deferred to the state was reached, if all of that
- 8:23it had been known, I really think the analysis would
- 8:26have proceeded differently, because that was a lot of work
- 8:29that was probably as much work, if not more than
- 8:32a trial question, right, right, right. Meanwhile, and we'll talk
- 8:37about the actual text of the NPA in a moment.
- 8:39But following that, No, actually, before it was being finalized,
- 8:44before it was finalized or redacted, was working to identify
- 8:47a federal charge, as we discussed before. In that process
- 8:52she came up with a plan that would have resulted
- 8:54cobpling things together in an eighteen month sentence instead of
- 8:57twenty four months. Somehow that became the new floor, the
- 9:01new standard. Do you know how that came about and
- 9:03who actually agreed to that? Answer? I don't. I referenced
- 9:08the one email where I think redacted says he argued
- 9:10twelve question right, answer, I said, twenty four, we agree
- 9:14to eighteen. I assume in the give and take this
- 9:17was an agreement that was reached. Question, But that was
- 9:21eighteen as to the potential federal charges. It somehow became
- 9:26imported into the state disposition. Answer. I can't speak to that.
- 9:31This was something that the trial team was negotiating, and
- 9:34from my perspective, these were the terms that we wanted,
- 9:38These were the terms that I expected if they came
- 9:40back and said no, deal, disappointed, but go forward. But
- 9:44they tried to get a deal and he gets cut
- 9:47off there question the defense tried answer, No, the prosecutors,
- 9:51and to some extent, you know, they and the give
- 9:54and take of any negotiation. I don't think it's unfair
- 9:57for an AUSA to give up some things. Question, but
- 10:01you had stated clearly to not only the defense team
- 10:04through the mental letter, but also I believe at the
- 10:07end of September seventh meeting that two years was the deal.
- 10:11So did somebody come to you and say, looks like
- 10:13it's going to be eighteen months and allow you to
- 10:16then approve that answer? I don't recall if someone came
- 10:19to me separately or independently of the final judgment. I
- 10:23clearly approved it at some point, and so to the
- 10:25extent it was approved that that's on me. But I
- 10:28would argue that you know someone's negotiating. One says twenty four,
- 10:32another side says twelve, they say let's agree to eighteen.
- 10:37To some extent, As US attorney, I think I have
- 10:40to back the negotiating discretion of my ausas. But you
- 10:44explained quite eloquently the reasoning for the two year plea
- 10:48as being what Epstein would have faced if he had
- 10:51been prosecuted, you know, absentia, but the state appropriately and
- 10:55then suddenly, without any apparent relationship to that analysis, the
- 10:59eighteen months pop up from an effort to try to
- 11:01get federal charges. And so how do you how does
- 11:05that not undercut the basis for the two years? Answer?
- 11:09So I can provide the reasoning for the two years.
- 11:11I can also, though, think as a supervisor a US attorney,
- 11:16it's important to understand that when individuals go out in
- 11:19the field, negotiations take place, and if every time there
- 11:22is some give, they need to come back to the
- 11:24US attorney or there is a fear that the US
- 11:26attorney will not back us. And you know, there is
- 11:29a certain I think there's a management issue therein that
- 11:33if an AUSA speaking on behalf of the US makes
- 11:36an argument or an agreement, as long as that agreement
- 11:39is within a certain range, the US attorney should back
- 11:42that because they're the ones that are in or on
- 11:45the ground, they're on the line, they're the ones that
- 11:47are managing the case, and it's sort of unfair to
- 11:50consistently second guess those late night. I don't want to
- 11:53characterize it as late night negotiations, but those that give
- 11:58and take that happen sometimes conference room or on the phone. Question,
- 12:03do you know exactly what give and take occurred in
- 12:05this case regarding the eighteen months? Answer? I do not.
- 12:09I read that one document. Question. Okay, answer, but I
- 12:13do not question really quick. I agree with what you're
- 12:16saying in principle, But in this case, you had a
- 12:20almost like a mandatory two years is a minimum that
- 12:23the US attorney will accept under those circumstances where you
- 12:27have come out and said this is the minimum that
- 12:30will accept. Would you have expected them to have to
- 12:32come back to you to get approval for any kind
- 12:35of reduction in that amount? Answer? Would I have expected them?
- 12:39I think misreadacted was in a tough position because opposing
- 12:43counsel was coming at her. It was a tough negotiation.
- 12:47Would I have wanted two years? Yes? Would I falter
- 12:50for agreeing to eighteen months? I don't think that's for
- 12:53to her question? You could have said no, right answer,
- 12:57I could have, but it was she agreed to it.
- 13:00The process has gone further down, and to some extent,
- 13:03I think that there is a need to respect the process.
- 13:07I guess I was getting you know, this is not
- 13:09the only case where a supervisor sort of says this
- 13:12is the standard, and at some point things move and
- 13:15you've got to provide some discretion question. All right, okay, folks,
- 13:20we're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next
- 13:22episode dealing with the topic, we'll pick up where we
- 13:25left off. All of the information that goes with this
- 13:28episode can be found in the description box.