Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep1: GRD001 - Should I Take Social Security at Age 62?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a coin
- 0:30winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to argue.
- 0:33And both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions, whether we
- 0:38agree with them or not at the end of each.
- 0:42There's going to be one clear winner, you a more informed saver
- 0:45who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate to your
- 0:49own personal situation, to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Jeff Levine: Welcome to episode one of the great retirement debate.
- 1:06I am Jeff Levine with me ed slot ed.
- 1:09It is great to be with you today.
- 1:11And I am really looking forward to our first great retirement debate.
- 1:16Ed Slott: I'm excited about getting these critical topics out to people
- 1:20who are viewing or listening.
- 1:22These are critical issues for those heading into retirement already there,
- 1:26and even beyond to your beneficiaries.
- 1:28Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 1:29We'll be talking about a, a slew of issues related to retirement and
- 1:33sort of highlighting the pros and cons by arguing each side, but of.
- 1:37No decision is, or rarely is a decision.
- 1:40All pluses are all minuses and it's just gonna be a matter of individuals weighing
- 1:46these decisions and pros and cons for themselves as to how they should act.
- 1:50But simply knowing the pluses and minuses is a really important first step.
- 1:56Ed Slott: That's true.
- 1:57And the big takeaways you'll get from each of these items, each
- 2:00of these debate episodes, you know, we may be debating aside.
- 2:04We don't even agree on we're gonna flip a coin, but the benefit to
- 2:08you is you'll have a good list.
- 2:10You know, if you are thinking about making this decision,
- 2:13you'll have the pros and cons.
- 2:14And as Jeff said, the pluses and minus.
- 2:16Benefits or drawbacks, and you'll be able to formulate, which of these
- 2:20items are most important to you based on your own particular facts
- 2:24and finances and circumstances.
- 2:26And I believe this will help you make important financial decisions.
- 2:30Jeff Levine: Well, that's certainly the goal.
- 2:31And over the course of, uh, over the course of time, ed we'll
- 2:35debate things that may apply to some people, but not others.
- 2:38But today in episode one, We're going to kick it off with a topic
- 2:43that applies to just about everybody and that's social security.
- 2:46And specifically, we're gonna start by debating, should I
- 2:51take social security at age 62?
- 2:55Ed, my topic means your choice for the coin flip.
- 2:58What do you want head I'll say or.
- 3:00Ed Slott: I'll say heads, heads.
- 3:02Jeff Levine: All right.
- 3:03Heads.
- 3:03It is.
- 3:04We're gonna flip a coin here and you're listening.
- 3:06So you're just gonna have to take our word for it that we're
- 3:08flipping the coin, but we've got it.
- 3:10And ed, it is heads.
- 3:11So what do you want to argue?
- 3:13Do you wanna argue today, uh, that you should delay social security beyond 62?
- 3:17Or do you want to argue, take it as early as possible?
- 3:20Ed Slott: Oh, I got a break on this first episode because I would always
- 3:22say not always, nothing is always, but I feel more comfortable holding off
- 3:27till age 70 when you get the highest.
- 3:30Jeff Levine: All right.
- 3:30Well, thanks very much.
- 3:31I will then take the, uh, the side of the argument that says, take it
- 3:35at 62 and I'm gonna start with my potentially biggest argument, which
- 3:38is, I don't know what the future holds.
- 3:41Ed, what if I die at 63?
- 3:43What if I die at 64?
- 3:45What if I die young?
- 3:46Ed Slott: Let me stop you there.
- 3:47If you die at 63 at 64, you're dead.
- 3:49You won't need it anymore.
- 3:51Jeff Levine: Yeah, but think about all the money I would've left on the table.
- 3:55If I had delayed taking social security until let's say full retirement age,
- 4:00somewhere between 66 and 67, or even as late as 70, I might not get anything.
- 4:05If I wait until 70 and I die at 69, there's no back check that my airs
- 4:10get for nine years of missed payments.
- 4:14Ed Slott: That's true.
- 4:15And it always is going to come down to your best estimate
- 4:20of when you're going to die.
- 4:21Sorry to say.
- 4:22I mean, it all comes out.
- 4:24Even social security actuarily has this figured out.
- 4:27I don't know what the actual break even day, uh, year is.
- 4:30Age?
- 4:31Uh, I think it's 83.
- 4:32Is that about right?
- 4:3382, 83?
- 4:34What, what is?
- 4:35Jeff Levine: Yeah, roughly somewhere in there depends upon the individual
- 4:37and when they're full retirement ages and all their benefits, but yeah,
- 4:40usually you have to live to about 82, 83 to see a crossover benefit.
- 4:45Ed Slott: Right.
- 4:45So that's really the question.
- 4:47Do you want smaller checks for a longer period of time or larger checks for
- 4:52a shorter period of time, but if you hit break, even you will break even.
- 4:58Uh, but if you live hopefully a long and healthy life, then you're going
- 5:02to benefit from those extra years.
- 5:06Jeff Levine: Yeah, I, I, well look, most people end up doing that and
- 5:09most people do end up taking it early.
- 5:11Uh, in fact, there's research from social security and we can put, a
- 5:15link to this in the show notes that talks about how more than seven in
- 5:1910 people, more than 70% of people.
- 5:23Are taking social security, uh, before they hit 64.
- 5:28So maybe not as early as 62, but pretty early well before full retirement age,
- 5:33and one of the reasons they may be doing it is that they may need that income.
- 5:38You know, unfortunately there are a lot of people we'll talk about a
- 5:41lot of topics that on this show that applied to, uh, people of all different
- 5:45wealth spheres, people with right less wealth people with more wealth.
- 5:49But those who work kind of the typical blue collar jobs, the,
- 5:53the physically demanding jobs, they tend to need to retire sooner
- 5:58because they can't work anymore.
- 6:01They're physically not able to.
- 6:02And if you're not able to do that well, social security may
- 6:06be your only income stream.
- 6:08Ed Slott: Right, so then obviously I agree with that because if you need
- 6:10the money, you have to take it, but then you are also, uh, locking in
- 6:14lower checks for the rest of your life.
- 6:18One option is if you really needed the money and you were fortunate enough
- 6:22maybe to have an IRA, you're better off taking from your IRA, even though
- 6:26those distributions are taxable.
- 6:28If you needed the money, you'd probably be in a much lower bracket and, uh, IRAs
- 6:34are, you know, a hundred percent taxable.
- 6:36Whereas social security, at most is only 85% taxable, but you may do better.
- 6:41I think you would do better, tapping your taxable IRA at low rates for
- 6:46those years, 62 to 70, and then, uh, your RMDs at 72 will probably be lower
- 6:54because you tapped in earlier and then you can, uh, have the larger social
- 6:58security check take over at age 70.
- 7:01Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 7:01So let let's break down some of what you were just talking about.
- 7:04Cause there's a lot to unpack there, ed, for, for those listening today.
- 7:07So first off as hopefully most people know if you take social
- 7:12security early at 62, you will have your monthly benefit reduced.
- 7:16At full retirement age, which varies depending upon
- 7:19your ear, your year of birth.
- 7:20And we'll put a link to that, uh, site for social security in our show notes as well.
- 7:25Uh, depending upon the year you were born, your full retirement age is likely to be
- 7:30right now, somewhere between 66 and 67.
- 7:32If you take social security early for each month, you claim early,
- 7:36there's kind of like a penalty.
- 7:37If you will.
- 7:38Then at full retirement age, you get what's called your UNUC benefit
- 7:42effectively, your full social security benefit, but that's not the
- 7:46biggest benefit that you could get.
- 7:48Because if you wait beyond your full retirement age, you get an 8% increase
- 7:53per year or one 12th of 8% per month that you wait beyond your full retirement age.
- 8:00You see your payments for life automatically increased by that amount.
- 8:05In addition, ed, you referenced RMDs there.
- 8:07Of course you were referring to required minimum distributions,
- 8:09Ed Slott: Right, right.
- 8:10Jeff Levine: The requirement that once you hit 72, you must begin to
- 8:15take distributions from your IRAs.
- 8:18Which can increase your income and cause other sorts of tax impacts, whether
- 8:21it raises your Medicare part B premium or increases your tax bracket, etc.
- 8:26So, a lot to unpack there.
- 8:29But , I think one of the other issues I would point to here is that is,
- 8:33is actually echoing a thought that you made, but looking at it from the
- 8:36opposite side, which is, if i don't if I take my retirement dollars and
- 8:43I delay social security, that means i'm burning down my retirement assets,
- 8:48my liquid assets, the things that I could leave to an heir or that I might
- 8:51use the assets later on in my life.
- 8:53Whereas if I take social security early, That means I can leave maybe
- 8:58more of my IRA or 401k or other assets invested for the long run.
- 9:02And if something happens to me, those assets do get past the heirs.
- 9:05And if I can let them grow, then they are available later in life for me.
- 9:09Well, here's what I would say to that.
- 9:11Ed Slott: If you need the money, that would be the only reason.
- 9:14If somebody came to me and said, should I take it early?
- 9:16And they absolutely need the money.
- 9:18If you need the money, you shouldn't be worried about your heir.
- 9:21They're gonna get whatever is left.
- 9:22They're an afterthought.
- 9:24If you need the money, you have to take your take care of yourself first.
- 9:28And if you need the money, you're better off taking from your IRA.
- 9:31Don't worry.
- 9:32What you're going to leave to your kids.
- 9:33Take from your IRA, uh, because you'll have a much lower tax.
- 9:37Bill, because I'm assuming if you need the money, you're probably in a lower bracket
- 9:41and then you can get that much larger.
- 9:44You can lock in a larger check.
- 9:46If you hold off on the social security till age 70.
- 9:49Yes, you'll have a lower IRA, but that's lower taxes you'll have going forward.
- 9:55While you'll have social security now, uh, it could be that if you've taken down more
- 10:00of your IRA during your lifetime, maybe your income would be low enough with RMDs.
- 10:06Those required minimum distributions that less of your now locked in
- 10:10largest social security check, actually largest, uh, uh, 70.
- 10:15It doesn't go past that.
- 10:17That's your lock in less of that will become taxable due to increased income.
- 10:22If you, um, Have a larger IRA because you held off your RMDs could be larger
- 10:28and that could trigger taxation of, of your social security or higher taxation.
- 10:34But to one of your other points, Jeff, you said if I need the money and
- 10:37again, I think we both agree if you need the money, you have to take it.
- 10:39And there are no alternatives.
- 10:41But if let's say, uh, I'll talk about another penalty you didn't mention.
- 10:45Let's say you need the money.
- 10:47You take social security early, but you still need money and you get a job at 62.
- 10:52What happens then?
- 10:54Jeff Levine: Well, if I make too much, they withhold my social security and it's
- 10:57like, I never claimed in the first place.
- 10:59Ed Slott: And that's gone.
- 11:00Jeff Levine: Well, if you live long enough, if you live, let's
- 11:03say until full retirement age.
- 11:04Yeah.
- 11:04They effectively will add back those dollars.
- 11:07Right.
- 11:07It treats it as though you hadn't claimed it, but yes, you're certainly not
- 11:10getting social security for those months.
- 11:13Ed Slott: So if you need the money, obviously you have to take it, but
- 11:16you should look for other resources.
- 11:18If you do have traditional IRAs, I always say you're better off
- 11:21in your sixties using your IRAs.
- 11:23Not before sixties at 59 and a half.
- 11:25There's a penalty if you tap it too early.
- 11:28But you're better off using, in my opinion, I'm taking that side of
- 11:31the argument and I'm glad I'm taking that side because many times on
- 11:35these debates, you're going to find, uh, based on the flip of the coin,
- 11:38we're taking a side we really don't agree with, but that's your benefit.
- 11:42We're arguing both sides of the coin here.
- 11:44Uh, but, uh, that's the side I would've argued anyway, to hold off
- 11:48to lock in the largest possible check, uh, given today's life expectancy,
- 11:53you could go into your nineties.
- 11:54I'd rather you have a check, a larger, a larger check locked in at
- 11:58age 70 for the rest of your life.
- 12:00Jeff Levine: All right.
- 12:01Well, I'm gonna, I'm gonna hit on that for a moment by delaying
- 12:05you a larger check down the road.
- 12:07Like at some point.
- 12:08I'm not gonna be traveling as much anymore.
- 12:10I'm not gonna be doing the things, right.
- 12:11Like in retirement, we often hear people refer to as the three phases of retirement
- 12:15to go go years, your slow years, and then sadly your, your no go years.
- 12:21Right.
- 12:22And so what, what do I care from getting a bigger check when I'm 85?
- 12:26Like who really cares, cuz I'm not gonna be able to enjoy it at that time.
- 12:29Whereas at 62, you know, I, 62 63, 64.
- 12:34Hey, ed 62 is the new 42.
- 12:37Right?
- 12:37So , so with that in mind, maybe I'd rather have that
- 12:42income, even if I don't need it.
- 12:44Right.
- 12:44Even if I do have these other assets that I could tap, maybe I'd rather
- 12:47take that social security now, you know, if it means a lower check later
- 12:51in life who cares, cause I got more money, more income at the time of
- 12:55my life when I could enjoy it more.
- 12:57Ed Slott: All right.
- 12:57Here's where all of you will benefit from, uh, Jeff and I doing
- 13:01this great retirement debate.
- 13:03Our age difference probably around 30 years.
- 13:07Jeff has just described the mantra for maybe his generation Yolo , uh,
- 13:13you only live once, spend it now and don't worry about the future.
- 13:17Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 13:18Ed Slott: Uh, but I'm with my generation, the baby boomers, maybe
- 13:22more of you, uh, listening here now.
- 13:25And.
- 13:26Everybody wants a larger check.
- 13:28So watch you don't spend it on the things you can't do as many things.
- 13:31There's other things you will need that money.
- 13:35Jeff Levine: All right.
- 13:35Fair enough.
- 13:36Maybe some generational differences.
- 13:37I'm also forced to make this argument.
- 13:40I must point out once again.
- 13:43uh, ed, what any other key insights you have as to why someone should
- 13:48not take social security at age 62?
- 13:50Ed Slott: It's simply to lock in the largest possible check
- 13:54for the longest period of time.
- 13:56And I believe that's by holding.
- 13:58If you can, Jeff makes a good point.
- 14:00If you can, till age 70 and lock that in now, Jeff, a point you didn't make,
- 14:06uh, which I'll go on your side, but I don't think it's a big point, but
- 14:09I'll, I'll throw one on your end of the
- 14:11Jeff Levine: Yeah throw me a bone.
- 14:12I got a hard argument here to start,
- 14:14Ed Slott: Right, right.
- 14:15You see, I saw a story.
- 14:16I mean, you see it every day, social security's going bankrupt.
- 14:19So get it while you can back to your Yolo argument.
- 14:23Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 14:23Get it while you cause right now, if we do nothing and, and that's a fair,
- 14:26I was gonna, I was gonna to, to bring that up here at the end, but I, I
- 14:30appreciate you, you raising it , right?
- 14:32Social security is currently scheduled to go.
- 14:36Now in fairness, not bankrupt, truly in the sense that it won't be
- 14:39able to pay anything, but benefits are only scheduled to be about
- 14:4275, 80% of what they're promised beginning in about 10 years or so.
- 14:49And so do you want to count on our politicians creating this fix at the
- 14:54last minute as they often do or, are we likely to continue to see a lot of
- 14:58what's going on today in our political climate, which is no compromise
- 15:03on anything, no matter what it.
- 15:06Right.
- 15:07And
- 15:07Ed Slott: here's another benefit of the generational difference.
- 15:09I'm not worried about that because, uh, no politician, it's the third
- 15:14rail is gonna touch social security for people of my age, who vote.
- 15:20They're not going to touch it.
- 15:22And you know what I paid in all those years, let the kids and the
- 15:26grandkids behind me let them pay in.
- 15:28And, uh, they're on their own.
- 15:31. Jeff Levine: All right.
- 15:32Well, so now, now we really are on our own.
- 15:34See, now, you know, now I know why we want to YOLO.
- 15:36Ed Slott: Yeah, yeah.
- 15:37Right.
- 15:38No, I, I admit it that way, but really, you know, if you're looking
- 15:41at it from our, my age to baby boomers, we've been paying into
- 15:45this for most of our working years.
- 15:47Since the, the day I got that first check and just...
- 15:49Jeff Levine: yeah, but you've been paying in for other people
- 15:51and I'll be paying in for you,
- 15:53Ed Slott: right.
- 15:56Jeff Levine: That still me.
- 15:56Unfortunately, there were just too many of you, ed.
- 15:59There's just so many darn boomers that we're gonna run outta.
- 16:02Ed Slott: Oh, I know.
- 16:03So I'll wait till 70, but you keep paying in for me, Jeff.
- 16:07I think that's so, so great of you in the generation below me.
- 16:11Jeff Levine: I am happy to do it.
- 16:12It's it's it's my, my.
- 16:14My privilege that's uh, well, and I'll give you one more, uh, ed and, and I,
- 16:18and I'll, I'll make, uh, you know, you were so kind as to throw me a bone, I
- 16:22I'll make, uh, I'll make an easy argument for you if you're the lower earner.
- 16:25So already I know where you can go here with another argument, but if
- 16:28you are the lower earner of a married couple claiming it's 62 can be pretty
- 16:34beneficial as well, because there.
- 16:37Either you or your spouse die young.
- 16:41That becomes a good decision because if you are the lower earner,
- 16:45when whoever dies first dies.
- 16:48So too, does your lower check, right?
- 16:51So if you are the lower earner, it's really not a matter of when will I die.
- 16:55It's a matter of when will I or my spouse die.
- 16:59And while mathematically and actuarily, we could say, well, if you live to
- 17:0282 or 83, It actually, if you're married couple, most couples, the
- 17:07lower earner probably shouldn't wait until 70 because it requires both
- 17:11people to live a really long time in order for that decision to pay off.
- 17:15So maybe 62 is, is early and I'm forced to make an argument
- 17:18Ed Slott: that's too early, but maybe if you're in your late sixties,
- 17:21that argument could hold water.
- 17:23Uh, for example, if spouse is older than you, like you.
- 17:27Jeff Levine: Yeah, right.
- 17:27Because at, at, at the first death, that higher check will
- 17:31live on with the survivor,
- 17:32Ed Slott: right.
- 17:33Jeff Levine: No matter who it is.
- 17:34And so the lower spouse, like when people come into my office, right?
- 17:37You, you talk about like real office situations.
- 17:39When people come in and they're kind of set and they say, well, we really
- 17:41wanted to start taking social security.
- 17:43I always say, if you wanna play with one of them and get it early,
- 17:46use the lower income spouse, like have them take it early and let the
- 17:51higher spouse be the one to delay.
- 17:54Ed Slott: All right, these are all good arguments.
- 17:56I still stick, uh, stick to my guns, get the largest check for
- 17:59the longest period of time, but not everything's for everyone.
- 18:03So, Jeff, I want you to explain how each one of these episodes are going to end
- 18:08that you have to make your own decisions.
- 18:10We hope we gave you all the information, the pluses, minuses,
- 18:13benefits, and drawbacks, and all the considerations to make the best decision.
- 18:17Remember, this is a long term decision.
- 18:20There's no going back on that.
- 18:21So it takes a lot of.
- 18:23Jeff Levine: You're right.
- 18:23And, and that's why we say there are two sides to every coin, but your
- 18:28life, your retirement decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 18:33And so the one thing that ed and I always agree on is that you should
- 18:37make sure you're discussing these important decisions with a knowledgeable
- 18:42financial advisor or tax professional so that you can weigh the pros and
- 18:45cons of the different options against your specific goals and circumstances.
- 18:50Now, ed and I would love to hear from you what'd you like.
- 18:54What can we do better?
- 18:55Do you have a thought on why you should take social security earlier
- 18:58later we didn't mention, or a particular point you thought was,
- 19:01uh, that important or you just have a topic for us for a future debate.
- 19:06Again, we'd love to hear from you.
- 19:07You can reach out to us on Twitter, reach out to ed at @theslottreport.
- 19:12That's at the slot with two Ts report and you can reach out to.
- 19:15Using the, handle @CPAPlanner.
- 19:18Again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 19:20Uh, we thank you for joining us.
- 19:22We look forward to this project.
- 19:23We've got a lot more topics lined up, uh, for the future.
- 19:27And I sincerely hope that you're able to make better decisions
- 19:31because of some of the information you've learned here today and in our
- 19:34future episodes, ed, this was fun.
- 19:36I look forward to doing this again real soon.
- 19:38Thanks so much.
- 19:39Ed Slott: All right, Jeff, we'll see, on the next episode
- 19:41of the great retirement debate!