Latest / Reformed Thinking / Christian Freedom | John Calvin

Transcript

Christian Freedom | John Calvin · Reformed Thinking

0:00
Welcome to The Deep Dive, the show where we take your sources
0:03
and distill the most compelling insights, helping you become
0:06
truly well informed. Today we're doing a deep dive
0:09
into something really foundational for for our walk as
0:13
Christians. It's this concept from Reformed
0:15
thinking known as Christian freedom.
0:17
We've got a great set of sources here, mainly from 1, you know,
0:20
highly influential theologian unpacking this doctrine.
0:24
And our mission really for this deep dive is to get a handle on
0:27
Christian freedom in its, well, it's true nature.
0:30
What does it mean for your conscience before God?
0:33
How does it change the way you approach obedience?
0:35
And how does it guide your everyday choices, your
0:37
interactions with others? So yeah, get ready for some, I
0:40
think, really enlightening distinctions and some very
0:42
practical wisdom. Yeah, It was really interesting
0:45
looking at these sources, how they present Christian freedom.
0:47
It's not just some, you know, abstract theological point.
0:50
They actually call it a prime necessity for genuine peace of
0:53
soul. That's pretty strong language.
0:56
It suggests that if you don't grasp this properly, it can lead
0:58
to a whole lot of doubt, anxiety, even even fear in your
1:02
spiritual life. A prime necessity.
1:05
Exactly. And this deep dive, I think,
1:07
will show us that Christian freedom isn't simple.
1:10
It's got different parts, distinct aspects, and each one
1:13
addresses a really critical area of our relationship with God and
1:16
also with our neighbor. And if you step back and look at
1:19
the bigger picture, you can see why this teaching has been,
1:23
well, frankly so often misunderstood or even misused
1:26
throughout history. Sometimes it's twisted into an
1:28
excuse for just doing whatever you want, unrestrained desires.
1:31
Other times people just dismiss it entirely.
1:34
So it's easily distorted then? Very easily, which raises a
1:37
really pertinent question for all of us, for you listening,
1:40
How do we actually walk in the real liberty crisis provided
1:44
without falling into, you know, 1 ditch or the other these
1:47
common traps? Right.
1:49
That's the balancing act. We need to figure out one vital
1:52
nature of Christian freedom. OK, let's unpack that necessity
1:54
part first. You said the sources call it a
1:56
prime necessity. Why?
1:58
Why is understanding this so absolutely crucial for us?
2:01
What's really at stake if we just sort of skim over it?
2:03
Well, the picture the sources paint is pretty stark, actually.
2:07
They say that without this understanding, our consciences
2:10
would, and I'm quoting here, dare undertake almost nothing
2:13
without doubting. Imagine that they'd hesitate and
2:17
recoil from many things. They constantly waver and are
2:20
afraid. Wow, that sounds exhausting.
2:22
Just constant second guessing. It really does.
2:25
It depicts a soul that's genuinely troubled, you know,
2:28
lacking any settled peace, any real repose before God.
2:31
It's someone living with his constant spiritual hesitation,
2:34
annoying uncertainty about pretty much every action, every
2:37
thought. Are they doing enough?
2:39
Are they messing up? Are they offending God?
2:41
They get paralyzed by scruples, basically unable to move forward
2:45
with any kind of joyful conviction.
2:46
OK. So it directly impacts our inner
2:48
peace. Hugely.
2:49
And it's tied to something else foundational.
2:52
The doctrine is also described as an appendage of
2:54
justification. An appendage?
2:55
What does that mean exactly? Like an add on.
2:57
Not quite just an add on, more like something intrinsically
3:00
connected, something that helps us fully grasp the implications
3:04
of justification. Justification, you know, is how
3:07
God declares his righteous in his sight, not because of us,
3:10
but because of Christ's work credited to us.
3:13
Christian freedom helps us understand the scope, the reach,
3:16
the practical effect of that declaration in our lives.
3:20
Without it, we can't really get the full weight of what it means
3:23
to be declared righteous. It's kind of the living it out
3:25
part of justification. I see.
3:27
So justification declares our standing, and freedom helps us
3:31
live out of that standing without fear.
3:33
That's a good way to put it, and the sources go further.
3:35
They say the absence of this knowledge leaves us unable to
3:38
rightly know Christ, specifically in his liberating
3:42
work. We can't fully grasp gospel
3:44
truth and it's freeing aspects, and we certainly can't
3:47
experience that inner acquisive skull they keep mentioning.
3:50
So yeah, it's considered absolutely vital in this
3:52
theological framework. You can't suppress it without
3:55
really damaging A believer's spiritual health and their
3:57
ability to live a life that actually pleases God without
3:59
being crippled by fear. OK, it's clearly central then
4:03
foundational to our well-being, our daily experience of faith.
4:06
But you also mentioned dangers. If it's misunderstood, what are
4:10
these pitfalls? What do they look like in real
4:12
life? Right, there are two main
4:13
dangers the sources point out. Kind of opposite extremes.
4:16
On one side you have misapplication.
4:19
Some people grab onto this idea of freedom and as the sources
4:22
put it, they shake off all obedience toward God and break
4:24
out into unbridled license. So using freedom as an excuse to
4:28
sin. Exactly.
4:29
They twist liberty into basically a permission slip for
4:33
sinful living, indulging their own desires, misusing God's good
4:36
gifts for purely selfish ends. The sources give examples like
4:40
lavish and ostentatious banquets, bodily apparel, and
4:43
domestic architecture. It's not just enjoying nice
4:45
things, it's this drive to outstrip neighbors and all sorts
4:49
of elegance and justifying it all by saying, hey, I'm free in
4:52
Christ. Keeping up with the Joneses.
4:54
Christian Edition. Kind of, yeah.
4:56
It turns freedom into an excuse for immoderate prodigality,
5:01
vanity and arrogance. People can wonderfully flatter
5:05
themselves in their luxury, thinking they're totally fine
5:07
because technically these things are indifferent.
5:10
But that completely misses the point.
5:12
True freedom, the sources argue, leads to greater restraint and
5:15
love, not just letting loose. OK, so that's one danger
5:19
license. What's the other side?
5:21
The. Other side is that some people
5:22
disdain Christian freedom altogether.
5:25
They think it takes away all moderation, order, and choice of
5:27
things. These folks often fear that
5:30
freedom leads to chaos, moral looseness, or disrespect for
5:34
proper boundaries and authority. So they cling too tightly to
5:37
rules. Often, yes.
5:38
They might cling to external rules, human traditions,
5:41
specific observances, even when they're not commanded by God,
5:45
all out of the sort of misplaced desire for spiritual certainty
5:48
or control. They might see genuine Christian
5:50
liberty as a threat to piety or good order, which can lead them
5:53
down a path of being overly scrupulous, even legalistic.
5:56
They end up burdened by things God never intended to burden
5:59
them with. So license on one side, legalism
6:01
or fear on the other. Precisely.
6:04
And this brings us back to that key question, how do we make
6:07
sure this essential doctrine is understood correctly so that
6:10
it's, well, it's incomparable benefit can actually be enjoyed
6:14
by people who seriously fear God, rather than being dismissed
6:18
by those who feared or caricatured and abused by those
6:21
who just want an excuse for their desires.
6:24
Our aim here is really to clarify these points, to show
6:26
that Christian freedom's real purpose is always, as the
6:29
sources say, to encourage us to good, never, ever to excuse sin.
6:34
The striking thing is Christian freedom is meant to bring peace,
6:37
but if you misuse it or reject it, you end up with either
6:40
unrestrained living or crippling legalism.
6:43
Both really undermine genuine faith.
6:45
That really sets the stage. Well, we see why it's needed and
6:47
what happens when it goes wrong. So let's get into the specifics.
6:51
Our sources break Christian freedom down into 3 distinct
6:53
parts. Let's tackle the first one.
6:56
Freedom from the law for justification.
6:58
What does that mean for us practically, especially when we
7:00
think about standing before God? The three components of
7:03
Christian freedom. OK.
7:04
This first part is fundamental. It tells us that when we're
7:08
seeking assurance of our justification, you know how
7:11
we're declared righteous and accepted by God.
7:14
Our consciences should rise above and advance beyond the
7:17
law, forgetting all law righteousness.
7:20
Forgetting all law righteousness, that sounds
7:22
pretty radical. It is.
7:23
It's a complete ship in perspective.
7:25
The basis for it is straightforward, the law, and
7:28
it's perfect standard. It's pure form.
7:30
Well, it leaves no one righteous through their own efforts.
7:34
None of us measures up. If we're judged by that absolute
7:37
standard, we always fall short. So when we're talking about how
7:40
we become righteous in God's eyes, we have to be freed from
7:43
the law's demands, its condemnations.
7:46
We take no account of works. Because our works will always be
7:49
imperfect. Always the law, if you apply its
7:52
full rigor, condemns every single imperfection.
7:55
And since all our works, even our very best ones, are tainted
7:58
by sin, somehow they just don't pass muster before God's perfect
8:01
judgement. They'd always be found wanting.
8:03
So what do we look to then, if not the law or our works?
8:06
Instead, the sources say, we embrace God's mercy alone, turn
8:10
our attention from ourselves, and look only to Christ.
8:14
The focus completely shifts. It's not about how we become
8:18
righteous through our own striving or how we might somehow
8:20
manage to fulfill the law perfectly because we can't.
8:23
Rather, the question becomes how, being unrighteous and
8:26
unworthy, we may be reckoned righteous.
8:29
And the answer is solely through Christ, through His perfect
8:33
life, His death that paid for our sin, His resurrection.
8:36
So when it comes to that ultimate question of our
8:38
standing before God at His judgment seat, our conscience is
8:42
totally free from the law's demands and condemnation.
8:45
It rests completely confidently in Christ alone.
8:47
OK, so the law has absolutely no role in getting us justified.
8:51
But that raises a big question for a lot of people, I think.
8:53
Does that make the law totally irrelevant for believers then?
8:56
Does it just have no ongoing place in our lives if we're free
8:58
from it in this specific way? That's a really common question,
9:01
and it's crucial, and it's exactly where the sources draw a
9:04
very careful, very necessary distinction.
9:07
They want to make sure this freedom doesn't slide into
9:10
antinomianism. You know, the idea that the law
9:14
is just useless for believers now.
9:15
Right against the law entirely. Exactly so this freedom
9:19
definitely does not mean the law is quote superfluous for
9:23
believers. Not at all.
9:24
In fact, the law still has a vital role.
9:27
It continues to teach, exhort, and urge them to good.
9:30
It awakens and believers A zeal for holiness and innocence.
9:34
It functions as an indispensable guide for living out our
9:37
practice of godliness. It shows us what pleases God.
9:40
It reveals his character. It provides a standard for our
9:42
conduct, inspiring us toward righteous living.
9:45
OK, so it's still our guide for living.
9:46
Yes, but, and this is the critical distinction before
9:50
God's judgement seat, it has no place in their consciences.
9:53
When the question is about justification, how are we made
9:56
right with God? That's a vital separation.
9:59
There's a difference between the law's role in showing us how to
10:01
live righteously and it's complete inability to actually
10:04
make us righteous or earn God's favor.
10:06
So guide for life yes. Basis for acceptance, No.
10:10
You've got it. And this distinction, the
10:12
sources argue, is right at the heart of Paul's letter to the
10:15
Galatians. They point out that Paul's
10:17
intense argument in Galatians isn't just about, say, freedom
10:21
from Jewish ceremonial laws like dietary rules or festivals,
10:25
though those were certainly abolished in Christ.
10:27
It's about a much higher, much more central point Christ
10:31
fulfills with the law only foreshadowed, and because of
10:34
that, believers are now free from the condemnation of the law
10:38
through Christ's work on the cross.
10:40
This allows them to rest with full assurance in Christ alone
10:44
for their standing with God. Paul is adamant if anyone tries
10:48
to get justified by keeping the law, Christ will be of no
10:51
advantage to them at all. That's powerful.
10:53
The revolutionary idea here seems to be that our righteous
10:56
standing before God is entirely outside of ourselves.
10:58
It's found only in Christ. Exactly.
11:00
And that liberates our conscience from that impossible
11:03
burden of trying to perform more perfectly that constant
11:05
treadmill of trying to earn acceptance.
11:07
OK, that clarifies the first part significantly.
11:10
The law guides us but doesn't condemn us in Christ.
11:13
So what about the second part of Christian freedom?
11:16
You called it freedom for willing obedience.
11:18
How does that change our relationship with God's will?
11:20
Does it move us beyond just fearful obligation?
11:23
Yes, absolutely. The second part ensures that our
11:26
consciences observe the law not as is constrained by the
11:30
necessity of the law, but that, freed from the law's yoke, they
11:33
willingly obey God's will. Think about what life would be
11:37
like under the law's strict demands without this freedom.
11:40
The sources describe it as living in perpetual dread.
11:43
Dread. That sounds awful.
11:44
It does, and that kind of dread inherently stifles any eager
11:48
readiness to obey God. It kills joy.
11:51
If our works were constantly being measured against the law's
11:54
perfect standard, they'd always be judged, accursed because of
11:57
our human imperfection. I mean, take the greatest
11:59
commandment. Love God with all your heart,
12:01
soul, strength, mine, even the most mature believers, right?
12:04
We still wrestle with sin, with selfish desires.
12:07
We fall short of that perfect command every single day.
12:10
If our efforts were judged only by that rigorous standard, we
12:13
just feel constant condemnation. We'd never really experienced
12:16
peace with God. So how does freedom change that
12:19
dynamic? Well, freed from this severe
12:21
requirement to this entire rigor of the law's judgement,
12:24
believers now hear God calling them with fatherly gentleness.
12:28
That's the language the sources use.
12:30
And this enables them to cheerfully and with great
12:32
eagerness answer and follow His leading.
12:35
It completely changes the motivation for obedience.
12:38
It shifts from fear, fear of punishment, fear of failure, to
12:41
a joyful, willing response to God's loving call.
12:44
It assures us that our service, even though it's imperfect, is
12:47
accepted and approved by God because of our relationship with
12:50
Him through Christ. It means obedience stops being
12:53
this heavy, burdensome obligation and becomes a more
12:56
natural outflow of a heart that's been set free.
12:58
That sounds like a really radical shift in motivation from
13:01
fearful duty to cheerful willingness.
13:03
But does that risk making us complacent, you know, lazy and
13:06
pursuing holiness, if we're not constantly worried about
13:08
judgment? How do the sources illustrate
13:10
this shift in a way that still encourages genuine effort, but
13:13
without that crippling? That's a really perceptive
13:16
question. Does this freedom lead to
13:18
laziness? And the sources addressed this
13:21
directly, using a great analogy to make the shift clear and show
13:25
it doesn't lead to complacency. They contrast servants and sons.
13:30
OK, servants and sons, how does that work?
13:32
Well, servants. They're bound by specific tasks,
13:35
strict demands. They constantly fear they've
13:37
accomplished nothing unless they fulfill the exact measure of
13:40
their duties, down to the last detail.
13:43
They wouldn't dare show up before their master with work
13:45
that's imperfect or incomplete because they know they'll be
13:48
judged by the strictness of the rules.
13:50
That, the sources suggest, is like the condition of someone
13:54
still living under the law's condemnation.
13:56
Their obedience is driven by fear of failure, fear of
13:59
punishment. It lacks warmth, spontaneity.
14:01
Right, just checking boxes out of fear.
14:04
Exactly. But sons, the analogy goes, are
14:07
treated more generously and candidly by their fathers.
14:10
Sons do not hesitate to offer them incomplete and half done
14:13
and even defective works. Why?
14:16
Because they trust the relationship.
14:17
They trust that their obedience and readiness of mine will be
14:20
accepted by their fathers, even if the work itself isn't
14:23
perfect. The father sees their effort
14:25
through the lens of love, of their desire to please, not
14:28
through a lens of strict legal judgement.
14:30
So the relationship changes how the work is received.
14:33
Precisely, and this means believers need not fear the
14:37
remnants of Finn that's still cling to us in this life.
14:40
We've been emancipated from the law by grace so that their works
14:44
are not to be measured according to its rules when it comes to
14:46
our acceptance before God. Now this is critical.
14:49
It doesn't excuse sin. It doesn't make sin OK or
14:51
unimportant. Rather, the sources are
14:53
explicit. The authentic purpose of this
14:55
freedom is to encourage us to good, not to give us a license
14:58
to sin. It assures us that God isn't
15:01
constantly offended by our imperfections or holding them
15:04
against us in a way that paralyzes us.
15:06
Instead, it brings assurance that God is actually honored by
15:08
our works when they're done with genuine reference chordium, even
15:11
when they're mixed with the imperfections of our fallen
15:13
nature. This allows for a confident,
15:16
eager pursuit of holiness, not a hesitant, fearful, or just
15:19
begrudging one. The powerful shift here is that
15:21
our relationship with God moves from anxious duty to joyous
15:25
sonship that empowers us to serve him confidently, knowing
15:29
our genuine efforts, imperfect as they are, are welcomed by a
15:32
loving Father. That brings so much relief to
15:34
the idea of obedience. OK, that covers the second part.
15:37
Now the third part, freedom in things indifferent.
15:41
What exactly are these things? And why is getting this right so
15:45
necessary for our daily lives, for our Peace of Mind?
15:48
Right things. Indifferent.
15:50
The sources explain these as outward matters, things in the
15:53
external world that are neither specifically commanded nor
15:56
specifically forbidden by God in His Word.
15:59
They're neutral in themselves, morally speaking.
16:02
There's no inherent right or wrong attached to them by divine
16:05
law. Examples given include things
16:07
like eating certain foods, maybe meat versus vegetables or eating
16:10
meat on particular days, or the use or non use of specific
16:14
holidays that aren't biblically mandated, or even things like
16:17
what kind of clothes you wear. In these areas.
16:19
Believers are not bound before God by any religious obligation
16:22
to use them or not use them. We can choose indifferently,
16:25
meaning based on wisdom, context, love, but not because
16:29
the thing itself is commanded or forbidden.
16:31
OK, so things not directly addressed by scriptures commands
16:34
or prohibitions. Why is no we have freedom here
16:37
so very necessary, as the sources put it.
16:40
Because without it, the sources say, our consciences would have
16:43
no repose, no rest, and there will be no end to superstitions.
16:48
They paint this vivid picture of how if you don't understand this
16:51
freedom, doubts but really minor things can just spiral out of
16:55
control. The example given is about using
16:57
linen, maybe for sheets or handkerchiefs.
16:59
If someone starts doubting that, it can escalate into this
17:02
inextricable maze of anxiety. And inextricable maze?
17:05
How so? Well if linen is questionable,
17:07
then what about hemp? What about toe?
17:10
Then you start questioning basic food and drink.
17:13
If someone thinks daintier food is wrong, they might end up not
17:16
being at peace eating even black bread or common rituals because
17:20
they're constantly wondering if they should be eating something
17:22
even coarser. If they worry about sweet wine,
17:25
maybe they won't even feel free to drink water if it seems
17:28
sweeter and cleaner than some other water.
17:30
You see how it spirals? This constant questioning, the
17:33
scrupulosity, seeing potential offensive conscience everywhere
17:36
present. It can lead to just despair and
17:38
confusion, total spiritual paralysis.
17:41
Or, tragically, the sources warn, some people might get so
17:44
frustrated by all these self-imposed rules that they
17:47
just give up, despise God and abandoned fear of Him
17:50
altogether. It's absolutely essential for
17:52
inner peace and to stop us from getting tangled up in endless
17:55
anxieties over non moral trivial matters.
17:58
Wow. So it frees us from the tyranny
18:00
of trivialities, from being ensnared by endless scruples.
18:03
How then does this freedom relate to our actual actions?
18:06
And particularly you mentioned the attitude of Thanksgiving.
18:09
Paul's teaching in Romans 14 is key here.
18:11
He says nothing is common, meaning inherently profane or
18:14
unclean, but it is common for anyone who thinks it common.
18:18
This means all outward things are subject to our freedom
18:22
provided, and this is the condition our minds are assured
18:25
that the basis for such freedom stands before God.
18:28
In other words, if your conscience, informed by
18:30
Scripture, is convinced something is morally
18:32
permissible, then for you it is. Conversely, if a superstitious
18:36
opinion poses A stumbling block, if someone mistakenly believes
18:40
something different is actually sinful, then even things that
18:42
are of their own nature pure are for us corrupt because of that
18:46
mistaken belief. Because acting against your
18:48
conscience is wrong, even if the conscience is mistaken.
18:51
Exactly. That's Paul's point.
18:53
Whatever is not a faith is sin. If you do something you believe
18:57
is wrong, even if it's objectively permissible, you've
19:00
sinned because you violated your own conviction before God.
19:03
It highlights the importance of the heart's inner disposition.
19:06
So this freedom allows us to use God's gifts with no scruple of
19:09
conscience, no trouble of mind. It liberates us from fear and
19:12
doubt about everyday things, food, drink, clothing, holidays.
19:17
And this inner peace directly fosters Thanksgiving, which
19:19
proceeds from the mind that recognizes in His gifts the
19:22
kindness and goodness of God. This recognition is vital.
19:25
If you're not persuaded that these good things are gifts from
19:28
God-given, without strings attached regarding their use or
19:31
non use, you can't properly thank Him as the generous giver
19:34
He is. This freedom ensures our minds
19:37
will be at peace with Him and will recognize His liberality
19:40
toward us. And it applies not just to food
19:42
and clothes, but also to all ceremonies whose observance is
19:45
optional. Our consciences aren't
19:46
constrained by any necessity to observe them.
19:49
It really broadens the scope of peace in our daily lives.
19:52
The real insight here is that Christian freedom in these
19:54
indifferent things dismantles that endless religious anxiety,
19:58
paving the way for joyful Thanksgiving and pure hearted
20:00
living in every area. Mine 3.
20:03
Proper application and limitations of Christian
20:06
freedom. OK, this freedom sounds immense,
20:08
genuinely liberating. But as you hinted earlier, the
20:11
sources are really careful to point out that it's a spiritual
20:14
thing and definitely not meant for misuse.
20:17
How can this freedom be perversely interpreted, As they
20:20
say? How does it get twisted in
20:22
harmful ways? Right, the sources emphasize its
20:25
core purpose. The whole force of this freedom
20:28
is about quieting frightened consciences before God.
20:32
Whether their conscience is troubled over forgiveness or
20:34
anxious about imperfect works or tormented about using things in
20:38
different it's fundamentally about inner peace with God.
20:41
It gets perversely interpreted or dangerously distorted by
20:44
people who grab onto it as an excuse for their desires, using
20:47
it to abuse God's good gifts to their own lust.
20:50
So basically turning freedom into selfishness.
20:53
Pretty much twisting freedom into a license for self
20:56
indulgence, for excessive luxury, for unbridled appetite.
21:00
And we see this played out in those examples mentioned
21:02
earlier. Lavish and ostentatious
21:04
banquets, bodily apparel and domestic architecture, or that
21:08
desire to outstrip neighbors and all sorts of elegance.
21:12
People defend these things under the banner of Christian freedom.
21:14
They might say, well, God made all things good, I'm free to
21:17
enjoy them to the Max. But the sources argue that while
21:20
the things themselves might be indifferent, they become defiled
21:24
by these vices when they're coveted to greedily or proudly
21:27
boasted of, or lavishly squandered.
21:30
The use becomes sinful because of the internal vice driving it.
21:33
The greed, the pride, the extravagance.
21:35
So the problem isn't the thing, but the heart attitude behind
21:39
its use. Exactly.
21:40
That's why the sources issue this strong call for soberness
21:43
and moderation. They remind us that God
21:46
nourishes them to live, not to luxuriate.
21:49
We're called to learn to be content in whatever
21:52
circumstances we find ourselves, whether we have abundance or we
21:55
have little. It's a Callaway from
21:56
uncontrolled desire, immoderate prodigality, vanity, and
22:01
arrogance. The goal is that people might
22:03
cleanly use God's gifts with a clear conscience, recognizing
22:07
their proper place and purpose. The heart has to be tempered by
22:10
this soberness, otherwise, the source is warned, even seemingly
22:14
base and common pleasures are too much if they're pursued with
22:17
a greedy or proud spirit. The core take away is that
22:19
Christian freedom isn't a permission slip for self
22:22
indulgence. It's actually a summons to
22:24
soberness, to contentment, directing our desires toward
22:26
God's glory, not our own excess. OK, so moderation, contentment,
22:31
checking our hearts, motives, those are key guardrails.
22:34
This freedom also clearly impacts how we interact with
22:36
other Christians, especially around this issue of offenses.
22:39
What does our freedom mean for how we should treat, say, weaker
22:41
brothers and sisters? How do we apply it responsibly
22:44
within the community? This is a huge area of
22:46
application. The sources point out that many
22:48
people mess up here by using their freedom indiscriminately
22:51
and unwisely, and in doing so they cause offense to weak
22:55
brothers. It's crucial to remember that
22:58
freedom primarily exists before God in our conscience, and
23:02
interestingly, it consists as much in abstaining as in using.
23:06
What do you mean as much in abstaining as in using?
23:08
It means choosing not to do something you're free to do
23:11
doesn't make you less free. Your freedom isn't diminished if
23:14
you choose to abstain, maybe out of love for someone else, as
23:18
long as your conscience remains free before God in that choice.
23:21
For example, you're free to eat meat any day of the week, but if
23:25
you choose not to eat it in front of someone whose
23:27
conscience is troubled by it, you haven't lost your freedom.
23:29
You've exercised it in love. OK, so freedom includes the
23:32
freedom not to exercise a freedom.
23:35
Exactly. And the clear rule for how we
23:37
interact with the weak is laid out.
23:39
We are to bear with the infirmities of the weak and not
23:42
to please ourselves, but let each of us please his neighbor
23:45
for his good, to edify him. That means we should actively
23:49
avoid putting a the stumbling block or occasion to fall in the
23:52
way of our brother. Why?
23:54
Because love makes us their servants in all things.
23:57
Think about a new believer, maybe someone coming out of a
23:59
background with really strict dietary rules.
24:02
They might be genuinely wrestling with whether it's OK
24:05
to eat certain foods, and you, as a more mature believer, know
24:09
you're free to eat whatever. But love might lead you to
24:11
abstain when you're with them. Or at least explain your freedom
24:14
very gently so you don't pressure them into violating
24:17
their own conscience while it's still developing, or cause them
24:19
to stumble in their faith. A godly person, the sources say,
24:23
realizes that this free ability and outward matters has been
24:26
given him in order that he may be the more ready for all the
24:29
duties of love. So while our conscience is free
24:33
or outward, actions need to be governed by love for those who
24:35
are less mature or more sensitive, always aiming to
24:38
build them up, not knock them down.
24:39
That's a really clear, loving guideline for navigating these
24:43
tricky situations. But the sources also draw this
24:46
interesting distinction between offense given and offense
24:50
received. That sounds important.
24:52
Can you break down the difference and explain how our
24:54
approach might need to change depending on which one we're
24:56
dealing with? Yes, this distinction is
24:58
incredibly helpful for applying freedom wisely in a messy world,
25:02
an offense given. This happens when someone
25:05
performs an action, maybe an indifferent one, but does it
25:08
with unseemly levity or wantonness or rashness, or maybe
25:12
just at the wrong time or place, out of his proper order or
25:15
place. And this carelessness, this lack
25:17
of consideration, causes the ignorant and the simple to
25:20
stumble. The fault here lies with the
25:23
person doing the action because their manner or timing was
25:26
inconsiderate. This is called the offense of
25:28
the weak because it mainly effects those with tender
25:31
consciences, people easily LED astray by a thoughtless, maybe
25:35
even arrogant display of freedom.
25:37
For this kind of offense, the sources are clear.
25:40
We should temper the use of our freedom.
25:42
We need to adjust how we exercise our liberty to account
25:45
for their ignorance, their spiritual fragility.
25:47
We choose to restrict ourselves out of genuine love and concern
25:50
for their spiritual well-being. It's about putting their growth
25:53
ahead of our preference. OK, so offense given is our
25:56
fault due to carelessness and we adjust for the weak.
25:58
What's offense received then? Offense received is different.
26:02
This happens when an action is performed properly, otherwise
26:05
not wickedly or unseasonably committed.
26:08
So the action itself was fine, the motives were right, the
26:10
manner appropriate. But someone else, by ill will or
26:13
malicious intent of mind, twist that good action and makes it an
26:17
occasion for offense. They wrench it out of context.
26:20
In this case, the sources say, there is no given offense from
26:23
the person acting. The problem lies entirely with
26:26
the wicked interpreters, these persons of bitter disposition
26:30
and pharisaical pride. This is called the offense of
26:32
the Pharisees, and for them, the sources say, we should not at
26:36
all yield. We shouldn't give way.
26:39
The Lord Himself told his disciples regarding the
26:41
Pharisees, Let them alone. They're blind guides.
26:44
This means we are not obligated to cater to those who are just
26:47
maliciously looking for fault, trying to find reasons to
26:49
condemn us, or attempting to impose their own legalistic
26:52
demands under some false guise of piety.
26:54
We don't compromise gospel truth or genuine freedom just to
26:57
appease those whose goal is to trap or judge.
27:00
That's a really sharp distinction.
27:01
So patience and self restraint for the genuine weak, but firm
27:05
resolve against those with malicious intent, the Pharisees.
27:10
Given that, are there times when we actually must assert our
27:13
freedom, even if we know it might cause a stir or upset some
27:16
people? Yes, absolutely.
27:19
Well, the general principle is always to use our freedom for
27:21
the edification of our neighbor, building them up in love.
27:24
There are critical moments when our freedom must be declared
27:27
before men. When does this happen?
27:30
Specifically, the sources say if through the unjust demands of
27:33
false apostles it be endangered in weak consciences.
27:36
This describes a situation where some external demand, may be a
27:40
legalistic teaching or a false doctrine, threatens to pull
27:42
believers back into spiritual bondage, obscuring the truth of
27:45
the gospel itself. In that situation, staying
27:48
silent or yielding would actually be compromising the
27:51
very truth Christ died to secure for us.
27:53
Can you give an example of that? Balls own actions give us the
27:56
best illustration of handling this tension.
27:59
On the one hand, he chose to circumcise Timothy.
28:02
Why? To accommodate Jewish believers,
28:05
To avoid putting an unnecessary stumbling block before them,
28:08
showing his willingness to restrict his freedom when it was
28:11
fruitful for winning people or avoiding harm to those with
28:14
sensitive consciences. That's wisdom and moderation.
28:18
But on the other hand, he absolutely refused to circumcise
28:21
Titus. While the difference because in
28:24
Titus's case, false brethren, legalist trying to sneak in and
28:27
insist that circumcision was necessary for salvation, were
28:30
trying to bring us into bondage. In that critical moment, Paul
28:33
stood firm. He wouldn't yield an inch.
28:35
He said that the truth of the gospel might be preserved among
28:38
them. He saw that the core message,
28:40
salvation by grace alone through faith alone, was directly under
28:44
attack. Comparing those two situations
28:46
helps us see how to discern when we should yield out of love and
28:49
when we must assert our freedom for the sake of the Gospels.
28:52
Purity. The goal is always edification,
28:55
but sometimes true edification requires standing firm for
28:57
truth, even if it causes friction.
29:00
That makes sense. It's about discerning what's
29:02
truly at stake, and the sources mentioned something about how
29:05
love ought to abide under purity of faith.
29:08
What does that phrase mean? It sounds like a really critical
29:10
balance to maintain. It is a critical balance.
29:13
It means that while our Christian freedom should always
29:15
be exercised in love, we should always be striving to act
29:19
lovingly toward our neighbor. Love itself isn't the ultimate
29:22
authority. Love ought to abide under purity
29:25
of faith. This means that things necessary
29:28
to be done must not be omitted for fear of any offense.
29:32
Let me put that simpler Our duty to love our neighbor and avoid
29:35
causing them unnecessary offense applies mainly to those things
29:38
intermediate and indifferent, the areas where God has given us
29:42
liberty. But that duty to avoid offense
29:45
never applies when it comes to God's direct commands, the core
29:48
truths of the gospel, or participating in practices that
29:51
actually compromise our faith or lead others into error.
29:54
So we can't use love as an excuse to disobey God.
29:57
Exactly. We must not offend against God
29:59
for the neighbor's sake. No obstacle, no threat from the
30:03
world or Satan, No Fear of causing offense should make us
30:06
turn away from God's clear commands or stop us from doing
30:10
what He clearly appoints as essential.
30:12
This means that even if doing what God requires does cause
30:15
offense to some people, we have to vigorously go forward
30:18
regardless of the potential dangers or misunderstandings.
30:21
The sources give an example. Paul wouldn't participate in a
30:24
papal mask just to avoid offending people, because doing
30:27
so would be participating in something he saw as
30:29
fundamentally wrong, something that would actually build up
30:32
neighbors consciences into evil, not good.
30:35
You would be offering poison, not milk.
30:37
We're not supposed to build up our neighbors consciences into
30:40
evil by letting them stay comfortable and harmful
30:42
practices or false beliefs just because we want to be gentle.
30:46
Our first loyalty has to be to God's authority and the purity
30:48
of His truth. The insight here is that while
30:51
Christian freedom always expresses itself in love, that
30:54
love is grounded in and must be guided by the truth of God's
30:57
Word. We never compromise core
30:59
biblical principles just to avoid ruffling feathers for
31:03
Christian freedom and civil law, the two kingdoms.
31:07
This whole discussion about conscience, our actions, how we
31:09
relate to our neighbor, it brings us to another really
31:12
crucial .1 that's often misunderstood.
31:15
How does our Christian freedom relate to human laws, to
31:18
governments, to the governing authorities?
31:21
Our sources use this concept of two kingdoms to help clarify
31:24
this. Yes, the two kingdoms or twofold
31:27
government idea is vital here. The sources start by stating
31:30
that believers consciences are released from the power of all
31:33
men when it comes to those matters where the Lord Himself
31:35
His will them to be free. Matters of faith, justification,
31:39
how we relate directly to God. To let our consciousness get
31:43
ensnared by the bonds of laws and constitutions imposed by
31:47
human beings in these spiritual areas would effectively nullify
31:51
Christ's death. Why?
31:53
Because this very freedom, this liberation of the conscience
31:56
before God was purchased for us with his own blood.
31:59
Tampering with it diminishes Christ work.
32:01
OK, so our conscience is free from human control and spiritual
32:04
matters. How does the twofold government
32:06
idea explain this further? It clarifies things by
32:09
distinguishing 2 spheres of rule in human life.
32:12
One is the spiritual government. Its role is to instruct our
32:16
conscience in piety and in reverencing God.
32:19
It deals with the life of the soul and operates in the inner
32:22
mind. This is the realm of faith, our
32:25
direct relationship with God, matters of spiritual conviction.
32:28
You could call this the spiritual Kingdom, where Christ
32:31
alone rules the conscience. All right, the spiritual Kingdom
32:34
within. What's the second one?
32:35
The second is the political government or civil government.
32:39
Its role is to educate us for the duties of humanity and
32:41
citizenship. It concerns the present life,
32:44
regulating our outward behavior. This includes things necessary
32:47
for living honorably and temperately, among others in
32:50
society, like laws about property, contracts, public
32:53
order, even external things like food and clothing regulations in
32:56
some contexts. This is the political Kingdom
32:59
governing our external actions and our role in civil society.
33:02
It deals with outward order, public justice.
33:04
So 2 distinct spheres of governance, one internal
33:09
spiritual, the other external political.
33:12
That sounds really important, but how do we stop ourselves
33:14
from mixing them up? Why is keeping this distinction
33:17
so central for Christians living in the world?
33:19
It's absolutely central because mixing them up causes huge
33:22
problems. The sources stressed that these
33:25
two worlds, over which different kings and different laws have
33:29
authority, must always be examined separately.
33:32
They say when one is being considered, we must call away
33:34
and turn aside the mind from thinking about the other.
33:37
Why? Because it's crucial not to miss
33:39
Apply to the political order, the gospel teaching on spiritual
33:42
freedom. For instance, someone might
33:45
mistakenly think, because my conscience is free in Christ,
33:48
I'm therefore released from all civic duties.
33:50
I don't have to obey human laws. That's mixing the kingdoms.
33:54
I see spiritual freedom doesn't mean anarchy in the civil realm.
33:58
Precisely. Christians are not less subject
34:00
as concerns outward government to human laws just because their
34:04
consciences are free before God in spiritual things.
34:07
Spiritual freedom doesn't mean we're released from all bodily
34:10
servitudes simply because we're free in our spirit.
34:12
Its purpose is not to get rid of civil obedience or to encourage
34:15
people to rebel or cause sedition.
34:18
The sources condemn those who twist this doctrine about
34:20
freedom from human rules to stir up huge troubles, acting as if
34:24
all obedience to civil authority is just gone.
34:27
That's a fundamental misunderstanding of this vital
34:29
distinction. The spiritual Kingdom is about
34:31
the soul and God. The political Kingdom regulates
34:35
outward behavior and societal order.
34:37
Keeping them distinct prevents chaos, allows for proper
34:40
Christian living in the world, and avoids undermining either
34:43
our spiritual liberty or the necessary civil order.
34:46
The core insight is that Christian freedom liberates your
34:48
conscience from human spiritual tyranny, but at the same time it
34:51
calls you to be a responsible, dutiful citizen within the civil
34:54
order. That distinction is incredibly
34:56
helpful, but it does raise that interesting point you alluded to
34:59
earlier from Romans 13. Paul tells us there to obey the
35:03
magistrates, the governing authorities, not just because of
35:06
potential punishment, but for conscience sake.
35:10
Now, if our conscience is free from the power of all men, like
35:12
you just explained, how can it also be bound by civil laws for
35:16
conscience sake? That feels like a bit of a
35:18
paradox. It does seem like a paradox,
35:20
doesn't it? And the sources tackle this head
35:22
on by defining conscience itself very carefully.
35:26
Conscience is described as more than just personal opinion.
35:28
It's a sense of divine judgement.
35:30
It's like a witness joined to them us, which does not allow
35:34
them to hide their sins from being accused before the judge's
35:36
tribunal. It's called a certain mean
35:38
between God and man, something that pursues us to convict us
35:41
when we do wrong. It's also like a guardian
35:44
appointed for man to note and spy out all his secrets.
35:48
So properly speaking, the sources argue, conscience refers
35:51
to God alone. It's primarily about our
35:53
awareness of our standing before God, our inward integrity of
35:56
heart, that divinely implanted faculty bearing witness to God's
35:59
law within us. OK, so conscience is
36:02
fundamentally God oriented. How does that help with the
36:05
Romans 13 issue? It helps because it
36:07
distinguishes how different kinds of laws bind us.
36:10
A lot truly binds the conscience when it simply binds a man
36:13
without regard to other men. Meaning it applies directly to
36:17
your guilt before God, even if no one else ever knew.
36:20
For example, God's command to keep your mind pure from lust,
36:23
or his forbidding obscene speech.
36:26
Those bind your conscience directly before him, even if you
36:29
were alone on a desert island. An intemperate person, the
36:32
sources say, sins partly because they set a bad example, sure,
36:36
but more fundamentally, their conscience is bound by guilt
36:38
before God for violating his command against intemperance.
36:41
OK, so God's laws bind the conscience directly.
36:44
What about human laws? Human laws, especially those
36:47
dealing with things of themselves and different things
36:50
not inherently moral or immoral, work differently.
36:52
Think about speeding when no one's around or parking
36:55
illegally for a minute. The external action can
36:57
certainly be limited by human laws for the sake of public
37:00
order, or even limited out of love for a brother's sake, like
37:03
Paul saying abstain from idle meat for the other man's
37:05
conscience. But in that situation, the
37:08
believers own conscience regarding the inherent
37:10
indifference of the action itself, like the meat still does
37:14
not cease to keep freedom of conscience before God.
37:18
So Paul's point in Romans 13 isn't that the traffic law
37:20
itself binds your spiritual conscience in the same way God's
37:23
command do not murder does. Rather, God commands us to
37:26
submit to governing authorities who are His servants for
37:29
maintaining order. Therefore, our conscience is
37:32
bound to obey God's command to obey the authorities.
37:35
It's an indirect binding We obey the civil law out of conscience
37:39
toward God who instituted civil government, not because the
37:42
human law itself has inherent spiritual authority over our
37:45
inner being. Our outward conduct is subject
37:47
to human laws as part of our duty to God, but our inner
37:50
conviction are standing before God remains liberated in Christ.
37:55
Wow. This deep dive into Christian
37:58
freedom has really, I think, unveiled A remarkable framework
38:01
for our walk. We've seen clearly it's not a
38:04
license for doing whatever we want.
38:06
It's a vital gift that addresses that core need we all have for
38:09
peace before God. It frees us from the law's
38:12
condemnation, letting us rest completely in Christ alone for
38:15
our justification. It reshapes our obedience,
38:18
moving it away from fear and dread toward cheerful, willing
38:20
service, even knowing we're still imperfect.
38:23
And it liberates us in all those things, indifferent, saving us
38:26
from endless scruples, while at the same time calling us to use
38:29
that freedom wisely, tempering it for the sake of love, and
38:31
building others up, knowing how to discern between genuine
38:34
weakness and, well, pharisaical pride.
38:36
Yeah, and if you connect all that to the bigger picture of
38:38
our faith, Christian freedom really stands out as a spiritual
38:42
reality, its whole focus, its entire force, His aim squarely
38:46
at quieting our consciences before God.
38:49
And that clear distinction it draws between our inner liberty
38:52
before God and our outward duties in the world is so
38:54
helpful. The constant reminder, isn't it,
38:56
that being free in Christ doesn't somehow excuse us from
39:00
being responsible citizens, from fulfilling our duties in the
39:02
civil realm, Which I think brings us to a really
39:05
significant question for you, for everyone listening to maybe
39:08
reflect on what is this understanding of Christian
39:10
Freedom Call you personally to release?
39:14
Are there lingering doubts, maybe fears of imperfection or
39:17
perhaps some legalistic burdens you're still carrying that
39:19
Christ wants to lift? And on the flip side, what does
39:22
this Freedom Call you to embrace?
39:24
Maybe new steps of Willy obedience done with joy, a
39:27
deeper gratitude for God's gifts used with soberness, or perhaps
39:30
a more intentional loving self restraint when dealing with your
39:33
neighbor. All for the glory of God and for
39:35
the genuine benefit of your community.