Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Gaza, India, COP28, US, Russia | The World According To Irina Tsukerman (Ep 7)
Transcript
- 0:20Welcome to this special episode of The World According to Irena
- 0:24Sukerman, our very special series on global politics on the
- 0:28KJ Master Class Live Irena Sukerman.
- 0:31As you can see on the screen she is AUS based national security
- 0:35and human rights lawyer as well as the renowned geopolitical
- 0:38analyst. Her writings and commentary have
- 0:40appeared in diverse US and international media and have
- 0:43been translated to over a dozen languages.
- 0:47Every fortnight in the world According to IRENA Superman.
- 0:50We traverse the geopolitical landscape and delve into
- 0:54pressing international issues and gain insight from Irena's
- 0:58expert perspective. Welcome to the show once again,
- 1:01IRENA. Thank you so much as always,
- 1:04very glad to be here. Thank you Adina.
- 1:07Thank you and and it's been a wonderful show.
- 1:11Now it's been this is the 7th episode and this this particular
- 1:15series is doing very well. A lot of people are liking it.
- 1:18We have got you know hundreds and thousands of views on our
- 1:22this on this particular series. So we will continue to serve
- 1:26people as long as we can. So the let's talk there were
- 1:30several big topics again, you know last week, we last
- 1:33fortnight we talked about COP 28.
- 1:36Now that is over. Now that we are talking, let's
- 1:39talk about the final outcomes of COP 28.
- 1:43Help us understand how should we look at it.
- 1:46Finally there was an agreement, you know to transition from
- 1:50fossil fuels. That agreement came after a lot
- 1:53of discussion. What language that should be
- 1:55help us understand you are the expert.
- 1:58Well, there was a big a lot of drama surrounding that
- 2:01particular major outcome. The final agreement was a
- 2:05compromise solution because a number of oil producing
- 2:09countries threatened to boycott the push to transition from
- 2:14fossil fuels. The big push was from a number
- 2:18of countries who wanted a mandatory, binding process that
- 2:23would basically force everyone to essentially ban fossil fuels.
- 2:28The final agreement does not ban them, but creates our process
- 2:33towards increasingly moving towards more sustainable
- 2:39outcomes as as COP 20 defines us.
- 2:42I think one of the biggest practical implications for that
- 2:45is the growing support for nuclear energy.
- 2:49I think that's very important because nuclear energy is
- 2:53something that everyone can agree on, is clean, abundant in
- 2:58many parts parts of the world, easy to produce, and would not
- 3:02necessarily place an unfair burden on developing countries.
- 3:06Unlike many of the other green transition processes that are
- 3:12forcing many countries to choose between economic environmental
- 3:16concerns. And ironically one of the
- 3:19biggest trends is that the those countries like Germany that shut
- 3:22down their nuclear facilities, nuclear civilian plants are now
- 3:28forced to open up coal plants which are far dirtier than even
- 3:32oil or gas, gas reliant technologies and gas is actually
- 3:40a very clean form of energy. It's much better than coal.
- 3:43There's been an effort the the US is now one of the leading and
- 3:48at times the top lead produce of oil and natural gas.
- 3:53But but the another issue with these forms of energies is that
- 3:59transporting them, as we have seen places can place a
- 4:03geopolitical risk. We are seeing that supplies of
- 4:08fossil fuels are heavily affected by geopolitical
- 4:11realities. The war in Ukraine disrupted a
- 4:14lot of energy related processes. It created opportunities for
- 4:20some countries, but it also created risks for the fossil
- 4:24fuel import dependent countries countries.
- 4:28So these nuclear focused developments, the seeing that so
- 4:33many countries are coming together to support that form of
- 4:35energy, is actually a positive development even for the
- 4:39skeptics of the most extreme climate change policies.
- 4:44And you know, there's been a controversy about that too.
- 4:47Another major aspect besides this transition agreement, which
- 4:51by the way, I think ultimately will take far longer than what
- 4:55is agreed on paper. That's just the economic
- 4:59reality. Transitioning from anything to
- 5:01anything always takes time, probably more time than
- 5:05anticipated. And who knows what will happen
- 5:07between now and whatever the theoretical deadlines are for
- 5:12these things. But in the meantime, another
- 5:14major development is agriculture and food security that are being
- 5:19and for and the farming that have been discussed and taken
- 5:23seriously and the impact of climate change and changing
- 5:28changing circumstances on these issues and supporting developing
- 5:31countries and also developing more environmentally friendly
- 5:36processes for getting all of this done.
- 5:40And so here I am with mixed minds because the concept of
- 5:43expanding this reality to agriculture I think is very
- 5:46positive. And I think it is true that in
- 5:49many countries, in hot climates, it's a real issue.
- 5:52Water is a real issue, environmental impact is a real
- 5:56issue. Pollution and just changing
- 5:58patterns of climate over time. It's just something happens
- 6:01regardless of what causes it. But at the same time, we must be
- 6:06cautioned by what has happened in the United States, in
- 6:09Netherlands and other countries, major food producing countries,
- 6:13where ESG standards imposed on farmers, reporting standards and
- 6:19adherence to various standards related to climate change,
- 6:23related concerns, emissions and so forth, created extensive
- 6:28burdens, limited land production in a way that's not healthy.
- 6:32In Netherlands it caused the political backlash.
- 6:35In the US there's been also a have a pushback from the farmers
- 6:39and some of these egg standards are being, you know, being kind
- 6:44of realized they're just not really sustainable.
- 6:48So this has to be balanced. I think one of the outcomes was
- 6:52talking about rebalancing meat production.
- 6:56But actually what they should be looking at instead in my opinion
- 7:00is their practices, water conservation practices around
- 7:04agriculture in general. Because I think that's actually
- 7:08far more over over general concern that you can talk about
- 7:12limiting or not limiting meat, but there are various ways to
- 7:16feed animals whereas crops or need water, 100% of them.
- 7:20So and that's actually is probably the major factor in all
- 7:28these in terms of farming. But All in all, there's been a
- 7:33lot of breakthroughs in, in that sense.
- 7:36And of course I think a lot of it was very much geared towards
- 7:41coming up with investment opportunities, not to be
- 7:44cynical, but for for for companies for innovation
- 7:49technologies to showcase their possibilities.
- 7:52And I think a lot of deals have been made and I think the
- 7:56political trends and outcomes are less important than these
- 8:01immediate opportunities in technical development.
- 8:04I think the AI and innovation in the AI when when it comes to
- 8:08tutology has been also a major point of discussion.
- 8:11And it's going to be a bit and probably very positive factor in
- 8:15improving the efficiency of technologies which hopefully
- 8:19will make a lot of these practices less labour intensive,
- 8:24more efficient and helpful to to everyone engaging them.
- 8:29So next year's Cup is going to be in Azerbaijan, which is
- 8:33ironically another major oil and gas producing country that is at
- 8:38the same time also working with EU on developing a lot of green
- 8:42technologies, green, green, green energy projects.
- 8:46So that's going to be very interesting as well how all
- 8:49these countries that are actually the most who are doing
- 8:53extremely well at times of energy crisis and who are now
- 8:57leading the experts of energy to Europe and other places, first
- 9:01UE, now Azerbaijan are also at the same time investing heavily
- 9:06in the green transition without sacrificing their main current
- 9:11source of income. So I think they have been very
- 9:14much able to hold their own in under the circumstances and I
- 9:18think that's not as surprising as it should be given the
- 9:22realities of the fact that whatever the future outcomes
- 9:25today, there's still everyone still needs to make money.
- 9:29Right, right. Arena in terms of you know,
- 9:32Azerbaijan hosting COP 29, it's his it is the host for next
- 9:37year's you know climate meet meeting is that that is a
- 9:41growing perception you know that that cops have been partly
- 9:44captured by fossil fuel interest.
- 9:47This time it was Dubai and next time it is Azerbaijan.
- 9:51They have been, you know, they are very much into this fossil
- 9:55fuels. They have said they have got gas
- 9:56reserves, that's the promise. How do you look at?
- 9:59There was a lot of wrangling around who will host next
- 10:02year's. Finally, Armenia given in and
- 10:04Azerbaijan getting in with the support of Russia and all.
- 10:08How do you look at this part? How do you look at this
- 10:11perception and is it a good perception?
- 10:14How should we look at it from outside, I think.
- 10:18The process of these green projects and climatry is
- 10:21indispensable. With the the the participation
- 10:25of of fossil fuels industries is indispensable.
- 10:28I think it's naive to pretend that there can be any transition
- 10:32without their participation first, because even a very
- 10:35gradual process needs to involve more efficient and cleaner forms
- 10:39of delivery. Well, whatever the investment we
- 10:43want to see is happening. And 2nd, most of these so-called
- 10:48green technologies are reliant on oil and gas to for production
- 10:53purposes. They are the only alternative to
- 10:56that is either coal or nuclear energy.
- 10:58Nobody really wants coal. People use it if they have no
- 11:02other options but nobody there's not one country that is going to
- 11:06say that there's their preferred option if they had to they it's
- 11:10only because if they don't have any other option.
- 11:12So it's the cheapest and that's it's simply not a priority for
- 11:15them. But nuclear energy is also
- 11:18something that has not something something that yet is yet to be
- 11:23developed to its full potential. So we are not there yet.
- 11:27There is growing investment into it.
- 11:30It's a great sign but we're not at the point where it's
- 11:32completely can be completely self-sustaining for all forms of
- 11:36industry. So oil and gas, I mean necessary
- 11:39to fuel electrification, to fuel the development of military
- 11:45technologies. Anything you look at, you cannot
- 11:47do it without the use of of these industries.
- 11:52And of course plastic is made on the petroleum based products.
- 11:57There's been some effort to get rid of plastic, but that's also
- 12:01I think a little bit far off from reality at this point in
- 12:06time. It's also it's only natural that
- 12:09these industries are not only necessary but a big investors
- 12:14into these forms. They know that they that they
- 12:18can make money from being from their products being used in all
- 12:22these different industries, and they're looking for new ways to
- 12:25distribute their their range. And of course, Azerbaijan's
- 12:31participation is doubly symbolic because it is seen as a sign of
- 12:35regional integration in South Caucasus.
- 12:38Final conflicts and tensions are being put behind these
- 12:44countries, and they're moving towards a more solid economic
- 12:49and energy cooperation, which is something a lot of countries
- 12:53want to see. And it's ironic that Russia and
- 12:56the US, I agree on that one point, along with the EU.
- 12:59That might be the only point they agree on, actually.
- 13:03Right, right. From from COPS 28 and COP 29,
- 13:08let's move on to India. The FBI director, he was here,
- 13:12Christopher Ray, he was here, met a lot of security and you
- 13:16know in Indian security and services personnel here and a
- 13:21lot of other things that we may not know.
- 13:23How do you look at this visit normally you know they there are
- 13:28visits but FBI directors especially in the backdrop of
- 13:31this you know indictment of a of a Indian there panoon
- 13:36assassination plot all these things.
- 13:38How do you look at it all from that perspective?
- 13:42So obviously there was a lot to discuss, both in terms of
- 13:47dealing with the with this, with the legal and political aspects
- 13:50of this particular incident, but also, as I suspected and as I
- 13:54was hoping to happen, with the broader framework for future
- 13:58cooperation. And a lot was reported on the
- 14:01fact that the war is counter terrorism cooperation, security
- 14:04cooperation, discussed. There was the discussion of a
- 14:07framework for dealing with this Palestinian situation.
- 14:12I think it's major though that FBI is only one entity in the
- 14:17US. It is not a decision maker.
- 14:18It's a tactical security entity. It can only move towards best
- 14:24practices sharing with India, which is, which would be a very
- 14:27positive sign. But in terms of the politics of
- 14:30the situation, it's not sufficient.
- 14:32It's only a first step and necessary in the inevitable step
- 14:36even. But I think broader public
- 14:39perception needs to be shifted through information education
- 14:44engagement to gain broader support in the West and to gain
- 14:49the sort of public understanding that you'll help smooth over the
- 14:53ages from this, from this situation.
- 14:57At the same time, there's something else was going on
- 15:00besides this particular incident which is which has not been
- 15:04import reported as widely as this scandalous story.
- 15:11Which is the fact that around the anniversary of the 2008
- 15:16Mumbai attacks, we have seen a takedown of a number of ISIS
- 15:20linked cells from in several different parts of parts of the
- 15:25country and approximately 19 or so locations including major,
- 15:31major cities. And while I'm extremely happy
- 15:36that this a major disaster, and attacks in various locations
- 15:42have been prevented at the time, it's a sobering sign that
- 15:46neither ISIS nor terrorism, extremist ideologies in general,
- 15:49have been finished. That in this offers yet another
- 15:53ground for cooperation with the United States, because the rise
- 15:57of these organizations is back. Just because they're state
- 16:01actors at war with each other in different parts of the world and
- 16:05proxy wars and so forth going on doesn't mean that the
- 16:07international jihadist organizations have gone
- 16:10anywhere. On the contrary, they're
- 16:12capitalizing on crisis and on the destruction and on the
- 16:16shifting strategies to return to the field.
- 16:20And this could have been a major disaster.
- 16:23And these people, if not they fully quote in this time their
- 16:29handlers and their supporters and founders, if they're not, if
- 16:36they're not identified and through the international
- 16:43cooperation taken down, you can see these networks proliferate
- 16:47elsewhere, maybe in India Today, some other part of the Asia
- 16:50tomorrow, back to Europe the day after the United States the day
- 16:55after that. And I, I'm hoping that the visit
- 16:58by the FBI chief and his team attached on these issues.
- 17:03And I am hoping that this announced major success in
- 17:09counterterrorism was positively impacted by these discussions
- 17:14because these guys don't tend to stay in one place, this
- 17:19ideology. He's a transnational
- 17:21transporter. They didn't care about borders.
- 17:24They're looking to build that caliphate everywhere they can
- 17:27and to reclaim whatever lands they think they're entitled to.
- 17:33And it's the fact that it's not a big, a bigger story is only
- 17:38due to the fact that we have two major wars going on elsewhere.
- 17:42Otherwise they should, they should have been front pages,
- 17:45news elsewhere, chose a very significant planning effort,
- 17:49very significant recruitment effort and then chose to me that
- 17:53that despite all the counter terrorism, counter extremism,
- 17:56extremism, investment by various countries around the world, the
- 18:02whoever is investing into it in the other side, in terms of
- 18:05funding, in terms of intelligence, in terms of
- 18:08logistics, they haven't gone anywhere, they haven't been
- 18:12deterred and this ideology has not been successfully finished.
- 18:17So we have to understand why is there such a huge return, such a
- 18:23brazen return at this time. It's symbolic of course in terms
- 18:27of their anniversary and trying to send a message, but there is
- 18:31got to be more to the story. There seems to be that it's also
- 18:35timed with the fact that other terrorist organizations are now
- 18:39reactivating, feeling emboldened, and that sends a
- 18:42message, even to unrelated or seemingly unrelated global
- 18:47causes, to that they have more freedom to act.
- 18:50And that's very concerning. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 18:54Staying with India, you know, how do you see this security
- 18:58beach of India's parliament, you know and and there must be,
- 19:02there was a lot of news that's continued to talk about that.
- 19:05There's continued talk around this.
- 19:07How did you see it from that part of the world?
- 19:14Could you just repeat the first part that I missed the point
- 19:17security breach? At India?
- 19:20Oh, so yes. Yes, yes, yes.
- 19:22Yeah. I again, I think this is part of
- 19:25the pattern of activity going on because as we mentioned last
- 19:28time, there's also been a wave of cyber attacks around the
- 19:32world, but there's been also a rise in incidents.
- 19:36Some of them are linked to specific parties, otherwise
- 19:39others have not been identified. In Greece there's been a bomb
- 19:43planted near police station, supposedly by far left
- 19:47protesters. But this far left protesters may
- 19:50have ties to foreign regimes hostile to the current Greek
- 19:57government. Similarly the security breach in
- 20:01parliament. Yes, of course security
- 20:03procedures and protocols need to be reviewed, but the question is
- 20:07why now? And once again, we have the
- 20:09context of the anniversary. When we have this ISIS operation
- 20:14going on, we have continuous, you know, the Palestinians may
- 20:18have been actually emboldened by the by these last developments
- 20:23and other unidentified actors just seeing that there is a, you
- 20:28know, a rise in security incidents are trying to take
- 20:33advantage of the cares and make it even more difficult to keep
- 20:36up with the with the situation. So I think we can actually
- 20:40expect more attempts to distract, more attempts to
- 20:44create a chaotic security environment from different
- 20:48directions, and we need to be very vigilant.
- 20:52Right, Right. Let's now move on to the Middle
- 20:55East. What's happening at Gaza and
- 20:58from Gaza? Things are happening now in
- 21:00Denmark, Germany. They plotted Hamas attacks in
- 21:03Europe. So what do these operations,
- 21:06globalized operations by Hamas means what is happening between
- 21:11US and Israel? There seem to be a lot of
- 21:14different voices coming. Is US now moving away from
- 21:18Israel? How does it all look like?
- 21:21There are lots of visit happening.
- 21:23I want to understand, you know, what is happening at that end in
- 21:27terms of Hamas, in terms of globalized operation, in terms
- 21:31of the relationship between US and Israel?
- 21:35Well, it's been a complicated few weeks, but Hamas is actually
- 21:39carrying out exactly what it promised to do, and it can be
- 21:43trusted to. Once it starts talking publicly,
- 21:46you can you can be sure that what they say is exactly what
- 21:50they mean when they're deceiving.
- 21:52When they're quiet, they may be lying, they may be pretending.
- 21:55But once they start discussing the strategy, they are very
- 21:58clear about their goals and agenda.
- 22:00And they're following exactly what they laid out in the very
- 22:03beginning of the war, which was that they had plans with Iran's
- 22:08backing to attack locations in other countries and European
- 22:13countries where they started targeting Israelis.
- 22:17Where are those countries? They they are going global.
- 22:19They have been global for a while.
- 22:21The financing certainly has been global.
- 22:25We have seen articles coming out on various investment projects
- 22:29in various parts of the world, in the in Europe, in Turkey, and
- 22:33now we're seeing that their cells are coming to fruition.
- 22:36Germany has been rounding up some of the Hamas operatives,
- 22:40but other parts of the world have not been as aggressive and
- 22:43even Germany can't necessarily identify every single location
- 22:47and every single cell. So there's been a cross-border
- 22:50cooperation in trying to stage these attacks.
- 22:54For now they're still sticking to Israeli targets and but it
- 22:59But first of all, in a terrorist attack even non Israelis can be
- 23:04harmed. And 2nd, it's only a matter of
- 23:06time when before they start targeting everyone else.
- 23:09As we have seen during during the war, they deliberately took
- 23:13foreign workers hostage, they took Arab Israelis hostage, they
- 23:18have killed Arab Israelis and other foreigners.
- 23:22So there is no ethnic or religious discrimination.
- 23:26There's only a particular strategy, and the strategy is
- 23:30only likely to expand. As far as the US and Israel are
- 23:34concerned, yes, there are differences.
- 23:36The biggest difference is about the future.
- 23:40Who will govern Gaza? Personal.
- 23:41I think it's still too early to count those chickens, and
- 23:45actually it's too early to count on the complete success of the
- 23:49separation. I don't think that the entire
- 23:54military echelon from Hamas is going to be eliminated,
- 23:57eliminated anytime soon. They may take out a few leaders
- 24:01and that all of the hostages have been released or rescued
- 24:04yet. And of course in the all of
- 24:07these tunnels that need to be destroyed are very difficult to
- 24:10destroy. Now there may be a shifting
- 24:13strategy in trying to break them up into molds because blowing up
- 24:18of gas is just not feasible. It's creating a lot of outrage,
- 24:23and there's been several incidents of friendly fire and
- 24:28accidents involving civilians, Christians and Gaza and so forth
- 24:32that just created a lot of very bad objects.
- 24:36US has also been trying to get Israel to have a plan for
- 24:42transition to different to a different strategy in the
- 24:46future. The fact is, on the one hand, US
- 24:49is putting some of this pressure too early.
- 24:52On the other hand, Israel doesn't seem to have an actual
- 24:55transition plan. So anything different they have
- 24:59a general objection. I'm not entirely sure they know
- 25:01how to quite get to that point. So I think it is wise to start
- 25:07thinking what to do next. But I also agree with John
- 25:12Kirby, who said that it's not wise to put timelines and
- 25:16timestamps on the any phase of the operation because it will
- 25:20simply give Hamas an unfair leverage.
- 25:23It will tell them exactly what to expect and how to restructure
- 25:27their aims. Now, Israel is proposing a new
- 25:30ceasefire for lasting over a week if Hamas releases over
- 25:35three dozen hostages unharmed. Hamas has previously rejected
- 25:41the possibility of such exchanges very recently.
- 25:44I don't know how they will react to this latest development
- 25:48that's been brokered by Qatar, but they have also at various
- 25:53points asked for a ceasefire on terms that Israel could not
- 25:56accept. So.
- 25:57So they clearly do want and need a pause.
- 26:00It's said that Israel is getting closer to Yahir Sinbad.
- 26:03His brother was observed riding through one of the biggest
- 26:07tunnels uncovered so far. So if Yahir Simba is liquidated
- 26:15or captured, that would be a huge PR victory for Israel to
- 26:20build a huge military breakthrough.
- 26:23But until that point, they still have to deal with the reality
- 26:28that Hamas is has been thoroughly entrenched in Gaza,
- 26:34and Hamas also has links outside Gaza, and they're seeing that
- 26:40US, European countries are only starting to sanction a lot of
- 26:43these Hamas players. It's unclear where the sanctions
- 26:47were in the past, given that Hamas is on the terrorist list
- 26:51in all these countries. But I guess they thought that
- 26:55Hamas was not an immediate great danger and did not feel like
- 26:59stirring the hornet's nest by aggressively and publicly going
- 27:05after these actors. Whatever the case may be,
- 27:07they're starting to do that now and it will be a while before
- 27:10these sanctions really take effect on the financing.
- 27:13But the good news is Israel did eliminate one of the top Hamas
- 27:19financiers in Gaza. So.
- 27:22So that should send a message at least.
- 27:25There's also rumors that some of the Hamas leadership left Qatar
- 27:29and Turkey in an unknown direction after Israel's threats
- 27:35to assassinate them. That could be also be a minus
- 27:38because now that we don't know where they are, it took it
- 27:40harder to find it and actually kill them.
- 27:43So I don't know whether that public announcement really was
- 27:47necessary, but I think at the end of the day, US and Israel,
- 27:51despite whatever these differences in strategy, they
- 27:55are kind of stuck together. Whatever Netanyahu may say to
- 27:59the public and whatever US may say in an election year to its
- 28:03very diverse constituents, the security situation is such that
- 28:08neither country can afford to the West from another.
- 28:12You have US is relying on local Israeli contacts, intelligence
- 28:19contacts for Hamas intelligence. the US has not been following
- 28:23that intelligence for the last two years and the US does want
- 28:25Hamas eliminated. With that, Israel let's simply
- 28:28not going to be possible. We'll be back to where we
- 28:31started the 2nd cater The lieutenants will rebuild if if
- 28:37they're left in power, they'll continue holding Palestinians
- 28:40hostage, and they'll simply take over Gaza again as soon as it
- 28:43becomes feasible. If they're not fully destroyed
- 28:48or eliminated in such in some way, in such a way that they
- 28:52cannot easily restructure, it's still a huge job and there still
- 28:56needs to be a lot of political pressure, financial pressure,
- 28:59simply cutting off weapons for financing, creating an
- 29:05international involvement in some way.
- 29:08All of these things are complicated and necessary.
- 29:11But at the end of the day, Israel and the US rely on each
- 29:15other for security reasons, and the situation in the Middle East
- 29:19is becoming far more complicated.
- 29:22We are seeing attacks by the cookies on a daily basis.
- 29:25We are seeing a new coalition of ships trying to take down
- 29:31drones, coming to the area in missiles and protecting
- 29:35commercial ships. We're seeing the impact this
- 29:38time on the economy, and we're seeing many state visits to the
- 29:42region in parts to convince Israel to take measures to
- 29:47prevent escalation in reported with Simpson Gaza.
- 29:51But again, there's a lot of disagreement on whether those
- 29:54numbers are real and what should actually be done.
- 29:57And there's also other discussions, discussions
- 30:00concerning the Red Sea security. And now the cookies are also
- 30:04directly threatening other countries, including the US,
- 30:08including Bahrain and other members of that coalition.
- 30:12So we there's a lot to discuss, but there is a major difference
- 30:16inside the GCC which is preventing A unified strategy.
- 30:21So your Rebus, specifically as the US to abstain from offensive
- 30:25attack on Hoochie launch sites. They are afraid.
- 30:30They're concerned about direct attacks in their own territory,
- 30:34which have happened before and in some cases just failed to
- 30:38come to the rescue. UE on the other hand, has asked
- 30:42us to do exactly the opposite. They encourage us to intervene.
- 30:46And US has also been in the past attacked and threatened by the
- 30:49Huggies. So this uneven strategy
- 30:53unfortunately is playing right into the hands of Iran, which is
- 30:56masterminding with all of this disruption.
- 30:59It's causing some ships to take the long scenic route around
- 31:02Cape, delaying delivery of oil and gas, raising prices for the
- 31:07Far East countries like Japan and South Korea, heavily
- 31:10dependent on imports, and also causing a gas spike in Europe as
- 31:15well. So we are seeing that cookies
- 31:17are actually achieving their goals and they do not feel at
- 31:21all threatened. And all these visits so far have
- 31:24not resulted in any solution for all of this.
- 31:28Right, right. In terms of, you know, Middle
- 31:31East, US has been, you know, it's almost like every subtle
- 31:34diplomacy at a high level, a lot of visits already made.
- 31:38Now National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan, US Secretary of
- 31:42Defence, Lloyd Austin, they have been, they are now travelling to
- 31:45Middle East, meeting not only the Middle East also, but also
- 31:49MBS and others. What does this all indicate?
- 31:52What should we understand? What is it that they can't
- 31:54convey on the phone that they have to visit there?
- 31:57I I I think first of all, I think they're hoping that Saudi
- 32:02Arabia will shift in the direction of some more active
- 32:06role in Gaza because the current scenario is kind of a dead end.
- 32:14It's unclear how long the Israeli operation is going to
- 32:19proceed. It's like we're going to be long
- 32:21term. There needs to be US is looking
- 32:24for investors in Gaza for a rebuilding process.
- 32:27They want some solution for their ID, PS and for the
- 32:31refugees, and they want additional sources of
- 32:34humanitarian aid. But just as important that there
- 32:39is a a concern about the Hoki situation, about the regional
- 32:43security, possible escalation of Hezbollah and what to do about
- 32:47it. And I think the US is not happy
- 32:50that the Saudi Saudis have been preventing US from taking more
- 32:56active measures, which US has threatened to do.
- 32:59And well, to be fair, in the past US has been extremely
- 33:03reluctant to get involved in Yemen on that level and against,
- 33:07which is the fact that the targets have become so
- 33:10persistent and overwhelming and the disruptions to the freedom
- 33:14of navigation has been so significant.
- 33:17I think it has shifted even the Pentagon thinking on this, but
- 33:21the Saudis remain an obstacle and I think that meeting was at
- 33:26least partially geared towards getting some sort of agreement.
- 33:31To that end, it remains to be seen what, if anything, because
- 33:35you know what red line has come out of it.
- 33:38So far it's not clear if there has been any.
- 33:42Right, right, Arena. Let's move on to another area,
- 33:45another war. That's about Ukraine and Russia.
- 33:49Ukraine is is is trying to get as much help as possible.
- 33:54Trying to get help from the UU and be part of it.
- 33:58Zelensky's visit to Washington and NDAA, past passage, What
- 34:03does that mean? How should we understand?
- 34:05How was that visit? And in terms of now, when we are
- 34:08talking of Ukraine, European Union, Hungary's Prime Minister
- 34:13Viktor, or when he seems to be making a lot of news, you know,
- 34:17at one point in time he was of a different opinion.
- 34:21He goes out and then it is a different opinion.
- 34:23What should we understand? You know, and now you know,
- 34:27Moldovia is also looking at getting being a part of, how
- 34:30does this all pan out in terms of Ukraine, in terms of, you
- 34:34know, NATO membership, the EU membership, All these things
- 34:39help us understand. And also in terms of Hungary's
- 34:43Prime Minister, who is he? Obviously he's the Hungary's
- 34:46Prime Minister, but what exactly does he want to achieve in terms
- 34:50of all these different talks? But at the end I all I can see
- 34:53is making a lot of news. Well, yeah, there's a lot of
- 34:57good money, he went. His visit to the US was largely
- 35:02unsuccessful. He did the right thing by trying
- 35:05to engage the Republicans and not, you know, he's had a pretty
- 35:08positive message in many things. I think he should be talking a
- 35:12lot more about US self-interest in Ukraine and less about the
- 35:16Reagan and democracy because quite frankly, a lot of
- 35:19Republican institutions have moved past that.
- 35:22They're much more populist now, much more isolationist, and that
- 35:25sort of messaging does not speak to them, unfortunately.
- 35:28That's the reality. But I think the main issue has
- 35:32been actually Les Zelensky himself or whatever messaging
- 35:37from Ukraine and more internal disagreements between Democrats
- 35:41and Republicans over the fact that Ukraine funding has been
- 35:45tied to the border security issues, and there's been no
- 35:49progress in resolving that. The White House finally offered
- 35:54major concessions regarding some of the implementation of these
- 35:59issues, but it's not clear exactly where the Republican
- 36:04redline is on this issue. Nobody's happy with the state of
- 36:07things, but they're not articulating clear, measurable
- 36:10goals that they want the White House achieved.
- 36:13That could lead to a practical negotiation that could result in
- 36:17some sort of an agreement. They're just holding out for
- 36:20something. But I think I'm almost getting
- 36:24in the sense they're more concerned with being seen as not
- 36:28giving in on Ukraine aid than actually resolving the border
- 36:31security issue, because I'm not seeing practical suggestions
- 36:35from them. And I'm somebody who is in full
- 36:37agreement that this is a very grave security threat that needs
- 36:41to be dealt with as soon as possible.
- 36:43The fact that they're not, in fact dealing with it, despite a
- 36:46lot of grandstanding is for someone who is actually security
- 36:51oriented, isn't deeply disconcerting when it comes to
- 36:55Ukraine. Ukraine has had to.
- 36:57Actually, there is a practical impact of the a delays in that
- 37:00Ukraine has had to cut down on military operations.
- 37:05And lest the US and others forget, if Russia succeeds in
- 37:11its goals in Ukraine, it can and will likely expand its field of
- 37:16operations to towards minor NATO members like Estonia, Latvia or
- 37:21Lithuania. And and it then, if you need to
- 37:28view, invoke the Article 5 and it will force US to bring in
- 37:32troops. And that can lead to American
- 37:35injuries and that's which is exactly what everyone's been
- 37:38trying to avoid in the 1st place.
- 37:40So I think investing money wisely is much better than
- 37:45actually having to spend a lot more later when the problem has
- 37:48become a lot bigger. But so far we've seen major
- 37:52disasters. The bills are likely not going
- 37:55to be implemented until 2024 because Congress is now going
- 38:02into recess. This means weeks of warfare with
- 38:06the Russian making progress in some areas and very slow
- 38:09progress on Ukraine's apart in other areas.
- 38:13There's been success in taking down some of the Russian
- 38:17weapons, but Russia has been compensating far faster than
- 38:22than than anyone who's been willing to give it credit for,
- 38:26For its human losses, for its military losses, it has been
- 38:31circumventing sanctions. Some of the sanctions have not
- 38:34been enforced. Others are simply being being
- 38:40taken down by countries and entities, and it has a good
- 38:45chance to make a breakthrough by the time the spring arrives, if
- 38:48Ukraine's drone warfare strategy does not succeed, and if US and
- 38:54others do not resolve the funding issues Europe so far has
- 38:58been trying to compensate through both individual
- 39:03countries in EU as a whole. But this is where the Hungary
- 39:08issue comes in. Let's recall who Urban was.
- 39:11He was someone who pretended to be a classical liberal visionary
- 39:16future of them of Hungary. But he came from a far left
- 39:21background and he eventually his party eventually shifted towards
- 39:27the right and eventually subsumed all of the conservative
- 39:31movements in Hungary from centrist, conservative,
- 39:35classical liberal oriented movements.
- 39:37It became increasingly populist. And now if we had to compare
- 39:41urban with anybody in the world, it would be Turkish President
- 39:46Erdogan. Because they operate in the
- 39:49identical manner, using populist language to appeal to the
- 39:55constituencies, grandstanding about sovereignty.
- 39:58While also, you know, in Turkey's case, violating
- 40:03sovereignty of others and in Hungary's case, demanding huge
- 40:07financial boons and having a very weak economy, highly
- 40:11dependent on the rest of Europe, very small popular base from
- 40:16which to do on. So it's kind of grandstand about
- 40:18sovereignty, but it's so dependent on the financial.
- 40:23Financials from others. It's difficult to respect the
- 40:26position. If you want to be independent,
- 40:28then don't take money from your neighbors and while making
- 40:31demands from them. And Orban has revealed himself
- 40:34to not be particularly concerned about institutions, civil
- 40:40institutions, I think. I would not call him a dictator,
- 40:45though. I think it's very important to
- 40:46make the distinction precisely because he has such a large
- 40:49popular support inside the country.
- 40:51He has managed to win over a lot of people.
- 40:54Many people are dissatisfied with the way he rules with the
- 40:57way wasn't being changed. And it's very fair argument and
- 41:01I agree with that. I don't agree that he's doing so
- 41:05without any popular approval whatsoever.
- 41:09And that's important because if you, I think calling someone a
- 41:14dictator when they actually have a broad popular base will likely
- 41:17backfire and only entrench these people and have them become
- 41:22martyrs for the cause without without a need.
- 41:26And he is now also, he's very close.
- 41:29This is somebody very close to Putin, who he is in as an entity
- 41:34that's basically laundering money from oligarchs and Russian
- 41:38institutions into the West and is being basically a satellite
- 41:42intermediary for various Russian operations, finding of
- 41:46propaganda, information warfare, investment into pro Russian
- 41:51education in especially in conservative or transnational
- 41:57kind of isolationist circles. Some of them also come from the
- 42:02left as well. He also is making a pact, a
- 42:06political pact with Serbia and other Russian ally, as well as
- 42:10with Turkey and increasingly trying to move into Turkic
- 42:14states. And it's very open.
- 42:15Hungary is very open about it. And they're trying to create
- 42:19this energy pact with certain countries and also a political
- 42:23pact. And we should understand that
- 42:25they're moving strategically, that it's not random, and that
- 42:29they're exploiting certain political games being played
- 42:35within the EU by trying to move in with some of the countries
- 42:39there and kind of make false analogies of supposed
- 42:45similarities between them about how all of them are being
- 42:49victimized by Westerners or isolated.
- 42:52And there is some truth to some of it because some of the allies
- 42:56have been picked on by various political parties.
- 42:59But that's not to say that Hungary itself is being fixed on
- 43:03unfairly, completely. They have been, as I said, using
- 43:08their position as a single with veto country to pull exactly the
- 43:13sort of political stance Erdogan has been doing holding up aid
- 43:20for Ukraine, despite the fact that that every day that aid is
- 43:24held up, Russia grows stronger. It has more opportunities to
- 43:30entrench militarily, more opportunities to move
- 43:34politically deeper into EU support more pro Russian parties
- 43:38and of course also been in try to block the the European
- 43:44Ukrainian entry into the European Union.
- 43:48The talks that are only a starting point for long
- 43:54complicated process in exchange for billions of dollars in the
- 43:58aid it's supposedly doesn't need because it's so prosperous and
- 44:02and successful. I mean that's why I'm I'm a
- 44:04little bit surprised quite frankly at the fact that so many
- 44:08conservatives in Europe and the US are looking towards Hungary
- 44:11as an example to emulate given the fact that a it has to
- 44:16essentially extort concessions from EU.
- 44:20If you are a successful country you should have enough of a
- 44:23diplomatic presence and relationships do not have to do
- 44:26that. Second, its agenda is anti
- 44:29western quite openly 3rd it's not actually successful.
- 44:33Its economy is significantly underdeveloped after all these
- 44:37cash infusions. It's has a very small in the
- 44:41dwindling population which means it's conservative family values
- 44:45are simply not working for whatever reason and the and
- 44:53quite frankly a lot of it is just bluster.
- 44:56A lot of it is bluster that is appealing in terms of messaging
- 45:01but does not is not practically supported by action and by
- 45:05results. So it's it's not actually a
- 45:08conservative example to emulate. It is simply another Russian
- 45:13proxy that is playing the exact sort of talking points Russia
- 45:17has consistently played directly as well.
- 45:19And I think anyone should be willing to should be able to see
- 45:23through that it's not an economic powerhouse that that
- 45:28conservatives would like to emulate.
- 45:30It's not like Poland that's in fact quickly growing.
- 45:33It's not religious. It's like most of its population
- 45:37is actually one of the least religious countries in Europe.
- 45:40So I'm not entirely sure why everyone is suddenly so swept
- 45:44with Orban and his rhetoric. But this is not the man who
- 45:47presented himself as a Reaganesque leader, you know, 20
- 45:52years ago. This is a completely different
- 45:54person. Right, right.
- 45:56So all these developments around Ukraine, how do you think Russia
- 46:01will look at it? Putin will look at it.
- 46:03He, you know, just a few hours back he, he was speaking at a
- 46:07military brass, you know, talking with top military brass
- 46:11and he talked that, you know, about the conflict.
- 46:13And he said that they have seized the initiative on the
- 46:16battlefield and now they are well positioned to achieve
- 46:20Moscow's goals. How do you look at, do you think
- 46:23Russia is looking at all these developments around Ukraine?
- 46:27I know a lot of people like to make fun of Putin because it's
- 46:30very tempting. They like to make fun of his
- 46:32huge table. That looks ridiculous.
- 46:35Some people are even trying, spending their time guessing
- 46:37whether he's actually dead or or alive.
- 46:42But But quite frankly, the speech should be disconcerting
- 46:47to many simply because it's on target, and because he astutely
- 46:52understood exactly how the West is polarized right now, How the
- 46:58West has interrupted itself into these games, That that came in
- 47:03large point from internal dissatisfaction and distrust in
- 47:08its own institutions and in parts was fuelled by Russian
- 47:11propaganda. And it's taking set to take
- 47:14advantage of that politically, by funding and investing into
- 47:18parties that are rising to power.
- 47:19Slovakia is one example, Hungary.
- 47:23It's another survey is the third.
- 47:25In Spain we're seeing the same dynamic and I could name a
- 47:30number of others but and militarily, because the more
- 47:36Ukraine is denied aid the more whatever advantage it has
- 47:40managed to gain due to successful operation.
- 47:45You know, operations in the beginning of the war are being
- 47:49erased and the time placed to Russia's advantage, the time
- 47:54that they spent without within action placed to Russia's
- 47:57advantage. And they can replace people
- 48:00because they have a far bigger population than than Ukraine and
- 48:03Ukraine cannot replace their fighters that easily.
- 48:06They're scrambling to find people and it creates a very an
- 48:11economy. Ukraine's economy continues to
- 48:14suffer. Yes, Russia's economy has also
- 48:17faced taken a big blow, but it has managed to recover somewhat.
- 48:21It continues doing deals around the world.
- 48:23It has expanded far beyond the West, and summer ends been
- 48:28laundering a lot of money in in the Middle East.
- 48:31It's been robbing Africa of its gold through its through Wagner
- 48:37and now direct intelligence operations and the various
- 48:41criminal enterprises. It has its ways of getting
- 48:44around the various inconveniences placed on it by
- 48:47Western sanctions and other limitations.
- 48:52It has support. It's not going anywhere without
- 48:55a very aggressive pushback. And we have seen that that
- 48:58pushback has an impact. Once Ukraine gained more
- 49:02sophisticated weapons like Athens, they have in climbers,
- 49:08they have been making a lot of progress.
- 49:10As soon as that flow stopped, so has the progress.
- 49:14So these weapons were making a major difference.
- 49:17They can. They are the difference between
- 49:19victory and a protracted, entrenched conflict that is
- 49:22threatens the entire West and not just Ukraine.
- 49:27Right. Right.
- 49:27And talking of Russia, that intelligence file, the Intel
- 49:31file one file has gone you know has suddenly disappeared Take
- 49:38out that that is it because more more related to elections new
- 49:43come coming up of new elections 2024 that this 202,016 US
- 49:48election related to Donald Trump.
- 49:51You know that file has suddenly gone missing and that was about
- 49:55intelligence on, you know, Russia, Russia about their role
- 50:00or not role in the US elections at that point in time.
- 50:04Where is the pile? Where do you think is the pile?
- 50:06Irena, you are very well connected.
- 50:08You should know where the pile is.
- 50:10Well, I wish I knew because if I had known it wouldn't have been
- 50:14missing by this point anymore. But, but I think it's very
- 50:19interesting that Mark Meadows assistant explain that he had
- 50:23the file that she saw him have that file Mark Meadows of course
- 50:28category of the death authorities to testify against
- 50:31Trump. The question is if he had the
- 50:34file at any point in time and probably was acting on Trump's
- 50:40behalf and either hid it somewhere or gave it to Trump or
- 50:45gave it to somebody else, why and at what point would he
- 50:48disclose that information in exchange to for what If, on the
- 50:53other hand he you know she was mistaken and he did not have
- 50:57that file or or or he had something that looks like that
- 51:03file but somebody else got it, You know, that file remains a
- 51:10weapon that can be used as a form of extortion.
- 51:13It could be used to target the American E assets in various
- 51:18country countries related to Russia.
- 51:21It can be used to cover up infiltration into the US.
- 51:27It can be used to in damaging ways.
- 51:29So the question is if it was left in a safe to begin with in
- 51:34a vault, were there no security cameras that would indicate when
- 51:38it was relieved? If there was interference
- 51:42tampering with the camera? Is there no evidence to who
- 51:45could he could have done it. A file just doesn't disappear on
- 51:49its own. Someone took it.
- 51:51If Meadows did it, why? You know, after all this time
- 51:56the US, the intelligence hasn't been able to get that
- 52:00information from him as to what happened to it.
- 52:04If somebody else did it there. Only a few people had access to
- 52:08that area. Where?
- 52:10Where? How is it?
- 52:12No evidence has been found to where it could have gone other
- 52:16than Mark Meadows. To me, I feel like there's
- 52:20something more going on with the story that some part of it is
- 52:23missing or somebody may may know some something, but is
- 52:28deliberately preventing the investigation from reaching a
- 52:32successful conclusion. Maybe somebody inside from the
- 52:36investigation team is not being honest with us concerning the
- 52:40evidence that we see. Because it seems to me that
- 52:43after over 2 years with the cooperating witness who has all
- 52:47the reason in the world to cooperate against Donald Trump
- 52:50right now, you would think that if he was in any way involved,
- 52:53they would have found something by now.
- 52:55The fact that the fire has disappeared into an area nobody
- 52:59knows, I don't believe that. I think somebody knows very and
- 53:05deliberately covering up leads in in this case.
- 53:09Absolutely, absolutely. Russia is in a lot of news.
- 53:12The word intelligence is in a lot of news and moving on from
- 53:16the Russia related intelligence in the US, Donald Trump.
- 53:20Now let's move on to Russian intelligence.
- 53:23There are reports that is taking over Wagner operations in
- 53:26Africa. You know how?
- 53:28What is your take on this on these reports?
- 53:31How should we look at it? Well, Wagner was always supposed
- 53:34to be a tool of Russian foreign policy.
- 53:37These these were less professional fighters.
- 53:40A lot of them were criminals and foreign recruits that we used to
- 53:45as a means of plausible deniability for the intelligence
- 53:49to begin with. With precautions, removal from
- 53:55public view, and presumed elimination.
- 54:00Though nobody has ever confirmed that he's outside permanent own
- 54:05reports that his body was actually found there.
- 54:07Whatever the case may be, he's presumed to not no longer be
- 54:11leading these operations. And I think it was a natural
- 54:15transition to what Russia wanted to do in the 1st place, which is
- 54:19simply establish its presence formally in Africa and to make
- 54:23official claim to be to its to its fears of influence in those
- 54:30countries. However, I don't think the
- 54:33intelligence will do much better than Wagner, which only met with
- 54:37partial success. Yes, they are able to loot a
- 54:40lot, yes they're propping up friendly regimes, but US is now
- 54:44re establishing relations with Niger.
- 54:46A number of countries were not happy with Wagner rule and now
- 54:50the waves of terrorists that are essentially lining up against
- 54:54these regimes and against Wagner specifically.
- 54:58So I'm not entirely sure how long they will last even, you
- 55:02know, in terms of simply security preparation for this
- 55:07sort of security challenges. Can they really fight wars with
- 55:11all these jihadists when when they're also stretched in
- 55:16Ukraine it's yes they can make progress there but they it's
- 55:20still a big a big burden. I don't.
- 55:24I I actually think that they may be may end up shooting
- 55:27themselves in the foot by overreaching in areas that are
- 55:31very difficult to control under the best of circumstances.
- 55:35Right, right. Talking of you know US to
- 55:38restart relations with Niger, you know what does that mean for
- 55:43West Africa security? Recently the Niger was in a lot
- 55:47of news and now US is again looking to restart its stock.
- 55:52How should we look at it? Well, I think US is hoping that
- 55:56it can have a positive impact by first preventing a huge internal
- 56:01war with other W African countries and also preventing
- 56:07jihadists from establishing a an even bigger foothold than they
- 56:11already have. That would be a mess, a huge
- 56:13refugee crisis. I think US understands that
- 56:17dealing with the pro Russian junta is not exactly great, but
- 56:22if Niger is willing to tell it right, these relations, there
- 56:27could be an opening if Wagner or the Russian intelligence or
- 56:31whoever, whatever Russian presence is there, if they fail
- 56:35and if they will fail because they're inviting problems by by
- 56:39the strategy they have developed inside the country against the
- 56:44various groups there. So I think US is looking to try
- 56:48to shift back and to try to cooperate and maybe squeeze
- 56:52Russia out of that to the best of their abilities.
- 56:54I am not sure they will be successful in the short run.
- 56:57In the long run I think that Kunta without support by the
- 57:03Russians will ultimately fall and we are seeing that in Mali
- 57:09the the the local regime is also already having problems between
- 57:14the losing support of some of the of the initial anti French
- 57:20parties. And we are seeing that some of
- 57:22the support coalitions could collapse of their own free will
- 57:27and we could see the re establishment of previous
- 57:30governments or some versions of them in the near future.
- 57:33There could be changes. I think US is trying to position
- 57:37themselves to be ready to take advantage of them if there is a
- 57:40shift in a positive direction. Right, right.
- 57:44In a lot of politics happening all across the world.
- 57:47Lot of things happening with Russia in about Russia.
- 57:51A lot of things happening also in the US about intelligence and
- 57:56now politics has seems to have entered a lot on the US
- 57:59campuses. anti-Semitism crisis. This is the new crisis.
- 58:04What does what? What should we understand about
- 58:08this? All these talks happening around
- 58:10anti-Semitism around in US campuses?
- 58:14How should we look? Investigations are happening.
- 58:17How should we understand that? There are several factors that I
- 58:21would name. First, the GEI curriculum.
- 58:25This sort of very woke diversity, equity inclusion
- 58:34paradigms ultimately end up being anti-Semitic just by their
- 58:40nation. They actually very similar to
- 58:43quota systems that were directly openly anti-Semitic, imposed by
- 58:48universities back in the 1920s, turkeys, 50s and so forth.
- 58:54A lot of them openly exclude Jewish students, and there's
- 58:57been lawsuits to try to revise all of that.
- 59:00I don't think it's revisable. I think the very concept of
- 59:03focusing on identity, race and other biological factors as
- 59:08opposed to merit and the effort and the individual
- 59:13contributions, I think it's always going to backfire and
- 59:16victimize one group or another. And Jews are just simply the
- 59:20easiest scapegoats for various reasons.
- 59:23Second factor is is the funding by foreign unfriendly regimes
- 59:30such as Qatar and Iran who have been pouring money into outright
- 59:36anti-Semitic curricula in groups on campuses and university
- 59:41cities have been going along with that.
- 59:43And a lot of the students who are openly anti-Semitic and
- 59:46harassment harassing a foreigners US therefore they pay
- 59:49a lot of money upfront in cash and the universities don't want
- 59:54to get rid of them. That's how they enable some of
- 59:58this activity. The sort of factor is
- 1:00:00unfortunately social media. A lot of students simply don't
- 1:00:04know anything and they learn most of the information about
- 1:00:08conflicts and about anything really from TikTok.
- 1:00:12And TikTok has been spreading outright pro Hamas and
- 1:00:15anti-Semitic propaganda despite US efforts to get it to stop the
- 1:00:19company. Claims to take measures, but
- 1:00:21it's China and China has been openly anti-Semitic and pro
- 1:00:25Hamas in its own propaganda outlets.
- 1:00:28So why should social media and at the West be indifferent?
- 1:00:32That's kind of the goal. It's the strategy.
- 1:00:34The 4th factor has been the long standing radicalization of
- 1:00:38faculty and that's been something growing for
- 1:00:41generations. Started under the Soviet Union.
- 1:00:44Of course, Soviet Union was also filled with anti-Semitic
- 1:00:47propaganda, which they brought in parts to the Middle East
- 1:00:51influence, the Muslim Brotherhood, the Islamist
- 1:00:53organizations and of course campus ideology which has come
- 1:00:57back to Qantas after several generations of increasing cycle
- 1:01:02of brainwashing, elimination of alternative perspectives is
- 1:01:06people, students at top schools. When they go to Middle East
- 1:01:11studies class, they learn they that somebody like Osama bin
- 1:01:15Laden is a freedom fighter, not a terrorist.
- 1:01:18When they go learn about American politics, they learn
- 1:01:21that whether underground, a terrorist group, were actually
- 1:01:25wonderful educators, things of that nature.
- 1:01:27So how can we expect these students who learn similar
- 1:01:31things in schools, by the way K through 12, then go on to
- 1:01:34universities with no critical thing, skills or intimidated
- 1:01:38into spouting out garbage just to get a good grade so that
- 1:01:43that's the situation. And these factors will not be
- 1:01:46easy to undo because a whole generation of young people,
- 1:01:50future leaders, thinkers, journalists, analysts, they have
- 1:01:56have already been brainwashing. They're already out of school,
- 1:01:58they're already out there seeking employment.
- 1:02:01And some law firms, some medical school, medical hospitals have
- 1:02:07withdrawn job offers to the worst of the lab that have been
- 1:02:10shown to have radical sentiments on the social media or in the OR
- 1:02:16in the press. But not everybody is that vocal
- 1:02:19about how they feel and what they think.
- 1:02:21And I think this will come back to brightest in 1015 years, you
- 1:02:25even less as they enter higher office and jobs and and so
- 1:02:30forth. Right, right.
- 1:02:33Arena. The world is getting full of
- 1:02:35disagreements everywhere, either on the political battlefield or
- 1:02:39even in campuses. And this is not a good thing
- 1:02:43talking about, you know, disagreements.
- 1:02:46But what about Taiwan? Why are they disagreeing?
- 1:02:49You know, can't agree on the future of submarine production.
- 1:02:52The elections are next month. Then whoever wins can decide,
- 1:02:56you know, and will get that. But why there is talk, so much
- 1:02:59of talk about submarine, especially during elections, And
- 1:03:04how do we see that? How should we?
- 1:03:06Why can't the elections just happen and everyone then
- 1:03:09decides, takes, decides on the next move?
- 1:03:13Security and concerns about China's aggressions obviously
- 1:03:16play into a lot of what the candidates would be pushing for
- 1:03:20the, you know, I think it's natural for, you know, a pro
- 1:03:23security candidate to promise the development over some major
- 1:03:29defense mechanism that will make the country less dependent on
- 1:03:34foreign aid. However, there are alternative
- 1:03:38points of view from other candidates.
- 1:03:39Which view such discussions as provocative to China and
- 1:03:44inviting aggression from China. Which claimed that any attempt
- 1:03:49to scale up any sort of defensive mechanisms could be
- 1:03:54viewed as an aggressive maneuver against China.
- 1:03:57Finally there you know and and this is the middle perspective
- 1:04:01and the third perspective is that Taiwan should simply be
- 1:04:04moving to negotiate some sort of a agreement with China.
- 1:04:08And these are and there is, let's not forget China is
- 1:04:11heavily invested into Taiwan. It's done a lot of business
- 1:04:15there. It has been until recently
- 1:04:18heavily dependent on chips, cheap semiconductor production
- 1:04:22in Taiwan. So they have a fair amount of
- 1:04:25influence in politics as well. China has been meddling in
- 1:04:28Taiwan election process. And I think some of this
- 1:04:31rhetoric, some of this unnecessary disagreement about
- 1:04:35what to anyone else would seem like a rather obvious next step
- 1:04:39comes from that, from that camp to try to create fear inside the
- 1:04:45population that if they do start, even discuss a production
- 1:04:51of new submarines, China could that could actually invite an
- 1:04:54attack. I think that's the kind of thing
- 1:04:56that the, you know, that China wants to the Taiwanese voters to
- 1:05:02worry about. Right, right.
- 1:05:06Agreement or disagreement, you know, meetings can always help.
- 1:05:09What happened at the meeting between Venezuela and Guyana?
- 1:05:13Again, it is about oil. Do we, what do we look at there?
- 1:05:17Is it? Is it going to be a better
- 1:05:19future between these two countries, the better, you know,
- 1:05:22or this dispute will get solved? Or is it the oil is going to
- 1:05:26continue to be slippery for them?
- 1:05:28Well, here's the thing. The territory that Venezuela is
- 1:05:31claiming, it's not just a small slip of land with a lot of oil
- 1:05:36on it, unlike, you know, other countries where that's the case.
- 1:05:39This is 2/3 of Guyana's territory, and Guyana is a very
- 1:05:42small country. So they're basically threatening
- 1:05:46to annex the entire country. And they have not moved away
- 1:05:49from their legal claims. They have only mutually
- 1:05:52committed to abstain from violence.
- 1:05:55Now Venezuela is concerned about growing US presence and
- 1:05:59commitment. But on the other hand, it is
- 1:06:01also believes that the US cannot indefinitely maintain the
- 1:06:05presence, especially if that presence is ultimately needed
- 1:06:08somewhere else. So they're testing the waters to
- 1:06:12seek how far they can push the envelope at this moment.
- 1:06:15And they have seen that there are overflights.
- 1:06:18But then, you know, overflights cannot solve all problems.
- 1:06:23If the if there's a ground invasion, how far is US willing
- 1:06:26to go? Are they going to conduct air
- 1:06:28strikes? Are they going to send ground
- 1:06:30troops? What?
- 1:06:31How much are they willing to help?
- 1:06:33I think we in over the next few weeks, if not sooner, we will
- 1:06:37see how Venezuela interprets US movement.
- 1:06:41And if US withdraws after some period, they may strike.
- 1:06:45Then they may evaluate this agreement because they need the
- 1:06:49oil They owe billions to China and Russia and to Europe as
- 1:06:54well. And the the country is
- 1:06:56completely corrupt, it's ruled less by Maduro and mobile Cubans
- 1:07:01and Cuba is also bankrupt. So they they they need the
- 1:07:05money. They are deeply in debt.
- 1:07:08And they're also looking to subsidize the networks of
- 1:07:12intelligence operatives over Latin America, despite having no
- 1:07:17funding for food and basic necessities and facing and one
- 1:07:21of the largest refugee crisis in the world in a brain drain.
- 1:07:26So This is why we find them looking at completely desperate
- 1:07:30measures such as takeover over their neighbors as a as a
- 1:07:34solution to their own financial problems.
- 1:07:37Right, right. All these things need solution.
- 1:07:40But amidst all these things, you know the one concrete result
- 1:07:43that has come is the elections in Egypt.
- 1:07:48Abdel Fattah Al Sisi. He has swept to back to a third
- 1:07:51term. How should we look at this?
- 1:07:53You know, how should the world look at this?
- 1:07:57Well, that's not altogether surprising, to put it mildly.
- 1:08:01But at the same time, we can expect Egypt to stay on course
- 1:08:04in trying to be helpful in resolving the Israel Hamas
- 1:08:08crisis. And they have been very, very
- 1:08:11strong diplomatic presence and they have been trying to play a
- 1:08:14much more active role and and much more consistent and
- 1:08:18positive role than Qatar in this case.
- 1:08:22And unlike Qatar, they do not have ulterior motives of dealing
- 1:08:26with Hamas. Hamas actually presents a
- 1:08:28security problem to Egyptians as well.
- 1:08:32So there I think there's a great deal for diplomatic cooperation.
- 1:08:37I think that the financial crisis in Egypt requires a lot
- 1:08:41more attention because foreign parties have been trying to use
- 1:08:45this situation to gain hold there.
- 1:08:48The whole situation, the Israel, Hamas war, has not helped on the
- 1:08:52popular level at all. And I think the combination of
- 1:08:56these factors, this populist pressure from Islamists and this
- 1:09:01financial crisis can lead to a wave of unrest that can result
- 1:09:08in very, very dire situation in Egypt.
- 1:09:11And I think this is the time for US to put away all the scandals,
- 1:09:15all the, you know, human rights grievances by various groups and
- 1:09:20focus on the big picture. The big picture is we cannot
- 1:09:23afford another Morsi type presence in Egypt.
- 1:09:27This is not something anyone can afford among all the other
- 1:09:31security issues. So we just need to do what we
- 1:09:34have to do to resolve those problems, help Egypt resolve
- 1:09:38those problems and ensure stability inside the country
- 1:09:41that's right next door to Israel and that has over 100 million
- 1:09:46people. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 1:09:49This was the last of the topic for today.
- 1:09:51And as the world continues to do good things or not so good
- 1:09:55things politically or in terms of anything, we will continue to
- 1:09:59bring your perspective, you know, every fortnight to the
- 1:10:03viewers and who will get the right kind of perspective to the
- 1:10:06things happening all around this world with this.
- 1:10:09It's a wrap on this very special edition of the KJ Master Class
- 1:10:13slide. Thank you so much indeed for
- 1:10:15joining us. Thank you so much.
- 1:10:17I appreciate it as always.