Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / Bob Reiss What If Technology Had The Power To Be Evil The Impossible Detective
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Maybe it's just a radio thing. Variety, give people a variety,
- 0:04and that's what we do on aero dot net a
- 0:06r r oe dot Net. It's not just a podcast
- 0:10with rock stars and movie stars. Oh, it's about lifestyle
- 0:14and beyond. It's variety a r r oe dot Net.
- 0:19Enjoy the exploration. Hello and good morning. How are you
- 0:22doing today?
- 0:23Speaker 2: I'm good? How are you?
- 0:24Speaker 3: Absolutely fantastic? Rob Man? We're you at these days?
- 0:29Speaker 2: I'm up in New York City where we have a
- 0:32sleep store.
- 0:33Speaker 4: Well, yeah, we're down here in the Carolinas where it's
- 0:35down here. We got down to seventeen last night, so yeah, okay,
- 0:37I just want to know if we're sharing the same
- 0:39kind of cold.
- 0:40Speaker 2: Well where you guys have been freakishly hit with all
- 0:43kinds of bad weather recently. Yeah, we have.
- 0:46Speaker 4: What does that do for you as a writer, because
- 0:48I know that as a daily writer, for me and
- 0:51somebody who shares stories, the weather conditions can fit right
- 0:54into a storyline. Do you use the same kind of energy?
- 0:58Speaker 2: Not an a way you suggest? In New York City,
- 1:01I have two windows that look outside. In the summer,
- 1:06I want to look at green. In the winter, I
- 1:08retreat into an office with no windows. So it's a
- 1:11question of when you want to be distracted and when
- 1:14you just want to be in your head.
- 1:17Speaker 4: I got to let you know that I'm actually broadcasting
- 1:20from a library right here in downtown Charlotte and overlooking
- 1:23Seventh Street in Bavard. So to share a conversation with
- 1:26somebody who has allowed writing to become such a major
- 1:29part of their lives is so important to the people
- 1:32who are here to learn how to become storytellers. And
- 1:35so I mean, it's amazing what you have done with
- 1:37The Impossible Detective, because it sounds like that you made
- 1:39an exploration here that really takes us into a modern age.
- 1:45Speaker 2: You know, it's more than a modern age. I never
- 1:48I've always tried to write my novels in a way
- 1:51that I'm addressing important issues in society. I never liked.
- 1:55I never liked the term artificial intelligence. And if you
- 1:58think about it, some Gus marketing guy came up with
- 2:01that term because it implies to us that we are superior.
- 2:05It's artificial. We don't really consider it as a threat,
- 2:08but I consider AI think of it as a moral intelligence. Right.
- 2:13It still has power, but it doesn't have empathy. It
- 2:16doesn't have morals, it doesn't have Christianity, it doesn't have religion.
- 2:20It just makes decisions. And now we're about to hand
- 2:22over all kinds of important decisions in society to this
- 2:26amorl entity. And the only thing that's lacking to make
- 2:31it truly dangerous at this point is were to become conscious.
- 2:35And so I did research on this. I spoke to experts,
- 2:38I spoke to military experts, and when I started the book,
- 2:42people would say, well, consciousness might be possible in twelve years.
- 2:47Then it became ten years, then eight, and six, then five,
- 2:51And so I wanted to write a book about the
- 2:54very first second, the very first second when AI becomes
- 2:58conscious but nobody knows it yet except AI, and it
- 3:02has and it has the power to make choices, choices.
- 3:06What would the very voice choice be?
- 3:10Speaker 3: Yeah?
- 3:11Speaker 4: And that's what's scary about this, because I mean, everybody's
- 3:13running to chat GPT and every gunk or grunk or
- 3:16whatever it is, and they're trying to get information. But
- 3:18what happens if that AI turns like you're saying, and
- 3:21all of a sudden, it's not expecting our questions, it's
- 3:23just doing it. And That's what I love about The
- 3:25Impossible Detective is the fact that you put us in
- 3:28a position of where we get to sit inside something
- 3:31that we just kind of put to the side, but
- 3:32we can't anymore because we're going to pay attention to it.
- 3:36Speaker 2: We have to pay attention to it. You know. It's interesting.
- 3:39It's already affecting our lives in so many ways. It's
- 3:42so interesting to me that you're in a library because
- 3:44I bet every author who has a book in that
- 3:47library has had a similar experience to the one I
- 3:50had just last week. All authors I know are periodically
- 3:54contacted by people who are offering to for money, of course,
- 3:58improve their website, improve their rich improve their publicity. Recently,
- 4:03these letters, these emails that we get from these people
- 4:06have changed suddenly. The people seem to have read our
- 4:09books that will flir to specific passages. They seem like people.
- 4:14It's a Nigerian scam. It's AI that's contacting us. And
- 4:18I bet everyone listening to you today is being contacted
- 4:22by AI daily, dealing with it daily. Personally. It drives
- 4:26me nutt.
- 4:27Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, I'll tell you the way that I've handled
- 4:30it with podcasting, because you're absolutely right. They're sending these letters.
- 4:33They make it sound like they're emotionally and compassionately involved
- 4:36in what's going on. And so I'll send them a
- 4:38simple question. I'll go, so, what was I thinking about
- 4:41before I posted this interview? Please tell me, expecting them
- 4:44to give me an answer, going you didn't say anything,
- 4:46but they won't even say that.
- 4:47Speaker 3: That's how I know it's a fake.
- 4:50Speaker 2: Yeah, it's so funny coming up with strategies. My next
- 4:54strategy will be because I got about six of days
- 4:56a week, So the next one that comes in, whatever
- 4:59the solicit is, I'm going to send them back a
- 5:02message that says, my wife and I ordered a pizza
- 5:05from you last week and it was cold, and the
- 5:08salaman was bad and the meat walls were bad. What's
- 5:11going on with your pizzas? And I'm curious if it's
- 5:14ai how it will reas farm.
- 5:17Speaker 4: The story itself in The Impossible Detective is set in
- 5:20New York City. Now, of course that excites me because
- 5:22I love the city for its size, But I think
- 5:25there's more to it than that that put it inside
- 5:27this book.
- 5:29Speaker 2: You know, the hero in this An Impossible Detective, lives
- 5:32on Edgar Allan Poet Street, where he lived and which
- 5:36is six blocks away from my apartment. I thought, what
- 5:40better place to have AI breakout than here? And what
- 5:45happened with this book was interesting the way I've got
- 5:48like twenty five books, but none of the books until
- 5:51this happened this way. RKO Films came to me about
- 5:55two years ago and they had a franchise that you
- 5:59maybe familiar with from the fifties called The Falcon. I
- 6:02had a hero, George Saunders played the Falcon. Tom Conway
- 6:06played the Falcon, and they were looking to bring the
- 6:10franchise back to life and they wanted to know if
- 6:13I had any interest in doing that. They wouldn't tell
- 6:16me what to do. I could make it totally modern,
- 6:19I could do whatever I wanted. And I said to them,
- 6:22you can't see the drafts and they agreed, you will
- 6:25have no input and they agreed, and so, yeah, who's
- 6:30going to turn that down? Ron?
- 6:31Speaker 3: So did you not know that that was an AI
- 6:33letter that was sent to you? Come on now?
- 6:35Speaker 4: I would have said, Ah, this is fake, there's no way.
- 6:39Speaker 2: Well, you're right, you're right. The way I knew is
- 6:41that I went I physically went to the agent representing
- 6:44them's apartment in Manhattan and we sat down and you know,
- 6:47we had a negotiation. There were human voices, and then
- 6:51we were in a restaurant. So what unless they were robuts,
- 6:54which maybe in the future a I could do. I
- 6:57knew these were real people.
- 6:59Speaker 4: Okay, I'm going to bring that up because that's one
- 7:01of my questions today is that do you think that
- 7:02the future is full of robots? Because I'm that kid
- 7:05that used to have those little you know, those robots
- 7:07that you would have with a remote control. And I
- 7:09never believed it then and I still don't believe it
- 7:11today that they will be in control. What's your gut
- 7:14with all the research that you've done, well.
- 7:16Speaker 2: With all the research I've done, I'm more concerned about
- 7:20other ways that AI could get it as Yeah, sure
- 7:23there could be robots. I mean, I've visited the Robotics
- 7:26place over at Columbia University for this I mustand that
- 7:29at what robots are being able to do. But it's
- 7:33what AI is already able to do that's so frightening.
- 7:36You know, I've read rand reports on how states like
- 7:40China and Russia are using AI. Corporations are firing people
- 7:44firing white and blue collar workers both and replacing them
- 7:47with AI. And just yesterday I thought of another possibility
- 7:50which really freaks me out, which is when you talk
- 7:54to experts about AI, you know, who are doubtful that
- 7:57it might be negative in the future. They'll say, well,
- 8:01we'll just program it to do this, or we'll just
- 8:04program it to do that. But think about this, because
- 8:07I bet you and every single person listening to us
- 8:09today has had this experience. We write an email to
- 8:13someone we know, we think that the email is clear,
- 8:17it turns out that it's not clear. They misinterpreted it,
- 8:20and suddenly we're in a fight. So who is to say?
- 8:23And I teach writing and oftentimes people will write things
- 8:27that don't reflect what they're really thinking. So sooner or
- 8:30later a programmer will do that. A programmer will tell
- 8:34AI to do something, thinking that they just gave it
- 8:38a clear command. AI will interpret it differently. God knows
- 8:42what will happen.
- 8:43Speaker 4: Then, well, yeah, anytime you go in to chat GPT
- 8:46and you ask a question, or if you're trying to
- 8:48get them to do a logo for you, and it
- 8:50has to sit there and ask questions, I'm going you
- 8:52have no idea who I am? You have no idea
- 8:53the emotion of what I put into this. Okay, I'm
- 8:55going on to the next thing because chat GPT you're
- 8:57not doing it for me.
- 9:00Speaker 2: Yeah. Well, at this point we still have enough discernment
- 9:03to understand that it is chat GBT. But you know,
- 9:06just last night I was reading this Ramp Corporation report
- 9:09on chat GBT and they said it's getting harder and
- 9:13harder and harder for people to distinguish between real and fake,
- 9:17and it will only continue to get harder.
- 9:19Speaker 1: Please should not move. There's more with Bob Reese coming
- 9:22up next. The name of the book, The Impossible Detective.
- 9:28We are back with author Bob Reese.
- 9:30Speaker 4: So let me ask you this question when you talk
- 9:32about this book being a sci fi The Impossible Detective. Okay,
- 9:36so if we feel that it's going to happen, then
- 9:38why is it still qualified sci fi if we think
- 9:41it's going to be factual.
- 9:43Speaker 2: Well, that's a great question. I don't consider it sci fi.
- 9:46I consider it speculative fiction. Speculative fiction, and a lot
- 9:50of my fection is this because I really like to
- 9:52think what could happen. My background is as a journalist
- 9:56and a novelist, and you know, and it's interesting because
- 10:00I always want to pick off on the topic I'm
- 10:02concerned about, when do you do it as a journalist?
- 10:05When do you do it as a novelist. Well, you
- 10:07do it as a journalist when the bad thing has
- 10:09already happened and you're covering it. But how do you
- 10:12cover something that you're afraid of that hasn't happened yet.
- 10:16That's when it becomes speculative fiction. That's when you tell
- 10:19the same story of what could happen, but not with
- 10:22a flow chart or an algorithm or a speech, but
- 10:25with real people going through the issue, and with something
- 10:29like this, which is ai a moral intelligence. The challenge
- 10:34is it's easy to make a sci fire movie like
- 10:37Arnold Schwazener artificial intelligence has taken over, right, and it's
- 10:41fifty years in the future. But what if you're writing
- 10:44about something that could happen today at five o'clock this evening,
- 10:49and the world is the stand except somewhere secretly in
- 10:53some apartment, the tiny little change happens that changes the
- 10:56whole world. That you have to do with fiction. You
- 11:00have to have people, you have to have you have
- 11:02to have an issue. You know, this is a private
- 11:05detective book, The Impossible Detective. There is a private detective
- 11:08on the surface underneath all these issues.
- 11:11Speaker 4: So now would you qualify this then as a true
- 11:14crime because I mean in reality, I mean there's some
- 11:16bad things are going to happen here for the readers
- 11:19and to me that get you know what, what what
- 11:21is the new definition of crime?
- 11:24Speaker 2: Well, crime is we all know what crime is. I
- 11:27would still make the speculative fiction before, as you say,
- 11:31you could call it speculative crime. Science fiction is fiction. Clearly,
- 11:36this book is made up, so it's fiction when I write.
- 11:40When I write nonfiction, believe me, I stick with facts.
- 11:43It's still storytelling. You still have good characters, you still
- 11:47have to make choice, but it's facts. I don't believe
- 11:50there's a blurring of fact and fiction. You really keep
- 11:52it separate. So this would be speculative political fiction.
- 11:57Speaker 4: So now as that author are you received the letters
- 12:00as well from the publishers as well as the people
- 12:03that are distributing the book in the way of saying,
- 12:05we need to know that one hundred percent that this
- 12:07has nothing to do with AI technology, because they're doing
- 12:10that with podcasters where they want to make sure that
- 12:12we are authentic, that we are not relying on AI
- 12:16because they've got to go out there and put it
- 12:17on their platform. So as an author, what does that
- 12:19do for you?
- 12:21Speaker 2: Well, as an author, I have different kind of dealings
- 12:24with AI. Okay, the publisher knows that I'm a human being,
- 12:27so I'm not going to get a suspicious letter who
- 12:30are you? But the way I'm dealing with AI is
- 12:33and this surprised me. Over the last year, I've been
- 12:37contacted by two lossuits. These are class action lawsuits, one
- 12:41against Meta I think, and one against this other outfit.
- 12:45And both of those outfits have used I think eight
- 12:48of my books to train their large language models. And
- 12:52so now this is in the courts now in one
- 12:57I got a letter the other day that come to
- 12:59us littlement, but thousands of This is a one point
- 13:02five million dollar settlement for the authors all around the
- 13:06country whose works have been used without their knowledge to
- 13:10trade to train. That's the way I deal with it.
- 13:13Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, I got to tell you this, And this
- 13:15is to go along with people who are still trying
- 13:17to understand what AI technology is. Is the fact that
- 13:20I even went to the AI technology and asked them,
- 13:22could you help me write my show prep so that
- 13:25I can go into it better prepared? And it literally
- 13:28told me no, because it went back and it listened
- 13:30to every all the questions, the styles that I had,
- 13:33and it says, I can't put the emotion in it
- 13:35that you do.
- 13:37Speaker 2: Well, that was an honest one, but yeah, yeah, I mean,
- 13:41but how many people have programmed there for honesty? And
- 13:44if you take a survey of professors, as you know,
- 13:48more and more of them are seeing their class papers
- 13:50come and written by AI, letters being written by AI.
- 13:53It's sort of like and writing skills. As writing skills
- 13:58decline in the population, more and more people are going
- 14:02to be relying on AI.
- 14:04Speaker 4: Don't you think though that you cause I'll tell you
- 14:05what the one thing that The Impossible Detective has really
- 14:08done for my imagination. It reminds me so much of
- 14:11those early holiday or Hollywood films where it shows the
- 14:15rocket crashing into the moon, and really, as we've lived
- 14:17it today, that's not really what happens. But the fact
- 14:19is is that you're identifying AI technology in The Impossible
- 14:23Detective and how it affects us as human beings, and
- 14:25people aren't talking about this, So that makes you a
- 14:27pioneer of sorts in the way of writing stories.
- 14:32Speaker 2: Well, I don't know if it's pioneer. Writers have always
- 14:36anticipated things, you know, HG. Wells.
- 14:38Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 14:38Speaker 2: I saw this movie from nineteen thirty two the other night,
- 14:41Things to Come, Things to Come, And it's an HG.
- 14:45Well Well's film based on a story he wrote anticipating
- 14:50World War Two, anticipating rockets, anticipating all this kind of stuff.
- 14:55So I think this is what writers do, if we're
- 15:00doing it right. Somehow, writers can synthesize the patterns that
- 15:04are evident every day, and following those patterns, they predict
- 15:09what's going to happen next, or if we keep going
- 15:12in this direction, what it'll be like in five years,
- 15:14ten years, twenty years, one hundred years. And so often
- 15:18they're right.
- 15:19Speaker 4: Wow, where can people go to find out more about you?
- 15:22Speaker 2: Rob?
- 15:22Speaker 4: Because you just talked about all of the books that
- 15:24you've got published, and you're also a journalist. I want
- 15:26people to tap into your multiple personalities as well as
- 15:29your walk in way of reaching people as that writer.
- 15:33It's so important that we talk about being a writer
- 15:35because a lot of people would rather go to a
- 15:37computer to have it written for them.
- 15:40Speaker 2: Well, thanks for us in that question. And certainly my
- 15:42wife is always asking about multi personality. So in a
- 15:48loving way and a loving way, the way they could
- 15:51find is Bob Reese, Bob r EISs Rees. Bobrees dot
- 15:59com is my website and has the twenty five books
- 16:01and journalism and speeches and if you want to bring
- 16:05me in to give a speech, how to contact me
- 16:07all that stuff.
- 16:08Speaker 3: I love it.
- 16:09Speaker 4: You got to come back to this show anytime in
- 16:10the future. The door is always going to be open
- 16:12for you.
- 16:13Speaker 2: Well, I would love to come back. I love talking
- 16:16with you. These questions are terrific.
- 16:17Speaker 4: Well, I'll tell you what I've got so many for
- 16:19twenty twenty six. I have so many conversations coming up
- 16:22with people of AI technology that I feel like that
- 16:25I should invite you into a zoom link and you
- 16:27participate with it in the way that you bring your knowledge.
- 16:30I come from my side of it, and we ask
- 16:32these pros you know what's going on, because if we
- 16:34don't talk about it, how are we going to help
- 16:37shape it.
- 16:37Speaker 2: Here's the thing about AI. See, every time throughout history
- 16:41there has been a new invention, there has been an
- 16:43argument will this be good for your manity? Or will
- 16:46this be bad for your manager? But here's the deal. See,
- 16:49here's the difference. This AI is the very first time
- 16:53that the invention will be able to think for itself.
- 16:57The invention will be able to make choices for itself.
- 17:00And the invention has already surprised the makers of itself
- 17:04with abilities that even they didn't think it could have.
- 17:07Oh my god, So how could they assure us? How
- 17:09could they be so positive that there will be no
- 17:12negative effects? Here? It's already affecting every aspect of our lives.
- 17:16It will continue to do that, it will affect more
- 17:18and more. How much power do we want to give it?
- 17:21And the last thing, you know, Donald Trump, I think
- 17:24even this week is urging New York State to stop
- 17:29trying to control AI, to stop having any kind of
- 17:33oversight of AI. That's the battle of the future. How
- 17:37do we want to oversee this thing?
- 17:39Speaker 3: Yep?
- 17:39Speaker 4: Because we have an AI as are now they just
- 17:42announced the ais are.
- 17:45Speaker 2: And the purpose of the ais are. If it's federal,
- 17:47we'll probably be to try to shut down any overser.
- 17:50Speaker 3: You're right, you're right, you're right.
- 17:51Speaker 4: Wow, Well, please come back to this show anytime in
- 17:54the future.
- 17:55Speaker 2: Sir, I accept, thank you and thank you for having
- 17:59me today.
- 18:00Speaker 3: You be brilliant today. Okay.
- 18:03Speaker 2: I love compliments, strength,