Latest / Reformed Thinking / Remembered by God: Providence, Forgetfulness, and Hope (Genesis 40:20-23)
Transcript
- 0:00You know, usually when we talk about doing the right thing,
- 0:02there's this expectation of a clean cause and effect
- 0:06relationship. We treat obedience kind of like
- 0:08a vending machine. You drop in your coin of
- 0:11faithfulness, you pull the lever, and well, out pops the
- 0:14blessing. Right.
- 0:15It is clean, it is binary, and it makes total sense to our
- 0:18modern sensibilities. Yeah, but then you step into the
- 0:21world of divine Providence, specifically when affliction is
- 0:24involved, and you realize that the machine does not work the
- 0:27way you thought it did. So welcome to Reform Thinking.
- 0:31This is our deep dive into a text that shatters that vending
- 0:35machine theology completely. It really does.
- 0:37It just completely dismantles it.
- 0:38We are looking at Genesis chapter 40 verses 20 through 23
- 0:42today and you probably already know the context.
- 0:44Joseph is sitting in an Egyptian prison.
- 0:47He just Florida State interpreted the dreams of two
- 0:50high-ranking royal officials, the chief cupbearer and the
- 0:54chief Baker. And his interpretations come to
- 0:56pass with terrifying precision. OK, he asked the cupbearer for a
- 1:00single favor to recall his innocence before Pharaoh, and
- 1:03the result of his perfect obedience is total, absolute
- 1:07silence. I mean he is forgotten.
- 1:10The silence following that flawless obedience is what makes
- 1:13this text so agonizing. We are looking at a universal
- 1:16human ache here. It is that feeling of being
- 1:19unseen and abandoned despite doing everything right.
- 1:23Oh man, yeah, that is a heavy feeling.
- 1:25It really is, and modern evangelicalism has a habit of
- 1:28offering, well, shallow platitudes for this specific
- 1:30pain. You will find endless lists of
- 1:32steps to achieve a better life or psychological coping
- 1:35mechanisms, or a prosperity driven guarantee that a
- 1:38breakthrough is just around the. But Genesis 40 offers none of
- 1:41that. No, not at all.
- 1:42It offers massive theological realities about Providence.
- 1:45It forces you to confront the tension between our earthly
- 1:48abandonment and the decrees of heaven, and it does it without
- 1:51giving you a quick escape hatch. I want to push on that tension
- 1:53for a second because we are not just talking about a minor
- 1:56inconvenience here. I mean, think about the
- 1:59corporate equivalent today. You get the specialized degree,
- 2:02you work weekends for years, you deliver the presentation.
- 2:04That saves your firm millions of dollars.
- 2:07You execute your role. Yeah, Florida State.
- 2:11And then you watch the promotion go to an external hire while the
- 2:14CEO forgets your name. That stings.
- 2:18But Joseph is not dealing with a missed promotion.
- 2:21No, he is dealing with a dungeon.
- 2:23Right. To understand the sheer
- 2:24devastation of this moment, we have to grasp the terrifying
- 2:28absolute authority of the Egyptian system holding him
- 2:31captive. We're not looking at a modern
- 2:33justice system with appeals and parole boards.
- 2:35Are we not even close? The setting here is the opulent,
- 2:39idolatrous court of Pharaoh, and it is juxtaposed against the
- 2:42miserable subterranean reality of the royal prison.
- 2:46Verse 20 mentions Pharaoh's birthday.
- 2:48Which is a big deal I assume. Oh, massive.
- 2:50In Hebrew, that is. Yom Holodit E Pero, in the
- 2:53ancient near east of Pharaoh's birthday was not just some
- 2:55private party with cake. It was a massive event of
- 2:58statecraft. Yeah, the Pharaoh was viewed as
- 3:01a divine being, a literal incarnation of the God Horus.
- 3:05So this birthday celebration was a moment of supreme religious
- 3:09and political magnitude. So he is flexing his authority.
- 3:12Precisely. The monarch would use this day
- 3:14to grant sweeping amnesties or to execute enemies.
- 3:18It was a calculated display of his absolute authority over life
- 3:21and death. The lives of his officials
- 3:23literally depended on his passing mood on that specific
- 3:26day. That is terrifying, and
- 3:28contracting that absolute terrifying authority is the
- 3:31absolute misery of where Joseph was sitting.
- 3:34The text uses the Hebrew word Sohar for the prison.
- 3:37Yes, Sohar. That we need to erase any mental
- 3:39image of a modern penitentiary. A Sohar indicates a Roundhouse
- 3:43fortress dungeon. It was a subterranean pit, a
- 3:45literal. Hole in the ground.
- 3:47Right Psalm One O 5, verse 18 gives us an inspired historical
- 3:50commentary on Joseph's specific condition.
- 3:53It says his feet were afflicted with fetters and he was late in
- 3:55irons. That is just brutal.
- 3:57It is. This was a place of disease,
- 3:59sensory deprivation and severe malnourishment.
- 4:02I mean you are in the dark, chained to a wall, waiting for a
- 4:05ruler who thinks he is a God to decide if you live or die.
- 4:09And we also have to recognize the status of his cellmates, the
- 4:12chief cupbearer, the Mashka, and the chief Baker, the OFA.
- 4:16These were high-ranking state officials.
- 4:18Like White House chief of staff level.
- 4:19Yeah, very much like that. The cup bearer was an intimate
- 4:23confidant who tasted the wine to prevent assassination by poison.
- 4:27He had unparalleled direct access to the most authoritative
- 4:31ruler on Earth. That political reality explains
- 4:34why Joseph placed his hope in this specific man.
- 4:37Joseph understood the political machinery of Egypt.
- 4:40He knew that a single whispered word from the mash guy into
- 4:43Pharaoh's ear could mean instant freedom.
- 4:45It was a very strategic, logical human hope.
- 4:48But against this terrifying backdrop of absolute human rule
- 4:50and political maneuvering, the text suddenly pulls back the
- 4:53curtain to reveal an even higher, unassailable authority.
- 4:58God is orchestrating these events down to the precise day.
- 5:01The timing is meticulous. It really is.
- 5:04Verse 20 gives us this temporal marker.
- 5:06It says on the third day that aligns Florida State with what
- 5:10Joseph prophesied. The grammar the author uses here
- 5:13is staggering. Really.
- 5:15In verses 2021 and 22, the text uses a brilliant Hebrew idiom.
- 5:20It is Yisa at Rosh, which translates to He lifted up the
- 5:24head. OK, I love this part.
- 5:26Tell us about that double meaning.
- 5:28It holds a terrifying double meeting in the ancient Near East
- 5:31to lift up the head of a servant meant to summon them from prison
- 5:35to stand trial or to be reviewed.
- 5:36Oh, because they are literally down in a hole, Yes.
- 5:39Exactly. You have to picture the physical
- 5:41reality of the Sohar. They were in a subterranean pit.
- 5:44They literally had to have their heads lifted up out of the
- 5:46ground to stand before the monarch.
- 5:48That makes so much sense. But the outcome was radically
- 5:50different for the two men. For the cut bearer, Farrell
- 5:53lifted up his head and restored him to his office.
- 5:55For the Baker, Farrell lifted up his head from off his body.
- 5:59He executed him by hanging. Wow, that linguistic double
- 6:03meaning is brilliant and chilling.
- 6:05The exact same royal action brings life to 1 and death to
- 6:09the other. It is a stark contrast.
- 6:11But this brings up a massive theological hurdle.
- 6:15If we are operating under Reformed theology, specifically
- 6:18the doctrines outlined in the Westminster Confession, we say
- 6:21that God from all eternity did, by the most wise and holy
- 6:25counsel of his own will, freely and unchangeably ordain
- 6:29whatsoever comes to pass. That is the core of it, yes.
- 6:33So God did not simply look down the corridors of time to see
- 6:36what Pharaoh would randomly decide to do on his birthday.
- 6:39God ordained the birthday, the feast, the mercy for the
- 6:42cupbearer and the wrath for the Baker, all to align Florida
- 6:45State with the words spoken by Joseph three days prior.
- 6:48He ordained all of it. But critics will argue that this
- 6:51turns God into a cosmic puppeteer manipulating a rigged
- 6:54game. How do we defend God's goodness
- 6:56here, especially when he's ordaining a man's execution just
- 6:59to match a prophecy? Well, the confession also states
- 7:02that God ordains these things in such a way that he is neither
- 7:04the author of sin nor is violence offered to the will of
- 7:07the creatures. OK, so the secondary causes
- 7:09matter. Oh, absolutely.
- 7:11The liberty or contingency of second causes is not taken away,
- 7:15but rather established. Pharaoh acted according to his
- 7:18own tyrannical human will. The Baker suffered for his own
- 7:22real offenses against the Crown. So they are acting out their own
- 7:25desires. Yes, God uses the natural
- 7:28actions, the political systems, and the free agency of humans as
- 7:31secondary causes to accomplish His primary decree.
- 7:35That is a crucial distinction it.
- 7:36Is modern liberal theology constantly tries to edit God by
- 7:40separating his kindness from his wrath?
- 7:43They want a deity who restores the cupbearer.
- 7:45That has nothing to do with the hanging of the Baker.
- 7:47They want a safe, sanitized version of God.
- 7:49Right, but the text will not allow for a sentimentalized God.
- 7:53The Word of God is judicial, It gives life according to mercy,
- 7:57and it announces death according to judgement.
- 7:59That is heavy. The restored cupbearer and the
- 8:01condemned Baker should awaken reverence before the God whose
- 8:04word never fails. I totally agree.
- 8:07So the narrative moves at breakneck speed through this
- 8:09flawless execution of divine decrees.
- 8:13Prophecy is given, the third day arrives, the feast happens.
- 8:16The head is lifted, 1 is restored, 1 is hanged.
- 8:19The. Machinery is working perfectly.
- 8:20Right. The machinery is working, but
- 8:22then the narrative hits a devastating brick wall.
- 8:26The focus shifts from divine action back to human action, and
- 8:29verse 23 is just crushing. What does it say?
- 8:31It says yet the chief cupbearer did not remember Joseph, but
- 8:35forgot him. The syntax shifts dramatically
- 8:37there. The author moves from the
- 8:39heights of a royal banquet to the devastating silence of an
- 8:42unchanged reality in the dungeon.
- 8:43It is such a stark drop off. It really is.
- 8:46The Hebrew grammar uses a striking redundancy to make its
- 8:50point. It pairs a negative assertion lo
- 8:52Zucker, which means did not remember with a consecutive
- 8:57imperfect verb weish kachehu meaning and he forgot.
- 9:01Him so it is saying the same thing twice.
- 9:03Yes, for emphasis, the verb shakok means to obliterate from
- 9:07memory to willfully neglect. When the Septuagint translates
- 9:11this, it uses the word epilantheno.
- 9:13OK. Does that show up anywhere else?
- 9:14Actually, it does. This is the same word used later
- 9:17in the New Testament in James chapter 1 to describe someone
- 9:20who looks in a mirror, walks away and immediately forgets
- 9:23what they look like. Oh wow, so it is a total blank.
- 9:26It is an absolute erasure from the mind.
- 9:29But the sources make a theological claim here that it's
- 9:32kind of hard to swallow for some people.
- 9:35They argue that this forgetting was not a tragic accident.
- 9:38It was not a slip of the mind because the cupbearer was
- 9:41distracted by the opulent banquet.
- 9:43No, it was much more purposeful than that.
- 9:45They argue God close the womb of the cupbearer's memory.
- 9:49This forces us right back into the tension we just discussed.
- 9:52If God causes the cup bearer to forget, which is a sinful
- 9:56neglect of a man who saved his life, how is God not the author
- 9:59of that sin? It goes back to how God works
- 10:02with secondary causes. God does not inject evil or
- 10:05forgetfulness into the cup bearer.
- 10:06He simply removes his restraining grace, allowing the
- 10:10cup bearers natural self absorbed human inclination to
- 10:13take over. Ah, so the cup bearer just does
- 10:15what selfish humans do. Precisely.
- 10:18The cup bearer naturally wants to forget the trauma of the
- 10:20dungeon. He wants to forget the squalor,
- 10:23the fear, and anyone associated with it.
- 10:26By leaving the cupbearer to his own selfish devices, God ensures
- 10:30the man forgets. That makes total sense.
- 10:32If the cupbearer had remembered instantly, Joseph's release
- 10:36would have been credited to human networking, would have
- 10:38been seen as clever political maneuvering.
- 10:40Oh, Joseph would have owed his freedom to a Pagan official,
- 10:43yes. God actively orchestrated the
- 10:46circumstances so that Joseph would remain in the dungeon
- 10:49until the exact predestined moment of Pharaohs dreams 2 full
- 10:54years later. Two full years.
- 10:56Think about the psychological toll of that reality.
- 10:58It is unimaginable. I try to picture it like
- 11:00surviving A horrific shipwreck with a wealthy magnate.
- 11:04You were both clinging to a piece of debris in the freezing
- 11:06ocean. You keep each other awake, you
- 11:08share your last rations, and he promises you a lucrative
- 11:11position at his company if you both make it out alive.
- 11:14A. Literal life or death bond.
- 11:16Right. And then a rescue boat pulls him
- 11:18from the water, but they miss you in the dark.
- 11:21Days later, you managed to wash ashore.
- 11:24You find out he is back at his Country Club giving interviews
- 11:27about his survival. And when you reach out, he
- 11:29pretends he has no idea who you are.
- 11:31That is a brutal analogy, but spot on.
- 11:34Consider the sheer agony of those two extra years in irons
- 11:38in the Sohar, knowing the guy whose life you saved with your
- 11:42interpretation is sipping wine in the palace of the king.
- 11:45It had to be agonizing for him. The memory of Joseph was
- 11:49entirely erased from the cupbearer's mind.
- 11:51It was not a race from God's mind.
- 11:54The text strips away all human means of deliverance.
- 11:57The author eliminates the arm of flesh.
- 11:59Which was a massive lesson for the people reading this.
- 12:01Oh, absolutely. We have to look at the people
- 12:03this account was originally written for to grasp the weight
- 12:05of this lesson. The original audience was the
- 12:07Israelites gathered on the plains of Moab under the
- 12:10leadership of Moses. So they are about to enter the
- 12:12promised land. Right.
- 12:14They were poised to enter, but they had recently been liberated
- 12:17from the very nation where this story took place.
- 12:20They knew the terror of Pharaoh intimately.
- 12:23They knew the bitterness of Egyptian bondage.
- 12:26They also had a severe corporate addiction, didn't they?
- 12:28They did. They constantly wanted to return
- 12:30to Egypt. Every time they faced a
- 12:32challenge in the wilderness, they complained to Moses.
- 12:35They wanted the leeks and the onions.
- 12:36Yeah, they wanted to make alliances with the surrounding
- 12:39nations. They relied on the arm of flesh
- 12:41and Pagan treaties rather than trusting Yahweh in the desert.
- 12:45So Moses used this account of Joseph to strip away their
- 12:49idolatrous leanings toward political pragmatism.
- 12:52Moses demonstrated that divine delays are not divine denials.
- 12:56That is a great way to put it. If the chief cup bearer whose
- 12:59life Joseph saved could forget him the second he experienced
- 13:02prosperity, how could Israel ever trust the treaties and
- 13:06promises of Pagan nations? They couldn't.
- 13:09Exactly. Moses intended to correct their
- 13:11reliance on human institutions. Now, this is not a prohibition
- 13:15against lawful means. Right, because Joseph did ask
- 13:18for help. Yes, Joseph did not sin when he
- 13:21asked the cup bearer for help. Using lawful means to improve
- 13:24your situation is fine. The warning is against placing
- 13:27your ultimate confidence in mortal patrons.
- 13:30Putting all your eggs in the human basket, right?
- 13:33The passage aims to produce a corporate covenantal patience
- 13:37within the nation. They were to understand that
- 13:39their current hardships in the wilderness were analogous to
- 13:42Joseph's time in the dungeon. It was a necessary period of
- 13:44preparation. Yes, divinely orchestrated
- 13:47before the realization of the promise.
- 13:49The ancient Israelites tendency to trust political alliances
- 13:53over divine Providence is the exact same struggle you face
- 13:57today as a listener. It never really changes, does
- 13:59it? No, it doesn't.
- 14:00The application of this passage lands heavily on the modern
- 14:03listener because we are constantly bombarded by
- 14:05ideologies that preach the exact opposite of Genesis 40.
- 14:08Oh, without a doubt. I mean, look at the prosperity
- 14:10gospel. It teaches that having enough
- 14:13faith guarantees an unbroken ascent of immediate, tangible
- 14:17earthly blessings. It preaches a theology of glory
- 14:21without a theology of the cross. It is a very dangerous message.
- 14:24It is. They tell you that if you claim
- 14:26it, the dungeon doors will fly open.
- 14:28But Joseph possessed extraordinary faith.
- 14:31He was Florida State faithful in his obedience.
- 14:34He gave God the glory. And what did that get him?
- 14:37His flawless faithfulness earned him two more years in a pitch
- 14:41black dungeon. That is the hard truth people do
- 14:43not want to hear. God matures His people through
- 14:46deferred hope. This is the doctrine of
- 14:48sanctification through suffering.
- 14:50It is so countercultural. It really is.
- 14:53The world tells you to build your brand, network with the
- 14:55right people, and make yourself unforgettable.
- 14:58Scripture tells you to submit to the God who remembers His
- 15:01covenant. Wow.
- 15:02Build your brand versus submit to God.
- 15:04Yes, God mortifies our reliance on human institutions by making
- 15:08us wait. It is fascinating how the source
- 15:11material applies this ancient text to modern times.
- 15:14They draw a sharp critique against relying on earthly
- 15:17utopias. We see that everywhere right
- 15:19now. Regardless of where you, the
- 15:21listener, sit on the political spectrum, the underlying
- 15:24argument here is that relying on any human political system is a
- 15:27repeat of Israel's mistake. Our hope is never political
- 15:31reform in the current systems, but the sovereign deliverance of
- 15:34Yahweh. The Church age is much like
- 15:36Joseph's time in the dungeon. We are a heavenly people living
- 15:40in the Kingdom of men, waiting for the true King to return and
- 15:43exalt us. While the world just keeps
- 15:45partying, right? The world, much like the
- 15:47cupbearer, goes about his feasts and his politics, entirely
- 15:51forgetting the Church and the promises of God.
- 15:53Joseph did not start a prison riot to overthrow the Egyptian
- 15:56system. He.
- 15:57Submitted to the Providence of God while waiting for
- 15:59deliverance, Yeah. But I have to say, it is easy to
- 16:03sit here and say that we should submit to Providence.
- 16:06But what do you do when the pain is daily?
- 16:08What do you do when the silence from heaven feels suffocating?
- 16:11That is the $1,000,000 question. Because Christianity is not
- 16:15Stoicism. We don't just pretend it doesn't
- 16:17hurt. The text allows us to name the
- 16:19wound. Lament is appropriate.
- 16:21Lament is a thoroughly biblical response.
- 16:23We can acknowledge the closed door.
- 16:26We can feel the sting of the cupbearer's amnesia.
- 16:29But we must view the closed door as a comma, not a period.
- 16:33A comma, not a period. I like that.
- 16:34We cannot conclude that truth has failed or that service has
- 16:38been wasted just because our current sentence is unresolved.
- 16:41The passage trains the covenant people to wait, to trust and to
- 16:45interpret their lives not by the last sentence they have
- 16:47experienced, but by the Lord who is writing the whole story.
- 16:50That is so good, and Joseph's righteous suffering and the
- 16:54total crushing failure of his human mediator inevitably pushes
- 16:58us to look for a flawless mediator.
- 17:00We need someone who never suffers from amnesia.
- 17:02We absolutely do, and the redemptive historical lines from
- 17:05Genesis 40 trace straight to the cross of Christ.
- 17:09Let's dig into that because it is amazing.
- 17:11It is. Joseph is unequivocally one of
- 17:13the most vivid, detailed, and divinely ordained types of the
- 17:17Lord Jesus Christ in all of Scripture.
- 17:19Look at the Christological parallels.
- 17:21They are everywhere. Joseph is the righteous,
- 17:24innocent sufferer. He was sent by his father,
- 17:26rejected by his brothers, stripped of his garments,
- 17:29falsely accused and placed in a pit of condemnation, flanked by
- 17:33two criminals. It is a striking portrait of
- 17:35Calvary. I mean, you have Jesus, the
- 17:37sinless Son of God, stripped of his garments and nailed to a
- 17:41cross between two thieves. Look at the outcomes to Joseph
- 17:44stands between the cupbearer and the Baker to 1.
- 17:47He delivers a message of life and restoration to the other, a
- 17:51message of impending judgment. It perfectly mirrors the
- 17:54crucifixion. It really does.
- 17:56On the cross, Christ is between two criminals.
- 17:59To the repentant thief he gives a message of life.
- 18:01He says, today you will be with me in paradise.
- 18:04To the unrepentant thief, there is only the silence of impending
- 18:07judgment. The parallels are exact, but we
- 18:10also see a contrast that highlights the superiority of
- 18:13Christ. Joseph begged the cupbearer to
- 18:15remember him, and the cupbearer failed.
- 18:18He forgot. He totally blanked.
- 18:19Yeah, but on the cross, when the dying thief cried out, Jesus,
- 18:22Remember Me when you come into your Kingdom, Christ did not
- 18:25forget. He never forgets.
- 18:26That is the beauty of Christ as our great High Priest.
- 18:30It really is. The cupbearer ascended to the
- 18:32comfortable palace of Pharaoh, and completely forgot the man
- 18:35suffering in the dungeon. Christ suffered in the dungeon
- 18:39of God's wrath, and then he ascended to the right hand of
- 18:41the majesty on high, and he perpetually remembers his
- 18:45covenant people. Human mediators fail you the
- 18:48second their own circumstances improve.
- 18:51The exalted Christ never forgets those who belong to Him.
- 18:55He has inscribed us on the palms of His hand.
- 18:57That is such a comfort. We also see a connection in the
- 19:00temporal marker in Genesis 40. The third day brings vindication
- 19:04of God spoken word through Joseph.
- 19:06The third day is when the destinies of life and death
- 19:08diverge. The third day is everywhere in
- 19:10Scripture, right? In the Gospels, the third day
- 19:12brings the ultimate vindication of the Word made flesh bursting
- 19:15from the tomb. Joseph's third day is a shadow.
- 19:18Christ's third day is the blazing reality that secures our
- 19:22eternal deliverance from the dungeon of sin and death.
- 19:24Amen to that. So, having seen the flawless
- 19:27memory of Christ compared to the failing, fragile memory of man,
- 19:31we bring our discussion to a close.
- 19:34If you are listening to this and you are building your hope on
- 19:37the arm of flesh, you need to hear this clearly.
- 19:40Pay attention to this part. The arm of flesh will always
- 19:43fail you. If you build your hope for
- 19:44deliverance or peace on the fragile memories or the
- 19:47political cloud of mortal men, it will collapse under the
- 19:50weight of reality. It is just a matter of time.
- 19:52The cupbearer forgot. Your friends may forget.
- 19:55The systems of this world will crumble.
- 19:57But the Ancient of Days never forgets his covenant.
- 20:01If you are in a season of suffering, you're waiting is not
- 20:04a cosmic accident. It is the meticulous decree of a
- 20:07loving Father who is preparing you for glory.
- 20:10He is mortifying your reliance on the world so that you will
- 20:13lean entirely on Him. That is the whole point of the
- 20:16dungeon. Exactly.
- 20:17I want to leave you with one final thought to Mull over.
- 20:20Consider the cupbearer shock. 2 full years later.
- 20:23Pharaoh has a terrifying dream. All the wise men of Egypt fail.
- 20:27Nobody can figure it out. Right.
- 20:29And suddenly the memory of Joseph hits the cup barrel like
- 20:32a physical blow. Genesis 41 tells us.
- 20:34He says. I remember my offenses today.
- 20:38How often does God use our season of being forgotten to
- 20:41perfectly position us for a moment of deliverance that we
- 20:44never could have orchestrated ourselves?
- 20:46Think about it. If Joseph had been released
- 20:48early, he would have just been a free Hebrew slave wandering
- 20:51Egypt. Because he was forgotten, he was
- 20:54in the exact position to be pulled from the dungeon to save
- 20:57the known world. God's timing is rarely our
- 21:00timing, but it is always flawless.
- 21:02It really is. We started by talking about that
- 21:04broken vending machine, the frustration of doing the right
- 21:07thing and getting silence in return.
- 21:09Genesis 40 shows us that the machine isn't broken, it's just
- 21:12not a vending machine at all. It is something so much bigger.
- 21:15It is the sovereign, unassailable decree of a God who
- 21:19works all things for His glory and your good.
- 21:22Even when the dungeon is dark and the cup bearer has lost his
- 21:25memory, rest in the hands of the God who writes the end from the
- 21:28beginning. Thank you for joining us on this
- 21:30deep dive into Genesis 40.