Latest / FWDstart / Nafez Dakkak (Anara Capital) on Why AI Tutors Will Fail, Is MENA EdTech's "Sleeping Giant" & Solving the Arabic Literacy Crisis
Transcript
- Episode 5 - Nafez Dakkak on EdTech, Arabic Learning, and Impact Investing === [00:00:00] Nafez: The problem with education is everybody trying to fix it already has an education. I generally don't think AI tutors will work. There's something about having another human care about you that makes you kind of want to invest and sort of do more. If you see kids play games, they will spend hours repeating the same level, same boss, basically masochistic, and if you offer them an easy way out, they don't want it. [00:00:18] Nafez: What we're missing in education is that GPS moment—the idea that I just opened the app and it already knows where I am. How do you get to a point where the AI tutor already knows where you are? Gamification is overrated. It's like chocolate-covered broccoli. Your education is all you have. Anything can be taken away, but kind of what's in your head—that you can sort of carry across borders. [00:00:42] Jamie: I am delighted to say that my guest today is Nafez Dakkak. Nafez is the managing partner of Anara Impact Capital, a new $50 million fund investing in impact-driven sectors across the region, including education, climate, and health tech—you get the drill. Before founding Anara, Nafez helped lead Edraak, the online learning platform established by the Queen Rania Foundation, where he played a central role in scaling it into one of the most widely used Arabic education platforms. [00:01:03] Jamie: He then went on to co-found Builder, a venture studio based in Oman that launched startups focused on the future of work and talent. In this conversation, we take the opportunity to dig into a number of perspectives that Nafez has shared over the years. We talk about the current state of EdTech in MENA and why the sector maybe hasn't taken off to the extent that many expected in 2021. [00:01:21] Jamie: We look at whether AI will be a net positive or a negative for learning and for the education ecosystem broadly, and we get into the idea of "vibe learning" and what exactly that means in practice. And we also touch on impact investing too, which often gets a bad rap. So we maybe look at the structural issues shaping the sector and what a more rigorous approach could potentially look like. [00:01:40] Jamie: Nafez has been a friend and supporter of Forward Start and myself since day one, so this was a very long overdue conversation. I enormously enjoyed recording and chatting to him as always, and I hope that you equally enjoy listening to it. But before we get into it, Warren Buffett once said, "The stock market is designed to transfer money from the active to the patient." [00:01:59] Jamie: And Lebanese-American mathematician Nassim Nicholas Taleb reminded us that you cannot predict, you can only get ready. Those two insights define today's investing environment. You don't win by guessing the next move—you win by preparing, cutting through the noise, and letting discipline compound over time. [00:02:14] Jamie: That's exactly what Sarwa delivers. Sarwa's modern platform is grounded in simplicity and lets you trade stocks, ETFs, crypto, options, and high-yield savings—all in one app. They keep your fees low, so more of your money goes to work, with minimums as low as $500. Sarwa is loved by experts, not just beginners. [00:02:29] Jamie: Whether you're a first-timer, an active investor, or a day trader, you'll join hundreds of thousands of users who choose Sarwa to grow their wealth. As a Forward Start listener, you get $200 when you open a new account with code "ForwardStart." All the details are in the description, and if you're chatting to the team, please do tell them that JB sent you. [00:02:44] Jamie: So what are you waiting for? Get started in minutes and take control of your money your way. Sarwa is regulated by the ADGM Financial Services Regulatory Authority. The information shared in this segment is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investing involves risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results. [00:03:01] Jamie: Nafez, very welcome to the podcast. Thank you so much. [00:03:05] Nafez: Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. [00:03:05] Jamie: Okay, so can we go back to 2021? If that's okay. [00:03:08] Nafez: Yeah, yeah. [00:03:10] Jamie: You published—and this is actually how I first discovered you— [00:03:13] Nafez: Oh, okay. [00:03:14] Jamie: It was actually via your Substack, "Nafez Notes," which we'll link in the description so people can check that out and you get an influx of subscribers, I'm sure. But it was the piece you did on "MENA's EdTech Sleeping Giant," which I found incredibly influential because I'd started seeking out pieces on the EdTech space in the region, and there wasn't a whole pile there. And I came across you and I was like, "Oh, amazing." And I went through your entire back catalog and I was like, "This guy knows his shit. This is great." [00:03:36] Nafez: I appreciate it. Thank you. [00:03:38] Jamie: But one of the comparisons that you made—I'm not sure if it was in that piece or a previous piece—but you sort of said that the path of educational progress is more like the path of a butterfly than a bullet. Where is the butterfly at the moment? Has the butterfly landed? Is the butterfly dead? Where are we, as far as that thesis is concerned? [00:04:04] Nafez: Yeah, yeah. Oh, that's a great question. I don't know if I mentioned that in that piece or a different piece, but that's certainly something to look at and think about. Maybe clearly—and I think there are sort of two parts to this equation. One is the butterfly path is certainly how I describe things around, you know, very pedagogy-centric, very learning-centric. It's not always going to be very quick, very zero-to-one. And in some cases, you know, it might just not lend itself very easily to kind of a venture funding model. And I'm sure we'll sort of get to that. [00:04:28] Nafez: Some of the stuff that's maybe auxiliary, you know, like finding substitute teachers or like some kind of operational or automated—some of the stuff around learning could certainly, you know, follow the path of a bullet. I mean, when we did the "Sleeping Giant" piece, I did it with Mueed at GSV, and I think this was like right before or right after their investment in Abwaab, which was probably like one of the first kind of US VCs investing in a Jordanian—in a regional EdTech. [00:04:59] Nafez: And we were sort of just very amazed that like, you know, there's a lot of high spend on education in MENA, some of the highest literacy rates in the world—and again, that's not always accurate, but just generally speaking, I'd say kind of a high reverence for education. But that sort of just wasn't translating into kind of MENA's own EdTech unicorn. And we talked about, you know, three barriers at the time. We talked about, I think, the market fragmentation. We talked about digital payments. And we talked about exits. [00:05:17] Nafez: I don't know if anything has landed. I think digital payments—it does seem that's kind of like really not an issue anymore. I think a lot of people have sort of figured that out, thanks to people outside EdTech, not necessarily just in EdTech. Exits—I mean, you've been covering it at Forward Start, and obviously, you know, we've obviously had Edraak's exit, we've now had Noon's, I guess, exit. And we've had a few more as well. So I do think, finally, the EdTech exits are starting to happen—at what multiple, at what valuation, I think that's kind of something for somebody else to dig into. [00:05:53] Nafez: The part that's probably still there is the fragmentation. And there's sort of two parts to this. I think for pre-K or sort of outside of K-12, that's probably less relevant. So if you're doing a product targeted at kids outside of school, I mean, there you still have to factor in dialect. You need to think about a lot of that. But generally, sort of literacy, numeracy content, like Montessori content, whatever—it's not as... you wouldn't worry as much about the fragmentation. And post-K-12, that's also like, when it's very skills-based education, I think you still need to worry less about that. [00:06:27] Nafez: When you think about K-12, it is a bit fragmented. But if you're building a product in the US for K-12, you still have to think about going from state to state. If you're building something in the UK, you still have to think about, you know, different schools and what they're doing. And ironically, I would say in MENA, in K-12, in public schools, it's very centralized decision-making, which is a double-edged sword—it just means your sales cycle is so much longer. But it does mean if you are in a geography where there is a budget, once you get kind of that top approval, it's very kind of top-down. It's very quick and it makes it, I'd say, somewhat easier. That's kind of a long-winded answer to say I don't know if it's landed, but I do think we're on the right trajectory. [00:07:06] Jamie: What do you think the impediment to progress has been? Because I feel like 2021—we had kind of heady days where we saw these relatively large funding rounds for the likes of Abwaab, for Noon. And not to say that it seems sort of stuck in stasis or in amber, but it certainly seems that it hasn't maybe kicked on to the extent that we thought it would have. Is that the fragmentation or is it something else? [00:07:27] Nafez: I mean, I think that's a great observation. To be fair, it's probably a macro globally, right? Like I think 2021 really pulled a lot of behavior forward in terms of people just being sort of more comfortable with the idea of doing stuff online, learning online, et cetera. Post-pandemic, there's been maybe a bit of a backlash against that in working and in school, right? Like a lot of people asking now—do people actually go to the office or not as much? Sort of working from home. [00:07:53] Nafez: So I will say it's kind of a global trend. I think one of the things—and again, this is kind of just taking a step back, irrespective of the pandemic or otherwise—is when we think of scaling in EdTech, we only think of sort of computer engineering scaling. The idea is that, you know, I'm going to build it once, ship the widget, and kind of just—very kind of vanilla SaaS kind of template, exponentially just going to scale. [00:08:18] Nafez: When it comes to education—and again, I'm plagiarizing a bunch of people here, probably Bror Saxberg, who I kind of interviewed for the Substack—there's another kind of engineering, which is like civil engineering. We know how to build a bridge, but you don't copy a bridge from Dubai and just take it to Abu Dhabi and just expect it to work. You take the science of how do you build a bridge and then you customize for that local context. [00:08:37] Nafez: And I think that's what's still missing to a certain extent to kind of really make EdTech, you know, scale much faster, much quicker. And what the problem is—I'm not saying there's a silver bullet to any of this, of course—but in a very interesting way, leveraging kind of large language models, AI in general, at that sort of UI/UX stage, at kind of that last mile of delivery, probably allows you to contextualize more than you ever could before. [00:09:09] Nafez: Having said that, there's obviously a lot of issues in using large language models for learning, for education. They're not trained on good data. I mean, people that are kind of a lot more intelligent and sort of, I'd say, technical than me have kind of marveled at the fact that large language models work given the underlying dataset. [00:09:29] Nafez: I think there was a—Andre Karpathy, if I'm pronouncing his name right—he had an interview maybe like two or three weeks ago on the Lex Fridman podcast where he says something like, "People think, oh, this is being trained on Financial Times, Wall Street Journal, The National, whatever." It's actually trained on like Reddit threads. And he's like, "I have no idea how this works because I don't know if we can—like the input is crap. How is the output...?" [00:09:49] Nafez: So I mean, I will say that the challenge is obviously using LLMs for that last kind of mile delivery in education for contextualization is you just don't have enough or as much good or well-instructionally-designed content in the training dataset. So you end up kind of probably delivering not great stuff. But there is potential, I'd say, to get there. [00:10:15] Jamie: Is that problem exacerbated then when it comes to Arabic in particular? [00:10:19] Nafez: Oh, for sure. I mean, again, I'm not an AI expert by any means, and I'm sure you'll talk to people a lot more kind of knowledgeable than I am. But I mean, in general, like that's the problem with the internet. That's the problem with large language models. I mean, I don't know, like people keep saying like, "Oh, we're at AGI, it's so close," and then I use any of these models in Arabic—I'm like, "Okay, we're a million years away." This thing has no idea. It's really sort of an autocomplete. [00:10:44] Jamie: Can we go back then, actually, because I'm led to believe—did you want to be a neurosurgeon? [00:10:48] Nafez: Yeah, yeah, yeah. [00:10:48] Jamie: Where does that come from? [00:10:50] Nafez: I think I've kind of always been fascinated by the human body, the human brain. [00:10:59] Jamie: It's hyper-specific though, in terms of—so for context, even coming out of school, I wanted to be a doctor as well, funnily enough. So I wanted to study medicine. I had no idea in terms of specialism. I wasn't like, "I wanted to do X, Y, and Z." But you were steadfast, and you were like, "This is what I want to do." [00:11:13] Nafez: I mean, again, I was like 17, 18, so I don't know if I knew what I wanted to do the same way any 17-year-old knows what they want to do. But yeah, I mean, the idea, I'd say the vision was go to med school—and that's like, I'm Lebanese, right? Like if you do well in school, the three options are doctor, engineer, lawyer. [00:11:24] Nafez: Same in Ireland. So it was like, okay, I'm going to be a doctor. And I was like, okay, I'm going to be a neurosurgeon. But I had no idea kind of what that meant or sort of what that entailed. But I think very quickly, kind of when I got to university, when I started thinking about kind of the change I wanted to make, I kind of realized like—if I do become a neurosurgeon, one, it's a very long path. And you're kind of waiting a very long time. Again, it's an incredibly noble profession, of course. I'm not kind of debating that. But I was, I'd say, a lot more—a lot less patient or more impatient to kind of just start getting stuff done, start building, start working. [00:11:49] Nafez: And I also wanted to make sure that I would want to have kind of a societal impact. And that's when I was like, okay, instead of kind of performing surgery on kind of one brain at a time, what could you do that kind of affects many brains at the same time? And that's kind of what led, I guess, to thinking more about education. [00:12:06] Nafez: Lulwa Al-Khater, who's, I guess, a Saudi kind of celebrity influencer, philanthropist—she was a World Fellow at Yale at the time, and she gave me this book called, I think it was at the Dubai School of Government at the time, called "Generation in Waiting." And it just talked about kind of this unemployed—this number of unemployed youth, the youth bulge. Like, how do you make sure that's kind of a youth dividend? And the solution to all of these problems was education. [00:12:27] Nafez: I think naively at the time I was like, "Okay, education is going to solve all our problems." I quickly realized that's not the case. But yeah, that's how I kind of went from neurosurgeon to kind of education policy strategy. [00:12:55] Jamie: And having, I suppose, worked in the—having the societal impact or that broader sort of impact over the course of the last many years—do you ever think you missed a sort of, I don't know, tangible clarity that would come from, you know, working on one individual person? [00:13:11] Nafez: For sure. But I would say, I mean, kind of the complaint I always say to my wife is, I was kind of—not that I'd had any potential, but I was kind of an athlete. Because I feel like in sports, the scoreboard is very clear. Like, you know, did you win today? Did you lose today? You can tell—did the team win because I played well, or did they win in spite of me playing well? Like it's very, very clear kind of in sports. [00:13:18] Nafez: So I mean, I do feel like there are times when I look at any athlete—that doesn't have to mean, obviously, football is what you and I sometimes talk about—but any sport, just very clear, the results are there. Everybody can see the scoreboard. It's a lot less clear in sort of other areas of life. A lot less clear in venture, right? Like you're talking a 10-year cycle before you get any kind of... but you know you're good. [00:13:56] Jamie: It's a pretty long feedback loop. Can I ask as well, in terms of growing up Palestinian—has that shaped how you maybe view social inequity? [00:14:03] Nafez: Oh, for sure. For sure. I mean, I'd say growing up Palestinian, growing up in Palestine, growing up under occupation, right—like the one kind of message that's just always kind of, I'd say, hammered really into you is: your education is all you have. Like, anything can be taken away. Any kind of material possession can be taken away. You can take nothing for granted. But kind of what's in your head, that you can sort of carry across borders, you can sort of take with you anywhere. [00:14:31] Nafez: What's the one thing that kind of stuck with you from growing up there? Just like how hungry people were to learn, how difficult it was to get to kind of school. I mean, I guess I came of age during the Second Intifada, so 2001, 2002, before kind of early 2003, maybe moving to Dubai. And like, we would be crossing checkpoints, like going through all that to kind of make it to school. Like, you'd have classmates that were potentially—I don't know if this is the right venue for the podcast, but like you'd have classmates getting shot on the way to school. And that kind of just leaves you with—you don't take any of that for granted. [00:14:50] Nafez: And that's kind of like what I worry about with my own daughter, right? Like, how do I make sure if she's growing up in London that she has that kind of hunger or that kind of appreciation for—let's not take any of that for granted? Because I mean, transitioning, coming here to kind of the UAE in 2003, that was probably the culture shock. Like, you see the same Palestinian kids that kind of grew up here—like, just take it all for granted, right? Like, it has nothing to do with kind of where you're from. It has to kind of—like how soft the environment around you is and kind of what that pushes you to do. [00:15:29] Jamie: Okay. So maybe go back to EdTech for a second. And we look at, I guess, maybe the evolution—and maybe we can think about it in three phases, arguably, where we've had maybe EdTech 1.0, which is access—and definitely going to speak to you about Edraak as it pertains to that. Maybe 2.0 is sort of the process, maybe the SaaS kind of things. And now supposedly we're in the outcomes and AI. So maybe we could categorize that as 3.0. Can you talk to me a small bit about Edraak? Because I'm super curious about maybe just initially what the thesis was and then how you actually approached building that as well. [00:16:00] Nafez: Yeah, I mean, again, I'd say very naively, it's kind of the whole thing, right? Like if you knew how hard something was, you probably wouldn't do it. [00:16:07] Jamie: The Jensen Huang video. [00:16:10] Nafez: I mean, I don't know if it's as impactful a video. No, look, don't, don't, don't—no, not at all. I said it, not you. It's okay. Maybe one day. I don't want the headline to be—it's clipped now. I'd say, yeah, just—I'll say like, given how hard it was, I'm not saying it wasn't worth it, but it's kind of, of course, just building that from scratch. [00:16:17] Nafez: I think the idea was kind of—this was right as this whole idea of massive open online courses were sort of coming out. In Jordan, like Her Majesty, the Queen Rania Foundation board were sort of very keen on, you know, how do you make this kind of revolution—and this is the problem with education, like talk about revolutions—make sure that the region doesn't miss out on that. [00:16:44] Nafez: And you know, there's something I've been also thinking about. I was kind of moonlighting for Wamda as an EdTech journalist at the time, and I still remember—I'm forgetting what the platform was called—but it was something kind of inspired by kind of the first university in Tunis. And this guy was pre-MOOCs, and he was doing kind of like just virtual live sessions, kind of like an online night school. And he was telling me—he's like, "The number of specifically women under 40 that are signing up for these courses just across the region." He's like, "I barely spent anything on marketing." And I just felt like something was there. [00:17:25] Nafez: So combining, I'd say, that kind of experience I'd kind of like prototyped in my head. But then, you know, with the willingness of Queen Rania Foundation to really take this to the next level, we were lucky in the sense that Open edX had open-sourced their codebase. So we sort of jumped on that. Worked with two brilliant people that I think without whom this wouldn't have happened: Mohammed Zuhair and Hamad Abu Ghazaleh. Both were kind of doing very, very different things at the time, but they helped us kind of prototype that first version of Edraak. [00:17:44] Nafez: And I think the rest is history, right? Like we learned a lot, some stuff worked, some stuff didn't. I mean, today, Edraak's done probably over 10 million learners. That's kind of, I'd say, probably millions of learners annually. I'm not involved kind of day-to-day anymore, to be honest. But from an access perspective, that's certainly, I think, it's kind of really been a game-changer in terms of getting high-quality higher education content. [00:18:02] Nafez: And I saw incredible kind of stories come to mind like two—just very quickly. I mean, one, I will say, I mean, when we first kind of localized the Open edX codebase, I just will never forget this—when we first called the guys at MIT, like we had like a Zoom call, actually we didn't—like, we picked up the phone and called them, and we said, "You know, we're going to try to localize this. We think we have an instance up on a local server or we can get one soon." They're like, "No, no, no, guys. Like, there's no documentation. This is Python. Like, Python—oh my god. Don't hurt yourselves, basically." [00:18:42] Nafez: And then obviously Zuhair and Hamad kind of sat down, and I'd say like within a week or two weeks maybe, they had an instance up and running. And when we told the guys at MIT, they were like, "There's no way this is true." And then I remember when we flew to MIT to kind of sign with edX to translate some of their courses, they kind of wanted to sit down with Zuhair and Hamad to understand like, "How did you guys set this up on a local instance?" Right? Unicode support, right-to-left. And they sent like some junior engineer. [00:18:58] Nafez: And at some point, like I'm sitting there, and the guy's like, "Guys, can you just hold on for a second?" Goes, comes back with what seems like the entire engineering team. And then suddenly these two guys from Jordan are sitting on the board at MIT, right? Like, clearly—it was way too technical for me—but clearly they were just wrapped up, like enamored with everything Zuhair and Hamad were saying. [00:19:19] Nafez: The other kind of story that always sticks with me is—we're sitting in the office on like a random Tuesday, and somebody walks in to the team and says, "Nafez, this woman has flown in from Saudi with her Edraak certificate and wants us to certify it." I thought she wants us to what? "Wait, did you say she flew in from Saudi?" He's like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah. She flew in from Jeddah for the day." Because she took a course on Edraak and she wanted it to account for something, for some credit to get work. But they told her she needs to get it certified, and customer service obviously told her, "We just don't certify." [00:20:01] Nafez: So she came to Amman, somehow found our offices. And they're like, "What do we do?" I'm like, "I don't know, man. Like, she's here. Just stamp it for her." And we—but I mean, I went and I spoke to her. I was like, just to understand—I think she did like an interior design course or one of the courses we had. And again, clearly did well, kind of had a high grade. But I thought, just to be clear, like this is not accredited. She said, "No, no, no. I know. I just need you to stamp it." We stamped it, and apparently she just headed back to the airport and went back to Saudi. And that's when I felt like, okay, no, there's something here that's kind of working if somebody's getting on a plane. [00:20:52] Jamie: If you were building Edraak again from scratch today, what do you think the core difference in product experience would be? [00:21:00] Nafez: That's a great question. I think the first one that we learned kind of the first year on is—initially a lot of people had this idea that we want to translate the best content from the world and bring it to the region. That didn't work. Like, there were some early signs. So what we would do is, right, we'd bring a course, we'd translate it, we'd then hire professors locally to kind of, I'd say, audit the course, make some changes, just kind of make sure everything makes sense. [00:21:13] Nafez: And one of these—we were translating, I think, a physics course, and the professor was like, "Oh, is this meant for like an 18-month course, like multiple semesters?" "No, no, this is a one-semester course." He's like, "That's not going to work. That's just not how we teach this stuff." I'm like, "No, no, no. Like, you don't get it. We'll find people." This is kind of online. [00:21:35] Nafez: And it went live, and I think like 30,000 people signed up for that course, but like a fraction of that completed. So ever since then, we'd kind of work with the best professors in the region to create global-standard content, but kind of tailored and customized for the region. So I'd say that's the second thing. [00:21:51] Nafez: And people always ask me like, "Oh, was it worth it—you did a master's in education neuroscience, was it worth it?" Like literally, I had kind of a mentorship chat yesterday, and I was like, "I mean, I don't know if it was worth it." But the one lesson that I always say I take, and I think it's very relevant in education—I had a professor that said something like, "You know, 90% of people think it's an instructional challenge, or if I could only teach this better, explain it clearer. It's actually 90% of the time a motivational challenge." [00:22:08] Nafez: So for me, that's something that I'd probably spend more time thinking about. We tried a bit at Edraak, you know, we tried to add a bit of gamification, and I'm sure maybe the team now is sort of doing other stuff. But when I was there, I think we were a lot more focused on the instructional part and less on the motivational part. So that's definitely something I think about a lot. [00:22:47] Jamie: Yeah. That's something I was always curious about with the MOOC platforms—is the actual completion rates. Have you ever been able to provide any insight into, even from your time, what that kind of looked like? Because I can't tell you the number of times I've signed up—I've signed up for so many—I've never gotten past like the first two to three weeks. [00:23:02] Nafez: Yeah. I mean, global completion—again, I don't know what the rate is, but when I was kind of stepping out, probably around 7 to 8% globally. If Edraak was getting 15%, some courses we got to 20%. But I don't think we ever managed to get above 20%. And that's partly a motivational challenge, I'd say. Certainly. I'd say also, right, there's this whole idea in education of, kind of friction. Because it's so easy to sign up, right? It's not even a commitment. [00:23:29] Nafez: And again, like Coursera, I mean Udacity, which I don't know if they're still around anymore—they've all found that like when you make somebody pay for the course, right, the completion rates like triple. Because that's kind of a very solid commitment. Like you hand out a card. If you're just creating a profile and signing up, it's kind of like, "Oh, I'd like to learn about this at some point." [00:23:49] Jamie: Can you talk to me about the Game Boy principle? Would you mind expanding on this? Because I find this super, super interesting and very persuasive. [00:23:55] Nafez: Yeah. I mean, again, obviously it's not anything I sort of came up with. Like when Nintendo launched the Game Boy, they didn't use any new technology. It was actually technology that they'd been sitting on that was available to their competitors for a very long time. But they had kind of the genius and sort of craft to sort of think about using that in sort of different ways that completely transformed how gaming works. And I'd say that they've probably done that a few times, right? Like when they first released the Wii. [00:24:21] Nafez: I mean, I don't know how much of that has translated into the Switch, but certainly they've tried. And I think that is part of sometimes what's missing in a lot of innovation, because it's very easy to kind of just take the latest, shiniest, brightest new thing. Because people will not blame you for taking that. But if you try to take a thoughtful approach, use something that already exists to kind of reinvent how we do something, that just takes a lot more, I'd say, kind of just raw experimentation but also kind of intelligence and sort of deep thinking. [00:24:39] Nafez: So I'd say that's sort of really the concept behind it. And it's certainly, I'd say, sometimes missing—at a risk of kind of sensing this part of the world. The problem, and again, this is kind of a Scorsese reference. Like he talks about, you know, some of his best movies were his early movies because they were sort of underfunded. And this whole idea that, you know, constraints drive innovation. I think with withered technology, it's not the exact same concept, but it's kind of somewhat related that, you know, you're taking these kind of withered technologies that are a bit kind of older. They have their own set of constraints, and they force you to sort of think about, you know, how do you kind of tackle these problems differently. [00:25:11] Nafez: And yeah, I'd love to see more of that. I'd love to see less pitches about how we're going to use our own kind of LLM and more about, "Actually, we're taking something really old, but we're doing this very differently." Super scalable, low-cost. [00:25:41] Jamie: Because I think we're probably seeing more of that with AI now as well, where you just kind of throw it in—like you have your AI-powered tutor and that's EdTech. But that's not really addressing maybe the core sort of fundamental problem, which is the pedagogy, you know, the learning process underneath that. [00:25:57] Nafez: Yeah. I mean, I generally don't think AI tutors will work. [00:25:59] Jamie: Really? Genuinely? [00:26:00] Nafez: Yeah. [00:26:01] Jamie: Why? [00:26:01] Nafez: So in general, when people try to talk about—because the simple one is motivation. People think, "Oh, how do I make AI tutors work? Oh, they're all going to customize everything. Oh, you like this team, you like that sport? They're going to make every example about that." [00:26:16] Nafez: And I think that will maybe make it slightly better, but it's not going to get to kind of the two-sigma Bloom's problem that everybody's obsessed with. And for a few reasons—and I don't want to make this kind of a monologue on this. But one: friction is an important, integral part of human relationships. And that doesn't happen kind of with the machine, at least yet. Maybe there's something I'm missing. It will happen. But there's something about having another human care about you that makes you kind of want to invest and sort of do more. [00:26:34] Nafez: And it's usually those are the kids that need that help, right? Like if you're an A+ student—and maybe this is where maybe I'll qualify what I'll say—if you're motivated, an AI tutor is excellent. Of course, it's amazing. Like if you are already motivated, if that fire has already been lit—actually an AI tutor would be wonderful. But the problem is like, that's not 80% of kids. [00:26:54] Nafez: I was at—it was two weeks ago, Google did an AI kind of—it's first kind of AI learning forum. And somebody said something to me, it's like, "We're not building for anybody in this room." Because everybody in this room, maybe even if they weren't the top of their class, at some point they found the motivation to decide, "I care enough about topic X." Or how do you build for the 80, sometimes 90% of people? [00:27:25] Jamie: Do you think that's a problem sometimes? You're kind of building for this like filter bubble or— [00:27:29] Nafez: Oh, I always say that the problem with education is everybody trying to fix it already has an education. I mean, obviously there are sort of some innovators like Paulo Freire, "Pedagogy of the Oppressed," that kind of stuff. But that's probably not the kind of stuff that gets mainstreamed into sort of certainly, I'd say, EdTech or education. Again, there are sort of exceptions and people that are very thoughtful about this. [00:27:48] Nafez: But yeah, I mean, I'd say that that's just kind of what it boils down to when people think about the AI tutor. I'm like, yeah, who are you building this for? What world? What classroom? Because like, "Oh yeah, we're going to train it not to give somebody the answer." How do you make sure the kid doesn't want you to give them the answer until you can solve that problem? [00:28:07] Nafez: And again, games are fantastic. People—one of my, I'd say, pet peeves—people are like, "Oh, education's too hard." No, no. Like if you've seen kids play games, they will spend hours repeating the same level, same boss. It's basically masochistic. But they will keep doing it. And if you offer them an easy way out, they don't want it. Because there's something about how the game has been designed, about their identity, the kind of culture that's been created around it that makes them feel like they want, they crave that sense of achievement. [00:28:35] Nafez: I'll just add to that point—I really think a big part of that solution, like if AI is going to reform education, a big part of it's—what do we do in the culture to make children, learners in general, interested in the process of learning? Like I worry about this—like, "Oh no, we're going to make everything easy." Because that doesn't work. Like you need friction in everything. [00:28:55] Nafez: I always use this idea that people are obsessed with Ozempic, and I'm sure things like Ozempic will be relevant to some people that maybe just have kind of medical conditions. But the problem is when you go to the gym, you don't just go to the gym for the health benefits. You go for the mental part. You go for the social part. You go for all that. Like if you're suddenly just doing all that—and the same thing with social media, right? Like social media—the irony is people feel a lot more lonely now, right? Because all these human interactions now are so easy, so quick, and they're just not meaningful because there's no friction around it. [00:29:13] Nafez: So I do think we need to go where the friction is and be very thoughtful about when we need to remove it and when we need it because it's actually part of the value. [00:29:37] Jamie: This is maybe a fear I had as well—is that we're oversimplifying things without thinking of the actual societal or social impact further down the road as well. And just sort of the "vibe learning" phenomenon, which you've written about and unfortunately equated to my beloved team, Manchester United. [00:29:51] Nafez: I will say that's been the gift that keeps on giving. I really hope Amorim doesn't turn around this season, although it does seem like he finally will. So just for you— [00:29:58] Jamie: Well, we'll see tonight. I don't know. We live in hope, and it's the hope that kills you. Ultimately, how do you introduce that friction then? Can you—any sort of methods from an AI perspective, any ideas, anything that you've read that you think— [00:30:13] Nafez: Yeah, I mean, so I think the idea is like—so the friction isn't just the goal, right? The friction is kind of part of the process. There's sort of two things that matter here. One is this whole idea of sort of desirable difficulty. I mean, what my grandma says, like, easy come, easy go, right? Like, the whole idea is that you want that productive struggle. Some people even say like productive failure—like find out how not to do something to figure out how to do it. [00:30:32] Nafez: So I think that is kind of just scientifically proven to drive better learning outcomes. I think that's the first one—is how do you create productive struggle? How do you scaffold the learner in the right way where this isn't so easy that it's kind of effortless vibe learning, but also not so hard that they kind of feel like, "I'm not going to get there." [00:30:54] Nafez: The other part is—why are we actually asking people to learn? We usually want them to transfer that skill somewhere. I mean, the whole idea of the Manchester United problem, I called it, is there's this assumption that, you know, if you just pay more, just make it easier—and United has certainly, you know, paid a lot in the transfer market, but it just hasn't transferred well because you don't want just to get the players, you want the players to fit in the system. [00:31:00] Nafez: And to be fair, I mean, just again, because I feel like the football analogy is just helpful sometimes for people. United was getting good players. I mean, like people could argue, but like good players. Paul Pogba was a good player. Romelu Lukaku was a good player. Once they've gone somewhere else, they've worked quite well with different systems. The idea is—how do you make sure that transfers well into the new context that you want? [00:31:21] Nafez: And that's sort of usually kind of—you know, do you want near transfer, do you want far transfer? And sort of how do we go on that? I think the ultimate kind of gold standard for learning is always far transfer. I teach you a skill in a specific context because I want you to apply it to all these other contexts. One way to do that, and I've also talked about this a lot, is assessment. How do you create better, kind of more realistic assessment? [00:31:48] Nafez: I'm actually—I mean, that's probably one area where I'm a bit optimistic. Because I think the conversational nature of at least this current iteration could be super interesting in developing kind of more of a granular sort of assessment and understanding of what people know, how they perform. You can do kind of more role-play-based assessment. [00:32:08] Nafez: And I'll just end on this note—like I think what we're missing in education is that GPS moment. The GPS moment, which obviously a lot of us now take for granted, but underpins everything. Like, I wouldn't be able to get here if I wasn't able to order, you know, Careem. [00:32:28] Nafez: That idea that I just opened the app and it already knows where I am on kind of a map is the analogy that we need in education. How do you get to a point where the AI tutor or whatever instructional material, again, already knows where you are and then can sort of motivate you, or the larger culture can then motivate you to get to point B. We're not there yet, but I'm hopeful. There are things like stealth assessments and other areas where I think we could get there. [00:32:56] Jamie: Is the fear, like, retention on one level? Like if you're failing, it's less likely maybe that you'll come back. [00:33:02] Nafez: Yeah. I mean, I think the challenge, right, in EdTech specifically, is this tension. Because from a product management perspective, and again, I'm kind of being very kind of—like summarizing at very high level as well—"Don't make me think," right? Like it needs to be super easy, super clear. It needs to be intuitive. If you're going to make me think for more than five seconds, I'm going to churn. Versus for you to learn something, you actually need to struggle with it. You need to come from a productive struggle. [00:33:20] Nafez: And for example, at Duolingo—I've interviewed a bunch of people there. I don't think this is an official line I couldn't quote anybody on—but they have a product team, my understanding, they have a learning team, and they each have their own metrics. At some point, right, the metrics will kind of contradict each other. And then at some point the senior PM needs to make a call: Are we willing to sacrifice a bit of retention here for more learning? Or are we going to sacrifice a bit of learning for more retention? [00:33:41] Nafez: And I just think that's kind of a very real struggle for a lot of people. I'd say in many ways defined by the culture within which this is in. Again, Duolingo really works also for a specific subset of people that are really interested in learning language. And then they've done that very well. It's kind of no criticism to them. But I don't know how well that scales to other subjects, other topics. [00:34:01] Nafez: Part of me does feel that for some of the hardest subjects, you're just not going to learn them swiping on a phone. Like this was one of the debates we always had at Edraak. Like, we want a mobile learning app, but are you really going to learn quantum mechanics on the phone, on a bus? Like maybe you'll review some notes, you'll re-listen to the lecture, but you really need to be probably sitting down. And again, maybe there are people that can, but I wouldn't be able to do quantum mechanics unless I'm sitting down and trying to wrap my head around it. [00:34:39] Jamie: So there'll always be a place for human supervision. [00:34:42] Nafez: I mean, I think there's going to always be a place for human relationships. I think they've kind of been really undervalued recently, at least kind of from my perspective. And I think that is—I don't think it'll go away, right? Like when you think of, what did—a moment back in school that kind of inspired you? I feel like it always goes back to that person—even though it wasn't a teacher, maybe it was a peer. [00:35:00] Nafez: And I think that is kind of really, really important. So you will need the person to light that fire. And I think this assumption that you're going to light the fire once, I think, is also false. That you need that person to constantly kind of keep coming back and sort of helping you refine that sort of passion. But then, yeah, maybe you'll have kind of AI scaffolds to kind of expedite your learning, take you down those rabbit holes. But again, that needs to be designed well and sort of thought about. [00:35:28] Jamie: Can we talk about Arabic and Arabic AI specifically? [00:35:34] Nafez: Yes. I can talk about it for a long time. [00:35:35] Jamie: Maybe just to start off, can you just explain this, I suppose, concept of sort of Arabic diglossia? I think that'd be helpful. [00:35:40] Nafez: Arabic is a diglossic language. Some people try to debate that. I think it's not based in science. I think scientifically, research-wise, Arabic is a diglossic language. Any Arabic speaker experiences that diglossia on a regular basis. And it's basically, you know, I have a higher, higher form I use kind of in an academic sense, and kind of a lower form. So the Modern Standard Arabic and then kind of the dialect or ammiya that people speak day-to-day. [00:36:09] Nafez: And I think that's not unique to Arabic. I mean, I think sometimes in the Arab world people have to kind of feel special. There are other sort of diglossic languages. Greek is diglossic. Chinese has some kind of maybe facets of diglossia, although I don't know if it's actually qualified as diglossic. So there are sort of other languages that have this challenge. [00:36:26] Nafez: And I think this creates a specific educational challenge, specifically around literacy. So an English speaker—and ironically, English is actually a very difficult language to learn to read. And then maybe this is something to take a step back on. Humans have a language instinct. If you did nothing with a child other than just them hearing you speak and you speak to them—obviously the more you speak to them, the more stimulus you give them, the faster they'll learn—but generally, humans will just learn how to speak. Not just—it's a human instinct. It's kind of pre-wired. You don't have to do much. [00:36:43] Nafez: Reading is not an instinct. Like reading is actually—it's not even natural. Like you have to take over parts of the brain that are actually usually kind of specialized for other things to get people to sort of read and write. However, in sort of non-diglossic contexts, a kid will learn a word, let's say "cat," and then they will see the letters C-A-T. You will teach them that C is /k/, A is /a/, and then they will hear that word and start linking the word "cat" and how it's written—the orthography—to an image in their head of a cat or a kitten or something they've seen. [00:37:16] Nafez: In Arabic, that's not the case, right? Because if I show a child—depending on sort of where in the Arab world that kid is from—they might have no idea what it is, right? Like in Palestine, we'd say "bissa." In Lebanon, they'd say "qitta." In like Bahrain, they'd say "qurwa." In the UAE, maybe it's "qawa." Like, right? In Saudi it's "qitta." I'm not even sure. But the idea is that that disconnect creates, I think, a particular challenge for kids going to school. [00:37:32] Nafez: And a lot of people are not going to like this, maybe not in kind of VC tech context, but I'd say in academic context. But I do kind of, I'd say we are asking kids, certainly in elementary—unless we teach them how to read and write Arabic in Modern Standard Arabic well—to learn in a foreign language. Because they show up to class, they kind of recognize some of the words, et cetera, but it's not where it needs to be. And it's certainly not where it is for a kid in a non-diglossic context. [00:38:23] Nafez: And I'll just end because people assume I'm trying to argue against MSA. I think MSA is an incredible asset across the region. What I'm arguing for is better instruction of MSA. There's sort of multiple ways to do this. There are people even arguing for speaking in MSA to kids from when they were born. When they're born. I think for 99% of people, that's not practical. But sure, if it works for some people. I think the other way to do it is to actually think, how do you scaffold kids? How do you give them better MSA exposure? [00:38:43] Nafez: So that's what I talk about in the "Captain Majid" podcast. Like, how do you expose them to cartoons in MSA? How do you get them more excited about MSA really early on? But I just think probably the most important challenge for the region, in my mind, is getting over this literacy challenge. Because the other way you could go down, and certainly some people do this, right—"I'm just going to teach my kids English. They're just going to speak in English, they're going to study in English." [00:38:57] Nafez: I think you lose so much doing that. There's so much culture, history. Yeah. I mean, I think the very unique thing about Arabic, which is—if I read Beowulf, if we try to read Beowulf today, right, we'd have no idea what it says. But if I pick a thousand-year-old text in Arabic, probably there's a chance that most people just understand generally what it's saying. I mean, again, language has changed, some words, et cetera. I'm not saying it's perfect. But I'm saying that that connection to the past and history, which is really important, I think is really lost in translation if you don't spend time teaching your kids MSA, which I think we should. [00:39:54] Jamie: Let's move to Builder then. Okay. So you're on the operator side of things. I guess this is sort of a midway bridge between operator and investor. This is sort of, you know, you're moving there. What precipitated your desire for building a venture studio? [00:40:08] Nafez: Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think, you know, basically Edraak felt like venture building. We kind of venture-built that within the Queen Rania Foundation. Obviously at the time didn't think of it as venture building, but we had centralized services, right? Like HR, finance, all that. But then we venture-built this from scratch, you know, tested some of the assumptions, scaled it, and then eventually kind of spun it out, and it did really well. [00:40:19] Nafez: So Zuhair and I went back and said like, what if we could do this, kind of systemize it, do it at scale? And yeah, I'd say that was kind of it. And like you said, it's sort of a really good bridge for me going from the operator side, I'd say a lot more sort of impact-focused, really on the operator side. And then thinking about that where—I mean, we still kind of tried to venture-build in EdTech, FinTech, future of work. And then now with Anara, really just on the—I mean, again, big focus on impact, but really just on the investment side. [00:40:58] Jamie: What was your biggest learning from Builder? [00:41:02] Nafez: Building things is really hard. No, I mean, I guess on a more serious note. I think, so two things that stuck with me. I mean, Tambi and I—and I think, you know, Tambi and I have this debate kind of always, a few times on LinkedIn—I think go-to-market is a lot harder than people kind of assume. I think people assume it's like, "Oh, I need to find the problem, build a prototype, get kind of my beachhead." For me, go-to-market is really hard. [00:41:11] Nafez: And I think before, when I used to think of unfair advantage for founders, I used to think, "Okay, are they obsessed with this problem?" And I think that's probably another thing I'll talk about. Or are they—how much do they know? Have they worked in this space? Now I think about also, do they have an unfair go-to-market here? So I think, yeah, just how hard go-to-market is. How hard—and now, right, with AI, like vibe coding or like shipping and building is just so much easier. [00:41:49] Nafez: So standing out from the noise is even so much harder than when we even did Builder. So I think go-to-market is one. The second one is just working with a lot more founders, a lot more kind of iterations. So understanding the difference between somebody that's passionate about something and somebody that's obsessed with it. [00:42:05] Jamie: What is that difference? What's the distinction? [00:42:07] Nafez: Yeah, I mean, I think there are people that are very interested in the topic. Like maybe they'll read books, they're—but then there are people that are like, this is literally their life. Like they think of nothing else. It is their identity. I think it probably has bad mental health repercussions down the line if the startup doesn't work because once the startup doesn't work, they're like, "Okay, who am I? What does that mean?" [00:42:28] Jamie: The founder of Figma was talking about this recently, actually, in terms of, obviously founders have this chip on their shoulder and it's very helpful, but at some point you probably should maybe address what that chip on your shoulder is because, you know, that might necessarily end up damaging those around you as well in the long term. [00:42:42] Nafez: Oh, for sure. No, a hundred percent. And so I think that's probably the second lesson. I mean, third lesson—and again, I don't know if it's just validation—there's just a lot of talent. I mean, it's dispersed. It's not easy to find. But if you take the region as a whole, there's just a lot of incredible talent across the region. [00:43:00] Jamie: Did you have a bias towards a particular founder type? Is your idea now with Anara—has that changed based on your experience building? [00:43:07] Nafez: I think what's changed is now I do reference checks really seriously. I think when we do DD now with Anara, I think one of the things that—I don't know if other, I'm sure other funds do this at some level—but I feel like some of the founders are like, "Wait, why are you talking to so many people? I've already introduced you to three." I was like, "Yeah, we try to talk to 15 people per founder." Like, really kind of get a sense for who they are. [00:43:22] Nafez: And I think also as an impact fund—but that's really important for me. Because sometimes the LPs are like, "Oh, you know, you invested in the company." What if the founder just doesn't care about the impact anymore? Well, I've done a bad job because if I'm trying to litigate them back to impact, then it's already kind of a lose-lose. So what I'm doing is spending as much time as we can as a team talking to people that have known them for longer than we have, that kind of have a better sense of who they are and sort of why they're doing this. Like what are their weaknesses, what are their strengths? [00:43:35] Nafez: So I think, yeah, definitely I think one of the things—and then a great guy on this is Graham Duncan. Don't know him personally. Think he was interviewed on a Tim Ferriss podcast, but then I'm kind of—he's done kind of a bunch of pieces on this. Super, super helpful. Kind of looking at him if anybody's interested in the topic. [00:44:14] Jamie: Okay, we've touched on Anara, we haven't actually provided context about what Anara necessarily is. Would you mind just providing an overview? [00:44:19] Nafez: Yeah, yeah, sure. So we are a $50 million impact fund focused on learning, climate, and wellbeing across MENA. We do early-stage companies, so seed to series A is probably really our soft spot. And focused across the region, I'd say with specific emphasis really on the Levant and North Africa. [00:44:25] Nafez: And yeah, we're just about going. Hopefully before the end of the year we'll announce—I mean maybe actually early into next year we'll announce, but close before the end of the year—one or two investments, mostly depending on sort of how that goes. [00:44:49] Jamie: Impact sometimes has negative connotations. [00:44:51] Nafez: Oh. I mean, I feel like impact can sometimes be a dirty word, man. Like, people conflate it with philanthropy in that. [00:44:55] Jamie: Yeah. Like how much of the process, and even from a fund fundraising perspective, is sort of like deprogramming bias? [00:45:00] Nafez: Yeah, no, a hundred percent. I mean, I think it really depends. I mean, I will say, I mean, you sometimes speak to investors that surprise you. Like they understand what it is. They've seen it before. They've been curious about why there isn't more in the region. And you talk to people that—they hear impact, they think, "Oh, should you be talking to our CSR team?" And I'm like, "No, no. This is not philanthropy. This is a fund. We are explicitly aiming to make returns while doing well, doing good." [00:45:15] Nafez: And I think it's something maybe you and I talked about—how? Because sometimes people say, "Well listen, I'll just do my own philanthropy. I'll do my own charity." I think the part that they don't get—there's sort of three parts of this. One is with impact investment, the goal is to be intentional, additional, and scalable, right? We want to be intentional about the kind of impact we want to create. So we're investing in specific sectors that we think underpin the quality of life for people across the region. [00:45:48] Nafez: Then we want to make sure that our capital is additional. And here I won't only think about financial capital, we also think about the social capital we bring to this. I think with the set of limited partners that we have, the idea is to kind of use their profiles as well to kind of raise the profile of some of these initiatives. [00:46:04] Nafez: The last thing, and I'd say I learned this because I was on the other side, you know, with philanthropy—and I think that there is a huge role for that. I think there's a role for philanthropy, there's a role for different kinds of capital, and maybe we can talk about it. But there's something about venture where you can align incentives to make this a lot more scalable. [00:46:18] Nafez: Like the challenge with building a charity is—and again, it depends on kind of what problem you're solving—but it's not scalable, it's not necessarily revenue-generating. And that might be right because it's specifically maybe solving a problem for bottom of the pyramid, right? Like if you are, you know, in Gaza right now, post-genocide, I don't think should be—I mean there might be opportunities, but I think the first focus should be on sort of first response, on aid, on sort of everything there to just make sure that people are able to live or able to sort of do everything they need. [00:46:37] Nafez: And I don't think that's sort of where you should be thinking. Like if your choice is between philanthropy there and impact investment, then actually no, you probably should be thinking about philanthropy. But if you're thinking about, "How do I scale access to food? Access to water for a hundred million people across the region?" That is something that requires venture scale. That's not something that I think small charities or philanthropies across the region are going to solve at a scalable level. [00:47:21] Jamie: It's often said fund size determines strategy. What's the thinking behind the fund size then? [00:47:26] Nafez: Yeah, no, it's a great—I mean, a hundred percent. I mean, I think we, from a strategy perspective—because again, I think this whole idea of there is a lot of philanthropy in the region, and I think sometimes founders are not sure, you know, whether they want to do this as a startup or they want to do this as a grant-based organization. So we wanted to wait a bit later on to make sure that they're set on the direction, set as a venture, a scalable venture before going in. [00:47:28] Nafez: So that's why we, I'd say, chose kind of late seed to series A, because we also don't want to necessarily be the first kind of institutional capital coming in. The other thing is, this is still kind of, I'd say, an emerging, kind of early space. So we didn't think, you know, you could do a larger fund there. And last but not least, we want to be, I'd say, in a very healthy way, kind of just very involved in supporting the founders. And we felt if we went beyond that, we wouldn't be able to do that and help them, you know, think about their theory of change, measuring impact, and getting all that done. [00:48:23] Jamie: And from a deal flow perspective or from the pipeline, how many companies out there are there regionally that sort of fit your mandate? [00:48:30] Nafez: Yeah, I mean, so I mean, I think it surprises people—deal flow hasn't been an issue. Like I'd say, I mean at this point, and again, it's not just me, right? Like my colleagues, Nada and Hamad—I wouldn't be able to do it without them. We've probably looked, and again, we've only kind of been, I'd say, doing this full-time for about a year. Hamad joined for six months. Probably looked at like 55 companies, right? [00:48:39] Nafez: And again, these are just companies we talked to. I'd say we probably spent more time with about 10 of them, and I'd say more intently with five. And now, you know, taking two hopefully to IC to sort of consider them for investment. [00:49:04] Jamie: We talked about the exit problem earlier. So what does that look like for an EdTech company in particular, where we've seen so little graduate to the point where they—obviously we have the capital markets developing here. We've had Saudi context or a UAE context. Is that the natural route for an EdTech company regionally? Is it to go public or is it strategic acquisition? We saw that with Nahla and Nabbat, we've seen that with Abwaab. [00:49:28] Nafez: Yeah. I mean, I think again, it depends on the kind of EdTech company you are doing. Because like you said, like Nahla and Nabbat, Abwaab in Saudi—all of these were sort of strategically acquired. I don't think there's any issue with that. Edraak as well. [00:49:45] Nafez: But I think for example, like a company like Baims—I don't know if they'll be acquired or they'll IPO. If I had to bet on the founder, I think they're going to go very big. Again, I'm not invested, have kind of no skin in the game. So I don't know if there's kind of one size fits all, to be honest. [00:49:53] Nafez: I think the first maybe thing to start with is, as you said, the capital markets are improving, I think drastically, kind of where we were when we wrote the piece in 2021 to where we are today. And obviously the dynamics are changing. Having said that, there probably is, and I kind of touched on this before, just the lack of a kind of full capital stack. You know, there isn't probably enough private equity activity yet. It's starting to change, kind of post-Abraaj, kind of hopefully coming back again, getting more private equity. [00:50:10] Nafez: IPO markets, whether, you know, it's Tadawul in Saudi or here in the DFM—that's also, you know, starting to kind of open up opportunities for a lot of other players. So I think that's starting to change. I think last but not least, and maybe this is more on the strategic acquisition side, is this market because of efforts here in the UAE, because of efforts in Saudi and other places, is becoming more strategic as a place for kind of global companies, global players. [00:50:27] Nafez: And the way for a lot of them to get in is to acquire sort of a foothold. So I think that'll become a lot more interesting. And kind of a tangent here—like you're also seeing Revolut is moving here. Like you're finally getting also companies kind of relocate. Obviously again, like the risk of being early and being wrong can be the same thing. But also being early and being right can be kind of a big win. So, I mean, I'm obviously betting on being early and being right. [00:51:18] Jamie: You publish something every year called your "favorite problems." What are your favorite problems at the moment? Do your favorite problems sync up with what you're trying to do with Anara now? Is there alignment there? [00:51:31] Nafez: I try. I'd say certainly I try. I don't know how fully they sync. I mean, I'd say I certainly write just to help me think about my problems. I mean, ironically, every time I publish I probably lose like 20 followers or 20 subscribers. I don't know what that means about my writing. It's okay, happens to me as well. I think people subscribe and they're like, "Oh wait, I signed up for this thing." [00:51:43] Nafez: But yeah. I mean, I'd say the reason I write is to kind of help me think very deeply about these problems. I think the main problem that I still worry about, as kind of mentioned, is—how do we hack this motivation thing? How do we make sure when the reward is no longer the output that you get people, specifically young people, to care about the process? Because I think that really matters. How do you get them engaged and interested in that desirable difficulty? [00:52:02] Nafez: Because if they're like, "Oh, everything needs to come easy," I think that's a problem. I'm still very interested in solving this whole diglossia challenge, this Arabic content challenge. I think now to kind of align a bit more with Anara, starting to think more about the climate crisis and sort of what it means. I think water scarcity as a problem here in the region is something I'm thinking about a lot. [00:52:20] Nafez: And last but not least, I'd say mental wellbeing. Both mental health and mental wellbeing. But also, again, with the rise of AI, something I'd like—so like mental fitness paradigm, right? Like how do you get people—if we have gyms now for physical labor, I don't know if we'll have gyms for kind of mental labor. [00:52:37] Nafez: There obviously have been a lot of snake oil salesmen in the past with these apps that will improve your memory. None of it's science-based, none of it fact-based. But I feel like now—I did this course or online course at some point, you know, David Perell. Name rings a bell? Forget actually what it was called—"Write of Passage," not "Write the Passage." [00:52:55] Nafez: And he used to do these things called writing gyms, which I actually thought were really—it was live, in person. You'd go in, he'd have a very specific method—over 10 minutes now, just write, write, write. Like don't stop for 10 minutes. Now brainstorm with other people and then for another 10 minutes, let's refine the ideas. And I actually think there's something in there for sort of just getting people to continue to be excited about doing this kind of stuff. [00:53:36] Jamie: Yeah. Sort of touches on this MIT study regarding the cognitive offloading. Is that something that concerns you? [00:53:43] Nafez: Oh, for sure, for sure. I mean, I think there are sort of—and I will say, and I feel like where I've come across as negative—I think AI is super useful. I mean, I certainly use it. I know a lot of people that use it. I just think we need to be careful about sort of how you use it. Because again, there's always going to be this tendency to be lazy and kind of not think through things. [00:54:04] Nafez: And I was on a panel recently where this other participant was saying something like, "Oh, their younger sibling uses AI to help them speak to their mom." So basically, you know, whenever the mom sends a message, they'll put it into whatever, and they were kind of trying to spin it positively. I'm like, "But what—one, what happens if there's no—if your sibling has no data? Do they stop responding to your mom because they can't think about what to say? And two, right? That's where—talking to your parents is probably where you—the first safe space where you learn how to talk to people." [00:54:31] Nafez: If you're doing it via chatbot, that's huge cognitive offloading with potentially huge consequences. [00:54:49] Jamie: I definitely find this even with just email communication. I understand some of email communication doesn't need to be as formal and it's probably not worth the best investment of time. Love when there's a typo in someone's email or there's a comma in the wrong place and I'm like, "Okay, you did take the time to send the email irrespective of how cursory it was or how, you know, even if you didn't address my question." I'm like, "Okay, well at least it was actually you as opposed to you just, you know, parroting back what I said and the structure is slightly off and all of that kind of thing." [00:55:11] Nafez: Yeah, basically. There was this—it was New Yorker or something where they had this cartoon where, "Make this email into—make these bullet points into an email," and then on the other end, "Make this email into bullet points." And I notice all the time, you know, when you know somebody in person, then you see them posting on LinkedIn or emailing you. I'm like, "That's not—" Absolutely. It's so jarring and I'm like, "I'm not interested in that version." [00:55:32] Jamie: Yeah. What's the last major thing you changed your opinion of? [00:55:36] Nafez: That's a great question. I'd say this idea that—first, I still think first impressions are important. Like I still think there's a lot of kind of intuition in that. But I'm starting to think you need to be kind of more patient, spend more time, do more reference checks. You know, that thinking—I think that is something. Because if you're thinking of somebody else, like regardless of what they're doing, their first impression is still the first impression they're taking into other interactions with people. [00:55:44] Nafez: And if a lot of decisions are being made quickly, unless they can work on their first impression—but I'm kind of learning to kind of be a bit more sort of patient with that and I'd say reserve judgment. I'd say one thing, and I'd say this is maybe not that recent, but also on topic. I still remember in 2010 a friend recommended the book "The Shallows" to me. It's about kind of how search and the internet are sort of rewiring, changing our minds. [00:55:57] Nafez: I was like, "Come on man. You're being so negative. Why are you doing this? We're going to be fine if we only read online and don't read in books." I think again, as we've been saying now with the rise of AI, I was like, "You know what? He is onto something." We need to be thoughtful. And again, it's not against—so just we need to be thoughtful about how, with anything else, if you're introducing it to your life, what are you losing? What's the trade-off? There are trade-offs to everything. [00:56:53] Jamie: If you weren't doing venture tomorrow, what would you be doing? [00:56:56] Nafez: I mean, people—I'd be an Arabic teacher. [00:56:58] Jamie: Really? [00:56:59] Nafez: Yeah, yeah, yeah. [00:57:00] Jamie: Would you like to ever do that? [00:57:01] Nafez: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's actually what I wanted. I mean, it wasn't an option, right? Like I had to be a surgeon or an engineer. I mean, when I was graduating, I told my parents, "I'd love to teach Arabic." They're like, "What are you talking about? Like, don't even think about that. You're not going to be a teacher, you're not going to teach Arabic. There's no money in that." So maybe at some point. Not that I'm any good. I need to probably go and—but yeah. No, I'd like to do that. [00:57:23] Jamie: No, I love that. Maybe some quick fires if that's cool. Overrated or underrated? Gamification. [00:57:30] Nafez: Gamification. Overrated. [00:57:33] Jamie: Ooh, I need to pick your brain on that. It's supposed to be quick fire, but why? [00:57:36] Nafez: Because it depends primarily on extrinsic motivation and it's very shallow application. I think the more interesting thing is game-full design. Because gamification—and again, I think I'm just—this is Justin Reich, I think—it's like chocolate-covered broccoli. So I just don't—my daughter loves broccoli. Absolutely. Blows my mind. But it's because her mom is kind of a lot more—because I'm like, her mom's much better with eating healthy than I am. [00:57:43] Nafez: It's very intentional. Been feeding—kid loves broccoli. I mean, I hope she never hears this podcast and realizes this is not normal. But again, probably be at that point too late. [00:58:12] Jamie: Hey look, I have a soft spot for broccoli as well. I won't lie. I don't know why, but since I was young as well, so yeah. [00:58:17] Nafez: Gamification is just chocolate-covered broccoli. All like, let's take this broccoli that we never taught you to like—let's just put a lot of bad stuff on it and this kind of instant. So yeah. Gamification, I'd say overrated. [00:58:27] Jamie: One skill you wish you had learned earlier. [00:58:30] Nafez: I do wish I spent more time on my ball control and football earlier, but I feel like that's very random. We're all there. [00:58:36] Jamie: I fully agree with you. Remote work, yes or no? [00:58:39] Nafez: I think context-dependent. It sounds really old and ageist and I feel like this is very grandfather-ish. But I feel like for—if it's your first job, I think it's a lot more valuable for you to spend time in the office. Just genuinely, you build relationships with people, you get to see them more closely. You get to see them in their downtime. [00:58:56] Nafez: So I will say a percentage of sort of face-to-face is important. But I do take issue with people that feel like remote doesn't work because I feel like if you think remote doesn't work, it's usually for the wrong reasons. Because you don't trust your people. And I don't think the right way to compensate for that is kind of command and control. Like, "I need to see you working." Because we all know that person that's in the office for the face time. So I feel it's not an easy solution. It'll really depend. [00:59:29] Jamie: What's one thing you strongly believe in now that you have a hunch that you're going to be wrong on in five years? [00:59:35] Nafez: Maybe the AI tutoring thing. [00:59:38] Jamie: Really? [00:59:38] Nafez: Maybe. Maybe I've kind of been too pessimistic. But yeah. [00:59:41] Jamie: Maybe once Mr. Musk introduces some sort of humanoid robots and maybe that can fill a vacuum of affairs. [00:59:46] Nafez: If Musk is behind it, then I'm pretty sure I'm right. But if somebody else, then I could be wrong. [00:59:50] Jamie: Yes. I'm inclined to agree. Well, Nafez, that's all the questions I have, so thank you so much. Thank you so much for your time. Really, really enjoyed this. Thank you.