Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Naughty Marietta (1935)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Pirates. I know, that's a
- 0:25weird intro. So I was a little shocked, right,
- 0:28with this movie. Yeah, I think anyone who knows
- 0:31what movie we're talking about and just heard
- 0:32that opening was like, what? Yeah. Was Captain
- 0:36Blood up already? Exactly. Pretty pirate -heavy
- 0:39year, then. That's true. Right? Yeah, that's
- 0:42wild. I mean, two out of 12, but still. That's
- 0:45more than anything we've done. That's true, yeah.
- 0:47Yeah, so I just think, I started this movie,
- 0:49right? And I was like, all right, let's see.
- 0:51Teehee, haha, the name. Sounds funny, cute. We've
- 0:54made the joke about you and your ankles before.
- 0:56That's true, which they're out today. Looking
- 0:58good. Thank you. But yeah, I started the movie,
- 1:02and then there were some swashbucklers that made
- 1:05an appearance, and I was like, what? What? And
- 1:08then I got excited because I like pirates. By
- 1:10the way, happy Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced
- 1:14week. Goodie. I mean, that came out recently.
- 1:18I just played that game for the first time last
- 1:19year. That's great. And then they announced the
- 1:22remaster and I was like, great. Did you beat
- 1:26it? I did. Oh, so you have like no reason to
- 1:28go back. I will never go back. I will. That's
- 1:30good. I hope you enjoy it. I am Jack from Lost.
- 1:33We got to go back. Oh. We got to go back. I'm
- 1:37somebody that. was on the tail end of the plane,
- 1:39didn't show up until the second season, and then
- 1:41died very early in the third season. You're like,
- 1:44yeah, I experienced that. Yeah. I'm like Hurley's
- 1:46girlfriend. You know what? So many people look
- 1:49at you and they're like, is that Hurley's girlfriend?
- 1:52You know, it's my claim to fame. You could do
- 1:53worse. You'd be Locke's girlfriend. These references
- 1:57are like the most clouded memories in my mind.
- 2:01It's been so long since I've seen it. Would you
- 2:02say it was like a black cloud? You mean like...
- 2:06A smoke monster? Are there pirates in Lost? So,
- 2:08Naughty Marietta, I don't think there's any pirates
- 2:11in Lost. I don't think so either. Now, I think
- 2:13technically you could call the others. Are they
- 2:16the others? Is that their name? That sounds right.
- 2:18The others, I think you could say that they are
- 2:20pirate -esque in the way that they're taking,
- 2:23and I do see them on a boat once or twice, but
- 2:25I don't think they are considering themselves
- 2:27pirates. Qualifications for a pirate. Knocked
- 2:30it out. On a boat every once in a while? Are
- 2:31you stealing things that don't belong to you?
- 2:33Yeah. Are you sailing the seas? But yeah, we're
- 2:36talking about Nani Marietta today. This one does
- 2:38have a lot of things going for it. It is a period
- 2:41piece. It is colonial. Pirates. Pirates. Even
- 2:44a little bit of an adventure frontier. with like
- 2:47a Davy Crockett type thing. Like I, at one point
- 2:51was like, I have fever dreamed this movie. You
- 2:53know, well, we'll introduce the movie and then
- 2:56I'll - There you go. Yeah. So Naughty Marietta
- 2:58was up for two nominations. Obviously one of
- 3:00them, you know about, we'll get there in a second.
- 3:02Sound recording, our absolute, like the guy who's
- 3:06probably been talked about maybe the most. Yeah,
- 3:09at least tied. Hey man, good to see you again.
- 3:11Oh, you're here again? Where's your sister? Of
- 3:14any shearer, I thought Norma Shearer would be
- 3:17talked about a little bit more, but Douglas Shearer
- 3:18has popped back up. He's busy. He is busy. Sound
- 3:21recording is his nomination here. And then outstanding
- 3:24production, of course, this was for the studio
- 3:26MGM. This marks the return of director W .S.
- 3:30Van Dyke, who, if you remember, directed The
- 3:33Thin Man. Sure did. And like the first three
- 3:35of the sequels of that, which obviously we haven't
- 3:38watched for the show. He directed what he could
- 3:40before he passed. That's true. That's very true.
- 3:42R .I .P. Another director, too. What? There was
- 3:46another director as well. Can you enlighten me
- 3:48to that? I absolutely can. So Robert Z. Leonard
- 3:51was the original director of this, but he actually
- 3:53asked for his release after the first day of
- 3:55the shoot. Don't know what that means. I don't
- 3:57know if they opened on the pirate scenes or any
- 3:59of the wilderness out there. But after the first
- 4:01day, he said, yeah, I'm out. Can't do it. And
- 4:04he was replaced by W .S. Van Dyke. So you're
- 4:06correct that W .S. Van Dyke is the listed director.
- 4:09But Robert Z. Leonard does have a partial credit
- 4:12on this because he did film the first day. I
- 4:14can't believe that I'm looking at my notes like.
- 4:17Oh, my God. What did I miss? Is it there? And
- 4:18you're discrediting me for a one -day director?
- 4:22No. Look, I'm not saying that he was a co -director.
- 4:26I'm just saying he got partial credit because
- 4:28he did film on the first day. And I just want
- 4:30to ask you, of all the movies that we've watched,
- 4:33and we'll get to the cast here in a second, of
- 4:35all the movies that we've watched where we've
- 4:36seen troubled productions, Traitor Horn, Viva
- 4:40Via. There's another one that I'm forgetting
- 4:43right now that I remember being like, oh, that
- 4:44was not a great situation. Lives of a Bengal
- 4:47Lancer. Sure, yeah, Lives of a Bengal Lancer.
- 4:49Of all those troubled productions, when you hear
- 4:52about a director leaving after the first day,
- 4:55would you think Naughty Marietta? The first thing
- 4:58I would say is... Were they outside? Well, and
- 5:01that's the thing. I guess the question is if
- 5:03the movie was filmed in sequence, which I did
- 5:06not read that it was. Which doesn't mean it wasn't.
- 5:08Yeah. Well, I feel like it's rare. Most films
- 5:10that are filmed in sequence, it will be announced
- 5:13filmed in sequence. They like to showboat a little
- 5:17bit with that. So maybe it was like the pirate
- 5:19sequences. Maybe it was like, you know, the first
- 5:22meeting with Warrington. which is kind of the,
- 5:25you know, wilderness Davy Crockett thing I was
- 5:27talking about. Right. But outside of that, if
- 5:30it was filmed in New Orleans, maybe it was really
- 5:32hot. I don't know. Yeah, I don't know. There's
- 5:35no details around it. Curious. Curious why he
- 5:38left. Curious. But you're right. W .S. Van Dyke.
- 5:41I do want to know, like, how quickly this was
- 5:43filmed, because I think I read 17 days. That's
- 5:46pretty quick. Pretty quick. He's known for shooting
- 5:48quick. So this also marks the return of Jeanette
- 5:52MacDonald, who you will remember from The Love
- 5:54Parade and I think one other Lubitsch movie.
- 5:57One Hour With You. She was in that one? Okay.
- 5:59So if you'll remember what she was known in those
- 6:03movies for, it was her voice and her comedy.
- 6:06I love her in The Love Parade. Well, she had
- 6:08some history as a silent film actress as well.
- 6:13Nothing we've seen her in for the pod. But that
- 6:16makes a lot of sense because Jeanette MacDonald,
- 6:18to me, is one of the most expressive. I think
- 6:21her smile lights up the screen whenever she's
- 6:24on, whenever she's being filmed. So I was wondering,
- 6:27so much of her seems like I have to be this performative
- 6:30for silent film, but I've adapted really well
- 6:32because I can sing. So I wonder how much of that
- 6:35has changed. has helped her. But I agree. Magnetic
- 6:37on the screen. Yes. And her voice, calling back
- 6:41to the Lubitsch movies, is such a huge element
- 6:45of this movie. Because we haven't said, this
- 6:47is a musical as well. It is. And that's another
- 6:50thing I didn't expect. I have a better double
- 6:52feature. My God. You haven't announced it yet,
- 6:55so you have plenty of time to change it. So,
- 6:56Jeanette MacDonald plays Princess Marie de Namur
- 7:00de la Bonfein. Also kind of Marietta. Eventually.
- 7:05Yeah. Yeah. So she is a princess in France who
- 7:08is set for an arranged marriage with a Spaniard.
- 7:13Correct. Yes. Who is just awful. You don't spend
- 7:16a lot of time with him, but he's terrible. And
- 7:18she has zero interest in this relationship with
- 7:21this man. So she decides that she is going to
- 7:24be a casquette girl and hop on a ship to the.
- 7:29I guess it's not the New World at this point,
- 7:31but down to New Orleans. And a casket girl is
- 7:34a woman who leaves France with the goal of marrying
- 7:38somebody in New Orleans. Yes. On her journey
- 7:41out here, her ship is overrun with, you guessed
- 7:44it, pirates. They're rescued by... Warrington.
- 7:49Yes, Warrington. Nelson Eddy, who is... Not only
- 7:53her co -star in this film, but will go on to
- 7:55be in many films with Jeanette MacDonald. The
- 7:57first of eight for them. Yes. They become, what
- 7:59was it? The America's Singing Sweethearts. Correct.
- 8:03Yes. And basically a romance ensues between them.
- 8:05And she spends a little time in New Orleans posing
- 8:08as a woman named Marietta. Trying to not get
- 8:13married, but also... slowly falling in love with
- 8:16warrington help me with something okay in the
- 8:19beginning when she decides to do this is it her
- 8:21caretaker julie or marietta because i thought
- 8:25her caretaker's name was marietta and that's
- 8:27why she takes over her persona i thought so too
- 8:30but then later she's like julie yes come here
- 8:33i wonder if her name's julie marietta Maybe.
- 8:36But this is what happens is like she hears, oh,
- 8:39hey, this is what I'm going to go do. I'm going
- 8:41to be a casket girl. I'm leaving France. I'm
- 8:43going to go to New Orleans and I'm going to find
- 8:45someone to marry. And Princess Marie says, hey,
- 8:49this sounds great to me. That's what I want to
- 8:51do. Let's switch. You stay here and you be the
- 8:54princess here and get married. And then I'm going
- 8:57to leave. And that is a very normal setup. However.
- 9:01It is also the funniest, like, this will last
- 9:04five seconds scenario. Yeah. Where, like, as
- 9:06soon as, like, the king sees his daughter, he's
- 9:08like, so that's not my daughter. So this isn't
- 9:12going to fly very long at all. They even kind
- 9:15of show the marriage or the wedding a little
- 9:17bit where, like, the Spaniard's like, yeah, cool,
- 9:19whatever. I mean, you're fine, I guess. And her
- 9:22dad's like, so that's not who you are. Where
- 9:25is my daughter? And they're looking for her.
- 9:27And the main people who go looking for her are
- 9:30her, I think, uncle, the governor? Governor Dennard.
- 9:34This is Frank Morgan. Oh, that's not her uncle.
- 9:37Oh, it's not her uncle? No, he's the governor
- 9:39in New Orleans. Okay, yes. So he's the governor
- 9:42of New Orleans, and he is looking with her also
- 9:46with Elsa Lanchester. Which is super cool, because
- 9:49that means you have... The Wizard of Oz and the
- 9:52Bride of Frankenstein trying to hunt down Naughty
- 9:55Marietta. Which is, and you know what? Elsa Lanchester
- 9:58is a chameleon in the sense that sometimes I
- 10:01don't really see her and I'm like, that's the
- 10:02bride. Yeah. But I mean, you know, she's really
- 10:04great at a number of roles. Frank Morgan, I'm
- 10:07not discrediting his performance or, you know,
- 10:10his acting ability. But there's something about
- 10:12his voice specifically that as soon as he speaks,
- 10:15I'm like, that's the Wizard of Oz. Right. Like,
- 10:17that's just the first thing I'm going to think
- 10:18of every time. He kind of. through his words
- 10:21a little bit. And at first I thought this was
- 10:24who the wizard was. And then I watched, I just
- 10:26got my head in the song of if ever there was
- 10:29a wizard was whatever. So, but in this, as soon
- 10:33as the governor starts speaking and he does that
- 10:35kind of like the stumbling you're talking about
- 10:37of, well, I, well, you know, that thing, it feels
- 10:42so like I'm in the wizard of Oz right now. And.
- 10:45It's funny, I read that he was not happy about
- 10:48doing this because he had to shave his mustache.
- 10:51The amount of times that I've had to shave for
- 10:55a role on set. Oh, sure. And there's a, oh, what
- 11:00show was it? Bruce Campbell was in it recently,
- 11:03and it was like a horror show. It's not Creepshow,
- 11:07right? No, it had one season, I think it was
- 11:10on Hulu. Oh, okay. I think it started with an
- 11:13H. It was about like the satanic panic in the
- 11:1780s. But there was one time where I had to shave
- 11:21everything but my mustache to play a parent.
- 11:25And man, I am not a mustache guy. Can I ask you,
- 11:29how do you feel about your facial hair? Is it
- 11:31like, obviously, if you have to shave, you're
- 11:33going to, but how do you feel about? I think
- 11:35I prefer to have like a short beard. But it's
- 11:39so often that I have to shave it that I'm like,
- 11:41yeah, I'm kind of indifferent for the most part.
- 11:43But if I have a choice, I keep it long. I think
- 11:46it's smart to keep it like you are right now.
- 11:48Because if they ever need someone who has a beard,
- 11:50you're like, well, hey, I'm getting into it.
- 11:52Right. And if they need someone who's clean shaven,
- 11:53I can be clean shaven in like 30 minutes. Right.
- 11:55The funny thing with that show after I had the
- 11:58mustache is two days later, they were like, hey,
- 12:01can you play a high schooler? So I had to shave
- 12:04the mustache as well. And then it was just like.
- 12:06It was like a reverse Pokemon evolution. What
- 12:09I think is funny about you playing a high schooler
- 12:10after having a mustache is you probably shouldn't
- 12:13have shaved your entire mustache. You probably
- 12:16should have like plucked out like a hundred of
- 12:18the like 130 hairs. Yeah. And then like just
- 12:21keep the other ones and be like, hi. And they're
- 12:23like, great. High schooler. Yeah. They get really
- 12:26mad when I. When I do that. When you do the what?
- 12:29When I leave like a little bit and I'm like,
- 12:31this is what I look like. And they're like, we
- 12:33don't care. But anyway, I feel Frank Morgan's
- 12:36pain is what I'm trying to say. Yeah. I mean,
- 12:38clearly he still gives one incredible performance
- 12:42here in what he's doing. He's kind of the comedic
- 12:45relief in this. I think he's very funny. He's
- 12:47very funny. I mean, I think everyone kind of
- 12:49has a little bit of comedic to them to where
- 12:52this is kind of a comedy. You're right, this
- 12:54is a musical. But it's also worth pointing out
- 12:56that this is a musical in the same sense that
- 12:58One Night of Love was a musical. Because that
- 13:01was an opera. And this is based on an opera as
- 13:04well. Specifically, the original operetta opened
- 13:07in London October 24th, 1910. I believe it was
- 13:10of the same name, Naughty Mariana. So you're
- 13:13right that Jeanette MacDonald, we've seen her
- 13:15sing before, but we haven't really seen or heard
- 13:17her like this. Because the Lubitsch musicals
- 13:21really are just more kind of like, you know,
- 13:23I mean, I don't know how to describe this, but
- 13:25it's like a normal singing for a musical. It's
- 13:28like sing -songy. Sing -songy. That's the right
- 13:30phrase. Thank you. In this, it is operatic, where
- 13:34every song is an opera and the singing requires
- 13:36that. And Jeanette MacDonald is up for the task.
- 13:39And she does really well. This does feel a lot
- 13:43of like a call and response to something like
- 13:45One Night of Love, to where, hey, that did really
- 13:48well. Why don't we try this? And I got to tell
- 13:50you, I'm not as big of a fan. It's something
- 13:52about the opera. Right? I think the movie is
- 13:55completely fine. It's not a bad movie by any
- 13:58means. But something about the opera and this
- 14:01specific movie is not available on demand. This
- 14:04is not something that you can go out and get
- 14:05the... I didn't find any physical copy of this.
- 14:08DVD or Blu -ray. There is a Warner Archive copy.
- 14:12There is. Yeah, a DVD. And there's also a box
- 14:15set of Nelson... I almost said Nettie Elson.
- 14:20Nelson, Eddie, and Jeanette McDonald. It's like
- 14:22a four -pack movie. Okay. So I looked up Naughty
- 14:27Marietta on Blu -ray. Nothing. I typed in Nani
- 14:30Marietta into my Google search and I had to wipe
- 14:33my Google search. And I couldn't find any other
- 14:37DVD or Blu -ray announcement of it. So I'm glad
- 14:39you did the research there. But we had to find
- 14:41it through other means. And that other means
- 14:43did not allow us to have closed captioning. So
- 14:47with closed captioning not being an option and
- 14:50it being an opera, a lot of those words and phrases
- 14:54are kind of lost to time. It made it to where
- 14:58I just wasn't as interested because I couldn't
- 15:01really understand what they were conveying in
- 15:04the song. Sure. Right? In Lubitsch musicals and
- 15:06other musicals we've seen, you can follow along
- 15:08and be like, oh, this is them like proclaiming
- 15:10their love, doing this. The only time this is
- 15:13really noticeable, or not noticeable, but the
- 15:15only time this is really not a problem is whenever
- 15:17Warrington is on a, I think it's a little canoe,
- 15:21like a boat, tiny little boat with him and Marie.
- 15:24uh he sings i think it was i'm falling in love
- 15:28with someone that song pretty clear and it's
- 15:31because warrenton i don't think is super known
- 15:33for his operatic singing voice i say warrenton
- 15:36nelson eddie i don't know he's he's hitting some
- 15:39some notes oh he's good yeah i'm just saying
- 15:41in comparison to like jeanette mcdonald he was
- 15:43like i am uh was it grace more from Grace Moore,
- 15:47yes. Yeah, One Night of Love. Yeah, I don't know
- 15:50what it is about operas. It's just, it's hard
- 15:52to hook me. And this is an hour and 40 minutes,
- 15:55but it felt like it could have been over two
- 15:56because it's just, it is a wide scope of a story.
- 16:00I understand like the, it's hard to follow along
- 16:03with the opera songs. I agree with that. As cool
- 16:05as it is that this was nominated for sound recording
- 16:07and it did in fact win for that, it is very hard
- 16:11to make things out. And you can't really blame
- 16:13the movie for that because you are like, You're
- 16:16limited by certain technologies and things. Sure.
- 16:18I wanted to give the movie a fighting chance.
- 16:21So I pulled up the lyrics to all of the songs
- 16:24so I could kind of like Disney sing along. Oh,
- 16:27sure. Bouncing ball. Yeah. And it does help just
- 16:30so you can. understand the story otherwise it's
- 16:32like you're you're watching a movie in a different
- 16:34language that's what it is yeah and you're right
- 16:37you always want to give the movie a little bit
- 16:38of a chance and that's why i always do closed
- 16:40captions when i can right because i want to like
- 16:43hey i know the sound recording wasn't the best
- 16:44back then i'm not going to judge it off that
- 16:46so i'm still going to try and follow the story
- 16:48i wasn't able to yeah it's a really good idea
- 16:50looking up the lyrics to the songs i should have
- 16:52thought about that how did that help you i mean
- 16:54it really it really did help you can't deny the
- 16:57impressiveness of the singing in this movie I'm
- 17:01not going to go back and like bop around to the
- 17:03songs or anything. They're more just impressive.
- 17:05But being able to see the lyrics and know what
- 17:08they're saying obviously helped quite a bit.
- 17:11And it does give you a better idea of the story
- 17:14itself. So I don't know. In no world am I going
- 17:18to be like. Ryan, you should have pulled up the
- 17:20lyrics. Come on, because you're watching a movie.
- 17:24In theory, you shouldn't have to do that. Exactly.
- 17:25Even with closed captioning, you shouldn't have
- 17:27to do that. But the exception we've made for
- 17:29that is this is the 1930s. So sound recording
- 17:32is not, and even some of the prints, unless we're
- 17:34watching a restorative copy of it, it's not going
- 17:39to have the perfect quality for us to hear. So
- 17:41you've already made exceptions for that. But
- 17:43closed captioning is kind of the thing that has
- 17:45helped it. And again, not available when this
- 17:47isn't, you know, on physical, if you don't have
- 17:50it on physical release. So it is possible for
- 17:52you to do that and not need this. But to your
- 17:54point, with it being an opera, so much of the
- 17:57narrative is in that song. And you're missing
- 18:00those words. Absolutely. Now, maybe this is a
- 18:02scenario where someone listens to the opera all
- 18:04the time and they watch this movie and they're
- 18:05like. Get good nerds. Like, I don't want to tell
- 18:07you. How do you not know this? Exactly. How can
- 18:09you not hear the exact, like, tone and intonation
- 18:12of what they're saying? The Muppets make a reference
- 18:14to this in season two. Not just the Muppets.
- 18:17Young Frankenstein. Oh, yes. I love how this
- 18:20movie is referenced over time. Yeah. Specifically,
- 18:23you're talking about, is it Awesweet Mysteries
- 18:25of Life? Yes. Yeah. Madeline Kahn sings it. Yep,
- 18:29which is funny because she is portraying, well,
- 18:32she's in Young Frankenstein, and she references
- 18:34this movie that features the Bride of Frankenstein.
- 18:36Oh, yeah, yeah. And she plays the Bride of Frankenstein.
- 18:39There you go. It's so crazy. Very funny how that
- 18:42works out. And then, of course, yeah, The Muppet
- 18:44Show. I think Piggy references wanting to do
- 18:46Naughty Marietta as a production. It's a very
- 18:50well -known, beloved musical. many references
- 18:54it's not just those two right tons of references
- 18:56through time i think bobby hill says something
- 18:58about it too is this when the this flower is
- 19:01wielding so it might be yeah i i think overall
- 19:04like i was kind of into the story i didn't think
- 19:08i was going to be because this almost feels very
- 19:11similar to ruggles of red gap where it is kind
- 19:15of like okay a fish out of water this is a french
- 19:17princess who ends up in the united states in
- 19:22new orleans And now she's kind of leading this
- 19:24like secret life, which is different than Ruggles,
- 19:27but still very similar in this like, okay, this
- 19:30is a new life for me, a new world. And the music,
- 19:34like I said, isn't my cup of tea, but it was
- 19:36impressive enough that I enjoyed it. I think
- 19:39the most exciting thing for me with this is it
- 19:43feels like it is cut from the same cloth that
- 19:48every early Disney film was cut from. This style
- 19:53of musical where they will have a conversation
- 19:55and live their normal life and then break out
- 19:58into song feels exactly like Snow White or Sleeping
- 20:03Beauty. I'll give you a perfect example. I think
- 20:06we talked. This movie owes a lot to One Night
- 20:08of Love. The opening of this movie is Princess
- 20:12Marie walking outside, and she's surrounded by
- 20:15at least 30 people. And they're all just talking,
- 20:18and she's talking with them, and they're all
- 20:19kind of laughing. And they break out into song.
- 20:22And this feels very Beauty and the Beast. Yes.
- 20:25A lot of what we talked about, like one night
- 20:27of love with like that whole sequence of her
- 20:28singing in the village and everyone singing back
- 20:30with her. And in this, that scene specifically
- 20:33of the lead up to that, where it's her walking
- 20:35outside and everyone's in very nice dress for
- 20:38like colonial times. And they are just like the
- 20:41way that they all interact and talk. It just
- 20:43feels very like you can almost feel the music
- 20:46in the background. well that's a very good question
- 20:49yes it just you can feel the lead up of like
- 20:52oh there's a song coming and that's not a bad
- 20:54thing but it's exactly what you're talking about
- 20:56where like it sets up that trope of what like
- 20:58disney musicals tend to be yeah so i i hear you
- 21:01100 and when you say musicals to me i'm not even
- 21:03thinking like the animated movies it's like the
- 21:05mary poppins the newsies like yeah it feels like
- 21:09it is a setup yes totally I'm so excited. Or
- 21:13rather it has a setup. I don't mean it's like
- 21:15a bait and switch. Right. But yeah. We've got
- 21:17the whole place surrounded. I'm really excited
- 21:20for when we, years from now, get to Beauty and
- 21:23the Beast because that was nominated. And it's
- 21:26going to be wild to look back at all of the musicals
- 21:30that we've covered up to that point and see like,
- 21:33even now I'm almost having an understanding of,
- 21:37okay, Disney was just doing the same thing that
- 21:40everybody else was. They were making musicals,
- 21:42but they were making them bright and colorful
- 21:46and kind of doing things that you couldn't do
- 21:49at this point. Yes. If you haven't been watching
- 21:51along, we're still watching black and white films.
- 21:53Yeah. So, yeah, I just have almost like a different
- 21:56perspective of Disney films now. Well, and I
- 22:00think they found something and stayed consistent.
- 22:03I think that there's a Disney brand. The funny
- 22:05thing is that you really can't say there's an
- 22:07MGM brand or there's a Universal brand. Sure,
- 22:10there's Universal Monsters, but you can't say
- 22:12that the way you can say that about Disney. And
- 22:15again, the kind of Disney we're talking about,
- 22:17you can say there's Disney Animation brand, there's
- 22:19Disney Pixar brand, there's Walt Disney Musical
- 22:23brand. Yeah, now for sure. Now for sure. And
- 22:25that stands out to me. And that's why I think...
- 22:29that Disney was able to kind of capitalize on
- 22:31this because a lot of what they did back then
- 22:32was specifically in this genre and they stayed
- 22:36consistent. Other studios, they're kind of branching
- 22:39out and saying, well, hey, we're going to do
- 22:40noir. We're going to do this. Yeah. Disney was
- 22:43a bit different. So again, that's not what's
- 22:45happening right now. That's what's going to happen
- 22:47right now in 1935. That's what's going to end
- 22:52up happening. I think that's why we have that
- 22:54connotation. I do want to point out when we're
- 22:56talking about the music, Victor Herbert was the
- 22:58original composer for this with the music. Now,
- 23:01this was for the operetta, that he did the music.
- 23:05So the music was used for this film specifically.
- 23:08But the plot is like vastly different than the
- 23:10original. Yeah, they shifted a lot. They did.
- 23:12Cut characters as well, if I remember correctly.
- 23:15They did. Yeah, they cut characters out. And
- 23:17Rita Johnson Young's lyrics were changed as well.
- 23:20So the music is the same, but they changed some
- 23:22of the lyrics for this. So this really is more
- 23:25of an adaptation than it is like, you know, we've
- 23:27put it on the screen. Sure. It really is just
- 23:30more like, hey, cool. That was fun inspiration
- 23:31for what we're going to go do. Yeah. So very
- 23:34different. So obviously with the screenplay,
- 23:36that's going to be pretty different if you're
- 23:37changing the lyrics. you're changing the story
- 23:38pretty significantly. John Lee Mann, Francis
- 23:41Goodrich, and Albert Hackett are the three screenplay
- 23:44writers for this who adapted this for the screen.
- 23:47This was one that I couldn't get a tone. I think
- 23:51the tone of this movie to me felt kind of all
- 23:53over the place because you're right. We open
- 23:56in France and we see a princess and she's going
- 23:58to get married, but she wants to leave. So she
- 24:01gets on a ship and there's a whole sequence of
- 24:03like, hey, I don't know if I'm going to be able
- 24:04to leave because they've already spotted me here.
- 24:06And then they're like, Never mind. So long. And
- 24:09she takes off. Yeah. And she's now on the sea.
- 24:11And you're like, great. She's on her way to New
- 24:13Orleans. I wonder what you're going to come across
- 24:15in this time period when you're sailing from
- 24:19France to New Orleans. And then pirates show
- 24:21up. And pirates show up. It's kind of like they're
- 24:26dressed very almost comically. There's a guy
- 24:28in a vest and he has a tattoo on his stomach.
- 24:30Very stereotypical. Very, very, very stereotypical.
- 24:34And this feels kind of like. the pirates might
- 24:38like break out in a song and then hit him with
- 24:40a little bit of like hearing that a woman is
- 24:43shot and killed it's crazy it's that was the
- 24:47biggest just jaw drop i think i've gotten the
- 24:50entire run of the podcast i this man pulls out
- 24:54what it and you know that whole thing where like
- 24:56you kind of exaggerate in your memory now when
- 24:59like you caught a fish and it was like a little
- 25:00minnow yeah then like five years later you're
- 25:02like so i caught a sea bass right I don't know.
- 25:05I watched this movie yesterday. So I don't think
- 25:07I'm doing it that exaggerated. This man pulls
- 25:10out the biggest gun I've ever seen. It's like
- 25:12a cannon. You're right. Here's my blunderbuss.
- 25:15Yes. He pulls out a blunderbuss and then shoots
- 25:18this woman. And it just cuts to black. And then
- 25:21it opens on them. They've gotten on land. And
- 25:23they're holding all the women on the ship hostage.
- 25:26And we move on from her death instantly. It's
- 25:31so quick. And I'm sure this is, like, a censor
- 25:33issue where it's like, hey, you really can't
- 25:34show, like, a lot of people dying. We'll talk
- 25:36about that in our next episode. Yeah. And I don't
- 25:39know what the censor was around that. But they
- 25:42move on so quickly to where, like, five minutes
- 25:44later, Warrington and Princess Marie are, like,
- 25:47singing. And I was like, a woman's dead. Right.
- 25:49Like, not even was she shot and wounded. She's
- 25:52gone from this earth. And you're just like, oh.
- 25:55The body's still warm, guys. Yeah, it was. so
- 25:59crazy and it comes out of well i don't want to
- 26:02say it comes out of nowhere because pirates did
- 26:03just board the ship and like they take out the
- 26:06entire crew it's just they don't really show
- 26:09that or if they do it's like our avast we're
- 26:12battling people are probably dying it's implied
- 26:15but with this it really is like she's begging
- 26:18for the lives of all of the women and he's just
- 26:21like nah Well, she is almost like a, I'm not
- 26:25sure of the term, but like a matriarchal character.
- 26:27Like she's kind of like taking care of them or
- 26:29the head mother or something. Yeah, I think she
- 26:32was the one that was going to like set them up
- 26:34out in New Orleans. Oh, sure. Like a ranger.
- 26:38Yes. There's got to be a word for that. There
- 26:39definitely is. I don't know what it is. And unfortunately,
- 26:42she can't tell me. Cupid. Yeah, she's like, she's
- 26:45cute. My God, that pirate shot Cupid. He did.
- 26:48He's like, I hate love. She had her bow in air
- 26:50and he's like, bet. He did the Indiana Jones.
- 26:54Yes, exactly. You know what? You bring up a good
- 26:57point that they cut to black and then it opens
- 26:59up with like them. They have like landed ashore.
- 27:01So who knows what happened in between that time?
- 27:03There's no time period to say, you know, the
- 27:05next day it's still dark out. So you think this
- 27:08is probably the same night and it just. It only
- 27:12conveys that one person was really hurt, which
- 27:14again, if there's a whole number of people that
- 27:16were hurt and killed, maybe she's moved on a
- 27:19little differently and it's like you grieve a
- 27:21different way. This is someone who has not been
- 27:23surrounded by death, is my understanding. And
- 27:26a pirate coming on board their ship and shooting
- 27:28and killing a woman just feels like when you
- 27:30watch the rest of the movie, you're like, what
- 27:31happened in this movie? Yeah, I wonder how common
- 27:35death is during this time period. You know, if
- 27:39it's like, oh, my God, he's dead. Anyway. Yeah.
- 27:42You got to move on. You know, you got to keep
- 27:44surviving. And I'm with you on that. But at the
- 27:47same time, I think death and shot and murdered
- 27:50by a pirate. Yeah. I classify those as two different
- 27:54things. She's a strong woman. You know, she survived
- 27:58and she's got to keep surviving. How do you do
- 28:02that? I want so badly for the last 15 minutes
- 28:05of this movie. For her to have a speech, a monologue
- 28:08to warrant it and be like, I am a strong, independent
- 28:10woman. Things happen to me and I move on. You
- 28:13tell me I'm going to get married, I'm going to
- 28:15flee my country. He's like, yep. You tell me
- 28:17that I can't do something, I'm going to do it
- 28:19anyways. He's like, yeah, that makes sense. You
- 28:21shoot a woman in front of me and kill her, I'm
- 28:23going to move on. He's like, what? When did that
- 28:26happen? Stop there for a second. What was that
- 28:28last part? Do I need to call the police? Well,
- 28:30it wasn't a pirate or anything. She's like, it
- 28:31was a pirate. Yeah. We got to have a conversation.
- 28:33I need to know a little bit more about that.
- 28:35The woman was a pirate? No. Back up. You're taking
- 28:39the wrong thing away from this story. Yeah. This
- 28:41was just like. It was wild. Totally a little
- 28:43all over the place. And I want to say it's just
- 28:46kind of like at the 40 % mark. Like this movie
- 28:50goes on too long. Which, you know, is kind of
- 28:53part of the course now for movies this time period.
- 28:56Yeah. Especially something like We Felt the Same
- 28:58Way About One Night of Love, where it just continues
- 29:00to go. Yeah, yeah. And I felt a similar thing
- 29:03from this. But when I say tonally all over the
- 29:05place, I don't think it's tonally inconsistent
- 29:08for 100 % of the movie. I think when it finds
- 29:11its tone, which is shortly after she arrives
- 29:14in New Orleans, proper, I think that's when the
- 29:17tone is really found and it stays. Sure. It is
- 29:21inconsistent up until that point. So for me,
- 29:24I just had such a tough time getting into this.
- 29:27This felt like, like I said, just kind of like
- 29:29the cookie cutter Disney plot. I think there's
- 29:32a lot of stuff here that I was surprised was
- 29:34in it since we are in like the Hays Code era.
- 29:38I mean, the murder of the woman, of course. But
- 29:40then there's also the implication that like,
- 29:43you know, the pirates have all of these women
- 29:45and they're about to take them for themselves.
- 29:47But then there. Like Frank Morgan has a lot of
- 29:51jokes about how he's very interested in Marietta
- 29:55and some of the other girls. And Elsa Lanchester,
- 29:58his wife in this film, the entire time is just
- 30:01like, chill out. Yeah. Chill out, bro. Leave
- 30:03it alone. Yeah. Did you forget we're together?
- 30:05She's very funny. But all of that, like the jokes
- 30:09about infidelity and things, I was surprised
- 30:11to see all of those. And I guess those are the
- 30:12things where if you were to make an animated
- 30:15Disney version of this, it'd be like, we probably
- 30:17should cut some of this stuff out. It feels like
- 30:19an unsanitized Disney musical. Yeah. Yeah. But
- 30:23I think the fact that it followed that formula,
- 30:26I was kind of into this and I was having fun
- 30:29with it. I want to talk about some of the technical
- 30:32elements of this movie. And we can start with
- 30:34sound because it was nominated and it did win.
- 30:36The first indication I had of sound just being
- 30:40noticeable in this movie is when she's still
- 30:43back in Paris. And she's talking to Julia or
- 30:47Marietta, questionable. But she's in the aviary
- 30:51of the palace or wherever it is she's staying.
- 30:54And there are birds chirping like crazy. And
- 30:58I thought the sound mixing here was so unbalanced.
- 31:01I was trying to hear the conversation and these
- 31:03birds are just going off, like screaming at the
- 31:06top of their lungs. Did you notice? The birds?
- 31:09Oh, yeah. I mean, it's hard not to. Yeah, it's
- 31:12wild. You notice the sound of it, but also they
- 31:14have a giant room behind her. They've built like
- 31:18a giant cage. It's almost like a sunroom. But
- 31:21what she does is she finds a bird and she opens
- 31:22the door and lets them in to join the other birds
- 31:24and then closes it. And there are no less than
- 31:27like 75 to 100 birds in this thing just flying
- 31:31around chirping. So while she's talking, it's
- 31:33like, I need you to move to a different room
- 31:35because you've already established giant bird
- 31:37room. Yes. The tiki room, if you will, the enchanted
- 31:41tiki room behind you, is going off. It is stuck
- 31:44on replay. And you are continuing to talk, and
- 31:47I need you to give it a second. And it's also
- 31:49a little, like, ham -fisted in, like, the way
- 31:52that they try to show some stuff. So when she's
- 31:54like, I gotta get out of here. I gotta break
- 31:56free. I gotta leave. A window opens in the bird
- 31:59room, and all the birds fly out. And I was like,
- 32:01okay. Yeah, it's very... like you've already
- 32:05subtle it's not subtle and that's the thing is
- 32:07that she's already like announced her escape
- 32:08like i i'm leaving if you had her kind of like
- 32:12wondering like looking around kind of like wondering
- 32:14silently to herself what she's gonna do and then
- 32:16that shot happens you're like great i understand
- 32:18she's flying the coop like she's leaving or as
- 32:21she stands up and runs the birds are spooked
- 32:24and they also fly at the same time. Totally.
- 32:26Like something that can like symbolize that and
- 32:28be a little more subtle. But when you have the
- 32:30line announcing that you're doing this and that
- 32:32happening, it just feels like, yeah, I know.
- 32:35It felt more like an insert than an actual moment
- 32:39in the movie. Like it felt like something that
- 32:40they wrote. And then afterwards they're like,
- 32:42well, that's not clear enough. We need to add
- 32:44this line in, but they still keep that shot anyways.
- 32:46Yeah. It just didn't work really for me, but
- 32:49the audio you're right. Like it was something
- 32:51that to me was. It was just distracting. Yeah,
- 32:54it was weird. I was like, okay, I'm looking for
- 32:57the things that this was nominated for, just
- 32:59sound recording, really. And when I got to that
- 33:01point, I was like, huh, it is so distracting
- 33:04at this moment. The next time that I was aware
- 33:09of the sound, this was very cool to me, the song
- 33:13Owl and the Bobcat, which is the first time you're
- 33:18really hearing Warrington sing. And he's kind
- 33:21of just going off and showing off. She is talking
- 33:25to another one of the casquette girls on the
- 33:27beach while he's performing. So it cuts back
- 33:30and forth between him singing and then her having
- 33:32a conversation. Right. And that's not really
- 33:35something we've seen in any of the musicals we've
- 33:38covered. It's kind of like, okay, we've set up
- 33:40the mics and everything for this musical performance.
- 33:43Nobody is going to have dialogue outside of that
- 33:47until the song is over. So I thought this was...
- 33:50probably one of the reasons this was nominated
- 33:52for sound recording because it was attempting
- 33:54this kind of new tactic, I guess. It's a good
- 33:57call out. I think that that's something that,
- 33:59you know, back then people were kind of amazed
- 34:01at, oh man, I didn't, I didn't know you could
- 34:03even do this. And now we've seen so many movies
- 34:06like this that we see that happen. And it's kind
- 34:08of just like, yeah, of course, right. That's
- 34:10a tracking shot. Yes, of course. This is a split
- 34:12diopter. Like we know those terms, but back then
- 34:15I imagine it was so impressive that like, It's
- 34:18not, hey, I didn't know that you could do this
- 34:19and this. It's more, I didn't know that while
- 34:21that's happening, you could go over here. Right.
- 34:23And that's what lends itself to sound recording.
- 34:25I think sound recording is one of those categories
- 34:28that I'm finding it extremely difficult to kind
- 34:31of fully judge. Because when we see things like
- 34:35the front page or something that's been fully
- 34:37restored, that's not the true sound recording
- 34:40back then. Sure. Right. So we're kind of judging
- 34:43like how good it sounds now. That's not how it
- 34:45sounded back then. So we kind of have to look
- 34:48a little bit more for, at least this is my understanding,
- 34:51it's a lot like the system director category.
- 34:53where we're kind of looking at the reasons that
- 34:55we think maybe they were nominated of. Was this
- 34:57a troubled shoot? Was there a lot for you to
- 35:00have to navigate and fix with this? Sound recording
- 35:02is a similar thing where I think you're right.
- 35:04We have to look at, well, have we done this before
- 35:07at this time period where we have someone singing,
- 35:09but then we also have two people to the side
- 35:11that we can hear very clearly. I think that's
- 35:13the right mindset we need to have when we talk
- 35:15about sound recording, because otherwise I feel
- 35:18like if I'm really impressed with sound, I'm
- 35:20like, okay, hold on. Was this restored? Like
- 35:22this Blu -ray copy that I'm watching. That's
- 35:24the tough thing. It's like you're either getting
- 35:26the 4K, it happened one night, and you're comparing
- 35:30apples to oranges at that point. Well, and specifically,
- 35:34I was like, wow, look at the shimmer on that
- 35:36river that they're crossing, and it happened
- 35:37one night. And then I'm like, well, that's definitely
- 35:39digitally re -added. Right. And that's one of
- 35:42the, this is kind of a tangent, that's one of
- 35:44the reasons I'm not big on like 4K restorations
- 35:48of a certain era of film. Because at that point,
- 35:52I'm like, this isn't how you were supposed to
- 35:55watch this movie. I think you were onto something
- 35:57when we talked about White Parade, where it's
- 35:58like, you should give me the restored stuff,
- 36:00but you should also include the original. Yeah.
- 36:02And if it's incomplete, that's fine. And if it
- 36:05doesn't look as good, that's okay, too. I just
- 36:06kind of want the original version that was out
- 36:08there. Right. Because that's really cool to say,
- 36:10hey, this was the original copy. So I don't think
- 36:13that's going to happen as much. I'd love to see
- 36:15it happen more often. But... That's just kind
- 36:18of a slight tangent of what I've noticed with
- 36:21sound recording, which is I think that you're
- 36:23dead on that we have to be focusing on seeing
- 36:25the challenges of some things. I think that there's
- 36:28some Tubi movies that I'll watch where I was
- 36:29like, oh, this is the original sound recording.
- 36:31And I can judge it off that for sure. But mostly
- 36:33now we're getting into the late 30s, early 40s,
- 36:37and I think we're going to see more restorations.
- 36:39And that's going to make things a little more
- 36:42complicated when it comes to sound recording.
- 36:43So we'll see. Right, yeah. But that's just a
- 36:46side thing that I noticed. Some of the other
- 36:48things that really stood out to me outside of
- 36:50sound recording that I'm kind of bummed that
- 36:53they didn't get nominated. One, it's always shocking
- 36:56when a musical is nominated for Best Picture
- 36:58or Outstanding Production and doesn't get a nomination.
- 37:02Again, neither one of us were huge fans of this
- 37:04music in general. But at the same time, it's
- 37:08a musical, nominated, but they didn't like the
- 37:10music enough to nominate it. So that's always
- 37:12just... interesting to me you know it's weird
- 37:14because we talk about one night of love last
- 37:16week wow last year and that had uh not only been
- 37:22recognized for its score but it was nominated
- 37:24for the score as well so you would think if we're
- 37:27doing such a similar thing that the score here
- 37:29would also be recognized And it wasn't. Song
- 37:32-wise, I think you can easily say that Ah, Sweet
- 37:34Mysteries of Life is probably the most recognizable.
- 37:37Yeah. But I can't speak to whether or not that's
- 37:40truly an original song for this. Yeah, I think
- 37:42that comes from the operetta. Right. So then
- 37:45it couldn't be nominated for Best Song there.
- 37:47Now, maybe it could because it's not an original
- 37:49song. Right. It is just listed as song. But I
- 37:52think the anticipation is that it would be something
- 37:55that's written for the movie. I'm excited for
- 37:57the ceremony episode where we can dive into what
- 37:59was nominated and why. There's a lot to talk
- 38:02about with this movie and next week's movie.
- 38:03Yeah. The set design, though. This is MGM. So,
- 38:08again, we had Douglas Shearer show up for sound
- 38:10recording. But there are multiple names now.
- 38:12And I think I do it more with MGM than I do with
- 38:15any other studio. Where, oh, this is an MGM movie?
- 38:19Sound recording? I know that's Douglas Shearer.
- 38:21Right. Oh. The set design, I know it's going
- 38:24to be Cedric Gibbons. And I love Cedric Gibbons.
- 38:27Again, we've talked about him with The Wizard
- 38:29of Oz and many, many of his other movies, things
- 38:32that we've covered a million times or, you know,
- 38:35we've brought his name up a million times on
- 38:36the show. And while it wasn't nominated here,
- 38:40there's so much of this movie that just looks
- 38:42fantastic. I don't think anybody does an interior
- 38:45set like Cedric Gibbons during this time period.
- 38:48The nice thing about it being so all over the
- 38:50place and tonally inconsistent is that it calls
- 38:53for a lot of different scenes. And a lot of different
- 38:55sceneries. So you have France. You have a boat.
- 38:58You have pirates. You have an island. You have
- 39:01New Orleans. You have a lot that you can do.
- 39:04And Cedric Gibbons is up for the task. This is
- 39:07why I think production design. is going to be
- 39:09such an important thing when that's introduced.
- 39:11Yeah. But for the time being with it not being
- 39:13there, you kind of look at more art direction.
- 39:15And I think at that time it was kind of considered
- 39:17like backdrops art direction was. Right, the
- 39:20matte paintings and all that. Matte paintings.
- 39:21And there's just not a ton of that here. So the
- 39:24design itself is great. It's just there's not
- 39:26a ton of art design. It's more the production.
- 39:29Yeah. I mean, there is. Oh, no, that's recent
- 39:32that I'm thinking the set design and all of that.
- 39:34Yeah. I just feel like his name doesn't show
- 39:37up nearly enough at the Academy. And he's one
- 39:40of the most decorated art designers of all time.
- 39:46Artists? Minor stroke. Yeah, yeah. And so, I
- 39:50don't know. Like, all of the scenes that take
- 39:53place on the ship were very cool to me. When
- 39:55she's first singing her send -off song, I think
- 39:59it's called Prayer. And all of the visuals of
- 40:01people, like... letting the sails down and doing
- 40:05all the ship things that i don't know the terms
- 40:07for it was really exciting and cool and it did
- 40:10feel like like you were setting off on this adventure
- 40:13with them and i think without those those really
- 40:17cool heightened ship action scenes It wouldn't
- 40:21have that same feel with just the song and them
- 40:23standing on the side of the boat. And I don't
- 40:24even know if that's part of the set design, but
- 40:26I enjoyed it. I like the pirate ship stuff. Would
- 40:29you say that a portion of this movie was nautical?
- 40:33Yeah, there's a little section of it that's definitely
- 40:36ship warfare. Wouldn't it be funny if this was
- 40:39called Naughty Marietta because she was just
- 40:42nautical for half the movie? You know, her full
- 40:44name, as I mentioned, was Princess Marie de Nemours.
- 40:49Uh -oh. The Submariner. Uh -oh. Watch out. Where?
- 40:55That was her. Yeah. Underwater. Yeah. Where's
- 40:59Sue Storm when you need her? Is that right? Sue
- 41:01Storm? Yeah. Yeah. One of my favorites. Yeah,
- 41:04because Johnny Storm. One of my favorite little
- 41:06panels from an old Fantastic Four thing is the
- 41:09Sue Storm thing. This has nothing to do with
- 41:11anything. But it's a guy commenting, I think,
- 41:14on her haircut. And her response is, beat it,
- 41:17repulsive. And I think about that a lot. I love
- 41:22that anyone who's listening to this that may
- 41:25have a bit of X -Men slash Fantastic Four knowledge
- 41:28is just absolutely thrilled. It's got to be that
- 41:32Leo meme pointing at the screen. They did it.
- 41:35They referenced the Sub -Mariner. They did it.
- 41:39The most famous Marvel superhero of all time.
- 41:41And the guy who created him is like, is he? Yeah,
- 41:46he's like, is he in the top 20? I haven't gotten
- 41:47my due. Yeah, so you're right in that Cedric
- 41:52Gibbons isn't being highlighted as much. However,
- 41:55I think that's the fun of looking at this historically
- 41:58from the beginning to the end is, or I shouldn't
- 42:01say the end, to now, is that we, we're fine,
- 42:05it's okay, is that we get to see Over time, them
- 42:08realizing, wow, we're really kind of subbing
- 42:10this category, aren't we? We're not really paying
- 42:13respects where we need to. Because you heard
- 42:15so much about the music. You heard so much about
- 42:17the score. You heard so much about songs. And
- 42:19now we're seeing more and more of it. Sound is
- 42:22always going to be something that's focused a
- 42:24little bit more than anything else because it
- 42:25is the newest party trick. Right. Right? It is.
- 42:28And I say new. We've been talking about it for
- 42:30like five years now. Yeah. Well, five months.
- 42:33But at this point, it's been five years. That's
- 42:35going to get confusing. That's still a new party
- 42:38trick. Right. They're like, look what we can
- 42:40do. And now there's a lot of work for it. So
- 42:41let's recognize that. Over time, as these movies
- 42:44get bigger and bigger, they're going to be like,
- 42:46wow, this person has been doing this for so long
- 42:49and they're so recognized in this field. Maybe
- 42:51we need to put some kind of award there. Even
- 42:53to now, where like stunt work has been going
- 42:56on forever. And we're just starting to recognize
- 42:59stunt work. There's a lot of things that have
- 43:02been criminally overlooked for a long time. And
- 43:04Cedric Gibbons and his work has been appreciated
- 43:07by us and many other people, which is why he's
- 43:09continuing to get the work that he's getting.
- 43:11Right. But he won't be recognized for that for
- 43:13a pretty long time, unfortunately. Well, I mean,
- 43:17you're right with art direction, but with production
- 43:18design. Yeah, yeah. Speaking of another category,
- 43:22though, not getting recognized, we don't have
- 43:24a costume design in the Academy Awards yet. Right.
- 43:30the gowns were made by for this film. I didn't.
- 43:34So it's just like Douglas Shearer showing up
- 43:36and Cedric Gibbons showing up all the time for
- 43:38MGM. There is another gentleman who is constantly
- 43:42working on these MGM films and is so widely praised
- 43:47historically for his costume designs. It says
- 43:51gowns by Adrian. And he only goes by the name
- 43:54Adrian. And he has done so many movies up to
- 43:58this point. He's most known for working on the
- 44:02Ruby Slippers from The Wizard of Oz, which we'll
- 44:04talk about. Obviously, we'll talk about so many
- 44:07times for so many reasons. But I don't know if
- 44:10you heard, last year there was a film released.
- 44:12It's a Joan Crawford movie that came out in 1932.
- 44:16Letty Linton. It was just in theaters at the
- 44:20Plaza. like a month ago oh wow and this is a
- 44:23movie that there there was like a legal battle
- 44:26where they said oh this was plagiarism you can't
- 44:29show this movie anymore so it was pulled from
- 44:31the theaters and just distribution and circulation
- 44:34completely for years but now it's approaching
- 44:38the when that copyright is ending so it just
- 44:42last year by the great grand something of the
- 44:47director They were like, hey, it's okay. We can
- 44:50release this movie now because everything's kind
- 44:52of wrapping up. And it just got a wide release
- 44:55in theaters that the Plaza did, which is super
- 44:58cool. And it came out on 4K June 30th of this
- 45:04year. Oh, wow. Like just a few weeks ago. But
- 45:07Adrian did the dress for Joan Crawford in that
- 45:10movie. It's a white dress with like puffy sleeves.
- 45:12And that dress like shifted Hollywood fashion
- 45:16completely. So he's so well -known and beloved,
- 45:21and his name has popped up in movies that we've
- 45:24talked about, and we've just kind of glazed over
- 45:25it, and it's because there isn't a costume design
- 45:28category yet. So I thought that was super cool.
- 45:32Also, I was reading his wiki page, just getting
- 45:35some info, and he was married to Janet Gaynor.
- 45:39I went and I saw Janet Gaynor's grave. At the
- 45:44Hollywood Forever Cemetery? Yeah. She's buried
- 45:46right next to his grave. I have a picture of
- 45:48their graves together. Oh, that's so sweet. Isn't
- 45:50that crazy? Wow. I had no idea. When I was there,
- 45:53I snapped a photo and I was like, oh, Janet Gaynor
- 45:55and Adrian. I don't really know who that is.
- 45:58So the tombstone just says Adrian. That's it.
- 46:00And it has, you know, their birth and death dates.
- 46:02Right. But yeah. Yeah. And there are these two
- 46:04trees that were planted at the head of both of
- 46:06their tombstones that are just massive. I know
- 46:10we're going to cover A Star is Born with Janet
- 46:12Gaynor. Do we know if... She was styled by Adrian
- 46:14often, or was that just a partnership outside
- 46:16of the film? I don't know where she was contracted
- 46:20at this point. Oh, sure. I want to say she was
- 46:24with Paramount. Exclusive and MGM. Yeah. Yeah.
- 46:26Yeah. So I don't think so, because I think she
- 46:29was at Paramount throughout most of her career.
- 46:33But yeah, I just thought that was really cool.
- 46:35I think one thing that I really enjoy about what
- 46:38we've been able to do with this episode is that
- 46:39we've been able to highlight sound recording
- 46:42and the reason this was nominated, but at the
- 46:45same time also highlight some of the benefits
- 46:47of this movie. Benefits? I guess I'm trying to
- 46:50avoid the word highlight, but the highlight of
- 46:52this film, there were many other things, like
- 46:54the production design, the costume design. There's
- 46:57a lot to this that... The awards don't exist
- 47:00at this point. Right. So they deserve the recognition,
- 47:02but they haven't got them just yet. So it's very
- 47:04cool to see unsung heroes like Cedric Gibbons
- 47:07to a lesser extent, but more so Adrian and like
- 47:10the costume designers. Because this is a movie
- 47:12that is full of dresses. Elsa Lanchester's dresses
- 47:15are so cool. And I don't like this is the same
- 47:20year. She is in Bride of Frankenstein. Correct.
- 47:23So it's not like they're a callback to that movie
- 47:26and like a tribute to it, but they are like this
- 47:28monochromatic design. And they're so cool looking.
- 47:32They're definitely dressing her specifically
- 47:34well for the time. Yeah. Like, well, this is
- 47:37going to pop this way on the screen. And the
- 47:39way this gray or monochromatic is correct, but
- 47:42they're doing it intentionally to try and make
- 47:44sure that different things are highlighted. Yes.
- 47:46And she looks gorgeous in both. It's so cool.
- 47:49She's got the big hoop skirt and everything.
- 47:51I love the first dress she shows up in so much.
- 47:54It's so cool. But yeah, I mean, and when we say
- 47:58unsung heroes, like. We know these are such just
- 48:02acclaimed artists now, historically, it's just
- 48:05wild because there were no categories or the
- 48:08categories were kind of analyzed in a different
- 48:10way. Like they're not showing up as often, especially
- 48:12Adrian. Yeah. I'd say unsung for this movie though.
- 48:15Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, that too. So I, yeah,
- 48:19I just thought that was interesting. And this
- 48:20movie, because there were so many things that
- 48:22I thought were impressive that weren't highlighted,
- 48:25it was a good opportunity to kind of. shy away
- 48:28from well not shy away we still talked about
- 48:30the movie but you know what i mean just call
- 48:32them out not not spend as much time with the
- 48:34movie but more on the background behind it yeah
- 48:36yeah i think that's great what what would you
- 48:39say is like the highlight of the movie overall
- 48:41or like we'll talk about the song like what was
- 48:44the best song because that really is what came
- 48:46out of this was the america's singing sweethearts
- 48:48yeah i mean i think all sweet mysteries of life
- 48:51i think that's the song in this i think what's
- 48:54very very close is that i'm falling in love with
- 48:56someone from warrington but nelson eddie singing
- 49:00that but i think awesweet mysteries of life is
- 49:03the best number in terms of like not just the
- 49:07song but like the actual like production of that
- 49:09scene and i also think that's the song that is
- 49:12it knows the song knows it's that girl Like it
- 49:16knows you're going to be singing this one when
- 49:18you leave to a point where like the theme of
- 49:20that shows up later to you and people are still
- 49:23humming it kind of later on. And you're right.
- 49:25Like this has existed well before the movie and
- 49:28it has existed well after as well. So I do think
- 49:32that's the song to me that sticks out the most.
- 49:34Yeah. It's the most memorable. And that is the
- 49:36finale song, correct? Correct. Yeah. So this
- 49:39is kind of like the spoiler for Moulin Rouge,
- 49:42like the come what may. where they come together
- 49:45at the end and they run away and live. That's
- 49:49Marietta and Warrington come together and find
- 49:52their romance. Correct. I thought you meant spoiler
- 49:54for the end of Moulin Rouge. Yeah, that there's
- 49:57a Come What May song at the end of Moulin Rouge.
- 49:59Someone's watching Moulin Rouge and Come What
- 50:01May comes on like, well, I guess this is the
- 50:02end. Yeah, exactly. But that song comes up twice
- 50:06in that movie. So good luck for the fake out.
- 50:10So last thing I want to touch on here. Adriana
- 50:13Casalotti makes an uncredited appearance in this.
- 50:16And this is an actress who is not on screen in
- 50:20a lot of movies at all. I'm looking at her letterbox
- 50:23and she has 12 movies listed. Wow. She is the
- 50:27voice of Snow White in the 1937 Walt Disney film.
- 50:33Oh, wow. And when I saw she was listed and, you
- 50:36know, the trivia on IMDb is like... eagle -eyed
- 50:39viewers can spot blub blub uh adriana casaletti
- 50:42i was not eagle -eyed i did not see her but it
- 50:46is interesting to know that she was here i feel
- 50:47like if she spoke maybe part of me would be like
- 50:49oh that's no way yeah but even then i'd be like
- 50:52oh that's just a high -pitched voice Right. So
- 50:54probably not. Man, that's really interesting.
- 50:56Yeah. 12 movies on IMDb. That is like less than
- 51:00what some of these actors we're talking about
- 51:01did in one year. Yeah, exactly. And it was spread
- 51:05out. She was in It's a Wonderful Life at some
- 51:07point as well. Oh, interesting. Was she named
- 51:10or was she kind of a background? I don't know.
- 51:12Okay. We'll have to check when we get there.
- 51:15Yeah. Yeah. So getting into ratings here, I can
- 51:18agree with you that like the pairing of Jeanette
- 51:22mcdonald and nelson eddie they're not as intriguing
- 51:27to me as like another musical pairing of fred
- 51:31astaire and ginger rogers sure and i think a
- 51:33lot of that is with okay this is opera here not
- 51:36only is it my type of music but it's more difficult
- 51:39for me to follow along because it's just hard
- 51:43to hear the lyrics overall in opera in modern
- 51:45times but now we also have the sound working
- 51:47against us here so While I do think they're impressive
- 51:51on screen together, and I think like their chemistry
- 51:54is fine. It's not my favorite romance. The movie
- 51:58is fun. It plays out like a Disney movie to me.
- 52:01I think it has a good dose of like adventure,
- 52:03a good dose of comedy, especially with Frank
- 52:05Morgan and Elsa Lanchester. And all of the technical
- 52:09things that we touched on with Adrian's gowns,
- 52:12with... Cedric Gibbons, his art design and all
- 52:14of that. There was a lot here that I enjoyed.
- 52:16But overall, it felt like a kind of run of the
- 52:21mill Disney, early Disney film without the pop
- 52:25of the animation. So I gave this film three stars.
- 52:28Yeah, it's so funny. I feel like we're on the
- 52:31opposite end of the spectrum. I feel like with
- 52:33me, I really liked their chemistry enough to
- 52:37where hearing that this is the first of eight.
- 52:39run -ins for them uh known as you know the america's
- 52:42singing sweethearts i'm open to watching them
- 52:45do more and i maybe this was just the wrong movie
- 52:48so to me i kind of blame the movie more than
- 52:50i blame their relationship and i'm not to say
- 52:52that you put blame anywhere but i think you favored
- 52:54the movie over the chemistry between them I think
- 52:58I favored the chemistry over the movie because
- 53:00I just felt like this was totally all over the
- 53:02place. I didn't necessarily see the Disney thing
- 53:04as soon as you did. So to me, I wasn't able to
- 53:07make that comp. I went two stars on this. To
- 53:10me, this felt like it just was, it felt a bit
- 53:13reductive to be just a year, maybe even less
- 53:16from one night of love. Like, and it felt very
- 53:19similar in the story beats and how long it went
- 53:23on. And I just, I couldn't get into some parts
- 53:26of it. But I feel like Jeanette MacDonald is
- 53:28doing wonderfully. I've never, to my knowledge,
- 53:31we hadn't seen Nelson Eddy before in a nominated
- 53:34film. So I enjoyed his performance. I thought
- 53:37they're good together. I believed their relationship.
- 53:40But it just went on so long. I agree with you
- 53:42that Frank Morgan and Elsa Lanchester are fantastic
- 53:45with the comedic relief in this. So there's things
- 53:47I enjoyed about it. And it's not a bad movie
- 53:49by any means. But the things that do bring it
- 53:52down for me, I think, are the movie itself and
- 53:53not the acting. Sure. Yeah, two stars. Two stars
- 53:57feels low for this, but I understand. I understand.
- 54:00Yeah, maybe it's two and a half when I revisit
- 54:03it again or watch more of them. But I just, it
- 54:05wasn't. Here's what I'll say. Three stars sounds
- 54:08about right, but this is just so not for me.
- 54:11Sure. Right. That's fair. So it's not that it's
- 54:13a terrible movie. It's just, I couldn't get into
- 54:15it because the opera just tends to turn me away
- 54:18from it. But two stars felt honest to my experience
- 54:21without kind of giving it like a pity star. Yeah.
- 54:23And I didn't want to do that. I wanted to be
- 54:24honest. Well, the thing too is we have our. ratings
- 54:28and everything listed on our letterboxd and the
- 54:30way that i put the show's rating is i just average
- 54:34out the two so this will be two and a half it'll
- 54:36be two and a half it'll be i think right where
- 54:38it might truly deserve to be yeah i think you're
- 54:42a little high you're on it i'm a little lower
- 54:44i think if we meet in the middle with that that
- 54:46sounds about right where the movie actually you're
- 54:48a little bit country i'm a little bit rock and
- 54:50roll yeah wait Well, now you took both, so thanks.
- 54:53So I guess that makes me, who's rock and roll
- 54:56and country? Kid Rock? Oh, I don't want that.
- 55:00Take it back. You could be rock and roll and
- 55:03country. Now, Lynyrd Skynyrd. Okay, I'll take
- 55:07Lynyrd Skynyrd. I do want to be a cowboy, baby.
- 55:11Oh, yeah. Back in the sunshine shining. Cowboy.
- 55:16I can just say it again. I can smell a pig from
- 55:19a mile away. Wow, I didn't know that you were
- 55:23such a big kid rock fan. You know, man, when
- 55:26I was a kid... Rock. Exactly. That's all I have
- 55:29to say about that. That's all we should say about
- 55:31that. This is true, yeah. Double features. So,
- 55:35how are you feeling? Yeah, I'm going to start
- 55:38because mine... After as much Disney as I brought
- 55:41up in this, it almost feels a little uninspired.
- 55:43This is the updated one. The one you thought
- 55:46of. I decided to stick with my original. The
- 55:48other one felt like... I said pirate in the show
- 55:51once, and I was like, I know what I want to do.
- 55:54Curse of the Black Pearl. Already did that one.
- 55:57Oh, that's true. Well, good thing there's like
- 55:58five others. This is true. So I went with a Disney
- 56:01film animated because this really felt like that
- 56:04exact thing to me. And I went with a story of
- 56:08a woman who is about to be committed to a life
- 56:13that she does not want to be in, which is a pretty
- 56:15common trope in a Disney movie. But she decides
- 56:18to go off on her own little adventure and has
- 56:21to kind of hide and disguise herself a little
- 56:24bit. Yeah. So this isn't like a one -to -one
- 56:27double feature comparison, but I went with Mulan.
- 56:30Yeah, I think you got it. So who is that girl
- 56:32I see standing there in New Orleans? Wow. Look
- 56:36at you making that work. There we go. Man, this
- 56:39movie would have been so much better with Eddie
- 56:40Murphy. Wouldn't everyone? That's true. That's
- 56:44what the tour might... Paramount Studio Tour,
- 56:47there was a couple on that that they thought
- 56:50that. They loved Eddie Murphy. I was trying to
- 56:54look at all the Cleopatra jewelry, and they were
- 56:56like, oh, look, something from The Nutty Professor
- 56:582. And they were so giddy. It was strange. Anyway,
- 57:02your double feature. They love to party all the
- 57:04time. They do. Party all the time, party all
- 57:06the time. A reference I feel much better about
- 57:07making than kid rock songs. So for my double
- 57:10feature, I went with kind of a gender -bent swap
- 57:13on what happened with this movie. Specifically,
- 57:17Princess Marie fleeing France to come to New
- 57:19Orleans. I saw a scenario in which a prince would
- 57:23try to escape his fate and fall in love. And
- 57:26this reminded me of the Queen of the 2000s for
- 57:29me personally. honestly, with romantic comedies,
- 57:32came to be a teen romantic comedy. I think the
- 57:34queen of this in the early 2000s was, maybe late
- 57:3790s, was Julia Stiles. This was The Prince and
- 57:39Me in 2004, directed by Martha Coolidge. I am
- 57:44familiar with The Prince and Me, mostly in a
- 57:48cover, like the DVD cover of her sitting very
- 57:51unprofessionally or uncasually on a... On a throne.
- 57:55Yeah, with, like, I think Matthew Goode is the
- 57:58prince behind her. Okay. But this is the romance
- 58:00between royalty and, I don't want to say commonwealth,
- 58:04but, like, you know, the mass audiences. Us.
- 58:07Us, yeah. The prince and us. Yeah. And this,
- 58:11to me, felt like what an evolution of Naughty
- 58:15Marietta. Interesting. Of the gender -bent swap,
- 58:17which we're even seeing in, like, 1940 gender
- 58:19swap comedies. Prince and Me. Shout out to my
- 58:24wife and the kind of movies that she got me onto.
- 58:26Very cool. Very cool. I've never seen this movie.
- 58:29Maybe saw the cover. Julia Stiles. Are you a
- 58:32fan? Pro? Familiar? Yes. Familiar enough. What
- 58:37is it? How to Lose a Guy? Ten Things. Ten Things
- 58:41I Hate About You. That's what it is. How to Lose
- 58:42a Guy in Ten Days is Kate Hudson. And Matthew
- 58:44McConaughey. You got it. Thanks, Mom. And Fool's
- 58:47Gold is... Jennifer Lopez and... Matthew Broderick.
- 58:51You're so close. Really? It is also Kate Hudson
- 58:54and Matthew McConaughey. Oh. Ghosts of Girlfriends
- 58:57passed, real quick. Uma Thurman and... Pierce
- 59:03Brosnan. No. Matthew McConaughey and... Julia
- 59:08Stiles. No. It was instead Jennifer Garner. I
- 59:11don't like that I had better luck with the Kid
- 59:14Rock references than I did with this. And what
- 59:17does that say? Once again, thanks, Mom. She's
- 59:20not a Kid Rock fan now. Listeners at home, please
- 59:22understand. We were young. We didn't know. We
- 59:25had no idea. We just knew one thing, and that
- 59:27was ba with da ba. Da bang da bang. Diggy diggy.
- 59:30Right? Yeah. With... I don't know the rest. Don't
- 59:34support Kid Rock. No. Anyway, that's going to
- 59:37do it for Naughty Marietta. If you guys have
- 59:39thoughts on this movie and the America's Singing
- 59:42Sweethearts, let us know. Shoot us an email at
- 59:45outaopodcast at gmail .com. Be sure to check
- 59:48out the Patreon. patreon .com slash O -U -T -A
- 59:51-O podcast for tons of cool benefits. We talk
- 59:55about them frequently. We've got the Discord.
- 59:57Recently, I posted my LA highlight trip. Like
- 1:00:01an hour long with like a presentation and everything.
- 1:00:03It's so long. Yeah, I did like a PowerPoint.
- 1:00:05I didn't actually do a PowerPoint, but. But you
- 1:00:07had like the images and the videos ready to go.
- 1:00:09Like you had a whole thing. Yeah, it was a whole
- 1:00:11thing. And I'll post this on social media, but
- 1:00:14the Janet Gaynor and Adrian Grave, that is in
- 1:00:18that. or PowerPoint or whatever. But we've got
- 1:00:21all kinds of cool things over at the Patreon,
- 1:00:23so check that out. We also do Horror of the Overlooked,
- 1:00:26which is an exclusive to Patreon, out on the
- 1:00:2913th of every month. Yeah, we just did coverage
- 1:00:31of The Bride of Frankenstein, which we talked
- 1:00:32about a little bit here in this episode, so check
- 1:00:35that out. Next episode, we'll be talking about
- 1:00:37the Overlooked horror movies of 1935. Next episode,
- 1:00:41we'll be covering a John Ford film, The Informer.
- 1:00:45And that will be the last episode of this month.
- 1:00:48Again, this is a split year, so no ceremony episode
- 1:00:52in July, at least moving forward. August will
- 1:00:56be the remainder of the 1935 movies and the 1936
- 1:01:01Academy Awards ceremony. I think that's all I've
- 1:01:03got. Need anything else out in the open? You
- 1:01:06want to promote anything? I think we've promoted
- 1:01:08some people more than we probably intended to.
- 1:01:10Probably have. So I'm just glad that of America's
- 1:01:13singing sweethearts, the ones we're talking about
- 1:01:15are, I almost called her Janet Gaynor, Janet
- 1:01:18McDonald and Nettie Elson. Yes. Wait. Did I say
- 1:01:22that right? Nettie Elson. Yeah. Right? Nelson
- 1:01:25Nettie. Nelson Nettie. Literally what you talked
- 1:01:28about being worried about in the beginning, I
- 1:01:31did. Whoops. Hey, guys. That doesn't sound right.
- 1:01:33Go support the chicks. They're a cool band that
- 1:01:36my mom liked when I was young that have made
- 1:01:38better choices. Yeah. And you know what? Goodbye,
- 1:01:41Earl. Yeah. And audience. And audience. But not
- 1:01:45in the same way. Earl, terrible fate. Audience,
- 1:01:48we appreciate you. Yes. And we will be back.
- 1:01:51As always, I'm Kyle. I think I'm Ryan. And we'll
- 1:01:54see you at the movies.