Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Motions for Summary Judgment: Writing for Two Audiences
Transcript
- 0:02I am Neda Sagafi. I'm vice chair of BHBA's litigation
- 0:07section. I am delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:11Marshall Shepperson. Thank you so much, Marshall,
- 0:14for being here with us today. Marshall practices
- 0:17with Frazier Watson Crouch, defending physicians,
- 0:20hospitals, and other health care professionals
- 0:23with a particular focus on law and motion and
- 0:26appellate work. He began his career in 2007,
- 0:30defending medical professionals in New York,
- 0:32where he made his name in motion practice and
- 0:35on appeal, including a federal anti -slap dismissal
- 0:39in Ginks versus Soho Alliance, a published opinion
- 0:42that courts nationwide still cite today. Since
- 0:46returning to healthcare defense in 2019, his
- 0:49work has centered on research, writing, and oral
- 0:52advocacy. He has given CLE presentations on summary
- 0:56judgment in the medical malpractice context and
- 0:58his recent appellate wins include the affirmance
- 1:01on a summary judgment he first secured at trial
- 1:05over expert -supported opposition. He has admitted
- 1:08to practice in California, New York, and Texas.
- 1:12So thank you, Marshall, for being here with us
- 1:15today. And now let's get started. Thank you so
- 1:18much, Nata, for that kindly introduction. And
- 1:20it's great to meet you. And I really appreciate
- 1:26your kind words and your guidance and your technical
- 1:28support already. Of course. We're looking forward
- 1:32to your program. OK. So I'm going to do my best
- 1:35to try to share my power. PowerPoint presentation.
- 1:45And if, Neda, if you're still on audio, if you
- 1:48can confirm, you can see that. Looks great. Great.
- 1:52Thank you. OK. So thank you for everybody who
- 1:56is logged on and registered and watching this
- 1:59right now. I hope to offer some illustrations
- 2:04of principles that I think make for effective
- 2:07motion practice for summary judgment, as well
- 2:10as some notes about opposing them. And the theme,
- 2:15in fact, of the thing is motions for summary
- 2:19judgment, writing for two audiences. And by that,
- 2:23I mean that anybody making a motion for summary
- 2:25judgment is writing to the judge, but just as
- 2:30much should keep in mind that the moving party
- 2:34is writing to the plaintiff's lawyer who will
- 2:37be opposing the motion or deciding not to oppose
- 2:41it. And so the slant of this presentation is
- 2:45to talk about where you might be able to influence
- 2:49the would -be opposing party so as to get them
- 2:54to back down based on the strength of your presentation.
- 2:59So. As Neda kindly introduced me, my name is
- 3:05Marshall Shepperton, and I have this slide just
- 3:07to try to establish some cred on the topic, why
- 3:14do I think I can tell anybody about making a
- 3:17motion for summary judgment? When I was a freshly
- 3:21licensed attorney in New York, this was my place
- 3:24of work, 111 Center Street, which is part of
- 3:28the New York trial court system, which is called
- 3:32the Supreme Court there, but I would call it
- 3:34the MSJ foundry. This was not a prestigious federal
- 3:39judge clerkship. This was a high volume, extremely
- 3:45diverse workflow type of environment where I
- 3:50processed many, many motions for summary judgment
- 3:53at various levels of skill and competence. And
- 3:59so I think I got a unique view into what works
- 4:03and what doesn't work. And so when I first started
- 4:07working at a small men -male defense firm, Bel
- 4:11Air and Evans, my first project was a motion
- 4:14for summary judgment. I think my mentor, Ray
- 4:18Bel Air, thought it was going to haze me. But
- 4:21I was able to get the motion filed. And the plaintiff's
- 4:26lawyer responded by agreeing to drop the case.
- 4:30And so that sort of colored my view of what to
- 4:35expect when making an MSJ. I probably got a distorted
- 4:40impression that if I just put up a really strong
- 4:44presentation on the strength of our defense,
- 4:46supported by an expert, the plaintiff's lawyer
- 4:49should let the thing go, right? That hasn't happened
- 4:53every time, but it has happened enough times
- 4:55to make it a worthwhile exercise. And so, I'm
- 4:59always writing to the judge trying to keep in
- 5:04mind how to persuade the judge that there's no
- 5:06evidence against the defendant, but I'm always
- 5:09considering how the plaintiff's attorney is going
- 5:12to take the thing, and I'm trying to persuade
- 5:15the plaintiff's attorney that the case isn't
- 5:17worth the effort. This is especially powerful,
- 5:20of course, when there are multiple defendants
- 5:22in the case. And you might be able to get out
- 5:26of the case without the plaintiff abandoning
- 5:29the entire project. And they might be able to
- 5:31go after the ones who are going to be easier
- 5:33targets. So the plaintiff's attorney always has
- 5:40to keep the expense in mind. And so if you can
- 5:45put up a strong enough front, you can at least
- 5:49give a sense to the plaintiff's attorney of what
- 5:51it's going to cost to retain an expert and develop
- 5:55an opinion to try to beat this. And if you can
- 6:00give the plaintiff's attorney the sense that
- 6:02even if he skirts by summary judgment, it's going
- 6:05to cost him a fortune on a questionable theory,
- 6:11he might just back down at the summary judgment
- 6:14stage. And so the MSA process has benefits for
- 6:22the trial attorney as well, developing issues
- 6:24with the defense experts and smoking out the
- 6:26plaintiff's experts. However, it should be treated
- 6:29as a real chance to win and close a case and
- 6:32not just a preparatory task. And the trial attorney
- 6:35should be seen as the last line of defense. The
- 6:38high standard I like to hold myself to is that
- 6:42if the case goes to trial, I've already lost
- 6:46because the MSJ, I think, is a real first best
- 6:50chance to resolve a case. Okay, so step one,
- 6:56when does MSJ planning begin? And I have the
- 7:00wonderful stock image of a baby there because
- 7:04I think the MSJ planning begins right away. In
- 7:08the med mal setting, it begins as soon as you
- 7:12start obtaining the medical records. because
- 7:14the records will only support an MSJ if they
- 7:17are properly authenticated by the custodian of
- 7:20records. And that is under the case Garibay versus
- 7:23Hamat, a case that has caused the defense bar
- 7:27undue grief and consternation. So all Garibay
- 7:32says is that a declaration from the custodian
- 7:35of records is the essential enabling element
- 7:38without which the chart is inadmissible hearsay.
- 7:44So the defense bar overreacted to Garamay. This
- 7:47happened before I was practicing in California,
- 7:50but it is obvious from the various court records
- 7:54that I've seen. And also, I think I learned about
- 7:58it when I was on the plaintiff's side. And I
- 8:02realized that we were in the age of lodging,
- 8:05which is a dark age of superstition and foolish
- 8:13ceremony that we are still living in. And I think
- 8:18I became aware of this only when I was working
- 8:20on the plaintiff's side and defendants would
- 8:23move for summary judgment and they would go through
- 8:26this elaborate side process of lodging documents.
- 8:30And I only came to gather over time that this
- 8:33was, in their mind, this was their way of satisfying
- 8:37the scary case Garibay. When really, in principle,
- 8:42Garibay said nothing more than do MSJs the way
- 8:46you've been doing them, but just make sure there's
- 8:48a custodian of record declaration attached somewhere
- 8:52to each medical record. That's really all it
- 8:54says. If you search the opinion for the lodge
- 8:59prefix, there are zero results. The court says
- 9:02nothing about lodging, and there's no reason
- 9:04to think that Garibay requires us to go through
- 9:06this strange exercise in meat space. printing
- 9:13out documents and sending them to the court on
- 9:16top of filing them conventionally. So what Garibay
- 9:20really requires is this, just the declaration
- 9:23of the custodian of records. And I highly recommend
- 9:28to defense attorneys that they include language
- 9:34regarding the custodian declaration in their
- 9:38own attorney declaration. And I do this for the
- 9:43practical purpose of reminding myself to make
- 9:48sure that it's there when I'm putting my final
- 9:51exhibits together. Because without it, Garibay
- 9:54is going to give the plaintiff a really good
- 9:58crown to have your medical records excluded from
- 10:03consideration because they are not properly authenticated.
- 10:08So including this in my declaration because I
- 10:11read my declarations before I sign them reminds
- 10:14me that I need to check the record again make
- 10:16sure that the custodian deck is included and
- 10:21so it reads I say I say a true and correct copy
- 10:25of the medical records including a declaration
- 10:28of custodian of records certifying that they
- 10:30were prepared in the ordinary course of business
- 10:32at or near the time of the acts conditions and
- 10:36events reflected therein Why is it written this
- 10:40way? This is because the summary judgment statute
- 10:46in California, 437C, requires quote, admissible
- 10:52evidence in support of an MSJ. Now this is in
- 10:56felicitous drafting, the federal rule of evidence
- 11:01analog, rule 56C2, puts it more carefully. It
- 11:06says, objection that a fact is not supported
- 11:09by admissible evidence. A party may object that
- 11:11the material cited to support or dispute a fact
- 11:15cannot be presented in a form that would be admissible
- 11:19in evidence. This is a much better way of thinking
- 11:23about it. There's an impossibility built into
- 11:30saying the MSJ has to be supported by admissible
- 11:33evidence, because for the most part, everything
- 11:37is going to have one layer of hearsay that can't
- 11:41be resolved on papers, that can be resolved at
- 11:44trial. So the federal rule of evidence is just
- 11:49a better formulation of it. It highlights, and
- 11:56it highlights the reason for the overreaction
- 11:58to Garavé because I think that on some level,
- 12:05the defense bar panicked and said, wait, what's
- 12:08not admissible about this? How do we make this
- 12:10admissible? And it led them to start this lodging
- 12:14business, which is actually wasteful and it doesn't
- 12:18actually get to the issue. And in fact, it can
- 12:22distract from the issue. I have seen co -defendants,
- 12:26MSJs file where they... say in their declaration
- 12:30specifically that they are lodging the materials
- 12:32in satisfaction of Garibay, and then when I look
- 12:36at their lodged version, it doesn't include a
- 12:39declaration from the custodian of records. So
- 12:42they are fulfilling their own superstitious belief
- 12:46about what it requires and not fulfilling what
- 12:49it actually requires. grumpy justices make for
- 12:56neurotic lawyers. This is because what the Garibay
- 12:59court was really upset about and the cases in
- 13:02your trial material or the presentation materials
- 13:06that I provided to the Bar Association, so hopefully
- 13:08everybody watching can get a copy of the case
- 13:11if they want one. But what the Court of Appeal
- 13:16was really grumpy about was that the defense
- 13:20lawyer and his expert had not included the medical
- 13:25records at all. The court was just expected to
- 13:28take everything the expert said in the declaration
- 13:31at face value and not be able to verify or back
- 13:34it up with the medical records. And the court
- 13:37really took offense to that, but I think went
- 13:41a little bit too far by bringing up the topic
- 13:44of the custodian of record deck, because that
- 13:49actually wasn't the issue in front of the court.
- 13:51But they were trying to give guidance on some
- 13:54level, and they were also sort of trying to rectify
- 13:58what I think was a bad practice that was already
- 14:01frustrating them. So why isn't the medical record
- 14:05admissible without that declaration? Because
- 14:09it's hearsay. Until the offering party establishes
- 14:14an exception to hearsay. So the exception that
- 14:20applies for medical records is the business records
- 14:24exception, which is codified at CCP 1271. And
- 14:30here is the language of it, which tracks the
- 14:35language I was recommending people include in
- 14:37their attorney deck. And I don't think any of
- 14:41this is new to anybody, so I'm not going to read
- 14:43it. And in federal court, the analogous rule
- 14:47is federal rule of evidence 8036. And unlike
- 14:52the other statute where the federal rule was
- 14:55superior, here it's functionally the same. So
- 15:03serendipitously, Satisfying Garibay will also
- 15:09conveniently satisfy the later decided people
- 15:13v. Sanchez, which confirmed that an expert's
- 15:18ability to introduce hearsay is limited by the
- 15:20admissibility of the material standing alone.
- 15:23So I think that on that level, the later decision
- 15:28of people versus Sanchez proves that the Garibay
- 15:32court had a point and the two are very harmonious.
- 15:37with each other. So if you can satisfy the Garibay
- 15:40objection and beat it, you'll also be beating
- 15:44the Sanchez objection. So satisfying Garibay
- 15:50requires getting MSJ ready medical records. When
- 15:53the custodian is your client, it can pose a special
- 15:56challenge. Because if they're not your client,
- 15:59it's easy. You just subpoena the records, and
- 16:02it comes with a pre -drafted declaration from
- 16:06a custodian of record. On the other hand, when
- 16:08it's your client and you get the record by informal
- 16:13means, sometimes you have to hound them and twist
- 16:16our arm. And sometimes they want to give you
- 16:20their own house version, which looks something
- 16:27like this. And it certifies that the record is
- 16:32a true copy of all the records. And that's it.
- 16:37And that does not satisfy the Garibay exception.
- 16:42And so that's not going to do the trick as far
- 16:46as Megan and MSJ. Here is what you want it to
- 16:55actually look like. You want to make sure that
- 16:58your client's declaration Reads the records were
- 17:03prepared by the personnel in the ordinary course
- 17:05of business at or near the time of act Photocopying
- 17:08record submitted here with her true guys. Okay,
- 17:10so this is the business records exception Criteria
- 17:17reflected in the deck that you need Oops Okay
- 17:33So, step two, after obtaining the records in
- 17:38an MSJ ready form, is reviewing the records.
- 17:41And so anybody who might need to make an MSJ
- 17:44should be thinking about finding the useful facts
- 17:48that can be plugged into a separate statement
- 17:51later on. But don't be too literal about plugging
- 17:55in facts. So your record summary should be a
- 17:59good start to educating a judge who is very intelligent
- 18:03but not all knowing about key medical topics
- 18:07and terms and the concepts that led to the injury,
- 18:11the etiology, as well as the plaintiff's attorney.
- 18:16So if you state your facts on MSJ in a way that
- 18:21is readable and digestible by an intelligent
- 18:25lay person, you're going to be in a good position
- 18:29because you'll be educating the reader on the
- 18:33medical background that's going to become relevant
- 18:37to deciding the motion or to deciding whether
- 18:40to oppose the motion. When your adversary is
- 18:43learning his or her own medical knowledge from
- 18:48you, you will begin at a great advantage. So
- 18:54how do we make our record summaries? useful to
- 19:02a lay, intelligent reader? Well, we define medical
- 19:06terms. Sometimes the MSJ is just full of data
- 19:12dumps and medical terminology that's never unpacked,
- 19:15it's never defined, and a lot of it is not helpful
- 19:19to the judge. And so the rule of thumb is, if
- 19:25you don't know what it means, neither does the
- 19:28judge. I don't think that's being unfair. In
- 19:33fact, I think it's unfair to in any way shift
- 19:37the burden to the court to do research in medical
- 19:42terms. It should be explained in the papers.
- 19:47And ideally, it should be explained in lay terms
- 19:50by the expert declaration. Define drug names,
- 19:56again. If you just rattle off a bunch of drugs
- 20:01that were being taken by the plaintiff or the
- 20:03decedent, it's not going to give much useful
- 20:08information to the reader unless the nature and
- 20:13the purpose of the drugs is spelled out and the
- 20:16purpose of even talking about those drugs is
- 20:18made clear. So if you're defining your medical
- 20:22terms and your drug names. Before you know it,
- 20:26the judge will be passively taking quasi -judicial
- 20:28notice of your version of the facts because you're
- 20:31teaching the court everything it knows. Meanwhile,
- 20:35the opposing attorney might learn something new
- 20:37that paints the plaintiff case in a less favorable
- 20:41light. And that's more likely to happen if you're
- 20:45educating them on the medical background. Unpack
- 20:50acronyms. Again, a An alphabet soup of acronyms
- 20:56in the expert deck or in the motion is not helpful
- 20:59to the court or to the plaintiff's attorney.
- 21:02In the olden days, we used to have medical abbreviation
- 21:05pocketbooks, but Google is just fine to figure
- 21:09out what a lot of these acronyms mean. And then
- 21:11of course, once you've unpacked the acronym,
- 21:13it's always helpful to define what the terms
- 21:15mean that make up the acronym. So step three,
- 21:20and this is an under... utilized aspect of MSJ
- 21:28practice. So once you've got the medical records,
- 21:33what other evidence is there to serve as a building
- 21:35block for your MSJ? So we've got the complaint,
- 21:40which delimits the cause of action under the
- 21:43well -known Oakland Raiders case. You've got
- 21:47the deposition of the plaintiff and other parties,
- 21:51which is going to be especially important for
- 21:53statute of limitations and informed consent claims.
- 21:58And then the most overlooked of all are the contention
- 22:01interrogatories. If the plaintiff attorney discloses
- 22:06their contentions in good faith, those will serve
- 22:08as a roadmap to what might otherwise seem hopelessly
- 22:12open -ended, because there is this sense that
- 22:15the movement for summary judgment has to has
- 22:19to anticipate every possible theory the plaintiff
- 22:22might come up with to pivot to. But if you narrow
- 22:27them down with their complaint and with their
- 22:29own contentions, that's harder for them to do.
- 22:32And so you can make the task more manageable.
- 22:38Also, you'll set up a reply argument based on
- 22:43Jacobs versus Coldwell Banker residential, which
- 22:46held that if plaintiff tries to pivot to an undisclosed
- 22:50theory, they lose. They're not entitled to defeat
- 22:55MSJ with a new theory that wasn't disclosed.
- 23:01So this is just an example of a page from a memo
- 23:07that just puts it right in the middle, that in
- 23:09discovery, plaintiff has disclosed the following
- 23:12contentions and just list them out the way that
- 23:15they were phrased. And that's going to serve
- 23:17as the court's roadmap of what they're going
- 23:22to expect the motion is going to debunk. So although
- 23:26it's still quite general, the framework provides
- 23:28a general pattern for your expert to address
- 23:31in an orderly fashion. So step three is complete.
- 23:38You've got all your discovery in a form suitable
- 23:40to MSJ. What's next? Stock animations. So now
- 23:49you need to start making sure that you're going
- 23:52to file the thing timely, setting and scheduling.
- 23:55So these dates were recently adjusted by the
- 24:00legislature. And so now our outside deadline
- 24:04is 116 days before the trial date if you're going
- 24:10to serve the thing electronically. That date
- 24:17comes from the trial date minus the 30 days,
- 24:20because the hearing has to be at least 30 days
- 24:22before trial, minus the 81 days of statutory
- 24:25notice minus the five or two for the method of
- 24:30service. So that's hard enough to comply with.
- 24:37And then the local courts have to make it even
- 24:41more challenging and fun by adding the local
- 24:48rules on electronic reservation of hearing dates.
- 24:53So in Los Angeles, another move that caused perhaps
- 24:57undue distress in the defense bar was the three
- 25:00-day filing rule. And just a couple of months
- 25:06ago, the three -day filing rule was to some degree
- 25:12approved or at least permitted by the court of
- 25:15appeal. That didn't involve MSJ. That was a safe
- 25:19harbor case. But the Court of Appeals said, it's
- 25:27up to you to work around these local rules, essentially.
- 25:32And so for now, the three -day rule is here to
- 25:39stay. Interestingly, in this opinion, in footnote
- 25:43four, The Court of Appeal pointed out that Orange
- 25:47and San Bernardino counties have exceptions to
- 25:50their filing rule. Their filing rules generally
- 25:55require you to file the motion within three days
- 25:58of reserving a hearing date or else the hearing
- 26:03date gets canceled. But those counties have express
- 26:07exceptions for certain classes of motions, including
- 26:11MSJs. the Court of Appeal said it's up to the
- 26:16LA Superior Court to elect to modify its e -filing
- 26:19rules if it will at all. And for now, we all
- 26:24have to live with it. So far, it hasn't been
- 26:31fatal on any of the matters that I've worked
- 26:33on. It's just required us to have everything
- 26:37in order well in advance. I do want to note another
- 26:44recent case that might save the MSJ from the
- 26:51local rules. This is a case where the Court of
- 26:56Appeal stressed that a defendant is entitled
- 26:59to a hearing on a motion for summary judgment
- 27:01that is timely filed even if they failed to comply
- 27:04with the local rules. So this was in Riverside.
- 27:07They have a rule where a motion has to be filed
- 27:10within 10 days. after reserving the hearing or
- 27:13that the hearing will be canceled. They filed
- 27:17the motion before the hearing was canceled, but
- 27:19then the clerk went ahead and canceled it anyway.
- 27:23The motion was therefore vacated, denied, and
- 27:28the court of appeal said, no, you've got to set
- 27:31this for hearing because defendants have a right
- 27:33to have their MSJ heard as long as it was timely
- 27:37in the first case. But you don't want to be the
- 27:39test case to confirm that that's going to hold
- 27:46true for the LA three -day filing rule. So try
- 27:51to meet the three -day filing rule. So what's
- 27:55next? Step five, the roundup. I call it the roundup
- 28:01because this is where you know how long you have
- 28:04to make your motion, when it has to be filed
- 28:06by, and now we have to decide what the scope
- 28:08of the motion is going to be. What are all the
- 28:10issues that need to be addressed? And what are
- 28:14all the ancillary filings that we need to prepare
- 28:19for? So the rules of court, 3 .1350, have this
- 28:25nice breakdown of the components of an MSJ. And
- 28:30I think of it very much as four necessary separate
- 28:35components on equal dignities. You've got the
- 28:38notice. You've got the separate statement You've
- 28:41got the memorandum of points and authorities
- 28:43and then you've got the evidence and these are
- 28:46all these as far as I'm concerned these should
- 28:48all be filed as separate pleadings with their
- 28:52own separate captions and separate Signature
- 28:55blocks sometimes requests for judicial notice
- 28:58might be useful Another superstition that I'd
- 29:01like to point out is you do not have to do a
- 29:04request for judicial notice of the complaint
- 29:06in the case. The complaint is part of the court
- 29:08file. There's no need for a request for judicial
- 29:11notice. So I consider the four things that we
- 29:17always use as the four pillars of the MSJ filing,
- 29:21and this is them in order of importance. You
- 29:24have the separate statement, the evidence, the
- 29:27memorandum, and the notice of motion. And so
- 29:31those four separate works of literature should
- 29:36all be filed when you file your motion envelope.
- 29:42If anybody remembers the days of law backs, this
- 29:45is how many law backed, stapled, tabbed documents
- 29:50you would need to take down to the hearing with
- 29:53you. So the order of tasks that I recommend is
- 29:59to start with a separate statement. Now I know
- 30:01this is not common. This is unorthodox. but I
- 30:05think it's got a lot of practical benefits and
- 30:08it helps streamline motions into the best and
- 30:13most effective possible presentation. Starting
- 30:16with a separate statement, then once that's done,
- 30:19translating that into an expert declaration,
- 30:22then once that's done, just sort of plugging
- 30:25in the expert opinions into your memorandum of
- 30:29support. And then finally, finishing up the ancillary
- 30:34filings, which are the evidence and the notice.
- 30:43Something that I think I want to be a takeaway
- 30:46of this program is that the separate statement
- 30:49is the most important component of the entire
- 30:52filing. And that's why it gets such special focus
- 30:56and treatment in the California Rules of Court
- 30:58and elsewhere. There are some case law regarding
- 31:02the so -called golden rule of MSJ. So essentially,
- 31:10the golden rule is that essentially the separate
- 31:12statement and the response to the separate statement
- 31:14are the only things that the judge should need
- 31:18to look at before making a ruling. So here's
- 31:23a quote from a case. All material facts must
- 31:25be set forth in the separate statement. This
- 31:27is the golden rule of summary adjudication. If
- 31:29it is not set forth in the separate statement,
- 31:32it does not exist. Both the court and the opposing
- 31:35party are entitled to have all the facts upon
- 31:37which the moving party bases its motion plainly
- 31:42set forth in the separate statement. That's from
- 31:46United Community Church versus Garson. And that
- 31:49becomes most important when it comes to the ultimate
- 31:54opinions on standard of care and causation by
- 31:59your expert or if it's not a med mal case if
- 32:02if it's another case it's going to be the ultimate
- 32:06opinions of your expert no matter what they are
- 32:09need to be reflected in the separate statement
- 32:11so this is again this is this is an example that
- 32:20uses med mal concepts but the principles all
- 32:23will carry into any other case that you have.
- 32:27So here's just an example, the paradigmatic outline
- 32:30of an MSJ for hospital liability. You would address
- 32:34legal issues like a statute of limitations first,
- 32:38because that's a threshold issue. And then you
- 32:41would address standard of care. The standard
- 32:44of care is going to be defined by the elements
- 32:49in KC 514 on the duty. of a hospital, then a
- 32:54hospital needs to address ostensible agency,
- 32:57which again is defined by the elements in KC
- 33:013714. If it's pled, the hospital needs to address
- 33:06its so -called LAM duty for medical staff screening,
- 33:11and that's going to be defined by the elements
- 33:13in KC 516. So those are all sub -components of
- 33:17standard of care. Causation is your next big
- 33:20issue. And that can always be teased into two
- 33:24separate concepts, or usually. There's but for
- 33:28causation, which is that the injury was or wasn't
- 33:30preventable. But then there's also the deeper
- 33:33medical causation, where if you can show that
- 33:36the alleged conduct wasn't the cause of the medical
- 33:42process that gave rise to injury, you can win
- 33:46that way too. And then a hospital often has to
- 33:49address informed consent. they can so the MSJ
- 33:54would have to establish that the consent was
- 33:56obtained and or that the plaintiff would not
- 34:01have declined the treatment even if He or she
- 34:06had been informed of the risks. So that's just
- 34:09an example. This is these are all the elements
- 34:12that are typically implicated in a hospital MSJ
- 34:17so Casey, for the person making the motion, Casey
- 34:21is the guiding guru for the elements. Each part
- 34:27of your memo and argument should be designed
- 34:31around the elements set forth in Casey. Here's
- 34:35just an example on the informed consent issue.
- 34:38So what I'm trying to get across with this slide
- 34:39is on any given case, you want to look at the
- 34:42Casey elements and evaluate each element in your
- 34:47and your facts and think which one of these is
- 34:50vulnerable to MSJ. Which one of these elements
- 34:54is there enough evidence that we can prove our
- 34:57defense and maybe the plaintiff will back down.
- 35:04So as part of this process you want to pick your
- 35:07themes and rather than cutting and pasting boilerplate
- 35:11case citations without thinking what I'm suggesting
- 35:14is that Each time you make a motion, you refer
- 35:17thoughtfully to the Casey elements on point and
- 35:20think which one or ones should the plaintiff
- 35:23lose on? But do be sure always cite the actual
- 35:32authority and not Casey Casey is not a A source
- 35:38of authority. It's a restatement and I have seen
- 35:41judges get very irate about briefs that only
- 35:45cite Casey and not the actual underlying case
- 35:49law that Casey is based on. But Casey makes it
- 35:52easy for you because the good news is that Casey
- 35:58gives you the actual authority right in the comments.
- 36:01So when you're going through Casey and building
- 36:04your arguments and you need the authority, you
- 36:08just look to the case notes and you cite that
- 36:10instead of citing Casey 514 or whatever. Okay,
- 36:15so now you've got your themes and your outline.
- 36:19What's next? So step six, the separate statement.
- 36:22And again, this is the most important part. The
- 36:27separate statement is addressed at some length
- 36:30in both the CCP and the rules of court. And when
- 36:34you're doing your separate statement, cut and
- 36:36paste if you must, but don't data dump. This
- 36:41is... certainly a common practice, and it's one
- 36:47that I would suggest is not just counterproductive,
- 36:52but dangerous. So, the rules of court set forth
- 36:59what is appropriate for the separate statement,
- 37:03and the important part is emphasized there. The
- 37:07separate statement should include only material
- 37:09facts and not any facts that are not pertinent
- 37:12to the disposition of the motion. So when I go
- 37:16over a draft separate statement with an associate,
- 37:20I expect the associate's going to be prepared
- 37:23to justify each inclusion in the separate statement
- 37:27and say how it helps the motion, how it moves
- 37:31the ball at all, and what the purpose of it is.
- 37:34And without a clear articulation of that, I think
- 37:38that it should typically be excluded. I don't
- 37:41think that the prevailing sentiment of over inclusiveness
- 37:46just to be safe is sound. We'll get to why. So
- 37:54the rule says, don't include facts that are not
- 38:01pertinent to the disposition of the motion. And
- 38:04then that's just a suggestion, right? LOL, no.
- 38:10By including the fact in the separate statement,
- 38:11the defense has conceded that the fact is material.
- 38:15Here's another case I included in the materials
- 38:19because it is so very important. And Nasir cited
- 38:25the rudder guide for that principle and approved
- 38:29it. So this is a strongly. understood principle
- 38:35by the the courts and the commentators so it
- 38:38means that if the if the person opposing the
- 38:43motion can create a genuine dispute as to any
- 38:46of the facts that you put in your separate statement
- 38:48then your motion fails okay so if you're including
- 38:55facts in there that aren't actually material
- 38:59to your defense And it turns out that there's
- 39:03some ambiguity in the records and actually that's
- 39:06a fact that can be disputed. Your motion gets
- 39:09dumped. And so the more facts that are included
- 39:13in your separate statement, the more chances
- 39:17the plaintiff has to knock it down. I'm not making
- 39:20this up. So here's how the rudder guide that
- 39:23was cited by the court puts it. include only
- 39:28those facts which are truly material to the claims
- 39:30or defenses, because the separate statement effectively
- 39:33concedes the materiality of whatever facts are
- 39:37included. Thus, if a tribal issue is raised as
- 39:40to any of the facts in your separate statement,
- 39:42the motion must be denied! And again, that sentiment
- 39:47was cited with approval by the Court of Appeal
- 39:50in the Nazar case. In the Nazar case, another
- 39:53reason I included it in the materials is it's
- 39:55got a lot of really important background information
- 40:00on MSJ, and I think it's just generally a very
- 40:04excellent piece of guidance. So navigating the
- 40:10skilla and caribdis of the separate statement.
- 40:14So everything we've learned so far has several
- 40:17implications. So don't clutter your motion with
- 40:19distracting and hazardous irrelevancies, because
- 40:23if... the plaintiff's attorney can pick apart
- 40:26one of them, your whole motion sinks down to
- 40:29the bottom of the Aegean. Don't include a UMF
- 40:33that you know they will dispute. So that seems
- 40:38like it should be obvious, but I see many motions
- 40:41that include highly contentious and ambiguous
- 40:45statements of fact that are very easy to create
- 40:49a dispute on. But they're not material. And so
- 40:54that's something that can be avoided. Of course,
- 40:57ultimate facts have to be included according
- 40:59to the what we said was the golden rule. So you
- 41:04can't leave out your expert opinions, which is
- 41:06the point where you know the plaintiff is going
- 41:10to do their darnedest to create a dispute of
- 41:13fact by getting their own expert. But guess what?
- 41:16If they're going to get their own expert to dispute
- 41:18it, you're going to lose anyway. So you can't
- 41:21keep out your expert opinions from your separate
- 41:24statement in hopes that you can just avoid any
- 41:28dispute as to your material facts. But plaintiffs,
- 41:37don't get too excited about this. On one level,
- 41:41yeah, it's easy to defeat an MSJ by just creating
- 41:46a a dispute as to one fact, and I've seen some
- 41:51responses to separate statements from plaintiff's
- 41:53lawyers that include that language from the Nazir
- 41:57case and the Rudder Guide, and I think that's
- 41:59pretty clever. I appreciate that move. But trial
- 42:05judges can tell the difference between a genuine
- 42:09dispute and, on one hand, an evasion, diversion,
- 42:13and non sequitur on the other. So here's a nice
- 42:17passage from a more recent case, responses, and
- 42:20this is in the separate statement, responses
- 42:22should directly address the facts stated, and
- 42:25if that fact is not in dispute, the opposing
- 42:27party must so admit. It is completely unhelpful
- 42:30to evade the stated fact in an attempt to create
- 42:33a dispute where none exists. Courts should also
- 42:36not hesitate to disregard attempts to game the
- 42:38system by the opposing party claiming facts are
- 42:41disputed when the uncontroversial uncontroverted
- 42:45evidence clearly shows otherwise. So the principle
- 42:48here is that the opposing party will squander
- 42:56their credibility by trying to address what every
- 43:01UMF is getting at and arguing the ultimate issues
- 43:05in every box of the separate statement in their
- 43:08response. rather than just candidly admitting
- 43:13damaging undisputed facts. Again, for the plaintiff's
- 43:19bar, your burden is not to explain away every
- 43:25seemingly damaging fact. The only burden you
- 43:28have is to just create a dispute as to one of
- 43:31the facts. And so you can actually bury a genuine
- 43:36dispute in a bunch of contentious rhetoric that
- 43:44can actually make it more likely that the motion
- 43:48is going to be granted. So you should really
- 43:51just bite the bullet and admit facts that you
- 43:55don't have any evidence to contradict and really
- 43:57focus on the ones that you can contradict with
- 44:01hard evidence. So the form of the separate statement
- 44:06should be a stepwise series of very straightforward
- 44:12self -contained and objectively documented facts
- 44:16Typically there are exceptions, but typically
- 44:19it should be strictly in chronological order
- 44:22And it there should be it should be completely
- 44:26free of any argumentative rhetoric So when you're
- 44:32building your separate statement and this is
- 44:35all part of why I I think it's important to it
- 44:37first is when you're beginning to psychologize
- 44:42both the court and your opponent by showing how
- 44:46unassailable all of your supporting evidence
- 44:48really is. You break out uncontroversial facts
- 44:52into their maximum granularity and that's for
- 44:56emphasis because you're emphasizing how many
- 44:59sub facts are actually helpful to your defense
- 45:02and you avoid controversial facts entirely. A
- 45:06series of undisputed by the plaintiff will gain
- 45:10the movement momentum. The court starts to think
- 45:12that the case is futile and the opponent starts
- 45:14appreciating what an uphill battle he's got to
- 45:18develop genuine contrary evidence. So once we
- 45:25have all of the facts that we're going to use
- 45:27in the defense of our case, then we want to translate
- 45:32those into an expert declaration. and most people
- 45:35do it the reverse way. I understand most people
- 45:37draft their expert deck and once it's signed
- 45:39then they just cut and paste the whole thing
- 45:42into their separate statement. That is a dangerous
- 45:44maneuver because you're going to end up back
- 45:47importing a lot of commentary and rhetoric and
- 45:52slanted language from your expert that is not
- 45:56proper or appropriate for the MSJ or for the
- 45:59separate statement and will in fact make it easier
- 46:03for the plaintiff to create a dispute, because
- 46:07if you have expert commentary on some arcane
- 46:11medical topic saying, you know, that such and
- 46:17such cell has two nuclei, they're going to be
- 46:21able to have their expert pick it apart and say,
- 46:23no, that cell has one nucleus. And so including
- 46:26a bunch of expert rhetoric is very dangerous.
- 46:32So but it should include every fact in your separate
- 46:35statement plus Facts that are basically amount
- 46:38to dicta. They're sort of the expert version
- 46:41of dicta that provide commentary and background
- 46:45and flesh out and Educate the reader on these
- 46:48topics But are not themselves undisputed facts
- 46:52so The expert declaration can contain whatever
- 46:57your expert thinks is germane to the opinions
- 46:59and explanations of medical topics Plus, most
- 47:02importantly, commentary and transitional phrases
- 47:06that tell the reader why each statement of fact
- 47:08is important. So you won't have that in your
- 47:11separate statement. It'll just be a series of
- 47:13dry facts. But the expert can now tie those all
- 47:17together into a unified narrative. And he can
- 47:25also pepper the thing with commentary on why
- 47:29each of the acts reflected in the chart is proper
- 47:33and within the standard of care. And so I know
- 47:37that the typical practice for defense lawyers
- 47:39is to save all the opinions for the end. Just
- 47:42lay out all the facts, just like they were in
- 47:44the separate statement, and then at the very
- 47:45end, state the opinion. I don't think that's
- 47:48a very effective presentation. I think the more
- 47:51effective presentation is to weave the expert's
- 47:55point of view and his attitude throughout the
- 47:59narrative and to justify each stage of the medical
- 48:03treatment in terms of the standard of care as
- 48:07the story is told. So just as a well -pleaded
- 48:13complaint needs a crucial charging paragraph,
- 48:15so too does an expert declaration need a summary
- 48:19opinion that is responsive to the plaintiff's
- 48:22contentions. So if the capper on the expert deck
- 48:27is just and so -and -so met the standard of care
- 48:31in all respects. That's not a very compelling
- 48:34narrative for the court or to, more importantly,
- 48:38or to persuade the plaintiff's lawyer that he's
- 48:40got a real hard job in front of him. So the summary,
- 48:46the summation opinion by the expert should be
- 48:48very responsive to the plaintiff's contention.
- 48:53So here is... This is actually a page from an
- 49:03appellate opinion, affirming one of my summary
- 49:07judgments, where a judge, this is presiding Justice
- 49:13Moore, pulled out, in a very proud moment for
- 49:19me, why the expert deck was unassailable. So
- 49:26here, my expert said, I understand that the plaintiff
- 49:30is contending that he complained of a possible
- 49:32foreign body and so forth. Even if that's true,
- 49:37the foreign body was removed within a short and
- 49:39reasonable time and within the standard of care.
- 49:41So it's not just a generic statement that the
- 49:45standard of care was met in all respects. It's
- 49:48a specific responsive opinion. that actually
- 49:53addresses what the plaintiff's theory is in the
- 49:55case. Okay, so now we're on a step eight, the
- 50:04memorandum of points and authorities. This might
- 50:06be a little bit controversial or surprising,
- 50:09but hopefully it's good news to some people.
- 50:12Surprise! An MSJ memorandum is not really a legally
- 50:19intensive component. Most memos filed in support
- 50:26of an MSJ are extremely lengthy with lots and
- 50:31lots of boilerplate block quotations from case
- 50:34after case. And I call that the throat clearing.
- 50:37I don't think that the throat clearing case law
- 50:40and statutory block quotes add anything to an
- 50:42MSJ. A judge knows what the standard of an MSJ
- 50:45is. In fact, I think that type of verbosity detracts
- 50:51by burying your content in a pile of legalese.
- 50:56Only discuss pertinent operative legal issues,
- 51:00like statute of limitations or ostensible agency.
- 51:03The judge knows the basic standard and procedure
- 51:05for summary judgment under the code. And I say,
- 51:10in the same way that a trial is about evidence,
- 51:14so too is an MSJ, because it serves the same
- 51:17evidence testing purposes. trial lawyers don't
- 51:21spend the trial making legal arguments to the
- 51:24juries. The MSJ functions much more like a presentation
- 51:28of evidence to a jury because you're presenting
- 51:32evidence to sort of a precursor jury, the court,
- 51:40but it is an evidence testing process. I had
- 51:43just an example just to show that the same memo
- 51:47that was affirmed by that Court of Appeal opinion,
- 51:50it was only eight pages long, and it did have
- 51:53a relatively nuanced legal issue on the side
- 51:58that had to be addressed. But for the most part,
- 52:01it should just be a basic introduction, a slanted
- 52:06statement of facts, and then your expert opinions,
- 52:10because that's all that really matters. So this
- 52:15is just the memo. It's only eight pages long.
- 52:21And then step nine is the notice. Now, this seems
- 52:25like a throwaway thing. This is just a cut and
- 52:28paste job. But I disagree. Well, first off, this
- 52:32is the only place you have to cite CCP 437C.
- 52:38And I have an example here. But what I wanted
- 52:41to get across is that there is an art to the
- 52:45notice. It's not just copying and pasting and
- 52:48plugging in the date that you reserved. It should,
- 52:52with some specificity and content, lay out what
- 52:55the actual issues are in a way that really primes
- 53:00the court to think that this motion has some
- 53:03real substance behind it. So here's a notice,
- 53:09and it's just a good example because it did have
- 53:11an intensive legal issue. where it lent itself
- 53:17to this sort of outline. So the motion is made
- 53:20on the grounds that the plaintiff's claim of
- 53:23battery and Bain Act are facially inapplicable
- 53:26as well as legally precluded under the doctrine
- 53:28of race judicata. So the notice doesn't just
- 53:33say on the grounds that the plaintiff's claim
- 53:35has no merit. It gives a little preview to the
- 53:39specific grounds that are going to be asserted
- 53:41once the judge really gets into the supporting
- 53:46papers. And so I just think that's an important
- 53:49and often overlooked tool in creating an effective
- 53:54MSJ presentation. Okay, so now you've got the
- 54:02four pillars of the motion, the notice, the separate
- 54:05statement, the evidence, and the memo. You've
- 54:09got them all in the bag and you have filed them
- 54:12timely. Your beautiful work of art is complete
- 54:16now what? Well Now you have to be prepared for
- 54:22what to do if the plaintiff does decide to drop
- 54:25the matter and seek out easier prey Again, this
- 54:29is this is common when there are multiple defendants
- 54:34Involved and the plaintiff at the early stages
- 54:38can think that maybe the the wise economic choice
- 54:42is to drop one of them and to focus uh his or
- 54:46her resources on the remaining defendants the
- 54:50target defendants and so uh you might be able
- 54:53to to get out so what do you do when the plaintiff's
- 54:57lawyer calls you up and says hey um maybe we
- 55:00can maybe we can come to an understanding so
- 55:03the twist is you might not want a dismissal So
- 55:08if you have put up such a strong front that the
- 55:13plaintiff's attorney is considering dropping
- 55:15the claim against you, people's first instinct
- 55:18is to say, okay, great, file a dismissal in exchange
- 55:21for a waiver of cost. That, especially if there
- 55:24are multiple defendants involved, that's actually
- 55:26not what you want. The ideal outcome of an MSJ
- 55:29is not necessarily a final ruling or even a voluntary
- 55:33dismissal. The better goal is a written agreement
- 55:37that plaintiff will file a notice of non -opposition
- 55:40in exchange for a waiver of costs. So why would
- 55:45a non -opposition be better than a voluntary
- 55:48dismissal? Well, it's not just better for the
- 55:52moving party. It's better for the plaintiff's
- 55:55attorney. It is mutually beneficial because it
- 55:58will protect the movement's client in this case,
- 56:04the medical provider, from being vilified at
- 56:06trial by a co -defendant. They can't point fingers
- 56:09at an empty chair under CCP437C sub Lima. So
- 56:20that subsection basically says that a defendant
- 56:24at trial cannot assert a theory of comparative
- 56:28fall against any defendant that... obtained summary
- 56:33judgment before trial. And so the defense attorney
- 56:37is going to be nicely covered from any fingers
- 56:41being pointed against it as an empty chair. And
- 56:44it also protects the plaintiff's attorney. So
- 56:47the plaintiff's attorney is going to be insulated
- 56:50from any accusation of fault for dismissing a
- 56:53defendant who may otherwise be blamed at trial
- 56:57because It's not inconceivable that a plaintiff
- 57:02gets thrown into a position where one of the
- 57:05co -defendants can cook up a theory against a
- 57:10dismissed defendant. And the plaintiff's client,
- 57:16the actual plaintiff, is scratching their head
- 57:18and saying, well, how come you let that guy out
- 57:22of this case? the summary judgment is actually
- 57:29granted in favor of that departing defendant,
- 57:34the plaintiff's attorney is protected from that
- 57:36type of unfortunate situation. Also, a trial
- 57:43court will almost always support the granting
- 57:48of an unopposed summary judgment with a pro forma
- 57:52statement that the moving party met the initial
- 57:56burden and that therefore the case against that
- 58:00defendant had no merit. And so both the defense
- 58:04attorney and the plaintiff's attorney are protected
- 58:07by a ruling on an unopposed MSJ. Hopefully that
- 58:15made sense. I hope I put that clearly because
- 58:17I think it's a very important thing to do and
- 58:20can benefit members of the plaintiff's floor.
- 58:23So the ultimate goal is to get it all. You get
- 58:27a resolution with no contest, and you also get
- 58:30a formal ruling in your favor. In other words,
- 58:34both of your audiences have given you the reaction
- 58:37and the reward you hoped for. The end. Thank
- 58:42you so much. I'm going to try to stop sharing
- 58:44my screen. All righty, Marshall. It does look
- 58:55like we have a few questions that you'd like
- 58:57to take the time to answer. Absolutely. I'm trying
- 59:04to stop the share. Did it work? Did I stop the
- 59:06share? Yes. Great. All right. So our first question
- 59:11is from Michael. How do you get the custodian
- 59:13to sign a declaration that satisfies Barabay?
- 59:16They often use their own forms when they respond
- 59:19to the subpoena. Well, they shouldn't do that.
- 59:23OK, so if that's happening, that would be a headache.
- 59:28But that really shouldn't happen because the
- 59:31subpoena companies, it's sort of their duty to
- 59:35make sure that they obtain with the records a
- 59:40custodian deck that passes muster. So if they're
- 59:45not doing their job, that could be a headache.
- 59:49I haven't seen that happen. But if it does, you
- 59:55would need to reach out to a point of contact.
- 1:00:00For instance, if it was a defendant that had
- 1:00:04counsel for a deposition or something, you would
- 1:00:06want to reach out to them. If it's somebody that
- 1:00:10was not represented at any point in the proceedings,
- 1:00:17that's just a practical, that's just a matter
- 1:00:21of legwork. And you would need to either work
- 1:00:24that out with the subpoena company to get a rectified
- 1:00:29declaration, or you would have to reach out to
- 1:00:33the administration of the provider and give them
- 1:00:39a proposed deck and see if they could sign it.
- 1:00:42But that would definitely be a sticky wicket.
- 1:00:47It really shouldn't happen. The only time I've
- 1:00:50ever had to twist a provider's arm is when it
- 1:00:53was my own client. All right. It looks like we
- 1:00:57have another question to combine these two. What
- 1:01:01do most plaintiffs get wrong on MSJ? And then
- 1:01:04what do most defendants get wrong? So I'll answer
- 1:01:09the defendant part first. I think I sort of touched
- 1:01:12on it. The defendants do a lot of superstitious
- 1:01:16things that are unnecessary. But the deep oversight
- 1:01:23that I see on the defense bar is that they forget
- 1:01:27that their burden is to show the absence of any
- 1:01:32dispute of genuine fact. And they think that
- 1:01:34they just have this sort of general opportunity
- 1:01:38to convince the judge that the case is nonsense.
- 1:01:42And they get dragged into arguing, into the weeds
- 1:01:46on things that are going nowhere. This goes so
- 1:01:49far as defense attorneys will, in fact, they'll
- 1:01:54file their own response to the plaintiff's additional
- 1:01:58facts. And this is a very counterproductive process.
- 1:02:04I understand why plaintiffs wanna introduce their
- 1:02:06own additional facts, but I think I can safely
- 1:02:10say that the case is never really gonna turn
- 1:02:15on that. And if the defense... response to the
- 1:02:20additional facts raised by the plaintiff, they're
- 1:02:25basically conceding that there's a question of
- 1:02:28fact. In fact, I've seen filings from the defense
- 1:02:33where they object to the additional facts of
- 1:02:37the plaintiff on the grounds that this is a question
- 1:02:40of fact to be determined by the jury. So, yes,
- 1:02:45the defense bar can often that sour their own
- 1:02:51efforts by losing sight of what their burden
- 1:02:54really is and just trying to argue the merits
- 1:02:56of the case in a general way. What do plaintiffs
- 1:03:00get wrong? So this might be a little more specific,
- 1:03:04but I can tell you that there are a lot of recent
- 1:03:07entrants into medical malpractice that coincide
- 1:03:12with the relaxation of the micro constraints.
- 1:03:18I've seen multiple instances where plaintiff's
- 1:03:20lawyers, they don't really grasp in time that
- 1:03:26they really do need an expert declaration to
- 1:03:29beat MSJ. So if people in the plaintiff's bar
- 1:03:33think that they can create a question of fact
- 1:03:37just with their brilliant arguments, and often
- 1:03:39the arguments are clever, but the more clever
- 1:03:41your arguments have to be, the more likely it
- 1:03:43is you're gonna lose. And the only way you're...
- 1:03:45you're ever going to defeat an MSJ that's supported
- 1:03:49by an expert is by having your own contrary expert.
- 1:03:58All right, and then I have one last question
- 1:04:01here. What language is in the notice of non -opposition?
- 1:04:07I don't think there's any science to it. I think
- 1:04:11that It should it should essentially be a Caption
- 1:04:18the the caption title should read notice of non
- 1:04:20-opposition. It should be filed by the by the
- 1:04:23actual opposing attorney Okay, this is another
- 1:04:25mistake made by the defense bar is the defense
- 1:04:28bar will sometimes File a notice of non -opposition
- 1:04:32on motions Which will only you know, it will
- 1:04:37only spur their opponent into action if anything
- 1:04:41I have never understood them doing that So the
- 1:04:44only person who should ever file a notice of
- 1:04:46non -opposition is the actual party that would
- 1:04:49be opposing. And it should just say, in the case
- 1:04:55of a plaintiff not opposing an MSJ, it should
- 1:04:57just say, Plaintiff Jane Doe hereby gives notice
- 1:05:03that it does not oppose the motion for summary
- 1:05:07judgment filed by defendant Acme Inc. set to
- 1:05:12be heard on such and such a date. So just anything
- 1:05:16that identifies the motion clearly and states
- 1:05:19the intent to waive opposition. All right, that
- 1:05:27looks like it's it for questions. Marshall, do
- 1:05:29you have any other concluding remarks that you'd
- 1:05:31like to make? No, I really thank everybody for
- 1:05:36plugging in. I hope I didn't speak too fast.
- 1:05:40If I can put up my first slide again. Oops. Oh,
- 1:05:44it's too late. Hopefully my email was in the
- 1:05:49course materials. And if not, I guess I can be
- 1:05:56found. Oh, it's on my last slide here. There
- 1:05:58we go. So I'm going to share that again. So if
- 1:06:04anybody wants to email me for. any further clarification
- 1:06:09because I might have gone really fast on some
- 1:06:11of those topics. By all means, feel free to email
- 1:06:15me and I can give you cases or samples or clarification
- 1:06:20if you wish. Perfect. All right. This concludes
- 1:06:25today's presentation. Thank you so much again,
- 1:06:27Marshall, for an excellent presentation today
- 1:06:29and thank you so much to our audience for joining
- 1:06:31us. Have a great day, everybody. Thanks, everybody.