Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / Kublai Khan and the Chinese Scholars Who Resisted Him
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about Kublai's wars — the invasions of Japan, Java, Vietnam — and his big infrastructure projects like the Grand Canal and paper money. But one thing we haven't really touched on is what happened to the Chinese scholar-officials after the Song fell. Luna: You mean the Confucian literati who'd run the civil service for centuries? Lucas: Exactly. Under the Song, these men — and they were almost all men — were the backbone of the state. They passed the imperial examinations, they staffed the bureaucracy, they saw themselves as the moral conscience of the empire. But when the Mongols conquered, suddenly their world was turned upside down. The exams were suspended for decades, and the new rulers didn't really value Confucian learning the same way. Lucas: Many of these scholars faced a painful choice: collaborate with the Mongol regime and risk betraying their principles, or withdraw from public life entirely. The ones who refused to serve called themselves yi min — literally 'leftover subjects' or 'remnant people.' They saw themselves as preserving the true culture of the Song in exile, often in their own minds or in small communities. Luna: Yi min. That's a powerful term — leftover subjects, like scraps of a dynasty that refused to be swept away. Lucas: Right. And one of the most famous yi min was a painter named Zheng Sixiao. He lived through the fall of the Song in the 1270s and retreated into seclusion. He's best known for his ink paintings of orchids — but here's the thing: he always painted them without soil. When someone asked him why, he said the soil had been taken over by the Mongols, so his orchids would not grow on foreign dirt. Luna: That's such a quietly defiant image — orchids without roots, floating in nothing. Lucas: Exactly. It's a subtle but unmistakable protest. And Zheng wasn't alone. There was a whole network of loyalists who wrote poetry about the loss of the Song, who collected artifacts and books, who taught private students outside the official system. They were keeping a flame alive. Lucas: But not everyone could afford to refuse. Some scholars did enter Mongol service — and they faced intense criticism from their peers. The most famous example is Zhao Mengfu. He was a descendant of the Song imperial family, a brilliant painter and calligrapher. In 1286, Kublai Khan personally invited him to court in Dadu, and after much hesitation, he accepted. Luna: A Song prince working for the Mongols — that must have been a huge scandal. Lucas: It was. Zhao Mengfu spent the rest of his life defending his decision. He argued that by serving, he could actually help his fellow Chinese — soften the harsher edges of Mongol rule, protect cultural institutions. And he did produce some remarkable art under the Yuan, blending Song traditions with new influences. But he was always haunted by accusations of betrayal. In his poems, you can feel this deep ambivalence. Lucas: There's also the example of Ma Duanlin, a scholar who never held high office but compiled an enormous encyclopedia called the Wenxian Tongkao — a comprehensive study of Chinese institutions and history. He finished it around 1307, long after the Song fell. Many see it as a quiet act of preservation: he was keeping the intellectual heritage of China alive for future generations, even under Mongol rule. Luna: It's like they found different ways to resist — some by refusing, some by serving but staying true to their values, some by documenting everything so it wouldn't be lost. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thing about intellectual resistance — it's not always loud. Sometimes it's a painting of a rootless orchid, or a poem full of longing, or a massive encyclopedia compiled in obscurity. The Mongols controlled the armies and the taxes, but they couldn't always control what people thought or remembered. Lucas: And speaking of what we remember and preserve — if you've been stepping into history with us episode by episode, you know this show is made possible by listeners who chip in to keep it ad-free and independent. We don't run corporate sponsors, which means we can dig into the specifics that fascinate us, like this quiet corner of Yuan dynasty culture. If you've gotten something out of these conversations, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to help us keep telling stories that don't always make it into the textbooks. Luna: Yeah, it really does make a difference — every bit helps us spend the time on research and scripting. Lucas: So back to those scholar-officials. One of the most interesting tensions was over the civil service exams. Under the Song, the exams were the gateway to power and prestige. But Kublai and his advisors were skeptical. They thought the exams produced men who were good at writing poetry but useless for governing a multi-ethnic empire. So they scrapped them for decades. Luna: They just abolished the entire system? Lucas: For the most part, yes. From 1274 — just before the fall of the Song — until 1315, the exams were not held. That's a whole generation of scholars who had no way to enter official life through the traditional route. Some adapted by learning practical skills like accounting or law, which the Yuan valued. Others simply retreated into private study. Lucas: This created a real crisis of identity for the literati. Their whole self-image was built on being the moral guides of society — but under the Mongols, they were often sidelined in favor of Central Asian Muslims or even European adventurers like Marco Polo. The Semu — the 'colored-eye people,' as they were called — held many key posts. Luna: So the scholars who did end up serving were often in lower-ranking positions or cultural roles. Lucas: Exactly. They were kept at arm's length from real power. But they still found ways to exert influence. For example, Zhao Mengfu used his position to recommend other Chinese scholars for posts, and he helped preserve calligraphy and painting traditions at the imperial court. There's a sense that they were playing a long game — trying to Sinicize the Yuan from within. Lucas: And then there were those who simply refused any contact with the regime. One story tells of a scholar named Xie Ao, who after the Song's final defeat, wandered the mountains for years, weeping and writing poems. He once visited a famous site associated with a Song loyalist from centuries earlier — the poet Wen Tianxiang, who had been executed by the Mongols — and wrote a lament that became a classic. Luna: There's something so poignant about that — a man mourning his lost dynasty by communing with the ghost of another loyalist. Lucas: It really captures the mood. The yi min weren't just political dissidents; they were creating a whole culture of remembrance. They wrote poems about the old capital, Lin'an, now called Hangzhou, and idealized the Song as a golden age of refinement. Some of them even refused to use the Yuan calendar, dating their works by Song reign names long after those had ceased to be official. Lucas: This kind of cultural resistance probably mattered more than any armed rebellion. The Mongols could defeat armies, but they couldn't erase the memory of a thousand years of Chinese civilization. And in the end, the Yuan dynasty only lasted about a century. When it fell, the scholars who had preserved those traditions were ready to step back in. Luna: So the Ming dynasty that followed really picked up where the Song left off, culturally speaking? Lucas: In many ways, yes. The Ming restored the civil service exams and promoted Neo-Confucianism. They consciously framed themselves as the heirs of the Song, skipping over the Yuan as a foreign interruption. And the works of the yi min — the poems, the paintings, the encyclopedias — became touchstones for that revival. So in a sense, the scholars who refused to serve Kublai Khan ended up having the last word. Luna: It's amazing how a quiet refusal can echo through centuries. Lucas: That's what I love about this story. We tend to think of history as battles and treaties, but sometimes the most powerful force is a person who simply says no — and then spends the rest of their life cultivating what they love, preserving it for the future.