Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP233: The Future of Analytics and Digital Marketing: Insights From The Elevar Summit
Transcript
- 0:03You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 0:05experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 0:11featuring interviews with leading e-commerce, retailers,
- 0:14industry thoughtless and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:19and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:25help fine tune your ecom strategy and tech stack.
- 0:28Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James or Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:33We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Today's episode is sponsored by Scale Commerce Engine and Swap
- 0:38Commerce. And let me set the scene.
- 0:40We're talking about the L of our summit in the US that Paul and
- 0:43Josh from Vivald recently attended, focused on the feature
- 0:46of analytics, digital marketing. So this can be a fun episode for
- 0:49me because it's one where I get to sit back and grill and Marcel
- 0:51its questions and learn what's going on.
- 0:55So let's let's start. Well, let's do a quick intro
- 0:57because Josh, you haven't been on the podcast before, have you?
- 0:59I've just realised it's your first time.
- 1:01Well. So do you know heard a lot about
- 1:04the podcast and I am an an avid listener and yeah, so the other
- 1:08Co founder of the barn I the cast, the performance marketing
- 1:11side. And yeah, I've been in
- 1:13performance for well years or so.
- 1:16And yeah, Paul and I've worked together so about nine years and
- 1:21then four with them on seven years ago.
- 1:22Oh and yeah, glad to be at forecast.
- 1:27Yeah, great to have you on. And I know that Paul did
- 1:29brilliantly and drop you in on this literally a couple of hours
- 1:31ago to say we're doing a podcast.
- 1:33So in in true inside commerce planning, it's almost like real
- 1:36types. See.
- 1:38I'm intrigued. Yeah, yeah, true lastminute.com
- 1:43podcasting. So let's get let's get crazy.
- 1:47Let's set a bit of a scene, because there'll be people who
- 1:49know who relevant are, people who don't, and those who won't
- 1:53have a clue what this event was about.
- 1:55So let's give it a context, But what was the event?
- 1:57What was it about? What were the core topics being
- 1:59discussed? And obviously, why is this
- 2:01interesting to the E Com audience?
- 2:04Yeah, great. So I'll start that one because a
- 2:06lot of these topics are more relevant to Josh.
- 2:09So I'll let him kind of cover a lot of the other questions.
- 2:13Yeah, basically. And it was quite interesting
- 2:15actually because like you, I attend quite a lot of E com
- 2:18events, but I've not attended many around kind of analytics
- 2:22data and kind of a few surrounding topics for
- 2:26performance. So yeah, I found it really
- 2:28interesting. But yeah, like main topics were
- 2:32kind of measurement in general, kind of reporting trends like
- 2:36all of the privacy shifts and kind of data collection
- 2:39generally. There's a lot of talk around
- 2:42kind of profit level optimization for performance.
- 2:46So kind of gearing how you're talking about performance to
- 2:50like ACFO or CEO, but also kind of optimizing towards AP and L,
- 2:55which was quite interesting for me, again, just because I'm not
- 2:59exposed to those kind of conversations as much.
- 3:03And then kind of brand creative content was the last theme, just
- 3:07because I think again just from hearing Josh talk a lot, it's
- 3:10kind of where performance has gone in terms of like really
- 3:14pushing kind of growth and you know, kind of gearing up
- 3:18activity, all that kind of stuff.
- 3:20So they were the main ones. Anything you'd add to that?
- 3:22Well, the only thing I'd touch on is we'll probably reference
- 3:25our talk a few times in the podcast.
- 3:27So our talk was very all-encompassing and we probably
- 3:30touched on all of those areas. So we might have to do a bit of
- 3:33that view with kind of like 2024 where brands should be
- 3:37prioritising and we kind of touched on small parts of the
- 3:41loss you ever talked and but yeah, they were kind of like the
- 3:45key things from. Just to add to just to add a bit
- 3:48of context to that. So yeah, I've known Brad for
- 3:51quite a long time, elevated their first conference last year
- 3:55which looked like it was a big success.
- 3:57I think it's about a hundred 150 people.
- 4:00So this year was a little bit bigger, I think it was probably
- 4:02more around 2:50. And yeah, it's just the kind of
- 4:05their similar to kind of the conference we run, it's kind of
- 4:09their customer partner and then generally kind of industry
- 4:15conference focused on all the areas around their product,
- 4:18which is primarily kind of measurement and you know server
- 4:22side tracking all of that stuff. Hi, I'm Thomas, Director, Growth
- 4:26at Scale, the world's fastest growing e-commerce platform has
- 4:30landed in the UK with global brands like Manchester United,
- 4:34Deichmann, Snipes and Marco Polo trusting us to scale their
- 4:37commerce businesses. Are you ready for a new E Com
- 4:40experience? Talk to Scale today, because
- 4:42life is just too short for painful commerce.
- 4:46Excellent. Well, let's drill into it in
- 4:48some of the specifics. So the the first area is you
- 4:50said there was quite big focus on privacy changes and
- 4:53attribution. I'm not surprised the
- 4:54attribution words come up because that's still something
- 4:57they should have had 10 years down the line where people are
- 4:59still struggling about exactly how to do it.
- 5:02So yeah, I guess just what were the key discussion points and
- 5:04outcomes? Yeah, so.
- 5:08So there's a. Few different themes.
- 5:10So I think one of the core areas we picked up on was from our
- 5:15perspective a lot of brands aren't fully utilizing GF Four
- 5:18and aren't using it to the extent of its capability.
- 5:21So whether people aren't confident using the platform or
- 5:24just kind of like haven't built out a lot of the reporting and
- 5:28functionality and but it does feel like the capability is
- 5:31quite far ahead of how brands are using it.
- 5:34And there's also much more which can be done with
- 5:36personalisation. So L of R done kind of like AP
- 5:40note at the end and it was talking about their road map and
- 5:44essentially they wanted to begin feeding in consumer data to
- 5:48offline data segments. So you've got a much more
- 5:51comprehensive view of your audience.
- 5:53So you know you might know if they might know if every income,
- 5:56you might know their lifestyle and interests.
- 5:58So way beyond just kind of like behaviour on site having that
- 6:02tied back to other data sources. So I think everything out of our
- 6:06looking to introduce on that front will be really
- 6:08interesting. And then yeah, a lot of kind of
- 6:10like talk around third party tools.
- 6:13So triple well N bean obviously it's kind of a commoditized
- 6:17space now in terms of attribution tools.
- 6:19So I'm sure we'll come on to attribution Chairman's more
- 6:22specifically. But yeah, that was kind of like
- 6:25a big overall discussion around how GA can be used, help is
- 6:30used, and and then, yeah, kind of like an overview of the
- 6:33different solutions from that attribution sector.
- 6:36And I was just going to add to that.
- 6:37So I think with the GA point, majority of people there,
- 6:41because we'll come on to kind of people's hatred of GA 4, which I
- 6:46think, James, you and I have talked about in the past and
- 6:48kind of trends around that. But I think what you're
- 6:50referring to there is kind of more you can do around some of
- 6:54the native models and kind of more kind of custom tracking
- 6:58within GA 4, which can then be taken out of GA and used via
- 7:04other solutions and data warehouses and whatever it was.
- 7:07And the only other thing I was going to add is so L of R was
- 7:10acquired a month ago, two months ago, something like that.
- 7:13And and it was the box at Buxton and their power company.
- 7:16And they're more focused on consumer data and like consumer
- 7:19intelligence. Quite cool hearing how they're
- 7:22planning on using the two datasets and yeah, kind of
- 7:26stitching together some of the like first party data with other
- 7:32sources of data. Swap is the e-commerce operating
- 7:36system powering brands looking to scale from shipping, tracking
- 7:38and package protection to returns.
- 7:40And cross-border Swap improves every pain point in your
- 7:43operations journey, trading your tech stack for the one system
- 7:45that can manage it. Or this is e-commerce Evolved.
- 7:49I know Josh you you got some some other discussion points
- 7:51around attribution later so I'll I'll park.
- 7:53That for you? Let's move on to.
- 7:56So I was quite interested, we were talking before we start
- 7:58record about you're saying that that there's a big shift towards
- 8:01the investment in content and creative.
- 8:05So and that was covered you covered in your talk was covered
- 8:07in other ones. Can you be a bit more explicit
- 8:09on that? So what on what area is this?
- 8:11Is this in your, you know, the bitch you look after around the
- 8:14fullest margin? Is this in broader brand
- 8:15creative? Yeah, Sunday.
- 8:18So on that ball was that China survey which he kind of bite
- 8:21round to a number of E contractors before we went out.
- 8:24And but yeah, big part of our talk was around rather content
- 8:28and how we're seeing essentially retailers move back to brand
- 8:32storytelling, long form content that moving away from purely
- 8:37relying on alternated tactics. So you know P Max and ASC
- 8:41generally has a bit of a ceiling and you do need to be running
- 8:44supplementary activity which is you know long before and you're
- 8:47reaching the right audience, you're serving more engaging
- 8:49content. That was 1 clock.
- 8:51What's slightly interesting around essentially how to build
- 8:54the best of and the core theme now was modularity or like
- 8:59modular creative. So this is the big thing we're
- 9:01seeing in the space where essentially what you'd do is
- 9:04you'd build a 10 second video with four different frames and
- 9:08then you've got the ability to change different frames based on
- 9:11the performance metrics. So if for instance your thumb
- 9:15stock ratio, which is the percentage of people who watch
- 9:18over 3 seconds, if that's very low, you would change the first
- 9:22sequence, so you'd change the 1st frame.
- 9:25So what you're seeing now is like much more advertisers
- 9:29testing within the creative itself.
- 9:30So you've got the ability to kind of like build 50 ads from
- 9:34one wrong video where you're just like cropping and changing
- 9:38different segments of the film. So that was a big part of their
- 9:40talk and their proposed view of the best asset was essentially
- 9:45having like a foot and a problem and then an introduction to a
- 9:49brand and then the demo. So I think that's obviously
- 9:51relevant to the set of brands potentially not as much for a
- 9:55you know premium fashion brand who we tend to work with.
- 9:59But yeah their view as well was quite similar around testing you
- 10:02know multiple variations of those last three seconds to
- 10:05understand what really captures attention.
- 10:08And and yeah, kind of like within our talk as well, we had
- 10:12a number of studies which kind of like went into the
- 10:16understanding of like how do you drive attention and yeah, how
- 10:20much more benefit is there if you drive attention versus just
- 10:24serving the impression. And you know, we just in the
- 10:26display landscape, you're seeing the ad platform starting to use
- 10:33eye tracking technology, so they can kind of like report back to
- 10:36retailers whether people are actually watching the ad and
- 10:39viewing the ad as opposed to just being served an impression.
- 10:42So as there's so much movement in the space from I guess both
- 10:46the content perspective and then equally if you have platforms in
- 10:49terms of how do we actually track whether people are
- 10:52watching and engaging with content?
- 10:54So I guess I'll add to that and so watch I should talk about
- 10:58very different to my kind of knowledge and experience.
- 11:03But I think we've definitely seen a trend where our clients
- 11:06are investing higher proportion of their budget in photography,
- 11:10storytelling like even the higher level like kind of
- 11:13overall design art direction to build kind of more of a branded
- 11:18experience And like some of that will be tested against
- 11:21performance traffic as well. So like top of funnel demand and
- 11:25like you know sending them to a more branded experience versus
- 11:29kind of traditional econ landing pages and templates.
- 11:34And I think so we did this mini survey with 25 ecom directors
- 11:38just to get a view of that and that and the highest increase
- 11:45investment area was photography. But I think to your what you
- 11:48were just talking about that and the bit that I think you missed
- 11:51was our average client is basically spending a lot more on
- 11:56the creative side and like producing video and you know
- 11:59they're factoring kind of adds more into photo shoots and all
- 12:03that stuff, right? Actually, yeah.
- 12:04So one thing I'd add on that point as well just around the
- 12:07importance of content, we bought into creative.
- 12:10So like as an agency now we've moved towards targeting our
- 12:14audience through the creative. So we've got an amazing like
- 12:18reference with one client where historically they've been very
- 12:22user generated content. First they relied on influences,
- 12:27it's been kind of like quite a young and sun brand and they've
- 12:30kept that part of their activity is BAU cut by.
- 12:33They've kept campaign stalk around that and they've
- 12:36introduced a brand new form of content.
- 12:38So it would be much more premium, it's much more
- 12:41lifestyle. And what we found is that
- 12:44Facebook is reaching a new audience that content, so
- 12:47reaching people who the Aovs panics and I are generally
- 12:51speaking they're an older audience and rather than going
- 12:55out to meta with a new target profile on Nuke the seminar, we
- 12:59just built content which talks about audience.
- 13:02So this is kind of like one of the key trends we're saying
- 13:04seeing and and what it does require.
- 13:07So it does require brands have like a multitude of content.
- 13:11They've got different types of content for different audiences.
- 13:15One of the brands randomly, which gets recognised quite a
- 13:18lot as Dove. So if you look at the Facebook
- 13:22ad library, just look at the content they push out.
- 13:24They've just got so much and it's like a brilliant example as
- 13:28to how they talk such a bloated audience through different types
- 13:32of content. So yeah, just from a great
- 13:34perspective, content is key and and one of the reasons why we're
- 13:38seeing like more investment in. Area and I guess that was a
- 13:41pretty big theme of the event generally because one theatre we
- 13:44were on last on the second day or pretty much last, which is I
- 13:48guess the concern was that there would be themes and trends which
- 13:51don't mean a line with what we were talking about, but it did
- 13:54end up being a big focus for most people's talk so.
- 13:57A lot of. People's talk.
- 13:59Yeah. Question view this because I
- 14:00guess there'll be people listening to this thinking look
- 14:02I I get that and a band like Dove, they have the resource and
- 14:05the team size. It feels like it, it feels like
- 14:09a play for bigger teams and is this a play, is this a
- 14:12resourcing, is it a budget thing, Is it both because
- 14:15typically the brands I work, I don't work with as many I guess
- 14:19premium like fashion brands like you guys do.
- 14:21I've worked with a couple of luxury brands over the years and
- 14:24and the ones who I've seen where they've gone down investment
- 14:27they they've either been people with big internal content teams
- 14:30and and like art direction in house or they're people with a
- 14:34big big investment budget where they can then outsource
- 14:37specialist agencies and do that at volume with because the
- 14:40internal team called teller. I said what what you see, what
- 14:43type of business does they see? What resources do you need to
- 14:45make this work? So I mean that's a great
- 14:48question and that many jumping in now quickly because that's a
- 14:50big part of our like hated social offering is around how we
- 14:55recreate it. And we certainly work with
- 14:57brands without huge pockets to just be investing in you know
- 15:01different Butch and hunt knees. And I'll say generally what we'd
- 15:05recommend is just having, it's quite easy to leave a shoot with
- 15:08all of your content that's been quite consistent and quite
- 15:11similar. So we would just recommend
- 15:13having, you know you on the shoot itself.
- 15:15You've got different lenses which are bacon photography with
- 15:19and there's a lot like shooter brands who use separate flash
- 15:22for instance or it just gives you a completely different look
- 15:24and feel of the content. It's still within the same shoot
- 15:28itself and you might use different transitions to so it
- 15:31looks more engaging. It's faster moving so you can
- 15:35you can build out kind of like different styles of content
- 15:39within kind of like your current start again.
- 15:41So yeah it doesn't necessarily need to be completely different
- 15:45and but what we would recommend is come back on the day just
- 15:48having you know you're doing different transitions.
- 15:51You're kind of like got some fast movement, some slow
- 15:53movement, but lenses and angles that you're using.
- 15:56So there's quite a lot you can do just within your current
- 15:59scope of how you produce them. One thing I was just going to
- 16:02add to that just so it doesn't sound sales is I think a lot of
- 16:05paid agencies are going this way just because of the importance
- 16:07of creatives like most agencies will be the same.
- 16:10And then one other thing I was going to ask, I guess just
- 16:16purely because this isn't my area as well.
- 16:18So they were talking about influencer whitelisting like
- 16:20stuff like that. I guess is an alternative to
- 16:22that, right As well. And like, do people do people
- 16:25tend to use like content from other places still like because
- 16:29for a while like that TikTok style content was massive and
- 16:32like low budget and yeah. Yeah, great budget and side set.
- 16:35So our client base doesn't typically use like a massive
- 16:40array of influences of space, but it certainly is still a
- 16:44hugely growing industry. So influencers is kind of like a
- 16:47segment as more money going in but than other influencer
- 16:51whitelisting of which is a big trend with that.
- 16:53So essentially what influencer whitelisting is, is where it
- 16:57looks as though the ad is being pushed from their organic page.
- 17:01So it looks much more organic and it gives much more social
- 17:06proof behind the ad where it's not being pushed from the up
- 17:08iser, it's being pushed on your Glencer.
- 17:11So this is the tribal standby introduced maybe even two years
- 17:14ago or so now, but it's becoming much more of a common tactic.
- 17:18And so, yeah, the influence of space is probably one of the
- 17:21main areas where people are are able to diversify their content
- 17:25quite cost effectively. And you know, there's so many
- 17:28tools now which allow brands to reach out to influencers.
- 17:32So there's so many kind of like marketplaces as such, which
- 17:36would be good luck to look at as one Shopify app where it gives
- 17:40you the Instagram followers for all of your past purchases.
- 17:43It's dual tech, isn't that we've got, we've got a couple of
- 17:47clients that use that and I think they do have e-mail as
- 17:50well and they just highlight, yeah, basically anyone who has
- 17:54some level of influence, it's purchased.
- 17:56And that and that's just a great way to kind of like reach out to
- 17:58and new influencers. And yeah, as as we've mentioned,
- 18:01if you're looking to build out more content more quickly and at
- 18:05lower cost influences, we're a great OTP and obviously you've
- 18:09got the trend of like micro influences as well in terms of
- 18:12adding you know lower cost access to to more people
- 18:17building to the long term. And one of the talks you said
- 18:21was about performance channels and thinking more about the the
- 18:25P&L and working towards financial metrics not just
- 18:28campaign based metrics. Can you just talk a bit through
- 18:30that like what what was being talked about?
- 18:33Are you seeing this trend? You know, is this something
- 18:35you've seen in your accounts as well?
- 18:38I'll maybe I'll start that because I found it particularly
- 18:40interesting. So the guy is called Taylor
- 18:42Holiday who a lot of people might have heard of.
- 18:44So he's found a common thread Co or collective.
- 18:48So they're quite well known for putting a lot of really good
- 18:51content out there. They've got a really good log,
- 18:53lots of templates. We realised after it's one of
- 18:55our clients is using that P&L template actually which is
- 18:59essentially like a digital marketing report and tracker
- 19:04that is built off the back of AP and L But yeah, I found that
- 19:08really interesting actually because I guess I again I hadn't
- 19:10been exposed to it. He was talking about basically
- 19:13just relating the day-to-day performance to like EBITDA and
- 19:17he was talking a lot about like cost of goods sold and stuff
- 19:20like that where that fits into like a modern strategy.
- 19:23But yeah, Josh, it's your your areas.
- 19:25Yeah, certainly. So I think you know the start of
- 19:29our talk, we pre faced it with kind of like the increase in
- 19:32media spend and this is in the US specifically, but there's
- 19:36kind of like such a rising area and there's more and more brands
- 19:39who are reliant on performance marketing as a channel.
- 19:42So what we're seeing just before any of this kind of like was
- 19:45introduced was just more scrutiny performance investment.
- 19:49So you know we're now having much more calls with finance
- 19:52teams, there's more private equity involvement in terms of
- 19:55how we're spending money and but generally speaking there's just
- 19:58more scrutiny and what every pound being spent.
- 20:01So what we're seeing is more I guess.
- 20:06More expectation that around what's being reported that.
- 20:09So historically you just report that a ROWAS number, it would
- 20:13probably be in platform and we'll obviously come back to
- 20:16come by attribution that there's a lot of limitations of that
- 20:19whereas some part of a holidays saw was around pulling in
- 20:25inventory is a Oh yeah that mark as to how you optimize.
- 20:32So if you are working to a cat or a customer acquisition cost
- 20:36and you're hardly to spend £50 on each new customer, you might
- 20:40be willing to spend 80 LB on the new customer if it's sold on
- 20:45stock which has been kind of like not sold in the last nine
- 20:49months, you know, so that was it.
- 20:51An interesting point around using inventory as a factor and
- 20:55how would you make decisions And then that's kind of in mind with
- 20:57what we had banned in our folks. So for a lot of our science will
- 21:01bake in returns data and serve a certain product is more likely
- 21:04to be returned. You might want to be a bit more
- 21:07aggressive with what your cack is.
- 21:09And then equally if you've got a certain product category.
- 21:11And I quite like the example from lululemon where underwear's
- 21:16a man and black lady and females where they're much more likely
- 21:19to buy again if that's the first product they buy.
- 21:22And so essentially what brands should be doing is looking at
- 21:25having different allowable cats or Rowas based on what's being
- 21:30bought. So if you know there's a product
- 21:32which doesn't get returned, it's high margin and it's more like
- 21:36beast drive like on value, you can justify a much more higher
- 21:41cap than can watch your standard products.
- 21:43So, yeah, that was some of the data I guess around like being
- 21:47able to pulling in And then yeah, Taylor's talk was more
- 21:50advanced around essentially reporting back on how the
- 21:54metrics impact EBITDA. And a lot of that was around the
- 21:57inventory pieces. I wasn't it.
- 21:59So, like, not essentially selling the infantry?
- 22:01Fast enough and stuff like that, Yeah, Exactly how quickly can
- 22:04you buy new stock based on your sell out rate and and nothing
- 22:09else? Yeah, I love that bit around the
- 22:12infantry piece because you also get that that whole that that
- 22:15conflict where different parts of business want to sell the
- 22:17same stock file and if someone's aggressively discounting for
- 22:21performance to to acquire customers, but actually that
- 22:23stock sells really well anyway at full price.
- 22:26You get that whole margin erosion for no reason and you're
- 22:29better off focusing on the products.
- 22:30So yeah, very interesting. The next thing you said was a
- 22:34big theme and I'm not surprised because Paul, we've talked about
- 22:37a bit on this podcast and I mean literally every business you
- 22:39work with nowadays is obsessed with first party data, capturing
- 22:43more data using it. Yeah.
- 22:45One of the areas we talked to previously is about, you know,
- 22:47using the accounts areas more effectively to capture data,
- 22:52working the pet brand lilies, they're doing stuff around pet
- 22:54profiles and that's feeding it to CRM.
- 22:57So lots of people are doing this.
- 22:58What was being discussed at the conference?
- 23:01What were some of the interesting outtakes?
- 23:04Yeah. So, so I mean it's very, a lot
- 23:06of it was kind of very in line with what we've discussed
- 23:08before. So essentially pushing people to
- 23:11build an account, building accounts like kind of some of
- 23:14the mechanisms you can use to make that more appealing to a
- 23:17consumer. So you know things like free
- 23:19shipping, free returns, all of that stuff and some of the kind
- 23:23of economics around that as well.
- 23:27And then kind of the best places to then kind of ask for more
- 23:31data be that kind of a proactive question.
- 23:34So like one of the examples I mentioned in my talk was
- 23:36interior define and I know they push the Swatch journey a lot
- 23:41and in my experience that whole piece massively increases
- 23:45conversion. And you know it's obviously a
- 23:47core journey for anyone in kind of furniture or those types of
- 23:51kind of build your or kind of you know manufactured products.
- 23:57And as part of that you know once they've got a certain way
- 24:00through the process they will ask questions about the project,
- 24:02about your kind of core interests etcetera And that
- 24:06principle was talked about quite a lot.
- 24:08So like and it's the same as the quiz style things.
- 24:11So just being a bit more proactive around how you're
- 24:14capturing data through different journeys and then pushing that
- 24:17into your CRM or CDP and you know trying to stitch that
- 24:20together of other data. So yeah, and then bit more
- 24:24around kind of data capture generally it's been a bit more
- 24:26proactive. We spent a bit of time talking
- 24:28to Matt from Faring which is a post post purchase data capture
- 24:34company. So they're a bit bigger than us.
- 24:36Obviously we've got a little kind of side project that we run
- 24:39called Census, but they've been doing it a lot longer and it's
- 24:43quite interesting hearing some of his insights and how people
- 24:45are using that. I think you know their bigger
- 24:48focus is attribution. But again you can collect a lot
- 24:50of data in a post purchase survey and then the last bits
- 24:54which to be perfectly honest I did struggle to understand a lot
- 24:57of it that was around the whole Buxton and Allivar piece.
- 25:01So essentially Allivar doing their best to track every single
- 25:06conversion and interaction with the site and all of those key
- 25:10points like via the server side tracking and you know offline
- 25:14tracking etcetera. And then stitching that together
- 25:17with Buxton's data which would be more likely to house like you
- 25:21know retail store visits and visits to your competitors sites
- 25:26and things like that. But it is super interesting like
- 25:30kind of where they were talking about getting to, but there was
- 25:33quite a lot that that went over my head.
- 25:35I don't actually agree with that, Josh.
- 25:37Well, yeah, I guess it kind of would be comparable to like like
- 25:41being in your CRM and so like Xperia and just going, you know,
- 25:45a broader mosaic profile at consumers.
- 25:47But as Paul said, it's like. They do more like.
- 25:49Real line, yeah. Stuck in in real time.
- 25:51Yeah. Like where consumers are like
- 25:54they've gone into a competitive store.
- 25:56So it's like that reference that it's made tie ends.
- 25:59To and they talked about being able to like essentially target
- 26:02people via different channels based on like a customer walking
- 26:06past the store and stuff like that.
- 26:07Well, I did not necessarily your store.
- 26:09So we need to get them on. I think would be the ideal
- 26:12because I felt that I it was super interesting, but one, I
- 26:15wasn't paying loads of attention because it was the last talk,
- 26:18just straight after ours. And also it was, yeah, quite,
- 26:22quite complicated. OK.
- 26:27So yeah, that sounds like that that that's an area to drill
- 26:30into. Definitely.
- 26:31I'm intrigued by that that that real time real time target.
- 26:34I be to be honest this this is shades of discussions that I had
- 26:38several years ago when were people talking about all of the
- 26:42things you could do whether it was beacons you name it, the,
- 26:44you know the, the, the situation, locational devices
- 26:48that could interact with people's device, mobile devices,
- 26:51apps and then start to target in real time.
- 26:55It never really went anywhere. So I've been treated to know
- 26:58what's going on there. But let's move on.
- 27:00Let's move on to the next bit which will definitely be of
- 27:02interest when listening is come back to a point about
- 27:06attribution and reporting attribution trends around
- 27:10attribution generally. So Josh, do you want to give us
- 27:12a bit more insights? What what are the hot topics?
- 27:15What are the interesting Nuggets that you took away from the
- 27:18summer? Yeah, definitely.
- 27:21So it's going to be, I'll answer this about I guess just giving
- 27:24my own view as to essentially what what good practice would be
- 27:28and and I guess more So what Google and Macca are pushing out
- 27:33in terms of their communications and recommendations for it.
- 27:36But I guess overall that one of the key outtakes was just how
- 27:40much more of a commodity and 3rd party attribution tools are now
- 27:45and versus kind of like 15 years ago.
- 27:47You know historically for a media mix model you would be
- 27:51looking at an Accenture or someone to run modelling or your
- 27:55house WPT agency, you know from like running these programs for
- 27:59you. Whereas now essentially any
- 28:02merchant or retailer can plug into an elemental to get that
- 28:07letter of output in terms of essentially A regression model
- 28:11building the correlation correlation between Mediaspat
- 28:14and revenue and then showing you kind of like a true
- 28:18contribution. But one of the one of the key
- 28:20themes would be the combination of multi touch attribution and
- 28:25MMM. So one of the one of the key
- 28:27reasons we're seeing this is due to multi touch attribution
- 28:32missing the impact of the views and impressions.
- 28:36So multiple touch only takes you so far if you're running YouTube
- 28:40campaigns where you're not necessarily giving your
- 28:45attribution tool all of the data around all of the views you're
- 28:48serving on YouTube or video on demand or whatever it might be.
- 28:52So one of the biggest themes is kind of like how those two have
- 28:56been combined and a lot of solutions do this now.
- 29:00So all you need to do is Google, you know Triple L and you'll
- 29:03have all of our competitors kind of like fitting on the brand and
- 29:07trying to showcase that on their offer that and yeah, most
- 29:11schools are quite similar now. So Triple Ln being foster, three
- 29:14main ones we look at and some of our plaintudes, but it would be
- 29:18the combination of NCA and MMN. What I quite like is the
- 29:23comprehensive data it gives you. So within Triple L for instance,
- 29:26it says 7 different attribution tools you can use.
- 29:31But the, the overall kind of like trend in the industry, and
- 29:34I guess this is less so than what was brought out in L Bar,
- 29:37but just more so in the industry, is that there's no
- 29:40true way of having a complete accurate view of your
- 29:44attribution. And what we're starting to see
- 29:47now is the introduction of experimentation to really prove
- 29:52your, yeah, your model. So what brands will start to
- 29:56really do is they'll use a third party tool to hypothesize what
- 30:01each channel drives and then they'll run some form of
- 30:03experimentation to test it. So what I quite like is you're
- 30:06seeing almost return of control and expose testing.
- 30:11So you know historically where 10 people would see your ad, 10
- 30:14people would see a charity ad, if seven people buy.
- 30:17If you saw your ad and three people who'd buy who sold
- 30:20charity ads, you know, Yep, that's just the four and you
- 30:23would model that into essentially what you had spent.
- 30:26So what we're starting to see if like more models relying on that
- 30:32validation or what you're seeing in future is kind of like an and
- 30:35then will be calibrated via these test results.
- 30:38So real time they'll just be calibrated and adjusted
- 30:42basically based on these test results.
- 30:44And then equally as Paul mentioned at start, you're also
- 30:46seeing survey data as a proxy to kind of like speeding in the
- 30:51accuracy of the model. So you're now also using survey
- 30:54data and by yeah, validate what what your mother was pulling
- 30:58out. So overall I think the key theme
- 31:00is there's more data than other. And you know if you look at
- 31:05Triple L for instance, it almost operates like Bigquery and you
- 31:08can query the data to get out, you know your VIP, top spending
- 31:13customer, what channel that they touched in the last year.
- 31:15You know you could put up more dates than other.
- 31:19But there's no one who's solely confident in what model to give
- 31:22you or what the actual kind of like contribution is.
- 31:26So I'd imagine you're going to see more and more brands running
- 31:29their own experimentation to really foods food hypothesis.
- 31:34Yeah. So that that's interesting about
- 31:36the experimentation. I hadn't heard about that that
- 31:38kind of pickup in that trend. But what what always makes me
- 31:41laugh at attribution is, is that we're basically back to where we
- 31:44were. Square one, where there are
- 31:45different models and no one's 100% accurate.
- 31:48But almost with attribution, it's you've got to pick a model
- 31:51and use it to make decisions and model and and check and validate
- 31:55the impact of making decision off the back of it rather than
- 31:58trying to do everything at once. Although from what Josh said, it
- 32:02sounds like people now modelling the models.
- 32:04Yeah, the new track and. We'll add some AI on top of that
- 32:08to model that and make sure it's all right.
- 32:10I I do, I do the the experimentation thing though I
- 32:12like it because it's coming back to bring in scientific data into
- 32:16it, which is if you can do a control and test cell and
- 32:18measure it a decent size of sales, you get a read on the
- 32:23impact and at least you can make a more informed decision about
- 32:25your strategy. So that makes perfect sense.
- 32:29Final question then. Well let's bring this back fully
- 32:32to the glory of GA 4. I'm not in the in the weed to
- 32:36the data anymore as much as I used to be but even anecdotally
- 32:41for the limited amount I use GA4I find it an absolute arse of
- 32:44a tool compared with UA. Therefore for non analytical
- 32:49non-technical people I just don't think it's a good
- 32:51interface. You made an interesting comment
- 32:53earlier just about people still still using it quite a lot but
- 32:56they're not doing they're not doing it within the tool because
- 32:58the interface actually they're using the data to export it.
- 33:01So I'd love to hear what your what your overall seeing and
- 33:04what your I I guess what your advice is when you're working
- 33:07with clients. Is Is are?
- 33:09Yeah. Are people using less GA for
- 33:11less or are they just spending less time within the tool and
- 33:14are they moving to other tools to do like visualisation and
- 33:17reporting? So maybe I'll, I'll start this
- 33:21So exactly I'm discuss reporting a bit more or maybe that's not
- 33:24true actually different sides to report it.
- 33:27Yeah, I would say in my recent experience like majority of
- 33:33people are trying to avoid being in the UI of GI and I think that
- 33:37started off as people using different tools and like you
- 33:42know the ones that I've listed here that our clients tend to
- 33:45use. So Polar Analytics number of our
- 33:46clients moving to pretty affordable and yeah nice set of
- 33:52reports around acquisition on site.
- 33:55Fairly basic though like customer and then like general
- 33:59kind of like trade dashboard, Omni commerce, very similar 42
- 34:03very similar suite analytics pretty similar.
- 34:06And the interesting thing that I took out of the elevator, one of
- 34:10the most interesting is how many people are actually using
- 34:13Bigquery themselves and using look at Studio alongside it.
- 34:18And I would say I was quite surprised at that like so many
- 34:21people have actually rebuilt a lot of their reporting
- 34:25themselves and you know that is pulling data from in particular
- 34:28if your stack is Shopify, Google Meta Clavier.
- 34:33A few others like they're using either pre built connectors or
- 34:36services or they're just using the OR they're just pulling the
- 34:39data out of the APR is straight into Bigquery and then they're
- 34:42using look at Studio to visualise different data.
- 34:45And yeah, so many people were doing that, that we talked to at
- 34:48that event. And one of our clients, Timex,
- 34:51came to the event and he was talking around how he's
- 34:54gradually rebuilt all of their reporting with that approach.
- 34:58So yeah, it's quite interesting. And one interesting thing that
- 35:00I, or one thing that I found particularly interesting about
- 35:03overusing the word interested was that he was talking about
- 35:08how Google have actually monetized GA 4 pretty well
- 35:12because of the Big Query stuff. And I guess I had a really
- 35:16thought of that, but actually, yeah, I mean like you know,
- 35:18they're spending, you know, a few $1000 or whatever on Big
- 35:21Query and a lot of our other clients are in the same bracket.
- 35:23And if more people are using it actually, then you know, maybe
- 35:26that's one of the few positives for GA 4.
- 35:30But yeah, I would say overall like you know, we've got between
- 35:335:00 and 10:00 clients using Content Square that never would
- 35:37have dreamed of using Content Square pre GA 4.
- 35:40So they're using that more in place of some of the behavioural
- 35:44reports and how they would have used events in the past.
- 35:48And then yeah, a lot of our clients have either invested in
- 35:50something off the shelf or gone down the route of building
- 35:53something be that with or about Big Query.
- 35:56But they those trends I think were pretty what we had seen.
- 36:00And again some of that was in the survey were pretty similar
- 36:03to what came up with alibar. Anything you'd add to that
- 36:05judge? No, I don't think so.
- 36:07Have you just touched on my point initially, but like I
- 36:09still so much which is possible with GA four, I don't know kind
- 36:15of like a talk on attribution quite recently.
- 36:17And I guess my view was that you should at least had the
- 36:20knowledge that of how to pull some of this eight wrap GA 4
- 36:22like a lot of hard lines just now report on a cost of sale or
- 36:25CAC and have just completely moved away from any level of
- 36:29segmentation or channel reporting.
- 36:31And there's still some very powerful data you can get from
- 36:34the backbone. So you know, you can look at the
- 36:36conversion part of every user. You can see what what a social
- 36:40was kind of like at the 1st early stages of someone, kind of
- 36:44like clicking for buying if it's the mid stage or the last
- 36:46stages. And I still think that data is
- 36:48really important. You know, if e-mail was still
- 36:51kind of like a heavily dependent on your sales kind of like at
- 36:55the end of the funnel, you want to make sure your content being
- 36:59pushed out is kind of like in line with that.
- 37:01And if you're already reporting for an ecom platform, you just
- 37:04wouldn't get that data. So there's definitely a lot
- 37:07which can be pulled out of GA 4. You know, even the behavioural
- 37:10data staff the lifetime value and you know you cannot even
- 37:14plug in non Google ad spend if you wanted to, kind of like have
- 37:18you and Cal rowas and everything else in the flat floor because I
- 37:21was like people aren't comfortable with that and it's
- 37:24immediately moved away one. One thing I'd add is that's like
- 37:28now that people are saying they've moved away, other people
- 37:30that they're moving away, it's quite funny.
- 37:33I've definitely seen a bit of a trend of that, like when more
- 37:36brands are talking to other brands.
- 37:38And I feel like the last 6, nine months in particular, people
- 37:43have just stopped like, you know, painfully working with it
- 37:47and have just started using other tools or yeah, taking the
- 37:50data out. But it is a shame because
- 37:53something's missing that are like three years ago with
- 37:56Universal Analytics, like James, I'm sure you'd be the same as me
- 37:59or to like, you know, I need checks I make.
- 38:00I'll just immediately go into Google Analytics, I'll know
- 38:03exactly where to look for it. I'll apply a segment, you know,
- 38:06I can you know use events etcetera and like now no one
- 38:09really has all that, a lot have that.
- 38:14Yeah, exactly. I I think this is inevitability.
- 38:16Is it? It's a it's almost like a crack
- 38:19for the econ population like everyone was, was built into the
- 38:22addition of GA because the simplicity of the UI and
- 38:25advanced segmentation like Carson Dimension, it was easier
- 38:28to configure and set up yourself.
- 38:30It's now moved to understand it. It's atomized really smartly
- 38:34from an event and user point of view, but you need far more
- 38:38technical knowledge and skills to get it set up, to set up the
- 38:41funnels to make things work. And a lot of businesses don't
- 38:44have that expertise in house and they probably don't have the
- 38:48budgets to employ a specialist to set it all up.
- 38:50So actually switch to this better visualisation tool, just
- 38:54get the data in it and hey look, there's a suite of 30 reports
- 38:57ready for me. People like simplicity and ease,
- 39:00don't they? So, yeah, interesting to hear
- 39:02that I've definitely seen speaking said to Oliver from
- 39:06Sweet Analytics recently, I've definitely seen it an uptick in
- 39:08interest in that as well. I know they've been doing very
- 39:10well. They've got a lot of clients
- 39:12already, but I know a few businesses who weren't too
- 39:16distraught what Google did with UI.
- 39:21Makes sense? Well, I found that really
- 39:22interesting. Thank you.
- 39:23And Josh, thanks for taking time to join us and anyone who's
- 39:26listening. If you want to learn more about
- 39:29the, you know, the key outtakes of this, this event or where the
- 39:34analytics and attribution side is going and even push Josh and
- 39:38Paul on what they were talking about, feel free to reach out to
- 39:40them directly. And if you've got any questions,
- 39:43you can connect with us on LinkedIn.
- 39:45Thanks for listening as always. And make sure you are following
- 39:48Inside Commerce on LinkedIn. And don't forget to subscribe to
- 39:50our ecom newsletter. Until next time everyone.
- 39:55You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 39:58experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 40:01Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 40:03featuring interviews with leading e-commerce, retailers,
- 40:06industry thoughtless and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 40:09explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 40:11and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 40:14really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 40:17to help fine tune your ecom strategy and text.
- 40:20Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James Report if you'd
- 40:23like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 40:25We hope you enjoy the latest episode.