Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The White House Is Building a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve—w/ Arch Lending
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08never assembled in the history of Gutless 1974198792972. 1000
- 0:17and whatever we want to call. This it's all just the same
- 0:20thing. Over.
- 0:21And over we can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. I say when we sell.
- 0:33All right. This week we sat down with Dhruv
- 0:35and Homanshu from Arch Lending. Dhruv is the CEO and Co founder
- 0:39and Homanshu is the CTO and Co founder.
- 0:42Great conversation. We talked quite a bit about
- 0:46their backgrounds and expertise in the second-half of the
- 0:48episode as it relates to founding Arch doing Bitcoin back
- 0:52loans the right way. Really important to take into
- 0:55consideration counterparty risk, collateral management, who the
- 0:59lenders are, non re hypothecation, all these things.
- 1:03We talked about the business in the second-half of the show and
- 1:05why we partnered with them at on ramp first half of the show.
- 1:08We talked about the report that came out this Wednesday from the
- 1:11White House on the digital asset side, had some good and bad
- 1:15takes there. We also talked about PNC,
- 1:18JPMorgan Chase, stepping into the Bitcoin and crypto space,
- 1:22announcing partnerships with Coinbase.
- 1:25And I want to say we also talked about some things that happened
- 1:28at FOMC, if I recall correctly. So we had a wide-ranging
- 1:32conversation. I will say for anyone who's
- 1:34interested in Bitcoin back loans, certainly check out our
- 1:37website on rampbitcoin.com. We have information on Bitcoin
- 1:41back loans and you can always speak with myself or someone
- 1:44else on the team if you want to learn more about how we manage
- 1:46that in a very conservative way. And also I would certainly
- 1:50encourage you to check out the second-half of this episode
- 1:53where we talked in detail about how Arch manages Bitcoin back
- 1:56loans. It's, it's incredibly important,
- 1:59especially you've seen over past cycles so much counterparty risk
- 2:03for a number of reasons. And so Arch has AI would say a
- 2:06low time preference approach to building their business.
- 2:09And they've really been a great partner, have a lot of clients
- 2:11that are satisfied with the experience working with them.
- 2:14So stay tuned, hope you enjoyed the episode and check out our
- 2:17website if you want to learn more about Bitcoin, back loans,
- 2:20custody, inheritance, etcetera. All right, we're recording.
- 2:23It's the last trade. We have 5 people on today's
- 2:27podcast. 5 heads. Two or three months ago, this
- 2:30was a common occurrence, but we've had four people on the
- 2:33podcast for the past several weeks, so this will be a special
- 2:36episode. We're joined by two of Arch
- 2:39Lending's Co founders, Himanshu Sahay and Dhruv Patel.
- 2:45Dhruv is the CEO and Himanshu is the CTO on ramp has partnered
- 2:50with Arch. We're going to talk about that
- 2:51later in the episode and then we are also joined by Co host Brian
- 2:56Cabela's and Michael Tanguma. So gentlemen, it's nice to see
- 3:00all of you today Arch fellas, how how's life in New York?
- 3:04You guys are dialing in from the office today.
- 3:06It's. Hot it's It's a bit of a sign,
- 3:09but let's go. There's kind of a a running joke
- 3:14internally where Jackson is going to take on some
- 3:17conservative leverage. And so I'm convinced part of
- 3:19having you guys on was to discuss if now is the time or if
- 3:23he missed the boat at the 79 K drawdown and and he just has to
- 3:27sit back on the sidelines. It's been killing him week after
- 3:29week. If loan volumes or anything to
- 3:32speak of then you've not missed the boat for sure.
- 3:36All right then. Well, yeah, this episode is
- 3:38actually just for for me to convince myself that I need to
- 3:40take some leverage out. So excited for this one.
- 3:43A good place for us to start would be the report that came
- 3:46out from the working group in the White House.
- 3:49We have some mixed opinions. We have some good and some bad
- 3:52to talk about. So the best place to start would
- 3:54be just pulling up an interview. Just a quick clip here of Bo
- 3:58Hines, who is involved in the the digital working group for
- 4:04the White House tasked with this report that dropped last or just
- 4:09yesterday actually. So want to pull this What's the?
- 4:12Update on a potential Bitcoin strategic reserve.
- 4:15Well, look, we we have it, it's been, it's been established the
- 4:19executive order and the SBR. We also have the Strategic
- 4:22National Stockpile, you know, I sorry, the digital assets
- 4:26national stockpile. I think that one, we wanted to
- 4:28recognize Bitcoin for being unique and we talked about, you
- 4:30know, what that looks like and kind of the threshold that that
- 4:34Bitcoin has created, you know, it's, it's in the class of its
- 4:37own and everyone recognizes that.
- 4:38We also wanted to give credence to the work and the developments
- 4:41happening across other ecosystems.
- 4:43And that's why we have this national stockpile alongside,
- 4:45you know, this, this actually requires some labor to get this
- 4:48set up properly. You have to build the
- 4:49infrastructure, you have to make sure that you're you're crossing
- 4:53your TS and down in your eyes. Give this time the right way and
- 4:55have long term, long term success with it.
- 4:57But I've said that nauseam. You know, we do believe in
- 5:00accumulation, obviously in budget neutral ways as the
- 5:02presidents outlined, but there are countless ways that we can
- 5:05engage in that. We'll act on those that I can be
- 5:08most expeditiously implemented and I think that, you know,
- 5:11people will be very pleased with the direction that we go in and
- 5:14we'll start moving on that in short order.
- 5:15But obviously, in this report, if you read the first digital
- 5:18asset CEO, we're tasked with creating a clear and robust
- 5:20regulatory framework. And so that's what we focus on
- 5:22here. We understand the importance of
- 5:24the strategic Bitcoin reserve or you know, enormous fans of of
- 5:28Bitcoin in the Bitcoin community and we want to deliver for them
- 5:31as well and I'm certain that we will how much Bitcoin does the
- 5:33federal government have? I can't discuss that right now.
- 5:35Give. Us a ballpark.
- 5:37I can't. Is it going to be a public?
- 5:39There are there are several reasons in which we're we're not
- 5:42disclosing that at this time. There might be a time in which
- 5:44we do, but what I will say is, you know, we want as much as we
- 5:47can possibly get and that's what I continue to say and we're
- 5:49going to continue to work on that.
- 5:52Was there never more cryptic, cryptic conversation or
- 5:57explanation of anything that's going on?
- 5:59He said a lot without saying much.
- 6:01So I did want to hear Brian, we'll hand it over to you first.
- 6:04Are we going to be pleased? Bo Hines said we were going to
- 6:07be pleased. But are you pleased right now?
- 6:09And he keeps saying. He keeps saying that.
- 6:11He keeps saying we're going to be pleased.
- 6:13I think there's, there's a lot to unpack here within the report
- 6:17that sound bite. But you know, my initial
- 6:20reaction to the report and I think a lot of people in the
- 6:23Bitcoin community was like, yeah, this wasn't really what
- 6:26the initial plans when they talked about the working group,
- 6:30they talked about this report that would come months later.
- 6:33I think there was a line of thinking that, you know, we
- 6:36would get an update on specifically the SBR, the US
- 6:41government's current holdings and plans for accumulation.
- 6:44I think as he sort of stated there, that was never really the
- 6:47intent of this report necessarily.
- 6:50And so there's a little, you know, piece of the end of the
- 6:52report that speaks specifically to the SPR, but it's basically
- 6:56just lifted from the executive order and it's the same
- 6:59commentary and language around we're going to try to find
- 7:02budget neutral ways to accumulate more Bitcoin.
- 7:05And so I think like, you know, like with anything, there's
- 7:07nuance to this, right? Like I think there's, it's
- 7:09natural for people in the Bitcoin world to be disappointed
- 7:13or say, you know, where is the audit?
- 7:14That's something that I've jokingly said, like I'm once
- 7:17again asking how much Bitcoin does the United States own?
- 7:21But if you just if you zoom out and just like look at the report
- 7:24in its totality and like the actual ramifications of of what
- 7:29this represents, I think it's extremely constructive in the
- 7:33sense that, you know, Bitcoin is mentioned hundreds of times in
- 7:37the report. Satoshi is quoted at like the
- 7:39beginning of every section, basically.
- 7:42And there's real reverence for Bitcoin, its strategic
- 7:46implications and it's and it's distinction from the broader
- 7:50crypto space. And so the report, you know, a
- 7:53lot of the meat of it is, is centered around stable coins and
- 7:57the classification of, of other assets X Bitcoin.
- 8:01And so I think there's a natural, you know, desire for,
- 8:04for people to focus specifically on Bitcoin to be like, well, you
- 8:07know, what about Bitcoin? What are you doing with Bitcoin?
- 8:10But the broader take away to me is like, you know, Bitcoin
- 8:14doesn't really need all of the the meat around its regulatory
- 8:19status, right, because it is has been viewed for many years as a
- 8:23commodity. So it doesn't need as much work
- 8:25from this working group on classifying what Bitcoin is.
- 8:28They give it the reverence it deserves and they talk about the
- 8:31other things that are less clear, basically.
- 8:34And so that was, you know, after my initial sort of response to
- 8:37it, as I like sort of stepped back, I was like, you know, this
- 8:40is pretty incredible that a government issued report is
- 8:45quoting Satoshi several times. And if you just, you know, think
- 8:49about 1-2, three years ago, like that would be kind of insane to
- 8:54to think that the US government is quoting Satoshi in an
- 8:57official report. So all of that is to say, I
- 9:00think it's constructive and bullish and and part of the
- 9:04cryptic nature of Bose response in that interview post the
- 9:08release of the report is like, yeah, the other way of looking
- 9:11at this is like, you know, it doesn't it wouldn't really make
- 9:13a ton of sense for them to announce an accumulation plan
- 9:17ahead of actually starting to accumulate just from a game
- 9:19theoretic standpoint. Like you would probably want to
- 9:22be accumulating quietly and then announce what you have and go
- 9:28forward plans. And the other sort of wrinkle in
- 9:32all of this is like the number of Bitcoin that people think the
- 9:35US government has is like 200 K and it might be less than that.
- 9:39And that could be the other reason that they don't want to
- 9:40say it basically. So there's a lot, a lot there.
- 9:44But that was my my broad take away or overview.
- 9:48I think 1 progression we can see from the report and just from
- 9:53him speaking today is when the exact about it came out earlier
- 9:57in the year, it was all the assets together.
- 10:00It was like a couple lines that was it.
- 10:02And you know, national XRP mentioned a few other assets.
- 10:06Now there's a clear distinction between Bitcoin and the other
- 10:09assets. And I think that I see has
- 10:10progress and they've called the Bitcoin reserve versus the
- 10:14digital stockpile. Initially it was the strategic
- 10:16crypto reserve. So I do see some deviation
- 10:22towards Bitcoin was and other assets and I think what this
- 10:25might end up with is as quicker progress on the Bitcoin side and
- 10:28then the stockpile, like whatever the incentives to do
- 10:32that might be, will be on its own path separately.
- 10:36Yeah, I agree with all that. And I would also say, just to
- 10:39reiterate some Brian's points really quickly, and then there's
- 10:43another thing I want to pull up is this is still remarkable,
- 10:46right? To have this amount of progress
- 10:48within the first seven months or so of the administration.
- 10:52These are things that were unprecedented that in some ways,
- 10:57this administration has followed through with a lot of the
- 10:59promises on the campaign trail. In other ways, they haven't.
- 11:03But that point aside, it is nice to know that what was once
- 11:07headwinds just a year ago really are now massive tailwinds.
- 11:11And this ties into something that we wanted to pull up on
- 11:14bitcointreasuries.net. Listen, everyone, I'm always
- 11:19going to say this because it's it's really fundamental and it's
- 11:22true in every case. Like people look out for their
- 11:24own interests. And if you look at the top
- 11:27holders, public companies of Bitcoin, you have Trump Media
- 11:31and Technology Group here, number six, they just had done
- 11:34another purchase in the past week or so.
- 11:37But then if you also look at other companies here in the top
- 11:39five, namely let's see here, 21 Capital with Jack Myler's Cantor
- 11:44Fitzgerald, you have people that are very close to the Trump
- 11:48administration as well that have massive positions of Bitcoin.
- 11:53And these are not stupid people. These are financially motivated
- 11:56people. They would not be taking out
- 11:58massive bets on Bitcoin and MSTR.
- 12:01I think I remember back at the start of this year, Cantor's
- 12:06holdings were were published for Q4 of 2024 and they have like a
- 12:1020% position in strategy alone. So I don't know what this tells
- 12:15you guys, but at the end of the day, I think there are some
- 12:18things that are happening behind the scenes.
- 12:19There are likely strategic reasons as to why the audit has
- 12:23not yet been made public. There's strategic reasons why
- 12:26the US government hasn't disclosed exact purchasing
- 12:29plans. But if you kind of look just
- 12:32next layer of the onion here, there's plenty of data to look
- 12:35at to show that the people you know in the Trump family and in
- 12:39the administration have some big plans for the rest of this year
- 12:43and into next. Yeah, I'd be, I was going to say
- 12:47I'd be curious from you, Himanshu and Dhruv, like your
- 12:49guys's take from where you were sitting a few years ago because
- 12:53I don't think we've ever talked about this.
- 12:55Would love to hear, you know, how involved in like 21 you were
- 12:58in the industry. I think that was roughly around
- 13:01when Arch was founded, maybe a little later.
- 13:03And like what your perception of like this, I mean, I pulled up
- 13:06on the the page for listeners, this is whitehouse.gov/crypto.
- 13:10I mean, it's pretty insane to Jackson's point, like how far
- 13:13and how fast we've come. But just curious like what your
- 13:16guys's feel has been from a couple years ago to now and what
- 13:21all this means and how you're seeing it like impact your side
- 13:24of the market? Yeah, definitely.
- 13:26I think there is, you know, and I think that it touches on a few
- 13:31different things that we're going to discuss later on
- 13:33anyways. But if you go back to like end
- 13:36of 21, early 22, you know, we were in a sort of hot cycle.
- 13:41But even during those moments, it was mostly like retail and
- 13:46crypto participants and bitcoiners, if you will, right?
- 13:49Like there, there wasn't many companies having Bitcoin on
- 13:51their balance sheet. Certainly you didn't have any of
- 13:54the large financial like magnets, Ray Dalio, Jamie Dimon,
- 13:58et cetera talking in a positive way about Bitcoin.
- 14:01And if you Fast forward now, yeah, we had.
- 14:05A lot of companies. Sort of exit the space via
- 14:07bankruptcies and just things that they were doing that were a
- 14:10little too risk on and and immature from a financial sort
- 14:15of security and management. But overall, this space has sort
- 14:19of continued to grow in a positive way.
- 14:21And now I think the conversations you see around
- 14:24Bitcoin are not oh, should this be part of a portfolio?
- 14:27It's yes, it should. And what percentage are we
- 14:30talking about? And people are sort of like
- 14:32updating their priors there. And I think you see it from
- 14:36companies now holding it across. I mean, we have the pleasure of
- 14:39seeing all sorts of businesses that have Bitcoin on their
- 14:43balance sheets and are borrowing with Arch.
- 14:45It's not just your publicly listed companies that I think
- 14:48get the bulk of the attention, but we see like toy businesses,
- 14:51energy companies, all sorts of small and medium businesses
- 14:55throughout America that have Bitcoin on their balance sheet.
- 14:58And it's sort of been a good way for them to expand their
- 15:01businesses and continue to grow there.
- 15:04So I think at a high level the conversation has changed from,
- 15:08OK, like should we own Bitcoin, to now, how much should we and
- 15:12what's like an appropriate allocation?
- 15:14I think one, one story that maybe and actually I want to
- 15:19hear you guys opinion on this. So we're seeing every week
- 15:23there's three to five new Bitcoin treasuries that are
- 15:25raising money, appealing in a few weeks worth packing or
- 15:28whatever. We're going to see this happen
- 15:32across a number of public companies.
- 15:33And these companies are going and building a company from a
- 15:37very different perspective than will be done in the past.
- 15:40What they're doing is they're building a floor price for what
- 15:43the stock will be by accumulating as much Bitcoin as
- 15:45they can and they'll build the company after that.
- 15:48So whatever happens now the floor is the Bitcoin price and
- 15:51the amount of Bitcoin they have. And this is a very different way
- 15:54of building a business than was done in the past.
- 15:57Right now, your floor is how much Bitcoin you own and
- 15:59everything else is beyond that. If you look at Fold, for
- 16:02example, fold went public recently.
- 16:04Fold had about 1000 Bitcoin for the last several years.
- 16:07Their revenues are not that much to justify the stock price, but
- 16:09the Bitcoin they have is a significant portion of of that
- 16:13market cap. Yeah, I think it's a.
- 16:17It's a great point to call out and it's something I've thought
- 16:21a lot about and I think it's to your, you know, as you
- 16:24described, it does sort of flip the the mental model of like how
- 16:29you how you go about building a business in terms of the order
- 16:31of operations, right. And I I would contend though
- 16:35that like the floor isn't necessarily one times MNF.
- 16:39Like if they really screw up the business building, there's no
- 16:42reason the company and its equity can't trade lower than if
- 16:47you go. Down the list of Bitcoin
- 16:49treasuries, you see that a lot actually on that.
- 16:52It's already it's already happening.
- 16:54And and so I think that would be the one caveat to that is like
- 16:57we don't know that that model of business building necessarily
- 17:03works. Like I think strategy is, is
- 17:06certainly an outlier and very unique in that they had a core
- 17:11business. It didn't really matter at the
- 17:12end, you know, once they really got started with their Bitcoin
- 17:15accumulation strategy and their business turned into like
- 17:19productizing the stock itself, right?
- 17:21All the different machinate, different instruments that
- 17:24they've created. So that became their business
- 17:26and they've been very successful at doing that.
- 17:29Not everyone's going to be able to replicate that.
- 17:30And so now you hear the 21 Capitals and others talking
- 17:34about future plans for Bitcoin native financial services.
- 17:40And that sounds nice, but it's like you actually have to go
- 17:44build something and it acts, it has to, you know, gain traction,
- 17:47market share, have product market fit all these things.
- 17:50And I think it's, you know, we may just still be in the early
- 17:55innings of this and and it may get crazier and crazier in terms
- 17:59of more and more companies trying to go this route of
- 18:02accumulating first, building a business second.
- 18:05But I just, I don't think we've seen outside of strategy like a
- 18:09real legitimate, you know, example of this working out like
- 18:14typically, you know, for all of you know, history up to this
- 18:18point in terms of business building, like you build a
- 18:20business 1st and then figure out how to store your value, store
- 18:24your cash flows in a better way, adopt Bitcoin, etcetera.
- 18:28So I just I think it's an interesting call out, but I
- 18:30would say like the 11 XM NAV is not necessarily the floor for
- 18:35these things these. Codes, they don't necessarily
- 18:40have to build their own business.
- 18:41They're going to be acquisitory and they'll acquire other
- 18:43businesses, but now they have the leverage to go acquire
- 18:46bigger businesses than they would have just on their own or
- 18:48build a business themselves. So now they have access to a
- 18:51very high tier capital markets, super low interest rates, access
- 18:54to a lot of capital and they can now use that as leverage to go
- 18:59acquire other businesses. Yeah.
- 19:03I think from the overarching angle, I think what's
- 19:07fascinating about all this is there's a natural valve that
- 19:12crypto in general and Bitcoin will help.
- 19:14There's a strategic reason where the ETS were approved.
- 19:17And to your point, business owners are accessing liquidity.
- 19:20They're getting increased purchasing power in an asset.
- 19:24So it's allowing for like GDP and growth.
- 19:29So there's some strategic like it's not even have to be
- 19:31ideological why they're putting, you know, Bitcoin on the balance
- 19:33sheet and and or from the from the administration side.
- 19:36And then the four O 1K is a great example of this with like
- 19:39loosening those requirements. But like the Wild West, right,
- 19:43That's how I think about, you know, digital assets and all
- 19:45this stuff happening is it's the Wild West and there's a lot of
- 19:47money to be made, but there's also going to be a lot of money
- 19:49to be lost. And so that's just the
- 19:52interesting dynamic. A couple of things you and Brian
- 19:55touched on. One is never in 15 years has
- 19:57like a new product come about in Bitcoin where there hasn't been
- 20:00a lot of heartache because ultimately, like you guys
- 20:02touched on, we'll talk about at the end of the pod about, you
- 20:05know, what you guys are building and why we're excited.
- 20:07But ultimately it takes digitally native people that
- 20:10have kind of gone through reps or have very are very
- 20:12conservative and 1st principles thinking or you end up blowing
- 20:15up in this space because there are no bailouts.
- 20:18And so I think a lot of these net new companies coming in with
- 20:21new strategies like the default should be really.
- 20:25Cynical and and are you just careful because of what we just
- 20:29talked about? The other part that it comes up
- 20:32a lot I kind of like differ is imagine like on your guys's side
- 20:35if there was some firm that had access to arbitrage capital to
- 20:38go raise a big balance sheet and build a lending business.
- 20:41You guys as entrepreneurs probably like we can out
- 20:42compete. I mean, maybe slower, but we're
- 20:44just better operators. And so that's how I take it from
- 20:47that stance because there's a lot of codes out there saying
- 20:49we're going to raise a bunch of Bitcoin, make acquisitions.
- 20:51It's like if you raise a bunch of dollars and make
- 20:53acquisitions, if you know how to build the business and know how
- 20:55to be super like agile and just all the things that naturally go
- 21:00into business building. And that's what I think is going
- 21:01to happen to me. Take longer And it's similar to
- 21:03Fiat, right? You see companies go Adam Newman
- 21:06and we works a great example, raise a shit ton of money and
- 21:08then they just like kind of, you know, drown themselves in it.
- 21:12So I think that's what's going to happen.
- 21:13I think what you need is the natural first principle thinker.
- 21:15That's a good builder and that leverages bitcoins properties.
- 21:18Now that's when you end up with like the the magic sauce.
- 21:22Yep, yeah, I think that's why the like who's running these
- 21:25treasury companies that are launching is so important.
- 21:30We like we're seeing people like Adam back and involved Wong can
- 21:34involved people like that I think know how to build
- 21:36businesses, but then there's also other opportunities that
- 21:39maybe go beyond the long term of not having as much success, but
- 21:44the. Deadly 1 is, is the tether,
- 21:46right? Like they pulled out their
- 21:47reports and like they're playing at that level and you can see it
- 21:50from revenue from employee, the way they think about just
- 21:53diversifying risk across gold land and BTC.
- 21:56Like that's the kind of thing that ends up deadly with the the
- 21:58balance sheet. Plus, they're just looking at
- 22:00the world in a completely different view versus the one
- 22:03that's like the elephant in the room is the MSTR deal because
- 22:06they have all the Bitcoin, but like, you know, they're not
- 22:09really familiar with the space outside of like financial
- 22:11engineering and how to create structure products for all the
- 22:15capital that's in the market. But like what do they do with
- 22:17that Bitcoin and how do they accrete value on the other side
- 22:21of it? Yeah.
- 22:23My, my concern and then we'll shift topics is I'm generally
- 22:27interested in a fan of what Sailor is doing.
- 22:29I think it is fascinating. But the concern that I have that
- 22:33most of the enthusiasts of the stock do not talk enough about
- 22:39is, well, if you're monetizing the balance sheet, why does no
- 22:44one talk about the risks to the balance sheet?
- 22:47Like there's very little discussion around what could
- 22:49potentially happen with how those assets are secured.
- 22:53And if the entire basis of your company is becoming monetization
- 22:57of the balance sheet and offering financial products
- 22:59based on the amount of Bitcoin you hold, I would at least think
- 23:02that there'd be more serious discourse about what could
- 23:05potentially be a catastrophic risk to to that company.
- 23:09But shifting gears a little bit, I want to go back into maturity
- 23:14within this asset class. So Drew, it was something that
- 23:16you'd mentioned earlier, right, Just comparing to where we are
- 23:19today versus where we were three or four years ago when you
- 23:23started the business. And there are two pieces of news
- 23:26that I think all of us saw and we wanted to talk about was both
- 23:30PNCI think it was last week and then Chase this week, both
- 23:35announcing partnerships with Coinbase.
- 23:38So from a high level, what is happening here, at least on the
- 23:42Chase side is MPNC you'll be able to link your bank account
- 23:46directly with back end integrations to Coinbase.
- 23:49So you can buy, sell, store different cryptos, I guess
- 23:53Bitcoin and I'm not sure exactly the menu that will be offered.
- 23:56And then Chase, I saw is offering some things with credit
- 23:59card purchases and then also Chase ultimate reward points,
- 24:02which could be redeemed for USDC, which I thought was
- 24:05interesting and odd. I don't know how big of a Tam
- 24:08that is quite yet, but point aside, I'm curious.
- 24:10I'll hand it over to you guys for some initial thoughts on the
- 24:13banks stepping in. How do you think this all
- 24:16matures over the next coming months?
- 24:18Yeah, How do you think these banks will differentiate?
- 24:21What kind of adoption do you think you'll see there?
- 24:23And then we can open up the floor after that, yeah.
- 24:26I think first like the, the thing to notice is that the
- 24:31amount of distribution that's about to be unlocked here,
- 24:33right? Like the clients of PNC,
- 24:35JPMorgan and all these other banks are huge relative to the
- 24:39number of accounts on Coinbase or any of these, you know,
- 24:43Bitcoin companies. And so the number of folks that
- 24:45will now have access and exposure will be huge.
- 24:48And I think that's just big for the space number of new holders.
- 24:51The other piece is also with respect to these financial
- 24:54institutions. I know many of our high network
- 24:57clients are in executive positions across a lot of these
- 25:00businesses. Some have, you know, smaller
- 25:04banks that they own etcetera. And one thing we've heard from
- 25:06them for over like for a few years now is they see outflows
- 25:11to Coinbase and other Bitcoin companies in their own client
- 25:15activity. And so this is now finally the
- 25:18time for them to participate and say, look like our clients are
- 25:21doing it with or without us, We might as well lean in now and
- 25:24figure out a way for them to do this activity through US itself.
- 25:28And so, well, I think it's positive overall through the
- 25:30like ecosystem, but I think we definitely saw the writing on
- 25:34the walls here just given that it was either to participate or
- 25:37sort of get left behind here. I want to speak to the Chase
- 25:41deal because I think that's quite interesting, specifically
- 25:45to the fact that you can now pay with your credit card and use
- 25:48points. The points saying whatever, I
- 25:50think it's going to be a very bad redemption.
- 25:52The one to one probably. You don't use Chase points to
- 25:55pay for cash users. You use it for travel usually
- 25:58where you actually get a benefit to using it.
- 26:01If you use ultimate rewards from South far as though you get a
- 26:031.5 X bonus, much more useful that way.
- 26:06I've been there for years, it's fantastic.
- 26:10Paying. For crypto and depending on the
- 26:13amounts allowed with your credit card could be a very interesting
- 26:17double edged sword that could lead us deeper into the credit
- 26:19card we're in today. You know, we're seeing BNPL
- 26:22default rates be sky high. A lot of people that you suffer
- 26:26as eventually other trade products tend to be younger,
- 26:29maybe more risk on with credit. And we'll, I just worry that
- 26:35depending on what they're buying, we might see an
- 26:38acceleration of the credit crunch that we already are
- 26:40seeing in, in the US today. And also just just one more
- 26:46thing to add. You're going to be paying really
- 26:48high interchange plus Coinbase fees to buy that.
- 26:51So you're paying 2 1/2% interchange for Chase plus
- 26:54Coinbase fees is typically 100 bit, so another percent on top
- 26:57of that. Yeah, I don't want to dock some
- 27:00on you, but I will is if you're familiar with the points guy,
- 27:03he's been running that for the past website for the for the you
- 27:07know, you are the points guy, you were the one behind that you
- 27:12but. You know.
- 27:16I I would imagine so I didn't realize is that for sure that
- 27:19you can buy crypto with your credit card with that part of
- 27:22the that was part of the announcement.
- 27:24I. Remember that being the case
- 27:25like five to seven years ago and then they changed it so that you
- 27:28couldn't do that. So it is interesting to see them
- 27:30go back the other way to. Buy the credit card and even
- 27:34then they bought a couple times to go through it.
- 27:38Yeah, I. Think there's a few topics that
- 27:41were interesting there. One is I think the the notion of
- 27:44just stable coins and the proliferation, something we've
- 27:47been talking about a lot is while it's a bad use of the
- 27:50points, there's still something really nice about you can get
- 27:53the points in a BTC. It's one more click, but you can
- 27:55get to USDC, to BTC. And I think that's naturally
- 27:57going to just help in the understanding the digitization
- 28:01of capital and people like tightening that, which will be
- 28:03positive for for downward pressure on Bitcoin or up
- 28:06upwards. The thing that's kind of really
- 28:10interesting is just Jamie Diamonds like antagonistic
- 28:13nature to Bitcoin and then this JPMC thing coming out because
- 28:16stuff like this has been worked on for 6 to 12 months at a
- 28:18minimum, probably post ETF. And it just feels this is like
- 28:23on the backs of three weeks ago. I'm sure you guys saw with some
- 28:26of the Plaid kind of bottlenecking and the data that
- 28:30JPMC making a play somewhere and Coinbase sits right in the
- 28:34middle of so many things, whether it's ETF capital and
- 28:37flows, JP Morgan, which is one of the largest banks in the
- 28:40country, and then this connectivity there that with
- 28:45Coinbase or just something like brewing.
- 28:47That may not be best long term because it's something that not
- 28:50on this list. But Balkuna has caught that some
- 28:52of the SEC requirements around Futures Trading is going to be
- 28:55based on spot trading or Futures Trading on Coinbase.
- 28:59So if you the the heuristic at least proposes if it's been
- 29:03trading on the futures market on Coinbase for over six months,
- 29:05it's like automatically like approved from the SEC side for
- 29:08futures. And you can start to see like
- 29:11this in integration where Coinbase is effectively just
- 29:13starts to become insanely systemic to the whole industry
- 29:17and it's just something to keep an eye on.
- 29:20It already yeah, I mean it already is a systemic risk as
- 29:23well. I mean, I don't think enough.
- 29:25There's, there's two thoughts I have AI don't understand like
- 29:28where the point of differentiation is if all the
- 29:31largest banks are going to partner with the same company.
- 29:34And then the second piece is as an industry, there just needs to
- 29:38be, I think a higher standard, quite frankly, because Coinbase
- 29:41already custodies 10% of the Bitcoin supply and more than
- 29:45that, if you account for Bitcoin, that's been permanently
- 29:48lost. So I think we're already at a
- 29:50point of systemic risk with Coinbase in particular.
- 29:54And I just like think about 2022.
- 29:58I. Imagine, you know, the fallout
- 30:00of FTX and all of the firms that collapsed in the contagion
- 30:05there. And I can just imagine how much
- 30:09reputational damage, some sort of risk or hack or breach a
- 30:16material of material size would be a coin base for this
- 30:19industry. Like you remember back in 2022
- 30:22with FTX, everyone who's outside of the industry sees the
- 30:26collapse of FTX, sees SBF and all this crazy shit happening.
- 30:29And they're like, oh, well, I guess, you know, Bitcoin is
- 30:32done, right? And so it took quite a long time
- 30:35for people outside of this industry to understand, oh,
- 30:39well, FTX is an exchange, an offshore exchange.
- 30:42It's different than what Bitcoin is, a digital form of money, a
- 30:45commodity. And you can imagine if the
- 30:47largest custodian, by far the largest player in capital
- 30:52markets for Bitcoin and crypto suffered some sort of loss.
- 30:56I just don't know. I think there is a recovery for
- 30:59the industry, but I don't know how long that would take.
- 31:01And that's honestly one thing that concerns me.
- 31:04Yeah. No, go ahead.
- 31:08Sorry and. I was going to say.
- 31:09There's two things. One, I think like definitely a
- 31:11systemic risk, right? Like just given that they
- 31:14custody for a lot of the ETFs, like there's so much that's
- 31:18actually built on top of of Coinbase there.
- 31:20But then going back to your first point about, OK, all the
- 31:23largest banks partner with the same company to offer trading.
- 31:26Like what is their differentiation?
- 31:28I actually don't. Think they're looking?
- 31:29For differentiation, I think they're just trying to keep
- 31:31their existing client base, right?
- 31:32Because if you don't have it, you're going to lose your
- 31:34existing clients going over to the next bank.
- 31:36So it's not something that they're trying to win on on its
- 31:39own. No one's joining PNC for the
- 31:41crypto trading functionality, but existing clients I think
- 31:44will stay there because they're now able to just do it through
- 31:47them instead of having to go over to some other bank and
- 31:50frankly. If you're trying to walk enough
- 31:51for trading, there's not that many options that have the
- 31:55reputation and the history of Coinbase.
- 31:57So it's kind of the default when you are looking to offer
- 32:01trading. Yeah, I mean.
- 32:03This is where it goes back to the the whole Wild West aspect
- 32:07of you reference. What's the differentiation?
- 32:10And if you said to a local bank, what's the differentiation of
- 32:13how you park your dollars? They're all the same.
- 32:15It rolls up to sub custody with like BNY Mellon.
- 32:18The mental model is just incorrect.
- 32:20It's the same thing when you think about lending, like not
- 32:22all counterparties when you lend Bitcoin are going to be the same
- 32:26how they custody their their ratio and the the overarching
- 32:30mental model is there's bailouts.
- 32:31So everyone's not concerned with counterparty risk in the
- 32:34existing system because we've historically just been lulled to
- 32:36sleep that it will be made whole in the beauty.
- 32:39You guys probably don't hear it, but we had Eric Balkunas on last
- 32:41week's POD and it was a fat. It was probably one of my
- 32:43favorite because he's writing a book.
- 32:45He studied all of this and he's worried about Coinbase.
- 32:48And we brought it up. He's like, well, the Fed will
- 32:50bail him out. And I was like, are they going
- 32:51to print more Bitcoin? He's like, Oh yeah, yeah,
- 32:52they'll figure it out. And it's like, that's the thing
- 32:54that nobody gets. There are no bailouts here.
- 32:56And there's a reason why half of the $2 trillion market cap
- 33:00literally sits in self custody and hardware devices.
- 33:02And it's not because everyone's just completely an ideologue and
- 33:05crazy. It's just that was the only way
- 33:07to sever the Internet connection to protect your underlying
- 33:09assets. And so so it's just we're just
- 33:13in the early stages of all this. And so a lot of people have to
- 33:16get burned before like the right frameworks get built that the
- 33:20market will adopt going into like the next 10 to 100 years.
- 33:26Yeah, I think Drew, Drew brought up a great point in that just
- 33:30partnering with Coinbase is certainly the the path of least
- 33:33resistance today. It's how you get fastest to
- 33:35market. It's how you stop the, you know,
- 33:38the, the bleeding, so to say, of losing clients that are, you
- 33:43know, withdrawing assets from from the bank.
- 33:46But that is very that's, that's, you know, short term thinking.
- 33:49I think the the longer term opportunity is to find some
- 33:52element of differentiation because you know, as you know,
- 33:57while they need to make these plays just to be fastest to
- 33:59market. Like if you're actually thinking
- 34:01about the medium to long term implications of how you're
- 34:05custodying the asset, not having too much concentration risk with
- 34:08any single custodian, like the real opportunity for any of
- 34:11these banks, small, medium, large is to actually figure out
- 34:14ways to differentiate themselves.
- 34:16Yeah, I think. In the future, they'll end up
- 34:18working with everyone who's a relevant player and have the
- 34:22differentiation. I just don't think like that
- 34:24exists today. But again, we're here.
- 34:27I won't even say year one like we're in like month 3 of people
- 34:30even thinking about this and the long ago.
- 34:36So Drew, one of the topic that you wanted to bring up was
- 34:39Kraken's IPO in 2026. I'll hand it over to you just
- 34:45for some initial thoughts and then, you know, the group can
- 34:47discuss before moving on to some of the lending topics.
- 34:50Yeah. You know, I think this is just
- 34:53like a good line in general for the space.
- 34:57If you look at it prior to maybe circle, the only exposure like
- 35:03traditional investors or equity investors had to like Bitcoin in
- 35:07this space broadly was basically Coinbase.
- 35:09And so the more outcomes that happen in this space, one,
- 35:13people get to participate in the upside of the industry broadly.
- 35:17Second, I think these companies having liquidity is good for the
- 35:20space One in terms of, you know, makes it easier for the next set
- 35:26of like builders to come and build companies because it
- 35:29trickles down everywhere, right? Like venture investors have now
- 35:31made some money. They have liquidity to invest
- 35:34more. And so I think these sorts of
- 35:36outcomes are great. You're like you saw it with
- 35:39circles reception and how that stock just like sort of ran like
- 35:43crazy. And I think what you see is real
- 35:46appetite from investors to have exposure to companies that are
- 35:50building real businesses in this space.
- 35:52Yeah, I. Think it's it goes beyond crack
- 35:54into receipt like they go file figures going to file so far is
- 35:58about to file. So there's all these companies
- 36:00that are either directly encrypted or exposed to crypto
- 36:03that are now looking at this as an opportunity to go public
- 36:06because they think they'll have a good reception.
- 36:07And I think that's very positive.
- 36:10Yeah, the firm that made out like a bandit, it was incredible
- 36:13force foresight was Dan Tapiro and 10 T because this is kind of
- 36:16like the thesis of the whole firm of institutional capital
- 36:19that may not feel comfortable or have a mandate to buy spot
- 36:22Bitcoin, but directional bets into large revenue players that
- 36:26we're going to IPO. And you have to imagine behind
- 36:29closed doors are like this all hinges on regulatory clarity
- 36:31because if it's there, then we're going to you know, we're
- 36:33going to crush it. And they kind of are with I
- 36:35think they're in circle. They had the Derabit
- 36:36acquisition. There's a few, a few others that
- 36:39have gone public or are public. And yet to your point, I think
- 36:44it's going to be interesting to see the acquisition in a public
- 36:46markets space because I think like BICO goes public, but
- 36:49ultimately it ends up at some point ends up like a BNY Mellon
- 36:52or some large bank product. Because again, there's only so
- 36:55many firms that are digitally native that understand, you
- 36:58know, whether it's out of custody list, execute, lend
- 37:00against this asset. And we all know like anybody
- 37:03that's going to work for you doesn't want to work at those
- 37:05firms. So it's like you have to like
- 37:07Aqua hire the talent. So it's going to be very
- 37:10interesting to see how that plays out.
- 37:14Yeah. I mean, there's only a handful
- 37:16of like well repeated custodians.
- 37:18And if they're going public then for a bank or a larger FI that
- 37:23might want to make an acquisition, they probably just
- 37:26have to acquire these companies as their public.
- 37:28I did actually make one error here.
- 37:31I wanted, Brian, one topic that you brought to the table, I
- 37:33wanted to discuss quickly before the lending was the most recent
- 37:39FOMC meeting. And I had no idea that there's
- 37:44just been consensus by the Fed Board of Governors on interest
- 37:49rate policy for the past 30 years.
- 37:52And this is, I guess, a signpost, Brian, you want to
- 37:55share some, share some thoughts on this?
- 37:57Yeah, I mean. Nothing like no, no super deep
- 38:00thoughts around interest rates themselves or you know, FMC in
- 38:04general. But I was surprised by this as
- 38:06well. I, I had not realized that
- 38:08consensus is usually that narrow.
- 38:11I think there's been several instances of, of 1 governor
- 38:15dissenting in these decisions. But yeah, the last time 2
- 38:19separate governors dissented was, you know, 30 years ago,
- 38:22which is just kind of a, a crazy stat.
- 38:25And to me, it signals like there is real pressure from Trump
- 38:29specifically, obviously to lower rates.
- 38:33I mean, the more I've thought about it, though, it's like,
- 38:37does it, does it really warrant, like does the current economy
- 38:40really warrant lowering interest rates?
- 38:42Maybe if you look through, you know, various government data,
- 38:46but like, you know, we talk about it all the time on this
- 38:49show. Like we don't really believe CPI
- 38:51is a, a good measure of inflation.
- 38:53So if inflation, if we're assuming inflation is actually
- 38:56much higher than two to 3%, then, you know, maybe there
- 38:59isn't really room to be lowering interest rates right now.
- 39:02So I think it's a, it's a very muddled and Gray discussion
- 39:06around what's happening with the Fed and interest rates right
- 39:09now. But this, I, I thought it was
- 39:10worth just bringing up because it, it shows a real distinction
- 39:15in like where sort of Fed independence sits today relative
- 39:20to, to all of history. So that's, that's not to say I
- 39:24think, you know, I don't think Powell's going to get fired or
- 39:26resign. I think he's going to serve out
- 39:28his term and Trump's going to put in somebody who really flies
- 39:33in the face of Fed independence, probably to the strongest extent
- 39:37we've ever seen. So I think that's coming
- 39:39regardless of what you think about the economy.
- 39:43But yeah, I thought it was just, it was worth mentioning because
- 39:45I it surprised me as well. Yeah, I also didn't realize, I
- 39:50haven't verified this, but I'll take it at face value that both
- 39:53of these people, Christopher Waller and Michelle Bowman, are
- 39:57both hoping to be appointed as the next Fed chair.
- 39:59So, yeah, certainly, you know, showcase of political influence
- 40:04and I think directionally, you know, rates go lower.
- 40:07They have to, given the fiscal circumstances the United States
- 40:10government is in. And so I ultimately think that
- 40:14it's important for people to follow this just because what
- 40:17served as a major headwind for the industry in 2021 into 22
- 40:22with the rate hike cycle, I think being the fastest ever
- 40:26that in history since the Federal Reserve was created over
- 40:29100 years ago and has been punishing US ever since.
- 40:33But so this is going to be a tailwind now.
- 40:35It's something hasn't even been accounted for where you just
- 40:37have lower rates, more liquidity entering the system.
- 40:40And ultimately, I don't know, does that play into an extended
- 40:43cycle for this industry? Does that break or contribute to
- 40:46breaking the four year cycle we've seen historically?
- 40:48I'm not sure, but there's certainly reasons to believe
- 40:51that it could could impact this cycle going forward, you know, I
- 40:56think. It's also important to note
- 40:58historically where rates have been, rates have never really
- 41:02been low until 08 until the 08/09 crash.
- 41:08And that direct reaction of that was the creation of Bitcoin.
- 41:13But if you look at rates before that, they were I think in the
- 41:1660s and 70s, they were as high as 16%.
- 41:19We had rates at about 8-9 percent in the 90s and we
- 41:24artificially lowered them after the crash to help the economy
- 41:28recover and did very quickly. But then we've kind of been on
- 41:31this almost like on roller coasters since where they've
- 41:35gone up, they've come down significantly.
- 41:36Now they're going up or they're staying up.
- 41:39And I don't know if if the right answer is to always be in or or
- 41:46to be in a lower interest environment.
- 41:48I think the market has other ways to adapt beyond just low
- 41:52interest rates. And I think people have to
- 41:55normalize the rates we are at today, not just look for like
- 42:00the panacea of of bringing rates down.
- 42:03I. I, I generally agree with that.
- 42:05I think the, the caveat that Jackson sort of alluded to is
- 42:09like just from a fiscal perspective and the interest
- 42:14expense on the debt, like it's, it's, we can't have rates here
- 42:18for much longer. Basically, like there's just a,
- 42:20a, a baked in reality that we're spending too much on interest
- 42:24expense. And so basically in my mind,
- 42:27like they're going to find some reason to lower rates.
- 42:31And if it's just because Trump says he wants that, that might
- 42:33be like the, you know, the easiest way.
- 42:36But like they they, I agree with your general sentiment that like
- 42:40rates can and should be around this level if not higher, but
- 42:44it's just not palatable for the government and the Fed right
- 42:46now. I can barely engage in in these
- 42:50conversations anymore because like the proposition is so
- 42:52insane. Like the just the notion of if
- 42:56we were going to fix like down the street, you buying your,
- 42:59your sandwich and what the eggs cost or the bread or whatever it
- 43:02was, we would all probably think like you can't fix the cost of
- 43:06any good. That's just not how free markets
- 43:08work. But we accept that we can fix
- 43:10the cost of the money and that and ultimately going up or down
- 43:14causes reflexivity and break and things that break.
- 43:17And so the market determines the rates if like we're all on gold
- 43:22or Bitcoin or whatever it would be like in natural localized
- 43:25markets, rates would fluctuate because that's just how free
- 43:29markets work. And so like the thing that we
- 43:30like just to have the conversation about where the
- 43:32rate should be is, is almost like it's not a nonsense.
- 43:35It will be like there's, it's worth a discussion, but it's
- 43:38just not like nobody even talks about like the notion that we
- 43:41fix rates is an insane proposition in itself because
- 43:43we're fixing the money or the cost of the money.
- 43:46And that naturally will have second, third order effects that
- 43:48you can't actually account for, which is why you shouldn't be
- 43:52able to do it. No, they, they have actually
- 43:55fantastic models, Michael. They're they're great at pricing
- 43:58everything. And you know, we should keep the
- 44:01Fed, I think. I think they do a nice job.
- 44:03If you're a frequent listener of the show, you know what time it
- 44:06is. I need you to show up, please.
- 44:09My life, my career depends on it.
- 44:11Please hit the like button. Please leave a comment.
- 44:15Please leave five stars on Spotify or Apple.
- 44:19Subscribe if you haven't on YouTube already.
- 44:21There is, like I say, every single week a lot of work goes
- 44:25into doing these podcasts. We have to book guests.
- 44:29We have to get the guests to show up.
- 44:30Sometimes they don't want to do that.
- 44:32We have to prepare for the show. So it's a good use of your time.
- 44:36We have to record the show and we have to edit the show,
- 44:40distribute it, etcetera. So if you could take just a few
- 44:44seconds, please leave us a like leave us a comment.
- 44:47I really appreciate it. I respond to most comments.
- 44:51I would say I really try to. So just a token of appreciation.
- 44:55If you're getting value out of the last trade, out of all the
- 44:59content we have here at Onramp, please support the show.
- 45:03My life depends on it. Let's move on.
- 45:06Let's talk about something that happened in the lending world.
- 45:10And this I think will open up a more broader discussion about
- 45:13Arch and people who do things the right way.
- 45:16How about that? That's a nice thing, isn't it?
- 45:19So Michael, I'll hand it over to you.
- 45:20This was something you flagged to the group here.
- 45:23And then if you want to share any opening thoughts just on the
- 45:25partnership as well? Yeah.
- 45:27I mean, so this kind of ties directly into the rates issue
- 45:30because I'm not saying that's a product of what this shot we
- 45:34just brought up, but it's effectively crypto lender Aubrey
- 45:37positive withdrawals as dozens of customers fear their funds
- 45:39are gone. This isn't probably won't
- 45:42surprise a lot of folks on this call, but like the other's been
- 45:45a little bit of a, you know, unscrupulous or Gray area.
- 45:50I think they were sued for fraud.
- 45:51They had a settlement in 2024. But what was the most shocking
- 45:56or surprising to me was that it's we're sitting at in a bull
- 46:00market at 120 K and this has happened.
- 46:03And so TBD on what the cause is ultimately that they've halted
- 46:08withdrawals. They sent out a note in July.
- 46:10We'll link to the the article in the notes.
- 46:14The CEO sent out an e-mail saying that they're paused.
- 46:19But the main point is that this is what we'll continue to drive
- 46:23on podcasts and as we write content and information is
- 46:27picking your counterparties, being super vigilant on how
- 46:30people do things. We talked about it on there's no
- 46:33bailouts in Bitcoin. So if there's a loss of funds,
- 46:36whether it's on a custodial side for just pure spot custody or if
- 46:40there's some nominal yield being offered, you're putting all of
- 46:43your capital at risk for the best performing asset that's
- 46:46ever existed. And people just somehow forgot
- 46:50about 2022 and the insanity and how many people were burned and
- 46:54how many lives were destroyed. And sadly, we're just going to
- 46:57see it again because going back to the Wild West theme, we're so
- 46:59early in Bitcoins adoption that people don't know a where the
- 47:03risk is. And then which like don't know
- 47:05which crypto asset to buy, let alone then once you buy it,
- 47:08where do you park it? So on that, we were just pulling
- 47:11up the the Trustpilot. If anybody's interested in in,
- 47:14you know, who your counterparties are, you should
- 47:15probably do a little diligence. If you want to find out about
- 47:18opera more, you can check out Trustpilot.
- 47:21But curious Gervin Humanshu's feedback and thoughts based on
- 47:24that news, Yeah. But you hate to see something
- 47:27like this happen, especially when we went through something
- 47:30like this 2:00-ish years ago or in 20 at the end of 2022.
- 47:34I think there's a few things. And Michael, you rightfully
- 47:38pointed out one, like just the diligence on the counterparty.
- 47:41It's not the company itself, right?
- 47:43That's one piece of it. Where, what are they doing and
- 47:46where are they holding your Bitcoin?
- 47:47Like that's a whole other piece that needs to be looked at as
- 47:50well. And so I think some of the
- 47:53there, there's two important pieces, right?
- 47:54One is, is there rehypothecation or not?
- 47:57And what this like literally means is does that lender move
- 48:01your Bitcoin into somebody else's name, right?
- 48:04Like typically you're the borrower you go to like a
- 48:07lending company like Arch, you're transferring Bitcoin.
- 48:10Arch is not transferring that Bitcoin to any other third party
- 48:14like it stays in an Arch account, right.
- 48:17So there's no re hypothecation. The other is now where is it
- 48:20held right? There's a few different like
- 48:23custody approaches people self custody people use qualified
- 48:27custodians that are well reputed.
- 48:29So just making sure you do your diligence on where these
- 48:32underlying assets are and that you feel comfortable with how
- 48:36they're folding it, because those are two additional vectors
- 48:39of failure here. And I think the third is also
- 48:43like, you know, lenders can have some way of proving it.
- 48:46Like we segregate assets and we can just share their unchanged
- 48:49bit, you know, Bitcoin wallet address with with folks and they
- 48:54can look it up 24/7 knowing, look, nothing else has come in
- 48:56or out. This is me knowing that arch
- 48:59isn't rehab complicating. So I think those are a lot of
- 49:02the things I wouldn't be wary of if I was a borrower and just
- 49:06make sure that I truly understand what's going on under
- 49:09the hood because, yeah, I mean, it's unfortunate that we're
- 49:13seeing this story sort of play out again in an industry that's
- 49:17that's had enough of these, I think.
- 49:18The apple story is kind of frustrating in some ways because
- 49:21they went for the last cycle. I know they had a tomato fine,
- 49:28but they kind of hopefully learned the mistakes of the
- 49:32other lenders and survive through it.
- 49:33And then to go from there to have this happen now I know the
- 49:37full reason isn't out yet, but I'm sure it'll come out over the
- 49:40coming days. It's it's a bit frustrating
- 49:42you've seen that happen today with someone who's not the new
- 49:45kid on the block who's like been around for a while and has a
- 49:49decent amount of of assets and management.
- 49:53So yeah, we'll see what happens. Unfortunately, these
- 49:56bankruptcies, if there is a bankruptcy to happen, they take
- 50:00two plus years and people get paid in kind, not every time.
- 50:05Sometimes it's a dollar amount of what the price was at that
- 50:09time. So we'll see what happens.
- 50:11It's it's annoying, but also it really should wake people up, as
- 50:18we mentioned, to verifying who your counterparties are, who
- 50:21their counterparties are, what risk controls do have in place,
- 50:24and how can you be sure that the arrests are going to be safe?
- 50:28Yeah. The last thing I'll touch on
- 50:30here, Michael, I know you, you referenced it, which is like,
- 50:34oh, we're only at like 120 and this is happening again.
- 50:37You'll you'll realize like the need for borrowing against these
- 50:41assets actually like just continues to increase as price
- 50:45appreciates, right? Because people have more and
- 50:46more of a, a wealth base in Bitcoin and, but they need to
- 50:50live like their day-to-day lives.
- 50:52And so you'll see this continue to happen as Bitcoin price
- 50:56increases. And I think, you know, lending
- 50:59sort of needs to mature along the way.
- 51:01And, and so that's one thing to, to just understand is as price
- 51:04continues to run up, more and more people will need this
- 51:08solution. So it's really important to get
- 51:11material like this out there so people can understand what to
- 51:15even look out for and, and how you go and start diligent seeing
- 51:18these types of products. And I hope we're not looking at
- 51:21this from just a cycle perspective.
- 51:23The last lenders lasted one or two cycles, but they did things
- 51:27that were risk on that, made sure that when it was a very
- 51:30exuberant cycle like those risk controls failed.
- 51:34I think the goal now when we're building financial services is
- 51:36to go for a lifetime and beyond, not just for a cycle, because I
- 51:40think we're going away from Bitcoin being just these
- 51:42technical assets that loses interest from retail and from a
- 51:45lot of people at the end of the cycle.
- 51:48Now we're seeing long term holders very significantly
- 51:52buying and they and and and as a result retail will also need
- 51:58long term services here. So we shouldn't be respond
- 52:01looking for additional yield or just slightly lower rate just
- 52:06for like the year or two when you can offer that.
- 52:09I think we should be looking at long term approaches here and
- 52:11that's what we're doing. It's really well said because
- 52:15that's really what drew us to the partnership and what was
- 52:18refreshing and shouldn't be, but it was a anomaly basically in
- 52:22the spaces you guys like, this is a reputation game.
- 52:25At the end of the day, your reputation is tied to delivering
- 52:28good service, but also everyone building, educating and
- 52:32explaining these things and then ultimately living like lasting.
- 52:36And so that's historically been the game in Bitcoin is just live
- 52:39through these cycles, whether it's the volatility and little
- 52:41layoffs or also not getting caught in the counterparty risk.
- 52:46The thing with aura looks like, you know, this whole notion of
- 52:50complexity is the enemy of security.
- 52:51They're doing a bunch of things and ultimately offering yield
- 52:54and other products. And we saw one of the hedge
- 52:57funds that was a liquid fund kind of like down 90% or
- 52:59whatever, like a lot of all coins haven't performed.
- 53:01And so if they're participating, these other active strategies
- 53:05with individuals Bitcoin promising A yield, that's
- 53:08probably part of where it have got that has them in a hole, not
- 53:11be able to make their obligations.
- 53:14But one thing to go a little bit in the weeds and then we can
- 53:18zoom back out on on lending, but is on the like securitization of
- 53:21lending versus like the the pure eyes on the underlying
- 53:25collateral. These I think there's a lot of
- 53:27competitors and people in the space that will say there's no
- 53:30re hypothecation, but there's a lot of things that happen under
- 53:33the hood that are above my pay grade.
- 53:34But you can help us and understanding where they'll, you
- 53:37know, have the lending books and then they'll sell it to somebody
- 53:40else. And if that counterparty ends up
- 53:42in a hole that they sold it to you assets are potentially at
- 53:48risk. And a good example or a cousin
- 53:50of this is in like the IRA space we saw in Bitcoin with like
- 53:54Prime Trust and Fortress where they had the Trust Company.
- 53:57There are qualified custodians, but because they ended up with
- 54:00holes on their balance sheet, a lot of these like assets that
- 54:03were titled at the Trust Company but maybe sat in somewhere
- 54:06else's custody, all in it had to be frozen because there was a
- 54:10hole in the balance sheet. They end up in receivership.
- 54:12And I think a lot of this is just so in the weeds, but also
- 54:15important for the the opposite of complexity and really just
- 54:18simplified versions of non rehypothecated, audible and on
- 54:22chain. So existing investors of these
- 54:26products that are allocating millions of dollars at risk for
- 54:29their loans feel comfortable who their counterparty is.
- 54:33Yeah. Speak to, I think you should
- 54:36speak to to desynchronization piece.
- 54:38So I think besides just one LL re hypothecation, which is
- 54:42lending your big, there's a number of other strategies that
- 54:46some lenders today adopt, which I think people should look out
- 54:49for. Is 1 is sure they're saying
- 54:52they're not re hypothecating, but they're giving the Bitcoin
- 54:54away to someone else who is typically the capital partner
- 54:57and the capital comes from there, but they're giving it
- 54:59away fully. It's not an entire party or
- 55:01multi institution. It's just completely with them.
- 55:03That is also in effect replication because if something
- 55:06happens to the capital partner, then you have no control of the
- 55:09lender and what happens to to the collateral.
- 55:12The other piece is if a lender takes custody and then is using
- 55:16that as collateral to trade somewhere else and like an SMA
- 55:19account or something, that also is replication where sure you're
- 55:23not moving the Bitcoin out, but it is being used to affect
- 55:26something else, some other financial service.
- 55:29So there is a lot of risk introduced there as well.
- 55:33And I think we still haven't fully figured out how to
- 55:35mitigate that risk. So it's best not to do it at
- 55:38this point. Can I say one thing?
- 55:40Before trans in, because this is really felt viscerally because I
- 55:44lived through it, operating at Unchained competing against
- 55:47Block FI all day long back in the day when interest rates were
- 55:50lower. And Block FI, remember
- 55:52specifically was 7.9% dollar loans against BTC unchanged were
- 55:569.9, but unchanged models married similar to Arches and
- 56:02that these assets were on chain, verifiable, titled to the
- 56:05individual. And so we would explain that
- 56:11risk adjusted or nominally, it's a little bit more expensive.
- 56:15Risk adjusted, it's much cheaper because of what you're putting
- 56:17at risk. And a lot of people like, once
- 56:19they heard it and understood it, they would make the right
- 56:23decision. But then a lot of people lost
- 56:24their their money because it just gets easy or they're not
- 56:27educated. And so I think that's a core
- 56:28part of what you're describing is when you see loans that are
- 56:32definitely in the lower single digits, you should really raise
- 56:35a red flag. But there's a reason where the
- 56:38cost of capital may vary by a few percentage points and you're
- 56:40ultimately paying for that risk. It's the same thing we think
- 56:42about when people pay for our custody.
- 56:44It's like maybe it's a little more expensive nominally, but
- 56:46risk adjusted, your assets are secure on chain, verifiable and
- 56:50you're not Privy to your house burning down or somebody come in
- 56:53to take your kid for your BTC versus the traditional way that
- 56:57we operate. If you're, if you're a customer,
- 57:00if you think about it this way, right, everybody has access to
- 57:03the same capital markets. These things are not like in the
- 57:05shadows. The way you use them is what
- 57:09defines the rate. And I think if you're using them
- 57:12in a conservative manner, then yeah, you do have a slightly
- 57:14higher cost. But as a result, there's more
- 57:16security. And if you're using them in a
- 57:18more discount manner, you can get that, but you have less
- 57:22security on what happens. And it's like when you go rent a
- 57:24car, you can get the minimum liable insurance, which is like
- 57:29if something happens, you're on the hook for a lot, or you can
- 57:31get the good insurance and then you can scratch the car.
- 57:34It's fine. Like you'll, you'll still be
- 57:35made like you, you won't have to pay much if if something
- 57:40happens. Yeah, I also.
- 57:41Think it's a mind shift, Michael, like what you talked
- 57:44about, right? This is an asset like what
- 57:47annual tiger over 50%. So does it like, you know,
- 57:51paying the extra 1 or 2% interest rate or paying the
- 57:54extra bits on custody doesn't really matter in the long term
- 57:59of it. Like you should be willing to
- 58:00pay up for that security and that Peace of Mind in general,
- 58:03because the asset is appreciating so much faster than
- 58:06any of these costs that it more than makes up for it just being
- 58:11there and knowing that you can always access it.
- 58:13So that's that's like roughly the frame of mind that that I
- 58:16would also position that on which is look like.
- 58:20Part of that. 'Cause you can like absorb
- 58:22anyways, just because bitcoins appreciating at such a good
- 58:26pace, but the way like touching back on on building on what
- 58:30Himanshu was talking about with OK, how do like lenders finance
- 58:32themselves right, like we talked about just pure rehypothecation,
- 58:36moving the Bitcoin into some other lenders, you know,
- 58:39control. They give you the dollars you
- 58:41lend it out to your end clients. What we've done is is sort of
- 58:44different than than most others in this space is raise the CLO
- 58:48now the stands for collateralized loan obligation.
- 58:51It's more so a fancy way of seeing we raise capital from a
- 58:56variety of large financial institutions that allow us to go
- 59:02and then lend out. And the structure we've done,
- 59:05the reason we've done it in that structure is 1.
- 59:08We do not ever need to rehypothecate the Bitcoin stays
- 59:12with us at our custodian partner Anchorage Digital.
- 59:15And as a result, there isn't a fail safe in the system.
- 59:19And the the the sort of dollars that we raise are also fixed in
- 59:23terms. And so that's another thing that
- 59:25gets a lot of lenders into trouble, which is, you know,
- 59:27people are doing one year, 2 year term loans, but the money
- 59:30that they have raised on their side is maybe retail deposits,
- 59:34which are, you know, instant liquidity.
- 59:37And you see a lot of companies with these earned products and
- 59:40that's sort of what they're doing right there.
- 59:41They're allowing individuals to put up dollars to fund a loan
- 59:46book. The problem is you have loans
- 59:48that you've given out for a year and your retail dollars can be
- 59:51redeemed, call it, you know, in a week or two week.
- 59:54And it creates that everything is fine in a bull market.
- 59:57But really the second like things start to move downwards a
- 1:00:00little bit, that's when you get these massive companies that go
- 1:00:03upside down. And so that's really like how
- 1:00:05we've thought about it. There's a lot more that we don't
- 1:00:08need to go in the weeds of that Arch has done behind the scenes
- 1:00:11things like. Backup servicers, you know,
- 1:00:13really mimicking traditional finance to make sure our clients
- 1:00:17are always protected in all sorts of scenarios, but that's
- 1:00:20sort of how we think about it. Yeah, do you all think?
- 1:00:25Yeah, the duration thing is, is a huge deal in matching that
- 1:00:29duration. How do you guys think about like
- 1:00:32the compression of cost of capital?
- 1:00:34Because I think this is an important thing to talk about
- 1:00:36that we're in a different era, but we're still not fully there
- 1:00:40yet. So all of this capital has been
- 1:00:41private capital. And a lot of our clients or
- 1:00:44clients, I'm sure you guys see a lot.
- 1:00:46It has the traditional heuristic of the inorganic cost of
- 1:00:49capital, which is like fed funds rate and they're looking at
- 1:00:51HELOC or their home or home loan or for their car versus what a
- 1:00:57private company is offering from Bitcoin back loans.
- 1:00:59And they think they're getting scammed.
- 1:01:00And reality is it's the opposite.
- 1:01:02It's that private capital still thinks this asset class is super
- 1:01:05risky. Just curious like if you guys
- 1:01:07can speak to that. And then also where do you see
- 1:01:10that, if any coming down as more banking institutions come into
- 1:01:13where where banks obviously have access to the Fed fund in the
- 1:01:16Fed window and can get lower cost, is that like on the
- 1:01:19shorter or middle term horizon? Yeah.
- 1:01:21So I think 2 days. One is, I don't know Brian or
- 1:01:25Jackson, if you have the ability to put this in the, the call,
- 1:01:28the, the notes here, but Arch and on ramp put out a good piece
- 1:01:31about like why rates are where they are a while ago.
- 1:01:34And I encourage people to read through that.
- 1:01:36But essentially, yeah, Michael, you, you, you put it right,
- 1:01:38right. Like these are dollar
- 1:01:40denominated. Look, so the base rate you could
- 1:01:42ever have is the Fed funds rate, right?
- 1:01:44Because otherwise people can just go and give it to the
- 1:01:47government and get that return. So now everyone else is a spread
- 1:01:50on top. And so right now the call it,
- 1:01:53it's between 4:00 and 1/4 and 4 1/2 percent mortgages run you
- 1:01:57maybe like between 7:00 to 8:00, depending on the type of
- 1:01:59property, who you are, etcetera. And you would think like
- 1:02:03naturally everyone in this call is like, look, Bitcoin is
- 1:02:06pristine collateral, right? It's better than real estate.
- 1:02:08It's trades 24/7. You have like custody of it.
- 1:02:11You don't have to go evict someone from their home to take
- 1:02:13over, etcetera. So it should be like somewhere
- 1:02:16more in that line or maybe even less.
- 1:02:19But why is it slightly above? I think it's for that exactly 1
- 1:02:23the that like arbitrage still exists of people perceiving
- 1:02:27bitcoins volatility and risk higher than what it truly is and
- 1:02:302nd the lowest pockets of capital like everyone lending in
- 1:02:34this space to date is a non bank lender.
- 1:02:36The lowest pockets of capital are banks, right, that can
- 1:02:39access directly federal funds cost or your insurance, pockets
- 1:02:43of money, your pension funds, things of that sort.
- 1:02:46And I think it's a matter of time before they start to
- 1:02:49understand these products and try to participate.
- 1:02:52And the way that we envision them participating because we're
- 1:02:55having these conversations on our side is actually they just
- 1:02:58come to arch and say, look, here is a pool of money for you guys
- 1:03:02to go lend out because these banks and institutions don't
- 1:03:06want to be in the business of managing, you know, a couple
- 1:03:09thousand loans, 24/7 management, you know, it's a different world
- 1:03:13and a ball game doing client services for all of these folks.
- 1:03:16And so that's at least how we've been seeing it.
- 1:03:19And the conversations so far have been very receptive.
- 1:03:22And as that happens, cost will start to come down more in line
- 1:03:26to where we all expect it to be. And that's kind.
- 1:03:28Of why we raised our structure, our Seattle structure where it's
- 1:03:32tranched. So there's different seniority
- 1:03:34just like you would in a traditional debt structure.
- 1:03:38And the banks come in typically at a higher seniority and
- 1:03:42they're providing outside capital there where as a result
- 1:03:45the whole book is now at a cheaper rate.
- 1:03:47So we'll see at least for us and we're seeing with other lenders
- 1:03:50too, rates come down over the course of the year.
- 1:03:53And we'll definitely get to some in the neighborhood of call it
- 1:04:00where mortgage are today, I want to say by next year.
- 1:04:05Could you guys speak to a little bit more just in terms of how do
- 1:04:08you think about, so you talked about RE hypothecation and why
- 1:04:11investors need to be wary of that and how to think about it
- 1:04:15from a risk management perspective.
- 1:04:17Could you also talk about bankruptcy remote and what that
- 1:04:20means from a custodial perspective?
- 1:04:22Anecdotally, because I'm speaking with clients
- 1:04:25frequently, a lot of people appreciate the fact that a non
- 1:04:29re hypothecated collateral B on chain segregated wallet which
- 1:04:34you can view 24/7 even external the Arch platform.
- 1:04:37And then the third would be bankruptcy remote and insured.
- 1:04:41So can you speak to that last component as well as it relates
- 1:04:44to just managing collateral? Yeah.
- 1:04:46So I think like on the bankruptcy remoteness, right.
- 1:04:49And Johnson, correct me if I'm wrong, there's two pieces here,
- 1:04:52but one is like where the actual assets are custody.
- 1:04:56So there's a variety of different custodians out there,
- 1:04:58but one class of them is what's known as a qualified custodian.
- 1:05:02And that's that's the class Arch uses as well, specifically
- 1:05:05Anchorage. Now they're a federally
- 1:05:07Chartered Bank, the first one to be able to to do this in custody
- 1:05:11crypto. And yeah, as much we just said
- 1:05:13the only one, all of these assets are how bankruptcy remote
- 1:05:17from Anchorage. So what that means is shouldn't
- 1:05:19anything happen to Anchorage digital, the parent company,
- 1:05:23these assets, Bitcoin custody there, everything is held
- 1:05:26separately and can be accessed as as like business as normal.
- 1:05:30And so that that's one that's really important because if you
- 1:05:33use another class of custodian or maybe, you know, you sell
- 1:05:37you, you're holding it just as yourself, like you're you as a
- 1:05:39business are self custodying these.
- 1:05:41That is like a risk that gets exposed and, and and is 1 that
- 1:05:45should be looked out for. The second is OK.
- 1:05:47Then what happens if the underlying lender themselves
- 1:05:51goes bankrupt? Right here you have a few
- 1:05:54different protections. 1 is like not rehypothecation ensures like
- 1:05:58those assets will be there. But then second like arch goes
- 1:06:01above and beyond and I don't know there's another lender in
- 1:06:04the space to my knowledge that does this, but we actually have
- 1:06:06contracted backup servicer firms.
- 1:06:09And so these are firms that will step in and continue to absorb
- 1:06:13your monthly loan payments and will process the return of
- 1:06:17Bitcoin for you. And so that's like traditional
- 1:06:20too. If your mortgage lender goes
- 1:06:21under, someone else, someone, you know, another company just
- 1:06:24steps in and says, look like you just keep making the payments to
- 1:06:27me and everything will be fine. And so I think that is something
- 1:06:31that, you know, we've sort of innovative in this space.
- 1:06:35Yeah, they're all critical components without putting you
- 1:06:39guys on the spot. You're happy to speak to it, but
- 1:06:41you know, we've had like ETF providers on the podcast and
- 1:06:44afterwards they say multi institution is bulletproof, but
- 1:06:47it melts brains. And so there's a notion of what
- 1:06:50you guys are describing, but like a peek behind the scenes
- 1:06:52for anybody's listening because we hear the interest in arch
- 1:06:55loans on multi institution. There's a lot of complexity and
- 1:06:58work that has to be done to get Capital Partners for by
- 1:07:02comfortable all the way down to bankruptcy remote and the
- 1:07:05processes around it. But that's just a core component
- 1:07:09that goes into and you can't just like roll out a lending
- 1:07:12product and just you kind of Willy Nilla to do it the way
- 1:07:14that Arch has done it. But it's definitely on the radar
- 1:07:16and something that we hear a lot of folks ask for and that we're
- 1:07:18working on for sure. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:07:21Something that we've been having conversations with, you know,
- 1:07:23ever since we first partnered and it's something that I think
- 1:07:25we've made good progress till date and have some more work to
- 1:07:28do before we're able to really present this out there.
- 1:07:32Yeah. I think that that key that you
- 1:07:34guys launched that was really makes a lot of sense after this
- 1:07:38discussion it made previous. But maybe for listeners is the
- 1:07:41vertical integration is really important around the
- 1:07:44comfortability with Capital Partners and everything's public
- 1:07:47that you guys referenced in Galaxy and the liquidity
- 1:07:49partnership in Anchorage that makes everyone comfortable up
- 1:07:52and down the stack on where the Bitcoin sits and where the
- 1:07:54dollars are coming in. So when you start to segregate
- 1:07:58that and have different custodial relationships, now you
- 1:08:01have to get the capital partner comfortable or we have to get a
- 1:08:03capital partner comfortable. You have to get the client.
- 1:08:05There's and then the mechanics of title and where the Bitcoin
- 1:08:08sits and who owns it. So there's a lot of work to do
- 1:08:11it the right way, but it's it'll be interesting to see to him on
- 1:08:16she's point earlier about there's kind of like an equally
- 1:08:20equilibrium in the private market that doesn't get talked
- 1:08:23about on once somebody de rest the Bitcoin back loans to a
- 1:08:26certain point. This, the logical thing is just
- 1:08:28to buy the Bitcoin so it can only hit a certain part or just
- 1:08:32like I'll just go buy the Bitcoin and hold it.
- 1:08:33So that's a component that I think will, if we can execute on
- 1:08:38the honor side and the vision of like the security and
- 1:08:40segregation of those assets, theoretically that should also
- 1:08:43help in reducing the cost of capital because there is some
- 1:08:46priced in meta of all the losses before.
- 1:08:48And that like if you can, we have 100% hit rate on never
- 1:08:52having a loss and eyes and these different like permissions and
- 1:08:55processes with different custodians.
- 1:08:57I think about insurance in a similar format where insurance I
- 1:09:00think across the industry is only like 250 million because of
- 1:09:03the omnibus way that people structure it.
- 1:09:05But if it was segregated and then you have multiple
- 1:09:07institutions that were already underwritten by like Lloyd's,
- 1:09:11you can theoretically create larger policies because there's
- 1:09:13more larger insurance pools willing to step in.
- 1:09:17And there's not that like systemic risk of a sub custodian
- 1:09:20going down with billions of dollars.
- 1:09:22And because gold I think runs in the same issue now where the
- 1:09:25price of gold is risen. So now nobody will insure these
- 1:09:28large places where it's stored. And so yeah, it's just a
- 1:09:32fascinating kind of like way the market structure will have to
- 1:09:35develop around the the nominal dollar amounts that are continue
- 1:09:38to increase. Yeah, we're.
- 1:09:40Working on a a much more enhanced insurance product which
- 1:09:44should be coming out soon where everything is fully insured.
- 1:09:47But yeah to your point it only works in a segregated matter.
- 1:09:51If everything is omnibus then it's just too large to protect.
- 1:09:56Which is wild because that's like the most simple version of
- 1:10:00I think about it as like it came out there was a study only like
- 1:10:03less than 20% of people know there's only 21 million Bitcoin.
- 1:10:07And I think that similarly majority of Tradfi has no idea
- 1:10:11about a segregated wallet or an on chain and like address.
- 1:10:15And they think of it as insanely complex.
- 1:10:18And also it's an operational burden.
- 1:10:20And that's why you see even world class firms like Fidelity
- 1:10:22just literally park all of clients assets in there.
- 1:10:26And so it's just kind of a while we're that early that people
- 1:10:29don't even delineate between the two and the risk associated.
- 1:10:36The public equities, the way I see the held are very different,
- 1:10:39right? In Bitcoin, I mean, we've spent
- 1:10:42probably half of this conversation talking about this,
- 1:10:45but it's because it's so important on how it's held and
- 1:10:49in trying to fight anything, but it's abstracted away.
- 1:10:51And worse comes to worse, there's a backstop and you'll
- 1:10:53get bailed out and there's let the government backing you.
- 1:10:58Here, you don't have that. So how you store assets is
- 1:11:00extremely, extremely important. Anything else that I might have
- 1:11:05missed? Was there some other topics you
- 1:11:06want to get through? I think we covered a lot, but I
- 1:11:09was curious if Mont, you and Dhruva, anything you guys want
- 1:11:11to share notable on the business things coming out, anything
- 1:11:15worth any calls to actions for folks to reach out or leverage
- 1:11:19the services? Yeah.
- 1:11:21I mean, you know, lending's been going great.
- 1:11:25We've had a good partnership. Our own book's been going really
- 1:11:27well. We've partnered with someone
- 1:11:30called Mark Moss to launch a series of more nuanced lending
- 1:11:33products. So you have like the vanilla
- 1:11:35lending option, come get a loan. But there's a lot of people that
- 1:11:38have very specific use cases, you know, whether you're
- 1:11:40retiring or you want to depreciate taxes or you want to
- 1:11:43invest in real estate or whatever else that have more
- 1:11:46specific needs. So our goal now is to launch
- 1:11:48more specific tailored lending products for them.
- 1:11:51So we've launched one recently where it's called Bitcoin
- 1:11:55perpetual income. It basically gives you tax free
- 1:11:58income against your Bitcoin every year and under the load.
- 1:12:00It's a, it's a more complicated way of doing a series of loans,
- 1:12:05but we manage all that for you. You're say 7075 years old,
- 1:12:09you're retired, you're just getting X amount of tax free
- 1:12:12income every year in perpetuity can be priced in the the
- 1:12:15expected appreciation of Bitcoin drawdowns, etcetera on that.
- 1:12:19So you don't have to worry about it.
- 1:12:21So that's one. Another one we're launching soon
- 1:12:23is so this actually is quite topical.
- 1:12:26So the big beautiful bill that just came out, it's so big that
- 1:12:29no one actually knows what's in it.
- 1:12:31But one of the points that's in it is that you can now
- 1:12:34depreciate, you can do 100% bonus depreciation against your
- 1:12:38income. So if you buy a qualifying
- 1:12:40capital asset, you can depreciate the full amount
- 1:12:42against your income. So if you say you've made 500K,
- 1:12:45you buy something or you owe a tax on 500K, you buy something
- 1:12:49that's qualifying for 500K and you can depreciate that.
- 1:12:52So we're launching a product in that realm that lets you
- 1:12:55leverage a Bitcoin to do that, both appreciation, so you get
- 1:12:58immediate 40% benefit on the taxes and then also the
- 1:13:02appreciation of the asset itself that's coming from there.
- 1:13:07And we'll definitely be launching more in this realm on
- 1:13:11lending. We'll continue to innovate.
- 1:13:13I know we're talking about some stuff on MIC which we just spoke
- 1:13:15about. There's more coming on our own,
- 1:13:20our own insurance piece. And then there's also stuff
- 1:13:22coming down the pipe on like reducing liquidation risk,
- 1:13:29things like that, that just make if, if you're a client, the goal
- 1:13:32is to make you think about this as little as possible.
- 1:13:35If you have a loan out, you shouldn't be thinking about that
- 1:13:37all the time. You should just have that, as I
- 1:13:39said, and forget it thing. And our goal is to get to that
- 1:13:42in every way possible over the coming months and years.
- 1:13:45One other thing I would call out as well that we might have
- 1:13:48missed is it's incredibly easy to take a loan out with Arch.
- 1:13:52I've had a lot of clients that have done this and they've all
- 1:13:55been shocked by how easy, simple, straightforward the
- 1:14:00process is from configuring the loan to KYC to actually getting
- 1:14:04disbursement of liquidity, which in many cases for several of my
- 1:14:07clients has been same day. Because you can do USDC, you can
- 1:14:10also do USD. So I just think it's a, you
- 1:14:13know, really testament to a fantastic product that you guys
- 1:14:16have built. Had a lot of great feedback.
- 1:14:19I'll hopefully do a better job of, of sharing that with you
- 1:14:22from, from our clients. But I, I would just say on
- 1:14:25behalf of the people that at least I'm working with, it's
- 1:14:28really appreciated how you 2 and the firm have taken a
- 1:14:33conservative approach to building a business.
- 1:14:36I forget which one of you mentioned, but you know,
- 1:14:38thinking about a lifetime in terms of reputation and, and
- 1:14:42business building and not just trying to get through the next
- 1:14:44cycle. So it certainly comes through
- 1:14:46with the client experience and, and the product you've built.
- 1:14:50So really appreciate that. Yeah, we appreciate that and you
- 1:14:53know I think we've had a great partnership and and looking
- 1:14:55forward to the the innovation that we do together as well.
- 1:14:59Yeah. One thing just to to call out on
- 1:15:01Jackson's note is being around the space for a while, like the
- 1:15:04leverage can kill you, but conservative leverage can really
- 1:15:08like help you thrive because we all have a dollar denominated
- 1:15:11expenses, whether somebody's getting engaged, putting down
- 1:15:13payment on some property. And it really, if you can manage
- 1:15:17that in conservative way. When you look at inflation
- 1:15:21coupled with traditional cost of capital, it's actually, you
- 1:15:26know, that's how I think about when it when people complain
- 1:15:29about the interest rates, regardless of where they're at
- 1:15:31for, for loans, It's like, well, when you look at bitcoins kegger
- 1:15:34and you look at what inflation is and then you look at the cost
- 1:15:36of this traditional loan, it's actually much cheaper than
- 1:15:40selling your Bitcoin, especially when cap gains comes in.
- 1:15:42You just have to like be very thoughtful in how you do it and
- 1:15:46make sure you have cash flow coming in and all or a large
- 1:15:49enough stack that you you can leverage for that capital to
- 1:15:52pay, pay down that. But bitcoins kegger takes care
- 1:15:55of the rest if you can just make sure you stay alive.
- 1:15:57Not financial advice, just more of like how to think about it if
- 1:16:00you have to live in a your day-to-day while you're trying
- 1:16:02to preserve your stack into the future idea.
- 1:16:05Behind so a lot of partial income product.
- 1:16:07The whole idea behind that is using bitcoins kegger to not
- 1:16:11have to pay back the loans use the kegger to like, you know, as
- 1:16:14it grows you can pay a little bit off, but you don't have to
- 1:16:18worry about paying off, you know, at the end of the year
- 1:16:21coming back paying off another one.
- 1:16:23And I think with a lot of Bitcoin loan products, they're
- 1:16:28one or two year term and then that's it right.
- 1:16:30Like with us people keep going much longer so they keep rolling
- 1:16:33over the loans without paying back principal.
- 1:16:35So you really can borrow for life.
- 1:16:37It's the same thing in the private banking world.
- 1:16:39You have this very popular notion of buy or die, but you
- 1:16:42accumulated assets. You never sell your assets, just
- 1:16:47you buy them, you borrow against them, and then one day everybody
- 1:16:49does. Yeah, hopefully not soon,
- 1:16:53though. Not that soon.
- 1:16:55But we'll use this as a reminder somebody made it to the very
- 1:16:58end, Brian and Jackson, we should share with the guys, the
- 1:17:01doc that Glenn is putting together for some of the dynasty
- 1:17:04trust planning because we're going to be rolling out some
- 1:17:06interesting stuff around asset protection trust.
- 1:17:09And then there's interesting modeling into kind of similar to
- 1:17:11yours where you're referencing the perpetuity of being able to
- 1:17:16have those assets parked given the seven or $14 million gift
- 1:17:21tax exemption, but then lending against them in that way and
- 1:17:24then offsetting it. It's a little bit above my pay
- 1:17:26grade, but we're putting out a piece on this in a few weeks.
- 1:17:29And Arch would be the natural place to take those loans out.
- 1:17:31So we should probably get your guys feedback on it.
- 1:17:34So we'll send that over. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:17:36Please do. Well, how about a like and a
- 1:17:39comment for Guruvan Himanshu? For people.
- 1:17:42Who actually don't re hypothecate your collateral.
- 1:17:45Please show show them some love so we can have them back on the
- 1:17:48show. Gentlemen, really appreciate the
- 1:17:49partnership. Thanks for coming on today.
- 1:17:51It was a nice conversation and you guys are doing some great
- 1:17:54work. Thank you.
- 1:17:55Thanks. For having us.
- 1:17:57Thanks fellows. Thanks guys.
- 1:17:58Thanks for. Listening to this week's episode
- 1:18:00of the show? If you found the information
- 1:18:02valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:18:04rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:18:06All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:18:09notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:18:11reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:18:14entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:18:17investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:18:20your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:18:22Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:18:26one of our private Client Advisors.