Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Graduation Dinner Was a Lie… | The Whitaker Family Murders
Transcript
- Mom: December tenth, two thousand and three. For the Whitaker family, this should have been one of the happiest nights of their lives. A family that sits around a table in a restaurant in Sugarland, Texas. They're laughing, taking pictures, sharing a meal, and celebrating a milestone they thought had finally arrived. Their son, Bart Whitaker, was graduating from college, or at least that's what everyone believed. Zalle: And that's one of the things that makes this case so disturbing because before anyone was talking about murder, before detectives were looking at evidence, there ⁓ was already a lie at the center of the story. Mom: a that would eventually unravel an entire family's life. Bert's mother, Trisha, was proud. His father, Kent, was relieved. His younger brother, Kevin, was excited about the future. For a few hours everything seemed normal. There were smiles, there were congratulations. There was absolutely no reason to think that this would be the last night Trisha and Kevin would ever spend alive. After dinner, the family climbed into their vehicle and headed home. The streets were quiet, the neighborhood was peaceful. Christmas was just around the corner and nothing seemed out of place. Zalle: Which honestly makes what happened next feel even more horrifying because they weren't walking into danger as far as they knew. They were just going home. Mom: The family opened the front door and stepped inside. And within moments everything changed. Trisha Whitaker was shot and killed. Kevin Whitaker was fatally wounded. Kent Whitaker was shot in the chest but somehow survived. And Bart Whitaker was shot in the shoulder. Zalle: At first, investigators believed they were looking at a terrible home invasion, a random act of violence, the kind of nightmare every family hopes never happens to them. Mom: But the deeper detectives dug, the less the story made sense. Nothing appeared to be stolen. The attack seemed to be precise, too planned, and too personal. Zalle: And that's when investigators started asking a terrifying question. What if the killer wasn't a stranger at all? Mom: What they eventually uncovered would shock Texas and capture national attention. A fake graduation, a murder for hire plot, a father who survived against all odds, and allegations that the person everyone was mourning alongside may have helped set the entire tragedy in motion. Zalle: This isn't just a story about murder. It's a story about deception, greed, betrayal, and a family destroyed from the inside out. Mom: So grab your coffee. Zalle: And settling. Mom: Welcome to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicole, Mom. Zalle: And I'm Zay. Mom: And today we're talking about the Whitaker family slang. Zalle: Yeah, and this one is one that comes with mini twist. So let's into it. Mom: Let's do it. Zalle: All right, before then, mom. Coffee check. What you're drinking? Mom: I'm drinking very dark roasted espresso with a little whip on top. Zalle: Okay, okay, okay. I am ⁓ a coffee today. But like a caramel dose flavor. And I trying this new creamer. It's called coconut cream and it it's kinda giving me life. Mom: Mm-hmm. Yeah. I love coconut and pineapple. Zalle: D yeah. Yeah, you know I was on that Ube coconut thing for a while. Mom: You and Ube, you got past the Ube. Zalle: He well, Starbucks took it off his menu, so I didn't have a choice. Mom: ⁓ mm, okay. It wasn't voluntary. It just happened. It happened to you. Zalle: No, yeah, I didn't have a cho I just had to let it go. Mom: Sometimes that happens. Zalle: Yeah. This episode is one of the ones that come with a lot of ooh, I don't think I really saw that coming moments. So Yeah, I think we're just gonna ⁓ crazy. Yeah, I think we should just go ahead and get into it. Mom: Yeah, definitely. It's a crazy one. So as we said, we're talking about the Whitaker family slames. This family was Kent Whitaker, who was the father. He was an accountant, ⁓ pretty successful, and the mom, Trisha Whitaker, who was an elementary school teacher. Thus I just assume that elementary school teachers all sound like Miss Rachel and behave that way. So she s is coming off sweet right off the top. Zalle: Well, from what everybody was saying, she was super loving. All the parents loved her. She was very active in her school and like involved and trying to make sure all her students were taken care of. So sweet is definitely Yeah. Mom: Mm-hmm. Yeah. That's what I picture. That's I think you kinda have to have that personality to be a preschool teacher or elementary school teacher with small kids. and then Kevin Whitaker was the younger brother. Zalle: Kevin Whitaker, they didn't really say what he was doing, but he was known to be like the sensitive one. ⁓ dad said that even though he was sensitive, he was a man from a young age. ⁓ he wouldn't back down from injustice, but he was also super quick to forgive. They didn't really say what he was doing, but they just described him as a person. Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So yeah. Yeah. I was like But they you know they had a good reputation in Sugarland. Sugarland is kind of a luxury, kind of a upper class area in parts. Zalle: ⁓ yeah, sugarin's defin definitely for the most part ubbity. Mom: Uppity. Okay. Yeah. And and they were Zalle: Mm. Mm. For sure. Yeah, 'cause you go through what you're going through Missouri City. Well, if you're from Houston, it makes sense. You know what I'm saying? You'll you'll know. Mom: You understand. You understand. Because you Missouri City is not uppity anymore. It was when I was growing up. You know, there's kind of the progression of neighborhoods, So as we said, ⁓ Bart they celebrating his graduation from college. and ⁓ we find out that he was not graduating college. as we go on with the episode, the detectives, as they're doing their investigation after the killings, they find out that he had not graduated. And ⁓ we can't really say that that's why this happened. Zalle: Yeah. Mom: at all. He doesn't really give us any good reason other than they're kind of assuming he just says he hated his family, but it was they think that if he was the one who did it, which he is in prison for it then he did it to inherit his family's money. Zalle: Yes. So The murders took on December tenth, two and three. And the night started off by I all of the family was at home. Bart came home and he told ⁓ Kent and Trisha, Hey, I finished my finals. I'm done. That means I'm getting ready to graduate. Let's go out and have dinner and let's celebrate. Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And so the family was like, Yeah, let's do it. We're gonna celebrate. We're gonna go do this dinner for you. They went to the dinner, they took pictures, they were laughing. It was like everything was fine. Kent and Trisha gifted Bart a Rolex as a graduation present because that was something he always wanted. ⁓ ⁓ was like for the rest of the family, or for the whole family, this was like a Mom: Yes, Jerry. Yeah. Roblex. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And you you can see in the pictures like a real night of celebration, everybody's smiling, everybody's excited. Mom: ⁓ yeah. Zalle: ⁓ and He's pretending ⁓ that he's graduating and he not. Yeah. And the family ⁓ Mom: when he's graduated. I always wonder when people do that, what is the end game? Do you he decide that, yeah, this is what I'm gonna do, I could just say whatever, ⁓ Zalle: So after the murders and they started investigating him when the lead detective s Slaugh, I think that's how you say his name, the detective Slaugh was talking to him and Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Bart the detective that he was graduating or he had graduated from Sam Houston State University. And so he looked into it and called the school and the school sent him his Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: transcripts they told him he's not even enrolled as a student. He was a student, but he stopped going to school as a freshman ⁓ their in their system, ⁓ still a freshman out on academic probation. ⁓ So ⁓ didn't even make it to senior year. Yeah, he didn't even he didn't even make it. Mom: Wow. Wow. So he didn't even like just complete his freshman year. Wow. Zalle: and when ⁓ ⁓ they asked him why he lied, he basically just said he didn't want to disappoint his family. And that he just needed break and it was too much on him. And so that's why he lied and just told everybody he was still in school and doing awesome. but he wasn't. And yeah. Mom: That's just crazy. Because I mean, eventually they're gonna know that that's not true. I mean, unless you're that one guy who did it, he Zalle: I mean I I guess not. Mom: went through college, said he graduated from like med school or something. He worked for who? The World Health Organization. He didn't, but that's what he told his family. And Zalle: Mm-hmm. Mom: he was maybe in his thirties or forties by the time. Anybody found out of course the tea killed people off. But it's kinda like that ends up having to be you're out because unless you're just gonna come clean. Zalle: Yeah, I don't know how that worked out. But yeah, he lied the whole time. Nobody knew. Mom: that's I I don't know what type of psychology or how messed up you have to be. Because it doesn't seem like, you know, from anything that they found that he was abused or mistreated in any way. It showed I saw that they were going on vacations, skiing vacations, all of those things. Zalle: No. Yeah, they did a whole bunch of stuff together and from what the family's friends and the people that they knew when they described them, they described the family as being super religious. The how their house was like the cool house where everybody went to go hang out because they felt safe. It was a nurturing, fun, and loving environment. So I don't understand that part. ⁓ Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. It's just always, you know, that argument, is it are these types of ment I it has to be some type of mental issue or psychological issue. And are those things caused by, ⁓ you know, n nature or nurture? In this case it doesn't look like it has anything to do with how he was raised, you know. Zalle: Right. Yeah. so I'm just gonna back up and kind of walk you guys through because we kind of jumped a little bit once we started talking about like the police investigation. So on December 10th, 2003, Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: the family went out to go eat after Bart said he finished finals and he wanted to celebrate. ⁓ All of that happened. They had a great night, it was cool. So then the family's leaving and they're going home. ⁓ They arrive at the house, everybody rolled in one car. So they're all getting out of the car. Kevin out first. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Trisha, his mom, gets out after and she's following him inside and immediately after that is the dad who is Kent. Kevin opens the door and as soon as he walks into the doorway, boom, he's shot. He was shot dead in the sternum. Mom: Yeah. Yeah. Mm. Zalle: He died right there. Next, the mom was behind him, behind Kevin. She was walking in, heard the sound, she saw him fall, didn't really realize what was happening, and her response was ⁓ no. So she stepped forward, like to go into the house to see what was going on with her son, and she was shot. Mom: ⁓ yeah. Yeah. Zalle: then next was Kent, dad. ⁓ And he didn't walk inside. After he saw his wife drop, he was like kinda at an angle. So said he peeked around the corner, but I guess half ⁓ the upper half of his body, like went around the door frame. Mom: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: To kind of see what was like in the house. And he said when he peeked inside, he saw a figure standing there in a ski mask. And as soon as he saw it, he was shot. Mom: Wow. Zalle: Yeah, and if I'm not mistaken, he was shot in the chest or in the stomach. Mom: Yeah. Zalle: after Kent was shot, Bart, who is the oldest brother, he chased the figure into the house. And the said as soon as he saw him getting close to the figure, then he was shot in his shoulder. And he fell. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: nobody really like knew what was happening, what was going on. Then Mom: It sounds like chaos. Can you I can't imagine that situation. Zalle: Yeah, right. Like I'm coming home from a peaceful night and then boom, walk in. Right, and you're so relaxed. Mm-hmm. Mom: Right, and you're so relaxed, every you know, your family, your kids, your bro you know, your siblings, you're just comfortable. And then that happened. Zalle: Yeah, we're all on this high, right? Like everybody's having a great night. Mom: Right. Zalle: it ⁓ is insane. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: the person who shot whatever I get obviously fled after he shot Bart. Then I guess hearing all of this, the neighbor Stanley, sorry, Cliff Stanley, he came over to see what was going on. He walks Mom: Right. Mm-hmm. Mm. Zalle: To the front door, obviously he sees that the door is open. So the first person he sees is Kent laying in front of the doorway. He saw Kent Kent was bleeding bad. And he was just like, he Kent told him I'm bleeding out, you know, whatever, whatever's like something's not right. So then ⁓ Cliff gets up to go try to check on the rest of the family The first person he saw obviously was Trisha. Mom: Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: She was still alive when he got there. And he said that she looked up at him and she told him, He shot us. And then after that, she was like out of it. She wouldn't, you know, she wouldn't speak it anymore. But he didn't know who it was. He didn't know who he was. Yeah. So then he said from where he was standing with Trisha, he stood up to look and he could see, Mom: ⁓ wow. Yeah. Yeah. Who did it, yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Kevin in the living room and he was already dead. Mom: my goodness. Zalle: Who's already there? And I guess after that he didn't go in further. He called the cops and then got the cops there. then the police came, they obviously start doing the search, they do the investigation. But while they're searching and they're doing the investigation, what made them kind of be like, Mm, something's not right here ⁓ is they thought it was possibly a burglary gone wrong was their first motive. They walk in, the house isn't trashed. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: So that's one. Cause normally if it's a burglary, people just throwing shit around trying to get to stuff. Well, he said they went upstairs to the main bedroom and the drawers to the dresser were open, but they were all open the exact distance. Really? Yeah. All the drawers were open the exact distance. It wasn't like somebody was, you know, going through it. He was like, That stuck out to me. Like that was weird. I then they're searching the house and looking for like all the Mom: Mm. Right. They're looking for stuff, yeah. Really. Right. Zalle: important stuff like the valuables so they get to the I it was like his art one of the offices the dad's office and somewhere in the office it was like tucked into like this corner like you had to know where it was they found his safe and it was pried open. But the ⁓ it was ⁓ like in the crawl space. It was like think it was like in a crawl space. Yeah, you had to know where it was at. It was hidden. Yeah. ⁓ Mom: Uh-huh. Yeah. Uhhuh. And they said it was like in a crawl space, right? You had to know where it was. Yeah. Zalle: that that was another thing that they were like, This is a weird spot. And if it this was a regular burglary, you wouldn't have thought to look here. Mom: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: They found a gun. And the gun was Whitaker's gun. It was Kent's gun. So whoever shot them pried out the safe and took the gun. So so far that's the only thing that was moved around in the house other than the drawers being opened the same distance. ⁓ Mom: They came out of the gun safe. Right, and they would have had to bring something to open a gun safe to pry it open. So even if they happened upon it, they just happened to have the right tool to pry this gun safe and then you came without ⁓ that's just crazy. Zalle: To opening a gun safe. Yep. Yeah, yeah. ⁓ And so that they were Yeah, we don't really know, like this kinda fishy. This don't seem like it was a random person. This seems like it was intentional, like somebody was after them trying to basically assassin whole family. Mom: Mm-hmm. Right. Right, it had to be planned. There's too many things, yeah. Zalle: Yeah. So the detective was like, I'm gonna go back and I'm gonna talk to the two survivors and let's reinterview them. And obviously Kent was pissed off. He was mad and Bart was mad. And so they said that their energy was like, Let's find out whoever this was. let's really do it. And the dad was like, Whatever, look into us, and they said Bart was helpful too. He tried to yeah, look into all the information, whatever he told them he graduated, he was giving up all this stuff. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: the detective was like, cool, awesome. But then that's when he looked into what both of them were saying. Right. Obviously, all the dad's stuff came back, it's clear. But Bart stuff came back, and that's when they found out about the school. And after the school ⁓ and the talking him, that's when they were like, Mm, that's a big ass lie. you were saying, this is years worth of a lie. Mom: Right. Mm-hmm. Yeah. what like at least three years. Zalle: four. Cause it started freshman year. ⁓ Yeah. Started year. He got all the way to senior year. ⁓ And yeah, reasoning was that he didn't want to disappoint his family and he just needed a break. Insane. Mom: Yeah, ⁓ well yeah, because he didn't even finish the freshman year. That's crazy. I mean, okay, take a break. Take a break, you know, but go back. ⁓ just never went back and didn't tell anybody. I'm assuming that somebody's paying for this schooling. So that's what you just living off of. I just thought about that. Somebody's doling out money somewhere. Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: A semester. A summer. Right. Yeah, he said, Yeah, ⁓ bump this. I'm done. I'm done. I don't have time for this. Right. Yeah. Right. So the parents clearly paid for all of this. So then they all the investigation, found the lie. it just made them look into it even more. And then five days after the murder, Mom: Mm-hmm. Sounds good. Zalle: Somebody walked into the police station. The desk cop went back and got detective slow and was like, somebody wants to talk you. They're outside. The person was outside behind the police station at like 11, 11 30 p.m. Off the wall last time to go to the police station to ask a cop to talk to you and then not talk to the cop inside, meet me out back. That's some weird ass shit. Mom: What? Right. Okay. Zalle: Shady. Mom: It sounds crazy. Zalle: But the cop went to the back and met him in the back. Okay. He went on back there. so he needed the information. Cause what they said was ⁓ he said to the desk cop was I think I have some information regarding the murders that could help. And so he was like, I'm gonna go check it out. And so that's why he went to the back, right? But it's weird. I feel like a bla I feel like a black cop would have been like, ⁓ go get him. Mom: I'm gonna make He said you need the information. That's very weird. Zalle: Let's bring him to my office. And we're gonna talk in here in interview room one. Yeah. Mom: Yeah, tell him come on inside. What? Maybe this maybe this this happens all the time. Maybe this happens all the time. We're just not cops. Maybe they go in the back and talk to people at eleven thirty. It's maybe it's like the norm. People just meet back there at the back. Cops just go out around eleven thirty. Anyone out here? They just meet. Anybody out here? Zalle: Maybe. They're at the back and that's what they do. Maybe. I mean you had to go into the police station to tell the desktop to send the detective out. He was already inside. I didn't even know why you'd left. You should have just stayed in the front. Just wait in the lobby if you don't want to be outside. Yeah, we where it's a minimum it's v it's well lit in the police station. We need it to be dark. We need you to come to the back. Mom: No. The outside ⁓ that's where we tell secrets outside in the alley. Yeah, we need the light. The light hurts my eyes. Zalle: Okay. Yeah, right. Like I'm I'm vampirish. Okay, so so it ended up being an old friend of Bart. Mom: Mm-hmm. Okay. Zalle: And it was a ⁓ a man named Adam Hip. And Adam Hip. Mom: Adam Hill Hibb. Zalle: Hip. told Detective Slaugh that he had actually been approached by Bart in the past saying that he wanted him, that Bart wanted ⁓ Adam to him kill his family. Mom: Mm-hmm. So he just walking around any friends he has and nobody thought perhaps we should talk to the police about him wanting people to kill his whole family. Zalle: Right. And the crazy part is I guess after that came out, they were talking to like other family members and Kevin had a best friend who was a girl. And he had told her that it was already stuff happening before the murders. Like weird shit. And he was nervous thinking that somebody was trying to hurt his family. Mom: Uh-huh. Mm-hmm. wow. Zalle: Right. the day ⁓ after that, they had the funeral for Trisha and Kevin. ⁓ And a thousand people up to their funeral. Being people from their friends, family, of these people showed up. How amazing they were as a ⁓ actual family. Mom: Yeah. Right. That just tells you what what people thought of them. Yeah. Right. That's a lot of people. Mm-hmm. Yes. Zalle: A thousand people. That's a shit ton of people. obviously, you know, Bart is supposedly he's crying. Kent is having a full breakdown, it's a whole horrible experience, right? Mom: Yeah. Zalle: Well, while all of that is happening, Detective Slaugh is sitting on this information that Adam Hip told him. And he also said that this was ⁓ years earlier. And he didn't just ask him to help. He had detailed on Mom: that's what we started with. Mm-hmm. ⁓ wow. Zalle: He wanted this to happen. And so drew up a diagram of the plan that Bart gave to him to kill his family. And so basically it was like a blueprint of the house. And he just like wrote, this is what he said he wanted where he wanted me to be, how to attack them. The whole plan. Mom: ⁓ wow. Wow. Mm-hmm. Right. That's crazy. Zalle: Was exactly the same as what happened on December 10th, 2003, when the family was actually murdered. Exactly the same. Mom: Wow. ⁓ I guess he thought it was a good plan, so he was gonna stick with it. Zalle: I guess, but mind you, this is only five days after the murder. So a lot of the information they haven't released a lot of the the stuff to the public. So then you walk in and you come out and you lay out a blueprint for what he told you to do and it's exactly what is happening in this murder case. Mom: Right. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm. Yeah, yeah, it Zalle: it included Bart being shot in the shoulder. So that way it would trick up the police and they wouldn't feel like Bart had anything to do with it. Mind you, Bart was shot in the shoulder. Mom: Mm. Right, 'cause he was hurt. mean he didn't change anything up just in case once his family was killed somebody said, hmm, that seems familiar. I think I've heard of that before. Was this the movie? Zalle: Hmm. That sound like we had this conversation. Mom: Whoa. That does not make sense. That is not that is not Zalle: Insane. Insane. No, it doesn't. And mind you, Bart doesn't know that the detective was brought this information. Mom: ⁓ you're right. He don't know yet. Zalle: He doesn't know this. So still being helpful ⁓ the investigation. He even offers to recreate or ⁓ ⁓ happened the night of the shooting to take the cops back to the house and walk them through exactly what happened. Mom: Mm-hmm. ⁓ that was nice of him. He offered this. Like they didn't say, Hey, Bart, we need for you to come. No, he said, Hey guys, I would like to reenact my family being killed. Zalle: I don't think that they asked him specifically. I know that they were thinking about it. Yeah, I think that they brought it up. Like this is something we're thinking about. And he was like, Yeah, I'll do the reenactment for you guys. ⁓ I think almost like trying to keep dad from having to do it. But also I think that he felt like he was smarter than everybody else. So if he went through and did the reenactment, Mom: Mm. Okay, okay. He definitely Zalle: Then he could like, you know, say what he need what however he needed to say and maybe try to like trick the police more. Yeah. Right. But it backfired because the detectives said his behavior was very sketchy. One, one, he was very vague. When they were asking him about, like, hey, so this is where this is how far you were from the shooter, or where was your mom, or whatever. A lot of his answers were like, Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Anyway. Bye. Zalle: ⁓ was this far, I think, or I don't remember. I don't really remember. Or, you know, vague details. And it's like this just this didn't happen that long ago. Mom: Yeah. And it's traumatic. So I would think that you it that you will remember Zalle: And it's traumatic. And you don't have any kind of head injury from this. You were shot in the shoulder. So I don't think that that should affect your memory at all. He gave very little details about what happened. And so the cop was like, Yeah, that's even more suspicious. And at this point, he's already a suspect, but he doesn't know. Mom: Right. Those are kind of important details. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right, he just didn't know. Zalle: So then Slo was like, you know what? Adam Hill is an old friend of Bart. He came forward and said that this is a plan that Bart had. Let's look into some of Bart's other close friends. So the two people that he went to first were Bart's ex college for the I'm gonna make a joke, but for the like four weeks that he was at college. Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm. Zalle: I didn't want to say it and then y'all be like, ⁓ he was only there for four weeks. I don't know how long he actually res was residing on campus. Mom: What? It was just funny how you let us all know that the joke was coming. I'm gonna make a joke. Zalle: We gotta make a joke. I want everybody to take this serious. This is not factual information. I'm pulling it out of my ass, okay? Disclaimer. Disclaimer. Joe coming. This is don't take me serious. His his ex-college roommates for the four weeks he was enrolled. Mom: Disclaimer Joe Cubby Okay Zalle: Right. they obviously ⁓ with them separately, but both of them were ex-coworkers of BARTS. They all worked at a country club together so they weren't really ⁓ giving much ⁓ information. Like, no, I really know No, no, no, no, no, nothing really happened. So the detective was like, give us a scent sample. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: So I guess like where they could I they take like a piece of your clothing or like something like that. So they can have the dogs your scent. And then they can take that and so what they did was they took the dogs, took the scent samples, let them smell it and let them loose on the crime scene. So they could see if they smelled them at the crime scene. Mom: Hello. Okay. That's really. Mm-hmm. ⁓ wow, that's smart. Zalle: As hell, as hell, so smart. Out of all of the stuff that I've looked into, that's the first time I've ever seen anybody say, Let's take a scent sample. I've never heard of a scent sample. Right. That's what I did. A scent sample. You mean like at like bath and put the little thing and you go like this? Yeah, I was like, what the? Mom: That's very smart. I've never heard of that before. That's why I was looking at you like what exactly is that? Thanks for Yeah. ⁓ Zalle: Im not a cop Okay. So they did that. Steven, I'm sorry, the two best friends. I didn't even tell you guys their name. My bad. The two best friends were Mom: Okay, all right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Chris Brashier and Steven Champagne. always want to say champ champagne, but that's not how you say it. So they Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Champagne. Zalle: Took the scent samples, went and did the thing while they were doing the scent search, I guess, at the house. Steven's scent did not come back. But Chris Brashier's scent did come back. It came back on one, the gun. And two, if I'm not mistaken, it was somewhere near Trisha's body where the second scent was. So there's that. Clearly. Mom: ⁓ nice. Okay. Mm-hmm. Wow. Mm-hmm. I don't know. Zalle: You were at the crime scene. So they brought both of them back, but they focused Steven because, you know, clearly Chris was there. So you're gonna try your hardest to cover it up. We don't have the scent for Steven, but we feel like you know something. So they pressured Steven. He cracked. Mom: Clearly. Mm-hmm. Yeah yeah. Right. Of course. Zalle: He cracked he told them that he was there at the crime scene, but he never ⁓ anywhere near the house. He was the getaway driver. He sat in the car the whole time. Mom: Okay, that makes sense. That's why I said wasn't in it. Zalle: So that's why his scent wasn't there. That Chris was there and he was the shooter, obviously, since his scent was on the gun. And that Whitaker the Wow. He even told them where to find all of the evidence they needed to prove that Chris was there. Like when they went to go get rid of Mom: Mm. On the gun, yeah. Wow. Wow. Zalle: whatever they had on them, he sh he told them exactly where it was. They had taken this bag and I guess put it under a bridge ⁓ on Lake Conroe. Mom: Mm-hmm. Just under the bridge. Zalle: Under the bridge. Mom: Okay. So where anybody could find it, any homeless person, somebody going fishing. Zalle: So in the I mean you really have to no on Lake Con yeah, you on Lake Conroe. So like over the water. Yeah, you gotta be on a boat, but you really gotta be look like it's not they hit it up there, you know. So it's not you wouldn't just seen it. You had to have known it was there and look for it. Right. But in the bag was a chisel, which is the chisel that they used to break into the safe, which how they got the gun. Ammo, which was the remaining bullets. Mom: Okay, so somebody going fishing. Okay, okay, okay. Right. For the gun's sake. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: that was in the gun that they left at the house, which I don't know why you took the rest of the ammo. If you're gonna leave the gun, dumb as fuck. Okay. And then it was two cell phones, which were cell phones that Bart gave to Chris and Steven so that they could communicate during the murders. Mom: Mm-hmm. But why did they okay, smart, you put it under the bridge up there where nobody could see it, but you put everything and left the gun at the house. Three brains together and they didn't come up within I've never committed murder before. Ever, ever. And I think that I could Zalle: And left the gun at the damn house. I feel like if I am even if this is like a pay a a killer for hire situation, somebody like, hey, I'm about to give you ten point sixty seven gagillion. I need to go off these people. I'm gonna go in there and I'm gonna off these people, right? But I'm going to take whatever I use to offset people with me, whether I brought it here or not. It's coming with me. Because how you gonna find a gun once I got the shit? That's all I'm Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Right. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. ⁓ Why? I mean like I don't understand. At least take the gun. You you got in the gun safe. If you have a gun safe, I'm assuming you have more than one gun, at least if you stole some of the guns and took them away from the house, it would seem like maybe that's why you came to steal from the house. Zalle: And I mean, you're then and then on top of this, you took the gun from Sugarland the way to Lake Conroe. I for facts you passed ⁓ several of construction on the highway, okay? Or the water, or the before you even before you even made it to the Conroe, the bayou, any of that. It's several places where they were doing some kind of it's wet cement somewhere along the way. Why you ain't just stuffed that shit in the cement and walked on about your damn deck? Mom: I would love the boy. Yes. Out of water. Bayous. We got yes. Yes. Zalle: Who would have known who gonna bust the cement open? Mom: I feel like this is the reason that they keep fences around construction areas so that people don't their killer weapons in their cement. ⁓ Zalle: can jump fences. People that's why they have fence cutters. Or or people can jump. Mom: ⁓ you're gonna be a killer, you gotta be willing to go the whole way. And nobody thought this out. I mean, it's amazing ⁓ he had this plan for years. He had asked multiple people, and that was the best ending to this scenario that he had in years. He had all of these years. He wasn't going to school. What else did he have to focus on? Zalle: Gotta be willing to do it. Yeah. Right. So so at this point, they got all this damn evidence, right? So clearly they're suspects. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: So ⁓ then ⁓ seven months later, after and this is months the murder. Okay. ⁓ Bart tells Kent that he's gonna go out to a club and that he'll be back the next day. And Bart got the fuck up out of there. He never came back. He never Mom: The murder. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: He fled the country. See you later. Catch me if you can, is what he said. he got gone. ⁓ Mom: mean, I knew what happened, but And Bra got to fuck about it. Zalle: He got the fucking right there. He was gone. I'm not sticking around for this shit. What? Mom: Yeah. Zalle: I at this point I'm sure Chris and Steven done told them what's happening. Steven had to have said, Hey, look, I cracked. I snitched. I done told the people. Mom: Yeah, he probably got tipped off that ⁓ they know. Zalle: So he was gone. He didn't come And he ended up in Seralvo, Mexico. Mom: Okay. Never heard of that like. Zalle: And he left he yeah, I don't know. It's right off the border. So it's not far from the border, the Texas and Mexico border. He went with seven thousand dollars that he stole from his dad. From the house. Mom: Okay. Mm-hmm. Wow. Okay. So we kill his wife and his son and then stole his money. Zalle: Still money. went there and changed his name to Rudy Rios. And he was there for 14 months. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: He ended up meeting woman named Cindy Lou. And they started dating. And I guess they got serious. And so Cindy introduced at this time Bart is Rudy, introduced Bart to ⁓ her And her family owned a furniture store. And so the dad was like, I'll give you a job. And he worked at the furniture store and befriended and got really close with the whole family. Wow. He told them. Mom: Mm-hmm. Wow. Zalle: that were the family he never had. Mom: my god. Zalle: And the brother ended up being like super close with him. And he said, Yeah, he was a super cool guy. The dad said he loved him. He had like spoke of him in the highest regards. and they would ask about the bullet wound. Clearly, they saw it. He told them that his bullet wound was from a surprise attack from the Mom: Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: the Afghanistan people because he was a soldier during the Afghanistan war. Mom: ⁓ he wasn't. He wasn't. He was not. Zalle: He was not. He was never in the military. He never graduated. He never went to the military. Mom: He never did any of these things. Zalle: Never did any of that shit. And his name is not Rudy Rios. No. But he said that that's how Cindy Lou. Send that's her real name. Her name is Cindy Lou. That's what I was like, wow. They love the Grinch. Mom: No. And I didn't know they had people named Cindy Lou in Mexico. That That is beautiful. But I was like, that's that's what I was thinking of. That's what I was thinking of. Zalle: Yeah. And Cindy Lou said that while he was there and obviously they were getting to n you know, know each other, he told her he was an only child and that he never loved his mom because his mom ⁓ never loved him and that she was a And she never gave any ⁓ any love to him and she just ignored ⁓ She was out hooking all the time. ⁓ Mom: Wow. What is wrong with this man? So he killed his mama and then turned it into that is horrible. I guess this is not funny, Sam, but he is ridiculous. Zalle: I'm sorry. And then turned her into a prostitute. Now she's a a woman of the night. It's not. It is not. But it is like just the lies because the whole time you're lying to your your parents about the school. Then all this happens to your mom and your dad and like the whole shooting. Now you're lying to your dad and the police about being involved in any of that shit. Then on top of that lie, you're gonna lie to your dad and be like, Hey, I'm about to go to the strip club, I'll be back tomorrow, dipped out here. Mom: Wow. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Stole his bread and got gone. Okay. Then you make it to Mexico. You meet these people after you lied about who you were. And then you keep lying more about who you are. Now I'm a soldier. I was in the Afghanistan war. I got shot. It was a surprise attack. Boom. Got me. Right? And I was born from a prostitute. I don't know who my daddy was. It could have been anybody. But my mama never loved me. Mom: You just keep making up schools. Wow. And my mom never left me. This is just wow. Zalle: When you say all of that shit together. Mom: Sound crazy, right? is crazy. Zalle: All of that is is is insane. But while he's gone, on September of two thousand and five, which is two years from when the shooting happened, they arrested Chris and Steven for the murders. But they could not find Bart. And if I'm not mistaken, that wasn't long after they gave the confession. Mom: Mm-hmm. Okay. Okay. Okay. Zalle: But they couldn't find Bart. But they had drafted up the warrant for his arrest for the murders of his mom and his dad. He's out there living in Mexico his best life for 14 months. Never called, never went back, never spoke to his dad, dipped out. Killed his mom, killed his brother, lied, abandoned his dad. Mom: Mm-hmm. Does he have a girlfriend? Zalle: Stole from him and then that was it. Like that that life is gone. His poor dad. Mom: And his poor dad his poor dad when he Wow. He lost his son, his wife. And then this one, everybody, you know, I feel like people's probably are the people, maybe not the police, but people was talking about it had to be him. And the dad is trying not to believe that and then he burns out, steals his money and he don't hear from from over here. Zalle: Poor there. Well Right. So then crazy part how they found Bart. They put a reward for ten thousand dollars for anybody who knew any information. Well, the real Rudy Rios Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: So yeah. I think I could I could use that money. He called him. So I know where that motherfucker's at. Go get him. Give me my bread. And then go get him. Mom: This a this sounds like a dark comedy, is what it sounds like. ⁓ my god. Zalle: Sounds horrible. So Rudy with Bart while like during the time of the murders. ⁓ And told Rudy, Hey, I think I might be in trouble with the police, realizing that they were investigating him and he was a suspect. So Rudy told him, Hey, well, let me know if you need any help with that or you need to get out of here. I got people in Mexico. Mom: Mm-hmm. Okay. Mm-hmm. Uh-huh. Zalle: Who will help you? Mom: Okay. And then Rudy heard about the money. Zalle: So So then he told him, like, yeah, I need that help. So Rudy was like, Bet, use my name. I'll help you get whatever you need we you we'll get you to Mexico. You can stay with my people till you get together. So he went to Mexico. Through help of Rudy's family. Okay. And he paid the real Rudy three thousand dollars. Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: To get to Mexico. Mom: Wow. Zalle: And so Rudy was like, Shit, I see this ten thousand dollars, I'ma come up 'cause you weren't offering enough, my friend. My friend. I'm coming up. I'm coming up. Mom: Yeah. I am I making all the money. He making all this money. He ain't even had to kill nobody. He got thirteen thousand. Zalle: And I feel like somewhere along the line the real Rudy should have been arrested. You should have been put in jail. F first of all, because why are we offering services to people to get to Mexico when they know they are having Mom: I think he should have. Definitely. Right. How many other people how many Rudy Rioses do we have in Mexico that look like a Brit or a or not a Rudy? Zalle: It was nothing real about Bart. Okay. Whittaker. Whyte That is a whyte man. With a Y. A white man. Okay. whyte whyte Mom: Nothing. He was the he was he was yeah, he was he was What? Zalle: Okay, so after he was arrested. Kent came to see Bart. Once they finally like led people, yeah, once they finally let people see him. And Bart apologized to him for the murders. And Kent was like, he just remembers he walked in there and he saw him and he was like, Well, you look like you're doing good. That was the first thing he said to his son. It didn't have nothing to do with him murdering his mom. That tells you. And Kent said Mom: In jail. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm. Yeah. you have to have so many emotions because your first emotion as a parent, even with grown children, that's my baby. That is you will you will always see them that way. And then to know that that person did this horrible thing, I don't ⁓ it feels like my would separate. Like I I would break because I wouldn't know how to put those two things together. Zalle: Yeah. That's what he said. Yeah. Yeah. He was like, it didn't hit him. Like, you know, while all of this was happening after the murders and whatever, of course, people started coming up to him like, hey, you don't think whatever. Even when the detective brought it up to him to let him know that, hey, he's a suspect, he was like, It's no way he did this. Like, it's no way. It's him. He said, I just I could not. And then he said, even after like all of that happened, it wasn't Mom: Yeah. Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Even once the friends were arrested, it wasn't until Bart f fled and like he didn't like he never came back. You know, like he said it he was gone for a while. a couple of weeks before it just dawned on him. And he said ⁓ that night when he left, said he was going out and he never came back the next day. He said, I just sat and I cried. I just cried. And I was like, ⁓ that's heartbreaking. Mom: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Okay. ⁓ my god. I know like I could just feel it in my heart. ⁓ Zalle: Heart heartbreaking. So Fred Felkman was the that got. And he described Bart ⁓ as ⁓ a Mom: Yeah. Zalle: He wasn't playing no games with Bart. You're not getting no kind of leniency from me. So obviously he went for the death penalty. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: But Kent did not want Bart to die. He fought tooth and nail for them to keep him alive. said that if they killed him, it would have just caused more trauma for him because he was the last living person ⁓ his actual family. He was all he had left. And he Mom: I thought that. Yeah. It just makes me sad. Zalle: It did. And he said it's also like for him, it was about his eternal soul. If that ain't a southern daddy for you. Mom: Ain't it? Ain't it? I don't want him to die. Zalle: Not right now. I don't want ⁓ to die at all. But but definitely not now. Yeah. Mom: But he need right, but I need for him yeah, in and no. He needs to pay for it, but he don't need to die. Zalle: No. So he don't need to die for it. So they brought some wicked ass evidence with them. Okay. Mind you, the trial started three years after the murder. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: And they had Steven Champagne testify. Mom: Wow. Zalle: And he said that two months before the murder, Bart offered them part of a million dollars to kill the family. Because the prosecutors were saying that if all of them had actually died, the dad increased died with the brother and the mom, he would have inherited one point five million. Mom: Mm-hmm. Wow. Zalle: At least one point five million. Mom: Yeah. Wow. Zalle: So he offered them part of a million to kill the family. And during this, the trial, they learned that Bart had tried ⁓ three at least three separate to kill the family with three separate groups of friends. Mom: That's what I think. Wow. I mean, come on people. What group of people are you hanging out with that you got three groups, sets of friends that are willing to commit murder? Zalle: That agreed. So here's the crazy part. All of the people, or at least the ones that came forward and were and admitted this shit, the people who came forward and was like, Yeah, I said yes. All of them were bankers. like s everybody had been to college. They all had degrees, masters. They were like all successful men that you would not like Mom: Yeah. Zalle: something you're not supposed to look at. That's ⁓ it's pattern. It's a pat Mom: Well not in this sloppy stuff. You know, I would at least think it would be something that, you know, we'd be all guessing if it was people with brains. Zalle: Man, that's where the pedos be the the that's those are the people. The ones that look like the regular schmegular Johns who are doing what they supposed to be doing. Yeah. Then that's why. Right. Right. So Bart's first attempt to kill his family was in December of two thousand, which was three years before he actually did it. Literally. Mom: Yeah, yeah. The ones you wouldn't look twice at. Mm-hmm. That's why they can get away with it for so long. Wow. Zalle: Literally three years before he actually did it. Come committed. Committed. This was his his life's purpose was to off his people. Okay. I'm sorry. Those were the college roommates. Not not Chris and Stevens. ⁓ Mom: He was he was committed. Mm-hmm. Zalle: They were just his other best friends. They weren't roommates. So I apologize. That was error on my part. Will Anthony and Justin Peters were the college roommates. And for them, the plan that Bart gave to them was that Will and Justin were supposed to enter through a window, a back window in the house and come in and like off everybody in the night. And yeah. Mom: Okay. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Wow. Zalle: obviously shoot Bart in the shoulder. Connecting factor. Mom: Mm-hmm. Same same plan, yeah. Zalle: Right. But that didn't go through because they did go to do it. They went to the house to commit the murder. But as soon as touched the window, the alarm went off and they fled. Mom: ⁓ wow. Zalle: And so that's the only reason why the family wasn't murdered that night. And they didn't try again after that. Mom: ⁓ my goodness. Zalle: The second attempt Was in February of 2001. And this was with Adam Hip, the one who met the the detective in alley. Right at 11 30 BM. He ⁓ said that he agreed to this, not because he wanted to kill the family, but because he wanted to see how far Bart would take it. That is what he said on the stand during trial. That's a quote. Mom: Right, in the alley, yeah. Wow. Zalle: I wanted to see how far he would take it. That's your reasoning. Mom: I don't even understand that. Why? Why did you want to say that? What Zalle: That's the reasoning to agreeing to off this man's family. Insane. But that was the same exact plan the night of when he actually murdered the family. However, that never got past the talking phase. He never they like Adam never actually attempted anything. Which makes sense why he never got charged. I don't think that they charged Mom: Crazy. Wow. Okay. Okay. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Will Anthony are Justin Peters, which is insane to me because they should have that's at least attempted murder. You went to try. Mom: Yeah. You tried, right. Wow. Zalle: Anywho, his third attempt. That we know of. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: was on April of two thousand and one, which was two months after his second attempt with Adam Hip that didn't go anywhere. So once he realized Adam was with the bull wasn't with the bull, he wouldn't gonna go with the plan. He was like, Yeah, whatever, whatever, whatever. So apparently he had been talking about this with somebody and his friend Mom: Wow. Mm-hmm. Be moving on. Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: From the the school, her name was Jennifer Jaffat or Javet. I cannot rem excuse me if I said that wrong. She found out about it. I guess she heard w him talking about it. And she asked him, And like, Are you really gonna like are you okay with this? You're really gonna let this happen? And she said that his response to her was Mom: Uh-huh. Right. Okay, so let me just stop you right there. Because if I wasn't gonna call the cops because I heard you talking about it, when you came up and hugged me and whispered in my very oral canal, my hearing hole, you whisper that shit to me like every serial killer in every movie that I have ever seen. I'm calling the police because now I'm scared. Now I've said something to you. Zalle: I'm for show hugged me. I need to know why the hell you felt like you touching. And you know I know. And I know you with killing people. Mom: What? I'm going directly to the police officers. I will meet me in the alley at eleven thirty at night. Under the cover of darkness. Zalle: Yeah. She said he smiled. She right right. Right. Since Detective Slaugh is out here meeting people in the dark. Matter of fact, go and put me on the books. So I don't have to even come inside. You got a you got a portal where I can do this online? Mom: Just people in in the back of the police department. Right, just text me. Brian, you got an email or can we you got Discord something we can talk somewhere else? Zalle: Discord something. A O L. Like Mom: Not that you said AOL. Zalle: I'm I I'm old enough for AOL. Okay. Mom: That is the very beginnings of the internet. That is when the internet began being the internet. Yeah, that is when the internet just opened its doors. That's when the internet came on the C D. Yes. Zalle: The beginnings of the instant messaging. Yeah. And it was popping. Okay. Was slow as hell and it was doing its thing. Okay. That is crazy. But so obviously called the police. Told the police everything ⁓ she knew about the plan. ⁓ police then Mom: Yes. Okay, good job. Mm-hmm. Zalle: went and told Bart's parents about this plan for Bart to kill them. That somebody came and said planning it. This is an actual report. And they were like, yeah, no, this we don't believe this. Like it's no way. Like that's gotta be a joke. And when they when they asked Bart, his response wasn't that it wasn't true. Mom: Mm-hmm. Mm. Yeah. I I understand. Yeah. Zalle: His response was it was a misunderstanding. Mom: What? Who misunderstood what? What was it that they misunderstood? Zalle: That would have been my questions. But those are the answers that I did not get and no that's not what di he didn't say they ass shit. He they was just like, ⁓ all right. It's a misunderstanding y that you out here telling people you're trying to kill us. Mom: That wasn't their question. Let's Because I need to understand what you said that she misunderstood. Zalle: 'Cause that would be my questi. Well, let me know. the what the hell was you talking about? That somebody misunderstood that you got a plot for my life. Mom: What did you say? Right. A whole plan that you were talking to people about because it got back to us. So you trying to get people to kill us actively. Zalle: For un alive in me. Mom: Ooh. Zalle: Yeah. All of that came out during the trial. All of that was evidence. Mom: Wow. I mean, I've watched the documentary, but this is really a roller coaster. It's this is of the craziness and the dumbest shit is just rolling right on out of this story. Zalle: Well, thank goodness the jury was some partial a at least everybody had some kind of educational, some common sense. So the trial lasted seven days. Right. For a trial that's fast as hell. Mom: Mm-hmm. That is very fast for a murder trial. Zalle: It lasted seven days. The jury only deliberated for two hours. And obviously they found him guilty. Mom: Wow. Yes. Zalle: So I feel like the fact that all of this happened and the dad was like, When well, obviously we're sitting in trial or even before the case started, we're look I'm looking back on things and I'm like, How did I not see this? But he was like, I just it and it's my kid. It never dawned on me that my kid would really be and he said, I thought we were happy. I th I thought everybody was living a good life. Like I was completely blindsided. Mom: Yeah. Right. Yeah. I c ⁓ that poor man. That poor man. ⁓ my gosh. Zalle: I know ⁓ man. I know So after found guilty, they go through the punishment phase where they go to figure out what his punishment would be. So during the trial, while he everybody's talk Steven then came up and said this man came up two months before the murder, he did this. Mom: ⁓ Yeah. Zalle: Jennifer then came and said, yeah, he hugged me and said everything gonna be okay. Adam then came up and said, yeah, he gave me the exact same plan, but nothing ever happened. I just wanted to see how far he'd take it. All of this information has come out. He's been found guilty. He never cried during any of that. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: The punishment part starts. now he's trying to cry. No, he you could see he's trying, but maybe like a tear fell. Like it's no like, and then you see like a lip quivering, but it's no actual like sobbing or what it should be if you have real remorse ⁓ he's saying he's sorry and all of this. And the whole time his dad is fighting. Mom: Криза Петрива. Uh-huh. Right. Zalle: For the jury to spare his life and forgive him the way that he forgave him. And so Bart Mom: Wow. I I don't even know what to say. my God. That's just every time you talk about his dad, my heart just it just ⁓ my God. Zalle: Just breaks a little bit. It just shatters for him because you know he killed your wife and your son. But he's all you have left. And so I'm gonna fight for him. Mom: Right. But he's your son. Yes, but he's your son. my God. Zalle: I can't. But during the punishment phase, obviously Bart once again thinks that he's smarter than everybody else and he can talk his way out of it. So he takes the stand. First of all, all this shit already came out. I don't even know why you got your ass on a stand. Mom: Right, yeah. Why, why? Zalle: I don't know why got up there. he took the stand. And so he did take accountability and he said that 100% I did this. I made the plans. It's all me, whatever. And he's saying he's remorseful. I'm sorry. But he can't say why he did it. he kept saying it. It's nothing, I guess nothing that points to it. But if I had to pick a reason, then it would be that I felt like the love that my parents and my brother had for me were. conditional and that they had a standards for me that I just didn't feel like I could live up to. And he said, go ahead. Mom: So ⁓ I'm just gonna kill everybody. Yeah. And then nobody but what? Zalle: I would kill everybody. You don't love me, your standards are too high. Or you do love me, but it's only if I meet this. Instead of just not talking to these people. Mom: I mean you could decide you don't want to have a relationship with me, maybe, maybe move away for a little while, maybe go to another country. I don't know. Zalle: Yeah, no, no. And he's for word said on the stand. Mind you, his dad, who is fighting for him to stay alive, is sitting in the courtroom. And Bart Mom: Right. Zalle: said Mom: What? Zalle: And when the prosecutor Fred he said it's funny you're saying that. And yet it's your dad who is fighting us to keep you alive. Because we ⁓ just want we put if we put you to death. Yeah. Because I if this dedicated to killing your parents, what is your next obsession gonna be? Mom: Right. Mm-hmm. We're just killing. Yeah. Because it really seems like anybody who you're close to who expects anything out of you is just too much. So if one day you get married and then she expects you to I don't know, take the trash out. Zalle: She's dead to death, okay? And that's gonna be easy as hell. We ain't even gotta pay people for that. I sleep right on next to you every night. Every night I'ma go and get me a little baby needle and I'ma shoot you with something between your toes and they're never gonna find it. Mom: Right. And nobody gonna know. Zalle: But that is the craziest part. Like you literally sat there and said all of that. And then immediately followed up and was like, Yeah, my dad's become my best friend over this past year while he has been on trial. Hell yeah, he been your best friend because he the only motherfucker trying to keep you alive. What are you saying to me? He your best friend cause he's the only benefit in this situation. Cause you thought you were gonna get away for you thought you were free. You're out here telling people in in Mexico with Cindy Lou. Mom: It's it's a right. Right. He benefits you. He has to be a psychopath. He has to be a psychopath. Zalle: I don't love none of them motherfuckers. I ain't never loved nobody. My mom ain't loved me. I ain't love her. I was a only child. I'm a child a prostitute. I don't even know who my daddy is. He could have been any old joke. But now your daddy your best friend. Come on, Bart. Come on, Bart. Mom: Yeah. How this? He has to I mean, I'm not a I'm not a psychologist or anything, but this just all sounds like he is a psychopath. Zalle: Come on, Bart. He's crazy as hell. Okay? He's crazy as shit. the funny was that so he was sentenced to death after of this, after the dad fighting. ⁓ And it only took 10 hours for them to deliberate. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: this is when they did show the interview of the jurors and one of the men was a black man and he said what it did it for him was during the trial they showed the picture that the family took the night at dinner. And it's Three of them and they're all smiling. Mom: Mm-hmm. Zalle: like natural smile, everybody's cheesing happy, like genuinely happy. And he said what that's what did it for me because you can see how happy he is in this picture whole time. He's the only one that knows that everybody else in here is about to die. Mom: Yeah. Right. Right. That's what I was thinking. Like when when we were when we started and we're talking about them pulling up, driving home, going up to the door. He knew all every step of the way what was gonna happen. Because he planned it and he this he had tried already before. Zalle: Yes, all of the whole time you knew. The whole time. This was his plan. That's the crazy part. It's not like you hired people like you come up, you I'ma hire you and you just do the job. No, I got the plan. I'm a supp for for who was it? For I think it was Will Will Anthony. He even gave him the black pants, the black shirt, the ski mask to go to get into the window. For ⁓ Chris and Steven, he gave them the cell phones so that they Mom: Right. Right. Zalle: He was the main one doing it. Wasn't like he just hired people and stepped back. Right. He took an active role. Mom: Right. He came up with the whole plan exactly how he wanted it. Because he thinks that he's smarter than everybody else. So the only way for this to come out right is if he plans it and he has to have his fingers on every part of it and then still you're still fucking up. Zalle: After you did it. Mm-hmm. Yeah, and that's what one of the other jurors said was like if he can fixate and continuously try to kill his parents, what's gonna what's gonna be your next fixation? Because you would not it didn't matter. First of all, you had you had known that you had been reported to the police by Jennifer for kill for doing this stuff to because they told your parents and your parents told you, so you know. Okay. Mom: Right. Right. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. You knew that. Zalle: You didn't give a damn. You didn't care. You didn't care at the alarm. Mom: And you had the opportunity to stop then. Zalle: Yeah. You didn't care about any of that. Mom: To be like, Whoa, I almost got caught and just step away from it. No. Zalle: You didn't care after the first attempt with the alarm. That should have been like, ⁓ this is scary, maybe okay, I can't do that. No, you tried again. Mom: Nope. Uh-huh. Right. Zalle: once he was sentenced to death, Bart said that he would not abandon his He said Mom: Wow. Zalle: that I know ⁓ that when I die I'm gonna go to heaven and see my wife and Kevin there. And I want Bart to be up there with us too. Mom: Hmm. That's a parent. That's apparent. Zalle: And so I'm gonna forgive him. I'm gonna forgive him and work on trying to make sure that while he's here, my goal is that hopefully some point he'll be able to have like open visits where I can come in and at least hug my son again. That was his goal. That was his goal. Mom: I I don't even know what to say that because I could just feel it like I don't know. That's crazy. That's appearance love. Cause nobody else can love you like that. Like you tried to not only did you kill my wife and my son, you killed you tried to kill me and would have been happy if I had died and you got away with this. Zalle: ⁓ yeah. No. No. And got away. and I know this. And I know this. Mom: Mm-hmm. Right. ⁓ Zalle: But Bart got lucky though, because he was sentenced to death. But in two thousand and seventeen his sentence was commuted to life in prison without the possibility of parole. And I'm gonna say that that has something to do ⁓ with dad. Mom: Yeah, he got me. with his dad. Yeah, 'cause they said he had his last meal. His dad came and had his last visit with him. And it was like forty five minutes before they were supposed to kill him that they got the message that they were commuting it to life. So like it was the last minute yeah, he he had had his last meal and everything. So like he was about to go and and the governor signed the the Zalle: Shut up. Shut up. I did not see that. Wow, he was about to die. Baby. Mom: Whatever the thing is going. Thank you, the pardon. So he was very lucky, like now until the last hour. Zalle: The pardon and got commuted. Mm. I wonder, I wonder if that was and he got lucky because that was during the time when all of that shit was happening when the Texas prisons were overrun and they had and went to had to go release all them damn people w that we talked about in that last episode, where it was like 250 people getting released a week. A week. my God. He was one of the Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah, they were just letting people out. Mm-hmm. Zalle: The luck unlucky, lucky month, bro. Ain't that balsome? And he Mom: That's crazy. Zalle: So as far as the other people who agreed to this shit before it actually happened, like I said, I don't think that Mom: Mm-hmm. My dad chance. Zalle: Will Anthony or Justin Peters, they weren't charged with anything that I know of. That I know of. But Mom: Well Zalle: Chris Brashier, he pled guilty when he was arrested in 05, he pled guilty murder he got life. Mom: Mm-hmm. Hm good. Zalle: However, Steven Champagne, he also, that was the driver, but he also pled guilty to murder. But he only got 15 years. But that was in exchange for him testifying against Bart in his case. So that he had made that deal once he narked. Mom: Mm-hmm. That was the driver. Okay. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: 'cause Bart was gone at this time. So he made the deal that once they found him, he would testify and that's how he was able to l lessen his sentence. And he was released in two thousand and fifteen. Mom: Yeah. Yeah. Hmm. Wow. Zalle: Yeah. So he only did ten of the fifteen years. Mom: Wow. Zalle: And got out. that shit is insane. That's a crazy ass case. All the way around it's it's crazy. Mom: That story is crazy. Yes. Zalle: they about and described who was as far as his aspect in the family, they said was a good son. Like him and his dad had a good relationship. They they went bicycling often. they did trips together. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. So other than the fact that he had other people do the actual killing, he sounds a lot like ⁓ what they call like a family annihilator. Because those are normally people who, whatever reason, when they feel like their life is falling apart or like they are a failure, they but so there are a few things that are different, but they end up killing like Zalle: So I don't understand like where it was in his brain. Mom: their family off. Like they they don't they don't describe it as they don't want them to see them fail. They describe it as almost like they're doing their family a favor by killing them off. they normally kill them though. So like it's a little bit different because he had someone do it. ⁓ mean but the outcome and all the the lies about school and that kind of stuff ⁓ very much like what Zalle: Like ⁓ like they Uh-huh. Mom: is normally described as a family annihilator because they take out their their own family as in their minds some some grace to their family. So I don't know. Mm-hmm. Zalle: That shit is insane. That is crazy to me. That is crazy to me. my ⁓ flabbers were gasted watching this, I was sitting there what in the what? ⁓ What? And they were telling about dinner and how they pulled up and I was thinking the same thing. He was the only one. How ⁓ I can't imagine that being me knowing all that's about to happen. And at some point I don't be like, ⁓ my God, let's go here. Mom: Hmm. Zalle: Or let's go do this. Like, you know, I don't have a change of heart, something switched. He went all the way through that shit. All the way down to getting shot. Mom: Yeah. Yeah, let me call it off. Yeah. Mm-hmm. he was dedicated. I mean, ⁓ we went through all the times he tried it. So when it got down to it, I mean this was the this was his reality. This is what was going to happen. Zalle: This was clearly an obsession. This was an obsession. And I wholeheartedly agree with the prosecutor when he was like he's a evil motherfucker because ain't no way. Ain't no way you're dedicate this dedicated to killing your family for absolutely no reason. Mom: It was. Mm-hmm. Right. No reason. But you hate them so much. Then they're the only people you've ever hated. And I feel like he said that to help himself because that means that he's not a danger to anybody else. But again, it's so selfish because you don't care what you're what you're doing to your dad again. You're just gonna sit in his face. Zalle: And it completely backfired. Well, I can right. And I can see how you felt like that like he thought that that was gonna help him, but also I don't feel see how you feel like that's gonna help you because, sir, that makes it worse. These are the closest people to you ever in life. You have no reason, you have no actual reason to hate them, but these are the only people you've ever hated in life. Mom: Righty, these are your parents. Right. Makes no sense. What you're saying does not make sense, sir. Zalle: Does not it did not help. Mom: Whoa. Zalle: Well, I would love to hear what you guys think about this case. Because if your mind was completely blown and it was even more like shaking ⁓ that this in Mom: You're right. It's not this is like a affluent area of town. I mean, I'm not affluent. Don't take that that Zalle: Ye out of all places sugar land. Sugarland, like out of everywhere it could have happened, it's crazy. Cause lived far from Sugarland se at several during my life. Mom: Not far at all. Zalle: So all of that doesn't make s like it's and I hadn't heard of it before then. Mom: Right. It doesn't go together. Mm-mm. I hadn't I hadn't heard of this one either until I went researching these cases and I was like, wow, this one is like right there. But it doesn't fit with anything that you would normally see. But when you think about what why he probably killed them for the money, well, I mean, these are the people who have the money. Zalle: Right here. Yeah, that that I mean the area and motive definitely fits. Mom: Yeah. Zalle: But I would love to hear how y'all feel about it because it definitely it shook me. It was very shook it. So make your comments, make your review, send in the emails if you guys have any more stories like this ⁓ anywhere. Let us know so we can do a episode on them because clearly Jazz. Mom: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, these these 'cause some of these cases are the craziest ones, ones that aren't out there in the media everywhere, you know, and there it is it's some crazy stuff. Zalle: Yeah. Mom: These cases are wow. Well, if you guys enjoyed today's ⁓ like Zalle said, make sure let us know what you think. Follow us, subscribe, share our stories when we're posting on social media, engage with our polls. We really want to hear from you guys. but thank you for spending your time with us. Zalle: Yes, thank you. And until next time, you guys, stay safe and sip carefully. Mom: Bye guys. Zalle: Bye.