Latest / Insights Now / The outlook for real estate
Transcript
- 0:13Welcome back to Insights
- 0:14Now,
- 0:15I'm David Kelly,
- 0:16Chief Global Strategist here at J.P. Morgan Asset Management.
- 0:20While the broader economy has remained resilient this year,
- 0:23the real estate sector has spaced its fair share of headwinds.
- 0:27Higher mortgage rates and home prices have weighed on the residential sector.
- 0:30Tighter lending conditions following the regional banking crisis have created a challenging backdrop for commercial real estate.
- 0:36Additionally,
- 0:37it remains unclear whether pandemic induced disruptions are merely road bumps in the longer term landscape or the beginnings of a new regime within real estate.
- 0:45For today's episode,
- 0:46I'm joined by Dave Esrig portfolio manager in our real estate America's group who will share his thoughts on the trajectory of real estate and discuss what opportunities he finds.
- 0:55Interesting.
- 0:56Also,
- 0:56if you're listening to the audio version of this podcast,
- 0:58you can now watch along on Youtube by tuning into our JP Morgan Asset Management channel linked to the slow notes.
- 1:04Now,
- 1:04let's get started,
- 1:05Dave.
- 1:05Welcome to insights now.
- 1:06Thank you.
- 1:07So let's let's sort of start with a broad question.
- 1:10What is the state of commercial real estate right now?
- 1:13Right.
- 1:13So we're in an interesting time right now.
- 1:18So after extremely strong growth during 2021 and early 2022 we've seen pricing in the market come off rather sharply.
- 1:29So we're down about 15% and that's really due to the rise in interest rates,
- 1:34but also a deceleration we're seeing in operating performance on the property side.
- 1:40So for example,
- 1:41in multi family,
- 1:43we've seen rent growth go from about 15% down to about a 0%.
- 1:49So that's,
- 1:51that's something we've seen kind of across the board.
- 1:53Now,
- 1:53office has been very differentiated from the rest of the commercial property market.
- 1:59We've seen office week really since 2020 due to the work from home phenomenon.
- 2:04But we do see a call back into the office continuing.
- 2:09And as a consequence,
- 2:11we see going forward a bit of an increase in,
- 2:15in office activities.
- 2:17Uh but we don't think we're gonna get back uh to the 2019 level any time soon.
- 2:23And of course,
- 2:24that's opened up the question.
- 2:25A lot of people have asked about converting office space into residential real estate space.
- 2:29So what do you think about that?
- 2:31Right.
- 2:31So that's something people are talking about a lot and it's,
- 2:35it's actually gotten a little pushback from people in the industry who think it is very expensive.
- 2:42And so just to step back and talk about sort of the opportunity and the problem here,
- 2:47we have across the country,
- 2:49only 2.5% vacancy across all housing.
- 2:56So in the U so that's housing for rent and housing for sale.
- 3:01Uh And so if you can convert a fair amount of office into residential,
- 3:05you're really killing two birds with one stone.
- 3:07You're,
- 3:07you're obviously you're helping the housing issue.
- 3:09Uh And you're,
- 3:10you're Ameliorating the problem of,
- 3:13of uh too much office stock,
- 3:15especially in,
- 3:16in America's downtowns.
- 3:18Uh The challenge has been the,
- 3:19the expense of the conversions,
- 3:21but I,
- 3:22I would argue that a substantial sort of share of the cost of converting from,
- 3:29from office to residential is actually due to regulatory issues and not due to actual kind of physical changes.
- 3:37And,
- 3:37and an example of that is there is a legal requirement that the uh windows and residences be operable.
- 3:45Uh And that's really based on sort of old uh sensibilities around fresh air that really don't uh apply to that.
- 3:54You really don't need to open a window up on the 30th floor.
- 3:57I would be scared if I did.
- 3:59Yes,
- 3:59that's right.
- 4:00So,
- 4:00so that's,
- 4:01uh that's something that uh from a regulatory perspective is,
- 4:05is looking to change.
- 4:08Uh And we think that'll improve uh the office and,
- 4:11and are,
- 4:11is there a push to change those regulations then?
- 4:14Yes.
- 4:14So that's,
- 4:15that's under discussion,
- 4:16for example,
- 4:17in New York.
- 4:17Uh and,
- 4:18and that uh we're hearing in several other markets.
- 4:21So talking about very much the here and now we've seen a sudden recent surge in long term interest rates and mortgage rates.
- 4:28In fact,
- 4:28we've got now the highest 30 year fixed rate mortgage that we've seen in over 20 years.
- 4:33How's that affecting your perspective of real estate at this,
- 4:35at this point?
- 4:37Right.
- 4:37So,
- 4:38uh we actually uh see the rise in interest rates as creating AAA bit of a benefit in the market and as much as took the froth out uh of commercial property pricing that we were seeing uh in 2021 and as I mentioned,
- 4:52uh early,
- 4:53early 2022.
- 4:54So,
- 4:55so right now if you have dry powder to put to work,
- 4:58you're able to,
- 4:59to buy properties that have been reset to this lower,
- 5:02lower price.
- 5:03You can't lever uh in a in a cheap way.
- 5:05But,
- 5:06but we do like uh the idea of putting money to work with cheap properties as opposed to expensive properties and and cheap debt.
- 5:14So interestingly,
- 5:15uh single family homes have fallen generally in price by less than commercial properties.
- 5:21So commercial properties have been more affected by the rise in mortgage interest rates than,
- 5:26than uh single family homes from what we observe.
- 5:28Interesting,
- 5:29of course,
- 5:29there's supply issues and in fact,
- 5:31if you look at the whole uh residential side,
- 5:34uh you know,
- 5:35I've noticed some very different trends in terms of multi family and single family units.
- 5:39Can you talk a little bit to that?
- 5:40Sure.
- 5:41So,
- 5:42uh on the on the multi family side we saw this deceleration that I that I uh mentioned and if you look at the way residents are behaving in this environment,
- 5:54they're doubling up roommate situations and and sort of conserving money by,
- 6:00by renting fewer fewer spaces,
- 6:02the market is still tight.
- 6:04We think as the economy re accelerates later,
- 6:07rent growth will accelerate.
- 6:10But the apartment market,
- 6:11as I said has seen rent growth fall fall to zero.
- 6:14We've seen on the single family side,
- 6:17uh this uh terrific challenge with relatively sticky home prices and these incredibly high interest rates making single family home purchases extremely expensive.
- 6:29So it's forced families who are not typically doubling up as roommate situations,
- 6:33forced families to,
- 6:36to rent more,
- 6:37more single family home.
- 6:38So we've seen extraordinary growth in that.
- 6:40And in fact,
- 6:41rent growth in that space is running 8 to 10%.
- 6:45So that's a business.
- 6:46We've been in a lot of JP Morgan Investment management and uh one way or really the only way we've approached it is to build new stuff.
- 6:56So we're never bidding against single family against families who were looking to buy single family homes.
- 7:03We're always building new product.
- 7:05It's both easier to operate,
- 7:07but we're not competing against families looking to buy houses.
- 7:09And of course,
- 7:10I,
- 7:10you know,
- 7:10I,
- 7:10I appreciate that,
- 7:11that we're building new stuff and adding to the to the stock.
- 7:14But there is also a really interesting dynamic by which people really can't sell their home beca because,
- 7:20uh you know,
- 7:20mortgages are not assumable so they,
- 7:22they can't retake their,
- 7:24their mortgage to a new property.
- 7:25But I suppose you could rent out the home.
- 7:27And,
- 7:28uh,
- 7:28you know,
- 7:28I think you,
- 7:29I think everybody needs to be a little bit more flexible in finding housing solutions here.
- 7:33Um Looking forward and sort of thinking big picture.
- 7:37We've been talking a lot about artificial intelligence uh this year And it's sort of the buzzword I know in,
- 7:42in,
- 7:42in the stock market,
- 7:43but it,
- 7:44it really does have significant implications for all sectors of the economy.
- 7:48How do you see it affecting real estate?
- 7:51Well,
- 7:52so there,
- 7:53there's been a lot of news about how data centers are going to benefit from this in,
- 8:00in the real estate space and,
- 8:02and just to step back a little bit uh for several years,
- 8:05data centers actually were were seeing falling rents and that was really due to significant additions to supply and actually very rapid uh technological changes that made it much cheaper to uh to have high data throughput in these in these centers.
- 8:23About two years ago.
- 8:25Uh electric utilities uh started to say,
- 8:29wait a minute,
- 8:30we can't deliver as much electricity to these centers as we could before.
- 8:34And that really stopped a lot of the development we are seeing at that point.
- 8:39And so owners of existing data centers were enjoying very strong rent growth because there was almost no new supply.
- 8:48What we've seen recently is that the supply has picked up again,
- 8:51the electric utilities have have,
- 8:54have started to deliver the electricity and the enormous gain uh in sales that NVIDIA just reported,
- 9:03we see as evidence actually of supply really picking up quickly.
- 9:08Uh Those chips are all being used in new data centers.
- 9:11So ironically,
- 9:12it it feels like a very hot market.
- 9:14But actually,
- 9:15if you're an owner of existing data centers,
- 9:18you're seeing more supply,
- 9:19which is where all those NVIDIA chips are going.
- 9:21So whether or not all the new A I use fills and utilizes that those data centers uh is,
- 9:29you know,
- 9:30to be seen.
- 9:31But for now there's a a rapid increase in data center supply.
- 9:35It's,
- 9:35it's,
- 9:35I mean,
- 9:36it's the sort of area of real estate where,
- 9:39you know,
- 9:39a generation ago,
- 9:40people wouldn't even know what you were talking about to talk about,
- 9:42talk about this kind of real estate.
- 9:44What other opportunities are you seeing um in,
- 9:47you know,
- 9:47in some of the evolution of,
- 9:49of commercial real estate,
- 9:50right?
- 9:50So practically speaking,
- 9:52right now,
- 9:52we have a capital markets environment that is that is challenging uh for many existing property owners and folks who want to buy commercial properties.
- 10:01And so as a consequence,
- 10:03uh we are actually able to lend uh mezzanine debt uh very profitably.
- 10:10Uh So uh that business uh really involves uh taking the call it the 50 to 60% LTV slice uh for,
- 10:23for capital staff where the 0 to 50% slice is lent by say,
- 10:28a regional bank.
- 10:30If they can still lend or,
- 10:31or some other lender,
- 10:33those lenders don't want to take the risk of that last 50 to 60 slice.
- 10:37We're able to lend on properties that we would actually love to have as equity in our portfolios.
- 10:44So it's a kind of a win win for us if,
- 10:47if we do believe they'll pay off and that will earn us a good return.
- 10:50But if they don't pay off,
- 10:51we get to take the property and have it in our portfolio.
- 10:54So we believe in it,
- 10:55but we can't really take an equity stake.
- 10:57So we'd like to take a,
- 10:57a high yielding uh uh lending stake in this,
- 11:01right.
- 11:02We also we also like building single family rental.
- 11:05So as I mentioned that before and another space,
- 11:08uh we like our last mile uh retail,
- 11:12last uh last mile services oriented retail and we're seeing terrific growth in tenant demand in that space.
- 11:18And that's coming from Americans shifting their,
- 11:21their spending patterns and they're doing this kind of structurally and cyclically from buying a lot of goods to buying more services.
- 11:27So restaurants,
- 11:29uh we're actually seeing more medical services showing up in these various types of of sort of health club club kind of concept,
- 11:36big increases in veterinary bills uh for example,
- 11:40veterinary spending.
- 11:41So that's,
- 11:42that's been a big driver to absorption in these centers.
- 11:44We like those in relatively dense,
- 11:46prosperous communities just following changing consumer behavior or trying to predict changing consumer behavior.
- 11:52Um So you mentioned regional banks briefly there.
- 11:56Uh But I have it's kind of the elephant of the room here because we,
- 11:59you know,
- 11:59obviously you look at the balance sheets,
- 12:01regional banks have got a lot more exposure to commercial real estate than the biggest banks in this country.
- 12:08Um How do you feel about that right now after what we saw this winter?
- 12:11Sure.
- 12:12So uh so yeah,
- 12:14with their deposits leaving uh this,
- 12:17they,
- 12:17they uh they have a certain capital challenges.
- 12:20Uh and,
- 12:21and they have these large books of commercial real estate and they have been important lenders in this space.
- 12:25Uh Certainly not an expert in in banking,
- 12:28but one thing we are observing from where we sit is uh that they are extending loans uh backed by uh office buildings.
- 12:38So,
- 12:39so their inflows from mortgage payments are likely slowing broadly.
- 12:45So that does slow their lending.
- 12:47And I think it hurts their capital position from us in commercial real estate,
- 12:52you know,
- 12:52as we think about capital being supplied to the space,
- 12:58uh I would,
- 12:59I would characterize the environment,
- 13:00for example,
- 13:01as much different from what we saw in 2009 in the global financial crisis.
- 13:05And that that was kind of a systematic wide credit crunch.
- 13:08This is more narrowly defined to one type of credit supplier.
- 13:12We also have CM BS.
- 13:14We have uh we have insurance companies who are able to supply capital and they're actually able to step up and supply more capital to the real estate space as the market starts to improve.
- 13:27So,
- 13:27so the regional bank issue may linger but there'll be other capital sources for us in commercial real estate.
- 13:33So it's still,
- 13:34it's still a macro issue but not necessarily as much of an issue for commercial real estate.
- 13:39I think.
- 13:39So,
- 13:40thinking about portfolios,
- 13:41investors often allocate to real estate because it's an inflation hedge and provides income now yields on high quality fixed income are extremely high because of what the FED has been doing and inflation has been coming down.
- 13:53Although the FED doesn't seem to quite notice that as much as I do.
- 13:56Uh But in that kind of environment,
- 13:58do you think real estate still has a place in a portfolio?
- 14:01Yes,
- 14:01I think so.
- 14:01And if,
- 14:02if uh we may pat ourselves on the back.
- 14:04Uh Part of that,
- 14:05the inflation hedge bit uh during 2021 and early 2022 as inflation was accelerating.
- 14:12Commercial property prices were rising very sharply too as were rents.
- 14:15In fact,
- 14:16rents and multi family assets were a big driver to the to the inflation uh challenges.
- 14:22And so real estate did what it was supposed to do and that is act like an inflation hedge And so the question is now with our,
- 14:29with our yields where they are and the fed doing what it's doing is does,
- 14:33does real estate still have a place uh in this environment?
- 14:37And I,
- 14:37I do think it's important to still think of real estate as a total return uh investment.
- 14:43So uh we are seeing given the rep price in the market,
- 14:48uh total returns,
- 14:50total underwriting returns in commercial real estate at a fairly large spread to investment grade uh bonds.
- 14:59So,
- 14:59so we still like or we actually really like where it is today even on an un levered basis.
- 15:05And as time goes on and interest rates start to fall,
- 15:08we see an opportunity opportunistically to lever these properties even if we do them on an un levered basis today.
- 15:15Finally,
- 15:16for those who are thinking about adding real estate to a portfolio,
- 15:19I think,
- 15:20you know,
- 15:20you've made a good case for why it needs to be in there for particularly for larger investors.
- 15:25But what do you think about res versus more direct owned real estate?
- 15:29Right.
- 15:29So,
- 15:30you know,
- 15:30I think res get some guff from observers due to their volatility and that that can be driven a lot by the fact that a large share of reach shares are owned by so called yield chasers and investors who are if you will chasing narratives,
- 15:50for example,
- 15:51you know,
- 15:51retail is good today and it's,
- 15:54you know,
- 15:54bad tomorrow and,
- 15:55and back and forth.
- 15:57But the truth of the matter is uh res uh or the reheat industry has some of the best operators in the entire real real estate industry,
- 16:06publicly traded res uh for example,
- 16:09uh in the data center space or some of the best operators.
- 16:13Uh So if you're looking to sort of play that angle with A I right now,
- 16:18that's,
- 16:18that's something to consider.
- 16:19And I would say to uh in,
- 16:22in the tower space.
- 16:22So the absolute dominant players in uh the five G tower space are are in the publicly traded weed market.
- 16:29So we we do think,
- 16:30think it makes sense for most real estate investors to allocate to direct properties as well as publicly traded rates.
- 16:37This has been fascinating.
- 16:38Thank you very much for joining us on our next episode of this summer series.
- 16:41I'll be joined by Mike Folli,
- 16:42chief us economist at JP Morgan for a conversation on the US economy.
- 16:46Thank you all for listening.
- 16:47I'll speak with you soon.
- 16:48This content is intended for information only based on assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change.
- 16:54No warranty of accuracy is given this content does not contain sufficient information to support investment decisions.
- 17:00It is not to be construed as research,
- 17:02legal regulatory tax accounting or investment advice,
- 17:06investments involve risks.
- 17:08Investors should seek professional advice or make an independent evaluation before investing the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate including loss of capital past performance and yield are not indicative of current or future results forecasts and estimates may or may not come to pass.
- 17:24Jpmorgan Asset Management is the asset management business of JP Morgan Chase and Company and its affiliates worldwide.