Latest / Ego and Other Things / Who Pays For Evil?
Transcript
- William: Who Pays for Evil Evil's hidden costs from child abuse to coffee to the national debt by Liam Gray. One of the inexorable laws of our world, one may go so far as to call it a divine law, is that evil has consequences. In the unjust and fallen world in which we live, the consequences of evil is itself not something which falls on the shoulder of the one committing evil. This is part of what gives evil its evil character. That its destructive consequences strike at the innocent as much, if not more, than the perpetrator. Otherwise, evil would not truly strike us as so much evil, but merely the result of one's own actions, entirely contained to the one committing evil, and thus not of concern to anyone else. Sadly, however, evil is unjust, and its consequence spreads as far as it is allowed, almost always reverberating for generations in unseen and invisible ways. An obvious example of this would be something like child abuse, an obvious example which has only so recently become obvious. The old adage, hurt people, hurt people, is no more true than it is here. Child abuse sets up the expectations the child has about other people. about himself and about the world. These expectations create fear, narcissistic defensiveness, reactive anger, a numbness which cuts off empathy, and anxious withdrawal, among other symptoms. Even if the child now adult resolves to change, resolves to never repeat the abuse they themselves endured, unconscious projection and the cacophony of cognitive schema inherited from their early environment Will set them up to symbolically repeat their abuse on the people who risk getting close to them. Indeed, such a schema will drive the child now adult away from seeking help at all, mistrustful of authority as they intrinsically are and have the right to be based on all prior experienced, based even on the reality and history of human beings. It is the relatively healthy in this regard who seek aid. not those who are enduring an emergency of the mind. These ones receive help when they break and collapse, if at all. If the traumatized have children, it is inevitable that they will symbolically repeat the kinds of disasters they themselves experienced, despite any good intention. It is only if the parent is conscious of such a possibility, can recognize and apologize for it when it appears, that some progress of the next generation can take place. However, as psychohistorians such as Lloyd Damas and physicians such as Gabor Mate have shown us, the consequences of the abuse of our ancestors against children have had reverberating consequences for millennia. Who pays the cost? Not the abuser not the abusers themselves, rather each generation pays the cost in its own way. Studies like ACE can show us a bit of the costs we each pay over a lifetime, which is in itself enormous, but how could we possibly calculate the historical cost, which also affects us, as it is the context out of which our current moment exists? Despite its obvious evil, it is beyond our conception to quantify just how evil it is. A far more discussed but less obvious evil is an economic one. Let us look at the micro example before looking at the macro issue. Call this the evil of wasted money. It is a cruel evil which is absolutely rampant in modern Western society, especially in the United States. I don't escape from it myself and find it incredibly difficult to overcome. From my perspective as a follower of Christ, it is especially egregious. We know everything we have comes from God and is in fact his. This includes our money. Money is talked about again and again in the Word. We are called to steward it well. What does it mean to steward God's money well? It means to give what you have generously to those who are in need of it. This does not mean simply to give it away uncritically. without discernment to a person regardless of their intentions or its usefulness. We are to combine wisdom with generosity, though many have relied on wisdom to excuse generosity. As they walk by the unhoused man with the outstretched hand, they think to themselves, I would give him some money, but I don't know what I'll use it for. That would be unwise, because it might harm him in the long run. Yet the money they would have Given does not then get shovelled to a place where it could be more wisely distributed or used, it gets spent on a latte or a trinket instead. If it is not this selfishness which causes a fellow to wrench back his money, it is the fear of poverty which drives him. He must hold on to every penny he's got, or else he might end up in the same place as the unhoused man. Jesus and his disciples were unhoused men, friends to the poor, which does not mean just financially poor, but those of low status, who gave generously to all to the point of at times being without shelter. Or food. Christ Himself became poor so that we might become rich. He came down from the glory of heaven, where he quite literally rules as king in a kingdom infinitely richer in all ways than the richest nation ever was or will be, just in order to suffer and die so that you and I might live. Yet an ounce of this poverty in our own lifetime is something, despite our faith. which terrifies us so completely that we must hoard our wealth for the future in bank accounts, stocks, and bonds. For terror of all terrors, we may go hungry, or become unhoused without a warm bed to sleep on, or may not be able to afford proper health care. All the while, because of our fear and hoarding, hundreds of millions suffer this exact fate at this very moment. Yet We are not willing to become poor for their sake, as Christ did for us. Yes, I know the hypocrisy of this while typing on a laptop in my apartment. We are all sinners, including myself. We are all weak, we are all full of fear, we all find it immensely difficult. Yet, will this excuse do? Will the Lord say to us as he tallies up the hordes of wealth we have buried beneath the soil of our fears? Well done, good and faithful servant. No, he will not. We waste beyond compare, and harm everyone around us because of it. For again, the consequences of evil does not fall squarely on the perpetrator. you and I, through our squandering, benefit, if anything, for a season from such evil, while masses suffer because of our tightly clenched. fists. Indeed, the clench fist of ungenerosity is far more violent and destructive to our fellows than would be the simple clench fist of an out and out punch. To the micro example as way of illustration, coffee. Let us suppose, for the sake of argument, drinking two cups of coffee is in fact of greater benefit than not. There is some loose correlational data to suggest it increases overall productivity and decreases some health risk factors, such as Parkinson's and high blood pressure. Of course, such data comes from the examination of the coffee itself, not what we often put in it. And so the actual consumption of coffee comes out in the wash, except for, as was mentioned, boost to overall productivity. Regardless, let us say two cups of coffee compared to what is minimally spent on it is of actual cost benefit. cost for out-of-home coffee consumption varies, but comes out to the average of about $1,100 per year. If between the ages of 18 and 30 I had put this money into a basic savings account, it would total $13,600. If I continued to do this until I was 70, the total amount would be $62,600. For a high yield savings account, this would amount to $17,000 and $174,700 respectfully. Some of you might quibble that this really doesn't amount to much. Or that inflation would eat away at much of the value of this, the human mind is greedy for its sin. Yet I have known how many people in my life for whom $13,600 would be absolutely life-changing. There are people I've encountered in my street ministry who, if the funds were properly used, could turn their entire lives around for half as much, if not significantly improve their current situation, or else simply pay for desperately needed. medicine. The coffee we claim to need so much is entirely denied to millions every day. How much of a need then is it? remind yourself too that this is only one item of luxury which we cling to and justify ourselves of. Begin to tally all your little luxuries and needs and see what massive wealth you waste away. The thirteen thousand six hundred dollars is only the sin of one person. Let us say a million people could have done the same over the past 10 years, a paltry number of people. What would this amount to? The answer is $13,600,000,000,000. According to Feeding America, this would amount to $136 billion meals for those without access to food security. This is the hidden cost of one luxury item of a fraction of the world population who spends on it over the course of only 10 years. Walk yourself over this thought experiment. If today every person refused to spend their money on anything else except what they actually needed, and instead pooled that money together in order to use it to give generously to those who do not have what they need, what might that amount to? If we stretched this thought experiment out for a year, for ten, for a thousand, since the dawn of man, what could have all that wealth and abundance have done? That is a cost of this one evil. I hear the siren call of all those who say, Yes, but jobs depend on all that excess spending. If we did that, the economy would collapse. We will continue to reach for our excuses. Perhaps it will collapse. Our economy is built from our sin. If at once we stop sinning, the resources which propped up our sin will have to go somewhere else, somewhere better. And so what we now have will have to be retooled, causing mass destruction. Another hidden cost of sin. Yet, should economic disruptions Dissuade us? When the slave owners let go of their slaves, I can tell you there was much economic disruption. Some of it still lingers on in the South, which used to be much more prosperous when they could exploit the free labor. Many slavers even argued against abolition from this very excuse of economic disruption. What is economic disruption in the face of evil, however? It is nothing, far less than nothing, in fact. It is only that slavery stared many in the face. The evil of ungenerosity and selfish luxuries is easily hidden in a conspiracy of obliviousness that is at our most sympathetic moments only unfortunate. But of course, never solvable because we do not want to solve it. Jesus did not say the poor will always be with you because it was impossible for us to end poverty. But because he knew what our hearts were like. This example was only rolled out to show the hidden cost of everyday evil, and evil we do not call evil because we routinely blind ourselves to its real and destructive effects. It was also given to show the unjust effects of evil. Those who hoard wealth do not suffer by it. It is the ones who they do not give to who suffer. Such a hoarding is theft, for the money does not belong to us, but to God, who tells us. Give to everyone who asks you. When we refuse or excuse ourselves, we steal from God, who has entrusted us with what we have. Again, we worry over our wealth while so many have no wealth over which to worry. We steal daily, and yet it is the poor who suffer for it. Yet many, even Christians, have the audacity to morally judge them or feel pity for them, as if poverty were the fault of the poor. and not the result of the clenched fist, of which many churches are the prime example. Do not be tempted to look away from your own evil by an appeal to whataboutism. Many whine that the millionaires, the billionaires, the one percent, the state are far more destructive with their ungenerosity. Sure, and this speaks to them as much as to anyone else. You are ungenerous not because of your lack of funds or power, but because of your heart. one man's murder does not become justified by comparing it with genocide. one man's theft does not become justified by comparing it with the systemic theft of the state. Either way, the original intention of this post was something else, for it was supposed to be about the fruit of another evil tree starting to bear its poisonous fruit. The US debt. It has been an ongoing evil that economists across the spectrum have been ensuring us is entirely banal, if not beneficial. gesture which prior generations, now either dead or nearing death, have expertly bequeathed to their children, who must soon bear the costs, as Cain did the sin of his father Adam. The ones still left. alive now squeeze us like vampires, living off the youthful energies of our productivity what we pay and dramatically outsize proportions for their livelihood and health care. It is a contract which we never signed up for, but which was written for us by politicians long before we were born. So now one and all have become unwilling slaves to geriatrics who have swindled us out of our most productive years. Their same productive years were utilized to build up their wealth, hoard the housing market, put away a nice cushion for themselves, and yet still not put away enough because they could rely on the labor of generations not yet born to do it for them. They were given a license to be even more frivolous with their wealth than prior generations. Spend as they please, who cares? The young will pay for my social security, unable to gain security themselves. What is left to us Who are still laboring for their comfort and will be for decades. A forty trillion dollar debt has been left to us as our inheritance. A debt to pay in one way or another, which they will never have to, For they are all dying, but the debt is beginning to show signs of degenerating into economic catastrophe, of which it was always bound to do, no matter what excuses the prior generations gave themselves. The debt is not sustainable, and at no point was it. The economists used two fantasies to give us hope in a problem that could not be solved. The first was to claim that low interest rates made the debt over the long run manageable. Low interest rates meant Low payments. Combine this with the fiat inflation rate of 2%, and they could kick the can down the road almost indefinitely. Sure, the debt could pile and pile, but payments were manageable. So the size of the debt didn't matter as our GDP would grow at a fast enough rate to keep pace. Of course, this didn't happen. The debt to GDP ratio continued to climb even during the years and years of low interest rates, driven to keep anemic GDP growth alive. At the cost of inflation. For here's the exact trick. The state drains a nation of its resources and puts it into all kinds of areas and sectors which could not survive on their own under normal market conditions. It manipulates the markets for its own ends. And this routinely creates problems which blow up into corrections and recessions. The solution of the government is to borrow and print money. Instead of allowing deflation and demand drops to reallocate resources to where they are actually desired, they inject the economy with cash, causing the debt to build and inflation to climb. This helps powerful businesses stay afloat, but devalues everyone else's money and keeps the underlying economy inefficient in the same ways. which caused the crash in the first place. This inflation then becomes a problem, and the Fed increases interest rates to combat this. The artificial rise in interest rates both causes problems in the normal economy, money priced at a higher rate in the market demands causes missed allocations of resources to real demand due to the lack of investment, which will lead to further corrections and recessions later on. As well, however, the debt begins to increase At a higher rate as interest payments increase. The state must continue to borrow and to print money in order to keep a healthy rate of growth and employment so that people won't riot, and then combat their self-caused artificial inflation through higher interest rates. When the economy crashes, the debt grows by borrowing. When the economy is growing, the debt grows by interest rates. These cycle ever higher with one another, where the debt is what funds the growth, but only through Misallocation. This eventuality of exploding debts whose interest payments outstread the government's ability to pay was always an inevitability of how governments misallocate resources away from the real economy through violent theft and towards those programs they use to bribe voters. The pandemic, the retiring boomers, and the recent demands of AI companies for investments has only accelerated the underlying increase of interest rates over time. The state has wanted to kick the can down further, but the can is getting heavier and harder to budge. Interest rates were never going to stay low, and the debt was always going to explode as a result. The second fantasy they sold us, which is a favorite of the politicians, was that. Even if the debt would continue to grow, our economy could outgrow it. This is not a fantasy because it is not impossible for the real economy to outpace the debt, though this would mean an economic growth of about 6% sustained forever, entirely taxed, simply to balance the current budget deficit. Never mind create a surplus, which is unheard of for an advanced economy. In fact, AI may be able to pull off again what the internet did in the 90s, the last time we hit a surplus. The problem is not the theoretical possibility of outgrowing the debt. Though again, even this is highly unlikely, but the certainty that such a surplus would not be spent to reduce the debt. Any surplus generated like this would be used for new programs to bribe voters by whichever waves of sociopaths were deciding to run at the time. How do I know this would happen? Well, in the first place, this is how democracy works. The entire purpose of the state is to violently take from some in order to give to others. Not to manage the wealth of a nation wisely. Secondly, however, this is what the state has done every time it's been handed a surplus. It spends it. This is what the state did in the 90s. This is what the state did post-World War II. This is how you bribe voters. So that is what politicians who crave power do. So, there is no maintaining the debt indefinitely, and there is no growing our way out of the debt. There is only paying our way out. One way. or another. Who pays? Not those who implement the theft. These are all long dead. Certainly not those who have most benefited from the theft. They are both dead and dying soon. It is the young who will pay, and many who are not yet born, for the effects of this collapse will be enormous. How will they pay? The state has four options it will impose through violence. One, taxes. The state could tax However, even if the people really paid this tax, things would fall apart. The poor and middle classes do not have enough to give to cover the bill. They would simply riot if taxed at the level necessary because they would quickly be starving and unhoused. You could tax the rich, but they will not pay. If you tax them enough, they will flee, or else they will spend, or else they will shutter their businesses. Certainly the amount of wealth that would be necessary to tax in order to pay the debt is not. Would drain capital stores enough to send us into another crash, prompting government borrowing and extending the debt they plan to pay off. Practically speaking, this is the same result whether you tax the spenders, the capitalists, the poor, or the middle class. At any level, the amount of taxation required would cause a massive economic disruption, if not riots from the poor and bribery by the wealthy. Such a proposal wouldn't even make it to the president's desk. This would further destabilize the tax base which they draw on and ultimately increase the debt. Both outcomes would create uncertainty about the state's ability to pay, driving interest rates up even further. 2. Inflation. The state could print its way out of debt, but this would lead to a complete collapse of confidence in state debt. Creditors would be swindled out of the real value of their bonds and no longer lend money to the state. The state would have to pay dramatically higher interest rates to new borrowers in order to cover the risk, or else no one would buy state bonds anymore. Not only would the underlying real economy crash due to a massive inflation spike, but the state would either end up back in the same position through astronomical interest rates, or else there would be a complete credit dry-up. And the state would cease to function entirely. A complete collapse in all state funding programs would occur, driving a miscallocation further, ending in a deep depression and social chaos. Such events have historically ended in the rise of a military dictatorship or worse. The old will likely die in a situation like that, but the young will be forced to suffer. 3. Cut spending. The state could cut spending. The main reason this would fail is because it would be an extended amount of pain no politician could survive. To reach equilibrium, you would have to cut year over year GDP by 6%. To pay down the debt, you would have to cut this further and keep it there for over a decade. This would drive down tax receipts, which would force the state to make deeper cuts while maintaining what spending they have allocated towards interest payments. All of the benefits which generations have come to quite literally call entitlements would have to be severely cut back, if not eliminated entirely. Many have come to depend on such entitless and programs. The entire economy would be forced to retool towards these basic needs instead of living off the high of an endless credit card. Real economy investments would be severely curtailed as well. All of this would not only cause riots in the meantime, the masses would quickly vote out of office any politician which even hinted at it as a possibility, what would likely cause a crash, which the state would borrow to overcome, landing it right back where it started. This is what has been called austerity. Austerity only ever comes about when the old exploit the not yet born. The old enjoy the windfall, while the young endure austerity. four war. This is a favorite of the state and the old alike, for neither will be forced to fight in the slaughter necessary for this option. However, Is quite effective in dealing with the burdensome national debt. The state can borrow more, tax more, spend more, cut domestic spending more, and benefit from the exploitation of the nation it conquers. This is how the original debt from the two world wars were paid. The US came out as international conquerors, and there was no one to contest their dominance. We built our wealth then largely through building back up the rest of the world, exploiting both their leftover wealth, their intellectual resources, their natural resources, Their low wages, among much else besides. Beyond this, some percentage of the debt is always held by the nation's enemies. When it goes to war, this debt is immediately canceled by fiat, but is excused by investors as a result of the war. It is one of the only tools the state has to cancel debt and retain buyers. The patriotism and nationalism aroused in domestic investors, which are the majority in the US. Creates an incentive for these investors not to call up their debts or even buy more from the state in the hopes of eventual victory. All in all, it is a very effective tool for dealing with a nation's debt, at least in the immediate view. It only costs the deaths of many thousands of young innocents and the unjust, systematic domination of another country. It is the option which we are more likely headed towards because it does nothing. But benefit the old and the politicians at the expense of the young and the powerless. Historically at any rate, this is practically always the option, if for no other reason than that the prior three options, if seriously implemented, always lead to various civilizations. and revolutionary wars anyway. Yet the catastrophe that we are headed for, especially for those who had little to do with creating the problem, is something which has been the work of over 100 years or more, at least as far back as we can reasonably trace it. Though you could bring its origins back further to the currency debates of the 1890s, Which came from the exploitation and economic dependence built upon slavery, which came from, etc. Can we blame all these people who have been caught up in the thrust of history for supporting the erection of state violence? In such a way that it benefited them greatly, while it even more greatly cost those born generations after them. Yes, I think we can. They are historical thieves who have gotten away with it. So worried over their own security, they are willing to sacrifice us at the altar of mammon. So now we must bear the costs. Now we must bear the credit collapse, the war, and the economic destitution. This is the unjust nature of evil. The innocent always pay a cost, and the cost is far more than can be directly seen or known. The consequences spread out in infinite directions. what measurements we can get of its effects are disappointingly shallow, no matter how much we write about, or talk of, or study it. We cannot bring the full, tragic nature to bear on our minds. It is easy to push it out of one's mind, because the true costs are not borne by the individual. And the true costs can be forgotten. Thinkers like Viktor Frankel and Alexander Soltsonitschen argued in their works that the horrors of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union were not merely the product of the state, the military and the bureaucracy which enabled their malicious machinery. And their personal reflections they could not help but see each of the seemingly small moments of evil which allowed the carnage to continue. Cowardice, greed, The domination of fear, excuses upon excuses for non confrontation, the mantra that one needed to survive no matter the costs, compromise after compromise placed at the altar of death. Veritable Christians assured of a gift of eternal life, unable to risk the smallest amount of sacrifice for others. There were notable and heroic exceptions, as there always are, but that they are notable exceptions is the greatest. Crime, who had to pay the costs for all these small evils? We can never directly know. Some existentialists have gone so far as to say that the evil of the whole world can be placed squarely on the shoulders of each and every individual, that in this world there is no one who can be truly called innocent. for every choice is meaningful. So much so that the term meaningful cannot truly grasp it. It has a weighty consequence which reverberates out for all time. There are no inconsequential choices. There are no choices which do not affect the world for good or for evil. Each decision has an effect, each non action determines an outcome as much as any positive action. The older generations, the ones who have left us with Legacies of abuse, war, debt, and waste are not the only ones who have blood on their hands. The old are an easy target, they've been around longer, and so have naturally sinned greater than we have had the chance to do ourselves. We cannot truthfully seek justice against them. They will simply never pay the costs. Rather We will pay it for them. Evil is not just. Our lesson cannot be one of vengeance or even hatred and disdain. Rather, it is one of extreme caution. We burn at what they have left us with, what they have done to us through selfishness and thoughtlessness. But what of ourselves? What of the generation which comes up behind us? What evil will we commit against them through the same innate? destructiveness, what legacy of sin will we leave them with to pay for? If we hate what has been done to us, surely we must hate what we have done to them, or else we'll do. So the true and revealing question becomes what evil are you doing which others will have to pay for? What sin of ours will bear fruit generations from now? And what Will we do to stop it?