Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Can I Hear Cremated People in My Spirit Box? (and more listener calls)
Transcript
- 0:04The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an idea.
- 0:10The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:19it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:23book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth, beauty,
- 0:32and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything,
- 0:39and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Said Andrews.
- 0:56It has been a busy month of July, going to be a busy August.
- 1:00In September, I am speaking on July the twenty third. That's a
- 1:04Sunday morning at Kansas City Oasis and Kansas City, Missouri, totally free for
- 1:10everybody to come out. I have the honor of being the keynote at the
- 1:14thirtieth anniversary celebration of the Robert Green Ingersoll Museum in Dresden, New York.
- 1:19That's August twelfth. Baja Con twenty twenty three, Sarnia, Ontario, the
- 1:25weekend of August twenty fifth, and then I'm back to Wichita, Kansas.
- 1:30I'll be speaking there on the seventeenth of September. All the details and links
- 1:34and everything at Seth Andrews dot com slash events. And speaking of busy,
- 1:46I have been busy recording the audiobook of doctor Abbey Hayfer's The Not So Intelligent
- 1:53Designer. As you recall was I think a month or two ago. I
- 1:57had doctor Hayfer back on and we were talking about what I would do differently
- 2:01if I was the Intelligent Designer. And I'm thinking about doing a whole speech
- 2:07on this, like writing a visual presentation and taking it on the road,
- 2:12because I've got some ideas. I've got some great ideas. But the book
- 2:15released like twenty fifteen. It's been out for a while, but there was
- 2:21no audio version, and so I reached out to doctor Hayfer and I said,
- 2:25he, would you be interested in having a narrator. I know I'm
- 2:30a dude, and I know you're a great science communicator, but I think
- 2:32it'd be fun to be a part of it. And she said absolutely,
- 2:38And if you're looking for some new audiobook to listen to, expect that to
- 2:42release some time in the month of August. My wife peeked her head in
- 2:47my office recently. I'm just babbling here, and she's said, you need
- 2:53to straighten this place up, And she didn't mean like messy. I think
- 2:58she laments the fact that I have so many of these little chotchkes, just
- 3:04stuff, just weird stuff that I've accumulated over the years that on display,
- 3:08especially on this one shelf that I have in my office, where she's thinking
- 3:13decor, Let's get a beautiful vase, you know, let's put a portrait
- 3:17here, and let's have some kind of an accent that hits the color off
- 3:22of the couch in the background, and let's make it look like an office.
- 3:25And I'm thinking, I want stuff like this, my Darwin bobblehead,
- 3:32which I have had for I want to say, like ten years. Somebody
- 3:36custom made this a long time ago. I believe they were overseas and just
- 3:42hand carved the Darwin bobblehead. And I was like, well, yeah,
- 3:46that's the shit I want in my cabinet. I've got all kinds of stuff
- 3:51like that. I used to accumulate it whenever I was in radio. We'd
- 3:53have a studio, right and we'd always just have stuff, just crap everywhere,
- 3:59but every piece of ramp had a story and it was all kind of
- 4:01fun. Like this. I have a mug that is a skull or is
- 4:08a carving or ceramic skull. It's a skull, some kind of skull,
- 4:12and it's encased in metal. And then there's two big ram horns coming down
- 4:15on each side, and the ram horns are the handles. I think r
- 4:21and Raw actually has one of these and drinks from it like the cellie,
- 4:27Like he puts his dark beer in and then he seasons it with that hot
- 4:30sauce. Insanity. What's hot sauce and freaking beer? I don't know what's
- 4:34wrong with the man, but he drinks out of this right, It's almost
- 4:38like he's drinking from the skull of a vanquished enemy. This is cool.
- 4:42I don't know where it came from. Is this worth something somewhere? And
- 4:46is it related? Is there a game or something where people drink out of
- 4:49the skull? Cllie? What else do I have? I just assembled some
- 4:54stuff. I have a candle of the Nazi from Raiders of the Lost Arc.
- 5:00Now, the reason I have a Nazi candle is, if you remember
- 5:03the finale, he opens the ark of the Covenant and the power of God
- 5:09melts his face off. This candle will melt his face off. I actually
- 5:15bought two so I could light one. God. This is forever ago that
- 5:19I bought this, that you could light one and watch the Nazi melt.
- 5:26Now, it took forever and he didn't actually melt his face didn't melt off.
- 5:30He kind of melts down the back, which is a design flaw.
- 5:33But he's got his mouth open in the screaming position. And so I did
- 5:38a time lapse. I don't even know where I put that video. It's
- 5:42an archive somewhere, probably lost forever. But the melt a Nazi candle,
- 5:47I mean, that is something that you have to have if you're someone like
- 5:51me, right, you got to have that and you display it and when
- 5:55people walk in, they're like, wow, that's amazing. Where did you
- 5:58get it? Right? Which is what interesting decor ought to be something else?
- 6:03When I saw the ad on Facebook from a Concord aerospace, just a
- 6:10gag, just something funny, but I couldn't resist it is a Jewish space
- 6:15laser trigger. If you remember Marjorie Taylor Green whack Adoodle conspiracy theorist believes that
- 6:25a conglomerate of secret Jews have been flying satellites over in California using lasers to
- 6:31ignite wildfires so that we will become more app to promote climate change legislation.
- 6:39It's all a vast conspiracy. So somebody at Concord thought, well, let's
- 6:45just make it official. So there are two buttons. The one on the
- 6:48left says ARC reactor on. It's an actual switch. On the right side
- 6:56with the Jewish star on it is a fire button. And this looks on
- 7:04the back it looks like it has actual metal leads. This is a metal
- 7:09piece, right. It looks like you could hook this up to something like
- 7:14you could turn on your office lights with the Jewish space laser trigger. Well,
- 7:20when you see something like that, you have to have one. You
- 7:25must own this. So now I have a Jewish space laser trigger and I
- 7:30have it on display in my office. Couple more, just while I'm waiting
- 7:35for the for the switchboard to populate, I have this. I have a
- 7:41bronze statue of Jean Luke piccard face palming. I don't know why I had
- 7:47to have this. It's Jean Luke face palming and it's like a big paper
- 7:54weight. You need to set it on stuff. You have to have that
- 7:57kind of thing if you're going to decorate an office. I have here.
- 8:01I don't know why I had to have this, because the last two films
- 8:05sucked a Michael Myers mask, and this is the latest incarnation of Michael Myers.
- 8:11The twenty eighteen film was actually not bad when they picked the story up
- 8:16forty years later and they did away with all of that sister plot nonsense.
- 8:22And so at that time I picked up the mask and have it on display
- 8:28in my office. I actually put this on the grand kid the other day
- 8:31and it was awesome. A little bitty munchkin man with a full size adult
- 8:35Michael Myers mask on you got it? You know, just awesome. And
- 8:39I put under the cab. I posted online. I said, this is
- 8:43why I'm never asked to babysit. Right. That's why, by the way,
- 8:48do not see Halloween Kills or Halloween Ends, because they are walk out
- 8:52of the theater. Bad betrayal of the franchise us who wrote those two movies.
- 9:01So I've got the hell Raiser Cube. I'm trying to remember which configuration
- 9:07is Lament configuration. It does come apart. I always look for the mechanism,
- 9:11trying to figure it. Yeah, there it is, so it does
- 9:16come apart. Natalie doesn't know that this opens a portal to hell. I
- 9:20haven't really had that conversation with her, you know, But yes, you
- 9:24can open a portal to hell. I have a copy of the Necronomicon from
- 9:31the Evil Dead movies. If you don't know what this is, just google
- 9:35Evil Dead Necronomicon. It's a book supposedly bound in human flesh and inked and
- 9:41human blood, and if you read the incantations, you unleash the demons.
- 9:46I see a pattern here. Apparently I'm going to want to unleash the evil.
- 9:52All my stuff unlocks the doors to evil. It's a pattern. I
- 9:56don't know. Oh, switching to the forces of light. I've got a
- 10:03candle. This looks very sacred looking. I mean it looks very serious,
- 10:07and there's Jesus on it, the sort of oil painting looking thing of Jesus
- 10:11on the side of the candle. But the head is not Jesus. It's
- 10:16Big Lebowski. It's Jeff Bridges as the Big Lebowski with a big halo.
- 10:20And I always thought that his character was kind of a Jesus figure in the
- 10:24movie. You know, the dude abide this sort of zen, I don't
- 10:28a way of living. You know, He's come to save us all by
- 10:33doing as little as possible, you know. And there's a whole religion.
- 10:39There's an actual religion that popped up around that movie, The Big Lebowski,
- 10:43the Church to the Latter Day Dude, and I am an ordained dudist priest.
- 10:46I mean, it's an actual religion, Like you can marry people,
- 10:50you can be an officiant at a wedding as a dudist, and so you
- 10:54know, if you want to become an ordained minister, just go to the
- 10:58church at the Latter Day Dude. But I like the sacrilege of it.
- 11:01There's a little bit of a heresy when someone walks in and they say any
- 11:05any depiction of Christ. But somebody's mucked with it and done something. You
- 11:11know, I'm gonna run. That's supposed to be Jesus. Why would you
- 11:13des a great Jesus? And I enjoy that just a little bit, just
- 11:18in case a devout believer walks in the office. It just makes me happy.
- 11:22Plus I love the movie. Okay, I have babbled long enough.
- 11:26Let's find out what you want to talk about. Raphael at nine seven eight
- 11:31Are you there? Yes, how's it going? I'm well, sir.
- 11:35What's on your mind? Well, I'm an immigrant to the US, and
- 11:39when we moved here, my family joined a church that was from the same
- 11:43community abroad, and recently I've noticed that there's a lot of coal like mechanisms
- 11:50keeping them involved in the church, like when you leave, you're shunned by
- 11:54the community. And I've tried to broach these topics with the mom, but
- 11:58she's very defensive because she's a believer in airing on the fundamentalist side. I'm
- 12:01wondering if it's worth to continue those conversations or just to accept that there's not
- 12:07gonna be any kind of changes there. I don't like the idea of giving
- 12:11up on anyone. We do know the psychology behind the programming shows us that
- 12:18saying you're an occult never works. Now, you can't fix them. All
- 12:22you can do is perhaps show them that, hey, you've got concerns,
- 12:26you see real problems, and you would love to have that discussion and good
- 12:30faith someday. We do have a lot of conversations about certain topics, you
- 12:35know, slavery or whatever, some of these issues that they don't like to
- 12:37talk about. But she doesn't want to talk about it, and I do
- 12:41push a lot to extend these conversations. Is that should I let those conversations
- 12:45kind of go and just take the long approach to the journey or should I
- 12:48keep kind of pushing. I've done a lot of this. I'm not an
- 12:50expert in human psychology, but I can pretty much guarantee you that if they
- 12:56have an emotional connection to their belief, if it is an identity belief,
- 13:01if you go in and you begin to try to push that around, they
- 13:05are not going to respond in the way that you want them to. Reveal
- 13:11that you have some concerns. I wouldn't say, you know, this is
- 13:15bogus, you're an occult, this is stupid, it's offensive, even though
- 13:18all of that may be true, that's language that's going to put them back
- 13:22on their heels. You're not going to change their minds with that. But
- 13:26I think if you walk in and say, you know, I've been looking
- 13:28around at this and I've got some concerns and I just want to kind of
- 13:33tell you where I'm at in the hopes that perhaps you could help me reconcile
- 13:37those things. It places the burden of proof on them. They don't feel
- 13:41as attacked, and maybe you can have a conversation. But dude, changing
- 13:46them is not your problem. You want them to be free of the addiction,
- 13:50you want them to be sober, you want them to get their lives
- 13:54together. But that decision, ultimately, that's a journey they are going to
- 13:56have to take. Okay, perfect much, All right, good loud bron
- 14:01See it's hard, I think when people we care about are involvedn't it.
- 14:07But I remember being a devout Christian. If somebody come up to me and
- 14:09been like, well, this is wrong, this is wrong, this is
- 14:11wrong, and you're kind of an occult, my first thought would have been,
- 14:16well, you're just an agent of the devil, right, You've come
- 14:20to try to weaken my faith and instill doubt. And the fact that I'm
- 14:24I'm being attacked by the devil proves that there is a devil, and the
- 14:30Lord has defeated the devil, and I rebuke you in the name of Jesus.
- 14:33And then I would have just checked out and probably physically walked away.
- 14:37You know what, I'm going to pray for you. Yeah, I mean
- 14:41that tactic, the confrontational tactic in the one on ones. I mean,
- 14:45come on, if you to come after me. In my brain, it
- 14:48would have validated that verse where it talks about blessed are those who are persecuted.
- 14:52For Jesus's sake, I'm persecuted. They're coming after me, Thank you
- 14:56Jesus. I probably would have thought that, you know, six one zero,
- 15:03Nick, thanks for calling. What's on your mind? Well, I
- 15:07have been a part of this show for a very very long time. This
- 15:11has really helped me in a lot of ways. I suffer from our suffer.
- 15:16I've been suffering from PTSD and as we, religious trauma all my life,
- 15:22and like lately, the past couple of months or so, I've just
- 15:28begun to hone in on exactly what it is, you know, And I
- 15:31knew I was messed up because of religion. I mean I started school in
- 15:37that nineteen forty eight and said that puts me into a parochial school. And
- 15:45that was a disaster right off the bat. You know, we had brutal
- 15:48child abuse was rampant. I mean we had a nun that had to beat
- 15:52two or three kids, a day just to feel good. Let me give
- 15:56you an example here. This woman would take us. I was five and
- 16:00a half years old when I started school, and she would take a child,
- 16:06hold his hands over his head with their big mit and he would barely
- 16:11be touching the ground. She was a strong woman. And then she would
- 16:15smack him back and forth in the face with the other hand, crying and
- 16:21screaming, and drop them down on the ground again. And that was it.
- 16:23And that's what we witnessed day after day. And there were other nuns
- 16:27that had reputations for doing the same thing, so you know, we called
- 16:33her to the hanging Nun. These experiences produced in you a sense of real
- 16:37trauma that you carried with you for a long period of time. You mentioned
- 16:41PTSD religious trauma exactly. And these are new terms. I'm just learning,
- 16:47believe or not because your reality contacts at that particular time. I mean,
- 16:52in life, you're developing years are really messed up. I mean, you
- 16:56just don't have any and you seem to be going down the river and floating
- 17:00down the stream of life with everybody else, but you're not quite there.
- 17:06I've been talking about it lately a little bit more to other things. But
- 17:10here's the point. I've been listening to your show and a few shows after
- 17:15other times other people rather and it's been years since I've been listening to you,
- 17:21But it takes so long for what I've been listened to penetry to get
- 17:26in to do its work. And it's a good thing you're doing. That's
- 17:30what I want to express. It's helpful. I bet there's a lot of
- 17:34guys out there, maybe not to the extremes that I've experienced, but at
- 17:40the same time, the opportunity to express it, the opportunity to hear things,
- 17:45because You've had a lot of good guests on your show that has verbalized
- 17:51what I couldn't, but I could hear it. You know what I'm saying,
- 17:53Yeah, I got you. I mean, this is my tactic,
- 17:56Nick. I bring in people much smarter and more effect given me and I
- 18:00let them talk and then I take credit for the show. I mean,
- 18:03that's just what I do, Nick, But I know I appreciate that the
- 18:07kind words I myself want to recommend. I don't know if you follow janus
- 18:11Selby at Divorcing Religion, but she does a lot on religious trauma syndrome recovering
- 18:18from religion. Dot org does a lot about religious trauma, and you know,
- 18:23leaving the abuse the high control religions, and you are not alone in
- 18:29this, and you know those people, and there are a lot of people,
- 18:33I think, who are just now becoming introduced to that concept religious trauma.
- 18:37Some people have scoffed at it. What do you mean trauma? How
- 18:40could religion harm you? And I think this is such a monumentally dismissive,
- 18:44in naive thing, because religion, high control religions can scar people for the
- 18:48rest of their lives. You'd agree with that, right, Nick, Well,
- 18:52I'm eighty years old, Yes, I will agree with that. I
- 18:56was born in nineteen forty two. How long ago did you start to I
- 19:02don't know, go through this sea change, because you know, there are
- 19:03a lot of people that are thinking eighty well, the die is cast,
- 19:07setting their ways, they'll never change. But do you sound like a reputation
- 19:11to the current now? No? I look, well, I had an
- 19:18addiction. Now I'm a little bit of an anomaly here. In nineteen sixty
- 19:23four, I was in I joined a program and everybody knows what it is.
- 19:30I joined a program and to stay sober and I have been sober ever
- 19:37since, so we're talking fifty eight years. At the same time, what's
- 19:44been going on with me is that a driving force whatever you want to call
- 19:48it, some little thing, some little spark, just has never never gone
- 19:53out. I've never let go of it, and it has never let go
- 19:56with me. The one thing I can say is I stay sober every single
- 20:02day, and that was my saving grace, so to speak. And at
- 20:04the same time, these men they accepted me as I was, as I
- 20:08am. That was a very big thing in my life. And I'm still
- 20:15driving. I'm not going to stop. I don't want to lay down.
- 20:18I don't want to give up. I've been through the ringer and I don't
- 20:22know what you know. I've been looking for things that will help me to
- 20:29release me, so to speak. Well, let me ask you a question,
- 20:33Nick. Let me jump in and ask you a question. As you
- 20:37found liberation from alcoholism, you found, like you know, the bonds were
- 20:41off, You're no longer a slave to that. Did you come to feel
- 20:45that way about your former religion? You know, you were controlled, maybe
- 20:49even addicted, and yet you sort of I don't know you you went through
- 20:55whatever program you needed even if it was just watching and listening to online activist
- 21:00reading doing your own thinking. Do you feel like that was the same kind
- 21:03of liberation from an addiction of religion in the sense I have? But the
- 21:08effect of the negative experiences put me in a mindset where I was grounded in
- 21:15fear. And that type of thing that I'm beginning to see is so over
- 21:21It just stops you at every point. So the only thing I've found that
- 21:26is beginning to help is, yes, those programs that you've mentioned, I'm
- 21:30just beginning to pick some of them up, by the way, okay,
- 21:33and thank you very much for your suggestions. But the other thing is somehow
- 21:37I feel as though I have to put myself to the test. In other
- 21:41words, those things want to stop me from doing everything in my life.
- 21:48Anything I've wanted to learn, college, writing, music, the whole nine
- 21:52yards have always pushed me back. And things like this and the pain and
- 21:56the fear and what they bring on is like, who the hell do you
- 22:00think you are? You stupid asshole? Catch it in a nutshell, And
- 22:06I'm still fighting that. So what I had, I mean, I journal,
- 22:11I'm back into my music, and I'm meeting up with my demons.
- 22:15You know what I hear, Nick, I hear You're free, or you
- 22:19are becoming more and more free every day, and now you are engaging with
- 22:25the things that resonate and give you joy, and you're doing it on your
- 22:30own terms. And you have made a commitment that you will no longer be
- 22:34controlled, and at the age of eighty, I take great inspiration from that.
- 22:41I think it's absolutely amazing. I'm seeing a ton of love for you
- 22:45in the chat as the commenters are jumping in. So just know that even
- 22:49as you're on your journey, I think you've encouraged others in there. I
- 22:55hope so. You are much appreciated and thanks for sharing your story. And
- 23:00as the journey continues, just keep kicking, okay. Thank you very much,
- 23:03chat and I will keep listening. Thank you so much. The Heathen
- 23:10ree and Shenanigans continue after this short break. Hang on my patron to get
- 23:22the broadcast early and commercial free, and I so appreciate your support at patreon
- 23:27dot com. Slash Seth Andrews Karen at four zero four, thanks for waiting
- 23:37on me, aren't you there? Good afternoon, Seth. How are you?
- 23:41I'm well? Thanks for calling what do you want to talk about?
- 23:44Well, I I myself am an atheist, although I was baptized in my
- 23:49youth, and that's what I to my family, who is launchly Christian and
- 23:55worried about me. I tell him, well, I was baptized. But
- 23:57recently they've come up something that I'm not sure where they're coming from. Are
- 24:03all Christians dislay or just them? They don't want me to cremated. Me
- 24:08and my husband and both decided that's the way to go. We don't want
- 24:11to take up part of the earth for useless reasons. But they think that
- 24:17is against the body, against Christ. We can't be raptured or something.
- 24:22And my point is, didn't you supposedly make adomat of clay and dust and
- 24:26even from a rib? And what about people who are exploded in Vietnam are
- 24:32in war somewhere. Can they not be raptured? What does she take on
- 24:37this position? Oh, I just love the fact that you called, because
- 24:41I wrote a whole chapter about this in my book. Christianity made me talk
- 24:47like an idiot. Just a few points. My mother was upset when my
- 24:52grandmother passed away because they had not pointed her casket at the open casket.
- 24:57They had not pointed it where she was facing to the east. And the
- 25:02reason is because they draw this verse out of the Bible, where as Christ
- 25:07comes from the east. And so if you go through Christian cemeteries you will
- 25:11actually see there is a tradition that people who are Christians are buried facing east.
- 25:15And it's this weird thing that people lose their minds over. But in
- 25:18that chapter, I'm like, well, okay, hang on east relative to
- 25:22where like that? You know, is Christ going to return east of Tulsa
- 25:26or west or whatever of Tulsa, Oklahoma? I mean, wouldn't you go
- 25:30back to Jerusalem? And yeah? What about people who have already died and
- 25:33their particles the atoms have been incorporated into other things. How will they be
- 25:38reconstituted? What about people who died in thermonuclear war? What about people who
- 25:44you know, have all the if they lost a limb, the limbs crawl
- 25:47over to the body and then reattach and they go up to meet Jesus.
- 25:51Logistically, the idea of Christ's second coming and the resurrection of the saints,
- 25:56it's just fascinating because it creates so many legitis to go problems and you have
- 26:02raised awareness again of how it's all just crazy. Well, thank you very
- 26:07much. I just wish I knew how to reassure them that it will be
- 26:11okay. You know, is it the Mormon Church that doesn't want you cremated
- 26:18because they want to baptize you in the afterlife? There's a ceremonial baptism of
- 26:23the dead. And I think it's for that reason that the Mormon Church discourages
- 26:29cremation, because apparently they think it's you know, it would be in theory
- 26:33more difficult to baptize your ashes. If you are an ex Mormon, please
- 26:37contact me and correct whatever misconceptions I've got. But it isn't it interesting the
- 26:42stuff that people getting a twist over. Right, Jesus comes back and you're
- 26:47cremated at how is he going to resurrect you? And I'm like, well,
- 26:49wait a minute. You know this opens Pandora's box. You've drawn some
- 26:55attention to it. Thanks Karen for Colin. You're very welcome. Thank you
- 26:59for your work. Take care of yourself. Okay, as Karen was talking
- 27:03here, I took the liberty of typing into a Google search. How does
- 27:08Jesus resurrect cremated. I just put those words in and lo and behold right
- 27:15here at the top of my search Billy Graham's website, the late Billy Graham,
- 27:19the Evangelist, the website the ministry continues, and they have a whole
- 27:23article here titled when a Christian dies, is it all right to cremate the
- 27:29body? And I'm just reading this cold here. The first part says the
- 27:34Bible does not give specific directions for the disposal of the body following death.
- 27:41Looks like they are listing various practices for internment or the Hebrews. The Hebrews
- 27:48did not normally cremate. Later, Babylonians burned they're dead and deposited their ashes
- 27:56in funerary urns. Third paragraphs, will want to show respect for the body,
- 28:03even though the essential person or spirit has moved on to an eternal destiny.
- 28:07The body is the tangible reminder of all that person meant to us.
- 28:12In addition, the body is destined for resurrection, transformation, and reunion with
- 28:18the spirit at Christ's return. Okay, now we're cooking quote. At the
- 28:25resurrection, it will not make any difference whether a person's body has been buried
- 28:30or cremated. God knows how to raise the body, and that's it.
- 28:37It goes on. There's a couple sentences about how our next body is going
- 28:41to be awesome, will be eternal, spiritual, etc. But beyond God
- 28:48will do it because he knows how to do it. I don't see any
- 28:52explanation, Like they don't get into any of it. How disappointing, But
- 28:56I think it's a reflection on this sort of blinking away any logistical challenges because
- 29:02hashtag God will do it. What's our next body going to look? Like?
- 29:06Let's say I'm a believer. Do I glow like? Do I have
- 29:08a golden light about me? Can I fly? I want to fly?
- 29:14Like? Do I get to do that in heaven? Well I have skin?
- 29:17Will I feel sensation on that skin? Will I have the ability to
- 29:21do whatever I want? Like I've always wanted to learn to play Spanish guitar?
- 29:26Will I have that ability in heaven? I've dreamed of being able to
- 29:29draw and paint. I can't do either of those things in heaven? Will
- 29:33I have that ability? What about sex? Will there be sexual activity in
- 29:40heaven? Right? Godly sex? It'll a godly sex. Probably the missionary
- 29:44position whatever, But will there be sex in heaven? I have questions.
- 29:48I mean, I guess in that case, I can see the need to
- 29:51reconstitute a physical body, because you know, how does a ghost have sex,
- 29:56unless, of course, you are the Holy Spirit impres nating the Virgin
- 30:00Mary in the New Testament. I guess that is ghost sex. I don't
- 30:06know, so many questions. This whole reason thing is such a pain in
- 30:11the ass. I've got nine to three six? Hi? Who's this?
- 30:18Hi? This is a bear bear? Thanks for calling. What do you
- 30:19want to talk about? I just wanted to take a moment to commiserate with
- 30:25you about our very religious mothers. Now, go ahead, go ahead,
- 30:29let's tell me your travels. Well, most recently, I'll work backwards chronologically.
- 30:34My mother has moved back to the state that I currently live in,
- 30:38and then she messaged a group chat of me and my sisters asking if we
- 30:44wanted to go to a church service with her because she's looking for a new
- 30:48church home in the state that I live in. But she knows I'm an
- 30:52atheist and my two sisters they haven't really been going to church either, so
- 30:59I'm not really sure what she's trying to get at she wants you to attend,
- 31:04yes, and you don't want to go? Correct, Okay, you
- 31:10just answered your own question. Thank you for the invitation. I'm going to
- 31:14politely decline. Have a nice day. Do you feel obligated to go?
- 31:18Not really, I'm just I don't understand why she's asking. I mean,
- 31:26it could be a number of things. It could be naive sincerity, it
- 31:30could be maneuvering, passive aggression. You know, maybe she's tricking you into
- 31:34church. Maybe she's lonely. I mean, you know, I can't read
- 31:38her mind. I myself had become kind of suspicious about those types of requests.
- 31:45I think I've told the story about when my father passed away and my
- 31:48devout evangelical mother, who has just been pawing at me for a decade and
- 31:53a half. Her request for my participation in his funeral service was for me
- 31:59to stand on the platform and play two of his favorite hymns, deeply religious
- 32:07songs from the old classic hymnals. And I don't remember what the songs were,
- 32:12but I mean they're overtly Jesus and God and Christianity and Bible and my
- 32:17father, despite his profound hearing loss did have a couple of hymns that he
- 32:22enjoyed back from earlier in his life when he could hear. And Mom's like,
- 32:27oh, Seth plays the piano. I sure we'd like him to take
- 32:30the stage and play his father's favorite hymns to Jesus. And knowing the context,
- 32:38knowing the history, did I think, Oh, she's naively sincere,
- 32:44I did not. I thought this a trick. She wants her atheist act
- 32:50of his son on record on stage playing Jesus songs before the entire auditorium.
- 32:58And I said, thank you know, yeah, I think I remember you
- 33:01telling that story on a previous episode. Whatever, Maybe I've already sort of
- 33:06opened that particular can of worms. Maybe I air too much dirty laundry.
- 33:09I just think it's it's so interesting, like you want to believe, believe
- 33:15if it makes you happy, knock yourself out, if it serves some need
- 33:19in you, and whatever, you know, I knock yourself out. I'm
- 33:22not banging on her door anybody else's door saying stop believing in God. My
- 33:28issue isn't with people who just want to believe something. It's when those beliefs
- 33:31ripple out to have a net negative effect. On the rest of us,
- 33:36which is an alarming amount of the time. In your case, she can
- 33:42ask, you can say no. If she pressures you, you say you
- 33:46don't get to pressure me, and you get on with your day. Okay.
- 33:50There's one other thing I wanted to mention a real quick Yeah, my
- 33:53mother is also actually a published author, and I am dedicated in the book
- 34:00that she has written. But I haven't read it yet, and her book
- 34:05was published by the publishing branch of Trinity Broadcasting Network. What did she say
- 34:12about you in the book? I mean, you haven't read the book,
- 34:15but you certainly know what the dedication says, right. It's a short general
- 34:20dedication just to me and my sisters, honestly. Okay, So it's not
- 34:23a book that says I am writing this in the hopes of reaching my prodigal
- 34:29son. I'm not sure if she would even want to necessarily admit that in
- 34:32the dedication of the book. Are you going to read the book? I'm
- 34:37not sure if I am. Which all the book is is a retelling of
- 34:42the book of Job from the wife's perspective. I would like to legitimately know
- 34:47what Job's wife was thinking when God totally screwed up her husband's entire existence and
- 34:54guild is children, And I'd like to know what Job's wife was thinking.
- 35:00But I kind of doubt your mom has an objective opinion or perspective about that.
- 35:05Yeah, that's part of the reason why I haven't read it yet either.
- 35:07Thanks for calling. Take care of yourself see him. Job's wife was
- 35:14also murdered by God, Jacques said in the comments. Is that true?
- 35:19I hadn't remembered that. Okay, we got to go back to Google here
- 35:22real fast, because I want to make sure I'm giving you accurate information.
- 35:27God killed Job's family. Oh look, it's an apologetics website. This ought
- 35:36to be fun. I always enjoy the apologist trying to explain why the story
- 35:39of massacring human beings is a demonstration of God's goodness. That's always fun.
- 35:45This one is from Honest Talk with God, The Death of Job's Children.
- 35:53Job had ten children. When Satan challenged God's assertion of Job's righteous he asked
- 36:00God for permission to harm Job's loved ones and take Job's possessions. God acquiesced,
- 36:08and Satan used human conflict and natural disaster to destroy all that Job had
- 36:15and kill all whom Job loved, save his wife. According to this blogger,
- 36:22the wife survived. I guess I could go read the book of Job,
- 36:24but I find this more interesting. Okay, So for some reason,
- 36:29God felt like he cared what Satan thought, and he decided to make Job
- 36:34an example of how if I muck up Job's life, He's still gonna love
- 36:37me. I'm scrolling down here. Oh look, we pinball directly to the
- 36:43New Testament Matthew chapter six, which says, do not worry about your life
- 36:47or your body. Are you not of more value than the birds of the
- 36:52air and God cares about them? Jesus clearly states that God loves us and
- 36:58values us, and provides for scrolling down context context. Oh check the first
- 37:06sentence in this paragraph. Death is not always the worst thing to happen to
- 37:12someone. We don't see the Job story from the perspective of Job's children.
- 37:16Their view is never considered from their vantage point. Maybe something is gained by
- 37:22their deaths. I don't know. I look into the New Testament and see
- 37:29Stephen willingly face death for the sake of the gospel. Oh maybe the children
- 37:37before they were massacred looked up to heaven and said, yes, God,
- 37:40please massacre me so that I may demonstrate your love and goodness beyond myself.
- 37:46After all, am I not worth more than the birds of the air?
- 37:52Ah? What a lovely God. Now bring the horrible death that thou hast
- 37:57planned for me. I submit to your hashtag goodness A beautiful story. Five
- 38:06zero eight? Hi? Who's this? Hi says it's crafty or grant,
- 38:10whatever you prefer to call me. Grant works for me. What's on your
- 38:13mind? What do you want to talk about? I have a the is
- 38:15a skeptical not so skeptical atheism call. I know the two are separate,
- 38:21but I have an atheist friend who still believes in an afterlife, even going
- 38:25so far because he's a big fan of ghost movies and horror stories, just
- 38:30like me. And he goes forth with buying an app for his iPad and
- 38:37carting it around and taking posting videos on YouTube. He has a YouTube channel
- 38:40where he walks people through talking through his spirit Box app on his iPad.
- 38:49And I was wondering what your two cents were on the whole discussion we had
- 38:55where it was basically I pointed out, how this is very religious. I
- 39:00yeah, this is the idea that the soul goes on, that there even
- 39:02is a soul, and that it goes on to an afterlife and you're able
- 39:06to tap into it with a ten dollar app that doesn't even work the same
- 39:10way as the traditional quote unquote spirit box, which is just a radio transceiver
- 39:15that picks up different kinds of static and radio waves, the whole EVP stick.
- 39:21And he credulously bought that. I even told him, Hey, are
- 39:24you a medium? He's like, no, no, no, I'm not.
- 39:27I don't have any powers. I don't believe I actually have any psychic
- 39:29abilities. All right, Well, you know about Schister mediums who have been
- 39:34caught in the act, famous ones, you know, thanks to James Randy
- 39:37for example, And he just could not handle the question of hey, how
- 39:44do you tell the difference between the Shister mediums and the real ones which you
- 39:47assume exist? And he just couldn't answer that. Now, he's probably just
- 39:52wants to be leave. I get that. I mean I understand the desire
- 39:58to believe that we continue on. There's kind of a mystery to it,
- 40:01you know, it's a magic to it, and perhaps I'm interested in this
- 40:06app ten dollars turns your phone into a spirit box or your iPad into a
- 40:10spirit box. I might have to look that up. I'm not going to
- 40:14pay for it, but I'd like to know what it is. No.
- 40:15No, But I pointed out to him too, it's software. Somebody wrote
- 40:20that. And he says, yeah, but but I mean it works,
- 40:22Like, how do you know it works? Well? Look, I speak
- 40:24into it and it starts to say words back at me. It's like,
- 40:29there's voice recognition software that exists, there's voice replications software, you know,
- 40:35text to speech that exists, and it's easy enough to write an algorithm that
- 40:39links the two together and sell it for ten bucks on your app. He's
- 40:43like, yeah, but but you know it's not a problem. I'm like,
- 40:45you literally spent money you could have spent feeding your child on an app
- 40:51that buys into this notion that it is possible to be a spirit medium.
- 40:54Let alone have an app that takes care of it for you. And then
- 40:59he shops it around. He goes out and meets people in public, random
- 41:02people, and does the whole medium ship. He's like, yeah, but
- 41:05I don't ask him for money. I'm not doing it for profit. I'm
- 41:09just doing it so they can talk to their loved one, Like, how
- 41:13do you know they're actually talking to their loved ones? How do you know
- 41:15you're not giving them bad advice? It's like, yeah, I can't.
- 41:19I'm not intending to give them bad advice, therefore I can't be giving them
- 41:22bad advice. Oh sure, nobody can do any harm? Yeah without intent?
- 41:28Yeah, no one who's ever been sincere has ever done any harm.
- 41:31Right, great, Yeah, I'll I'll have to look this up on my
- 41:36phone. I'm now insanely curious about the online app driven spirit detection industry.
- 41:44But it sounds like your friend just wants to believe that's going to be a
- 41:47tough row. But you're right to be skeptical, and you're right to encourage
- 41:51skepticism around him. I myself would continue asking the questions how do you know?
- 41:57And who knows, maybe he'll start to ask himself somewhere down the road.
- 42:00Yeah, thankfully he has started like questioning that and being more skeptical,
- 42:04to the point where he stopped posting to that YouTube channel and just has another
- 42:07YouTube channel entirely for family videos and geocashing fun. I'm geo cashed, you
- 42:15know, I don't know, I yeah, I found it a lot of
- 42:16fun and there were no ghosts involved, and I totally bothered that, Grant.
- 42:21I appreciate your good luck with your friend, and I'm going to go
- 42:23search for some spirit boxes. Okay, thank you, sir, to keep
- 42:27up a great works. See you later. As he was speaking, I
- 42:30hope it wasn't rude, but I opened up my iPhone app store spirit box.
- 42:36There's a whole industry for this ghost science M three. There is Ghost
- 42:44two, the SLS camera for paranormal investigators with night vision. Ghost Tube.
- 42:52SLS camera detects humanoid bodies in your environment, similar to the way in which
- 42:59they can SLS camera works used by real paranormal investigators. There's another ghost detector,
- 43:06ghost hunting, ghost observer, ghost talker. Find ghosts, ask questions,
- 43:14and take a shot of the ghost. Share with friends, find a
- 43:17ghost nearby using a built in radar app, communicate without typing anything. The
- 43:25app will ask questions for you. Paranormal emf oh yeah, an essential free
- 43:34tool for people with an interest in paranormal investigation. Real measurements using the magnetometer.
- 43:44Sorry, I'm fascinated by this. Interesting that these apps exist and yet
- 43:49no one has won a Nobel Prize for proving the existence of ghosts. Speaking
- 43:55of ghosts coming up, I believe next month I'm going to be speaking.
- 44:00A full time paranormal investigator name is Kenny Biddle, does a lot of work
- 44:05with skeptical inquirer and he goes out to ghost houses and he stays the night
- 44:10and he uses the equipment, and he takes the equipment apart like all the
- 44:15people are saying this measures a ghost. And he grabs the equipment, he
- 44:20dissects it, takes it apart, reverse engineers it, and he's got some
- 44:23great stories. So if you like debunking ghosts or at least examining ghostly claims,
- 44:30Kenny Biddle's going to join me here in a few weeks and he is
- 44:32gonna be big fun. Okay, this is probably a mistake, but I'm
- 44:39going to download one of these here Sono X ten spirit Box Age appropriate seventeen
- 44:46plus. It's free. This is probably one of those deals where it's free
- 44:52until it's not. Like, we'll give you the free app if you want
- 44:55to talk to the low tier rear Raft ghosts. If you have the premium
- 45:01ghosts, that's going to cost you. Okay, it downloads quickly opening the
- 45:07app, it looks like a scanner sensor signal okay for those who aren't familiar
- 45:23with the spirit Box. It scans or ostensibly scans radio frequencies. It grabs
- 45:30a piece of audio from that frequency, and then it moves on to the
- 45:34next one. And you're supposed to be able to hear patterns as the ghost
- 45:37speak to you. So let's ask it a question, how did you die?
- 45:50I have no idea, which is probably the point right pattern seekers will
- 45:55insert meaning here or connect thousand consonants here, and I was kind of an
- 46:02anti climax. I'm sorry, my friends. I'm not going to download anymore.
- 46:07Actually, even this damn app looks like it's nothing but ads add here
- 46:12and add their upgrade to premium. No, I'm not going to do that.
- 46:15Instead, I'm going to wish you a wonderful week, and we're going
- 46:19to talk about all this in much more detail with Kenny Biddle, Paranormal Investigator,
- 46:24coming up in the month of August. I'll catch you back here next
- 46:28time. We'll see you soon. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 46:31for a complete archive of podcasts and videos. Products like mugs and t shirts
- 46:37featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 46:42on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking
- 46:46Atheist dot com