Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #39: Open Primaries w/ Guest Sila Avcil
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:02I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:04As you can see, it's another special edition of the show because we have another guest.
- 0:08But before we get to her, just whether you are new to this podcast or not, I always make note
- 0:13in guest episodes that I don't take a specific stance for or against anybody's political views
- 0:18or any groups they belong to.
- 0:20But that being said, today's guest has a lot of experience and interesting takes with today's
- 0:26topic, and that topic is open primaries.
- 0:29Primary elections are how we come up with the candidates that run-in the general election who
- 0:35we then choose from to ultimately win an elected office.
- 0:38And many of these states use closed primaries where only Democrats can vote in Democratic
- 0:44primaries and only Republicans can vote in Republican primaries.
- 0:48But in New Mexico, the state government just enacted legislation to open up primaries to
- 0:53where independents can start participating in them.
- 0:57And our special guest today played a major role in making that happen.
- 1:02Her name is Silla Avgio.
- 1:04Silla cofounded and serves as the executive director of New Mexico Voters First and is also
- 1:10the executive director of New Mexico Open Elections.
- 1:13Previously, she was a national organizer with open primaries.
- 1:17And on the educational side, she earned a BA in international studies and MA in political
- 1:22science, both from the University of New Mexico.
- 1:25So she's New Mexico through and through.
- 1:28Silla is here today to talk all things open primaries, current and future.
- 1:33So please welcome to the show, Silla Avgil.
- 1:37Silla, thank you so much for being here and taking the time to talk to me today.
- 1:40How are you doing today?
- 1:41I'm good, Paul.
- 1:42Thanks for having me on.
- 1:44Yeah.
- 1:44Absolutely.
- 1:45Thanks once again for coming on.
- 1:47So I think it only makes sense to start from the very beginning.
- 1:51How did you get involved with this whole endeavor of getting open primaries implemented
- 1:56in New Mexico?
- 1:59Well, no story is ever short enough, but I'll I'll tell you.
- 2:03So as you mentioned, I have master's in political science from the University of New
- 2:07Mexico.
- 2:09And because of my international background, I was always interested in studying international
- 2:13relations and comparative politics.
- 2:16But through my program, I was required to take two classes outside of my, research field.
- 2:23So I was like, let's just take some classes in American politics, public policy.
- 2:28Let's see what that's all about.
- 2:30And, Paul, I have to tell you, I fell in love with American politics.
- 2:34I thought it was incredibly intriguing.
- 2:36It's so different from any other, you know, political system that I've observed around the
- 2:42country, around the world.
- 2:44And so I was very interested in learning more about it.
- 2:49But immediately after graduating with my master's, I got a job in another local
- 2:54nonprofit, which is technically where I got connected to this field because the founder of
- 3:00New Mexico Open Elections is also the honorary consul for Germany.
- 3:05And so because of his international background and my international background, we connected
- 3:10and he was like, Hey, Silla, I'm looking for a young executive director for this group that I
- 3:16founded.
- 3:16Do you happen to know anyone?
- 3:18And I was like, yeah, I do.
- 3:20It's me.
- 3:22And so we started working together in 2022.
- 3:26I had no idea what I was fully signing up for.
- 3:29You know, I had an idea of like, oh, we're doing public education of election reforms, but
- 3:34I had no idea what that meant and like what it entailed and what I was about to do this year.
- 3:41And so the more I learned, the more I became even more intrigued and I served as the expert
- 3:47witness for our bill in 2023 at the sixty day legislative session.
- 3:53And then in 2024, we had drafted a bill, but New Mexico's legislative process is incredibly
- 4:00tedious.
- 4:00So every other year we have a sixty day and every other year we have a thirty day
- 4:05legislative session.
- 4:06And then every thirty day session, you can only introduce things that are, you know, big in
- 4:14budget that's going to affect the state in terms of finances, or if they're constitutional
- 4:19amendments.
- 4:20And we really didn't want this to be a constitutional amendment because the New Mexico
- 4:25constitution doesn't need to be amended for open primaries to be enacted.
- 4:30The current constitution allows for that.
- 4:33But it would have given us, you know, an easier access to the shorter sessions.
- 4:38Anyways, we didn't get a message from the governor, which is another way that you can
- 4:43introduce bills in a thirty day session in New Mexico.
- 4:46We didn't get that, but we knew she was supportive.
- 4:48She just didn't want to prioritize this bill that year.
- 4:52And so 2025, we were like, okay, that's our golden year.
- 4:57We're not doing anything in the thirty day and '24, but we're gonna work right now all the way
- 5:03until next session so that we will get this done in 2025.
- 5:06And so here we are now.
- 5:10Wow.
- 5:10Yeah.
- 5:10And and you you you're talking about just getting drawn into, you know, just how the
- 5:16whole American system of government, functions or works.
- 5:20That's that's that's the big thing that really, you know, drew me into it was just under trying
- 5:25to figure out how it how it all works.
- 5:26And, you you know, with your international, background, I I I do find fascination in
- 5:31looking at how other countries do it too, but it's definitely not my forte.
- 5:36And I'm glad that you brought up about a little bit about that that legislative process because
- 5:40we are gonna get into that, in a little bit, but a little bit more on the history of the
- 5:46closed primary system in New Mexico.
- 5:48Has it always been a closed primary system since there's been primaries?
- 5:52Did they previously have any other kind of open primaries or has it effectively always been a
- 5:58closed primary system in New Mexico?
- 6:00So New Mexico as a state was founded with closed primaries, which back when we were
- 6:06founded, these conversations weren't really a thing about like reform and democracy and
- 6:11access.
- 6:12And so we have always been a closed primary state.
- 6:15We do have neighboring states that have been always open primary states.
- 6:20And we also have neighboring states that have gone from closed to semi open and are exploring
- 6:27fully open, such as Colorado and Arizona.
- 6:31And so it's been really interesting, again, to like learn about these processes and American
- 6:37politics as to like which states were founded with fully closed primaries, which states were
- 6:42founded with semi open and etcetera.
- 6:45And so, but New Mexico was always closed and New Mexico Open Elections was working since
- 6:522015.
- 6:53So ten years this year on getting something passed and getting the public educated about
- 6:59like, hey, there are alternatives and we could change the law.
- 7:05Okay.
- 7:06Interesting.
- 7:06Fascinating.
- 7:07Yes.
- 7:07I wanna say it's what?
- 7:081911, I think, is when New Mexico became a state.
- 7:11I I've been doing a a side project I've been working on is just basically the partisan
- 7:17history of all the states and and delves a little bit into New Mexico.
- 7:22I think every every state's partisan history is is fascinating to some degree, but a little bit
- 7:27more obviously about the closed primary system even though now now that it's it's changed in
- 7:33New Mexico.
- 7:34In your own words, just can hear some what some people say about the closed primary system in
- 7:40general, but I'd rather just hear it straight from you.
- 7:43In your own words, describe what is wrong with the closed primary system.
- 7:48What are the issues that you've seen arisen from it, and why did it need to be changed?
- 7:55That's a great question, Paul.
- 7:57I think first and foremost, closed primaries are taxation without representation because
- 8:03primary elections are funded by tax payer dollars.
- 8:07And if you're saying that, Oh, we'll take your taxes to pay for these elections, but then you
- 8:12don't get to vote in them unless you become a member of a party when those parties aren't the
- 8:17ones paying for these elections to take place.
- 8:20And so I think that's number one, first and foremost, that every taxpayer has, should have
- 8:26equal access to every taxpayer funded election without having to go through added barriers,
- 8:32which are also additionally costly.
- 8:34Cause in New Mexico, before this law, we had same day registration.
- 8:39We still have it.
- 8:40But the main purpose of same day registration is for voters who aren't registered to register
- 8:46so that they can vote.
- 8:48But in New Mexico, that process became, if you're an independent, then you can use same
- 8:54day to become a member of a party and then you can vote in that party's primary.
- 8:59And then you can go home and change your registration again.
- 9:02And we really saw that this was becoming burdensome and it wasn't as seamless as elected
- 9:08officials were making it to be because as the ED of these two organizations for the past
- 9:15three years, I've been contacted multiple times by independents saying, hey, Silla.
- 9:20I tried to use the same day process, but it took me six months to reregister as an
- 9:25independent.
- 9:26And if that is an option provided to voters, that should never be taken away and never be a
- 9:34burden that takes six months long to become who you want to be as registered voter again.
- 9:40And so it's really, really about making the process easier and more accessible to people.
- 9:48And in particular, young voters in New Mexico and all around the nation are more and more
- 9:55registering as independent voters.
- 9:58Because, I mean, I don't know why, because I'm, you know, not, I don't read everyone's mind,
- 10:04but most of them, their reason for that is that they grew up with their families fighting
- 10:11during Thanksgiving dinner politics.
- 10:14And so they really don't want to get involved in that because they see it as a negative
- 10:19factor in their lives.
- 10:21And so they register as independent, which I think in and of itself is a political
- 10:26statement, saying that they don't want to be part of a club, but they still want their
- 10:31voices to be heard because they still want to participate in the process.
- 10:36And so for me personally, being a younger person who has a lot of friends my age that are
- 10:41independent voters, it was personal to me too, that closed primaries prevented my friends from
- 10:47participating in the most consequential elections that determine the winners of many
- 10:54districts in our state and in the country.
- 10:56So many, many reasons.
- 10:58But
- 11:01Yeah.
- 11:01I I wanna say if if correct me if I'm wrong.
- 11:05Was something like a quarter of the electorate in New Mexico is registered as independent?
- 11:10Yes.
- 11:11Yeah.
- 11:11So it's a that's a that's a pretty decent sized chunk.
- 11:14It's here, I'm I'm in Florida, and it's something like 34%.
- 11:18But you you you you a lot of states, see something like about quarter of the electorate
- 11:24or even, like, a third or even I think Massachusetts actually has, like, over half
- 11:29that are registered as independents.
- 11:31And I actually had another guest a few weeks ago talk a bit about some of the reasons that
- 11:37independents register as such too.
- 11:40But back to the arguments for and against or for the arguments that you you made the case
- 11:48for open primaries, but, obviously, closed primary advocates have their own arguments that
- 11:54they make too, whether they're you know, obviously, for those listening, you can decide
- 11:59for yourself how valid they are.
- 12:01But one of the major arguments that closed primary advocates give is that party members
- 12:07should have the right to choose their nominees that represent them.
- 12:10They'll they'll often cite the First Amendment right to assembly as one of their main
- 12:14arguments and say, you know, other party members or independents coming into their their
- 12:20primaries is is it's not letting them come to make their own decisions for their own groups.
- 12:27So as an open primary advocate, how do you respond to that argument in particular?
- 12:33Well, Paul, being at the legislature for sixty days straight gave me many exposures and
- 12:39experiences to all the arguments that exist above the ground.
- 12:44And honestly, like, to the First Amendment argument, it's also in the constitution that
- 12:52every citizen gets the right to vote.
- 12:55And so that's my counterargument, and every taxpayer should be able to participate in every
- 13:00tax funded election.
- 13:02And so that's like my favorite counterpoint to that.
- 13:05And then that, like, gets people thinking like, oh, that's correct.
- 13:10But also, like I was saying earlier, because these are taxpayer funded and not funded by the
- 13:16parties, and the parties have every single right to fund their own elections.
- 13:22But because they're not funded by the parties themselves, and they're funded by the people,
- 13:27and this government is by the people for the people, then all the people should be able to
- 13:32participate regardless of how they're registered, as long as they only get to vote in
- 13:36one primary of one party.
- 13:40Again, unless it's a fully open primary, and that's a whole other rabbit hole that we can
- 13:44get into.
- 13:45But under the semi open system, the party ballots are still separate.
- 13:50And any voter that is not registered with a party can just go and pick whichever party's
- 13:57ballot they would like to choose that year.
- 14:02And so hopefully, you know, this helps more people understand that like, this is really not
- 14:08a party issue.
- 14:09It's a voter issue, and it's an access issue, and it's a democracy and participation issue.
- 14:16And also, parties still have the right to hold their pre primary conventions and pick their
- 14:23candidates that way and keep it within the party that way.
- 14:26But these people at the end of the day, don't represent parties.
- 14:31They represent districts of people, of the people that elected them.
- 14:36And I think that was a huge argument for us at the legislature is that you're not here
- 14:41representing the Democratic Party of New Mexico or the Republican Party of New Mexico.
- 14:46You are here representing District XYZ because that's who elected you to be here today.
- 14:52And I think that's just the most important thing that we continue to say to people when
- 14:57they bring these arguments up.
- 15:00Gotcha.
- 15:00So you you just talked about how you've seen basically all the arguments that closed primary
- 15:06advocates make, which obviously makes sense to you since you were so ingrained in the
- 15:10legislative process.
- 15:12What what are a couple of the other common arguments?
- 15:15Maybe just one or two.
- 15:17Or or if you wanna get more than that, that's fine.
- 15:19But one or two of the other common arguments you've heard from closed primary advocates and
- 15:23what you and your team had in response to those?
- 15:28I think one of my favorite ones, because it's just funny, is that why don't independents just
- 15:34start their own party and run their own candidates in the primary?
- 15:38And the whole point of being independent is that, so you don't do that.
- 15:44There's plenty of third parties and minor parties that people have the choice of being
- 15:49involved in.
- 15:51But the point is that a majority of these people don't choose to affiliate with any of
- 15:56these parties, not just the major parties.
- 16:00And so that was, that one's always fun because it's like, have you read the law?
- 16:05Do you know that running an independent candidacy is ridiculously hard compared to
- 16:11being part of any other party?
- 16:14In New Mexico, independent candidates have to collect like 10,000 more signatures in a given
- 16:21district, depending on what they're running for.
- 16:23So it's really almost impossible.
- 16:27And then the second favorite argument that I heard a lot was, what if all these people start
- 16:35voting and then they start voting for the bad people that we don't want, and then they raid
- 16:40all of our primaries?
- 16:42And it's like, guys, these people don't vote.
- 16:46The whole point and the whole problem is that they don't vote and we want them to vote and
- 16:50they want to vote too.
- 16:52And so when you give someone the chance to vote, they're not gonna go and be malicious.
- 16:58We have to trust our voters and our people in our state that they're going to vote their
- 17:02conscience and for the people that they actually like.
- 17:05And there's so much data showing that people, most people who vote don't vote strategically.
- 17:12They vote for the candidates that they actually like, because it's such a gamble that you're
- 17:17throwing.
- 17:17And even the most organized effort of strategic voting in the state of California was
- 17:25incredibly unsuccessful.
- 17:27And so we see strategic voting happening more often in a closed primary, which is not even
- 17:33significant levels, but it's 1.8% of the time.
- 17:37But under any form of open primary, it's 1.2 of the time.
- 17:41And so this change makes it even better for strategic voting to not happen as often as it
- 17:49already does.
- 17:51Yeah.
- 17:52With with the the whole, you know, voting bad candidates, it's I I feel like you can anybody
- 17:59can make that argument for general elections too.
- 18:01Sometimes people just vote for people that you don't like.
- 18:05And with with the ballot access, I I was reminds me of a book I had self published a few
- 18:12years ago.
- 18:12I I but, basically, just how onerous ballot access can be for candidates who are not with
- 18:21one of the two major parties and whether so a lot of times they don't I mean, I'm sure you've
- 18:26I don't know exactly how New Mexico's works, but I'm sure you've seen it before is just how
- 18:30either they don't have the option to pay to get on the ballot, and they have to get in certain
- 18:35number of signature ballot or a petition signatures to put them on the ballot.
- 18:39And then a lot of times, they need a much higher amount than Democrats or Republicans do.
- 18:44But it's, yeah, it's kinda like that whole, if you don't like something, why don't you just do
- 18:48this?
- 18:48It's like, well, you make it sound like that's an easy thing to do.
- 18:51It's not necessarily an easy thing to do.
- 18:54Whether it should be done or not, it's not necessarily an easy thing to do.
- 18:58But let's let's change gears here a little bit.
- 19:01So just to just to make things clear because there are several different types of more open
- 19:07primaries and just for people listening at home and and, you know, even for myself, is the
- 19:14change that you were a part of in New Mexico so it's just anybody who does not have a party can
- 19:19participate in either democrat or republican primaries, but it's not democrats still have to
- 19:26vote in democratic primaries, and then republicans still have to vote in republican
- 19:29primaries.
- 19:29Is that correct?
- 19:31Okay.
- 19:32So so since we so we established that nonparty voters can choose either party's primary.
- 19:40Were you helping to have a primary where anybody of any party could go into either
- 19:50primary, or or was it just just focused on independence?
- 19:55So cross party voting is unconstitutional.
- 20:00So that part is fair and true.
- 20:03If I'm a registered Democrat, I cannot go and vote in the Republican primary.
- 20:10What is not unconstitutional, so what is constitutional is, if there's not separate
- 20:16ballots for each party and every candidate is on one ballot, which we call open primaries and
- 20:23jungle primaries, then you can vote for any candidate as any registered voter or however
- 20:30you're registered.
- 20:33And then because you see every candidate on the same ballot, so you could be like, I want this
- 20:38Republican.
- 20:39I want this Green Party.
- 20:40I want this Libertarian and so on and so forth.
- 20:44Under the system that we have passed, the two ballots are still separate for each major
- 20:50party.
- 20:51And in fact, Libertarian Party used to be a major party in the state of New Mexico.
- 20:56I believe they recently lost their major party status here.
- 21:01So the law only affects independent, non affiliated registered voters to be able to pick
- 21:10only one ballot of one party and then vote.
- 21:15Originally, the bill had included minor party and third party voters as well because they
- 21:21don't have technically primaries, but we also found that that could be a challenge
- 21:27constitutionally, going back to your First Amendment argument, is that they are already
- 21:33choosing to affiliate with a party regardless of what party that is.
- 21:38And so, and they sometimes host, conventions if they have candidates on that are live going
- 21:45somewhere.
- 21:46And so that having them not having to change their registration and be able to vote in
- 21:54another party's primary was what was the argument that was made.
- 21:59And so we had to amend our bill to remove all references to minor and third party voters.
- 22:06But I'm sure it's different in every state, just as everything is in every state.
- 22:10But in New Mexico, third parties don't have status under the secretary of state.
- 22:16So if you're, let's say a working families party member in New Mexico, you're technically
- 22:21registered as an independent, as an unaffiliated voter.
- 22:25But it's like a dropdown addition when you're selecting your registration.
- 22:32And so we got a little backlash from our local minor parties about that, about them being
- 22:40excluded from the process, which is totally fair.
- 22:44But at the end of the day, when we looked at the numbers, people registered with a minor
- 22:50party in New Mexico were only 12,000 people compared to 300,000 people that were registered
- 22:56independent.
- 22:58So the bill still did so much more than we ever could have imagined by passing and getting,
- 23:04getting signed and, you know, restoring voting rights for so many people that are, that didn't
- 23:10want to vote by becoming a member of another club.
- 23:15But yeah.
- 23:15So the it doesn't include minor third party or cross party voting.
- 23:22Gotcha.
- 23:22So I guess that was kind of part of the whole calculus.
- 23:25You were just talking about how you wanted this specifically to be legislation, not a
- 23:29constitutional amendment because then, obviously, there's a whole other brick and roll
- 23:33you have to go through there.
- 23:35But I guess that so that's that's you you because you went with the legislation route,
- 23:39you kinda had to you you were basically forced to exclude third parties then.
- 23:45So am am I understanding that correctly then?
- 23:48Yeah.
- 23:48Just for the purpose of not being challenged if the bill did get passed because there's as you
- 23:54can see, there are so many challenges to any form of open primary across the country right
- 23:59now.
- 23:59And so we really wanted to be super duper safe with the bill that we knew was going to pass
- 24:04and hopefully get signed, which it did.
- 24:07And so we believe that if it had included minor parties as a signed bill, then it would have
- 24:14been challenged up in the courts, and we probably would have lost because of the
- 24:19constitutional, affiliation rights.
- 24:22Got you.
- 24:23Yeah.
- 24:23And then you obviously, you you know, you're trying to include as many people as possible,
- 24:27but minor parties do have such really, in every state, they there is such a small proportion of
- 24:33them.
- 24:33But that that's a good segue into this next question.
- 24:36So forget exactly the state constitutional provisions for New Mexico.
- 24:44Is the new primary system you have, is that the one you most wanted to see?
- 24:49So is there a different type of primary you find ideal where those third parties could also
- 24:54become part of or be able to choose whichever major party primary they want or even that
- 25:02Democrats and Republicans can choose whichever primary.
- 25:05Is is there one of those that you specifically wanna see?
- 25:08Do you think that this is the ideal way to do it the way it's it's being done right now?
- 25:13Or do you not have any particular preference as long as it is not a closed primary?
- 25:20Definitely the last one.
- 25:22And Right.
- 25:23I think that because, you know, closed primaries are not good for participation, for
- 25:29representation.
- 25:31And I think that every state is special and we believe that semi open was the best form of
- 25:37primary for New Mexico.
- 25:39We know that, you know, California, Texas, other states have fully open primaries, which
- 25:45work for them.
- 25:46And we really don't have that much competition anyways in our elections.
- 25:51And so the main point was just to get more people involved in the voting process, in the
- 25:56electoral process, and hoping that that in and of itself leads to more representation with
- 26:04more representative people being elected into office.
- 26:08And, you know, I think any form of open primary is great.
- 26:11It just depends on which state you're in and what the appetite is in that state.
- 26:16And if there's like, if there's more competition, if there's constantly people
- 26:20running all the time, then obviously something more like a fully open or a ranked choice model
- 26:25would work better.
- 26:26But we're, our population is so small in our state.
- 26:29I believe we have more cows than people in the state.
- 26:32Someone needs to fact check me on that.
- 26:36But so like, there's no point in having a bigger or, you know, different model than what
- 26:43we have just passed.
- 26:44And I think it's gonna take a little bit of time for us to implement this anyways, and to
- 26:49get people to know their new rights, that they can just vote as they are and they don't have
- 26:54to change their registration.
- 26:56And so that's gonna take enough time in and of itself and hopefully lead to more
- 27:01representation for New Mexico.
- 27:04Was that was that also then part of the calculation too?
- 27:07Not not just obviously having to account for what the state constitution says, but just
- 27:11trying to do almost like a baby step kind of thing.
- 27:14You didn't want was it really just, hey.
- 27:16We don't wanna go, you know, get too far reaching right now anyways.
- 27:20We're just trying to, you know, build our way to get there.
- 27:23Was that part of the calculation too, or are we really just focused on right now?
- 27:27We're just we're just trying to do get anything that's not a closed primary system.
- 27:33Basically, so for like I said, for the past ten years, New Mexico Open Elections was
- 27:38introducing bills at the legislative session, and they had introduced various types of
- 27:43primary systems.
- 27:45They had introduced rank trace voting.
- 27:47So we saw how our elected officials were responding to each bill and the interest levels
- 27:53and the support levels.
- 27:54So all of that was put into a calculation when we decided that semi open was the bill.
- 28:01And that was the bill that was going to pass because none of the other forms of primaries
- 28:06had any support from the public.
- 28:08They didn't really get it.
- 28:10But when you said independents should be able to vote, it clicked automatically.
- 28:14And so that made so much more sense.
- 28:17And like you said, people call it a baby step, but for us, it's a huge step for humanity, and
- 28:24our democracy and being the only second state to be able to pass this through a legislature
- 28:29is just huge And
- 28:31for the
- 28:30huge for the And so, cause most states that changed their electoral process changed it
- 28:36through a ballot initiative.
- 28:38And so it's Maine and then us, we're the only two that have been able to get this through a
- 28:43legislature and convincing party elected officials basically to say, Hey, you guys
- 28:51should invite independence to the table, was probably our biggest challenge because some of
- 28:57these are like old school Democrats, old school Republicans that just don't want to change the
- 29:01way that they have been elected for the past twenty years.
- 29:05And then there's a handful of newer, younger elected officials that were like, no, I see the
- 29:09problem.
- 29:10I know that we need to change this and this will make everything better.
- 29:13And so there was a lot of interesting, dynamics there.
- 29:19And once you have a bill that is like supported by partisan, but also opposed by partisan, to
- 29:25me, that's when you know you have a good bill.
- 29:28I got I got excuse me.
- 29:30I got you there.
- 29:32A little bit before we get to the because I did wanna get to you touched a little bit on it,
- 29:39the actual legislative process.
- 29:42Do you so you're you are talking about primaries being more competitive.
- 29:46And and even though I I don't officially take sides on on most things, I I do think that we
- 29:53have a very serious problem with political competition in general or rather lack thereof.
- 29:59And there is whether we do close primaries, open primaries, whatever, there is a very
- 30:04serious issue we have with a lack of competition in politics.
- 30:09So you're you are talking about primaries being more competitive.
- 30:14And so do you ultimately feel like this will lead to more competitive general elections as
- 30:20well because of more people being involved in the primary process, or is that even or you
- 30:27just mostly just focus on, look, we just want the representation in the primary general
- 30:32election, whatever happens happens kind of thing.
- 30:35How how do you see it in that regard?
- 30:38So there's a study from Unite America that shows 80% of congressional seats are decided in
- 30:47the primary because the districts are so gerrymandered to favor one party over another.
- 30:53And I believe New Mexico has recently redistricted because when I first got involved,
- 31:01my state senator was somebody else, and then they literally districted him out.
- 31:06So he's he didn't even get, like, not reelected.
- 31:09He just got kicked out of his own district.
- 31:11And I mean, he was personally ready to resign and, like, retire.
- 31:15So I guess it worked out for him.
- 31:18But I would be, like, going to town halls and shaking hands and be like, Oh, you're my
- 31:22Senator.
- 31:22Nice to meet you.
- 31:23And they'd be like, No, I'm not.
- 31:24I just, I'm not your Senator anymore.
- 31:26Where do you live?
- 31:27And so that was really interesting to see.
- 31:31Because of how these districts are drawn and how like that all goes down and works.
- 31:39Because in New Mexico, we don't have an independent redistricting commission.
- 31:43Our districts are drawn by basically the legislators and people that they appoint to
- 31:49like go through this process.
- 31:51And then they have to account for all the tribes and pueblos that we have in New Mexico.
- 31:57We have 23 federally recognized sovereign nations and we have 19 Pueblos in the entire
- 32:04state.
- 32:05So we have probably one of the most highest indigenous populations in the country.
- 32:10So they also get included in the process to make sure that everything looks good and that
- 32:16they approve it.
- 32:17And this process doesn't happen often.
- 32:20I know it just happened somewhat recently, but it doesn't happen often.
- 32:23It was challenged multiple times, but it's how it is now.
- 32:28And so I don't think it would create, the bill that we just passed would create any changes to
- 32:35like districts or competitiveness in those districts between parties.
- 32:42But I think it might create some form of competitiveness in primaries Because like you
- 32:49said, more people are going to be participating and these candidates who are not used to
- 32:54talking to more people than just the top 3% voters in their districts, they're going to
- 33:00have to be talking to everybody now.
- 33:04Which is, in my opinion, what every candidate should be doing anyways, rather than trying to
- 33:09get out the vote of three people that already vote to vote for them.
- 33:14Now they have to talk to those people and the independents and the other people in their
- 33:19party and everybody that will have a say in that primary.
- 33:24And so it's going to be very interesting to see what the outcome is going to be, because the
- 33:29next time we're going to use this system, which is going to be the first time we're going to
- 33:33use this system, is going to be the twenty twenty six primaries for the state where a
- 33:40handful of state representatives are going to be up for reelection.
- 33:43Our governor is up for election.
- 33:46We're going to have a primary for a few other seats, I believe.
- 33:52I don't have a full list in front of me, but so the governor's race is what everyone is paying
- 33:57attention to right now.
- 33:59Because there's a progressive Democrat, and the first indigenous person to hold the office of
- 34:06secretary of interior for the Biden administration is running for governor.
- 34:10And then our district attorney, is also running for governor.
- 34:15So there's like a little divide of progressive versus kind of moderate Democrat happening
- 34:20right now.
- 34:21So the this primary should be very interesting to see, who the voters, especially the
- 34:26independents favor.
- 34:28Right.
- 34:28And because, governor Michelle Lujan Grisham, she's term limited.
- 34:32Right?
- 34:33Correct.
- 34:34K.
- 34:34Gotcha.
- 34:35So, obviously, because she was involved because she had to sign the bill, let's get a little
- 34:43bit into the actual legislative process.
- 34:46And there's actually kind of multiple questions in one.
- 34:48So let just to make this easier to to go through, I'll I'll just focus on one specific
- 34:54piece.
- 34:55So let's let listeners peer under the hood a little bit, so to speak, at the finer workings
- 35:00of this process because you were so heavily involved in getting this bill passed.
- 35:06So give me some sense of and we'll try to hopefully get back to some of the previous
- 35:12instances that you tried to get a bill passed, and it and it wasn't quite as successful just
- 35:17to compare, to today.
- 35:19But first, let's look at the successful venture this time around.
- 35:25So how difficult was it to get this bill passed?
- 35:27I know you talked a little bit about it with the whole sixty day and thirty day legislation.
- 35:32So just a little bit more in-depth about how difficult it was to get this bill passed.
- 35:38It was this year was not as difficult as previous years because we were so prepared.
- 35:46We had an entire strategy.
- 35:48We knew exactly which committees we were going to.
- 35:51We knew exactly which votes we needed because we had a previous, floor vote from the senate
- 35:56from previous years.
- 35:58That was extremely helpful to have unsuccessful sessions in the past to have that data and look
- 36:05at it and say, okay.
- 36:07Like, the top five people voted yes.
- 36:09We need these three people to vote yes and, you know, so on and so forth.
- 36:13So, like, strategically, this session was actually pretty easy.
- 36:18The hardest part of any legislative session is being patient because this is New Mexico.
- 36:25We call it the land of Manana, which means the land of tomorrow.
- 36:29So you have to sit there and wait until tomorrow comes, and then the smallest little
- 36:36update comes to you and you're like, great, I can work with that.
- 36:40And so it's very patience oriented and like, you have to know the right people.
- 36:47You have to have connections.
- 36:49It's very, very connections oriented.
- 36:51So for us to be able to hire a lobbyist that was full time there with me every single day,
- 36:57who had connections that I didn't.
- 36:59And then when he didn't have the relationships and that I could just step in and fill, fill in
- 37:04the gap.
- 37:04So that was incredibly important.
- 37:07Plus we had worked for the past year and a half to build a coalition of organizations.
- 37:13So it wasn't just a New Mexico open elections issue.
- 37:16It was an entire like community issue that we all cared about.
- 37:20And we had diverse voices there.
- 37:22We had veterans groups.
- 37:24We had young people.
- 37:25We had NM native vote.
- 37:27We had the Asian American, family center for New Mexico and everybody pitched in as much as
- 37:34they could.
- 37:34And that just made a huge, huge difference.
- 37:38Gotcha.
- 37:39So actually, you you kind of just went into a little bit of of the next question that I was
- 37:43just gonna ask is how did the, alliances and opposition stack up a little bit more?
- 37:48Like, any other particular groups that might have stood out besides, like, those veteran
- 37:54groups, or the, the Pueblo villages that you were talking about?
- 37:59Actual elected officials, was it a was it a pretty bipartisan push then, or what was there
- 38:06also a bipartisan pushback?
- 38:08Was it mostly one party?
- 38:09Are any particular or are there legislative leaders that led opposition or alliance with
- 38:16it?
- 38:17Walk me a little bit through more of some of, like, the particular, prominent players in
- 38:23elected office, whether they were allied with your movement or against it.
- 38:31In terms of our allies, we were, again, super strategic with who we wanted on our coalition
- 38:39as our sponsors.
- 38:40We wanted leadership, and particularly from the senate to hop on board and sponsor this bill.
- 38:48So we got Senate leader, Peter Wirth, who is a Democrat who has served for many years.
- 38:53He was one of our major sponsors.
- 38:55And for leadership to sponsor anything is huge.
- 38:59And we had met with him multiple times.
- 39:01He was supportive.
- 39:02He said he would like go out of his way and speak to committee chairs and his colleagues
- 39:09about this issue, which again, for a leadership role in any chamber is huge because they
- 39:15already have a full stack of things that they have to deal with on a daily basis.
- 39:19And so for him to prioritize semi open primaries was a game changer for us.
- 39:26And then we also had sponsors who were, very invested in this issue, who knew a lot about
- 39:34the issue, who could defend this bill on the floor and on their own without the expertise
- 39:39that we brought to the table.
- 39:41So like building that trust was very important.
- 39:45And then in the house, we had some more progressive Democrats that we really needed
- 39:50because as you may know, people who tend to oppose things like this issue tend to be on the
- 39:56fringes of, of the parties.
- 39:59And so we wanted a, like I said, young, progressive facing coalition and sponsorship
- 40:06because we live in New Mexico, which is a dem majority state.
- 40:10They're almost in a super majority.
- 40:13So we really needed as many Democrats as we could get on our side.
- 40:17And so we really needed to convince those progressive Democrats that were like, Oh, I
- 40:21don't want people voting in my primary to, to around.
- 40:25So we had great leadership from Representatives, Kate, Parajon, and Rubio, who
- 40:31are all, you know, from here, they get the issue.
- 40:35They work with diverse organizations.
- 40:38And so we really needed them to be champions of this bill, which they were.
- 40:43And then in terms of the coalition, we had Common Cause New Mexico, which for those
- 40:48listening out there, like tap into your local Common Cause organization.
- 40:52They're amazing.
- 40:52They have so much information and support and they always need people to be involved.
- 40:59And then, like you said, Paul, we had NM Native Vote, which is the indigenous serving
- 41:05organization.
- 41:06They do get out the vote every single year and they came to us and said, Hey, we keep hearing
- 41:11from our populations that people don't want to register with a party.
- 41:17There's already so much mistrust with the government.
- 41:19Why would they pick a party?
- 41:21And so, and then they don't get to vote in the primaries.
- 41:24And majority of young Indigenous voters, 40% of them are registered independent.
- 41:31So this was a huge important issue for And then, as I was mentioning, the New Mexico Asian
- 41:36Family Center, they also got data from their national partners saying that, like they saw an
- 41:44increase in independent registration within the Asian American community as well.
- 41:50And that when they did get out the vote and, you know, monitored polling locations where
- 41:56Asian Americans were voting in New Mexico, a lot of people were telling them like, no, I
- 42:01don't want to party.
- 42:02I just want to vote.
- 42:03And so this became super important for them.
- 42:06And like I was saying earlier as well, we, we were probably the only bill that was able to
- 42:11mobilize a healthy group of young people, through the young Democrats and the UNM college
- 42:19Democrats, which some of them were independent voters, but they just wanted to be part of a
- 42:24club.
- 42:25And so they joined the college Democrats group and they sent letters and made phone calls to
- 42:31legislators and talked to them for us.
- 42:33And so, and like they wrote op eds for us and stuff like that.
- 42:37So it was amazing to see just the, the love and passion they had to, to be participating in the
- 42:45process.
- 42:47And then for opposition, there wasn't that much like organized effort against this.
- 42:58The sad part was that this has always been a bipartisan support, bipartisan opposition bill.
- 43:05But this year we lost a lot of our bipartisan support from the Republican side, even though
- 43:10it still passed, like, on bipartisan lines.
- 43:13It wasn't as strong as we wanted it to be because the New Mexico Republican party opposed
- 43:19this bill passionately this year, and they always have, but this year felt more strong
- 43:27than before.
- 43:28And they were constantly sending mailers.
- 43:31They were making phone calls to county clerks, telling them to call elected officials to tell
- 43:36them to vote no on this bill and threatening them to, like, primary them if they vote for
- 43:42this and stuff like that.
- 43:43So it got way out of hand, towards the end there, because towards the end, they found out
- 43:49that we were actually going to pass this bill.
- 43:52So it was really sad to lose some of our, like, best supporters on the Republican side on our
- 43:59house vote.
- 44:00But at the end of the day, the bill passed, and we'll still continue building that trust and
- 44:06relationship with our elected officials and, you know, reassure them that, like, this is a
- 44:12good bill.
- 44:13This is not going to hurt anyone.
- 44:15Like, this isn't trying to raid anyone's party primary.
- 44:19Just, you know, repeating the arguments that we've been since the beginning.
- 44:24And then another group of opposition that I wasn't even expecting was a handful of campaign
- 44:30managers reached out to some legislators, you know, just questioning the bill and their
- 44:37support on it.
- 44:38And I was able to talk to a few of them and, you know, give some ease to their minds about
- 44:43this bill.
- 44:45But that was also very interesting to see, like who the players are that really cared about
- 44:50this change.
- 44:53What I just continue to tell people is like, Hey, you already reach out to independent
- 44:59voters in the general election as a campaign manager, as a candidate.
- 45:03So why not just do it a little bit earlier in the year in the primary?
- 45:07And then you'll just have even more support for the general because more people will be voting
- 45:11for your candidate.
- 45:13And so I think that helped a little bit, but I was not expecting to have campaign managers
- 45:19like, contacting a position.
- 45:21So that was that was very interesting.
- 45:24Yeah.
- 45:24Because that's that's not usually I mean, mean, they obviously do get involved to some extent
- 45:29in the legislative process, but not you wouldn't necessarily expect it to be to that
- 45:34degree.
- 45:34And also kind of interesting, and this is purely a knee jerk from the outside looking in
- 45:39considering that, as you mentioned before, is a it's a pretty decidedly democratic state.
- 45:47What what I thought that Republicans might be a little bit more amenable to it because of
- 45:52their, to the bill because of their disadvantaged state.
- 45:55But but, obviously, I'm not you're obviously a lot more privy to more of the details, than
- 46:01than I am in that regard.
- 46:03But still, just just from, like, initial reaction, that is interesting that a lot more
- 46:09of the opposition came on that side compared to democrats.
- 46:12But was it there was still, like, a pretty decent republican support of the bill then, or
- 46:18was was was that fairly muted?
- 46:21In the senate, yes.
- 46:23It was fairly more, you know, bipartisan.
- 46:27But in the house, we were expecting at least 10 votes from Republicans, which I believe there's
- 46:3326 of them.
- 46:34And we only got two.
- 46:36Oh, wow.
- 46:37And that all flipped like in the moment on the floor as they were voting.
- 46:42And like you said, Paul, like there was a Senator, her name is Senator Crystal Brantley.
- 46:47Her main argument on the floor, and she was a huge supporter of this bill, was what more do
- 46:53we have to lose as the Republican Party and as Republican candidates?
- 46:58Like, they're already in the minority.
- 47:00They don't have a single statewide elected official.
- 47:03What more did they have to lose?
- 47:05But because the party just put so much pressure on them to not support this, most of them
- 47:11didn't end up doing so.
- 47:13Okay.
- 47:13Her her name is one I I do, know about.
- 47:18I mean, I I don't know know about a whole lot about her, but she hers is a name I I am
- 47:23familiar with.
- 47:24Kinda made me think of, this actually was something I had been involved a little bit
- 47:30with, and, you were talking about way way back in the beginning about, grad school and, the
- 47:37internship I I had to do in grad school.
- 47:40But, long story short, we had some involvement in the in the US senate race in Massachusetts
- 47:46that year, and the it was just odd to see the Republican whether again, I'm not saying
- 47:53whether I support or oppose any of this candidate's particular views, but the
- 47:59Republican candidate in Massachusetts was pretty starkly pro Trump, which seemed like
- 48:05didn't seem like a very viable strategy in a very blue state like Massachusetts.
- 48:11But I I guess, you know, it's that calculus of it's some maybe something similar in New Mexico
- 48:16where there's just something about their strategy.
- 48:19They think that this is the way to go about things.
- 48:22In in your case, going against against your bill, you you know, you never know how some
- 48:26people see a situation that even if they're not necessarily whether whether you agree with them
- 48:35on on things or not, just sometimes even just the calculation of strategy sometimes can be
- 48:41just so starkly different.
- 48:42It can be interesting to see how people regard that.
- 48:46So it's funny that you talked about this New Mexico state government being the land of
- 48:52Manana.
- 48:53I think a lot of people who are involved in other state government processes could
- 48:58empathize both Republican and Democrat.
- 49:01So did this did the process of this bill take the just to clarify, did it take the entire
- 49:08legislative session to get it over the finish line?
- 49:10Because you did talk talk about how it required a lot of patience, or was it most of the
- 49:14session?
- 49:16Basically, just how long was the process for getting it over the finish line?
- 49:21Paul, it was literally from day one to day zero.
- 49:24Like, it
- 49:24Oh, there you go.
- 49:25The entire time, which is crazy because people will come up to you and say, Hey, don't worry.
- 49:32I've passed bills in four days before.
- 49:34I'm like, nearly how?
- 49:36Because we pre filed the bill.
- 49:40So the bill existed before session even started.
- 49:44And then on the first day of session, you get assigned a bill number.
- 49:47And then from then you go on.
- 49:49So just for the listeners, we have two chambers, the house and the Senate.
- 49:54And in each chamber, depending on where you start the bill, which we started in the Senate,
- 49:58which is why it's Senate Bill 16.
- 50:01And we had two committees in each chamber.
- 50:03We already knew that.
- 50:05We worked with leadership to make sure that that was still the case.
- 50:08And our first hearing took two whole weeks to be And that's up to the chair's discretion.
- 50:16It's up to what other things they have going on as a committee.
- 50:19And like, as soon as we got out of that committee, it was quick.
- 50:24We got out of the Senate within the next, I want to say week and a half.
- 50:29So second Senate committee hearing, Senate floor hearing, we were out.
- 50:34And then it took a little bit longer to get our second house committee hearing.
- 50:40Our first house committee hearing was also pretty quick.
- 50:43As long as you're like red on the floor that day, you could be scheduled as early as that
- 50:47day if your committee meets in the afternoon.
- 50:52But our second committee hearing in the house also took about two whole weeks to just be
- 50:58scheduled.
- 50:59And then towards the end of session, you start getting into your late evenings because there's
- 51:04longer floor debates in the middle of the day.
- 51:08And so we got out of our last committee at 12:30AM on like a And then we were just sitting
- 51:20and waiting for that to be scheduled on the house floor and house floor leadership was
- 51:25supportive, but they don't schedule things unless they know you have the votes.
- 51:30So we had our own WIP tracker.
- 51:32We gave it to the WIP.
- 51:33She was supposed to like go and like reconfirm all the votes that we thought we had.
- 51:40And that was not possible until the bill was already on the floor and we were already being
- 51:46voted upon as they were whipping.
- 51:49And so it was just the most chaotic hour and a half of my life, being on the house floor and
- 51:55seeing the, like the big screen on the wall.
- 51:59It's like green and red, and it just constantly kept changing to green, red, green, red.
- 52:03And then it was 33 to 36 votes.
- 52:06That's how close we were.
- 52:08Oh, wow.
- 52:09Wow.
- 52:10That is that is fascinating.
- 52:11And, you know, I I think the the one of the things that people out you know, those of us
- 52:18who are not or people who are not involved in politics like you or I, I think one of the
- 52:22things that people are least privy to is just how the political agenda works is, you know,
- 52:29all the ways.
- 52:30Sometimes there's just a lot of other pressing things that get put on the agenda and something
- 52:34sometimes people, if they really don't want a piece of legislation her heard, but they they
- 52:40feel that they're gonna lose, they'll sometimes try whatever they can to get it pushed down the
- 52:44agenda so there's just no time to hear it.
- 52:46Really just fascinating and and dirty, just some of the ways that people use to try to make
- 52:54something just not not even not necessarily not just pass, but not even get heard.
- 52:59And you you said that it's a pretty relatively short legislative session there.
- 53:06We, in Florida's Florida's actually is let's go in a little bit of overtime because it's it's
- 53:11they have a state budget issues to work out.
- 53:14But, usually, the session would actually be ending today.
- 53:19But you just, again, just goes back to how does the political agenda work and how long
- 53:24legislative sessions are.
- 53:27But earlier, talked a little bit about how I wanted to try to compare this to previous
- 53:32efforts that you had.
- 53:33And I was gonna ask you if this was your first legislative bill that you were so closely
- 53:37involved with.
- 53:37We established that it's not.
- 53:39But with other legisl other times that you have tried to push this or even not necessarily just
- 53:45open primary stuff, but any other legislation that you may have been involved in.
- 53:50But I I guess maybe the op comparing it to other open primaries attempts might be a little
- 53:56bit easier to compare to.
- 53:58What what exactly was similar and different about the times you tried to push it then
- 54:06versus now besides the fact that, obviously, now you have more experience with it?
- 54:11Yeah.
- 54:13I would say that previous years, we really didn't walk into the building with a strategy.
- 54:21We walked into the building with a bill and we said, we're just going to see how far it goes.
- 54:27And we really weren't allowed to be there for too long because we were a five zero
- 54:34one(three).
- 54:35So per IRS regulations, had like very limited capacity for lobbying and money.
- 54:42And so this year we founded a five zero one(four) which is unlimited lobbying and you
- 54:49can play in campaigns if you want to.
- 54:53So that enabled us so much more access to the roundhouse.
- 54:58Again, I was there every single day from eight to midnight sometimes.
- 55:03And so that was just a huge game changer because we had a strategy.
- 55:08We knew exactly what we needed to do because of the experience.
- 55:11And then we were able to be there every day because sometimes you don't know, and someone's
- 55:16in a committee that you really need to talk to and you text them and they're like, okay, come
- 55:22here at 07:30PM.
- 55:24So it was so much easier for me to have direct access to the roundhouse to be like, okay, I'm
- 55:30gonna I'm gonna run and go talk to this person now.
- 55:34Whereas, again, in previous years, we were like, here's a bill.
- 55:37We have a sponsor.
- 55:38Let's go get them, which is very, you know, grassroots of us because that's how we were
- 55:45founded and how we started, and that's how any good idea starts.
- 55:48But if you are dedicated to getting it passed and done, absolutely need a C4.
- 55:56You need funding for that C4.
- 55:58You need smart people to surround yourself with, like the lobbyists that we hired and the
- 56:03coalition that we built and good sponsors that we were able to identify.
- 56:09And so I think that was just the hugest game changer.
- 56:12And then also another issue that we supported this year was legislative modernization.
- 56:19We call it that, but it's basically creating an independent salary commission for our
- 56:24legislators because we are the only unsalaried legislature in the country.
- 56:30These people are there from their own time, spending their own money to be there, which
- 56:36makes it incredibly inaccessible for 99% of New Mexicans to run for office and to be elected
- 56:42and to serve.
- 56:44So that was another bill that we were supporting.
- 56:46It unfortunately died in its second committee, even though it passed its first committee
- 56:51unanimously.
- 56:53I was not as involved as I would have liked to be because our top priority was open primaries.
- 56:59And usually we had committees at the same time or we were lobbying at the same time.
- 57:04So I couldn't like double dip and help other people as much as I wanted to.
- 57:11And this effort was being run by the Common Cause of New Mexico, which doesn't have, C4
- 57:18funding, even though they do have a C4.
- 57:21So you can have staff there, but then you can't pay them to be there because C3 can't pay for
- 57:27C4 lobbying, you know?
- 57:30And so there was a lot of like limitations in that area as well.
- 57:35And I really think like pairing salaries with open primaries would make elections a little
- 57:41bit more competitive because more people could run for office now and more people would be
- 57:46voting.
- 57:47So like, to me, that's the best of both worlds where we would have better representative
- 57:51elected officials if we had salaries with open primaries.
- 57:56And I think, you know, the downfalls of that was kind of what you were saying, Paul, with
- 58:00the back end politics, like behind the curtain stuff that we really don't see, because that
- 58:06bill tied in a committee, which means it's dead unless someone wasn't there.
- 58:11They come back and they are a yes vote.
- 58:13Then they can bring the bill back.
- 58:15But they really wanted like to negotiate things.
- 58:19It was a Republican and like, they wanted different things from leadership and leadership
- 58:24wasn't willing to budge on certain things.
- 58:27And so, and, but that one is an amendment, so that could be introduced whenever.
- 58:32And I'm really excited to work with Common Cause to see like what we can explore in that
- 58:38area.
- 58:40But yeah, it's a messy, messy system.
- 58:45Yeah.
- 58:45You just talked to, but not to go too far off track, you were talking about the fact that New
- 58:53Mexico legislators don't have a salary.
- 58:55I believe they have a per diem.
- 58:56Right?
- 58:57Yeah.
- 58:57They get a hundred something dollars a day.
- 59:00Yeah.
- 59:01Because I I a previous episode of the of the podcast, like, a couple months ago or
- 59:07something, I I I talked about full time versus part time legislators and, you know, I I I I
- 59:14know about New Mexico's before, but obviously doing more in-depth research for that.
- 59:19Was just like, man, I can't believe they don't get paid, like, anything.
- 59:22And then you you compare it to something like, California and New York are the the two states
- 59:27where the legislators get paid 6 figures, but they're also in have a much longer, legislative
- 59:33session, but still just fascinating to to see the how how much the 50 states can differ.
- 59:40And, the the four zero one or, excuse me, five zero ones, c three, and c four.
- 59:45So, really, thank you for all that bit of insight, not just for listeners, but, you know,
- 59:49I learned I learned stuff, plenty of times interviewing guests too.
- 59:53So it's it's it's really just fascinating to see all those, differences.
- 59:58So now moving past the endeavor that you just undertook and now looking towards the future,
- 1:00:06what do you see as the impact of this change for New Mexico primary systems being beyond the
- 1:00:13state's borders?
- 1:00:14Are you hoping more states follow suit in enacting the same kind of system or at least
- 1:00:18just ending their closed primary status?
- 1:00:20Do you think it's gonna have a tidal wave effect for lack of a better term?
- 1:00:27And are you gonna have any involvement with those efforts, or are you mostly just focused
- 1:00:31on New Mexico and implementing other changes to the New Mexico system of politics?
- 1:00:40Yeah.
- 1:00:41So we are definitely going to get into a very intensive, like I said, public education
- 1:00:47campaign to let the 300,000 people know that they can now vote and being the only second
- 1:00:55state to do this through a legislature.
- 1:00:57I do hope that it lights like a beacon of hope for other States that have maybe tried ballot
- 1:01:04initiatives, but not legislative processes before to give it a shot.
- 1:01:09I mean, on average, it takes the bill ten years to pass.
- 1:01:12And literally this is the tenth year that we have introduced this So hopefully it doesn't
- 1:01:17take people that long in other states because of their previous, like, ballot initiative
- 1:01:23efforts.
- 1:01:25But we really do hope that this, you know, gives some form of hope to all the election
- 1:01:30reformers out there because we know last year was pretty tough with the ballot initiative
- 1:01:35losses in seven states.
- 1:01:38And but, like, the one big huge win was Washington DC as a city passed ranked choice in
- 1:01:44open primary, so that was huge.
- 1:01:47Shout out to Lisa Rice.
- 1:01:48She led an amazing campaign.
- 1:01:51And she was actually one of my, like, icons in this in this field.
- 1:01:56If you haven't interviewed her, I highly recommend.
- 1:01:59She's amazing.
- 1:02:00What's her name again?
- 1:02:01Sorry.
- 1:02:01Lisa Rice.
- 1:02:02Lisa Rice.
- 1:02:03Okay.
- 1:02:03I'll I'll definitely have to look her up then.
- 1:02:05Yeah.
- 1:02:06And, you know, that gave me so much inspiration to say like, we could do this too.
- 1:02:12And if we like build a good coalition, if we follow all the, you know, steps that we need
- 1:02:17to, and lo and behold, we did.
- 1:02:19And so if other states are interested, I would love to be as supportive as I can.
- 1:02:25I hope to, you know, my future career five to ten years from now to be able to work in this
- 1:02:31field nationally and help other states, accomplish their goals and see like which form
- 1:02:39of primary is best fitting for their state and their state's needs.
- 1:02:43Like I was saying about my favorite form of open primaries, any form of open primary.
- 1:02:49So, I think that we could definitely learn from each other and build a lot.
- 1:02:57And hopefully more states will have open primaries.
- 1:03:00I know a majority of states have some form of open primary, but there's still too many states
- 1:03:05with closed primaries, and we can hopefully change that.
- 1:03:09Alright.
- 1:03:10Okay.
- 1:03:11Before we, I think that's a nice segue into the final question about open primaries and then
- 1:03:18one final final question.
- 1:03:21Any besides that, any final thoughts you want to leave with us with about open primaries?
- 1:03:31I guess my one final thought is the whole point of why we did this, why we've been doing this,
- 1:03:37and why we are extremely excited to continue working on this is so that people can vote
- 1:03:46because this is a country that was built on democracy and people's rights and any form of
- 1:03:54open primary just reinforces that parties are not included in the constitution, but people
- 1:04:01are.
- 1:04:02And I think that we just need to go back and see that and figure out how we can continue
- 1:04:09building upon this wind, which was huge, not just for us, but for our country, and get more
- 1:04:16people involved in the process and make voting more easier in a time when so many people are
- 1:04:22trying to make it more difficult.
- 1:04:24I think this just is so much more important now than it was before.
- 1:04:29All right.
- 1:04:30Well, there yeah.
- 1:04:30There's the there's the mic drop on on open primaries here.
- 1:04:34I think that that'll certainly resonate with a a lot of people there.
- 1:04:38So that is the end for the open primary segment.
- 1:04:41So now one final question.
- 1:04:44I like to whenever I have a guest, I like to end on a random fun nonpolitical question
- 1:04:49because it's not always about politics.
- 1:04:50I like to be well rounded individuals here.
- 1:04:54And I think New Mexico would be a particularly good state for this because even though I've
- 1:04:58never been to New Mexico, I've been to I told you a little bit earlier before we started to
- 1:05:03have a little bit of family in Arizona, but the the physical the beauty of of the states in the
- 1:05:11Southwest is something I find very fascinating.
- 1:05:13So even though I have yet to visit New Mexico, maybe for whenever I do, I've seen some
- 1:05:19pictures of some amazing landscape out there in that part of the country, and I just like
- 1:05:24delving into places, history, and and and just the physical beauty of it all.
- 1:05:29So what are give me two to three landmarks, parks, cities, whatever it is that you would
- 1:05:35recommend visitors to New Mexico to go over to.
- 1:05:38And I'll I'll I'll give a few for for my state.
- 1:05:41Okay.
- 1:05:42So for New Mexico, and this is extremely special to me because I just recently went
- 1:05:47there for the first time, is our Carlsbad Caverns in Southern New Mexico.
- 1:05:54It looks like it's another planet.
- 1:05:56Like, it does not belong on the planet Earth.
- 1:05:59It is beautiful.
- 1:06:00It is just so magical.
- 1:06:03And I highly recommend hiking down and then taking the elevator up so you don't have to
- 1:06:08hike all the way back up because it is a bit of a walk.
- 1:06:11Yeah.
- 1:06:12But it's just gorgeous.
- 1:06:14And if you go during bat season, you can watch the bats, like, come out during sunset.
- 1:06:19I did not get to see the bats.
- 1:06:21But and then right around the corner from there is White Sands National Monument.
- 1:06:28It is also just, again, otherworldly.
- 1:06:31It is miles and miles and miles of just white sand that looks like snow, and you can rent a
- 1:06:38little sled and go sledding, and you can have a little picnic.
- 1:06:42You can take beautiful sunset pictures there, and you can literally spend all day there and
- 1:06:47not know that you did that.
- 1:06:49And they're luckily close by each other.
- 1:06:51And right in the middle of them is probably one of my favorite barbecue spots in Cloudcroft,
- 1:06:56New Mexico.
- 1:06:58So highly like, there's only one.
- 1:07:00So when you go there, you'll know which one.
- 1:07:02Okay.
- 1:07:03So, I mean, I'm a central kind of Northern New Mexico girly, but I love Southern New Mexico so
- 1:07:09much.
- 1:07:10There's amazing things to do.
- 1:07:12And the caverns have so much special, like conspiracies and stories, and it used to be,
- 1:07:19like, underwater.
- 1:07:21Our state used to be underwater, but now we're one of the biggest deserts of this country.
- 1:07:25So it's really cool to see, like, all the fossils and stuff like that.
- 1:07:30But yeah.
- 1:07:31Yeah.
- 1:07:32I I I like a good harmless conspiracy as long as people are not actually suffering any sort
- 1:07:38of injury from it.
- 1:07:39I like a good harmless conspiracy just how crazy some of it can get.
- 1:07:45Carlsbad just made me think of even though it's not a cavern.
- 1:07:47If you ever make it to South Dakota because my my maternal grandfather is from there, it just
- 1:07:55kinda made me think of talk about otherworldly going to see the Badlands National Park for, at
- 1:08:00sunset is whether it for any place I've been to or suggest seeing pictures of, it's one of the
- 1:08:06most beautiful places I've ever seen.
- 1:08:08But for for my state, Florida, I will definitely if you ever find yourself in this
- 1:08:13neck of the woods, obviously, I'm a Tampa Bay Area guy, so I'll I'll vouch for the Tampa Bay
- 1:08:18Area in general.
- 1:08:19But, really nice city to go to, and there's still a lot of Florida that I have yet to see.
- 1:08:24But, I always recommend anybody to go to Saint Augustine, which is the up in Northeast
- 1:08:30Florida.
- 1:08:31It is what it is the longest trying to think of the specific term.
- 1:08:36It's the longest continuously settled or consensually lived in settlement founded by
- 1:08:42Europeans in the continent.
- 1:08:45So it is it is is incredible to go see that, see the oldest street in, North America.
- 1:08:50Just incredible stuff to go see.
- 1:08:53But there's there's all sorts of things to go see in Florida too.
- 1:08:56So but whenever I make it to New Mexico, I will definitely go check out, Carlsbad and the was
- 1:09:01it the White Rock National Monument?
- 1:09:03Which
- 1:09:03one?
- 1:09:03White
- 1:09:04Sands.
- 1:09:05White Sands.
- 1:09:06Gotcha.
- 1:09:06So, yay, you you make it out to New Mexico.
- 1:09:09For those of you listening at home, you definitely go ahead and and check those places
- 1:09:13out.
- 1:09:13But that is gonna wrap things up today for the politics with Paul podcast.
- 1:09:17Once again, Nicola, thank you so much for coming on to talk talk with us about all things
- 1:09:24open primaries.
- 1:09:25We'll see how this if this starts to feed into other states.
- 1:09:31Floor my my state, Florida, is also a closed primary state, so we'll see maybe if it has
- 1:09:36some impact there on and in other states, and definitely stay tuned for all of that.
- 1:09:41So once again, to all of you listening, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:09:44Oh, I'll also links in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, my Medium page, my my my
- 1:09:51self published book on Amazon actually talks a little bit about independence, why independence
- 1:09:56rarely win elections, and I could they how they can become more competitive.
- 1:10:00Silla, I I almost forgot to ask you.
- 1:10:03Any other links that you want to share before we go?
- 1:10:08If you're listening from New Mexico, visit nmvotersfirst.org to see how you can get
- 1:10:13involved and support us.
- 1:10:15We truly love everyone participating.
- 1:10:18And especially if you know independent voters in New Mexico, please send them our way.
- 1:10:22We would love to connect with them.
- 1:10:24All right.
- 1:10:24Well, there you go.
- 1:10:25Once again, everybody, thank you so much for watching and listening, and until next time,
- 1:10:30take care.