Latest / Putting the AI in MRKTNG / Uncorking a Crisis: Can AI Rescue the U.S. Wine Industry
Transcript
- Fall Foliage VO: For decades, the wine industry thrived on baby boomers, face-to-face experiences, and great stories. It was a dinner with friends, a visit to a tasting room, a handshake, and a glass of wine with the winemaker. Then COVID hit, and everything changed. Wineries closed, restaurants closed, consumer habits shifted. And younger generations weren't embracing wine. But the big harvests they kept coming. Today, wineries are merging. Some are closing, some simply abandoned. For those still open, they're leaving grapes on the vine because it's actually cheaper than harvesting. Let that sink in for a minute. In 2025, direct-to-consumer wine shipments in the US declined 15%, with $230 million in lost sales. Yet Silicon Valley Bank's 2026 direct-to-consumer wine report revealed a striking performance gap. The top 25% of surveyed wineries grew DTC revenue by 22%, while the bottom 25% experienced a 13% decline. So how did an industry that seemed unstoppable get here? Are millennials to blame? GLP1s? Gummies? My guest is Skip Carabian, general manager at Michele Schlumberger He's a 30-year veteran who's seen it all, heard it all, tasted it all. And worked with some of the best known wine brands and winemakers and personalities, I might add, across Sonoma County and Napa Valley, including Duckhorn, Hudson Ranch, Elizabeth Spencer, Regusci, and Wilson Daniels. All right, Skip, great to see ya. How are you today? Skip Karabian: I'm good. How are you, Chris? Fall Foliage VO: I'm doing good on this Aloha Friday. And since we are recording on a Friday, I thought, what better opportunity to do some maybe afternoon drinking? So I have poured myself something a little local. I've got a little Grassini Pinot Grigio with me to enjoy during our conversation. And I'm assuming you're probably drinking the house, the house palate, as we like to say. Pretty. Skip Karabian: I I too, I too have something here with me. I've got a little Bordeaux red called Quatre Foil that is part of our Michele Schlumberger Estate wines. you know, we're a Bordeaux winery and so a Bordeaux blend like that that's predominantly Cabernet with a little bit of Malbec and Merlot is is right up, you know, right up the Friday afternoon alley. And I know that's what most people perceive those of us Fall Foliage VO: I like it. Skip Karabian: in the wine industry are doing most of the time anyway. So why not? Fall Foliage VO: But a little a little less known secret for those outside of the wine industry, we would probably be drinking tequila or something brown. Skip Karabian: We we definitely would would have our feet up and a little tequila in the glass. Fall Foliage VO: There we go. There we go. Well, good to see ya. Listen, you and I have been we've been, you know, part of the wine industry, either directly or indirectly for a number of years now. And I wanted to have this conversation, on the podcast because it's something you and I have been talking about for a long, long time. You've you've been in the business for 30 years, you you've seen it all, you've done it all, you know, across DTC, hospitality, wholesale, you know, even farming. Give us the lay of the land, Skip. I mean, just how bad is it today with this downturn? How long has it been building? Skip Karabian: It's it's very interesting that that you know, I mean, we haven't seen these these this kind of confluence circumstances in the 30 years that I've been in the business. And when you talk to people, which I frequently do that have been in the business a lot longer than I have, they too, you know, will say that they've never seen this. you know, it is certainly the most challenging era of the wine industry. And it's a, it's, you know, kind of the merging of a lot of challenges that have come together at the same time. It is, you know, I'm, I don't know that I would say that I'm an eternal optimist because I don't know that that's that would be a fair assessment Fall Foliage VO: Ha ha ha. Skip Karabian: of me. But at the same time, you know, there's always positives. There's, there's always things that you can look at and say that, that, you know, we're going to work our way through this and we're going to get out of it. But it is, hard to deny that it is the most challenging time that we've seen. And, you know, I mean, there's a there's a lot of of negative activity out there that we are, you know, just have to take time and and focus to work through. Fall Foliage VO: Well, I I know you're an eternal optimist because you're a San Francisco Giants fan. You've got you've got no choice, my friend. You had a run. You had a good run. Skip Karabian: We had our we had a period. We had a period that rewarded that optimism. It's just not recently. Fall Foliage VO: I know, I hear ya. Well, hey, let's peel back the onion then a little bit. Let's talk about some of the different drivers. And I have to assume that there was an effect, w with with COVID, with the pandemic, but it probably started before even the pandemic. I'm I'm gonna guess. Skip Karabian: COVID actually masked a number of the factors that were, yeah, that that Fall Foliage VO: No pun intended. Skip Karabian: they went somewhat unnoticed and they covered up what was, you know, kind of those little signs of the the chink in the armor. And it it created, you know, a very different moment of all of a sudden, you know, people were at home and they were drinking. And they were consuming, they weren't going to restaurants. And so the the kind of the metrics of what was happening were were very hard to to you know kind of read through at that moment because Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: their activity was unlike anything we'd ever been able to see. And so that that decrease in demand that we've seen since was very much masked by people being at home and consumption and and going out to or ordering through retail and and people people using those moments of being at home to enjoy a glass of wine. But what's happened after that is we've seen generational shifts, we've seen Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: you know, we've seen an oversupply when that you know, when production wasn't adjusted because of what had been seen during COVID, people just kind of kept doing what they were doing. And They didn't see the signs of, hey, there is some weakening of consumption here. And we need to identify that and decrease the amount that we're producing. And that Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: created, you know, some of the circumstances that we're seeing now. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Well, y you know, with the wine industry, it's been about experiential marketing, right? Meaning either you're gonna taste wine, enjoy brands at a restaurant, or you're gonna come to the winery itself and do a tasting. But it was always about an experience. And before COVID, you could do that. During COVID, you could not do that. What happened after COVID? Did you start to see people coming back to the wineries and the tasting rooms and restaurants? And then was there even a shift, you know, when things really opened up when myself Skip Karabian: Specifically. Fall Foliage VO: I jumped ship, I got out of the country, I started travelling, abroad instead of domestically. Skip Karabian: It's it's one of the things that that when things opened up, many wineries, because of our physical location, have outdoor facilities. And so when things opened up, the weather actually happened to be nice. And here on the you know, on the west coast, you know it as well as any that you know could you could do wine tasting outside. You were in kind of a semi-lockdown, but people came out. I mean, the the Bay Area came to Napa and Sonoma and and that was an exciting period for many wineries because they've been closed and now all of a sudden they're open and people wanted to get out. But then when the world really opened back up, people did exactly as you said. They hopped on planes, they went to Europe, they did the things that they hadn't really done for a couple of years. And that trend has has continued. I mean, we've heard that Fall Foliage VO: Mm. Skip Karabian: through European experiences of people, you know, flooding Spain and, you know, I mean, just the the Counter of that. Well, that that return to wine tasting and experience, and look, there are other factors, but that hasn't ever really come back. And so the Napa and Sonoma Valleys have really experienced a significant decrease in the visitation that had been part of that person-to-person marketing that was critical to Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: Introducing people to wineries and to Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: you know how you got to know the people behind a brand. And those Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: are the stories that are are critical to this business. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah, yeah. It's it's it's amazing. And we talk a lot about brands and branding and brand strategies, brand promises on this podcast. And you know, that was for for you know, wineries and wine tasting rooms, delivering on that brand promise was bringing people in, letting them meet a Dan Duckhorn or a Margaret Duckhorn or a Bruce Regalia, whoever it may be at at Duckhorn, and have a glass of wine with them and sit down and shake their hand and hear hear a great story and all of a sudden, you know, you've got them customer for life. Skip Karabian: You know, I mean, I've I've listened to your prior podcasts and and enjoyed them immensely. And Fall Foliage VO: Thank you. Skip Karabian: a lot of that brand discussion is it's about delivering service and delivering connection. And you and I have talked about this because we've done it sitting, you know, Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: sitting at a dinner table, eating, having a glass of wine. That's what this industry is about. That's That's the experience that we bring to people. And the brand is built on sharing that. And it's that individual connection that is so critical. That is branding in the wine industry. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: And, you know, we've without having as many people in front of you, it has created challenges for the industry to find ways to reach those connections. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. We're we're gonna park that because as we start getting in the conversation about AI, I wanna see how you're addressing that. here locally, I'm a I'm a wine club member for different wineries. One of them is Pence, which I really enjoy. and I love their experience when we go up there to pick up wine. Dimitria the same thing. What I'm finding with some of these wineries though, whether we're a member or not, is they're actually leaving Grapes on the vine. it's what is it, November 6th today when we're recording? November 7th. I I'm not sure. But, you know, we're we're probably on the tail end of the harvest. Are you seeing in your region, Sonoma County, Napa Valley, are there also wineries that are leaving grapes on the vine? Are there certain either regions, producers, varietals, maybe even price categories that are getting hit harder and they're just we're just not gonna harvest. Skip Karabian: There was and still is a significant amount of that. And the the more volume-based regions are where it's been the hardest. and the more well-known regions, there is certainly an aspect of that, a significant aspect of that. But there is, it is, you know, the the more that there is is is based surely on location and the it just decreases as you get to the more well-known regions or the more sought after regions. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. Skip Karabian: But it is it is everywhere. It's it's here in Dry Creek, it's in Napa, it's in Sonoma. it is it is a it is a factor. And it's part of the adjustment that the industry is making to the demand and the oversupply that has been a part of the challenge that we're facing. It's it is a simple Fall Foliage VO: Supply and demand. Yeah. Yeah. Fascinating. Skip Karabian: supply and demand curve, and we are working our way through that. One of the challenges, and this is a challenge that a lot of people that don't know the industry real well is that not only do we harvest right now, but we have last year's harvest in the winery and we have the year before before's harvest getting ready to release in bottle. And so the the solutions are not it's not as simple as a commodity. These are years worth of decisions that go, you know, into a a factor of okay, I can scale back, but that scaling back is not going to come for a couple of years. And and that Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Is this Skip Karabian: is really what drives challenges in this industry is is time. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, I didn't mean to cut you there. I was just I was wondering and listening to you, do you have to lower prices to to to move inventory? And maybe not just your winery, but in in general, is that is that a strategy? Skip Karabian: For sure. one of the things that that is a big driver for that is maybe it's not seen directly by consumers as much, but there's what's called the bulk market, which is where essentially wine that was produced a year or two ago is can is sold from one winery to another based on their particular makeup and how they do what they do. And that bulk market, which has always existed. went to a place in the last couple of years where you almost can't give things away. Fall Foliage VO: Mm. Skip Karabian: there is no demand for that aspect of the wine industry, where there's very limited demand. And that is that has created it very challenging for each winery because all of us do need that in some way. But for example, if you produce wine that isn't maybe necessarily to the cut of what you want to put out to someone. It's not your highest quality because this is Mother Nature. It's not perfect. You need an outlet to be able to sell that. If there is no market for it, you're essentially just taking a loss on that. And that Fall Foliage VO: Yeah, yeah. Skip Karabian: has hit wineries very hard. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah, interesting. So we talked about some of the drivers leading up. We talked about COVID, et cetera. so something else has happened just within this last year, and that's the Trump administration and the tariffs, right? So US wineries have been hit by the tariffs. That started back in in March with the Canadian boycott. US wine exports to Canada dropped four hundred and sixty million dollars just in twenty twenty-four alone to 103 million in twenty twenty-five. So if if face-to-face experiences are the way forward, then you know, looking kind of back to the future, how does the industry win back these customers? How how how how do we win back Canada? Skip Karabian: it it's it's it's more complicated than that as well, Chris, because the the tariffs on the surface do affect glass and other things that go as part of producing a bottle of wine. And losing a market like Canada, which is, one of the largest markets for export of West Coast wines, those are significant things. But it's also because of the distribution model, the three-tier model where wines are sold across the country by distributors. Almost every distributor is selling both domestic wines and imports. And when they're dealing with those challenges, that affects their bottom lines and it limits their ability to sell domestic wines, even if there is less demand on import wines. So there are some significant challenges. Yes, people, you know, will come back to wines. Canada will find its way back, but that will take time. And it it Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. It'll take time. Skip Karabian: will require effort and energy to mend the fences that have, you know. have created the the disagreements that that you know essentially caused Canada to empty its shelves of domestic of California produced and West Coast produced wine. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. And bourbons as well. it isn't it's not just wine. Yeah. Yeah. Skip Karabian: Yeah, it's it's it's affected the entire industry dramatically. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. A hundred percent. So I wanna ask you a question. And I don't know if you've got some data to back this up or just what you know, your what your opinion on this is. So I think millennials and Gen Z, it it it it seems pretty clear that they're not embracing wine the way their moms and dads did, their grandparents did that, you know, the previous generations. Has wine lost its relevance with these consumers? And if it has, what what are they doing? what are they replicating? Is is there a pivot to be made here to maybe make non-alcoholic wines? Skip Karabian: There, I just was, I don't have specific figures, but I was literally just at a seminar last week and that that covered this along with many other topics of the wine industry at the current state. And one of the things that that is starting to show signs right now is that no, those younger generations are not foregoing wine. They're just later arriving to it than their Fall Foliage VO: Mm. Skip Karabian: predecessors. And they're Not only later, but they're slower adopting than their predecessors. You know, part of that is the the reality of the the financial status of that era of consumers is that they're reaching their earning years a little bit later. Costs are more, you know, significant to people on that scale currently. Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: And so that has caused them to join. that cohort a little bit more slowly than maybe prior generations. But Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: I think it's, and we'll go back to my optimist statement and and my love for the San Francisco Giants, but that Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: that that yeah you if you know you know Fall Foliage VO: Grab some pine meat. If you know, you know. Skip Karabian: if if you look at that that group They were raised by parents who adopted wine as part of their culture and part of their dining and entertaining experiences. So it's not that they're fully foregoing it and that they have no interest. It's that wine is is expensive. It's not a, you know, it's a hobby for many people that is a is a pricey hobby. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. Skip Karabian: And so it takes a little longer to get into that realm where you are in your area of having the financial means to get more and more invested in it. But again, the optimist in me believes that those people, that generation of people, when they go to a nice restaurant, they're not gonna at some point say, you know, we just we don't drink wine. it's more complicated than that, but they're gonna get to that. And when they Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. Skip Karabian: get to their prime earning years and their years where they are entertaining Fall Foliage VO: Okay. Skip Karabian: more frequently, that will be a part of what they do. Fall Foliage VO: So to address that market, you you talk you talked about costs and things, you know, being expensive. It is an expensive hobby. it didn't used to be a hobby necessarily, it was just a daily way of life for a lot of people. You know, I remember when I could go to Napa with my wife, go up to Sonoma and wine tastings were free, maybe ten bucks. I can remember, you know, living in Napa Valley and going to Sonoma. And Erika as a as a chef, the first executive chef for Duck Horn, we would and she would flash a card and we would take some stick for actually being a winery that was charging for tastings. Now they're 75 bucks, $150 for a tasting isn't unusual. are the wineries doing themselves a disservice and pricing themselves out of this potential younger market? Skip Karabian: it is hard to argue with some of that. Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: And you and I have had this conversation that that Erika and I in some ways take some responsibility for some of that Fall Foliage VO: Yes. Skip Karabian: because we we were in the very early stages of of of Fall Foliage VO: Pioneers of food and wine experiences. Skip Karabian: charging higher you know fees for people coming. But I I will still defend some of that. Has it gone potentially maybe farther than it should have? Yes. But We went back, you and I were just talking about how do we engage those younger people. Part of it is that those experiences are about connecting individually. And the cost of maintaining a winery and the staff and the people involved that are knowledgeable about wine have learned and been through the process to be able to be in front of you and host you and give people An individualized experience, they are not small. And that really is what drove those increases. And the demand and interest on the higher end consumer was for these individualized experiences. And so the ANTI kept getting raised to, you know, to it duplicate Erika's chef pairing wine tasting. And so that that elevated. It now has probably reached a point where to energize that younger customer base, you have to have experiences that are a little more approachable. And we've seen much discussion about that. We've started to see the beginnings of those. I know on our end as a winery, we are trying to meet customers where they are in that sense of let's make experiences that are fun and that are have less of a barrier of entry and allow for that direct engagement. Those are the Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: ways that we counteract some of that thought process of, it's so expensive. And look, it it is because real estate around here is very expensive. The hotels have gotten expensive to operate. All of the factors that have created the financial institutions around us to drive prices up. There are reasons why they have done that. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: That does still go to argue that we have to find ways to engage that customer base at a price point that works for them. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. No, a hundred percent. And it's it's really, I think there's there has to be a shift in meeting them where these new customers are at. It's really kind of identifying a new buyer persona. The traditional ways and means maybe aren't gonna work anymore because that generation has been kind of aged out. one of the things I wanted to ask you too, I'm I'm really curious about this. You know, the rise in GLP ones and and and and gummies, right? it seems like, hey. I'm not eating and drinking as much if I'm on a GLP one, or maybe I prefer a gummy to having some alcohol and I could have maybe one glass, or maybe I can have a Fresca Danny with my gummy and relax and watch a Giants game. is it is it having an impact? I mean, do you think it's making any kind of an impact on the business? Skip Karabian: I think the research is is early on that, but it I would I would think I would be lying if I said it it isn't. It definitely is. There is, there is more choice out there. There is a change in habits. You have entire industries. Looking at the effects of GLP ones and seeing that there is significant impact that is going into people's purchase decisions and related things. And that it denying it would be would be foolish. And I'm a lot of things. Hopefully, foolish isn't one of them. Fall Foliage VO: Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna pour myself a second glass here and f for Skip Karabian: Well then I'm gonna take a sip while you're doing this. Fall Foliage VO: all for all the the non GLP ones out the kids out there. Skip Karabian: Yeah. Fall Foliage VO: All right. Good stuff. I love it. it's a fascinating story of where the wine industry has been, what's happened. I want to kind of start to lean in on on where we're going and and talk about the impact, the potential impact of AI and the capabilities and using AI as a tool. So when we were talking about having this podcast, you and I were were talking that you you're experimenting potentially, I think, with maybe Claude agents and with your CRM system and so just tell us some of the tools that you guys are using, some of the AI tools you're using. Are there any specific, use cases and problems that you're trying to solve that that that are working? And maybe if you're seeing some ROI, maybe you could share that with the audience. Skip Karabian: I I think what what we've seen so far is that that all of our all of our providers, let's call them, the the folks that that have the wine industry CRMs and the folks that that you know have accounting-based software that that keeps track of inventory and and wine inventory and that are specific to the industry. All of them are integrating AI into their systems. And so far, those are, I would say, the most widespread things that are out there. The the other aspects of adoption that are out there are certainly are a case by case basis, depending upon a winery's interest in or or comfortability with with how they want to adopt those practices. I know on our side we're We are using that for accounting review, business review. we're using AI to quickly summarize things for us and using it as a tool that is is in the background at this point. It is it is not reached the point where we are using agents at every desk, let's say, to simplify Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: tasks. I I think that time period will come. I know there is lots of experimentation in our industry. But at the same time, strangely, and you and I have had this conversation in years past, the wine industry, for all its proximity to Silicon Valley and all of the the Fall Foliage VO: Slow, slow to adopt. Skip Karabian: the connection to the technologies industries, has been a very slow adopter. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: And and part of it is, I I think you and I talked about this when we talked prior, is that know i there's still there's still so many options out there and so people are are it is not the clear cut which which path do i follow so unless you are a really early adopter which path to follow is not clear i know that Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: our our IT company is is very deep into and they're they're not just wine industry related related they are They do that in other focus areas, but they are literally working to figure out here's the here's the best case scenarios for our wine clients. Here's the things we think you can adopt. And I know I listened to a podcast this week about that or a a a talk about here's the areas in which you can implement these things in your business now. And here's the areas that we think that, you know. you will be able to six months from now. all those are all those are factors that, you know, we mean Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: every small business, and we are small family businesses, we are not Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: big organizations for the most part, are trying to f to find their way through that adoption process. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. What works? You know, what flavors are we going to use? are they gonna integrate seamlessly with our legacy systems? Is stuff just gonna work or are we gonna be, you know, SOL or something? You know, what the hell's gonna happen? there's data, there's privacy concerns, there's security. I mean, there's there's been a lot of headlines lately with with hacks, including myself, unfortunately. so no, it's it's a real deal. And and and I think it's it's okay, I think to not be in a hurry. Sometimes it's good to go slow. And, you know, buying, a new Windows machine back in the day or upgrading to an operating system, it was, the old rule was don't be first. Let them work the bugs out. Right. So Skip Karabian: Yeah. Fall Foliage VO: maybe that's a maybe that's a good a a good approach here. Skip Karabian: I think that that I've thought about this in the last couple of months, that you know, there was an era in the wine industry, and it's something you and I have talked about a little bit and will probably come up, you know, as we talk about this, where social media was everybody's like, you've got to be in social media in the wine industry. You have to be using this platform to reach new customers. And and I think a lot of that was true, but it wasn't what was promised necessarily. In the sense of what it helped us do is helped us market and tell stories, but it didn't introduce us to new customers Fall Foliage VO: Hmm. Skip Karabian: necessarily. And so some people dove into it thinking, hey, this is gonna, you know, I mean, all of a sudden, really boost my my mailing list and really connect me with all these new people. And that wasn't the reality. And it took some time to find here's the best practices. Of how you can use social media as a benefit to your business. It's not necessarily going to have an immediate ROI, but it's going to be something that's going to help connect you to the people that do know you. And it's going to help to validate the story of what it is that you're doing and how you're operating. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. I love that. use it as a tool to to help amplify what you're doing, the good things that you're doing from a brand perspective. But there there are tools out there that you can use now that can help you listen to customers' prospects, what's going on out there, even what's happening with your competitors. So I encourage you to take a look at that. One thing too, I wanted to tell you, I know you follow me on LinkedIn, but boy, has it been blowing up over the last week or two as One analyst said that the blender has been spinning with all of the the merger activity between CRM companies and CX companies. So I encourage you to have your your IT department take a look at what's been going on because we're seeing a lot of consolidation in that space, which I think has been a long time coming. I've played in that space for a while. it has been a long time coming. I think it's gonna be good for. the actual end users themselves. They're not going to have multiple systems, you know, that's it's kind of gets back to that one neck to grab, if you will. But it's also integrating with legacy systems, but all of the new AI capabilities that are coming out. So keep an eye on that. I think it could be something that could can benefit you guys. Skip Karabian: Yeah, it's we we've seen that already in the industry in the sense of over the last over the last five to ten years, there have been shifts in you know the the the CRM that is used by most wineries. And that Some of that has been driven by acquisitions. Some of it has been driven by shifts in technology and the ability for things to be more efficient than they once were and better integrations. And so we are always the industry is always very aware of that. But I do think that you're right that we're we're expecting to see more of that. And and I think AI is a big factor in that because is making those those technologies more functional for individualized industries in a more rapid fashion than they were in the past, because it took hours of programming to customize it to wineries. And it doesn't take that now. And that puts more Fall Foliage VO: Right, right. Exactly. Skip Karabian: power in our fingertips. And we're, you know, I mean, as an industry, we'll take any of that that we can get. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. And I I think you're gonna see more and more people actually building their own CRM systems actually for a for a small business. May not need all the bells and whistles. you just have to make sure that it works and Skip Karabian: Yeah. Fall Foliage VO: make sure that it's safe, right? 'Cause you're gonna have a a lot of a lot of data in that. You know, the the the dark side of AI is is you know the discussion around all of the AI slop, right? So, you know, the wine industry's been built on these larger than life founders, we've known a lot of them. We've sat down and drank a lot of wine and drank a lot of tequila and done some cool things with them over the years. You know, they've been telling their stories and we've loved hearing those stories. are you seeing in your industry, I mean, do you see a lot of AI slop? Are are some of the wineries, are they starting to look and sound the same? I do you notice that? And and if so, are you guys, saying, hey, wait a minute, maybe it's time to get back to, what got us here, those grassroots, those person to person, Marketing experiences. What are you seeing out there? Skip Karabian: I I think that there is there is a lot of that. I think wineries are pretty sensitive to begin with, at least the small family run wineries have been pretty sensitive to not engaging in you know kind of AI slop. But it is definitely out there and we're all inundated with it at at all times. And and there is certainly a part of it in the industry. But I do think the you know the the wine industry as a whole of late is talking about individual engagement in speaking directly to people. because right now We are we are challenged as an industry to reconnect with people that have been traveling to Europe and haven't been to Sonoma Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: or Napa in some time. You know, there is that that need to connect on a person-to-person basis. And I think you you can see out in the outside world outside of our industry. That there is some pushback of people, the feeling grass and you know, I mean all the things that are related to, hey, I'm gonna step away from technology for a moment and I'm going to focus on the person in front of me. And I'm gonna have an experience that that leaves technology behind for an evening or a a few hours or whatever that may be. And as you and I know, because we've had many of those moments away from our technology. We're here for that as an industry. We that we are about that. That is that engagement of sitting around a table with a glass of wine and having good food and having conversation that that at times feels lost in our current, you know, kind of atmosphere is what we're about. Those are the stories that we're telling. And those people that you talk about that we've been fortunate enough to be around in this industry. It is those big personalities and those experiences that were created by those personalities that created this industry to begin with. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: And it'll it's it's the memory of those people and the people that learned from them that will continue to tell those stories and will create the future Fall Foliage VO: I sure hope so. Yeah. Skip Karabian: of that. I mean, you know, you know, your wife and I both hold some people that we worked with in some very high esteem that that. That I know in the back of our minds, doing what we both do, her as a chef and myself in the on the wine side of things, you know, we tell those stories, we connect to those moments Fall Foliage VO: Still. Skip Karabian: that we had and we tell them to other people because they're important to why we love this industry and why we love this, the lifestyle that it brings, and that we're essentially trying to remind people to enjoy. Fall Foliage VO: So can can we use AI to maybe bring those stories to life again? is there that that that gets into a moral dilemma, which is weird. Do we bring back and resurrect some of these personalities? I I don't know if that's the right thing to do, but I'm just I'm listening to you and remember, you know, taking a bottle and and and and taking a walk through the vineyard or walking down to the river, and we're just gonna chill and we're gonna have a have drink a bottle down there and talk about it and stuff. But now you've got A younger generation that's growing up on devices, they've got their face and phones and whatever it is. They're on TikTok, Instagram, all the things. Are they going to be receptive to that kind of social interaction? d when you're seeing maybe the younger generation come to the winery, are they engaged? Are they off devices? Do they want to take a ride with Skip across the the vineyard in the in the golf cart type of thing, which is one of my favorite things to do? Skip Karabian: It's as you're t as you're saying that, Chris, I'm literally thinking about taking our kids and you know, I mean taking them on a hike that none of them wanted to go on. And mid-hike, we realize when they look around. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. What v what vineyard was that? Was w Hudson, yeah. Skip Karabian: That was that was at Hudson. you know, that that was up on the, you know, I mean, overlooking San Francisco Bay. It's an absolutely stunning piece of property. We Fall Foliage VO: Beautiful. Beautiful. Yeah. Skip Karabian: do we do I did something similar to that just recently here at Michelle Schlumberger. We we took a group and I led a hike of 20 people and walked the vineyards and and showed them what it was about. And then we had a small bonfire afterwards and and ate around the bonfire. And it's those experiences that are what engages people to to come back. And you know, the group that we had, we wanted it to be a small 20-person group, but we covered the you know the age group from probably about 30 at the youngest to about you know 65 or so at the oldest. And and that that does show that those things are possible and we can get those people. And To your to your original question, I think we can use AI as a tool to help us in the production of the ability to tell those stories. They still have to be told by a person. They still need a human touch to them, but all the tools that it creates, that was not something that you could have done in the past to, you know, you needed a camera crew and you to make it look like Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: something was. was very challenging to do if you were a small winery. But Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: in the hands of our small little team here, I know we have people, we have our hospitality team can create images and create video of those things. And with the tools that AI creates, we can tell that story and show somebody, hey, if you come up here, this could be an experience that you enjoy as well. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Yeah. I want to make a little bit of a pivot and we're we're we're we're getting close on time here. you know, there's been a lot of discussion with the midterms about regulating the AI industry. But in our conversations that we've had, there's something there's there's a little dark secret that probably a lot of people don't know about. And it's, you know, you're the three-tier distribution system that's been around for decades that has caused, I think, some problems. I think there's probably still some. some it's handicapping the recovery, I think, of the wine industry. So talk a little bit to our audience who may not know much about shipping regulations. And it it may be a nerdy topic, but I think it's fascinating for people to understand what really goes on behind the scenes and how this may be impacting the actual recovery of the industry itself. Skip Karabian: I I always start this conversation to say, look, we work with distributors in multiple states across the country, and I love our distributors. I am happy to work with them. I don't believe that the industry exists without what they do in one way or another. But when it comes to regulation, all 50 states have different laws that allow for how wine is shipped into them. So it creates a compliance effort for each individual small winery to have a permit for every single state to be able to ship wine from a to a consumer. To be able to ship wine to a distributor. And the layers of regulation that are involved in this make it very challenging for that small family business that you want to support that has been producing wine for 30 or 40 years because it makes it harder for them to reach. And if they're small and only make five or six thousand cases, which is the majority of wineries, it makes it very prohibitive. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: For them to have access to the entire breadth of people that potentially want their wines or could be introduced to their wines. And the the regulation has been such that it it, like everything, it hasn't gotten easier, it's gotten harder with time. And it's really the area where, you know, if there was a means to be able to create a 50-state solution that allowed for it to be the same set of circumstances for all 50 states, whether that be shipping, whether it be taxes, whether it be all the little things that go into and are involved in that process, it would make the small businesses that operate in this world. And I think how a lot of people want to consume wine is from a small business, from a Fall Foliage VO: Right. Skip Karabian: family-owned winery, that would that would Fall Foliage VO: They can make a connection too. Yeah. Skip Karabian: Yeah, that that that alleviates a lot of the the the challenges of how we accomplish what we do of reaching new customers. Fall Foliage VO: Sounds like it's time to write your your Congress person because I'm well I'm I'm thinking about what's happened with the tariffs and the boycotting with Canada. and the Democrats, they they're taking over come January and the message of affordability, maybe there's a there's a path here that they can help the wine industry. Let's get rid of the tariffs, let's open this back up, let's kind of help with the regulations and and the the distribution system that they have to support. particularly the small wineries, right? Okay. So skip, I'm gonna make you the the czar of the US wine industry. This is this is the question you've been waiting for. You have the power to change anything, whether it's marketing, distribution, regulations, even how wine is positioned to consumers. you know, I'm gonna leave it to you. You know, what's your plan to save the US wine industry? Skip Karabian: Well, I I think there's there's a couple of things that I would do. The the first part, and we we haven't really touched on this, you and I yet, but I know we've talked about it in the past, is I would would reframe the discussion on health in regards to the the wine industry right now. And and and to alcohol in some ways. You know, I think I am a firm believer in moderation in in most things. And I think that we've we've lost that in the discussion of alcohol is bad. you know, don't touch it, dry January, stay, stay Fall Foliage VO: There's campaign for sure. Skip Karabian: away. I I think that there is, you know, alcohol and and the European lifestyle has has had the exact opposite discussion. In the sense that that little bit of wine a couple times a week, and good food, well prepared, is part of what has made generations of Europeans live much longer than Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: our consumption-driven American lifestyle. So I think I would reframe that. I also would probably work from a standpoint of Let's do more research about alcohol and let's let's try to have it come from a more neutral base than you know both sides paying for specific people to do research that comes with the conclusion that they want to represent. that's a that's a theme in our politics everywhere, but but let's let's try and let's try and have science-backed, you know, fact-based information. And then I think second to that is. Let's take a very long look at regulation and how the alcohol system is set up. I don't think we dismantle it. Like I said, I believe in distributors. To be able to sell wine to a restaurant in Ohio, I need somebody in the state of Ohio to be able to do that for me. And a distributor can do that. But if a restaurant calls me and wants to carry my wine and I don't have a distributor because I'm a small winery, why can't I find a way to be able to put that wine in front of them and let them sell it? Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: Right now there's no solution for that. And in some states, why can't I ship a bottle of wine to a customer that wants it? well, I have to have a permit for that particular state, and I have to have all these things that make it cost prohibitive for me to do that. I think we can we can work our way through those things. And as the czar of the wine industry, first of all, the giants are getting all of the heads up that they need to move ahead. But B, I think we can look at those things and we can find some balance and compromise of how we make those things more consumer friendly for the winery, but also for the end consumer. Fall Foliage VO: As your brand strategist, I'm gonna say let's remove the Coke bottle in left field and replace that with a Michel Schlumberger bottle. And and we're in business. Skip Karabian: I'm I'm down for that marketing. Fall Foliage VO: I think we're I think we're in business. Listen, one last question for you? You know, it we're we're coming up on the holidays and by the time this podcast gets published, it'll probably be around Thanksgiving. For any of the wineries that that are out there that might be struggling. and and and stressed out and they're they're through their harvest and they're looking to next year. what could they do differently? Is there one thing that you could say, hey, maybe think about this as as you're as you're thinking about the upcoming year, or you're thinking about maybe trying to move some inventory, like you mentioned, you've got a couple years of inventory sitting around. What what's what's something that you can do that would have an immediate positive impact? Skip Karabian: Well, I I think a lot of people, you have to be very realistic about the circumstances that you're in. And I think that's that's a hard part because there is so much passion for being in this industry that that it's it's often lost, that these are frequently small family businesses and it you know, to operate them is is not easy. And not everybody is, you know, I mean, is wildly business savvy and really understands the complications that that are out there. And so I think you have to be realistic about the circumstances and and you have to kind of be aggressive and not wait for, hey, you know, consumption is going to go back up, and when it does, we'll be fine. You've You gotta be a little bit more aggressive than that. But I also think the biggest thing, and and we talked about this a little bit ahead before, is, you've got to meet people where they are. You have to engage the individual consumer in every opportunity. That's not always easy for small businesses because it requires, you know, funds and it requires doing things. But doing things the exact same way as they've always been done Is not a solution to get yourself through this time period. You really Fall Foliage VO: Yeah. Skip Karabian: have to work harder and smarter. And, to lend to your topic here of AI, there's a lot that those things can do to create efficiencies in the way you review your business and the way you look at what you're doing that helps you to understand. mean, I I can think of years past, nobody would have had an easy solution to, how much more inventory do I have than I need? That actually was a that's a that's a hard problem in our industry because you've got wine in barrel, you've got wine in bottle, you've got grapes on the vine. Doing that math is more complicated than it sounds. And Fall Foliage VO: Mm-hmm. Skip Karabian: we have tools that can help you to say, This is how much you're selling annually. This is how much you should be producing in the future. There's a lot of information to be able to guide you to analyze where you stand. And this business, as you and I have talked about, is customer facing. It is person to person. And you have to engage people where they're, where they're ready to enjoy that lifestyle that we are presenting. And you have to really create those connections. The most critical thing that we can do, I say this all the time to the team here, is, every day when people come in to visit our property, that's the most important thing that's happening on this property today. And we have to continue to do that. And that is what that is what I tell anybody in this industry all the time is. Those customers that are in front of you, they're the most important people to your future. You have to engage them. Fall Foliage VO: I love that. I absolutely love that because AI can't create that human connection and it can't create the meaning. And that's what you're talking about. And just pr providing Skip Karabian: It it it it Fall Foliage VO: those experiences to people and making those connections. And that's a common thread that's coming up on this podcast. And so you're in the wine business. I talk to a lot of people in tech, but it's it's same old, same old. Make connections, provide Great experiences over and over again so that people want to keep coming back and hanging out with you and drinking some wine and taking a walk down to the river or a hike around the property, around the vineyard, because you do those kind of things that delivers on a brand promise and and you can get real sticky with customers, if you keep that mindset and can actually have that kind of brand operating system as we've talked about on this podcast as well, for your employees to execute on and and to live by. And that that is the baseline. Skip Karabian: Brands are people and execution of that connection to those people. Internal, Fall Foliage VO: I love it. Skip Karabian: internal customers, external customers, however you want to look at it. That that is what makes up a a brand. And executing at the highest level of customer service and those things, that's that's what builds those kind of connections. Fall Foliage VO: Beautiful. No, you you you said it perfectly. Skip, where can people find you if if they want to purchase some some Michelle Schlumberger wine? Skip Karabian: Well they can come visit us up here in Healdsburg in in Dry Creek. Michelle Schlumberger.com is is where they can find out all about us and and reach out to us and and they can see us on social media, Michelle Schlumberger, and you know they can they can hear the stories and see all those things that that we're doing, like many of our our neighbors and and other people in this industry. We are we are here, you know. ready to have people come and visit us. And we we love to tell our story and the story of the regions that we come from and the wines that we make and the history behind them. That's that's that makes us that makes us excited, puts smiles on our faces and helps us to enjoy glasses like these on a Friday afternoon. Fall Foliage VO: Cheers, mate. Appreciate you. It's it's yeah, it's been great to see ya. Skip Karabian: Cheers. Always good to talk to you about this stuff. Well, you and I you and I love these discussions. Fall Foliage VO: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I I love I love you telling the story today. So thanks for joining us and happy holidays to you. Enjoy and and hopefully we'll be seeing you soon. Skip Karabian: I I sure hope so. Fall Foliage VO: All right. Take care, Skip. Good to see ya. Thanks for joining. B all Skip Karabian: Thanks, Chris. Talk to later. Fall Foliage VO: right. Bye bye. Skip Karabian: Bye.