Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Polymarket Trap Exposed: From Election Whales to Assassination Markets
Transcript
- 0:00You know, we all want to know the future.
- 0:01It's a, it's the oldest human obsession.
- 0:04We want the cheat codes. We want to know who wins the
- 0:07election when a war might end. Or, you know, even if aliens are
- 0:10finally going to show up. Which is usually nothing.
- 0:12Usually those predictions are worth absolutely.
- 0:14Nothing exactly, but today we're looking at a machine that
- 0:18actually puts a price tag on the future.
- 0:20We're doing a deep dive into Polymarket and I know you're
- 0:25thinking, oh great, another crypto thing, but this one, it's
- 0:29actually broken out of that bubble.
- 0:30We're seeing major outlets like the Wall Street Journal, The New
- 0:33York Times citing this platforms odds right alongside their own
- 0:37polls. It's become a genuine cultural
- 0:39phenomenon. And what's so interesting to me
- 0:41is that on the surface it looks, it looks exactly like a
- 0:45degenerate GAMBLING SITE. It does.
- 0:46It looks like a casino. But if you actually pop the
- 0:49hood, which is what we're doing today, it's designed to be a
- 0:51truth seeking engine. OK, hold.
- 0:53On I have to push back on that immediately.
- 0:55Truth seeking engine sounds very, very noble.
- 0:58But if I log onto the site, I see people betting on whether
- 1:01Taylor Swift gets engaged. How is that different from me
- 1:05walking into a sports book in Vegas and putting money on the
- 1:07Super Bowl? It feels the same, I get that,
- 1:10but the mechanics are they're just fundamentally different.
- 1:13Think about a casino. You are playing against the
- 1:16house. And the house always wins.
- 1:18Because the house sets the odds, they have an algorithm or some
- 1:21centralized expert who decides the price to make sure they make
- 1:24a profit. But in a prediction market like
- 1:26Poly market, there is no house. So it's peer-to-peer.
- 1:29Exactly. The users set the odds.
- 1:31So if I want to bet yes on something, I have to find
- 1:33someone on the other side willing to bet no.
- 1:36Precisely, You're buying and selling shares of a future
- 1:38event, and the brilliance is in the simplicity.
- 1:41Every single share pays out exactly $1.00 if you're right
- 1:44and 0 if you're not. So it's binary, all or nothing,
- 1:47right? And because that payout is
- 1:49locked at $1.00, the price of the share becomes a perfect
- 1:53percentage. If it sure costs say $0.60, the
- 1:56market is basically screaming that there is a 60% probability
- 2:00of that event happening. OK, but.
- 2:01Why is that truth? If a bunch of random people on
- 2:04the Internet decide something is 60% likely, isn't that just mob
- 2:09mentality? Why is that better than asking?
- 2:12You know a pH D in political science.
- 2:14So this takes us all the way back to Friedrich Hayek, the
- 2:16economist. In 1945, he wrote this Seminole
- 2:19paper on the use of knowledge in society, and his whole argument
- 2:23was that knowledge isn't concentrated in the heads of a
- 2:25few experts, right? It's dispersed.
- 2:27It's scattered across millions of people.
- 2:29The classic example is the shopkeeper knows more about the
- 2:31local economy than the central banker in some far off capital.
- 2:34Precisely. Hayek argued that markets are
- 2:36the only way to aggregate all that tiny, scattered
- 2:38information. But Polymarket adds the secret
- 2:41ingredient skin in the game. Money, money.
- 2:44On Twitter, you can say, oh, I think this candidate will win by
- 2:47a landslide. And it costs you nothing to be
- 2:48wrong, right? You get clout if you're right,
- 2:50and you just delete the tweet if you're wrong.
- 2:53But here you have to pay to have an opinion.
- 2:55That financial risk, It filters out all the noise.
- 2:58It strips away the wishful thinking.
- 3:00So it forces honesty. Yeah, you might want your team
- 3:03to win the championship, but you're not going to bet your
- 3:06mortgage on them unless you really, truly believe they're
- 3:09going to win. That's the theory.
- 3:10When money is on the line, the bullshit walks.
- 3:12But is this actually a new idea? I mean, it feels like humans
- 3:15have been betting on outcomes since we lived in caves.
- 3:17Oh, the tech is new, but the behavior is ancient.
- 3:20In the 16th century, there were these massive betting markets on
- 3:23who the next Pope would be. Betting on the Pope?
- 3:27Seriously, that feels, I don't know, a little sacrilegious?
- 3:30The Vatican definitely thought so.
- 3:31They eventually banned it, but it just kept evolving.
- 3:34In London in the 1700s, you had Jonathan's Coffeehouse.
- 3:37This was basically the Twitter of its day, but with cash.
- 3:40Wow. People would trade rumors about
- 3:42wars and politics and back them up with actual coin.
- 3:44It was the precursor to the London Stock Exchange.
- 3:47So the stock market basically started as a bunch of guys in a
- 3:50coffee shop betting on rumors. That's incredible.
- 3:53Pretty much. And here in the US, up until the
- 3:56mid 20th century, betting on presidential elections was huge.
- 3:59Candidates would publicly bet on themselves just to show
- 4:01confidence. No way.
- 4:02Yeah, it was a standard part of the whole political process
- 4:04until strict gambling regulations shut it all down.
- 4:08So he killed the market and now crypto has brought it back.
- 4:11But why did Polymarket succeed? I remember hearing about a
- 4:15project called Auger back in 2018 that was supposed to be the
- 4:19big thing. Auger was the right idea at the
- 4:21wrong time with totally the wrong execution.
- 4:24It was built on Ethereum when Ethereum was incredibly slow and
- 4:26expensive, right? So placing a $10 bet might cost
- 4:29you $50.00 in transaction fees. Plus the interface.
- 4:33It was built for computer scientists, not for normal.
- 4:36People, it was just a ghost town.
- 4:37No one was using it. Exactly.
- 4:39And liquidity is everything in these markets.
- 4:41If there's no one there to take the other side of your bet, the
- 4:43market just dies. Polymarket fixed the user
- 4:46experience. It looks like a new site.
- 4:48It uses USDC so you aren't worrying about the price of
- 4:51Bitcoin going up and down, just the dollar value.
- 4:53And it's fast. They just they lowered the
- 4:55barrier to entry enough that regular people and big money
- 4:59could actually show up. And show if they did, we have to
- 5:01talk about the French whale. Yeah, this was the defining
- 5:05story of the 2024 election. While the rest of the world was
- 5:09looking at polling data that said yeah, it's a coin flip,
- 5:12this one guy was pointing a totally different picture.
- 5:14This is the perfect case study for why these markets work.
- 5:17This trader, known only as Theo, bet roughly $70 million on
- 5:22Donald Trump to win. 70 million dollars.
- 5:25I mean, I don't care who you are, that is a terrifying amount
- 5:27of money to put on a hunch. But that's the key.
- 5:29It wasn't a hunch. Theo didn't trust the mainstream
- 5:32polls. He thought they were
- 5:33structurally broken. OK, he believed that there was a
- 5:35shy voter effect, that the polls were completely missing people
- 5:39who wouldn't admit to a pollster that they were voting for Trump,
- 5:41but would absolutely pull that lever in the voting booth.
- 5:44But everyone talks about the shy voter effect.
- 5:46That's not a new idea. How did he prove it?
- 5:48He commissioned his own private polling, but he used something
- 5:51called the neighbor method. The neighbor method OK me
- 5:54through this. How does asking about a neighbor
- 5:57fix the data? It's a brilliant psychological
- 6:00hack. If I ask you, who are you voting
- 6:02for, You might lie because you want to look virtuous or you're
- 6:06afraid I'll judge you. It's called social desirability
- 6:09bias, right? But if I ask you, who do you
- 6:11think your neighbor is voting for?
- 6:13You drop the ego. You just answer honestly based
- 6:16on what you see, The yard signs, the bumper stickers, the
- 6:18conversations you overhear. You become a neutral observer of
- 6:21your environment. Exactly.
- 6:23Seya's data showed that while people were noncommittal about
- 6:26themselves, they were convinced their neighbors were all voting
- 6:28for Trump. He saw that discrepancy,
- 6:30realized the market was mispricing the odds, and he went
- 6:32all in. But.
- 6:33If you drop $70 million into a market, you make a splash, you
- 6:37move the odds. Everyone sees the whale coming.
- 6:39And he tried to be subtle. He used 11 different anonymous
- 6:42accounts to drip feed the bets. But on a public blockchain, you
- 6:45can't hide forever. Online sleuths started linking
- 6:48the accounts, realizing they were all funded from the same
- 6:50place. By then, though, the signal was
- 6:52out. The market shifted toward Trump
- 6:55long before the votes were ever counted.
- 6:57And he walked away with what was the final number.
- 7:00About $80 million in profit, roughly a $150 million total
- 7:05payout. Wow.
- 7:07That is the ultimate. I told you so.
- 7:08It totally validates the Hayek theory.
- 7:11A motivated individual with better data corrected the entire
- 7:14market. The polls were free and they
- 7:16were wrong. The market was expensive and it
- 7:17was right. OK.
- 7:18So that's the high minded geopolitical side of things.
- 7:21But looking through the source material, there is some
- 7:22absolutely bizarre stuff on this platform.
- 7:24It's not just elections. Oh, not at all.
- 7:26It acts as a news aggregator for everything there are markets
- 7:29for. Will Bitcoin hit 150K?
- 7:32Will Taylor Swift break up with her boyfriend?
- 7:34Or my personal favorite, will Jesus return to Earth in 2025?
- 7:37I saw that. And I mean, first of all, how do
- 7:40you verify that? Does Jesus have to hold a press
- 7:42conference? But secondly, who on earth is
- 7:44betting on this? People are.
- 7:46But the financial mechanics of that specific bet are actually a
- 7:49fascinating lesson in economic. Please don't tell me there's a
- 7:52smart way to bet on the apocalypse.
- 7:53There is, think about it, the no shares betting that Jesus won't
- 7:57return. They trade at roughly 96 or 97
- 8:01cents. OK.
- 8:01So it's almost a sure thing, right?
- 8:03If you buy that share, you are locking in a three or 4%
- 8:07annualized return on your money. Which is basically the same as
- 8:10buying a U.S. Treasury bond.
- 8:12Exactly. So the market is effectively
- 8:14treating the continued absence of Jesus as a risk free asset on
- 8:18par with U.S. government debt. It's an arbitrage on theological
- 8:21risk. That is hilarious.
- 8:23So I can either lend my money to the US government or I can bet
- 8:26against the second coming and the yield is about the same and.
- 8:28Hey, if you're wrong and Jesus does return, losing your dollar
- 8:31is probably the least of your concerns at that point.
- 8:34Fairpoint, if the sky rips open, I am not checking My Portfolio.
- 8:38But you mentioned arbitrage and the sources say this is where
- 8:41the robots come in. Yes, we focus on the big human
- 8:44stories, but a huge portion of the volume on Polymarket is just
- 8:48automated. Remember how we said yes plus no
- 8:51must always equal $1.00, right? $0.60 + 40 cents.
- 8:55Well, sometimes because of market volatility, yes, might be
- 8:5961 cents and no might be $0.41. That adds up to $1.02.
- 9:04It's a mass error. And the bots just spot it
- 9:06instantly. Instantly they buy the
- 9:07inefficiency and log in a guaranteed risk free profit.
- 9:11It's estimated these bots are making around $40 million a year
- 9:13just sweeping up these pennies. They're like the janitors of the
- 9:16prediction market, keeping the math honest.
- 9:18That's wild. OK, but let's pivot to the dark
- 9:20side here because so far we've painted this picture of a
- 9:23perfect truth seeking machine. But there are cracks in the
- 9:26system, and the biggest one seems to be who decides who
- 9:29actually won? The Oracle problem.
- 9:31Right. The outline calls this
- 9:33Zelensky's suit. This is a classic example.
- 9:36A market asked a very simple question.
- 9:38Will President Zelensky wear a suit to this specific event?
- 9:42OK, sounds simple. Did he wear a suit or not?
- 9:43Wow. He showed up wearing a matching
- 9:46jacket and trousers, but it wasn't a tuxedo and it wasn't
- 9:49your typical business suit. It was formal, but it was
- 9:52distinct. So did he wear a suit?
- 9:54That's completely subjective. I might say yes, you might say
- 9:57no. And millions of dollars were
- 9:58hanging on that definition. Now, in a decentralized system,
- 10:01there's no CEO of Polymarket to call and ask.
- 10:04They use a system called UMA. Basically token holders vote on
- 10:08the outcome. It's a Democratic jury.
- 10:09Right democratic truth. But here's the flaw.
- 10:12It's a plutocracy, not a democracy. 1 token equals one
- 10:15vote. So if there's a massive market,
- 10:17say $50 million is at stake, and it cost me $5,000,000 to buy
- 10:21enough tokens to swing the vote. You spend the 5 million to win
- 10:23the 50 million. Exactly.
- 10:24It's a 51% attack on the truth. The sources mentioned a case
- 10:28where a whale allegedly did exactly this.
- 10:30They had enough money to just bribe the jury, effectively
- 10:32making their version of reality the true one.
- 10:35So reality just goes to the highest bidder.
- 10:37That is terrifying if we start using this for things that
- 10:39actually matter. It creates a crisis of
- 10:41confidence. If you can't trust the judge,
- 10:43you won't play the game. But there's a risk that's even
- 10:47more dangerous than a rigged jury.
- 10:48Reflexivity. Reflexivity.
- 10:50This is the George Soros concept, right?
- 10:52Yes. The fundamental question is,
- 10:54does the market just predict the event, or can the market
- 10:57actually cause the event? Give me a concrete example, OK?
- 11:00Imagine a political candidate is falling behind in the polls.
- 11:03They're desperate. A wealthy donor or maybe even a
- 11:07foreign government pumps $20 million into Poly market,
- 11:10betting on that candidate to win.
- 11:12So the odd spike, they go way. Up the odd spike.
- 11:15The news picks it up. Canada X surges in prediction
- 11:17markets. Suddenly, other donors start
- 11:19writing checks again. Voters think, oh wow, maybe he
- 11:21can actually win. The momentum shifts.
- 11:24The bet didn't predict the surge.
- 11:26The bet manufactured the surge. Becomes a self fulfilling
- 11:28prophecy. You're basically just buying the
- 11:30narrative. And we saw accusations of this
- 11:32with someone like Elon Musk suggesting his tweets or his
- 11:35influence might be shifting odds on purpose.
- 11:37Whether it's true or not, the mechanism exists.
- 11:40You can turn the prediction market into a marketing channel.
- 11:43And then there's the other side of that insider info, the war
- 11:45markets. This part of the research really
- 11:48crept me out. It should.
- 11:49There are markets asking will Israel bomb Iran before Friday
- 11:53or will Ukraine strike this specific bridge?
- 11:56And people are betting real money on this.
- 11:58Not just people, the patterns strongly suggest insiders.
- 12:01You'll see these fresh crypto wallets funded an hour ago
- 12:04dropping $100,000 on yes right before an airstrike actually
- 12:08happened. That's a it's a effectively an
- 12:10intelligence. It is.
- 12:11If you work at the Pentagon or the Mossad, you have information
- 12:14that is worth millions of dollars on Polymarket.
- 12:17It turns the platform into a leak machine.
- 12:19If the odds of an invasion suddenly spike to 90% out of
- 12:22nowhere, you don't need ACIA briefing to know what's about to
- 12:25happen. The money knows first.
- 12:27That gives me chills. It's like the market is
- 12:29omniscient, but for all the wrong reasons.
- 12:31It forces us to confront the morality of it all.
- 12:33We're commodifying disaster. We're putting a bounty on
- 12:36outcomes which. Leads to the darkest thought of
- 12:39all, doesn't it? Yeah, if you follow this logic
- 12:41to its absolute end. If you can bet on literally
- 12:45anything. You eventually get to
- 12:46assassination markets. Meaning I bet that a specific
- 12:49person dies on a certain date and by.
- 12:50Placing that bet, you create a pot of money, a reward for
- 12:55anyone who makes it happen. If the market for Will This
- 12:57Person Die in 2026 hits $10 million, that is essentially a
- 13:02crowd sourced hit. And suddenly, prediction markets
- 13:04aren't just observing the world, they're actively shaping the
- 13:07absolute worst parts of it. It is the ultimate double edged
- 13:10sword. We have built a tool that can
- 13:11harness the wisdom of crowds to outsmart experts in polls.
- 13:14It's efficient, it's powerful, and it can be brutally honest.
- 13:18But a tool that powerful? It doesn't care about ethics, it
- 13:21just cares about the payout. Wow, it's a lot to process.
- 13:24We started with fun gambling app and ended up at crowdsourced
- 13:27Hitman. That is the nature of the deep
- 13:29dive. Well, on that cheerful note, we
- 13:30should probably wrap up. Just a quick reminder to
- 13:33everyone listening, this deep dive is for educational purposes
- 13:37only. We are not financial advisors.
- 13:39And please don't go betting your life savings on whether aliens
- 13:43are going to land next Tuesday. Although you know if the odds
- 13:46get good enough. Don't.
- 13:47Just don't. Thanks for listening everyone.
- 13:48We'll catch you in the future.