Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.36 Mount Polley, Indigenous Land Rights and the Real Cost of Mining – with Nuskmata
Transcript
- 0:00Marella,
- 0:01hello and welcome to the Save Our Sperrin podcast. Voices
- 0:05from the front line. My name is Marella Fyffe, your host and
- 0:09member of the Save Our Sperrins team. And this podcast comes
- 0:13from the Sperrin mountains in Northern Ireland.
- 0:16is an ancient land shaped by mountains and bogs and by the
- 0:20communities born from them, and whose same peoples are now
- 0:23living with growing pressure from mining and large scale
- 0:27upland development. That pressure isn't unique to here.
- 0:31Across the world, the so called energy transition is driving
- 0:35ever more extraction. There's a growing demand for critical
- 0:39minerals and rare earth metals,
- 0:42and that demand is landing on local communities, asking them
- 0:46to live with long term impacts of toxic mining.
- 0:50Season one looked at why the Sperrin mountains matter through
- 0:54the voices of the people who live here and know this place
- 0:58well. Season Two keeps those local voices at the centre,
- 1:02while also stepping back a bit, in season two, we look at
- 1:06extractivism more broadly, how it's been justified, how it is
- 1:10fundamental to a system of accelerated growth, plundering
- 1:14evermore from a finite planet designed only To feed predatory
- 1:19capitalism, creating untold and unprecedented misery simply to
- 1:23support the bottom line of a balance sheet in some distant,
- 1:27glass walled boardrooms far from the ground we're standing on.
- 1:31Thanks for listening, and let's begin.
- 1:38Today. I'm speaking with Nuskmata, also known as Jacinda.
- 1:42Mack is an indigenous land defender, advocate and thought
- 1:46leader from the Nlaka’pamux and Secwépemc peoples in what's now
- 1:51called British Columbia. She holds a Bachelor of Arts from
- 1:55the University of Victoria and a master's in communication from
- 1:59York University in Toronto.
- 2:02Many listeners will know her name from the aftermath of the
- 2:062014
- 2:07mount poly mine disaster. Nusmata served as spokesperson
- 2:12for the northern tribal council at that time and played a
- 2:17central role in the development of their indigenous mining
- 2:20policy. Work that has had a lasting influence.
- 2:25She's worked both at community and international level, serving
- 2:28on the board of the initiative for Responsible mining
- 2:31assurance, advising the global industry standard on tailings
- 2:35management through the Global tailings review, and
- 2:38collaborating with organisations such as Amnesty International
- 2:42and mining watch Canada. Across all of this, her focus has
- 2:46remained clear, ensuring indigenous rights, environmental
- 2:50protection and accountability are not sidelined in decisions
- 2:54about the extractive industry.
- 2:58In 2024
- 2:59she received the Andrew Thompson award from West Coast
- 3:03environmental law in recognition of her Leadership in
- 3:05Environmental Justice and indigenous land rights
- 3:09today. Nusmata is executive director of the moccasin
- 3:13footprint Society, an all indigenous charity supporting
- 3:18grassroots, cultural environment and community led initiatives in
- 3:22IK and northern Secwépemc homelands work rooted in
- 3:26strengthening self determination and stewardship of land.
- 3:31Welcome, Nuskmata , would you like to introduce yourself to
- 3:35the listeners and tell us where you are today? And
- 3:40let's start there. Okay. Joos, Madam hooks insla, news, Kamada,
- 3:45hello, relatives. My name is Nuskmata . I'm from the newscast
- 3:49village of the new Nlaka’pamux nation, and that's located on
- 3:53the northwest coast of so called Canada. We are sovereign people.
- 3:57We've never signed away any of our lands, and we are an
- 4:01occupied nation. I'm coming to you today from the Banff Centre
- 4:06for arts and creativity up in the Rocky Mountains where we're
- 4:10I'm here with other indigenous musicians, and we're creating
- 4:14songs for the revolution.
- 4:17Here in my studio, you can see my Oh, cool. All the stuff set
- 4:21up here. Yeah, so I'm in a music residency, so it's a three weeks
- 4:27of creating music and working with different faculty,
- 4:32collaborating with other musicians. And, yeah, I had the
- 4:36studio recording last night, and we're having soundtracks and
- 4:39stuff today, so I'm a little all over the place, but I've got
- 4:41time now, so it should be okay. Okay, I'm sure you need this,
- 4:45like a hole in your head, you know, when you're up to that
- 4:48kind of because it's completely different, you know, track, line
- 4:53for you, you'd have to shift out of this gear into that gear, you
- 4:56know. Yeah, I sympathise with you. It's so.
- 5:00Much, you know, thank you.
- 5:04Your type of music, what is it you actually, do you play? Do
- 5:08you sing? What?
- 5:10I'm a terrible guitar player, but I'm a pretty decent singer
- 5:15songwriter, so I collaborate with other musicians. And
- 5:19actually, during the residency I've I've been introduced to a
- 5:21bunch of new tools for me to start creating loops and beats
- 5:25to write to, and then to be able to share with musicians and say,
- 5:29This is what I want it to sound like, and then just work with
- 5:32people who are much better than I to make it sound really good.
- 5:37So we did an album all in our language. So this is all in new
- 5:39cult language. Oh, brilliant. Brilliant, yeah, so cool. If you
- 5:43want to use any of it in the podcast, please do new Hulk
- 5:46radio. It's called news, news,
- 5:50which means releasing the light. My Tracks are two, four and
- 5:58nine.
- 6:00Okay, it's for the revolution.
- 6:04We're focusing on the land and our people and a healthy,
- 6:08beautiful future looking forward. So I'm happy to be here
- 6:12today. That's great, and that's a lovely introduction. Our topic
- 6:16here today is the mount poly mine disaster, and I believe you
- 6:21were the response coordinator at that time. Can you take us back
- 6:25to that time? Tell us first how you ended up being the response
- 6:29coordinator, and then give us the story of the whole disaster
- 6:35for your community.
- 6:38I was hired as the Natural Resources Manager for the hutzul
- 6:41First Nation, and that's in the northern suquam homelands of
- 6:45what's now considered the interior plateau of British
- 6:48Columbia, Canada. And within our territory, we have a lot of
- 6:52mining, and actually it's really tied to the history of
- 6:54colonisation, because there was so much gold, and there was a
- 6:57huge gold rush in the 1850s
- 6:59and so when the gold rush from California was ending and there
- 7:02were water restrictions and guidelines happening, there
- 7:06people moved north, and they came into British Columbia, or
- 7:08what would become British Columbia, after all of the
- 7:10mining started. And the mining in the area actually are
- 7:15foundational laws for the province of British Columbia to
- 7:18be established. And a lot of the laws have remained unchanged
- 7:21even since the 1850s so we're working really hard to update
- 7:24them
- 7:25in 2024
- 7:27in 2014
- 7:29the Mount polymine Imperial Metals Mount polymine tailings
- 7:33facility, the waste storage facility, collapsed under its
- 7:36own weight. It had gotten too big. There wasn't enough
- 7:39buttressing. There wasn't enough support on the dam wall, and so
- 7:45the the wall slipped, and there was a layer of glacial clay
- 7:50underneath the dam. And so when that happened, all of the waste
- 7:56and the water covering the waste all started to flow out of the
- 8:00tailings facility and down the mountain path along the
- 8:03Hazeltine creek down into Quesnel lake. And so that was
- 8:08catastrophic fail event. And this mine was really held up
- 8:13Mount polymine was really held up by the province of BC, and
- 8:16the mining industry as like the crown jewel of mining Imperial
- 8:21Metals, crown jewel, very colonial, and it failed in under
- 8:2520 years. And they had all the best engineers, all the best
- 8:30experts, and it still failed in under 20 years. And what we
- 8:34learned within the big investigation afterward is that
- 8:39there were alarm systems that weren't working, that weren't
- 8:42being checked. The mine was monitoring itself. Everything
- 8:46was getting offloaded by the Ministry of Environment and
- 8:49other ministries that were supposed to be watch, watching
- 8:53the mine. And when this disaster happened, it was really
- 8:58experienced as a death in our community, and we actually had
- 9:01ceremonies on the river and out in the area of grieving and
- 9:05mourning ceremonies to acknowledge that this relative,
- 9:09this lake, this living system of ours, had been impacted again by
- 9:12mining, and people were really hurt and really afraid because
- 9:17the salmon were coming up the river at the same time. So we
- 9:19knew it was impacting the water. It was impacting all of the
- 9:22wildlife in the area. It's a very special ceremonial place.
- 9:26The salmon were coming and it was and it washed the remnants
- 9:29of our ancient villages off the side of the mountain with the
- 9:32slide coming down. So it was just layer on layer on layer.
- 9:35And people were just devastated, right?
- 9:39That's a lot to take on in one conversation. The first fact
- 9:45about that that really astonished what astonished me
- 9:48was that it was only 20 years old the before it collapsed.
- 9:53That's, yeah, just under 20 years yep, that's, it wasn't
- 9:57even 20 years old. Yeah, in less than 20 years.
- 10:00It failed. And so this was the model that Imperial Metals was
- 10:03using to build other mines. And so the next mine after this was
- 10:06the red Chris mine in talatan territory. So it really sent
- 10:09ripple effects out into indigenous communities, out into
- 10:12the mining community. You know, there were, there were so many,
- 10:18so many cracks in the system that worked well to make money,
- 10:23but not well to protect communities, to protect the
- 10:26water, to protect the wildlife and the like the birds, all of
- 10:30the cumulative impacts were going unchecked
- 10:33and in your community. What was the attitude to mining, before
- 10:39the mining collapse, before the waste, waste, waste went into
- 10:44the into the creek and into the lakes and in general, within
- 10:49your community locally,
- 10:51I think people who worked at the mine just kind of kept their
- 10:55heads down and were working along. And then when the
- 10:57disaster happened, it really brought into focus, this is
- 11:00real. Not only can Is it possible to happen, it has
- 11:04happened, and now we have to deal with the impacts of that
- 11:06which are unknown. And the mine had no like plan to deal with a
- 11:12disaster, because they they simply told us it was an
- 11:15impossible event, and it happened in less than 20 years.
- 11:18So it really brought into question people who were working
- 11:22there, if they can, if they even wanted to continue working at
- 11:25the mine. There was a lot of education that happened about
- 11:28mining after that, because I was sharing everything that I knew.
- 11:32I created a Facebook page because I was just sharing
- 11:35everything on my personal account. I was like, we need, we
- 11:38need somewhere where all of this can go that will live beyond me.
- 11:41And so I created a page mount poly mind disaster information.
- 11:45I think I just kept it really simple and added all of the
- 11:50newspaper clippings and added comments like, that's not quite
- 11:54right. This is actually what's happening. Here's a meeting
- 11:57that's coming up. You know. Just try to put everything as
- 11:59transparently as possible, and people really started to
- 12:04question mining, and started to talk about mining as a colonial
- 12:08instrument, and started to look at the mining laws, which are so
- 12:11outdated. So it really created a lot of noise, and it was wild to
- 12:16me that just you know, how much people were learned like they
- 12:20were reading the mining codes in the mineral tenure act, and they
- 12:23were reading the permits, and they were really wanting to get
- 12:27to the bottom of it, to the truth, because the mine was
- 12:29deflecting and denying and playing it down, of course, and
- 12:34the community members were like, We want to shut down forever,
- 12:38which didn't happen. The mine was eventually permitted to go
- 12:41back into business. And they said, well, we can't afford to
- 12:45clean it up if we're not operating. And so they were,
- 12:49they were allowed to continue operating, and they cleaned up
- 12:52enough for them to go back into business. But the rest of the
- 12:55the waste and the tailings is still in the forest beside the
- 12:59creek, and it's still at the bottom of the lake, which is
- 13:01still drawn upon for cleaning drinking water.
- 13:05Okay, so a couple of questions there. Can you describe
- 13:09the creek and the lake before the mining disaster?
- 13:14Yeah, so before the disaster, the little creek that came out
- 13:17below the
- 13:19tailings dam drained out from a lake that was very close to the
- 13:23mine called Polly Lake, and there was a little creek that
- 13:26came out of it trickled down that was Hazeltine Creek. And
- 13:29that creek was about four feet across, very shallow. It was
- 13:33coho salmon spawning habitat,
- 13:37and then it drained down into the lake, the larger lake below,
- 13:41which is a great big, deep fjord lake. It has its own weather
- 13:44system. It's very beautiful, very clean. There's been some
- 13:49logging in the area in the past, but basically, like the water in
- 13:54that lake, in that deep Cornell Lake, was much cleaner than
- 13:59water quality drinking standards. And you know, the the
- 14:02aquatic life in there. It was so, so clean and so cold. It was
- 14:07a major nursing habitat for salmon, of all five species of
- 14:12salmon coming up the Fraser River into the Cornell river and
- 14:14then into Cornell lake system. So very clean water, massive
- 14:19abundance of water for our territory, interior rainforest,
- 14:23and it was
- 14:26completely transformed after the disaster, because when that dam
- 14:31broke, it came down this little four foot Creek, like four foot
- 14:34wide Creek, and scoured out like in some places it was probably
- 14:38like 60 feet wide, scoured down to bedrock, all of the trees,
- 14:42all of the soil, everything in its path, got washed out. And
- 14:46while that dam was draining, it sounded like jumbo jet engines
- 14:49roaring for like 12 to 15 hours as it just poured out of the dam
- 14:54down into the lake,
- 14:57so a creek that was four feet.
- 15:00It suddenly becomes 50 or 60 feet wide, and it's scored. And
- 15:06looking at it today, what does it look like
- 15:12today? It looks like a Rock Canyon coming down from the from
- 15:16the mine site. It's there's tailings all along the side of
- 15:20the creek still. They didn't remove it.
- 15:22So the animals are still walking through it. We saw tracks going
- 15:26through the tailings. Birds are still nesting in the area. When
- 15:30you get down to the to the bottom of the creek, it dealt us
- 15:35out to probably, oh, maybe two to 300 feet wide, maybe like 100
- 15:41100 to 50 metres wide at the bottom, a huge delta. And right
- 15:46after the disaster, like, of course, all the forest had been
- 15:49scoured out, so there were just massive amounts of trees in the
- 15:53water, and the sediments were like dropping down into the
- 15:55lake. And I believe one of the fisheries texts had said that it
- 16:01used to be like a 200 foot
- 16:05like drop in the lake, and then after the tailings came in, it
- 16:08went down to, like 50 feet below the surface of the water. Yeah.
- 16:12So it had filled this huge canyon under with all of those
- 16:16tailings. So there's a massive amount of tailings in the lake
- 16:19still. So because it was because it was so dense it had gone to
- 16:22the bottom of the lake, and so that's where it lies to this
- 16:25day. Is that correct? Yeah, yeah, that's right. And, and the
- 16:29delta, like on the sides of the canyon in the delta, where it's
- 16:32wider and flatter by the lake, none of the trees have grown
- 16:35back. They planted 50,000 stems of Willow, which grows
- 16:39everywhere. Yeah, any little bit, right? They planted 50,000
- 16:44stems of Willow in their reclamation process, and it
- 16:47wouldn't grow in the feelings. That's extraordinary, because
- 16:51we're very familiar with Willow here. And there's a joke.
- 16:54There's a local joke, if you stood still with a willow
- 16:58walking stick, it would root in the ground.
- 17:02And for it not to root,
- 17:04that's extraordinary. And I was actually looking at some of the
- 17:08company videos, and there were, there were bumming about how
- 17:11well the reclamation was going and how well the trees were
- 17:15growing, and all that, you know. So it's lovely to hear the other
- 17:19side of it. You know, obviously I can't go and see it myself.
- 17:23So because it was such a pristine area, pristine nature,
- 17:30full of nature, and
- 17:38your people, you talk about the importance of the salmon. Would
- 17:42you we have no idea of the culture around the salmon. I
- 17:46have some idea because I've been reading up about it. But could
- 17:49you explain to people in Ireland about the culture of the salmon
- 17:53in relation to your people,
- 17:56the salmon are a really keystone species for food, but also also
- 18:03culturally, because they bring us to the river, and it's our
- 18:06relationship with the river that really is a key part of our
- 18:10culture. And the salmon are used to get through the winter
- 18:15months, so we we dry the salmon with smoke and salt and wind in
- 18:20the summer months and preserve that for the winter. We jar the
- 18:23salmon. We home, preserve it in glass jars. Home preserving. We
- 18:27freeze it, we make it into soups, we trade it for other
- 18:32foods and medicines. And so without that salmon, there's
- 18:36this really big gap, not only for nutrition, but we're not
- 18:39going to the river. We're not going to those places anymore.
- 18:42So it really is more than just protein on a plate for us. It's
- 18:46a really,
- 18:48my, my, my partner, who's passed would say that salmon brings
- 18:52families together and keeps families together. You know, we
- 18:56harvest together, we process, we eat the food together. And it's
- 18:59there's a real, loving component to that, that that keeps us
- 19:04strong. And so it's, it was a, it was a devastation to think
- 19:09that, well, the reality of, like, a lot of people just never
- 19:12fished anymore after that disaster happened, and it's
- 19:15like, what do you eat? You know, what do you eat if you don't
- 19:19have salmon? So
- 19:21it was really, it was a really difficult time, and still,
- 19:23people are having trouble with it because a lot of people don't
- 19:26have the confidence to eat it anymore.
- 19:31So salmon would be fundamental to your tradition and culture?
- 19:37Would you agree? Yes, yes, salmon is fundamental to our
- 19:40traditional culture and all along the river, not just our
- 19:44community, all along the Fraser River, and it connects us to our
- 19:48neighbours at the mouth of the river and along the coast as
- 19:51well. So the salmon comes up the rivers to spawn in the interior,
- 19:56in the mountains and the lakes, and then, you know, goes down to
- 19:59the ocean to spend.
- 20:00This time. So it wasn't only us. It was all of the coastal
- 20:03nations too that also depend on salmon that are moving through
- 20:06their territories when they're fishing. So it just had this
- 20:09huge unknown ripple effect. And,
- 20:12you know, just that impact of like, is it even safe to eat,
- 20:16you know, all of the bio accumulation, the compacting of
- 20:19that in the body, and to eat that it just, it just made
- 20:24people feel really uneasy. To eat it again.
- 20:28That's That's extraordinary, you know, to suddenly, to have that
- 20:32completely taken out from underneath you and and not being
- 20:35able to trust us, it's like almost not being able to trust
- 20:39your own body. And yet you feel like you're you're letting
- 20:42letting the salmon down because you don't trust them.
- 20:46And it's heartbreaking. Is absolutely heartbreaking,
- 20:50absolutely the the mining industry has completely changed
- 20:54our relationship with salmon. It's changed our relationship
- 20:57with the lake, with the water, and it's changed relationships
- 21:00in our communities as well, because there were people who
- 21:03are working for the mine, and that's how they put food on the
- 21:05table for their family. Not a lot of people, but enough that
- 21:09they could feel the tensions and the real social pressure to not
- 21:13say anything or they would lose their job. There was the fear
- 21:16that they would lose their job. And so you know the difference
- 21:19between the mining culture and our indigenous culture, like our
- 21:23culture is about transparency and sharing the wealth and
- 21:26redistribution, and mining culture is all about extraction
- 21:30for like, capital gain and greed at any cost. And so those two
- 21:35systems are coming up against each other, like human versus
- 21:38money. Yeah, yeah. And
- 21:41on one side you've got material, realistic, consume, devour,
- 21:46devour, devour, devour. And on the other side,
- 21:50what's what's of value to your people and our people is our
- 21:56tradition, our heritage, and everything that goes along with
- 21:59that. And material materialism is very much second, you know,
- 22:05it's,
- 22:06it's, it's really interesting, because in our campaign,
- 22:11everyone involved in it,
- 22:13nobody is interested in in money or anything like that. It's just
- 22:17we, we realise what's at stake here, you know, and we have
- 22:22different things, our bogs and our mountains, which are sacred
- 22:26to us, and the communities in those areas, which will be
- 22:30there'll be complete upheaval.
- 22:33And it already is. The mining has created splits in the
- 22:37community because a farmer sold his field to allow the mine in.
- 22:43And,
- 22:44you know, so all that, all that takes place as well. So we can
- 22:48understand that and and how, possibly, in relation to salmon,
- 22:53I know doesn't make you smile, but the potato was a big thing
- 22:57here for us, and there's very many traditions and so on around
- 23:02the potato, and the eating of the potato, and
- 23:04we experienced a great hunger here, caused by colonialism in
- 23:09the past. And I think 2 million people died as a result of that,
- 23:12and that's because the potato crops failed. But there was a
- 23:17reliance created by the colonial government here at the time,
- 23:24that the people were forced to eat potato and nothing else.
- 23:28They had nothing else. So when he took the potato away, then
- 23:31that was really a way of clearing the land and getting
- 23:35rid of people, you know, so similar story different parts of
- 23:39the world and around food as well, and around the salmon or
- 23:44around the potato. So
- 23:48there probably was an element of tourism and other commercial
- 23:52things going on in relation to the pristine environment. Do
- 23:55those things still go on or as a result of that? Or have you
- 24:00noticed a difference?
- 24:02Yeah, after the disaster, when all the tailings went into the
- 24:05water, it definitely changed the lake, which impacted the local
- 24:09lodges, because people didn't want to come, everybody
- 24:12cancelled all of their reservations to come and fish
- 24:15and to be in the area out of feel fear for what all of the
- 24:19the heavy metals were, you know, in the water. And also, for
- 24:25during the cleanup, there was they were burning the the logs
- 24:28that were covered in the waste tailings, and so the smoke was
- 24:30in the air. And so that that year, in 2014 all of the lodges
- 24:35just basically, didn't they, all of you know, everything had been
- 24:38cancelled for the rest of the summer, and then all through the
- 24:40fall. So they lost money on that. There were people who were
- 24:44trying to sell their homes that couldn't sell their homes
- 24:46because they're basically the value had dropped so low after
- 24:49the disaster, because it's like, well, where do you draw your
- 24:51water? On the lake? Well, we don't want to be drinking my
- 24:55mining tailings water. So that had impacts on folks.
- 25:00And I think that there's been some recovery since then, I
- 25:04think mostly because a lot of people have it's there's been
- 25:07enough time that people are kind of forgetting it's not in the
- 25:09news anymore, yeah, and I, I mean, I don't know specifically,
- 25:15but I know that there were some deep impacts, and people were
- 25:18looking for compensation. Some people received a bit of
- 25:22compensation, but from the mind, but it was a very like, tedious
- 25:26and stressful and complicated process, from what I heard.
- 25:31But I personally didn't apply for any of that, so I'm not I
- 25:35couldn't give you any specific numbers, but it was impacted.
- 25:39Yeah, and can I bring you back to the topic water?
- 25:44What happened to the drinking water?
- 25:47So after the disaster happened, there was a complete water ban.
- 25:52So no water was being used, like, not even to flush the
- 25:54toilets, because they were like, We don't know what's in there.
- 25:56We don't know if you want to be bringing it into your home. And
- 25:59so that lasted for a couple of weeks, the water quality dropped
- 26:03from better than drinking water standards, better than aquatic
- 26:08levels for aquatic life to exist. And I had talked to one
- 26:14of the locals there who he had a filter on his water, and he said
- 26:19that he would change his filter every two years, not because it
- 26:22was clogged and needed to be changed. It would still look
- 26:24brand new, but because he just wanted to have, you know, was
- 26:27like, Okay, well, I should change it. But after the
- 26:29disaster happened, he was changing his water filter every
- 26:32week. And he's just said the cost was very expensive to be
- 26:36doing that every single week, just so that they had they were
- 26:39taking some of the turbidity out, and he said he also wasn't
- 26:42sure if it was getting all of the chemicals out, because they
- 26:45use a lot of chemicals to process the gold and the silver
- 26:48and whatever they're after. And in addition to that, in the
- 26:51tailings facility, there's treated sewage that would be
- 26:54trucked up from Vancouver to put dumped into the tailings
- 26:57facility, because it is a waste facility. And I think that's the
- 27:00biggest thing that people don't connect with a mine, is they
- 27:03think about, they think about the gold, they think about the
- 27:06money. They think about, you know, all of, all of the jobs.
- 27:09But they don't talk about that a mine is a waste storage
- 27:12facility. Like probably over 90% of what comes out of a mine and
- 27:16what is crushed up and put into the facility is waste. And not
- 27:19only that, but you're taking it deep from the ground. You're
- 27:22exposing it to air and the elements, which it's never been
- 27:25you know, happened, probably in millions of years. And you're,
- 27:30you're, you're creating a whole new environment. And so there's
- 27:36reasons why the tailings facility is covered in water is
- 27:39to limit that exposure to the wider environment. So when the
- 27:42disaster happened, all of that was just let loose in the world,
- 27:45without any type of way to track it or to contain it. And now the
- 27:50mine is pumping directly the waste,
- 27:54the tailings, into
- 27:56groundwater, and so there's no way to track that at all. And so
- 27:59they're getting sneakier and more clever, and how they hide
- 28:03what those readings are
- 28:07when you say they're pumping so they're pumping the mine out
- 28:12into groundwater. So because mines go so deep, for anyone
- 28:16that's listening to this, the pumps need to be going all the
- 28:19time to keep the water out of the mines, is that the water
- 28:22you're talking about, yeah, that they're pumping out,
- 28:25it's the excess water from the tailing storage facility, from
- 28:28the water so they cover it in water. And when they have too
- 28:31much water, that was what was happening, like they need to
- 28:34have a stable level. And so when they get too much because it's
- 28:37in an interior rain forest, so there's a lot of rain, yeah, and
- 28:40so you have to deal with the excess water. So if you have too
- 28:43much water, or it's that's a problem too, right? And so you
- 28:47could topple them down again. So they need to pump off the excess
- 28:50water. So that's they were. They're pumping that out into
- 28:54the creek, the little creek that's now the giant Creek,
- 28:56yeah, but they still needed to pump more, because they had a
- 29:00certain amount they could pump into the creek, but they still
- 29:03needed to pump more water. So then they started pumping it
- 29:07into groundwater, absolutely disgusting. And our community
- 29:13has, and the community of likely, the the settler
- 29:16community of likely, we have, you know, challenge the permits.
- 29:21We have called it into question. We've called for more
- 29:24environmental assessments. Because actually, Mount holy
- 29:27mine never underwent an environmental assessment when it
- 29:30was built. And so our community was pushing for saying, like, we
- 29:33need to have a full environmental assessment before
- 29:35any expansion plans happen, before any more dumping happens.
- 29:39And it was denied,
- 29:42and was there a reason given as to why it was denied? Or you
- 29:45don't know, or you can't remember, like the way that the
- 29:49permitting process is in Canada is that once you, once you get
- 29:52it, once you get a the green light to build the project,
- 29:56basically, the system is set up to just continue to permit.
- 30:00It's called a permit. It's a permit, it's an allowance, it's
- 30:03a yes. So it's a process to get to yes always. And so getting a
- 30:08no is a very difficult thing, and even with a major disaster,
- 30:13we still didn't get a no, and the mine still didn't get a
- 30:15fine. So that's how,
- 30:18that's how it is to mine in Canada. So that's why a lot of,
- 30:21I think over 70% of the world's mining companies are
- 30:24headquartered in Canada, because of the slack regulations. And
- 30:28it's just like the laws are geared to promote mining, right?
- 30:34Okay, here we are. We haven't started our mine. It's it's only
- 30:39in, in the planning.
- 30:42What would you say to us in relation to that? What
- 30:47I would say that if, if the mind hasn't started yet, then you are
- 30:51in the strongest position that you will be in, from my
- 30:53experience, and to continue to organise and to push back and to
- 30:59have different speakers and the community really has a lot more
- 31:02power than you think you do. Mines put a lot of money into
- 31:07messaging that makes it seem like it's a done deal. They talk
- 31:11about it in present tense. They talk about it like this will be,
- 31:14this is how we're going to do it. They call it the mind,
- 31:17I would say, you know, really being aware of your language,
- 31:21around calling it a proposed project, around instilling doubt
- 31:24into the mind, around, you know, having the community realise
- 31:30that there is power in that collective organising and the
- 31:34mind puts a lot of money toward trying to, you know, smooth out
- 31:38public relations. And really, here in Canada, really focuses
- 31:42on jobs, but they never really tell you what kind of jobs. And
- 31:45so if local folks are working at the mine, they might experience
- 31:48for our people, it's low level jobs that aren't union jobs.
- 31:53They don't get any additional training to advance in those
- 31:57jobs, and people are flown in from all over the world to do
- 32:00the more advanced jobs. And the the labour workforce, like the
- 32:04general labour workforce, is
- 32:07coming from all over and has no connection to the local
- 32:09community. And there's an influx of money and influx of drugs and
- 32:13influx of alcohol, an influx of sexual violence. And so these,
- 32:19these are just facts. This is we've seen over and over and
- 32:22over so, you know, thinking about beyond just the job, it's
- 32:26like thinking about your children, thinking about the
- 32:28safety of your community, thinking about the health
- 32:31facilities, if they can even handle that influx of spikes in,
- 32:36you know, trips to the hospital, all of Those types of things
- 32:40aren't usually worked into like environmental impact assessment,
- 32:45so there's the bigger picture to think about and to really
- 32:49organise your community around that, and just your relationship
- 32:52with the land will be forever changed. Your
- 32:57like going out to Quesnel Lake, to me, is now it's it's a sad
- 33:01thing, whereas before it was so clean and so beautiful and so
- 33:06empowering, and we bathe in the lake and have ceremonies and all
- 33:10of that, and now it just feels like visiting a terminally ill
- 33:15relative.
- 33:17So it's, it's very impactful. That's such a strong image what
- 33:23you said there, and there's a lot for us to to listen to and
- 33:27to become aware of,
- 33:30just such, such a great opportunity, you know, to have
- 33:34your experience right in front of the audience here in the
- 33:37sparring mountains in Northern Ireland, to hear that, because
- 33:40that's what. It's realistic.
- 33:44Draw you back a little bit.
- 33:47Was there ever restitution made to community in general? Or,
- 33:54you know, where is the community now? How are they? How how's the
- 33:59community feeling. How is it? Where's all that
- 34:04in our community, there's a lot of frustration with Mount
- 34:07polymine Because they promised a lot of things that they didn't
- 34:11deliver on. You know, they promised that they would clean
- 34:14up the tailings, which they didn't. They only promise, they
- 34:18only cleaned up enough to go to back into operation, and then
- 34:21the mine life keeps getting extended and extend further and
- 34:25further as they explore for different
- 34:28gold and silver and other areas of the property. Can I ask you,
- 34:32when they extend the mine life? Do they also extend the waste
- 34:36mine tailings facility? Or how do they manage that?
- 34:40Yeah, yeah, everything just gets expanded. So they'll start with
- 34:43a small project, and then they'll just keep adding on and
- 34:46adding on. They call it project splitting. So in order to not
- 34:50trigger an environmental assessment, they'll add one
- 34:52little piece over here, but they'll be like, applying for,
- 34:55like, say, 15 different small permits instead of one big
- 34:59permit. That's.
- 35:00Comprehensive overview, they'll split it up into a whole bunch
- 35:03of little permits so that each little permit won't trigger a
- 35:06review. And then with, with every expansion, if they're, say
- 35:11they're, they're, they're exploring in a new area, and
- 35:13they're gonna they want to expand the mine, to have a new
- 35:15pit in a new area, then they have to expand the tailings
- 35:19facility. And the original design for the tailings facility
- 35:22is for a much smaller footprint. It's for that smaller nine and
- 35:26so that's what happened at Mount poly, is it kept getting bigger
- 35:28and bigger and bigger until it just split its seams and just
- 35:31pour it out. And then when they were permitted to go back into
- 35:36operation, to repair and to clean up, they just patched it
- 35:41up, and then just kept going. And so
- 35:45the laws around
- 35:48the you know, with the requirements for cleanup and the
- 35:52requirements for permitting or for environmental assessments,
- 35:55really haven't changed, and it's just really frustrating. It's a
- 35:59really frustrating thing. So having this knowledge upfront
- 36:03for your community to know that you are actually quite powerful
- 36:07in this position right now, and to look to other places that
- 36:10have
- 36:12defeated
- 36:13the monster, like the title cotin, where they have stopped
- 36:18the Tico mines and they drew on their neighbours to help them do
- 36:22that as well. And so knowing that what ever happens at a mine
- 36:27like that is going to travel through the world, that's going
- 36:30to move in water, that's going to, you know, move with the
- 36:33animals, moving through like it isn't actually ever super
- 36:36contained, even if they have a tailings facility. And if it
- 36:39fails, then, you know it's definitely not going to be
- 36:43contained and is going to travel everywhere,
- 36:47right? Oh,
- 36:49have you ever seen an example of responsible mining
- 36:53anywhere in Canada, or one that upholds human rights even
- 36:59I sat on a board called the initiative for Responsible
- 37:02mining, assurance, or Irma, and
- 37:06they were trying to create a standard. Well, I was part of
- 37:09that at the time, trying to create a standard that had
- 37:12responsible mining. And as far as I know, there hasn't been a
- 37:17mine that has satisfied all of those things like protecting the
- 37:21water and human rights seem to be pretty basic
- 37:26things. But when you get into a mining permit or into, you
- 37:32know, a standard, often they are complicated, to the point that
- 37:35they are the mines are able to say, well, oh, that's that's too
- 37:39costly.
- 37:41We can't do that. How about we do this lesser version? And it's
- 37:47been really an education for me, like I remember after the mount
- 37:51poly disaster, and I was asked to sit on as an advisor to the
- 37:55global tailings review committee.
- 37:58People were talking about, people in the mining industry
- 38:00were talking about what the acceptable level of death was,
- 38:04and I said, well, one death is too many. And they laughed at me
- 38:08and said that I didn't understand what they were
- 38:10talking about. And I said, No, I just disagree and have very
- 38:12different values than what you're talking about, and they
- 38:15don't include death of animals or impacts to the ecosystem in
- 38:20their evaluations, either. So if you are an integral part of that
- 38:24system that you live in, and like the salmon are all gone,
- 38:28they don't even include that in terms of their their death
- 38:31assessment. They just, they only count human life. But even in,
- 38:35like the disasters that happened after mount poly, like in
- 38:38Mariana, Brazil and brumadeno, where there was significant loss
- 38:41of life.
- 38:43You know, they are still building dams in the same
- 38:46manner, and they just deem it as acceptable. So there's a huge
- 38:52despairing disparity in values around that
- 38:58that's quite startling. You know, what's an acceptable level
- 39:01of death? Yeah, yeah, water, professionalism, yeah. And
- 39:06that's why I say mining is always mining at all costs. They
- 39:09need to get their cash. They, you know,
- 39:13they will do whatever it takes to make that happen. So, you
- 39:17know, communities who are organising really need to be
- 39:21have a plan, and, yeah, learn from others. There's a lot of
- 39:25resources out there. There's a really great book by Joan kuyek
- 39:29called,
- 39:31what is it called? Is it unearthed? Joan kuyek, she was
- 39:35part of the Canadian mining watch, and she has a it's a
- 39:39really good book about community organising. So how's this
- 39:42disaster shaped your path since? Or has it?
- 39:48Yeah, the this, the my, the mount poly mining disaster
- 39:51really changed the trajectory of my life. Personally, I think in
- 39:55the
- 39:56like the first eight months following the disaster, I was
- 39:59just all kind.
- 40:00Consumed in being part of the response and this, like
- 40:03emergency, state of emergency in our community. I was working 18
- 40:09hour days for months on end, and I got really sick, and it was
- 40:13just a very frustrating and disheartening, like
- 40:19heartbreaking, work to do, but I knew that it was something that
- 40:22I could contribute to our community, to be part of that.
- 40:25And I stayed as long as I could, basically. And then I just had
- 40:27to step back and and then I really turned toward sharing our
- 40:31story of what we went through with other communities who are
- 40:34facing mining, and talking about the Canadian model. I did a lot
- 40:37of work in Alaska, helping them, because in northwestern British
- 40:41Columbia, all of that mining water or any disasters would
- 40:46flow down into Southeast Alaska. So they're very interested in
- 40:49what's happening in Canada and British Columbia, and also
- 40:53working with other folks
- 40:56on the East Coast who are facing community mining projects, and
- 40:59basically just sharing our experience so that the community
- 41:02has a much more informed understanding of what the
- 41:05realities of mining are and what the potential impacts are of a
- 41:08disaster. Because the mine will always say, Oh, that's a really
- 41:13like. That's a really small chance of that happening, which
- 41:16is untrue. Yeah. And if you, if you look at the the the third
- 41:21party report that was put out
- 41:25after the mount poly disaster.
- 41:28Oh, gosh.
- 41:30Kirk van oh, what's his name? Now it's been so long so that
- 41:33think of these names, these engineers names. It was a
- 41:37commissioned report that British Columbia had, and they had these
- 41:42well regarded and respected engineers put a report together.
- 41:45But one of the things that they said in that report was that,
- 41:48you know, to kind of expect, like, statistically,
- 41:53two fails every decade for mining the way that mines are
- 41:57being built today. And so not long after that, we had the
- 42:01Mariana disaster. We had the Bromedino disaster. And then
- 42:05there are other incidents that happen that may not trigger
- 42:10an investigation or a report, but they're cumulatively
- 42:13happening like there's oil spills on mine sites all the
- 42:16time. And if it is, if it's under, I think at Mount Paul, it
- 42:20was 200 litres, if it was anything less than 200 litres of
- 42:23oil, they didn't have to report it like that's a 200 litres.
- 42:27It's a lot of Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then you think about all of
- 42:30the exploration and the drill rigs and the machines, and it's
- 42:33a lot of diesel, and you know all that. So yeah, you can
- 42:37imagine what isn't being reported. And so when you add
- 42:41all of that up, it is a giant waste site in every in every
- 42:45aspect
- 42:47I was reading recently,
- 42:51whatever. But the the working mines which are open and
- 42:56working, an even bigger problem is the mines that are closed and
- 43:00they run into the hundreds, if not 1000s, particularly in BC
- 43:04and Alaska and so on. And now there's a big problem, because
- 43:09the permafrost is melting and the walls are collapsing, and
- 43:14then they're all old. It's all running into the same
- 43:17watersheds, you know, which, again, is wiping out more salmon
- 43:21runs and more, you know, all the way down to the coast. So, like,
- 43:27it's a cumulative problem. And it's, it can only get bigger
- 43:32as it is, you know, can only get worse. And it's, it's, it's
- 43:38outrageous. It is outrageous. Yeah, the climate change and
- 43:43climate disaster that those are, they go hand in hand with
- 43:48mining, because right now, the mining industry is trying to
- 43:51convince people that they can mine their way out of climate
- 43:53crisis. Yeah, and because, because they're providing, like,
- 43:56rare earth minerals for solar panels and copper and all of
- 44:00this stuff where they're not telling you is that they are,
- 44:03like, forcing their way into communities that don't want
- 44:06them. They're mining without consent. They're poisoning the
- 44:08water, and in places like
- 44:11in South America, we're in the high desert, and they're going
- 44:14after like, lithium, where there's like, very little water
- 44:18to begin with. They're they're using all of the water for their
- 44:21mining operations, and then it's polluted by the time they
- 44:24finished using it. And then in our territory, like in new Hulk,
- 44:29the glaciers are melting, and so there's new areas opening up
- 44:33under the glaciers, where those exploration companies are just
- 44:37frothing at the mouth to get in there using disgusting language
- 44:40like virgin land that they're ready to like pillage, which
- 44:45also reflects the cultural kind of values based
- 44:50perspective that these miners have towards not only the land,
- 44:54but towards the communities that they're coming into to extract,
- 44:58to pillage, to do all.
- 45:00These terrible things, and that cumulatively is going to run
- 45:04down the mountains into the watersheds, impact the salmon,
- 45:07like you said, impact the grass beds, where all of the, you
- 45:11know, there's this, these whole sub ecosystems that we are aware
- 45:14of, yeah, and then, and then, and then, like the other species
- 45:18out in the ocean that depend on salmon or depend on the little,
- 45:21you know, the little fry that are going out for food. Yeah,
- 45:24all of that's impact. And then so you're having this bio
- 45:27accumulation of, like, polluted, polluted bodies, basically, or
- 45:32just a complete collapse due to starvation. And that just
- 45:36ripples through everything. So it just goes so much farther
- 45:40than what they are required to report or consider, yeah, one
- 45:46wonders how,
- 45:48how it's going to end. You know,
- 45:53can only end badly for us all you know,
- 45:56and it's 1000s of years of repair, like you don't know, and
- 46:00then the potential for acid formation, like acid rock
- 46:03formation, yeah, they'll always downplay it, that it's like
- 46:06potential, you know, but it's like, yeah, but you don't know,
- 46:10you haven't had enough time, because that could be, that
- 46:13could be over maybe a decade, that could be over two decades.
- 46:16Like, one of the things I told a mining executive at Imperial
- 46:20Metals was, I said, you know, when this project's done, you
- 46:23will move on to the next project. You will take your
- 46:25money, you will take all the money that you extracted from
- 46:27our homelands, and you will move on to the next thing, and you'll
- 46:30never think about us again. But for those of us who are left
- 46:33here, whose home is here, this is now part of our identity and
- 46:38part of the identity of our children going forward, like my
- 46:41grandchildren are going to have to deal with this disaster, with
- 46:44this pollution, and you'll never think twice about it. You'll
- 46:47just move on to the next place. And that's the reality of
- 46:51mining. It's a boom and bust system also. So if you're
- 46:53working for a mine and prices dip, you're going to be out of a
- 46:56job like there's no there's no safety net for you. So that job
- 47:00that they're really hammering, that you're going to have this
- 47:03really well paying job is always at the mercy of the markets, and
- 47:07so there's not a whole lot of confidence in so if you're
- 47:11buying houses and trucks and whatever, you're spending your
- 47:14money on investing in mortgaging, that could all just
- 47:17go away. If there's a crash in the market, yeah, a disaster
- 47:21happens, and prices dip, and then your mind that you're at
- 47:24goes into care and maintenance, and you just have to wait it out
- 47:28so they don't tell you that either. Yeah, not a good news
- 47:32story.
- 47:34No, I always say that mining is like the biggest secret you've
- 47:37never heard about. You know, they keep it very, very tight
- 47:41lipped about mining. They don't have social media accounts and
- 47:44share other than in their own inner circle. Yeah, yeah.
- 47:51I think my last question is, what gives you hope?
- 47:55Oh, I think that the human spirit is absolutely incredible,
- 48:00and when people care and organise and talk to each other
- 48:03and support each other and get their kids involved and use
- 48:07creativity, I think it's incredible what people can
- 48:10achieve. We had, we had a exploration company, company
- 48:15come into new hall territory in 2021
- 48:18and we issued them an eviction order and raised hell with them.
- 48:21And, you know, had media statements ready and plunged
- 48:25their market value on the stock exchange. And I trolled their
- 48:29their president on LinkedIn, and he was the only person I
- 48:32followed. And every post he said, I was like, You have no
- 48:35authority to be a new club territory, like, say, the hell
- 48:37out of our out of our homelands. And just, you know, I actually
- 48:42when we issued that eviction order, the RCMP, the police, the
- 48:46Federal Police, contacted me and left me a voicemail, and they're
- 48:49like, We need to talk to you. And so we took that voicemail
- 48:52and we put it on social media and basically made fun of them,
- 48:55like, you have no authority to be trying to, like, shut me up,
- 48:59like I have every right to have my opinion, and I know what I'm
- 49:02talking about, and they never called me back. So, you know,
- 49:06good trouble, have fun with it. You got to enjoy the resistance,
- 49:11you know, spreading the word and really focusing on your values
- 49:15and what you're trying to pre protect, I think, is probably
- 49:19the thing that really gives me hope, like people are amazing,
- 49:23and a small group of really caring, organised people can do
- 49:26a lot of good work.
- 49:29Yeah, and I think that's a good, good place to leave this
- 49:32conversation. Nuskmata thank you very much for coming on.
- 49:36Really appreciate it, and I really enjoyed talking with you
- 49:39today. Excellent. Thank you. I'm so glad and standing in
- 49:43solidarity from the clock a limp with you and yeah, give him
- 49:52hell as we close, I keep thinking about distance, the
- 49:56distance between the Fraser River and Greencastle, between.
- 50:00The Secwépemc territory and the Sperrins between one tailings
- 50:04dam and another proposed mine, and yet the patterns feel
- 50:08painfully close at Mount Polly, the dam collapsed within 20
- 50:13years, 20 years, a single generation, and when the dam
- 50:17failed, it ran through people's food systems. It travelled the
- 50:22Fraser River, salmon routes, drinking water, the places where
- 50:26children learn to fish.
- 50:30There's been little real compensation, no restoration
- 50:34that can return a river to what it was, no check that replaces
- 50:38certainty when you turn on a tap and wonder at the quality of the
- 50:41water.
- 50:44Thanks for spending time with this conversation. What you've
- 50:48heard here comes out of people's day to day reality and from a
- 50:52place that's living with a lot of unanswered questions. And if
- 50:57you'd like to understand more of the wider picture behind it, you
- 51:01might want to listen to episode 23 a conversation with Dr Steven
- 51:05emmerman The science of failure true risk and responsibility. In
- 51:11that episode, Stephen speaks in detail about mine tailings dams
- 51:15and slag heaps and about the long term risks they carry for
- 51:18people and places. If you feel that stories and information
- 51:22like this matter and deserve to be heard more widely, you can
- 51:25help by following the podcast, leaving a five star review and
- 51:29sharing it with others. It makes a real difference. We'll be back
- 51:33with another conversation soon for the air we breathe, the
- 51:37water we drink, and the earth that supports us we hold the
- 51:40line you.