Latest / The Narrative with Aaron Baer / Wolves In White Coats - HHS Report Discussion
Transcript
- Narrative Studio: Again, everybody, we've got a special episode of the narrative podcast for you today. Mike Andrews, Aaron Bear, and we are coming to you live because big, big news that we wanted to talk about. really a historic day in a lot of ways because of a bombshell report that just dropped today called Wolves in White Coats. It is exposing the fraud that's been running rampant through the medical system and how the subtitle is how doctors and hospitals pushed and profited. From the fraud of gender medicine. Aaron, you're listed as a as a author on this report. first of all, thanks for your work in in bringing this to light. And how did all this start coming together, first of all? Yeah, you know, this has been something that's been in the works for a long time. and something that, you know, for a lot of us who have been involved in protecting kids from gender medicine, we have been wanting to see Because, you know, i it's a little it's still jarring when you really step back and think about what's been going on in our country, where children and families were wrapped up into what was so very clearly a lie, right? So it it's it's one thing for you know, say it's an experimental cancer medicine or something like that, but this was a a lie of like your kid's born in the wrong body, right? Something so obviously stupid. but the question was, how was this allowed to become so pervasive? It was everywhere, right? You see that in the report. It it was in a handful of clinics in the early 2010s, and there was hundreds by you know the the early 2020s. so how did that actually happen? and so this has been the the the work of a lot of a lot of great researchers, doctors, lawyers who wanted to answer that question. How did this happen and how do we make sure this never happened again? That was sort of the The impetus of the question. and because I think for a lot of us, Mike, the most disturbing thing, yeah, you know, we passed the SAFE Act in Ohio to ban these procedures in our state and lots of other states have done the same. but then and and federally, President Trump, you know, signed the executive order to stop that. But all the folks who were involved in this still have jobs, the vast majority, they're still there. So, how do we explain how this happened and how do we make sure those folks are held accountable? And that this never happens again. I'm curious, Aaron, because we did so much work here on the Safe Act and a lot of those foundations were laid before I was even at C C B. Yeah. Were were some of the seeds for this report planted as you were hearing from transitioners or detransitioners as part of that process and and is that some of what informed the report? Yeah, you know, I I think for a lot of we we saw some really obvious things about how this happened, right? And it was it was so shocking. like seeing the the I I think the the most evident example that the report exposes that a lot of us knew about have been talked about in other places is the professional associations, right? So you know, the American College of Ped yeah American Academy of Pediatrics and the American, you know, Pediatric Enderkin Society, WPATH, all of these professional associations went all in on gender medicine on kids with no evidence, right? They just they they were just completely bought and we saw that in in the nationwide fight to to end these procedures on kids because it was always, hey, this is really stupid. They should not be doing this. And the left and the media would come back with like, no, the the professional associations, the experts, trust the experts, they all say, we got to do this. This is good medicine. It's not dangerous. You know, you can pause puberty and then turn it right back on and there's no harms of Cross-sex hormones and you know, all of that. You know, if you don't do it, the kids are gonna kill themselves, right? That was the the big one they would they would say all the time. No evidence behind it, but the professional associations just said, yeah, let's do it. So we were aware of that. when Biden came in and they really started pushing all of this from the FDA level, we were aware of that. I think the the big thing that surprised us as we began this report, and I think the the linchpin of all of it was the profit motive behind these behind these procedures. And without that, I don't think it would have become so pervasive. but with that it's it was the lighter fluid that made these things explode. Yeah. A lot of money to be made as they found out and exploited. And that's probably the most chilling thing that this report reveals. And it exposes what, fifty million dollars in Medicaid fraud as as part of And and that's just one one core of it, right? There there was there's another area where we show ten million dollars of fraud. And again, all of this is just the tip of the iceberg. And we can get into how we we went about researching and finding it. But I think one of the things that we talked about early on in the report that again helps understand how this this happens. I wanted to to to find the this isn't on page eight. That that cost data estimates illustrate the scale of the the revenues for these these hospitals that did this, especially these these children's hospitals. According to a comprehensive 2022 analysis of commercially insured transgender patients, insured transgender patients using claims data spanning nearly three decades, cross-sex hormone therapy entails average yearly payer costs per patient ranging between five hundred and forty-five dollars for androgens, seven hundred and thirty-five dollars for estrogens. And sixteen thousand three hundred and eighty-five dollars for the more costly puberty blockers. So just understand what that's 16,000 for puberty blockers, right? Like this is for hospitals and for for those involved in all of this. this was such a a a big moneymaker because Mike, think about what what medicine is supposed to be, right? And I even want to talk about this from a Christian perspective, which I say is a true perspective. you know, our bodies were made with a purpose to function a certain way, right? And what an illness is, when you have a virus, your your body is it's something is happening to your body, and what ends up happening is your body is fighting to bring it back to health, wants to bring it back to sort of the status quo. and that's what good medicine is. There's something, you broke an arm, you want to set it back so your body can operate functionally, and your body participates in that healing. Process. What transgender medicine is, is we need to break your body. And then we need to continually break it because your body is going to want to fight back to get back to full health. And transgender medicine is like, no, we just want to continue to break it and keep it broken. And we have to actually fight your body, right? So your body wants to naturally produce estrogen and and not have Mass amounts of testosterone. Nope. We want to inject you with high doses of testosterone and have to continue to fight the estrogen that wants to come on. Or your body wants to go through puberty and wants to continue to go through puberty. We need to fight puberty. And it's not a, it's not a tumor, right? Where you're gonna take the tumor out and it's gone. It is nonstop puberty blockers to make you do this. And then it it goes on to say this: lifetime totals for a patient starting as a minor. Can reach 25,000 to 75,000 even without surgeries. For context, we can compare this to the average healthcare spending for children under the age of 18, which is around $3,000. So right there, why why did these children's hospitals, when these purple-haired docs walk into their office and say, hey, we want to start a gender clinic? You know, do I think that the children's hospital CEOs were all ideologues, no. I think there were corrupt capitalists that when they came in said, We want to do this, we don't want to do that. So then they put the big dollar signs in front of and you can see how all of a sudden every child you know, not every the vast majority or or at least a lot of children's hospitals, the vast majority in Ohio certainly, launch gender clinics. Yeah, and so the point of the profit motive isn't lost. They're creating what this report calls captive patients. and to your point about needing to continue on the wrong sex hormones and those types of things in in order to to fight what their body naturally wants to do. You just have that patient that's gonna continually go back, cut the check, give you more money, and and that's how the money continues to flow in. And and you can see from what this report details that once they found that that was a revenue stream for them that they were willing to go all in on it. And Average cost, so if if they can get you to progress from the hormones and the puberty blockers to the surgeries, average total cost per person reach fifty-three thousand six hundred and forty-five dollars for vaginoplasty and over a hundred and thirty thousand dollars for phalloplasty. and I'll let you know, don't Google those things, but you can figure out what those things actually are. and this is again, if we don't understand this issue through the money making lens. it doesn't make sense why something so obviously dumb like the the concept that a man could get pregnant would be endorsed by basically every major medical institution in the country. Yeah. And they're targeting children. Yeah. Like we we can't ignore that part. it's like the cigarette companies, right? Start young because then they've gotta continue down this and and they they just have those again, the captive patient is the is the term that they use. A as we look at the the fraud that's outlined here, Aaron, it can seem a little hard to understand, I think on one level, but I think on the other, when you just get a basic understanding of how medicine works and how medical billing works, you can kind of see pretty easily how they were able to to get around the system. And basically they just said, We're treating you for this or we're going to change the the code as they call it of of your condition in order to be able to prescribe this in a way that your insurance or Medicaid will approve so that we can get money for it. So Right. That that that's right. So, you know, for those anybody who's ever had to fight your insurance company to who has ever had to fight an insurance company? right. you you medical billing is really a a two step process, right? you have the diagnostic code, which is what they say, hey, this is what the the injury is, and then you have the treatment code. right. So this is this is what we're doing to to to do and this is the language that the insurance companies use to determine whether they're gonna pay for a procedure. so I I've we we got kids, so you have a strep throat, I'm reposol, right? so or no, I'm oxicillin rather. right. So you go Get the diagnosis for strep throat, the amoxicillin, they pay for it under your your insurance. you say she's got strep throat, nope, we're gonna put a cast on her right leg. They're gonna say, nope, we're not covering Exactly. It's a nutshell, right? and so that that's and hospitals, you know, one of the major divisions at every hospital. I I mean, you came from healthcare, is medical billing, right? It is the lifeblood. If you get this wrong. it it actually can be massive false claim act fines, right? That can come your I mean you're there's you just look, you you'll find hospitals being billed hundreds of find hundreds of millions of dollars for f false claims. And so all of the this is the language of the hospital. Everybody there knows this. This is a part of the reason why everything is so documented. And you know, you're sitting down, when you're sitting down to in the doctor's office, they're looking at their screen the entire time and typing because they have to make sure they get this right. what our report found was how they were actually going about billing these things to get them to get them paid out. and what we used was we used a tenured sample ten year sample from twenty twenty twenty fifteen to twenty twenty five of an all insurance payer database. now this is gonna sound creepy and but it has been the way th this is not a modern sort of AI, blame the AI why this Well given some of the other things we've already talked about, they're plenty creepy. So this is relatively mild considering. So basically, every insurance claim that's ever made, or or health insurance claim that's ever made is tracked in a publicly available database. Anybody can actually buy this. This is what the these insurance databases are what what insurance companies use to set rates and and monitor trends and all the health trends, all that kind of stuff. It's all de identified, so you can't you don't know who the person is. But you can actually track a person's medical journey over years across multiple providers, all of those things, right? It's it's it's one of the ways we we study trends today. this is actually very similar to how the Ethics and Public Policy Center, similar database that was used on the FDA study regarding Miphopristone, right? So we we used one of these databases and and researched trends around puberty blockers on minors. and the various diagnosis codes and all of that. And so Mike, your your point about fifty million dollars in fraud, that's sort of like the the big headline that we found on this, which was you know, a a report earlier from last year that came out from HHS under Lior Sapir found there was this massive spike in endocrine disorders diagnoses in minors over the last ten years. Hmm. I wonder if that corresponds with anything. Why would that happen? Well, what what they found was actually a lot of minors were being diagnosed with an endocrine disorder so that they could be prescribed a puberty blocker, right? because the condition precocious puberty is an endocrine disorder, very rare disorder, but it is ex and that's why these puberty blockers exist. Well, two problems with that. it is illegal, actually, it is a a false claims act violation. If there is a more specific code. To not use that specific code for for a diagnosis and try to hide what that is, because that's really, you know, the that's the reason why you these things are are public, because they want to be able to monitor trends and see are things actually going right. If you're purposely not using the correct code or not using the exact code, that's a a violation. and what we so we started looking into, okay, where how much were these endocrine disorders actually being this endocrine disorder Diagnosis unspecified being given to kids, followed by a prescription for a puberty blocker with no gender dysphoria diagnosis, which is a diagnosis in the report, and no puberty block and no precocious puberty blocker diagnosis, right? So endocrine disorder diagnosis, puberty blocker treatment on minors. Very clearly a a fraud situation. and we found $47 million in that. $8 million over $8 million in Medicaid, that means taxpayers paid for this. and let's be clear. the kids that they were transing did not have anything wrong with their endocrine systems. Their endocrine systems were completely healthy, right? and this same trend, and again, all the normal caveats, this is potential fraud, right? But we we see the spikes here. This same trend was what was used to that the Department of Justice used when they went after the Cleveland clinic, and the Cleveland Clinic struck that settlement where they ended up having to pay a three hundred thousand dollar fine and establish a two million dollar detransitioner clinic. so already we've seen this methodology be used to successfully prosecute a a hospital. and what we see in here. Is that this is more widespread all across the country and even in Ohio as well. and and that's just one of the the cases of fraud that the report finds. Yeah, the the other one that I wanna mention, just because of the sheer absurdity of it, is when they did prescribe the puberty blocking drugs to kids who were thirteen to seventeen years old. Right, right. Who are in the range for puberty. Exact and in that case they gave them the precocious puberty diagnosis, which How can you be thirteen years old and be going through puberties too soon? It's not possible. It's impossible, right? The average age of puberty for girls is nine to ten. The average age for boys is ten and eleven. Right? By the time you're th by the time you're sixteen, seventeen, you certainly can't be going through pu and I will say there were other things we saw in here where potential diagnoses for pre precocious puberty for like twenty year olds. Again, we didn't die we didn't dive into that here. There's just so much as we were diving into the data that we were like, this is insane that was was coming out. And digging up receipts that were available because this wasn't something that was well one or two ideologues that were doing this kind of off on their own in their own practice found and it's in the report training that was taking place from these professional organizations telling their people how to bill fraudulently in order to get kids on these drugs. Mike, that's that's one of the things that jumped out to all of us 'cause we had a number of medical professionals involved in the the research and writing of this report. And, you know, again, for anybody who works in the healthcare industry, getting diagnosed codes rights and taking the false claims act seriously is one of the most important things, right? Like this is i it's one of the things you'll often hear doctors just complain about is how much how cumbersome this is. but it's important. and What we found from WPATH, right, which was just in the news earlier this week, but what we found was were slides from WPATH where they were actually training doctors on how to use the endocrine disorder unspecified diagnostic code in order to get these things reimbursed. Now now why? Well, you could think of a couple of reasons why. again, we we don't know sp we always have to say allegedly potentially all those types of things here. But think about it this way. Number one, if you are in a red state, let's say, you don't wanna see it probably would look bad for you if all of a sudden there were massive amounts of gender dysphoria diagnoses spiking in your state, right? you would imagine that folks wouldn't wanna see that. So you wanna if you make an endocrine disorder unspecified, you're not gonna, you know, raise the spotlight on you with splatch. Or maybe, you know, gender dysphoria. And there are still some people that when all of this was going on believed the truth. Gender dys dysphoria, as Admiral Brian Christine, who's the head of the office of the Assistant Secretary of Health, that's where the report came from. that was his it was his division that that published our report. a as as he said, you know, this makes it potentially more likely that these guys would reimburse this, right? And so you know, I I really think you know, from from that perspective you can see why these hospitals would go down this path. Yeah. And you mentioned W path, Aaron, a couple of times and and them being in the news recently. a lot of this treatment that has been so just accepted in our culture as this is what you do if someone is dealing with gender dysphoria came from What they said were the the you really informed standards of care. they were informed by data. This was stuff that had been thoroughly researched and all that. And what they're in a deposition or something this week and and a court filing. Cour court filing, court filing. Yeah. Had to or I don't know, had to, but they did come out and say, nope, that was opinion. Yep. Was essentially No, it it's it's what again it's one of these things, Mike, again, that the Thank God for Jesus that we know ultimately justice will be done because these things just drive you mad. there were so many times as we've been fighting against these transgender medicine, this this transing of kids that folks in the media would just call us knuckle draggers and they'd be like, It's you gotta trust the experts. This is the standards of care. You're not a doctor. How would you know? Trust the science. Trust the science, all of this kind of stuff. And they would point to the World Professional Association of Transgender Health. Here's the you know, the standards of care says this is what we you need to do. And we were like, This is so obviously stupid, right? Like i it's a bad idea to inject children. And we European countries that have been doing this for thirty years were backing off of all of their standards because they were finding there was no benefit to doing this. Yes. And and so th there was no evidence, there was no science to back this up. Everything they had was like opinion polls or Like the the it was just such bad research is studies that they would use of like people who opted in but wouldn't be long term studies of these individuals. And in a court filing this week in WPATH admitted that their so called standards of care were just their opinion. Right? And I think for so many folks, like I pray, this is not this should be headline news everywhere, right? Because this is such a betrayal of the trust of the American people. but You know, all of the folks that just went all in on this deserve like d need to apologize and and or or be held accountable because because they were so unquestioning of the authorities of the time, so many kids got hurt. Yeah. And there's there's gonna be a lot of cover for for these groups because when parents are faced with a reckoning of what they've allowed to happen to their kids, they almost have no choice but to just kind of dig their heels in and double down on it because otherwise they've got to face the reality of what they let happen to their kid. Yeah. And so they'll they'll say, well, yeah, the standards were there. We right, even if they were opinion, it was good opinion. And well and and then you had people like Dr. Aton Haim, who's one of the authors on the report, who blew the whistle on these hospital on Texas children's, right? and they were the FBI came after They were trying to be silenced by their clinic. Like this is the It was such a surreal time, right? And i it it reminds me of COVID in some ways of just the the expectations that we checked our brains out of what was going on and just trust the experts. This is the reason why that can't happen. While there are financial figures that are in this report and they are staggering financial figures, it also really details the most significant cost of the the kids who had their lives ruined. At the expense of these procedures. There's eight stories, heart-wrenching stories, heart-wrenching stories of what families went through, what these children went through, how they were abandoned by this medical community, by medical professionals who said they only wanted the best for them by transing them. And then when they decide I don't want this anymore, they had no answers for They had no care to provide for them, and just left them on their own in very painful circumstances because of the surgeries and mutilation that had happened to their bodies. Yeah. No, I mean that's the you you go through that was the thing is with this report that we wanted to really land the plane on here, which was okay, as a as parents, you know, when my kid is sick, if something's going on with my my kid that I I don't know, there's there's three places I I think we could typically trust, right? Would be my my children's hospital, my medical provider. the FDA, right? The the the federal government's you know regulating body over these things. and certainly the professional associations, right? Those these three institutions are ones that when we hear, hey the FDA if I hear a drug has been approved by the FDA, I guess prior to twenty twenty, I would have been prior to the shot. Yeah, prior to this stuff, I would have been like, okay, I I should be able to trust. I'm that means something to me, right? Or I if I heard that again the American Academy of Pediatrics said this is the recommended treatment for my kid, I would have said, okay, then we probably should follow that. I I'm not a doctor, I don't know these stuff. I I I should be able to trust them. or if I go see my, you know, provider at a children's hospital and they were recommending it, I'd I'd I'd want to say, let me do that. and we see all three of these areas failed. And We wanted to show the real life cost of this. And so you you see these stories of, you know, Clementine Breen, who started down this path at at twelve years old and had a double mastectomy at fourteen years old, right? or Layla Jane, who at eleven started experiencing discomfort with her sex, and at twelve she was put on puberty blockers and soon after started testosterone and on her thirteenth birthday she underwent a double mastectomy in San Francisco. Her parents were told the failing to allow this sex rejection procedure could mean losing their child. The the framing was stark, a live son or a dead daughter. The and the crazy thing about that, Mike, is Layla Jane went through this and San Francisco. We heard these same things here in Columbus and in Cincinnati, right? There were there was a script for this stuff. and all of these kids were harmed because and these are just eight examples. And some of these are parent stories too, where you hear the parents talking about the pressure they were under, right, to go through with these things. And we saw just here in Ohio as well, one family where they lost their daughter because they wouldn't agree to put her on. I dose testosterone. this is the kind of stuff like the that that says to me, we need real consequences for what was done. It's not enough to just ban these things. The people that did this need to be punished so that they know to never do it again and the next generation never does this again. What are some of those potential consequences? I know we can't really speculate, but we do know Vice President JD Vance came out today with a with a video after this report was released and saying that people who were named in this report have been referred to the Department of Justice and to the HHS Inspector General. So what does that mean and and what where could that lead? Yeah, you know, I so I would start with looking at what happened with the Cleveland Clinic and Texas children's, right? So I think the examples there are really great examples of the types of primarily civil. penalties that can be levied against these folks. I do know, like our report ends, for example, with, hey, this, there's potential criminal activity that's gone on here. where as we were researching what was going on, the puberty blocker fraud is a lot, it's all really hard to f to to understand. You you you need a lot of great minds to to work through this stuff. The puberty blocker fraud is easier to identify. The cross-sex hormone fraud is a little bit more difficult. But one of the things we found when we were working on this report was minors given a gender dysphoria diagnosis, and then on the same day being d prescribed a hormone. and those were done in a state where these procedures were banned. so we include that in the report as just and it's one of the reasons we're calling in Ohio alone, hey, Attorney General Andy Wilson. You need to investigate these claims and see what was going on here. so that's an I mean, that could be criminal penalties in some states where that happened. the other thing though, that we're gonna be calling for is hearings in Congress, right? these children's hospital CEOs that oversaw this, they need to be held to account, right? Because that's the thing that when these children's hospitals understand that defrauding the the government, defrauding insurance. and harming kids is never worth the money you're making. they apparently didn't know that. so they need to be taught that lesson. Yeah. And I need to plug here too, it's a little bit of a tangent, but not much. this really shows that the ideology is still out there, especially with an election coming up. my gosh, one hundred percent. Because you know, we've seen it with the stuff that's going on with the WNBA right now, with with what this report reveals about gender ideology. There's so much of this that We can't as Christians just sit back and say, Well, I thought Trump took care of that with the executive order. You need to get out and vote because these issues are still very much in play this November. Right. So you already saw Vivek Ramaswamy called this out. Where's Amy Acton on this, right? David Pepper, her running mate, criticized the the Save Ohio sport the Save Women's Sports Bill in Ohio, right? you know, we have huge Senate elections all over the country right now, but not just here in Ohio. but your your state we're we're in Minnesota as everyone where what's going all all of these folks need to answer because they they have clinics in their state that participated in this. and are they going to allow this to just kick back up in the in the years to come? It's it's one of those questions that is one, should be easy for everyone to answer, don't trans kids. and and and and two, is one of those things that is a a real litmus test of of the courage that you're gonna have as a leader. For people listening who want more information on this, we've got a website. It's HHS insurance fraud dot org. You can download a copy of the report. You can read some of the stories. There's a a very powerful documentary that HHS put together with a number of these You gotta see it. It's thirteen minutes long. It's well worth it. Yeah. Parental advisory on that one and they do put that up before before the video starts, but very powerful stories about why this is so necessary. you can also fill out our action alert to contact the Ohio Attorney General there as well. And hopefully that's a great resource that you can share with people to let them know why this is such a big deal, why it needs to be taken seriously, and what they can do about it. because Christians, we need you on this one to be the change that we want to see. Yeah, no, that that's right. And Mike, I I just I I'd be remiss if I didn't just say, number one, God bless and thank you, President Trump, for building out a administration that would publish a report like this, right? And would not be afraid of the medical institutions that were harming it. 'Cause right, the easy answer here is like, all right, they stopped. You know, everyone kinda likes the children's hospitals. We don't wanna kick the horn and shit. Shouldn't leave them alone now? Right. And it's like, no, there needs to be accountability. So so credit to to President Trump for doing this and and certainly to Vice President Vance and his anti fraud task force for bringing it forward. Obviously, Robert F. Kennedy has been phenomenal on this issue. w it what shouldn't be lost on this, is that this report was released from It's called OASH, the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Health, that's led by an incredible man of God, Admiral Brian Christine. was previous led by another man named Richard Levine, who went by the name Rachel Levine. Babylon B's Man of the Year. Babylon B's man of the year, right? and it it is just so poetic that I mean under Richard Levine, that's where l so much of the harm was done, right? It's documented in this report of how much his office was driving these things on kids. And so for for that same office now to be publishing this report exposing it is just impactful. so I'm so grateful for for all of them. Natalie Dodson over in HHS as well was was incredibly involved in this and and phenomenal. and then just the co authors, you know, Dr. Aaron Cariotti, Dr. Aitan Haim, Rachel Morrison from the Ethics and Public Policy Center, Dr. Quentin Van Meter, Victoria Coley, and all of her team over at the Independent Women's Forum. obviously, you know, David Mahan and Ryan Folse here at C C V. Mike, you and your team, with all of the amazing resources. May Mailman, who is involved in this as well. It just was There are so many talented and committed people. That's how we've been able to get on this course is that people have shown more co curves day than ever before. and hopefully this report will will r truly be the the the moment of accountability that so many people have been afraid of and so many people have been calling for. Well, grateful for your leadership on this, Aaron, for your contributions to this report. HHS Insurance Fraud is where you can learn more about it. HHS insurance fraud dot org is where you can learn more about it. Thank you for listening into this conversation today and and stay tuned. I'm sure there's plenty more to come as as we see where this goes from here. So thanks for tuning in today on the narrative.