Latest / TFTC: A Bitcoin Podcast / Bitcoin Offtake Unlocks Oil Production | Chris Alfano, Center of Hash E003
Transcript
- 0:00Chris Alfano, welcome to the Center of Hash.
- 0:04Parker Lewis, it's great to be here.
- 0:05Yeah.
- 0:07Before we get into the topic of the day, we co-work here out of Bitcoin Park.
- 0:13It's mid-July in the Texas summer.
- 0:16How's the summer been?
- 0:18It's been hot, good, rainy.
- 0:22You know, we've done some family trips and stuff like that, so try to get out of it.
- 0:26We're heading to California end of this week.
- 0:29so upstream mining that isn't impacted by the 4 cp you're in texas no natural gas mining
- 0:36no grid no 4 cp no curtailment smu footballs on the horizon uh on the horizon and rising
- 0:44you uh you were at happy valley for that i was disastrous that was a uh not our best not our
- 0:52best effort cool experience though our expectations is high this expectations are high
- 0:57coach is uh saying big things he's a good target for other schools so got to keep him happy at smu
- 1:06but you know good transfer portal given texas run for the money as best team in texas i'll be uh
- 1:12very pleased if we make it to another playoff that might not happen again in quite some time but
- 1:18that's what i said last year with will cole when we were sitting here in the summer looking at the
- 1:23team but you know should be better this year than we were last year so very pumped well uh hopefully
- 1:29hash price is higher in come football season in a month that would be nice got to get the uh
- 1:35ordinal people back selling uh their jpegs that's controversial we'll talk about that towards the end
- 1:41but um we'll use that as a segue into um the topic of the day so in the in in the first couple
- 1:48episodes we've discussed mining at a very broad high level and today we're going to go deep on a
- 1:56specific energy strategy and mining strategy um chris is the co-founder and ceo of 360 energy
- 2:05um chris just give a little bit about your background and what 360 does and kind of what
- 2:13defines your strategy yeah yeah so 360 energy right before 360 uh i went to smu if it wasn't
- 2:22obvious before um studied finance and economics there and started a company 2016 with a hedge fund
- 2:30manager in dallas called keyman intelligence and built that company for four years sold that
- 2:36company in 2020 and started 360 and uh what did that company do that we did a sas solutions for
- 2:45private credit hedge funds so we would uh standardize a bunch of the reporting data from
- 2:51you know these these clo's have 300 positions in private credit um so a bunch of companies that
- 2:58aren't publicly traded don't adhere to gap and so uh what we would do is aggregate all the data
- 3:03that all of those portfolio positions would report so like their financials um sims credit
- 3:10agreements everything like that we'd aggregate that all into uh our platform and we'd standardize
- 3:15it um so customers of ours like other hedge funds clos would have access to the platform they'd log
- 3:22in they'd be able to see all their borrowers uh be able to see kind of standard financial data
- 3:27across their whole portfolio, right?
- 3:32If different borrowers report in different ways
- 3:34and even in borrowers quarter to quarter.
- 3:38So yeah, it was just a tool to make analysts
- 3:41more efficient at actually analyzing,
- 3:43kind of get them out of the monkey labor
- 3:45of having to spread financials
- 3:46and figure out where pieces of information were.
- 3:49So it was just kind of like a database
- 3:51with standardization for everything to do
- 3:53with their portfolio positions.
- 3:56And how'd you get from there to 360?
- 3:57Well, sold the company, moved down to Austin, was out of a job at that point, kind of figuring out what I wanted to do next.
- 4:08COVID happened.
- 4:09So I'm a Bitcoin class of 2020 going down the rabbit hole at that point, kind of right after the company.
- 4:17And obviously fell in love with Bitcoin for many of the same reasons everyone else does.
- 4:21And being a finance guy, being a tech guy, really made a lot of sense in my mind.
- 4:26And so I wanted to start another company.
- 4:28I was kind of sick of doing software stuff.
- 4:31Networked around Austin.
- 4:33I met a great guy named Mike Hamilton, kind of told me all about this Bitcoin mining thing,
- 4:37which sounded really cool.
- 4:39And so kind of started going down the Bitcoin mining rabbit hole.
- 4:43As anyone does, you try to figure out, okay, now I can basically plug in a Bitcoin miner
- 4:48anywhere, but how do I do it, you know, cheaply for a long term to kind of protect the downside,
- 4:54protect the margin, all that stuff.
- 4:55So for us, that was looking at grid, looking at solar, looking at many different, you know, potential options to power our miners kind of settled on natural gas as something that's very abundant in Texas and something that's relatively cheap.
- 5:11We wanted to take it a step further and actually vertically integrate the natural gas into the Bitcoin mining as a way of kind of controlling that future, having, you know, decade at a single location, having complete operational control.
- 5:24And so built a team with Sean Milmo, my co-founder and a few other guys that had a lot more oil and gas background than I did to stand up 360 energy.
- 5:34And at that time, the company's objective was self-mining through the ownership and operation of the natural gas assets.
- 5:44So we went out and bought some old producing gas wells in the Barnett Shale right outside of Fort Worth, just 20 minutes north of downtown Fort Worth.
- 5:53And that's really how we got our start. So took over those wells, put our first Bitcoin mine out there in late 21 and started, you know, mining at probably the worst possible time to be mining and buying infrastructure and stuff like that.
- 6:09But yeah, that was really what it was all about was, you know, how do we find these old, relatively unattractive natural gas assets to traditional oil and gas people and turn that into something much more profitable, much more valuable through Bitcoin mining.
- 6:28Two questions.
- 6:29What initially, so you mentioned in 2020, what made you go down the Bitcoin rabbit hole just quickly?
- 6:34And then second, you started out vertically integrated, owning the assets, but that's evolved a bit.
- 6:43Yes.
- 6:44Yeah.
- 6:45I mean, the rabbit hole was a function of time and a function of just kind of the macroeconomic conditions in the U.S.
- 6:54Right.
- 6:55Knowing enough to know a ton of money printing is probably not good.
- 7:00and seeing all the free money that was going out there was concerning.
- 7:08And so, and also, you know, I'd actually been, you know, I've heard about Bitcoin.
- 7:12My first experience with Bitcoin was actually in 2011.
- 7:16I bought some Bitcoin for one function only,
- 7:19which is actually purchasing some fake IDs for me and all my high school buddies.
- 7:22Common amongst the youngins.
- 7:23So I refuse to look back at how much Bitcoin I had at that time.
- 7:28But, you know, it was purely buy Bitcoin, send it to China, get fake IDs.
- 7:33And so I've kind of known about Bitcoin, but never spent the time kind of throughout college and in my first job really learning about it.
- 7:39And so selling the company, having the time, having all of the QE infinity printing COVID madness all like, you know, put me down the rabbit hole.
- 7:48Yeah. One of the things that I, if I'm explaining Bitcoin to somebody having nothing to do with energy or mining, just using the example that people can't drill an oil well and then sell, you know, in terms, it's not sustainable to do that operation and all of the capital that requires human capital, physical capital, monetary money and time and energy, and then sell it for something that can be easily printed.
- 8:14that can be created on a computer screen in the Fed.
- 8:18And today we're going to be talking a lot about natural gas,
- 8:20but talk a little bit about how your strategy has evolved.
- 8:24And then I want to talk about the natural gas market specifically
- 8:26in terms of how you guys arrived at that part of the energy system
- 8:33to be used as a fuel source for mining Bitcoin.
- 8:37Yeah.
- 8:38Yeah, so getting into natural gas Bitcoin mining,
- 8:43um you know it's i like to say uh sean's background you know is finance investment
- 8:50banking private equity right my background was in software so he's really good at spreadsheets i'm
- 8:54really good at code and so when we built the model for 360 we're like oh you know it looks
- 9:00good in excel i'm used to fixing problems in the real world with you know just changing lines of
- 9:05code. So the first deployment we did was anything, you know, it was not what we expected at all. It
- 9:13was a lot more expensive, a lot more time consuming to actually commercialize this model in the oil
- 9:22field. There's a lot more that, you know, I naively thought, hey, you just plug a Bitcoin miner,
- 9:26it's going to work, right? But there's plenty of considerations in Bitcoin mining, people would
- 9:31you know, cooling server type, stuff like that. And then on the natural gas side, there's,
- 9:34there's plenty of stuff there as well. So it really took us two and a half years. And so
- 9:38to, to actually go from first deployment to a fully standardized, repeatable,
- 9:44dependable gas offtake and monetization system kind of through Bitcoin mining. And during that time,
- 9:51you know, gas prices had gone up tremendously after the, you know, Nord Stream, Russia,
- 9:58Ukraine thing. And then they fell, you know, just as fast. And we were actually approached by a few
- 10:03other upstream oil and gas companies in the Barnett Shale who had caught wind of what we were doing
- 10:08and how much money we were making by mining Bitcoin on our assets. And they asked us
- 10:14to help them do the same thing. And so that was like a big turning point for the company,
- 10:21realizing, you know, that the big realization was like when we started the company,
- 10:25it was, hey, oil and gas is means to an end for Bitcoin mining. Those ends are, you know,
- 10:32sub three cent power, control, long term deployments, no counterparties, right? That's
- 10:37what we were after when we started 360. Becoming an upstream oil and gas producer, talking to other
- 10:44producers, talking to our field personnel, we kind of realized that the paradigm exists on the exact
- 10:51the other end with Bitcoin mining being a means to an end for oil and gas outcomes.
- 10:57And so during that two and a half years figuring this thing out, we were realizing like,
- 11:02hey, you know, we have really cheap power for Bitcoin mining.
- 11:04But if you look at the rewards of Bitcoin mining, how much money we're making, then
- 11:08you put that in oil and gas terms like that is a much better market to monetize natural
- 11:13gas than, you know, selling gas into the pipeline.
- 11:16So we realized like, hey, this is actually very impactful for oil and gas companies who
- 11:20don't really care about Bitcoin or Bitcoin mining, but care about being commercial and making money.
- 11:25And then you combine that with other EMPs asking us to do the same thing for them. And that really
- 11:31launched our services business, which is our main focus today. So today, 360 goes, we deploy and
- 11:37operate these, you know, we call them, call it apex gas offtake is what we call it, but it's really,
- 11:43generators, data center servers that we go deploy out for other EMPs to help them solve their natural
- 11:50gas problems. The benefit to them is they're not having to go down the same school of hard knocks
- 11:57we did, learning all the same things, making the same mistakes, spending all the time doing it.
- 12:01They'd rather, just like an oil and gas company would hire Halberton to go frack wells because
- 12:05it's highly technical and nuanced, they'll hire 360 to go do this gas offtake system for them.
- 12:13So that's been really successful for us.
- 12:14It's really interesting, you know, taking this model and selling it as a service to oil and gas companies.
- 12:21And you guys don't have the capital intensity of then also having to purchase the wells.
- 12:27Yeah, exactly. Exactly.
- 12:28So now we're doing it on behalf of people who have wells.
- 12:32So we're not having to go take on any of the upstream operations or the capital expenditure to actually go take down the asset.
- 12:39Do you guys think of yourselves as an oil field services company?
- 12:43Yeah, I think, you know, in the simplest terms, it's what we're providing is a service to the oil field. You know, I think of it maybe more as like a distributed energy infrastructure company. You know, but it's, you know, six one way, half a dozen another.
- 13:01well let's back up and i want to talk about specific
- 13:05use cases upstream you know in terms of mining at the well site leveraging natural gas i want to
- 13:16just kind of zoom out to paint the picture of the of the natural gas market it's at least specific
- 13:22to the US. And so, you know, approximately 40% of the market is of natural gas is ultimately
- 13:31converted to the electric power industry. Approximately 32% is for industrial purposes.
- 13:37I think like 14% is residential, 10% commercial, and then 4% transportation, just in terms of the
- 13:44end market for natural gas. And now increasingly some of that say electric power is being used to
- 13:50to mine Bitcoin and avenues are being leveraged upstream,
- 13:54like what you guys are doing to monetize natural gas before it ever hits a
- 13:58pipeline.
- 13:59But talk a little bit just about the market for natural gas in the United
- 14:04States,
- 14:04where natural gas is typically drilled and how you guys arrived at what I think
- 14:10is typically North Texas and West Texas for opportunities to monetize Bitcoin
- 14:17mining or to use Bitcoin mining to create a solution in the oil field.
- 14:20Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, natural gas is extremely abundant all over the United States, really in many parts of the world.
- 14:29You know, in the Northeast, you have the Marcellus, which I think is the biggest natural gas play in the U.S.
- 14:37It's like Pennsylvania, West Virginia.
- 14:41You know, then the Bakken in North Dakota, there's a bunch of oil and gas there.
- 14:45Then you keep going down Powder River in Wyoming, DJ Basin in Colorado.
- 14:51You get into New Mexico, San Juan Basin, but further south, Permian Basin, which then bleeds over into Texas.
- 14:59So you start moving east through Texas.
- 15:01You have the Permian Basin, which is probably the biggest oil and gas play in the U.S.
- 15:09You have the Eagleford in south Texas, tons of oil and gas there.
- 15:12You have the Haynesville, which is predominantly a gas play in East Texas.
- 15:18And then you have you know the Barnett Shale North Texas you get into Oklahoma you know Scoop Stack And you keep going up There natural gas in Michigan and in Nebraska and Kansas
- 15:29You know, there's a ton of oil and gas all over.
- 15:33Now, I think what's really interesting about oil is there's effectively, you know, WTI is kind of the benchmark for oil.
- 15:43You can truck oil.
- 15:44You can move oil pretty much anywhere.
- 15:47And there's effectively one benchmark for oil prices, whereas natural gas is highly localized markets.
- 15:55So, you know, not all, you know, gas can have the exact same composition, can look the same, but can earn widely different prices for that gas.
- 16:08Just depending on the local hub you sell that gas into and then the terms of your midstream agreement.
- 16:13So in Hainesville, for example, there's a tremendous amount of gas.
- 16:17Where's the Hainesville?
- 16:18East Texas.
- 16:19Okay.
- 16:20Tremendous amount of gas in East Texas.
- 16:23And it earns a really good price.
- 16:25They're, you know, getting not far off from Henry Hub, which is kind of the benchmark or Houston Ship Channel.
- 16:32Whereas you go to West Texas and the Permian, those guys are selling into Waha, which is usually trades at like a $2 discount.
- 16:39and often goes negative to, you know, prices in East Texas and elsewhere.
- 16:46San Juan Basin, you know, that gas going west earns sometimes higher than even Henry Hub.
- 16:52So as we...
- 16:54Explain some of those dynamics that cause that.
- 16:57And then also if you said that in West Texas at the Waha Hub,
- 17:03it might trade at a $2 discount for an order of magnitude to Henry Hub,
- 17:07like give some sense of where henry hub is today just so you have an order of magnitude of what
- 17:12that discount looks like yeah so henry hub is at you know three dollars fifty cents that's no
- 17:18for mcf it's like the benchmark for for gas um your haynesville producers are probably after
- 17:26midstream fees are getting maybe three dollars twenty cents an mcf so they're getting pretty
- 17:31close tight a tight band to henry hub whereas in west texas you know i think waha is trading at a
- 17:38two dollar discount today to henry hub so that same molecule of gas and then after midstream fees
- 17:44you know might make a dollar an mcf um and not two dollars on fifty dollars like you know yeah
- 17:52it's like a 60 70 discount and the gas can look the exact same it could be the same quantities
- 17:57but widely different revenue generation potential just based on where it is.
- 18:03I think, you know, why that is, right, there's a lot of gas in the Hainesville, there's a lot of gas in the Permian.
- 18:08Well, the Hainesville is really close to the coast, all the LNG export terminals, a lot of industrial uses, Houston and the Gulf Coast.
- 18:15So there's a lot of demand for natural gas in that particular demographic.
- 18:20Whereas the Permian in West Texas, there's no industrial, I mean, hardly any industrial uses out there.
- 18:26So it's really a function of supply and demand. There is a ton of supply of natural gas in West Texas. There's no real localized demand for it. And there's not enough takeaway capacity with pipelines to bring it to where demand centers are.
- 18:42And so just economics 101, you have a way oversupply of natural gas compared to the ability to actually transport it to major markets.
- 18:52And so that's why you have this large differential to Henry Hub.
- 18:58You know, and I would say the band of like the discount that Waha gets to Henry Hub is actually a lot better today than it was this time last year.
- 19:10I think Waha was negative for more than 20% of last year.
- 19:14So Henry Hub could have been $2.50, $3 an MCF.
- 19:17But the differential in Waha was more than Henry Hub.
- 19:22And so if you're an oil and gas producer in West Texas and Waha is negative,
- 19:27like you're selling gas into a pipeline,
- 19:29but you're actually getting charged to put it into a pipeline because the price is negative.
- 19:33You're not making revenue.
- 19:35You're actually having to pay to get that gas taken away.
- 19:37I think most people might be familiar with when solar power or power trades at a negative cost in West Texas because of production tax credits or various different tax incentives that might dictate an abnormal economic situation.
- 19:59what would cause a economic scenario, obviously way more supply than there is demand, but why would the market be producing all of that if there's not similarly some tax anomaly that's causing the distortion?
- 20:20Yeah, that's a really good distinguisher, right?
- 20:23So in your Haynesville, like those are wells drilled with the intention of finding natural gas.
- 20:27but those are natural gas only wells and so when they're underwriting drilling those wells it's
- 20:32it's for gas economics whereas most natural gas in the permian is called associated gas
- 20:38so that's gas coming out of a well that was drilled for oil and so the main economic driver
- 20:43in the permian you're like you're not there for the gas like the gas is a byproduct that you really
- 20:48wish you didn't have to deal with um you're there for oil and so you know no one is going right now
- 20:55was like drilling, you know, banger gas wells in the Permian because the market is so bad for that
- 21:01gas. Um, but they are drilling for oil, um, and a lot of it. And so, you know, and then getting a
- 21:09little more technical, like a lot of that, like tier one acreage in the Permian has been, you
- 21:13know, drilled up. And so now they're moving on to, you know, tier two, tier three, uh, around the
- 21:17Permian basin, which is, is gassier. And so they're, you know, still after oil, you know, but they're
- 21:24those wells inevitably going to produce more gas than those tier one wells are. So it's really
- 21:30the continued growth of natural gas supply in the Permian Basin is a function of more and more
- 21:37drilling for oil and more and more associated gas coming up with that oil. And, you know,
- 21:43Permian's getting gassier over time as gas oil ratios widen. So if there was no oil in the Permian,
- 21:52you wouldn't have this problem because people probably wouldn't be drilling much in the Permian
- 21:56at all because again that gas market is so bad and then you know on top of that you can have
- 22:01you know you can have pipelines that need maintenance that get shut in that you know
- 22:06compressor stations need to be overhauled things like that that can have like temporary decreases
- 22:11in the ability to move gas out of the Permian and that'll cause that differential that Waha price
- 22:17to be worse than, you know, it's trading at today.
- 22:21And with another example, something like the Marcellus,
- 22:23is that more like the Haynesville where they're drilling for natural gas specifically?
- 22:27Correct.
- 22:28Versus in the Permian being associated gas.
- 22:32The primary asset that they're trying to get out of the ground is oil
- 22:34and there's this associated gas and it's highly variable.
- 22:38Correct.
- 22:38And I guess the other thing that you said is now that they're at tier two,
- 22:43you know, tier one might've been wells that were expected to be
- 22:46predominantly oil literal little associated natural gas that now increasingly wells oil
- 22:54wells are being drilled that have more gas yeah yeah so then use that maybe to describe
- 23:01the connection between um that dynamic and why what the why that creates an opportunity to mine
- 23:10bitcoin more it being more attractive potentially in west texas versus the haynesville or the
- 23:16ourselves yeah yeah so then to answer that question gets into the next like two distinctions
- 23:22of gas it can be associated gas or not but it can also have a pipeline like associated gas can be
- 23:31sold into a pipeline maybe talk a little bit about that like okay now go to a well out in west texas
- 23:37and what happens from there to get gas to market conventionally?
- 23:45Yeah.
- 23:46I mean, no matter where the well is,
- 23:49to get gas to market conventionally, you need a pipeline.
- 23:53So whether it's a well drilled for natural gas in the Haynesville
- 23:57or associated gas coming out of an oil well in the Permian,
- 23:59to get that gas to market, it has to go into a pipeline.
- 24:03um so people in the haynesville that are drilling wells like they're not going to go drill a gas
- 24:09well if they don't have line of sight on offtake on a pipeline right that wouldn't make any sense
- 24:14so those guys yeah again they're underwriting it all around natural gas economics and they
- 24:19have a pipeline and so you do have a ton of gas in the haynesville but you also have a ton of
- 24:23takeaway capacity for all that gas um whereas in the permian
- 24:29ideally you are drilling wells and you have takeaway for that gas even if the terms of that
- 24:36takeaway are pretty bad given waha um but oftentimes you're there for the oil and you'll actually go
- 24:43flare the gas so the the big distinction is stranded gas versus non-stranded gas
- 24:48stranded gas can occur everywhere it can occur in the haynesville and the marcellus
- 24:51um you know and in the permian there's a higher propensity of stranded gas in predominantly oil
- 24:58plays because again gas is the byproduct and they're just trying to get to the oil so um you
- 25:04know you'll flare that gas off because you can't sell it into the pipeline um because there is no
- 25:09pipeline or the pipeline's going maintenance or or anything like that um and that that's kind of
- 25:15what creates the opportunity so if we talk about as we look at our opportunity set as a services
- 25:20company like what assets are we chasing like who's the ideal customer profile um talking about
- 25:26pipeline connected gas wells we have never done a deal in the haynesville because that gas is
- 25:32pipeline connected and it's making great netbacks and so those oil and gas companies that do have
- 25:38those you know pipeline connected gas wells that get good price like they don't feel the pain
- 25:42they don't need a solution an economic solution for that gas like they're a-okay selling it into
- 25:50the pipeline like there's just not a lot of value for our services there but if you look at pipeline
- 25:54connected gas in the Permian, especially if you looked, you know, six, nine months ago when it was
- 25:59negative, like you might as well just flare it, right? Because the pipeline's not paying you
- 26:04anything for the gas. So like that's, you know, finding just purely talking about pipeline connected
- 26:09gas wells, the opportunity lies in the worst markets. So find me the gas wells that have the
- 26:17worst midstream contracts selling into the worst hub. And those are the best opportunities because
- 26:22the uplift that Bitcoin mining provides over what they're getting from the pipeline, that chasm is
- 26:27much wider. Whereas the uplift it provides in the Haynesville, you know, it's still there, but it's
- 26:33just not as attractive. So purely on pipeline connected gas wells, we're targeting, you know,
- 26:40the Permian Basin, the Bakken, areas where there's an oversupply of natural gas and the realized gas
- 26:46price even if it does have a pipeline is bad um talking stranded gas you know that if it's
- 26:54stranded it has no pipeline it has no market and so bitcoin mining works anywhere stranded gas
- 26:58exists and so when you talk when you specifically say stranded gas it is where there's a oil and
- 27:05gas well where gas is the byproduct or a gas well that doesn't have a pipeline but typically they
- 27:13wouldn't drill a purely gas well if they didn't already have the pipeline correct correct so a lot
- 27:19of like your gas wells that are stranded are older production where the pipeline company's gone away
- 27:25or the pipeline company's lines 30 years old and they're not going to invest in overhauling it and
- 27:30maintaining it and so that can strand those wells because you know if the pipeline goes away you
- 27:36have nowhere to sell your gas um so again like it's not as common in the haynesville to have
- 27:44you know stranded gas um but you do have pockets in the haynesville and elsewhere where
- 27:48you know like in wharton county we're looking at a deal um it's like texas gulf coast like
- 27:52warden county county is texas on the gulf coast um you know where you have all these producers
- 27:58impacted by a pipeline decommission so you have this pocket of like nine different companies that
- 28:04all produce in the same region that all sell into the same pipeline and the pipeline's going away
- 28:08so all those guys are effectively stranded now and why would the pipeline be decommissioned just
- 28:13because like the decline curve of the gas yeah decline curve of the gas the age of the pipeline
- 28:18the pipeline company's cost to maintain overhaul it like eventually gets to the point where the
- 28:24juice isn't worth the squeeze for the pipeline company and so they'll abandon the line effectively
- 28:30give notice and you know the upstream producers are you know out of luck and just to map out that
- 28:38picture starts at a well there's a pipeline it goes to a typically a natural gas processing plant
- 28:43and then from there goes further downstream to either you know uh lng on the coast to atmos
- 28:53power plant on course power plants um you know like the barnett gas is pipeline quality in many
- 29:01parts coming out of the ground it's like you know i know our asset in the barnet like that
- 29:05is literally like energy transfer transports that directly from our pad to the gas power plant that's
- 29:12you know five ten miles away like doesn't touch a processor at all it's just field gas going
- 29:16straight into power plant so not all gas is created the same however and so and like in the
- 29:23Permian, like all of that gas is going through processing plants before it is reaching its end customer.
- 29:29Talk about specifics in terms of the set of scenarios that create a tangible opportunity to mine Bitcoin.
- 29:40And what incentives dictate mining upstream off of natural gas.
- 29:47yeah so there's three main value propositions that bitcoin mining in the oil field provides
- 29:55an oil and gas company the first two you call it environmental um slash oil related right so
- 30:04um in in these cases think of oil and gas companies that are flaring natural gas
- 30:10right so they don't have a pipeline but they have to keep producing the well to get the oil out
- 30:15gas has got to go somewhere. Their best option is lighting it on fire in a flare.
- 30:21Business as usual has changed over the last five years where it's becoming harder and harder,
- 30:27more costly to flare at the federal level from the EPA, but also at the state level.
- 30:34And so gone are the days of companies drilling big oil and gas wells and just flaring gas into perpetuity even in Texas large quantities of gas And not based on one political party or the other No no
- 30:51It's just kind of been a slow burn in that direction.
- 30:54And then you have states like New Mexico and Colorado that tend to be more liberal leaning
- 30:59who have statewide mandates.
- 31:01So it's a lot harder to flare New Mexico and Colorado than it is in Texas.
- 31:06But even in Texas, you can't be flaring large quantities of gas forever.
- 31:09because that hits like federal thresholds.
- 31:13And even Texas has some state rules around that.
- 31:17So if you think of an oil and gas company,
- 31:19you're like, okay, I am here in New Mexico
- 31:22in the Permian Basin.
- 31:23I'm a big top 20 oil and gas company
- 31:25producing all of this oil.
- 31:27And I'm only allowed to flare this gas
- 31:29for a little bit of time.
- 31:30And if I don't have a pipeline,
- 31:32I am in a bad spot
- 31:35because eventually I can't flare.
- 31:37And if I can't flare,
- 31:38and I have nowhere for the gas to go, I have to shut my well in. But I'm not there for the gas,
- 31:42I'm there for the oil. And I have to shut my well in, I'm foregoing, you know, hundreds of barrels
- 31:47of oil per day. That's, you know, 7,000, 10,000, $15,000 a day of revenue that these guys are not
- 31:53able to produce. And so taking a step back, I talked to value props like environmental, some,
- 31:59you know, big public like Exxon, companies like that are, you know, by 2030, we're not going to
- 32:04flare any gas at all. So even if it's not jeopardizing their oil, like they have a mandate to
- 32:09reduce flaring. And so purely a company could deploy a Bitcoin mine for no other reason than,
- 32:17hey, flaring is bad for the environment. Burning that gas through, you know, 360s clean burning
- 32:21generators is better for the environment. I am not flaring anymore. I look good for my ESG score.
- 32:27Like that is a very real value prop, especially your bigger companies that are worried about that.
- 32:32more often is the case where that flaring is actually starting to jeopardize the well itself
- 32:39and their ability to produce oil so yes it's environmental great you know we've reduced our
- 32:45emissions by going with 360 but that's really not the primary driver the primary driver is
- 32:49if i don't have a solution in two months like i'm gonna have to shut my oil well in and that's a
- 32:52million dollars of revenue i'm not going to be able to produce and that's a very real very impactful
- 32:59problem that that we're solving for we are giving people an outlet for natural gas so that they can
- 33:06produce more oil uh you know we're working with you know one of the top 20 u.s onshore oil and gas
- 33:12producers uh on the you just to kind of put a real example around it like it's helpful you know this
- 33:18is a site in the texas gulf where you know they drilled this great oil well it's making 350 barrels
- 33:24a day has been for the last you know three years um doesn't make a ton of gas makes around you know
- 33:30two megawatts worth and they're flaring all that gas like they have this big that seems like a lot
- 33:36of gas two megawatts yeah well i mean there's a lot you know go to the bakken and the permian
- 33:41there's a lot more quantities of gas being flared but for this company like it was okay
- 33:46you know they're flaring as much as they're able to flare but they want to go drill other wells
- 33:51like in the on this lease because they have a great oil well but there's never going to be a
- 33:55pipeline getting to the site and they're already at the capacity of what they're able to flare so
- 34:01they've been kind of sitting on their hands for the past five years in with an inability to
- 34:07drill more wells and so we're working with them now we've deployed um you know we've we've done
- 34:14two different deployments with them to capture that gas so now like they're still producing the
- 34:19oil and now they have a solution for the gas. Their flaring has gone way down. Their emissions
- 34:23have gone way down. What does that mean? Well, now they've drilled and completed another well
- 34:26and brought another, I think this new one's doing like 450 barrels of oil a day. So,
- 34:31you know, yes, this Bitcoin mine is making them a little bit of money on the gas. Yes,
- 34:37it's a feel good emission story. But what we've really done is unlocked their ability to make
- 34:41another 450 barrels of oil a day. And that's worth, you know, well over a million dollars of
- 34:46annual revenue and so that's where you're really starting to add value it's like that's really the
- 34:52sites where after we're putting another one up in the powder river uh it'll be a little over three
- 34:58megawatts where's the powder river powder rivers in wyoming okay and so you know you know this is a
- 35:04top 50 onshore oil and gas company that you know has a very similar problem they're you know the
- 35:09biggest producers in wyoming and so um you know these problems are prevalent right these are
- 35:15widely like this is one site in wyoming these guys operate thousands of wells and this is not
- 35:22a one-off thing it's you know portfolio wide across many different assets um so that's so
- 35:29finishing long-winded answer your question like that's the emissions oil value problem and one
- 35:34way to think about that is you're it's it's less about the bitcoin mining economics it's more about
- 35:41combination of reducing a liability, flaring,
- 35:45as well as
- 35:49unlocking an asset, being able to
- 35:53tap more capacity on the oil side that you wouldn't otherwise
- 35:57be able to because of limitations on the environmental
- 36:01side. Correct. That's exactly right. And then
- 36:05where are then the opportunities
- 36:09or how do you guys think about
- 36:11where it's actually about the Bitcoin mining economics
- 36:14and how does that vary from a setup
- 36:15that you just described?
- 36:17And if you could give some specific examples,
- 36:19that would also help.
- 36:20Yeah, definitely.
- 36:21So then the third value prop
- 36:23is an economic value prop.
- 36:25So purely people saying,
- 36:27I can monetize my gas in a Bitcoin mine
- 36:30and make, you know,
- 36:31I said Henry Hubbs at $3.50 in MCF,
- 36:34like mining Bitcoin with new gen servers
- 36:36in the oil field is $13.50.
- 36:38cents. It's $10 more in MCF to go mine Bitcoin. And so you have people that again, find me like
- 36:47this is a better fit for pipeline connected gas producers in the Permian that are sick of getting
- 36:52ripped off selling gas into the pipeline for nothing. Like they can say to hell with that.
- 36:57I'm going to deploy one of 360 energy systems on my site and I'm not going to sell gas to the
- 37:03pipeline. I'm just going to monetize it, you know, through the Bitcoin mine.
- 37:06um and so you know we've done a lot of deal like when we first launched the services company like
- 37:12those first two deals in the barnet like that's what they wanted they wanted to fund all the
- 37:16capex buy all the infrastructure and mine bitcoin at their site so they can make a lot more than
- 37:21they were getting in the pipeline and we've continued to do uh deals like that i think
- 37:26those deals like i mean there's just so much gas out there there's plenty of opportunity to do that
- 37:34I think the challenge there is most oil and gas companies don't know anything about Bitcoin,
- 37:42certainly don't know anything about Bitcoin mining and hash price, nor are they in the
- 37:48business of spending millions of dollars of capital to, with that payback and that return
- 37:56being determined by Bitcoin mining economics is very out of pattern for an oil and gas company.
- 38:01And so, you know, our customers that have done that model tend to be smaller, family owned, multi-generational, independent oil and gas companies.
- 38:12And we've deployed that particular model where they're purely chasing the economics, you know, all over Texas.
- 38:19Not in the Haynesville, but we've done that in the Panhandle, in the Barnett, in the Permian, and other places.
- 38:24again for those you know even if you did have that same characteristic multi-generational you
- 38:30know family owned oil and gas company in the haynesville they're still probably not going to
- 38:33do it because they're not feeling the pain they're getting you know three dollars 25 cents an mcf
- 38:37that same guy in west texas you know he might be willing to go spend two five ten million dollars
- 38:42on a bitcoin mine because the chasm and the uplift that this provides is is so much better
- 38:48because if because functionally the revenue side of the equation for either of those mines looks
- 38:54almost identical to each other but the cost side of the natural gas
- 38:59there's a there's a material differential in terms of if you could make 320 or 350 depending on
- 39:08Houston chip channel or Henry hub index versus a dollar then that would be a spread that would
- 39:17create an economic incentive potentially to mine bitcoin yeah like bitcoin doesn't care but
- 39:22hash rate's going to be created anywhere and it's going to get cleared out at hash price
- 39:25so you can deploy this anywhere natural gas is available uh it's just where does it provide the
- 39:32most uplift maybe walk through the like in a in a tangible way like you mentioned 1350 mcf if
- 39:42you're mining bitcoin but it comes with additional infrastructure just maybe talk a little bit about
- 39:47what the actual operation looks like.
- 39:51There's infrastructure on the gas well,
- 39:54but you have to bring infrastructure out
- 39:56and how that, you know,
- 39:59it's not, you're not just getting the benefit
- 40:01of the differential between a buck
- 40:04or a buck 50 and 1350 of,
- 40:07hey, if I were to go down the traditional route,
- 40:10this is what the economics would look like.
- 40:11But if I brought on incremental infrastructure,
- 40:14took on the capital costs,
- 40:15what that incremental kind of bottom line looks like on a gas unit yeah yeah so traditionally
- 40:26on the upstream side only on the oil and gas side they're going to drill well they're going to have
- 40:31you know tank battery and facilities to separate water and oil and gas and they're going to have
- 40:38storage tanks for water storage tanks for oil and they're going to have some offtake for that gas
- 40:44which would there be a pipeline or it'll be a flare stack um it's like that's your traditional
- 40:49you know that's what exists on wells all over the world right that typical facility um on the
- 40:57bitcoin mining side you know to go deploy these at one of these sites you're talking big natural
- 41:03gas generators that's the first component um so you're you're plumbing you're having to plumb that
- 41:09natural gas generator into their system where the gas is flowing um and then downstream of that
- 41:15generator you know so that generator is consuming all of the gas um create a bunch of electricity
- 41:21right and then where's that electricity go well you know 10 feet away you wire that
- 41:26generator into one of these data center boxes um and inside one of those boxes are hundreds of
- 41:33servers. And so that's, you know, a very simple way of talking about the three main components.
- 41:42You know, there's, we, you know, we have to meter the gas, you know, we put separators and volume
- 41:46tanks and pressure regulation. There's a lot of other little nuanced infrastructure between all
- 41:51these steps, but the three main components that you have to add to an oil and gas site is a generator,
- 41:55data center servers and you know data centers are air cooled or immersion or hydro and servers
- 42:03there's old ones new ones efficient ones different deals come together in different ways that warrant
- 42:09different infrastructure for us we only deploy one type of generator that works very well on
- 42:17associated gas and a wide range of natural gas right i think the hardest part about this business
- 42:23is the continuous operation of converting gas into electricity for Bitcoin mining.
- 42:30And the mining servers are relatively dumb.
- 42:32You know, as long as they're getting power, they're pretty much going to run.
- 42:35And as long as you have a Starlink satellite, you're good.
- 42:39But the proof is in, like, the uptime is really in the power side,
- 42:43the ability to consistently generate power.
- 42:45And so we've, as a company, been through many different generators.
- 42:48small big paralleled island mode and can go on and on but that's the typical infrastructure we're
- 42:56putting out at every site every site's going to have generator data center servers it's just a
- 43:01matter of who owns the equipment and what the servers produce in terms of hash rate
- 43:10And so if you're looking at a site that is particularly attractive to actually mine for the Bitcoin economics and the mining economics versus reducing liability or unlocking an asset, like, you know, being able to drill more oil, do the scale of those differ typically?
- 43:33or what is the traditional, like, what is the typical scale that you guys work at in terms of,
- 43:37you know, the, the, the size of a generator or the ultimate conversion?
- 43:41Yeah. So we only deploy one type of generator, right? We deploy Waukesha's and those are 1.3
- 43:48megawatts a piece. So for us to do any type of deal, you know, it has to be at least, you know,
- 43:53300 MCF a day of gas, which is enough to feed that Waukesha. We use the same, most of our sites
- 44:02use the same air cooled data center um and then the servers can vary widely so no matter who owns
- 44:10the asset like we have two different commercial models which we can get into um the ability to
- 44:18convert gas into hash rate is really a function of what servers you have the new 2025 best in class
- 44:25what's miners or or ant miners like those are what's making 1350 an mcf um they just make a
- 44:33lot they're way more efficient at producing hash rate from the same amount of power um you know
- 44:37some of our sites were deploying old 2020 miners used miners that are very very cheap to get and
- 44:43you know make significantly less dollars per mcf they're three times less efficient they're you
- 44:49know four times cheaper um so it really just depends for the customer you know what they're
- 44:54after um you know should i talk about the commercial models yeah if you could yeah so
- 45:00we have a rental model and we have a purchase model right as what i talked about earlier
- 45:06focusing on purchase first that's where the oil and gas company will actually buy the generator
- 45:10by the data center by the servers they're doing that purely for the economic value prop
- 45:17of bitcoin mining of bitcoin mining the uplift that that provides versus what the pipeline will
- 45:23pay them or if the gas is stranded. Typically what we've seen is those customers prefer best
- 45:30in class miners. So they're trying to maximize the Bitcoin production in the shortest amount of time
- 45:35possible before the next halving. You know, they're bullish on Bitcoin, they're bullish on hash price.
- 45:41And so they'll want to deploy the best servers and hodl as much of the Bitcoin that they mine.
- 45:45That product is not a great fit for your oil and gas companies that have the environmental
- 45:57oil problem.
- 45:58What we heard over and over from customers is and just from traditional oil and gas patterns right These guys don want to fund capital into anything other than drilling wells What they will do is rent compressors rent production equipment rent gas treatment facilities It like it much easier for them to spend OPEX versus CAPEX
- 46:19And so, you know, and especially as, you know, if we're after these curtailed oil situations,
- 46:28these environmental situations, those are usually bigger EMPs, like your big pubcos,
- 46:31your big privates, uh, who, you know, have a lot of gas. Um, they're a better fit for rental
- 46:38because one, you know, renting infrastructure is way more in pattern for them. Um, you know,
- 46:44the, what we'll do in rental, they'll pay us a fat flat fixed monthly cost. We own all the assets.
- 46:51So same exact generator, same exact data center, but we're putting in older used miners, uh, which
- 46:58are a lot less capital intensive. It's more a function of getting their rental cost to be
- 47:04achievable and not offensive, while also still giving us the ability to make a return
- 47:11on our capital investment on our units. So in the rental, you know, they will pay fixed flat
- 47:18monthly cost to us. They'll get the Bitcoin mining rewards. Traditionally, these are big companies,
- 47:23they don't have the accounting to custody Bitcoin, they don't want to custody Bitcoin,
- 47:27they just get cash at the end of the month and so same system different servers owned by 360 will go
- 47:35deploy to capture that gas for them they'll get the u.s dollars at the end of the month it's not
- 47:411350 in mcf because we're using you know 2020 2021 servers um so net net net they're paying us 50
- 47:49you know 50 grand 60 grand 40 grand depending on the site and how many units we're deploying and
- 47:54the term length but they're coming out of that you know right now making about five grand a month
- 47:58um however if hash price is that what does that translate to on a mcf basis about a dollar an mcf
- 48:06right but it's highly sensitive to and realistically in those scenarios those operators care less
- 48:13about yes exactly what the uplift is to their natural gas they are not there chasing gas
- 48:18economics. If they can subsidize the rental rate with, you know, the cash they get at the end of
- 48:24the month, like that's great. But the reality is like, even if they're losing 20 grand a month,
- 48:29let's say hash, you know, Bitcoin goes from 120 today to 70 grand. Like all of our customers on
- 48:34rental are not making money. They're losing money. They're paying us a rental rate. Cash they get
- 48:39back at the end of the month is not more than the rental rate. Right now it is more and it comes out
- 48:43to about a dollar an mcf but the point is like those guys are not there for gas economics most
- 48:48leases they do in the oil field are cost centers and so this right now is great because it's you
- 48:53know it's not a cost center for these guys but what they're the reason they'll still do this
- 48:58even if they're losing money every month on our deal is because they're getting oil out of the
- 49:02ground yeah it's a cost center or in in certain scenarios it's a marginal profit center but it's
- 49:09really there to enable yes uh the monetization of an asset they couldn't otherwise exactly exactly
- 49:16so that's that's exactly right like they're willing to lose you know call it 20 grand a month
- 49:20on our deal because now they're making an extra 500 grand a month of oil that they wouldn't be
- 49:26able to produce without us there so it's it's cost of doing business and then walk through
- 49:30the economics of us of a typical site in the in the other scenario where they're actually going
- 49:37after the Bitcoin, it's a stranded gas play in terms of a lot more capital, so more costs.
- 49:45They might be getting the $13.50 in MCF, but they're investing what per MCF and what does
- 49:51the uplift look like versus what they might get from selling to a pipeline like the Waha,
- 50:00assuming it's not negative, but it's a dollar in MCF.
- 50:02Yeah. So in that case, right, focusing on best in class, right again, same generator, you know, same data center, and then best servers cost roughly $2 million per megawatt per 300 MCF a day of gas.
- 50:19that infrastructure stack deployed at their site turns around and makes call it 1350 an mcf
- 50:29of top line revenue which comes out again you're investing 2 million and across a year that's about
- 50:361.7 million dollars of top line revenue after all your mining expenses generator maintenance expenses
- 50:42site expenses like OPEX, you know, you're making about, call it $11 in MCF, $10 in MCF of EBITDA
- 50:51per MCF, which is substantial, which rounds out to about 1.3, $1.4 million of EBITDA per year.
- 51:02So our customers who are making this big investment in the infrastructure are also
- 51:07looking at really attractive paybacks. And so, you know, they're making their money back in
- 51:12in less than two years at current hash price. Um, it's a good time to do that. Miners are
- 51:18obviously a lot cheaper than they were, you know, when we started the company back in 21 and hash
- 51:21price was at $400 today, hash price is about $60. So, you know, and all the things hold true. Like
- 51:27it's just funny. And the payback on the same well would be far longer if they were just
- 51:31selling to a pipeline. Yeah, generally. And, and so then the next question,
- 51:38because you mentioned this before, like the variability in hash price.
- 51:42And I would presume that the first scenario where it's less about the mining economics
- 51:47are more agnostic to the variability in hash price.
- 51:53But talk about how you got 360, how you manage this operationally,
- 52:01but then also how you manage it in evaluating target situations or target sites.
- 52:08In terms of managing volatility of Bitcoin, as well as volatility in natural gas, because, you know, almost at the start, you talked about the scenario where natural gas.
- 52:19What was the scenario where natural gas went to like nine dollars?
- 52:24Yeah. Yeah. So that's a perfect example.
- 52:26But just talk about that generally, but also potentially specifically to scenario planning and site planning of how you manage volatility of both of those.
- 52:37The Bitcoin price and hash price, as well as the cost of natural gas, which is revenue potential.
- 52:47Totally.
- 52:48I think the best way to look at that would be like our company owned Wells and site and Bitcoin mine in Fort Worth.
- 52:55Right.
- 52:55So when we started the company, gas prices were at $3.
- 53:02Mining Bitcoin was $40 at MCF.
- 53:05So it was like worth deploying that infrastructure to realize that outsized gain.
- 53:14Because that chasm was so wide, right?
- 53:15And then kind of play it out over the next year and a half.
- 53:20Operationally, we were not doing well.
- 53:22Like we're trying to figure this thing out for the first time.
- 53:25Like we were not, you know, having to spend way more money.
- 53:28The uptime was not good, you know, and then what you had happen was, you know, FTX and
- 53:32Sam Bankman freed and Bitcoin went from, you know, 63,000 to 17,000, 16,000 and hash price.
- 53:40Yeah.
- 53:41Just 22.
- 53:42And like coincide, like, you know, happenstance, Russia, Ukraine happened, Nord Stream blew
- 53:47up, gas prices went to $9.
- 53:49At that period of time, you know, the mining rewards were $7 in MCF.
- 53:54gas prices were nine dollars in mcf we had all these operational issues we actually shut our
- 53:59well or shut our bitcoin mine completely down for six months hired halberton fracked three more
- 54:06refracted recompleted three of our wells um went from you know 400 mcf a day to well over 2000 mcf
- 54:14a day which is really a function of these two uncorrelated markets it was like well the hell
- 54:19with the Bitcoin mine, you know, if we can sell gas for $9, let's go invest in our wells and,
- 54:24you know, make a great return in natural gas. And so you do have these two uncorrelated markets,
- 54:31you know, a lot of, some of our customers look at this as like revenue optionality.
- 54:35Why have one market when you can have two? And so, yeah, there certainly is like a function.
- 54:40Describe that, like just like that idea of having the optionality.
- 54:43um like do people when you're talking to customers does that resonate it definitely resonates
- 54:53it's you know the challenge is like to make a return on the bitcoin mine you need to be running
- 55:03the bitcoin mine 24 7 and so it people have many different ways of thinking about it um
- 55:09but generally you know having a pipeline there and having a bitcoin mine gives you optionality
- 55:17so you can sell gas for gas prices or you can effectively sell gas into the bitcoin mining
- 55:22market you know for a widely different gas price and historically the bitcoin has way outperformed
- 55:29henry hub um we have a chart on our website that plots it out over five years like the only
- 55:34crossover was for three months kind of during that refrac period that we had.
- 55:40Generally, customers, if they're going to go do this, are thinking about like, it would
- 55:44be very bad if I was having to sell gas to the pipeline.
- 55:47You know, they're doing this thinking Bitcoin mining is going to be the sole offtake for
- 55:52that gas, you know, for the foreseeable future.
- 55:55And so we had a conversation previously.
- 55:58My understanding, though, is that certain midstream pipeline agreements basically dictate under all scenarios they have your gas.
- 56:07So you don't have that optionality.
- 56:08So you might be looking at scenarios where they do have the option.
- 56:11Correct. Yeah, correct.
- 56:13I would say just overarching theme here is it's a lot harder to do any type of deal on pipeline connected gas because that gas is earning some nominal or attractive gas price.
- 56:24First and foremost, to your point, you're alluding to like acreage dedication.
- 56:28so why can we do this at our site in the barnett but maybe not at you know exxon site in the permian
- 56:35right i think you know what our wells were drilled in 2007 right at that time
- 56:41and these are gas wells right so traditionally when a new well is drilled in oil and gas
- 56:47you have an offtake for that gas energy transfer targa or one of the big midstream companies
- 56:52they'll say okay you know you need to get this gas sold i will build the pipeline to you i will
- 56:58invest in the infrastructure so energy transfer will go pay you know a million bucks or however
- 57:03far they have to build out but in return for that they're going to say and i'm going to do this for
- 57:08you but you have to sell all your gas to me under all scenarios no matter what for the next 5 10
- 57:1420 years right and so it's unfortunate because in west texas like you'd think everyone would
- 57:22be doing this but a lot of guys especially last year when waha was negative uh you know if you're
- 57:27dedicated to targa like you can't siphon off gas to go mine bitcoin even if gas prices are negative
- 57:34right all that gas has to go into the pipeline company contractually because they invested to
- 57:41build out to you um and so again the acreage dedications are a big there's like two main
- 57:48disqualifiers in natural gas bitcoin mining acreage dedications are one they're really hard
- 57:52to get out of and around. And you definitely don't want to go toe to toe with these big
- 57:56mainstream companies and violate those terms. And then, you know, gas composition, like if you have
- 58:01a lot of H2S, like sour gas, can't really do much about that. It's very cost prohibitive to treat
- 58:05sour gas. And so like, if it's sour, it's really not much you can do because that's highly corrosive
- 58:09will destroy your generator dangerous for people. So those are the two main deals. But, you know,
- 58:14I'd say in the Permian, like there are a lot of dedications. And so you'd think a lot of pipeline
- 58:18connected guys out there would be doing this but you know your newer wells your five year old wells
- 58:23and newer like if there is a pipeline like the acreage dedicated we run into that a lot when
- 58:28we're talking to your top 150 oil and gas companies you know that have newer production
- 58:34they're you know tied in with the midstream and they can't do anything i would also gather that
- 58:40even if you were someone that owned an asset and looked at this equation and understood it and
- 58:48wanted the optionality that in most cases, if you want the pipeline, you don't have any leverage to
- 58:54preserve optionality in just in terms of negotiating power with a midstream company.
- 59:02Yeah. I mean, like you're every deal we've done on pipeline gas has been older production.
- 59:07We've not done any like new wells because chances are it was dedicated at one point and the
- 59:12dedication's rolled off. It's termed out 10 years later, five years later. So now those guys do have
- 59:17optionality like they're not mandated to sell gas to the midstream companies they do have the
- 59:22functional ability to do something else with that gas um but again it's it's asset by asset
- 59:29so from a customer segmentation standpoint like when we're looking at selling the product where
- 59:36the oil and gas company purchase it like we're finding we're targeting like the worst potential
- 59:42assets from a gas realization perspective, which would imply like Permian Basin,
- 59:51older conventional wells that, you know, don't have oil. It's like there's, you know, pockets of
- 59:57the, you know, southeastern Permian, like Valverde, Crockett County, where you have older production
- 1:00:04that's predominantly gas. It's old, you know, 20 years plus. They have a pipeline, but chances are
- 1:00:11the midstream company is not taking very good care of it.
- 1:00:13It's not dedicated.
- 1:00:14So like those would be great targets for those companies specifically.
- 1:00:18Like those turn,
- 1:00:19those wells turn into cost centers,
- 1:00:20right?
- 1:00:21If they only produce gas and you have to pay a guy to go out there and
- 1:00:23chemicals and everything to actually produce the gas and you're selling it
- 1:00:27for 50 cents or a dollar,
- 1:00:28like chances are like those wells are shut in,
- 1:00:30not producing because they're on economic.
- 1:00:32Like that's where this would be a great fit.
- 1:00:35Do you just basically being in the market,
- 1:00:38do you expect midstream companies you know it would be unlikely to to mine upstream but to
- 1:00:46start mining at the point of aggregation and do you see that as competitive
- 1:00:50not necessarily competitive but potentially um a competitive dynamic when evaluating sites of
- 1:01:00what would make something an attractive site to mine bitcoin upstream yeah i think
- 1:01:07midstream companies are very conservative they are um they like to clip their fee
- 1:01:11just by moving molecules so i don't foresee in the near future uh you know again just like oil
- 1:01:21and gas companies their dollars are to drill wells like midstream companies dollars are to
- 1:01:25drill i'm not to drill but to build pipe and processing so for them to go way out of pad
- 1:01:31And then at these gathering centers that these military companies have, I mean, shit, it's like hundreds of megawatts you could do.
- 1:01:37So like, I don't see those companies doing this themselves and capturing the spread.
- 1:01:45Very, very easily, like energy transfer could go do that in the Permian right now.
- 1:01:50They have custody of the gas.
- 1:01:52They're stripping out all of the valuable parts of the gas, like the NGLs and propane and all that.
- 1:01:57they're left with the least valuable, which is just the methane, like the dry gas.
- 1:02:03You know, they very easily could do that. I think what we're seeing is more
- 1:02:07those guys facilitating, energy transfers of the world, facilitating sales to your hyperscale
- 1:02:13data centers or your big Bitcoin miners, where they'll say, you know, look, we have all this gas,
- 1:02:19you can buy it from me for some premium over Waha, that energy transfer, like some premium
- 1:02:24over energy transfer would get just moving it down the pipe. So I don't see that as competitive.
- 1:02:30I don't think that kind of runs into any of our evaluation like that particular one. I mean,
- 1:02:34I do think it'd be, there's a future where midstream leverages Bitcoin mining as a way to
- 1:02:39maybe win more deals. So like if you're a midstream company, you want this big Exxon pad,
- 1:02:45right? You say, hey, Mr. Exxon, this is in New Mexico. I can help you complete these wells three
- 1:02:51months faster than any of the other midstream companies because i can put a mobile gas offtake
- 1:02:55solution while the pipeline's being built out i do see that as a future for for midstream
- 1:03:00one one last question on kind of the evaluation of of sites and then i want to zoom out to
- 1:03:10more of the bitcoin side of it how do you guys manage the client curves of wells you talked about
- 1:03:17those scenarios where you know customers actually going to buy the infrastructure to mine they're
- 1:03:23buying that latest high sm machine it is highly efficient but expensive
- 1:03:30how do you guys in mining bitcoin at as high utilization as possible is most ideal if you
- 1:03:38have those expensive machines how does that factor into evaluating the sites and then also
- 1:03:45thinking about the duration of how long one of these solutions is at an individual site and
- 1:03:50moving between sites yeah like those are like that's a great question to just kind of go and
- 1:03:55going into like wow there's a lot more to this than i thought in 2021 um because you're totally
- 1:04:01right like old conventional wells like are producing flat like new horizontal wells are
- 1:04:07dropping off a cliff in the first two years right and so and then gas composition right is widely
- 1:04:15different and different gas compositions will perform differently in the generator will you know
- 1:04:21really lean dry gas low btu that's less efficient in the generator than like a richer 1200 btu gas so
- 1:04:28moral of the story is like our customers both in rental and in the purchase model like they're
- 1:04:34leaning on us to evaluate with them how many units how long where this makes sense which means
- 1:04:42Are we talking about a single well? Like that's not ideal. Um, single point of failure. We're
- 1:04:47talking multiple wells, a gathering system. What's the decline on all these wells? Show me the
- 1:04:52production history over the last three months. Show me the gas composition. Is the gas composition
- 1:04:55for all the wells the same? Um, the ambient conditions of the site, you know, is it high
- 1:05:01elevation? Is it cold? Is it hot? Um, the pressure, like flowing field pressure of the gas, like,
- 1:05:07are the wells on artificial lift? Are they free flowing? Like there's all these considerations
- 1:05:14to really evaluate the quality of a site to put a Bitcoin mine on there and have it be a legitimate
- 1:05:2224 seven operation. And how many units do we need and how long can they be there for?
- 1:05:26So like that's part of every, you know, customer journey evaluating those fine details to actually
- 1:05:33propose them something that we're confident in and something that they can be confident in.
- 1:05:39And all of this adds up to Bitcoin mining solving an upstream energy problem.
- 1:05:47Describing principally two different types of problem.
- 1:05:50One, unlocking oil, reducing environmental liability.
- 1:05:54The other side, greater monetization of natural gas than could otherwise be monetized traditionally
- 1:06:00or conventionally.
- 1:06:03Zooming out, for someone that's a traditional energy professional that might know less on the Bitcoin side,
- 1:06:14how do you personally, but then also 360, think about Bitcoin, the money side,
- 1:06:21in terms of what is actually creating this demand?
- 1:06:26And so I'd just like to hear your views on that, of the actual source of the demand, because I can envision you're talking to customers, talking about how you can get $13 an MCF versus $1 an MCF or $10 to $11 of EBITDA, or talking to someone about eliminating environmental liability and being able to unlock oil.
- 1:06:54and that tracking and then saying, well, how do I know this is going to exist in two years or three years
- 1:06:59if I invest in this infrastructure? So just talk a little bit from your own perspective of how you think about
- 1:07:05the Bitcoin side of what is actually creating the demand to make this sustainable.
- 1:07:15So what's kind of like just Bitcoin in general? Like what am I telling customers?
- 1:07:19Yeah. You know, I think, I mean, I'm a 360. We're very bullish on Bitcoin. Always have been and try to maximize our holdings. And so when we're talking to customers, like, you know, I tell them I don't have a crystal ball. Like, I can't tell you a Bitcoin is going to be at 200,000 at the end of the year or 50,000.
- 1:07:37What I can tell you is, you know, it's, if you look at the last, you know, you look at
- 1:07:43the history of Bitcoin, it's the best performing asset over the last 15 years.
- 1:07:48And you just look at some of the macroeconomic tailwinds of the ETFs are a big one, right?
- 1:07:54A lot of our customers are old school but when I can say look BlackRock is the biggest purchaser of Bitcoin Fidelity is buying Bitcoin Texas has a strategic reserve The US has a strategic reserve Wisconsin Pension Fund just bought you know 250 million And some of those like tangible
- 1:08:12macroeconomic tailwinds really help people come to terms that like Bitcoin is not, you know,
- 1:08:19fly by night, um, snake oil scam. Right. And then, you know, the fixed 21 million, uh, Bitcoin
- 1:08:26supply. And then in light of, you know, trillions of dollars, you know, they can keep printing them,
- 1:08:32right. It's you have, and then the deficit, I mean, you, you can get really philosophical on
- 1:08:37Bitcoin, but I think the main diffuser for customers is like talking about Texas, talking
- 1:08:47about BlackRock being like, look, if it's good enough for these massive institutions,
- 1:08:50like it's not going anywhere. So I think that is how we frame it. I can't tell you what hash price
- 1:08:57is going to be, but I can tell you that, you know, things are going to continue to get better for
- 1:09:02Bitcoin. If you look at some of the things that are happening right now, I think that helps people,
- 1:09:08you know, come to terms with it. Make no mistake, if someone's going to go buy
- 1:09:11$2 million plus of our infrastructure, like they are going to have to go down the Bitcoin
- 1:09:16rabbit hole themselves some of them already have some of them are are more new to it some of them
- 1:09:20are more risk takers wildcatters families that know they want some bitcoin exposure and this is
- 1:09:24a way to get it um on the rental side again like that level of evangelism like frankly doesn't
- 1:09:32happen because they could give a shit about bitcoin it's about getting oil out of the ground
- 1:09:36like i'm not having to like they're not worried if they make 10 grand this month or lose 10 grand
- 1:09:42next month on our deal they're worried about getting oil out of the ground and if this works
- 1:09:46and we have the track record and customers and backing and they know it works like they're fine
- 1:09:50with it you know irrespective of bitcoin and in that scenario they're just renting equipment for
- 1:09:55you so they don't really care if two years from now three years from now doesn't turn out because
- 1:10:02they don't have a huge amount of capital investment so now now they in theory could
- 1:10:05have gone and drilled an oil well and then if you're not able to continue to to pay because
- 1:10:12but worst case scenario like bitcoin goes to zero like this will still function as the same service
- 1:10:19that off takes gas that lets them produce oil so like if bitcoin's at zero like we can still run
- 1:10:23i would challenge that well i mean you could still run the cost so you could you could i guess what
- 1:10:27you're saying is you could still reduce the emission yeah just be i'm still unlocking oil
- 1:10:33for them and if they're paying us you know 50 grand a month and they're getting zero dollars
- 1:10:37back but now they're making 500 grand of oil like still you know it's less attractive but
- 1:10:44again for them it's not really about how much money am i going to make on this bitcoin mining
- 1:10:49deal it's about how much more oil am i getting out of the ground and then how do you think about
- 1:10:56this is obviously in the oil field i presume even though this is people have been mining upstream
- 1:11:03for probably a decade now.
- 1:11:08It's still very nascent.
- 1:11:10It's still a drop in the bucket.
- 1:11:15Do you see, or I don't want to say, do you see,
- 1:11:20what would Bitcoin in terms of scale
- 1:11:22need to be to more meaningfully change
- 1:11:27maybe how the legacy industry sees the map
- 1:11:32such that they're more proactive about using Bitcoin to solve these problems rather than having you show up to try to educate them.
- 1:11:42Yeah, I mean, my business partner, Sean, always says that, you know, one day the Bitcoin mining is going to be a tailwind for 360 energy, not a headwind.
- 1:11:51Right now, it's a headwind because, you know, a lot of customers are like, can you do anything else?
- 1:11:56Can you do AI? Can you do any? Does it have to be Bitcoin? Right.
- 1:11:59Because they still have this phobia that Bitcoin is, you know, a scam.
- 1:12:03So that is changing, though.
- 1:12:05Like, it's absolutely changing.
- 1:12:07I think the level of evangelism we're doing now is a lot less than we've been doing.
- 1:12:13I think that's also a product of being more mature as a company, having real institutional backing, you know, track record, being producers ourselves.
- 1:12:21Like, we come across more trustworthy, more proven.
- 1:12:25But, you know, I don't know.
- 1:12:28know i don't you know if it's 500 000 bitcoin i don't know if it's the u.s buying five percent of
- 1:12:32the outstanding supply um i don't know if they'll ever do this or if they'll continue to outsource
- 1:12:41it i mean i think you can look at as maybe as a comp is you know some of these big super major
- 1:12:47exxon bp getting into some more the renewables and they're kind of dabbling into geothermal
- 1:12:51which is at least more tangential on the energy side like i don't think in the next three years
- 1:13:00and i don't even know if it's a bitcoin price signal i just don't see these big oil and gas
- 1:13:04companies wanting to go invest a huge amount of money in bitcoin mining to go do this themselves
- 1:13:11in the near future i think they'd rather outsource it via the rental product
- 1:13:17to get the oil and gas value propositions
- 1:13:24that they're looking for.
- 1:13:25I could be wrong.
- 1:13:26I just...
- 1:13:27Now, when you guys look at the map,
- 1:13:31what percentage of wells that you would say,
- 1:13:35hey, this would be a great opportunity
- 1:13:37to unlock oil production for an EMP company,
- 1:13:43what percentage of them have some type of solution?
- 1:13:46Is it 1%? Is it 0.1%? Is it, you know?
- 1:13:49Yeah, that's a great question.
- 1:13:53I don't want to get the statistics wrong,
- 1:13:56but I believe about half a percent,
- 1:14:01the 1% of natural gas in the United States was flared last year of produced
- 1:14:06gas. I think it's a half a percent.
- 1:14:10I think pretty sure it's half a percent,
- 1:14:12somewhere between half a percent, 1%.
- 1:14:14So that's all stranded gas that's creating emissions that may or may not be curtailing
- 1:14:19oil production.
- 1:14:20That's addressable.
- 1:14:21What does that mean?
- 1:14:22That over two gigawatts of electrical generation Bitcoin mining capacity just in the US of gas that specifically being flared and that not talking about gas that being sold into waha or negative that not talking about
- 1:14:36wells that are shut in because they the market's uneconomic um that addressable market you know
- 1:14:43is four to five times larger in the middle east it's about the same size if not bigger in south
- 1:14:48America. Um, you know, and so for us, you know, all over Texas today, putting stuff in New Mexico,
- 1:14:59Wyoming, you know, going to be going to North Dakota this year. Like, um, that's a huge
- 1:15:05addressable market, you know, for us to, to go do this. And so I think that's, I don't know if
- 1:15:11that answers your question. No, it does. And then my last, my last question on this, and I want to
- 1:15:14pivot for the last 10 minutes is
- 1:15:17if you're going to mine Bitcoin at the top level,
- 1:15:23why are you guys focused from a strategy perspective,
- 1:15:28upstream natural gas versus other potential points at where somebody could
- 1:15:34capture some natural resource, convert to power, mine Bitcoin?
- 1:15:40Yeah, I mean, it's, it's a good question. I think
- 1:15:43what we're really energized about like culturally like what is exciting about
- 1:15:49our bitcoin mining application is like it's solving real world problems and if you're going
- 1:15:55to go plug in 500 megawatts on the grid like are you really solving any problems maybe it's the
- 1:16:00load balancing it's you know better for the grid it's something i'm not as well versed in but i
- 1:16:05think what we're really energized about is you know this bitcoin mining being a function of solving
- 1:16:11real oil and gas problems for these guys that has nothing to do with Bitcoin, but it's a tool in a
- 1:16:17toolbox to solve those problems. I think that's what really gets us excited. Um, you know, we don't
- 1:16:22want to be a big self-mining company. Um, you know, for a variety of reasons, I think
- 1:16:31in our future, like I definitely see us getting back on, on the upstream side. Like if, if the
- 1:16:39right opportunity came about i could see us going and doing something larger completely vertically
- 1:16:44integrated i don't think we're ever gonna do some big gas purchase agreement with energy transfer
- 1:16:49and just put a bunch of bitcoin mines out there on their gas because it you know is makes sense
- 1:16:54from a bitcoin mining side i don't know our what we're seeing right now is like is a massive problem
- 1:17:01that we have a solution for that is growing very fast,
- 1:17:08both in 360 size, deployment size, customer profile, and backers.
- 1:17:16And so I think to some extent we have some really positive momentum
- 1:17:21that we want to keep.
- 1:17:22Why change if it's not broken sort of thing?
- 1:17:25And we have a lot of runway ahead of us to go really make an impact
- 1:17:29in this flare gas market.
- 1:17:31stranded gas market now to pivot though from the energy side and um i mentioned that i wanted to go
- 1:17:39here to the bitcoin side and even though you know certain of your target customers are more
- 1:17:47mining bitcoin for the bitcoin side of it others are solving a different problem to mitigate
- 1:17:53you guys are either helping others you're operating others to mine bitcoin or you're
- 1:18:02mining bitcoin and people are renting equipment from you how do you guys think about your role
- 1:18:09as bitcoin miners and your assets within the broader bitcoin ecosystem in terms of the
- 1:18:17function they're providing yeah great question i think you know as a bitcoiner we are distributing
- 1:18:27hash rate um away from your call it at a very low cost right the cost to mine the bitcoin is very
- 1:18:36low and so that enables us to kind of distribute hash rate away from maybe your largest publicly
- 1:18:43traded Bitcoin miners that control a lot of that hash rate. So philosophically, like that's
- 1:18:48attractive to have these smaller distributed nodes, uh, of Bitcoin mining. And so I think
- 1:18:54that's something that, you know, is an asset to Bitcoin in general. Um, you know, I know we talked
- 1:19:00a lot about pool centralization, right. Which is its own problem, but I think our function in the
- 1:19:06broader bitcoin ecosystem as like distributed nodes of hash rate is uh is pretty cool but on
- 1:19:15that point of you know a lot of bitcoiners and then bitcoin developers talk about
- 1:19:20mining centralization and mining incentives
- 1:19:23do you guys think about
- 1:19:28pool centralization as a risk to your business or a risk to bitcoin because while maybe
- 1:19:36the further away you get from Bitcoin to the end customer,
- 1:19:41the Bitcoin side of it doesn't come into play as much.
- 1:19:46But the long-term integrity of Bitcoin is critical to the demand for these
- 1:19:51solutions. And as Bitcoin grows, the demand for the solutions will grow.
- 1:19:58And perfectly fine if you guys don't think a lot about it,
- 1:20:01But I'm just curious if you do evaluate those risks and how you think about the risks of centralization within the mining ecosystem.
- 1:20:13Because from my vantage point, it's not in the interest of the actual miners, the people that are distributing the hash rate like yourselves.
- 1:20:22I'm just curious how you guys evaluate or whether or not you view it as a material risk and just how you think about that.
- 1:20:33Yeah, you know, it's hard because like on one end we're running a business.
- 1:20:37So it's like we're incentivized for ourselves and our customers to go with the pool option that's the most reliable from a payout perspective for the lowest fees.
- 1:20:47Right. Trying to run a business, we need to maximize or optimize around those points.
- 1:20:51right What does that mean It means we usually pointing hash rate at some of these big pools right Which is a conflict from your point about pool centralization And you know I think a lot of miners would say oh but you know if Boundary starts acting nefariously
- 1:21:06we can easily just switch the pool address
- 1:21:09on all of our miners and move our hash rate somewhere else,
- 1:21:12which is true.
- 1:21:13I think there's a lot more to it, right?
- 1:21:15I think it's not, you know, a five-minute process to go do that,
- 1:21:21especially, you know, if you're not set up on other pools
- 1:21:23and the KYC and all the stuff that goes along with it.
- 1:21:26So yeah, I, you know, again, our little portion of the global hash rate, you know, from our
- 1:21:36day-to-day business, we're not optimizing around the risk of pool centralization.
- 1:21:42We're optimizing around, you know, what's going to maximize our cashflow and the cashflow
- 1:21:46of customers in the most predictable way.
- 1:21:48but you know I do think there's something to be said about pool centralization as being a risk
- 1:21:55and I'd say it's fair to say that mining Bitcoin is for all the things that we talked about in
- 1:22:01terms of all the different variables that you have to think about in terms of evaluating sites
- 1:22:05mining Bitcoin is difficult not for the faint of heart probably not you know similar but different
- 1:22:13to the you know anybody who's going to drill well not for the faint of heart not for everybody
- 1:22:17but that um you guys don't have a lot of time to think about or consider regardless of you know
- 1:22:27the consequences of pool centralization but just as changes are being considered yeah to the bitcoin
- 1:22:34network and your role in that you know in terms of what you know where you're pointing at hash rate
- 1:22:44not just that like hey is centralization risk and do i want to have a second option
- 1:22:49i'm curious if you guys have ever thought about kind of splitting hash rate across pools
- 1:22:53to to have that solidly de-risked but then also you know is it fair to say you you know you guys
- 1:23:01aren't you know as changes are being proposed in bitcoin or people are evaluating soft forks
- 1:23:05that doesn't really get surfaced and you're certainly not day-to-day but rarely yeah no i
- 1:23:13As a Bitcoiner, personally, and at the company, I'm very interested in some of the more thematic.
- 1:23:20The quantum computing is a big one.
- 1:23:22How do we make Bitcoin quantum resistant?
- 1:23:24Am I active in discussions?
- 1:23:25I don't know anything about the code base.
- 1:23:27I can't speak competently on all the fine details, but I recognize the problem and I'm excited to hear what potential solutions are and will be.
- 1:23:39I think as a Bitcoiner, I'm very concerned about that.
- 1:23:42I think, you know, we have tested a couple of different pools.
- 1:23:44One we're excited about trying is ocean.
- 1:23:48You know, could we do a better job of that?
- 1:23:50Absolutely.
- 1:23:51But to your point, we're got 10,000 other things going on.
- 1:23:54Running a pool test is not the number one objective right now.
- 1:24:03But, you know, we do talk about that stuff.
- 1:24:05And we certainly talk about some of the more thematic things coming down the pipe for Bitcoin
- 1:24:10and what those mean.
- 1:24:13And, you know, I would say both my normie friends
- 1:24:15and customers like quantum is the one
- 1:24:17that a lot of people are talking about right now.
- 1:24:20So, you know, we need to be educated
- 1:24:22on what the risks or not risks are
- 1:24:24and what timeline and, you know,
- 1:24:26what Bitcoin Core is, you know, doing about that.
- 1:24:28So, all right, well, take that opportunity to wrap.
- 1:24:32But last question,
- 1:24:35what are you guys most strategically focused on
- 1:24:39And what do you see maybe categorically shifting your business in the next few years?
- 1:24:48Yeah, you know, I think our focus is on putting out as many units as possible for large oil and gas companies.
- 1:24:58Obviously, we're trying to build the biggest, you know, business we can build, the biggest services company we can build,
- 1:25:04which is really a function of, of putting units out in the field. I mean, you know,
- 1:25:13we don't look at 360 like, Oh, we got to sell the company in the next three years or,
- 1:25:16you know, we're more focused on building a company that is solving problems in the oil field,
- 1:25:23which is a function of evangelizing people on who we are, what we do, how it works and why they
- 1:25:29should do it. And then getting units out in the field. I think a lot of like, that's the near term
- 1:25:34focus. Like we need to get to 20 rental units out in the field before the end of this year,
- 1:25:38right? That unlocks our ability to go raise more money, get better cost of capital on credit
- 1:25:46facilities to then continue doing that. We're really focused on partnerships. Like one of our
- 1:25:51investors is Halliburton. And so, you know, continuing to work with Halliburton on strategic
- 1:25:55initiatives together is a big driver for us and our growth. You know, I think over the next,
- 1:26:03you know, two years, I imagine we're going to continue to be across the lower 48, potentially
- 1:26:10Alaska. You know, we are evaluating some international opportunities as well. And so,
- 1:26:16you know, if we're successful domestically, there's no reason this can't be successful at a much larger
- 1:26:20scale internationally, whether that's the Middle East or South America. So, you know, we're, you
- 1:26:24know, we're excited. The addressable market for what we're doing is massive. You know, Bitcoin
- 1:26:29mining as a function is uniquely situated to solve the problem. Like you can't go put an AI
- 1:26:36data center in the middle of the oil field and run it off Starlink. There's not many other things
- 1:26:40that are so flexible like Bitcoin mining. So, um, and we're good at it and we've been doing it now
- 1:26:46for four years and we're producers ourselves. So, uh, you know, I do think to some extent there's
- 1:26:51lightning in a bottle right now and it's trying to just capitalize on that, grow that and, um,
- 1:26:56you know, grow the company.
- 1:26:57All right.
- 1:26:58Well, last question.
- 1:26:59What is, what SMU football game are you most,
- 1:27:02you have starred on the calendar?
- 1:27:04You go to virtually all of them.
- 1:27:05Yeah, I go to most.
- 1:27:08Clemson, SMU at Clemson.
- 1:27:10Oh, nice.
- 1:27:11That's going to be really exciting.
- 1:27:14And the U is coming to.
- 1:27:15And the U is coming to SMU.
- 1:27:17Dallas, the big D.
- 1:27:18Yeah.
- 1:27:19Carson Beck, that's going to be interesting.
- 1:27:21Yeah, I love it.
- 1:27:23Well, appreciate you coming on.
- 1:27:25Center of Hash.
- 1:27:26episode three yeah thank you thanks for having me appreciate it