Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Why Real-World Driving is Kinder to Your Battery
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. If you're thinking about an EV,
- 0:13or maybe you already own one, well, you know what we're
- 0:16talking about. Today we are tackling that
- 0:18single most valuable component, the one that causes all the
- 0:21excitement, but also, let's be honest, a lot of the worry, the
- 0:25battery. For years, the big blocker, the
- 0:28thing everyone talked about was battery anxiety.
- 0:30Right, that fear. Yeah, this idea that you're
- 0:33buying this, I don't know, giant smartphone on wheels, basically
- 0:38super expensive. And then it's going to degrade
- 0:40just like your phone battery get worse and worse until it's
- 0:43almost useless. Exactly that the core value, the
- 0:46battery itself is just destined to fade away quickly, is the
- 0:50heart of the car, but also the source of so much dread.
- 0:54Well, that anxiety, you know, it's often based on older
- 0:57information, maybe some myths that have stuck around.
- 0:59So our mission today is really to cut through that noise.
- 1:02We're going to look at what the hard numbers, the latest data
- 1:05actually tell us. We've pulled together findings
- 1:07from some really large scale real world studies.
- 1:11There's market analysis from KV Deal, a Swedish car broker
- 1:15looking at actual used cars. Real cars, not lab tests.
- 1:18Precisely. And then there's some
- 1:19fascinating science coming out of Stanford University and the
- 1:22SLEC National Accelerator Lab. So we're basically giving you
- 1:26the shortcut today, the truth about how these modern EV
- 1:28batteries are really holding up after years on the road.
- 1:31And maybe some surprises about what helps them last.
- 1:33Oh, definitely. Including the surprising fact
- 1:36that how you drive every day might actually be helping, not
- 1:39hurting. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:41So where do we start? The hard evidence seems like the
- 1:44place you mentioned KVD Bill. Yeah, let's.
- 1:45Start there because the data they gathered is frankly pretty
- 1:48reassuring. It really pushes back against
- 1:50that old narrative of rapid decline.
- 1:52This wasn't a simulation. They looked at 1366 actual
- 1:56vehicles driving around Sweden. 723 fully electric 643 plug in
- 2:03hybrids. OK, so decent sample size.
- 2:05What did they find? Get this 8 out of 10 of those
- 2:08vehicles, that's 80% still had over 90% of their original
- 2:12battery capacity left. 80% kept over 90% capacity after several
- 2:17years on the road. Exactly.
- 2:19Even after years of use, 10s of thousands of kilometers, that
- 2:2390% figure, that's the key metric.
- 2:25Wow. OK, so what's the term they use
- 2:27for that? Is it state of health?
- 2:28That's the one state of health or so age.
- 2:30It's really simple. Just the percentage of the
- 2:33battery is original energy capacity, it can still hold.
- 2:36So if your car shows say 92% so aged, it means the battery is
- 2:41performing 92% as well as it did on day one.
- 2:44And this big study confirms that for most people, that sudden,
- 2:48dramatic drop off in battery life just isn't happening.
- 2:52That's huge. Were there any specific models
- 2:54that stood out like battery champions?
- 2:57Yeah, they did highlight some leaders.
- 2:59The Kia EV6 actually came out on top, showing the least
- 3:02degradation overall in their sample.
- 3:04Interesting. A Kia.
- 3:05Yeah, and it wasn't just the Super high end brands performing
- 3:08well. They saw great results from the
- 3:09Kia E Nero too, the Audi Q4 E Tron, Tesla's Model Y, even the
- 3:14Opal Maca E. So good battery life isn't just
- 3:16for the luxury tier anymore. Not at all.
- 3:18It shows solid engineering is pretty widespread now.
- 3:21The baseline seems quite high across the board.
- 3:24OK, so the Real World Report looks surprisingly good, much
- 3:29better than feared. Overwhelmingly positive I'd say.
- 3:32But that leads to a really interesting question, doesn't
- 3:34it? Which is, if the old
- 3:36predictions, maybe based on earlier tech or lab tests
- 3:39expected faster decline, why are real world batteries doing so
- 3:44much better? What were those initial tests
- 3:46missing? OK.
- 3:48And that brings us to the Stanford and SLIC research.
- 3:51Exactly. That's our second key source,
- 3:53and their big finding basically blows up a major assumption
- 3:56about battery testing. Which assumption is that?
- 3:59That traditional lab tests are the best way to predict
- 4:01lifespan. Stanford and SLAC found those
- 4:04tests are actually too pessimistic because they don't
- 4:06mimic reality well enough. How so?
- 4:08What's wrong with the lab tests? We'll think about how they work.
- 4:11They typically age batteries using these very clean, very
- 4:14steady, constant discharge and recharge cycles.
- 4:18It's predictable, controlled. And completely unlike real
- 4:21driving. Precisely.
- 4:22Your actual driving is dynamic, right?
- 4:25You speed up, you slow down down, you brake, sometimes using
- 4:28regen braking which is like a mini charge.
- 4:31You sit in traffic, you. Sit in traffic, and maybe most
- 4:34importantly, your car spends way more time parked just resting
- 4:39than it does actively driving. OK.
- 4:42And that matters, the resting part.
- 4:44It seems to matter a lot. That whole varied pattern, the
- 4:47dynamic driving, the braking, and especially those long rest
- 4:51periods turns out to be actively good for the battery's internal
- 4:54chemistry. Wait, hang on.
- 4:55So the stop start, the varied pace, the sitting parked that's
- 5:00helping the battery. That's what the science is
- 5:02suggesting. OK, here's where it gets really
- 5:04interesting. Doesn't it?
- 5:05Because the implication from the Stanford study is huge, they
- 5:09estimate that because of these real world patterns, consumer EV
- 5:12batteries might actually last up to 40% longer than those older
- 5:16projections based on standard lab tests. 40% longer.
- 5:19That's massive. That completely changes the
- 5:22calculation. It really does.
- 5:23It suggests the industry's own standard tests where maybe
- 5:26missing a huge piece of the puzzle.
- 5:27So all those years people were told, you know, Dr. Gently
- 5:31accelerate smoothly to save the battery.
- 5:33The reality is that my normal, sometimes jerky commute might
- 5:38have actually been better for it.
- 5:40It sounds counterintuitive, I know, but one of the
- 5:43researchers, Simona Onori, basically said that real driving
- 5:46patterns with all the acceleration and braking seem to
- 5:49help batteries last longer than they expected.
- 5:51How? What's the mechanism?
- 5:54It seems that the rapid little charges during region breaking
- 5:57and the demands of acceleration help keep the lithium ions
- 6:01distributed more evenly within the battery structure.
- 6:04It prevents them from getting sort of snuck, which can happen
- 6:07with very slow steady use or long periods at full or empty.
- 6:12Okay, that makes some sense, but what about flooring it?
- 6:14Everyone knows that matching the accelerator kills your battery,
- 6:16right? Well, that was the other big
- 6:17myth they busted. The data actually correlated
- 6:20those sharp short bursts of power like flooring it, with
- 6:23slower degradation. Slower, not faster.
- 6:26How on earth does that work? It's likely down to where in the
- 6:29batteries charge level you're operating.
- 6:31When you accelerate hard, the car system pulls power
- 6:34aggressively, yes, but often from the middle range of the
- 6:37batteries capacity, say between 30% and 70% state of charge.
- 6:42The middle range. Why does that matter?
- 6:44Because that middle zone is chemically the most stable part
- 6:47for the battery, it's the least stressful place for it to be.
- 6:50You're not pushing it to the extremes fully charged or nearly
- 6:54empty, which is where more stress and degradation tend to
- 6:57happen. So flooring it might use more
- 6:59energy now, but it's drawing that energy from the battery's
- 7:03comfort zone, so to speak. That seems to be the idea.
- 7:06You're using power quickly, but in the sweet spot.
- 7:09It helps us understand a key distinction too.
- 7:12There's cycle aging, which is where from charging and
- 7:15discharging we're using it. And then there's time induced
- 7:17aging or calendar aging, the where that happens just because
- 7:21time is passing regardless of use, OK.
- 7:24And for most consumer EVs, which, let's face it, are parked
- 7:27most of the time. Yeah, like 95% of the time for
- 7:29many people. Exactly, for those cars that
- 7:33time induced aging is actually the dominant factor more so than
- 7:36the where from driving cycles. Your dynamic driving isn't the
- 7:40big bad wolf we thought it was. This is fascinating.
- 7:42It really shifts the perspective.
- 7:44It does, and it leads us to think about what really
- 7:47influences how long your specific battery lasts.
- 7:51If the tech itself is this robust, what makes the
- 7:54difference between Car A and car B?
- 7:57OK, So what is it then? Well, the test manager back at
- 8:00KVD, Bill, the Swedish study, made a really telling comment.
- 8:03He said that state of health, the SO H, doesn't seem to depend
- 8:06so much on the specific manufacturer.
- 8:08Not the brand. Not primarily, no, but it
- 8:11depends much more on how the car is used, the climate it lives
- 8:14in, and especially the owner's charging habits.
- 8:17So it comes back to the owner, to you, the driver.
- 8:19Absolutely. It underscores that your
- 8:21personal habits, the way you treat the battery, probably
- 8:24matter more than the badge on the front of the car.
- 8:26You are the biggest variable. OK, this is the empowering part
- 8:29then. If the batteries are built well
- 8:31and driving normally isn't hurting them like we thought,
- 8:34what can you, the listener, actually do to maximize that
- 8:38lifespan even further? That's the crucial question, and
- 8:41the research points to some clear, practical steps.
- 8:44So let's give people the golden rules for battery care based on
- 8:47this data rule #1. Rule 1.
- 8:49Avoid charging to 100% every single day.
- 8:52OK, why not? Isn't in full full.
- 8:55It is, but consistently pushing the battery to that absolute
- 8:58100% state of charge uses higher voltages internally.
- 9:02Over time, that extra stress can accelerate where on the battery
- 9:06chemistry. So for just normal daily
- 9:08driving, commuting, errands, what's the target?
- 9:11Aim for about 80%. Charge it up to 80% for your
- 9:14routine use. Only push it to 100% when you
- 9:16genuinely need that maximum range, like for a long road
- 9:19trip. Makes sense, less stress
- 9:21day-to-day. But wait, isn't there an
- 9:22exception? Something about LFP batteries?
- 9:25Yes, crucial point. If your car specifically uses
- 9:28LFP, that's lithium iron phosphate chemistry.
- 9:30The advice is different. So with LFP you actually should
- 9:34charge it to 100% fairly regularly, maybe once a week or
- 9:37so. Why the difference?
- 9:38Is LFP less durable? No, actually.
- 9:41LFT is known for being very durable, but the reason for the
- 9:45100% charge is more about calibration.
- 9:47The car's battery management system needs that full charge
- 9:50point to accurately estimate the remaining range.
- 9:54If you only charge LFP to 80%, it can sometimes get a bit lost
- 9:58and your range display might become less accurate.
- 10:00OK, so know your battery chemistry.
- 10:02For most common types, 80% daily is the goal for LFP.
- 10:06Hit 100% regularly for calibration.
- 10:08Got it. Rule 2.
- 10:09Rule 2. Limit your use of DC fast
- 10:12charging. The superchargers, the ones you
- 10:13find on the highway. Exactly.
- 10:15They are fantastic and absolutely necessary for long
- 10:17trips, but they pump energy in very quickly and that generates
- 10:21a lot more heat inside the battery pack compared to slower.
- 10:24Charges and heat is bad for batteries right the.
- 10:25Heat is basically battery kryptonite.
- 10:27It's the number one enemy of long term chemical stability.
- 10:30So the advice is use fast chargers when you need them on
- 10:33the road, but for your regular day-to-day charging at home or
- 10:36work. Stick to the slower AC charging,
- 10:39like overnight. Precisely.
- 10:41Slower AC charging is much gentler, keeps the temperature
- 10:44down, and minimizes stress on the battery components.
- 10:47Think of fast charging as a Sprint and AC charging as a
- 10:50marathon piece. OK.
- 10:52Gentle daily charging makes sense and Rule 3.
- 10:55Rule 3. Try to avoid parking in extreme
- 10:58temperatures for long periods. So this isn't about driving, but
- 11:02about where the car sits. Yeah, leaving the car parked for
- 11:05hours and hours in blazing summer sun or in deep freezing
- 11:09conditions can also stress the battery chemistry.
- 11:12So if you can, park in a garage or at least find a shady spot in
- 11:16the summer. Exactly, it's about mitigating
- 11:18those extremes. If you live in a place with very
- 11:21hot summers or very cold winters, just being mindful of
- 11:24where you park can make a noticeable difference to long
- 11:26term health. So pretty simple adjustments
- 11:28really. Charged to 80% daily.
- 11:30Usually prefer slow charging at home and park smart in extreme
- 11:34weather. That's the core of it, and those
- 11:37simple habits can significantly extend the life of what is,
- 11:40let's face it, the most expensive single part of the
- 11:42car. OK, let's pull this all together
- 11:44then. What's the ultimate take away
- 11:47for someone listening right now, maybe still feeling that battery
- 11:50anxiety? I think there are three main
- 11:52things to remember before 1. The real world data is genuinely
- 11:57reassuring. Remember that KVD bill study 8
- 12:02out of 10 EVs keeping over 90% capacity after years.
- 12:06The fear of rapid failure just isn't matching reality for most
- 12:09modern EVs. OK.
- 12:11Good news first. 2 Your normal dynamic driving, the stop start,
- 12:16the acceleration, even the long periods parked is actually good
- 12:19for the battery, or at least certainly not as harmful as
- 12:21those old pessimistic lab tests suggested.
- 12:24It might even help it last longer.
- 12:25Right, driving like a normal person is OK.
- 12:27Totally, OK. And three, you have significant
- 12:30control. Your charging habits and how you
- 12:32treat the car in extreme weather matter a lot, probably more than
- 12:35the brand name. So you're in the driver's seat,
- 12:37literally and figuratively. Exactly.
- 12:39So what does this all mean, big picture?
- 12:41Well, I think it means the challenge has fundamentally
- 12:44changed. For years, the big hurdle was
- 12:46technical. Could we even build an EV
- 12:48battery that would last long enough?
- 12:50And the answer seems to be yes. The data strongly suggests yes,
- 12:54they are robust. They're lasting much longer than
- 12:57many predicted. The engineering hurdle for basic
- 13:00durability seems to have been largely cleared.
- 13:03So if the tech is there, what's the problem now?
- 13:07The real barrier now, I believe, is perception.
- 13:10It's communication. That old battery anxiety
- 13:13narrative is sticky even though the data has moved on.
- 13:16People haven't caught up with the reality.
- 13:18Pretty much think about it this way.
- 13:19What if people understood that their modern EV battery was
- 13:23engineered to be as fundamentally durable and
- 13:25reliable as, I don't know, say, a classic bulletproof vintage
- 13:30Honda Accord? The benchmark for reliability.
- 13:33Exactly. If that level of trust existed
- 13:36for EV batteries, based on the actual performance data we're
- 13:38seeing, would battery anxiety even be a thing anymore?
- 13:42Adoption fears would likely plummet.
- 13:44So the industry's job now isn't just building better batteries,
- 13:47but convincing people that the batteries they already build are
- 13:50great. That's a huge part of it.
- 13:52It's about building trust in the technologies proven longevity.
- 13:56The hurdle isn't just engineering anymore, it's
- 13:58psychology and communication. Thank you so much for joining us
- 14:01today and really digging into the reality of EV batteries.
- 14:05It's genuinely reassuring to see the data dismantling some of
- 14:08those long held fears. And for everyone listening, just
- 14:10found this deep dive helpful. Please do make sure you follow
- 14:13the channel, subscribe to the deep dive.
- 14:15That way you'll never miss another shortcut to being this
- 14:17well informed. We really appreciate you tuning
- 14:19in. Until next time.