Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / On The Entry To The Path Of Mediation
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I Love You. Keep Going.
- 0:21It is March 14th, 2024 at 7:36 PM Pacific Standard Time, and
- 0:27last week we talked about enlightenment, which is in some
- 0:31sense the end of the path. And I thought that it might be
- 0:34useful to talk about the beginning of the path, the entry
- 0:37into doing that undertaking, this practice.
- 0:42I talk often about the preliminary practices, which I
- 0:45think is the attachment work. But even before the the
- 0:49undertaking, the preliminary practices, there is the decision
- 0:55to practice, the decision to come into this all together,
- 1:00which I've often described as making the decision to be a good
- 1:04person. What does that mean to me?
- 1:09It means that you take an ethical stance and then we talk
- 1:15about the framework of an ethical stance as the precepts.
- 1:19The monastic precepts are in the hundreds, of course, but the lay
- 1:25precepts are five typically undertaking the practice not to
- 1:31kill, undertaking the practice not to steal, undertaking the
- 1:36practice not to engage in sexual conduct that's harmful, not to
- 1:42engage in harsh or false speech, and not to engage in the use of
- 1:48intoxicants that lead to heedlessness.
- 1:53What the hell is heedlessness? Maybe we should say that do not
- 2:03lead to the destruction of your social network.
- 2:10Maybe that's a good way that is not addictive.
- 2:16But then the consumption of things that that can be
- 2:18addictive goes beyond substances into processes.
- 2:22So gambling, debtting, danger, sex.
- 2:34So what is it? To take an ethical stance, it's
- 2:36in my America where the privilege is amazing and the our
- 2:47colonial nature is just bred into the culture where we take
- 2:53whatever we want really and come up with some rationale for it.
- 2:59It it is a a a nuanced and difficult process to open that
- 3:06up. I think it's it's not as
- 3:15difficult if you're not in that group because you already have
- 3:18the experience of of less then that main group has and then you
- 3:28know for instance we're out gay people if they're they're white
- 3:33and male, may start in that group but then are as soon as
- 3:37that's revealed or devalued from it.
- 3:40So there's an awakening there. Sometimes the first of the
- 3:47precepts is not to kill. It's an interesting thing we're
- 3:51we're we're very meat centric culture and so the the killing
- 3:56of things is just built in everywhere.
- 3:58It's from the the first real conscious experience that's
- 4:02that's just part of it. It's part of the landscape of it
- 4:08And we're not talking about a few we're talking about billions
- 4:14of of beings that are slaughtered.
- 4:17I'm using that in in the conventional term, not as the
- 4:21sort of pejorative term, but it also expands out from there.
- 4:30David Attenborough in one of the films that he made about the
- 4:33environment said that if we want to stabilize the environment
- 4:36that we have, we need to reduce the the farmland by 2/3.
- 4:41And that 2/3 is mainly in the cultivation of of animals.
- 4:51And we look at the the process of climate change that's
- 4:54happening which is affecting everybody mainly the West, the
- 5:00privileged West is the energy, the engine of that climate
- 5:04change which disproportionately effects people that aren't in
- 5:08that position of power. And and even there we're quite a
- 5:16privilege particularly in North America when you think about the
- 5:21production of meat, it takes 70 portions of grain to make one
- 5:27portion of meat. So in a meat centric society, we
- 5:31already have a reduction of population that comes from that
- 5:35because it's so energy intensive to produce that our population
- 5:40hasn't really expanded. So when you look at North
- 5:44America and and Western Europe, our populations are about 1/3 of
- 5:49what Asia's population is because of that.
- 5:57And so as the the environment gets really bad and we lose the
- 6:02capacity to produce so much grain and all of the other
- 6:10things that we use to support that, let's say we lose half of
- 6:16that capacity in North America and in, in Europe, we're just
- 6:21going to be able to adjust and eat less meat because we'll
- 6:25we'll still have the, the, the resources that produce the meat
- 6:30available if we don't use it for that.
- 6:34But in Asia they're not meat centric.
- 6:39They're already mainly vegetarian.
- 6:43So they don't have that option and and so as the climate
- 6:46changes and the the band of the equator is no longer really
- 6:51habitable all of those people are gonna have to move somewhere
- 6:56where it's more habitable in order to eat 20% at least of the
- 7:04populations of the of the of of the planet won't be habitable
- 7:08and and that's you know 4 billion people.
- 7:15So our little wall that we're building along Texas it's not
- 7:22going to be good enough. We're actually we've abandoned
- 7:25the wall in Texas. It's too bad of a publicity
- 7:27machine. We're building it between
- 7:29Guatemala and Mexico now, which is much it's shorter and more
- 7:37remote, so it's easier to lied. And the great advantage that
- 7:45North America has is we're surrounded by water.
- 7:47There's no way to walk here. But Europe isn't so lucky.
- 7:52Asia can just walk over. What are they going to do about
- 7:54that? When did you ever feel about the
- 8:07killing of all of these beings, all of these sentient beings?
- 8:11I know it says in the in the first precept that not to kill
- 8:15sentient beings and that in traditional Buddhism animals are
- 8:19not sentient. That's the the sort of way out
- 8:22of that. But our Western science of
- 8:27course easily examines these things and finds them to be
- 8:32sentient. Then what are we going to do
- 8:39about the taking? What's not freely given?
- 8:43I I was very tickled but also disturbed by Trevor Noah's
- 8:50comment that the thing that white people really like are
- 8:53museums to white people. We sort of take everything from
- 8:58everywhere and put them into a museum.
- 9:00And somehow that makes that all right and that that whole
- 9:07history, say the last 5 or 600 years of the West going around
- 9:13the planet and just taking everything, it's really built
- 9:16into it and and it produces such wealth that we get used to a
- 9:25level of it, you know, in some sense entitled to it.
- 9:31So how are we gonna do that piece?
- 9:37Sexual misconduct? The Jeez, that one's really
- 9:45hard, too. It's everywhere you look.
- 9:50We've sexualized selling stuff. In a way.
- 9:56We created the Internet and and turns out that pornography is
- 10:04the number one thing on the Internet.
- 10:06Not particularly surprising. And now with AI, there's gonna
- 10:12be no limit to what we can do there.
- 10:14What will that produce? And how does that affect the
- 10:19actual interaction with the real people, which is one of the
- 10:22things that's so puzzling. But we actually need that not to
- 10:31engage in harsh speech or just really in a in an interesting
- 10:37period in our culture where the speech and the harshness of it
- 10:43and the meanness of it is, is also everywhere.
- 10:48There is no more in some sense limit on it all of the different
- 10:53ways of communicating what's open and what isn't open and
- 10:59then imbibing in in intoxicants. I live in Los Angeles and and
- 11:05one of the things that's apparent about Los Angeles that
- 11:09I know it hasn't yet happened in other places is the invasion of
- 11:14what I call the meth zombies. But it's the fentanyl,
- 11:20methamphetamine, but it's not the old meth that was based on
- 11:25the phedrine. And this is the the new method
- 11:28that's made out of agricultural chemicals because we control the
- 11:36ephedrine so much. They the the traffickers moved
- 11:39into other things and and it it it because it isn't the same
- 11:44exact formulation as that old euphoric drug, they add fentanyl
- 11:51to it so that the euphoric pieces back and it's cheap.
- 11:58It is so cheap to make that and it causes unlike the old meth,
- 12:08the new meth causes permanent cognitive injury from moderate
- 12:13use. Is then this, this harm to not
- 12:1910s of thousands but hundreds of thousands of young people.
- 12:23What are we gonna do with with hundreds of thousands of
- 12:28cognitively impaired young people for their their whole
- 12:32lives. I live in Los Angeles and and
- 12:39it's very apparent if you if you live somewhere else,
- 12:43particularly places that get cold, you don't have the the
- 12:47roving tent cities that that we have maybe.
- 12:54How can we live in a society that is so rich and have 10s of
- 13:02thousands of people living in tents on the street.
- 13:09So you see the dilemma of saying to anyone that as we enter into
- 13:19this path of seeking to understand ourselves and seeking
- 13:24to understand the human condition that you need to take
- 13:30an ethical stance in in order to be able to do that on an
- 13:34individual level. What we're really talking about
- 13:36is freeing the mind so that it isn't caught up in all of these
- 13:42things. So that you then have the the
- 13:46capacity to concentrate and then to see how the the the mind, the
- 13:53body mind through the sensing experiences takes in what's
- 13:59around and creates the experience that you.
- 14:06So we we need to care for the body so that we have this
- 14:10vehicle in which to explore and then we have our role in the
- 14:18community or the society that we live in.
- 14:25I think one of the things about our society, which is so
- 14:29organized around distraction and the normalizing of all of these
- 14:32things is it's really easy not to pay attention to it.
- 14:40I think that's one of the pieces about practice, of course, which
- 14:47is paying attention. That's what the the practice is
- 14:50really about. We're in this push with the the
- 14:54general way in which our culture operates and we really have
- 15:03allowed the accumulation of money at the top and with that
- 15:08accumulation of money the acquisition of of all of the
- 15:14community based organizations that would function to provide a
- 15:21point of view that is beyond just the interests of of the
- 15:26moneyed class. So we also have a difficulty
- 15:31understanding what's happening based on the information that
- 15:36we're given. Anyway, I'm describing a picture
- 15:43of the world that that I experienced that I think is a a
- 15:48a common shared experience. How then do we take an ethical
- 15:54stance and open into the capacity to practice so that we
- 16:00can see our own conditioning, which of course is affected by
- 16:06this? What is your first reference, or
- 16:13your first recognition of being affected by the culture in which
- 16:18we live? The effect, of course, has
- 16:24preceded that early conscious memory of things, and we come
- 16:31into a culture that's already functioning, that's already
- 16:34affecting the family that we live with.
- 16:40And our caregivers, of course, have adapted a relationship to
- 16:46the culture, which we are also exposed to pretty early.
- 16:51Do you remember a time when you didn't feel that the cultural
- 16:59values that your family's system was holding matched yours pretty
- 17:05well? Or did Or did you find that it
- 17:10it that it did match pretty well and you you had a sense of ease
- 17:14about it? I would just think back the in
- 17:29the town I grew up in, in Evanston, IL.
- 17:32The school systems, like they often are in the US, are based
- 17:38on property taxes and so they're rich communities.
- 17:42The schools were better and with kids in Evanston, IL in the 50s,
- 17:52when I was in grade school, the schools were also segregated by
- 17:59race. I don't know if you had the
- 18:01experience of that. Elementary schools were
- 18:07segregated by race, and intermediate schools and high
- 18:11schools were integrated and they were intentionally integrated.
- 18:18The idea was that school children would learn how to be
- 18:22in relationship with their community.
- 18:25And then by the time puberty hit and they went into middle school
- 18:29and high school, they would already have formed those bonds
- 18:32and so they wouldn't be cross race bonds was very thought out
- 18:39as a representation of culture. So in the 50s that was actually,
- 18:43I think, quite open, more acceptable than it was in the
- 18:4660s when there was a lot of objection to that.
- 18:58Do you remember whether or not as a child the television that
- 19:03you were able to watch was in color or was in black and white?
- 19:09If you're my age, you will remember a time where there was
- 19:13no television because I was born before it happened.
- 19:19And then in the late 50s we got these little portable TV's that
- 19:29that were black and white and everything was in black and
- 19:31white and Motorola's. We had a Motorola which was a 2
- 19:40tone Motorola and it had knobs on it and it looked like the
- 19:44cars look right. That was sort of a a dark green
- 19:50on the bottom and it's sort of Gray on the top and it had a
- 19:53gold handle on it and the knobs were gold and it looked very
- 19:57nice and and most of the cartoon programs were on UHF.
- 20:03So you had you you had to tune into it like a radio.
- 20:07It wasn't stations and it was a wonderful thing.
- 20:17And then? In the 60s they started making
- 20:21color televisions and the the tubes were were round.
- 20:24They weren't square, but it didn't matter where you had a
- 20:30color television because everything was broadcast in
- 20:32black and white. I remember the first show that I
- 20:37saw was the Dean Martin show, and that was in color.
- 20:44And that was a show where they had women walking around in
- 20:46bikinis and the men were in suits and they had cocktails and
- 20:50they were smoking cigarettes. That's the the picture that was
- 20:55supposed to be. And then Garfield Goose, the the
- 21:00children's show was was shown in color.
- 21:07And all of these messages come at you when when you're kids, of
- 21:11course, you're really looking for your caregivers in order to
- 21:14assign the value of it. And I I grew up in a in a sort
- 21:18of hard right Republican environment in Chicago.
- 21:24At that time, everybody had the newspaper delivered.
- 21:27Every day. You remember newspapers being
- 21:31delivered, and if it was the Tribune, you were in a
- 21:35conservative family, and if it was the Sun Times, you were in a
- 21:39liberal family. Nobody really took both papers,
- 21:42and so the stories were quite different.
- 21:44And you knew that as a kid because the Tribune was very
- 21:49staid and very formal and the pages were big and the And the
- 21:53Sun Times is more of a tabloid, different size and different
- 21:58kinds of writing. All of the kids that went to
- 22:09those old white elementary schools were were primed from
- 22:15the very beginning to go to college.
- 22:17That was the thing. But that wasn't true in middle
- 22:21school or high school. In middle school and high school
- 22:24you could actually get a job and and and get married and have
- 22:28kids and have a house and A and a car on on on a job that you
- 22:33could get at the high school diploma.
- 22:40So the purpose of practice of course is to begin to understand
- 22:45how all of these things that stack up on you before you even
- 22:49have the capacity to understand them, create the way that you
- 22:57experience yourself in the world.
- 23:00Is that making sense? So we really are in some sense
- 23:05undertaking this practice of pulling all of that apart and
- 23:09seeing how all of those things have affected us.
- 23:13And then undertaking these practices of not harming really,
- 23:21I think is a easier way to talk about it not harming.
- 23:26So how do you undo the cultural conditioning where you don't
- 23:29even notice the harm, and then pull out of that a behavior and
- 23:35move into a way of being in the world where you aren't harming?
- 23:42How do you object to harm that that you see around you without
- 23:48harming? In the objection is one of the
- 23:51great puzzles of this I I learned a new way, a word today
- 24:03which I thought was fabulous, which was vegan phobic, vegan
- 24:12phobic. People who are terrified of
- 24:14vegans because they come at you with such fierceness, you know,
- 24:21you know, you're a you're a blood soaked planet killer,
- 24:25which is probably not the best way to open a dialogue.
- 24:36I think there was a New Yorker cartoon.
- 24:38That is, if you don't read history, you're liable to repeat
- 24:47it. And if you do read history, you
- 24:49have to find a way to sit with the people who don't read
- 24:53history repeating it, which is one of those things about waking
- 24:58up. I was talking to somebody about
- 25:00it, and that there they found that the deeper their insight
- 25:06got, the more isolated that they felt.
- 25:13How do you then keep this relationship, keep this
- 25:17openness, keep this sense of generosity, of compassion, and
- 25:22then also see all of this stuff happening with?
- 25:25Because what can happen when you can't do that, of course, is
- 25:29that you begin to withdraw from it.
- 25:32The practice is not meant to enable you to withdraw from
- 25:37engagement. It's in fact the opposite.
- 25:39It's meant to push you in, fully engaging and at the same time
- 25:45keeping your balance so that you don't get knocked into anger, or
- 25:52to envy and jealousy and to cruelty, to craving version of
- 26:00consciousness. How do you, when you find that
- 26:05you've been culturally acclimatized to engaging into
- 26:10these behaviors and you begin to withdraw from them?
- 26:13What you notice often is this intense craving for the
- 26:17experiences that they provided. Even though you know that
- 26:21they're harming experience, they're harming in some way.
- 26:25There is a sense of delight or pleasure that is associated with
- 26:29the whole history of the experience of using them.
- 26:34What is it that makes you think back to a childhood experience
- 26:39that's pleasant and engaging? Is it food?
- 26:43Is it color? Is it smell?
- 26:45What is it that actually able to do that?
- 26:51Then how? How can we reorient the present?
- 26:53Reorient to the present in a way that we're actually actively
- 26:58engaged in a non harming stance and keep those references.
- 27:04Keep that sense of continuity, that sense of warmth about that.
- 27:16I happen to be in a growth family where the 5th precept was
- 27:21just slaughtered. Everybody in my my family
- 27:28imbibed in a heedless way. Really, I think I I I'm being
- 27:37unfair to them in a way, because it's really my perspective and
- 27:42maybe not theirs. It was very painful.
- 27:55So you come into practice, you make a decision to be a good
- 27:58person. I I used to say that that meant
- 28:00you give up revenge as a goal in life.
- 28:05You give up the idea that you need to get powerful enough to
- 28:10exact revenge on the people that have harmed you.
- 28:18You give up on seeking powers that you can't be hurt anymore.
- 28:28It isn't in our culture, a common thing to undertake
- 28:33meditation practice at a deep level.
- 28:36We we really aren't organized in that way.
- 28:39It's a small minority of people who engage in meditation
- 28:45practice, an even smaller minority that is organized
- 28:50around Buddhist practice. They're a largely a Christian
- 28:58culture. So you make the decision, I'm
- 29:10gonna be a good person. I'm gonna give up revenge, I'm
- 29:13gonna give up power. I'm gonna take an ethical
- 29:20stance. And so then the practice is
- 29:25really about examining what is that stance, what is it, the
- 29:30ethics that you're embracing. So I would say that in Western
- 29:37Buddhist meditation practice, the first precept, which is the
- 29:42to undertake the practice not to kill, is, is really
- 29:46conservatively engaged as not to harm sentient beings, which
- 29:51means human animals only. I have a dog.
- 30:01I don't know. Does anybody have a dog?
- 30:04I look at my dog's face and I think, Oh my God, this being,
- 30:08this delightful being is here, How lovely.
- 30:13I wouldn't kill it and eat it. I grew up in the Midwest, of
- 30:22course, And so in the summers we went to the farms and we'd walk
- 30:25along and there there'd be these cows wandering around.
- 30:29They they looked, when you engaged them, beautiful.
- 30:36I see the I see them as beautiful.
- 30:38And really, I guess the thing that bothers me the most is
- 30:42there. They appeared to be so beautiful
- 30:45to me. Why would you destroy beauty?
- 30:50And then when I layer on top of it the destruction of our the
- 30:53habitability of our planet, it seems extremely frivolous.
- 31:07I have a sometimes it tell a story of a a girl sitting on her
- 31:14grandfather's lap with a picture book.
- 31:15Have you ever been around small kids?
- 31:20When my godchild Guthrie was young, I would come in and he
- 31:24would see me and he'd go, I'll be right back.
- 31:26And then he would rush off. Then he would come back, like
- 31:28with as many books as he could carry.
- 31:32He would sit on my lap with the pile of books next to him and we
- 31:36would go through page after page.
- 31:40I was thinking, Oh my God, how are we ever gonna get through
- 31:42these books? And his mother, Suzanne said,
- 31:44you know, they don't notice if you skip pages.
- 31:47And so we, I, the, the small kids don't have the same sort of
- 31:52through narratives that we have. I don't know if you've ever
- 31:55watched a cartoon aimed at really young kids.
- 31:58There's no narrative. It's just things happening,
- 32:15that sense of aliveness, that sense of beauty.
- 32:24So you take your stance on not killing, and then what is it
- 32:27about taking? Stealing, I guess, is one way.
- 32:32There seems to be a general sense of stealing as not being a
- 32:36good thing. When I was a kid, of course I,
- 32:51I, I and growing in the family I did.
- 32:54Money was extremely restricted for children.
- 32:58If you wanted anything really, you couldn't have it.
- 33:01And and so we did all learn to steal as a result of that.
- 33:08I think I would. I could steal a dollar from my
- 33:15mother in change, so it was hardly noticeable.
- 33:18And then I could go to the grocery store and I could buy a
- 33:21box of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.
- 33:24They were a nickel, so I could buy 20 of them quite, quite a
- 33:29haul. And so that ease around that and
- 33:36then of course now with the Internet and all all of the
- 33:39stuff around and the the pirating, that's just so easy
- 33:43and fluid. At what point do you draw the
- 33:45line on taking stuff that actually probably is not offered
- 33:50freely, Christian? Or just might sound like a
- 33:59question that a thief would ask, but I'm curious if that precept,
- 34:05if you're aware of that precept, having some kind of particular
- 34:10like socio, political, historical aspect to it of like
- 34:16what stealing might have meant at that time.
- 34:19Like, I mean in the guy from Les Miserables steals a loaf of
- 34:25bread or something and then we're all rooting for him even
- 34:28though he's he obviously should go to jail, but so like, we can
- 34:33make exceptions for this, right? So I'm kind of curious about the
- 34:35nuances of that one, given how much inequality there is in this
- 34:40world right now. Right.
- 34:44It's a a staggering amount of of inequality and and largely
- 34:52legal. But then that's because the
- 34:54system is so corrupt and what is it And this is where these stand
- 34:59These on a cultural, societal level begin to just collapse
- 35:03because it's it's it's so clearly unfair.
- 35:13At what point did justice become who's in power and not what's
- 35:18fair? The question may be, but still
- 35:23in this environment is in the way that it is you have the
- 35:29position to define what this is. What is it?
- 35:35Do you have a sense of entitlement so that the
- 35:37copyright doesn't matter? I'll just take what I want.
- 35:50How's that work? Remember, the goal of this is is
- 35:54a mind that then is at peace, that you can open into
- 36:00understanding the nature of the human condition.
- 36:03That the mind that is agitated or worried or or Blighty because
- 36:11of it, distracted because of it, prevents that from happening.
- 36:20But it's unquestionably unfair and it's very hard to avoid that
- 36:32experience of it. So how are you able to hold the
- 36:35experience of that unfairness? And in our culture, the main way
- 36:41of doing that is distraction, which is the opposite of the
- 36:45attention that we're trying to bring to explore these things.
- 36:50So these are the conundrums. This also goes into consent in a
- 37:03way that is I think interesting also in our culture, the
- 37:07constant dialogue around what is consent and what is in consent
- 37:18And are you confident that you have consent?
- 37:21And once consent is given, are you also sensitive that it can
- 37:27be withdrawn, or does it simply mean that you were stuck, that
- 37:36you don't have enough power where your consent means
- 37:39anything or the legal structure doesn't allow consent?
- 37:43You know, when I was in my 20s, which is usually a time of
- 37:50exploration and and particularly in relationships and sexuality,
- 37:57homosexuality was illegal in all 50 states.
- 38:02And there, there was no consent from our community for that.
- 38:12And and what that resulted in was a kind of appearance.
- 38:19If you could pass for straight, some people could pass for
- 38:23straight. And so they lived a dual life.
- 38:29But there was no consent anywhere in that because most of
- 38:32the time the two lives were not connected.
- 38:35And so people in one life did not actually have the experience
- 38:39of the other life. And it's, you know, it's one of
- 38:50those paradoxes of all of this. When AIDS happened, Reagan was
- 38:59in office and and he did not feel that there was a need for
- 39:04society to respond to our community.
- 39:07It did not feel a need to offer resources to the community.
- 39:13Really had the idea that we were completely separate and that
- 39:16this dual experience of life. I I don't know how he couldn't
- 39:21have thought that. But at least publicly he
- 39:23maintained that that sense that the communities were separate,
- 39:3114,000 people had died. Can you imagine 14,000 straight
- 39:36people dying and the president not commenting on it?
- 39:43Can you imagine 50 dying? And yet there we were, 14,000
- 39:48dead and still no comment from the White House.
- 40:02So we live in a in a society where there's different kinds of
- 40:05pressures, culture that create an experience around consent.
- 40:15This is particularly true in the sexual arena where consent is
- 40:19important, essential really. And then the power positions
- 40:28have a lot, lot of effect on that.
- 40:35We're kind of running out of time to continue talking about
- 40:37it. This is a a a deep topic and and
- 40:39and there's a lot of nuance to it and and I like to layer it
- 40:47and layer it and layer it so that it has the range of meaning
- 40:54to it. And I think that this is an
- 40:58essential piece of the practice and it isn't just at the
- 41:00beginning of practice that we really do need to stand in our
- 41:05understanding of what is ethical, what is just what is
- 41:12fair. We are extremely moral beings,
- 41:17and this is essential to our capacity for peace.
- 41:21To be able to take on an ethical stance and to stand in it, which
- 41:27also means the expression of it, and then to find a way to be
- 41:33expressive of it in a way that actually is commutative.
- 41:36Because that's consent, right? To communicate it in in a way
- 41:41that other people can understand what you're talking about so
- 41:46that they can be responsive to that.
- 41:50That's that process of consent. But we that it's a difficult
- 42:01time for that, I think. Anyway,
- 42:19do you have a sense of how beautiful this life is, how
- 42:23beautiful all of these beings are everywhere?
- 42:27How beautiful the plants are, how beautiful to be alive and to
- 42:35be engaged in all of this? Do you have a sense at the core
- 42:40of this, how exquisitely beautiful this is, how sacred
- 42:44this is? That's the place that that
- 42:49ethical stance, that that sense of justice is.
- 42:53This fairness takes you. I think that's why it it's
- 42:58essential that we we come here at the beginning and begin this
- 43:04process. Because what you're gonna find
- 43:07is that your conditioning has you wrapped up in ways that
- 43:13prevent you from actually being able to see all of that.
- 43:15And what the the practice is really about is unwinding that
- 43:20so that you can come into that place and see it.
- 43:30Which would you rather the pasta or meta insight or loving
- 43:36kindness? Maybe compassion?
- 43:40We can do some karuna. So go ahead and take your
- 43:49meditation posture. All right.
- 43:52Let go of the meditation. Any comments or questions on
- 44:03that? So we have a new website which
- 44:16we we're just getting up, which is kind of fun.
- 44:19I like it. It's it's very close to my
- 44:24aesthetic as it is. So take a look at it.
- 44:31Hopefully it's fun and we have some stuff coming up in April.
- 44:37We're going to do level one on four Saturday mornings from 9:00
- 44:41to 1:00. Take a look at that.
- 44:44If you're interested in the preliminary practices of the
- 44:46attachment stuff, it's there. We have two retreats up there.
- 44:52We have a two week residential retreat in Poland.
- 44:57We have only five spaces there and so there's a waiting list
- 45:01for that in case some of the some people don't make it.
- 45:04And then there's a four day retreat in Utrecht which is
- 45:12meditation and attachment level one retreat.
- 45:14So we do the whole thing in in four days.
- 45:20What else is happening? We're going to do a Level 2
- 45:26meditation and attachment starting in July, and I'm also
- 45:30going to offer meditation and addiction, both a level one and
- 45:36a level 2. We've we've never done a Level 2
- 45:39meditation and addiction in an online version before.
- 45:44It's a 12 week course that meets three times a week for an hour.
- 45:49So six o'clock, 6:00 PM Pacific Time, Monday, Wednesday and
- 45:56Friday. The format of that is a Monday
- 46:00is a didactic. So the information Wednesday is
- 46:06meditation instruction and Friday is a a processing of the
- 46:10material. We'd go through the four modules
- 46:14of the meditation and addiction, craving and urging stress, anger
- 46:19and depression. Persistent negative emotions and
- 46:24difficult interpersonal relationships are the the the
- 46:27main conduits for relapse. So this is really intended for
- 46:31people that have abstinence or harm reduction strategies in
- 46:39place that are then looking to support that.
- 46:42And we use the attachment lens to talk about the the underlying
- 46:47conditioning that leads people into addictive paths.
- 46:54So that's what's coming up. Take a look at it.
- 46:56It should be on the website Christian.
- 47:00Georgia did have a question about the compassion meditation.
- 47:03OK. Do you see like getting into the
- 47:08mind state as like going hand in hand with opening up to like
- 47:15whatever emotions are coming up or like opening up the feel in
- 47:17space or kind of like sensitizing oneself to that for
- 47:22for self compassion practice? In in in compassion for self,
- 47:30you know my my mind gets hung up on the the the language self
- 47:35compassion is, is really sympathy.
- 47:40But one of the things that happens when we we are
- 47:49conditioned is that we begin to limit the information that we
- 47:53allow ourselves to know about ourselves.
- 47:55And so I really think that self compassion or or compassion for
- 47:59self practice is about opening up and allowing all of the
- 48:04information about the self, allowing yourself to know
- 48:08everything about you. You know what are your what are
- 48:14your thought processes, what are your desires, what are what is
- 48:18it that that operates that makes the experience of you good and
- 48:26bad right. Sometimes we we we asked value
- 48:32on the the the quality of those processes which is largely
- 48:36related to our conditioning. And so it it really does produce
- 48:41these insights into into the nature of our experience.
- 48:47You might say that shame was one of those experiences but how is
- 48:51that? Is that the experience of shame
- 48:55arising around certain things, actually what it is that you
- 48:59feel? Or is it actually the response
- 49:03to the conditions of your earlier life that have cast
- 49:07those particular desires, their thoughts in that That way you
- 49:13know if you were to use an attachment to reference,
- 49:16dismissing people's suppressed awareness of their emotions as
- 49:20the primary way of regulating themselves and so with
- 49:23compassion practice, what you would be doing is opening a
- 49:27space where you are allowed to have those experiences of
- 49:30emotion. So everybody's conditioning is
- 49:33different and and the the process of filtering or
- 49:36restricting what's knowable about yourself differs quite a
- 49:40bit depending on your experience.
- 49:42And so really what this is, is this opening to allow all of
- 49:47that information, everything that you can know about yourself
- 49:51into a conscious experience of it, which is actually very
- 49:56freeing. It doesn't mean, of course that
- 49:57you have to act on every thought that you have.
- 50:02You probably wouldn't want that but but to know.
- 50:06Because if you don't allow yourself to know, it's still
- 50:09operational. Because the unis the Christian
- 50:13is is unconscious and all of those decisions are already made
- 50:17in that unconscious process. And if you simply don't allow
- 50:19the information consciously, you can't really understand why you
- 50:23act in the way that you do, why you respond in the way that you.
- 50:27So that compassion for self practice is to open up and hold
- 50:31the whole thing so that you have the capacity to understand how
- 50:37you've made reality. That's really what we're trying
- 50:39to get. ATI just made this up.
- 50:41Why did I make it up like this? And if you don't let yourself in
- 50:46on it, then I just made this up and I can't understand my
- 50:50reaction to this because I don't have, I'm not allowing myself to
- 50:54know what the meaning is. That's what we're trying to do.
- 51:01Great. I think, I mean, I was having
- 51:07the experience of like, I I I was wondering if I was
- 51:13emotionally regulating by, like getting sleepy, 'cause I found
- 51:18myself starting really sleepy and and as I, as the practice
- 51:21went on, I it actually that really went away.
- 51:27And I was like, oh, I wonder if I like tuning into some emotion
- 51:31that's maybe difficult or something, instead of going to
- 51:38sleep, which doesn't seem like a conscious process.
- 51:42That is one of the great defenses, right?
- 51:47OK. Yeah.
- 51:49Well, thanks. Yeah, we want to get to that
- 51:51place where we don't have to defend ourselves from ourselves.
- 51:58Would be nice. Thank you for coming.
- 52:02I really appreciate your practice.
- 52:04I think it's important Ioffer the teaching freely, but I do
- 52:09hope if you're resourced and you can that you'll make a a
- 52:12donation. There's a link on the website.
- 52:15I'm not actually even sure where it is, but I think there's a
- 52:18donate button there somewhere. The other thing you might
- 52:22consider on the website is my great passion, my great
- 52:27exploration in life is photographs.
- 52:30And so I added that to the site as a discussion of exploration,
- 52:36which I think is an important thing.
- 52:38I don't think you'd necessarily need to make photographs, but I
- 52:41think that that we really, if we haven't been supported in our
- 52:48primary exploration, we don't do enough of it.
- 52:51And so the idea then is to understand what that the nature
- 52:55of primary exploration is and then to go do it because that's
- 53:00the thing that propels us through this human condition.
- 53:04And if we don't do it enough, the just the difficulty of it,
- 53:08particularly as you age becomes greater and greater and then
- 53:12then you have a tendency to withdraw more than rather than
- 53:17engage. Thank you.
- 53:20We'll see you soon, I hope. Bye.