Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #73🎙️ |Public Inquiry Archaeological Mitigation Week Beginning 2nd June 2026 Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:06Unknown: I confess, I had to force myself to sit down this
- 0:09evening and start to write the podcast before every memory of
- 0:13today drifted off into a place never to be retrieved,
- 0:17exacerbated by badly scribbled notes equally irretrievable.
- 0:23There were many elements to today's public inquiry, with
- 0:25some surprising twists and turns along the way. First up, a
- 0:30heartfelt thank you to the Earth Mamas, whose voices led us into
- 0:35the public inquiry. There was something incredibly powerful
- 0:39about seeing so many people show up, sing out, and remind
- 0:44everyone why this fight matters.
- 0:46The
- 0:46passion, solidarity, and soul that came through from you, the
- 0:50singers, was something quite special. Thanks to all of you
- 0:55for coming along, for your support, for your song, for your
- 0:59listening, and for giving your time and energy to protecting
- 1:03the spurns. Every voice matters, every act of support matters,
- 1:09and together we're helping to keep this issue visible and
- 1:12impossible to ignore.
- 1:17Now, now. Hog my head in Saurabh, we know Ning Lega Haga.
- 1:55Now, what else? I must not have been paying attention today, or
- 2:00perhaps I was simply tired. Instead of the usual 20 pages of
- 2:04notes, I've only got five this evening, not on top of my game
- 2:08or something. Topics today included peatlands and
- 2:13subsurface archaeology. First up, we were presented with a
- 2:19long and detailed and comprehensively of Dr. Jill
- 2:23Plunkett's accreditations and impressive academic
- 2:26achievements. I don't recall this level of detail happening
- 2:30with any of the other experts who had previously appeared on
- 2:34behalf of the applicant. Were they trying to ensure that
- 2:39nobody else in the room suffered from an inflated sense of their
- 2:42own intelligence, or maybe attempting to establish that Dr.
- 2:47Plunkett is in fact the cleverest person any of us are
- 2:50ever likely to encounter. That said, she set about in a
- 2:55business-like fashion rebutting the historic Environmental
- 2:58Department, hed previous arguments as to the presence or
- 3:03not of organic and stone archaeological remains in
- 3:06peatland, and by a dint of discussion arrived at the
- 3:11conclusion that the only thing we need to consider is the sub
- 3:14peat archaeology. Things that came to light during the course
- 3:18of the conversation were that only a small area the site had
- 3:22been assessed by Plunkett. She maintained that slopes are too
- 3:26steep for archaeological remains. This was quite amusing,
- 3:30given the number of archaeological remains that are
- 3:32on the sides of mountains in Ireland, and going on to say
- 3:36that there was less than one per cent chance of archaeological
- 3:39sites in the area. Later on, in the morning in the morning, Dr.
- 3:43Gormley from HED basically demolished Plunkett's arguments,
- 3:48saying that the area had not been subject to a detailed
- 3:51archaeological investigation, saying it was a desktop review,
- 3:57where, as Dr. Plunkett visited the area, she did not walk the
- 4:01site that developments will change the hydrological
- 4:06environment, and that organic remains will not survive
- 4:10hydrological fluctuations. She spoke about additional possible
- 4:15fracturing of the surrounding peat due to the volume of peat
- 4:20to be removed, she criticised the proposed mitigation for the
- 4:24peat, i.e. keeping it wet in order to reuse it, and that the
- 4:29archaeological records are expected to be skewed because of
- 4:32this peat removal. What puzzled us, the third parties, was not
- 4:39Dr. Plunkett's expertise, which was beyond question, but how a
- 4:43scholar so closely associated with the conservation of
- 4:46peatland archaeology arrives at conclusions that appear to sit
- 4:50comfortably alongside a major mining proposal, whether that
- 4:55reflects a different reading of the evidence or a narrow. Or
- 5:00professional remit, or a different philosophy of
- 5:03conservation, is perhaps one of the more interesting questions
- 5:07raised by today's proceedings. The next question that came up
- 5:13referenced the impact of the industrial incursion on the St.
- 5:16Mary's Church based in Ruski. He remarked that was too far away
- 5:20to have any impact, and then Mary Brawley raised the annoying
- 5:25little fact that the church had no foundations, and wanted to
- 5:28know if there was a neighbourhood notification, or
- 5:32indeed was the priest notified of the forementioned industrial
- 5:35blight. Beattie counsel for DFI didn't seem to be sure about
- 5:40this, and said he would get back to the commissioner. There was a
- 5:44fair amount of time spent discussing conditions attached
- 5:47to archaeology and power lines, yet whenever third parties
- 5:53sought stronger safeguards, the response from the applicants was
- 5:57generally some variation of not that condition. It's a curious
- 6:01process. Everyone spends hours debating conditions that would
- 6:05only come into play if the mind is approved, yet many of the
- 6:09people seeking those safeguards will have no influence over
- 6:14whether they are actually implemented in the years ahead,
- 6:18and that's the thing about conditions - they aren't the
- 6:21barrier to approval. They assume approval, and once you're
- 6:24discussing the conditions under which damage might occur, you've
- 6:28already moved a long way from the question of whether the nine
- 6:32should occur at all. After all, conditions don't stop a mine;
- 6:38they simply set the terms under which one proceeds, and lastly,
- 6:45for a few matters that remain stubbornly unresolved, at least
- 6:49in my mind, third parties have been under constant pressure to
- 6:53move things along, and significant timetable changes
- 6:57were introduced on the basis that time was running short.
- 7:01Those changes have real consequences, particularly for
- 7:04our expert witnesses who have arranged their lives around
- 7:07dates that now appear to be shifting beneath their feet.
- 7:12Yet, despite repeated requests for updates on the schedule, the
- 7:16answers remain a blunt no. No indication of where things
- 7:20stand, no clarity on what happens next, and no
- 7:23acknowledgment of the difficulties these changes
- 7:26create for those trying to participate. It's beginning to
- 7:30feel like a curious mix of hurry up and wait, urgency when it
- 7:35comes to limiting scrutiny, but far less urgency when it comes
- 7:39to keeping us participants informed one development that
- 7:44has left third parties feeling rather bruised is the decision
- 7:47to quietly retire certain topics on the grounds that they have
- 7:51been adequately covered. This raises an interesting question
- 7:57in a public inquiry. Who gets to decide when a subject has been
- 8:00sufficiently examined as the people whose lives, livelihoods,
- 8:05and communities may be affected, or is it simply a matter of
- 8:09keeping the timetable moving. As a pretend planning consultant, I
- 8:17might be tempted to submit the following entirely fictional
- 8:20statement of case matter, premature closure of
- 8:24inconvenient questions. Case for the objectors, certain issues
- 8:29remain unresolved. Case for the timetable. Yes, but have you
- 8:34considered the clock recommendation? The clock wins.
- 8:38Joking aside, all of these issues are complicated,
- 8:43contested, and important. That's exactly why we're here in the
- 8:46first place. The fact that they're difficult or time
- 8:49consuming to examine doesn't make them any less worthy of
- 8:52examination. There seems to be a curious logic at work here. A
- 8:57public inquiry appears to be in danger of becoming impatient
- 9:01with the public, and lastly, this evening one final
- 9:06observation I'd like to make, and I offer it in the spirit of
- 9:10constructive reflection rather than criticism. Public inquiry
- 9:15is not just about what is said, it's also about what's been
- 9:18communicated through tone, body language, small signals to tell
- 9:24people whether they are being heard. Now, I fully accept that
- 9:29some third parties can test the patience of even the most
- 9:32saintly amongst us. We are, after all, a passionate bunch,
- 9:38but there are moments when the size, the visible frustration,
- 9:42the facial expressions, and the general air of exasperation
- 9:46becomes part of the proceedings too. The difficulty is that
- 9:51these things are rarely directed at one individual. When they
- 9:55happen, everyone on the third party benches feels them. The
- 10:00message received, whether intended or not, is that public
- 10:04participation is something to be endured rather than welcomed. I
- 10:09suspect none of this is conscious. Most bias isn't, but
- 10:13it is
- 10:14worth remembering that respect is communicated in many ways,
- 10:17and impartiality is not only something that has to be
- 10:20practised. It also has to be seen to be practised for those
- 10:25of us who have given up our time to engage in this process. That
- 10:29distinction really matters. I think I better leave it here for
- 10:34now, as usual. Thanks for listening, and see you all
- 10:41soon. Hey.