Latest / The Vegan Report / Navigating the Left and Right Divide | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, this is TheVeganReport and my
- 0:04name is Sandro Ianni. I'm a PhD student in psychology
- 0:08at the University of Zurich in Switzerland. There
- 0:11I'm working with Professor Chris Hubwood at the
- 0:15Personality Psychology Lab. In today's episode
- 0:19I have the great pleasure to present some of
- 0:21the research I've conducted so far during my
- 0:24PhD. My research can be broadly summarized as
- 0:28studying the political psychology of sustainable
- 0:31plant -based food system change. What this means
- 0:35is that I'm taking a psychological perspective
- 0:38to look at the political factors that shape our
- 0:41journey towards a world where food production
- 0:44and consumption is more beneficial to humans,
- 0:47the environment and non -human animals. I've
- 0:51decided to structure this episode around several
- 0:54topics that guide my research and which are hopefully
- 0:58also highly relevant to you as listeners. Each
- 1:01part will feature some recently published or
- 1:05soon to be published work, so I will be able
- 1:08to share some fresh findings with you. My goal
- 1:11is to provide you with the big picture and the
- 1:15key research findings and to spare you some of
- 1:17the details. But for those who would like to
- 1:20take a deeper look I will share links to my papers
- 1:23which are all open access in the description
- 1:27of this episode. You can also find me on LinkedIn
- 1:30where I regularly post research updates or you
- 1:35can reach out to me via email. My contact information
- 1:39will also be mentioned in the description. And
- 1:42as a reminder you can find new episodes of this
- 1:46series every Wednesday on this podcast. It would
- 1:49be great if you could share this episode and
- 1:52the podcast with your community. Okay, so the
- 1:57first question I will be talking about today
- 1:59is what are some political challenges and opportunities
- 2:04for sustainable plant -based food system change?
- 2:07Here I will mainly talk about a study where we
- 2:11analyze large sets of public opinion data from
- 2:14Switzerland. The goal was to identify differences
- 2:19and similarities across the political spectrum
- 2:22when it comes to priorities around food system
- 2:25issues. So things like environmental protection,
- 2:30domestic food production or animal welfare. After
- 2:34that part I will cover another study where we
- 2:38looked at the political polarization around farm
- 2:41animal welfare across the entire European Union
- 2:45and the UK. Then the next question I'll be talking
- 2:51about today is what are some challenges and opportunities
- 2:56for the animal welfare movement in the current
- 2:58political context. This part will feature content
- 3:03from a recently published commentary article
- 3:06in FAIR, which is the journal on the psychology
- 3:11of human -animal intergroup relations. As a fourth
- 3:18topic, I will briefly talk about a study where
- 3:21we checked how communication shapes engagement
- 3:25with food system change advocacy across the political
- 3:29spectrum. And lastly I will share a quick outlook
- 3:33on some upcoming projects. As a short note before
- 3:40I start, in this episode I will often talk about
- 3:44differences across the left -right political
- 3:47spectrum and I want to highlight here that these
- 3:50statements will represent statistical trends
- 3:53and are meant to make findings more comprehensible.
- 3:57But of course political beliefs are complex and
- 4:00not all individuals with similar political orientations
- 4:04will hold identical opinions about the things
- 4:08I will talk about. So just keep that in mind.
- 4:15With that let's jump into the first question
- 4:18about political challenges and opportunities
- 4:20for sustainable food system change. I think it's
- 4:24safe to say that reforming established food systems
- 4:28brings a lot of challenges. Like in other areas,
- 4:32there are strong interest groups which tend to
- 4:34oppose more meaningful changes. And I won't talk
- 4:38so much about this aspect today. But often there
- 4:42is also, to some extent at least, some skepticism
- 4:46from the larger public. People might worry about
- 4:50what change will mean to them personally, so
- 4:52their living conditions, for their values and
- 4:56for the world they know. And as a psychologist
- 4:59I'm particularly interested in public opinions.
- 5:03In my view, if we want to make food systems more
- 5:06sustainable, we first need to understand what
- 5:09priorities and concerns people have. Otherwise,
- 5:13reforms could face backlash, which could mean
- 5:15significant setbacks for reforms that are actually
- 5:18very pressing. So in short, reforms must align
- 5:22with what people value. Now the challenge is
- 5:26that people are in many ways different from each
- 5:29other, also with respect to their values. A convenient,
- 5:35although not perfect way to approximate differences
- 5:38in values is to ask people about their position
- 5:41on the left -right political spectrum. From political
- 5:46psychology we know that there are certain values
- 5:48and worldviews that are, at least on average,
- 5:52more strongly endorsed on either side of the
- 5:54political spectrum. These broad values and worldviews
- 5:59are often quite useful to understand why people
- 6:01across the political spectrum hold different
- 6:04opinions on more concrete topics. Some researchers
- 6:09have already attempted to make a link between
- 6:12political orientation and food system issues,
- 6:15most prominently regarding environmental and
- 6:19climate protection. In the first paper I want
- 6:23to present today titled political orientation
- 6:25and attitudes about agricultural reforms around
- 6:29sustainability. I've examined relationships between
- 6:34political orientation and various food system
- 6:37issues in Switzerland. This project was realized
- 6:41together with my supervisor Chris Hopewood and
- 6:44two researchers from the Swiss Competence Center
- 6:47for Agricultural Research. I'm Janine Ammann
- 6:51and Judith Irek. For the project we used existing
- 6:57public opinion data from our collaborators and
- 7:01also data from post -vote surveys of recent popular
- 7:05initiatives around agricultural policies. So
- 7:09for some context in Switzerland citizens can
- 7:13regularly vote on policy proposals as a form
- 7:17of direct democracy. And for this project we
- 7:20were interested in three separate proposals that
- 7:24would have brought substantial changes to the
- 7:28Swiss food system. Two were primarily focused
- 7:33on promoting the environment. That is, one was
- 7:36an initiative on biodiversity promotion. and
- 7:40the other was the so -called drinking water initiative.
- 7:45So their major focus was to reduce the use of
- 7:48chemicals in agriculture. And the third initiative
- 7:52was about animal welfare and basically demanded
- 7:55that the abolishment of vector farming in Switzerland.
- 8:01All three initiatives were rejected by roughly
- 8:0460 percent of voters. I would say that these
- 8:09cases nicely highlight the importance of public
- 8:12opinions for food system reforms, particularly
- 8:16in Switzerland with its rather distinct political
- 8:19system. But I think it is also safe to say that
- 8:22in other kinds of democracies, such reforms would
- 8:26face small chances to pass or even get onto the
- 8:29political agenda if a majority of voters oppose
- 8:34them. But now back to the study. So we analyzed
- 8:39the data of almost 10 ,000 Swiss residents who
- 8:43provided information about their political views
- 8:46on a common left -right self -placement scale.
- 8:51For some of them there was also data on how they
- 8:54rated the importance of different criteria that
- 8:58might matter when one buys food and The same
- 9:02people also provided ratings on the personal
- 9:04importance of different food policy issues. So
- 9:09in other words, we had information about people's
- 9:12priorities as consumers and voters. And many
- 9:17of these assessed shopping criteria and political
- 9:22policy issues were very similar. So for instance,
- 9:26they included animal welfare, various environmental
- 9:30issues, questions about food prices or social
- 9:34standards in food production. And what we then
- 9:39did is we tested the association between political
- 9:42orientation and those importance ratings. The
- 9:49results, or the results, the main results at
- 9:52least suggested that among people with more political
- 9:56left orientation all environmental goals were
- 10:00prioritized. So that means that issues like biodiversity,
- 10:05reducing plant protection products or the use
- 10:08of plant protection products, nutrient surpluses
- 10:12and particularly reducing greenhouse gas emissions
- 10:16from food production were given more importance
- 10:20on the left. And this aligns with a lot of previous
- 10:24research. which tends to show that most environmental
- 10:28issues tend to be quite polarized today. As we
- 10:35describe in the paper, some of this research
- 10:38argues that this difference could be due to how
- 10:41people on the left versus right tend to assign
- 10:44moral concerns differently. But there's also
- 10:48some evidence that at least part of this division
- 10:53might come from how environmental issues are
- 10:56discussed by political parties and the media.
- 11:02With people on the political right, on the other
- 11:05hand, we found that they valued increasing domestic
- 11:09food production more strongly and also showed
- 11:13stronger commitments to meat consumption. The
- 11:17second point is already already relatively common
- 11:22finding in research but in our study we expanded
- 11:26this finding in some way by looking also at two
- 11:29more indirect indicators of meat attachment.
- 11:33The way we did this is a bit more complex so
- 11:35I recommend checking the paper if you are interested
- 11:39in this. Concerning the finding on domestic food
- 11:44production there was actually less prior research
- 11:48on this particular topic. However, there were
- 11:52good reasons to expect this association because
- 11:55of how a strong domestic food sector could promote
- 11:59more typically conservative values. Another insight
- 12:05from the study is that people with more right
- 12:08-leaning orientations tended to be less willing
- 12:12to compromise on farmers income and low food
- 12:16prices for environmental policy goals. Here I
- 12:21should note that we were able to examine individuals
- 12:24willingness to compromise on certain issues by
- 12:28having questions where people had to make decisions
- 12:33in sort of a trade -off scenario. So basically
- 12:37people had to say how they would weigh the importance
- 12:41of two contrasting policy goals. And this measure
- 12:46was particularly interesting because in reality
- 12:48it is oftentimes difficult to give equal weight
- 12:52to all issues at once. Now concerning farmed
- 12:58animal welfare, we found that even though importance
- 13:01ratings were slightly higher on the left, Concerns
- 13:06were also quite high on the right. For example,
- 13:09among people on the right, there was a tendency
- 13:12to weigh animal welfare equally to domestic food
- 13:15production, protecting farmers' incomes and low
- 13:19food prices. Interestingly, it turned out that
- 13:24animal welfare was less of a polarizing issue
- 13:28than environmental protection. We found that
- 13:34even with the post -vote survey data, the effect
- 13:39of political orientation on the likelihood of
- 13:42rejecting the factory farming initiative was
- 13:45smaller than for both environmentally focused
- 13:48initiatives. Later in this episode I will talk
- 13:53about the relationship between political orientation
- 13:56and animal welfare in more detail. A final observation
- 14:01from this study I wanted to share with you is
- 14:04that people on the left and right did not differ
- 14:07in how important foods taste, price and healthiness
- 14:10was to them. So taken together I think our study
- 14:15provides some important insight into how the
- 14:18chances for sustainable food system reforms could
- 14:21be improved. I think a pragmatic pragmatic way
- 14:25forward needs to be one where reforms will respect
- 14:29the priorities of both sides of the political
- 14:31spectrum and this could be done by forming packages
- 14:36of policy instruments that attempt to balance
- 14:39concerns for environmental protection on the
- 14:43one hand as well as domestic production, farmers
- 14:47income and food prices on the other side. Of
- 14:52course this might be more challenging than pursuing
- 14:54a one -sided focus, but I think ultimately that
- 14:59forming broader coalitions and ensuring wider
- 15:02public support will be more successful and a
- 15:05more feasible long -term strategy. Fortunately
- 15:10there were also certain things where disagreements
- 15:13were smaller or even absent. So overall promoting
- 15:18a food system that produces affordable tasty
- 15:21and healthy food is definitely a good idea. And
- 15:25as our study also showed there tends to be more
- 15:28of a political consensus around animal welfare
- 15:32in Switzerland. In the next section I will share
- 15:36some data on these specific issues for the broader
- 15:39European context. But before I do that, as a
- 15:45final note to the study, I wanted to mention
- 15:48that we also looked at people's trust in farmers
- 15:51and in environmental and animal welfare advocacy
- 15:55organizations, and we also analyzed support for
- 15:59the main campaign arguments from those three
- 16:02initiatives. So if this kind of stuff is interesting
- 16:05and relevant for you, feel free to check out
- 16:07the paper. Let's move on to the second question
- 16:13of today's episode, which is about how political
- 16:16orientation relates to concerns for farm animal
- 16:20welfare across countries from the European Union
- 16:23and the UK. As I mentioned earlier, in Switzerland
- 16:27we found that there was a relatively small association
- 16:31between more left political orientation and concerns
- 16:35for animal welfare. This is actually a quite
- 16:39common finding in research, but so far most studies
- 16:43have been conducted with people from North America
- 16:46or Northwestern Europe. Because this pattern
- 16:50tends to be quite consistent, there has been
- 16:53some theorizing about a possible connection between
- 16:56more typical left -wing values and animal welfare
- 17:00concerns. Broadly summarized, the arguments are
- 17:04that people on the left are often more in favor
- 17:07of expanding moral concerns and are concerned
- 17:10with establishing equality, whereas on the right
- 17:14there is a stronger desire for respecting traditions
- 17:16and preserving the status quo. Now, as with prioritizing
- 17:21climate goals, it is also likely that some of
- 17:25these differences are due to context effects.
- 17:28This is why it is important to look at a more
- 17:32diverse set of countries and to compare differences
- 17:35across time. And for those reasons we conducted
- 17:39a study on the political polarization of farm
- 17:43animal welfare across the entire EU, so including
- 17:47many countries where there has been no research
- 17:50on this topic before. In this study, which is
- 17:54not published yet, we used existing data from
- 17:57the Eurobarometer survey where questions about
- 18:01farm animal welfare were asked. So those surveys
- 18:05are conducted on behalf of the European Union
- 18:08with representative samples from each member
- 18:11state. There were three surveys which asked the
- 18:17same questions about farm animal welfare concerns,
- 18:20one in 2006, one in 2015, and one in 2023. For
- 18:27the UK we only had the data for the first two
- 18:30waves because of Brexit. Simply put, we then
- 18:34tested how self -reported left -right political
- 18:37orientation was correlated with reported concerns
- 18:42for farm animal welfare. There were multiple
- 18:46questions on this topic, each with a somewhat
- 18:49different focus. We analyzed those separately
- 18:53but I will focus on the two most central questions
- 18:56where results were very similar. That is one
- 19:00asked about the personal importance of farm animal
- 19:03welfare and the other question asked about whether
- 19:06one believes that farm animal welfare needs to
- 19:09be improved in one's country. Our results indicated
- 19:15that on average across all countries and time
- 19:18points There was a very small association in
- 19:22the direction of stronger concerns with more
- 19:24left political orientation. There was also not
- 19:28much evidence that the average association changed
- 19:31between 2006 and 2023. However, we found important
- 19:37variation across countries. I won't go into details
- 19:40for specific countries, but overall the tendency
- 19:44was that the association with left orientation
- 19:47was stronger in countries from northwestern Europe
- 19:51compared to countries from southern Europe and
- 19:55particularly eastern Europe. In addition, our
- 19:59analysis suggested that between 2006 and 2023
- 20:03this association got stronger primarily in northwestern
- 20:08European countries. So all together these patterns
- 20:12suggest that differences in country context might
- 20:16matter. And to explore this a bit more, we also
- 20:20tested whether two kinds of context factors could
- 20:23help to explain our findings. Firstly, we took
- 20:27information about each country's level of economic
- 20:31and social development at each time point. Specifically,
- 20:36we used the UN's Human Development Index. Secondly,
- 20:40we tried to gather information about how political
- 20:43parties within each country politicized animal
- 20:46welfare. For that we downloaded parties, election
- 20:50manifestos and coded how often they mentioned
- 20:54animal welfare issues. I should note here that
- 20:57we did not code how exactly they talked about
- 21:00animal welfare, just the frequency, but our analysis
- 21:05was restricted on content that had a pro -animal
- 21:08welfare focus, so the general direction was clear.
- 21:12The paper will provide more details on how this
- 21:15indicator was created. Now, across countries
- 21:19and our free time points there was a strong positive
- 21:24correlation between the development index and
- 21:28the party politicization of animal welfare. So
- 21:32in more developed countries parties also tended
- 21:35to mention this issue more frequently. We also
- 21:39found that overall left -oriented political parties
- 21:43tended to highlight animal welfare more often,
- 21:46especially those parties from the green party
- 21:50family. We were able to test this because the
- 21:53party manifesto data also provided an indicator
- 21:57of parties' left -right positioning. Now importantly,
- 22:02both context factors also roughly aligned with
- 22:06geographic regions, and help to statistically
- 22:09explain the polarization pattern among the general
- 22:13population. So the higher the development index
- 22:17and the more parties mentioned animal welfare,
- 22:21the more there was an association between left
- 22:24political orientation and farm animal welfare
- 22:27concerns. At this point I should highlight that
- 22:31this finding is correlational and we could not
- 22:35test these things in a causal way. In the paper
- 22:39we provide some theoretical reasoning for our
- 22:42results. Essentially we hypothesize that higher
- 22:47country development could promote an expansion
- 22:51of moral concerns for animals, particularly among
- 22:56progressives. And political parties mostly those
- 23:00on the left, might then become more likely to
- 23:03consider this issue for their political agenda.
- 23:07This could increase the saliency of the topic
- 23:10in political debates and parties might also start
- 23:13to position themselves differently on this issue.
- 23:17All of this could lead ultimately to stronger
- 23:21issue polarization among the public. However,
- 23:25we cannot rule out that other things like differences
- 23:28in political institutions are involved. So taken
- 23:32together, this study provides some nuance to
- 23:36the relationship between political orientation
- 23:38and concerns for farm animals. The role of context
- 23:44might be bigger than we thought. Like with our
- 23:49study in Switzerland, it is also important to
- 23:52point out that in an absolute sense, reported
- 23:55concerns for animals were quite high across the
- 23:58political spectrum. So overall it seems more
- 24:01that in certain countries there is a relatively
- 24:05strong desire among people on the left for more
- 24:08far -reaching reforms. And this brings me to
- 24:12the next question I wanted to talk about. But
- 24:16before that, quick reminder that if you would
- 24:19like to read this paper when it's published,
- 24:21I recommend following me on LinkedIn or setting
- 24:24up a Google Alert. As a third topic of this episode,
- 24:31I'm going to talk about political challenges
- 24:33and opportunities for the animal welfare movement.
- 24:37This part is largely based on a commentary piece
- 24:41that I wrote together with Dylan de Gourville
- 24:43and Seda Rice, which was recently published in
- 24:46the Fair Journal. The starting point for this
- 24:49article is the following question. How could
- 24:52the animal welfare movement, which tends to be
- 24:56rather left progressive, thrive in a world where
- 24:59a lot of issues are politically polarized and
- 25:03also where the public, parliaments and governments
- 25:06have become more conservatively minded in many
- 25:09places in the world. Like with other social movements
- 25:13before, this kind of question can spark very
- 25:16different opinions. Some people might think that
- 25:19this context asks for more inclusive advocacy
- 25:23and more openness for compromises. Others might
- 25:28be hesitant to accept these ideas, either for
- 25:32pragmatic or principled reasons. For our commentary
- 25:36we first gathered some of the common arguments
- 25:39for both positions. Overall those arguments were
- 25:42usually quite compelling and plausible. However,
- 25:46they were also rather speculative since research
- 25:50is somewhat missing in this area. In the second
- 25:54part of this article we then describe ways in
- 25:58which research could help to find more robust
- 26:00answers. Our article is quite compact and only
- 26:04about three pages long, so it's a short read.
- 26:07But here are the main points. First, there are
- 26:13pragmatic reasons for why advocacy might need
- 26:15to become more politically inclusive. To pass
- 26:19animal welfare policies, it is often essential
- 26:23that there is a broader coalition of voters and
- 26:26or politicians who support them. There are good
- 26:30examples of this point relating to animal welfare,
- 26:34but also if we look at other instances of social
- 26:38reforms. Similarly, if caring about animal welfare
- 26:45becomes something that people generally perceive
- 26:49as left -wing, it could make the issue unnecessarily
- 26:53divisive. where people engage with the topic
- 26:57more from an us versus them perspective. And
- 27:01such dynamics might be very hard to reverse later.
- 27:05It can also be argued that the foundation for
- 27:08more inclusive advocacy is already somewhat given.
- 27:12As I described earlier, the differences across
- 27:16the political spectrum are often not that large
- 27:19and especially if one compares those to other
- 27:22debated topics. The real question might not be
- 27:26so much about whether one wants animal welfare
- 27:30improvements, but how reforms should look like
- 27:34and how far they should go. Now this last point
- 27:39might be a source of possible tension within
- 27:41movements. If reaching out to people with different
- 27:45values means that one has to adapt demands and
- 27:48messages to match those values, some advocates
- 27:52might feel like they're not authentic. In addition,
- 27:56it could mean that for the sake of reducing friction,
- 28:02it becomes necessary to stay focused on a single,
- 28:05well -defined issue, whereas other important
- 28:08but potentially polarizing issues need to be
- 28:11avoided. This could, for example, concern things
- 28:16like climate change or social justice issues.
- 28:20but often different movements are important allies
- 28:23for each other's causes. So the question is whether
- 28:27taking this path is worth the risk of potentially
- 28:30hurting cross -movement collaborations. The last
- 28:35point we raise in the argument section is that
- 28:39supporting advocacy which comes from people who
- 28:42actually identify as conservatives might be more
- 28:46desirable. For them it would be more natural
- 28:50to promote animal welfare as a right of center
- 28:53issue and such advocacy would be more credible
- 28:58on authentic. So an idea could be to support
- 29:01movement building within more conservatively
- 29:05minded organizations. We then go on in the article
- 29:10with some ideas for future research related to
- 29:13these arguments. This section is mostly targeted
- 29:16at people working in the field either from academia
- 29:19or NGOs so I therefore won't discuss these points
- 29:24here but some things relate quite closely to
- 29:27what I've talked about so far in this episode.
- 29:31In the end of course it's the members of the
- 29:33animal welfare movement who have to decide how
- 29:36these different arguments and the corresponding
- 29:39research should be weighted and used. Okay, let's
- 29:46move on to the last research findings of today.
- 29:50Here I will talk about an idea that has become
- 29:53quite popular in psychological research over
- 29:56the last couple of years and which basically
- 29:59aims to reduce polarization around disputed topics.
- 30:03It is a communication approach called moral reframing.
- 30:07The simple idea is that if you want to make advocacy
- 30:11for a certain topic more convincing to people
- 30:14with different moral convictions, you need to
- 30:17match your message content to the values of these
- 30:20different groups. Or in other words you need
- 30:23to use the right moral framing for your audience.
- 30:28Based on my impression of the literature, there
- 30:31is mixed evidence for the effectiveness of this
- 30:33approach. It seems like it's often not as simple
- 30:37as that and we probably need more research to
- 30:40better understand why it works in some cases
- 30:43and fails in others. The study I want to present
- 30:48is an application of this moral reframing approach
- 30:51to the advocacy for more plant -based food systems.
- 30:55The goal wasn't to promote individual diet change
- 30:59but to argue for the benefits of shifting the
- 31:03larger food system. To do this we first picked
- 31:06five general issues where a more plant -based
- 31:09food system would bring benefits. Those were
- 31:13animal welfare, environmental protection, food
- 31:16security, public health and something we called
- 31:19inconsistency in society. We then created two
- 31:25message versions for each issue. One that was
- 31:28framed in values more associated with the political
- 31:32left and one with values from the right. For
- 31:36the values we followed the common psychological
- 31:39framework and we pre -tested the messages to
- 31:41make sure the different values were explicit
- 31:44enough. Next we conducted our first study where
- 31:50people from Switzerland rated those messages
- 31:53on how convincing they find them. Also they were
- 31:57asked about their political orientation. After
- 32:01this first study we conducted a second one which
- 32:05was very similar but for that one we created
- 32:08new message types where we separated two important
- 32:14elements of the original messages. One type of
- 32:18message only included the main moral appeal of
- 32:22the originals excluding the actual reasoned arguments.
- 32:27The other message type included only the reasoned
- 32:30arguments, so there we removed all parts that
- 32:34made explicit appeals to moral values. We did
- 32:38this because most research on moral reframing
- 32:42didn't compare morally framed messages to messages
- 32:46where one only uses purely reasoning based messages.
- 32:51and this is a problem because in some cases it
- 32:54might be counterproductive to moralize an issue.
- 33:00Now after conducting both studies we tested a
- 33:03total of 32 messages which talked about one of
- 33:08the five general issues use left or right framings
- 33:12and a varied message type so like the moral framing
- 33:16plus reasoning only moral framing or the only
- 33:21recent arguments messages. All were rated on
- 33:25the same evaluation scale. For the results I
- 33:31focus here on the big picture. Our paper which
- 33:35is not published yet will include an online tool
- 33:37where one can find detailed comparison of individual
- 33:41messages. What we found overall is that messages
- 33:46which matched people's values were indeed more
- 33:49convincing than those which mismatched people's
- 33:53values. And this was especially the case for
- 33:56people on the political left. So this means that
- 34:00left value framed messages were more appealing
- 34:03to those people than right value framed messages.
- 34:08However, messages which only used reason and
- 34:13reasoned arguments were actually even more appealing
- 34:16to people on the left and for people on the right
- 34:19the reasoning only messages were usually as strong
- 34:23as those messages which used or which also included
- 34:27right moral framing so at least in the context
- 34:31of our study it seems like there is no real benefit
- 34:35of framing messages in moral terms and it would
- 34:39be better overall to stick to more reasoning
- 34:42based messages. Importantly we also found that
- 34:46the issue focus of messages made a considerable
- 34:51difference. So environmental protection messages
- 34:55were strongly appealing on the left but not so
- 34:58much among the right. Conversely, domestic food
- 35:04security messages were particularly strong on
- 35:07the right, but not so much on the left, at least
- 35:10compared to other topics. The issue that was
- 35:14the strongest across the political spectrum was
- 35:18animal welfare. Specifically, messages specifically
- 35:23messages that had a harm -based focus but not
- 35:28those which promoted more of an animal rights
- 35:31appeal. I think it is also quite interesting
- 35:37that the way these issues related to political
- 35:40orientation in this study nicely replicate what
- 35:44we found in the larger survey study with people
- 35:48from Switzerland that I presented at the beginning
- 35:50of this episode. So, taken together, our messaging
- 35:56study makes a case for using more well -reasoned,
- 36:00non -moralizing animal welfare arguments to promote
- 36:03plant -based food systems across the political
- 36:06spectrum. However, more research would be important
- 36:11to check the robustness of our findings, especially
- 36:14studies in more applied settings or in other
- 36:17countries. As a final point I wanted to share
- 36:23a short outlook on some future projects. A major
- 36:27focus for my next studies will be about understanding
- 36:31what shapes support for plant -based policies,
- 36:35so policy measures that would promote a more
- 36:37plant -based food system. This will include the
- 36:41role of individual differences like political
- 36:43beliefs but also much more than that. In general,
- 36:47I think that there is a large research gap in
- 36:50how we can promote more systemic solutions compared
- 36:54to individual behavior change interventions and
- 36:57studying policy support is an important pathway
- 37:01to do this. Other than that, we are also looking
- 37:05into how people's concerns about animals could
- 37:09be measured in a more valid and reliable way.
- 37:12Much of the research so far had to rely on somewhat
- 37:17limited assessment tools which might prevent
- 37:20us from uncovering individual differences in
- 37:23more precise and informative ways. And with that
- 37:27we've reached the end of today's episode. Before
- 37:31I stop I would like to quickly bring your attention
- 37:34to the amazing work that my colleagues are doing.
- 37:37You should definitely check out the other research
- 37:40of our team in Zurich. You will find the link
- 37:43to our group website in the description. That's
- 37:47all from me. Thank you very much for listening.
- 37:50I appreciate your interest and feel free to share
- 37:53this episode with those who might be interested
- 37:55in today's topic. Thank you.