Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Sunk Cost Fallacy Traps You in Bad Work Projects
Transcript
- Lucas: You've been working on a project for nine months. It's not going well. Your gut says it's time to pull the plug, but then that voice in your head says, 'I've already put in nine months — if I quit now, it's all wasted.' Luna: Oh, that voice is loud. I've definitely heard it. And I think most of us have. Lucas: That voice is the sunk cost fallacy in action. And it's one of the most expensive cognitive biases in the workplace. Today I want to look at a specific case — a mid-level marketing manager at a Fortune 500 consumer goods company who spent eighteen months on a campaign that was clearly dying by month six. Luna: Eighteen months? That's a long time to keep pushing on something that's not working. What was the product? Lucas: It was a new line of plant-based cleaning products. The research was solid, the timing felt right, but the launch just didn't land. Early sales were disappointing, retailer feedback was lukewarm, and the internal metrics were trending red by the second quarter. But the manager had already poured in her reputation, her team's hours, a big chunk of the annual marketing budget. And her leadership wasn't asking hard questions — they were just saying 'keep going.' Luna: And she stayed with it. Which, honestly, I get. Walking away feels like admitting failure. And if you're the one who championed the project, it's your baby. Lucas: Exactly. There's a personal identity investment too. But this is where the sunk cost fallacy does its real damage — it keeps you from reallocating time, money, and attention to something that actually works. A 2025 survey from Harvard Business Review found that 62 percent of professionals admitted to continuing a project primarily because of the time they'd already invested. Not because of future potential. Because of past effort. Luna: Sixty-two percent. That's huge. And that's just the people willing to admit it. I bet the real number is higher. Lucas: Probably. And look, this applies way beyond one marketing campaign. It applies to staying in a job that's clearly not a fit. It applies to sticking with a software platform your company has outgrown. It applies to holding onto a stock that's been tanking for two years. Luna: And if we've helped you think through a career move or decision like that — whether to stay or walk away — it's worth mentioning that this show stays ad-free because of listeners who chip in. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Yeah, it really does make a difference. So back to that marketing manager. What finally got her to stop? An outside consultant came in, did a zero-based review of the portfolio, and asked a simple question: 'If you had zero time invested in this project today, would you start it from scratch?' She said no. And that was the moment. Luna: That's such a powerful frame. 'The outsider test.' If someone else came in with no history, would they greenlight this? Usually the answer is no. Lucas: Right. And once she had permission to see it that way, she killed the project. Reassigned the team to a different initiative that ended up being one of the company's better performers that year. But she told me later that the hardest part wasn't the decision itself — it was the two months of agonizing before the consultant arrived. She knew. She just needed an external voice to say what she already knew. Luna: That's the trap, isn't it? We know internally, but we don't trust that knowledge because we're too close. There's a personal cost to admitting you were wrong. It feels like you're admitting you wasted time. Lucas: And that's the fallacy's core deception. Past time is gone either way. The only thing that matters is what you do with the time you have now. That's the economic definition — sunk costs are irrecoverable. They shouldn't factor into future decisions. But emotionally, they dominate. Luna: I want to bring in another example. A friend of mine — software engineer — stayed at a startup two years longer than he wanted to because he was waiting for his equity to vest. He hated the work, the culture was toxic, but he kept telling himself 'I've already put in three years. If I leave now, I lose the stock.' Lucas: Classic golden handcuffs. And in that case, the sunk cost isn't just time — it's potential money. But here's the thing: that unvested equity is future money, not past money. The three years are gone. The decision is whether the next two years of misery are worth whatever the equity might be worth. Luna: In his case, it wasn't. He left, took a pay cut at a different company, and six months later said it was the best decision he'd made in years. The equity he gave up? The startup eventually got acquired, but his shares would have been wiped out in the deal structure anyway. So he would have gotten nothing. Lucas: That happens more often than people realize. The sunk cost fallacy makes us overvalue what we're leaving behind and undervalue the opportunity cost of staying. One of the best tools I've seen to counter this is something called a 'pre-commitment review gate.' Luna: What does that look like? Lucas: At the start of a project, you and your team agree on specific checkpoints — say, at month three and month six — where you'll review progress against a set of predetermined criteria. And here's the key: the criteria are set before you're emotionally invested. So when you hit month six and the numbers are red, you don't have to debate. The gate is closed. You kill it automatically unless someone makes a compelling case to override. Luna: That removes the personal from the decision. It's not 'I'm killing my project.' It's 'the process says we stop.' That's smart. Lucas: Exactly. And it works because it outsources the hard decision to a rule you made when you were rational. Amazon uses a version of this with their 'working backwards' process — they write the press release before they start. If they can't write a compelling press release about a future launch, they don't start the project. That's a pre-commitment gate at the idea stage. Luna: What about for individuals, not teams? If you're by yourself trying to decide whether to quit a project or a job? Lucas: I'd recommend the 'outsider test' that came up earlier. But do it formally. Write down the current situation as if you were describing it to a friend. Then ask: if this friend were in the same situation, what would you advise them? That distance helps you separate from the sunk cost. Another tactic is to ask yourself, 'If I had to start over today, what would I do?' And then do that thing. Luna: It's almost like you're giving yourself permission to be a rational advisor to yourself. Which is harder than it sounds because we're terrible at being objective about our own lives. Lucas: We are. And that's why it helps to have an actual person in that role. A mentor, a coach, a trusted colleague who has no skin in the game. The marketing manager I mentioned — she now has a rule that any project she's running for more than six months gets a mandatory external review. Not because she doesn't trust herself, but because she knows how easy it is to get attached. Luna: I think that's a great takeaway. Set the rules when you're clear-headed, and then follow them when you're not. That's a defense against the sunk cost fallacy. Lucas: And the other piece is to reframe how you think about past effort. Instead of seeing it as something you have to 'get value out of,' see it as learning. The eighteen months on that doomed campaign — it wasn't wasted. The manager learned a ton about what doesn't work in that category. She took those insights to her next role and succeeded faster because of them. Luna: So the effort has value even if the project doesn't. That's a much healthier way to look at it. Lucas: Exactly. The money is gone. The time is gone. But the knowledge isn't. And that knowledge has future value. The sunk cost fallacy tricks you into thinking the only way to validate past effort is to continue. But you can validate it by learning and moving on. That's the real win. Luna: Alright, I'm going to start using the outsider test this week. I have a small project that's been dragging on for longer than it should. I think I know the answer. Lucas: I'd be curious to hear how it goes. And for everyone else listening — if there's a project or role you've been hesitating to walk away from, try the test. You might surprise yourself.