Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Brad Edwards And His Affidavit In Support Of Epstein Related Transparency By The DOJ (Part 4)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're picking up where we
- 0:06left off with Brad Edwards and his cvra Affi David
- 0:14RFP number eighteen asked for information about why the US
- 0:17Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida was conflicted
- 0:21out of handling various issues related to the Epstein case.
- 0:24This information is needed to show why the victims did
- 0:28not receive proper notification about the NPA that the office
- 0:32negotiated with Epstein. It appears that the conflict of interest
- 0:36that has been recognized may have had to do with
- 0:38the office's treatment of the victims. Moreover, in its production
- 0:42of documents and in follow up correspondence, the US Attorney's
- 0:46Office for the Southern District of Florida has indicated that
- 0:49there are no responsive documents being held by the US
- 0:52Attorney's Office in the other district that is handling conflict matters.
- 0:57It appears that this other office in the Middle District
- 1:00of Florida. This appears to be improbable because the conflict
- 1:04matters would presumably generate many documents covered by the victim's
- 1:08discovery requests, including the OPR investigative file. Accordingly, the conflict
- 1:14matter is highly relevant to determining whether the U S
- 1:17Attorney's Office has provided complete production to the victims. A
- 1:21conflict of interest would also be highly relevant to the
- 1:24motivations of the government attorneys throughout the handling of the
- 1:28Epstein case RFP number nineteen. As for information supporting allegations
- 1:33made in March of twenty eleven by former US Attorney
- 1:37Alexandra Acosta, he sent a three page letter to the
- 1:41news media in which he claimed that when government attorneys
- 1:45began investigating Epstein, Epstein launched a year long assault on
- 1:48the prosecution and prosecutors. This information is needed to explain
- 1:53why the US Attorney's Office would have withheld notifications from
- 1:56victims about the NPA. If prosecutors were being assaulted, as
- 2:00a Costa has said they were, then they would have
- 2:04reason to disregard their obligations to crime victims. In addition,
- 2:08this would show improper behavior by Epstein, which would be
- 2:11relevant at the remedy stage of the case in determining
- 2:14the scope of any remedy. These allegations would also bear
- 2:18strong on motive and bias are if P number twenty
- 2:22request documents between the government and state and local prosecutors
- 2:26and police agencies, including the Palm Beach Police Department regarding
- 2:30the non prosecution Agreement. Because this involves information outside of
- 2:34the department, it is the victims understanding that the government
- 2:37has already turned over all of this information to them,
- 2:40as the Court has directed. For the sake of completeness, however,
- 2:44it's worth noting that this information is needed to demonstrate
- 2:48that the victims were not properly informed that Epstein's plea
- 2:51to state charges would trigger the NPA and preclude prosecution
- 2:55for crimes committed against them. Are if P Number twenty
- 2:58one request correspondent regarding the NPA. Here, again, the victims
- 3:02understand that the government is prepared to produce all of
- 3:05this information to them once the stay pending action by
- 3:09the Eleventh Circuit is lifted. Again, for the sake of completeness,
- 3:13it's worth noting that the correspondence is needed to demonstrate
- 3:16the victim's claims that the government was concealing the existence
- 3:20of the NPA from them, and that this was done
- 3:22at Epstein's behest. The Court has specifically noted that the
- 3:26victims have a need for information that will allow them
- 3:29to argue to the court in support of their allegation
- 3:32of a deliberate conspiracy between EPSTEIN and federal prosecutors to
- 3:37keep the victims in the dark on the pendency of
- 3:39negotiation between EPSTEIN and federal authorities until well after the
- 3:44fact and presentation of the non prosecution agreement to them.
- 3:51RFP number twenty two requests information about consideration that EPSTEIN
- 3:55provided or offered to provide to any individual within the government.
- 4:00Here again, the victims understand that this information is being
- 4:02provided to them. It's again worth noting, however, that this
- 4:06information is highly relevant to explaining why the US Attorney's
- 4:09Office would not have properly notified the victims about what's
- 4:12happening in their case, an allegation that is at the
- 4:15center of the victim's summary judgment motion RFP number twenty three.
- 4:20As for documents that will assist Jane DO one and
- 4:23Jane DO two and protecting their rights under the CVRA,
- 4:27the request links to the government's obligation under the CVRA
- 4:31to use its best efforts to protect victims' rights. US
- 4:34Code eighteen, Section thirty seven seventy one C one. The
- 4:38direct connection between this request and the victim's case is
- 4:41self explanatory. RFP number twenty four requests correspondence related to
- 4:46the Epstein prosecution that the government had with entities outside
- 4:50the federal government. Here again, it's my understanding that these
- 4:54materials have already been ordered produced CDE one ninety eight two.
- 4:59For the sake of go completeness. This information is again
- 5:01relevant to showing the course of the Epstein investigation and
- 5:05why the victims were not properly notified about the event
- 5:09during that investigation. RFP number twenty five request all initial
- 5:13productions that are required under the Federal Rules of Civil procedure.
- 5:17This is a protective request to ensure that should it
- 5:21be determined that the civil rules apply, they then receive
- 5:24all material to which they are entitled. In June of
- 5:28twenty thirteen, the victims sent a supplemental request for production
- 5:32asking the government to provide any information concerning any investigation
- 5:36that the Department undertook concerning the treatment of the victims
- 5:40during the investigation in the case, including any FBI grand jury, OPR,
- 5:45or other investigation in the Southern District of Florida, Middle
- 5:49District of Florida, or elsewhere. Here Again, this information is
- 5:53critically needed, as it would go directly to proving the
- 5:56victim's allegations that their rights were violated during the investigation
- 6:00of Epstein. This information would also go directly to defeating
- 6:04the government's estoppel argument. The information would also show a
- 6:08motive and bias. Inadequate privileged log. The government has produced
- 6:14a privileged log that violates the court's order in the
- 6:16case I have been greatly hampered in responding to the
- 6:20government's assertions of privilege because of that inadequate log. Indeed,
- 6:25in many cases, it's impossible to determine whether the government's
- 6:29assertions of privilege are even plausible because of the inadequacy
- 6:33of the log. The court is directed the government to
- 6:36produce a privileged log that clearly identifies each document as
- 6:40to which privilege is asserted by the author, addresseee, recipient date,
- 6:45and general subject matter. Many of the entries into the
- 6:49privileged log failed to meet the requirement. A good illustration
- 6:53of the inadequacies of the privileged log comes from the
- 6:55very first entry in the log, covering box number one
- 7:00nine pages of documents. Yet the only description of these
- 7:04thirty nine pages is file folder entitled cor r R
- 7:09GJ Subpoenas, containing correspondence related to various grandjury subpoenas and
- 7:14Attorney Villafana's handwritten notes. Another good illustration of the inadequacies
- 7:20of the privileged log is provided on page twenty of
- 7:23the first privileged log with regard to box number three.
- 7:26The government asserts privilege here regarding ninety pages of documents,
- 7:31yet the only description of these ninety pages is file
- 7:34folder entitled key Documents containing correspondence between a USA and
- 7:39case agent regarding indictment prep questions, victim identification information, corrections
- 7:45to draft indictment, indictment preparation timeline, key grand jury materials.
- 7:51There are many other illustrations of the inadequacies of that
- 7:54privileged log that the court will see when it examines it.
- 7:58I have also filed contemporaneously response to the Government's privileged log,
- 8:02which identifies many situations of an inadequate privilege log, as
- 8:07well as other responses that are needed to respond to
- 8:10the government's log. The Government has never contacted ME or
- 8:14Co Council about any burdens associated with producing a privileged
- 8:18log that complied with the government directives at all times
- 8:23relevant to this case, I would have been willing to
- 8:26work with the Government Council to minimize any excessive burden
- 8:29from producing an adequate privilege log. The request for production
- 8:33that I sent to the Government specifically invited discussions to
- 8:37avoid any excessive burden failure to prove factual underpinning of
- 8:42privileged claim Many of the government's privilege assertions require factual premise,
- 8:47such as the existence of an attorney client relationship and
- 8:51the rendition of legal services within that relationship. Yet the
- 8:55government has not provided the factual underpinnings of any of
- 8:58its privileged assertions. An illustration of the problem is found
- 9:02on page one of the Supplemental Privilege Log with regard
- 9:05to Supplemental Box number three. The entry here reads seven
- 9:09ten eight emails between j. Slowman and Marie Villafauna k
- 9:13Atkinson and FBI are e proposed response to Goldberger's letter
- 9:18victim notification. The log then indicates that the government is
- 9:22asserting attorney client privilege, work product privilege, and deliberative process privilege.
- 9:27The government, however, does not provide any document for any
- 9:30of the factual underpinnings of any of these claims. For example,
- 9:34with regard to the attorney client claim, the government does
- 9:37not explain who the attorney is and who the client is.
- 9:41With regard to the work product claim, the government does
- 9:44not explain what litigation this document contemplated. And with regard
- 9:48to the deliberative process, the government does not explain what
- 9:52deliberative process was involved. There are many other illustrations of
- 9:56the government's failure to prove the factual underpinnings of the privilegetions,
- 10:01which the court will see when it examines the Victim's
- 10:04responsive log. Waiver of confidentiality. Some of the privileges that
- 10:09the government asserted have been waived. Of course, a requirement
- 10:12of a privilege is that confidentiality be maintained. Some of
- 10:16the materials have been circulated outside of any confidential circle,
- 10:20thereby waiving privilege. An illustration of waiver found on page
- 10:24one of the Supplemental Privilege Log with regard to Supplemental
- 10:28Box number three. The entry here reads seven to eight
- 10:31AW eight email from Marie Vilafauna to alex Acosta J.
- 10:35Slowman Atkinson, an FBIRI proposed response to Goldberger's letter victim notification.
- 10:43The log then indicates that the government is asserting attorney
- 10:46client privilege with the email, but the emails were not
- 10:49internal to the US Attorney's office, but were also sent
- 10:52to the FBI. This is another illustration of the inadequacies
- 10:57of the privileged log because who in the FBI the
- 11:00materials we're sent to is not disclosed. But the FBI
- 11:04is a law enforcement investigative agency, not an agency that
- 11:07provides legal advice. Accordingly, any attorney client privilege would be
- 11:12waived by dissemination of these emails outside of the attorney's office.
- 11:18Another illustration a waiver is found on page three of
- 11:21the Supplemental Privilege Log with regard to supplemental box number three.
- 11:25The entry here reads file folder labeled meeting with ken
- 11:28Starr raa JS drew containing handwritten notes by A Marie
- 11:33Vilafuna ken Starr and of course a defense attorney who
- 11:37represented defend at Epstein. Recording information provided by a defense
- 11:41attorney is not part of any governmental attorney client privilege.
- 11:46Another illustration of waiver is found on page seven of
- 11:49the Supplemental Privileged Log with regard to the supplemental box
- 11:53number three. The entry here reads file folder entitled notes
- 11:57Plea Negotiations containing nine seventeen oh seven email from Maria
- 12:02Villa Fauna to Jay Richards and Kirkandall are e status
- 12:06update on dated and typed handwritten notes by Maria Villa Fauna.
- 12:10Items to be completed on case, strength of case, victim interviews,
- 12:15summary of evidence, guideline calculations. The government is asserting attorney
- 12:19client privilege regarding this email. I understand the reference to
- 12:23Richards and Kirkandall to be references to FBI agents, not
- 12:26attorneys in the US Attorney's office. Accordingly, the attorney client
- 12:31privilege would not extend to this email. All right, folks,
- 12:34We're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next
- 12:36episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where
- 12:39we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 12:42this episode can be found in the description box.