Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Layoff Gold Rush 2025❤️🔥: Cashing In on Corporate Downsizing. The Wild Math Behind Tech’s Big Purge
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever noticed how often you see those headlines?
- 0:01You know, major companies laying off thousands of employees?
- 0:04It almost always sounds like, well, like a bad sign, doesn't
- 0:07it? It really does.
- 0:08That's the immediate reaction. But have you ever stopped to
- 0:11really wonder about the actual financial costs and, maybe more
- 0:15surprisingly, the benefits for the companies themselves when
- 0:18they make these huge cuts? Today we're doing a deep dive
- 0:21into exactly that, the surprising financial impact and
- 0:24the cost benefit side of things. For large scale layoffs, we're
- 0:28looking at major S&P 500 companies, right?
- 0:31And focusing particularly on the tech sector, say from 2020
- 0:34through 2025. That period saw a lot of this.
- 0:38Yeah, it certainly did. In our mission today really is
- 0:40to unpack some real concrete examples.
- 0:43We're talking giants like Meta, Alphabet, Amazon, Microsoft,
- 0:46even Tesla. We're going to peel back the
- 0:48layers, look at the the big upfront HR costs involved, and
- 0:52then crucially, see how these strategic and sometimes, let's
- 0:55face it, controversial decisions actually play out on the
- 0:58company's financials. Do they actually save money in
- 1:00the long run? Exactly.
- 1:02Do they really lead to those long term savings they talk
- 1:05about? Hopefully by the end of this
- 1:06you'll have a much clearer picture of why companies make
- 1:10these tough calls. And you know what the numbers
- 1:12are really telling us? OK, let's get into it then.
- 1:14When a company announces mass layoffs, it's not just like
- 1:19saying goodbye, is it? It sounds quick, but what does
- 1:21it actually cost them right away?
- 1:24What are those immediate hits to their books?
- 1:26You're right, it's definitely not simple layoffs.
- 1:28Well, they actually cost a lot in human resources HR costs.
- 1:32The biggest things are usually severance pay.
- 1:34Then you've got extended benefits coverage like health
- 1:36insurance and often Korea transition services too.
- 1:39You know, help finding a new job.
- 1:40So actual cash going out the. Door serious cash.
- 1:43We're talking about really significant upfront costs per
- 1:46employee, especially when you think about those high salaries
- 1:50in tech. It's not just see you later,
- 1:51yeah, it's see you later. And here's a pretty substantial
- 1:54check. Can you give us some actual
- 1:56examples? Like what did meta and alphabet
- 1:58payout per person on average when they made those big cuts we
- 2:02heard about? Sure.
- 2:03So Meta, for instance, back in November 2022, they laid off
- 2:07around 11,000 employees. Yeah, I remember that.
- 2:10They ended up spending nearly a billion dollars just on
- 2:12severance and related costs, about $975,000,000 to be
- 2:18precise. Wow, per person.
- 2:20Well, if you average it out, yeah, it's roughly $88,000 per
- 2:24employee, which reflects some pretty generous packages,
- 2:26actually. Like what?
- 2:28Things like 16 weeks of base pay, plus another two weeks for
- 2:31every year they'd worked there, and six months of health
- 2:34insurance continuation. That's significant.
- 2:36It is. And remember they had a second
- 2:37round of about 10,000 cuts in spring 2023, which added even
- 2:41more charges later on. Now, Alphabet, Google's parent
- 2:44company, they cut 12,000 jobs early in 2023, right?
- 2:47Their severance costs went even higher, came in around $2.1
- 2:50billion by the third quarter of 2023.
- 2:52Two. Point 1 billion.
- 2:53Yeah, which suggests an average severance way over $150,000 per
- 2:58employee. That lines up with, you know,
- 3:00Google's typically high compensation levels.
- 3:02And what's also interesting there is they had another
- 3:04$856,000,000 in charges for things like getting out of
- 3:08office leases that would for the same restructuring after.
- 3:11That is just a staggering amount of money just to let people go.
- 3:13OK. What about Amazon and Microsoft?
- 3:15Microsoft, were there costs in the same ballpark or was it
- 3:18different? Amazon's corporate layoffs were
- 3:20big too, around 27,000 people in total across late 2022 and early
- 3:252023, right? Also costly, but the average per
- 3:28employee seemed a bit lower for their first round, about 18,000
- 3:32cuts. Amazon reported a $640 million
- 3:35charge. OK.
- 3:36If you average that, it comes out to maybe $35,000 per
- 3:39employee? Much lower than Google.
- 3:41Much lower, yeah. And that's likely because of the
- 3:43mix of roles affected, maybe more warehouse or less
- 3:46specialized corporate staff and potentially shorter severance
- 3:49deals, maybe around 8 to 12 weeks of pay, something like
- 3:52that. Gotcha.
- 3:52And Microsoft. Microsoft cut about 10,000 jobs
- 3:55in January 2023. They took a big one time charge
- 3:58of $1.2 billion for the whole restructuring and about $800
- 4:02million of that was specifically for employee severance.
- 4:06So do the math. Works out to roughly $80,000 per
- 4:11employee. Similar to meta then.
- 4:13Yeah, in that range. And their package also included
- 4:16things like 6 months of healthcare and career transition
- 4:19services. So still a lot of money, but
- 4:21quite a bit less per head than Alphabet.
- 4:23OK, this is what gets really interesting for me.
- 4:25Tesla, they always seem to be the outlier, kind of marching to
- 4:29their own drum. What was their approach with
- 4:31severance and did that carry any risks?
- 4:33Tesla's approach is, yeah, notably different.
- 4:36Their severance payouts? Generally pretty minimal.
- 4:38Minimal how? Well, for example, during
- 4:40layoffs back in June 2022, many staff who were let go reportedly
- 4:43got just one week of pay as severance.
- 4:45One week compared to 16 weeks plus at meta.
- 4:48Exactly. Which of course means much, much
- 4:51lower immediate HR costs per employee compared to the others
- 4:54we've talked. About Yeah, surely there's a
- 4:55downside. Oh yeah, this minimalist
- 4:57approach actually led to legal trouble for them.
- 4:59Tesla got sued under the WARN Act.
- 5:01The WARN Act. Yeah, it's the Worker Adjustment
- 5:03and Retraining Notification Act. Basically, it requires companies
- 5:07to give 60 days notice for mass layoffs in many situations.
- 5:10Tesla apparently didn't. So it really highlights the
- 5:14legal risks you run if you provide inadequate severance or
- 5:17notice, even if it saves cash upfront.
- 5:19And then in the April 2024, they cut over 14,000 employees again
- 5:23and the assumption is they probably followed a similar
- 5:25minimal severance path. So that raises a big question.
- 5:28Why does this cost per employee vary so much from you know,
- 5:33maybe 35 K at Amazon to over 150K at Google and then almost
- 5:38nothing at Tesla? It really boils down to a few
- 5:40key things. First, just the generosity of
- 5:43the severance terms themselves. Are we talking multi month
- 5:46packages like Meta and Alphabet? Or you know the minimal route
- 5:49like Tesla, right? Second, the average pay level of
- 5:51the employees being cut. High paid engineers for example,
- 5:54they naturally cost more in severance because it's often
- 5:56tied to salary. Makes sense.
- 5:58And 3rd, you've got local legal requirements.
- 6:00Different places have different tools about minimum severance or
- 6:03notice periods. Plus, companies often throw in
- 6:05extras like counseling or job placement services.
- 6:08And like Tesla discovered, legal costs can definitely pile up if
- 6:12layoffs aren't handled by the book.
- 6:14It's actually a pretty complex. Calculation.
- 6:15So OK, they pay these huge upfront bills.
- 6:17The next big question is how does Wall Street actually react?
- 6:21Do investors punish companies for these massive charges that
- 6:24obviously hit their quarterly profits, or is something else
- 6:29going on? And how do these costs actually
- 6:30show up on the financial statements?
- 6:32Right. So these layoff related
- 6:34expenses, they typically appear as one time charges, usually
- 6:37called restructuring charges and these directly reduce the
- 6:40company's reported profit in the quarter.
- 6:42They happen but companies are usually pretty careful to label
- 6:45them as non recurring. Meaning they tell investors hey
- 6:48look this is a one off hit. It's not part of our normal
- 6:50ongoing business costs. This is for a long term gain.
- 6:54Let's go back to Meta. Huge severance cost, as you
- 6:56said. How did that specifically impact
- 6:58their profits? And the really surprising part,
- 7:02how did investors react to such a big negative number?
- 7:04It just feels counterintuitive. It absolutely is
- 7:07counterintuitive. So Meadows big severance and
- 7:10restructuring costs in late 2022, they led to this massive
- 7:14$4.2 billion restructuring charge in the fourth quarter of
- 7:182022. 4.2 billion, yeah. And as a direct result, their
- 7:22net profit for that quarter, it was down a stunning 55% compared
- 7:26to the year before. Ouch.
- 7:28So the stock tanked. That's what you'd think, but
- 7:30here's the fascinating part. Meta stock actually jumped
- 7:33nearly 20% right after they announced these results, Despite
- 7:37that huge profit hit. 20%. Well, it seems the market saw it
- 7:40differently. It wasn't just about the cost,
- 7:42it was about the signal. Investors often see these kinds
- 7:45of drastic moves as a sign the company is finally getting
- 7:47serious about efficiency, about future profitability.
- 7:51The year of efficiency thing, they talked.
- 7:52About exactly It's like the market decided this painful
- 7:55surgery now would lead to a much healthier company later, and
- 7:59they rewarded that proactive decision.
- 8:01They clearly bought into the idea that this restructuring
- 8:03showed financial discipline and would improve margins down the
- 8:06road. That's quite a reaction.
- 8:08So the market looks past the short term pain.
- 8:10Do we see similar patterns with Alphabet, Amazon and Microsoft
- 8:14when their charges hit? Well, Alphabet took most of its
- 8:16big charge, around $2.0 billion for severance in the first
- 8:20quarter of 2023. And yeah, that directly lowered
- 8:24their operating profit for that quarter.
- 8:26Amazon's $640 million severance charge in Q 4/20/22 also played
- 8:31a part in them reporting their first net loss in years.
- 8:34Although it's fair to say other factors were definitely involved
- 8:36there too, right. And Microsoft similarly there
- 8:39are $1.2 billion charge in their Q2 of fiscal 2023 that also
- 8:43reduced their net income for that specific quarter.
- 8:46So yes, the charges are significant.
- 8:48They definitely impact the reported numbers.
- 8:50But just like with Meta, Wall Street often looks through these
- 8:53one off costs. Looks through them.
- 8:54Yeah, they tend to discount them when they're figuring out the
- 8:57company score, ongoing earning power.
- 8:59What investors and analysts focus on instead is the expected
- 9:02improvement in future earnings because, well, you have lower
- 9:05ongoing expenses. Now fewer salaries to pay.
- 9:07Exactly. And companies are usually pretty
- 9:09clear about this in their earnings calls.
- 9:11They help analysts adjust their models to focus on that future
- 9:14benefit. And Tesla, once again, the
- 9:16outlier, Yeah, different here because they're upfront costs
- 9:20were so low, meaning almost no big charge to look.
- 9:24Through precisely Tesla's financial statements didn't
- 9:26really show these large distinct restructuring charges because,
- 9:30as we said, their severance payments are minimal.
- 9:32So no big hit to immediate earnings.
- 9:34Barely any impact compared to the others.
- 9:36In fact, if you look back at Tesla's aggressive cost heading
- 9:39in 2018-2019, which included layoffs, that was actually a key
- 9:42reason they finally started achieving sustained quarterly
- 9:45profits. For them, it was almost an
- 9:47immediate boost to the bottom line because they skipped that
- 9:50big upfront payout phase. OK, so we've covered the big
- 9:52upfront costs, how they hit the books and how Wall Street often
- 9:56reacts surprisingly positively. But the whole point of layoffs,
- 9:59the promise is always about long term savings.
- 10:02How quickly do companies actually get that money back?
- 10:05What's the real trade off here for shareholders?
- 10:07This is really the heart of the financial calculation, isn't it?
- 10:10Companies pay those significant upfront costs specifically to
- 10:14cut their ongoing expenses, mainly salaries, benefits, maybe
- 10:18some overhead, right? And what we've seen in many of
- 10:20these cases, especially in tech recently, is that the annual
- 10:23savings they achieve can actually dwarf the one time
- 10:26layoff costs. Dwarf them?
- 10:28Really. Yeah, often they can recover
- 10:30that initial outlay in, well, significantly less than a year.
- 10:33It's a big bet upfront, but one that often pays off remarkably
- 10:37fast from a purely financial perspective.
- 10:39OK, give us the numbers. How much did Meta save annually
- 10:42compared to that $2 billion they spent on severance and
- 10:45restructuring? Right, so Meta's charges were
- 10:47around $2 billion across those two rounds of cuts.
- 10:50But here's the kicker. Meta's management indicated that
- 10:53these layoffs, cutting over 21,000 jobs in total, would
- 10:56remove an estimated $5 billion in annual operating costs on a
- 11:01net basis. 5 billion a year. 5 billion a year.
- 11:04So you can see the long term savings massively outweigh the
- 11:08one time charges. That initial $2 billion cost was
- 11:11basically recouped in what, less than six months of ongoing
- 11:13savings? That's an incredible return on
- 11:15that painful investment. Was it a similar story for
- 11:19Google and Amazon? You mentioned Alphabet also had
- 11:21those office lease cost. Did that add to savings too?
- 11:23Absolutely. Look at Alphabet, they're
- 11:25roughly $2.1 billion severance cost for 12,000 employees.
- 11:29That likely removed somewhere between, say, $2.5 billion and
- 11:32three-point billion dollars in annual costs.
- 11:34Again, pay back in under a year. Easily under a year just on
- 11:37salary savings. And yes, that extra $856 million
- 11:40Alphabet spent getting out of office leases.
- 11:43That should lead to lower rent and depreciation costs in future
- 11:45quarters, boosting the savings even more down the line.
- 11:48Amazon's estimated $1 billion total severance for about 27,000
- 11:53corporate rolls is projected to save roughly $2.7 billion per
- 11:58year in labor costs. So again, yes, we're couping
- 12:00that initial billion well within a year.
- 12:03These cuts for them were part of, you know, bigger cost
- 12:05optimization plans aiming for multi billion dollar annual
- 12:08savings. And it's not just big tech.
- 12:10You know, if we broaden the view slightly, companies like Disney,
- 12:14Goldman Sachs, they showed similar kinds of financial
- 12:17returns from their layoff programs.
- 12:19Well, Disney cut 7000 jobs, estimated severance cost maybe a
- 12:23few 100 million, but those cuts were expected to contribute $2.5
- 12:26billion towards their bigger goal of $5.5 billion in annual
- 12:30savings. And Goldman Sachs over in
- 12:32banking, they spent about $275 million on severance for around
- 12:353200 jobs, but they expected 500 to $600 million in annual
- 12:40savings just from those cuts. It's a pretty consistent pattern
- 12:42across different industries. It seems to be significant
- 12:45upfront cost, yes, but often a very rapid payback period
- 12:48through those ongoing savings. And let me guess, Tesla unique
- 12:51again because they're minimal severance costs mean the long
- 12:55term savings are almost pure profit right from the start.
- 12:58No big initial cost to claw. Back exactly right.
- 13:02Tesla's super low short term cost means almost no noticeable
- 13:06hit to their financials in the quarter.
- 13:08The layoff happens. Take their 2024 cut over 14,000
- 13:12employees. That could save them anywhere
- 13:14from, say, $700 million to maybe $1 billion a year in costs.
- 13:18And since the payout was tiny. Since the payout was tiny,
- 13:21almost all of that future saving drops straight to the bottom
- 13:24line, like immediately. It gives an instant boost to
- 13:26their profitability profile. It's a very aggressive approach
- 13:29to cost management, definitely a hallmark of how they operate.
- 13:32But this does raise, I think, a really important point.
- 13:34While the financial math often seems to work out quite clearly,
- 13:37are there hidden costs? You know, intangible things,
- 13:40longer term risk that don't show up so neatly on a spreadsheet?
- 13:43Yeah, that's why I was wondering.
- 13:44It can't all be positive, can? It no, absolutely not.
- 13:46There are definitely significant intangible costs, things that
- 13:49are much harder to put a dollar figure on liquid well.
- 13:52Probably the most critical is the loss of institutional
- 13:55knowledge and expertise. When experienced people leave,
- 13:59you lose their skills, their understanding of how things
- 14:02work. That can lead to project delays,
- 14:04maybe a dip in product quality, even missing out on new ideas or
- 14:08innovation. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 14:10And then there's the hit to employee morale among the people
- 14:13who remain the survivors. Exactly.
- 14:15It can create this climate of fear, uncertainty, impact,
- 14:19productivity. And sometimes your top remaining
- 14:22talent might start looking elsewhere too, leading to, you
- 14:25know, a a talent drain over time.
- 14:27So companies have to weigh that, too.
- 14:28They absolutely have to. They need to balance these clear
- 14:31financial upsides with these potential harder to measure long
- 14:34term downsides because some companies have found that after
- 14:36cutting really deep, they actually needed to rehire later
- 14:39to fuel growth and sometimes they end up bringing people back
- 14:41at even higher salaries than before.
- 14:43Wow, what an incredibly eye opening deep dive this has been.
- 14:47What I'm really taking away is that for these huge S&P 500
- 14:50firms, layoffs, while obviously so difficult for the people
- 14:54involved, they are often a very calculated financial move.
- 14:58Yeah, a tool in the toolbox. Right.
- 15:00They pay these significant one time hour costs, which
- 15:03definitely hurt earnings in the short term, but they do it with
- 15:06a really clear expectation and it seems and expectations often
- 15:09met of making the company financially stronger in the long
- 15:12run, mostly through cutting those recurring expenses way
- 15:15down. The data we looked at,
- 15:17especially from the last five years or so, it really does show
- 15:20that the annual savings usually dwarf those one time charges,
- 15:23often paying for themselves within just one year.
- 15:25Incredible. And like we saw so clearly with
- 15:27Meta, the market often rewards these announcements, which tells
- 15:30you that investors generally believe that long term
- 15:33efficiency, that improved profitability, it outweighs the
- 15:35the immediate cost. They're betting on a leaner,
- 15:37more focused future. It's that classic case of short
- 15:40term pain for long term gain, but with that weird twist, the
- 15:45market often seems to applaud the pain itself.
- 15:47So yeah, the next time you see a headline about a major company
- 15:50announcing big layoffs, hopefully you'll have a deeper
- 15:52sense that it's not just about the immediate job cuts.
- 15:56It's actually a strategic and pretty expensive investment and
- 15:58what they hope will be a leaner and potentially more profitable
- 16:03future. And that brings us to our final
- 16:05thought for you listening today. We've talked a lot about the
- 16:07pretty clear financial benefits companies get from these
- 16:10layoffs. But considering those intangible
- 16:12costs, we just touched on things like morale, losing expertise.
- 16:16Where do you think the line is? Is there a point where the drive
- 16:18for efficiency through layoffs actually starts to become a
- 16:22detriment to the company in the long run?
- 16:24When does cost cutting go too far?