Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 588. Unpacking the Peter Attia-Antonio Bianco Hypothyroidism Episode: What Was Missed, What Was Truth, What Was WRONG
Transcript
- 0:00I know the trends. I know the numbers. We know thyroid like it's the back of our hand. We can optimize someone blindfolded with our hands tied behind our back. We can do it in our sleep. So what they're saying as I was listening to this podcast, quite honestly, made me want to stab my eye out.
- 0:21Welcome to the new and completely reimagined Thyroid Fixer podcast, a podcast that refuses to sound like every other health show out there. We're here to disrupt this entire space. And now you are part of that disruption. If you're listening right now, it's because something inside you finally said, I'm done being ignored.
- 0:42And I'm here to tell you good, because this is where everything changes for you. This is where you say no more. No more being dismissed by your doctor. No more being told your labs are normal. No more recycled medical advice. No more recycled biohacking advice. No more being told you accept what you know isn't right.
- 1:03Here, you'll get truth. You'll get clarity. You'll get information you can actually use. Tools, strategy, and guidance. You can apply right now to take back your energy, your hormones, your metabolism, and your life.
- 1:19Every episode will give you something real, something that moves you forward, something that reminds you that you were never the problem, the system was. This is the Thyroid Fixer podcast. This is your turning point. This is where you rise. Get ready. We're about to disrupt everything you thought you knew about thyroid and hormone health. Let's go.
- 1:42Before I dive into the deconstruction of the Peter Atiyah, Dr. Antonio Bianco hypothyroid episode on Peter Atiyah's podcast, I want to make something very clear. I deeply admire and respect Peter Atiyah.
- 2:01Both of these individuals, Peter Atiyah and Antonio Bianco. Peter is brilliant. He's thoughtful. He's evidence driven. He's been one of the strongest public advocates for hormone therapy out there on 60 Minutes. He even said that withholding bioidentical hormone replacement therapy and the black box warning triggered by the flawed Women's Health Initiative study was one of the biggest medical catastrophes in modern female health.
- 2:29You go, Peter. I love you for that. And he's right. That study produced decades of fear that kept women from receiving life-saving hormones. It directly contributed to today's skyrocketing rates of heart disease, cancer, Alzheimer's, in women now in their 60s, 70s, 80s. My mother was one of them. And then Antonio Bianco, someone I've interviewed myself on this podcast, was one of the only researchers I came across during my doctoral work
- 2:59who articulated the true importance of T3. His work has genuinely advanced the scientific conversation. Now, why are we doing this episode? This interview between Peter Atiyah and Antonio Bianco is going to be consumed by the public as factual thyroid education. And that's the problem. And while parts of it are correct...
- 3:25Other parts are deeply misleading or incomplete. And that can be dangerous for real thyroid patients out there, like yourself who might be listening to this, who are trying to understand their bodies. So here's the thing. If you're a longtime listener of my podcast, I'm going to say,
- 3:44If you're in the Just Fix Your Thyroid Facebook group and you've been there for an extended period of time, reading, posting, joining me weekly on the Facebook Lives, asking questions, educating yourself...
- 3:57then you already know that a normal TSH does not mean that you're fine. You already know that symptoms absolutely matter. You know that free T3 runs the show and is so important. And that reverse T3 is clinically necessary to see whether or not you are converting your T4 to T3. You've learned these truths and they've changed your life.
- 4:20But the newly diagnosed, the ones that have all the symptoms that are desperately seeking answers, that are being dismissed and ignored by their PCP, their OBGYN, the next PCP, the next endocrinologist, five endocrinologists, a functional medicine practitioner, and a naturopathic doctor. And they're being ignored and dismissed and ignored and dismissed. And they're seeking real advice and real information. They don't know all of that.
- 4:49They don't know that yet. What about the women and the men just entering this space of thyroid and hormone dysfunction? What about the scared, exhausted, confused patients that we see every day entering our Just Fix Your Thyroid Facebook community who don't yet know what their labs mean, what optimal ranges are, or why they feel so terrible even with normal labs?
- 5:15What if they listen to this interview and walk away believing that a TSH of 3 means you're perfectly healthy? That symptoms, they just don't matter. That it can be anything, a multitude of problems. That a free T3 of a 2.5 is just fine. What if they walk away believing that reverse T3 is irrelevant unless it is catastrophically high? What if they walk away believing that a 2.5 microgram of T3 is somehow dangerous?
- 5:44All of which is false and all of which is stated in that interview. So this episode is not about attacking anyone. I'm not about that. I know there are influencers out there. There are influencers that have attacked me. I think that they have little man syndrome. They have issues.
- 6:00I don't do that, but I will deconstruct. And this is about protecting thyroid patients from misinformation that sounds scientific, but is incomplete or outdated and therefore harmful, or that is not properly understood by an individual who treats thyroid patients, but who also has a thyroid problem himself or herself. Okay.
- 6:28And I think that that's important because, you know, and I'm not tooting my own horn, but it's just the truth that, yes, I have treated, we have treated in the Advanced Thyroid Hormone Clinic, we have treated thousands, thousands, thousands of patients.
- 6:43Thousands. I know the trends. I know the numbers. We know thyroid like it's the back of our hand. We can optimize someone blindfolded with our hands tied behind our back. We can do it in our sleep.
- 6:58What they're saying as I was listening to this podcast, quite honestly, made me want to stab my eye out because I thought about all of the work that I've done, that my colleagues that are of like-mindedness have done to educate you on the thyroid, on the symptoms, on the testing, on the treatment, and then this. So we have to keep going because it's about giving these newly diagnosed patients the
- 7:28The clarity and the truth, and if you're one of them, then you deserve this. The clarity and the truth that you need to be able to advocate for yourself. So with utmost respect for both Peter and Antonio, let's break this down section by section.
- 7:47Okay, right in the beginning, section one, let's go to physiology, T4 versus T3, the iodinase, normal ranges, and reverse T3. That's what we're going to be talking about in this first section. So what do these guys get right? Number one, T4 is a pro-hormone. T3 is the active hormone that binds receptors. T3 is the active hormone that binds receptors.
- 8:07And diodonase enzymes convert T4 to T3, or they can come in, and this is discussed in the podcast, they can convert T4 to reverse T3. So the body does shift toward reverse T3 under stress or illness. All of those statements are different.
- 8:27True. And there is a little bit of love and a light shined on the importance of T3 being the active thyroid hormone and activating at the cell level. And yes, he is correct and also says, I give credit, that T4 is inactive. It doesn't do anything. It can't do anything. It cannot have an effect on a cell.
- 8:50Now, here's what they miss entirely, actually. Nowhere in that episode do they discuss normal versus optimal. They repeatedly use the phrase normal range, normal range, but never once explain how those ranges are created. Now, we've gone over this in previous episodes, but let's just explain and clarify. Those lab reference ranges, LabCorp, Quest, or your hospital, are
- 9:17They come from basically sick hospital populations, not optimized healthy individuals. If you want to dive deeper into labs, listen to my podcast episode with Dr. Ken Berry as we talk about his book, Common Sense Labs. Great episode. And this is where he breaks down exactly how we got those standard lab value ranges.
- 9:40And in a nutshell, we went to a hospital, we tested a bunch of people, and we said, well, here's where most people are coming in at. Whereas functional medicine comes in and says, give us your badasses. Give us your healthy individuals. Give us those people that are living their best life and who are asymptomatic. Let's test them because that's a much more narrow range.
- 10:03Now, these lab reference ranges, they include people with undiagnosed thyroid dysfunction as well. They reflect statistical averages, not functional wellness. So when Antonio says TSH is normal, TSH is normal, he means normal.
- 10:23In that standard lab value range for a data set filled with sick people, this is not the same thing as optimal or healthy. A normal TSH does not mean, and when I say normal, I'm referencing what Antonio says in this interview, normal, normal, normal, normal.
- 10:42means that you could have a TSH of a 4, and that's considered normal. Functional medicine says, no, no, we want you below a 2. That's optimal. So everywhere in this episode, when they say normal TSH...
- 10:58Normal, free T4, they mean within that standard lab value, sick reference range. So a normal TSH does not mean you have adequate tissue level thyroid hormone. It does not mean that your metabolism is functioning. It does not mean that your brain is functioning. It does not mean that your symptoms are irrelevant. Normal is a setting on the dryer. It should not be used to describe any, any, any set of labs.
- 11:26Okay, reverse T3. Antonio claims reverse T3 only matters at astronomical levels. That's a quote. Okay.
- 11:34This is absolutely false, and we know this. Reverse T3 becomes clinically relevant well before it becomes astronomical. Ask the woman that has a reverse T3 of a 19 whose doctor keeps giving her more T4, more natural desiccated thyroid. I've talked about my patient over and over again, Amanda, who has seen other thyroid practitioners and she's been told,
- 12:02who ignored her reverse T3 that in my eyes was astronomical. I don't know if it would be astronomical in Antonio's eyes, but she was in the 30s and the 20s with her reverse T3. And you know what they kept doing? They kept giving her more T4.
- 12:19They kept giving her, here's more T4 with a baby dose of T3, which we're also going to get into today. Or here's more NDT, more NDT. Well, NDT contains 80% T4. So her reverse T3 was being completely and totally ignored, even in the functional community. Ask the woman whose reverse T3 is a 16 that falls completely within the normal range, using air quotes here.
- 12:47normal range, and she is sick. And all she's on is T4 only, which Antonio also says is okay. So we're going to talk about that as well.
- 12:57who is on T4 only, whose reverse is a 16. Her body is in total, complete shutdown mode. Ask her if she wants to wait around until it becomes astronomical. In functional medicine and in real boots-on-the-ground thyroid care from a woman who has had a thyroid problem,
- 13:18Me. We have seen thousands of patients, treated thousands of patients, and I get it at a very personal, deep level, experiential level. Reverse T3 above a 12 already signals metabolic dysfunction.
- 13:35If we wait for the levels that Antonio is referring to, the patient will, or you, will already be in what the literature calls human dormancy syndrome. Now, what is this? So there's actually a patent. It's a published work describing this state.
- 13:52Reverse T3 is basically the central feature. So when someone has an elevated reverse T3, it mimics fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue, and mitochondrial dysfunction. So it puts your body into a human dormant, dormancy, dormant, shut down, survival, hibernation mode. It makes you like a bear in the winter. This is documented. This is tested. This is written about. Why is it ignored? Why?
- 14:21Then the physiology punchline, reverse T3 is not dead and it is not insignificant. Physiology. Let's look at basic physiology. Reverse T3 is not dead. Antonio refers to it as dead. It's the break. It's the break pedal on your metabolism. It's not insignificant at all. And when it rises, even moderately, the body is signaling, I can't convert T4. T4.
- 14:47I'm conserving energy. Please stop increasing T4. That's what the body is saying through reverse T3 increasing. But we don't have to wait until it gets to astronomical levels. In fact, and one thing I teach my patients, and one thing that you always hear me say,
- 15:06is that everyone's body is unique. Thyroid optimization is a nuanced art. Again, it's one that we can do with our hands tied behind our back eyes, blindfolded in our sleep. Like, honestly, it's that simple for us. However, it's nuanced. And it is an art form. When you do something over and over and over again, it becomes very easy. Right?
- 15:33It's like, it's fine. It's a no-brainer. That's fine. But if you're not doing something correctly over and over and over again, then that behavior and that way of doing it, the incorrect behavior gets ingrained as well. So I believe that that's what's happening to a lot of these functional practitioners out there. They learned a certain way or they came from conventional medicine and they are trying their best to practice functional medicine
- 16:00Or they're using it as a marketing term, either one. But they just haven't done it enough for it to become second nature to them. This is why I always say you have to go to a thyroid and hormone expert to treat your thyroid and hormones. You can't just go to a functional medicine expert because it can be a jack-of-all-trades master of none. But I'm diverting right now.
- 16:20And I know Antonio sees patients. He used to, maybe. I don't know if he still does, but he references seeing patients in the interview and in his book. But why would you wait for a reverse T3 to go astronomical? Yeah.
- 16:37Okay, well, he also talks about testing. So now we're going into the next section of ignoring T3 and reverse T3 assays because the assays vary. Assay variability does not justify ignoring the hormone that actually runs your metabolism. If we discard every test with variability, we would diagnose nothing. We look at patterns. Okay.
- 17:04We look at the person. We don't look at isolated numbers. Those numbers give us data. They give us the connection back to the answer to the most important question that your doctor can ask you or any practitioner working with you should ask you, and that is, how do you feel? Okay.
- 17:29Those numbers, whether perfect or not, tie back to an overlay on your symptoms. So you come to us, you say, listen, I put on 30 pounds in a couple of months. I'm doing all the things. I can't take it off. My hair is falling out. I'm really tired. I'm really tired.
- 17:49I'm constipated. I have brain fog. I'm losing the outer corners of my eyebrows. I'm cold all the time. Well, those symptoms pretty much point to hypothyroidism. Now let's just look at your labs to confirm or deny that. And that's where we overlay your labs on top of that. Now let's just say you had all of those symptoms. And by the way, I am also on 125 micrograms of T4.
- 18:16Great. So T4 is not working because if it did, you wouldn't have all those symptoms. And oh, look, your reverse T3 is a 19. You are on way too much T4 and you have conversion issues. That's what that 19 tells us. Now, if the assay isn't perfect, who cares? All right, let's do some margin of error.
- 18:37Person has a reverse T3 of a 19. Maybe it's a 16. Maybe it's a 25. Maybe it's a 15. Don't care because it's still high. Person's on T4 only, which we know doesn't work. Their doctor keeps increasing it and they keep getting worse and they have all of the symptoms of hypothyroidism. How hard is it to just say the reverse T3 is freaking high? Maybe the assay isn't perfection, but it's definitely giving us feedback to be able to then help the patient.
- 19:07So when we look at reverse T3, we look at free T3, we look at TSH, we look at free T4, we look at the antibodies, we look at the symptoms, and we look at trends over time. This is how you diagnose thyroid dysfunction accurately. This is how you diagnose a conversion problem by listening to the patient.
- 19:23listening to the patient. And then when we add the optimal ranges, like we already discussed, then that brings another layer to that puzzle. Because now we have where you should be. And if you are way outside of that range, the optimal range, then we know that something is wrong. And that that outside of the range number ties back to your symptoms. So,
- 19:50All right, next section. When they're talking diagnosis, their diagnostic criteria actually excludes millions of people. And this is the problem that we see every day in our practice, every day in the Facebook group. People being told that they're normal, that they don't have a thyroid problem because their TSH is within normal limits.
- 20:17It's within that standard lab value range. Now, he does a good job at explaining that TSH is not a thyroid hormone. It is a pituitary hormone.
- 20:26Yes, it is. And it is the signal that is given to the thyroid when the brain detects that the thyroid is not doing a great job at secreting enough thyroid hormone for the body. But it doesn't measure tissue-level hypothyroidism. So as we know, as I have said so many times,
- 20:47And many of my functional colleagues out there have this on repeat as well, that you can be profoundly hypothyroid with a normal TSH. Now, Antonio also goes into T4 and he says how we diagnose hypothyroidism is by an abnormal TSH and a low free T4.
- 21:14Low free T4. That's it. I'm thinking of at least five different lab panels that I've looked at in the last two days that have a TSH easily below a two. Check that box. For functional medicine, check that box.
- 21:30With a free T4 that is not flagged low. It's actually coming in at a 1.4. What if we stop there with Antonio? According to this interview, if you had just those two numbers...
- 21:46you would be told that you are normal and that you do not have hypothyroidism. How is this better than our conventional model where people are being misdiagnosed left and right? Now, I give Peter Atiyah credit that he does bring in the functional medicine belief system to a point. He brings it in when they talk about natural desiccated thyroid medication. He also brings it in with a little bit of a
- 22:10maybe a shadow on it that, well, you know, the belief is that everybody is hypothyroid. Here's the thing. A lot of people actually are. Because the thyroid gland head to toe runs the show, we know that a dysfunction of the thyroid gland will affect the entire body.
- 22:31We know that the thyroid gland is pummeled by toxin exposure, by heavy metals, by mold, Epstein-Barr virus, various infections, fluoride, chlorine, bromide, the toxic halogens, iodine deficiency, elevated cortisol, elevated insulin, inflammation in the body, dysregulated hormones. That's what thyropause is, ladies.
- 22:57After the age of 40, as your hormones go on a rollercoaster ride, you enter a thyropause where your thyroid gland craps the bed and you start getting symptoms. Now, this can also happen after pregnancy because pregnancy is also a hormonal rollercoaster. Autoimmune is on the rise. So is it wrong to say that 90 to 95% of the population over the age of 40 has a thyroid problem and half of them don't know it? Yeah.
- 23:25Absolutely. There are so many people being misdiagnosed. And if we go by only looking at TSH and low free T4, my God, how many more people will go misdiagnosed and suffer? Now, again, this is where I feel like in listening to this interview, I'm either bipolar or schizophrenic, like I'm back and forth, back and forth going, okay, I agree with that. But then you say this.
- 23:52So Antonio will state in this interview, and again, I give him credit for this. He will state in this interview that people are being misdiagnosed. He will state that only relying on the TSH is incorrect, but then he dismisses the free T3 and the reverse T3.
- 24:15So it gets very confusing, which is exactly why I needed to deconstruct this for you so that I can help unconfuse you. Because when I was listening to it, it felt like my brain was literally being pulled into different directions where he contradicted himself. And not a blatant contradiction. It wasn't he'll say this and then said the opposite. Yeah.
- 24:38But to the point where you go, wait, wait, wait, what? How can you say X, Y, Z here and yet say X, Y, Z over here? And it's like two different belief systems.
- 24:49Okay, I'm going to keep going here. So T4. So Antonio does say that we are looking for a low free T4. Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait. We have to go back. Oh my goodness. Back to the patient that I was just saying. So let's go back to that person. That patient with a TSH below a 2, a free T4 of a 1.4.
- 25:15Okay, now, since that patient's with us, we're going to keep going. Free T3 of a 2.5, reverse T3 of a 19. What does that pattern tell us? Okay, so if we stop at the TSH and the free T4, person is told you're normal, everything's fine, be on your way. Antonio said it's fine. But now we look deeper. And now we look at those two assays that they say are not normal.
- 25:44Accurate, not entirely accurate. So just because a test isn't a 10 out of a 10 at LabCorp and Quest, we're going to just throw it out?
- 25:55We're going to dismiss it. We're not going to look at it and use our scientific, brilliant minds to piece this together with a person's symptoms. I think we can do that. And I don't believe that a test would exist throughout multiple nationwide health care systems and through nationwide lab testing like LabCorp and Quest that.
- 26:20That was just willy-nilly all over the place, has no accuracy, nothing. It's pointless. It gives a difference. No. No.
- 26:30No, they wouldn't even be offering it. But that's ludicrous. There has to be some standard to which these lab companies run free T3 and reverse T3 to guarantee some level of accuracy because if it was all over the place, it wouldn't even be on an order form. It wouldn't even be tested. So when we look at that full pattern,
- 26:54Then we can see, okay, well, reverse T3 is telling us that this person is taking so much T4 because their doctor keeps increasing it. Yeah, their free T4 on paper looks good. It's actually in that beautiful, shiny, normal range that Antonio wants it in. And the TSH is normal.
- 27:16But now we go down and we can see the answers with the low free T3 and the elevated reverse T3 along with the person's symptoms. So if we throw out reverse and free T3, that person continues to worsen with their symptoms and can actually be detrimental. Another...
- 27:36prop I will give Antonio is that he does state in this interview the dire need to address hypothyroidism and how it can kill you. You know, I have said over and over again that
- 27:51You're not going to die without thyroid hormone, but realistically you can. If we remove your thyroid gland and we don't replace it, you will die. I mean, you absolutely will die without thyroid hormone because it runs your entire body. If you don't have adequate thyroid hormone replacement,
- 28:08At that point of time, you are at a higher risk of cardiovascular disease, which he does touch on as being of vital importance and being one of those things that we see quite often when the thyroid gland is not being properly treated.
- 28:24various heart conditions, various cardiovascular conditions, as well as an increased risk of Alzheimer's and dementia. It starts affecting the brain. I have done podcasts on this as well that you can certainly go back and listen to, especially the one on does Synthroid cause cancer? And in that, I'm explaining that it's not the medication itself causing cancer. It is the elevator reverse T3 and the lack of proper thyroid hormone replacement that is putting a person's
- 28:53body into a low immune, which we know that the immune system is what protects us from cancer, because our immune system is always looking for those mutated cancer cells invaders to go out and attack and get red and clean house. But...
- 29:09If we don't have a properly functioning immune system, if our thyroid is struggling so badly that our bodies can't work properly, then yes, you are going to be at a greater risk. So I give Antonio props for shining the spotlight on the severity and the dire need for people to wake up
- 29:29and address hypothyroidism. But here's the thing, Antonio, we got to address it the right way. We got to address it the right way. Okay, so treatment. Antonio claims that 80% do well on T4 only. I will say wholeheartedly with a stat from the Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, A4M,
- 29:50And with anecdotal evidence from the Advanced Thyroid and Hormone Clinic, and what we see every day and what I have seen for the past 30 years, is that 0% to 2% do well on T4 monotherapy. T4 monotherapy is standard of care.
- 30:08Now, like I said in the beginning, Dr. Bianco is one of the only researchers who has written, published literature on T3, being the active thyroid hormone and being used in treatment. But yet he makes a statement like 80% do well on T4 only and minimizes the amount of people that require T3, completely minimizes, if not eradicates the people that need T3 only.
- 30:37And here's a T3 only listener, me listening and saying, I'm one of them. Then I have a couple other patients that I know. So that makes it way, way more than like the 0.5 to 1% of the population that you're talking about that are on T3 only. No, T3 only is a real thing and has helped a tremendous amount of people. And again, you take that T3 only girl.
- 31:02You take me and you give me T4 and you will see me go hypothyroid in a week. You will see me gain weight because that is my physiology that requires T3 only. And again, we have to get back to personalized medicine and stop treating people like a lab marker.
- 31:19Stop treating everybody like everybody else. Everyone is so unique and different. If that person needs T3 only, then they need T3 only to live their best life. That should not be withheld from them. We should not keep pumping more and more NDT in them and cross our fingers and wish on a rainbow that 80% T4 and 20% T3 will work in a person with a conversion issue.
- 31:41It's not going to. It's going to make them worse. And this is the point of the podcast where I really got fired up, if you can't tell already. So in real clinical practice...
- 31:55100% of our patients are on T4 and T3 combined or T3 only. And we do it in a way that is personalized and individualized and works with their body and their physiology and their labs. And yes, their labs containing pre-T3 and reverse T3, both of which have been blown off as insufficient assays. And they don't test real well. And, you know, the numbers are all over the place. Yeah.
- 32:21Okay, but the numbers give us a sign. And I can tell you wholeheartedly that that person that is on 112 micrograms, that went to 125, that went to 150, because their conventional doctor just kept increasing their T4, and we can see the trend in their reverse T3. Again, who cares if the reverse T3 is off by one or two or three or four? We can see the trend. It keeps going up with each increase. It keeps going up. And oh, by the way, it also matches their symptoms
- 32:49getting worse and worse and worse with each increase. So I will give the Academy for Anti-Aging Medicine the benefit of the doubt and say, okay, we'll give you that 2% because I'm sure there are people out there that are just not in our practice.
- 33:05I'm sure there are people out there on T4 only. They're living their best life. They're thriving. That's fine. They're not coming to see us. So for us, it's 100%. T4 requires conversion. We've said this before. T4 is the inactive thyroid hormone that is discussed on the podcast. And it has to go through a conversion phase to become T3. It's the removal of one iodine molecule from the structure to basically make it into T3.
- 33:33There's a lot that goes into conversion. There's a lot that gets in the way of T4 to T3 conversion. Nutrient deficiencies, which most of us are. Stress, which most of us are. Elevated cortisol, elevated insulin, estrogen dominance.
- 33:50progesterone deficiency, iodine deficiency, a DIO1 and DIO2 SNP, which is genetics, saying basically you don't convert very well per your genes. There's so much that can get in the way of that conversion that patients will end up with a low T3 and high reverse T3. Okay. But Antonio isn't looking at that or paying attention to that.
- 34:13This is where I go bananas. They also discuss treatment with T3. So Antonio says that even 2.5 to 5 micrograms of T3 can cause issues. And Peter actually jumps in. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we've seen that. It's ludicrous. And who?
- 34:31Yes, of course, there is that subset of our patients who are very sensitive. So if you're listening to this going, oh, my God, Dr. Amy, 2.5 micrograms of T3 gave me heart palpitations. Yeah, but you're sensitive. Okay, you are. I love you, but you're very sensitive. We just have to go slower with you. I get it. But...
- 34:51Most of the other people over here, they're doing pretty good. So in dosing reality, I would say, and I get this question asked all the time, what's the average dose of T3 that you give your patients? It's very individual because what works for you might not work for someone else. So...
- 35:11Again, going back to my favorite phrase, my favorite thyroid medication is the one that works for you and the combination that works for you and the dose that works for you. Whatever that is, that's our job to figure out. But I would say most are between 20 and 100 micrograms. I know that's a big range, but I'll explain why I'm saying this. And some need more, some need less. You're always going to have those outliers, right? Whenever you have a range, you're going to have the outlier. You're going to have the person that's on 10 micrograms and is optimized.
- 35:41You're going to have the person that can't even take five micrograms or they're freaking out. You're going to have the person that's 150 or 200 micrograms and that's what keeps them optimized. So you're always going to have the outliers. I would say in general between 20 and 100 micrograms to fully optimize. That's about right. We have plenty of patients on these doses and they're doing just fine. They are living their best freaking life. No one's dropping dead of a heart attack, AFib, nobody's losing bones. No.
- 36:09Nobody's going hyperthyroid. So Antonio says that we need better treatment, but then defends T4 only. See, this is where my brain being pulled in two different directions. Like I feel schizophrenic. What are you saying? What are you saying here, Antonio? You cannot say we need better treatment and then defend the exact outdated model that
- 36:32that has failed the very people that you say need help. We need treatment to be whatever that person needs, whatever that person needs. Maybe it is natural desiccated thyroid medication.
- 36:48I'm not saying that's the be-all end-all. And I do appreciate Peter Atiyah for shining the light on functional practitioners really heavily relying on and almost kind of dying on the sword that, oh my gosh, this is all we need. All we need. All we need is NDT. That's it.
- 37:05Those synthetics are bad. Now, this is where I agree with Peter and Antonio. Antonio says, you know, there's nothing wrong with the synthetics. Thank you. You're correct. I call them biosynth, Antonio. Biosynthetics. This is your levo, your synthroid, lyothyronine. This is the T4 and the T3 separated out. They call them synthetics.
- 37:28T4 and T3. And then, you know, people out there with tinfoil hats and that hug trees, they're all like, well, I only want a medication that has the word natural in the title. Okay. So side note, Peter and Antonio didn't talk about this, but I'm going to let you in on something. It's still made by a drug company. Your arm or thyroid you got right there, your NP thyroid.
- 37:53It was dry from a pig. That's the only natural part about it. The rest, fillers, made by Big Pharma, put into an orange bottle that you then have to pick up from a pharmacy. It's really not that different from the levothyroxine or the lyothyronine that was created to mimic the T4 and the T3 that your body makes. And guess what?
- 38:16your natural pig thyroid. Listen, if it's working for you, then I'm all about it. I am not anti-NDT. I am pro whatever the hell is going to work for you to give you your best life. But I don't understand. It cannot wrap my mind around people who believe that natural desiccated thyroid is the only way. And there are many functional practitioners out there, like Peter shines a light on, which I love him for, that will only prescribe NDT.
- 38:44And that's doing as big of a disservice to the thyroid patient as the conventional doctor prescribing T4 only. It's still putting you in a box and it's not taking into account your individual physiology and your ability to convert T4 to T3.
- 38:59Next section, TSH normalization isn't enough, but they still rely on it. Okay, so they say that TSH normalization isn't the whole picture, but everything they recommend still hinges on TSH. They never say just throw TSH out like we do. Like at some point it's like, you know, you don't have to test TSH. It's okay. Like if it was an expensive test, I would totally leave it off of the panel. Like why even waste your money on it?
- 39:27but they rely on it. The most important question that I ask is, how do you feel? So labs inform the story. They don't override the story. We cannot hang our hat on normalizing TSH. And this is what Antonio keeps coming back to in the podcast is getting the TSH in the normal range. Well, what about the TSH that drops below normal, but yet the free T4 and the free T3 are
- 39:56They never reference optimal, but I'm saying it. Then what would you say? Would you say that that person is finally optimized on their thyroid hormone replacement? Yes. And they never discuss the basic premise, the basic physiology of what occurs when you give T3. Because T3 is fast acting, which they mentioned in the interview, it's
- 40:22It is, and it has a very short half-life. Yes, I mean, yes, you do have to dose it a couple times a day. Big freaking deal. I mean, if you are a blob of mush sitting on your couch watching game shows and eating bonbons all day, you're probably not going to be listening to this.
- 40:39But you're probably not really caring about anything. And you're going to be the one that complains that you have to take T3 twice a day, right? No, you're going to stay the blob on your couch eating bonbons, watching game shows. That's fine. That's your choice. But the people over here that want to live an active, healthy, vibrant life, feeling their best, they can set an alarm. They can remember to take their T3 twice a day. I promise.
- 41:04It's not that big of a deal. Because when you tell the woman who hasn't been able to lose weight, who has put on 40 pounds, who has lost half of her hair, who can't get off the damn couch, that she has to take this life-giving medication twice a day, you think she's going to be like, no, you know what? Just give me that T4 because it's really slow acting and I only have to take it once a day.
- 41:27I don't care. I don't care how I feel. I don't care about Gumball. No, she's going to take the T3 twice a day. It's not that big of a deal. So we need to treat properly. And please, if you listen to that interview, do not...
- 41:42get sucked into that standard of care is okay with T4 monotherapy. It's not. And that baby doses of T3 are okay because they're not. Now, I do want to pause here and go over a couple things that I loved that he said in the interview.
- 41:59Number one, when he was talking about hyperthyroidism, he did point out the fact that just because the TSH is low or suppressed does not mean a person has hyperthyroidism. They have to have an elevated free T3, an elevated free T4, and a suppressed TSH, and that you will be able to tell. It'll be that person that comes in, their hands are clammy, they're shaky, like you can tell their whole countenance is anxious.
- 42:28and amped up. That's your hyperthyroid patient. I give them credit for that. And that is true. So it's not just based on TSH being suppressed. You're hyperthyroid. You're overmedicated. Your TSH is suppressed. No. It has to have all of those factors combined. The other thing they get right is talking about radioactive iodine versus surgery. This is fantastic. They bring this in to the conversation for when a person does need to have their thyroid gland removed. Right.
- 42:57This is where Antonio is 100% correct. I'm so glad he brought it up. That whole discussion around radioactive iodine versus surgery. So historically, radioactive iodine was the default because surgery was invasive. There's anesthesia. There's recovery. It's surgery. There's a big scar. There's a big scar.
- 43:16But today, they have come so far. Surgeons are specialized in this. They do hundreds of cases a year, hundreds of surgeries a year. It's a microscopic scar. It's easily done, safe, precise, way safer than radioactive iodine because radioactive iodine does increase cancer risk. Listen, if there's a treatment that makes you avoid your friends, family, children, and pets...
- 43:39because you yourself are radioactive, maybe that's not something that you want to put in your body. Now, if you've already had it done, you've already had it done. Make sure you're taking iodine. But if you had that choice, I love that, Antonio, and I agree on this. We agree wholeheartedly on that statement that you definitely want to go toward surgery and away from RAI if you have that choice. Okay, elevated TSH but feels fine case.
- 44:08Yes, some people do feel fine with a mildly elevated TSH. Great. But that tiny minority should not dictate how we treat the millions who feel horrible with a normal TSH.
- 44:24You're always going to have outliers. You are always going to have those random numbers that are wonky. And this is where we have to ask you, how do you feel? So if we're looking at TSH, okay, yeah, easily. You could be walking around with a TSH of, let's say, a 5. And I would go, oh, my goodness, this person is so hypothyroid. Oh, how do you feel? How do you feel?
- 44:47And that person goes, I feel great. I'm good. Like I really have no symptoms whatsoever. And I've had these discussions too. I've had these discussions with people. So I know it exists. I've seen their labs. I've had the discussions. You know, I feel fine. I have no symptoms whatsoever. I go, really? Really? So no weight gain, no fatigue. I go through the list. Really? No, I'm good. Maybe a little fatigue, but that's about it.
- 45:11Okay, so we're just going to leave that alone. Because we also know that sometimes when you take iodine supplementation that can bump up TSH...
- 45:20Maybe you were exposed to a virus. Same thing with antibodies. Those can increase and decrease. You got glutened. Something happened. Okay, it's random. And at the same time, you could have someone with, I have said this before, Alrus and I have talked about this on a podcast before, you could have someone with a free T3 of a 2.9 and they feel great too. Like you go, no, really, Sally, any symptoms whatsoever? Because, you know, we can change your medication here based on this T3. No, I feel great.
- 45:49But then you could have another, I could have two women the same age, the same body weight. We'll make them all the same, same, same, same, same. And the one woman has a free T3 of a 2.9 and feels like garbage and can't get rid of any of her symptoms because she needs more T3. And the other woman feels fine and has zero symptoms. It's very unique. That's why we look at the number and then we ask you the question. We look at the number and we ask you the question.
- 46:18With an elevated TSH, of course, we're going to ask you, how do you feel? Because nine times out of 10, an elevated TSH is going to result in a person saying that they are symptomatic. Whereas that small percentage will say that they're fine. Okay, the conclusion. We're almost at the end here. Antonio ends by saying that 20 million Americans have hypothyroidism, but we need better treatment. So he is absolutely right.
- 46:44But the T4-only model, the fear of T3 or increasing it beyond that 2.5 or 5-microgram dose, the dismissal of reverse T3, reliance on TSH, these are the reasons that patients are suffering and begging for better treatments. If we truly want better outcomes, the treatment paradigm must change. Most patients need T3.
- 47:10Most patients do not convert T4 well, and TSH does not tell the whole story. The science must evolve to match clinical reality, not the other way around.