Latest / The Morning Edition / The best and worst moments of the World Cup
Transcript
- 0:07S1: For decades, the World Cup has carried fans from all
- 0:11S1: over the world to great heights of unity and joy
- 0:14S1: in a way that is perhaps unique to an event
- 0:17S1: that sees strangers drinking a foreign pub dry together and
- 0:21S1: reveling in the strange and wonderful offerings at the local
- 0:24S1: grocery store while witnessing incredible feats of football. But a
- 0:32S1: maelstrom of complications threatened the sense of inclusion this year,
- 0:36S1: not least of all because for the first time, one
- 0:39S1: team's country is currently at war with its host country.
- 0:43S1: I'm Samantha Selinger Morris, and you're listening to The Morning
- 0:46S1: Edition from The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald. Today,
- 0:51S1: deputy and investigations editor Nick Ralston on the joy and
- 0:55S1: tension he witnessed on the ground at World Cup matches
- 0:58S1: in the United States and Canada. And yes, that viral
- 1:02S1: Aussie chant about Donald Trump. It's July the 15th. Welcome, Nick,
- 1:12S1: back to the podcast.
- 1:13S2: It's good to be here.
- 1:15S1: Okay. Now, you just spent a month going to World
- 1:18S1: Cup games in the US, also in Canada. And I
- 1:21S1: just wanted to ask you, what was the expectation as
- 1:23S1: you were heading over there? Like was this expectation that
- 1:27S1: that this event in particular brings people together from all
- 1:29S1: around the world, unites them in some way?
- 1:32S2: Well, FIFA likes to promote itself as football unites. I
- 1:35S2: think there was sort of a bit of apprehension, a
- 1:38S2: bit of angst about how the 2026 FIFA World Cup
- 1:41S2: would probably play out. You know, the World Cup's got
- 1:44S2: a long history of sort of having this political overtones.
- 1:48S2: You know, you go back to 1930, even when the
- 1:51S2: very first World Cup tournament that was hosted by Uruguay
- 1:53S2: was sort of used as a nation building sort of
- 1:56S2: exercise that had sort of, you know, three decades or
- 1:59S2: so of Civil War. And then they get to host this,
- 2:01S2: you know, first ever world football tournament, which they also
- 2:05S2: famously won. You go to sort of 1934, where Mussolini
- 2:10S2: used it as a bit of a propaganda tool for
- 2:12S2: his fascist regime. I think there's even sort of reports of, uh,
- 2:15S2: it being sort of the first World Cup where there
- 2:17S2: was World Cup merchandise, where the fascist logo appeared on
- 2:21S2: some of that. Um, you know, and it's got a
- 2:23S2: long history of sort of being this, uh, uh, political
- 2:26S2: device as well as a footballing one. You know, 1978,
- 2:29S2: I think is the most controversial World Cup, uh, where
- 2:32S2: the military junta in Argentina, you know, there was corruption,
- 2:36S2: you know, match fixing and sort of seen as a
- 2:39S2: sort of a form of sports washing before it was
- 2:42S2: really a phrase back then to sort of try and
- 2:44S2: legitimize the regime there that was also sort of, you know,
- 2:47S2: oppressing and killing, uh, a number of its opponents. And then,
- 2:51S2: you know, more recent times you had Russia in 2018,
- 2:55S2: which was obviously a controversial choice as Putin tried to
- 2:58S2: sort of show Russia as this, you know, open, modern, uh, accepting, uh, society, uh,
- 3:04S2: with all the other sort of, uh, stuff playing out
- 3:07S2: in the background. And then Qatar, which had its own,
- 3:09S2: you know, it was the sort of real sportswashing tournament
- 3:12S2: as it tried to become a legitimate host nation. So
- 3:15S2: 2026 was awarded, I think, in 2016, ten years ago.
- 3:19S2: And I think at the time, everyone was sort of
- 3:21S2: expecting that a return to North America, the US had
- 3:25S2: hosted the tournament, uh, quite famously in 1994. I think
- 3:29S2: everyone thought the 2026 was going to be a return
- 3:31S2: to sort of some sort of normality, or at least
- 3:34S2: some sort of, um, a more simple way of, of
- 3:37S2: hosting a tournament. They weren't going to build big new stadiums.
- 3:40S2: They were going to use existing infrastructure. It was going
- 3:43S2: to be shared across three countries, sort of united all together.
- 3:47S2: But a lot happened in those ten years since, uh,
- 3:50S2: North America and North America were awarded it. And so
- 3:53S2: I think, look, I think myself flying into North America,
- 3:57S2: there was sort of apprehension about what to expect. A
- 4:00S2: lot was made about visas. There was a lot made
- 4:03S2: about ticket prices, about just general expenses towards this World
- 4:07S2: Cup and how it would go. It wasn't helped. I
- 4:10S2: think on the eve of the tournament, I think even
- 4:12S2: the day or two days before it kicked off, the
- 4:14S2: US rejected the visa application for a Somali refugee who
- 4:19S2: had been appointed by FIFA. Sort of. One of the
- 4:21S2: top referees in Africa was told he wasn't allowed into
- 4:24S2: the country. And I think everyone was sort of bracing
- 4:26S2: themselves as to what to expect. But as the World
- 4:31S2: Cup's known to do, once the sort of the first
- 4:33S2: whistle goes, and once we started watching, you know, Mexico
- 4:36S2: play in the Azteca Stadium in Mexico City against South Africa, uh,
- 4:40S2: you know, early goals, lots of red cards. The focus
- 4:44S2: very quickly turned to football. And I think, uh, for
- 4:48S2: much of the four weeks so far, the focus has
- 4:51S2: really been on football with, you know, with a few exceptions.
- 4:54S1: Okay. So can you tell us, I guess, some of
- 4:56S1: the moments that you witnessed on the ground that really
- 4:58S1: did sort of bring about a unity or perhaps celebration
- 5:02S1: of fans from different teams or, you know, sporting solidarity
- 5:05S1: or moments like, were there many moments like that on
- 5:08S1: the ground despite all of what you've just said, which is,
- 5:11S1: you know, slight feelings of trepidation given the Trump administration's
- 5:15S1: restrictive immigration policies and people being denied visas. Like, were
- 5:20S1: there still those moments of unity that FIFA sort of promises? But,
- 5:23S1: you know.
- 5:24S2: Yeah, once once the tournament itself kicked off, I think
- 5:26S2: all of that has faded massively into the background. I
- 5:29S2: think this is sort of a been very much a
- 5:33S2: a fan driven World Cup. You know, FIFA will take
- 5:36S2: a lot of the credits. Uh, you know, we've seen
- 5:38S2: record crowds, record number of goals. We are obviously seeing
- 5:41S2: more matches. Um, but it has really been the fans
- 5:44S2: for me as someone who was there for four weeks
- 5:46S2: that have really made this World Cup, it's had 16
- 5:50S2: different sort of host cities. So it's been very well
- 5:53S2: spread out. But you've seen some, you know, pretty remarkable
- 5:56S2: things happen. You've seen Scotland in their first World Cup
- 5:59S2: since 1998, taking over Boston, you know, literally drinking the
- 6:03S2: city dry. You've seen sort of, you know, Japanese fans
- 6:12S2: down in Dallas trying Texas barbecue for the first time
- 6:15S2: and being amazed by that. You've seen Norwegian fans on
- 6:18S2: the New York subway performing there, you know, now infamous
- 6:23S2: Viking Row as they went down the escalators into the
- 6:26S2: New York subway. And so it's been a very well
- 6:30S2: spread out tournament. You've seen lots of, I guess, parts
- 6:32S2: of America. I think I was reading before that the
- 6:35S2: Spanish team, you know, one of the favorites of the
- 6:37S2: tournament have been based at, at, at at Chattanooga in Tennessee, uh, where,
- 6:42S2: you know, locals have been able to come out and watch,
- 6:45S2: you know, some of the best footballers in the world
- 6:48S2: train out there. One of the Kansas university's learned the
- 6:52S2: one of the marching bands, learnt the how to perform
- 6:54S2: the Algerian national anthem because the Algerians were based out
- 6:59S2: of Kansas University as well. The Socceroos themselves were based
- 7:05S2: out in in Oakland, just outside of San Francisco, an
- 7:10S2: area sort of a bit down on its luck in
- 7:14S2: terms of sporting teams. They've, you know, lost an NFL team, uh,
- 7:17S2: moved to Vegas. The Golden State Warriors NBA team moved
- 7:21S2: into San Fran. So the Oakland residents really embraced the
- 7:24S2: Socceroos as well. So it's sort of been this sort of,
- 7:28S2: I guess, mix of fans from around the world coming
- 7:32S2: into America and Canada into probably areas that they might
- 7:36S2: not have been previously. And also people in America probably
- 7:39S2: being exposed to, to fans and cultures that they might
- 7:44S2: not previously have expected to be exposed to either.
- 7:47S3: Okay. So can you just, I guess.
- 7:49S1: Break it down for us as someone who's been there
- 7:51S1: on the ground, what is that World Cup fever like?
- 7:54S1: What is it that sort of brings this spirit of,
- 7:57S1: I guess, just unfettered joy among people who barrack for
- 8:01S1: different teams whose countries might be at odds, uh, in
- 8:05S1: very serious ways over the generations. Like, what is that?
- 8:08S2: Yeah. Look, I think it is kind of strange. I've
- 8:10S2: been I've been trying to think about this as sort
- 8:12S2: of we talk about Australian sport and Australian sport for
- 8:16S2: mine is, is very tribal. You know, there's a lot
- 8:18S2: of heated rivalries and tension between it all. I think
- 8:21S2: there's a different atmosphere, uh, in a World Cup. I mean,
- 8:24S2: I guess if you you have to be realistic about it.
- 8:27S2: There's probably only a handful of nations that, you know,
- 8:30S2: were ever going to be a chance of, of, of
- 8:32S2: lifting the trophy. So I think there is this expectation
- 8:35S2: that everyone goes there to support their nation, to show
- 8:40S2: a bit of pride, but really to enjoy themselves. And
- 8:43S2: in the hope that that their, their country may, you know,
- 8:46S2: exceed expectations on the field and go further than they,
- 8:49S2: than they possibly could. But I mean, the Australian fans
- 8:52S2: gained a bit of notoriety over there for, you know,
- 8:55S2: obviously some of the chants there was the one which
- 8:58S2: specifically referenced Donald Trump and being a sex offender. There
- 9:09S2: is also the sort of, you know, we're flying home,
- 9:11S2: you're stuck here chant, which they made at the US.
- 9:14S2: And there was also that moment in Dallas in the
- 9:17S2: lead up to the, uh, the tense, uh, morning lead
- 9:20S2: up to the game against Egypt, where a whole lot
- 9:22S2: of Australian fans took it upon themselves to go into
- 9:25S2: and take over a Walmart and start their, um, uh,
- 9:27S2: Aussie boys, uh, chant inside a Walmart, uh, to many
- 9:31S2: shocked shoppers on a, on a early morning in, uh,
- 9:35S2: in Arlington, just outside of Dallas.
- 9:38S4: Wal mart. Wal mart.
- 9:44S2: So I think this is this is a real feeling
- 9:47S2: of fun. And you know, there are obviously countries that
- 9:51S2: go to a World Cup expecting to do well. And
- 9:54S2: and you know expecting to win. But I think on
- 9:56S2: the whole I mean, you've seen Mexican fans over there,
- 9:59S2: sort of. They do this thing where they, you know,
- 10:02S2: love to pick up a you know, they've been doing
- 10:04S2: it with TV reporters, but they've been picking up, you know,
- 10:07S2: rival fans and tossing them up into the air. Just
- 10:09S2: everyone's celebrating in a way that I think only a
- 10:12S2: World Cup can really bring people together.
- 10:16S1: After the break.
- 10:18S2: There's this sort of feeling amongst the the diaspora that
- 10:22S2: whether or not supporting the football team would also be
- 10:26S2: supporting the regime, which many are against, but they also
- 10:29S2: wanted to use the opportunity of Iran playing on the
- 10:32S2: national stage to have their voices heard.
- 10:41S5: Virginia Giuffre helped vanquish a prince and a millionaire.
- 10:44S6: And I won't stop fighting. I will never be silenced.
- 10:47S5: But one of her toughest battles was a very private one.
- 10:51S7: It was the worst thing that could have happened to her.
- 10:53S7: Her children were her life.
- 10:58S5: Virginia, a podcast from the newsrooms of the age, The
- 11:02S5: Sydney Morning Herald and WA today, out now.
- 11:09S3: We have to talk.
- 11:10S1: About some of the sporting moments either that you witnessed
- 11:12S1: or that are just absolutely a standout at this particular
- 11:14S1: World Cup, because I saw in one of the stories
- 11:17S1: that you wrote, you wrote that there was three megastars
- 11:20S1: of the tournament Kylian Mbappe, Erling Haaland, Lionel Messi. They
- 11:25S1: all scored multiple goals across three separate stadiums. That must
- 11:28S1: have just been absolutely incredible. So I guess, what is
- 11:30S1: it like to be there to see that sort of
- 11:32S1: star playing on just an incredible scale, and were there
- 11:36S1: other just moments like that that really lit up this
- 11:38S1: World Cup, I guess?
- 11:40S2: Yeah, I think that one of the successes of this
- 11:42S2: World Cup has been that all of the, you know,
- 11:45S2: a number of the big footballing superstars, like you said,
- 11:47S2: your Erling Haaland, who seems to have captured the attention
- 11:51S2: of everyone. Ah, this World Cup Kylian Mbappe, you know,
- 11:55S2: Messi scoring a hat trick days just before he turned
- 11:58S2: 39 in his sixth World Cup. You know, Harry Kane
- 12:01S2: of England, Jude Bellingham of England have all really turned
- 12:05S2: up and performed. We've also got a situation where the
- 12:09S2: four highest ranked teams in the world are Spain, France,
- 12:13S2: Argentina and England are the last four teams left in
- 12:16S2: the tournament. So, uh, it's been, you know, remarkable that that's,
- 12:21S2: you know, that FIFA has had that outcome for this
- 12:24S2: World Cup. Some may say, you know, well, there was,
- 12:27S2: you know, things put in place to make that happen.
- 12:29S2: But there's been other great moments as well. You know,
- 12:31S2: I think everyone was sort of captivated by the run of,
- 12:33S2: you know, Cape Verde in their first World Cup, you know,
- 12:36S2: a tiny nation making it through to the to the
- 12:39S2: knockout stages. And, you know, even when when Curacao managed
- 12:42S2: to score its first World Cup goal against Germany, it
- 12:45S2: was one all against Germany. I think everyone was kind
- 12:47S2: of shocked that, you know, ended up losing that game
- 12:50S2: by a fair margin. But there's been moments like that
- 12:52S2: which there was a lot of criticism about, well, maybe
- 12:56S2: not so much criticism, but concern about whether or not
- 12:59S2: expanding the World Cup from 48 teams from 32 would
- 13:02S2: see a dilution in the sort of quality of games
- 13:06S2: and and how the tournament would play out. But I
- 13:09S2: think largely it's been it's been a massive success. And
- 13:13S2: for those reasons, you've seen a number of countries that
- 13:16S2: previously hadn't appeared at World Cups get to play and
- 13:19S2: and perform pretty well. You've seen other countries, you know,
- 13:23S2: for a long time, Oceania didn't get an automatic spot
- 13:25S2: in the World Cup. But New Zealand obviously got to
- 13:28S2: play again at this World Cup. So there's been, I think,
- 13:32S2: the quality of football. And I think the 48 teams
- 13:35S2: has worked, which I think has been another highlight.
- 13:38S3: I wanted to ask.
- 13:39S1: You about something you wrote about as well, which is
- 13:41S1: a complicated emotional element of this particular World Cup, which is,
- 13:44S1: of course, the presence of an Iranian team when, of course,
- 13:48S1: Iran has been at war with the host country, with
- 13:50S1: the United States. So what was that tension like on
- 13:52S1: the ground?
- 13:54S2: Yeah, I didn't really probably fully know what to expect
- 13:58S2: going into this game. So this was the first time
- 14:00S2: that a that a host nation in the US was
- 14:03S2: at war or a military conflict with a with a
- 14:06S2: participating nation in Iran. And they, uh, a lot of
- 14:11S2: sort of talk in the build up to the tournament.
- 14:12S2: Iran qualified sort of back in March last year, long
- 14:15S2: before any of the the strikes by Israel and the
- 14:18S2: US against Iran had had begun. And there was a
- 14:22S2: lot of talk about whether or not Iran should be
- 14:23S2: able to compete in this World Cup. Uh, they were
- 14:26S2: kicked out of their training base, was meant to be
- 14:29S2: in Arizona. They got moved to Mexico. And so I
- 14:33S2: went down to, to LA, to the SoFi Stadium, not
- 14:37S2: really knowing what to expect. But, you know, LA has
- 14:40S2: the largest, uh, Iranian community outside of Tehran or outside
- 14:44S2: of Iran. There's something like 125,000 Iranians living in the area.
- 14:50S2: And it was a very divided group of people. So
- 14:54S2: there's this sort of feeling amongst the diaspora that whether
- 14:59S2: or not supporting the football team would also be supporting
- 15:03S2: the regime, which many are against. But they also wanted
- 15:07S2: to use the opportunity of Iran playing on the national
- 15:10S2: stage to have their voices heard. FIFA tried to ban their,
- 15:15S2: you know, certain flags and symbols from inside the stadium.
- 15:18S2: So I was sort of outside the stadium. And you'd
- 15:21S2: speak to, you know, a mother who was there with
- 15:23S2: her son who said, oh, you know, I can't really
- 15:25S2: support the team. I'm just here to have my voice heard.
- 15:27S2: And then you turn to her son and he'd say, oh, no,
- 15:30S2: you know, I'm a former soccer player myself. I know
- 15:32S2: what these players have done to get here. I support
- 15:34S2: the team, but I don't support the regime. And I
- 15:37S2: spoke to another bloke as I was leaving who had spent,
- 15:41S2: I think it was something like 600 USD to be
- 15:43S2: there just to boo the national anthem and to jeer
- 15:45S2: the team as they ran onto the field. So it
- 15:47S2: was a very, yeah, complex situation. And, you know, I
- 15:54S2: sort of sort of almost hard to describe. Literally any.
- 15:57S2: Every person you spoke to there would have a different
- 15:59S2: view on the Iranian team and whether or not they
- 16:02S2: should be competing and whether or not they should be
- 16:04S2: supporting them. And, and, you know, many others opted to
- 16:07S2: stay at home because they didn't want to even be
- 16:08S2: be seen to be part of it. So it was
- 16:10S2: very complex and difficult situation.
- 16:12S1: But I'm assuming there was nothing like we saw during
- 16:14S1: that that women's cup here. Of course, famously, there was
- 16:17S1: a number of, uh, members of the women's team that
- 16:21S1: were looked like they were in the process of going
- 16:22S1: to defect. And I believed some of them stayed on
- 16:25S1: after being granted humanitarian visas. But there was nothing like that, though,
- 16:29S1: was there, uh, in the USA with Iranian players during
- 16:32S1: the World Cup?
- 16:33S2: No. And they had pretty strict restrictions put on place,
- 16:36S2: I guess, to sort of prevent any of that sort of, uh,
- 16:39S2: incident like that possibly taking place. The, as part of
- 16:42S2: their visa restrictions, the Iranians were only allowed to fly in,
- 16:45S2: I think, the day before a match and, uh, had
- 16:47S2: to fly out straight afterwards, which the team, uh, and
- 16:50S2: the coach complained about sort of saying no other team
- 16:53S2: should be had been subjected to, situations like this. But
- 16:56S2: I think that was, you know, in part to just
- 16:59S2: ensure that there wasn't any sort of issues around defections
- 17:02S2: or any other sort of political fallout from having the
- 17:05S2: Iranian players in the US.
- 17:07S1: It's really interesting. And Nick, just to wrap up, I
- 17:09S1: wanted to ask you about what we might see, I guess,
- 17:12S1: at the 2030 World Cup, because as you mentioned earlier,
- 17:14S1: this World Cup had 48 teams, and FIFA president Gianni
- 17:18S1: Infantino mentioned the other day that the organization is considering
- 17:21S1: having 64 teams for the 2030 World Cup. So tell us,
- 17:26S1: I guess, what you think might be the risks of
- 17:28S1: having that many teams. You know, is it going to
- 17:30S1: dilute the fun you know, or or the quality.
- 17:33S2: Well, you know, more fans, more fun possibly. I mean,
- 17:36S2: 64 is a lot. Uh, I think it's something like
- 17:39S2: more than, than 30% of, of, uh, of all FIFA
- 17:42S2: sort of countries who are playing football at the moment. 64. Uh,
- 17:47S2: does seem a lot. You've got to obviously find the
- 17:50S2: facilities and the infrastructure to, to host that many games. Uh,
- 17:54S2: I think 2030. We're already looking at a game, a
- 17:58S2: World Cup across three continents, because it will be 100
- 18:01S2: years since the first World Cup. I think they're playing
- 18:03S2: some games in South America, and then the rest will be, uh,
- 18:07S2: shared between Morocco, Spain and Portugal. Look, I think the
- 18:12S2: 48 teams has worked quite well, 64. There are some
- 18:16S2: reasons why it might work. Um, you know, it's a
- 18:19S2: cleaner number of teams. There's been a lot of, you know,
- 18:21S2: not to get too into the weeds, but there's all
- 18:23S2: this sort of maths around how a third place team
- 18:26S2: gets through to the knockout stages and, and, you know,
- 18:28S2: 64 teams gives you, you know, a cleaner number to
- 18:31S2: get to 32. That's the top two teams in every group.
- 18:34S2: But uh, yes, there's already talk about how how possible
- 18:39S2: it is for a. Well, I don't think, I don't
- 18:42S2: think a solo country could host a World Cup by
- 18:44S2: itself anymore. And then if you're getting to 64 teams, however,
- 18:48S2: any matches that works out to be finding base camps
- 18:51S2: for all those teams, finding stadiums to host all those games.
- 18:55S2: It's a big logistical exercise, but if there's one thing
- 18:59S2: we know with FIFA is that they make most of
- 19:01S2: their money, if not all their money from from a
- 19:05S2: World Cup and 64 teams probably means bigger broadcast deals,
- 19:10S2: more ticket sales, more merchandise, everything else. So if there's
- 19:14S2: money to be made, I don't doubt that FIFA will
- 19:17S2: take a a very long look at this if it's
- 19:20S2: not already possibly happening.
- 19:27S1: Thank you so much, Nick, as always for your time.
- 19:30S2: Thank you.
- 19:34S1: In other news today, Education Minister Jason Clare has categorized
- 19:38S1: the job ready graduate scheme, an attempt by Scott Morrison's
- 19:42S1: government to steer students away from the humanities to the
- 19:45S1: sciences by restructuring the cost of degrees as unfair and failed,
- 19:51S1: investing in more fossil fuels and halting wind and solar
- 19:54S1: farms could cut 5% from electricity costs by 2050, according
- 19:59S1: to the CSIRO, but would increase atmospheric pollution and accelerate
- 20:04S1: global warming. And in the past 40 years, there have
- 20:08S1: been ten property downturns, with seven lasting less than a year.
- 20:13S1: This time, experts are tipping that prices will keep falling
- 20:16S1: until there are signs of an interest rate cut, which
- 20:18S1: could be some time away. You can read more at
- 20:22S1: the age.com.au or smh.com.au. Today's episode was produced by Kai Wong.
- 20:31S1: Our executive producer is Tammy Mills, and our podcasts are
- 20:34S1: overseen by Lisa Muxworthy and Tom McKendrick. If you like
- 20:38S1: our show, follow The Morning Edition and leave a review
- 20:41S1: for us on Apple or Spotify. Thanks for listening.