Latest / Newcomer Pod / Inside Amazon’s $100B Automation Gamble
Transcript
- 0:00Is AI not nearly as powerful as some companies would lead us to
- 0:03believe? We're recording this episode hot
- 0:05on the heels of one of Andre Carpathi's AI State of the Union
- 0:08interviews. I'm only sounding pessimistic
- 0:10because when I go on my Twitter timeline, I see all this stuff
- 0:13that makes no sense to me. It has us reflecting on the
- 0:16vastly different takes people are having about AI.
- 0:18On the one hand, you have the New York Times reporting that
- 0:20America's biggest employer is moving towards complete
- 0:23automation, while on the other, we're seeing AI failing to
- 0:26impress. In today's episode, we want to
- 0:27look deeper into the power behind the potential a bubble
- 0:30we're seeing. But first, we'll be discussing a
- 0:32recent article written by Madeline Renberger in which she
- 0:35takes a deep dive into how Andreessen Horowitz are making
- 0:37off like such bandits. We'll look into the results
- 0:40they're expecting to end the year with and what moves they
- 0:42made to get nearly $25 billion in gains since its founding.
- 0:46This is the newcomer podcast. All right, Madeline, we've been
- 0:58diving deep into Andreessen's numbers over the last couple of
- 1:03weeks on Newcomer. And couple weeks ago we had a
- 1:07big story with a lot of their kind of unrealized and realized
- 1:10returns. But the question that came out
- 1:12of that story was like, but really how much was distributed
- 1:15back-to-back to partner, sorry, back to investors, which we now
- 1:19have a much more clear read on after the story that you and
- 1:22Eric did so. This is real venture nerddom.
- 1:25You know they absolute well. How is Andreessen doing?
- 1:28Yeah, you can see markups, but then, you know, we get feedback
- 1:31from our readers like, but what's the actual cash?
- 1:34How does they? Mean the real Yeah.
- 1:35What's a reasonable thing to want to know more about?
- 1:37I mean, this is always the question about venture, right?
- 1:39Especially in an era where, you know, there's not a lot of IP OS
- 1:43and you know, actual cash returns are like a big question
- 1:46for all of these companies. So what do we, what do we got in
- 1:49Andreessen? What did we, what did we learn
- 1:50from your piece? Yeah.
- 1:52So it's really a tale of where they made money kind of lands
- 1:56into two buckets. There's all of the funds pre
- 1:592014. So their first few funds, those
- 2:02have done incredibly well. And post 2014 crypto has done
- 2:07incredibly well. And that's basically the story
- 2:10of Andreessen's actual cash back to investors.
- 2:13I would say, you know, the first fund was spectacular.
- 2:16It has returned as this was of course, as of end of 2024.
- 2:20But they had returned 6X on the investment to investors from
- 2:25their first fund. That included their Skype exit,
- 2:28a couple other, you know, really big deals.
- 2:30But like it's that they really showed their money there.
- 2:33Like that first fund out of the gate.
- 2:35Super impressive, kind of set their reputation.
- 2:37Always good. If you start a venture firm, you
- 2:39want to, you want to come out of the gate strong, and they did
- 2:41that. And you should subscribe to
- 2:42newcomers. You can see the whole chart.
- 2:44We have all the numbers. You can follow along.
- 2:46And I think one thing I'm proud of in this story is that we got
- 2:50sort of the Cambridge Associates benchmarking data.
- 2:52So you not only see how Andreessen's doing, but at the
- 2:55same time what was sort of the top quartile and top 5% DPI
- 3:01distribute distributed to painting capital for venture.
- 3:05And you know, in this first one, Madeline's talking about
- 3:08Andreessen is 6X DPI at the time of this, you know, September
- 3:142024. And then top quartile is 2.37 X
- 3:19and then top five percent is 3.98 X.
- 3:23So by any measure that first fund that came out of the gate
- 3:26strong. The second fund, they're in the
- 3:29top quartile, but not the top 5%.
- 3:32The third fund they're in both the top quartile and top 5%.
- 3:36So that's that's the early days. Yeah, the early days, super
- 3:39impressive and yeah, they're basically like in the one, I
- 3:42won't go into direct averages, but like the very top of
- 3:45performance. These first funds, which is what
- 3:47you obviously want to see going forward.
- 3:50Obviously the closer we get to the present, you're not going to
- 3:53see as big of returns, right. But even their, you know, core
- 3:572016 fund which is almost 10 years old has a DPI of just .3.
- 4:02So we've gone from 6X on the first fund to .3 where you
- 4:06really should start seeing cash. So that one has really
- 4:10underperformed. I mean, it's below the median,
- 4:12so it's not even the top half of performance.
- 4:15With and those funds are bigger. I think a key thing with the
- 4:18Andreessen story is that they get more and more money, right?
- 4:20It's like they do well in the beginning and then they're like,
- 4:22screw, like the benchmark model and this small model of venture
- 4:25capital, we're going to get huge and we're going to raise a bunch
- 4:27of money. And so part of what you want to
- 4:30know as somebody covering Andreessen Horowitz, the, you
- 4:32know, the most prolific investor now in Silicon Valley, founded
- 4:37in 2009, you know, run by Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz,
- 4:41this epic venture capital firm. You want to know it's like, OK,
- 4:44they did well in his small venture capital.
- 4:47Are they going to do well as a huge sort of money manager?
- 4:50And those funds are not performing.
- 4:53You know, the 2016 fund is worse than what you're saying, even
- 4:56the median, right? So that is, yeah, it's not doing
- 4:59great, right. And then a lot of venture,
- 5:02Andreessen or or otherwise hasn't really returned a lot of
- 5:05money in, you know, the last nine years.
- 5:08I don't. Know I was going to say even as
- 5:10you to your point, as they've gotten bigger, they've expanded
- 5:12into other verticals. And so they have these biotech
- 5:15specific funds and obviously we're kind of in a biotech
- 5:17winter right now, but those have really underperformed even just
- 5:21the rest of the Andreessen portfolio, they're not doing
- 5:24well. I feel like, you know, they're
- 5:26capital halls that they've, you know, raised multiple bio funds,
- 5:28but even the first one is just not doing as well as the rest of
- 5:32these. But I will say the big asterisks
- 5:34and the big saving grace for these later funds for Andreessen
- 5:38is their crypto funds. The crypto funds, which began in
- 5:412018, have just done just so much better than all of these
- 5:46other recent funds, and they show cash back to LP's faster
- 5:50than the typical venture cycle. Flipping tokens, you get you
- 5:55invest equity and the you know, the businesses, but then you
- 5:58also get these tokens and you can sell them.
- 6:00I will also in our first and recent story, which you should
- 6:02also subscribe to the newsletter to read, we had they're making
- 6:06this staking revenue, which I only half understand.
- 6:08I'm sure some crypto die hard will listen to this and be like,
- 6:11duh, staking. But you know, they're they have
- 6:14money riding in these crypto projects and they they throw off
- 6:16millions of dollars of cash as an investment firm, just, you
- 6:19know, holding tokens and getting staking income.
- 6:22So they're, yeah, they're making a lot on crypto and it's it's
- 6:26been a boon for the firm. LP, though, how excited are you
- 6:31to be like basically getting paid back via crypto like token
- 6:35flipping? I guess like money is money and
- 6:37if you're getting what you want back, you're fine to a degree,
- 6:40But it doesn't seem like you're really fully indexed like across
- 6:42the tech, you know, ecosystem the way you might want to be if
- 6:45you're just getting like, you know, basically coin flipped.
- 6:48You couldn't get more index than Andreessen Horowitz.
- 6:51I don't know. I reading this.
- 6:54You know, if I was an LP, would I deploy in Andreessen?
- 6:58I wouldn't want them to bully me into bio.
- 7:00I guess that would be. But yeah, I think you get a
- 7:03broad coverage of venture capital and private technology
- 7:08for a fund that has proven that they can get sort of top access
- 7:12and has top performance. And then you just worry that
- 7:16this, I think you have to make this sort of question is like
- 7:19is, has the technology business gotten so much bigger to justify
- 7:22these much larger funds? And like, that's still playing
- 7:25out. And that's the question.
- 7:27You know, firms like CO2 and Tiger Global, you know, they
- 7:31raise enormous funds and sort of the pandemic, everything's
- 7:36digital frenzy of 2021, late 2020.
- 7:41And those funds haven't done very well.
- 7:44And so it seemed like, oh, we didn't need all that money.
- 7:46Andreessen has sort of kept kept sort of growing.
- 7:50And so I think there's this question about sort of large
- 7:53private investing. But I do think on a relative
- 7:56basis, Andreessen has done pretty well.
- 7:59Right. It's too early to.
- 8:00I was going to say, yeah, I agree.
- 8:01I think for the early funds, I certainly would have wanted to
- 8:04invest in those funds. What the big asterisks in the
- 8:07big test is that it's too soon to have any measurable DPI or
- 8:12cash back from these post 2020 funds.
- 8:15And that's when everything ballooned.
- 8:16So to your point, these mega funds, you know, off of the
- 8:20success of these early deals, they're raising more and more
- 8:22capital and they've raised, you know, they closed like a multi
- 8:25billion dollar crypto fund. This first crypto fund that
- 8:27returned super well was in the hundreds of millions.
- 8:30So the scale of can they replicate these impressive even
- 8:33token flipping returns, you know, well is remains to be
- 8:37seen. And does that mean you'd go buy
- 8:40in now? I don't know.
- 8:41But they are in every major tech deal.
- 8:43They do have the access which is part of the buy in right?
- 8:45And I, I do think there's value if I'm a limited partner to, you
- 8:50know, getting visibility like data bricks becomes a key
- 8:54company for Andreessen Horowitz. If I'm a limited partner in
- 8:57Andreessen, they keep backing up the truck into data bricks.
- 9:01Maybe one day I say, oh, I should, you know, if I'm a super
- 9:04wealthy, you know, sovereign wealth fund or if I'm a
- 9:07university, I say, oh, we'd like to jump in and do our own, you
- 9:11know, investment following on. So, so you get visibility into
- 9:15what's coming up. And then you can try, if you're
- 9:17savvy to sort of jump into winners yourself with the Intel
- 9:21you get. So they're non monetary reasons
- 9:25to invest. But but yeah, I think, you know,
- 9:28the days of Journal, I mean, Andreessen Horowitz comes on the
- 9:31scene in 2009 really loud and says like, you know, tech is
- 9:36much bigger, this whole world's going to get much bigger.
- 9:38And there are a bunch of the reporter class that was worried
- 9:41like bubble, bubble, bubble. And I think they were right.
- 9:44Like 22,009 to 2016 was a great time to invest funds did well,
- 9:49there is money to be made. And like a lot of the bubble
- 9:53concerns were misguided. And so I think, yeah, looking
- 9:58back on that period of worry on Twitter and, you know, just
- 10:02among sort of the chattering classes and tech observers, I
- 10:05think Andreessen was pretty right and the naysayers were
- 10:10were wrong. I don't know, Tom, what it as
- 10:13somebody who sort of watched the discourse, what's your?
- 10:16Take on that. Give us the discourse, yeah.
- 10:18Look, I, I think Andreessen, I think loud is the right word to
- 10:21use, right? I mean, they came onto the scene
- 10:23and and this was Marc Andreessen's software as eating
- 10:25the world declaration, which did prove for a time to be
- 10:30incredibly accurate. And sure, I mean, we talked in a
- 10:33previous episode about some of their key investments that
- 10:35worked out for them. There was Airbnb, a lot of the
- 10:38partners, by the way, they were behind these big investments are
- 10:40not there or the kind of not active with entries, which I
- 10:43think is worth pointing out to me.
- 10:46What's matters now, it's like we're talking about like you're
- 10:49saying, funds that are over a decade old now.
- 10:51So, so, and this just sort of is where my mind is going
- 10:55constantly with all of these funds right now with AI is like
- 10:58how strong is your portfolio within AI?
- 11:02And if you look at, you know, the spectrum of their
- 11:04investments that they have right now, correct me if I'm wrong
- 11:06here, but the banner ones that I see from Andreessen right now is
- 11:09they are an open AI. So they do have some, they do
- 11:12have some, some equity there, whatever.
- 11:13But they weren't like a core early.
- 11:15They weren't like so right about opening AI and in fact their
- 11:17crypto obsession blinded them a little I think to some of the AI
- 11:21stuff like they pivoted loudly, but I think they there's a
- 11:24little like, you know, we're decentralized and AI is
- 11:28centralized and there so there's this if you're close, close
- 11:31Swatcher, there is a little hesitation I think from the firm
- 11:33before. They were late, but they've
- 11:35bought up a pretty significant holding at this point.
- 11:39They can make a strong case to their LP's that they have
- 11:42exposure to to open AI. That should make them feel
- 11:44pretty good. Right, and they're in, I think
- 11:47they're big in XAI, they're huge thinking machines like, and
- 11:50they're in, you know, a lot of, I think like Replit, they're in
- 11:53Replit, you know, which is coding application type company
- 11:56that will speak at Cerebral Valley.
- 11:57But you know, they were in that, you know, several pivot or
- 12:01several moods ago for, for the company.
- 12:04So they, they have a, you know, portfolio of very recognizable
- 12:08names that are in the Silicon Valley zeitgeist where you look
- 12:11at, you know, some of these other firms, you know, if no,
- 12:15no, I mean Sequoia. I'm, I'm more saying like
- 12:17General Castle and Lightspeed, Like if you look through their
- 12:19decks, which we have also published in Newcomer, the AI
- 12:23names are a bit more random. And I think Andreessen's AI
- 12:27investments are names that you would know partially because
- 12:31Andreessen does a good job of making sure we hear them.
- 12:33We do know that I actually think lightspeed is OK.
- 12:35They're a little, there's a little bit of randomness with
- 12:38them, but they're, you know, they're big in in they're an
- 12:41anthropic. They they led some previous
- 12:42rounds there so they can. And they're and they're like
- 12:45their business. They're good at like real
- 12:46business. So often it's like, Oh yeah, we
- 12:48haven't heard of them because they're wonky going to make
- 12:50money. Whereas the Andreessen companies
- 12:52are a little bit more like in in the zeitgeist, I think.
- 12:54Yeah. Lightspeed I think is in like
- 12:55Glean and all other a couple of these other like enterprise
- 12:58tools that are like doing quite well, yeah.
- 13:00Actually, Eric, I'm interested in your thoughts here because
- 13:03you have like a good kind of, you know, higher altitude view
- 13:06of maybe where VC is trending. But do you think in some ways
- 13:10Thrive has kind of taken the mantle of like the loudest, most
- 13:13banner company oriented firm where it seems like they
- 13:16basically go very heavily into things like open AI and in a
- 13:20much more public way and probably more money than than
- 13:23Andreessen has. They're in Stripe, obviously.
- 13:26They've just done a good job of grabbing drives.
- 13:27Crushies. I mean, I think like you, there
- 13:31are in some ways like the benchmark of today.
- 13:35They're not like Benchmark in that they have tons of money,
- 13:38but like Benchmark in that they're small.
- 13:41You get to work with the actual people.
- 13:43There aren't a lot of like Andreessen is like who are all
- 13:45these people? Like your names aren't on the
- 13:46firm. Like I feel like Thrive is
- 13:48small. You're working with somebody.
- 13:50There's a sense that like you're working with the firm, like
- 13:52you've got at it and like, you know, that, you know, Josh looms
- 13:55super large there and Thrive has been able to pull in money from
- 13:59everywhere. Yeah.
- 14:00So and you know, I sort of teased them in one of the
- 14:03newsletters that they were like the top tick investor of the
- 14:06year. I forget what year that was, but
- 14:08they've been, you know, I don't some random deals, but like
- 14:10click house and there's just a lot of things where they were
- 14:13saying, oh, this stuff is going up and AI has gone up.
- 14:15You know, they they were bullish correctly.
- 14:18And again, I think a lot of being in VC is being bullish,
- 14:23you know, at the right time, you know?
- 14:26They've also kind of taken the mantle of being like the string
- 14:29pullers within tech, too. I mean, I don't know how much
- 14:31you want to go into it on this episode.
- 14:33And, you know, we've also been out.
- 14:35We should tell our listeners that Eric's been gone for a
- 14:36while on paternity leave. So what he knows about, you
- 14:40know, anything happening right now is time he's taking away
- 14:42from his new daughter. But you know, Thrive got this
- 14:47very gauzy profile published in a magazine that I had, not
- 14:52Colossus, which I I I don't really know exactly what it is.
- 14:55Seems like some sort of a industry trade magazine that
- 14:58publishes puff pieces on. It's very much in my media
- 15:01entrepreneur radar. I mean, Patrick O'Shaughnessy
- 15:04has a great podcast and he's built out a sort of media
- 15:07company. Yeah.
- 15:09Yeah. The article is very glossy,
- 15:11though. Yeah.
- 15:11Yeah, and, and, and, you know, I, I encourage people to try to
- 15:14read the whole thing because I couldn't do it.
- 15:17But, you know, the fact that this was, you know, and, and
- 15:20they, they're very difficult to to profile as, as a fund and,
- 15:23and they're, you know, jobs. They're definitely precious.
- 15:26They're very precious, yeah. They they don't give a lot of
- 15:29media openings, if you will. Yeah, and but to be clear, I can
- 15:33say this on the show, I like a lot of the people there and and
- 15:35when I've talked to them, they're they're very friendly.
- 15:37It's not like they're a mysterious cabal of people.
- 15:39They just are pick and choosey about their publicity.
- 15:43But they kind of by doing this Colossus profile, they sort of
- 15:47did the Andreessen thing, you know, like going direct, like
- 15:49they kind of actualized it. Like whereas Andreessen spent so
- 15:51much time building up a media entity.
- 15:53I understand that was something that they owned.
- 15:55But all the attention and momentum has headed, like we
- 15:58say, toward thrive right now. And they're also getting really
- 16:01nice articles written about at least Josh and the fund.
- 16:05And to me, it's like you, you see them owning the moment so
- 16:08much better than almost any other fund right now.
- 16:11And. I wonder where somebody
- 16:12Andreessen, to me, still has done the best on media.
- 16:15Like, I mean, they're a machine. They're huge.
- 16:17They're sort of synonymous with technology and venture capital.
- 16:23It'll, it'll be interesting. I mean, you know, they're Mark
- 16:27and Ben are still very active. So they have that going for
- 16:29them. They have a podcast, they're out
- 16:31there. You said earlier, like some of
- 16:33the people who've done the key and recent investments you were
- 16:35talking about like Jeff Jordan with Airbnb.
- 16:38But I think for the most part, a lot of them are there.
- 16:40I mean, Chris Dixon is the crypto guy.
- 16:42He did Coinbase. That was key like Ben did data
- 16:46bricks. Like I don't know a lot.
- 16:48Some of the key investments they are still around the hoop, but
- 16:52But Dr. Andreessen yeah, they're both they're both strong.
- 16:55I'm not I'm not I don't think this like Colossus profile of
- 16:59Josh. It like moves the needle that
- 17:02much. I don't know I I think it's good
- 17:04like Colossus like I think it's cool that they like prioritize
- 17:07writing and like people can be pro entrepreneur.
- 17:10I think we're in this era where it's like all the journalistic
- 17:14defensiveness about like a sort of captured media.
- 17:18I don't know, it's everywhere. Yeah, we talked about that a lot
- 17:22last week with Mike Solana. I, I guess the issue with
- 17:26Colossus was more, less the profile itself, which like, you
- 17:29know, your mileage may vary on how much you like that style of
- 17:32writing, but it was more like the declaration that like you
- 17:34don't need media anymore and you know, there was a.
- 17:39But I just think there's a sense among some of the text set and I
- 17:42think arena, which is another one of these publications.
- 17:46They're like, oh, the great thing about magazine is it's
- 17:48like it's glossy. It's like somebody's smart was
- 17:52paid to write something and then your picture is there and that's
- 17:55that's it. Like, you know, it's like the
- 17:57text is like, well, well composed.
- 17:59I don't I don't know. I feel like they miss the fact
- 18:02that it's like that somebody truly independent, that somebody
- 18:05is hard to persuade was persuaded that you're like cool
- 18:09and good. That's that's to me what what
- 18:12matters in a lot of these media, like marketing media sort of
- 18:15entities. They they give you the Sheen.
- 18:18They're like, oh, it's the good writing.
- 18:19It's glossy, like you're great because somebody who's totally
- 18:22captured and is destined to say positive things about you said
- 18:25something positive. Like I, I just don't think
- 18:27that's going to have people know who's like independent and whose
- 18:31voice is like, oh, wow, you had, I mean, you know, that's
- 18:33certainly what I'm trying to create here, which is like,
- 18:37we're, we say what we think, we criticize people when we're
- 18:40persuaded. You know, Andreessen and I,
- 18:41we've thought about tons of stuff.
- 18:42They freeze me out all the time. Like, but I went and we say, oh,
- 18:46the performance looks pretty good.
- 18:47Like the, the idea is that should carry some weight because
- 18:50it's like, there's this whole history.
- 18:51I have plenty of reasons just to needle them, you know what I
- 18:54mean? Whereas when you're getting this
- 18:56glowing profile from sort of an entity that's interested in
- 19:01writing positive things about entrepreneurs and investors, how
- 19:06much weight does that carry? Yeah, you're talking, I mean,
- 19:08it's kind of style over substance, right?
- 19:10Like the depth of where this is coming from.
- 19:14It has all the trappings of, you know, a glowing magazine profile
- 19:17with none of the actual gravitas behind that of, you know, the
- 19:21solid reporting backing up the. Reputation and none of the oh,
- 19:24this could have been a really negative piece and like they
- 19:27were they like them, you know, you need a little bit of that.
- 19:30It could have gone in different ways, right?
- 19:32Right. Yeah, especially with, you know,
- 19:34a successful firm or and a rich person who's married to a
- 19:37supermodel. Like, you do kind of need to
- 19:39overcome the inherent skepticism of a reader to make a better
- 19:43case as to why you care about them.
- 19:45If it's an audience that's already like, man, these guys
- 19:47are great and look how great they are.
- 19:49They they're telling me, I will say journalistically as someone
- 19:51who covered, because one of the elements of the story of Thrive
- 19:54was the role that Josh Kushner played in, you know, Sam
- 19:57Altman's ouster from Open AI, exactly how much string pulling
- 20:01he did to get him back on board. I had some qualms with the way
- 20:05it was described and I understand everyone is the hero
- 20:07of their own narrative and right, you know, even though
- 20:11it's. Funny that it's the same moment
- 20:12Jared Kushner is clearly trying to get tons of credit for this
- 20:15Israel deal. Both the Kushner's are like
- 20:18savvy and that Jared's getting in the New York Times in places.
- 20:21But both are clearly like moments of crisis.
- 20:24We're we're here. Yes, you could really trace the
- 20:26Israel Gaza deal back to the time in which Josh Kushner
- 20:29personally got Sam reinstalled back.
- 20:32That's the head of opening the eye and you're like, well, I got
- 20:34to top this somehow. What's what's on my list?
- 20:37Oh, wait. Peace in the Middle East.
- 20:39Yeah, yeah, TBD on that one, by the way.
- 20:42But anyway, look, I, I by the way, the ratings apparently go
- 20:46down on the podcast when we talk too much about media.
- 20:48So I don't want to. I don't want to.
- 20:49Dwell too much on this one. I did it.
- 20:51I'm sorry. It's my fault.
- 20:52We can't help ourselves. It's navel gazing.
- 20:55But but Andreessen look, I think the AI story is is still is
- 20:58still like everyone else is still to be told they have some,
- 21:01you know, exposure to a lot of top companies.
- 21:04I'm interested to see where the XAX AI1 in particular will go.
- 21:08But you know they. Lost Igor Babushkin, who was
- 21:12like one of their key executives.
- 21:13We're having one of their Co founders speak at cerebral
- 21:17valley on November 12th coming up so I'm we'll we'll be excited
- 21:20to hear how things are going XAI on stage.
- 21:25But yeah, it's a, it's a company that I, you know, I think people
- 21:30had underestimated and I was like.
- 21:33I did I say it? Big things are coming and they
- 21:36they caught up, but then I feel like, you know, we need to see
- 21:40like revenue and stuff like that come out of the company.
- 21:43Yeah, anyway, we'd love to do more stories on other VC funds
- 21:47returns, TVPI and DPI. Please keep sending them our way
- 21:51and. Subscribe and you know our
- 21:53readers and our listeners, you guys are in the business.
- 21:55You know as much about this as we do.
- 21:58Please send me you know well your commentary is anonymous.
- 22:01You know, if you say off the record, I'll take it off the
- 22:03record. Please send me your observations
- 22:06on what what you think the return where you think the
- 22:09returns are strong and weak would be eager to hear from you.
- 22:12We're just, we're all at newcomer.co, Eric.
- 22:15Yeah, we all have takes. You know, yeah, feel free to
- 22:18weigh in. Speaking of takes, let's check
- 22:22in on the state of hype within AI and where we're at in the
- 22:25cycle right now. It's been an interesting couple
- 22:29of weeks on that front. So we had Andre Carpathy
- 22:33appearing on the Dwarkesh podcast giving his, you know,
- 22:38fairly clear eyed. I wouldn't say skeptical or
- 22:43negative takes, but it definitely got a lot of people
- 22:45in the industry trying to either defend AI or claiming that they
- 22:49knew all this whole time that it was overhyped and not quite it
- 22:53was promised to be. It's an interesting piece also
- 22:55in the New York Times about Amazon and their plans to
- 22:58automate a lot of their back of house processes, which is of
- 23:03course, you know, robotics, but but AI as well.
- 23:06And then a lot of stuff going on with open AI.
- 23:09And I mean, they're just a non-stop hype train over there
- 23:12with. There's a browser claiming.
- 23:14Have you tried any kind? Of browser they're they're
- 23:18claiming that they're solving unsolvable math problems.
- 23:20It's basically just, you know, Matt Damon and, and and goodwill
- 23:23hunting, but. So isn't Matt Damon good at math
- 23:27in goodwill hunting? Yeah, well, so was.
- 23:30So was the claim of open AI people?
- 23:32Yeah, No, I think it is. Well, I think the Karpati thing
- 23:35kind of summed up his appearance on Dork Ash and his statements
- 23:38and kind of everyone's, you know, having a take about them
- 23:42from both the hype and the skepticism.
- 23:45It's not going far enough. It's sort of like if you give a
- 23:47nuanced state of play in the industry to someone, everyone is
- 23:51going to have a problem with it depending on where they're
- 23:53coming from. Because he basically was saying,
- 23:56I think, you know, that based on his understanding at the
- 23:59technological level, things are very impressive.
- 24:01We still have a lot to go bullish on AI overall, but AGI
- 24:06is not going to show up in 2027 like Dario and some other
- 24:10founders of the other big AI labs have said.
- 24:13And I think, you know, that level of nuance was certainly
- 24:17optimistic. He wasn't pessimistic.
- 24:19I think it was framed everywhere like he, you know, is shitting
- 24:21on the future of AI and thinks it's all wrong.
- 24:23But. When Andre Carpathy speaks, the
- 24:26AI world listens. You know, this is the guy who
- 24:29came up with the term vibe coding.
- 24:32I think he's very intelligent and very sort of plain spoken
- 24:37and direct. He's not someone who puts all
- 24:40these sort of false linguistical complications into his speech.
- 24:43He sort of says what he's thinking.
- 24:45He's trying to speak directly. And so I think just his style of
- 24:49communication, his obvious intelligence and how close he is
- 24:53to the development of this technology, people take what he
- 24:55has to say very seriously. And he's not.
- 24:59You know, we have people like Dario and Anthropic who, you
- 25:03know, I like he's spoken at Cerebral Valley.
- 25:06There's a lot to like about Anthropic but has made Santa.
- 25:09Roman politically too. I mean, he's like, yes.
- 25:11Yes, exactly. He's fighting with David Sachs.
- 25:14Everyone who fights with David Sachs, you know, enemy to my
- 25:17enemy. But the but you know, he's made
- 25:20some Dario has made some pretty grandiose predictions about the
- 25:25rate of AI improvement that I think at this point are not
- 25:28coming true at at that rate of improvement.
- 25:30And Sam Altman, obviously at open AI, you know, sometimes
- 25:34he's saying we're overvalued and sometimes, but he's always like
- 25:38talks in such big terms that it feels like hypey.
- 25:41Even when he's not being hypey, it feels like it's big.
- 25:44We need trillions of dollars. You know, we need more money
- 25:47that's been ever raised sort of thing.
- 25:49And so I think, you know, this Carpathy interview had a little
- 25:52bit more realism, which is a stance that, you know, we've,
- 25:57we've taken in Cerebral Valley, which is just sort of like it's
- 26:00clear if you really work with, you know, Chachi BT clawed the
- 26:04models. There's a lot of capability
- 26:06there that, you know, if it had a little more guardrails, if it
- 26:10was handed to the consumer in a more prepackaged way.
- 26:13It seems, you know, we've seen that with coding, with all these
- 26:16coding applications, if if you do that work, you connect it to
- 26:19data, there's a lot of value to be had there.
- 26:22And so I think, you know, the Andre point of view was like,
- 26:26there's still all this value to be had connecting with the
- 26:28models can do right to, you know, all this technology and
- 26:32all this data, but this sort of sense that they're gonna get so
- 26:36much smarter. We're gonna have AGI tomorrow.
- 26:39He was he was pushing back on. That I think the point that he
- 26:42really landed on here was in regards to agents, right?
- 26:45There's tons of venture capital hype around agents.
- 26:48Agents are being pitched everywhere is the next big
- 26:50thing. He basically said the industry
- 26:53is kind of overshooting the tooling with its present
- 26:56capability, which anyone who's kind of used these agents that
- 26:59are like claiming to be travel agents and book everything and
- 27:01do multi steps for you new already.
- 27:03And so it's kind of refreshing to have this very serious voice
- 27:07of technical leadership in AI speak to you honestly and say,
- 27:11yes, the agents are not quite there.
- 27:13That does not mean that AI is, sorry to the skeptics, all not
- 27:17going to work and won't ever get there.
- 27:19It's just the timelines we need to be a little more realistic on
- 27:22and we need to explore different technical angles to make these
- 27:24things work. And maybe we haven't figured
- 27:26those out yet. Well, the rise of agents was
- 27:29something super interesting to me when I was covering
- 27:31enterprises, enterprise businesses at the Wall Street
- 27:33Journal, because you basically saw the trajectory of AI go
- 27:37from, you know, Chachi, BT comes out.
- 27:39It's a consumer phenomenon. Microsoft built their own search
- 27:42engine and then basically Copilot was the term at that
- 27:45period. These were assistants that sit
- 27:47alongside you and can make you more efficient and can make your
- 27:50job that much easier to do or help you write e-mail, shit like
- 27:52that. And then with no major, in my
- 27:55opinion, technical breakthroughs between the Copilot era agents
- 27:59just sort of appeared on the scene.
- 28:01And suddenly these things that were like debatable as to how
- 28:04good they really could work became even more essential and
- 28:08autonomous in what they were supposed to do for you.
- 28:11And the technology didn't seem like it took, you know, a major
- 28:13leap. And so I was kind of scratching
- 28:16my head this whole time seeing Microsoft specifically go from
- 28:20like, oh, we have this copilot tool and everyone should pay
- 28:23extra for Microsoft 365 so you can use their copilot too.
- 28:26Oh yeah. Now you're supposed to use
- 28:27agents where it does all the shit for you.
- 28:29You know, obviously you want to show you that you're an AI
- 28:31forward company because that you get a premium on your stock.
- 28:34And so you have to make all kinds of statements when it
- 28:36comes to utility of this shit. Like they were just starting to
- 28:39figure out Co pilots and so now you're gonna start claiming
- 28:43there's agents. I just updated my Apple
- 28:45operating system, right? And if there's any company
- 28:47that's trying to force this AI thing that doesn't seem to have
- 28:50a view of what the actual value it drives, it's Apple, right?
- 28:54It promised all these phones based on Apple intelligence and
- 28:58they, they haven't really figured out what the value is.
- 29:01And it's like, you know, they they mess with your contacts and
- 29:04they say, oh, here's who we think.
- 29:05But it's like, I had a nice favorite list.
- 29:07It was organized how how is your like smaller, weirder version
- 29:11better than like my nicely organized 1.
- 29:13And so, yeah, IA lot of these companies have an incentive to,
- 29:18to force an AI narrative. I mean, Tom, you just wrote
- 29:22about Salesforce, which, you know, Marc Benioff has been like
- 29:24agent force, agent force, agent force.
- 29:26I mean, he's been the most sort of egregious in terms of just
- 29:30having, you know, the name of his company AI.
- 29:32You know, he's a, he's a sales guy, you know, he knows how to
- 29:36try to associate, but that that sort of heavy-handed approach
- 29:40hasn't resulted in a good stock performance.
- 29:43No, certainly not because they're stuck in this position
- 29:46where, you know, you see the rise of these agents or AI
- 29:49companies. And it's like either someone
- 29:51like a sales force is going to be able to, you know, leverage
- 29:54off of that and be able to sell these tools to the customers.
- 29:57Or there's going to be a whole new wave of tools built by not
- 29:59sales force that are just going to replace all of SAS.
- 30:02And you've seen there would be like a negative feeling about
- 30:05SAS for like the last year or so because of that worry.
- 30:09But the knock on sales force is that their agents don't work
- 30:13right. It's just like you're selling a
- 30:14product to people that have no real utility.
- 30:16It gets stuff wrong all the time.
- 30:18And, and I think that's what Carpathy was really trying to
- 30:21get at in his comments was like, look, there is a world in which
- 30:25agents have incredible impact on the economy and the way we do
- 30:29work and, and jobs and and the labor grid and all of these
- 30:33things, but we're not there yet. And if you're selling it to
- 30:35people now with the claim that it's, you know, 11 tick away
- 30:39from AGI and one tick away from being able to replace a huge
- 30:42percentage of your workforce, you're bound to be disappointed.
- 30:44It's going to fuck everything up.
- 30:46And I, I don't know. You know what's interesting to
- 30:50me with his comments is like how much of the hype around AI and
- 30:54the amount of money that Sam is consistently able to raise or
- 30:57stock jumps that he's able to generate through announcements
- 31:01are built on the premise that AGI is just around the corner.
- 31:04Like how much value is there in just a good utility for the next
- 31:085-10 years if AGI just doesn't exist on the timeline that
- 31:12people like Dario have been claiming?
- 31:14I. Know we still have some of those
- 31:16Edzitron fanboys hanging around just being like, what is this
- 31:19podcast I I still, you know, think the models themselves are
- 31:24so valuable. I talked to Chachi PT all day
- 31:26long like is it not like a key part of your lives?
- 31:30Like I feel like it's extremely valuable on day-to-day questions
- 31:34relative to like Google. I don't know, Yeah.
- 31:38You guys don't agree or? No, I use it.
- 31:41I use it quite a bit. I've used it for helping me
- 31:44figure out like recipes and stuff.
- 31:46And it's a much better search tool for a lot of things.
- 31:48But it's not even search because it does generate for you what
- 31:51you need, you know, and provide things for you.
- 31:53And it helps me, you know, proofread and things like that.
- 31:56I found it to be an incredibly useful tool.
- 31:58But I guess I do agree too, I think Kaprathi was getting at,
- 32:03which I think is where we land here is he, he was landing at
- 32:06how these can be great assistance and tools and this is
- 32:10an evolution and they are better.
- 32:12But what the problem is is you want it to make fewer.
- 32:15He actually wrote this in his post.
- 32:17I want it to make fewer assumptions and ask, collaborate
- 32:20with me when not sure about something.
- 32:22I want to learn along the way and become a better programmer,
- 32:25not just get served mountains of code that I'm told worse.
- 32:28And I was like, that's kind of the through where we're kind of
- 32:30digging out of right now. But.
- 32:32But that doesn't mean at all that these aren't useful tools.
- 32:34Right. What do you want?
- 32:36What do you guys make about Dario and his claims 'cause he's
- 32:40doesn't have an amazing track record right now of like
- 32:43timelines of when stuff is going to happen.
- 32:45And the thing that I keep thinking about was his claim, I
- 32:48think a year ago that basically at this time now more than 50%
- 32:52of code would be generated by AI.
- 32:53And I don't know what the actual number is, but everyone was
- 32:56dunking on that because we're clearly not even close to that
- 32:59right now. And it reminds me of yeah, yeah,
- 33:02and it reminds me of, you know, the, the, the self driving era
- 33:07where there were also outlandish claims about the timeline it
- 33:13would take for this technology to be St. ready and, and and and
- 33:17they were way off. And I was super bearish about
- 33:19that. To be clear, at the time I was
- 33:21in Ubers in 2016, I was like, they're intervening all the
- 33:24time. We are not about to be in Ubers
- 33:26without. Well, Uber, Uber in particular
- 33:29didn't have record audit like their tech was bad.
- 33:32But that's when they had the acquisition was auto, yeah.
- 33:35I mean, there was a period where Uber was really trying to assert
- 33:39that it was going to be the leader in self driving.
- 33:40And I think I mean, you know, and come at us at Zitron haters
- 33:44or the haters that Edwardson brought to the podcast.
- 33:46But like I, you know I. Think I'd like to say to them
- 33:49they're they're shooting at us in the comments.
- 33:51It's our fucking podcast. We can talk.
- 33:53We're supposed to talk like whatever.
- 33:55They just want to hand over the mic to somebody else.
- 33:57Yeah, anyway, go on. Yeah.
- 34:01Get your piece on Eric that's. Your back, yeah, they're still
- 34:04comments on that episode. They.
- 34:05Can shit on me as much as they well, we're just talking about
- 34:08AI bullishness or not. I'm fine with the negative
- 34:10comments. I love the comments that are
- 34:12like, I can't believe they've left the comments open.
- 34:14It's like, yeah, we can, we have thick enough skin that we can
- 34:16take a little bit of criticism. What I don't get is that on my
- 34:20on our own podcast, we're not supposed like, wait, just
- 34:24because you know that guy and he's on our podcast, we're not
- 34:26just like handing it over to him to just say whatever he wants
- 34:29the whole time. I.
- 34:29Don't know, I'd like to see the tail of the tape.
- 34:32I like Ed and we've continued. We let him talk so much.
- 34:35Yeah, he had a lot of time. He had like the time of
- 34:38possession was strong for Ed in. That episode.
- 34:40So I have no idea a new. Objection.
- 34:42Like if you're having like a through line argument, you need
- 34:45to hold some. It's like we're arguing about
- 34:47this thing and then you make points around it.
- 34:49He would just be like, oh what about energy, you know?
- 34:51Ohh anyway, I'm still still having flashbacks, clearly.
- 34:55Look, anyway, I'll, I'll bring these haters back here and
- 34:57saying like, I think self driving cars are really
- 35:00impressive. I think I I do pay a premium in
- 35:03San Francisco if I can take a Waymo versus an Uber.
- 35:07And a lot of the promises, yeah, the timelines are way off, but
- 35:10the technology did pan out to be non economical.
- 35:13There's all kinds of issues around like, you know, how much
- 35:15it costs to run these things. But like it proved itself at a
- 35:17different timeline than was initially predicted.
- 35:19And I guess the question is with with AI, you know, is there a
- 35:23timeline that does make sense that that someone like Carpathy
- 35:26agrees with where we do reach AGI?
- 35:27Or is this capability of, you know, these models were Tachi BT
- 35:32is now, which does seem like it's leveled off quite a bit.
- 35:36Is that enough to, you know, meet the, the hype of something?
- 35:40You know, it may not be to the level of displacement, but like
- 35:43there's a lot of utility. We're all seeing that in in
- 35:45these tools. And like, where does evaluation,
- 35:47you know, net out with that sort of thing?
- 35:48And I don't think he has an answer to that, but that to me
- 35:52is the question we should be asking in the next year or two.
- 35:55Hysterical, though unlike self driving cars, our whole economy
- 35:58seems staying on this question. Right self driving cars were
- 36:01more of like on the side. These companies can do this.
- 36:03This was a fad. And with this I do see.
- 36:06It is. Right.
- 36:06You know, kind of. Maybe you got a little annoyed
- 36:08that it's like, oh man, these companies are getting profiles
- 36:12that act like they're, you know, geniuses when it like they can't
- 36:15do what they say they can do. But like now I think we're
- 36:18underrating self driving cars. But the but the yeah, the AI
- 36:22stuff right now, I mean, just Nvidia's the most valuable
- 36:24company, you know, in the world. It's it so much of our economy
- 36:27hangs on continued adoption of artificial.
- 36:32And, and specifically CapEx spending on data center growth
- 36:35and that's like I would say 80 to 90% the responsibility of Sam
- 36:40and striking all these deals that are basically, you know,
- 36:44deals upon deals of, of data centers to be built.
- 36:47And so like, yeah, the point I guess you're making is like,
- 36:50yeah, it does need to be more than where it's at now.
- 36:51Like you're not going to be building all these data centers
- 36:54because AGI won't exist like that is, well, we'd like to.
- 36:57See another leap? You know, it's like, OK, Chachi
- 37:00PD has been great coding's cool, but like, I feel like our minds
- 37:05haven't been blown, you know, a little bit right?
- 37:08I mean, we we get impatient. When's the next the video stuff
- 37:11is mine the. Video I was gonna say sora was a
- 37:13big leap for the new sora app it you can still which.
- 37:17Is still number one on the App Store by the way I checked.
- 37:19Is it OK? Interesting, yeah, I see.
- 37:22I see the ones that make it over to TikTok but I I don't love
- 37:26them like. Well, there was, I will say
- 37:30this, this deep, this Sora video of like a a pastor, you know,
- 37:34condemning billionaires went pretty viral over this week that
- 37:39a lot of people fell for, including a lot of my.
- 37:41Friends, yeah, I like they are getting reality.
- 37:43Like I already hated the like I hate those.
- 37:46The people love those like skits where it's like clearly these
- 37:49are actors, but they get mad at it in the comments.
- 37:52You know what I'm talking about where it's like, yeah, it's like
- 37:54a husband and wife are fighting or something.
- 37:56But like all the comments, it's like, you know, treat it as if
- 37:59it was like real where they're like, this guy's a jerk or
- 38:01whatever. You know, it's like, but these
- 38:02are clearly actors. I feel like the sort sort of
- 38:05thing is like the next evolution of it.
- 38:06I just hate the media consumer that like buys into the fiction.
- 38:11Like they don't, they don't care like if it's real or not.
- 38:14They're like, oh, it feels real. And so I'll just react to the
- 38:17character. Because it's like.
- 38:18Wouldn't it be great if you. Know this is happening.
- 38:20There's been a there's been a tick tock meme, I don't know if
- 38:23you've seen it, of umm, putting various historical figures in
- 38:28the NBA and talking about how like their career is sort of
- 38:30ending. So it's like Queen Elizabeth and
- 38:33like in Celtics jersey being like I'm just sort of old now
- 38:36and like her like at the. Podium talking about.
- 38:38Tiring. And then it cuts to it's really
- 38:41fucking funny. I laugh every time like it's
- 38:43there's one with Queen Elizabeth, Winston Churchill.
- 38:48Who else has there been anyway? But so I watched them and I was
- 38:51like trying to show Rosa them and she's like, this is stupid.
- 38:54Stop showing this to me. But I and I feel kind of gross
- 38:57after I watch them too. Like I laugh at it.
- 38:59And then in the moment I was like, this truly is slop.
- 39:01I mean, this is the lowest form of of entertainment.
- 39:04And I understand these things will evolve over time in terms
- 39:07of acceptance culturally. But as it stands now, like,
- 39:10yeah, it does entertain me. I do laugh, but I don't feel
- 39:13good about it. But but the dream is that this
- 39:15is like some Tom specific video, like the dead.
- 39:18They've figured out some sliver of human psychology, and for
- 39:21some reason you think this odd thing is funny.
- 39:24And then they can target us all and we get all these weird like
- 39:27Freudian, like, oh, I like, you know, you, you have this weird,
- 39:30I don't know, yeah, it's just funny to me that you, you find
- 39:33it amusing. You haven't found many other
- 39:34people who find it funny. It's like this is this is the
- 39:37real dream of these AI generated videos that they can micro
- 39:40target everybody and. Right.
- 39:42And then? The panners to each of us.
- 39:45And it's engineered to be addictive, which is why there's
- 39:47like, you know, this existential fear in Hollywood over like, how
- 39:50can we compete against this, right?
- 39:52If it's all about a battle for attention, It's really hard to
- 39:55say like original story versus thing that like is almost to the
- 39:59precision of a casino in terms of how it.
- 40:02What is your attention amazing about language models that they
- 40:06haven't got enough credit for is that they were all built around
- 40:09the truth. They were trying to be like, how
- 40:11can we not hallucinate? How can we be as accurate as
- 40:13possible? Unlike, you know, social
- 40:16networks, which were built on engagement.
- 40:18And it's like, we'll deliver whatever we can get you to stay
- 40:21engaged. Obviously, AI is more and more
- 40:23involved in that, but we'll use the fact that the content has
- 40:26been created by humans as our excuse that we don't have to
- 40:30worry about the accuracy of these humans created it, even if
- 40:32we decided to distribute some of it and not others.
- 40:36And now obviously, something like Sora, you're like, screw
- 40:39it. Like let's just do something
- 40:41based on engagement. And that, you know, that's a
- 40:44dark path. Well, right.
- 40:46And then the question is, and I talked to Varun Shetty, who's
- 40:50the head of media partnerships and Open AI about this.
- 40:53Like are we supposed to view something like Sora as an off
- 40:57ramp as just sort of like some entertainment to the side while
- 41:01you guys are pursuing your path towards AGI or is it critical
- 41:04towards getting there? And his argument was the latter
- 41:06is that like, actually you can gain a huge amount of
- 41:08information about the real world through generating videos.
- 41:12And I don't know the, the training process that it takes
- 41:15to do that, which is controversial on its own.
- 41:18And so that point it's like, we'll improve it.
- 41:21Like you guys have made this viral Sora app that has gotten a
- 41:24ton of people addicted to it still number one on the App
- 41:27Store. Like right now Open AI has the
- 41:28number one and #2 slots on the App Store.
- 41:31Like you guys should really be getting towards AGI now, like
- 41:34'cause this is all just an off ramp towards slop and
- 41:36entertainment and replacing of social media at the very least.
- 41:39That's disappointing to investors and, you know, society
- 41:44at large. I'm sure it takes a huge amount
- 41:46of GPUs to get this stuff done. But yeah, it's like, I think
- 41:50they need to keep reminding people.
- 41:52And I think it's good for people like Karpati to keep talking
- 41:55about that is like, we know what the goal has to be.
- 41:57Let's keep in mind what the you know what the timeline is and be
- 42:01clear eyed about overhyping it. But like this is not about
- 42:05creating slob. I, I wanted to talk about, you
- 42:08know, the New York Times did this story on Amazon that
- 42:11basically said, you know, Amazon is set on automating a bunch of
- 42:15its workers. You know, Amazon, I think is the
- 42:17second largest employer in the United States, a company that
- 42:21really believes in robotics, already has many robots and
- 42:24they're driving to have even more robots doing work and that
- 42:29this is part of their grand strategy.
- 42:32And obviously there are robots that are not built on language
- 42:35models, but you know, the improvements with foundation
- 42:39models and language models have improved computer vision and now
- 42:44in some cases they're powering robots entirely.
- 42:46And so we're seeing improvements in robots relate powered in some
- 42:51cases by AI that could mean more automation.
- 42:56I'm curious what reaction you guys had to that story.
- 43:00I mean, this has sort of been a long time coming for Amazon.
- 43:03Like they have been building up their workforce.
- 43:06It's always been this kind of flex situation where they, like,
- 43:09over hire during the pandemic, and then they had to lay a bunch
- 43:11of people off and that caused a huge amount of turmoil there.
- 43:14But there's no question that long term, this business wants
- 43:18technology allowed, you know, robots to be able to put stuff
- 43:23on and off shelves or whatever. That's where it was going to go.
- 43:26So I was kind of surprised to see people mad about it.
- 43:28I understand, like, yeah, people losing their jobs is an
- 43:31upsetting prospect. But certainly given that it's,
- 43:34you know, to your point, probably one of the largest
- 43:37employers in the US, but at the I, I guess I agree with you,
- 43:40Tom, I was kind of surprised to see people kind of freak out
- 43:45about this story in that it seems like that's definitely was
- 43:49the goal the whole time. I don't know it, it's as if it
- 43:52was something new, you know, as if it was something new that
- 43:54automation is where this was going.
- 43:55It's just smarter automation, frankly, for.
- 43:57A lot. I just hated how ominous the
- 43:59story was. Like, I don't, yeah.
- 44:02I mean, Amazon's going to try and do things as cost
- 44:05effectively as possible. What?
- 44:07What? What else?
- 44:09Yeah, I mean, there, you know, and this one is more realistic
- 44:12than, like, drone delivery or other things that, you know,
- 44:14Amazon was more public about. But it's weird to see.
- 44:19You know, I remember, like, height of the pandemic, everyone
- 44:21was looking at the way that Amazon was hiring all these
- 44:24people. And remember that movie Nomad
- 44:26Land came out where you had Frances Mcdormand's character
- 44:28working temporarily as like an Amazon, which was done with
- 44:32partnership with Amazon. So it wasn't an anti Amazon
- 44:35thing. But we were all kind of
- 44:36wondering like, Oh my God, is like that going to be the new
- 44:39blue collar job for everyone across the country?
- 44:41And I, it's weird to see people looking at a job that previously
- 44:47we thought was like beneath the dignity of most human beings.
- 44:51And, you know, they're anti union.
- 44:52And that really pissed off a lot of people.
- 44:54The working conditions are really terrible.
- 44:56People were like, you know all the expose about people peeing
- 44:59in bottles to get the delivery quotas met, that kind of stuff.
- 45:02A lot of outrage about the jobs before.
- 45:05Yeah, and you know, Amazon did respond to that stuff and start
- 45:08paying people more, you know, out of public pressure from
- 45:10people from like Bernie Sanders. And remember AOC was
- 45:13successfully got Amazon to not build HQ 2IN and around New
- 45:17York, which kind of was an early win for her in the left wing
- 45:20movement. So I, yeah, I don't know, like
- 45:25this is just the direction of technology and has been for like
- 45:28dozens of years. They've automated huge portions
- 45:31of assembly lines in, in, in car manufacturing and stuff too.
- 45:35I mean, this is not like skilled labor in most respects.
- 45:39This is putting stuff in boxes. And I'd love there to be a world
- 45:42where people that had those jobs had more intellectually
- 45:45inspiring things to do or there's a Ubi that gets people
- 45:48to do other things. I mean, that to me seems a more
- 45:51reasonable conversation than worrying about, right?
- 45:55Companies should automate boring, dumb stuff nobody wants
- 45:59to do, and we should elect politicians who create a safety
- 46:02net so that every American has healthcare and nobody starves.
- 46:05But we shouldn't handicap Great American companies and say they
- 46:09can't use current technology to, you know, get me my, I don't
- 46:14know, battery packs here slightly faster or whatever.
- 46:18I ordered from Amazon, you know, in the last last day or two.
- 46:22Yeah, I don't know. And true leftists, I think,
- 46:24understand that as well. I mean.
- 46:25Do they, I don't know, I just feel like what annoys me about
- 46:28this kind of story is the, you know, the haters from both
- 46:31sides. The haters are like AI sucks and
- 46:34AI is killing all the jobs. It's like, which is it?
- 46:36That's that's what drives me crazy.
- 46:37This sort of like just ominous people who feel like they're
- 46:41driven by like ominous vibes and just like depressives reacting
- 46:45to everything with that is their sort of lens and then find a way
- 46:48to be negative about everything. That that's what drives me crazy
- 46:53just socially and interpersonally.
- 46:54I realize it's a small concern, but that's why these, I don't
- 46:58know, the The New York Times story just had that sort of like
- 47:01negative feel. It's like what?
- 47:03Yeah. Yeah, I understand the concern
- 47:07and fear about it. I mean, if we are talking, I
- 47:09mean, there are cities that were basically destroyed economically
- 47:13because of, I mean, globalization, but also the
- 47:16automation of a lot of jobs Like Detroit, you know, in many ways
- 47:19has not really recovered from many of these kind of third
- 47:23party assembly line businesses, not, you know, meeting as many
- 47:26people on the line as they used to.
- 47:28And, you know, I, I don't think the job of a union should
- 47:31primarily be to stop the progress of technology.
- 47:35I'm seeing a lot of this happening in Hollywood too,
- 47:36right, With AI. It's like, what role does a
- 47:38union have to play when you start to see a potential job
- 47:42displacing technology come about?
- 47:43And really, your job is to protect the livelihoods of the
- 47:46people who you know are affected by it.
- 47:49But trying to stop something from existing just doesn't.
- 47:52It doesn't fit with like the March of time.
- 47:54There's just not great success stories of stopping technology
- 47:57from existing so. I well the worst ones are these
- 48:00attempts to stop like ports from automating moving like
- 48:05containers around which is just insane.
- 48:08Oh, like the dock workers unions and.
- 48:10Yeah, yeah. Trying to block, you know, the
- 48:13automation of ports, which in our entire economy rests on
- 48:17moving these things in and out. Yeah, I feel like they should
- 48:20also be looking more at like the types of entities that are
- 48:22buying ports in America, which are like also fairly insane.
- 48:26I mean, you have a huge amount of Middle Eastern money
- 48:27essentially buying up and building new ports in the
- 48:30country. It's the only people who are
- 48:31investing in that sort of stuff. So I'd be more interested
- 48:36following the money there rather than saying we need to protect
- 48:39man. I don't want to get the dock
- 48:41workers pissed off at us and get that.
- 48:43Really. Comment section is full of
- 48:44Steven. No.
- 48:45People who the dock. Workers.
- 48:47Finding our podcast No. I'm not a union diehard, I.
- 48:53Know I'm the leftist on this podcast too.
- 48:55Wait, I'm the former Union maiden, but.
- 48:58Are you? Yeah.
- 48:59Yeah. Maiden was the title.
- 49:02Was my nickname. No, no, I was involved in the
- 49:05Business Insider union, but I feel like the attitude there has
- 49:09always been, you know, much more just, I guess not wanting your
- 49:13job completely automated. But it wasn't resistant to AI
- 49:17coming into The Newsroom at all. It was just like, how do we use
- 49:20this strategically? Do we use this to actually write
- 49:22copy? That's kind of the line that we
- 49:24land on, but you know, for brainstorming.
- 49:26And I mean, I feel like as an editorial rule, you know, I
- 49:29think it's kind of where it's landed in a lot of other news
- 49:32companies to, you know, not having, you know, plug your
- 49:36story into ChatGPT and just publish it, you know, not being
- 49:39what's expected of you well. Within journalism to like the
- 49:41types of jobs that an AI could do or would be doing or again,
- 49:45not very good jobs. I mean, certainly copy editors,
- 49:49yeah. I don't even think those people
- 49:50were part of the BI union, but it's like.
- 49:52They were but your article. Yeah, our human copywriter still
- 49:56generally outperforms Chachi BT, but.
- 49:58They chachi BT yeah is not quite as doesn't catch all the pieces
- 50:02as as a. Copywriter also, it hasn't.
- 50:04It's hard to teach it, obviously our house style and things like
- 50:07that, but I'm sure that's solvable.
- 50:09All right, anyway, that's our episode.
- 50:11Thanks Eric for for dropping on in.
- 50:14I think I don't know what are you going?
- 50:15To be in for a. Couple more episodes or what's
- 50:16the no? No, I'm back.
- 50:18Well, we're next. We're going to I think Cerebral
- 50:20Valley is going to take over the podcast.
- 50:22Max Child and James Wilsterman will be back on.
- 50:25We have, we love doing our draft of AI startups.
- 50:28So if you thought this was, you know, somewhat pro AI, we're
- 50:32about to take AI by the fire hose for the next couple
- 50:37episodes. So that'll be a lot of fun.
- 50:39I mean, we're, you know, we're going to be prepping for all
- 50:41these interviews with the CEO's of top AI companies.
- 50:45We have execs from Anthropic, XAI, Replit, Versal Speaking and
- 50:52so. We're Co versal.
- 50:53I'm sorry, I didn't know this is that.
- 50:54Yeah, Guillermo is speaking. All right, Guillermo, we got
- 50:57some questions for you. Interesting photo OPS that I'm
- 50:59sure will come up at some point in the conversation.
- 51:02She's. Just we, well, we have both
- 51:04Amjad at Replit and Guillermo Versal speaking, but I think
- 51:07we're and they've feuded a little on Twitter over
- 51:10international politics, but that is not the theme of our
- 51:14conference. We're talking about AI, but
- 51:16yeah, they. I don't think they're.
- 51:18On the same panel. No, no.
- 51:20And I don't think we're putting them next to each other.
- 51:22This isn't. This isn't Dario and David Sacks
- 51:24showing up at the Benioff party last week.
- 51:26Oh, how was that? Did they interact?
- 51:29Nope, Nope. And Dario?
- 51:30I overheard him. Here's a blind item for you.
- 51:33Dario kind of muttering to, I believe his PR person.
- 51:36Why am I here? Oh my God.
- 51:41So we we love a good pairing here at here in tech, but
- 51:45specifically at the the newcomer sub Repo Valley conference.
- 51:48Yeah, so that'll be fun. And this comes out.
- 51:53Oh yeah, this will come out this week.
- 51:55I, I should have a post in, in the newsletter about my child.
- 51:58I, I, I've sort of, you know, I, there's an Instagram post, you
- 52:02know, they're, they're bread crumbs, but I will talk about
- 52:05having a child and I've quietly been on paternity leave.
- 52:08I appreciate you guys stewarding the podcast in my absence.
- 52:11It feels you had some good episodes and I think we keep
- 52:14learning and improving the show and we've been punching up
- 52:17production and so excited to yeah, pick up from where you
- 52:21guys left off and keep keep growing the audience and
- 52:24improving the show. And we love your feedback.
- 52:27We subscribe to the newsletter, follow along and definitely tell
- 52:31us what's working. You know, we want we want
- 52:33feedback. What do you like?
- 52:33What don't you like? Send us an e-mail.
- 52:36Alright, thanks everyone. See you next.
- 52:38Week. Alright, thank you.
- 52:39See you. Bye.
- 52:39Thank you for tuning in to this week's episode of the podcast.
- 52:42If you're new here, please like and subscribe.
- 52:44It really helps out the channel. Listen in for new episodes every
- 52:46week, wherever you get your podcasts.