Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / Can I Say That Why Free Speech Matters From Dr Cloe Carmichael
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: It's all in one location. Ero dot net A r
- 0:03r oe dot net. I've talked about hosting seventeen different
- 0:06podcasts for how many years, and it's been like, well,
- 0:09where are they at? I don't know, just google it. Well,
- 0:11that's not a good idea ero dot net, A r
- 0:14r oe dot net. Good morning, doctor, How are you
- 0:17doing today?
- 0:19Speaker 2: Hey, I'm great, Thanks so much.
- 0:21Speaker 1: You do realize how important this book is, right because
- 0:23we are in an age where we've got a bunch
- 0:25of introverts taking on people that are extroverts, and somewhere
- 0:28in the middle there's silence and it's like, oh, but
- 0:32the doctor is up to something, Miss Chloe.
- 0:35Speaker 2: Yes, I think that's very well said. I'm glad that
- 0:39the topic clicks for you.
- 0:41Speaker 1: Well, it clicks with me because I've dedicated my soul
- 0:43to being in the public eye. But the problem is
- 0:45is I'm getting a lot of shrug shoulders, eyes that
- 0:47are rolling, people that would rather return to their smartphone.
- 0:50And when I stepped inside your pages, I'm going, this
- 0:52is the answer, this is what I've actually been looking for,
- 0:55because now I can utilize the tools and Doctor Chloe
- 0:59can step through that door and help these that are
- 1:01going whenever you only live once.
- 1:06Speaker 2: Well, thanks, Erro, I'm so glad to hear that. I'm
- 1:09glad you're excited about the topic.
- 1:11Speaker 1: Well, I mean your research in here is spot on.
- 1:13When you talk about eighty four percent of Americans believe that,
- 1:17you know, is that we're talking cancel culture, We're talking censorship,
- 1:20We're talking about serious issues. Eighty four percent of Americans
- 1:24know what's going on. But what are we doing about it?
- 1:29Speaker 2: Well, I think that they know what's going on, but
- 1:31they think that the safe move then is to just
- 1:34you know, stay quiet. And so my book is to
- 1:37help them realize that that's actually not the safe thing.
- 1:40That there's a mental health cost to stifling yourself, you know, repressions, depression, denial,
- 1:46actually loneliness as well, when we are you know, masking
- 1:49our true selves from people. So I want them to
- 1:52understand that if we really care about mental health, that
- 1:56doesn't mean everybody's shut up and be in a safe space.
- 1:59It means actually we learn how to be ourselves and
- 2:02let other people be themselves.
- 2:04Speaker 1: How many people had my dad for a dad who
- 2:06would look at me straight in the eye and say,
- 2:08do not speak unless you're spoken to and it's like,
- 2:11oh okay, and then I got into radio boy. I
- 2:13didn't listen to him, did I?
- 2:16Speaker 2: Well, yeah, you have it so special skill set. They're errow.
- 2:20Speaker 1: I mean, because I mean you're talking about the five
- 2:22tools of self restraint. Oh my god, this is so
- 2:25what's going on in the world. Because people are more
- 2:28apt to thinking, I've got a voice, I can say
- 2:29whatever I want. Now restrain it so I can listen
- 2:32to you, so I can patiently sit here and together
- 2:34we can create a solution.
- 2:37Speaker 2: Exactly. So I want people to understand that too, is
- 2:40that you know, we're not talking about having no filter here,
- 2:43that there's a difference between self censorship, which is where
- 2:47you're really holding back on true things that actually matter
- 2:49to you in terms of your values, versus you know,
- 2:52healthy self restraint, like you don't have to like literally
- 2:55say everything to everybody all the time. That there is
- 2:58a happy medium. But I think right now people are
- 3:01just so scared by cancel culture that they're just they're
- 3:04going too far into the silence, or they're making other
- 3:09people think that they have to be silent, you know,
- 3:11like the speech police type people.
- 3:14Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, doctor Cloyd. Do you know how many creative
- 3:16people from musicians to actors to even directors are telling
- 3:19me when I say, are you going to step out
- 3:21and speak? Oh no, no, no, no, no, no, I'm good.
- 3:23I'm good. And it's like, don't say that. Don't be
- 3:26afraid of cancel culture, because I mean, it's like, we've
- 3:29got to be able to keep moving forward here. That's
- 3:31who we are.
- 3:33Speaker 2: Totally. And you know, though, to be honest, I didn't
- 3:36even get this. As a clinical psychologist. I used to
- 3:40just do a lot of self censoring because I had
- 3:42a lot of big relationships in the media and you know,
- 3:45big business and getting a PhD in clinical psychology in
- 3:49New York, there's a lot of opinions, you know that
- 3:51you have to just keep to yourself, and so I
- 3:53just had done that so often without even realizing the
- 3:56toll it was taking. And then one day, with some
- 4:00COVID issues, I had just had enough and I spoke
- 4:03up and I was like, wow, like this is different.
- 4:06You know, there's cognitive benefits, there's emotional regulation benefits, all
- 4:11these you know, kind of network issues, and I said, wow,
- 4:15how could I have missed this that, like, of course
- 4:17we need to be authentic.
- 4:19Speaker 1: I would like to know how many families have been
- 4:21damaged by this, because I mean, first of all, we
- 4:24always called my sister she was mouth. That was her
- 4:26name in the family. She would say things right off
- 4:28the top of her head. And what do you say
- 4:30right here in your book? Relax your body and your mouth,
- 4:32Just relax it. But the thing about it is, though,
- 4:34when you talk about the mental health issues here, how
- 4:36many families are broken up and they're not going back.
- 4:39That is a mental health issue that needs to come together.
- 4:42Because we've all been family. We can't break up and
- 4:45not see each other again totally.
- 4:48Speaker 2: And so that gets into this whole confusion around the
- 4:50phrase that words are violence. That's why I think many
- 4:54families are getting broken up. And there's something called the
- 4:57five d's, which is different on social media, disinviting a speaker,
- 5:02declining to date, dropping contact altogether in real life, or
- 5:06just distancing contact in real life. And there's a certain
- 5:09group of people that are statistically a lot more likely
- 5:12to do that over political differences. And that same group
- 5:17of people is also statistically a lot more likely to
- 5:21endorse political violence against people that disagree with them. And
- 5:26so I think that you're really onto something there of
- 5:29noticing that there's a rift in families, and it's because
- 5:34of this whole idea that people have about you know,
- 5:36words or violence. And if you know my parents voted
- 5:39for somebody I didn't like, then I just have to
- 5:42uproot them out of my life. And I really believe
- 5:46they mean well, but they're misguided. They think that this
- 5:50is the road to a healthier, compassionate society. And I
- 5:54want them to know that cutting off dialogue is actually
- 5:57the worst thing we can do. If we want to
- 5:59have a peaceful, harmonious society, we have to learn how
- 6:02to have disagreements but still have respect for one another.
- 6:07Speaker 1: Please do not move. There's more with doctor Chloe Carmichael
- 6:10coming up next the name of a book. Can I
- 6:14say that we're back with doctor Chloe Carmichael. What is
- 6:17the best way to handle this, Doctor Chloe in the
- 6:19way of when somebody does come at you with something
- 6:22that you don't believe in. Because we all know the
- 6:24political world, and because I'm very quick to say, well,
- 6:27I understand your point of view, I want to listen
- 6:29to your point of view because I think you've got
- 6:31something I need to learn. And when I learned from
- 6:33that you have to take the time to listen to
- 6:35my side of the story. Am I am I? Am
- 6:37I a fire starter?
- 6:39Speaker 2: No, No, that's perfect. I love it because, as you said,
- 6:42if somebody comes at you with something that you disagree with,
- 6:45by definition, you know you have you expressed yourself, are
- 6:48coming at them with something that they disagree with. So
- 6:51it goes both ways. So I think what's helpful. There's
- 6:54a technique in the book called reflective listening. Yeah, so
- 6:57what you do then, and is you just say, hey, look,
- 6:59I think think we see this issue very differently, but
- 7:02I want to make sure we're not talking past each
- 7:04other because did you know that when people's heart rate
- 7:07goes above one hundred beats per minute, which it often
- 7:09does in heated discussions, they literally cognitively cannot comprehend fully
- 7:14and accurately what the other person is saying. So to
- 7:17solve that, you say, let's do the reflective listening technique.
- 7:21You say what you believe, and then I will just
- 7:24repeat it back to you, recap it, make sure I
- 7:26really got it, and when you feel sure that I
- 7:29truly heard you, then I'll do the same thing and
- 7:32you recap it back to me, and then we'll see
- 7:35just where our differences are. So step one there is
- 7:38to just make sure you're really truly hearing each other
- 7:41and that everybody's getting a chance to talk.
- 7:43Speaker 1: You know, doctor, I'm that guy when somebody comes at
- 7:46me and it raises my blood pressure like that and
- 7:48my heart rate up there like that, the first thing
- 7:50that I do is I go mum. And they'll sit
- 7:53there and say, oh, you're going to go quiet on me,
- 7:54and my answer is no, I'm meditating. Would you like
- 7:58me to show you how to meditate so that we
- 7:59can have a real peaceful conversation here, And I'm serious
- 8:02about that. I'll show you how to meditate.
- 8:05Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, that's that's so good. And then I think
- 8:08another thing that helps in those conversations is to explain
- 8:12to someone that you want the goal of the conversation
- 8:14not to be for one person to win or lose,
- 8:17or even to be persuaded. But how about if we
- 8:20try to figure out a whether we actually have a
- 8:23disagreement on objective facts, like something that could be looked
- 8:27up and determined or be whether we agree upon the facts,
- 8:32but we just simply interpret them and evaluate them differently,
- 8:35Because that way we're making it about information and getting
- 8:39to know each other rather than about you know, quote
- 8:41winning or losing.
- 8:43Speaker 1: God, I want to bring up this subject and I
- 8:45don't know how to bring it up. Because you're a doctor,
- 8:47I can bring it up, but at the same time,
- 8:48I don't want to offend anybody. I did not know
- 8:51who Charlie Kirk was. But when I went in there
- 8:53and I watched all the videos and I saw that
- 8:55he was a listener first, Oh my god, that opened
- 8:59up my eyes. And that's that's where I want to study.
- 9:01I want to be that guy that listens to everything
- 9:05that is going right or wrong. It's cross eyed, it
- 9:07doesn't matter. Just be the listener first. And then if
- 9:10you need to say something, put this book in your
- 9:12heart and grow with it and do it in a
- 9:15really very well faithful as well as a loving way.
- 9:20Speaker 2: Yeah, totally, I think you're really onto something there. And
- 9:24you know, Charlie Kirk was totally a master at that,
- 9:27of course, and you know, it's sad the way that
- 9:29so many people really vilified him. But one of the
- 9:32things you know that I think he also did is
- 9:34he would try to focus on something about the person speaking. Yep,
- 9:38that was actually likable, you know. I mean, so even
- 9:41if you totally disagree with what the person is saying,
- 9:44to just think to yourself, like, well, you know, this
- 9:46is probably actually a really intelligent person, or this is
- 9:49actually probably a very well intentioned person. And that's how
- 9:52he was able to keep rapport with people, and like
- 9:54you said, to listen to them and then that pounce
- 9:57on them with his opinion, but oftentimes there's respond to
- 10:00them with a question, and that was like really helpful
- 10:03because they realized he wasn't just trying to talk at them,
- 10:06he was truly trying to have a dialogue.
- 10:08Speaker 1: You bring up three common objections? Whoa wait a second,
- 10:11that means I'm relating with somebody. Three common objections to
- 10:15free speech? You mean we've got something in common here.
- 10:19Speaker 2: Totally, So yeah, like common you know, well intentioned objections
- 10:22to free speech or things like well what about misinformation?
- 10:26And you know, actually, as I explain, we have better
- 10:29quality information when we can have open debate and dialogue. Right,
- 10:34you know, so if somebody's wrong, great, you know, expose them,
- 10:37talk about it. But pushing someone underground actually only makes
- 10:41it harder, you know, to debunk them. Another common objection
- 10:44is you know, well, what about hate speech and bullying?
- 10:47And interestingly, you know, violence actually increases when dialogue ceases.
- 10:53And so if people are saying things you know that
- 10:55you think are hateful or mean or whatever, telling them
- 10:58to shut up is only going to like make the
- 11:02problem worse. It's so much better if we can invite
- 11:05them to share, talk it through, even agree to disagree.
- 11:09And that doesn't mean we have to tolerate abuse. But I
- 11:12just think in this you know, words of violence day
- 11:14and age, people will label anything as hate speech and bullying,
- 11:19and so when people are truly just sitting there at
- 11:21the dinner table having a conversation, I think, you know,
- 11:25to flip it on its head, the hate speech or
- 11:27bully is the person who's trying to shut the other
- 11:29people up and prevent them from expressing themselves.
- 11:32Speaker 1: Don't you think that hate speech and bullying can actually
- 11:35begin sometimes innocently in the way that two people can
- 11:38be over in the corner having a conversation. They happen
- 11:41to look at somebody and they're going, oh, they're talking
- 11:42about me. Oh my god, I hate these people. I
- 11:45know they're talking about me. They looked at me. How
- 11:47do we get beyond that. I mean, seriously, we're not
- 11:49talking about you. We were talking about McDonald's, and it's like,
- 11:52I'm so sorry that we looked up. But we are
- 11:54in that generation where everybody thinks we're talking about them.
- 11:58Speaker 2: Yeah, you know, I mean I feel like we could
- 12:00talk all day long about that Moneuly. I know we
- 12:02got to wrap up here soon, but that's a good question.
- 12:05I think we'll pick that one up next time. I
- 12:07love it.
- 12:07Speaker 1: Well, where can we go to find out more information
- 12:09about you?
- 12:11Speaker 2: I would love that. Go to free Speech today dot com.
- 12:14At free Speech today dot com, you can get my book,
- 12:17which is can I say that Why free speech matters
- 12:19and how to use it fearlessly. You can connect with
- 12:21me on social media all kinds of other stuff at
- 12:23freespeech today dot com.
- 12:25Speaker 1: Well, please come back to this show any time in
- 12:27the future. The door is always going to be open
- 12:28for you. A doctor.
- 12:30Speaker 2: Oh, thank you so much, Aero. I'd love that.
- 12:32Speaker 1: Will you be brilliant today you too?
- 12:36Speaker 2: Thanks again, Bye bye,