Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Volkswagen's Electric Era Reinvention and Global Challenges
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to The Deep Dive. Today we're digging into a
- 0:12company that's so much more than just a car maker.
- 0:14It's, well, it's a sprawling industrial empire.
- 0:18Volkswagen AG. That's absolutely right.
- 0:21When you say VW, you're not just talking about 1 brand.
- 0:23You're talking about this huge portfolio from, you know, Skoda
- 0:28and the VW line all the way up to Audi, Porsche, Lamborghini,
- 0:32and even heavy trucks like Scania.
- 0:35And our mission today is to really unpack the extraordinary
- 0:38challenges this Titan is facing right now.
- 0:41They're in the middle of this massive global reboot.
- 0:43It's like they're fighting a war on three fronts at once.
- 0:46Yeah, that's a good way to put it.
- 0:47You've got this fierce immediate competition in China, then you
- 0:50have the crippling weight of high cost back home in Europe.
- 0:53And on top of all that, the immense capital they need to
- 0:56fund this fundamental pivot to electric vehicles and software.
- 1:00So the sources, they show that VW has some incredible financial
- 1:04strike. I mean a deep war chest.
- 1:06Oh, absolutely. Their debt to EBITDA is running
- 1:08at a fantastic point, 3X in 2024.
- 1:12But here's the tension, right? They have the money, but the
- 1:15sources are all pointing to these severe headwinds for 2025.
- 1:18And that's reflected in a key metric.
- 1:20Exactly. Their forecast for free
- 1:22operating cash flow, or FOCF, is set to stay well below this, a
- 1:28crucial 3.0% threshold. So for you listening, what does
- 1:32that FOCF metric actually tell us about what's going on?
- 1:35It tells us they can afford to survive for sure, but they might
- 1:39struggle to rapidly fund this multi billion euro
- 1:42transformation and keep shareholders happy at the same
- 1:44time. I see FOCF is the cash you have
- 1:47left after you pay for everything you need to run the
- 1:49business and if that cash flow isn't strong enough, it stays
- 1:51below that 3% mark. It suggests the huge cost of
- 1:54their transition is eaten into their flexibility.
- 1:58They need to execute this turn around.
- 1:59Now, before that profitability gap becomes permanent.
- 2:02Right. So let's start where that
- 2:03financial pain is, well, most acute China.
- 2:06This market has just completely broken the old playbook.
- 2:10It's been a seismic shift and incredibly fast.
- 2:14I mean, think about this back in 2019.
- 2:16The internal combustion engine, VW's bread and butter, was over
- 2:2190% of the car market in China. Over 90% and today?
- 2:25Today in 2024, that number is less than half.
- 2:29The share of electric and plug in hybrids has just exploded to
- 2:32over 44%. Then VW was built for that old
- 2:35market. Exactly.
- 2:37That foundation has just crumbled from underneath them.
- 2:39So we're seeing this market shift translate directly into
- 2:42them losing market share with their EVs.
- 2:44Why are they struggling so much against the local Chinese
- 2:46brands? It really boils down to two
- 2:48things, speed and and tech relevance.
- 2:52Local giants like BYD and Geely are just launching new models at
- 2:56a blistering pace. And their tech is just better
- 2:58for the local market. Far better superior infotainment
- 3:01driver assistance systems that are actually designed for
- 3:03Chinese roads and traffic. VW's current stuff is just seen
- 3:06as a generation behind digitally.
- 3:08And the numbers really back that up.
- 3:10The sources forecast VW losing another one to two percentage
- 3:13points of market share in China next year.
- 3:15Which means they're projected to see the number two spot in the
- 3:19entire market to Geely. Wow, that is a massive blow not
- 3:23just to volume but to prestige. And the pain isn't just in the
- 3:27volume brands. This is where it gets really
- 3:29structurally challenging for their bottom line.
- 3:32It's hitting the premium. Brands It's hitting their cash
- 3:34cows. In the first half of 2025,
- 3:38Porsche sales slumped by a staggering 31% in China.
- 3:42Audi was down 15%. Wait, I thought premium was
- 3:45supposed to be insulated from this kind of thing?
- 3:47Historically, yeah, but the local Chinese brands are
- 3:50permanently changing what premium even means for a lot of
- 3:53young buyers there. It's not about German
- 3:55engineering pedigree anymore. It's about tech.
- 3:57It's about state-of-the-art tech seamless connectivity.
- 4:00When a local brand offers a tech loaded EV for less than a base
- 4:04Audi, they completely redefine the segment.
- 4:06So China is a huge structural crisis, but let's contrast that,
- 4:10like our sources do, with Europe, because there it seems
- 4:13like a totally different story. It's night and day.
- 4:15Europe is their vital stronghold.
- 4:17They are the clear leader in the battery electric vehicle market.
- 4:21They're holding about 20% of the the market in 2024.
- 4:24And it's growing. It is.
- 4:26The sources suggest they actually increase that to around
- 4:2826% in the first half of 2025. And that jump, that's down to
- 4:32the new models, right? Things like the ID .7, the new
- 4:36Audi A6 and Q6E Tron. Precisely.
- 4:39Those vehicles are absolutely crucial for winning over the big
- 4:43stable fleet customer segment in Europe.
- 4:46It shows they have the engineering chops.
- 4:47But the problem is cost. The problem is building those
- 4:50vehicles at a cost base that can compete with Chinese prices
- 4:53without just relying on those high premium margins.
- 4:56Which brings us directly to the next big challenge, the cost
- 4:59hammer. And there was 1 figure in the
- 5:01sources that just jumped right out.
- 5:02It's the one number that defines their entire European problem.
- 5:06VW's labor costs are about €77,000 for full time employee.
- 5:10€77,000. When you look at the price of a
- 5:12golf or a polo, that labor cost is just a massive non
- 5:16competitive burden. It's the trade off isn't it?
- 5:19Years of excellent wages and benefits in Germany now making
- 5:22it harder to fight a global price war.
- 5:24So how are they tackling it? Through a huge, and I mean
- 5:28painful, restructuring effort called the Future Volkswagen
- 5:31Agreement. And this isn't just trimming
- 5:33around the edges. No, this is targeting a
- 5:35reduction of approximately 35,000 employees.
- 5:38They're also suspending salary increases until 2030 and
- 5:42slashing production capacity in Germany by over 40%. 35,000
- 5:46jobs. That's the size of a small city
- 5:48that sounds like a social and political earthquake.
- 5:50And that's exactly why it's so complex and so slow.
- 5:53The restructuring costs alone are estimated at about a billion
- 5:56euros in 2025. And this is where they're unique
- 5:59ownership structure becomes a real problem.
- 6:01A huge headwind. Yeah, you've got the Porsche and
- 6:03Peach families, Qatar and, critically, the state of Flora
- 6:08Saxony. And the state has a veto.
- 6:10It does, and it's priority, naturally, is preserving German
- 6:14jobs. So these cuts can't be a rapid,
- 6:16brutal layoff. It has to be this slow,
- 6:18expensive negotiated process. So that €1 billion charge in
- 6:222025, that's the immediate price they have to pay.
- 6:26Exactly, and it's a major reason why Porsche's operating margin
- 6:29is forecast to drop so dramatically from over 14% down
- 6:33to just 5 or 6% in 2025. They have.
- 6:35To pay upfront to compete later. So that's the internal cost
- 6:38threat, but then there's this massive external risk tariffs
- 6:43specifically from the US. This is a huge risk because of
- 6:46VW's global sourcing strategy. US import tariffs on light
- 6:51vehicles could impact what 22 billion worth of their imports
- 6:54annually. 22 billion and the real problem is that it's mostly
- 6:57their high end models. It is.
- 6:59The bulk of that value comes from Audis and Porsches, which
- 7:02mostly don't have a big manufacturing footprint inside
- 7:05the United States. So they can't just shift
- 7:07production to get around it. What's the plan?
- 7:09Well, the estimates are that they can only offset about 25 to
- 7:1230% of the hit. That means price increases for
- 7:14you, the consumer, which is risky.
- 7:16And the rest just hits their bottom line.
- 7:18Exactly. It's yet another headwind
- 7:20hitting that cash flow we talked about.
- 7:22It is a squeeze from all sides. OK, let's shift focus to how
- 7:27they're fighting back. Let's talk about the technology
- 7:29road map. Right, because they're not just
- 7:30cutting, they are investing heavily to try and win back
- 7:34China and secure their software future.
- 7:36And it's a remarkable pivot after decades of doing
- 7:39everything in house. Their new strategy is
- 7:43partnership pure. Localization and partnership.
- 7:46They're essentially admitting they can't develop competitive
- 7:48tech fast enough on their own. And these are partnerships with
- 7:51their own competitors, which is fascinating.
- 7:53It is. They're launching 2 VW models
- 7:55using a platform directly from a Chinese competitor, X Peng,
- 7:59starting in 2026. And Audi is doing something
- 8:01similar. Yes, Audi is launching new
- 8:03models under a new tech sub brand using a platform developed
- 8:07with their partner Sic motor, with the first one coming as
- 8:10early as 2025. It's VW trying to operate at
- 8:13Chinese speed. But wait, isn't relying on a
- 8:16competitor's platform a huge risk?
- 8:18You're basically admitting defeat in your own R&D.
- 8:21It absolutely carries a long term risk of dependency, no
- 8:25question, but the immediate calculation is survival.
- 8:29They need relevant tech now to stop the bleeding.
- 8:31So regaining market share today outweighs the risk of dependency
- 8:35tomorrow? That's the bet they're making.
- 8:37You can't play catch up by trying to reinvent the wheel
- 8:39internally when you're this far behind.
- 8:41And beyond just buying platforms, they're attacking the
- 8:43cost of the vehicle itself. The sources really emphasize
- 8:47battery chemistry. It's absolutely crucial.
- 8:50They're launching their next Gen. platform, the CMP, and
- 8:52they're targeting an incredible 50% reduction in material cost
- 8:56per unit by 2026. 50%, that's transformative.
- 9:00How? The key is adopting lithium iron
- 9:03phosphate, or LFP batteries. LFP is much cheaper than the
- 9:07nickel, manganese, cobalt, or NMC batteries they've been
- 9:10using. So it's a strategic choice.
- 9:12They're prioritizing cost in the volume segments, especially for
- 9:14China, over just maximizing range and performance.
- 9:18That's exactly it. And central to this whole thing
- 9:21is their internal battery company, Powerco.
- 9:24They're ramping up production of a standardized unified cell.
- 9:27They can use different chemistry's like LFP or NMC.
- 9:30But again, like the restructuring, the upfront cost
- 9:32of doing this is enormous. It is.
- 9:34Powerco is expected to post operating losses of about €1
- 9:37billion in 2025 alone as they scale up.
- 9:41It's another huge upfront investment they believe will pay
- 9:44off later. And finally, let's touch on
- 9:46software, the other massive battlefield, the software
- 9:49defined vehicle. Yeah, the strategic imperative
- 9:53is to move to the central software driven architectures.
- 9:56It's essential for things like over the air updates and well,
- 10:00VW has really struggled with software.
- 10:01Which is why they did that joint venture with Rivian.
- 10:04Nobody saw that coming. It's a remarkable partnership,
- 10:06yeah. And it just speaks to the
- 10:07urgency of their software gap. Rivian is seen as a leader here.
- 10:12So the JV is designed to help them catch up faster.
- 10:15To speed up software adaptation for their current EV platforms.
- 10:18Yeah, it allows them to get their software stacks sorted out
- 10:21much earlier. It's a clear signal they'll
- 10:23partner with anyone, even a competitor, to fill these tech
- 10:26gaps. This whole.
- 10:27Story is just about existential tension.
- 10:30You've got the world's second largest carmaker, phenomenal
- 10:33financial strength, but they are just fighting a war against
- 10:36time. I mean if.
- 10:37You pull back, the company is going through a total corporate
- 10:40reboot. They're trying to slash these
- 10:42high European costs, a slow, politically difficult process.
- 10:46Well, at the. Same time funneling billions
- 10:48into Chinese platforms, battery tech via Powerco and Excel
- 10:52tolerating software with partners like Rivian.
- 10:54It is a. Phenomenal juggling act and the
- 10:57outcome really hinges on them successfully executing all of
- 11:01this by 2026, which raises. A really interesting question
- 11:04for you, the listener. What stands out to you about a
- 11:07company trying to manage a workforce reduction of 10s of
- 11:10thousands in a place like Germany, while simultaneously
- 11:13outsourcing Cortech and investing billions into a future
- 11:16that doesn't exist yet At scale, it really is a tightrope walk
- 11:20for this global Titan. The stakes.
- 11:22Just couldn't be higher. Thank you for joining us on this
- 11:25deep dive. If you want to continue
- 11:27following these high stakes corporate transformations, make
- 11:30sure to select the follow button on your app now.
- 11:32We appreciate your time and look forward to the next deep dive
- 11:35with you.