Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Justinian's Reconquest Destroyed More of Rome Than the Barbarians
Transcript
- 0:00Rome wasn't killed by its enemies.
- 0:02It was killed by a rescue. We picture the.
- 0:05Fall of Rome as the ending or 76.
- 0:09The last emperor, the barbarian king, the lights going out.
- 0:13We picture the. Eastern Empire watching
- 0:15helplessly from Constantinople. Too distant, too late.
- 0:20That's the myth. Here's the pattern.
- 0:23In 535, Justinian launched a war.
- 0:26To restore the West. 20 years of Gothic.
- 0:29Wars across Italy. His armies didn't liberate the
- 0:32peninsula, they emptied it. Milan one of the.
- 0:36Great cities. Of the North reduced.
- 0:40To rubble the survivors. Enslaved Rome itself besieged
- 0:44and fought over again and again in 20 years.
- 0:49Its aqueducts cut its. Population collapsed, the plague
- 0:53of Justinian riding the same roads as Belisarius's army,
- 0:58killing perhaps 1/3 of the Mediterranean world by the time
- 1:02Justinian declared. Victory there.
- 1:04Was no one left to govern? So the Pope.
- 1:06Started doing it not because God.
- 1:08Willed it. Because no one else was left
- 1:11standing. That's not ancient.
- 1:13History. That's the pattern.
- 1:15When a government tries to restore something that no
- 1:18longer. Exists it?
- 1:20Doesn't bring back. The past, it destroys what's
- 1:23left. You're watching it happening
- 1:25right now. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, and this
- 1:47is the Roman pattern and I want to show you something most
- 1:50history channel. Skip right over.
- 1:52Because the Barbarians didn't actually finish Rome off.
- 1:55If anything, Rome went and did that to.
- 1:58Itself. So let's start in the year 535
- 2:02in Italy, because it's Italy in 535 was not some burned out
- 2:06ruin, and that matters more than it sounds like it should.
- 2:09The. Story everyone knows says Rome
- 2:11fell in 476 and the lights just went out across the West and
- 2:16that's not really what happened when Romulus.
- 2:19Augustalis was deposed. In 476, the man who took his
- 2:23place was a general named ODA Walker, and he was a pragmatist
- 2:27about the whole thing. He kept the Senate running.
- 2:30He kept the bureaucracy in place.
- 2:32He kept the aqueducts. Flowing basically, he kept the
- 2:35machinery of Roman life going under new management.
- 2:39Then in 493. You get Theodoric the Great the.
- 2:42King of the Ostrogoths and Theodoric kills Odawaker at a
- 2:46dinner party personally with his own sword and then does the one
- 2:51thing that nobody saw coming. He runs Italy like a Roman.
- 2:55He keeps the whole. Roman administrative structure
- 2:58intact. Roman law for Romans and Gothic
- 3:01law for. Goths.
- 3:02And he's repairing infrastructure funding
- 3:04scholarship right into Constantinople like an equal
- 3:08instead of some subordinate. Warlord, his right.
- 3:11Hand was a Roman aristocrat named Cassiodorus.
- 3:15Who served this Gothic? King without the slightest
- 3:17embarrassment about it. And here's what gets me We can
- 3:21actually. Still read the paperwork.
- 3:23From all of this. Cassiodorus left.
- 3:25Behind a whole collection of. Official letters, he wrote.
- 3:28The very eye. And they show a Gothic king
- 3:31governing straight through Roman law, Roman titles, the Roman
- 3:35tax. Office as if.
- 3:37Nothing had really broken at all.
- 3:39So Italy under. Theodoric looked a lot.
- 3:41Less like a nightmare and a lot more.
- 3:44Like the afterlife of. Rome quieter, under different
- 3:47command, but still very much breathing.
- 3:50The people stayed where they were.
- 3:51The cities kept going, the institutions kept doing their
- 3:55jobs, and if nobody had come along to interfere.
- 3:59Italy would have just. Followed the same Rd. as every
- 4:01other Germanic. Successor state.
- 4:04New masters up top, the same civilization continuing
- 4:07underneath. That's the situation sitting on
- 4:09the table in 535, right up until Justinian decides he wants it.
- 4:14Back to get what? Happens next.
- 4:17You have to understand Justinian himself, because he wasn't just
- 4:20a soldier, he was more of a theologian, someone who thought
- 4:24in terms of centuries. He'd been born a peasant in
- 4:27what's now N Macedonia, and it was his uncle Justin who pulled
- 4:32him up to Constantinople. Where he studied.
- 4:34Law and theology and administration He married an
- 4:38actress, Theodora, which absolutely scandalized the.
- 4:41Court, though, that stopped. Mattering pretty fast once it
- 4:45became clear that Theodora. Had the sharpest political.
- 4:48Mind in the entire. Palace.
- 4:50And Justinian believed one thing above everything.
- 4:53Else which was. One empire, one law, under one
- 4:57church. A divided Roman world just
- 5:00didn't sit right with him. He saw.
- 5:02It as a wound, a mistake that was sitting there and waiting.
- 5:05To be corrected. By this point, he'd already.
- 5:08Pulled together all of. The Roman law into.
- 5:10A corpus of the juris civilians. The thing that still sits
- 5:15underneath most of the Western legal tradition today?
- 5:18He already built the Hagia Sophia.
- 5:21He'd already. Lived through the Nikiya riots
- 5:23and the most violent uprising in Byzantine history.
- 5:26And he survived those by. Sitting tight in the.
- 5:28Palace while Theodora. Talked him out of running for
- 5:32it. Something like 30,000 people
- 5:34died in the Hippodrome that week, and that number comes to
- 5:38us from Procopius, who was right there in Constantinople watching
- 5:42his own city. Tear itself apart so this.
- 5:45Is not a cautious or a modest man.
- 5:48He rebuilt the law. And the church He put up, the
- 5:51most magnificent building in the world, and about the only thing
- 5:54he hadn't gotten around to restoring yet was the map.
- 5:58He wanted the West back, and he happened to have exactly the
- 6:01right general who could go get it for him.
- 6:04Belisarius was probably. The greatest Roman general since
- 6:07Caesar, and in 533 Justin sent him off to North Africa.
- 6:12The vandals had held that. Territory for about a.
- 6:14Century at that point. Arthage had fallen to them back
- 6:17in 439, which meant Rome's old grain.
- 6:20Supply it's tax base, the bread basket that fed the capital.
- 6:24Had all been gone for about the better part of 100 years.
- 6:28Belisarius took the whole. Thing back in 14 months, 14
- 6:32months to reconquer a stretch of land about the size of modern
- 6:36Libya and Tunisia put together. And that speed is really the
- 6:39important part, because it handed Justinian a model, a
- 6:43proof of concept. If Africa could fall that
- 6:46quickly. Then why not Italy?
- 6:48And this is exactly. Where the easy early.
- 6:52Success gets dangerous because it sets the wrong expectation.
- 6:56Africa had been a Vandal Kingdom that grew isolated and divided
- 7:00against itself, and it simply wasn't ready for him when he
- 7:03came. Italy was a very different
- 7:05animal. The Ostrogoths were battle.
- 7:07Hardened and. Politically sophisticated.
- 7:10And they've been fighting for their own homes.
- 7:13But Justinia's mind was already made-up, so none of.
- 7:16That really registered. With him.
- 7:18The Gothic War started. Well, and honestly, everything
- 7:22in this. Story starts pretty well, which
- 7:24is part of the whole. Problem with the entire.
- 7:26Story Bellisarius. Landed in Sicily in 535 and.
- 7:31Sicily basically fell right away.
- 7:33The king at the time was Theodahad, Theodoric's nephew.
- 7:36A bookish. Sort of man who grabbed the
- 7:38throne by murdering Theodoric's own daughter and he put up
- 7:42almost no resistance at all. Naples came next in five. 36.
- 7:47And the way. Belisarius took it tells.
- 7:49You. Something about the man himself.
- 7:51He found an old aqueduct tunnel running underneath the city.
- 7:54Walls. And he sent his soldiers up
- 7:57through it in the dark, and Naples surrendered and the
- 8:00Gothic Garrison inside of it got massacred.
- 8:03That was enough to shake the Goths into action.
- 8:06So they. Deposed.
- 8:07The auto had. And put a real soldier in his
- 8:09place, a man named Wingatus, who understood exactly what kind of
- 8:14war. This was about to.
- 8:15Become. Wittigas.
- 8:17Pulled the north to Ravenna to gather his strength and he left
- 8:20only a small Garrison holding Rome, and that Garrison handed
- 8:24the. City over to Belisarius without
- 8:26a fight. December of five. 36 Belisarius
- 8:29walks. Into Rome.
- 8:30The senators are cheering. The Pope comes out to welcome
- 8:34him, the whole population is celebrating, and Witigus turns
- 8:38around and comes back with an enormous army.
- 8:41Procopius, who was. Serving on Bellisarius's own
- 8:44staff puts it at 150,000 men. He does tend to inflate the
- 8:50gothic numbers when it suits his story.
- 8:52So I'd hold that figure a little loosely.
- 8:55But even a fraction of that is overwhelming, so the siege of
- 8:58Rome begins in 537, with Witigus wrapping the city in a.
- 9:03Force that completely dwarfs whatever Belisarius has.
- 9:06And the first thing he does is cut.
- 9:08The aqueducts. Which had never once happened
- 9:11before in the entire. History of the city.
- 9:14Now here's why that mattered in a way that people don't expect.
- 9:18The mills that ground Rome's grain into flour all ran on
- 9:21water. Power.
- 9:22So the moment the aqueducts went dry, the city couldn't make
- 9:25bread. Bellisarius improvised his way
- 9:27around it. He anchored floating mills to
- 9:30boats. Out of the Tiber.
- 9:32And let the river current turn the mill stones instead.
- 9:35The siege dragged on for a year and nine days.
- 9:38You've got constant skirmishing at the gates, starvation setting
- 9:41in, disease moving through both camps, and both sides just
- 9:45bleeding steadily the whole time.
- 9:47Eventually. Witigus gave up.
- 9:49And pulled back N to Ravenna. So Belisarius had technically
- 9:53held the city. But the.
- 9:55Aqueducts were now broken, the population was rattled and the
- 9:59institutions were running on fumes.
- 10:01And the war. Itself.
- 10:02Was only one year old with 18 more.
- 10:06Still ahead of it. Now here's where I want to slow
- 10:08down because the next 20 years aren't really military history
- 10:12in the normal sense. They're more like a kill chain,
- 10:15where every single action connects straight into the next
- 10:18one, and every decision quietly sets up the next disaster.
- 10:22So let me walk you through how this actually works.
- 10:26The core. Problem was that Belisarius was
- 10:28fighting a war the Eastern Empire never.
- 10:31Fully paid for. Justinian had wars running on
- 10:33several fronts at one time. There was Persia.
- 10:36Off in the East there was the Danube frontier and.
- 10:40Africa still needed troops. Fighting on it.
- 10:42Italy was just one. Theater out of several.
- 10:46So Belisarius keeps asking. For more men and more supplies,
- 10:50and he keeps getting a fraction of what he actually needs.
- 10:53And he's good enough that he keeps winning anyway.
- 10:56But when you win without enough behind you, you win slowly.
- 11:00And winning slowly means the war just keeps going.
- 11:03And a war that keeps going in Italy doesn't only kill.
- 11:07Soldiers it kills. Everything around them too.
- 11:10This is the money side of it. Justinian had come into power
- 11:13sitting on one of the biggest. Treasury surpluses.
- 11:16The Empire had ever seen and the wars in the West.
- 11:19Burned right through it. He paid for the.
- 11:21Fighting by raising. Taxes back east.
- 11:24And by stripping. Resources out of territories.
- 11:26He'd only just reconquered before those places had a chance
- 11:30to. Recover at all Africa.
- 11:32Was supposed to help fund the Italian campaign after 533 and
- 11:36it just didn't. Because the Berber revolts over
- 11:38there kept. Pulling money and men.
- 11:40Back West, the whole. Financial logic of the
- 11:43Reconquest never actually closed.
- 11:46The places. Justinian wanted to restore,
- 11:48couldn't produce revenue fast enough to pay for.
- 11:51The war. And that.
- 11:52War was supposed to restore. Them and meanwhile the Italians
- 11:56were getting taxed and looted by occupying armies that kept
- 11:59losing and kept retaking the exact same ground.
- 12:02Neither side could afford. To win fast.
- 12:05So neither of them did. By 538, Belisarius had pushed.
- 12:08Up into northern Italy and a faction inside Milan opened the
- 12:12gates and invited him in. Wittigus answered that by
- 12:15calling in his Burgundian and Frankish allies, and together
- 12:19they threw a force around Milan and completely swamped the small
- 12:22Byzantine Garrison holding it. Belisarius did try to send.
- 12:26Relief columns, but they got blocked and delayed and pulled
- 12:30off course by subordinate commanders who couldn't
- 12:33coordinate with each other. And while all of that
- 12:35dysfunction played out, Milan. Slowly starved the city.
- 12:39Fell in 539 and what happened then is genuinely hard to take
- 12:44in. The men were slaughtered.
- 12:46The women and children were split up among the Goths and the
- 12:49Burgundians. As slaves.
- 12:51And the city itself was pulled down, the buildings torn.
- 12:54Apart the streets. Left completely empty.
- 12:57Procopius, who was on Belisarius.
- 12:59Staff through all of this. Wrote that Milan was levelled
- 13:03and that the entire male population, which he claims ran
- 13:07300,000, was put to the. Sword.
- 13:10Now, that number is almost certainly too high, because
- 13:13ancient writers love to round a catastrophe up.
- 13:16Until it shocked you. But even when you.
- 13:18Pull the figure back. Down the thing sitting
- 13:20underneath it doesn't really move.
- 13:23This was one of the great cities of the north and it was simply
- 13:26erased and no one did that to it in 476 when the so-called
- 13:30barbarian invasions happened. This happened in 539 in the
- 13:35middle. Of a war whose purpose was to
- 13:37restore. The Empire.
- 13:38That used to protect these very people, which is a.
- 13:41Strange thing to sit with. Because we file this whole.
- 13:44Period under the fall of Rome, when we're actually looking at.
- 13:48Is that the price? Of trying to undo.
- 13:50The fall is high. It's worth saying I'm.
- 13:53Procopius for a second because he travelled with Belisarius.
- 13:56For most of the campaign and saw the whole thing up close and he
- 14:00ended up writing three very different books about it.
- 14:04There's the Wars, which is the official.
- 14:06History of Justinian's campaigns, and it's careful and
- 14:10accurate and measured. There's the buildings, which is
- 14:13basically a. Flattering Commission tribute to
- 14:17all of Justinian's construction projects.
- 14:20And then there's the. Secret History, which he wrote
- 14:23privately. And never dared to.
- 14:24Publish while he was still. Alive because publishing it
- 14:27would have gotten him killed. In that one, Procopius flatly
- 14:31calls Justinian a demon in human form, and he lays out the
- 14:34destruction from the campaigns as a built in result.
- 14:37Of a policy that was really. Running on nothing but vanity.
- 14:41So the official. Version has Justinian restoring
- 14:44the West and the private version has him destroying it and the
- 14:48strange. Part is that both of those are.
- 14:50True at the same time then, in 541 the plague.
- 14:54Arrives. It comes into the Eastern Empire
- 14:57through Egypt and spreads. Through the exact trade routes.
- 15:01The Empire had. Worked so hard to reopen.
- 15:03This was bubonic plague. The first recorded.
- 15:06Outbreak of Yasina pestis anywhere in human history.
- 15:11The same bacterium that would come back centuries later.
- 15:14As the Black Death. And it kills in a completely
- 15:17different way than WAR does. War kills in one place at one
- 15:21time. But plague kills everywhere that
- 15:23the roads reach. In Constantinople, Procopius
- 15:27describes bodies being stacked up inside the.
- 15:29Towers of the Walls. Because the city had simply ran
- 15:33out of room to bury anyone, and by the end they were loading
- 15:36corpses onto ships and sailing them out.
- 15:38To sea the. Estimates for the death toll run
- 15:41from somewhere to. 25 to 50. Million.
- 15:44People across the Mediterranean. World.
- 15:47Maybe 1/4 to 1/3. Of the entire known population,
- 15:50although I'll say that modern historians.
- 15:52Argue pretty hard about. That now, and plenty of them
- 15:55think the older numbers run too high.
- 15:58Either way, the direction. Is the same, and this is where
- 16:00the kill chain really compounds on itself.
- 16:03Because the. Plague lands on Italy right in
- 16:05the middle. Of the Gothic War.
- 16:07The Byzantine army loses men it can't replace.
- 16:10The Gothic army loses men it can't replace, and both of them
- 16:14keep fighting over land that has fewer and fewer people left
- 16:17living on it. The farms go unworked.
- 16:20The harvest fails. And whoever.
- 16:22Survived the plague. Is now staring down famine.
- 16:25So you've got all three? Pressures hitting at once the
- 16:28money. Collapses because the people who
- 16:30paid the taxes are dead. The borders can't be reinforced.
- 16:33Because the plague has. Gutted the army back.
- 16:36East. And the raw power to control the
- 16:38peninsula is gone on both sides. Because neither the Goths.
- 16:42Nor the Byzantines have any men for it.
- 16:44Every one of those. Pressors showed.
- 16:46Up in the same. Window witigas got.
- 16:48Captured in 540 and Bellisarius took Ravenna, and right at that
- 16:52moment, Justinian recalled him. He'd grown suspicious of a
- 16:56general who'd become too. Powerful.
- 16:58And he was nervous. About what?
- 17:00A victorious Belisarius. Might do with an army that
- 17:03genuinely loved him. So he pulled.
- 17:05Out and handed the war off to the lesser commanders.
- 17:08The Goths meanwhile churned through a couple of short lived
- 17:12kings before they landed on one that actually mattered, and that
- 17:16was Totilla. And Totilla was something else.
- 17:20He retook Rome in 540. 6 lost it.
- 17:23And then retook it a second time.
- 17:25In 549. He swept down through southern
- 17:27Italy and out into Sicily and Sardinia.
- 17:31But the interesting thing isn't that he wasn't only fighting the
- 17:34Byzantines, he was appealing directly to ordinary Italians.
- 17:39He freed slaves who'd? Come to join his army, he
- 17:42cancelled. People's debts.
- 17:43And he set himself. Up with a protector of regular.
- 17:46Italians against Byzantine taxation, and that mattered for
- 17:50one very specific reason. Which is that the?
- 17:53Italian population started choosing Totilla.
- 17:55Over people who were supposedly there to liberate them.
- 17:59The very people. Justinian was rescuing preferred
- 18:01the Gothic king. Once that happens, you're really
- 18:05not looking at a military problem anymore.
- 18:07You're looking at a collapse of legitimacy underneath the whole
- 18:10enterprise when the people you're restoring order for stop
- 18:14believing in the order you're bringing them.
- 18:16The thing has already failed. And you just happen to be.
- 18:18Out there, still fighting. Justinian finally sent in
- 18:21Narcissus, an elderly eunuch general with an army that was
- 18:25big enough to end it. Narcissus beat Totilla.
- 18:29At the Battle of Busta. Galorem in 552 and Totilla died
- 18:34running from the field, and the last Gothic king Thea died the
- 18:37same year at Mons. Lectarius by 554 the war was.
- 18:42Officially finished, the Pragmatic Sanction declared the
- 18:45Reconquest complete, and Italy was Roman again.
- 18:49What that actually meant on the ground is the part that almost
- 18:53everyone. Skips right over.
- 18:55So in 554, Justinian declares victory.
- 18:58He has. Restored the Western Roman
- 19:00Empire and it's. Worth actually.
- 19:02Looking at what? He restored.
- 19:04Roman 554 held maybe 50,000 people at its height.
- 19:08Under Augustus the same city held over 1,000,000 and even
- 19:12under. Theodoric A full.
- 19:14Century after the supposed. Fall.
- 19:16It was still home to several 100,000.
- 19:19After. The Gothic War ended.
- 19:21The war that was fought to save it.
- 19:22You're down to 50,000. The aqueducts that got cut.
- 19:26In the first siege were never fully.
- 19:28Repaired the baths that. Depended on that.
- 19:30Water closed for good. The Kyrgios Maximus, which had
- 19:34once packed in 150,000 spectators.
- 19:37Held its very last chariot race. In 549, during one of the.
- 19:41Gothic Sieges. And after that nobody organized
- 19:44another one, the Senate of Rome. Technically kept.
- 19:47Existing in name for another generation or so.
- 19:51And then it quietly stopped meeting.
- 19:52It wasn't formally shut down or dissolved.
- 19:55It had simply become irrelevant, and eventually nobody even
- 19:59bothered. To show up.
- 20:00Because there was nothing left to.
- 20:01Actually govern the Otterick. Had run Italy in peace.
- 20:04For 33 years. And Justinian's reconquest
- 20:07managed to kill more Italians in 20.
- 20:10And this isn't me interpreting anything for you, that's just
- 20:13the arithmetic. Then in 568, only 14 years.
- 20:17After the big victory. The Lombards came over the Alps,
- 20:21They were another Germanic people.
- 20:23This one came out of Pannonia, which is modern Hungary, and
- 20:26they were harder than the Goths had been, less Romanized, and a
- 20:30great deal less interested in the kind of accommodation the
- 20:33Goths had made. There's a tradition that
- 20:35Narcissus himself, the very man who'd won Italy for Justinian,
- 20:40had been recalled and humiliated by Justinian's successor, Justin
- 20:43the 2nd, and that out of pure resentment, he invited the
- 20:46Lombards in. Whether that's literally true.
- 20:49Or not almost doesn't matter because it.
- 20:52Captures the logic. Of the moment perfectly.
- 20:54By then the army that had beaten the Goths was gone.
- 20:57The population that might have resisted was gone, and the
- 21:00infrastructure that could have supplied any real defence was
- 21:03gone right along with them. The Lombards essentially walked
- 21:06into an Italy that 20 years of Byzantine reconquest had gone
- 21:10and prepared for them. So the Gothic.
- 21:12War did something quite a bit. Worse.
- 21:15Than the fall to restore Rome. It cleared away.
- 21:18Everything that could have. Stopped whatever.
- 21:20Came next, the Lombards broke Italy into a.
- 21:23Patchwork of separate territories that would last.
- 21:26For centuries, and Italy wouldn't be a unified country
- 21:29again until 1861. Under Garibaldi, that's roughly
- 21:331300. Years.
- 21:35And that's what the Reconquest actually.
- 21:37Bought. So when Justinian declared his
- 21:39victory in 550. 4 The administrative structure.
- 21:43He claims to be restoring has basically nothing left to
- 21:46administer, the prefects, the governors, the municipal.
- 21:49Courts that the. Ostrogoths had kept running.
- 21:52All of that is gone and the people either killed in the.
- 21:55War or scattered? Or ground down so badly by 20
- 21:58years of plague and. Fighting that they can't.
- 22:01Function anymore and when you look around and who's still
- 22:04standing, it comes down to the Bishop of Rome.
- 22:07Now, the Pope hadn't been a political figure in the old
- 22:09Roman sense at all. He was a religious leader.
- 22:13And a theological authority. Who administered the church?
- 22:16Property and it's. Charitable resources.
- 22:19And that was more. Or the less of it.
- 22:22But that turns out to matter enormously.
- 22:24Because the church's property had survived the war.
- 22:27And it's charitable networks have kept feeding the.
- 22:29People all through the years, the government.
- 22:31Couldn't. On top of that, the Pope had
- 22:33been negotiating. Directly with the Gothic.
- 22:35Kings for decades already, simply because there was nobody
- 22:39else stable. Enough.
- 22:40To do the negotiating. So when Gregory the First
- 22:42becomes Pope in 590, he steps straight into all of it.
- 22:47He organizes. The city's food supply, he
- 22:49deals. Directly with the Lombards.
- 22:51When the Byzantine government can't, he manages the defense of
- 22:55the city. He's writing letters to.
- 22:57Kings all across Europe in the voice of someone setting policy,
- 23:01not the voice of a clergyman asking for a favor.
- 23:04He was running Rome for the simple reason that everyone else
- 23:08who might have done the job had just been wiped out.
- 23:10And the medieval. Papacy.
- 23:12The institution that would go on to dominate European politics
- 23:16for the next 800 years. It gets built right there.
- 23:19In the empty space the reconquest left behind and this.
- 23:23Is really the whole? Thing I keep circling back to
- 23:26power doesn't just vanish when an institution.
- 23:28Collapses. It moves.
- 23:30And whoever's still working ends up inheriting the vacuum.
- 23:34And in Rome and 590, the only thing still.
- 23:37Working with the church. Pragmatic sanction in five. 54.
- 23:41Formally put the whole Roman administrative structure.
- 23:44Back in place across Italy. At least on paper.
- 23:47And the structure was real enough.
- 23:49The laws were real. And the titles were.
- 23:51Real, but the people who used to fill all of those roles.
- 23:55The land owners, the Cure Isles and the municipal councillors
- 23:59who've been the backbone of the Roman city life for 500 years.
- 24:02Or dead, or they fled. Or 20 years of war and plague
- 24:06had stripped them down so. Far that they couldn't.
- 24:09Do the job anymore. You can bring an institution
- 24:11back, but you can't bring back the human beings who actually
- 24:15made the thing run. So the Eastern Empire poured
- 24:18decades and a staggering amount of money into rebuilding an
- 24:22administrative machine, and that machine was basically running
- 24:26for nobody. They restored the tax.
- 24:28System, but there weren't enough.
- 24:29People left to tax. They restored the courts.
- 24:33But there weren't enough people to bring cases.
- 24:36They restored the courts. But there weren't enough people
- 24:38to bring cases, and there wasn't enough stability to enforce a
- 24:42ruling even when you managed to get one.
- 24:44They restored the military command, but there weren't
- 24:47enough soldiers. To fill it out.
- 24:49And this is the. Power.
- 24:50Side of the collapse in the most complete form, where it isn't so
- 24:53much. The power that was lost as the
- 24:55power that was. Being acted out over an empty
- 24:58stage, the forms were all still. There.
- 25:00While the function had drained right out of them.
- 25:03And that's what I mean by the administrative ghost of Empire,
- 25:07where you've kept. All the structure.
- 25:09And none of the living that that.
- 25:10Structure was ever for. So let me run the whole chain
- 25:14back from the start, and we'll do it quickly.
- 25:17In 476, the Western Empire ends and Italy settles down over
- 25:21Germanic management. From 493 to 526.
- 25:25Theodoric. Rules Italy.
- 25:26And the cities keep going. The people stay put.
- 25:29And the institutions hold. Then in 527, Justinian becomes
- 25:33emperor. He's convinced the gap can be
- 25:35closed and the whole thing can be restored By 533.
- 25:38He's reconquered Africa in 14 months, and the model feels
- 25:42proven in. 535 the. Gothic War opens up with Italy.
- 25:46As the target across 5:30. 7 and 538 Rome gets.
- 25:50Besieged the aqueducts. Are cut, The infrastructure
- 25:53starts to break down. In 539, Milan is destroyed.
- 25:57The men are slaughtered, the women and children enslaved, the
- 26:00city levelled. Then in 541, the plague.
- 26:03Arrives. And the Mediterranean loses an
- 26:06enormous. Share of its people.
- 26:08In five. 46 tortilla sacks. Rome And in 549 he takes yet
- 26:13again, while the population keeps sliding downward between
- 26:165:52 and 5:50. 4 The Goths. Are finally beaten and victory
- 26:21is declared in 568. The Lombards arrive to find
- 26:25Italy. Far too.
- 26:26Broken to resist them, and by 590 Gregory becomes the Pope and
- 26:30starts governing whatever's left.
- 26:32Every one of those. Steps grows straight.
- 26:34Out of the one before it. And every mistake quietly builds
- 26:38the condition for the next disaster.
- 26:40And that's really what a system failing looks like, more than
- 26:43any run of bad luck. And I want to be.
- 26:45Clear that this. Isn't a story about Justinian
- 26:48being some uniquely evil man? Because he wasn't.
- 26:51And it isn't about Bellisarius being incompetent, because he
- 26:55plainly wasn't either. This is just what happens when a
- 26:58government. Can't accept.
- 27:00That a transformation is permanent when the whole.
- 27:03Policy is built. On restoring a past that only
- 27:06really exists now in documents and in memory, and when the cost
- 27:10of restoration lands on. Exactly the people who were all
- 27:14supposed to be saved. So this pattern repeats.
- 27:17They're never in quite the same shape, because these things
- 27:20never do repeat identically. What stays the same is the
- 27:24underlying shape. Of it a state.
- 27:26That used to hold something loses its grip and the.
- 27:29Loss is gradual. Then, all at once, some
- 27:32successor arrangement grows in the gap, and it's imperfect and
- 27:36it's different. But it works.
- 27:38Because something. Always has to work.
- 27:41And then the original state decides it wants the thing back,
- 27:44the restoration begins, the successor arrangement gets
- 27:48destroyed, and the original arrangement turns out to be
- 27:51impossible. To rebuild either because the
- 27:53people who built. It are gone or because the
- 27:56conditions that produced it just don't exist anymore and what
- 27:59you're left holding is worse than either of the two things
- 28:02you started with. The Goths were not good.
- 28:04Guys, let's be clear about that. They were Germanic warlords
- 28:08who'd seized Roman. Territory, but they kept up what
- 28:11they'd. Inherited, and they let it keep
- 28:14running. And Justinian's armies really
- 28:16were trying to restore something genuine.
- 28:18A single, unified Roman world running under one law and one
- 28:23faith. The vision itself wasn't the
- 28:25problem, because the vision actually hung together.
- 28:28The problem was that the thing that he wanted back had already
- 28:31been replaced by something that worked.
- 28:34The Italy of five. 35 was functional and the Italy.
- 28:37Of 560. 8 was anything but, and it was the restoration itself
- 28:42that opened up that gap. And the lesson in that is
- 28:45narrower than people usually want it to be.
- 28:47Plenty of empires do. Recover.
- 28:49And plenty of military campaigns really are necessary, so this
- 28:53isn't some blanket rule against either one.
- 28:55It's about a specific. Blind spot When you set out to
- 28:59restore an arrangement from the past, the first question can't
- 29:02be only whether you're able to win it.
- 29:04The question that actually matters is what's going to be
- 29:07left standing once you have it. Justinian asked himself the
- 29:11first question constantly, and he never once.
- 29:14Stopped. That's the second.
- 29:16Procopius finished the Secret History around 5:50, right in
- 29:20the middle of the Gothic. War.
- 29:22And by then, he'd been living inside this thing for 15 years.
- 29:25He'd watched Belisarius retake. Africa in Sicily and Rome and he
- 29:29watched the plague come in along with.
- 29:31The very trade routes. The Empire had reopened, he
- 29:34understood. Exactly what he was.
- 29:36Looking at and he wrote the truth of it down in a document
- 29:39he knew wouldn't be read until he was safely gone.
- 29:43And that really is what? Sets the secret history.
- 29:45Apart from every. Other source for this period?
- 29:49It was written by someone who fully understood the cost.
- 29:52Of what he'd seen. And had no interest at all in
- 29:55justifying the policy behind it. He knew Justinian's reconquest
- 29:59would go down in memory as a restoration, and he knew it had
- 30:03been something a lot. Closer to the opposite.
- 30:05In the textbooks, the. Date is 476, but the year Italy
- 30:09actually died is 554. The Barbarians took the.
- 30:13Crown and the Eastern. Empire took the civilization.
- 30:17And that's the thing I keep wanting people to sit with,
- 30:20because what finally kills a civilization isn't always an
- 30:23enemy standing at the gate. Sometimes the friend who shows
- 30:27up with the plan to save it. Restoration can turn out to be
- 30:31about the most destructive policy on the table, and that's
- 30:34not the some dusty piece of ancient history.
- 30:37It's closer to an operating manual.
- 30:38For basically every rescue. Operation that anyone has ever
- 30:42launched, so learn how this actually.
- 30:44Works before you go back. To the next rescue.
- 30:47This has been the Roman pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 30:51Be sure to like. This.
- 30:51Video Leave us a comment and smash the subscribe button if
- 30:55you want more of the Roman pattern.