Latest / Fintech Conversations with Fexingo: Banking, Payments, and Financial Software Companies / How Affirm and Klarna Changed Consumer Credit in 2026
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about embedded finance and super apps on this show, but I think one of the most interesting shifts in 2026 is how buy now, pay later has matured from a checkout gimmick into a real credit alternative. Luna: Yeah, it feels like every time I check out online, there's a Klarna or Affirm option. But are they actually making money now, or is it still a growth-at-all-costs story? Lucas: Great question. Let's focus on Affirm and Klarna as the two bellwethers. Affirm's latest numbers show they processed over 30 billion dollars in gross merchandise volume last fiscal year, and they've been profitable on a net income basis for three consecutive quarters. Luna: Wait, profitable? I remember when everyone said BNPL was a race to the bottom on merchant fees and delinquencies. Lucas: Right, and that skepticism was valid. But what changed is that Affirm leaned into longer-term loans — 12-month and 24-month installments — where they can charge higher APRs. The classic four-payment, zero-interest model was never the profit driver; it was the loss leader. Luna: So the zero-interest 'pay in four' is just the hook, and the real money is in the longer-term financing for bigger purchases. Lucas: Exactly. Their average loan duration has crept up to about 8 months, and they're now originating loans with APRs between 10 and 30 percent, depending on the customer's credit profile. That starts to look a lot like a traditional installment lender, but with a much better user experience. Luna: And Klarna? They've gone a different route, right? Lucas: Klarna has been pivoting toward becoming a full banking app. In 2026, they now offer a savings account, a debit card, and even a credit card in some markets. Their BNPL is still the entry point, but they're monetizing through interchange fees and account subscriptions. Luna: A subscription for BNPL? How does that work? Lucas: Klarna's 'Plus' tier costs about 8 dollars a month and gives you rewards points, no foreign transaction fees, and access to exclusive sales. It's a small but growing revenue stream. But the bigger picture is that Klarna wants to own the entire consumer financial relationship, not just the checkout button. Luna: Okay, so two different strategies. But I've also seen a lot of talk about regulation catching up. Are regulators looking at BNPL as a form of unsecured credit that needs stricter underwriting? Lucas: Absolutely. In the U.S., the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued new guidance in late 2025 that effectively treats BNPL loans like credit cards for dispute resolution and fee caps. That's raised the compliance cost for all players. Luna: So smaller BNPL providers might get squeezed out, leaving Affirm and Klarna as the dominant players? Lucas: That's the thesis. And we're already seeing consolidation. Just last month, Square's Afterpay acquired a smaller European competitor called Alma. The regulatory burden creates a moat for the incumbents. Luna: Speaking of incumbents, how are traditional credit card networks responding? Visa and Mastercard have to be watching this. Lucas: They're not sitting still. Visa launched a BNPL product called Visa Installments, which lets banks offer the feature on existing debit and credit cards. Mastercard partnered with Marqeta to do something similar. But the big difference is that Affirm and Klarna don't require the merchant to have a traditional payment processor — they're a standalone checkout option. Luna: Right, because they integrate directly with the e-commerce platform. Affirm's partnership with Shopify is a huge competitive advantage. Lucas: Huge. Affirm is the exclusive BNPL provider for Shopify's Shop Pay installments, and that alone drives over 10 billion dollars in annual GMV. Shopify merchants don't have to think about it — it's just a button in the checkout flow. Luna: But doesn't that make Affirm dependent on one platform? If Shopify builds its own BNPL product or switches providers, that's a big risk. Lucas: It is a concentration risk, and Affirm has been trying to diversify. They've struck deals with Amazon, Walmart, and a bunch of travel sites. But Shopify is still their largest partner by volume. The nice thing is that the deal is long-term — it runs through 2028. Luna: Interesting. Let's talk about the consumer side. Are we seeing any shift in credit scores or debt levels because of BNPL? Lucas: There's some concerning data. The CFPB found that BNPL users are more likely to carry balances on other credit products, and that they have higher delinquency rates on credit cards. But it's hard to say if BNPL causes that or if it's just that riskier borrowers self-select into BNPL. Luna: Right, correlation versus causation. But it does highlight the need for better underwriting. Affirm claims they use machine learning to assess creditworthiness in real time, but how robust is that? Lucas: They publish some loss data — their net charge-off rate is around 2.5 percent, which is actually lower than the industry average for unsecured personal loans. But that number might be artificially low because they reject a lot of high-risk applicants. Their approval rate is only about 20 percent for new users. Luna: So they're being selective. That's probably smart for long-term sustainability. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a big difference from the early BNPL days when some players were approving almost everyone. The era of easy credit is over. Luna: Hey Lucas, I know our listeners are often people building or running businesses in fintech or adjacent spaces. If this kind of deep dive is useful for what you're working on, I wanted to mention something quickly. Lucas: Sure, go ahead. Luna: This show stays ad-free because of listener support. If you get value from episodes like this, you can help keep it going at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure at all — just if it's worth a coffee to you. Lucas: Yeah, that really helps us keep the conversations independent and focused on what matters. So thank you to anyone who's already contributed. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. So we've covered Affirm and Klarna, what about the rest of the market? Is there room for more players? Lucas: I think we'll see a bifurcation: the big two or three players handle the mass market, and then niche players focus on specific verticals. For example, a company called Sunbit specializes in BNPL for auto repair — you can finance a thousand-dollar brake job over 12 months. Luna: That's smart. High-ticket, essential services where people might not have cash on hand. Lucas: Right. And there's a company called Uplift that focuses on travel — things like flights and hotels. Those verticals have higher average transaction sizes, so the financing fees can support the business model even with lower volumes. Luna: So the future of BNPL might not be one-size-fits-all. It's about integrating into specific moments in the consumer journey. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where embedded finance comes full circle. BNPL is just one form of credit that sits inside another product. The winners will be the ones that make the experience seamless and the underwriting smart. Luna: One last thing: do you see BNPL expanding into offline retail in a big way? I know Klarna has a card, but is it really taking off? Lucas: It's growing but slowly. The problem is that in-store, the checkout friction is much higher — you need to scan a QR code or hand over your phone. Apple Pay and contactless cards are just faster. I think BNPL will remain primarily an online phenomenon, at least for the next couple of years. Luna: That makes sense. So the big takeaway is that BNPL has evolved from a fintech gimmick into a legitimate credit tool, but with real risks and regulatory scrutiny. Lucas: And the key metric to watch isn't just GMV growth anymore — it's unit economics. Can they make money on each loan while keeping defaults low? If they can, this is a durable business. If not, it's just a cycle of cheap capital chasing growth. Luna: Well, we'll be watching. Thanks for breaking that down.