Latest / The Comedian Next Door / TCND: We're All Moderate/Centrists Now (And Other Rhetoric)
Transcript
- Welcome to the podcast! Come be part of the conversations that happen around my kitchen table. He's John Brandion and he's been a stand up comic for more than 30 years. She's a man to McKinney and she's been my daughter for her whole life. Our family believes laughter is a gift from God. We often discover it while discussing culture, faith and family. So go ahead and pull up a chair neighbor. Can I call you Carl? There's plenty of room here for you. Hey, welcome to the podcast Carl. Are you not a fan of the licorice? No. Why'd you take a bite of it? Because it's the pulling peel kind and I thought, oh, maybe I like this one a little better? I don't. I don't. It smells good. It smells great. I don't want to eat. But it tastes like medicine. Yeah, it does. It tastes like computer wires flavored like medicine. It tastes like, yeah, it tastes like something that's not really key. It does taste like wire. But you are. You are. Luke has always been a fan of the red licorice. Yeah, he prefers the original twizzlers. That one is not open yet. What do you mean? The original twizzlers. So one of those red vines? Are those red vines or are those twizzlers? These are just the strawberry pulling peel ones. They didn't open the regular twizzlers. Is that what you're saying? I do not feel like they missed out on much. That's all. We're sharing a microphone again. Yeah, this will be the last week you have to share a microphone. That's why I asked, did you share a vine here? No, I already took a bite. She already took a bite. She didn't like it. Just about gagged. I asked if you ordered one. I did. I ordered two actually because then we'll have. We don't really know if it's the microphone or the cord. It's the cord. See ordered cords. Yeah, we tried the cord and we tried the microphone with a new cord and it worked. So anyhow, it was what were you going to ask me? Here's the number one. I was going to ask if you ordered a new microphone. Guess right before we got started, you said it's the last week you'll have to share. And I said, why did you order a new one? And then you said, don't tell us, don't tell us until we start the podcast. Right. That was like news that you thought Carl wanted to know. Let's status of our mic cables. I said, did you order a new one and you said, huh? And I said, wait, don't tell us. I'll ask again on the podcast. Yeah. Yeah. I don't hear very well. I think I've mentioned that before. So it smells like red licorice and checks mix. It's wafting across. It's like a weird sort of sweet garlicky. It does smell good. I will say your breath that fake strawberry does smell good. It's also a mandarin orange mixed in. Oh, it's a whole, it's a popery. It's a medley of aromas. It's a sink truck. It's a cacophony of smell. I'll find bits of all of the above later when I'm doing the dishes. Yeah. You have to get closer to anything. Well, you don't have to. But it would be good if you did. You'd be able to hear you better if you got closer. Not interested. OK. We had a whirlwind show yesterday. I went down to it. You didn't even know I did that, did you? I forgot that you were going down there. Yeah, I flew down to Florida in the morning. I got up at 2 o'clock to get to the airport. Wow. My flight was at 6. I don't need to leave quite that early, but I'm always afraid I'm going to hit a deer or something's going to, the shuttle bus is going to break or something like that. And so it could happen. It could. It hasn't. But I left it 2.30. I got up at 2.30. That gets me down to the airport a little before 3. Which is 3 hours before your flight. Which is 3 hours before the flight. But it starts boarding in about 45 minutes ahead of time. And then I never know for sure. I need to start having more confidence in the process for checking in. Well, here's what I learned, Carl. I used to be a TSA pre-check guy, right? Because. Because you were flying like every day. Because I was flying all the time, right? But since I'm not flying as often as I used to, I've let my pre-check laps. And I've been thinking, I should probably get that renewed. But I'm not going to. And I don't think I need to, because they have streamlined the process. 9.11 is over 20 years ago now. And so the check in and the security process has been streamlined quite a bit in the last couple of decades. To where now, you don't even have to share your boarding pass getting through security. Which I never thought that that day would come again. But yeah, now everything is keyed to your ID. And so if you've got a valid boarding pass and you're checked in, then you just hand them your ID and they scan it. And then they take a little, you stand in front of a camera. And that's it. You don't have to chill them. You're boarding pass. They don't have to scan the boarding pass anymore. And so it's substantially faster. You don't have to take a shoes off anymore when you're going through regular security. They can scan everything. And so I don't think that the TSA pre-check and the clear and all that is that much faster. So they didn't change the benefits to the pre-check to coincide with the fact that now regular check in is more convenient? Well, I think what's happened is that everybody, or not everybody, but many, many, many people went with pre-check because it was so much faster. But what that did was that pulled hundreds of people out of the general check-in line. So now it's faster also because you've got so many people that are going through clear and pre-check that the general check-in now is that much shorter. So what would they need to do now? This is the question. That sort of happened with Cedar Point with their fast pass. It was so much faster to pay them, because they've got an amount for a fast pass where you get the shorter line. That now the lines are about equal. So same question for you about Disney World or whatever. What would they have to do now to make pre-check a special thing again? You don't have to take off your shoes. You don't have to share the boarding pass. And that's just for everybody across board. Now what would they have to do to upgrade the pre-check and make it worth your while? A warm hug. OK. Red-like-rich. I was thinking you were going to say, you have to let me drive the plane. If the let me, I would not want to do that. So at Disney World, what would they have to do? John has low confidence in himself. Are we going to correct this? No. No. OK. I'm OK with him not driving the plane. At Disney World, instead of cutting in front of everybody, you would get what? You would get to stay on the rides for a year. You don't have to get off. You can just stay on. You get to definitely once you have a seat. A sticker that shows that you are better than everyone. Where all the characters have to interact with you. Well, there's some people that actually think that status on a... This is not security, but you get status on an airline and you get to board earlier. And there are some people that really kind of get to charge out of that, out of being in the first boarding group. This is for our elite members. And then they walk up there and it's like, hey, what a great deal. You get to sit on the plane longer than the rest of us. Well, as a Sam's Club Plus member, I get to shop 30 minutes earlier in the regular paper. That's a powerful motivator for some people. I am not getting up. Some people really like the feeling of being in that group that everybody doesn't get to be... Well, but you also get the opportunity to do the shop, like click and shop or whatever. Pick up. Yeah, I get it. There's other perks. Right, right. And so on and so on. What would they have to do? What would the airline have to do to earn your... What would they have to do for pre-check? I really don't know what they could do to pre-check. TSA is not airlines. No, TSA is the federal... Right. Because you do still have frequent flyer... You are still a frequent flyer through... No, I lost that status too. How did you...? Yeah, I lost that in 2025 because I just wasn't flying anywhere. And they... The airline extended it, you know. But it's still... Yeah, I just don't fly enough. And there's a... That got in my head. That actually got in my head and then I started going, oh, I only need X number or more miles to get to the next... Status level. And then I was like, what am I doing here? I mean, I've already got a check bag for free. And, you know, what... What else does a guy need? Well, what else... That was what I said. What else do I need? I'm spending, you know, a lot of money with the airline in order to get these things... I don't care about it. I don't care about early boarding. The only thing I really care about is the free bag. And even that, the way I travel now, I don't usually have a check bag, you know. I travel with a single carry on. I felt that way about some of our streaming services, where as often as we watch a movie on the service, like it would be cheaper for us to just pay the rental fee for the... For the one off movie. Yeah. But, yeah. Yeah, I don't... So I don't know. Maybe that's what they could do. TSA pre-check would come with free streaming. Maybe I would get it. Or... Like a jelly of the month, peach. Yeah. You know, like you get... You don't have to take a shoes off. It's faster boarding and you get a surprise jelly in the mail. That's what I was waiting for, something like that. Well, apparently... So, Cammy was on a trip to a different state for a volleyball this weekend. And she checked in multiple times via text to make sure that Emory was logging in and keeping her dual lingo streak alive. Yeah. And so that kind of stuff is psychologically powerful. It is. It is. We like to be... We like to be members of elite groups. And so... So, Atlanta, Georgia, was the air... Or is the airport that pushed me to go with TSA pre-check because I went through... This was years ago when I first got pre-checked and I went... I had to fly out of Atlanta for some reason. I've flown through Atlanta so many times that I know that airport inside and out. But I don't fly out of Atlanta very often. And it is a nightmare. Or it was. It was a nightmare. To get there? To get through security because it is the busiest airport in the United States. Was it northern Florida then? Like you drove... Are you saying that you drove from the Atlanta airport to the venue? This was years ago. This was not this weekend. Oh, okay. I'm trying to pay attention to what we're talking about. I was not. And I was trying to figure out why you were in the Atlanta airport. When you're just catching a connecting flight, you're already through the security process. Right. And you're talking about booking a flight out. I was talking about years ago I had to fly out of Atlanta. So I originated in Atlanta. Right. You had to drive here. So I had to go through the security and it was like two and a half hours in line. And I was like, I'm going to miss my flight. And I don't remember if I did or not. But I remember going... I have to get TSA pre-checked. Everything takes longer in Atlanta. You can't drive through Atlanta. You can't find a bus going anywhere quick in Atlanta. So when was I... I was in Atlanta two weeks ago for that prison show and I had to fly out. And so they took me from the prison show and they drove me to the airport. And I told you about that about my driver who was... Oh, yeah. He was a nice guy. Yeah. He was a super nice guy. I really liked him. He was not a good driver. And... He was a little unnerving. He was a little... Carl, he was either... He was standing on the gas or the brake all the time. There was no coasting. If he wasn't touching the gas pedal, then he was touching the brake. We're making you sick. Luke, does that too? Yes. I don't do that. I coast all the time. It was a lot of... Okay, Luke does that. Anyway, so I got to the airport and I was grateful to God that I arrived alive. And I thought, man, I hope I don't have a two-hour process. But I breeze through Atlanta in regular general check-ins. So all that to say, I don't know that I'm going to get... Do you say pre-check again? All that to say, I forgot that you were going anywhere this weekend because I don't book the travel anymore. That's Tavis. Right. You don't pay any attention to me after we get a contract signed. You're like, it's out of your mind forever. Pay us. And if they're like, okay, I'm like, they'll never hear from me. I will never think of you again. I wash my hands of all of this. Yeah. So I texted her and I gave her an update about what was going on and she goes, wait, why? Specifically, his completely out of context is... It is, and out of blue. The blue clues confused you. We're talking about something cute, Bridger said. And like a couple hours later, Dad goes, so the priest said... Yeah, the priest is talking about how we shouldn't laugh... We should laugh with each other but not at each other. So that's what you said. And you can explain why you sent that to us in a second. But literally imagine us just sitting here on a random, like normal Saturday. Oh, yeah. And you text us, the priest said we shouldn't laugh at each other. And we were like, what? It's Dad having us. It's like, stroke? What's wrong with him? Are you referring... Like I thought you were being sarcastic, like the priest, this guy who seems to think he's the priest in charge of everybody. But he literally was a priest. Well, I thought you said, like a real priest. Like a real priest. Like a real priest. Usually you will send me a screenshot of some conversation and it's like, here's my commentary. This guy over here, this priest, he thinks that he's... Well, I understood why you were confused because you forgot that I was traveling that. You're like, I'm down in Florida at that Catholic show. Like, oh, so like the priest, like the real guy who's a priest, yeah. Well, and it was a whirlwind. Like I said, I got up at two and I went down to the airport and flew out. Did a show, ubered over, you know, ubered over, did the show, ubered back to the airport, got on the plane and flew home. Well, I didn't get to be at church this morning. I told Blue, like as of 1.30 p.m. on Saturday, you hadn't even gone on stage yet. And so I texted Andrew last night and was like, hey, are you going to be at church? He said, I will. And we even told Bridger, Uncle Andrew will be at church, but Grandpa John will not. He'll be flying back later in the afternoon. And then I texted him, it was like, what time are you getting in? And you're like, I'm on my way to church right now. And you're like, how did you do that? I got home with Brown midnight last night. I pulled in and it was a whirlwind. Yeah, that's crazy. Almost 24 hours a week at that point. It's a very... Did you sleep on the plane? Very glamorous. I did. I don't sleep well on the plane. I do this. I don't know anyone who does sleep well. Yeah, nobody goes, man, I can't wait to get on the plane and get... What I really need to do is book a flight because that's where I get my best sleep. It's like sleeping in a hospital. It's bad because you have to sit up. And I fall asleep, but then I lean forward and I'm... And fall over. And I jerk awake, you know. Yeah, it's not ideal. Yeah, and people go, once you lay the chair back and it's like you've never tried to do that. Or do you have to do it? Who does that? Is it Tim Hawkins? Who's Bid is that? A lot of people have a bit. A lot of people have a bit about how comfortable it is when you recline that seat. I thought it was... I don't know. That was Tim, but anyway. Anyway. Anyway, we're 17 minutes in. Yeah. And hang on, I'm going to pause for just a second. And it's in. All right. Okay. Well, I paused. And now we're unpossed. So did you have a thing that you wanted to discuss? Because... I can always discuss things, but Luke has heard a lot of my rant this week, so I've gotten it off my chest and then we can... A lot of it's been ranting at me about me. About me. About him. That would talk about me. Luke has been the source of the rant. We've had some really good discussions this week, but, you know, what was your... What were you going to bring up? Well, have you... Have you seen this abdual al-saeed guy who's running up in Michigan? Yeah. You guys have a different algorithm than I do. Yeah. Well, it's the men's job to pay attention to world politics. So... In Michigan? You consider that internet... So there's a little video here. And somebody at a town hall meeting stood up and asked him if you would disavow the Muslim brotherhood. That he has a family member that's a part of. I really don't know. I haven't been paying... Well, confess, I don't... I haven't paid a lot of attention to him. But this video has him basically... It's a reasonable back and forth that he's having with the Christian guy who asks him if he would disavow the Muslim brotherhood. And then he pushes back on this guy going, why would you ask that? Did you think I wouldn't? He goes, yeah. And he goes, why would that? Why would you think that I wouldn't? Well, the answer in the Christian guy doesn't say it, but the answer is because he's a Muslim, you know? And so... Right. And so then what they do is all the comments are how... You know, he just owned this Christian guy and took him in his place, you know? The comment is, it gave a masterclass in defanging and humiliating a troll today. This is how it's done. It's so good. The man folded like a lawn chair. Oh, MG laughing emoji. So he just took him apart by asking him, you know, he's very condescending and very, you know, like, dactic in his... He basically lectured him on the Constitution. I'll take a vow on the Constitution and it gives me the right to practice my religion. And you can practice your religion. We can pray or not pray. And all of it is correct. But here's the thing. He never got around to denouncing the Muslim brothers. He did. He did disavow them. Oh, he did. Yeah. He did disavow them. And then he turns around and asks this guy, he goes, do you disavow them? And he goes, yes, I do. And so they were... So why would you ask me if I would disavow them? Do you think I wouldn't? And he goes, yeah. And he goes, why would you think that I wouldn't? And well, the answer is because you're a Muslim, right? Right. And so it's a valid question. But the way that he embarrassed this guy and humiliated this guy was to suggest that this guy is some sort of a... Some sort of an extremist asking him if he denounces the Muslim Brotherhood. As if that's not a legitimate question to ask a Muslim. And so if you're... There was a bunch of applause breaks for this guy. And the rhetoric is now among many Christian people that it's Islamophobic to be suspicious about Muslims, particularly Muslims that are running for office, people that are trying to be installed in leadership. And this guy is giving a lecture ball. I'm going to take a vow to uphold the Constitution. And that means I can practice my religion. But here's the thing about Islam. It's more of a political position than it is a religious position. And it's intentional that it's in the Quran that you're allowed to deceive and lie. And manipulate people in order to advance the cause of Islam. And the Christian people don't know what the Quran says. A lot of Muslims don't know what the Quran says. But if you're a guy who's lecturing the Christians and lecturing America about what the Constitution is going to protect you from this, this could be deception. And it's completely legitimate for Christians and all of us to be going, okay, wait a second. What do you believe about the Quran? If you're identifying as a Muslim, explain to us what that is. Because there's a language in the Quran that talks about doing violence to non-believers. But also to your point, it's perfectly legitimate for us to ask those questions and then still not believe whatever answer you give us afterwards. Well, the thing that I want to point out is the number of Christians or non-believers who are applauding this guy who are like, he's a hero. He's the guy who's well spoken and good at rhetoric. But I don't trust Muslims. I mean, they are, it was, it's Muslims that crashed the planes into the World Trade Center. And we seem to have forgotten that. If you ask a person, pick any Muslim-led country, which one would you want to live in? And it wouldn't be any of them. But yet, they're perfectly fine electing them to our leaders. Well, a lot of people have confused categories between color or genetic background, you know, ethnic makeup and religious belief. And it's not just the leftists who are doing that anymore. And so our algorithms are very different. You guys have been seeing about this guy. I haven't seen anything about it because I went and got myself tangled up with white nationalist nonsense. I was like, I just don't see it in my algorithm. And I wonder if people like Samuel say are just like, because they keep clicking on it and engaging with more people. Yes. They start seeing more. Well, and there is truth to that. Your algorithm does determine what you think everybody is experiencing. Right. So I've been hearing from, you know, the white boys who are like, well, they, they are very political with their religion. And so therefore it's okay for me to also be have preference for white skin. It's like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, what? Yeah. We just went from talking about Muslims, which is people who belong to a competing false religion. Right. And you just confused that with the category of you having white skin and a preference for people who have white skin. White is not a synonym for Christian and brown is not a synonym for Muslim or Buddhist or Hindu or any of those. Right. And so, but to say that now gets you charged with obfuscating or being, you know, being obtuse. It's like, you're not even allowed to notice patterns. See, people like you won't even let us notice patterns. As if it's not true that most Middle Easterners are influenced by Islam or something like that. And it's like, okay, but again, like for now we're going to be talking about Islam and we're going to talk about where the concentration of Islam is. And that's fine. And I have no problem talking about that. But it's only a matter of a sentence or two before suddenly they're like, and that's why America should be predominantly white. Yeah. And it's like, can you stay on track? They can't. But it's the rhetoric like you're talking about that's really powerful. So one of the things I've been doing this week is watching a documentary on Nazi propaganda and how gobles the lead propaganda. His title was officially minister of propaganda because at the time it was just a clever word that they had created for this thing. They had the special style of disseminating information and they had no problem admitting that it was propaganda. It's the negative connotation that we've attached to it since then. But at the time they were super proud of it. They literally would stand up behind their podiums with their little swastikas on their arms and they'd be like, this government could not exist without propaganda. Just like propaganda could not exist without a strong, amazing government. Right. And they would declare that they were proud. Right. It was like advertising. I mean, propaganda. The reason it has a negative connotation now is because it's, we recognize it as basically false information. It's a false information campaign or it's at least a very controlled information campaign. Well, that's important because it has to, and gobles figured this out, it has to contain truth. And they were constantly trying to figure out how to switch gears or like pivot when battles would either go their way or not their way. Like what's the best way to handle this? And their propaganda was the best or it was the most effective when their war was happening in the west on the western. Right. So people couldn't see for themselves. They were reliant on. Right. Well, when, when they're, I mean on the western front of Germany. Right. So they could still see it. But when it was, it was successful for a time. But after so many years, they're, they started to get tired of bombs. And like their entire capital city was basically. Rubble. Distroied. Yeah. And people were like, huh, this is kind of terrible. And so then the, the Germans, the propaganda is pivoted to. Blaming the Jews for that. Right. And so they're now acknowledging, yes, this is terrible. It went from we're awesome. Nobody can ever defeat us to well actually. Well, the reason we got defeated is because. Right. Those guys are bad actually. And that's just because the Bolsheviks, you know. And so. Yeah, it's hard to talk about victory when people are living in holes. When they were like, there's literally a raid. Sirens going off like six times a day. Yeah. So originally they were trying to get them to be able to live this utopia as, as stable and as consistent as possible. Like they're supposed to be able to live normal lives as much as possible. But eventually they're like, well, that's not going to be possible. So now we need to invent a new story for why we're not able to live. Why people are living a different experience than what we're telling them. And certainly not because our government stinks and everything that we told them was actually false promises. Right. Well, and where we are now in America is where we are still. We're still living under the auspices of a Christian. You know, ethos. There's a Christian Christianity is what made this country. And that's not to say that it's perfect. And that there were all of the leaders were perfect and all of the all of the Christians were perfect. But it's it's it's Christianity that made America possible. Not Islam. It wasn't it was an Islam that made America. It was also the flavor, the false, I guess blasphemy, blasphemy toward the Christian God and the false use of the Christian label, which made Nazi propaganda. Correct. So destructive. And that's important too. It's important to acknowledge that sometimes often Satan twists scripture and uses it in you know disguises himself as an angel of light and comes in and says, you know, all we're doing is we're trying to protect our people are loved ones, you know, it's actually very Christian and God wants us to have an order of of love where God is first and then our immediate people are next. And so all we're doing is trying to protect them. Well, I was reading comments, you know, under this video and several people would say something along the lines of, yeah, the Christians want to the Christians of the ones who want to control everything. The Christians of the ones who want to force their religious views on people. It's good to see them get put into place and I'm like, you simple to this. It's like the Islamic texts specifically call for domination and subjugation of the unbelievers. It specifically has that language in it repeatedly. You don't find that language in the Bible. And so the people, people just are ignorant. They just don't know what Christianity is and they don't know what Islam is. Right. But that includes, again, that includes because my algorithm has taught me that that includes people who are now identifying as Christian who do nothing all day long except talk about the evils of Islam. And they think that that makes them right. And they think that it makes them understand the gospel when they don't actually, they're not actually Christians, but they like the the clout that using the word Christian gives them in spaces where they're going to go toe to toe. Sure, there are, there are those people. And I'm not, I'm not necessarily defending the apologetics aspect of it. I'm just saying that to people think that Islam and Christianity are basically the same thing. It's just they do. They don't or worse. They think that Islam is is basically the is just another word for Christianity that they that they they just don't understand that they're different religions outdated and tyrannical. I think that that's I don't but I don't think they think that the same. I don't know. I don't know what to believe anymore. I know that in our church circles. Everybody knows that Islam is a false religion. I know that in like normy normy chat groups like if it's homeschool moms or like people sharing tips for home making or something like most women that I know who identifies Christian know that Islam is a false religion. And so I think I think the secret is out that like it's violent and that it is. She thinks it's just people in Michigan. Well, or it's probably just these people in the video. It's progressive. It's progressive. Michigan voters are becoming increasingly Muslim themselves. Right. I don't think that I don't think that progressives are Orthodox Christians. I don't think they have been for a long time. But what I'm saying though is that they're having a way of like always the wings end up making each other more and more extreme like the wing nuts end up fighting and causing each other to go even further in the fringes. And so what's happening is I have bad news for both of you. You guys are now moderates. No, like the term the rhetoric that's being used by professing questions. I'm moving towards extreme right. No, in the middle. You're in the you're smack in the middle now. I used to be on the right. Right. So now you're moving closer to center. That's what I say. I'm moving closer to the leftist extremism. Well, that's how they were there. I think the right and left are moving further from him. But that's not how it's being spun. The rhetoric is such now where professing Christians have you haven't done anything different in like 15 years of blogging about this stuff. You have the same perspective on Islam that you always have. You have the same perspective on LGBT issues. You have the same perspective on Christ and the gospel message and all of those things. You haven't changed. And yet there are now people on the right using language that classifies you as center right center right because they now identify themselves as far right. And they do that for a reason. They wouldn't do that if it was somehow unpopular across the board to be far right. They're doing that to appeal to people who already agree that Muslim is bad and that mass immigration of pagans, for example, is bad. And that to just bring a bunch of people through the border so that they can vote Democrat is bad. Like they agree. And there must be enough people agreeing about that. That there's this whole I'm actually right of Doug Wilson. I'm actually to the right of John Braanian that actually gains traction now. There's a bunch of young men like Andrews age probably and younger who are actually being persuaded by the rhetoric that says you John Braan are in the center now. And you're actually very intolerant of people like me my friends and my family my kin we're just a little further right than you and it's always okay for you guys to punch right. It's always you always feel comfortable punching right and you never want a punch left which is just plain not true. But in their view they're punching left because they criticize Islam but they're also punching left because they criticize you for not being tough enough on Islam by saying not only do I not want Muslims to be the dominant political force. Also I don't want any brown people to cross the border at all. That's getting back to the point that you made earlier that there's a there is a distinction that people make that's based on basically skin color and then they make all of these cultural assumptions based on the color of a person. So they keep they keep they're playing fast and loose and they're doing it on purpose. And so I want to. I there are people who are trying to call this out so there are people who used to be considered far right including Doug Wilson and James White and Jeff Durbin and a bunch of others who we consider tribe you know family who are doing what they've always done which is calling out racism and you know partiality no matter where it's coming from. Feminism feminism and anti Christianity you know abhorrent sexual behavior all that and they are now being accused of being uncharitable of the far right and slandering them and they're destroying them destroying them and being in sin. Yeah because of their position which has always been the same. And so here's something that is something that's weird is that they don't disagree with the far right on most of those things but the far right of Jax because they don't they they're not pushing enough they're not vocal enough they're not they're not. It's it's it's it's propaganda propaganda that's making people fall for this because yes it's not logical it's purely emotional but here's what was shared this is a guy named Paul Liberati and he writes all the time and he tags his wife Vanessa and everything that he writes and it's just a bunch of stuff that's meant to sound academic and careful and balanced and it's just laced with a bunch of half truth or sometimes exaggerations and all out misconceptions so what he writes first of all is one of the accusations being leveled against the. The new Christian right. Either way attaching Christian to that new Christian right is the far right right is begging the question because the question is are they Christian at all and to your point dad they're completely offended that you should even ask that question it's completely inappropriate that you should even ask the quote. You write if they're Christian you just have to assume because they say yeah yeah I've lost count of the number of times I've been told it's disrespectful and and unloving to question somebody's faith you don't question a person's faith so this is a leftist tactic but it's on the right and so this guy is saying Paul is saying even by those more friendly to Christian nationalism in other words people who have been identifying as Christian nationalist themselves for a few years now the criticism is that there's too much of a question. Too much of a quote victimhood mentality driving our discussion right that's a card that's being played so often that it needs to be addressed here are some initial thoughts first victimization is a real thing Paul that's really thought provoking there victimizations a real thing you say it goes hand in hand with injustice because every crime has a victim big things happening there's some big thing happening over here from Paul. Every crime has a victim victimization is a real thing. They're all the victim mindset. So the category itself is a legitimate one yes well there are victims of crime I would agree. Okay I'm glad not the only one who found this. Thank goodness we've established that for sure. Second here's a second point second it's true the current political climate is quote driving the conversation mass immigration anti white discrimination and preference for foreign and non Christian students workers renters and employees have not escaped the notice of the further right. And yes it makes them angry but for most of my friends and reform churches that's led them in a positive direction to engage in more research to speak up and speak out to call for and work toward change. Sounds liberal and to go back and study the Bible and the reformed tradition a lot more carefully none of that is bad or inherently wrong. I can't remember if he gets back around to the question of whether he's got a victim mindset or not. He wants us to imagine a man goes through a divorce or the tragic loss of a child and it's the result of a great injustice that experience would break his heart drive him to his knees it would lead him to research the laws and the details of the case he would speak out higher lawyer and testifying court as a Christian he would give himself to a deeper and more careful study of scripture in the history of the church. And if necessary look for ways to change the very laws of the land the personal nature of that injustice whatever it was along with his righteous indignation would naturally propel him with greater passion and urgency as he takes up the work before him. And again none of that was wrong and it doesn't prove anything about the quality of his thinking or the accuracy of his conclusion that's true none of that does prove that he has accurate conclusion. He might even conclude that several factors had conspired against him to bring about the situation but we would be wrong to simply write him off as suffering from a quote with victimhood mentality as if that was driving his pursuits. So his point is that because people because people suffer injustices any sort of reaction that they have to that is justifiable. I don't think any sort of thing that a person does when they have been unjustly to make the point even more than he is I think you're attempting to be logical here and all he's doing is painting word pictures for all of these men who feel sorry for themselves is what he's doing well I don't understand I was you read that I was like okay what's he trying to say and I my initial thought was well he didn't really say anything. So here's the people have big feelings when bad things happen to them right and he didn't address whether it's an accurate charge that these people have given to. Well that was the question I was going to ask is is is are they justified in being a victim did a crime take place doesn't go around he doesn't get around to that because it wasn't useful. That's the most important part of this what he said was so for the record acknowledging that certain factors are driving the conversation about politics today is very different from what people are trying to accomplish by using the rhetoric of a victimhood mentality so they're he just concludes. He just goes straight to the conclusion that it is in fact rhetoric it is not a accurate charge think about it he says what's the actual purpose of using that description. The answer is that it serves to pre invalidate another man's arguments by suggesting he's approaching things from a wrong state of mind even when he appeals to scripture serves as a kind of presuppositional tactic an attempt to get behind him beneath his exegesis and identify some supposedly defective mentality that can be used to delegitimize anything else he tries to argue. But he started by saying that victimhood is a real thing right well yeah but none of that none of these are actual logical sylophysicism. So now he's leftist storytelling is what this is like but he's right wing yes is the leftist tactic of using rhetoric but it's an emotional appeals to emotion but it's being fed to white young men. So how I would interpret that if I was a non-thinking right wing young man is I would say yes victimhood is a real thing therefore I am actually a victim now and it's unjust and it is it's time for me to stand up and push back against this because I I too. I'm a victim of gross injustice and I can't really articulate exactly what that injustice is but it drove me to my knees in prayer yes it drove me to my knees in prayer and I cried out to God and I am now I'm willing to stand up and and take a stand I'm justified of being angry because this is going on for so long. Well eventually it's the bottom he's like basically when you're going to accuse him to be a victim you have to establish whether they were actually a victim and it has you know cloud of their judgment or whether it's a valid way for them to feel and it's like thanks Paul you wrote like 3000 unnecessary words to try to sound academic when really you just didn't even answer the question at the end of it. Are there people on the right who are playing the victim because it feels good to indulge their emotions yes absolutely that is like I don't have to name them specifically and I don't have to prove to them as an individual they belong to that category for us to surely we can agree that there are people in all different categories of life who fit the bill of victim minded and if you react the way that Paul just did hearing the word if you get should I say triggered when you hear the word victimhood you probably are the dog that is yelping because the rock hit you when it was tossed in the middle of the pile but I mean I'm just saying I'm just recognizing some patterns and human behavior here you should not have that reaction to hearing that some people play the victim instead of using logic well isn't it true that all of us could could probably come up with a few examples of times that we have been treated unjustly. Yeah well I'm thinking about that article that I should with you a little earlier last week about you know the woman who got a cost by the guy on the bike trail. And how and we actually had an exchange you know she and I about that and she would then she doubled down on what she said you know she was mad at me for not quoting her in my article but I said I left you anonymous because I wasn't trying to accuse you of lying and being sceptical I said what bothers me and I never question that you were afraid I never question that you felt like you were afraid. You had been you know unsafe that wasn't my my objection was the way that you paid it with a broad brush and told all men that they need to do better because this is quote happening to all women or lots of women all the time and it's like no it's not it happened it's a one time thing that happened to you. And so to go online and she does this she does this all the time it's like every anecdotal event that happens in her life is indicative of this huge systemic problem that men are just abusive and women are all unsafe because men are roaming on shaperone you know out in the world and it's just ridiculous. How often are we misunderstanding because we're trying to make too much sense out of their I said this before we're trying to make too much sense out of their essentially emotional blather like it's just they're not even trying to make a point she's not even trying to make the point that all men blah blah blah I know she used those words that's what she said I know she did and then the guy that shared it it was like scolding men do better and I'm like I know but like there's a way to get that and I was describing this for Luke and I was like I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I know I'm sorry. No I'm sorry. Yes I'm sorry. I just love it. No I'm sorry. Yes A bad challenge or something. Moto I just love it I just love it. Yes. Now what if we had twenty something you know had it like a long time ago that fs Z masked shot without me? or maybe with me? Again though it's me? And, yeah. His was showing himself a Haushalt forecast a right Brazil or really. It's like finding and curiating. When adults do it. It's infuriating too. But it's also like, something is going on here. When people are able to use the English words that say, a declarative sentence makes a statement. It ends with a period. And still, when you ask, okay, so what kind of sentence is this? It's a declarative. So what should it end with? And that poor little human being goes, I don't know what you're talking about! And it's like, you just said it. It was not landing for some reason. It wasn't clicking when they were saying it. And so they're using words. And they look like English words. And their words that we try to make sense out of. Because we're rational. And we're trying to figure out what their point is. Right. And they don't have a point. Except I feel things. Please feel with me. That's it. Like, it's not rational. It's not logical. And so what I'm saying to you is that we have people on the right and the left both who do not operate in the world of logic. They are extremely susceptible to rhetoric. And now we have people, we've always had Christians. I've always been aware of the Christian professing leftists who use rhetoric to their advantage and their wolves. And they take control of really goalable, mainly minorities, quote-unquote. They'll take advantage of very emotional people who are always very emotional people who are maybe brown or maybe gay or maybe young, you know. And so the leftists have all historically appealed to those types of people because they use this rhetoric, which is emotionally charged. Now I'm seeing more aware of the right wing version of that. You're seeing emotional language. And we have, so Eric Khan shared that quote, that whole big long post from Paul. And was like, great thoughts. That's objectively false, Eric. Those were not great thoughts. It was emotion. It was just a bunch of rhetoric. It was, but they were great because they made Eric feel away. Made it feel. But Eric added his own comments. And this is what Eric says. It is also unhelpful to resort to add hominem tropes about your opponents. Like everyone who disagrees with me is a basement dwelling in cell with daddy issues and a sub ADIQ. We should see many problems with this, including the fact that it is a ninth commandment violation to lie about other people. As Doug Wilson once said, we should seek to steal man our opponents and treat their arguments fairly. Right. One of the biggest issues in America is the forced genocide of white people. What the, where did that come from? I was, I was just about to say, isn't that an ad hominem? Well, that's not necessarily an ad hominem. That's just a randomly unsubstantiated claim. Right. It came out of left field. But he goes on. This includes the issues with displacement immigration. In today's climate, if you point out these problems, which I'm just going to take as givens, then many on the right will say you're bitter or envious or jealous. Also say you're crazy. The reality from my perspective is that many good facial Christian men and fathers with good families are rightly recognized. These are real problems. They are seeking to do good in real places to address these problems in a faithful manner. To slander such men continually is evil. They aren't Nazis, anti-Semites, racist, misogynist, bigots or homophobes either. They simply want to live out of the Ordo Amoris for their people as an expression of love to God and love to neighbor. And it's like they aren't Nazis. Who's not Nazi? They aren't Nazis or anti-Semites or racist, except for the ones who are. Right, Eric? Right. But I don't think, honestly, I don't think that his followers have IQs high enough. I know he's going to call that slander. You know, be heard me say it, call it slander. I genuinely don't think his followers have IQs smart enough, you know, high enough to know that they're being taken. This is not a rational argument. He did not make a case. He has not proven a point. He made claims like we know this is true. Very candid so-ons move. Yeah. And he didn't, he didn't back it up. So I actually responded. You responded. Actually responded. And you kind of proud of myself for not, I know we're over time, but I'm kind of proud of myself. We are over time. It's not my fault. I'm proud of myself for writing the kind of comment that literally can only be responded to with where's your husband log off? There's the only possible thing that these- The only reasonable response is where's your husband? The only thing that could possibly- You should take away your internet access. So what I said to Eric and by extension Paul was well done. It was a masterful decision to list mass immigration, which Wilson agrees is bad for any country, right next to quote genocide of white people, which is an emotionally charged bit of color specific rhetoric that leftists have used to motorized young black men for decades. Quick clarification. Are questions slanderous? I'm trying to tread carefully here so I don't scare off the not racist and not victim-minded young men who've been told their perspective against want an immigration is the real issue. It's not. That's a straw man actually. I've been called names by leftists for my perspective against immigration for years and years and years and so is Wilson. So there's something else being slipped into that package which is causing the real problems. Can you explain to me what you mean about forced white genocide without sounding like a Nazi? I definitely don't want you to sound like a Nazi using propaganda like real atrocities carefully mixed with untruths to manipulate those who are weary and vulnerable. So would you explain clearly and without appealing to emotion how white people like me are being forced into genocide? Do you mean via abortion, which is a great evil but not exactly quote forced so much as quote rebelliously and wickedly chosen by pagan white people? Or do you mean quote white people are committing suicide through the adoption of identity politics, which toppled the German Empire and neutered the so-called African American community in the United States because it's a poisonous ideology which God hates. Is that what you mean? If you mean either of those I completely agree and I find there to be no poo here in this porridge. That's a reference to the fact that he's big hurt over Doug Wilson saying his ideology is laced with poo. He said it like three times in one thread. Doug said we're laced with poo. Doug said we're laced with poo. The ideology is laced with poo. Yes, it was a victim of Doug's poo comment. Poo-pour-d. But I said if you're claiming quote one of the biggest issues in America is the genocide of white people and this includes displacement immigration what else does it include exactly? What else is happening that you're calling a genocide of white people? Right. Oh and also are you lamenting the displacement of Christian brother specifically or specifically the white ones? Yes, I took a screenshot. Oh clarification on this would help sir. Yes, I took a screenshot full disclosure. I've heard that you like to block those who are persistent with their questions. This will be a good opportunity to demonstrate that you really are motivated to quote address these problems in a faithful manner and certainly not crafting an insulated and unquestionable narrative for white young men. Did you get a response? No, but a guy above me did it got a like. Now to be fair, I posted that this morning and it's Sunday so. Oh, well wait, but he did have time to go and click like on this random. Guy who has an animated bear for a profile picture. Well, so. But they eat it up like catnip and it's it's people who feel vulnerable. They feel weak. They feel like they've been victimized by something which to your point is literally everybody on the planet and I've claimed that. I've been victimized. But these like like Michael the guy with the animated bears like when you look at UK and France today the obvious biggest problem obviously is mass immigration. The Muslims are taking over everything violence rate murder riots erupt in the streets. I don't want that here in my country. Okay, so far. So good. I totally agree with Michael that importing a whole bunch of Muslims into the UK and France. I want to a whole bunch of people with different ideology is not. But Eric slipped that in there. It's called a mountain Bailey. Yes, slipped it in there knowing that everybody on the right agrees with it and then said something stupid about. Grace and why do you want to say that he can't back up because he's dishonest right. Right. Right. You make the you make the claim that everybody agrees with and then you then you switch it out for the controversial extremist thing. Right. So he so you know Michael goes on says I speak out about it. I point out the people are different. They have different cultures different ways of thinking and behaving not to mention they have a different god they worship demons. And I don't want that here. Yeah, amen Michael. I agree. It'll be extremely bad for us and for our children. What's the response I have when I just have that opinion my church gets split up. I lost. I just get split up. His church gets split up and people people tell him that he doesn't have the right to that opinion basically. Oh, yeah, I have it. Yeah. Who are these people? That's that's what I that's the question that I'm asking more. I'm called specifically. I called all kinds of who's calling you names. Probably Muslims probably progressive Christians, but it's like Michael. Get over it. I've been called things by Eric Consfault. I've been told I'm a little woman who doesn't have a right to the opinion and somehow I'm able to carry on with my day. Yeah, somehow. So this is the victim mindset we're talking about. Oh, they called me names. Yes. And Doug Wilson is being called names. He's being called fat by Eric's leadership in his church. They're slandering and playing the victim. They're they dished out all the time and can't take it back. And so it's it's big. It's bad where the rhetoric on both sides is causing more and more extremism on both sides. So I posted a thing today that was not really a shot at the right. But this is more of a leftist thing where I said stop erasing me. I have the right to exist and by exist. I mean, demand legislation. The privilege is my opinions dog doesn't desire is with no regard for you. So stop erasing me. And I had a guy respond. And this is either this is either brilliant or these stupid. Are you stupid? Yeah, he said blocking you. Goodbye. I don't know what and I don't know if he's. Go either way. Yeah, I don't know. But that's that's either a brilliant response or he's an idiot. I'm not sure which it is. Well, listen, I I have been very sympathetic toward Christian nationalism. Thanks to the work of Doug Wilson. I can co there is a version of it that I could totally get behind. I don't think it's okay to replace our Christian culture with a false god and you know demons. Obviously. So I'm correct. But until these poor low IQ basement dwellers figure out the difference between white nationalism and Christian nationalism. I do not trust them. I don't want to live in a neighborhood full of people who worship demons. Yeah. And I don't want to live in a neighborhood full of people who worship white people. White demons. Yeah, white who have the white idols and white false gods that they are also guilty of worshipping. Yeah, I don't want to worship. I don't want to worship white people either. And I am a white people. Go home. Go home. They're thinking of horse boat and horse sandwich down on their thorny fort. Everybody to your room. Everybody means that that's quite enough. What do you have? I literally at some point during that conversation just live the mic over myself. Yeah, and that was fine. That was fine. I am the white man, so I have no say. He's impressed. Please! Somebody this week I don't want to hear from you, but if your husband has something to say here. has something to say on all ears. So what do you want to say to that man? That's so funny that he doesn't realize I don't have anything to say. Thanks for visiting the comedian's house. If you want to spend more time with our family, you can follow John Branion on YouTube and Facebook. Also email nextdoor at johnbranion.com with your comments and questions. We'll see you next time. See you next time.