Latest / Newcomer Pod / All Eyes Are on Apple's Augmented Reality Device As the Hunt for a Revolutionary Consumer Startup Continues (w/Max Child & James Wilsterman)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome, hello. I'm Eric newcomer, welcome to, I
- 0:16guess, we're still calling it a dead cat for the time.
- 0:18Being I have with me, Max child and James, will stir men who are
- 0:23the co-founders of volley, but who I first got to know, is sort
- 0:27of the older guard on the The Crimson, the newspaper.
- 0:31Max's, the President James was edshare, right?
- 0:35Yeah. Which is our sort of it opinion
- 0:37page, we'd, I guess. And so I don't know to the
- 0:41extent that newcomer has a secret board of directors.
- 0:45You know, they're on it out any upset.
- 0:49I don't know. Yeah, you wouldn't.
- 0:51You wouldn't let us invest. Yeah, not for me.
- 0:56Investment opportunity. If I ever raise give you
- 0:58allocation break, Free advice. Yeah.
- 1:03James wrote the slogan, you're seated, the cap table.
- 1:06Yeah. And you are a little skeptical
- 1:09of that at first, but I think it's had some saying Powers.
- 1:12I'm skeptical of everything in first, but yeah, and yeah.
- 1:16So they've been super involved. Great to have you guys on unlike
- 1:20my previous co-host, Max and James are startup Founders.
- 1:25And so, In The Biz and run a voice games company, Called
- 1:30Vale. So I'm gonna have them just
- 1:32like, give a little context on their company to start off with.
- 1:35I've been watching it sort of in when it was in the wilderness.
- 1:38Like, you know, as a friend they were insisting on living in Palo
- 1:42Alto just for the sort of I don't know, drudgery of it all
- 1:45to prove to prove Menlo Park, ofac check to prove their
- 1:50credentials but for this episode we want to talk about sort of
- 1:54looking for 2023 consumer apps and so I think useful to have a
- 1:58little context. Their company.
- 2:01So Vale is as used to lie described a voice game company.
- 2:05We got started on Amazon Alexa and Google home platforms about
- 2:10five years ago, we make games you can control with your voice.
- 2:14So a number of our most popular games are Name That Tune kind of
- 2:18music trivia game called song quiz for replay little clips of
- 2:21pop music and you shout out the Ted or the artist we also have a
- 2:24number of like game show properties, including Jeopardy
- 2:28Wheel of Fortune. The Price is Right Wants To Be A
- 2:31Millionaire bunch of good stuff like that and also some
- 2:34storytelling. So kind of Choose Your Own
- 2:36Adventure style, interactive fiction, kind of like audiobook,
- 2:40you control with your voice. And I know Eric likes one of
- 2:43those games that we made called guest sire.
- 2:47A medieval Knight, controlling your house.
- 2:50I've played song ways and I see the ads for it all the time, on
- 2:53Tick, Tock. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, totally.
- 2:58So, not saying much necessarily, I think we are the preeminent
- 3:01voice that game company. I think we have more users and
- 3:04more Revenue than any other. And in general, we kind of
- 3:07believe you're going to be talking to your computer's a lot
- 3:10more in the next five to ten years revenue from users or
- 3:13revenue from Amazon revenue from users, Amazon Google basically
- 3:17but front-end App, Store model. And so we have basically a
- 3:20subscription in our game. So like Jeopardy, you pay a
- 3:24subscription to play, you know, extra questions, Double
- 3:26Jeopardy, Final Jeopardy. And this is corruption is
- 3:29facilitated by By Amazon and they take their cut and we get
- 3:32the money from the users. And while you guys you did YC n
- 3:36FX, right? Yeah, we did what I see back in
- 3:40early 2018, and yeah nfx. Also, some of our earliest
- 3:44investors. So got somebody just say that,
- 3:46very assertive State deep in the Silicon Valley.
- 3:50Both big S Valley sort of circles and your, your lights be
- 3:55company. I can say that right this way.
- 3:57Yeah I really like is the one startup in the world that I'm
- 3:59required to. Keep secrets about.
- 4:01So I'm like, yeah, like what can we say here?
- 4:04What do you want to? Yeah, that's what do you want to
- 4:07ask here? How many rounds have you raised?
- 4:11I don't know, or I guess kind of beheading on how you count them.
- 4:14Something like that, but most recently raised a series B.
- 4:17Yeah, we're at Lightspeed portfolio company.
- 4:20Jeremy Lou who's obviously very famous for Snapchat.
- 4:22Among other things is a big investor in us and a good friend
- 4:27as well and yeah, I mean we're he's a reason Leaf World
- 4:30somewhere right now. He is off traveling, the world,
- 4:33he's living the dream right now. He's taking his kids off, 15
- 4:36months World Tour, which is pretty awesome.
- 4:38But, yeah, I mean in general, we've kind of seen Silicon
- 4:40Valley, like you said from the shitbox apartment and Menlo Park
- 4:44district. Seven years ago, all the way to
- 4:46being a series because put it outside of the company.
- 4:49I mean, I remember James was trying to convince me that Dows
- 4:54were like a huge thing. Definitely, at a time when I
- 4:57could have made a lot of money in that Space.
- 5:00If I ordered active investors you could have definitely lost a
- 5:04lot of money. Yeah that's how you know, if you
- 5:06had taken my advice as well but yeah, Max and I were both pretty
- 5:11early and sort of seeing the emergence of crypto.
- 5:15I think we personally didn't really, you know, become rich
- 5:18off of that bad rap. Yeah, benefit for me, either.
- 5:24I ran a test if Theory mm node from my computer, meaning a
- 5:27theory, but not launched yet, and he had did not By any
- 5:30Theory, I'm at that time which I would have paid off pretty well.
- 5:35But we did think sort of the mainstream Tech journalists like
- 5:38yourself at the time at Bloomberg were kind of ignoring
- 5:41the whole crypto Story. I mean this is like 2013 or 2014
- 5:45right so yeah or was it you feel about then burned by his there's
- 5:51a 2014 crash right? All the crashes start to run
- 5:54together wasn't this post sort of that?
- 5:57Runoff what or yeah yeah but I mean I think it was after that,
- 6:01what mizdow is were, after is sort of the big and now have
- 6:04nothing. Now hack was in 2016 are, right?
- 6:07So so so I think people felt reporters and I'm trying to move
- 6:11away from media but I think, you know, me reporters and myself.
- 6:15Felt like, yo, man, I don't know.
- 6:16We did this whole crypto thing. Yeah, yeah, we Max and I had the
- 6:20time that the Dow hack happened. We were just so astonished by
- 6:25how, you know, someone could steal 60 million dollars from
- 6:30Like a digital scale joke but just now a joke.
- 6:34Yeah, the there's been much worse scams and frauds.
- 6:37Yeah. We were fairly convinced.
- 6:40It was like the largest heist in world history at the time, I was
- 6:43like Ocean's 11 style but no one seemed to care.
- 6:47And now we just gotta to do so you can send good, see your four
- 6:49billion dollars, you know? So crypto interested voice game,
- 6:54lots of. I feel like you're and with a
- 6:57board or an investor who's known for Consumer investing.
- 7:01So those are some of the sort of consumer credentials.
- 7:04I mean, the goal here is to sort of look forward and think of
- 7:072023, but I sort of want to jump straight to sort of a tough
- 7:12question that I think helps frame it, which is just like, I
- 7:17don't know, theme attic investing at all.
- 7:19Like, you guys are built in my mind, at least on sort of
- 7:23Amazon, like, pumping out Alexa's all over the world and
- 7:27being like, Oh man, if they succeed in that, you know, No,
- 7:30we're gonna do great obviously. You see it as much bigger than
- 7:33that but I don't know. It's sort of where investors
- 7:36ever interested in the audio. There was a moment where people
- 7:39were like are pods are the next platform or how do you as a
- 7:42company. Think about sort of these VC
- 7:44driven like platform thematic. Sort of manias, I think maybe we
- 7:49should talk first about kind of what we were doing right before
- 7:52we started Bali which was working in the chat bot World
- 7:56which was yeah 0 remember an insane I'd say All of it, all of
- 8:00its own and we were building games for Facebook Messenger at
- 8:05the time that we got our first investment from nfx.
- 8:10So I think we've experienced a lot of these hype Cycles.
- 8:13We found that, you know, voice was kind of a natural extension,
- 8:17boys. Games was a natural extension
- 8:18off of our chat box game ideas. So we've seen that whole cycle
- 8:23and it's amazing to me right now that you're starting to see the
- 8:25chat bot whole hype cycle re-emerge with AI.
- 8:30A lot of the same ideas kind of becoming try it again.
- 8:33There were, there were lots of, you know, medical assistant,
- 8:35Chad bods and games and you know, anything tutors, right?
- 8:40Anything you can imagine Financial Services advisors
- 8:42there was all happening in 2016, and now, we're just seeing it
- 8:46again with the emergence of, you know, Ela Lems.
- 8:49So, I think it's just fascinating to think about how
- 8:53these go in waves and I think Max and I specifically, you
- 8:58know, maybe got started in a hype cycle.
- 9:00But pivoted into voice which I don't think was as hot ever as
- 9:04anything that, you know, probably you've seen.
- 9:08Yeah, I mean anyone who asked me like, oh, you know, how do you
- 9:11feel about voice? I feel like it was super hyped
- 9:14back in like, 2017, 2018, and now it's really cold and I'm
- 9:16like, I don't know. Can you name a vc-backed startup
- 9:20besides us in the void space like certainly not a consumer
- 9:24one, like I struggle. Yeah.
- 9:26I mean, I don't think there ever was a real.
- 9:28Wasn't least there was that like yeah.
- 9:30The group on guy didn't need to do some like, podcasting
- 9:33tortillas he's doing like a podcast editing thing.
- 9:36Yeah, was it any liked it? Pivoted to descriptive,
- 9:39interesting and amazing. Yeah, but, yeah, I mean, in
- 9:42general, I think like, sometimes the ratio of new stories to
- 9:45actual VC Investments about something is like, 20 21.
- 9:49You know, sometimes species actually are pretty caught up in
- 9:51the hype cycle, you know, I think, obviously web three in
- 9:54the last year to was a real hype cycle, right?
- 9:57I think and sometimes these Trends are really about one.
- 10:00Like people want to make it in time, but it's like Clubhouse
- 10:03and I uh, I mean, yeah, audio audio /.
- 10:06Yeah, social audio are pods was just Club at.
- 10:09I mean, that was no other company in that space.
- 10:11Like everybody's got their blog post out, but there was no other
- 10:15actual investment. Something I find interesting is
- 10:20kind of like what kicks off the hype cycle.
- 10:22Is it usually companies like raising a series a day or is it
- 10:26a consumer company that sort of reaches a Breakout Out, you
- 10:30know, user kind of download numbers or metrics on the App
- 10:34Store, is it? Something else, like, BC is
- 10:37themselves driving the hype cycle?
- 10:39I think, you know, there's a lot of kind of delay to the whole
- 10:44thing, right? Like the people who are now
- 10:46investing in AI, are investing in companies and Founders that
- 10:50have been thinking about AI for two to three years or more
- 10:54right, right. And raising money at the seed
- 10:56and proceed stage for the most part out there sort of the
- 11:00Either hype cycle and then sort of the more public hype cycle
- 11:03delayed and you know, part of what I'm trying to do is and the
- 11:06information I'd say we're trying to figure out what the height,
- 11:10you know that sort of inside Benchmark injury since Sequoia
- 11:13like who are they going after? But like I guess before we make
- 11:16predictions we can talk about like failed hype Cycles a little
- 11:19bit and like I mean Pop Shop seems in deep trouble like
- 11:23talking to people around that, you know, I haven't gotten story
- 11:26together but that this sort of yeah, that seems Really, really
- 11:30troubled and then whatnot. I got some sensor Tower data.
- 11:34That seem to show that they'd there were down from, from a
- 11:37peak. So that was the category that
- 11:39was hot. This sort of yeah, QVC near
- 11:41shopping. Yeah, right.
- 11:43Well, I think that was a trend, you know, a sort of metas trend
- 11:47of EC is investing in things that worked in China and
- 11:49consumer social and thinking, that that will translate the
- 11:53United States and a general. I'm not saying that's even
- 11:55wrong. I think that is actually a
- 11:56pretty interesting way to invest, right?
- 11:58Can you take the successes? Giant consumer internet
- 12:01companies in China and bring it over.
- 12:03And so, a bunch of really successful QVC's in China.
- 12:07I think the whatnot. I mean, I think you, and I
- 12:09talked about what not to let you know, 18 months ago and we're
- 12:11like my take was, what not is absolutely killing everyone
- 12:15else. Like there's a bunch of hype
- 12:17around the pop shops and newness and a couple other ones and
- 12:21whatnot is like a thousand times bigger than any of these
- 12:23companies. And I think there's still like a
- 12:26plausible case for whatnot, but I think they raised their last
- 12:29round at like two and a half. Billion-dollar valuation.
- 12:31And you know, if you look at what they're selling, it's
- 12:33basically like sneakers and Pokemon cards and collectible
- 12:37plush toys and stuff. And the price think I did the
- 12:40man, plumbing. But prices are always, things
- 12:43are plummeting a super correlated with the, you know,
- 12:45born obscenities in seventh and secondarily.
- 12:47I think, at a two and a half billion dollar valuation.
- 12:49I think with current and multiples, you basically have to
- 12:53have 100 percent market share in like, all of those markets to
- 12:57even sort of justify that valuation.
- 12:59So, You have basically have to have every baseball card in
- 13:02America soldier, what not, every Pokemon, pirate, every, and then
- 13:05so you gotta see on upside in other markets for it to make
- 13:07sense. Yeah.
- 13:08If they have to succeed in non collectible markets doesn't seem
- 13:12like that's working yet. There's also some question
- 13:15worried about ya, their Marketplace strategy in general,
- 13:18and are they basically having to do individual deals with these
- 13:23hobbyists collectible shops, or are people able to actually go
- 13:27on and sell their own Collectibles?
- 13:29And How does that kind of contribute to their own cost
- 13:32structure with like maintaining inventory of Collectibles that
- 13:35are super volatile and all these things right there is some
- 13:38question. Whether they actually own stuff
- 13:40themselves raised that we right? That's what I'm saying.
- 13:43Yeah yeah. Are they holding inventory and
- 13:46or just in the world and sweet. We interested we would like to
- 13:50know what. I think the second point is like
- 13:52are the people who are selling on what not are they essentially
- 13:55non-employees per se but effectively vertically
- 13:58integrated into what not right. I mean, are they?
- 14:00You know, are that part of what size are they to be selling on
- 14:04on what not? This is not unique to what?
- 14:06Not just Marketplace question. I think that's important to ask
- 14:10is. Yeah.
- 14:11How, how much is the supply side driven by the company striking,
- 14:16lots of deals with the suppliers versus a lot of like, pull from
- 14:20the, you know, the suppliers wanting to be on that platform.
- 14:23I mean, you covered obviously Uber extensively, so it's a
- 14:27similar type question, right? Like, are these Supply Liars of
- 14:30rides. You know, heavily incentivized.
- 14:32Are they employers? You know, total are they?
- 14:35Yeah, right. Well in Ubers case, you know,
- 14:37they all floated, the capital risk under the yeah.
- 14:40Anyway, I get talked about that. Unless, I mean, yeah, there's
- 14:42always that sort of opens the big question that James, our
- 14:45disgusting, like, a week ago, which is like, is marketplaces a
- 14:48fake Trend, like, you know, have there ever been any?
- 14:51Have there ever been any successful Market places besides
- 14:54eBay Amazon and like debatably uberX, like ever, you know, like
- 14:59that. He is not a Marketplace every
- 15:01day, I'm sorry. Yeah.
- 15:02That was are being damaged in our.
- 15:04Yeah. But if you think of Larry be
- 15:06reserved, is this a hot-melt logic where I like this?
- 15:09Yeah, yeah. Go go.
- 15:10Let's go forth. What is worth looking pathetic
- 15:13trick? Yes, we were looking at the, you
- 15:16know, the a 16 Marketplace list instacart is considered one of
- 15:20their top marketplaces. Tell me that somebody's keeps
- 15:23making noises valuation. You know the question is, are
- 15:26random people throwing up things to sell and it's very obviously
- 15:29not So what are those deals look like between instacart and the
- 15:33grocery stores chains. You know, I have no idea but
- 15:37it's certainly not like eBay or even Amazon where there's sort
- 15:40of this permissionless marketplace where anyone can
- 15:43just put things on it. And I think that's a kind of an
- 15:46important distinction. You guys had this sort of
- 15:48injury, you'll sometimes get frustrated with my stories where
- 15:51all right? Consumer investors are just like
- 15:54desperate for anything. They'd like, you know, anything
- 15:57to invest in like there's a, you know, basically, it's a Are you
- 16:00know, your consumer investor, some of the Smart Ones, you
- 16:03know, I am in Saratov old bench, mark.
- 16:05Kate analysis is one of her biggest companies.
- 16:07Not, not a consumer, but my point is, there are VCS who feel
- 16:10like they need to invest in consumer deals.
- 16:13But yet, it can still feel hard to raise sort of off theme, or
- 16:16how sort of talk talk through your experience with that
- 16:20Dynamic working. Feel like there's this money,
- 16:22chasing all these bad ideas and yet it's hard to get feces to
- 16:26pay attention to what you think is a real business.
- 16:28I don't think there's There's that much consumer investing at
- 16:32the A and B scale for the last five to seven years.
- 16:35I mean, I think we're joking around about the hot deals,
- 16:37right? You know, Clubhouse.
- 16:38And you know what? Not again, which I think is more
- 16:41of a real business than most, you know, a couple other in a
- 16:43market places that, you know, camping one that Saratov all did
- 16:47and some tips Camp, some hip Camp even be real, which I think
- 16:51is like a historically successful consumer, social app
- 16:54might not end up being an amazing.
- 16:55And I know I literally just pulled out like in France.
- 16:58It's already sort of leveling. If there are questions of
- 17:01whether it's leveling off the u.s. to.
- 17:03Yeah. So the question is, like, if you
- 17:05have maybe two, maybe three big consumer deals per year for the
- 17:08entire Sandhill industry. Like, you know, and you're
- 17:11talking the top 10, the top 20 of these days or whatever.
- 17:13Like it is consumer investing like a real category, almost
- 17:18like, it's sort of, I think we have found our way or whatever.
- 17:22But I think in general it's just not that hot of a space since
- 17:26maybe 2013 2014. And so I think, You know, we can
- 17:30joke around about the big deals making sense or not, but a
- 17:32general, I think the sort of quote unquote stupidbunny
- 17:35choosing bad deals. You know, which I don't
- 17:37necessarily ascribe to. But if you do ascribe to that
- 17:39its large, letting it be to be SAS crypto, you know, and a
- 17:43couple other things or interesting or Woods.
- 17:46I mean, they, you know, Clubhouse sub stack.
- 17:48I mean, I'm not gonna make you guys get on them, but you have
- 17:52oceans of money. Ocean money cheese.
- 17:54Pretty small user base is pretty small.
- 17:56Revenue basis is almost exclusively in B2B, SAS and
- 17:59crypto. And a couple crazy outlier deals
- 18:01in the last 5-10 years and gaming is a whole category of
- 18:05its own that we're somewhat, you know, in although we are
- 18:09building games on a new platform, which makes us more of
- 18:12a kind of consumer type investable play.
- 18:14Right. The thing about gaming, I think
- 18:16that's really important is the fact that you get Revenue
- 18:20earlier on in your trajectory. I think that's classic consumer
- 18:24Investments. Like, social networks haven't
- 18:28seem to work since, you know, 14 2015 where you are just
- 18:32creating, you know, a massive audience that can somehow
- 18:36monetize down the line and be real would be a perfect example
- 18:39of something like that. We haven't seen it, make any
- 18:41Revenue yet. I mean to talk about VC in sort
- 18:44of the most basic terms. People want to believe either
- 18:48there's a new platform and invest in the platform.
- 18:51And if you can't invest in somebody who uses it or invest
- 18:55in sort of a new style business new thesis empowered by
- 18:58technology, I mean that's sort of Marketplaces and platform
- 19:02plays and now it's sort of your sight, okay?
- 19:04But marketplaces were they even really, really that great and
- 19:10and they're having a new platforms, I mean, the iPhone is
- 19:14really the platform's iron, amazing investable strategy.
- 19:17I mean, that's our that would be our pitch for volley is if you
- 19:21can find a winner on the brand new platform and it actually
- 19:24turns into a very meaningful platform, that is a great
- 19:27investment. However, things very is.
- 19:29Voice of platform right now. Are your it'd still be a bet on?
- 19:33I think we talked about it as an interface out platform, right?
- 19:35I don't think like, I think we can all jacked up to say, like
- 19:38Alexa is going to be in 200 million houses, but is not going
- 19:42to be the iPhone, right? But like, do we think people are
- 19:45going to talk to their phones, their TVs, they're smart, you
- 19:49know, speaker devices eventually, you know, their
- 19:52computers, their ARB, our guys. Just like to me, it seems
- 19:54clearly. Yes, that, you know, people are
- 19:57going to be talking to computers a lot more five years.
- 20:00Today than they are today, right?
- 20:01And whether or not those computers are little hockey puck
- 20:03sold by Amazon. I think you can make the case
- 20:06either way. But fundamentally, like, you
- 20:08know, how could you have an arv, our glasses experience without
- 20:11robust voice control, right? How can you have an amazing
- 20:14Smart TV experience without good voice control?
- 20:16Right. It just seems like we're sort of
- 20:18long people talking to computers and and we're also long Alexa,
- 20:22don't get us wrong. But like the macro take is that
- 20:25people are going to talk computers a lot more 25 years
- 20:27for that the gaming piece. You touched on.
- 20:30I mean, I honestly don't know. Like do you have a sense of how
- 20:35that space is being affected by the downturn or I mean they're
- 20:38not investing it like gaming Investments today.
- 20:42I mean I yeah and this is so old.
- 20:44Now I think of like people invest in Zynga and rode that
- 20:48there were sort of the supercell investors who made a I mean, A
- 20:52lot of the gaming style Investments, I think of people
- 20:54being excited about in 2021 had a crypto element, right?
- 20:58Or what do you think of sort of gaming investors doing right
- 21:02now? I do you think like a lot of the
- 21:05gaming companies? There was a lot of m&a activity.
- 21:08Right? The biggest em, a deal of of the
- 21:10last year was Microsoft making an offer for Activision Blizzard
- 21:15great. So I think that, you know, these
- 21:19giant gaming companies that are on Platform imaginable, what
- 21:23including console and PC, and mobile are still great
- 21:27businesses, but maybe they're less kind of grow stock or you
- 21:32did there more kind of established businesses.
- 21:35The more exciting non crypto gaming stuff I think you have
- 21:39to, like, start to talk about a rvr or kind of metaverse, like,
- 21:43Roblox or kind of what epic is doing and where that goes.
- 21:47But I do think like, a lot of gaming, businesses are just huge
- 21:51Age Revenue businesses, maybe not growing super fast, right?
- 21:55Yeah. We sort of talked through some
- 21:56of the challenges of consumer but you guys, you know, aren't
- 22:01you here to prove the journalist don't have to be so negative.
- 22:04All right, let's talk about. All right.
- 22:11Yeah, 23, I mean clearly I think.
- 22:15Well, I won't give away my answer.
- 22:17I think we would all agree. What is the hottest Trend in
- 22:20your mind? Like going in?
- 22:2120:23 in terms of investing category.
- 22:24Hey, yeah. I mean, yeah.
- 22:26AI generation for sure. I think.
- 22:28Yeah. And you know what?
- 22:30You read on that space? Or are you optimistic?
- 22:33Yeah, I mean of course you want to go first a yeah?
- 22:38Yeah, yeah. James.
- 22:40No. I think I think I mean I'm
- 22:41generally pretty optimistic about any of these Trends.
- 22:46I guess I want to differentiate kind of the invest ability of
- 22:50transverses like Whether I believe in the technology like
- 22:53I'm long crypto. I'm excited about what that
- 22:55could lead to. I'm long AI.
- 22:58I'm on, you know, I was launched at Bots and I think the timing
- 23:01wasn't right in 2016. So I think that you can feel
- 23:05leave that these things will happen and not necessarily want
- 23:08to make a seed or series a investment at that moment in
- 23:12time. I think for a I specifically I'm
- 23:15pretty excited about this upcoming year.
- 23:18I think a lot will kind of depend on Wide open a.i.
- 23:23releases next. I can't you beautiful.
- 23:25Yeah, chat gbd4 I don't think anyone actually any of us know
- 23:29what that will be like there's a lot of like huge hype around
- 23:32that. So yeah.
- 23:34I could see that being a really important product and 2023 but I
- 23:39could also see it underwhelming. I do think that the next phase
- 23:43of the kind of AI thesis will be more more around.
- 23:48Chat GB, T 4X essentially, I think it'll be You know, chat
- 23:52GPT for law, chat GPT for medicine, chat, GPT for math,
- 23:58tutors chat, GPT for business, you know, Finance financial
- 24:03advisor. If I, you know, your track EP T
- 24:05in your spreadsheets, right. Everything just adding catchy
- 24:08PT. So it's a very similar to a lot
- 24:11of trends that we've seen come before where, you know, it over
- 24:144X or or whatever, you try to kind of take the existing
- 24:19technology to apply it to anything.
- 24:21Possibly imagine a lot of times that just doesn't work and it's
- 24:25a great story, if you're a Founder because you don't have
- 24:28to be an expert in AI. You can be like well figma is
- 24:32now disrupt the bull because we can be figma plus plug in some
- 24:36generative AI tools or you hear a lot of this story of like, oh,
- 24:41you know, the new companies are going to be product-driven and
- 24:43it's going to be tailoring it for end, you know?
- 24:47I mean there are a lots of Enterprise companies that give,
- 24:50you know, smaller. Our company's tools for things
- 24:53that they could Cobble together with existing products, but are
- 24:56made by for startups case for startups.
- 24:59I think the question will be do the existing incumbents kind of
- 25:04succeed, you know, better or first by just adding a i
- 25:09features to write what we saw that with Jasper fight, right?
- 25:13We're right. Exact Jasper was building off
- 25:16opening, I and then suddenly chat GPT was a big threat to
- 25:20them. Yeah.
- 25:21I think James is point. I think like, you know, startup
- 25:25Founders and the media. I think tend to be very like
- 25:27text-oriented individuals like they like to read the like to
- 25:30write and so chatty PT is super magical because you know, it's
- 25:35a, the world's greatest text generator, right?
- 25:37And I think, but most of this sort of kind of real world,
- 25:40applications of text are probably more like be to be
- 25:44oriented like the law. Like, you know, Finance like
- 25:47medicine, like sales communication like marketing
- 25:50copy, that kind of thing. You and I, yeah, I mean to this
- 25:53point, I would sort of be shocked if like Facebook doesn't
- 25:55launch a i generated ad copy, like in the next year or
- 25:58something, right? Or like, Google should launch a,
- 26:02i generated ad copy for search ads like yesterday, right?
- 26:05Like forget like, you know, marketing copywriters should be
- 26:09like obliterated in the next year, essentially, right?
- 26:11I mean, it's not gonna happen that quickly, but like he should
- 26:13be because you should just be able to ABCDE, test your
- 26:16marketing copy, you know, ad infinitum, and never really
- 26:19write anything anymore, right? Whereas, I think, On the
- 26:22consumer side of things, I'm a little more long, the sort of
- 26:25visual generation tools, that kind of make beautiful pictures
- 26:29and drawings and art and eventually I think 3D models and
- 26:32video and maybe games via the sort of AI generation.
- 26:35Like we made a little hack project where you can turn a
- 26:39stick figure drawing into like a Monet or a van Gogh or Pixar,
- 26:44you know, still right. And I think we're sort of you
- 26:47have these full-time dedicated Not not a present.
- 26:53No no. But in general like I just think
- 26:55that pictures resonate more with consumers than text to like
- 27:00distill it more fundamentally like Instagrams were popular.
- 27:03The Twitter Tick-Tock will probably be more eventually more
- 27:05popular than still pictures, right?
- 27:07Or videos already more popular than images, right?
- 27:09Like you know immersive imagery is always I think going to win
- 27:13with consumers whereas I think with B2B applications I think
- 27:17text input and output is is incredibly useful and I think
- 27:21Sort of at the Finish Line. Almost on that front.
- 27:24I do. You think another thing to watch
- 27:25on the consumer side that we're very invested in is how this a
- 27:31ilm large language model? Yes large language model
- 27:35effects, smart speakers, and boys interfaces.
- 27:39I think you know Alexa was invented in 2015.
- 27:43It's a very like mechanical interface in some ways it's you
- 27:47know, amazing for for the time it was amazing at how good it
- 27:51was. That voice recognition, but it's
- 27:53never been very conversational. You can't just kind of
- 27:57interrupted. You can't ask a lot of follow-up
- 28:00questions which were already seeing, like, Chad GPT blows
- 28:04that out of the water. So I would be surprised if kind
- 28:08of the voice companies, don't start adopting.
- 28:11Not ovule really dystopian if chats uet.
- 28:14I literally had somebody in my Twitter replies.
- 28:18I mean I could tell, you know, is some reply I from an AI
- 28:22startup company which also flagged it and I replied like
- 28:25GPT and he sent me a smile on your face but they're already
- 28:29people trying to deploy this shit like out in the wild as if
- 28:33it's a real person. I was like what a growth hack.
- 28:35But yeah once it's on speakers I mean isn't spam and generally
- 28:40going to be just like a huge problem.
- 28:41Like right, like exponentially more and more of a problem in
- 28:45the, make some weird work in the world to sort through, like
- 28:48idiots on social media as it is right.
- 28:50You got Buddy, who tweets at you and you're like, is this person
- 28:53worth listening to now you have to sort through?
- 28:56Is this an actual like robot non thinker, you know, it's it's a
- 29:00real burden for the information consumer.
- 29:03This is why the future will be more and more similar to tick
- 29:06tock and all that will matter is whether you like the thing and
- 29:11it can figure out what the present you next.
- 29:13It doesn't really you don't want in the future.
- 29:15I just don't think it makes sense.
- 29:16That he's sorting through anything like the a, I will just
- 29:19give us the thing that we will. The best dad was made.
- 29:22Yeah. You better night doesn't mean
- 29:24he's circling around Tick-Tock and I wanted to flag that with
- 29:29our mood around consumer. Be much more upbeat if Tick-Tock
- 29:33word American company because it's like, oh man, we have this
- 29:36huge. It was valued at like, I don't
- 29:37know, for in Sixty billion dollars at one point, just very
- 29:41valuable company. Yeah, we're like, oh, there have
- 29:44been no, great consumer companies, it's like, well,
- 29:46there has except for Tick-Tock. Yeah, that's a great one.
- 29:49I think Tick-Tock is really Resting because like for those
- 29:53who don't know the backstory, you know, they bought musically,
- 29:55which was this American app for lip-syncing, you know, for
- 29:58teenagers, right? That hadn't really gone anywhere
- 30:01at sort of topped out at a few tens of millions of users but
- 30:04never really rescale. They bought it the Chinese
- 30:06company by dance and they mashed it up with this news AI
- 30:10algorithm that they had developed for a noose AI app
- 30:13called tortilla right and they had developed as algorithm that
- 30:16showed you the newsfeed stuff you wanted to see text come back
- 30:19to text and mash it up with liquid.
- 30:21Making videos. And that was a huge hit in
- 30:23China, but then to bring it back to the United States.
- 30:26They had to spend, like five billion dollars on Facebook ads.
- 30:30Like, literally, they spend more money on Facebook ads.
- 30:32And I think Snapchat ads, they were the number one customer
- 30:35there as well. They bought out 25% of all
- 30:38Facebook ads. All Facebook ads in the United
- 30:40States for, like, a meaningful period of time.
- 30:43And I think that growth strategy would just never be adopted by a
- 30:47us company, or a VC vac company. Right?
- 30:49I mean, the idea that you're like, Okay, once we reach scale
- 30:53would be a huge multi-hundred billion our company, but it's
- 30:56going to cost five billion dollars in face.
- 30:58But the cats like, you know, more than the market cap of most
- 31:01companies to pull this off. So you know, hey you know,
- 31:04Sequoia drusen, right? You want to write us this five
- 31:06billion dollar check so we can reach the scale like no effing
- 31:09way, right? And so it's kind of a
- 31:11fascinating strippy, you know, it's almost like the Urgent 5
- 31:15billion or you is that just oh, yeah, no, they spent five
- 31:18billion on ads just in the United States like you could
- 31:20just look at the Documents from Facebook and Snapchat of stuff
- 31:23that just literally had to like, admit in their SEC documents
- 31:26that their biggest spender was a bite dance for like two years on
- 31:30the whole, she was basically gone.
- 31:32Yeah. Exactly.
- 31:33Right. Right.
- 31:34And so like, what's interesting and to come back to gaming?
- 31:37Actually, one thing that's interesting is gaming companies
- 31:39have never been shy about having to pay for their users about
- 31:42having to do paid marketing, right?
- 31:44Whereas in America, we've always had this sort of like, almost
- 31:47naivete that to build a social network, you have to get all
- 31:50your users for free. A or otherwise it's not real
- 31:52like you know oh no it's only real.
- 31:54If you get true morality and you get all your house this is like
- 31:57we Andrew Cheng. Yeah, style stuff, right, where
- 31:59people are learning is that right?
- 32:01You guys are more stops. It's like, sort of to be, I'm
- 32:04just, I'm saying, just not being afraid to pay for your users to
- 32:09build a social network or to build a true consumer.
- 32:12Like a pure consumer product is I think kind of an interesting
- 32:15strategy that has it really been adopted by any American
- 32:18companies like other than gaming companies where you're like,
- 32:21yeah, I have to do marketing to succeed, like that's just part
- 32:24of the way the world Works. Whereas every previous American
- 32:27Social Network, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, whatever,
- 32:30you know, even YouTube acquired older users for free essentially
- 32:33in the early days, arguably by stealing content.
- 32:36But whatever. But in general, I like the idea
- 32:40of the Chinese idea that you could build a true Social
- 32:42Network that has massive scale on success and network Effects
- 32:45by paying for almost all of your users.
- 32:48And not really having true virality.
- 32:50Has not really been Opted in the United States and I think is
- 32:52sort of an interesting Twist on growing consumer apps that maybe
- 32:57we'll get adopted, the United States at some point.
- 32:59And so, we'll see. I guess it's hard for me.
- 33:01Not to hear this is, and this is why we are going to spend a lot
- 33:05ads. Well, well, now we are gaming
- 33:08companies, so we're not afraid in our investors right out of
- 33:10breath, but like it, he'll buddy.
- 33:12It's interesting. The payback is, whereas, if
- 33:14you're a soda company that says listen trust us that we will
- 33:17make the pivot to monetization and trust that we will keep
- 33:20these users. You know, right.
- 33:22That's all really hard. I agree, totally.
- 33:25But, is there anything to be learned for Tick-Tock in terms
- 33:28of new startups coming up, or I mean, Tick-Tock was sort of an
- 33:32early force in just like if we wield, the super smart AI, we
- 33:38can produce sort of great things.
- 33:39So maybe it's a model, they're related to some of this
- 33:42generative AI or I don't know, what do you see in terms of what
- 33:46people can take from Tick-Tock success?
- 33:49All right, I guess. You said one is By the audience
- 33:52if you think you have a good good?
- 33:53Yeah, I think, the one other lesson in James alluded to, this
- 33:56may have more perspective on this as well.
- 33:58Like, I think the other Insight is that personalization of
- 34:02content like defeats every, other sort of form of content
- 34:06and some like, historically growing up.
- 34:08We had this idea that there were like, good movies and bad
- 34:11movies, right? And like, or you know, on on
- 34:13Instagram that there were like good photos of bad photos and
- 34:16and Facebook sort of started to change the perspective too.
- 34:20Well, Bad photos from your friends are still, like, almost
- 34:24as good as you know, quote unquote, good content because
- 34:28like they're your friends and so therefore like a stupid photo
- 34:31from your friend is so funny because you know them any of
- 34:33this American context relationship and everything.
- 34:34Right? Tick-Tock has sort of gone all
- 34:36the way which is like not a no, no legs are 10 times.
- 34:41Yeah, yeah, well, they're like forget about your friends.
- 34:44They're like, as long as we have this, a, I sort through all the
- 34:47content in the universe and personalize it to what you like,
- 34:50you will like that. More than your friends or then
- 34:53the good cods had that, you know, Hollywood or HBO or
- 34:57whatever thanks for going to like and not the quote-unquote,
- 34:59like good content won't exist still, but then the idea of
- 35:02like, finding the needle in the haystack and sort of dispensing,
- 35:05with this whole idea of friend relationships, being important
- 35:08is very interesting that personalization of the whole
- 35:12universe of content is more important than anything else.
- 35:14I think, could probably be adopted and probably paired with
- 35:17some of this generative, a, I think we were talking, no more
- 35:20friends, no more. Eggs, the computers to figure
- 35:22out what you like and deliver it to you.
- 35:25Yeah. And then to add to that the next
- 35:27step could be that we start seeing a lot more just a i
- 35:30generated content that had no human involvement.
- 35:33I don't know how close we are to that.
- 35:34That really depends on these LMS and you know how the kind of
- 35:39visuals to Max's Point earlier and you know, sound and voice
- 35:44cloning and things like that change.
- 35:46But you could imagine a world where you don't, you're just
- 35:48watching videos that never existed until the The algorithm
- 35:51decided they were needed for you.
- 35:53Or how far away are we from? I don't know.
- 35:55You guys aren't AI Scholars, but just like, if Tick-Tock can find
- 36:00the video you want, and it's just like a bunch of, you know,
- 36:03it's a 15 second series of pixels and sound.
- 36:07When exactly, when can they just like produce, you know?
- 36:10Oh yeah. This Creator.
- 36:11We're gonna build a whole universe of AI versions of this
- 36:16greater. Yeah, I don't have an answer for
- 36:18you on the timing of that, but I think that's kind of weird.
- 36:21It eventually I bet under five years probably over one year.
- 36:25Right, I mean I think of the ball feels very close to we just
- 36:29sit there and watch the a I dance for us.
- 36:31Like, that's a lot. Pretty much.
- 36:34Yeah, I have one more insight on Tick-Tock I think is interesting
- 36:39decide about Insight. Okay James uses the word.
- 36:47Well I'll trust that the when the a I can deliver Career
- 36:51better insights than me, then then, you know, you can have
- 36:53them on the podcast. But basically, the idea that
- 36:59Tick-Tock made it sort of lot less scary in some ways or, you
- 37:02know, dangerous to create content.
- 37:04Like, when I create a tweet or an Instagram post or anything,
- 37:09you know, all of my followers are seeing that essentially.
- 37:12I don't have a lot of control of that and what I like about
- 37:15Tick-Tock is that you can just create it and your your whole
- 37:18Social Circle, your network, you know, the broader world.
- 37:21Old won't see that content unless it's good according to
- 37:24some people, right? Which is a really fascinating
- 37:27kind of flip on the hall. If Twitter is distributed to
- 37:30people, people who are interested in Eric's Petty,
- 37:32Twitter, rights, doing save me a lot of drama.
- 37:37Like, why are you reading this? But it's like the Twitter
- 37:39algorithm is shoving it down their throat.
- 37:41He's on our last episode. We talked about this right now.
- 37:44People kind of didn't have the context and suddenly were very
- 37:47confused by your tweets, right? Yeah.
- 37:51Oh ization. You need, you need the
- 37:52personalized content. Even from the Creator's you
- 37:54follow, right? Right.
- 37:56I think one final code object. I think we had we'd be remiss
- 37:58in. Not saying, I would vastly
- 38:00prefer if this were an American company and I would hope real
- 38:05succeeds. I hope if he'll on decides to
- 38:07reboot Vine, I hope that succeeds.
- 38:08I hope statue has soft place to see if they help you to short
- 38:10succeeds. I think it is sort of bad that
- 38:13you that Tick Tock is this good compared to everything else and
- 38:15so fingers crossed it. Well, I think Zuckerberg is
- 38:18probably the horse to it back and Bridge.
- 38:20The In. Do you think Zach should have
- 38:24spent the money that he spent on the metaverse building reels and
- 38:28that would have been better for the world?
- 38:30And I mean, that, I don't know, probably, but I guess the real
- 38:34question I want to ask is just, you know, we made the point that
- 38:38there are a lot of app companies sort of software consumer
- 38:43companies, that sort of in some ways are sitting around and
- 38:46waiting for great Hardware to build, like the next great
- 38:49company off of. So, what, Do you see Hardware
- 38:53meaningful significant Hardware coming out in 2023?
- 38:57The changes the consumer investing landscape?
- 39:00Yeah, I mean I think we think Apple glasses are going to come
- 39:02out right and I feel like day one will be the narrative.
- 39:06That's always the case which is that this sucks.
- 39:09This flap this does weigh less than the meta Quest thing,
- 39:11whatever. Really it's too, it's too
- 39:14expensive. I mean, that's my perspective.
- 39:16I've never seen an apple launched in the last 20 years
- 39:19where that wasn't the insta. React from the Yeah, maybe the
- 39:21media has changed maybe that maybe has chaired for Apple now.
- 39:24I don't know. But like I just carried to your
- 39:26gonna get a raft of stories about how this is underpowered
- 39:29too expensive and like doesn't do all the things that the medic
- 39:32West does. Like I just I'll put out, put
- 39:35y'all all lay ten-to-one odds on that.
- 39:37I mean, that's there's a long tradition of Apple in society
- 39:40where there's sort of the Microsoft type people who say,
- 39:44oh, this is why it lacks XYZ. But I don't know in terms of
- 39:47media during Fireball and those people have sort of one to me.
- 39:50I mean, He's sort of one. Yeah, but I'm talking about like
- 39:53the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, like the
- 39:55information, like, you know, you know, whatever the big Tech.
- 39:59The Big Three, the big street newcomer newcomer coming on into
- 40:03solid number four. Yeah, exactly.
- 40:06Right. But, and that's just gonna be
- 40:07the narrative. But I, you know, if they get it
- 40:10right, I think historically, if you look at the iPhone, you
- 40:13know, about two years after the iPhone, launch was when all the
- 40:16mega-hit consumer startups, came out, right?
- 40:18It was like, uber came out in 09.
- 40:20Instagram came. 09 like Snapchat came out in 10 or something
- 40:24like, you know, you need a couple, maybe 18 months to sort
- 40:28of percolate, what the feel of the experiences before people
- 40:31could start building, you know, the hundred billion dollar
- 40:33companies off it. So my expectation would be is if
- 40:36they actually launched this year that you won't really see the
- 40:38Apple glasses Mega companies start to nail the product until
- 40:42like 20 25. I think an interesting question
- 40:44is, how they will sell it, whether they will mostly sell it
- 40:47as a consumer product, or there will be like an Prize aspect to
- 40:52it like more like a Mac Pro or something like you know where
- 40:56you use it to build video games or you use it to, you know,
- 41:01sculpt 3D objects for Designing motorcycles or something.
- 41:06I don't know, 100%, that it will be like a pure consumer product.
- 41:11You think that would be in lieu of the consumer product?
- 41:15Or I'd, I think a lot depends on just what they're trying to
- 41:19Target as a price point. I just have no idea.
- 41:21I mean Max right now better but I think yeah.
- 41:24Like the quest Pro which is has Pro in the name, right.
- 41:28I think they've tried to thread that needle a little bit, but
- 41:31it's very expensive and I think you know, isn't and this is
- 41:36going to go in real apple or but and you guys you guys are sort
- 41:40of Apple obsessives, but wasn't Tim Cook in favor of the carrier
- 41:48subsidies for the iPhone, understanding that you really
- 41:50needed. To drive price down and Steve
- 41:52Jobs wasn't, and that was one of his great victories.
- 41:55I mean, obviously just a key to the iPhone succeeding was that,
- 42:00you know, it was affordable instantly.
- 42:02Well, the crater wall to people or that was a huge insight.
- 42:06And I think like, the other craziest one is that Steve Jobs
- 42:10was fully against the app store for the first 18 months of the
- 42:13iPhone. Like what you again, we're
- 42:15talking about being the greatest platform of our lifetime like,
- 42:18Steve Jobs, not just had to be argued into the The App Store,
- 42:22it was like a Relentless battle within Apple for 18 months,
- 42:26whether or not other people should be able to write apps for
- 42:28it. And, you know, I think Scott
- 42:30Forstall who departed was a huge proponent of it, I don't know
- 42:34about Tim Cook, but I assumed he was in favor.
- 42:36And like finally, apparently Steve Jobs was basically like,
- 42:39all right, like, fuck off, like make the App Store.
- 42:42Like, I don't give a shit what you guys want, right?
- 42:45What it was company was the first, it was the 3G, which was
- 42:49the second phone so it was one year.
- 42:51And so, but initially they were going to, they were going to let
- 42:54people just write web apps for it.
- 42:56They're going to say, well, you run a little website and that's
- 42:58close enough to a nap. And people were, like nasty, we
- 43:01have to let people write relapse for this thing and it was just a
- 43:04massive battle that he finally just caved on.
- 43:06So, that's kind of an amazing history because that arguably,
- 43:10you know, was the most important thing about the iPhone.
- 43:12If you look at it in retrospect. But unless Apple has some magic
- 43:16trick up its sleeve, there's nothing like the carrier to
- 43:19subsidize. No, no, right?
- 43:22They are. And then if they could get away
- 43:24with this like corporate Story, I mean, I you could just imagine
- 43:28this sort of dark world where it's like, apple can figure out
- 43:31how to make the pricing work. You know, it's been talked about
- 43:34behind the scenes forever and so then they come out with his
- 43:38super expensive version and maybe they're a couple companies
- 43:41to try to build pro services. But what people really want is
- 43:45Apple to offer something aimed at the mass Market that gets a
- 43:49bunch of consumer adoption. Right.
- 43:51Exactly. I mean apples famous for having
- 43:54like five year plans so I'd be shocked if they're not going to
- 43:56launch it like 2999 and then have a five-year plan to get to
- 44:00999 basically or something, right?
- 44:02I mean, I think like, you have to imagine, they're seeing like,
- 44:05okay, 20:27. We can get this to 999, or so,
- 44:07right. I mean, you know, many, many
- 44:11episodes ago, I had Phil libin on who was shitting on virtual
- 44:16reality devices and just sort of he has a mall, you know?
- 44:19And they're all piled up in his closet and there.
- 44:21One for, you know, like 30 minutes and then I don't know
- 44:25what sort of the view here on VR vs.
- 44:29AR. I think that they are the VR is
- 44:33still kind of a niche popular device for people who just want
- 44:37kind of the gaming experience. And and I think there are some
- 44:40Fitness, you know, games sort of that are kind of more active.
- 44:45I think that it's a popular kind of Christmas gift.
- 44:48I think you know Quest, sales are still going up and I I think
- 44:51that it just hasn't penetrated into anywhere near kind of the
- 44:56install base. That would really allow large
- 45:00consumer startups to sort of emerge and focus solely on BR,
- 45:05you know, I think, you know, Max talked about the scale of
- 45:08Alexa's and potentially 200 million households.
- 45:12Like we're not anywhere close to that with VR, so, it just makes
- 45:15it a lot harder to build a brand new consumer startup, focus on a
- 45:19much smaller install base. Yeah, and nothing sort of
- 45:22technologically. The you think is on the horizon
- 45:26that's going to change that? Or is there anything that you
- 45:29would say would create an inflection point there on for VR
- 45:33specifically? I don't know, it's a good
- 45:35question. I might kind of a hotter take on
- 45:38this, is that everyone's trying to do games that require you to
- 45:43like, run around your house and kind of yeah, like be more
- 45:48Fitness oriented and I think people just want games.
- 45:51Is that you can sit and play and nobody's building games that you
- 45:54can sit and play the VR device can't tell when you actually
- 45:57job. So you're kind of having to
- 45:58like, you know, Crouch and stand up in order to like simulate
- 46:01jumping. I just think people need to
- 46:03focus on games where you can sit and chill.
- 46:07Like every other form of entertainment designers are not
- 46:10necessarily in touch with average American.
- 46:12Yeah, yeah. It's kind of, It kind of like
- 46:14that, I think. Yeah, give me a race car game or
- 46:16something that I that I don't have to stand and run around
- 46:18for, I mean, it's good for some people but I think I think that
- 46:21that's kind of the design space that hasn't been explored
- 46:23enough. So I mean, the crypto winner is
- 46:26this sort of a dead year coming up.
- 46:28Do you think for crypto? I mean, obviously, people have
- 46:30money, they've raised and they're going to keep working
- 46:33but I mean yeah. First of all, I guess, is there
- 46:36anything good about a downturn for crypto in terms of
- 46:40development? Is there anything good about it?
- 46:43I mean a lot of the original people involved in this space
- 46:46will always tell you that, you know, it's good when the winters
- 46:50happen because Is it kicks out all the tourists in the industry
- 46:55kind of like tamps down on the speculation aspects of crypto
- 47:00and allows real Builders to kind of continue working?
- 47:04If that's true to some degree. I definitely think this winter,
- 47:08this crypto winter was pretty, pretty, pretty dark and cold or
- 47:13something. I don't know.
- 47:14It was our the beauty of other crypto Winters is if there were
- 47:17still new suckers to bring in the next time, like if you Like
- 47:21they've gone through every fucking sucker in the world.
- 47:23Like, I like, is there another sucker for the next round of it?
- 47:27I mean, I'm still I guess let's all just say what we actually
- 47:31believe about crypto to moment. I still think there will be some
- 47:35great company built on blockchain and maybe even the
- 47:38financialization aspect, I don't think they will lean in super
- 47:42heavily to the crypto brand. And I think it could it doesn't
- 47:45mean that the space in general is successful.
- 47:49And I'm certainly not bullish on.
- 47:51On the actual currency values, or what about it these in
- 47:56gaming, because I think you are, the one who originally sort of
- 48:01got me interested in the idea that, you know, ft's could have
- 48:05a place in gaming. Yeah.
- 48:07I mean, I still think it's crazy that I like bought all these
- 48:09OverWatch skins and now they have nothing to do with my life.
- 48:14I think what would have been cool is just to see, sort of
- 48:18different big companies, recognizing The same system, but
- 48:23it was almost like a big company thing to me more than you know,
- 48:26it people with IP needed to lean into them in a way that we
- 48:30didn't see. So I don't know.
- 48:32I still think portability of Internet items would be cool but
- 48:38but I don't even know if you don't need the blockchain.
- 48:40I mean we could you know, two companies could just come to an
- 48:42agreement that they honored each other stuff, right?
- 48:45I mean it's cooler with the blockchain because there's a
- 48:47truth to it and other people could voluntarily.
- 48:51Participate. I mean I still think it's an
- 48:52exciting idea but we had this moment in time where there was
- 48:56so much every company had a reason to implement it because
- 49:00their stock could go up because they were doing the crypto thing
- 49:03and that it didn't work. Then I don't know that.
- 49:06I mean part of the bull case you would hear about crypto at the
- 49:08time was that all this sort of getting the money upfront.
- 49:13Meant that a lot of people were motivated to actually do
- 49:15something and that was going to get the flywheel going.
- 49:18Right? It's almost like Max's point.
- 49:20You guys spend The ads ahead of, you know, everything needs
- 49:23something. Whether it was YouTube getting
- 49:25content, that was probably illegal early, you need some
- 49:27reason why people are going to use this shitty thing early and
- 49:31that will get you into the world where it's actually more
- 49:33valuable. And so for crypto, it was
- 49:35supposed to be everybody getting rich early and that hasn't
- 49:39worked. Did you read the mat Iglesias
- 49:41story where he compared it to the Segway as like an amazing
- 49:46technology that basically has no use cases?
- 49:50Yeah. Yeah, I did read it kind of a
- 49:52narrow metaphor, but yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't know.
- 49:55Yeah, I think his point in the article was that when he was
- 50:00using the early internet comparison to crypto the things
- 50:03that do it was doing on it were sort of fun distractions
- 50:07comparable to, you know, otherwise watching HBO or
- 50:12reading a magazine or reading a book and it felt very much like
- 50:17a valuable use of his time even if it wasn't like World-changing
- 50:21in the early internet. And then in the future he kind
- 50:25of projects to you today and says like the same things that
- 50:29he was doing our, he's just doing a lot more and a lot more
- 50:32people are doing them on the internet in terms of like
- 50:34reading and writing and you know using it as a distraction and
- 50:38research tool and things. And so he thinks that you can't
- 50:41really project forward anything in crypto that would be
- 50:44valuable. I agree when I interviewed vinod
- 50:46khosla, he was still bringing up helium.
- 50:48You know, it's there are there. Nobody has a Good crypto.
- 50:51Use case 2.2. I don't yeah, I think that I
- 50:55think you can project forward pretty easily and say that and
- 50:59I'm kind of borrowing part of Max's thesis on this a bit.
- 51:02Which is that a lot of what crypto is right now is sort of
- 51:06regulatory Arbitrage, meaning you couldn't do this type of
- 51:10defy or whatever, because it was illegal or speculation like
- 51:14where, you know, it's a new way to gamble, it's a new way to,
- 51:17you know, bet on things, that's kind of fun.
- 51:20I think that's Actually accurate.
- 51:22I just think that that will just continue to expand and we are
- 51:25going to get really interesting companies in the future that do
- 51:28regulatory Arbitrage and do speculation on random internet
- 51:32assets. Whether that's, you know, video
- 51:34game items or, you know, cryptocurrencies Bitcoin,
- 51:39anything, you know that it you can imagine.
- 51:42I think we are just scratching the surface of like, what types
- 51:45of new speculation and gamble you, we can invent, you know, I
- 51:48guess like that's kind of a, you know?
- 51:51No, but if interest, that's what, yeah, I mean the
- 51:53regulatory status quo remains, but I mean they could have
- 51:56squander this opportunity if the everybody losing their shirts,
- 52:01means that the SEC and everybody else decides it's time.
- 52:04Totally. I think the cats out of the bag
- 52:06a little bit where you are gonna, you know, just like uber
- 52:10lived like, you're kind of like stuck with this world.
- 52:13Now that we invented this and people found it interesting.
- 52:17So yeah, I'm definitely not saying there won't be more
- 52:20regulation. I just think it'll be like,
- 52:23we're still going to see things in the future that, you know,
- 52:27are kind of similar to what we have in crypto right now.
- 52:29But even more kind of pushing the envelope in terms of
- 52:32regulatory, Arbitrage, Uber, and Lyft one over consumers hearts
- 52:35and not sure crypto has but generally I think like the you
- 52:38say it is. I just think that a financial
- 52:41use cases can still be used cases, right?
- 52:43I mean, if you think of like cross-border transactions that
- 52:46are really hard to do or keeping your money in something, you
- 52:49know, if you live in Argentina door, Hyperinflation where, you
- 52:52know, keep your money in something, it easy.
- 52:53The Argentinean peso is a real use case, right?
- 52:56So there's sort of those core Financial use cases and then,
- 52:59yeah, fundamentally I think the other product Market fits that
- 53:02exist today are essentially, I mean, James called a regulatory
- 53:05Arbitrage, you might just call it like, you know, evasion of
- 53:08the law and some sort of a fundamental principle Ray.
- 53:11And I think that like, you know, gambling is still somewhat
- 53:14illegal in the United States. I think prediction markets which
- 53:17where you predict things other than just Sports outcomes is
- 53:20something that James Always been really excited.
- 53:21About prediction markets are three core of our friend group,
- 53:25anywhere resigns and bullishness just in the, you know, I don't
- 53:29know, we've bet on who's going to win very selections and I
- 53:33think there's call she is yeah, call she's starting to do legal
- 53:37regular, you know, legal prediction markets, I think
- 53:40fundamentally yeah, loaning out your money and bizarre
- 53:43derivative Securities that you probably aren't allowed to
- 53:47invest in the United States whether or not.
- 53:49That's a good thing or not. That is a I'll use case, some
- 53:51people want to get 20% on their money, even if they have a 40%
- 53:55chance of losing all of their money, right.
- 53:57I think that, you know, the use cases of crypto are essentially
- 54:00Financial regulatory evasion, right?
- 54:03And in some cases, that's really valuable, if you're in a
- 54:05country, that's inflating your currency to nothing or if you're
- 54:08in Russia and it's essentially diamonds, you know that you're
- 54:12trying to smuggle out of Russia, right?
- 54:14You know Bitcoin is the new is the new jewelry that you hide in
- 54:17your suitcase, right? And so I think those are real
- 54:20use cases I think the end up season games saying and sort of
- 54:22more straightforward consumer use cases.
- 54:25I haven't really seen too much that works outside of like
- 54:28speculation in certain games. That kind of ended up being
- 54:32Ponzi schemes like actually Infinity for example, right?
- 54:35But maybe there will be something there where there's
- 54:37type of games that are, you know, it's amazing how much some
- 54:40of the stuff we just moved on from to make anything.
- 54:43Not a Ponzi is very, very difficult.
- 54:45And, you know, a lot of like traditional game industry,
- 54:49people kind of Scott. That crypto because they are
- 54:52like phds in economics, crafting the economy's for these games
- 54:56like Roebuck Roblox and wrote bucks in Roblox.
- 55:00Yeah. And yeah, and I think that a lot
- 55:05of people have kind of tried to cut Corners there, whereas you
- 55:09really need like extremely Advanced modeling to create a
- 55:14token ecosystem, that's like, no, we need central banks and
- 55:19sort of a technocrat In exchange for our currency to work Customs
- 55:24Mei, I love it, but I'm surprised to hear from you.
- 55:28Well, yeah, I think I definitely believe that there's something
- 55:32interesting happening and that kind of gave me creative space
- 55:35where people are kind of coming together.
- 55:37There's like the excitement of speculating on whether the game
- 55:40will exist and succeed and you can kind of buy Assets in
- 55:44advance. And then there's kind of the
- 55:46elements of Designing a ecosystem that kind of reward.
- 55:50The early adopters and grows as the game grows.
- 55:54You know, kind of Mercedes more centrally planned.
- 55:56While uses very, very centrally planned to do that well and
- 56:00nobody has figured out how to do this like in are truly
- 56:02decentralized way for sure. Like even board a yacht club
- 56:06which are, you know, working on their own version of a metaverse
- 56:09scheme, you know, they tightly tightly control, the kind of
- 56:14evolution of the game and the evolution of their currency they
- 56:18you know purely for legal. Three reasons, they kind of
- 56:21created that Dow out of the eight coin that they created.
- 56:25Right? But the you know they are
- 56:27they're definitely in control of where this all goes and the
- 56:29value of the value of the assets.
- 56:32I mean, yeah, I think Warren Buffett has this like famous
- 56:35quote free crypto where he says, like if you took all the gold in
- 56:40the world, it would be like a 70-foot, q body side, and it
- 56:43would like fit in like a baseball in feel like you
- 56:46wouldn't make it to first base, and I'd be all the gold in the
- 56:48world right? 70-foot key.
- 56:50It's on the baseball and field and he says, for the value, the
- 56:53supposed value of that gold, you could have like eight times the
- 56:57entire agricultural output at the United States.
- 57:00He times all the forming and the United States you could buy it
- 57:04eight times over, right? And he's like, I'm just the kind
- 57:07of guy who wants the Farms, not the cube of gold, right?
- 57:10And I really could do is cut of in the cube of gold phase, where
- 57:13some people are like. I Don't Know, Jack you but gold
- 57:15is pretty cool. Like, you know, can I get this
- 57:18place? Not here but yeah.
- 57:21On it. And, and it, yeah, it's actually
- 57:22very is very similar in my mind to, you know, especially the NFC
- 57:27world. But into art collection, you
- 57:29know, baseball card collection, any type of like hobbyist
- 57:32collection. We are talking about 190 action
- 57:34figures plus Java is like what, why do people collect these
- 57:37things? I mean, there's there's a mix of
- 57:40kind of, you know, human emotional attachment to the item
- 57:44and then there's like an idea of speculation that maybe this
- 57:48thing will go up. In value, was he really hard to
- 57:50untangle? But I feel like people really
- 57:52want to get rich when people are getting rich and I don't know,
- 57:54there is sort of a mood to clearly.
- 57:57There's, there's a reason and FTS and Pokemon cards have both
- 58:00Fallen, right? I mean, every trip and why not?
- 58:03Let's not enjoy Korean stock market is down.
- 58:06I think it's because there's just less of a sense that
- 58:10everybody's getting rich and I should be doing it some way to.
- 58:13So, I just think that's all going to cool off for someone
- 58:17either. I guess I would just say that
- 58:19speculating on things. That you kind of have a personal
- 58:22attachment to is a lifelong human.
- 58:26Yeah. Yeah but the Pokemon cards in
- 58:28your basement and we'll be back, you know, Ten Years, everybody
- 58:32will be playing this game again or whatever but yeah what
- 58:35showing off their gold jewelry or whatever?
- 58:37Right. I mean so Foley, what's the
- 58:39theme we've missed? I mean, I don't know if this is
- 58:42interesting, but we haven't really talked about the markets
- 58:44for the next year, or at least like a start-up Fund, Raising
- 58:46markets. Right?
- 58:47Obviously is very top of mind for Champs in hiding.
- 58:50Potential. Future startup Fund Raisers.
- 58:53So that W is the theme that I think about the most
- 58:57unfortunately or unfortunately, what's the vibe you're getting
- 58:59from Founders and people? I mean, the vibe right now is
- 59:03that it's colder than it has ever been talk about winters.
- 59:07If the late stage fundraising Market is like in a freaking
- 59:10100,000-year Ice Age right now. But you know the thing about you
- 59:14talked about it being a mood base, you know, Mark it.
- 59:17I feel like if the stock market goes up for two straight months
- 59:20or Are, you know, Sequoia does three big deals, you know, or
- 59:24something concert of those types of things.
- 59:26I feel like it could completely unlock again.
- 59:28I guess, my one hot take on this front is everyone seems
- 59:32convinced that we are either in a recession or we're just about
- 59:35to go into a recession or it's like so obvious.
- 59:37The whole markets in a recession.
- 59:38You know, I've not really seen any a macroeconomic indicators
- 59:43that are pointing towards a real recession.
- 59:45That's driven by normal consumers, especially now that
- 59:48gas an asset press is coming down.
- 59:50So I guess my hot take is like, I don't think we're really in a
- 59:53recession and maybe Powell will fly the plane into the ground
- 59:56and just keep raising rates. But if he doesn't do that, I
- 59:59think it could be kind of a boom year by mid-year.
- 1:00:01If everyone just wakes up at like, hey, the economy is still
- 1:00:04pretty good. And we tamed inflation.
- 1:00:06So kind of interested to see what how I'm against, but not
- 1:00:09because I'm betting strongly on a recession.
- 1:00:13But just because I think the valuation reset and the
- 1:00:18uncertainty, just the multiple In is ongoing in that just
- 1:00:23causes so much trouble. I mean, Tesla was such an anchor
- 1:00:29to so many like self-driving car type come, you know, you can
- 1:00:32just see sort of everything trickling out from there.
- 1:00:34And so, if you have public companies, I mean, Snapchat is
- 1:00:38down, like, 81, 80 something percent this year, right?
- 1:00:42I mean, it's, I just feel like that has not.
- 1:00:46I this isn't the word startup Founders want to hear, but I
- 1:00:49just don't think that's Seep through startup valuations I.
- 1:00:53So I think that did in this challenge.
- 1:00:55Yeah. I think it did in the second
- 1:00:57half of last year though. I mean you basically saw no
- 1:01:00deals happen. If fundament everyone like
- 1:01:02waited out series C Series Deep saying I don't want to help your
- 1:01:07overvalued company, maybe I'll give a little more cash to mind,
- 1:01:11but probably not, but then they still invested in highly valued
- 1:01:16series seed deals in series a believing like well, if the
- 1:01:20Comes back. I want to have ownership and
- 1:01:23we'll see. But we haven't really had the
- 1:01:25like, real sort of problem of, like, oh, I couldn't raise any
- 1:01:29money and now I agree with you. I think that next year, you'll
- 1:01:33see like a lot of bitch Elation from the founder side.
- 1:01:36So I think that you will start to see a lot of Founders going
- 1:01:39out there, raising down rounds or doing MMA, and selling their
- 1:01:44company, or going out of business because they just can't
- 1:01:47raise money, and they were running out of money.
- 1:01:49So I think like we Haven't seen that really?
- 1:01:51We've seen the layout phase but we haven't seen kind of the true
- 1:01:55pitch. Elation somebody suggested to me
- 1:01:57that I should try to make a list and any listeners, feel free to
- 1:02:01send your ideas of companies that are generating more money
- 1:02:06on interest from money that they've raised then from
- 1:02:09customers, you know. Because you know, there are some
- 1:02:13of these unicorns that raises, you know, a hundred million
- 1:02:15dollars that are million dollars, that's like 44 million
- 1:02:18dollars a year. So they have a fewer Smaller,
- 1:02:21you know, revenues from customs and that, you know, I totally
- 1:02:25think you're right. I think to just clarify my
- 1:02:27point, like, I think multiple compression is going to be a
- 1:02:31huge issue and I think to James's Point, your people are
- 1:02:33going to capitulate because they're going to want to keep
- 1:02:34the company's Alive At Any Price.
- 1:02:36Basically. Right.
- 1:02:37I do. Vo.
- 1:02:38Think that, like, if the economy is doing reasonably well in, you
- 1:02:41know, Q2 Q3 or whatever, you know, I think we'll start to see
- 1:02:45deals actually get done at, you know, 10 x, 15, x, 20 x,
- 1:02:50whatever. Instead of the ludicrous,
- 1:02:51hundred x, 200 x, you know, 2020 2021 cycle, right.
- 1:02:55And I think like the second half of last year, ice age has been,
- 1:02:59nobody has done anything other than stuff.
- 1:03:02They feel like they absolutely had to do to save the companies,
- 1:03:05but I think more a lot more action will happen next year.
- 1:03:08Especially if there's no recession it'll just be a
- 1:03:11multiple that our life saying, right, and so soon, I don't
- 1:03:15know, I just do not understand tinkle on this is just The
- 1:03:20uncertain supply of capital, right?
- 1:03:23I think it can't be underestimated.
- 1:03:25How much IPOs? We're actually a big source of
- 1:03:30sort of startup Capital, right? That is, you know, instacart
- 1:03:34stripe Etc. Could have raised a ton of money
- 1:03:36and IPO and that would have been a big source of funding and ibos
- 1:03:39have basically stopped and then IPOs are a validator of startup
- 1:03:45valuation. So as long as the IPO Market is
- 1:03:48super jammed up. That's really bad for start-up
- 1:03:52world and to I think there's just like has Tiger is Tiger
- 1:03:56going to be able to raise this next fun.
- 1:03:57How big is it going to be like these funds that have raised you
- 1:04:01know billions how much do they have?
- 1:04:03And like how much are there LPS telling them oh deploy that over
- 1:04:07you know six years not for what. I just think there's a lot.
- 1:04:11You know, it's their private markets and there's just a lot
- 1:04:14of uncertainty about how much dry powder that really is.
- 1:04:18Yeah, I mean, I think you're right, but I also think Like
- 1:04:202018 was sort of pre tiger or whatever or sort of pre Insanity
- 1:04:25to some degree, at least like you weren't getting 100x revenue
- 1:04:29for SAS companies, making two million dollars, right?
- 1:04:32And so I guess I believe the market can exist in a world
- 1:04:35where SAS capellini two million dollars gets a 50 million dollar
- 1:04:39valuation or whatever, right? Everybody's still believes in
- 1:04:42the you want to have ownership of basically, any price of the
- 1:04:46best company and the fact that like I could miss a figma deal,
- 1:04:49you know, got done. Activision and we're still
- 1:04:52seeing those like huge prices sort of into the downturn.
- 1:04:58Yeah, I think is a case that there's still a belief in the,
- 1:05:02you know, in the overall principles.
- 1:05:05But if if stocks turn around a little bit because they're, you
- 1:05:09know, isn't a huge recession or whatever, doesn't that to your
- 1:05:11point kind of flow through a little bit at some point, I
- 1:05:14mean, like, if we have an amazing, first three months and
- 1:05:17stocks are up, 15 20 %, what will that start cast?
- 1:05:20Skating down early, I don't know, I mean stocks are up the
- 1:05:23market that percent. I just my position that I've
- 1:05:27said over and over again, is there are companies that went
- 1:05:30public via spec, like bird is not bankrupt.
- 1:05:33Like there, there are crazy companies that have no path
- 1:05:37forward that are still alive, and until those companies are
- 1:05:42dead and people have had to be like, oh shit, that's scary.
- 1:05:46We're not close to the bottom because like that has to happen.
- 1:05:49We haven't had the Emotional reaction from that.
- 1:05:51And so I keep waiting for that to happen.
- 1:05:53And, you know, this isn't.com people believe in Tech, but
- 1:05:57like.com good companies were trading at like 1X Revenue.
- 1:06:01So there's certainly plenty of room for multiples to fall way
- 1:06:05further if there's more pessimism.
- 1:06:08Yeah. And tear point, I don't think
- 1:06:10we've seen a lot of companies God, a business, because they
- 1:06:13had so much runway and dried powder themselves.
- 1:06:16The companies that raised a lot of money, so I think that
- 1:06:19there's still time for that to happen.
- 1:06:20Tap, the founder VC, Dynamic. I mean, it feels like a VC is
- 1:06:27have more of the leverage again, or like, I don't know, how do
- 1:06:29you, what do you think? Sort of what's what's I
- 1:06:32thinking? Founders like what do you mean?
- 1:06:35I think Macy's themselves are you know, worried about how
- 1:06:40they're looking for their help. He's right.
- 1:06:41So everyone who has happened, all I guess, has leverage
- 1:06:45because capital is not free, right, ready?
- 1:06:47I think Founders have 11 more leverage or just General
- 1:06:51business owners have more leverage than employees did then
- 1:06:56than they did in the prior cycle, where you know, employees
- 1:06:59could demand really high salaries.
- 1:07:01I think, you know, employees. All, you know, we now had this
- 1:07:05whole work from home culture, I'm very interested to see how
- 1:07:09that changes next year. If like were describing, like
- 1:07:14there continues to be some Downstream effects on startups.
- 1:07:19Like and Larger companies, laying off more people, if there
- 1:07:22continues to be more Fallout from, you know, layoffs and
- 1:07:27companies going out of business and are you guys real,
- 1:07:30everybody? You people have to come in,
- 1:07:32like, what three days a week or what sort of your we do Tina.
- 1:07:36We do we cannot right now and everybody has to come in or
- 1:07:40everyone in person. So we have about 60 percent of
- 1:07:44our company working in the Bay Area and about 40%, they'll be
- 1:07:49fired remotely. So kind of a hybrid system for
- 1:07:53sure. Oh yeah, you guys both are, are
- 1:07:55you along San Francisco? I don't know.
- 1:07:58San Francisco is so frustrating sometimes, but I do think I do
- 1:08:03think. If you believe in network
- 1:08:04effects, it's like the greatest Tech that work affects city in
- 1:08:06the world by far. And I think that that's going to
- 1:08:08be really hard to break despite what other people think.
- 1:08:11And and anytime I meet folks from other cities, if you get
- 1:08:14them like three beers deep at the bar, they're like yeah it's
- 1:08:17actually unbelievably difficult to recruit people here.
- 1:08:20You've got a standard go to Miami.
- 1:08:22Even you go to New York. People are like yeah to be real
- 1:08:27with you. It's pretty hard to recruit
- 1:08:30relative like they think it's easier in San Francisco.
- 1:08:33Since there's the talent that you need to run a successful
- 1:08:37startup, I think there are people here who you know, the
- 1:08:41average engineer has a lot more experience or, you know, you can
- 1:08:44find the head of people or, you know, the recruiters who know
- 1:08:49what they're doing. I just I think there's so many
- 1:08:51people with a lot of experience, everyone kind of.
- 1:08:54I'm actually, I'm not sure what you guys will say to this.
- 1:08:57Do you believe in 10 xers lat? How do you define a bit more
- 1:09:03period where Mark Zuckerberg? And people would very clearly
- 1:09:06say, oh, you know, they, you know, a small segment of our
- 1:09:10Engineers are doing just far more are far more productive
- 1:09:14than the rest. And then, I think there's been
- 1:09:17like, as part of, I don't know, the sort of Woke politics, turn
- 1:09:21or whatever. I feel like there's been a push
- 1:09:23back against that idea and now people are being more honest
- 1:09:27again but I don't know. You don't have to win but I was
- 1:09:30just genuinely it was just a genuine curiosity.
- 1:09:33I would kind of turn this on its head which is I would say at a
- 1:09:36start-up where sort of fundamentally you know, we as a
- 1:09:40company are trying to be someday a thousand times bigger than we
- 1:09:43are today right to be successful.
- 1:09:45Right? I think it's really about.
- 1:09:48Can you prioritize The like one or maybe two things that are
- 1:09:53likely to have a massive upside impact for the company.
- 1:09:57And I think that kind of applies across all roles.
- 1:09:59And so it's not like, you know, you're a better, you know,
- 1:10:03engineer data science, or Finance person or co-founders
- 1:10:06like us or Business Development or whatever.
- 1:10:09Anything. It's like as you get further in
- 1:10:13your career, are you 10 to 100 times better at like picking the
- 1:10:18most important thing to work on? At that exact moment do they
- 1:10:21didn't ask that are actually useful or do they just but yeah,
- 1:10:25well it's not just useful but like do you collect the sort of
- 1:10:27basket of upside options that we're one of the ten will pay
- 1:10:31off 100 X or something. Right.
- 1:10:33And I think that that is sort of like a real skill in a lot of
- 1:10:37different roles and so it's not like you're in front of the, you
- 1:10:40know, the computer typing away like Mark Zuckerberg of the
- 1:10:43social network while drinking shots, right?
- 1:10:45It's more like you look at your list of eight things you could
- 1:10:48be working on and you like work on the To that might have like a
- 1:10:52huge payoff and the sort of training, your own neural
- 1:10:55network, as to what those two are I think is what all of us
- 1:10:59are trying to get better at right?
- 1:11:00And so I guess I believe in and that sends like, I'd like to
- 1:11:03think James and I are 10x better than our jobs 5, then we were
- 1:11:06five years ago, God willing, if we're not willing trouble like
- 1:11:09and so it's that I think ruthless prioritization and
- 1:11:14understanding of upside that I think exists across all roles.
- 1:11:17So and that's, I guess I would say, yeah.
- 1:11:20Side and kind of the risk profile.
- 1:11:22There are a lot of things that we can work on that have a, you
- 1:11:25know, only a 20 percent or 10 percent chance of succeeding, I
- 1:11:28Vale but we do them anyway because they you know, have this
- 1:11:33outsize upside. So we're willing to work on
- 1:11:35things that might not work out if they are you know, could be a
- 1:11:39gigantic success for the business.
- 1:11:40And we want all of our employees to be kind of thinking a little
- 1:11:43bit mathematically about these, you know, their work in some
- 1:11:46ways like what is worth working on, it's not just what's In
- 1:11:50front of you that will work. Its kind of what has that
- 1:11:54payoff? That makes sense for the risk.
- 1:11:56You're taking. Yeah.
- 1:11:58At newcomer you can write post that drive 10x more subscribers
- 1:12:01than others. Right?
- 1:12:02And hopefully over two years and me only you better Decks that
- 1:12:06you get your hands on please for my fiber for my family.
- 1:12:12Yeah. Yeah sorry I interrupted you.
- 1:12:16No no. I was just saying you are
- 1:12:18hopefully getting better at picking the 10.
- 1:12:20Ex posts, right? 100x posts, right?
- 1:12:22And like you have to believe, I think that you're better at that
- 1:12:25than you were two years ago and the two years from now.
- 1:12:29It's not like you're working 10 times harder there, right?
- 1:12:31Like to write that post that goes viral, part of it is like,
- 1:12:34what's the return on investment for any amount of work?
- 1:12:37You know, like if you will give me lots of great story ideas and
- 1:12:41sometimes I can seem lazy being like that's really hard.
- 1:12:43But what I'm really saying is like that's a lot of work to
- 1:12:46like get a list of, you know, a bazillion things that at-bat.
- 1:12:50It would be like a pretty good post, you know what I mean?
- 1:12:53Like if you're going to do a lot of work, it needs to, you know,
- 1:12:55have the upside sort of matching that and so, yeah.
- 1:12:59Especially when you're sort of, you know, creating your own
- 1:13:02product or whatever you really have to be smart about time,
- 1:13:05allocation. Well, I don't know if you
- 1:13:07remember, but when you came to visit our office over the summer
- 1:13:11and you kind of had a comment that was kind of a throwaway
- 1:13:14thing. Like oh you got a lot of like
- 1:13:16stuff in here. Like there's tables and laptops
- 1:13:19and plan. It's and it kind of like you
- 1:13:21guys have to like you think of it, I think journalists and BC
- 1:13:25is to a large extent, think of the business as the product.
- 1:13:28The idea, the founders, the amount of capital and like it's
- 1:13:31kind of a formulaic thing but like we, we have to deal with
- 1:13:35like, you know, where to put the lunch tables and kind of where I
- 1:13:39like, how to deal with, you know, people's emotions and
- 1:13:43things that I think it's very hard to think about as just a
- 1:13:46skill on its own. It's just like, yeah, it's just,
- 1:13:49can you make good decisions? Moment.
- 1:13:51And I think that would be a valuable kind of thing for more
- 1:13:56non operators. Kind of just think about, you
- 1:13:58know, most businesses and not being so formulaic.
- 1:14:02Like are they in a good Market? Are they are the founders good,
- 1:14:04you know. Did they hire the right people?
- 1:14:06It's like, are they making you know, the right decisions?
- 1:14:10You know over and over again, right?
- 1:14:12Cool. Well I'm glad we were able to
- 1:14:15make this happen blast. Have you guys on?
- 1:14:18Yeah, thanks for all the support for Or newcomer along the way.
- 1:14:22Thanks for having us and congrats crabs.
- 1:14:24A newcomer everyone. Yeah.
- 1:14:38Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:14:39Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:14:38Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:14:39Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.