Latest / A Hamster With a Blunt Penknife - a Doctor Who Commentary podcast / Talks to James Lark about his choice of The Mark of the Rani (1/2)
Transcript
- 0:33Hamster with a blump pen knife for doing quicker.
- 0:37Welcome back to Hamster with a Blump Pen Knife, the Doctor Who
- 0:40Commentary Podcast. I say the it's a Doctor Who
- 0:44Commentary podcast, but with guests like I have on tonight,
- 0:49it is the infinitely superior commentary podcast.
- 0:53Hello, Mr. James Lark. Hi Joe, surely the it's the the
- 0:59definite article. I mean, there's nearly 900
- 1:01episodes of this thing now. It's well maybe say, the most
- 1:04prolific commentary podcast. Joe, you must be so tired,
- 1:11barely lifted Toby. Hey man, called out.
- 1:16Is this hard enough? I bet you.
- 1:18Hang on, have I got praise of Gregory by mistake?
- 1:22He hates this story. Do you know?
- 1:24Can you imagine why? No, no, no, no, Joe, Nobody.
- 1:30That's a really sexy accent. Can you do the rest of the
- 1:33commentary in that accent please?
- 1:35I I'm going to veer between this accent and just a, a, a a a
- 1:40sporadic entrepreneurial vocabulary or pecan see for the
- 1:48sake of trying to capture both voices that we get in in in
- 1:51today's story. Not that the Prince of Darkness
- 1:54here would consider it piquant. This may be some small clues as
- 2:00to the story that we are going to be talking about today.
- 2:03At your request, I may add. And for once, I'm right.
- 2:08I spend most book clubs blaming James for every.
- 2:11Book No no, this was my absolutely right.
- 2:13Yes, but it's never your fault on the book club, is it?
- 2:16It's never my fault, never my fault.
- 2:18Actually, next time it is, you know, we're doing the writer's
- 2:20tale and you may have opted no, no, no.
- 2:21No, no, no, no, no. That was Ian Winston's fault.
- 2:24Oh, will you choose always. Always got an alibi?
- 2:27Yeah, you slippery snake. Well, we are here today to talk
- 2:32about the Mark of the Rani by Pip and Jane Baker.
- 2:36Obviously a story that everyone's beaten down while
- 2:38Dawes talk about. James, can I ask you?
- 2:42Say that you say that ironically, and that surprises
- 2:47me a little. Bit slightly sarcastically.
- 2:49Yeah. Well, I don't think people and
- 2:53Jane Baker have the best reputation amongst Doctor Who
- 2:55fans. Shall I tell you why this was on
- 2:58on on my list quite high up? Because when I did my classic
- 3:04Doctor Who marathon, the slowest marathon in the history of
- 3:08Vanda. How long did it take you?
- 3:10Oh. Yeah, the issue was I started it
- 3:13with my friend John who used to live down the road and we
- 3:16started it just before COVID and so and and he lived down the
- 3:21road and and it was sort of every, every weekend we get
- 3:23through kind of 8-9 episodes. Sorry to interrupt you.
- 3:25Have you ever had a chance to say something in a northern
- 3:28accent? John down the road.
- 3:30John down. John down.
- 3:32Oh, no, because I'm going to go. Because John down.
- 3:35Rd. John Down Rd. would he'd come up
- 3:39and we'd watch 8-9 episodes. Yeah.
- 3:44He's. Gone.
- 3:46He's gone now. No, he's not listening anymore.
- 3:48You'll be as rude as you like. I'm so sorry.
- 3:52Talk about crotons at some point.
- 3:53He's very unforgiving. No dominators.
- 3:56Oh my God, he's definitely. Oh no.
- 3:57Which note? Have I?
- 3:57Have I done the wrong? Not crotons.
- 4:01Oh no. Oh.
- 4:02I expect their threats soon. OK, sorry, no.
- 4:05Please continue. Should I said the quarks and I
- 4:07went quotants. The marathon was with my friend
- 4:13John. He'd he'd come up road and we'd
- 4:16get through kind of 89 episodes a weekend.
- 4:18And then COVID happened. That was even better.
- 4:20Like we couldn't see each other, but we could, we could zoom and
- 4:23we we and you know, and so we'd get through several stories a
- 4:28week online and then when we were allowed bubbles, even
- 4:33better. Like he'd spend the whole whole
- 4:35days round watching episodes and then.
- 4:37Living the life during COVID. I had a great pandemic.
- 4:41Oh, we're still working. You get all right and then we
- 4:45all had to go back to work and it was busier than ever.
- 4:47And and what has happened subsequently is that John is no
- 4:50no longer down the road. He's in freaking Dorking, which
- 4:56is kind of down the road if it's a.
- 4:58Choice. In a very metaphorical way, my
- 5:02apologies. To anyone who lives in Dorking.
- 5:05Dorking is, is, is lovely, but it's it's a very, very long way
- 5:08from me. So it's any watching that we do
- 5:10is going to be a kind of watch party type arrangement.
- 5:13But he was starting a new job. He had a social life, damn him.
- 5:18So yeah, so around about kind of the Peter Davidson era, we
- 5:23slowed down to an absolute crawl and we were managing kind of one
- 5:26episode of Fortnite or something like that.
- 5:28So then then it. Became a very because he was
- 5:30busy James, although it wasn't a.
- 5:32Quality story. No, because Peter Davidson was
- 5:35his era. He was loving that.
- 5:36That woman. No, we really did just get busy.
- 5:39But I do remember that when we got to Mark of the Rani in
- 5:44context, it felt like we'd arrived at a minor classic.
- 5:49And I think the quality that that gave it that feeling was
- 5:55very much it's being historical. If you think about if you think
- 5:58about when JNT came in, Tom Baker's last season doesn't have
- 6:04any historical stories. Pete, the Peter Davidson
- 6:06historicals are very flimsy indeed.
- 6:09You've you've got the King's demons.
- 6:11I guess it's the most kind of concerted effort to show a
- 6:14historical setting, and it's got all that jousting and stuff,
- 6:16which is great, but it's one episode in a story which I think
- 6:19most of us would at best say is rather lightweight.
- 6:24I'm not very interested in the historical.
- 6:27Even though by the new series it's sort of yeah, feels the
- 6:30need to eject a lot of sci-fi as.
- 6:32Well, it's a backdrop, but it's really just a showcase for this
- 6:35fabulous new robot that doesn't work.
- 6:38So when you get when you arrive at the mark of the runner,
- 6:41you're actually thinking. And of course, Graham Williams
- 6:43wasn't very interested in history either.
- 6:44He it's all kind of fantasy and different planets.
- 6:47I did feel like a previous commentary we did was it felt
- 6:50like a historical even though it wasn't.
- 6:53Yeah, but you you couldn't claim that the Android Attara is, is,
- 6:58is a historical or, or is it is in any way based on a, on a real
- 7:02historical setting. You know, it's got the trappings
- 7:04of of costume drama, but that's a different thing.
- 7:06What I'm talking about is actually the idea that we're in
- 7:08a time travel series and you can go back to the, the past that is
- 7:13reckoned, you know, the past of stuff that you studied in
- 7:16schools. And, and the marker of the
- 7:18Ronnie is such a, a, a, a, a complete effort to do that, both
- 7:26in the writing and in the realisation.
- 7:28And the minute it starts, you're there in that world.
- 7:31And, and certainly kind of after most of Colin Baker's first
- 7:36season and all of Peter Davidson's last, you just think,
- 7:39wow, it's been a while since the TARDIS went back in time and we
- 7:43were we were committing to realising a, a period in history
- 7:49this beautifully. And also, and I, I'm, I'm don't
- 7:54dislike Colin Baker's first season at all, but there is a
- 7:59there, there is a quality to it which is more traditional just
- 8:05in the way that Doctors written and in the way the the plot
- 8:08unfolds. You're you're not being, you're
- 8:13not being confronted with violent imagery.
- 8:16You're not being tricked into thinking that it's a heist
- 8:19movie. You're just, you're being shown
- 8:20good old fashioned Doctor Who in historical setting and in
- 8:23context. It just felt like, oh wow, we're
- 8:25in a really exciting place all of a sudden with this Doctor.
- 8:29I think Pip and Jay Baker as well are the only writers really
- 8:36in season 22 that remember that Colin Baker's 6th Doctor is at
- 8:42the heart of this show and is the hero of this show and should
- 8:46be at the forefront of the story because he's in absolutely like
- 8:50from the third scene, you know? And that's rare in 22.
- 8:53And and he's doing things that we expect the doctor to do.
- 8:58He is to use an overused were Doctor ish in it but he's show
- 9:02he is showing out a heck of a range as an actor but also as a
- 9:06as a character. You're talking about the
- 9:08discontinuity guide again? Aren't you?
- 9:10A doctor Ish doctor. Is that what it says?
- 9:12Is that what? I had actually forgotten that,
- 9:14but there. Under the bottom line, our
- 9:15favorite bits, but also as well, and correct me if I'm wrong, and
- 9:20I've said this many times, but I'm going to repeat myself
- 9:22because I think it bears repeating because I did last
- 9:26year. I don't know why I was in a bit
- 9:27of a self hate period. And I went to Outpost Gallifrey
- 9:30or Gallifrey base, whatever it's called these days.
- 9:33And they had a few sort of threads up of like the best and
- 9:35worst writers. And you have to choose your top
- 9:37three in both directions and everyone's top bottom 3 Pip and
- 9:41Jane Baker on it. And it made me so incandescent
- 9:44with rage because, OK, they do, right?
- 9:48Ripe dialogue. Yeah.
- 9:50But I love it because I, I do not mind a, a bit of verbosity
- 9:55in my dialogue. You know, I'm not a fan of
- 9:58Shakespeare, but I imagine if I went to see a Shakespeare play,
- 10:01I'd be tickled by some of the dialogue.
- 10:04Also, you'd find it much easier than Pip and Jane Baker to
- 10:07understand what they were talking about.
- 10:08Sure. What?
- 10:10The catharsis of spurious morality you mean?
- 10:12A web of mayhem and intrigue, Perhaps I could go on.
- 10:17Would be a more. Go on, just do the whole line.
- 10:23It's a something epithet, isn't it?
- 10:25I've gotten the the quote would be a more.
- 10:29No, it's an aposite epithet. It's.
- 10:31Oh, it's aposite epithet. Fortuitous.
- 10:33Fortuitous would be my aposite. There we go.
- 10:36God, no wonder we couldn't remember that line.
- 10:38But also as well, these are some strengths I think Pip and Jane
- 10:42have. Yeah.
- 10:42You know, I just want to lay them out.
- 10:44I think they remember the kids, and that's really important.
- 10:46And not a lot of stories in season 22 remember the kids.
- 10:49They're quite violent and they're quite brutal.
- 10:51This has violence in it, but I think it's all OK.
- 10:54It's sort of excitement and adventure rather than, well, I
- 10:58don't know what's going on in vengeance on Var or so, if I'm
- 11:00honest. Torture porn, we'll call it.
- 11:03Yeah. But they remember to give the
- 11:05show heart. They remember to.
- 11:08They remember that the side characters are important and we
- 11:11should care about them. And they remember the doctors
- 11:15having a relationship with his friend, and they like each
- 11:19other. There's a bit spiky in this, but
- 11:20they like each other. Yeah.
- 11:23And what the hell, they know how to write a villain as well.
- 11:27Oh goodness, they have the best time right at the time laws in
- 11:30this. I mean, I think I the comparison
- 11:33I would make is with stock Aiken and Waterman.
- 11:38I think Pip and Jane are the stock Aiken and Waterman of of
- 11:41Doctor Who writers. Well, so stock Aiken and
- 11:44Waterman became a kind of a joke and were very heavily criticized
- 11:48for churning out top ten hits. And then they have a 100 top ten
- 11:54hits eventually. Like they made it look that
- 11:58easy. Now that's a stupid criticism
- 12:00because no one can churn out top ten hits easily.
- 12:05They just made it look easy. And sure, they had a formula.
- 12:10That's how they were able to churn them out.
- 12:12You know, the, the, the way they were able to to get so many
- 12:16songs out, so many catchy songs out so fast is that they had
- 12:19tricks that they could draw on. And sure, if you were to listen
- 12:22to all 100 of those top ten hits, they would begin to sound
- 12:25a bit samey because they're using a similar language.
- 12:28Nevertheless, they were really, really bloody good at what they
- 12:32were doing. And I think Pip and Jane are a
- 12:33bit like that. They know what beats to hit.
- 12:36They are kind of hacks. And I don't mean that in a
- 12:39negative way. I think Malcolm Hulk had that
- 12:41reputation as well, to the extent that his nickname amongst
- 12:45other writers was Hack Mulk. And that's not necessarily a bad
- 12:49thing, particularly as we get in season 23 when the show is in
- 12:54absolute crisis and you need to who, who can you depend on to
- 12:57knock out a final installment in a a a very limited amount of
- 13:02time with no information about what was meant to go into?
- 13:05An impossible task. An impossible task which?
- 13:08They absolutely rise to where they came a cropper was when
- 13:13Andrew Cardinal took over. Because then you have someone
- 13:15with ambition and vision who is really looking for writers who
- 13:19are kind of brilliantly creative and, and, and thinkers outside
- 13:24the box. And they would.
- 13:26What they weren't is thinkers outside the box.
- 13:28They were going to turn in a brilliant script, absolutely,
- 13:33that fits inside that box perfectly.
- 13:35That's who they were and that's why in this season I think they
- 13:38were just absolutely in the right place to write for Colin
- 13:40Baker's Doctor. It's kind of sad because neither
- 13:43Eric's Award or Andrew Cartmel rated them and and sort of felt
- 13:47they were sort of Lombard with them.
- 13:49But boy, they understand structure as well.
- 13:51You know, they go as a structure, a bloody script.
- 13:54Yeah, but not a lot of people did in mid 80s.
- 13:56Who I I draw your attention to Time Lash.
- 14:01Oh, it's yeah. You know, I could, I could, I
- 14:04could, I could, I could stick a pin into the map of Eric
- 14:09Saywood's time as script editor and just go, well, here, here
- 14:12are a handful of things that don't conform to any kind of
- 14:14structure and suffer massively as a result.
- 14:17But Doctor fans go on well. I'm supposed to say the other
- 14:21thing that Pip and Jane absolutely can do is because
- 14:24they've worked on film, is that they understand how to work for
- 14:27location. Oh God, yeah.
- 14:30Gorgeous gift of all this additional location work for
- 14:34Mark of Iran, who was handed Pip and Jane got on the phone and
- 14:36went, don't you worry, we'll come to Bliss Hill and we'll
- 14:39write the scenes there. Colin can learn them overnight
- 14:42and we'll fill them the next day.
- 14:44And that's what they bloody well did.
- 14:45Perfect. And actually, although you say
- 14:48the script editors didn't have a lot of time for them and and
- 14:51when you see them interview interviewed, you can imagine
- 14:53they were probably quite difficult to work with, no?
- 14:56Jane Pip seems quite. When I speak of them, when I
- 15:01when I speak of them as a as a couple, obviously you're dealing
- 15:05with Jane. Yeah, she's great because I
- 15:07don't think Pip don't think had any say at all in what I think
- 15:13you don't. Hear that story that Cartmel's
- 15:14holding his fabulous script, Doctor?
- 15:17Yes. Where?
- 15:18Where? He phoned him up and Pip picked
- 15:20up the phone. It's like, oh, hello, Andrew.
- 15:22Yes, what's that a problem with the script?
- 15:24And then Andrew said he could hear in the background who's on
- 15:27the phone. And then she went, come here,
- 15:29give me that. Who's it?
- 15:30Andrew Cartmel? We're not changing that script.
- 15:33And she just put the phone down. She sounds great.
- 15:37You can see that in the interview.
- 15:38So yeah, he'll start talking. No, no, no, no, no, it wasn't.
- 15:43And who was, I think, oh, is it Richard Marsden described them
- 15:48as the Fanny and Johnny Craddock of script writing.
- 15:51I mean that they must have been a nightmare.
- 15:55Actually, if if, if things if they weren't doing what you
- 15:58wanted. But the people who speak highly
- 16:01of them and the actors, Colin Baker is a huge fan.
- 16:04And that's because because they were engaging with the the work
- 16:09in a way that actors absolutely want.
- 16:11And I and I bet they were helpful to directors as well.
- 16:16Colin said they knew how to give me words, of course.
- 16:18Why did they? Well, I'm actually talk about
- 16:22giving that doctor the right material.
- 16:25Yeah, well, I think he's one of the few.
- 16:27I mean, imagine poor John Perk where you say in this dialogue
- 16:30he'd ever had no hope. You know they're.
- 16:32Trying to there are very, there are very few doctors you can, I
- 16:36mean, Hartnell wouldn't have got through a single sentence, would
- 16:39he? Colin Baker is lexically gifted,
- 16:42isn't he? He is, you know, he can.
- 16:44He can pretty much say. He's a proper old school actor
- 16:48and and oh. No.
- 16:51Sorry, let me just let me just finish that.
- 16:53And because Colin Baker is also, and this is a a, a positive, he
- 17:00is theatrical. And I'm not saying that he
- 17:02doesn't understand how to deliver that kind of performance
- 17:05to the camera, because I think he generally does.
- 17:08But he he grew up through a theatre tradition in a way that
- 17:13is increasingly a rarity amongst television actors.
- 17:16And you can see in his performance he can deliver text.
- 17:19I mean, it is shake in that sense.
- 17:22You would totally trust Colin Baker to deliver full staff
- 17:25because he because he can, he understands long sentences.
- 17:30That's what you know the his best big Finnish performances
- 17:33have understood that and have given him huge pieces of
- 17:38dialogue or indeed soliloquy to deliver.
- 17:41And he always delivers because he understands how to approach
- 17:45that kind of verbose writing. Now, are you being infected by
- 17:50Pip and Jane Baker James on this call?
- 17:52Because where you just said as an aside or indeed soliloquy
- 17:55there, that's the most Pip and Jane thing you've ever said in
- 17:57one of these calls. Pip and Jane Jane.
- 18:02What? Jane, I haven't actually even
- 18:04asked you the question I was going to ask you.
- 18:06Because. I mean, we've been singing the
- 18:08praises of Fabulous Pip and Jane Baker, and that is, how did you
- 18:13find the 6th Doctor? Like, you know, he's a divisive
- 18:16fellow, but some people love him passionately.
- 18:19Other people say this as well. I've ducked out of the show,
- 18:21thank you very much. And I'm not having anything else
- 18:23to do with it. I think that a thing that is
- 18:28worth remembering is how low Colin Baker's cachet was when we
- 18:35were growing up, particularly well at the age when I was
- 18:39getting into Doctor Who, to the point where I remember when they
- 18:42started the 1992 repeat season that stopped and started and
- 18:48went on for ages. But I remember having
- 18:50conversation at school with someone and I was very excitedly
- 18:55saying, well, they're going to show a story from every doctor.
- 18:59And he said, well, surely not Colin Baker.
- 19:02That's that is, you know, Colin Baker had been the scapegoat for
- 19:06the cancellation, the near cancellation of Doctor Who.
- 19:10And I mean, God knows he took it well.
- 19:15I mean, I don't, I know, I know he's talked about it.
- 19:17And he didn't entirely take it well.
- 19:18But the, the generosity of the man to carry on giving those
- 19:21interviews and doing the PR and, and indeed and playing the
- 19:26Doctor on stage, but a couple of years later.
- 19:29So, I mean, he was so generous in the way that he kind of
- 19:33understood that it was basically just BBC politics.
- 19:36But that was kind of his reputation.
- 19:38And I'm not sure that fandom did enough to speak up for him.
- 19:42I, I, I remember what was written about him in well, it
- 19:46wasn't written about him. It was written about his doctor
- 19:48in the doctor yearbook 93, the first of the of the doctor
- 19:53yearbooks which had a a a rundown of every doctor and the
- 19:586th doctor was something along the lines of far too.
- 20:04It reflected the mid 80s far too well.
- 20:08And the word bombastic was throwing, you know, bombastic
- 20:11brash, that was. Apologetic description.
- 20:15Yeah, absolutely. Just kind of took the narrative
- 20:19and that was the description of the, the, the journey that was
- 20:22described. And bearing in mind, I had I, I
- 20:27had, I mean most of the writing about the the other doctors had
- 20:32been done before. So in, for example, Peter
- 20:35Haining is a celebration. You obviously only got the 1st 5
- 20:37doctors. So I was well versed in what the
- 20:401st 5 doctors were like. So this was the what probably
- 20:42the first book that I read that gave me what the 6th Doctor was
- 20:45like. And it was mostly kind of
- 20:47damning. And it may have said something
- 20:49like the actors struggled against the scripts, but but the
- 20:54narrative in that yearbook was very much like a real low point
- 20:57with the sick Doctor. And then thank goodness we had
- 21:00kind of three years with the glorious 7th Doctor before it
- 21:04was cancelled for good. And I just, I took that in.
- 21:08I, I, I mean, I had, I had absolutely nothing.
- 21:12I've not seen any Colin Baker. I loved Sylvester McCoy, so that
- 21:15narrative worked for me. I remember seeing Colin Baker on
- 21:19television before Roland Rat, in which he gives a pretty scary
- 21:23performance and the image of, you know, he, he, I, I think
- 21:27probably I don't, and I'm really don't have a problem in the
- 21:30costume. And I like the way the costume
- 21:31has become kind of iconic now, but I think he probably didn't
- 21:35do him any favours in terms of just what you saw as an image
- 21:39of, you know, what is Doctor Who like?
- 21:40Because if if you wanted to sum up kind of why is Doctor Who
- 21:45wonderful, That's that costume isn't is not what you'd.
- 21:49I think J&T needed to think what a non Doctor Who fan would think
- 21:54when putting on Doctor Who. I don't think you should do that
- 21:57very often, but this was one time where you know like that is
- 22:01making a statement I can assume. And I'm not sure, I'm not sure
- 22:04it did reflect the mid 80s far too much, but I but maybe it
- 22:10looks a little bit too children's television because
- 22:12because children's television was absolutely.
- 22:14If you think of the grotesques that were around in the mid 80s,
- 22:17you know, Rod Holland, Emu and, you know, there wasn't a single
- 22:21show on television. They weren't painted as stupid
- 22:22because. Yeah, exactly.
- 22:24But you know, pantomime was. It's the thing that my dad used
- 22:29to say killed crackerjack. It became a kind of pantomime
- 22:32with these grotesque costumes and gunge that kind of was the
- 22:36what I was getting kind of from Doctor Who.
- 22:39But if you and that if. You turn on your TV right at the
- 22:41wrong point in time Lash, and you see Colin Baker bounding
- 22:45across that set, throwing the ball right down that Tinsley
- 22:47time Lash. I mean, you know you're never
- 22:50going to come back to it. Indeed, Grade may have had a
- 22:52point. Or indeed, the mysterious
- 22:53planet, which, you know, there are scenes in that that do look
- 22:56like a bit of Cracker Jack where they're just getting gunged in
- 22:59horrible costumes. So by the time I saw Colin
- 23:03Baker, my expectations had been very, very substantially
- 23:06lowered. And that first story that I saw
- 23:08was Revelation of the Daleks, because that was part of the, I
- 23:13say, the 1992 repeat season. I think we were probably in
- 23:16about 2008 by the time they got around to Colin Baker.
- 23:19But I remember feeling that the Doctor wasn't in it very much
- 23:26and it was split into 4 episodes.
- 23:28So they were odd episodes, odd chunks and he's barely in the
- 23:30first one at all. I'd also remember by the final
- 23:34episode, the final quarter, he's in it quite a lot and really,
- 23:38really enjoying his performance and enjoying the the tension and
- 23:42the repartee between him and Davros and and the the his
- 23:46presence. And then the next Colin Baker
- 23:49story I watched was the Mark of the Rani, because that was one
- 23:53of the first ones to come out VHS.
- 23:54And I, I, I, I guess it's that it is a doctor ish doctor, isn't
- 24:01it? I mean, of course he he inhabits
- 24:03this story absolutely front and center stage and he's really
- 24:11appealing in it. That that was the other thing
- 24:13I've been, we all knew this, we the the rumour was of this
- 24:17unpleasant, he was the unpleasant Dr. the horrible
- 24:21doctor. That's, I mean genuinely the
- 24:23doctor so horrible that he nearly killed the program.
- 24:26So we see the mark of the Rani is completely different to that.
- 24:30And mind in this, do you remember where it goes?
- 24:32These are living beings, Rani, human beings that I've done you
- 24:35no harm. You know that's not a monster.
- 24:41And I have, I guess kind of from, from, that's kind of
- 24:50difficult beginning, but not of my own fault, but just kind of
- 24:54coming to Conor Bacon with the lowest expectations.
- 24:56My, I think my admiration for the man has just grown and grown
- 24:59and grown partly through having been fortunate enough to meet
- 25:02him a couple of times because he's just the loveliest guy in
- 25:05the flesh. I mean, I've met him very much
- 25:08as a fan queuing for an autograph.
- 25:10And nevertheless, he made me feel like the time I spent
- 25:14queuing was, was time well spent and that for that kind of 30
- 25:19seconds, I was his sole focus of attention.
- 25:24I've seen him on stage a couple of times and he's been
- 25:26brilliant. And I mean, that's the other
- 25:27thing is, you know, talking about his theatrical background.
- 25:30He's a really, really fine actor.
- 25:32He's he's, he's well. See him in corpse James when he.
- 25:35Got skewered to the drinks. Company and then got went into
- 25:39the wall and then in Act 2 he came back round again and he was
- 25:42still skewered to the wall. Oh man, he was great.
- 25:46I saw him in a touring production of Kind Hearts and
- 25:48Coronets, and he was playing the Alec Guinness roles, which is,
- 25:54if you think about it, that makes total sense.
- 25:56Like you're looking for someone who can be all those different
- 26:00characters. They were slightly larger than
- 26:01life in a way that Alec Guinness's interpretations were
- 26:03not. But it's it was a stage
- 26:05production. So yeah, big respect for him as
- 26:07a performer. And then then of course, the
- 26:10work he's done with Big Finish. And I think that he has achieved
- 26:14a level of consistency that none of the other doctors have for
- 26:17Big Finish. And I think you get the
- 26:19impression that people love writing for him.
- 26:21And that's because he can do anything.
- 26:24And I love the fact they've even gone down the road of telling
- 26:27him he's got different versions of this doctor in the same way
- 26:31that they have with Nicola Bryan.
- 26:32You know, you're playing this doctor.
- 26:34This is your early doctor. This is a later doctor.
- 26:36This is post male, this pre male.
- 26:38Do you know what I mean? I mean, for for a long time, it
- 26:42was the the 6th doctor Evelyn, which just seemed like such a an
- 26:47inspired idea to put in with an older lady who could hold her
- 26:51own. And she was brilliant as well.
- 26:53And what a joy. I mean, what what a joy to kind
- 26:57of discover through those that he might on some days be your
- 27:00favorite doctor. Oh, he is my favorite doctor,
- 27:03but on those days he's my favoritest favorite doctor.
- 27:07They were just made for each other, weren't they?
- 27:09You know, you said about meeting him in person.
- 27:10I'll never forget. Because, you know, he hates the
- 27:13the favorite thing, doesn't he? Favorite.
- 27:15Who's your favorite doctor? Who's your favorite?
- 27:16Of course, yeah. I went out to my Doctor Who and
- 27:19the Pirates, wonderful Doctor 6. And I said, oh, I said, I know
- 27:24you don't like this. It goes, you're my favorite
- 27:28doctor. And he jumps his face when it's
- 27:31like so serious. I thought, oh, shit.
- 27:34And now and then he had this naughty gleam in his eye and he
- 27:37sort of did this massive smile when and except when it's me, he
- 27:41went give it here. And he's so cheeky.
- 27:45Oh, he's lovely. But he was.
- 27:47He won one of those polls like 2 years into big finish.
- 27:51He was. It was the year of the pirates.
- 27:53I remember he. And it was also the year he did
- 27:55an astonishing series of interviews.
- 27:58Well, it was a single interview, but that must have taken about
- 28:00four hours for Doctor Who magazine and IS.
- 28:04That the tell one. It was just very.
- 28:06It was tell it was brutally honest, but it was also he like
- 28:12he's always been so fat. Given the way that other people
- 28:15have spoken about him, He's he's never been vindictive.
- 28:20He's never been kind of bitter. I it's like even when you get
- 28:23the tell all you, what you get is, yeah, that hurt.
- 28:27He's he's never really lashed out.
- 28:29He's he's never taken the the opportunities that he's been
- 28:32given to to kind of throw stones back.
- 28:37He's a decent guy. The funniest story he tells in
- 28:40his Colin Baker interview CDs he did with Nicholas Briggs and he
- 28:44said what have you heard those? I have, yeah.
- 28:46That's a brilliant. And he says again, after he was
- 28:50fired, he then went out to America to do something.
- 28:54And Michael Grade was. With Michael Grade and his wife.
- 28:57And they're like, oh, look, it's Colin from Doctor Who.
- 29:00Invite him over. Michael Grade's phone.
- 29:01No, no, let's not invite him over.
- 29:04And he said he had a lovely night with Michael Grade.
- 29:06Barnum champagne and the whole night.
- 29:08So like, yeah, he was. Michael Gray's wife there.
- 29:10When are you doing the next season of?
- 29:12Doctor indeed. Well, I'm not.
- 29:16Why ever not? Totes Orks.
- 29:19Well, look, I think we should watch him in action, you know.
- 29:22What do you reckon? Alongside some, I mean, we
- 29:25haven't even mentioned Sarah Hellings yet.
- 29:27And I must talk about. Oh my.
- 29:28Goodness, I mean, and many, many people to talk of in in this
- 29:31country. Jonathan Gibbs, James.
- 29:34It's a great score. It is a great.
- 29:36Score definitely have more to say about that.
- 29:38And, you know, given we've just had, you know, like the score
- 29:41from Attack of the Cybermen with the Steptoe and Sunrish, it's
- 29:45not a guarantee it's going to be a great score.
- 29:47Well, would you care to count us in?
- 29:49OK, we shall be watching Doctor Who, Mark of the Rani in 321 go.
- 30:00Oh boy, I've got the sound on Jesus that's frighten the life
- 30:03out of me. That sting?
- 30:04I've just got the subtitle that says in capital letters Doctor
- 30:07Who theme. Yes, right.
- 30:09Well, it is. And it's certainly a Doctor Who
- 30:11theme with an exclamation mark. Isn't it definitely in capital
- 30:14letters and ought to probably be in rainbow colours?
- 30:16Do you like the Peter Howe music?
- 30:18I do like it. I I don't love it, but if it
- 30:22wasn't my theme, it wasn't the one I grew up with.
- 30:24I but it's it's certainly. It does what it needed to do
- 30:28when it was written. Am I wrong in saying because I
- 30:30feel like it's dated worse than the John Perry Tom Baker one?
- 30:34Oh yeah, you know, I just think 80's the second I hear.
- 30:37It all of the all of the synth ones have, but I'll give a pass
- 30:41to the KEF McCulloch 1 because. It's our first.
- 30:43It's our first. It's our first.
- 30:45Now where are we? We're in Bliss Hill.
- 30:48Fabulous air museum. I haven't, no, but I know lots
- 30:52of people that have. So it was a place that my dad,
- 30:55we used to live in Cheltenham, which wasn't too far from I'm
- 31:00Bridge Gorge and my dad used to keep saying well we'll go there
- 31:02one day and we never did and I never have.
- 31:05Well, James, should we ever visit a Doctor Who location,
- 31:08we'll have a cream tea in Bliss Hill.
- 31:10It'll, yeah, it'll need to be a substantial cream tea.
- 31:12It's a bit of a schlep. This could be a expensive Sunday
- 31:17night ITV period drama, right? That's what I mean about when we
- 31:22started watching this in context.
- 31:25It's straight away just the quality comes off it and then we
- 31:31get the score cuts in, I mean. This, this now the pull back
- 31:34from the camera. Yeah, that goes.
- 31:36Up and up and it goes up and up and up, yeah.
- 31:38And the music. And of course.
- 31:39The location the location is brilliantly chosen because it
- 31:43it's it's it's gifted to them. It's already looks like this,
- 31:46but it genuinely looks like an very expensive piece of
- 31:51television costume drama, doesn't it?
- 31:53And Jonathan? It genuinely does suggest an end
- 31:56of the day sort of amble home. It's got the So Jonathan Gibbs
- 32:01says that he was doing something quite unusual in that he was
- 32:05writing for real instruments. They were going to be played by
- 32:07synths, but that was something that was slightly frowned upon.
- 32:10The radio phonic workshop with seen as people who dealt in
- 32:14otherworldly sounds because they would live in the same building
- 32:17as the BBC Symphony Orchestra. So This is why this store
- 32:20sticks, this score sticks out. It's because it's for the first
- 32:23time in ages we're having he's he's using sounds that are meant
- 32:27to sound a bit like the French horn.
- 32:28He's got a bit of a harp going on there.
- 32:30Because he did do the score for Vengeance and Virus which was
- 32:32the last story, which I think is a a good score.
- 32:35It is a good score, but it's very different to this.
- 32:37One. It's not as atmospheric as this
- 32:38one though, no. No, no.
- 32:40You know who is this old Crone honestly running the bathhouse.
- 32:45Is she? Is she an extra?
- 32:46Maybe she's in the studio as well as.
- 32:48She looks like the sort of actress you know that would be
- 32:50treated with terrible disrespect until the make up came off later
- 32:54on in the day, according to reports.
- 32:58These sets are good as well they they match the the exteriors
- 33:01pretty well I think. I think they're well lit too.
- 33:03I don't think 80s Doctor Who always did sort of outside
- 33:07inside particularly well. But what they've done well here
- 33:10is they've actually done outside light inside.
- 33:13So they you have the impression of light shining in through
- 33:18windows. And there's a bit of hazer as
- 33:20well. Maybe, probably it's not hazer,
- 33:22is it? They filmed this once already
- 33:24and there's a bit of smoke still sitting there, making the
- 33:26lighting look better. But yeah, a happy accident.
- 33:29They're well, and this is quite nice, you know, sort of well,
- 33:32this isn't nice. They're just currently it
- 33:34appears they're being gassed to death but.
- 33:36It always seems to upset me when when smoke would gas people but
- 33:41they would fall over before the smoke had actually reached them.
- 33:44Now I feel as if I've turned the channel to, I don't know, a
- 33:48light end show and there's a lot of colour, sort of me all of a
- 33:51sudden. I know a lot of people are
- 33:54malfunctioning. I mean, that's maybe not the
- 33:58finest. You did, James.
- 33:59It was the wrong question after all.
- 34:03Perry Perry is wearing something that looks like an actual dress
- 34:07in this, and I know some people have been unflattering about her
- 34:11costume in this, but you have to bear in mind that in every other
- 34:15story of the season, she dresses in a way that nobody in real
- 34:18life has ever dressed. No, only in the eyes of John
- 34:22Nathan Turner. Only John Nathan Turner in his
- 34:25imagination, in his. What he?
- 34:29Wore completely He's completely incapable of imagining a a
- 34:34normal, normally dressed teenage girl.
- 34:37Would imagine I'll never stop telling that story on the Twin
- 34:40Dilemma where he goes, well, Nicola, please get into costume.
- 34:43And they're like, no, no, she's in her costume because she was
- 34:45covered up right and beautiful and he went, no, she's not.
- 34:48And he made them tear off bits of the costume.
- 34:51Unbelievable, isn't it? But is this a different costume
- 34:54on location? Because it seems a lot yellower
- 34:57on location than it did in the studio.
- 34:59Or she put a jacket on. No, I think, I think it, I think
- 35:04you're right. I think it's a, I think it's
- 35:07probably a lighting thing. I don't know.
- 35:09Or is it a different? It does seem a lot yellower,
- 35:12doesn't it? Yeah, hoist up your skirts,
- 35:15James. Off we go.
- 35:17But yellow doesn't under studio lights, yellow does bleach.
- 35:21So I just wonder whether that film footage has been
- 35:23beautifully kind of graded and. You know, I've got to say to
- 35:27you, James, these chaps here, they seem sort of nice gentle
- 35:30folk when they were leaving work.
- 35:32Now they seem positively, I mean the things they do to these
- 35:35jacket potatoes. Yeah, though actually I've been,
- 35:37I've been in. I mean, this was what made games
- 35:40at school so traumatic. You'd go into the changing rooms
- 35:42and everyone had come out of maths and they were being very
- 35:44kind of gentle. By the end of games they'd be
- 35:46flicking towels at each other and kicking your potatoes over
- 35:49and. Really.
- 35:50That was quite fun actually. You know it.
- 35:52Wasn't. At the time, it wasn't.
- 35:55Oh, this is lovely Perry talking about the botany they do
- 35:57remember every now and again, but she's a student of botany.
- 36:00She's she's, she's got plenty of initiative in this one and the
- 36:04doctor trusts her. I, I think they write really
- 36:06well for her as well. There's.
- 36:08One moment though, 1 moment where she's spectacularly stupid
- 36:11at the wrong point and I will point that out.
- 36:14You could say there is precedent for companions to to be
- 36:16spectacularly stupid. This is very, this feels very
- 36:19traditional as well, doesn't it? The doctrine and companion,
- 36:23they're not arriving on the scene to.
- 36:25There's no jeopardy, but they're just wandering in and that and
- 36:29he's got a gadget. I mean, this could sort of be a
- 36:32heart, no historical at this point, couldn't it, you know?
- 36:38Scarecrow. We think move just.
- 36:39Said this so the scarecrow is one of the things where so where
- 36:43I think Pip and Jane don't always make sense is that they
- 36:47have they're very kind of image driven that wouldn't it be cool
- 36:50if the master was dressed as a scarecrow?
- 36:52Sorry, spoilers, that's the master.
- 36:54What? But what?
- 36:55Why? Why is he dressed as a
- 36:57scarecrow? Yeah, I think, yeah.
- 36:59I don't know. The only there's, the only
- 37:01motive you can give him is that he knows he's in Doctor Who and
- 37:04he needs to be in a disguise. But that doesn't make much
- 37:07sense, does it? Doesn't make a lot of sense.
- 37:10This is a great brandishing that knife.
- 37:11Then there's a lot of noise in Season 22.
- 37:16The actual smash, if the smashing of stuff, is genuinely
- 37:20violent, isn't it? And they are appropriate.
- 37:23I know that the hip, the shovel doesn't quite convince that it's
- 37:26made contact at any kind of speed, but Even so, that's a
- 37:30that's a nasty struggle, isn't it?
- 37:32I love Colin now, man of actually dashes in, he calms
- 37:35down the horse, he tends to the people that are hurt.
- 37:39You know, he's just there and involves stroke.
- 37:41Revelation of the Daleks. It takes him, you know, 45
- 37:44minutes to climb over a wall. It's all, it's all very, very
- 37:52well directed location as well. It's got it's got plenty of
- 37:55movement, plenty of drama. Sarah Hellings is really good.
- 37:57He said so. Colin says that he loved working
- 38:01with Sarah Hellings, that she was a very intuitive director
- 38:04and brilliant with actors, and I think you can see it actually.
- 38:07Oh totally. The shots are really beautiful
- 38:09frames and you can see how well the location has been not only
- 38:14chosen but used for for each particular scene.
- 38:17Oh, that line there makes me laugh.
- 38:18That was in a discontinuity. Go where Perry goes.
- 38:20You suspect another motive? I love the fact that the mark of
- 38:27the Ronnie is absolutely enormous and nobody could
- 38:30possibly miss it. Yeah.
- 38:32She needs a bit of foundation. Once I come out of that machine,
- 38:34she could just sort of dab them down and then no one would know.
- 38:38And the mark of the Ronnie is basically a Hickey, isn't it?
- 38:40Yeah. I mean, I've never had one that
- 38:42big, but yeah. Is it definitely from the
- 38:45machine or do you think the Ronnie it's her way of thanking
- 38:49them? Oh, no, you've seen the state of
- 38:52some of them. Come on now.
- 38:53Luke Ward, maybe. Oh, I need to warn you that
- 38:57later on in the in the story, well, you are on a call with me.
- 39:01Just remember that, OK? Luke Ward is very pretty.
- 39:04Now he is, but he's also packing too.
- 39:06Yes, you are. Packing.
- 39:07No, I, I, I, I have observed this, I think.
- 39:12I think that covers up maybe a not terribly well written
- 39:17character, but we can discuss that when we get that very well.
- 39:20Ask me a lad. Look, what are the potatoes
- 39:22being kicked down the road? That's good continuity, isn't
- 39:24it? The potatoes are all Chucky.
- 39:26Look at all these people, there's fucking extras
- 39:28everywhere. It does.
- 39:29Carrying things away, I mean. Were they just, were these sort
- 39:32of museum workers? Do you want to be a tourist
- 39:35Who's today? Come on.
- 39:37It's like one of those dress up shops.
- 39:39They must. Have down your cream tea.
- 39:40Let's go. They must have a they must have
- 39:44an old building full of costumes where you can dress up as a
- 39:46peasant or a Victorian. And it's so unusual, like at
- 39:49this point in a story to still be on location like.
- 39:52That is a reviewer way of filming the Rani in that scene
- 39:57as well, just having her in the background as they go past and
- 39:59the doctor doesn't even notice her but the camera just lingers
- 40:02on her going into the distance. Oh, can I say this is my one of
- 40:05my favorite perimobis in the story in a second where she
- 40:07charms the fella at the gate to let them in because she's really
- 40:11nice and the doctor's being a total prick.
- 40:14And then she goes, oh, please forgive him.
- 40:16He's a little bit eccentric. And then he looks straight to
- 40:18the camera and goes eccentric. Me.
- 40:20Preposterous. It's really fun.
- 40:23Yeah. No wonder you were seduced by
- 40:26him when you watched Martha second story.
- 40:30God, they're filthy, aren't they?
- 40:31They must be terrible down that mine.
- 40:35I'll sort of remember. That this time I'm going to the
- 40:37Tobys. I don't.
- 40:38What is all this talk of Toby's? What is a Toby?
- 40:41It's a Toby jug in it. It's a beer.
- 40:42Oh, of course it's a Toby Jug, but so is that a pint is?
- 40:45It a toppers will be along when they've emptied their tobys.
- 40:49Yeah, that's what they're trying to say.
- 40:50Oh my God, it's the master. Now his beard is rather
- 40:54different in this one, it usually joins up all the way
- 40:57around and they seem to have gone to a different mustachio
- 41:00for Anthony Amy's facial. It's literally like it's.
- 41:04Very like it's the most. In fact, I believe that beard
- 41:07also was being used by Tony Robinson and Maid Marian and her
- 41:10Merry Men at the same time. Is that a fact or have you just?
- 41:13Made that up, but I really hope that turn turns up in kind of
- 41:19what some kind of a reputable volume in a few years time.
- 41:24But you know what though? And I know a lot of people
- 41:26complain about the Master. I would not be out without the
- 41:29Master in this story. Him and the Ronnie, and we'll
- 41:33get there. I just think it's glorious.
- 41:35It's a love, it's a beautiful dynamic.
- 41:37They're great together. She can't be bothered with him
- 41:39at all, can she? And it sort of gives him a
- 41:42purpose for once. Yeah, but she, she basically
- 41:45says about the Doctor and the Master.
- 41:46What we think, right? Yeah, a pair of idiots.
- 41:51Oh, look at him, Gary. Look at Colin.
- 41:52I'm just going to walk straight in.
- 41:55I love him. Have you ever sort of entered
- 41:59somewhere like this with that much confidence, James?
- 42:02Not with a dog barking at me, no.
- 42:03Oh. No, he does look a bit.
- 42:05I no, because I it's how I try and go into work and I still
- 42:10sometimes get stopped at the gate and ask who I am.
- 42:12I'm working there 12 years. That confidence can't be faked.
- 42:17I try and Colin Bacon my way out and they're like.
- 42:19If I was there with you, I'll be going, oh, it's a bit eccentric,
- 42:22don't worry. Just let him throw do.
- 42:23You think it's a mistake wearing the full costume?
- 42:26What in this? No to work.
- 42:29Oh, you've got a Colin costume. Wow.
- 42:33No, I don't. I know you've got a Sylvester
- 42:34McCoy umbrella, so I would believe you.
- 42:37Yeah. I do know what people wear that
- 42:39Colin costume at all these conventions.
- 42:41I know it's become like the pride.
- 42:43Flag of Doctor Who costumes. And rightly so, because what?
- 42:46What else is it for? Yeah, have you?
- 42:49Seen that picture of him where someone drew where Yes, Perry
- 42:52goes factor. It's a pride parade.
- 42:54I found my people Perry. Look at Perry.
- 42:59She's so Chuck. And she does look beautiful,
- 43:01doesn't she? Yeah, I mean, she's pretty
- 43:03colourful. That's not a a particularly
- 43:06tasteful dress that she's wearing either, but.
- 43:08It was. Maybe it's just the colour,
- 43:10isn't it? Right.
- 43:11I think it's the trousers that that don't quite work.
- 43:14I don't think the coat is is the problem.
- 43:18I mean that skirt makes her look overweight and she most
- 43:21definitely. Oh yeah, no, her her skirt is
- 43:23not a flattering skirt, but I but I think it's more flattering
- 43:25than the kind of. The shot of the master through
- 43:27the gate is fab. Great, great.
- 43:31I'm just going to keep pointing out amazing camera work in this.
- 43:34Well, so and and it's going to get less and less because I
- 43:37think the amazing camera work is basically the location stuff and
- 43:40I don't think her studio work has quite the same dynamism.
- 43:45I think you'll be surprised how much location work there is in
- 43:48episode 2 though. Is there quite?
- 43:50There's a lot I. Seem to remember it kind of
- 43:52getting less and less and or there's quite a lot in that, in
- 43:55that well. We do my favorite thing house,
- 43:57my favorite Doctor Who thing. And you and I've talked about
- 43:59this before, Doctor Who in the woods, and we both love that.
- 44:03I do like Doctor in the Woods. This poor dog, he does look.
- 44:08He doesn't look as no. On location there was some
- 44:12genuine worrying dog action. This dog looks like a dog I
- 44:17would go and pet straight away. The doctor's trying to get out
- 44:20of the window. Look, I don't know.
- 44:24I just feel like he's always improvising his way through the
- 44:26story. You.
- 44:26Know he's very, he's a very visual performer.
- 44:31Again, it's the it's the theatre thing.
- 44:33He's used to being in a situation where he's got a very
- 44:36small space to work in, so his movements are very precisely
- 44:40calculated. What is the collective noun for
- 44:45a load of geniuses, James? I don't know.
- 44:51Pip and Jane Baker might know. How do I say it?
- 44:54An inspiration An. Inspiration.
- 44:55I didn't realize you were throwing me a quote, I thought.
- 44:59I thought this was. I know all the pick and Jane.
- 45:03Factual information like the one I gave you about Tony.
- 45:05Tony Robinson's beard. Well, that's why you're here,
- 45:08you know? Oh, well, he murders a dog.
- 45:10This is how we know. He does murder a dog.
- 45:14Not many, not many people do that on British television.
- 45:16Weird enough, I didn't really have too much of a problem with
- 45:19him destroying half a universe and Ligopolis, but killing this
- 45:22dog is just a step too far. And where do you stand on his
- 45:26slightly suggestive choice of weapon?
- 45:29Why would you ask me that question?
- 45:33I'll have you know I have 5 tissue compressor.
- 45:36Eliminators in the drawer. OK, different sizes.
- 45:40That's right, no. Many of them have 3 settings.
- 45:43I don't think they ever marketed them if I'm honest, although I
- 45:46wouldn't mind the Doctor's gadget there.
- 45:48The Doctor's gadget is very cool.
- 45:49No, I like that a lot. Apparently he created himself,
- 45:52didn't it? Because he gets across, he goes,
- 45:54yeah. Oh, after all the effort it went
- 45:55into making that he goes once they throw it down the pit.
- 45:58Oh, the Doctor did not Colin Baker.
- 46:01Oh well, no, I assume it was the doctor.
- 46:02Or not. No, Colin Baker has quite a few
- 46:04gadgets in his time, doesn't he? Yeah, well, So what he's got in
- 46:07Attack of the Side me. He shoves in the side man's
- 46:09chest. His Sonic Lance.
- 46:12Oh, because he's not allowed a Sonic screwdriver.
- 46:14Because that's. What's paying attention?
- 46:16What? Oh, this is the scene Fraser
- 46:19really hates. I you come to a lot of our jobs
- 46:22do. You think?
- 46:26I mean, did did Fraser grow up in a kind of mining community?
- 46:31And this is just bringing back some raw memories of those
- 46:34Luddite riots. You know, there's many pictures
- 46:38I've seen from when he was younger looking a bit sooty,
- 46:40yeah. Yeah.
- 46:41Yeah, and he loves Hovis Bridge. You know, he's always running up
- 46:44hills. Fraser, please come back.
- 46:48We do love you. No.
- 46:50He stopped. He stopped listening.
- 46:51It's fine. We can say what you like.
- 46:53He's just trying to save his old skin.
- 46:56Skin. I don't think those are
- 46:58authentic accents, James. I think they're pretty good.
- 47:03But again, this is where this Fraser is an expert and I'm just
- 47:06like, I think they, it sounds pretty.
- 47:09You have to remember that in the mid 80s we didn't, we didn't
- 47:12have regional accents on television at all.
- 47:15I remember when Johnny Briggs started on, on children's
- 47:17television. Do you remember that?
- 47:19No. Johnny Briggs was a the tale of
- 47:21a Northern lad. Worth it for the theme tune,
- 47:25which is a trump. It starts with a trombone going
- 47:29as Johnny Briggs slides down a slide.
- 47:32This northern sounding truck is, of course, brass instruments.
- 47:36Are very northern. And, and the first shot of this
- 47:41kid was him walking through kind of a scuzzy back alleyway into
- 47:45his house and his mum was shouting and they were all
- 47:48speaking in this incomprehensible dialect.
- 47:50Those were the first Northerners I ever saw.
- 47:52I'm surprised I won't pick it in the BBC.
- 47:54You know where that was going out, all these middle class
- 47:56mothers. I put they probably did they
- 47:59they do you remember how upset they were when Karen Keaton got
- 48:01a role on Blue Peter? Oh really?
- 48:03Well, when poor Jackie Lay got a role on Doctor Who.
- 48:07Well, they sorted, yeah, they sorted that out pretty quickly,
- 48:10didn't they? Did you just hear how the Master
- 48:13described the Doctor? This is just the start of 10 for
- 48:16the insult that I'm going to get a throw.
- 48:17And he goes, you can't miss this.
- 48:19You can't miss him. He's mean looking.
- 48:21He wears a vocally colored coat and ridiculous trousers, you
- 48:25know. So there's a, there's a variant
- 48:29on the same falling down a hole effect they use in Kezer and
- 48:33Razani and it's just not quite good enough.
- 48:36And it's a video effects on a on a film in this in this case.
- 48:39Did you know that Colin Baker had an injury from being on this
- 48:44chain? Dislocated a knuckle or
- 48:46something? At last.
- 48:47It's still got it to this date. An effect of that, yeah.
- 48:52It's pretty silent. I I.
- 48:54I just feel. Like they could have done the
- 48:56falling down the pit with a sound effect rather than trying
- 48:58to shut. It's too ambitious.
- 48:59It doesn't quite come off. And because he's genuinely
- 49:02holding on to that chain, that means the people that are
- 49:05attacking the chain are just sort of tapping it really gently
- 49:09whilst trying to make it look like they're being aggressive
- 49:11and comparing sort of gently throwing bits of coal at them.
- 49:15Yeah, it's not as dynamic as perhaps it could be.
- 49:20Oh, now this fella. So who is this?
- 49:23This is is this Gord Grainger or is that?
- 49:25No, I think this is Peter Childs.
- 49:29No, no, no. No, that's he's Jack Ward.
- 49:32Hang on. Lord Raisinsworth, this is Lord
- 49:35Ravensworth. Are you on wiki?
- 49:37Terence Alexander No, I just remembered that.
- 49:40Yeah, I'm on wiki. Apparently, and this is what
- 49:46Colin says in the commentary, he goes he was never out of work.
- 49:50And the reason he was never out of work is because he never took
- 49:53the lead in anything. He was always sort of like the
- 49:57secondary character, but he got jobs everywhere for being in
- 50:01that role. He's got that face as well.
- 50:03I mean, he's, I bet he grew his own side.
- 50:05I'm not sure whether he grew his own sideburns for this.
- 50:08Really, James? Do I look like a man who would
- 50:10wreck machines? It's this way the master's
- 50:13facial hair is wrong is there was so much other facial hair,
- 50:16they had a limited budget and the master's beard couldn't join
- 50:18up to his massage. Bit last state of decay, isn't
- 50:20it? You know those beards?
- 50:21Yeah. Yeah, too, too many beards.
- 50:24Yeah, a poor makeup. Maggie couldn't cope.
- 50:27I think, I mean, it's not surprising to hear that Terrence
- 50:30Alexander was constantly working because he's giving a really
- 50:33class performance here. It's a it's a fully rounded
- 50:36character and he's he doesn't actually have that much screen
- 50:40time, but and and he's having to kind of establish himself in in
- 50:44the way that characters did it. It's yeah.
- 50:46It's got a kind of Robin, Robert Holmes, Ian kind of feel feel to
- 50:49it in that he's given a few lines to establish a whole
- 50:52background and he doesn't read compellingly.
- 50:54But I think I think that's that is the work of somebody that has
- 50:59done a lot of work in these roles where you're playing a
- 51:02guest character and you're having to introduce yourself
- 51:05very quickly. Oh, that I don't like that line.
- 51:08Was it The violence has been horrendous.
- 51:10And then Perry goes murderous would be more apt.
- 51:16Oh, bless. But he seems like a just a
- 51:18decent fellow, doesn't he? And I like we get this in a few
- 51:22lines, but always have an excellent relationship with the
- 51:24men. You, you, you get that he's a
- 51:26good employer. And I.
- 51:30Bring the most women in here, will you?
- 51:32What actually, I love that scene in a minute where you get to see
- 51:35the impacts on the wives of the people, that the kids.
- 51:38That's another thing that 80s two doesn't do a lot.
- 51:41I really like as well just the very clear plotting in this
- 51:45episode, how the mystery comes together, how the doctor figures
- 51:49out that it's happening in the bath house, you know, because of
- 51:52the violence which leads him here.
- 51:54Then he talks to the people, they went to the bath house, he
- 51:57goes there. It all just flows beautifully.
- 52:02You get the sense that they never saw any of the characters
- 52:06as cannon fodder either. And they want to portray this is
- 52:12a genuine community where things are going to have ramifications.
- 52:15So the fact that you see the wives, the the fact that the
- 52:18there is a father son relationship in here.
- 52:21Luke, Luke Ward is the son of someone who's gone berserk.
- 52:25You get the sense that he's coming in from a, from a
- 52:27situation where he's already in a, you know, a difficult place
- 52:31emotionally, but you also. Get that warmth from Stephenson
- 52:35and Lord Ravensworth. Yes, he's his ward and his
- 52:37mentor respectively. Just lots of nice relationship.
- 52:42Oh, here we've got. Another effect shot here that
- 52:43doesn't quite work. I know, but I just adore this
- 52:46scene so much. I love that they tried it.
- 52:50I love that she no, I love that she sorry, ever so slightly
- 52:57different now. That's right.
- 52:59Oh look, he's trying to be charming as well.
- 53:01Anything connected to you, my dear Ronnie, would be
- 53:04fascinating. I like, I like that underneath
- 53:06her mask, she's very heavily made-up as well.
- 53:08Like she gets, she gets up in the morning, she puts on all of
- 53:12that makeup and then she puts on the Chrome mask I'm going to
- 53:16discard. Myself.
- 53:17How dare you? I'm going to discard myself, but
- 53:20I must know I have cheekbones underneath it.
- 53:23James Kate Amora has had those that blusher tattooed on her
- 53:26cheeks. All right?
- 53:27She never looked ugly once in her life.
- 53:32She goes, I said, you're pathetic.
- 53:33Clear off and let me get on with my work.
- 53:36I mean, she's just glorious. I mean, I'm not sure what I
- 53:41think about the subplot about Myers and Mia Goria and the
- 53:44brain fluids, but I do like the fact that she's been setting up
- 53:46shop in all of these violent periods of Earth's history to
- 53:50get the drug. We're in one scene on it and I
- 53:57love how compassionate the doctor is towards him as well.
- 54:01He seems generally concerned and the baby's a nice touch, isn't
- 54:04it? Yeah, you're right, but we don't
- 54:07get to see Colin being that compassionate in 2223 quite a
- 54:11lot. But in 22, look at the look he
- 54:14gives them. Excuse me, why has the Ronnie
- 54:20put Josh in that very short sleeved tunic?
- 54:24This is this is another of the Pip and Jane things where I
- 54:27think they thought wouldn't it be cool if she fed the maggots
- 54:32that were a slightly blue colour?
- 54:34Like why, Why maggots? Why?
- 54:36Why is that your way of delivering the your mind
- 54:39control? Because it's gross and the kids
- 54:41would go. Yeah.
- 54:45And that is, that's the entire reasoning.
- 54:47And that's where I think they are.
- 54:49Sometimes they just they write stuff because they think it's
- 54:53going to look good on screen and it doesn't quite make sense when
- 54:58you think about it. Are you referring to rubber
- 55:01trees as well? I'm I'm referring exactly to
- 55:03rubber trees in a way. I mean, all of the Ronnie's
- 55:07traps are stupid, but but her bubble traps that we see, oh
- 55:12boy, you know, in a couple of seasons time at least they move
- 55:15really fast and they look really cool.
- 55:16So you don't have time to question what why?
- 55:19Why not just explode them? What do you think about how she
- 55:22utilized the entire set of EastEnders as one massive trap
- 55:26for the Doctor? Oh, that's well, I think that's
- 55:29terribly well done, actually. Pickled in time, you might say.
- 55:32In time like like Ann Widdecombe sporting a Patrick Troughton
- 55:38costume. They're like Holmes and Watson
- 55:40here. Look at them, sort of.
- 55:41They're figuring about it, but they're figuring things out as
- 55:44well. Yeah.
- 55:47And I love the way they've worked it out, though.
- 55:48Yeah, we've got our history, we've got the Luddites, we've
- 55:51got a, a plausible backdrop, but it's, it's not the Luddites.
- 55:55They're it's more than that. And I ask because I don't, you
- 55:59know, I'm not really an expert in history.
- 56:01Did this meeting take place of all of these great minds?
- 56:03Between Between, between the Ronnie and the Master.
- 56:06You know what I mean? It doesn't sound like a real
- 56:10thing. No, I'm sure it I'm sure it
- 56:12didn't. MY1 complaint about the plot is
- 56:16I feel as if the first episode is teasing us that we're going
- 56:20to see that meeting in episode 2, and the Doctor's sort of
- 56:24going to have to come in and save that meeting from taking
- 56:26place. But actually what happens is
- 56:28sort of halfway for Episode 2, that's just abandoned, and we go
- 56:32far around in the woods with rubber trees.
- 56:35I think, yeah, I, I, I know that's interesting because it
- 56:39never occurred to me to expect to see the, the, the, the
- 56:43celebrity historical figures. But you're absolutely right.
- 56:46The second-half takes a a left turn and doesn't quite feel like
- 56:50it's telling the same story that's been set up here.
- 56:53I think that's I think that's true.
- 56:55If you want to see all the celebrities you can, you can
- 56:57always Fast forward to time in the Ronnie where you get to see
- 56:59them all in the TARDIS. Oh, it's I have Einstein.
- 57:03That's for Marcy. It's just glorious, isn't it?
- 57:05Do. You think that's, do you think
- 57:06that's the celebrities that they, they've all been invited
- 57:11to Luddite England from Ozzy and Albert Einstein.
- 57:17Lord Ravensworth is very well connected.
- 57:21Can I Can I get Einstein? I would pay to add that scene on
- 57:25the next DVD version of this. Yeah.
- 57:28Oh, do you know what I'd say that Turner's a bit too romantic
- 57:31for the Ronnie, wouldn't you? Think that looks like a Turner?
- 57:35No, but I think it's a very funny joke.
- 57:37Like I mean that trap is the most the.
- 57:41Stupidest of all, that's very, very stupid.
- 57:44But I love it all the same. And also if if it's there to
- 57:48disguise her TARDIS, she could have just built it another foot
- 57:52higher. I just like how she sort of
- 57:55thought about all these ingenious ways to kill people
- 57:57and then realized them in the most ridiculous way possible.
- 58:01I wish, I mean, it doesn't what the problem is she's establishes
- 58:05the rational one. Like I, I wish they'd lent into
- 58:07that a bit more and had the Master doing the ridiculous
- 58:09traps for the sake of it and the Rani being just ruthlessly
- 58:13logical and, and kind of drawing attention to how stupid the
- 58:17traps are. Because at the end of the day,
- 58:19the Rani is every bit as silly as the Master.
- 58:22Like I know. She does work with the Master in
- 58:24the second episode, yeah, but she's still just insulting him
- 58:27the whole time. Yeah, yeah, it's worth it for
- 58:30the dog. It's.
- 58:30A great double act and then you throw in the Doctor as well.
- 58:34I think what I'm saying is that she's not as great as she thinks
- 58:37she is. How dare you?
- 58:39Good grief. As a as a scientist, as a, as a
- 58:42villain, sure. Do you know what they repackage
- 58:46her for time on the right? I don't know.
- 58:48It's a very, she's very understated in this and well, I
- 58:51don't think you could say that about her performance in time of
- 58:54the role. Do you think?
- 58:54I mean, I think Anthony Amy has dialed it down a fair bit as
- 58:58well to kind of match her slightly understated villainy.
- 59:02He knows that he's the moustache twirling 1.
- 59:07He's not in a different universe to her in terms of performance,
- 59:10which he hasn't always been the case with him.
- 59:11Really slay on his master, right.
- 59:14But I think when they do, when they don't have him as the
- 59:16villain of peace. Yeah.
- 59:18So 5 Doctors where he's in that wonderful position of having to
- 59:21go and rescue the doctor. Hilarious and very entertaining.
- 59:25This where he's basically the Ronnies companion, glorious to
- 59:29watch and especially part 13 of Trial of a Time Lord where he
- 59:34turns up on the screen and goes, I've been watching this
- 59:36ridiculous affair for the last 12 weeks and I've been enjoying
- 59:40myself immensely and it's wonderful.
- 59:43It is interesting. Then when he does come back to
- 59:45being the villain in the Sylvester McCoy, yes, that's the
- 59:48best that he gives he's ever been.
- 59:52But the writing is better if you think about his worst
- 59:54performances, like what's he supposed to do in time flight?
- 59:58What's he supposed to? Do Shiraz.
- 1:00:00That's about it. He's been written as a
- 1:00:03completely 2 dimensional villain that I think Ailey is a is a
- 1:00:06really underrated actor. Actually.
- 1:00:09I don't, I'm not saying I think he's a kind of a first rate
- 1:00:14actor, but I think you see his potential in Lagopolis.
- 1:00:17I I think you do see a kind of slightly understated, genuinely
- 1:00:21kind of sinister. Go watch me keep her a truckon.
- 1:00:25Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, of course he's playing.
- 1:00:27That he's a fully rounded character keeper, a truckon, and
- 1:00:30then go and watch him when he's not being asked to dial it up in
- 1:00:33the survival. Yeah, but if you give him a
- 1:00:36stupid costume and a, you know, a silly accent to do what's what
- 1:00:40is he supposed to do with that? They've so obviously Amy
- 1:00:44complained that they would always say to him, you know,
- 1:00:46Gary Downey will be there going, you know, bring it up, bring it
- 1:00:48up. You know, the funniest thing is
- 1:00:50when you see the outtakes of Dimension in Time where Gary
- 1:00:53Downey steps up to Kate Omara and goes a little less camp and
- 1:00:57she looks straight to the camera and she goes camp.
- 1:01:00She goes, what show am I working on?
- 1:01:03She knows exactly what she's doing.
- 1:01:06James, Optical illusion created on a screen.
- 1:01:13You don't know what I'm talking about.
- 1:01:14Now do. You did what?
- 1:01:15Do they use a MB modem? I think the idea is, is that she
- 1:01:20can see through the eyes of her. I know, I know.
- 1:01:28I can't believe I just explained that to you and you're a Doctor
- 1:01:31Who fan. I love I love the bit in the
- 1:01:35trial of the Time Lord behind the scenes features where
- 1:01:39they're where they're saying we actually spoke to a computer
- 1:01:41friend of ours. He was really and when she says
- 1:01:44a MB modem, that was a real thing.
- 1:01:46Yes, yes. You still didn't understand what
- 1:01:50it was though, did you? No, bless them.
- 1:01:53Still doesn't make any sense. You mean a mazer, don't you?
- 1:01:56Microscopic application and stimulation of radiation.
- 1:02:00I did learn something. Say, mind you, you know what God
- 1:02:04he does say He loves Kip Pippenjane Dialogue.
- 1:02:07Because like, the kids might get so excited that they go and grab
- 1:02:10their dictionaries or thesaurus to figure out what on earth does
- 1:02:13that word mean. I did do that quite a bit when I
- 1:02:16watched these when I was younger because I like, I love learning
- 1:02:19words. Yeah, I, I, I absolutely agree
- 1:02:24with their mission statement, which is, you know, these words
- 1:02:28exist, why should we not use them?
- 1:02:31I think they use them slightly indiscriminately.
- 1:02:33And that's where it it's odd when it's out of Perry's mouth,
- 1:02:38Yes, feels like it should have been a character's choice.
- 1:02:40It feels like it should have been the Rani, but in particular
- 1:02:43or the, you know, the Doctor, of course.
- 1:02:45Well, so obviously they, they sort of do blast style.
- 1:02:48I don't know. So you've got the miners talking
- 1:02:50in that you know, Douglas will be along when they've emptied
- 1:02:52derbies. And then you've got Lord
- 1:02:54Raisinsworth who uses very eloquent sentences.
- 1:02:57And then the next level is the time laws.
- 1:03:00You know the top of the Gentry pile and their language is
- 1:03:03operatic. The master's drawn a pretty
- 1:03:07decent picture there. He went to the same art school
- 1:03:10as Tegan. Oh no, she's a little bit
- 1:03:12better. She was paying attention.
- 1:03:15He goes. I don't see any point in burying
- 1:03:17a box. I better bury him.
- 1:03:23I mean, he's being quite devious, isn't he?
- 1:03:25Yeah, I suppose. But he's it's all very, it's all
- 1:03:28very hushed tones. And because these guys are
- 1:03:31bringing in the, you know, the big acting.
- 1:03:35What do you think about his sort of blackmail of the Ronnie there
- 1:03:38with just that little vial of fluid?
- 1:03:40Can ask plausible? I, I think so if, I mean if
- 1:03:43that's all she's managed to get and it's implied that she's been
- 1:03:46to a lot of places and worked through quite a lot of people.
- 1:03:49Just to get that tiny amount just to.
- 1:03:50Get that tiny amount. Yeah, I wonder if you just think
- 1:03:52a little pipette's worth to make the aliens go to sleep.
- 1:03:55No, and maybe she should not have kept it on display and
- 1:03:58should have kept in a TARDIS for safekeeping.
- 1:04:00But I can't believe he said to her.
- 1:04:02You don't get much, do you? I'm honestly mind you these
- 1:04:07bitchy comments. Now it goes.
- 1:04:09Brain regeneration is what I need.
- 1:04:11Yeah, your regeneration is not too attractive either.
- 1:04:14That's. Lovely, though improved with
- 1:04:15each other, because it then turns the Master and the Ronnie
- 1:04:18and the Doctor into this kind of it's this lovely series of
- 1:04:22status relationships and they're all trying to get one up on each
- 1:04:25other. She's ready for dynasty after
- 1:04:29this story I'm telling you. Or was it dynasty or Dallas?
- 1:04:31I think it was dynasty. Dynasty, yeah.
- 1:04:34Not that I say that with. I say that with confidence.
- 1:04:36I've never seen Dynasty. I bet she had amazing hair in it
- 1:04:39though. I mean, they all did, I bet.
- 1:04:40She did. I bet she did.
- 1:04:42There are one of my favorite lines is in this.
- 1:04:45Pip and Jane are trying to bring a moralistic angle to the story.
- 1:04:49So, you know, do you think they worry about the lesser species
- 1:04:52when they sink their teeth into a lamb chop?
- 1:04:55What a lion. This is not a particularly
- 1:05:02flattering shot of Colin and this happens quite a lot to
- 1:05:05Colin. He's and ends up on his back and
- 1:05:07because of the shape of TV cameras, they can't get in
- 1:05:10overhead. So he he ends up very much kind
- 1:05:14of doing chin acting, which it's not his fault and it's not, I
- 1:05:20sort of feel like it doesn't display his doctor particularly
- 1:05:23flatteringly. I've I've got a theory about
- 1:05:27Colin and it's going to sound rude, but I'm going to say it
- 1:05:31because you see the publicity pictures of him and Nicola when
- 1:05:35they were first announced and he's in a beautiful suit and.
- 1:05:39She's in a gorgeous dress, gorgeous dress and they.
- 1:05:41Literally look like, I don't know, the next James Bond and a
- 1:05:44Bond girl. They look stunningly beautiful
- 1:05:46together. And we know tragically Colin
- 1:05:51lost a child not long after he took on the role of the doctor.
- 1:05:57And that does coincide with him putting on a lot of weight.
- 1:06:01And certainly between 22 and 23, I think you can see that, you
- 1:06:05know, he has put on a lot of weight.
- 1:06:06And I just, I wonder if that is just a consequence, you know,
- 1:06:10stressing whatever you want to call it.
- 1:06:14Possibly but but. They didn't ever like look at
- 1:06:17those pictures. That is exactly.
- 1:06:19What he could have been like, I don't I I also don't think that
- 1:06:24Colin Baker is is ever an unattractive man in Doctor Who,
- 1:06:28but I think, I think that, you know, what they required of him
- 1:06:32hair wise wasn't always in his favour.
- 1:06:36He says in the trial of a town like commentary, he goes, why
- 1:06:39did he says to Chris Clough in terror of the verb voice.
- 1:06:41Why didn't you get them to cut my hair?
- 1:06:44Look at me. I look ridiculous.
- 1:06:45Yeah. And he he kind of does.
- 1:06:50But have you ever read a original Terence Dix novel
- 1:06:56Description of Colin Baker's Doctor?
- 1:07:00No. No, you have because I've read
- 1:07:02your review of the 8 doctors so. You.
- 1:07:04Oh yes, of course. Yes, of.
- 1:07:06I have indeed. Full page just to the
- 1:07:10descriptions of I think he's a bit in love with the 6th Dr.
- 1:07:13Terror 6. But he gives him most of the
- 1:07:15plot as well. He.
- 1:07:15Goes it's a full face with beautiful, luscious lips,
- 1:07:21staggeringly beautiful curls. I'm not this, I'm not
- 1:07:24exaggerating. It literally does this.
- 1:07:27And Paul McCoy gets half a page in the entire book, you know?
- 1:07:32You know, it's right now it does stick out.
- 1:07:34The 6th Doctor is the main character in that.
- 1:07:36Yeah. Which, given that it's an Eighth
- 1:07:38Doctor novel, is a bit of a shame for Paul Mcgahn, isn't it?
- 1:07:41But this is the sort of doctor that terrorists like, right?
- 1:07:44You know. Oh yeah, definitely.
- 1:07:46There's a lot and there's a lot of the 3rd Doctor in the 6th
- 1:07:50Doctor, isn't there? There he is no you some of that
- 1:07:55famous. And so should the Ronnie was in
- 1:07:58the Trojan Wars. Do you think she was there kind
- 1:08:01of? Do you think those characters in
- 1:08:02the Myth makers were being kind of taken off and given the mark
- 1:08:08of the Rani? I think you didn't know this,
- 1:08:10but the Rani was in fact Cassandra and the myth makers in
- 1:08:14disguise. You know in a bit what?
- 1:08:16She said there we go. How dare.
- 1:08:18You. You know the reckon that we need
- 1:08:21that we need a fan novel to explain.
- 1:08:25You know how she sort of dragged off at the end, Cassandra, They
- 1:08:29went round the corner, she beat up all those guards and then ran
- 1:08:32to her tires and. Scarpered with a couple of them
- 1:08:35taking their liquids. Did she say the American War of
- 1:08:38Independence? She did say the American War of
- 1:08:40Independence. We can probably, we can probably
- 1:08:42get her into the war games as well if we're very kind with our
- 1:08:46with our fan novel. Yeah, if we could sort of have
- 1:08:49her in a scene with the war chief as well, because I think
- 1:08:51that would. Be a great relationship.
- 1:08:52A lovely, lovely exchange. I mean, it's basically we're
- 1:08:55just doing what Big Finish do now.
- 1:08:56Right. Pretty much, yes.
- 1:08:58Ronnie, Ronnie Box set. Ronnie War.
- 1:09:01This is the most overwritten scene in the whole thing.
- 1:09:04I love it. Hardly the prime characteristic.
- 1:09:11Oh, he's remembered Planet of Fire though, isn't he?
- 1:09:13Oh yes. I've got a score to settle.
- 1:09:15With he's remembered it better than I have to be honest.
- 1:09:18Yeah, so. We're about to get an extended
- 1:09:22music cue and that, and maybe it's a good time to come back to
- 1:09:25Jonathan Gibbs because of course we're listening to the second
- 1:09:29score written for episode 1 of The Mark of the Rani.
- 1:09:33I beg your pardon? It's one of two Doctor Who
- 1:09:36stories that you can hear with an alternate score now, unlike
- 1:09:42Paradise Towers, where a score was completely finished and then
- 1:09:45rejected. The composer of Mark Ronnie was
- 1:09:49originally a composer called John Lewis.
- 1:09:52Not that one. And John Lewis completed all of
- 1:09:58episode 1 and a little bit of episode 2 and then died
- 1:10:02tragically. And you can hear on the on the
- 1:10:08actually the DVD and the Blu-ray release, you can hear episode
- 1:10:11one with a different score. You can also hit a bit of
- 1:10:14episode 2 with with the old score.
- 1:10:19And John Lewis's family were apparently paid in full for the
- 1:10:21for the school, but then Jonathan Gibbs was employed to
- 1:10:25to start from scratch. And I don't.
- 1:10:27I do wonder if we are slightly again with John Lewis's score,
- 1:10:33listening to a rejected score, because there is precedent for
- 1:10:35Doctor Who to have more than one composer on a story.
- 1:10:38Megalos begins with a score by Not Peter Howell.
- 1:10:46Oh, who is it? Patti, Kingsland.
- 1:10:48Paddy Kingsland writes episode 1 of Meg Loss.
- 1:10:51That's right. And then Peter Howell takes over
- 1:10:53in a completely different style. He used a few.
- 1:10:55She prefer Paddy Kingston. Paddy Kingston writes a
- 1:10:59beautiful episode 1 and Peter Howell takes just a couple of
- 1:11:02sound effects but basically so you can do it.
- 1:11:06Why don't they use episode 1 of John Lewis's score?
- 1:11:09I suspect it was deemed to be not actually particularly good
- 1:11:13and whether it was because he was not well and didn't turn in
- 1:11:16a very good piece of work, whether it's because he'd never
- 1:11:18written for Doctor Who before, it's a much sparser experience.
- 1:11:23He doesn't write through in the way that Jonathan Gibbs does so
- 1:11:28beautifully. He mostly writes stings and
- 1:11:30atmosphere and so the whole thing feels quite disjointed and
- 1:11:33his scoring is is very sparse as well.
- 1:11:36It's, it's quite often monophonic, which would have
- 1:11:39worked in the 1970s. Well, would have been acceptable
- 1:11:43in the 1970s. I just, I don't think it is
- 1:11:45acceptable in the mid 80s. But what's interesting is how
- 1:11:50many similarities there are, not in terms of musical content, but
- 1:11:55just in ideas. So the opening is this pastoral
- 1:11:58English opening, Bitter Harp, which is, you know, a totally
- 1:12:06different piece of music from John Lewis, but has those
- 1:12:08qualities or the bit that's about to come up which has got
- 1:12:10the kind of rhythm of a railway track, this kind of.
- 1:12:14Yeah, that. And it suggests to me that Sarah
- 1:12:21Hellings was maybe quite hands on in what she wanted from her
- 1:12:25composers and had. Graham Harper was, wasn't it?
- 1:12:28We know that, yeah. Absolutely.
- 1:12:30It's just a theory. I mean, it may be that Jonathan
- 1:12:32Gibbs didn't have very long to write it and and listen to what
- 1:12:34had been done, but I think that would be a an unusual thing for
- 1:12:37a composer to do. It is the whole fact I was
- 1:12:39completely unaware of. I do want to go and listen to
- 1:12:41that whole time. It's.
- 1:12:42Well worth watching. It's it is if you watch on the
- 1:12:45Blu-ray, you can watch the the few cues in episode 2 that John
- 1:12:50Lewis wrote. And it is a relief when the
- 1:12:51Jonathan Gibbs kind of takes over and you sort of feel like
- 1:12:54you're, you're experiencing something much, much fuller and,
- 1:12:58and, and it and, and you're in more experienced hands.
- 1:13:00But but it's a real curio. Going back to the imagery for a
- 1:13:03second one, I just love, you know, when they're at the top of
- 1:13:06the hill and all, and it's like that sunlight on a, on a
- 1:13:09summer's afternoon sort of dappling over them.
- 1:13:11It just looks gorgeous. The TARDIS going down the pit is
- 1:13:15a terrific effect. It's a great effect, isn't it?
- 1:13:18And then this stunt, I mean, this is absurd, but it's a
- 1:13:21great. Stunt.
- 1:13:22Yeah. And that is Collin strapped to
- 1:13:24the top, being steered by someone.
- 1:13:26I mean, I feel like Colin was being quite brave doing his own
- 1:13:31stunts here, but the guy who's actually inside the machine
- 1:13:34steering it, That's, that's insane, isn't it?
- 1:13:37I've got a feeling Eric Sword may have written this bit, you
- 1:13:40know? Yeah, strap Colin down.
- 1:13:42Yeah, you can just tell that they've got about 3 meters of
- 1:13:45track here and they have to keep reusing the same corner.
- 1:13:49But I love a whip pan. Zoom and a straight on whip pan.
- 1:13:52We get a whip pan and a crash soon and and for once, nothing
- 1:13:55to Colin's face. It's a great cliffhanger.
- 1:13:58I I think that's the right call to end it on, you know, bit.
- 1:14:04And sort of, I mean, you can't really say how's it work as an
- 1:14:07establishing episode because it's half the story, because
- 1:14:09we're doing a different source of Doctor Who this year.
- 1:14:11But it has set its store well. It's introduced all of his
- 1:14:14characters. It's painted the setting
- 1:14:17beautifully. It's established what sort of a
- 1:14:19threat is. I think it's got everything
- 1:14:22going for it. I'll, I'll, I will, I'll say it
- 1:14:28now. I think Part 2 doesn't deliver
- 1:14:30in the way that you expected to from that part.
- 1:14:33I think it's a really excellent episode 1.
- 1:14:36What I will say about. Top two Doctor Who.
- 1:14:38Yeah. What I will say about two is,
- 1:14:40yeah, I agree. I think it is a bit of a dance
- 1:14:43grip of a climax, but it still has those characters in it.
- 1:14:49It still has that fruity dialogue.
- 1:14:51Sarah Hellings is still helming this thing.
- 1:14:53The music so like as a production it seemed to scene.
- 1:14:57It's still great fun to watch. Yeah, and it's, and it feels
- 1:15:00disciplined as well in a way that, you know, they splashed a
- 1:15:03lot of money on the the two doctors, which is, which has the
- 1:15:09look of kind of complete grandfather that has the look of
- 1:15:11they went on holiday and made some Doctor Who while they were
- 1:15:14there. You know, it's it's by far the
- 1:15:16more expensive story, but this is the one that looks like
- 1:15:20proper TV drama. Well James, do you fancy heading
- 1:15:24on into episode 2 and watching some more proper TV drama?
- 1:15:27I do indeed. Let's do it.