Latest / Boring Science / Boring Science for Sleep _ Why Do Stars Twinkle_
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Welcome to Boring Science for Sleep. This is your safe,
- 0:04sleepy corner of the universe, where science doesn't rush and
- 0:08curiosity gently floats between yawns. Whether you're listening in a
- 0:12quiet bedroom, a night bus seat, or curled up in
- 0:15a cozy corner somewhere far from noise, you're in the
- 0:19right place. And if you're still with me, what time
- 0:23is it where you are? Is it late evening in Oslo?
- 0:27A sleepless 3am in Boston? or a peaceful midnight in London?
- 0:32I'd love to hear. Drop your location and local time
- 0:36in the comments if you're still awake. It's always comforting
- 0:40to see just how far these quiet thoughts travel. And
- 0:44if this brought you even a single breath of calm,
- 0:47don't forget to like the video and subscribe to Boring
- 0:50Science for Sleep for more whisper-soft stories of the universe. Tonight,
- 0:55let's lie back and look up. There, in that quiet
- 0:59stretch of darkness above us, tiny points of light blink gently.
- 1:04They shimmer, they flutter, they flicker, as if whispering secrets
- 1:08too old to be told all at once. We call
- 1:11them stars. But have you ever wondered, why do they twinkle?
- 1:16It's a question so simple, so childlike, that we almost
- 1:20forget it's a mystery of the universe. And tonight, we'll
- 1:24explore that mystery together. Now, Let's settle in. Let the
- 1:29world fade. And start our slow journey into the sky.
- 1:34You step outside. Maybe it's just after brushing your teeth.
- 1:38Maybe it's a habit now, this little pause before bed.
- 1:42Maybe the air is cool tonight. Or maybe it's warm
- 1:45and still, holding the hush of late evening in its palms.
- 1:49Above you, the world has changed. The noise of the day,
- 1:53the tapping keys, the traffic horns, the hurried conversations, They
- 1:58all belong to a different realm now. Out here, everything hushes.
- 2:03And as your eyes adjust, there they are. The stars. Tiny,
- 2:08scattered lights, stitched across a dark cloth you cannot touch.
- 2:12Some brighter than others. Some holding still. And some twinkling.
- 2:19You know the kind I mean. That quick flicker. The
- 2:22shimmer like a faraway candle flame, just about to be
- 2:25blown out, then holding strong, dancing again. If you stare
- 2:30at them long enough, you might notice that not all
- 2:32of them do it. Some stars stay sharp and steady.
- 2:36Some pulse gently. Some blink so quickly you wonder if
- 2:40you imagined it. But somewhere in your mind, perhaps left
- 2:44over from childhood, you remember the rhyme. Twinkle, twinkle, little star.
- 2:50And so, it must be true, right? Stars twinkle. But Why?
- 2:57It's a question that doesn't feel urgent, not the kind
- 3:00of question that needs to be shouted into a lecture
- 3:03hall or scribbled across a blackboard in chalk. It's soft, patient,
- 3:09the kind of question that waits quietly in your mind
- 3:11for years, maybe decades, before you finally look up one
- 3:15quiet night and say, why do stars twinkle? Tonight, we're
- 3:20not chasing answers the way science sometimes does. with force
- 3:24or equations or urgency. We're not here to conquer mystery.
- 3:29We're here to rest within it, to float alongside the question.
- 3:33Because sometimes, understanding the universe doesn't mean decoding it. Sometimes
- 3:39it means learning to drift within it, like a feather
- 3:42in orbit. And so, as your head nestles into your pillow,
- 3:47as your breathing softens, let us look skyward, not to
- 3:50find something, but to follow something, to follow a single
- 3:54beam of light, to track it, softly, gently, from the
- 3:59surface of a star, through unimaginable space, across the trembling
- 4:04skin of our planet's atmosphere, and finally, into your eyes.
- 4:10That's the journey. That's the twinkle. And like any good
- 4:13bedtime story, it starts with stillness. The stillness of space.
- 4:19Imagine that first. A place with no wind, no sound,
- 4:24No air. The light of a star, any star, the
- 4:27one you choose, begins its journey. Perhaps from four light-years away,
- 4:32perhaps four hundred, and from the moment it's born, burning
- 4:36from hydrogen and heat, it races toward us. Not rushing
- 4:40with panic, but moving at the only speed it knows,
- 4:44the speed of light. Straight, steady, constant. No twinkling yet.
- 4:50Just light, pure and unwavering. Travelling through darkness like a promise.
- 4:56Through time. Through silence. Through everything. And then, just before
- 5:01it reaches us, it meets Earth. It meets the atmosphere.
- 5:06And that is where everything changes. But before we get there,
- 5:12before we dip below the edge of the sky, pause again.
- 5:15Breathe again. Think of how strange it is, how quiet
- 5:19and odd and beautiful that something so distant can end
- 5:23its journey in something as soft as your gaze. Think
- 5:26of how many millions of years that light has waited
- 5:30for this moment to reach your eyes tonight. So yes,
- 5:35stars twinkle. But not in space. Not in silence. Only here.
- 5:42Only now. Only in this thin layer of trembling air
- 5:46we call home. And over the next little while, as
- 5:49you begin to float into sleep, We'll follow that beam
- 5:52of light together, like stardust tracing its path home. Because
- 5:56behind every twinkle is a story. And tonight, we'll listen
- 6:02for it. The sky lies to us sometimes, but only
- 6:06in the gentlest way. You look up and see a
- 6:08star blink, shimmer, flicker like a spark that's almost lost.
- 6:13But it's not the star that's blinking. It's your experience
- 6:17of it. And that... is something far more personal than
- 6:21we often admit. You see, the eye is not a
- 6:25perfect camera. It doesn't record like a machine. It interprets.
- 6:30It guesses. It fills in blanks. And in the case
- 6:34of starlight, that guesswork becomes part of the magic. Tonight,
- 6:40let's soften our gaze, not only upward, but inward, into
- 6:45the quiet machine of the eye. Because when it comes
- 6:48to twinkling, What we think we see matters just as
- 6:51much as what's really there. Close your eyes for a moment. Yes,
- 6:56even now. Just let your lids drop gently over your gaze. There,
- 7:02in the dark behind your eyelids, are echoes. Shapes. Patterns.
- 7:07Faint pulses of memory. That's your brain, still looking, even
- 7:12when it has nothing to see. Because the truth is,
- 7:16we don't see with our eyes. We see with our minds.
- 7:20Our eyes are portals, yes. But the image, the vision,
- 7:24is stitched together somewhere deeper. So now, let's open them again, softly.
- 7:30And imagine this. You're staring at a single star. Let's
- 7:35say it's Vega, bright and blue-white, hanging high in the
- 7:38summer sky. You stare at it long enough, and it flickers.
- 7:43Just slightly. A twitch. A blink. A momentary sparkle. And
- 7:48your brain begins its work. It says, ah, something changed.
- 7:54Let's track that. It pulls in more detail, adjusts focus,
- 7:58enhances contrast. But in that act of correction, it might
- 8:03also add illusion. Maybe the shimmer is more dramatic now.
- 8:08Maybe it shifts colours. Maybe you think, just for a moment,
- 8:12that the star is dancing. But the star isn't dancing.
- 8:16It hasn't moved at all. It's been steady since the
- 8:20light left it, decades ago. What changed was you. Let's
- 8:25talk about the eye now. Not just the metaphorical one,
- 8:28but the physical, anatomical marvel. Your eye is a living lens,
- 8:34filled with fluid, muscle and motion. Even when you try
- 8:38to stare at one spot, tiny tremors ripple through it. Microsaccades,
- 8:43they're called. Little jumps in your gaze that you can't control.
- 8:47These jumps help refresh your vision, but they also mean
- 8:51that your eye is never truly still. So now, imagine this.
- 8:57A single, narrow beam of light, thousands of years old,
- 9:01is weaving through Earth's atmosphere. It bends slightly with each
- 9:05layer of warm and cool air. By the time it
- 9:08reaches you, it's a slightly wiggling line. Your eye, with
- 9:13its fluid and tremor, receives this beam and hands it
- 9:17to the brain. The brain says, hmm, wiggling light. It compares.
- 9:23It adjusts. It interprets. And, sometimes, it embellishes. It makes
- 9:30a flicker from a flutter. It paints a sparkle from
- 9:33a tremble. It gives you a twinkle. Now, let's slow
- 9:38it down further. You lie on a blanket under the
- 9:42open sky. There are no lights around you, no screens,
- 9:47no phone in your hand, just darkness and stars. And
- 9:52with time, your pupils expand. Your rods take over from
- 9:56your cones. You see less color but more contrast you
- 10:01start to notice things the stars near the horizon seem
- 10:05to flicker more than the ones overhead why is that
- 10:09well it's not just your eye anymore it's the distance
- 10:13the starlight must travel through the atmosphere when a star
- 10:16is low on the horizon Its light passes through more air,
- 10:20more haze, more heat, more layers of turbulence. By the
- 10:25time it reaches you, it's a flickering memory of itself.
- 10:29The star didn't change. But your view of it did.
- 10:33And so we learn that twinkling is a partnership between
- 10:37the star, the air, and the observer. Between the universe
- 10:43and you. There's something deeply human about that, isn't there?
- 10:47That even a star, something impossibly far away, can only
- 10:51be seen through the lens of our own imperfections. Our
- 10:55eye trembles. Our brain fills gaps. Our heart adds meaning.
- 11:01And together, they create something not just visual, but emotional.
- 11:06That's what a twinkle really is. It's science filtered through wonder.
- 11:11Physics blurred softly by poetry. Truth seen through a breathing,
- 11:16blinking lens. So tonight, if you happen to look up again,
- 11:21if you notice one star dancing a little more than
- 11:23the others, don't rush to correct it. Let it flicker.
- 11:28Let it tell you a story, even if it's only
- 11:30half true. Because what we think we see is just
- 11:35as worthy of wonder. And in this quiet moment before sleep,
- 11:39that's more than enough. Let's follow the light. Just one
- 11:43particle of it. A photon. born in the heart of
- 11:47a distant star. It's tiny, it's weightless, it's ancient, and
- 11:53it's headed for you. It began deep inside a sphere
- 11:57of fire, perhaps hundreds of thousands of light-years away. That
- 12:02star may be three times the size of our sun,
- 12:05or maybe just a small red dwarf, blinking faintly in
- 12:08the edge of a forgotten galaxy. Inside it, nuclear fusion
- 12:13churns endlessly, Hydrogen atoms crush together under gravity so immense
- 12:19they lose their individuality. In their collision, energy is born.
- 12:24And in that energy, a photon emerges. Not with purpose,
- 12:29not with direction. Just with momentum, an invitation to travel.
- 12:35It's hard to say how long it takes that photon
- 12:37to reach the surface of the star. Inside, it ricochets
- 12:41between atoms, deflected, absorbed, re-emitted. Some photons take thousands of
- 12:47years just to escape the dense core. Others are blocked forever.
- 12:53But our photon, it's lucky. After countless bounces and redirections,
- 12:58it reaches the surface and is released into the vastness
- 13:02of space. From there, it begins its true journey. Imagine that,
- 13:07a single pulse of light now hurtling across the cosmos.
- 13:11No pause, no rest. Just a constant glide at 299,792
- 13:19km per second. It does not age. It does not
- 13:23bend or slow. It simply moves forward. Through the cold,
- 13:29through the dark, through the emptiness between suns. It may
- 13:33pass other stars, never stopping. It may graze the edges
- 13:37of gas clouds, or drift through a silent field of
- 13:41comets frozen in time. Sometimes, For millions of years, nothing happens.
- 13:47Just motion. Just distance. Our photon is patient. Now, let's
- 13:53return to Earth. To your quiet room, your cosy bed,
- 13:58your soft breath. You lie still, but the universe is
- 14:02in motion around you. And our photon, our traveller, is
- 14:06finally nearing the finish line. As it approaches Earth, it
- 14:10enters the outer atmosphere. And here... things get tricky, because
- 14:15the calm void of space is no longer calm. Instead,
- 14:19it meets a living, swirling blanket of gas, our atmosphere.
- 14:24This is where temperature shifts, pressure waves, and rising heat
- 14:28play their invisible games. Like a river's surface that bends
- 14:32a straw, this air begins to tug and twist the
- 14:35path of light. And just like that, our photon begins
- 14:39to dance. It doesn't change its essence. It doesn't lose speed.
- 14:44But the direction wobbles, ever so slightly, and your eye
- 14:48catches that wobble. That's the twinkle. That's the entire journey,
- 14:54told in a flicker. But there's more to this story.
- 14:57Because some of the stars you see tonight, their light
- 15:01began travelling to you before humans even built the pyramids,
- 15:05before the wheel, before written language. When the light left
- 15:09its source, Earth looked nothing like it does now. Civilizations
- 15:15had not yet been dreamed. Oceans had not yet carved
- 15:18the coasts you know. And yet, the light has been moving, non-stop,
- 15:24ever since. That means, when you look at a star,
- 15:28you're not seeing it as it is now. You're seeing
- 15:31it as it was. Sometimes, a hundred years ago. Sometimes
- 15:36a thousand. Sometimes tens of thousands. In that way, the
- 15:42sky is a memory, a glowing archive, a reflection not
- 15:46of the present, but of the past. You don't just
- 15:50see light, you see time. And that makes the twinkle
- 15:54even more magical, doesn't it? Because it's not a random shimmer.
- 15:58It's the final punctuation mark in a story that took
- 16:01millennia to write. The wobble, the flicker, the blink you
- 16:06notice tonight, that's the very end of a cosmic sentence.
- 16:11written in fusion, delivered by gravity, edited by space, and
- 16:17whispered into your eyes. And yet, most nights, we don't notice.
- 16:22We walk beneath it. We check our phones. We say,
- 16:27it's cloudy, and turn away. But when we do look up,
- 16:31when we allow our attention to stretch farther than the ceiling,
- 16:35something inside us stretches, too. We remember that we are
- 16:39not just earthbound. We are sky connected, even in silence,
- 16:45even in sleep. And so, if tonight your eyes feel heavy,
- 16:50if you're already drifting in and out of thought, let
- 16:54that photon finish its work. Let it land softly behind
- 16:57your eyes. Let it tell its story, even if you
- 17:01don't hear the words. You don't have to understand all
- 17:04the physics. You don't have to remember all the science.
- 17:08Just know, that when a star twinkles, you are witnessing
- 17:12the final moment of a journey light began long before
- 17:15you were born. And that, in itself, is a kind
- 17:19of lullaby. Let's go back to the moment just before
- 17:23the twinkle. Back to that final stretch of a star's light,
- 17:27when its path is almost complete. It's made it so far,
- 17:31through galaxies, through time, through the emptiness between suns. But now,
- 17:37just before it reaches your eye, it encounters something unexpectedly alive.
- 17:43Earth's atmosphere. To us, it feels invisible. We move through
- 17:48it without thinking. We breathe it, we live within it,
- 17:52and often forget it's there. But from the perspective of
- 17:55a photon, this thin shell around our planet is anything
- 18:00but still. It is in constant motion, rising, falling, expanding, mixing,
- 18:06And for a particle of light that's been travelling in
- 18:08a straight line for thousands of years, meeting our atmosphere
- 18:12is like diving into a river in full swirl. The
- 18:16light bends. Not by choice. Not on its own. But
- 18:21because of refraction, let's drift into that word, refraction. A
- 18:26gentle curve. A turning of the path. It happens when
- 18:31light changes speed as it passes through one medium into another.
- 18:35From space to air. From calm to chaos. The atmosphere
- 18:40isn't just air. It's layers of air, stacked like an
- 18:44ever-changing blanket. Imagine this. At the very top, the air
- 18:49is cold, thin and still. As you move lower, it
- 18:54becomes denser, warmer and more turbulent. Warm air rises. Cold
- 19:00air sinks. Winds stir. Pressure fluctuates. And all of it
- 19:06bends light. But not in one consistent direction. No, that
- 19:11would be too simple. Instead, the path of the photon wiggles.
- 19:16Like watching a pencil through the surface of water, its
- 19:19shape shifts, slightly distorted. Not enough to change the essence
- 19:24of the light, but enough to jiggle its arrival point
- 19:27just a bit. And so, from your view below, what
- 19:32had once been a straight and steady beam flickers. It's
- 19:36not because the star flickers, it's because the medium between
- 19:40you and the star is dancing. Let's float now into
- 19:44the layers of the atmosphere themselves. They have names. Gentle,
- 19:49formal names you may have heard before. The troposphere, closest
- 19:53to the surface, where all the weather lives. The stratosphere,
- 19:58calm and cold, where jet planes leave soft trails. The mesosphere,
- 20:03where meteors quietly burn. The thermosphere, thin and hot, where
- 20:08auroras shimmer. and the exosphere, where air finally gives way
- 20:13to space. The light from a star must pass through
- 20:16all these layers, each one with a slightly different temperature, pressure,
- 20:22and composition, each one shifting moment to moment like waves
- 20:26overlapping on a lake. This isn't just theory. You've seen
- 20:31it before, haven't you? On a hot day, if you
- 20:34look just above the pavement, you might notice the air shimmers.
- 20:38Things far away look like they're floating, or melting. That's
- 20:42refraction too. Now scale that up, over miles of sky,
- 20:47and replace the pavement's heat with high-altitude currents and thermal updrafts.
- 20:52The same shimmering dance applies, only now it bends starlight.
- 20:57Let's consider the numbers. A typical beam of starlight might
- 21:02shift just a few arcseconds, an angle so tiny it's
- 21:06almost imperceptible. But your eye, your brain, they notice. They
- 21:12interpret even the subtlest movements as change. And thus, twinkle.
- 21:17Astronomers even have a name for this. They call it
- 21:20stellar scintillation. A lovely phrase, isn't it? Like a spell,
- 21:26like a whisper. Scintillation, the sparkle of a distant point
- 21:30of light caused not by the star, but by the
- 21:33churning ocean of air above us. Even more poetic, perhaps,
- 21:38is that this twinkle only happens to point sources of light.
- 21:42That is, stars. Stars are so far away that, even
- 21:47through a telescope, they appear as a single sharp dot. Planets,
- 21:52on the other hand, though they also reflect sunlight, are
- 21:55close enough to appear as tiny disks. And disks don't
- 22:00twinkle the same way. Their light comes from slightly wider angles.
- 22:05The distortions cancel each other out. And so, while stars
- 22:09shimmer and flicker, planets glow steady and calm. It's one
- 22:14way you can tell them apart. If you see a
- 22:17bright object that doesn't twinkle, it might be Jupiter, Venus
- 22:21or Mars. But if it sparkles like a diamond on velvet,
- 22:26you're looking at a star, winking through the soup of
- 22:28the sky. But the atmosphere doesn't just affect what we see.
- 22:33It affects what we can know. It's why astronomers build
- 22:36telescopes on mountaintops. The air is thinner there, fewer layers,
- 22:42less distortion. It's also why they build them in deserts,
- 22:46where the heat is dry and stable. Even better, they
- 22:50launch them into space, like Hubble or the James Webb,
- 22:54because the best way to beat the twinkle is to
- 22:57rise above it. But here, at sea level, or in
- 23:02your backyard, or from the window beside your bed, We
- 23:06embrace the twinkle. We make peace with it. We let
- 23:09it lull us to sleep. Because, in a strange way,
- 23:13the atmosphere is participating. It's adding its own texture, its
- 23:18own character. Without it, the stars would simply shine. But
- 23:23with it, they sing. There's something comforting in that, don't
- 23:27you think? That even our imperfect world, our ever-changing, sometimes
- 23:33chaotic air, adds beauty to the universe above, that what
- 23:37might be considered distortion is also what makes the sky
- 23:41feel alive. It's the same with life, really. We think
- 23:45of stillness as peace, of stability as truth. But sometimes,
- 23:51it's the small shifts, the tiny movements, that give meaning.
- 23:56So next time you see a star flicker, don't curse
- 24:00the air. Thank it. Thank the breeze, the warmth, The
- 24:05trembling veil between you and the cosmos. Because without it,
- 24:09the stars would still be there. But they wouldn't dance. Now,
- 24:14your body may be heavy with calm. Your thoughts softening,
- 24:18like clouds letting go of rain. Let the atmosphere wrap
- 24:22around you like a blanket. Let the flickers become lullabies.
- 24:27The great disturbance above is not a flaw. It's a gift.
- 24:32And the light of a star... shaken by wind, bent
- 24:35by temperature, reflected in your dreaming eyes, has finally come home.
- 24:41Take a slow breath. Not because you have to, but
- 24:44because you can. The world has quieted now. The rhythm
- 24:49of the day has given way to stillness. And somewhere
- 24:52above you, the stars are performing. But they don't know it.
- 24:57They simply shine, unwavering, unchanging, uninterrupted, and yet You see
- 25:04them dance. That flicker, that flutter, that soft glimmer in
- 25:08your vision. It isn't the star itself moving. It's the
- 25:12air in between. Dancing. Let's imagine that air for a moment.
- 25:17Not as empty space, but as a living thing. A
- 25:21layered ocean of unseen currents. Like a ballet of wind
- 25:25and warmth. A stage of transparent waves. And light. Gentle,
- 25:31ancient light from distant stars has no choice but to
- 25:35pass through it. Let's start simple. Light is made of waves. Tiny,
- 25:41invisible waves that ripple outward in all directions. In the
- 25:46vacuum of space, those waves travel without interference. They go straight. Clean. True.
- 25:54But Earth is not a vacuum. Earth is surrounded by
- 25:58a swirling, breathing atmosphere. an ever-changing mix of nitrogen, oxygen,
- 26:04water vapour and dust. And light, like any wave, is
- 26:09deeply affected by the medium it travels through. This is
- 26:13called refraction. Refraction happens when light moves from one material
- 26:18to another, like from space to air, or from cool
- 26:22air to warm air, or from dry to humid layers.
- 26:26Each shift causes the light to bend slightly. It doesn't
- 26:30slow to a stop. It doesn't disappear. It simply changes direction,
- 26:35ever so subtly, over and over again. And if the
- 26:39layers of air are constantly changing, the bending becomes dynamic. Fluid. Alive.
- 26:47This is the dance. Let's go higher. Picture the sky
- 26:51above you, not as a flat ceiling but as a
- 26:54vertical sea. Down at the bottom, you stand, your feet
- 26:58on the ground, your eyes turned upward. Above you, the troposphere,
- 27:03where clouds form and weather lives. Then higher, the stratosphere,
- 27:09smooth and cold. Above that, the mesosphere, even thinner, where
- 27:15meteors whisper into flame. And beyond that still, a fade
- 27:19into space. Each of these layers has a different density,
- 27:24a different temperature, a different motion. Some rise, In thermal columns.
- 27:31Some sink in cool spirals. Some are pushed sideways by
- 27:35winds borne a continent away. They don't move in harmony.
- 27:39They churn. And when a beam of starlight enters this
- 27:43layered world, it bends. And bends again. First one way.
- 27:49Then another. Not sharply. But enough. Enough to make the
- 27:54point of light shift ever so slightly as it arrives
- 27:57in your eye. That shift is what we see as
- 28:01a twinkle. Think of it like looking through water. If
- 28:04you've ever opened your eyes beneath a swimming pool's surface,
- 28:08you know how things change. Straight lines bend. Shapes wobble.
- 28:14Colours distort. That's refraction in action. Now imagine looking up
- 28:19at the stars through miles of moving water. That's what
- 28:23Earth's atmosphere is, in a way. A pool of invisible currents.
- 28:28distorting the straightness of light. But unlike the pool, you
- 28:32can't see the medium itself, only the effect. And the
- 28:36effect is beautiful. But there's more to this than physics.
- 28:41There's a poetry in the fact that we never see
- 28:43the stars directly. Not really. We see them filtered, bent
- 28:48and shaped by air we didn't notice, delivered to us
- 28:52with a shimmer added by our planet's own breath. It's humbling,
- 28:57isn't it? that even something as precise as light must
- 29:01submit to the softness of a breeze, that a star's
- 29:05truth is never received in full, only in fragments, only
- 29:09through interpretation. And yet, those fragments are enough to inspire awe,
- 29:16to guide sailors, to stir poets, to lull us to sleep.
- 29:21You might wonder, why don't we notice this dance in
- 29:24the daytime? Why doesn't the sun twinkle? And the answer is,
- 29:28it does, just not in the same way. The sun
- 29:32is close. Its light floods the entire sky. It's not
- 29:37a single point, but a disk. a vast, blinding presence.
- 29:43The small shifts in its light caused by the atmosphere
- 29:46get washed out. But at sunrise and sunset, when the
- 29:50light travels through more air, you do see the effects.
- 29:54That's when you notice the wobble, the warping, the sudden
- 29:58green flash. The rippling edge just before the sun disappears.
- 30:03Even then, the air dances. There's a kind of comfort
- 30:07in this chaos. A reassurance that even the firmest things,
- 30:11like light, can adapt. Can bend, gently, and still arrive.
- 30:17We often seek clarity. We want the truth to be
- 30:20sharp and steady. But sometimes, a little shimmer makes the
- 30:24world feel softer. And if you're lying down now, head
- 30:28on your pillow. eyes half-closed, know that the stars are
- 30:32still above you, and the light that reaches you tonight,
- 30:36after journeying for ages, was touched at the very end
- 30:39by this planet's breath. Its last steps were not clean.
- 30:44They were curved, distorted, warmed, made human. So next time
- 30:50you look up and you see a star flicker, don't
- 30:54rush to correct the image. Let it shimmer. Let it drift.
- 30:59Let it remind you that light is resilient, that it
- 31:02can pass through chaos and still be seen. Just like you.
- 31:07Just like every story worth hearing, every dream worth remembering.
- 31:12The dance of light through air is more than physics.
- 31:15It's a lullaby written by the planet itself. And tonight,
- 31:20it's being sung just for you. Not every light in
- 31:23the night sky twinkles. Some simply glow. Steady. Warm, unmoving,
- 31:31like a watchful guardian, or a quiet thought held for
- 31:35a long time. These are the planets. And if you've
- 31:39ever stood under the stars and noticed one light that
- 31:42didn't shimmer, didn't blink or waver, you were probably looking
- 31:47at one. You may have even mistaken it for a star.
- 31:51We often do. Their light is just as bright, sometimes brighter.
- 31:56And yet, they do not twinkle. tonight. Let's wonder why.
- 32:01It begins with distance. Stars, as we know, are unimaginably
- 32:06far away. Even the nearest ones sit light-years beyond our
- 32:11solar system. Their light travels for ages before it reaches us.
- 32:16Because of that immense distance, even powerful telescopes see stars
- 32:21as single points of light. No width, no shape, just
- 32:26a dot. And that dot, is fragile. As it passes
- 32:31through Earth's atmosphere, the thin thread of light is bent
- 32:35and jostled, just enough for it to shimmer. But planets?
- 32:40Planets are close. Some are just tens of millions of
- 32:44kilometres away, neighbours, in cosmic terms. And that closeness makes
- 32:50all the difference. When we look at a planet, we're
- 32:53not seeing a point. We're seeing a disk, a tiny,
- 32:58but measurable shape. It's still small, yes. You can't always
- 33:03see the circular outline with the naked eye, but it's
- 33:06wide enough to resist the dance of the air. Because
- 33:10atmospheric distortion, the very thing that makes stars twinkle, affects
- 33:15points of light more than disks. You can think of
- 33:18it like this. Imagine you're looking at a candle through
- 33:22a foggy window. If the flame is far away and tiny,
- 33:26Every bit of fog bends its light, and the flame flickers.
- 33:30But if the flame is closer, larger, its shape remains intact.
- 33:35The fog might soften it, but it doesn't make it dance.
- 33:39That's the planet. Calm, broad, resistant. It doesn't twinkle. It glows.
- 33:47This subtle difference has long been noticed. Even before we
- 33:51had words for atmosphere, or refraction, or optics, ancient sky
- 33:56watchers could tell a planet from a star without a telescope.
- 34:00Because the planet stood still, even when everything else shimmered,
- 34:05it made them feel different, important, solid. Planets, after all,
- 34:11move differently too. They don't stay in the same place
- 34:14like the stars do. They wander, slowly, across the sky,
- 34:19night by night, week by week. In fact, The word
- 34:24planet comes from the Greek word planetes, meaning wanderer. So
- 34:30imagine a light in the sky that does not twinkle
- 34:34and does not stay in one place. How strange, how
- 34:38powerful that must have seemed. Even now, it feels special.
- 34:43Let's bring this closer. You're lying in bed now, perhaps.
- 34:47The room is quiet. A soft pillow beneath you. A blanket.
- 34:52just heavy enough to keep the world away. And outside,
- 34:56somewhere above the clouds or the rooftops, Jupiter is hanging
- 35:01in the sky. You can't see it right now. But
- 35:04it's there. Its light left the planet maybe an hour ago.
- 35:08Not a thousand years ago like the stars. Just an hour.
- 35:14Fresh light. Recently reflected sunlight, bouncing off Jupiter's swirling clouds,
- 35:20travelling across space, through the atmosphere, and finally down to Earth.
- 35:26And that light is steady. Because it's wide. Because it's close.
- 35:32Because it's not a point. It's a world. A world
- 35:36large enough to hold its glow. There's something metaphorical in that,
- 35:40isn't there? That distant things flicker. But nearby things remain constant.
- 35:45That what is far and unknown can shimmer with mystery.
- 35:49while what is near and real can offer quiet steadiness.
- 35:53And maybe we need both, the sparkle and the calm,
- 35:58the unreachable and the familiar. Stars remind us how big
- 36:02the universe island, planets remind us that we are part
- 36:06of it, both lights in the same sky, but different
- 36:10in how they touch us. Now, if you were to
- 36:13look up on a clear night, you might spot Venus,
- 36:17bright and low near the horizon, or Mars, with its
- 36:21faint orange hue, or Saturn, dimmer but golden, near the
- 36:26belt of the Milky Way. Each of these lights appears
- 36:29soft and firm, their glow unwavering, and yet, in their steadiness,
- 36:35there is peace. No twinkle to chase, no shimmer to distract,
- 36:41just presence. Perhaps that's why ancient astrologers believed the planets
- 36:46held influence. They didn't flicker, They didn't disappear. They simply
- 36:52kept showing up. Night after night. A slow-moving light through
- 36:56a restless world. Astronomers use this difference too. When calibrating telescopes,
- 37:03they prefer planets. Because their stability offers clarity. When teaching
- 37:08beginners to identify constellations, they'll say, look for the lights
- 37:12that don't twinkle. Those are the planets. It's one of
- 37:16the oldest tips in the Stargazer's guidebook. and it still works.
- 37:21So next time you look up, and you see a
- 37:24bright light holding steady, gaze a little longer. That calm
- 37:29presence might just be Saturn, or Venus, or even the
- 37:33pale blush of Mars. A neighbour, a silent companion, not
- 37:39burning from within, but reflecting light gently from our shared Sunday.
- 37:45And so, as the night deepens, as your breathing slows,
- 37:50As the thoughts in your mind begin to soften, let
- 37:53that steady glow rest behind your eyes. Let it remind
- 37:57you that not all lights must dance. Some can simply remain. Solid, reliable, still,
- 38:05in a world of constant motion. Sometimes, calm is the
- 38:09greatest wonder of all. So, sleep now, under skies both
- 38:14shimmering and steady. And if you dream of distant things...
- 38:19Let one of them be a planet, quietly glowing for you.
- 38:23We've looked at the stars with our eyes. But what
- 38:26happens when we try to look closer? Let's drift now
- 38:30into the quiet world of telescopes. Because sometimes, wonder isn't
- 38:34just about what we see, but how we see it.
- 38:38Close your eyes for a moment, just for the length
- 38:41of a breath. And imagine a silent hilltop. The sky
- 38:46is cloudless. The air is cold and thin. Perched at
- 38:51the top of this peak is a giant instrument. A telescope, waiting. Still. Patient.
- 38:59Pointed upward like a question. Its purpose? To collect light.
- 39:05To quiet the shimmer. To turn a flicker into clarity.
- 39:09Because light, even from the farthest stars, is loyal. It
- 39:14carries everything. Temperature. Colour. Distance. direction, but once it reaches Earth,
- 39:21the air around us scatters it. The atmosphere, with all
- 39:25its beauty, is also noisy. So telescopes do what our
- 39:30eyes cannot. They rise above the noise. The earliest telescopes
- 39:35were simple tubes. Galileo's, for instance, just a few lenses
- 39:39in a wooden barrel. And yet, when he pointed it
- 39:42toward Jupiter, he saw four moons dancing around it. Little dots,
- 39:48moving night by night, proof that not everything circled Earth.
- 39:53And from that moment forward, we've been looking deeper, sharper, clearer.
- 39:59Modern telescopes are nothing like Galileo's Prusokin darting. Some are
- 40:04larger than houses. Some stretch across valleys. Some live in deserts,
- 40:09where the air is dry and stable. And some don't
- 40:13live on Earth at all. Let's float now, weightless, to
- 40:17the Hubble Space Telescope, launched in 1990. It was placed
- 40:23not too far above us, just 547 kilometres up, but
- 40:28above the atmosphere. And that made all the difference. Hubble's
- 40:32lens wasn't the biggest. Its mirror wasn't the most powerful,
- 40:37but its view was uninterrupted. No twinkling, no shimmer, just space,
- 40:44as it truly was. It gave us images of galaxies colliding,
- 40:49of nebulae stretching like silk, of stars forming in cold
- 40:53clouds millions of light years away. It changed how we
- 40:57saw the universe and how we saw ourselves. And then
- 41:03came James Webb, with mirrors of gold unfolding like a flower,
- 41:08peering not into visible light but into the infrared, the
- 41:12heat signatures of the deepest time. It could see light
- 41:16that had travelled for nearly the entire age of the universe.
- 41:20Not just stars, but their beginnings. But telescopes don't just
- 41:25show us what is out there. They show us when.
- 41:28Because remember, light is time. When you look at a
- 41:32star 500 light years away, you're seeing it as it
- 41:36was 500 years ago. So, in a way, telescopes are
- 41:41time machines. They let us look back, not into memory,
- 41:46but into physics. They reveal the slow unfolding of cosmic stories,
- 41:51galaxies forming, stars dying, black holes stirring space itself, all visible,
- 41:59if you know how to see. And yet, even with
- 42:02all this technology, with mirrors polished thinner than a human hair,
- 42:07with sensors colder than deep space, astronomers still fight the twinkle.
- 42:12They call it atmospheric turbulence. They build adaptive optics to
- 42:18correct it in real time, using lasers to measure distortions
- 42:22in the air, then flexing tiny mirrors thousands of times
- 42:26per second to cancel out the flicker. It's a delicate dance,
- 42:31one that lets them photograph a planet circling a distant Sunday,
- 42:35or a faint flash from a dying star. But it
- 42:39started with a human looking up, with eyes, and wonder. So,
- 42:45What does this mean for you? Lying here, blanket pulled
- 42:49to your chin, eyes closed, or maybe just fluttering at
- 42:54the edge of sleep. You don't need a telescope to
- 42:57feel the universe. You just need quiet and time. You've
- 43:02already travelled with photons across space. You've felt the atmosphere
- 43:06ripple between you and the stars. You've imagined the difference
- 43:10between a twinkle and a glow. And now, you've seen
- 43:14the science of sight. The way humans build instruments to
- 43:17extend the eye, to pierce the shimmer, to make distant
- 43:21truths a little less distant. But even telescopes have limits.
- 43:26They cannot touch what they see. They cannot hear the
- 43:30star sing. They cannot explain why we feel small and
- 43:34comforted at the same time. That's something only your mind
- 43:37can do. Only your heart. So, as you settle deeper
- 43:42into the night, Remember that clarity doesn't always come from
- 43:45looking harder. Sometimes it comes from softening your gaze. Letting
- 43:51things blur. Letting them drift. Letting light be just light.
- 43:58No science can improve on that. The sky tonight is
- 44:02full of stories. Told in shimmer. In silence. In stars
- 44:08older than the mountains. And even as telescopes search for more,
- 44:12There is beauty in what you already see. One light.
- 44:16One moment. One breath. Sleep now. Under a sky you've
- 44:22known all along. And dreamed your way into... A little
- 44:26more clearly. There's a secret in every star. A shimmer
- 44:30that doesn't reach your eyes. A light that flickers just
- 44:34beyond what you can see. Tonight, let's wander into it.
- 44:39Because not all twinkles are visible. Some happen in colours
- 44:42your eyes were never designed to notice. And yet, they're
- 44:46just as real. Let's begin with the edges. You see
- 44:51the world through a window. Not a glass one, but
- 44:54a biological one. A set of photoreceptors in your eyes,
- 44:58rods and cones, tuned to just a narrow sliver of light.
- 45:04That sliver is called the visible spectrum. It's what gives
- 45:08you red, orange, yellow, green... Blue, indigo, and violet. Roidbiv,
- 45:15if you like mnemonics. It feels like the full picture.
- 45:19But it isn't. Outside that band, both below and above,
- 45:23are wavelengths you'll never directly sense. Infrared, longer than red. Ultraviolet,
- 45:30shorter than violet. Then come microwaves, radio waves, x-rays, and
- 45:37gamma rays. A vast, invisible ocean of light. And the stars?
- 45:43They don't just shine in visible colours. They shine across
- 45:47all of it. If your eyes could see infrared, the
- 45:51sky would glow with heat. Cool stars, red dwarfs, planets,
- 45:57and even the dust between galaxies, they all radiate warmth
- 46:01like embers under a blanket. If you could see ultraviolet,
- 46:06young stars would blaze even brighter, their radiation slicing through
- 46:10clouds of gas. carving space with energetic whispers. And if
- 46:15you could see X-rays, you'd watch the dance of death.
- 46:20Black holes, neutron stars, supernova remnants, flashing with pulses and arcs.
- 46:27All of it, invisible to you. But there, still flickering,
- 46:33still twinkling. Astronomers have built instruments to peer into these
- 46:37hidden realms. Infrared telescopes, show stars forming inside dusty cradles.
- 46:44Microwave telescopes reveal the afterglow of the Big Bang. X-ray
- 46:48detectors capture the screams of colliding galaxies. And in every band,
- 46:54twinkling takes on new meaning. Because atmospheric distortion doesn't just
- 46:59affect visible light. It bends all light, though in different ways.
- 47:05Infrared light, for example, is easily absorbed by water vapour.
- 47:09So telescopes must climb to dry mountaintops or float in space.
- 47:15Ultraviolet light? It gets blocked by the ozone layer. Good
- 47:20for your skin. Bad for your data. So to see clearly,
- 47:24really clearly, you have to rise above it all. To space,
- 47:30where there is no shimmer. No air. No sound. Only light.
- 47:36Arriving pure. But here's the beautiful part. You don't need
- 47:40to see the twinkle to be touched by it. Think
- 47:43of how heat wraps around you on a sunny day.
- 47:47That's infrared. Unseen, but felt. Think of how a microwave
- 47:52oven warms your tea. That's electromagnetic radiation. Light, just at
- 47:57a different scale. Even radio signals from distant galaxies wash
- 48:02over your home at night. Quietly. Gently. Unknown. You are
- 48:07bathed in invisible twinkles. all the time. The universe doesn't
- 48:12stop being beautiful just because you can't perceive it. And
- 48:16maybe that's the most human thing about light. We assume
- 48:21the sky is dark when we turn off the lights.
- 48:24But it isn't. It's alive with wavelengths beyond our reach.
- 48:29Just because something is unseen doesn't mean it's not happening,
- 48:33or not important. In fact, some of the most powerful
- 48:37truths are invisible. Gravity. Love. Time. And light. Dancing where
- 48:45no eye can follow. Let's take this a step deeper.
- 48:49What if stars don't just twinkle differently in other wavelengths,
- 48:52but tell different stories altogether? In visible light, a star
- 48:57may appear calm. But in ultraviolet, it might be flaring wildly.
- 49:03In X-rays, it might be evaporating a nearby planet. In infrared,
- 49:08It may be wrapped in a cloud of gas, hiding
- 49:11newborn stars. Every layer of light reveals a new version
- 49:16of the truth. The star is never just one thing.
- 49:20and neither are you you are visible and invisible bright
- 49:25in some ways quiet in others you shine even when
- 49:30no one notices your thoughts shimmer your breath radiates your
- 49:36memories reflect and scatter and bend you too twinkle beyond
- 49:40the visible. So tonight, as you drift, remember that your
- 49:45body is made of particles that once glowed in unseen ways.
- 49:50That you're not just observing the cosmos. You're a part
- 49:54of its story. You shimmer in microwaves. You reflect in infrared.
- 49:59Your atoms were cooked in stars that flickered across the spectrum.
- 50:03And though your eyes close now, you still glow, like
- 50:07stardust remembering where it came from. Let the invisible twinkle
- 50:11soothe you. Let it remind you that even in the quiet,
- 50:16even in the dark, you are never alone. The stars
- 50:20are still singing. Somewhere. In colours you've never seen. And
- 50:25that is more than enough. Close your eyes and imagine
- 50:30a star. Just one. Not a whole sky. Not a galaxy.
- 50:36Just a single steady point of light. gently blinking in
- 50:40the dark. You can see it, can't you? Even with
- 50:43your eyes closed. That's the mind at work. The twinkle
- 50:48you remember, the shimmer, the softness, the little pulse of light,
- 50:53isn't just in the sky. It's in you. Because seeing
- 50:58is not just what your eyes do. It's what your
- 51:00brain makes of it. The moment starlight enters your eye,
- 51:05it's already changed, passed through your cornea. bent by your lens,
- 51:11filtered through vitreous gel, and then, finally, it lands on
- 51:16your retina. There, photoreceptors, rods and cones catch the light.
- 51:22Not the star itself, just the energy it left behind.
- 51:27A photon, a tiny packet of light, a traveller from
- 51:31light-years away, now absorbed in a cell at the back
- 51:34of your eye. That cell doesn't see a star. It
- 51:38just fires a signal. And then the magic begins. Your
- 51:43optic nerve carries that signal, like a message in a bottle,
- 51:47to the back of your brain, to the visual cortex,
- 51:51a space of quiet computation, a map made of neurons. There,
- 51:57your brain makes guesses. It doesn't just decode the message.
- 52:02It fills in the blanks, corrects distortions, smooths the image.
- 52:08adds context. It turns photons into perception, and sometimes into illusion.
- 52:16When you see a star twinkle, you're not seeing the
- 52:19atmosphere move. You're seeing your brain interpret flickering light and
- 52:23decide it's a sparkle. It's like how you see a
- 52:26face in the clouds, or hear a voice in the wind,
- 52:31or feel movement in the shadows. Your brain looks for patterns,
- 52:35even where there are none. So the twinkle? It's part physics,
- 52:40but also part poetry, authored by your own nervous system.
- 52:45Have you ever noticed how stars seem to twinkle more
- 52:48when you're tired? Or emotional? Or lost in thought? That's
- 52:53not the sky changing. That's you changing. The mind is
- 52:58not a camera. It's a canvas. And every glance at
- 53:02the night sky is coloured by how you feel in
- 53:05that moment. Lonely, the stars flicker like distant companions. Hopeful,
- 53:12they twinkle like promises. Heartbroken, they shimmer like tears you
- 53:17haven't cried yet. Your brain is painting. Even astronauts see it.
- 53:24Out in space, where there's no atmosphere, you might think
- 53:28stars appear perfectly still. But astronauts often report tiny flashes, sparks,
- 53:35brief pulses in their vision. These are not stars. They're
- 53:39cosmic rays, high-energy particles hitting their retinas. And yet, the
- 53:45brain turns them into light. A phantom twinkle, generated from within.
- 53:53It's a reminder that perception is never passive. It's creative.
- 53:57Your brain also filters. There are too many stars to count.
- 54:02Too many lights to process. Too many twinkles. So your
- 54:06brain picks. It chooses where to look, where to focus,
- 54:12what to remember. And sometimes, it chooses the sparkle. Not
- 54:17because it's important, but because it's beautiful. Your brain has taste.
- 54:23It favours the flicker that feels like magic. That speaks
- 54:27to something unspoken. And then there's memory. You might not
- 54:31see stars tonight. Clouds, city lights, or sleep may keep
- 54:36them from view. But you remember them. That sparkle from
- 54:40a childhood camping trip. That first kiss under a twinkling sky.
- 54:46That night you cried into the stars and felt heard.
- 54:49These aren't just memories. They're reconstructions. When you recall a
- 54:54star twinkling, your brain replays the shimmer. It fabricates the light.
- 55:00It makes it new. And in doing so, it becomes
- 55:04part of the experience. You are both viewer, and storyteller.
- 55:09So now, as you lie back, your pillow cool, your
- 55:14blanket soft, your breath slow, know that even if the
- 55:18sky outside is quiet, your mind is not. It holds
- 55:23an entire galaxy, a private sky, full of remembered twinkles,
- 55:29each one crafted from light and thought and wonder. Isn't
- 55:34it remarkable that the universe shines? And your brain, this
- 55:39quiet bundle of tissue, can not only detect it, but
- 55:44turn it into emotion, into comfort, into curiosity, into calm,
- 55:51into sleep. The twinkle you see before you drift off
- 55:54tonight might not be from a star. It might be
- 55:58from within. A neuron firing. A thought catching light. A
- 56:03dream beginning to form. So close your eyes now, Let
- 56:07your mind do what it does best. Let it create shimmer.
- 56:12Let it fill your darkness with flickers of soft light.
- 56:16Let it remind you that sometimes the most beautiful stars
- 56:22are the ones you imagine for yourself. So here we are.
- 56:26At the end of a journey that began with a flicker,
- 56:29a single light in the distance, a shimmer in the
- 56:32corner of your eye, we asked, why do stars twinkle?
- 56:37and found answers in air and atoms, in vision and velocity,
- 56:43in telescopes and thermodynamics. But now, let's ask something deeper.
- 56:49Why does it matter? Because the twinkle isn't just about light.
- 56:53It's about attention. The fact that you noticed, that you paused,
- 56:59that something so small, so faint, called to you. In
- 57:03a world of noise, where lights buzz and screens glow
- 57:08and clocks tick without mercy. You looked up and saw
- 57:12something gentle, fleeting, uncontrolled, a star that dared to shimmer
- 57:19in a sky that asked nothing of you. And that matters,
- 57:24because that shimmer brought you back to yourself. The twinkle
- 57:28is a reminder. Not everything has to be sharp. Not
- 57:32everything must be certain. A star wobbles, and it's beautiful.
- 57:38You feel unsure, and you're still worthy. Even the universe
- 57:42isn't always steady. It bends and dances and refracts. And still,
- 57:49it shines. Sometimes, clarity isn't found in the stillness, but
- 57:54in the movement, in the quiet flutter, in the glow
- 57:58that refuses to hold still. Maybe that's why we write
- 58:02poems about stars. Why we make wishes on them. Why
- 58:06we name them. Chart them. Sing to them. Because something
- 58:11in their flicker feels familiar. Like us, they are shaped
- 58:16by forces they can't control. Atmosphere. Gravity. Distance. Like us,
- 58:24they shine anyway. Lying here now, in your room, in
- 58:29your bed, wrapped in the hush of night, You are
- 58:32not so different from the stars. You've been through things.
- 58:37You've been scattered, bent, softened. By winds, by time, by memories.
- 58:44And still, you glow. You rest. You dream. You shimmer
- 58:51in your own way. The twinkle isn't a flaw. It's
- 58:54a feature. A sign that light is alive. That it's
- 58:58travelled far, and been changed, and still found its way
- 59:03to you. You might never visit a telescope. You might
- 59:06never calculate refraction or orbit or colour index. But you
- 59:11can still notice, still wonder, still lie beneath the stars,
- 59:17and ask, softly, what is that little shimmer trying to
- 59:20tell me? Maybe it's just light, bent by air, or
- 59:25maybe it's a message from the universe. That beauty doesn't
- 59:30have to be perfect. That light doesn't need to be still.
- 59:34That even across great distances, something can reach you and
- 59:39feel like home. So sleep now. Let your thoughts drift
- 59:44like starlight. Let your breath move like a gentle breeze.
- 59:48Let your heart flicker softly, sweetly, under the vastness above.
- 59:54The twinkle still happens, even with your eyes closed. You
- 59:58carry it inside because the stars don't just shine, they remind.
- 1:00:04And tonight, they remind you that even in the dark,
- 1:00:09you are never truly alone. Thank you for drifting through
- 1:00:13the stars with me tonight. Here at Boring Science for Sleep,
- 1:00:17we believe even the gentlest questions, like why stars twinkle,
- 1:00:22deserve a quiet, thoughtful answer. If this story helped you relax,
- 1:00:27or brought you a moment of calm, I'd love to
- 1:00:30hear where you're listening from and what time it is there.
- 1:00:34It's always beautiful to see how sleep connects us across cities, countries,
- 1:00:39and time zones. If you'd like more sleepy science stories
- 1:00:43to accompany your nights, feel free to subscribe. No pressure,
- 1:00:48just quiet curiosity whenever you're ready. Until next time, may
- 1:00:53your dreams be soft, your questions stay curious, and your
- 1:00:57sleep be peaceful. Good night.
- 1:01:58Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you. you Thank you.
- 1:09:06Speaker 1: Thank you.
- 1:11:25Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you. you Thank you.
- 1:17:21Speaker 1: Thank you.
- 1:18:31Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So, Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:33:57Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:43:23Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. you Thank you.
- 1:54:03Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:57:36Speaker 1: Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:58:50Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
- 2:11:49Thank you.