Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Are Medications Really More Effective Than Lifestyle? What the New DNA Data Tells Us
Transcript
- 0:00As you guys know, I come from mainstream medicine.
- 0:03Right?
- 0:03I was trained to be a doctor.
- 0:05I very much went through most of my medical career thinking that medications were more
- 0:11effective than anything you could possibly do with lifestyle.
- 0:14Sorta like lifestyle is nice, but, you know, the medications are doing the real work.
- 0:19Right?
- 0:19Did anybody else think that?
- 0:21Anybody else see yeah.
- 0:22Exactly.
- 0:23Right?
- 0:24So when, you know, different types of data started coming out, I started having to look
- 0:31past, I don't wanna say brainwashing, but the deep imprint that medical training had on me
- 0:41and how I view healing.
- 0:44And I think at this point, I have learned so much that I'm at a place where I really see
- 0:49healing in a different way.
- 0:51As you all know, the purpose of medications is to suppress pain in one way or another.
- 0:57I'm not saying they're all, like, opiates or something, but that is what we do with
- 1:02medications.
- 1:02We don't typically you know, we're not looking for root causes.
- 1:06We're not trying to fix any problems that are there in the body.
- 1:10It's really just how do we make it so this person can pop a pill, power through, get
- 1:16through their day.
- 1:16And those are important things to do, but, obviously, that's not a lasting solution
- 1:22because those problems that are percolating under the surface are still there.
- 1:26If And you ever want to get to a place of lasting relief, you have to find out what those
- 1:30problems are and fix those.
- 1:34So what I'm gonna do with this conversation is untangle a little bit about some of the reasons
- 1:40that we have all come to this place of thinking that medications work better than anything we
- 1:47could possibly do.
- 1:49What is it about the way we view science, the way we view pharma that has kind of made that
- 1:56our default belief.
- 1:58Why pharma shapes what you believe about healing.
- 2:04So, of course, many people assume that medications work better than lifestyle changes.
- 2:07We were just talking about that.
- 2:09And pharmaceutical companies spend billions of dollars making sure that you keep thinking
- 2:14that.
- 2:15So if you knew that magnesium could do something in your brain that no medication
- 2:19could, wouldn't you choose it first?
- 2:22Absolutely.
- 2:23You would.
- 2:24So the and this is an actual reality.
- 2:27So, magnesium, reversibly binds to a place in the brain.
- 2:35So when your brain starts overfiring in migraine, the magnesium will kick in and block
- 2:41that overfiring.
- 2:42There is no medication that does that.
- 2:47Topamax blocks that same receptor, but it does it permanently, and so it gives you a lot of
- 2:52side effects.
- 2:53It give you know, it can can give people troubles with memory, trouble with coming up
- 2:57with a word.
- 2:59But because of the way magnesium works that it only kicks in when it's needed as opposed to
- 3:06being there all the time, that makes it a much more effective solution.
- 3:10And if you think about it, that's the way we were designed.
- 3:13Right?
- 3:14We have built in mechanisms for dealing with the problems that happen to us.
- 3:19They may just be stronger or weaker given how we were you know, how how our DNA is.
- 3:25But we do have mechanisms within us to solve a lot of the problems that we face, including
- 3:32migraine and chronic headaches.
- 3:34So that's just one example.
- 3:37I think we all know that pharma has huge marketing budgets, and I don't need to persuade
- 3:41you that, of course, they're motivated to sell you drugs.
- 3:44So but I think that, this is part of the reason that goes into the backdrop that many people
- 3:52come at this with the idea that, medications work better than anything you could do with
- 3:57lifestyle.
- 3:58So here's another issue that is problematic here in The United States.
- 4:04We have direct to consumer marketing, and this is really a US problem.
- 4:10The United States is one of only two countries in the world, along with New Zealand, that
- 4:15allows pharmaceutical companies to market directly to consumers.
- 4:20So this drives demand and limits our ability to see less marketed solutions.
- 4:26Right?
- 4:26Is anybody out there putting, you know, magnesium commercials on the the Super Bowl
- 4:31Super Bowl?
- 4:32You know?
- 4:33I don't think so, but pharma is.
- 4:36So when patients, you know, come into my office back when I used to have an office asking for a
- 4:41specific pill, I mean, you know, because they saw it on TV, you're very much more motivated
- 4:48to prescribe them that pill.
- 4:50I mean, unless it's wrong.
- 4:51You know, I mean, we wanna keep you happy.
- 4:53We want you to move forward on your own personal journey.
- 4:56And if you think that's what's right for you, we wanna honor that.
- 4:59But what happens then is that all other conversations get shut down.
- 5:04I mean, I'm not gonna waste my time trying to tell you how you need to get better sleep if
- 5:08you are sold on, you know, needing an infusion of Vyepti.
- 5:12Right?
- 5:14Your your mind is in a very different place at that point.
- 5:17You're thinking that the medication is gonna be the be all, end all.
- 5:20It's gonna solve all your problems.
- 5:21Like, there's no room in that fifteen minute discussion to say, woah.
- 5:26Woah.
- 5:26Let's back up a minute.
- 5:27You're only sleeping three hours a night.
- 5:29It doesn't matter what drug I give you.
- 5:30You are not gonna get better right now.
- 5:32We really need to fix this other stuff.
- 5:35So I think that what happens and what is very frustrating for doctors is we just become pill
- 5:41pushers.
- 5:42People aren't even asking for our opinions, advice, thoughtful reflections anymore.
- 5:47And who benefits from this?
- 5:49It's pharma.
- 5:50It's pharma.
- 5:51And, yes, the medications have their role.
- 5:53I'm not saying they don't.
- 5:54You all know that I very much think that medications are a part of the solution.
- 5:59But I think the problem is that it blinds us to other solutions that are also effective and
- 6:06need to be a part of your overall treatment strategy for migraine.
- 6:13And I think the third thing that is a little bit probably harder to see if you're not in
- 6:17medicine is how pharma controls the science.
- 6:21So pharmaceutical companies actually fund the majority of what we call randomized controlled
- 6:27trials.
- 6:28It's kind of the gold standard for scientific research, and what we do in these studies is
- 6:34half the people get the drug and half the people get a placebo.
- 6:38So this is a fantastic model for studying a medication.
- 6:41Right?
- 6:41Half get it, half don't.
- 6:42We see who does better.
- 6:43Does the drug work or not?
- 6:45But what if half the people don't need the same thing, but what if half the people actually,
- 6:53let me phrase it this way.
- 6:54What if half the people need a dozen different things?
- 6:57And what if those dozen different things aren't even the same from person to person?
- 7:03You literally cannot do a randomized controlled trial with that setup.
- 7:08And that's what lifestyle solutions are.
- 7:10You need a dozen different things, and it's different for everybody.
- 7:13So it's very difficult to study in this gold standard style of research that pharma
- 7:20promotes.
- 7:21So pharma goes around saying, this is the only way to do science.
- 7:23No other science is legitimate.
- 7:26And that really rules out a lot of individualized lifestyle solutions.
- 7:30Do you see what I'm saying?
- 7:32Because they simply don't fit that model.
- 7:34But I wanna point out that just because there's not a randomized controlled trial to document
- 7:40that doesn't mean that there's no science.
- 7:43There's plenty of science.
- 7:45There's mountains and mountains worth of biology showing us that this is the way our
- 7:50pathways work.
- 7:51We've got the DNA on over a 100,000 people with migraine to tell us exactly what we need to do
- 7:59to help fix those root causes.
- 8:02And so I, you know, I just think that we need to take our eyes off of the thing that pharma
- 8:08is promoting for its own advantage and look at different types of scientific data.
- 8:15And that's when we can get to solutions that are actually more effective.
- 8:21Oops.
- 8:24Alright.
- 8:24So why one size fits all lifestyle advice fails?
- 8:29Now and I think that this is where a lot of people are stuck.
- 8:32They say, oh, well, I tried lifestyle.
- 8:34It didn't work for me.
- 8:35I tried supplements.
- 8:36It didn't work for me.
- 8:37But that's because they're doing generic one size fits all.
- 8:40This is what's good for migraine.
- 8:42Like, have you guys taken a look at Amazon recently to see how many migraine diets are out
- 8:46there?
- 8:47A bazillion.
- 8:48There's eat carbs every couple hours.
- 8:50And then at the totally opposite end of the spectrum, there's go carnivore and don't eat
- 8:55carbs ever.
- 8:56There's go vegan.
- 8:57There's drink milk and salt tablets.
- 9:00Like, we've got rec to go keto.
- 9:02Like, we've got recommendations all over the place.
- 9:05Who's right?
- 9:05Who's wrong?
- 9:06The answer is it depends on your biology.
- 9:09They're all right for some people.
- 9:11I think that all of those people, most likely, do really believe in what they're saying, and
- 9:16they've seen people be helped by their approach.
- 9:19And that's because they're seeing the subset of people who have that particular issue.
- 9:24They're seeing those people be helped by their approach, and that is why people get
- 9:29frustrated.
- 9:29They bounce from one thing to the next.
- 9:31They don't find the one thing.
- 9:33Right?
- 9:34So I think b b two and CoQ ten are a great example of that.
- 9:39We know that randomized randomized controlled trials support the use of those two
- 9:43supplements, so a lot of people do them.
- 9:45Basically, what they're doing is helping improve cellular energy production, which is
- 9:50great if that's actually your root cause.
- 9:54But if a common cause of reduced energy production is actually a buildup of
- 10:00environmental toxins like glyphosate.
- 10:03And if your body doesn't clear those toxins efficiently, no amount of b two and co q ten
- 10:07will fix the problem.
- 10:10It's not gonna work for you.
- 10:11You may need some detox foods.
- 10:13You may need some infrared sauna.
- 10:15You need the detox protocols we talk about in migraine relief code.
- 10:18I know some of you have been through those.
- 10:20So without that data about what your body actually needs, you will be frustrated with
- 10:25lifestyle change, partly because what you need is gonna vary based on your biology, and it's
- 10:33not gonna just be one thing.
- 10:34It's gonna need a it's gonna need a a it's going to the solution is going to be a whole
- 10:39puzzle worth of things.
- 10:41It's not just gonna be one piece.
- 10:45So other examples of how personalized lifestyle solutions vary, for those of you who have more
- 10:52prominent inflammatory drivers, you may need gluten free eating.
- 10:57You might need a probiotic.
- 10:59You may need cold plunges, and you may need to do all of those things together in order to
- 11:05really support that biological system in your body that regulates inflammation.
- 11:11On the other hand, if you have troubles with brain chemistry, let's say maybe your stress
- 11:16circuits, your adrenergic circuits are a little off, which is very common, you may need to
- 11:21avoid cold plunges entirely because, of course, those stress out your body.
- 11:25They're gonna make you worse.
- 11:27They're just gonna activate your stress circuits.
- 11:29They're going to make your migraines worse, so it can really vary.
- 11:33You may need other things if you have those brain chemistry issues as well.
- 11:37You might need tryptophan rich foods.
- 11:39You might need melatonin.
- 11:41Melatonin is made from serotonin.
- 11:43Maybe you're gonna really benefit from that.
- 11:46So I think that we have to keep in mind that, you know, directly opposite things can benefit
- 11:52different subsets.
- 11:54We talked a little bit about toxin clearance, so I won't go, back into that again.
- 11:58But this is just an example for you of why changing one variable so that we can do a
- 12:05randomized controlled trial on it, not gonna work for this type of science.
- 12:12I do wanna give you just a glimpse of some real world results of using precision medicine
- 12:19versus medication alone.
- 12:21So in our data, I collect the number of headache days everybody has in the past week on
- 12:28our calls every single week.
- 12:30I track this.
- 12:31I have data on hundreds of people over five, six years at this point.
- 12:36And so on average, we see a reduction of 2.9 headache days per week, which is about a dozen
- 12:45headache days a month, three days a week, four four weeks, you know, twelve days a month or
- 12:49so.
- 12:50In contrast, the randomized controlled trial data for AJOVY that they submitted to the FDA
- 12:56was that they saw a reduction of one headache day a week or about four headache days a month.
- 13:01Now if you're having headaches every single day, which one do you want?
- 13:05You'll take the 12, not the four.
- 13:07Right?
- 13:07Absolutely.
- 13:08And many people who are using precision medicine are on AJOVY in addition to all the
- 13:14other things.
- 13:15My point here isn't one or the other.
- 13:18My point is that medications are rarely enough.
- 13:21Once you start getting more and more headaches, if you're above two, maybe three headache days
- 13:25a week, the medications aren't gonna fix this for you.
- 13:27There's other stuff going on.
- 13:30So when we look at this data, we know that personalized lifestyle medicine is about three
- 13:35times more effective than medications alone.
- 13:38And I think in some ways, it's intuitive.
- 13:40We all know that you can't outmedicate a bad lifestyle.
- 13:44Like, let's say you are only sleeping three hours a night.
- 13:47We all intuitively know that's not gonna work.
- 13:49If you're eating Cheetos for breakfast, lunch, and dinner every day, I think we all
- 13:52intuitively know that's not gonna work.
- 13:54Right?
- 13:55So in some ways, I think we can also just tap into our own intuition, our wisdom as humans,
- 14:03and under you know?
- 14:04And then we we realize, yes.
- 14:06Absolutely.
- 14:07Of course, lifestyle matters.
- 14:08Right?
- 14:09I just wanna share one story with you.
- 14:13This one really, really got me when I got this email.
- 14:16Margaret sent this message to me.
- 14:18I went a week with no headache at all.
- 14:20I have not taken Maxalt in weeks.
- 14:22This is the longest I have ever gone without a headache since I was in my teens.
- 14:26Wow.
- 14:27Over fifty years.
- 14:29And Mhmm.
- 14:31I mean, just stop and think about that.
- 14:32Imagine how much better her life, her children's lives, her spouse's life, her
- 14:38community's life, her, you know, her workplace, how much better everybody's lives would have
- 14:43been if she had had these tools fifty years ago.
- 14:45They didn't exist.
- 14:47But I firmly, firmly feel that the benefits of one healthy woman ripple out to her entire
- 14:53community, and that is why this matters so much.
- 14:59So just to kind of recap, we know that medications are essential but not sufficient.
- 15:05And what medications do well, I think, is they provide acute relief great.
- 15:10I don't think that any herb or other strategy works quite as well as something like an
- 15:16Imitrex or a Gpants.
- 15:19Reduced frequency when the biology is a good match.
- 15:22They play an important role in a recovery plan.
- 15:25Some of the monoclonal antibodies have good data for helping people get out of
- 15:29chronification, and that matters.
- 15:31But what lifestyle medicine adds is it allows you to address those root causes that are
- 15:36driving your migraines.
- 15:38They're tailored to your unique biology, and they give all the missing pieces of what
- 15:43medication simply can't do.
- 15:46Alright.
- 15:47So that is kind of what we what we know to be true about precision lifestyle medicine.
- 15:55And then I would love to just turn it over to you guys.
- 16:00I have a few questions.
- 16:03I would love to just have a conversation.
- 16:05I'm gonna un thank you all so much for being here.
- 16:09Have an amazing week.
- 16:10Good luck on all of your married journeys.
- 16:14Yay.
- 16:15Everything.
- 16:15Yay.
- 16:16I can't get to work.
- 16:18Bye.
- 16:20Alrighty.
- 16:20Bye, guys.
- 16:21Bye.
- 16:22Bye.