Latest / Bloomberg Law / When the Judge Cries at Sentencing
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: I was astonished when you began your examination by commenting
- 0:14Speaker 2: on the defendant's post arrest silence.
- 0:18Speaker 1: That's basic law. It's been basic law in this country
- 0:21Speaker 1: for forty years, fifty years. We're used to seeing judges
- 0:24Speaker 1: yelling in court, reprimanding, even berating. What we're not used
- 0:29Speaker 1: to is judges crying in court, especially when telling the
- 0:32Speaker 1: defendant the good news that he doesn't have to go
- 0:35Speaker 1: to prison. But that's what happened when Brooklyn Federal Judge
- 0:38Speaker 1: Pamela Chen sentenced Alejandro Burzaco, a banker turned sports marketing
- 0:44Speaker 1: executive turned star witness at two FIFA corruption trials. Joining
- 0:49Speaker 1: me is Bloomberg Legal reporter Patricia Hurtado, who was in
- 0:52Speaker 1: the courtroom. Patty tell us about Brazaco.
- 0:55Speaker 2: He has been one of the most prolific and helpful witness,
- 1:00Speaker 2: says the US government has ever had. I've never covered
- 1:03Speaker 2: a case where at the sentencing, the federal judge who
- 1:07Speaker 2: presided over two trials and saw Berzakos on the stand
- 1:11Speaker 2: for fourteen days as a witness for the government, she
- 1:14Speaker 2: actually cried and had to stop and grabbed the tears
- 1:17Speaker 2: away as she told him how proud she was, some
- 1:20Speaker 2: privilege she was to see and hear his testimony, and
- 1:23Speaker 2: then she continued, but as you were speaking, mister Brazaco,
- 1:26Speaker 2: I felt some bit of privilege and pride about being
- 1:28Speaker 2: able to participate in this role in this system, because
- 1:32Speaker 2: this is a great justice system, and I think the
- 1:34Speaker 2: finest in the world, and it does, I hope, always
- 1:37Speaker 2: reward people for doing the right thing. And it was extraordinary.
- 1:40Speaker 2: As a reporter for decades of experience, I've never seen that.
- 1:44Speaker 1: I haven't either. It's stunning what the.
- 1:46Speaker 2: Government said he did is he helped them basically uncover
- 1:51Speaker 2: the fraud and rampant bribery that was in international soccer.
- 1:57Speaker 2: That there always been these rumors but no one had
- 1:59Speaker 2: ever been willing to come forward, and that Brazaco had
- 2:03Speaker 2: helped the US government disclose the actual fraud that was
- 2:07Speaker 2: involved in bribery. And after the trials has happened, there
- 2:11Speaker 2: was one in twenty seventeen that went on for weeks
- 2:14Speaker 2: and weeks, and the second trial that just finished was
- 2:18Speaker 2: like a twelve week trial. Earlier this year, she said
- 2:21Speaker 2: that now the truth is out that was bribery in soccer.
- 2:24Speaker 2: People couldn't deny it any longer. After all these witnesses testified.
- 2:28Speaker 1: What was he accused of.
- 2:30Speaker 2: Brazoco was accused and pled guilty to paying tens of
- 2:34Speaker 2: millions of dollars in bribe. Is sports marketing executive. It's
- 2:38Speaker 2: a very odd world. But basically, if you want to
- 2:41Speaker 2: get access to events, players, and you want to broadcast
- 2:46Speaker 2: those rights and endure certain teams, these bribes were paid
- 2:49Speaker 2: to the soccer bosses that were the heads of these
- 2:52Speaker 2: different soccer entities. So basically, these soccer bosses were taking
- 2:56Speaker 2: bribes from these corporations in exchange for are extraordinarily lucrative broadcast. Right.
- 3:03Speaker 1: So the judge said that by cooperating, he put his
- 3:06Speaker 1: life in danger.
- 3:07Speaker 2: Yeah, And the first trial actually had all the trappings
- 3:11Speaker 2: of a mafia case where witnesses, especially Brazaco, who were
- 3:15Speaker 2: basically escorted to and from court under guard of SBI agents.
- 3:20Speaker 2: The jurors were anonymous and their identities were not disclosed,
- 3:24Speaker 2: which is what you see in a mafia trial, you know,
- 3:26Speaker 2: a terrorism case. And he testified that because he was cooperating,
- 3:32Speaker 2: he was terrified for his own safety as well as
- 3:35Speaker 2: the safety of his family. His family was still living
- 3:38Speaker 2: in Argentina and some of his children still live there.
- 3:41Speaker 2: So in fact, his sentencing memo and the government's memo
- 3:45Speaker 2: everything is under steal and the court has refused to
- 3:48Speaker 2: release it. The allegation was that he and his family
- 3:51Speaker 2: had actually received death threats. So here's a guy that
- 3:54Speaker 2: basically can never return home to Argentina.
- 3:57Speaker 1: So he was on the stand a total of fourteen days,
- 4:00Speaker 1: two trials. What was he like on the stand?
- 4:03Speaker 2: He has a phenomenal memory, and because it was a
- 4:06Speaker 2: former businessman in banker, he knew about all the transactions
- 4:10Speaker 2: and he could talk about the financing. But then he
- 4:12Speaker 2: was I thought extraordinarily smart and down to earth guy
- 4:15Speaker 2: that knew how to communicate two jurors. He remembered people's conversations.
- 4:20Speaker 2: You remember the nicknames of some of these soccer bosses.
- 4:23Speaker 2: One of the guys in Argentina ran the empire from
- 4:27Speaker 2: a gas station and he was called in Spanish the Pope,
- 4:31Speaker 2: and he wore a big signet ring and people he
- 4:34Speaker 2: used to come and pay tribute to him and they
- 4:36Speaker 2: would have to kiss his ring, just like you have
- 4:38Speaker 2: to go when you see the Pope. So you can
- 4:40Speaker 2: see that there's all these anecdotes that Burzaco had at
- 4:45Speaker 2: the tip of his fingertips just off his memory, and
- 4:48Speaker 2: he could recite whole parts of conversations. He remembered details
- 4:53Speaker 2: about sitting in a restaurant and where they were sitting
- 4:56Speaker 2: Seventh Avenue in Manhattan near the News Court building. When
- 5:00Speaker 2: when were twenty first century Fox executives talked about paying
- 5:04Speaker 2: bribes to get lucrative broadcast rights, including some of the
- 5:08Speaker 2: allegations the government alleged was the rights to the twenty
- 5:12Speaker 2: twenty two World Cup.
- 5:14Speaker 1: How many people were convicted because of his testimony.
- 5:17Speaker 2: Dozens, more than two dozen were convicted. The soccer bosses
- 5:23Speaker 2: were convicted three a trial, two were acquitted. So of
- 5:26Speaker 2: five that went to trial, dozens and dozens pled guilty.
- 5:30Speaker 2: Sports marketing companies pled guilty. One of them is actually
- 5:34Speaker 2: trying to get out got convicted at the first trial.
- 5:37Speaker 2: Some of the biggest guys in the sports were ousted also,
- 5:41Speaker 2: like step Blatder, who was the boss of FIFA. He
- 5:44Speaker 2: was president for seventeen years and was kicked out of
- 5:48Speaker 2: the job. So prosecutors said that without Brazaco's help that
- 5:53Speaker 2: international soccer the true dirty underbelly would have never been exposed.
- 5:59Speaker 1: Tell us who he was in the courtroom for his sentencing.
- 6:02Speaker 2: It was kind of wild because he not only had
- 6:05Speaker 2: his lawyer, all of his family was there from Argentina,
- 6:09Speaker 2: his children, I understand, maybe two x wives and his
- 6:13Speaker 2: fiance and then you know, as reporters who cover courts,
- 6:18Speaker 2: you always hear these people that suddenly do good deeds
- 6:21Speaker 2: just ahead of their sentencing, where you know they're working
- 6:24Speaker 2: in a soup kitchen or working with a homeless or
- 6:27Speaker 2: something like that. Right, well, Brazaco actually had some of
- 6:30Speaker 2: the co workers from the food pantry he works with,
- 6:34Speaker 2: and there was a soup kitchen he works with where
- 6:38Speaker 2: he's so vigilant about working with him. From the description
- 6:42Speaker 2: of his lawyer, Jim Walden, it sounded like he had
- 6:45Speaker 2: felt so responsible after turning rogue as the former City
- 6:50Speaker 2: Group banker you know, turns bag man paying money millions
- 6:53Speaker 2: of dollars in Bride. He decided to turn over a
- 6:56Speaker 2: new leaf and cooperate with the government. But it didn't
- 6:58Speaker 2: just end there with help being in testifying as a
- 7:01Speaker 2: government witness. Here he is doing this good work for
- 7:04Speaker 2: years and years and years. So it's been eight years
- 7:06Speaker 2: since that raid at the five star hotel in Switzerland
- 7:10Speaker 2: when all the FIFA bosses got arrested, right he somehow
- 7:14Speaker 2: was in the dining room, but they didn't get him
- 7:18Speaker 2: for some reason. I don't know why. But he walked
- 7:21Speaker 2: out the back door and immediately went to the Swiss
- 7:25Speaker 2: Italian border and called his lawyers and immediately came in
- 7:29Speaker 2: and offered to help and then secretly pled guilty and
- 7:32Speaker 2: has been on Team America right helping the government. But
- 7:35Speaker 2: here he is for eight years. He's also been working
- 7:38Speaker 2: in the suit kitchens and food pantries, and he wanted
- 7:42Speaker 2: to make amends in such a way that when he
- 7:45Speaker 2: saw another guy at the soup kitchen getting attacked and
- 7:50Speaker 2: somebody was stealing his motorbike or his bicycle, Brazaco stepped
- 7:55Speaker 2: in to stop the crime and stopped to protect the
- 7:58Speaker 2: man it was getting hit by chains and call the cops.
- 8:02Speaker 2: And then when the DA found out who the witness was,
- 8:06Speaker 2: she had to tell the Manhattan Die's office who exactly
- 8:10Speaker 2: they wanted to call as a witness, that they couldn't
- 8:14Speaker 2: use him because they would interfere with their criminal case.
- 8:17Speaker 2: So Brazaco found another witness and convinced that guy to
- 8:21Speaker 2: come forward and testify against the wrongdoer. So his lawyer
- 8:26Speaker 2: called him the Superman of cooperators, and it really did
- 8:30Speaker 2: make him sound like Superman of all this good deeds
- 8:32Speaker 2: that he'd done that weren't just idle. You know, let's
- 8:35Speaker 2: do it for a weekend on Thanksgiving, and let's get
- 8:38Speaker 2: done with our public service. This is a guy who's
- 8:41Speaker 2: been committed for the last eight years to helping people.
- 8:44Speaker 1: Patty, besides family members and co workers at the food
- 8:48Speaker 1: kitchens he's worked at. Who else was at the sentencing.
- 8:52Speaker 2: That was the other extraordinary thing to see Rose and
- 8:56Speaker 2: rose of former prosecutors who've been on the case for
- 9:00Speaker 2: eight years and left the US Attorney's office and they're
- 9:03Speaker 2: sitting there and FBI agents I haven't clapped eyes on
- 9:07Speaker 2: in years, and they're sitting there, and all of them
- 9:10Speaker 2: had worked in the case, and they all came and
- 9:13Speaker 2: show support to him. And everyone said to me afterwards,
- 9:17Speaker 2: you know that you don't often see a federal judge crying,
- 9:20Speaker 2: And there she was crying about how proud she was
- 9:23Speaker 2: to have seen his testimony, and she noted that some
- 9:26Speaker 2: of the defense lawyers availed his credibility and called into
- 9:31Speaker 2: question his motives. He was assailed as a liar who
- 9:36Speaker 2: was fingering these other upstanding members of the community in
- 9:40Speaker 2: the soccer world just to get even or to hide
- 9:43Speaker 2: his crime. But you know, the judge said she had
- 9:46Speaker 2: not seen evidence of that and these guys, I mean,
- 9:49Speaker 2: it was just I've never seen anything like it. It
- 9:51Speaker 2: was quite the spectacle.
- 9:52Speaker 1: So tell us about what he said at the sentencing.
- 9:55Speaker 2: It was very emotional, you can tell you know that
- 9:58Speaker 2: this whole aspect of leaving one's country and his family
- 10:02Speaker 2: behind and trying to do the right thing and make
- 10:05Speaker 2: up for his crime weighs really heavily on him. He
- 10:08Speaker 2: seems a man who's very tortured and affected by the
- 10:12Speaker 2: remorse he feels. It was definitely palpable. He has to pause.
- 10:17Speaker 2: He reddened in the face at some points in time.
- 10:20Speaker 2: I mean, he got very emotional and his voice choked
- 10:23Speaker 2: up with emotion trying to talk about how horrified and
- 10:27Speaker 2: remorseful he was about the crimes he committed. And you know,
- 10:32Speaker 2: he had to live alone in the US and facing
- 10:36Speaker 2: the prospect and then imagine that you're on hold, you
- 10:39Speaker 2: have everything to put on hold. Well, you wait for
- 10:42Speaker 2: these two trials to go through the system, and so
- 10:44Speaker 2: the first one started in May twenty fifteen. The first
- 10:49Speaker 2: trial started in November twenty seventeen, so we're talking two
- 10:53Speaker 2: years later, and the second trial didn't happen un till
- 10:56Speaker 2: twenty twenty three because of the pandemic. So imagine having
- 10:59Speaker 2: your life and being put on ice like that, and
- 11:02Speaker 2: then you're having to stand by. He thanked everybody, you know,
- 11:05Speaker 2: He says, I want to say to all the victims,
- 11:07Speaker 2: I fully accept to take responsibility for the crimes I've committed.
- 11:11Speaker 2: I understood it was bad, and no one forced to
- 11:13Speaker 2: do me to do it, and I know my conduct
- 11:15Speaker 2: was wrong, it was very wrong. He apologized to the
- 11:18Speaker 2: soccer world, to the members of the soccer clubs in
- 11:21Speaker 2: South America, who he called the real shareholders of these clubs,
- 11:24Speaker 2: and these people who loved the sport, who were basically
- 11:27Speaker 2: betrayed by this fraud. Talked about how was his motivation,
- 11:30Speaker 2: why did he engage in this fraud. My conclusion is
- 11:33Speaker 2: that at the beginning of my career in the soccer
- 11:35Speaker 2: in industry, I was motivated by a desire to be
- 11:37Speaker 2: close to the people in the industry and He basically
- 11:40Speaker 2: wanted to get in where all the decisions were made
- 11:43Speaker 2: in big soccer. And of course what happens is when
- 11:46Speaker 2: he joined this company, Torneo Si Comenthensius, the soccer management company,
- 11:51Speaker 2: the people were paying bribes and it was sort of
- 11:53Speaker 2: like the way you had to do business to succeed.
- 11:56Speaker 2: So he saw firsthand what was going on, and then
- 11:59Speaker 2: he knowingly went along with it. So, you know, he said,
- 12:02Speaker 2: I was motivated by greed, and I deeply regret my actions,
- 12:06Speaker 2: and I was selfish, and I am ashamed of it,
- 12:08Speaker 2: and I'm still ashamed of it, and I want to
- 12:10Speaker 2: tell the victims. I've dedicated my last eight years to
- 12:13Speaker 2: repair this. It just was extraordinary. You don't most of
- 12:16Speaker 2: the time. I call it the Great American Apology. Mistakes
- 12:19Speaker 2: were made, things happened, but I don't have anything to
- 12:23Speaker 2: do with it, because that's the way some people act
- 12:25Speaker 2: after getting caught and pleading guilty. You know, they minimize
- 12:29Speaker 2: their role. He was definitely not that kind of guy.
- 12:32Speaker 1: It sounds like it was an extraordinary sentencing. Thanks so much, Patty.
- 12:36Speaker 1: That's Bloomberg Legal reporter Patricia Hurtado. The Supreme Court upheld
- 12:41Speaker 1: California's new humane pork law, rejecting an industry challenge in
- 12:46Speaker 1: a ruling buttressing the power of states to impose rules
- 12:50Speaker 1: that have a broad economic impact on other parts of
- 12:53Speaker 1: the country. The ruling could force pork producers to implement
- 12:57Speaker 1: costly changes to keep selling in the world rol's most
- 13:00Speaker 1: populous state. The industry argued, unsuccessfully that California is violating
- 13:06Speaker 1: the Constitution by regulating commerce outside its borders. Justice Neil
- 13:11Speaker 1: Gorsuch wrote for the five justice majority, saying the poork
- 13:15Speaker 1: industry would have us cast aside caution for boldness by
- 13:20Speaker 1: intervening where Congress had declined to act. The ruling cut
- 13:24Speaker 1: across the Court's left right divide Justice as Clarence Thomas,
- 13:28Speaker 1: Sonya Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Amy Coney Barrett joined Gorsuch
- 13:33Speaker 1: in voting to toss out the lawsuit. Although the majority
- 13:36Speaker 1: splintered in some of its reasoning, for Justice's Chief Justice
- 13:40Speaker 1: John Roberts and Justices Samuel Alito, Brett Kavanaugh, Katanji Brown
- 13:45Speaker 1: Jackson said they would have kicked the case back to
- 13:47Speaker 1: a federal appeals court for more scrutiny. My guest is
- 13:51Speaker 1: Harold Krant, a professor at the Chicago Kent College of Law.
- 13:55Speaker 1: First of all, tell us about California Proposition twelve, which
- 13:58Speaker 1: is one of the nation's strongest farm animal welfare laws.
- 14:04Speaker 3: California's PAS Proposition twelve to ensure sort of humane conditions
- 14:08Speaker 3: for pigs, and the problem was that pigs are usually
- 14:11Speaker 3: put in and tends very close to other pigs. There
- 14:14Speaker 3: can be violence, pigs don't get exercise, and so in
- 14:18Speaker 3: terms of cruelty, made people think that those kinds of
- 14:20Speaker 3: conditions should be banned. And California is not alone. There
- 14:24Speaker 3: are laws against cruelty in terms of raising food in
- 14:29Speaker 3: Massachusetts and Florida and other states. But this one is
- 14:32Speaker 3: noteworthy because California is such a large market and so
- 14:36Speaker 3: it decides that pigs have to be housed in humane conditions.
- 14:40Speaker 3: That's going to cause a huge ripple effect into the
- 14:43Speaker 3: pork industry as a whole.
- 14:45Speaker 1: The argument in this case is about this arcane constitutional
- 14:48Speaker 1: doctrine called the dormant Commerce clause. Explain what that is.
- 14:54Speaker 3: So we have a commerce clause in the Constitution which
- 14:56Speaker 3: gives Congress the ability to regulate amongst the states, and
- 15:01Speaker 3: that's not at state care and that's not controversial. But
- 15:05Speaker 3: the Supreme Court later in its history decided to read
- 15:08Speaker 3: a negative implication into that clause, suggesting that some kinds
- 15:13Speaker 3: of state regulatory actions, even if they're based upon public policy,
- 15:18Speaker 3: can't have the impact of interfering with interstate commerce. And
- 15:24Speaker 3: so the Court on its own will sort of judge
- 15:28Speaker 3: whether a state regulatory effort is discriminatory against out of
- 15:34Speaker 3: state commerce and therefore violates the spirit of the Constitution
- 15:39Speaker 3: by picking and choosing which kind of producers to value
- 15:44Speaker 3: from which states there should be an accepted commerce in
- 15:47Speaker 3: the states.
- 15:48Speaker 1: And what was the argument here by the pork industry.
- 15:52Speaker 3: The pork industry had two or three different arguments, depending
- 15:55Speaker 3: upon how one counts. The first might be called an
- 15:58Speaker 3: extra territorial print, so that any kind of state regulation
- 16:02Speaker 3: that has the impact that is felt mostly externally should
- 16:07Speaker 3: as a per se matter be found to be unconstitutional.
- 16:11Speaker 3: A variant of that is the fact that in this
- 16:13Speaker 3: case it wasn't just a state regulation, it was a
- 16:17Speaker 3: moral regulation. And both and Mikai as well as the
- 16:22Speaker 3: park industry said, look, if you allow California to impose
- 16:26Speaker 3: a kind of moral principle in terms of humane treatment
- 16:30Speaker 3: for pigs. What's the stop California from men saying is
- 16:34Speaker 3: a moral issue. We only want to deal with employers
- 16:37Speaker 3: who are fair to their employees, or we only want
- 16:40Speaker 3: to have products from employers that are fair to employees.
- 16:43Speaker 3: So we only want to deal with products in companies
- 16:47Speaker 3: which bide by the privacy rights of their female employees.
- 16:53Speaker 3: So the fear was that this kind of case opened
- 16:56Speaker 3: up the Pandora's box and giving sort of a green
- 17:00Speaker 3: like to states to impose all sorts of regulations that
- 17:04Speaker 3: have ability to do with the morals of the state
- 17:07Speaker 3: as opposed to any kind of legitimate protection for their citizens,
- 17:13Speaker 3: such as from poison or pollution or something along those lines.
- 17:18Speaker 3: So that was one argument, and as probably that's why
- 17:22Speaker 3: this case got so much attention because of this extraterritoriality
- 17:26Speaker 3: aspect of it. The second one was just a plain
- 17:29Speaker 3: balancing test, and in prior cases the court had held
- 17:33Speaker 3: that when the burdens of a state regulation are excessive
- 17:38Speaker 3: in comparison to the in state benefits, that that state
- 17:43Speaker 3: rule also violates the dormant commerce clause of which we've
- 17:46Speaker 3: been speaking with the second argument, there are some the
- 17:51Speaker 3: court that want to get rid of it, and this
- 17:53Speaker 3: balancing test was severely limited by the court. It wasn't
- 17:57Speaker 3: by a majority of the court, but three members of
- 17:59Speaker 3: the court or suggested that they'd get rid of this
- 18:02Speaker 3: balancing test in a proper case, and other members of
- 18:05Speaker 3: the court enough to get a majority, said that the
- 18:08Speaker 3: port producers had not demonstrated such a huge excessive burden
- 18:12Speaker 3: in this case. So that coalition, which led on the
- 18:16Speaker 3: second point this balancing which is called the pipe test,
- 18:21Speaker 3: led to the court ruling against the pork industry on
- 18:24Speaker 3: that one as well.
- 18:25Speaker 1: This was a weird lineup that cut across ideological divides
- 18:29Speaker 1: and resulted in five separate opinions. So what was the
- 18:34Speaker 1: strand in the majority?
- 18:37Speaker 3: Well, its trand. Majority held that you cannot parse a
- 18:40Speaker 3: state regulation and say that it's having to do mostly
- 18:44Speaker 3: with morals as opposed to protection for the citizens of
- 18:47Speaker 3: the state. So that distinction that was forwarded by the
- 18:50Speaker 3: port producers was clearly rejected by a majority of the court,
- 18:55Speaker 3: Which is the controversial aspect of the decision, because then
- 18:58Speaker 3: it does open up states to enact morals legislation, which
- 19:03Speaker 3: has an impact upon out of state commerce. Because again,
- 19:06Speaker 3: on the face this regulation Proposition twelve is neutral because
- 19:12Speaker 3: it would apply to pork producers in California as well
- 19:15Speaker 3: as pork producers outside. It's just that there are almost
- 19:19Speaker 3: zero pork producers in California, so obviously this had a
- 19:23Speaker 3: great out of state impact. So at least on the
- 19:26Speaker 3: first question, it's whether, if you have this kind of
- 19:30Speaker 3: huge impact, is that a per se violation of the
- 19:33Speaker 3: negative commerce clause. The court clearly came down no. On
- 19:38Speaker 3: the second issue, it had to do with this balancing
- 19:41Speaker 3: of in state benefits versus out of state burdens, and
- 19:45Speaker 3: that's where the court was fractured. On that case. Three
- 19:49Speaker 3: of the justices said, we get rid of this balancing test.
- 19:52Speaker 3: It's inappropriate for courts. How can you balance benefits and costs?
- 19:57Speaker 3: And then two members of the court said, well, we
- 20:00Speaker 3: need to keep the test, but it's a narrow test
- 20:03Speaker 3: and the Portunustry did not demonstrate the excessive burden in
- 20:08Speaker 3: this case, and to dissenting justices, they would have at
- 20:12Speaker 3: least held that the pro producers did make a facial
- 20:16Speaker 3: claim as to a substantial burden and that should be
- 20:21Speaker 3: remanded back to the court to make that kind of
- 20:24Speaker 3: balancing tests. Though they agreed that the test of balancing
- 20:28Speaker 3: burdens and benefits was difficult, but they said it wasn't impossible,
- 20:32Speaker 3: and that's what the lower court should undertake.
- 20:34Speaker 1: Do you have any inkling as to why this opinion
- 20:39Speaker 1: was so fractured and cut across ideological lines?
- 20:44Speaker 3: Well, I think in terms of ideology, what's interesting is
- 20:47Speaker 3: you have the kind of liberals who you might think
- 20:50Speaker 3: would be in support of California and this kind of
- 20:54Speaker 3: moral legislation. But then again you have the traditional stage
- 20:58Speaker 3: writers who believe that the dormant commerce clause should be
- 21:03Speaker 3: very limited if it exists at all, and therefore because
- 21:06Speaker 3: now would give more power to the states as well.
- 21:09Speaker 3: So you have two different types of movements which would
- 21:13Speaker 3: suggest that the states should get more power than they
- 21:17Speaker 3: have in higher commerce clause challenges. And of course the
- 21:20Speaker 3: line up on the other side cuts across ideological lines
- 21:24Speaker 3: as well, with Justice and Jackson agreeing with Chief Judges
- 21:28Speaker 3: Roberts saying that we ought to keep the balancing test.
- 21:31Speaker 3: That's the proper way to understand limits on state authorities,
- 21:37Speaker 3: and if the state action does have a disproportionate impact
- 21:40Speaker 3: outside the state, then that measure runs a follow dormant
- 21:43Speaker 3: commerce clause, and so again you had both Chief Justice
- 21:46Speaker 3: Roberts as well as Justice Alito and Justice Jackson, all
- 21:50Speaker 3: on the same side.
- 21:51Speaker 1: You don't often have the Supreme Court making decisions in
- 21:54Speaker 1: the animal welfare area. Is this a victory for the
- 21:59Speaker 1: animal welfare movement in more ways than one?
- 22:03Speaker 3: Well, it's absolutely theigory formal welfare sanctioning any kind of
- 22:07Speaker 3: state efforts to try to ensure that animals are housed
- 22:11Speaker 3: or slaughtered in a humane manner. You know, there are
- 22:15Speaker 3: states that ban the stale of horse meat, and obviously
- 22:19Speaker 3: states if they want to take other kinds of measures
- 22:21Speaker 3: to protect animals, they can do so. And maybe there's
- 22:24Speaker 3: true for fish farming too, but who knows.
- 22:27Speaker 1: Do you buy the pork producers saying that this is
- 22:30Speaker 1: going to increase prices for consumers and drive small farms
- 22:34Speaker 1: out of business and increase consolidation in the industry.
- 22:38Speaker 3: Because California is such a large market, its impact will
- 22:41Speaker 3: be felt in the industry. And I do think that
- 22:44Speaker 3: Proposition twelve US will give rise to higher prices because
- 22:48Speaker 3: you know, once you have to spend more money in
- 22:50Speaker 3: terms of housing pigs and ensuring exercise and so forth,
- 22:54Speaker 3: that is going to raise costs on doing business. So
- 22:58Speaker 3: how big of an effect is unknown, but it is
- 23:00Speaker 3: logical economically to think that this is going to drive
- 23:04Speaker 3: court prices up.
- 23:05Speaker 1: Also, just as Kavanaugh referred to the slippery slope argument
- 23:10Speaker 1: in his opinion, And there are some concerns that the
- 23:14Speaker 1: reasoning here, you know, the core issue the ability of
- 23:18Speaker 1: states to take actions with impacts beyond their borders, could
- 23:22Speaker 1: also be used by states in their efforts to restrict
- 23:26Speaker 1: or expand abortion access.
- 23:28Speaker 3: I'm skeptical that there'll be a direct impact here on
- 23:31Speaker 3: the question about what states can do in terms of
- 23:34Speaker 3: either ensuring the delivery of the abortion pill or precluding it.
- 23:38Speaker 3: That has to do with the Privileges and Immunities clause
- 23:41Speaker 3: and how that's developed in terms of the rights between
- 23:44Speaker 3: those in one state and another state. I think the
- 23:46Speaker 3: commerce issue here is distinct enough that there won't be
- 23:49Speaker 3: any spillover into the more contentious issue of what kind
- 23:53Speaker 3: of impact can one state have on citizens of another
- 23:57Speaker 3: state or prevent their own state from unveiling themselves of
- 24:01Speaker 3: the options available, whether it be marijuana or abortion services
- 24:05Speaker 3: in a different state. So I'm skeptical then there will
- 24:08Speaker 3: be any kind of carryover effect.
- 24:10Speaker 1: So how much does this buttress the power of states
- 24:13Speaker 1: to impose rules that have an impact and economic impact
- 24:17Speaker 1: on other parts of the country.
- 24:20Speaker 3: It's a huge win for states. States can take the
- 24:22Speaker 3: signal in the poor producer's case and decide on a
- 24:26Speaker 3: whole variety of local welfare type of regulation which has
- 24:31Speaker 3: the practical impact of imposing more costs on out of
- 24:35Speaker 3: state producers. They can't discriminate. They have to treat in
- 24:38Speaker 3: state producers the same as out of state producers, but
- 24:40Speaker 3: with that bare sort of minimum. It gives the states
- 24:44Speaker 3: rights to do that. Now that always is subject to
- 24:46Speaker 3: preemption by Congress. Congress under the Commerce power can say
- 24:49Speaker 3: that those kinds of restrictions are not conducive to free
- 24:52Speaker 3: flow of commerce from place to place, but subject to preemption,
- 24:56Speaker 3: that the states can make those decisions and impose as
- 25:00Speaker 3: long as they don't do so in a discriminatory manner.
- 25:03Speaker 3: It was interesting because the reason why this was controversial
- 25:06Speaker 3: is because of the sort of moral extra territoriality effect
- 25:11Speaker 3: of California's law, and yet all the members of the
- 25:14Speaker 3: court refuse to strike it down on that ground, seemingly
- 25:18Speaker 3: inviting the kind of retaliation or tit for tap. That
- 25:23Speaker 3: may well arise as states begin to regulate more in
- 25:27Speaker 3: the social area, whether it be an ESD type stuff
- 25:30Speaker 3: or another kinds of context.
- 25:32Speaker 1: Does any other red state have the economic power that
- 25:36Speaker 1: California does.
- 25:37Speaker 3: No, That's the underlying thing is that this gives big
- 25:41Speaker 3: states the advantage, particularly when it's talking about environmental pollution
- 25:46Speaker 3: or other kinds of activities. California can make a difference
- 25:49Speaker 3: just because of its size. Rhode Island and Arkansas aren't
- 25:52Speaker 3: going to have that kind of national prominence.
- 25:53Speaker 1: Well, we'll see if other states make any moves. Thanks
- 25:56Speaker 1: so much. How that's Professor Harald Krant do the Chicago
- 25:59Speaker 1: Kent College of Law. And that's it for this edition
- 26:01Speaker 1: of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get
- 26:04Speaker 1: the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcasts. You
- 26:07Speaker 1: can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www
- 26:11Speaker 1: dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, And remember
- 26:16Speaker 1: to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at
- 26:19Speaker 1: ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 26:22Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg