Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 246. Shared Wisdom: How Communication Defines Culture and Builds Community
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Community and communication not only have the same root word, but they
- 0:08work together to make us more effective.
- 0:11My name is Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:14Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:16Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:20Today I'm excited to have a conversation with Sandy Pentland.
- 0:23Sandy is a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he helped
- 0:27create and direct the MIT Media lab.
- 0:29He's also a Stanford Institute of Human-Centered AI Fellow.
- 0:33Sandy is recognized as a pioneer in computational social
- 0:36science and wearable computing.
- 0:38He has just released his newest book, Shared Wisdom Cultural
- 0:41Evolution in the Age of AI.
- 0:44Well, welcome Sandy.
- 0:45I have long admired your work and I'm very excited for our conversation.
- 0:49Sandy Pentland: Well, I'm really happy to be here.
- 0:50Matt Abrahams: Shall we get started?
- 0:51Sandy Pentland: Yes, please.
- 0:52Matt Abrahams: Well, let's start with Honest Signals.
- 0:53That's where I first got to know you and your work.
- 0:56Can you define what honest signals are and how you studied them?
- 0:59And then can you share how mastery of these signals can actually be
- 1:03effective tools to help us build trust and foster relationships, more
- 1:07than words might even be able to?
- 1:09Sandy Pentland: A way to think about this is that if you look at our
- 1:11closest ancestors, big, great apes, they actually communicate with hoots
- 1:16and pants and other sorts of sounds.
- 1:18Language seems to be built on top of that.
- 1:20But we didn't get rid of it.
- 1:21We kept it at its contrast to the words.
- 1:24So you can tell when someone's excited, of course, because they get
- 1:26all, oh they, that's a signal, right?
- 1:29And you can tell when they're not paying attention because there's these
- 1:32sort of awkward pauses sometimes.
- 1:34And those are the things that are the signals about what's going on in the
- 1:38person's head and about the relationship.
- 1:40And the ones that are most interesting, I think to me, and perhaps to
- 1:44your question, are the ones about the patterns of interaction.
- 1:47So it's not just about the person, it's about how they interact with other people.
- 1:51And we find that the pattern of people using each other, communicating with
- 1:56each other for help, both ways, is almost a perfect predictor of trust.
- 2:01Which is really interesting.
- 2:02So it's a relationship where you give me something and I give you something
- 2:06back, and we do that for a while.
- 2:08It also is something that's very closely related to friendship.
- 2:11People who do that, say about out work things, tend to become friends.
- 2:16And not just occasionally, very regularly.
- 2:19And if you look at groups of people, you see these same sorts of patterns define
- 2:24who's interested in a topic and who's not.
- 2:26In other words, what's the community?
- 2:28And so this is not something we're generally aware of, but you can
- 2:32look at these patterns and once you begin thinking about them, you
- 2:35can say, yeah, that makes sense.
- 2:38This guy must be interested in it and he gets something valuable out of it.
- 2:42So yeah, there's a certain level of trust there.
- 2:45Matt Abrahams: What I found really interesting is how you
- 2:46actually looked at these patterns.
- 2:48How did you study and look at the reciprocity that you found?
- 2:51Sandy Pentland: Oh, we've done it a number of ways.
- 2:53The one that people always remember is we built these little badges that
- 2:57would wear around your neck, and they had a microphone that didn't record the
- 3:00words, but did record how you moved and where you were and your tone of voice.
- 3:05And that turned out to be very informative about what was going on.
- 3:10For instance, who was leading a group, who was dissatisfied with it?
- 3:15And that's what the Honest Signals book is all about.
- 3:18Matt Abrahams: Did you find that there are certain signals that are more
- 3:21likely or more effective in determining power in relationships than others?
- 3:26So is it vocal intonation versus gestures versus physical orientation?
- 3:31Sandy Pentland: I think that's not the right way to think about it.
- 3:33What it is, is certain patterns of interaction, and those are
- 3:36accented by excitement or delay.
- 3:40In fact, we built a little, uh, sort of AI tool, which is actually in most
- 3:44call centers, and what it does is it tells the person when to listen, when
- 3:47to shut up, when to be excited, when to be a little cautious about it.
- 3:52What it does is it gets rid of the call center people fighting with the
- 3:55customers, so everybody has a better time.
- 3:59Matt Abrahams: What I've taken away from the Honest Signals work that
- 4:01you've done is that observing the patterns can be very insightful to what
- 4:08the results will be, and many of us don't pay attention to those patterns.
- 4:11Sandy Pentland: No.
- 4:11'Cause we're focused on the words or we're thinking about something else.
- 4:15Yeah.
- 4:15Matt Abrahams: I'm curious, now that we've shifted more to remote and hybrid
- 4:18work, what are your thoughts about that impact on Honest Signals and are there
- 4:22new things that we should develop and hone to help maintain stronger ties now
- 4:27that we're doing a lot of this remotely.
- 4:29Sandy Pentland: The obvious thing about say remote things and Zoom
- 4:32and all that is that it gets rid of a lot of the body language.
- 4:36The tone of voice is diminished.
- 4:37You can't tell about a lot of things.
- 4:39What I try to do with these things is have casual interactions, and in fact, we've
- 4:44built a little tool to help you do that.
- 4:46It's all free, all that.
- 4:48It's called Deliberation.io.
- 4:49It lets people talk about things in a sort of less structured way.
- 4:53And prevents overly large voices and gives people sort of
- 4:57summaries of what's going on.
- 4:59But the real thing is you have to have a personal connection
- 5:02that goes with these patterns.
- 5:04So when I do Zoom calls, I almost always start with five minutes of
- 5:07how are the kids doing and, you know, what's the weather, so that there's a
- 5:11sense that people actually care about the human and not just about the work.
- 5:16That's not the best thing because it's so much better to have that water cooler
- 5:21conversation or the little conversation after the meeting or before the meeting.
- 5:25Those are when things really get established in terms of trust and
- 5:29alignment and things like that.
- 5:32Matt Abrahams: It's really interesting 'cause when you and
- 5:33I were walking over to the studio we're in today, you did just that.
- 5:36We had this small talk to sort of get connected and it's very useful.
- 5:40You've pioneered the use of data to map social networks.
- 5:45How can this data be used to identify communication bottlenecks in a company or
- 5:49help create more effective and efficient teams once you understand the network?
- 5:53Sandy Pentland: We started with these little things that recorded
- 5:56sort of where you were, the tone of voice, whether you were talking to
- 5:59people or stuff, and we began to see that there were these bottlenecks.
- 6:03You say, these people don't talk to those people, they're gonna have
- 6:05a hard time coordinating, right?
- 6:07But what you can do with these is you can look at patterns of Slack messages,
- 6:11look at email, look at things like that, and you can do a really good
- 6:15job of saying, well, this group talks to this group, but not to that group.
- 6:18And maybe that's a problem and you want to think about that.
- 6:21We are building things here, we call AI buddies.
- 6:25It's basically a replacement for the manual that you never read, or all
- 6:29the newsletters that you never read.
- 6:30But what it does is it informs you about what other people are doing that
- 6:35are relevant to you and what's going on in the company or the organization,
- 6:40just to give you more context.
- 6:42And more sort of social awareness, and that's a huge amount of it, particularly
- 6:46with remote work, with international organizations, you lose context,
- 6:51you're not really in the loop anymore, and that's something that AI's can
- 6:55do really easily and fairly safely.
- 6:58Because, you know, they're not likely to hallucinate things like that very much.
- 7:02It's sort of like an automated newsletter that's meant to the
- 7:05particular thing you're doing right now, and people love it.
- 7:08It's good.
- 7:09It helps people connect.
- 7:10It helps business leaders actually change the organization.
- 7:14I was talking to the chairman of a large consulting firm, and he was going
- 7:18to reorganize how he ran his three hundred and fifty thousand employees,
- 7:22so he accepted the idea that there'd be fewer people in office, but use these
- 7:26sort of AI buddy techniques to have more remote people, more in the loop,
- 7:30and also to bring in people that are sort of on particular gigs or projects
- 7:34and have the confidence that they'll know what to do because they have this
- 7:39customized news and reminder service.
- 7:42Matt Abrahams: I really like that idea of giving people the information they
- 7:45need when they need it, to fill in those gaps and give the context, and
- 7:48AI allows you to make it very specific.
- 7:50Sandy Pentland: In many ways, not a new idea at all, but the new AI's are actually
- 7:54pretty good at this without all the concerns about hallucinations or whatever.
- 7:59And you don't need the frontier model to do this at all.
- 8:01You can do this with any of the open source ones.
- 8:04Matt Abrahams: So something that's germane and available to everybody.
- 8:06In your book, Social Physics, you discuss how ideas flow through a group.
- 8:11What's the best way for a leader to seed a new idea in a team, and what
- 8:15communication patterns will help that idea gain momentum over time?
- 8:20Sandy Pentland: You told me about this question and I sort of don't
- 8:22like it, and the reason is, is this idea of the leader in control and the
- 8:26leader defining the language about it, and those are both mistakes.
- 8:30Because in a group, what you need to have is you need to have people
- 8:34understand why something happens and what are the consequences
- 8:38and what do other people think.
- 8:40The reason we have so much polarization in this country, turns out that people just
- 8:44don't know what the other people think.
- 8:46If you set up a situation that let them know that, then they become rather
- 8:51dramatically more aligned with each other.
- 8:54It's really rather shocking.
- 8:55So the same thing is true in companies and so forth.
- 8:58So what a leader should do is say, here's something I'd like to discuss.
- 9:03Here's this idea.
- 9:04Have people talk about it, comment about it.
- 9:07And that's why we built this thing, Deliberation.io.
- 9:09You can just use it, it's free, but what it does is it doesn't
- 9:13allow the loud voices to dominate.
- 9:15And what you wanna do with this is you want to look at what
- 9:18is the language people use.
- 9:20I did some stuff with some political survey people, and they were talking
- 9:24about inflation and stuff, but humans, most people don't talk about inflation.
- 9:28They talk about cost of living.
- 9:30Oh yeah, sure, they're related, but one is far more salient than the other.
- 9:34Much more connected.
- 9:36And so, you need to have your conversation in the terms that the people understand.
- 9:41You need to listen to them because then they feel like they've been heard
- 9:45and they actually have been heard because they understand more about it.
- 9:48They've influenced a little bit.
- 9:50And all of that is this notion of shared wisdom, which enables
- 9:54action by the community, right?
- 9:57So collective action.
- 9:58'Cause that's what you really want.
- 10:00You don't really care about the ideas and the conversation.
- 10:02You want to actually do stuff.
- 10:04But that depends on having shared understanding, shared wisdom about
- 10:08what's the right thing to do.
- 10:09And that depends on people understanding each other.
- 10:12Matt Abrahams: So it's not the leader coming in and saying,
- 10:14thou shalt work on this.
- 10:16It's really posing questions that bring forth what's salient and even
- 10:20linguistically, what those words are that people use to describe what's salient.
- 10:24Sandy Pentland: Another sort of aspect of this is getting the right
- 10:26people in the room, the people that actually have skin in the game.
- 10:29So org charts, I have this joke is if you have an org chart, you have a map
- 10:33of how to have a stupid organization, because org charts don't reflect the
- 10:37sort of piece by piece, task by task type of thing that needs to happen.
- 10:41There's things that cut across all these different things.
- 10:44You need to have a way of getting those people discuss things in the same room
- 10:48and feel like they can really do it.
- 10:50It's intended to deal with some of that, not that it's perfect, but,
- 10:54but it gives you an idea of how you can actually build digital media
- 10:58that work for these sorts of things.
- 11:00Matt Abrahams: So using the tools to help.
- 11:01So you have to have the right people in the room.
- 11:03You have to use the right language, and you have to give people an opportunity
- 11:07to understand how others see it.
- 11:09And that's how you propagate ideas.
- 11:11Sandy Pentland: That's right.
- 11:11They have to sort of in their own heads say, oh yeah, that's why we're doing this.
- 11:15Matt Abrahams: You mentioned earlier that you study communities.
- 11:18I'm curious, what is the most surprising or counterintuitive finding your
- 11:21research has shown on how people interact and form communities?
- 11:25Sandy Pentland: I think the main thing is how smart communities can be.
- 11:29There's this sort of general sort of jokes, you know, stupid communities,
- 11:33madness, you know, et cetera.
- 11:35But actually when we look at things like people making financial decisions,
- 11:39people making other sort of decisions, if you have good patterns of communication
- 11:44between people and they have skin in the game and they're actually focused on it,
- 11:47they're usually better than the math.
- 11:50Take something like economics or trading where you know you can
- 11:53do all this quantitative stuff.
- 11:54The community version of that, which you know, has people who know the math,
- 11:59but now they're also talking to each other, works better over the long term
- 12:03than the people who just use the math.
- 12:05And the reason is, is that the community version of it has a broader
- 12:09view of what are the risks and opportunities than the math does.
- 12:13So it's a sort of myopic view when you're just trying to solve
- 12:17the equations or engineer it.
- 12:19You need to ask, how does this fit with everything?
- 12:21Have things changed?
- 12:23What are the things that are coming up?
- 12:25And we see that again and again.
- 12:26So it's possible to have wisdom, which is a capacity to make
- 12:30good decisions as a group, that outshines the scientific things.
- 12:35Not ignoring them, but incorporating them in a broader context.
- 12:39And I think that's the thing that people don't know and don't respect.
- 12:43Matt Abrahams: I wanna turn our attention to your new book.
- 12:45In your new book, Shared Wisdom, you state, and I'm quoting, it is
- 12:48important to remember that story sharing is as least as much for
- 12:52communities as it is for individuals.
- 12:55Can you help unpack this quote and discuss what story sharing does for us?
- 12:59Sandy Pentland: So the way to think about human society, and we'll imagine
- 13:03that it's five hundred years ago or ten thousand years ago, is that there's a
- 13:07constant conversation between people about, oh, this thing's interesting.
- 13:11Oh, that's terrible.
- 13:12Why did you think of that?
- 13:13And that's a type of deliberation to establish community norms.
- 13:18We like this.
- 13:19This is a good thing.
- 13:20We don't like that.
- 13:21That's a bad thing, right?
- 13:22And it's not a formal thing like where we sit down, we're gonna have the rules.
- 13:26It's this community sense or wisdom about how things should operate.
- 13:32And so that's really critical that you have people understand that why
- 13:37things are this way and not that way.
- 13:39And had the stories of, oh yeah, so and so ate those berries and got deadly sick.
- 13:43Don't do it, right?
- 13:45The sharing of stories educates the community 'cause it's passed on.
- 13:49It helps them define their culture.
- 13:52And they're incredibly sticky, also.
- 13:54If you look at Australian aborigines, they have stories, these, uh, songs
- 13:59about where to go and what to do that are authenticated to be more
- 14:03than seven thousand years old.
- 14:06It's just incredible.
- 14:07And what that's doing is defining the worldview and culture of that group.
- 14:12And different groups have different cultures, different songs that they sing.
- 14:17Matt Abrahams: Storytelling is a great vehicle to get your information across,
- 14:20but you're taking it to a new level.
- 14:22That stories help a society, a culture, a community to get their ideas across.
- 14:27So it's not just about the individuals.
- 14:29Sandy Pentland: Stories are the stuff of culture.
- 14:31You know, people talk about, oh, we need a good culture in this
- 14:33company, or whatever, right?
- 14:34That has to do with the stories you're telling each other.
- 14:37And it's not the official like newsletter or the CEO, it's the
- 14:40things that people tell each other.
- 14:42Usually before or after the meeting or, and the lunch room, something like that.
- 14:47And those stories permeate in various ways to be able to define the attitudes
- 14:52of people, which is the culture.
- 14:53And what we know also is that culture determines a great deal
- 14:57about the decisions we make and about the outcomes we get.
- 15:01So you really want it to get it to be right.
- 15:03And there's two ways.
- 15:04One is to make sure that good stories spread, but you also need
- 15:08to be able to have the stuff of stories to be able to spread.
- 15:13So you need to do things that are actually will help shape the community
- 15:18by saying, this is what we do.
- 15:20When somebody has a problem, we do this, and the conversation should end
- 15:23up being, yeah, we see why that's true.
- 15:26Matt Abrahams: Lots of rich ideas there.
- 15:28One thing I'm taking away from what you just shared is, if I am in a
- 15:31leadership position, in an organization, in a group, one of the ways to really
- 15:35understand the culture is to listen to the stories that are being told.
- 15:38Versus taking a survey or saying the culture is this,
- 15:42because I have said it is that.
- 15:44So this notion of listening and observing can be really helpful.
- 15:48Before we end, I like to ask three questions of all my guests.
- 15:51One I make up just for you and two are similar across everybody.
- 15:53Are you up for that?
- 15:54Sandy Pentland: Yeah, sure.
- 15:55Matt Abrahams: You are knee deep in AI.
- 15:58I'm curious what, what most excites you about AI and where it's headed?
- 16:03Sandy Pentland: The part that excites me most about it, first of all,
- 16:06I'm completely irritated by all the frontier model type of stuff, because
- 16:10that's not what people are gonna use.
- 16:12People are gonna use this much lighter weight specific type of stuff.
- 16:15I also don't like the sort of model where there's this big central company that
- 16:19runs everything and owns all your data.
- 16:22So I'm a real advocate of sort of personal AI tools to help people get along.
- 16:26Also for small businesses and so forth.
- 16:29I think that what we can get is a lot more of the things
- 16:32that we've been talking about.
- 16:33You can get things that are much more tuned to the preferences
- 16:36and needs of particular people in particular communities.
- 16:40And I think that will do an awful lot for making this more agile, for being
- 16:44able to address problems and feel a lot more like a member of the community that
- 16:49is doing something that we care about.
- 16:52Matt Abrahams: I really like that idea of using AI tools to help us even feel more
- 16:55tightly connected as part of a community.
- 16:57Sandy Pentland: Yeah, so AI for conversations, AI for community, not
- 17:02AI for big brain super intelligences that order you around, right?
- 17:07Matt Abrahams: Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:08Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 17:12Sandy Pentland: I like Steven Pinker.
- 17:13He has the courage to take things that everybody believes and aren't
- 17:18really necessarily exactly right and attack it sort of head on and with
- 17:24a lot of evidence and good argument.
- 17:26And at least what he does is even if you don't buy what his thesis is, he changes
- 17:31the conversation substantially and he picks things that are really important.
- 17:35Matt Abrahams: I love the fact that you and he are friends because
- 17:37you both do such interesting work.
- 17:39He was a guest on the show and really enjoyed talking to him
- 17:42about indirect communication.
- 17:44Question three, our final question.
- 17:46What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 17:51Sandy Pentland: I think that the things you need to do is first of all, know
- 17:53what people are talking about, right?
- 17:55So you need some way to be in the loop about what everybody's doing, and that
- 17:59requires avoiding dominance and status things, because I'm not gonna tell my boss
- 18:05or my boss's boss what I really think.
- 18:07So it has to be something where there's a certain level of anonymity,
- 18:11but also social consequence about it.
- 18:14And then you need to have a conversation about what should we do so that people
- 18:19understand what everybody's views are and why we're making certain choices.
- 18:23And then you need to also ask people, how are you going to help with doing this?
- 18:29What's your role?
- 18:30And I think that people are willing to do things.
- 18:33Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 18:34So I heard awareness of what the issues are and trying to minimize the loud
- 18:39voices in the room, synthesizing that with the people, and then inquire into the
- 18:44action that people are willing to take.
- 18:46And I think those are really important ingredients if you wanna affect
- 18:50change, and your research certainly is affecting change and how people
- 18:54interact verbally and non-verbally.
- 18:57Thank you for sharing your wisdom with us today, and best of
- 19:00luck on the book Shared Wisdom.
- 19:02Sandy Pentland: I just hope it has some effect on our institutions
- 19:05and the way we do things.
- 19:07So thank you very much for having me.
- 19:11Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 19:13Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 19:15To learn more about nonverbal communication, listen to
- 19:18episode 137 with Dana Carney.
- 19:20To learn more about communication networks, check out episode 65 with
- 19:24Michael Arena and Glenn Carroll.
- 19:26This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 19:31Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 19:33With thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 19:35Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 19:38Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 19:41Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram, and check out fastersmarter.io
- 19:45for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.
- 19:50Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes, and
- 19:53much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.