Latest / Reformed Thinking / The Psalms as Prayer, Praise, and Theology | D. R. W. Wood & I. Howard Marshall
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Reformed Thinking. I'm your host and I am very glad
- 0:03you joined us. We have a pretty significant
- 0:06task ahead of us today. We do.
- 0:08We're going to open the book of the Bible that, well, most of us
- 0:11probably think we know the best. It's the book you turn to when
- 0:14you're heartbroken or you know, when you need a quick verse for
- 0:17a greeting card. But today we're going to
- 0:19dismantle it, look at the engine and then put it all back
- 0:22together. We are talking about the
- 0:24Psalter. We are.
- 0:25It's the hymnal of the church, of course, but it's also one of
- 0:28the most intricate pieces of literature in human history.
- 0:31It's good to be here to discuss it.
- 0:34To guide us through this analysis, we're relying on a
- 0:37heavyweight source. We are breaking down the
- 0:39Introduction to the Psalms from the New Bible Dictionary, 3rd
- 0:42Edition, specifically the scholarship of DRW Wood and I
- 0:46Howard Marshall. It's solid, it's conservative,
- 0:49yet it's still critical scholarship.
- 0:51So yeah, it's a reliable place to start.
- 0:54Our mission for this deep dive is specific.
- 0:57We're not just reading poetry today.
- 0:58We really want to understand how this book was formed over
- 1:02centuries. We want to decode all that
- 1:05technical fine print that, let's be honest, everyone usually
- 1:08skips. Oh.
- 1:08Absolutely. And we want to get to the
- 1:10theological core. We're looking at this as the
- 1:13historical hymn book of God's people, and all through a
- 1:15Reformed lens. Which means we're looking for
- 1:18the Covenant, we're looking for that redemptive thread that runs
- 1:21from the first page all the way to the last.
- 1:24So let's get started. The source material begins with
- 1:27a claim that I think really sets the stage for everything else.
- 1:31It calls the Psalter a mirror. A mirror of the soul.
- 1:34It's a classic description, but one we should take very
- 1:37seriously. It is, but the force argues it
- 1:40mirrors every aspect of religious piety.
- 1:43And I think sometimes in the modern church we have a habit of
- 1:46cherry picking the encouragement.
- 1:48Oh, for sure, we want the verses that make us feel safe.
- 1:51But Wood and Marshall point out that this mirror reflects the
- 1:55dark nights of the soul just as much as the mountaintops.
- 1:58Exactly. It reflects sorrow for sin.
- 2:00It reflects that terrifying experience of walking in
- 2:03darkness, where God just feels absent.
- 2:07And that's where the Psalms are so distinct from a lot of other
- 2:10religious literature. They're just so honest.
- 2:12They are honest, but notice the balance.
- 2:15It's not just, you know, venting emotion.
- 2:17It's emotion that's been processed through the lamp of
- 2:20faith. It's the grind of obedience to
- 2:22the law, the struggle for perfection, and the humility of
- 2:26submitting to the chastening rod.
- 2:28That phrase chastening rod really stands out to me.
- 2:31It's powerful. It implies that the difficult
- 2:33things happening to the psalmist are not just bad luck.
- 2:36They're seen as part of God's parenting or or or God's
- 2:39discipline. Precisely the Hebrew poets took
- 2:42those raw, gritty experiences pain, fear, guilt, and they turn
- 2:46them into themes for songs they actually sang about the rod that
- 2:49corrected them which. Brings us to the first
- 2:51interesting fact about the name. In Hebrew.
- 2:53The title for the book is Tahilim.
- 2:55Yes, Tahilim. Which translates to Songs of
- 2:59Praise. Now I have to push back on this
- 3:00a little bit. OK, if I open the Psalms, I see
- 3:03a lot of complaining. I see laments, I see crying out
- 3:07for help. So why is the overarching title
- 3:09praise when so much of the content is pain?
- 3:12That is the paradox of Israel's faith, and the source explains
- 3:16this beautifully. Even the lament is a form of
- 3:20praise because it's directed toward God.
- 3:22It assumes God is there, that he hears, and that he can act.
- 3:26So the lament itself is an act of trust, and the expectation is
- 3:30always that God will act and that action will result in
- 3:34praise. So the destination is praise,
- 3:36even if the starting point is the pit.
- 3:38That's right, and the source brings in CS Lewis.
- 3:42Here from his 1958 work Reflections on the Psalms, Lewis
- 3:46makes a vital distinction that prevents us from reading this
- 3:48book incorrectly. What's up?
- 3:50He reminds us that these are poems.
- 3:52They're meant to be sung. They're not doctrinal treatises
- 3:54like, say, the Book of Romans, and they're not sermons like the
- 3:57book of Hebrews. Meaning we shouldn't try to
- 3:59parse every line for systematic theology in the same way we
- 4:03would a Pauline epistle. You have to read them as lyric
- 4:05poetry. They use hyperbole, they use
- 4:07imagery. They express the religion of
- 4:09Israel from the inside out. OK, And because the psalmist
- 4:12were heirs to a shared tradition, they weren't just
- 4:14writing private diary the entries, they were writing for
- 4:17the community. That is a key point.
- 4:19This was not David just journaling for himself in a cave
- 4:22somewhere. Not at all.
- 4:23He was giving expression to the shared faith of the covenant
- 4:27people. And because of that, the Psalms
- 4:29belong to all believers. They were the property of the
- 4:32Jew, and now, through Christ, they're the property of the
- 4:36Gentile. It's a universal liturgy.
- 4:38OK, let's talk about how we got this collection.
- 4:40I grew up hearing that the Psalms were the hymn book of the
- 4:43Second Temple. Basically the Psalms the Jews
- 4:46sang after they came back from Babylon.
- 4:48That's the common academic designation, yes.
- 4:50But our source seems to think that's a bit reductive, or at
- 4:55least potentially misleading. It is misleading.
- 4:58If you take it to mean the songs were written, then the
- 5:00collection might have been finalized for the second temple,
- 5:03but the material itself is ancient.
- 5:06The source is very firm on this. Psalmody did not just appear out
- 5:10of nowhere in the 5th century BC.
- 5:12He traced it all the way back to the Exodus.
- 5:13All the way back, Exodus 15, the song of Moses, that's a Psalm.
- 5:17You have the song of Deborah and Judges 5.
- 5:20You have Hannah's prayer in First Samuel 2.
- 5:22The source argues that the Psalm as a literary form was part of
- 5:26Israel's DNA from the very beginning.
- 5:28And not just Israel's DNA. This is the part of the deep
- 5:31dive that really surprised me. The source brings in the Raj
- 5:34Shamra tablets. The Ugaritic texts.
- 5:38This is fascinating. It is.
- 5:40We have archaeological evidence that the citizens of Ugarit and
- 5:44the Babylonians were writing poetry with very, very similar
- 5:48structures, The rhythm, the parallelism.
- 5:50This was a standard cultural vessel in the ancient Near East.
- 5:53So when God decided to give his people a hymn book, he didn't
- 5:57invent a brand new, you know, alien style of music.
- 6:00He used the pop culture or the high culture form that already
- 6:04existed. You're right, He used a vessel.
- 6:06They recognized the form was common to the culture.
- 6:08The content was distinct revelation.
- 6:11It's a great reminder that God speaks to us in ways we can
- 6:13understand within our own cultural context.
- 6:16So we have this ancient form spanning centuries.
- 6:19But who held the pen? The authorship debate.
- 6:22This is where the rubber meets the road for biblical authority.
- 6:24We have the list. David is attributed with 73
- 6:27psalms. Asaph has 50.
- 6:29You've got the sons of Korra, Solomon, Heemon, Ethan.
- 6:32Moses even gets. One Psalm 90, a great one.
- 6:35But the source highlights a major controversy here.
- 6:38Modern critical scholarship often denies Davidic authorship.
- 6:43They look at the David of the history books, the warlords, the
- 6:47general, the man of blood, and they say this guy could not have
- 6:50written the sensitive, delicate poetry of Psalm 23.
- 6:54Which, if you think about it, is a really shallow argument.
- 6:57It assumes a soldier can't be a poet.
- 6:59It just ignores the reality of human nature.
- 7:01General Patton wrote poetry. It's not mutually exclusive.
- 7:04But the source goes deeper than just psychoanalyzing David.
- 7:07It looks at the text. Right, we have to look at the
- 7:09historical record first. Samuel 16 explicitly describes
- 7:12David as a skilled musician. 2 S Samuel One shows him composing a
- 7:16high level lament for Saul and Jonathan, and the source points
- 7:20to Amos 6.5. Remind us what that says.
- 7:22Well, Amos, writing centuries later, references the musical
- 7:26instruments of David. This proves that the tradition
- 7:29of David as the founder of Israel's sacred music was not
- 7:32some later invention. It was an established historical
- 7:35fact in the minds of the Israelites.
- 7:37And for us, coming from a reformed perspective, we have an
- 7:40even bigger witness. The New Testament.
- 7:42This is crucial. Jesus and the apostles build
- 7:45theological arguments on the fact that David wrote these
- 7:48psalms. In Mark 12, Jesus quotes Psalm
- 7:51110 and says David himself said by the Holy Spirit.
- 7:55If David didn't write it, Jesus's whole argument
- 7:58collapses. So we can't just wave away those
- 8:00little titles at the top of the Psalms as you know, editorial
- 8:03mistakes. No, we treat the superscriptions
- 8:05as historically reliable. So we have the authors.
- 8:08Now let's look at the architecture.
- 8:10The Psalter isn't just a random shuffle of songs, it's
- 8:13organized. It is divided into 5.
- 8:15Books and the source suggests this was not an accident.
- 8:18Why 5? The prevailing theory is that it
- 8:21mimics the Torah, the Pentateuch.
- 8:23Oh, interesting. Moses gave five books of law to
- 8:26the people, so David, represented as the sweet
- 8:30psalmist of Israel, provides 5 books of response to that law.
- 8:34The law and the praise. That structure really helps you
- 8:37see the intent behind the editing.
- 8:39It does, and you can see the divisions clearly if you look
- 8:41for the doxologies at the end of Psalm 4172, 289, and 106,
- 8:46there's a formal closing statement of praise.
- 8:48OK. And then Psalm 150 functions as
- 8:51the doxology for the entire collection.
- 8:52It's a beautiful structure. There's also a strange pattern
- 8:55with the names of God that the source mentions.
- 8:58This is something I never noticed until I read this
- 9:00breakdown. The illahistic Psalter.
- 9:02Right in book 1 the name Yahweh, the Lord is dominant.
- 9:06But then you hit books 2 and 3, specifically Psalms 42 through
- 9:0983 and suddenly it switches. Everyone is saying Elohim God.
- 9:14It's a very stark statistical shift.
- 9:16What this tells us is that the Psalter was likely compiled from
- 9:18smaller pre-existing collections.
- 9:21It's like smaller EPS that were collected into a big album.
- 9:24That's a great way to put it. Someone gathered the Yahweh
- 9:26songs, someone gathered the Elohim songs, and eventually an
- 9:30editor stitched them together into the masterpiece we have
- 9:33today. It makes you realize the
- 9:35Providence of God in the editing process, not just the writing
- 9:39process. That is a very reformed way to
- 9:41look at it. Inspiration covers the
- 9:43compilation as well. I want to move to what I think
- 9:45is the most intriguing part of this deep dive.
- 9:48The small print, the technical terms sela, mictum.
- 9:53Get it? The source admits that even the
- 9:56guys translating the Old Testament into Greek in the 3rd
- 9:59century BC, the Septuagint, they were guessing at what these
- 10:03meant. It adds to the mystery.
- 10:05We're dealing with musical terminology from 3000 years ago.
- 10:08It's like someone finding a sheet of music in the year 5000
- 10:11that says distorted guitar solo and trying to figure out what
- 10:14religious ritual that refers to. So let's decode a few of these.
- 10:17Miz Moore. We see that everywhere.
- 10:19That's the technical word for a song with instrumental
- 10:22accompaniment. It implies structure.
- 10:24These weren't chanted a Capella in a cave.
- 10:26There were strings, percussion, flutes.
- 10:28It was a production. OK, then there's Mashil.
- 10:31Mashil comes from a root meaning to make wise or skillful.
- 10:36The source notes that psalms with this title, like Psalm 32
- 10:39or 78, are usually didactic. They are teaching songs, and
- 10:43often they teach through the lens of a chastening experience.
- 10:47So a Mashil is a song that says I went through something hard
- 10:50and here is the wisdom I gained from it.
- 10:51Yes, it's wisdom literature set to music.
- 10:54Now mictim. This one blew my mind.
- 10:57The source connects it to an Akkadian word katamu.
- 11:00Which means to cover. Right now in theology, when we
- 11:03hear cover, we immediately think of atonement covering sin.
- 11:07We do, but the source argues against that here.
- 11:09In this context, it's not about covering sin.
- 11:12It's about being covered protection.
- 11:15It's a plea for defense. The source uses a very modern
- 11:18analogy. It calls a victim an SOS.
- 11:21That changes how you read Psalm 16 or Psalm 56.
- 11:24A victim of David. It's not just a poem.
- 11:26It's David tapping out an SOS signal because he's in danger.
- 11:29It. Brings the orgency right to the
- 11:31surface. What about the most famous one,
- 11:33Ciala? It's in there 71 times.
- 11:35And we still debate it, but the route implies lifting up.
- 11:39Lifting up what? Most likely the sound.
- 11:42It's a musical direction. It probably signals an
- 11:44instrumental interlude where the choir stops and the orchestra
- 11:47lifts up the volume of crescendo.
- 11:51It's a pause for the mind, but an explosion for the ears.
- 11:55And finally, the two names. I love these because they just
- 11:58give us the flavor of the culture.
- 12:00You have a Psalm set to the tune of the Hind of the Dawn.
- 12:02Which is Psalm 22, a big one. Or the doves on far off
- 12:06terrabins. Mom, 56.
- 12:08And then do not destroy. That one is fascinating.
- 12:11The source links it to Isaiah 65.8 regarding the new wine in
- 12:15the cluster. The theory is that Do Not
- 12:18Destroy was a popular vintage song, a song the grape treaders
- 12:22sang during the harvest. So David takes a folk song, a
- 12:24work song that everybody knows, and he sits a heavy theological
- 12:27prayer to that melody. It shows that their worship
- 12:29wasn't cordoned off from their daily life.
- 12:31They brought the vineyard right into the sanctuary.
- 12:33We have to shift gears now to the the academic battlefield.
- 12:37The source brings up two German giants, Berman Gunkel and
- 12:41Sigmund Movengol. Now normally I might say we skip
- 12:45the German scholars, but the source insists their influence
- 12:48is unavoidable. You really can't understand
- 12:51modern Psalm study without Gunkel.
- 12:53He changed the question before him.
- 12:55Everyone asked who wrote this. Gunkel asked.
- 12:58How is this used? This is the Sits and Laban.
- 13:00The setting in life Gunkel developed the system of
- 13:03gonnigan, or classes. He grouped them hymns, community
- 13:06laments, royal psalms. And honestly, this is helpful.
- 13:11In what way? Well, if you know a Psalm is a
- 13:13community lament, you understand why it switches between singular
- 13:16and plural pronouns. It helps you track the flow.
- 13:18But then MO Winkle came along and maybe took it too far.
- 13:22MO Winkle is associated with the cultic approach.
- 13:25He became obsessed with the idea of a new year festival.
- 13:28He believed Israel had this massive festival just like the
- 13:31Babylonians where they celebrated Yahweh becoming king
- 13:34or ascending the throne. And he tried to force dozens of
- 13:37psalms into this hypothetical festival liturgy, right?
- 13:41And the source pushes back hard on this.
- 13:43It says, sure, the Psalms were used in worship the cultists,
- 13:47but if you push Moinkle's theory too far, you strip the Psalms of
- 13:51their historical reality. This is the danger.
- 13:53You end up saying Psalm 51 is not really David crying over his
- 13:56sin with Bathsheba. You say Oh no, this is just a
- 13:59generic confession form that a priest would read during the New
- 14:02Year festival. And that just sterilizes the
- 14:04Bible. It turns real blood and guts
- 14:06history into mere ritual. As reformed thinkers, we have to
- 14:10agree with the source's critique.
- 14:12We have to balance Gunkel's insights on form with the
- 14:15scriptural titles. The source uses Peter's sermon
- 14:18in Acts 2 to nail this down. Yes, Peter quotes David, but he
- 14:22says David spoke as a prophet. David was not just reciting A
- 14:26liturgy for a festival. He was, as the source says,
- 14:29foreseeing things beyond his own horizon.
- 14:31He was seeing the resurrection of Christ.
- 14:33Exactly. If we reduce the Psalms to just
- 14:35generic ritual texts, we lose that prophetic edge completely.
- 14:40So we keep the history. Now let's get to the theology.
- 14:44The source outlines the doctrine of God in the Psalter.
- 14:46It's majestic. God is Creator, ruler of
- 14:49history, but specifically he is the God of the Covenant, the God
- 14:53of Abraham and Moses. But we have to address the
- 14:56elephant in the room, the imprecatory psalms, the curses.
- 14:59The problem of the curses. I think every Christian has had
- 15:02this moment. You're reading a Psalm.
- 15:04It's beautiful. And then suddenly the writer
- 15:05says I hate them with a perfect hatred.
- 15:07Or, you know, blessed is he who dashes your little ones against
- 15:11the rocks, and you just. It is jarring, no question.
- 15:16How does the source explain this?
- 15:17Because love your enemies is our command.
- 15:21The source offers a three-part explanation that I found
- 15:24incredibly helpful. First, it's about zeal.
- 15:27These curses are not petty personal vendettas.
- 15:30The psalmist is aligning himself with God's 'cause he's saying,
- 15:34God, I love what you love, so I must hate what you hate.
- 15:37So it's a plea for justice, not just personal revenge.
- 15:39Right second, there's a historical limitation.
- 15:42They lived under the law. They did not have the full
- 15:45revelation of grace that comes with the cross.
- 15:47And the Third Point. This is the one that really
- 15:49stopped me in my tracks. The source states that the
- 15:52Psalter has no assured belief in a future life or resurrection.
- 15:57That sounds almost heretical to say.
- 15:58It does, but look at the text. There are flashes of hope, Psalm
- 16:0216, Psalm 73, where they expect to be with God, but they didn't
- 16:08have a settled doctrine of heaven and hell yet that
- 16:10revelation was progressive. So if you don't have a guarantee
- 16:14that the bad guy is going to face judgement day after he
- 16:16dies. Then he has to face judgement
- 16:18now. If justice doesn't happen in
- 16:20this life, it might not happen at all.
- 16:22Precisely that explains the desperation, that explains the
- 16:25violence of the prayer. They are screaming.
- 16:27God, if you are just, you have to destroy this wickedness right
- 16:31here. Because this is the only stage I
- 16:32know of. And they couldn't distinguish
- 16:34the Sinner from the sin. To destroy the wickedness meant
- 16:38destroying the wicked man. That's right.
- 16:40Now we standing on the other side of New Testament, we know
- 16:43about the final judgement. We know about the possibility of
- 16:46redemption for the worst Sinner. So we don't pray those curses.
- 16:50But, and here's the challenge, the source reminds us that these
- 16:53Psalms testify to the reality of moral judgement.
- 16:56They remind us that God does hate sin.
- 16:58We can't get so great focused that we become indifferent to
- 17:02evil. That is a heavy balance to
- 17:04strike and that leads us to the Messiah, because if their view
- 17:07of the afterlife was a bit dim, their hope for a Messiah was
- 17:10burning bright. It was the focus and the Psalter
- 17:13gives us 2 very different portraits of this Messiah and
- 17:17for centuries no one could figure out how they fit
- 17:20together. What are the 2 portraits?
- 17:21First you have the reigning king.
- 17:23Psalm 2, Psalm 110, the son of David, who crushes the nations
- 17:27with a rod of iron. He's victorious, powerful,
- 17:29political. And the second.
- 17:31The suffering servant, the priest king who is abandoned.
- 17:34Psalm 22 My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
- 17:36Psalm 69. He's mocked, beaten, rejected.
- 17:40You can see why the Jewish scholars were confused.
- 17:42Is he a conqueror or a victim? They seemed irreconcilable until
- 17:45Christ. The source points us to Luke 24.
- 17:49After the resurrection, Jesus walks with the disciples to
- 17:51Emmaus, and what does he do? He opens the scriptures.
- 17:54He opens the Psalms. He shows them that the Christ
- 17:57had to suffer first and then enter His glory.
- 18:00He's the key that unlocks the whole library.
- 18:02He is without Jesus. The Psalms are a book of
- 18:06contradictions with Jesus. They are a coherent prophecy.
- 18:10This brings us to our final section, the Christian and the
- 18:13Psalter. The source makes a beautiful
- 18:16point that I think we often overlook.
- 18:17This was not just a book about Jesus, it was the book Jesus
- 18:20used. It was his prayer book.
- 18:22Think about the humanity of that for a moment.
- 18:25Jesus learned to read with these texts.
- 18:27He memorized them in the synagogue when he was in the
- 18:29wilderness fight of Satan. He used scripture when he
- 18:33celebrated the Last Supper. They sang the halal psalms 113
- 18:36through 118 18. And on the cross.
- 18:38On the cross, in his moment of greatest agony, he didn't
- 18:42improvise. He went to the text that had
- 18:44formed him. Into your hands I commit my
- 18:46spirit. He died with the Psalms on his
- 18:48lips. That changes everything.
- 18:50If it was good enough for the master, it must be essential for
- 18:52the disciple. That's why the Church has always
- 18:54claimed the Psalter. The source mentions Martin
- 18:57Luther's famous description. He called the Psalter a Bible in
- 19:01miniature. It really is the whole story.
- 19:04Creation, fall, redemption, glory.
- 19:07Packed into 150 songs. And as the source concludes,
- 19:11even though it originated in the Jewish church, it is illuminated
- 19:14by the gospel. It is fully the property of the
- 19:17Christian Church for worship and adoration.
- 19:20We have covered a lot of ground today.
- 19:22We've gone from the ancient clay tablets of Ugarit to the SOS
- 19:26signals of David, through the arguments of German scholars,
- 19:30all the way to the theology of the cross.
- 19:32It's an incredible continuity. It shows us that our faith is
- 19:35not a novelty. We're not making this up as we
- 19:37go. When we sing the Psalms, we're
- 19:39joining a choir that has been singing for 3000 years.
- 19:42I want to leave you with a thought that's been nagging at
- 19:44me since we discussed the imprecatory psalms.
- 19:46OK? We said that the psalmists
- 19:48prayed for immediate, sometimes violent justice because they
- 19:52didn't have a clear guarantee of the future judgement.
- 19:54They were desperate for God to act now.
- 19:56They had a holy impatience. So here's the question for you
- 19:59listening today. Does our better theology make us
- 20:03lazy? We know there was a final
- 20:05judgement. We know God will settle the
- 20:07score in the end. Does that knowledge make us more
- 20:10patient with injustice than the psalmist were?
- 20:13Or does it just make us indifferent?
- 20:15That is a haunting question. Do we have that same burning
- 20:18zeal for righteousness in the here and now?
- 20:21Or do we just kind of shrug and say, well, God will sort it out
- 20:24later? The psalmist would not let God
- 20:26off the hook that easily. Maybe we shouldn't either.
- 20:28Something to think about. Thank you for joining us on this
- 20:31deep dive into the Psalms. I hope you open your Bible and
- 20:35see those ancient songs in a completely new light.
- 20:37Deep reading. We'll see you next time on
- 20:39reformed thinking.